Why is IT nearly all male?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by apotheon
Look at it this way:
If you picked out 100 women at random and 100 men at random, and of them 30% of women were vegan or vegetarian and 10% of men were vegan or vegetarian, wouldn't you say that the women in the study "tend" toward vegetarianism more than the men?
Now extend that. Let's say it's 1000 of each, so that you've got a more statistically significant sampling.
Let's make it 10000 of each, actually. Let's assume about the same percentages. Don't you think it would be fair to say that women "tend" to be vegetarians or vegans more often than men?
If a study suggest that women tend to act from emotion more often than men, that's the results of the study. Period. It only measures one metric, ignoring things like why women might tend to act more from emotion (such as the possibility that it is derived from being raised on Barbie and infant dolls rather than GI Joe and skateboards), or whether the smaller "logical" percentage of women might tend to act more logically than the larger "logical" percentage of men on average, but that doesn't change the fact that, according to the study's results, women tend to act from emotion more often than men.
I haven't checked out the study. I don't know how rigorously it was controlled, what definitions of terms they used, what the sampling was, or anything like that. For all I know, the study might actually be "bogus", due to a lack of good application of scientific principles and statistical analysis. You don't seem to be disagreeing with it on those grounds, though. You seem to be disagreeing with it because you [b]don't want it to be true[/b].
Political correctness should never stand in the way of legitimate research. Period.
by jdmercha
by neil higgins
by itgirli
by m_a_r_k
by ldyosng
by surflover
by surflover
by smallfred
Yeah, well...
Ok the short and sweet is that I think it is individual qualities rather than sex that pushes people into IT.
by jck
You see...others assumed that Drizzt because drow would be nothing but a dark, evil soul...but, he wasn't...he broke the mold.
Much as you assume me to be a single-faceted swill...simply because...you have a pre-conceived notion...
Guess swill don't do volunteer work for Habitat for Humanity or the Red Cross either. ;)
Keep guessin, ITgirli...one day, you'll be right...maybe...hahaha :D
by jck
well...it's all based on Dungeons and Dragons...a sub-set called "Forgotten Realms" that came out after the 5 companion sets, 6 companion books, and 1st and 2nd edition hard covers.
Evidently, ITgirli didn't know I have been in the game for over 25 years...hehehe.
Guess swill aren't supposed to read another other than skin rags either. Oh well, another pre-conceived notion of hers shot to hell. :D
by kneighbour
by apotheon
by carbynel
The problem with this emotions vs logic theory is that the two don't compare. They are not mutually exclusive, and they aren't opposites of each other. It is like saying men are better at reading and women are better at skiing, they aren't related!! So its an impossible conclusion! Not very logical if you ask me ;o)
It would be more accurate to suggest that women are generally more lateral in their thinking, and men are generally more logical. This isn't sexist, its just what a gender is predisposed to. It doesn't mean you don't get lateral thinking men, nor does it mean that you don't get logical women. How logical someone is has nothing to do with how emotional they are. Emotions aren't illogical reactions; people don't cry for no reason, nor do they yell for no reason. They are logical reactions to a situation... most often they are justified, and the severity of the reaction simply varies in each individual depending on how sensitive that person is (male or female).
by m_a_r_k
by smallfred
by apotheon
Sorry, but that doesn't seem to have anything to do with what I said in the previous post. Did you post that in the wrong place?
And what do you mean by "lateral"? Women think sideways?
by carbynel
Perhaps I did post in the wrong place, but it was difficult to trace back to where this emotions vs logic argument began. I thought you were responding along with others to this argument, and meant no offence by posting after you! I'm new to these boards, so cut me some slack! If you want this post moved, perhaps you can tell me how to do this?
Have you never heard of lateral thinking? Have you never done any lateral puzzles? It's a fairly common terminology so I'm slightly confused by which bit you don't understand. (Perhaps this is because I'm from the UK and you use a different word?) Maybe this link will help you to understand the word, or you could always try a dictionary!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lateral_thinking
As far as I was aware, defining men as having more logical thought processes, and women as having more lateral thought processes, was universally acknowledged.
As far as I understand it, lateral thinking is when the mind reverts from the normal verbal and symbolic mode and goes to the right side of the brain, where thinking is holistic and can take much more into account. This is thinking in parallel mode, where many factors are taken into account. Many example puzzles/exercises can be found online by simply searching for 'lateral puzzles' in google.
"women operate differently from men - the implication being that they operate more effectively: there is no hint of low self-esteem here. Women think laterally, rather than in a linear fashion, she says. Because they bear and nurture children, they understand process; they are not as goal-oriented, as men are." Liz McGregor writing for The Guardian Newspaper (UK)
by surflover
by apotheon
I just asked if you posted it in the wrong place. I didn't flame you for posting in the wrong place. I was trying to figure out whether there was some point of intersection with what I had said, or if you were responding to something I had said in a different thread of the discussion but (for some reason) responding here instead, or whether some other error had taken place. In discussions like this, it helps if there's some context for a comment like yours. In short, though: I wasn't offended, just unsure of your intent.
Hint, re: discussions -
Try to make your statements an actual response to something. Randomly dropping some in-depth argument somewhere that it doesn't exactly fit in context tends to confuse people as to what exactly you mean to challenge, debate, or otherwise address, and how you intend your statements to be read. Because we don't have nonliteral cues like tone of voice, body language, and so on, in online discussions like this, context for your statements becomes much more important than it is even in a face-to-face discussion, and context is of significant importance even face-to-face: if, in the midst of discussing your laundry, someone suddenly said "Yeah, but I think you should really get your oil changed," as a continuation of a discussion from last week, you'd probably be somewhat confused, at least at first. Keep that in mind, as well as the increased importance of context in text-only discussions, when deciding where to post a comment.
As for lateral thinking: I admit I've not run across the term in that usage at least in the last few years, and if I'd seen it before that I have since forgotten. I'm not sure if this is because the term is the creation of a British psychologist and I'm across the Pond from him, or if it's simply a matter of me being (un)lucky, but the fact of the matter is that I don't recall the term "lateral" used in that manner.
I have heard reference to terms like "right-brained", "holistic", "parallel", and similarly associated concepts as related to thinking patterns, however.
re: your statements about emotion and logic being unrelated/unopposed -
I don't entirely agree with you. While it's possible, as you suggest, for someone to be both logical and emotional, or to be neither, it is not possible for the primary factor in a decision-making process to be both logic and emotion. That's the point of the emotion vs. logic dichotomy that many have brought up: there is a primary motivator, or basis, for the decision making process (or so people suggest), and amongst men it tends to be more often logic, and in women more often emotion (or so people suggest). Whether or not I agree with that analysis, I can at least address the contrasting of emotion and logic as a reasonable perspective from which to make an analysis. The first really useful answer to that must be one from the options of "yes", "no", or "I don't think that's measurable (at this time)." To say it's a wholly irrelevant question seems unreasonable to me, and would require a far more well-supported counterargument to render it inapplicable than what you've offered, which is merely a statement of opinion without real supporting evidence or reasoning.
As for the suggestion that women are typically "more lateral thinkers" and men are typically "more logical thinkers", I haven't seen sufficient supporting statements to that effect to consider taking it as any kind of assumption. From the summary and overview of the ideas in the Wikipedia article, it looks more like the notion is built on social expectations than on rigorous testing and solid evidence. I'm especially skeptical of that division since I seem to excel at both logical and "lateral" thinking, in at least some circumstances, and from my own experience "lateral" thinking seems to consist of applying logical thinking in a parallel, rather than serial, manner. Logic produces valid results, and those valid results are true if sufficient true input is fed into the logical process. "Lateral", or parallel, thinking largely consists of multiple lines of logic applied to a single, complex circumstance, where arriving at a true result largely depends upon reaching a "critical mass" (if you will) of true input. Therefore, the division between "lateral" and logical seems to be largely artificial and incompatible with the realities of thinking processes.
Perhaps if "lateral", or a better word (such as "nonlinear"), had been contrasted with "linear" instead of "logical" there'd be some point to this exercise.
by av .
But, they also consider what they think will work the best for them. Usually, a position of responsibility in the IT world goes to a man.
I'm sure it has alot to do with maternity leave and raising young children, but employers can't say that. Women do lose their focus, temporarily. It can't be helped. Companies have to accommodate that. Unfortunately, if you are a woman with no children that has the same focus as a man, you are short-changed anyway because you could have children.
What if you are a man with a sick wife or parent that you have to take care of. What if you get sick? Doesn't that put you in the same category as a woman with kids? Maybe you should be paid at the woman's rate of pay because of that? $.70 on a $1. You are not as good as you were before your triple bypass, or your wife got sick or one of your parents has a long illness. You've lost your focus. You haven't kept up your skills. You are not as qualified as before.
Women have always been paid less to do the same job. Its better than it was 20 years ago, but it still happens. Companies can call a job any title they want, but its still the same job description.
We all have our limitations as human beings. Businesses pursue profit, always, but they need to figure in the human condition.
by av .
I think I would be wary of any boss that had a plaque that said "I am God." Even if I thought it was done in jest.
I guess theres an equal opportunity but no woman would really want the job even if she could do it. Thats ok.
Someone always has to answer the phone and make the tea, for sure, but I wouldn't choose a guy to do it either. Its not their thing in life and they stinketh at it.
by itgirli
people judged him by his appearence, I judge you by how you conduct yourself.
There is a difference.
by itgirli
by itgirli
by m_a_r_k
by surflover
by jck
by jdclyde
(posted here as last thread was too long to deal with)
I can't believe none of the IT Babes didn't come down on you HARD for calling them "chicks"! :D That has always been fight'en words whenever I hear them is seems! ;\
But yes, a dumb person is just annoying and I could never go out with a woman I thought was dumb. everytime they say something stupid, it is like another mental scar appears and after a while you can't stand to look at them!
And yes, a good catfight is always cool! go for the top! It's a rip'away! woo woo! ]:)
by apotheon
It seems that there is a distinct, statistically significant tendency for men to have those individual qualities more often than women. Individual qualities are, I'm sure, a combination of factors of both "nature" and "nurture" -- both intrinsic and largely unalterable qualities of the individual, in part related to gender, and qualities trained into an individual by environmental influences.
I'm of the opinion that the qualities that lead one to enter the IT field are mostly given rise to by developmental influence from our environment, however. While there are distinctly different basic neurochemical mechanisms between "normal" male and female brains, and that would indeed lend itself to differing attitudes toward various career fields, I believe that the environmental factors are much more of an influence in this regard. Social pressures train us from a very young age to think in particular manners and to enjoy certain types of endeavor. Women are taught and expected from a very young age to like and dislike certain things, and to believe themselves good or bad at certain things, and those activities that dovetail nicely with the IT industry usually fall on the "dislike" and "bad at" side of that.
On the other hand, there is some evidence from my personal experience to suggest that there's a more basic tendency at play here, as well. I don't know what intrinsic qualities might actually lend themselves to this, but my experience is that women have a tendency in romantic relationships to exhibit unwarranted jealousies toward the foci of their mates' attentions. In particular, I've noticed that for some reason women become jealous of the time computer geek men spend with their computers, whereas when situations are reversed men who aren't computer geeks don't get jealous of the time women who are spend withe their own computers: they just think it's weird and go back to watching football, or whatever it is that non computer geek men do. In fact, the women computer geeks I've met, rare as can be, don't even spend time with the computers themselves so much as they spend time doing things that happen to involve computers. There seems to be no specific focus on computers themselves so much as on associations with computers (wanting to bear the title of computer geek, et cetera) or specific activities that just happen to require computers (playing Diablo II, for instance).
I have only met a grand total of one, true, dyed in the wool female computer geek in my entire life. Any other woman claiming to be, or acting like, a computer geek ultimately is engaging in affectation or is simply misapplying the term without realizing it. Among men, however, I've met as many real computer geeks as those who aren't, really, and just play computer games or are wannabes -- about a 50:50 split.
I suspect that it's in part that significant variation in the level of absorption with the subject matter that accounts for the difference in comparatie quantities of the genders in the IT field. There might be as many women as men pursuing the IT industry as a career field, but there are far more men working in IT because they [b]truly enjoy the subject matter[/b] and simply couldn't see themselves doing much else.
There are about four different career fields, probably, that I could easily find myself in because I truly love, and am absorbed by, the subject matter. The IT industry provides one of those four. I'm a "real" computer geek. When outside of work, I continue to play with computers. I like to learn about programming languages, networking technologies, operating system architecture, system security, and so on, simply because the subjects fascinate me. I'd be learning about these things whether I had a job that depended on them or not, whether anyone was watching or not, et cetera. There are a small handful of other fields of endeavor that also appeal to me in that manner, but they tend to be related by way of some underlying principles. I'm in IT because I'm a computer geek. From what I've seen, women in the IT industry have a tendency to be computer geeks, if they become computer geeks at all, only after they get into the IT industry.
So . . . I don't know how much of that is nurture and how much nature. I prefer to think it's more "nurture" than "nature", because I'd rather like to see more women in IT.
by jdclyde
They make a POINT of diversity, instead of just taking the best applicate based only on skill. A qualified person can be turned away because they NEED to hire a "minority" or a woman or a "minority woman".
I also don't see the public sector as being quite as cold of a work environment. On the other hand, there is a lot more politics. I have worked private and public, union and non-union. I am a private non-union kind of guy. It is just where I thrive and can expect to advance based on what I do or don't do.
Good luck with your lists! :D Maybe someone will make a list to fix me? ;\
by jdclyde
going to local high schools and talking to the girls there?
I would bet that they would throw a girls-only session where you and others could talk about the posibilities in computers and science for women?
The other thing they need to see, is just because you get a job in IT doesn't mean your going to have to be working for IBM or MicroSoft. EVERY company now needs to have some level of IT, even if it is contracted.
It isn't that I feel women will make things better, it is that I feel good PEOPLE will make the field better. This isn't a field that requires being a macho guy to do your job well.
The biggest obstical I see? Many girls will play dumb because they know that many dumb guys will feel intimidated by them if the guys see how smart they are. Teach them to expect more out of themselves and others.
by jdclyde
I was betting that was going to be the direction you came from, rather than the game aspect being the read-a-holic that you are.
No wonder your single. Guys don't like to look stupid on comparison! That is why the blonde bimbos are so appealing to many! They make an average guy [b]APPEAR[/b] smart. While you make even many above-average guys look dumb. :D
Between that and your willingness to put people in their place makes a dangerous combination! If you ever find yourself in Michigan, I know an old geek that would buy you dinner! Some of us actually LIKE a smart woman. :x
by bizzo
Well there's your answer. I read the first 10 posts (80% men, 20% women). And 50% of the women, seem to be sexist ("they [men] hire other men"), are easily bored ("Women get sick of it"), inconsistent (?ask me one day and I'll fix everything, ask me the next and I give up?), and disloyal to the company (?someone offers me a job ? I'm gone?).
Or maybe I just read that wrong?
by apotheon
You get the Apotheonic Humor Award of this discussion. That was hilarious. I don't know if it bears any resemblance to women in the IT field outside of this discussion, but that was great within context.
. . . and, frankly, when someone comes into the discussion with a chip on his or her shoulder as denise.vrantsidis has, unmercifully logical humor is usually the only "effective" response.
by m_a_r_k
by maecuff
by jdmercha
"Men scream until they're blue in the face. Have you ever seen a woman do that?"
You've obviously never watched Cops.
BTY - The emotion vs. logic theory has nothing to do with abilities. It has more to do with gut reactions. A women is every bit as capable as a man at acting out of logic. It's the gut reaction, the first instint of a woman that tend to be more emotional.
by jck
you judge me on how I appear to conduct myself on here.
fact is, you have no idea how I conduct myself in my personal or professional life.
keep assuming...it fits you well.
by jck
by surflover
by jck
Fact is, I love a smart woman.
I just don't like crass, judgemental, overbearing, or pompous women...no matter how smart they are.
If a woman I'm interested in has to put others down to improve her own image...I don't need someone like that. I'm better off without her, because she'll eventually do that to me too. And, I don't need a backstabber in my personal life.
by maecuff
more off track with every post. Just from having children, I can say you are off base. My son hit his head when he was 7 months old and it started to bleed. His dad freaked out and I had to send him from the room so that I could tend to my child. Of course I was frightened, but I didn't let that take over UNTIL I determined that the injury wasn't as bad as it looked. I've had this conversation with MANY women. We've talked about falling to pieces AFTER a crises is tended to. If we acted, in the first instant, emotionally, we wouldn't be able to assess the problem as clearly. And, please, don't say this only applies to mothers and babies. I've had issues, as have female collegues, that required an immediate, non-emotional response. We usually handle it just fine. Without the yelling, screaming, spit flying from the mouth reaction that I've seen from men.
I'd have to say, that from your post, it is YOUR personal opinion that women are emotional at the 'first instant'. What support do you have for that claim?
Denise's profile indicates she is from Canada. Maybe that explains her arrogant attitude, like some (not all) of the Canadians who post here?
:-)
by m_a_r_k
by itgirli
by m_a_r_k
by jck
you're still making my point for me.
You're calling me things (callow, childish) when you judge me for supposedly doing to you what you are doing to me now.
where in that last post to you did I call you anything? or the one before that to you? I simply pointed out the error in your arguments. I never addressed you with any derrogatory adjectives or nouns. I simply pointed out that you think my banter on here is how I "conduct" myself...evidently...you seem to lack recognition of the sarcasm I post at times as well.
I won't go back to all the posts you put toward anyone who disagrees with your views, because it is obvious that anyone who doesn't fall in line or expresses something you take as a personal attack becomes a target of your scorn. As well by your own standards, your own words would prove yourself to not be "mature" as well.
And if you don't want to say anything to me or about me, I'd welcome that...more than you know.
by jck
ITgirli started hating me around the time I said (quite sarcastically) once that I wanted to date an 18 year old. That's when she (and Jessie) started calling me "swill".
I guess she takes personal offenses to guys who don't openly profess love for only women over 22, or women who are single parents. She seems to take it as a personal affront to her integrity.
For some reason, she just despises me and seems to think I'm in the league with axe murderers and pedophile priests.
Like I told her...let her keep assuming...
I'm like you, M_a_r_k. I like a woman who is unassuming, graceful, humble, and who knows when the appropriate and proper time to make corrective statements.
BTW, I think it's her bed...probably made of nails or broken glass ;)
P.S.- better get the weapons...cause...I won't be kissin anyone with that much venom coming out of their mouth.
by itgirli
by maecuff
just aquire one and hang it on my wall.
Your post made me laugh. I report to a VP here and I can assure you he would set you straight on my 'professionalism'. I routinely refer to him as, well, a very un-PC term that means homosexual. Either that, or I call him the foulest names I can think of just for shock value. And that's when we're getting along.
On the other hand, I do treat my employees and vendors with respect. And I can conduct myself in meetings without resorting to rude hand gestures. I won't say I'm not thinking rude things, but I can keep them to myself..
by carbynel
Okay, first off, I never said you flamed me for posting in the wrong place.
Re: your hint:-
As I said in my previous post, I WAS making a statement in response to something, and it was in context, it was just posted in the wrong place. I now realise I should have posted elsewhere, but that doesn't mean I needed a lesson in how to use tones when posting on a forum. I realise now the location of my posting made it unclear, and obviously wouldn't have posted here if I had realised this initially.
I'm sorry you have been ?(un)lucky? enough not to have heard of the term "lateral thinking". I only wish that in future you would do some research when you come across something you haven't heard of or don't understand, instead of simply dismissing it in jest. I never claimed to be an expert in lateral thinking, or anything of this nature, and was simply posting in response to something that was mentioned on this forum. However, after a brief search online I am now sure the US does use this terminology in the same way that we do. In addition to this, I would like to think that others are not so ignorant as to assume that because a scientific study did not come from their country, that it was automatically worthless, as you seem to have done.
In response to your other points:
Why do you say "it is not possible for the primary factor in a decision-making process to be both logic and emotion"? You also say there must be "a primary motivator, or basis, for the decision making process", but why is this the case? You're telling me it's not possible for a person to have multiple reasons for making a decision? Very often an emotional reaction to a situation is ALSO the most logical, and it seems ridiculous to me to suggest they must ALWAYS contradict each other.
Saying someone is logical and another is emotional, as if they are opposites, is completely unfair, and shows an alarming and potentially damaging misuse of the English language.
Also, to make a statement that generally women think more with their emotions than with logic suggests they would make stupid and foolhardy actions while following their emotions regardless of what the logical consequences may be (rather than combining the use of both effectively). The original poster is undermining women by suggesting they are less capable of acting as sensibly as men.
You then go on to say my argument is invalid as it is nothing more than an "opinion", however, you seem to fail to realise that this is exactly what yours is! What makes yours more valid? You have no proof that people make decisions based on "a primary motivator"!! And have proposed nothing to argue against a terminology that you yourself admitted to having no knowledge of prior to reading my original post!!!
However, since you're saying my argument has no merit as I fail to backup my claims with facts, I've found some information you might appreciate. As originally stated in your previous post, your understanding of lateral thinking is ?applying logical thinking in a parallel, rather than serial, manner." This article backs up this definition, and regards it as a more female trait, thereby concurring with the theory that women are more lateral thinkers.
"Men are able to focus on narrow issues and block out unrelated information and distractions. Women naturally see everyday things from a broader, ?big-picture? vantage point." Also, ""The male brain is highly specialized, using specific parts of one hemisphere or the other to accomplish specific tasks. The female brain is more diffused and utilizes significant portions of both hemispheres for a variety of tasks.""
(http://www.contentwatch.com/learn_center/article.php?id=165)
The point is, that even if we follow this flawed theory that women are all emotional wrecks and that men are all logically superior, all studies have shown that both genders use THEIR individual strengths to get to the same conclusion. At the end of the day, surely that is what is most important - The result. It doesn't matter how it is reached. For example:
"tests show that women generally can recall lists of words or paragraphs of text better than men. On the other hand, men usually perform better on tests that require the ability to mentally rotate an image in order to solve a problem. Mental rotation is thought to help people find their way, according to researchers. Does that leave the majority of women lost? Obviously not. Scientists believe that women may rely on their memory advantage and recall landmarks to find a destination." (http://web.sfn.org/)
I don?t have the time to research this for you in any more depth, but even if none of these quotes state exactly that women tend to be more lateral, and men tend to be more logical these quotes/articles do suggest that. This argument seems more to do with differences between American and British English than an actual disagreement in the validity of the theory.
"If I had to pick a brain, I think I'd take a female brain," says Jacobs. "It's symmetrical, multitasking and more resistant to stroke because language ability is stored in both hemispheres. The female brain is like a Swiss army knife - whereas males get stuck with one big blade."
I?m afraid, that apart from quoting the above studies and articles, there is nothing more that I can do to prove this ?opinion? as these are all still theories to the experts themselves. However, what I can say is that you will equally be unable to disprove it.
On a final note:- ?technology is the great equalizer: Even Arnold Schwarzenegger is an ant compared with a woman in the cockpit of an F-16.?
by carbynel
by jck
Here's a really brief recap for you, M_a_r_k:
ITgirli originally made the post about most of the world listening to Howard Stern being "swill" after I'd defended him...she was the first to imply I was swill...(4/20/05)
Jessie agreed later in other posts and called me swill too.
then in another thread, I'd joked with sleepindawg about thinking about askin if his 18 year old daughter was single after he'd started a friday yuk about daughters...
then...jdclyde said I was swill.
then, ITgirli jumped on to bash...and bash...and bash...
it hasn't stopped since then.
by jck
I didn't figure you would.
As for professionalism...you have an established rapport with that VP. Would you do that with any of the other top brass in the corp?
As I said, you seem professional and well-demeanored to me. You don't just fire off on anything and everything that crosses your belief system or etiquette.
Anyways...I better stop now before people think I'm suckin up to you. I've already chastised jdclyde for doing it. :D
by carole-y
I'm an IT girl myself, and have often wondered this. In fact, I am currently pursuing my Master's degree in MIS and have even done some research.
I'm a little sad that for all these responses so few of them are serious.
Professionally, (all private sector work) I have encountered 2 other woman in an IT dept. (a telecom woman, and a DBA) I've been doing IT about 6 years. The other women I met were great at what they did. (not that the men weren't)
However I think there are a couple of serious issues for women in IT.
1. It is not well marketed to young women. How many young women hear success stories or are encouraged to study the computer sciences? Only because I am a "geek" do I even have female friends who encourage me or were once in the field. I know women who have left IT to pursue other careers instead.
2. More importantly, it is a difficult lifestyle for women in general. I don't plan to have children, and I like the work so it suits me. However, technology is ever-changing. If you stopped to take care of children, even for a year or two, you are out of date and have fun interviewing and getting back into the field.
The downsizing and instability can be rough too.
Let's face it, I'm a network admin and that means 9-5 in the office for supporting people during business hours, off-hours work on servers and the network, and being on call 24/7. This kind of lifestyle does not scream family-oriented. Add onto that the constant study and certs, the keeping up with tech, and believe me I understand why women (more than men) would have a hard time balancing work, family, life, and potentially education issues.
I would really like to hear some other ideas why. I'd also like to ask if people think we could/should do anything to change this. How do we get more women involved in IT -- without resorting to an inequal scenario (i.e. hiring women over men because they are rare, etc.) ???
Thanks!
by jdmercha
Societal pressure.
Most parents will raise there daugters to be mothers and care givers. They will raise there sons to be aggressive and constructive.
Girls are still mostly raised playing with dolls and and babysitting. Most boys are still being raised learning aggression through sports and building with legos. Although the gap is narrowing all the time this is still how the majority of children are raise in the US.
This sterotype of what boys and girls should be is continued in the schools and supported through peer pressure. Thus boys are guided to technology while girls are guided to caregiving. Again it is not as bad as it used to be but it is still common.
What can be done? Get your daughters involved in athletics at an early age. Parents need to be involved with their childrens lives to help guide them to the choices that fit them best.
What is being done about it? Here is one thing, at least: http://wit.syr.edu/index.php
I guess it depends on where you work. At my employment, we joke they must put something in the water, since many women get pregnant shortly after starting work here. Management has no problem with women taking up to 12 weeks maternity leave, and they can use their short term disability pay for it. However, men are not allowed to use short term disability pay for "paternity leave" if their wives give birth, to help them out, so it is not exactly fair.
I think my company puts stuff in the water to make women fertile to keep the on-premises daycare full.
by jamesrl
In Canada, you get something like 9 months(12 if you don't mind getting paid for the last few months) AND you and hubby can split those weeks up. You can even use them if you adopt.
James
by apotheon
I think you've hit on a very good point relating to why there aren't more (successful) women in IT, by making two statements that relate in a way you might not have noticed.
First: "[i]Only because I am a "geek" do I even have female friends who encourage me or were once in the field. I know women who have left IT to pursue other careers instead.[/i]"
Second: "[i]If you stopped to take care of children, even for a year or two, you are out of date and have fun interviewing and getting back into the field.[/i]"
The people who are most successful in the field of IT, it seems (salesmen notwithstanding), are those who [b]really love the subject matter[/b]. These are people who don't go into the IT industry because they think it's a "lucrative career" or a "worthy field of employment", and they aren't people who stay on top of evolving technologies because it's in their job description. They're (or, rather, "we're") people who keep abreast of evolving technologies [b]because they enjoy it[/b]. We're the people who would keep up with changing technologies instead of watching Survivor, or going to NFL exhibition games, or playing a weekly game of bridge, or getting schnockered at the local watering hole every Friday night.
We're people that, if we got pregnant (assuming the biological equipment to do so), would spend a lot of time on maternity leave reading O'Reilly texts [b]because that's what we think of as fun[/b]. We're the people that, if kept out of work on disability leave for several months, wouldn't fall behind at all in our understanding of emerging technologies because we don't just "do IT" when getting paid for it -- we're the people who "do IT" because we like it, and consider ourselves lucky to have found a way to get paid for it.
You ask the kind of person who drops out of the IT industry to pursue a better career field why he or she was in IT to begin with, and he or she will tell you something about job security, the wave of teh future, the value of technical skills, and so on. You ask the kind of person who sticks with it through thick and thin and becomes a "Linux guru", or the hoary old bearded programmer in the back room, or me, or whatever, why he or she got into IT to begin with, and you'll get an answer like mine might be: "You mean someone wants to [b]pay me[/b] to play with computers?! Awesome!"
When you can answer the question "Why aren't more women real, true-blue computer geeks?" I think you'll be able to answer the question "Why aren't there more women in IT?"
As long as you keep trying to stage career days for women, you're missing the point: there's a lot more money and job security to be had for a lot less work in a great many other fields. If you want more women in IT, you need to find the girls who are naturally inclined toward working with computers [b]and encourage them to enjoy it[/b]. If you succeed in that, without ever once mentioning that there are actual jobs that pay you for playing with computers, you'll end up with more women in IT whether you like it or not.
How's that for "a good answer"? Was it worth the wait?
by carole-y
Yes, those are some good points! Thanks!
Still we are left to wonder why women don't think it's fun the way men do. And I still think that one reason is that, in general women are more conscious of the work/family/life balance.
But I think you hit on one of the underlying truths, for some reason and to a large degree, women just aren't as interested.
BTW... I also love video games - there aren't too many women gamers either. And for some reason, no one really cries out that video games aren't marketed to women/girls.
Well, it does allow me to get along with my husband and all of his friends nicely. Tho sometimes I feel like a weirdo among my girl friends or my family.
However, to some extent that is the nature of ANY technical profession. Those outside it do not understand. Just the "IT" label is a bit newer and more mystical to people. People know what a doctor is or a chemist, even if they don't understand the specifics. Even "software developer" is a bit more understood than "sys admin" or "network admin"...
I guess I just always wanted to look behind the curtain and see how things work from an infrastructure perspective. But admittedly, sis years ago I had no idea what "IT" was.... all I knew was that I liked computers but programming was NOT for me. Not the best way of discovering your future calling...maybe that is why there is a call to inform people better about our field and what we do.
One college internship in system administration later and I just couldn't shake IT!
So I think that is a good idea, that we should get the message out to people who might enjoy the infrastructure/netowrking side of the house that it exists and is an option. Maybe also the misconception that IT is sitting at your desk all day (ha! ha!) is also a small stumbling block. Or that there is no interaction with other people (I find myself personally interfacing with everyone in the company)!
maybe that is a new thread... debunking IT myths.
by carbynel
I?m almost afraid to respond in case apotheon starts to think I?ve got something against him personally (which I can assure you is not the case)
Generally I agree with what is being said, however, I get the impression that it is being suggested that a woman would naturally keep abreast of new technology if they really loved the subject, even if they are out of work for several years raising children. Whilst I agree that someone that finds technology as much a hobby as a career would spend leisure time keeping up to date, I find it slightly dismissive of the work involved when raising a child or children. This obviously is more than a full time job, which also encompasses weekends, and whilst I agree that a woman might be able to fit in some reading for pleasure; going by the women I have spoken to that have had children, they find it almost impossible to make time for any leisure activity, regardless of their passion. This would lead me to the conclusion that even if a woman did try hard to stay up to date, with technology changing so rapidly; and her priority now shifting towards the raising of her children, her knowledge of computing would decline, so that it was hard to get back into work.
Also, I don?t know how the US is affected by this, but it is universally acknowledged in the UK that part time jobs within the computer industry are few and far between. A lot of working mums have a preference towards going part time when their children are at school, and the fact that this is not always possible, is sometimes a reason why the IT industry is not considered a possible career option for working mums.
by jdmercha
by maecuff
by apotheon
by jdclyde
He says as the nightstick wacks him upside the head....
jkc - Do you really think I was sucking up? We both know that Girli isn't someone that would be going for someone like me, so you know that wouldn't be a motive. How many people OUR age do you know that have read half as much as she has? I was not sucking up, and was only stating what I see as facts. Was it a compliment? In my own sick and twisted way it was a very high compliment. Did she take it that way? Who knows...
Swill, as need as I can track it down the first reference was in "the Best Song of all time" discussion where jck prasied Howard Stern and girli commented [i]"The fact that people continue to listen to such refuse leads me to continue in my beliefs that the majority of our society is absolute ignorant swill."[/i]
The reply from jck was [i]"fact is tho, he's stayed in radio for 30 years now. Quite successfully, I might add
Well, I'm swill and an a**hole now.
I'll have to put that on the resume."[/i]
The exchange about the 18 year olds and such were not until after this title was self-proclaimed. (4/20/05)
It was refered to a few more times, many again self-proclaimed. From there is stuck as kind of a running joke I guess. Few took or take it seriously. Girli does.
Can't please everyone. I KNOW there are those that think much worse of me out here, but what can you do? Talk to the ones you agree with, argue with the ones you don't and ignore the ones that there is no chance of a middle ground.
I have been accused by you jck of sucking up a few times? Why when someone attacks you, I am your target? When I disagree with you, I address you directly, not as a sideways comment to someone else? And no matter how wrong I THINK you are at times, I still don't get personal and attack you? (calling you a liberal nut is not an attack! :) )
I won't get in the middle of whatever it is that is between the two of you or Max and you.
They both say a lot that I agree with and respect. Telling them this is not sucking up.
by maecuff
by jck
Listen...jdclyde...
that was meant jokingly... it's why I put the little :D thing after it...a smile...a laugh...joke...earth humour...ar ar...get it?
I'll just stop talkin to you if you can't take a poke. I thought we'd hashed out this serious crap months ago and got to actually understanding we had a playful banter going.
She did make the first allusion (not direct reference) on 4/20 in the Howard Stern thing that I was among the Stern listeners she thought swill.
Anyways...think what you want...I wish you luck too. But, I wasn't shoving crap in your face or trying to cut you down...
enjoy
by jck
by apotheon
"[i]I never said you flamed me for posting in the wrong place.[/i]"
I never said you did say that. You reacted defensively, though, so I thought I'd make it abundantly clear that I never intended any flames.
"[i]I WAS making a statement in response to something, and it was in context, it was just posted in the wrong place.[/i]"
If it's in the [b]wrong place[/b], it's [b]out of context[/b], by definition. Thus, my offered hint.
"[i]I only wish that in future you would do some research when you come across something you haven't heard of or don't understand, instead of simply dismissing it in jest.[/i]"
Again, don't be so defensive. I wasn't being dismissive: I was asking about it because I actually wanted to know what you meant. I would likely have gotten around to looking it up myself if you hadn't responded, but at the time I responded I was doing several things at once and something had to suffer. Since researching the term "lateral thinking" isn't part of my job, that's what I chose to put on the back burner.
"[i]I never claimed to be an expert in lateral thinking[/i]"
I'm not sure what that has to do with anything.
"[i]I would like to think that others are not so ignorant as to assume that because a scientific study did not come from their country, that it was automatically worthless, as you seem to have done.[/i]"
Are you trying to be combative and offensive, or does it just come naturally? You're making a lot of unfounded assumptions about me, and seem to be looking for opportunities to read the worst possible interpretations into everything I say. Are you perhaps overcompensating for the fact that I caught you in a contextual error? Would you be my friend if I bowed and scraped and agreed with everything you said? I in absolutely no way indicated that I thought anything was worthless because of its country of origin. Stop trying to put words in my mouth.
"[i]You also say there must be 'a primary motivator, or basis, for the decision making process', but why is this the case?[/i]"
I didn't say there must be any such thing. What I said was that some people [b]suggest[/b] that there is such a thing. I didn't indicate whether I agree or disagree with such a suggestion: I just pointed out the context of the argument. Why are you trying to assign to me everything with which you disagree?
"[i]You're telling me it's not possible for a person to have multiple reasons for making a decision?[/i]"
. . . and even if I [b]had[/b] said there must be a primary motivator or basis, that in no way makes it impossible for there to be more than one reason for acting in a certain manner. All it means is that one reason is more "primary" than others. Something is hardly worth calling "primary" if it's also "only", after all. The unspoken assumption would likely be that if there's a primary motivator, there is also probably a secondary and maybe even tertiary motivator, thus allowing for two or three reasons. Maybe there are more, such as quaternary motivators. The list goes on.
NOTE: I still haven't said that I necessarily subscribe to the suggested claim that emotion or logic must be a primary motivator or basis for decision making. Get that? I haven't said it must be so. I've repeated what others have said and made an attempt to explain how the reasoning works. Don't call me dismissive for failing to dismiss that argument in favor of yours.
"[i]Very often an emotional reaction to a situation is ALSO the most logical, and it seems ridiculous to me to suggest they must ALWAYS contradict each other.[/i]"
In point of fact, I don't remember anyone saying "they must ALWAYS contradict each other." Maybe you saw someone say it, but I guarantee you it wasn't me.
"[i]You then go on to say my argument is invalid as it is nothing more than an "opinion", however, you seem to fail to realise that this is exactly what yours is![/i]"
Uh, what? What exactly do opinion and validity have to do with each other in this context? [b]You[/b] are the one making claims that terms are mutually exclusive when they are not, it seems.
"[i]You have no proof that people make decisions based on 'a primary motivator'![/i]
When did I say that I do, or that people make decisions in that way? I explained an argument. I did not declare undying devotion to its underlying assumptions. I didn't even support it particularly. I only pointed out how your "dismissal" of it wasn't effective.
"[i]And have proposed nothing to argue against a terminology that you yourself admitted to having no knowledge of prior to reading my original post!![/i]"
Perhaps you didn't notice, but I never said you were wrong. I just pointed out some problems with the terminology used and indicated that your own arguments lacked some necessary support. It's entirely possible to make bad, unsupported, or invalid arguments and still be right.
"[i]This article backs up this definition, and regards it as a more female trait, thereby concurring with the theory that women are more lateral thinkers.[/i]"
What does that have to do with whether or not they're logical thinkers? That makes them more adept at parallelizing thought processes, not more or less logical in any way. That was my point. Again, of the two of us, you seem to be the one claiming things are mutually exclusive when, in fact, they are not.
"[i]this flawed theory that women are all emotional wrecks and that men are all logically superior[/i]"
I don't think that's what the study you spit on so freely was saying at all. I suppose you've never heard the term "emotional intelligence", for instance. I don't recall anything claiming that logically informed behavior is specifically superior to emotionally informed behavior, at least as far as researchers go.
"[i]tests show that women generally can recall lists of words or paragraphs of text better than men. On the other hand, men usually perform better on tests that require the ability to mentally rotate an image in order to solve a problem[/i]"
Yes, of course. I've been aware of studies suggesting that men are better at visualizing spatial relations and women at textual memorization for about two decades now. I'm not sure how that relates to the debate over whether I'm an evil person who disagrees with you, though.
"[i]even if none of these quotes state exactly that women tend to be more lateral, and men tend to be more logical these quotes/articles do suggest that[/i]"
The textual memorization vs. visualizing spatial relations bit actually seem to me to indicate, if anything related to "lateral" vs. non-"lateral" ("logical" is a very, very poor choice of term for contrasting with that use of "lateral", as I've already indicated), that in at least this one comparison men are better at massively parallel thinking than women. It's a very straightforward, linear process to memorize a block of text, while visualizing spatial relations requires the ability to track shape, volume, and attitude of an object on three axes, generally requiring the ability to hold several views of something in one's head simultaneously. Maybe there's some other interpretation of the applicability of this example that I'm not recognizing, though. I'm not arguing one way or another regarding the parallelizing capabilities of women vs. men at this point: it's you who is attempting to assign a stance on the issue to me.
"[i]you will equally be unable to disprove it.[/i]"
Fine. I never intended to disprove it. Why do you think I did intend any such thing?
You'll get along much better in online discussions if you look for signs someone is not disagreeing rather than assuming everyone's your enemy.
by maecuff
Y'all need to start playing nice. Cut it out, right now or you'll have to stand in the corner and hold hands.
Besides, none of this means ANYTHING anyway. Chill. Have a drink. Go cure cancer. Just stop taking this so seriously.
Of course, you realize this isn't true if I get my panties in a bunch about something. THEN it's important..
by jck
I got in trouble elsewhere...evidently, everyone takes me to be some hard-line, sicko perv.
I gotta quit teasing with people...evidently I don't put enough smilies in to let them know it's a joke or something.
by jck
I'm gonna suck up to you now, since you told me up yonder I wasn't in any danger ;) haha
I wanna be teacher's pet! WAH!!! :D hahaha
by m_a_r_k
by m_a_r_k
by carbynel
This is all just semantics!! This feels like a war of the words, can?t we have a proper debate?
"I just asked if you posted it in the wrong place. I didn't flame you for posting in the wrong place?
I never brought up the idea of being flamed. I didn?t consider you telling me that I had posted in the wrong place to be flaming, and the fact that you mentioned it lead me to believe you thought that I had considered your response to be flaming, so I simply replied saying that I hadn?t thought you had been flaming me! ?Okay, first off, I never said you flamed me for posting in the wrong place? I didn?t think this would be something we would still be debating!!
"If it's in the wrong place, it's out of context, by definition. Thus, my offered hint."
No, I read your original response to mean that it was out of context regardless of where it was posted. You knew that I posted in the wrong place, as I had already admitted this, and had apologised, so why go on about it being out of context, as that was self-evident?!? Your hint was unnecessary, and purposely patronising. Its not like I had queried why you didn?t understand my post, and why you had a problem with me posting there!
"Are you trying to be combative and offensive, or does it just come naturally?"
Oh, the irony!! It?s certainly difficult to maintain your composure with someone making aggressive/hypocritical remarks like that!
"Are you perhaps overcompensating for the fact that I caught you in a contextual error?"
You haven?t stated what contextual error I?ve been caught in, unless you simply mean I posted in the wrong place. (honestly, I have never met someone that made such a big deal over a thread!)
"Would you be my friend if I bowed and scraped and agreed with everything you said? I in absolutely no way indicated that I thought anything was worthless because of its country of origin. Stop trying to put words in my mouth."
Apparently I am the one being combative and offensive? I have never suggested I wanted you to bow down and agree with what I?ve said, and I really don?t see how this is relevant to this discussion.
"I didn't say there must be any such thing. What I said was that some people suggest that there is such a thing."
I apologise then, as I made the assumption that if you were arguing in support of these people?s opinions, you also agreed with them. I simply don?t understand why you are arguing their corner if you don?t actually agree with this suggestion.
"Don't call me dismissive for failing to dismiss that argument in favor of yours."
The reason I was calling you dismissive was not because you agree with them; or rather, fail to agree with me. So who?s making the assumptions now then? I found you dismissive because you originally posted ?Women think sideways??, which appeared to me to be dismissive of the term ?lateral thinking? to which you previously had no knowledge.
"Uh, what? What exactly do opinion and validity have to do with each other in this context?"
I?m afraid I simply don?t understand what you find confusing about this. I originally said ?You then go on to say my argument is invalid as it is nothing more than an "opinion", however, you seem to fail to realise that this is exactly what yours is!? Which means, why do you think your opinion is more valid (correct, worthy etc) than mine? Both are opinions, (neither can be proven or disproved) I?ve at least quoted sources, but your argument has not been backed up at all!
"I just pointed out some problems with the terminology used"
I?m sorry, but this seems to be the entire problem here. You?re too busy over analysing the semantics. I didn?t realise this was an English exam, I was posting on a forum! (which I now largely regret!!)
"That was my point. Again, of the two of us, you seem to be the one claiming things are mutually exclusive when, in fact, they are not."
Yes, that?s correct, I am claiming them to be mutually exclusive. When did I argue that I wasn?t? That had been my entire point. Logic vs Lateral in my opinion and from the research I?ve seen are mutually exclusive. (that?s not to say that the genders don?t cross over) I however, never said emotions vs logic was mutually exclusive. And it was THAT which I was arguing against.
"I suppose you've never heard the term "emotional intelligence", for instance."
Again, apparently I am the one assuming things about you, when throughout this whole post it really seems to be other way round. Of course I?ve heard of emotional intelligence, but I don?t see what that has to do with the emotions vs logic argument.
"relates to the debate over whether I'm an evil person who disagrees with you, though."
LOL, I never realised we were debating that. Is that another attempt to be aggressive?
"if anything related to "lateral" vs. non-"lateral" ("logical" is a very, very poor choice of term for contrasting with that use of "lateral", as I've already indicated)"
I just simply disagree with you on this. In everything that I have read on the subject (unfortunately this has been only in books, so I can?t reference it online) The psychologists always talk about them as being direct contrasts/opposites of each other. I can only assume that this is something that isn?t discussed in the US, because I?ve been talking to others in the UK today and they don?t understand your avid disagreement at this use of the terminology. I don?t know what else to say to you about it. It?s just what I?ve read, and I?m surprised you haven?t heard of it used like this. Maybe someone from the UK that also reads these forums could post and let us know if they too have heard lateral being used at the opposite of logical.
"Fine. I never intended to disprove it. Why do you think I did intend any such thing?"
I never said that you did intend to do such a thing. Why would you think that? I merely stated it would be impossible to disprove, if you, or anyone for that matter, ever felt so inclined. :o)
"You'll get along much better in online discussions if you look for signs someone is not disagreeing rather than assuming everyone's your enemy."
Oh, and there we go with the patronising comments disguised as helpful advice again! You really are unbelievable! I don?t normally have problems in online discussions. You my good sir, are a one of a kind. I?m surprised you work with computers at all, you should be a lawyer, you?d be great at twisting things to your benefit, as you seem to be all too keen to wilfully misunderstand everything I say!
by apotheon
"[i]I didn?t think this would be something we would still be debating![/i]"
(re: flaming)
Neither did I. I made a simple statement that I didn't flame you, the intent being that you not act as though I attacked anything you had to say maliciously. In response, you acted as though I'd attacked you for saying you flamed me (which didn't happen), thus indicating that the statement was indeed needed, but perhaps should have been phrased with more caution so that it would be [b]blindingly obvious[/b] that no offense was intended. And yet, after trying to explain that, you're now acting like I'm attacking you again. I guess the moral of the story is that if you really want to be offended, I can't stop you.
"[i]I read your original response to mean that it was out of context regardless of where it was posted.[/i]"
That's your mistake, not mine. The way you read it doesn't match the way I said it.
"[i]I had already admitted this, and had apologised, so why go on about it being out of context, as that was self-evident?!?[/i]"
Clearly, in your rush to feel attacked, you have again missed my actual intent. I in no way meant to attack you over any lack of context, but to point out that when you say your statement is not out of context as a response to my previous post, you're mistaken, because where you posted it was within the wrong context. How can I know you got my point about context if you keep insisting you didn't post out of context? I wasn't specifically disagreeing with you so much as attempting to explain where the misunderstanding happened to arise so that you'd be able to see my perspective on the matter.
"[i]Your hint was unnecessary, and purposely patronising.[/i]"
Bulls**t. If you really believe that, you need a few lessons in reading comprehension. I suspect that what it really boils down to is that you want to be a victim so you can make me the bad guy.
"[i]You haven?t stated what contextual error I?ve been caught in, unless you simply mean I posted in the wrong place.[/i]"
Yes, that's [b]exactly[/b] what I mean. Within the context of a branch of discussion completely unrelated to the arguments you launched, you posted a bunch of ranting that would have been in context somewhere else in the discussion. The mere fact that I dared point out that I had no idea why you were posting it there has caused you to come unglued, though. Congratulations on a job well done: you've made a brilliant first impression.
By the way, [b]that[/b] was patronizing. Nothing else I've said thus far was.
"[i]I have never met someone that made such a big deal over a thread![/i]"
I haven't. I said the equivalent of "Why did you post that here?" and you turned it into some kind of uproar of wounded pride.
"[i]I really don?t see how this is relevant to this discussion.[/i]"
(re: statements about value by country of origin)
Perhaps you missed the point where you accused me of being a nationalist bigot.
"[i]I apologise then, as I made the assumption that if you were arguing in support of these people?s opinions, you also agreed with them. I simply don?t understand why you are arguing their corner if you don?t actually agree with this suggestion.[/i]"
You're still not getting much of what I was trying to say: I wasn't arguing in support of anyone's opinion in particular. I was just pointing out that you hadn't satisfactorily argued against those opinions. I'd do the same to someone arguing ineffectively against your stance if they misposted it after some wholly unrelated comment of mine.
"[i]I found you dismissive because you originally posted 'Women think sideways?', which appeared to me to be dismissive of the term 'lateral thinking' to which you previously had no knowledge.[/i]"
Clearly, you have a problem with assumptions. Assuming ulterior intent is dangerous with most people, and doubly so with me. Take what I say at face value in debate: I say what I mean, because if I'm to "win" any debates, I'd prefer it be for rigorous logic and strong evidence, not underhanded tricks like appeals to ridicule. Note, for instance, that the one and only time I've used an intentionally patronizing tone with you, I ensured it bore a clear label as such.
"[i]Which means, why do you think your opinion is more valid (correct, worthy etc) than mine?[/i]"
Ah, I see the problem. The term "valid" doesn't apply there. Correct or worthy (depending on exactly what you meant) would have been more appropriate. That's where the confusion arose. In any case, since I wasn't supporting the opinion you thought I was, it's a moot point: it's not your opinion vs. mine at all. I didn't express one on that matter in particular. You said "[i]I?ve at least quoted sources, but your argument has not been backed up at all![/i]" when, in point of fact, I hadn't argued in favor of an opposing viewpoint at all. All I did, in fact, was point out that your argument wasn't sufficient to discount the opposing viewpoint, without stating whether the opposing viewpoint's arguments had any validity at all.
"[i]I?m sorry, but this seems to be the entire problem here. You?re too busy over analysing the semantics.[/i]"
I find it ironic that this lack of attention to correctness in terminology came from the same person that said "[i]Saying someone is logical and another is emotional, as if they are opposites, is completely unfair, and shows an alarming and potentially damaging misuse of the English language.[/i]" Perhaps you should take your own warnings about the inherent dangers of misusing terms to heart.
"[i]Yes, that?s correct, I am claiming them to be mutually exclusive. When did I argue that I wasn?t? That had been my entire point. Logic vs Lateral in my opinion and from the research I?ve seen are mutually exclusive.[/i]"
You didn't claim that you weren't saying that. Again, you've missed my intent. I wasn't pointing out some imagined false claim about your own actions, but rather an actual false claim about the mutual exclusivity of "lateral" application of logic with just plain ol' logic. I phrased that the way I did to contrast your incorrect assumption of mutual exclusivity with your similarly incorrect assumption that I had ever said emotion and logic were mutually exclusive.
I realize that was a rather labyrinthine sentence, but I haven't yet come up with a better way to phrase it. I hope it's clear enough.
"[i]Of course I?ve heard of emotional intelligence, but I don?t see what that has to do with the emotions vs logic argument.[/i]"
It has nothing to do with "the emotions vs. logic argument." I'm beginning to get the impression you simply aren't paying attention. I brought up emotional intelligence as part of my demonstration of the fact that it is [b]you[/b] making the emotion vs. logic argument into an argument that women are ineffectual, and not the people who conducted the emotion vs. logic studies in the first place. Nobody in that study was claiming that a tendency toward emotionally based decision making was in any way undesirable in general, but you very clearly were when you started talking about assertions that women were emotional wrecks and men were logically superior. You're the one that applied "wreck" and "superior" to the study results, not the people conducting the studies in question.
"[i]The psychologists always talk about them as being direct contrasts/opposites of each other.[/i]"
Mass agreement doesn't add up to truth. That's especially the case where a theory still under debate is concerned, when the agreeing mass is opposed by a disagreeing mass.
"[i]'You'll get along much better in online discussions if you look for signs someone is not disagreeing rather than assuming everyone's your enemy.'
Oh, and there we go with the patronising comments disguised as helpful advice again![/i]"
No . . .
But there you go assuming opposition and attack where it doesn't exist, again. As I said, I've been patronizing exactly once, and I marked it clearly for you. This was not that time.
"[i]you seem to be all too keen to wilfully misunderstand everything I say![/i]"
That must be why I've spent this entire discussion trying to explain three things:
1. You're wrong about my intent.
2. You're wrong in your assumptions that I necessarily disagree with the substance of Edward de Bono's theories of gender-based thinking, or that I necessarily agree with the emotion vs. logic theory of gender-based thinking.
3. There's a (yes, semantic) problem with contrasting "lateral" with "logical".
Somehow, you keep misunderstanding these three explanatory goals of mine for attacks against you, your opinions, and the value of British psychologists on the basis of their nationality. If anyone is willfully misunderstanding another, it's you, willfully misunderstanding me. I've done nothing but ask a couple of questions here and there and [b]try to explain where your assumptions of my malevolence are wrong[/b].
by apotheon
"[i]I?m almost afraid to respond in case apotheon starts to think I?ve got something against him personally (which I can assure you is not the case)[/i]"
As long as you don't take what I say as a personal affront, and don't make personal attacks against me, there's nothing to worry about. Starting your post with this comment wasn't the best way to avoid confrontation, though: if I was the sort to take offense easily, I might see that as flamebait. I'm not saying it was, only that it might be misunderstood as such, depending on who's reading it.
"[i]I find it slightly dismissive of the work involved when raising a child or children.[/i]"
Nonsense. I'm not nearly as dismissive of everything female as you seem to think I am (note the word "seem", based on your reactions to me thus far). Keep in mind that men rear children as well, and that child raising is not the only obligation that might add up to an onerous tax on one's leisure time. Being a full-time student and having a full-time job unrelated to IT might easily constitute as much of a tax on one's time as raising a child and, unless you've done both that (as I have) and raised a child (which I admittedly have not), you don't really have a basis for comparison from which to claim I'm being dismissive of one as compared with the other.
The point I was making is that everybody, at some point, has some leisure time (actual slaves notwithstanding). If you really enjoy the subject matter of IT, you'll pursue some knowledge of it in your leisure time. It's that simple. People do what they enjoy. It's natural.
"[i]going by the women I have spoken to that have had children, they find it almost impossible to make time for any leisure activity[/i]"
And yet, somehow I find the single mothers I know still finding a way to go to nightclubs, read books, watch television, and otherwise enjoy a little downtime while the tyke is in bed, in a playpen, or being babysat. It's true, I'm sure, that leisure time is reduced, but anyone without any leisure time at all would shortly go nuts and start killing people, I think.
Let me put it another way: I spend about ten hours a day in and around work. I spend an average of about three hours a day doing directly work-related things on the weekends. In the rest of my time, I watch movies, read fiction, sleep, shop for various necessities, and so on, but more than half of that non-work, non-sleep time is related to information technology skills. I do that for fun. I don't confine my learning about IT-related skills to work. I create websites, set up servers, write content management systems, explore new operating system configurations, read trade journals, attend LUG meetings and hacking society gatherings, and generally geek out about 70% of my non-work waking hours. I love the stuff. If I had less leisure time, watching movies would suffer before the time spent on IT-related skills would be reduced. Hanging out in coffee shops would drop first (though I spend a fair amount of time on a laptop even when I am hanging out in coffee shops, truth be told). I'd bring computer-related texts with me to social events more often than I already do, and would turn down social engagements more often than I already do if they'd interfere substantially with my hunger for additional knowledge. The only thing that wouldn't obviously suffer before the time I spend gaining IT-related skills is the time I spend engaged in hugrily absorbing knowledge about my other passions.
If I had a child, I might even read to him or her from O'Reilly's [u]Programming Perl[/u]. I think the first couple chapters of that are highly entertaining.
Yes, having a child cuts down on leisure time. No, that doesn't prevent you from learning. My point, ultimately, is that your statement "[i]even if a woman did try hard to stay up to date [. . .] her knowledge of computing would decline[/i]" entirely misses my point: that if you [b]try to stay up to date[/b] you are trying too hard, and probably just don't enjoy it as much as some of us do. I don't try to stay up to date at all. It's like breathing for me: I know a lot of what's going on each day in the IT industry because I open OSDir in my browser rather than the New York Times in the morning. It's the very fact that the woman in question (or man, if we happen to be talking about a man) thinks of it as "trying to stay up to date" that indicates the lack of passion to be the same sort of dedicated IT professional I am. It requires more than dedication to your career: it requires absorption by the subject matter. If it was a matter of choosing to be an IT professional or choosing to be able to learn about computers in my off-time, I'd find another career. The career itself is just a bonus that allows me to make money off the knowledge I'd have anyway, and gives me more opportunity to pursue the knowledge.
In other words, it's not about caring whether you can keep up with the industry so you can stay current in your career: it's about pursuing knowledge. The career is a side-effect.
by carbynel
?Starting your post with this comment wasn't the best way to avoid confrontation, though: if I was the sort to take offense easily, I might see that as flamebait.?
What??!!? Give me strength!! Where I come from telling someone you don?t have a problem with them is a good thing. How is that flamebait?! I?m starting to think that whatever I say is going to be wrong according to you!!
?I'm not nearly as dismissive of everything female as you seem to think I am?
Assumptions again!! I never said I thought you were dismissive of females. Nothing I have read could have given me that belief.
?Keep in mind that men rear children as well?
Yes, but since we were talking about women I didn?t see the point in referring to men.
?And yet, somehow I find the single mothers I know still finding a way to go to nightclubs, read books, watch television, and otherwise enjoy a little downtime while the tyke is in bed, in a playpen, or being babysat.?
Really? I don?t know any single mothers that find time to do all that. Or any of that unless their babysitter is round, which is usually a couple of times a month!! Even two parent families hardly have time for things like that, so I?m utterly amazed that you know so many single mothers that can fit all that in. Even if they are ?relaxing? at home their children often get out of bed and come and bother them, so the book they?re reading needs to be put down, or channel on the TV changed.
?try to stay up to date you are trying too hard, and probably just don't enjoy it as much as some of us do. I don't try to stay up to date at all. It's like breathing for me:?
Ok, let me rephrase this then, Even if a mother wished to relax in the evenings when her kiddies were in bed by dismantling her server/reading the latest IT magazine etc, it would often be filled with interruptions from the kiddies, or she would be so exhausted from the events of the day that she might fall asleep in the process. I don?t think that is through a lack of interest, or a lack of wanting to read. Regardless of whether the woman is reading for entertainment or not, it still would be difficult with a couple of sprogs interrupting her thought processes constantly. I?m amazed you have so much time to do stuff, I don?t seem to work half as much as you do, but hardly have time to read for pleasure at all, it doesn?t bear thinking about how it would be if I had a couple of kids to juggle also!
by apotheon
"[i]Where I come from telling someone you don?t have a problem with them is a good thing. How is that flamebait?[/i]"
Implying that any time you say something a certain someone is going to pick on you is often perceived as flamebait, even if it's couched in phrases like "I have nothing wrong with you, personally." Learn to see things from other perspectives than your own.
"[i]Yes, but since we were talking about women I didn?t see the point in referring to men.[/i]"
Funny, I thought we were talking about women [b]as compared with men[/b].
"[i]which is usually a couple of times a month![/i]"
I never said I was talking about more than a couple times a month.
"[i]interruptions from the kiddies[/i]"
If you think [b]that's[/b] bad, you should try having an ex-girlfriend as a roommate in a studio apartment.
"[i]so exhausted from the events of the day that she might fall asleep in the process[/i]"
Oh, yes, please forgive me. I've seen the light, now. [b]Every single day[/b] is absolute hell, filled every second with the squalling of infants, without a moment's respite ever, because morning noon and night there is [b]nothing else[/b] going on but care for children, who [b]never sleep[/b], and babysitters are essentially [b]nonexistent[/b]. Yes, that must be it. No mother ever has free time. My own mother's painting and (wonder of wonders) keeping up with the IT industry when I was an infant, lo these many decades ago, was just some sort of lucid dream I had a few weeks ago, and [b]never actually happened[/b]. It's a wonder women ever get to breath, they're so busy all the time. Surely, they never have the opportunity to read six pages a day. That would be [b]impossible[/b].
by surflover
by carbynel
?Neither did I. I made a simple statement that I didn't flame you?
Right, neither you nor I thought you were flaming me, okay? Since we are agreed, do you think we might drop this in favour of more important elements of the discussion?
?you're now acting like I'm attacking you again. I guess the moral of the story is that if you really want to be offended, I can't stop you.?
Look, please don?t tell me how I?m acting, I didn?t think you were attacking me, and I haven?t been offended. I really don?t get offended as easily as you seem to presume. I can assure you that if I really found you that ghastly I wouldn?t be communicating with you in any shape or form!
?Bulls**t. If you really believe that, you need a few lessons in reading comprehension. I suspect that what it really boils down to is that you want to be a victim so you can make me the bad guy.?
Nice! I had the impression that you weren?t one to sink to the use of such unnecessary foul language. I did believe you made a patronising remark, and that is how I read it. Perhaps it?s a misinterpretation of the tone of your post? I don?t know. However I?m not exactly sure what the point would be in me trying to make you out to be a ?bad guy?. As far as I know it might only be us two reading these posts anyway. Is that what you?re worried about then? How you will appear to others on this forum?
?Congratulations on a job well done: you've made a brilliant first impression.
By the way, that was patronizing. Nothing else I've said thus far was.?
Right, this seems to be where the problem lies. I deem ?patronising? as being condescending, or talking down to someone. Therefore, I wouldn?t have considered what you just said to have been patronising. Rude? Yes, argmentative? Maybe, but did I feel like you were talking to me as if I was inferior to you? No. On a separate note, I actually don?t give one iota whether I?ve made a good impression on you. Strangely enough, that wasn?t my objective when I started posting on these forums. But I must concur that this notion is entirely mutual!!
?Perhaps you missed the point where you accused me of being a nationalist bigot.?
Oh golly, I never meant to accuse you of that, and I fear you have read far too much into this. Look, I don?t know you from Adam, but my initial correspondence with you did lead me to believe that you were somewhat dismissive of the theory of lateral thinking on the basis that you said you probably haven?t heard of it because it was a British concept.
?Clearly, you have a problem with assumptions. Assuming ulterior intent is dangerous with most people, and doubly so with me.?
No, personally I don?t feel I have a problem with assumptions. I just think that everything that is read online has to be read with some amount of assumption for it to be understood. Its not like you?re sitting next to me and I can ask you to fully explain what is meant by every point, and ask you to clarify the tone, or read any body language. Therefore, we do have to make minor assumptions. I was attempting to be polite and say the mistake may have been down to my assumptions, but really, I believe anyone would have made the same assumptions based on what you were saying, in order to have made sense on the post. I believe it was due to a lack of lucidity on your part to leave any of the post up to my interpretation. But then again, it is difficult to communicate online, and impossible for anyone to do so and NEVER cause offence.
?Ah, I see the problem. The term "valid" doesn't apply there. Correct or worthy (depending on exactly what you meant) would have been more appropriate.?
Right, once again, if you?re going to be blatant enough to base your whole argument on something that can be verified then please check your facts first. I don?t know if this is again a case of ?Two nations divided by a common language? but in my dictionary valid does mean correct or worthy. Referencing www.dictionary.com ?Correctly inferred or deduced from a premise: a valid conclusion.? ?Containing premises from which the conclusion may logically be derived: a valid argument.? Or from the Oxford English dictionary? adjective 1 (of a reason, argument, etc.) well based or logical. 2 legally binding or acceptable.?
?I find it ironic that this lack of attention to correctness in terminology came from the same person?
The problem is not caused by being careful with your use of the English language, and its good to want clarity in an expression; however, the problem exists when you are twisting and over analysing words until their meaning is completely lost or distorted, or you are simply unaware of the meaning of words (such as my point above).
?Mass agreement doesn't add up to truth. That's especially the case where a theory still under debate is concerned, when the agreeing mass is opposed by a disagreeing mass.?
No, mass agreement doesn?t add up to truth, you?re right; but it?s as close to the truth as we are going to get for now, and since my intention was to simply give an opposition to the emotions vs logic theory, it stands up enough for that purpose.
?As I said, I've been patronizing exactly once, and I marked it clearly for you. This was not that time.?
And as I stated above, I believe you need to re-think your definition of what is patronising.
I believe you have completely misunderstood me, and this discussion seems to have been reduced to a slanging match instead. I don?t have any problems with you. I don?t even know you. I?m sorry if I have misunderstood your intentions, but I?ve read what you?ve said and I (either wrongly or rightly) interpreted as best I could the text on my screen. I enjoy a debate, and was enjoying our discussion, but you seem to want this to be nothing related to the original post and instead seem to be trying to make this about insults. I wonder why are you so touchy? I thought debating was fair sport.
I must apologise if any of this is hard to understand, but its gone midnight here, and I?m not feeling quite as awake as I was earlier on in the day!!!
by apotheon
1. I never said anything intending any insult, offense, attack, or other unpleasantness before the indicated intended patronizing remark. Despite this, you've found some way to describe or react to pretty much everything I've said as though it were an attack.
2. Every time I point out a specific instance of you reacting as though attacked, insulted, et cetera, you then directly contradicted yourself by claiming some other injury I've caused you was the actual point of contention.
3. You've implied my malicious intent on numerous occasions, and had the audacity to in one short paragraph both claim that you didn't suggest I was a nationalist bigot and paraphrase your own suggestion that I'm a nationalist bigot.
4. This all started because I asked two innocent questions, in answer to which you launched into a lengthy tirade about how awful a person I am for having dared to be patronizing.
5. You've quoted at me correct definitions of the word "valid" that are distinctly devoid of any connection to "worthiness" while claiming that they support your notion of "worthy" as a proper synonym of "valid", and that's only one example of how you have utterly failed to get the point when I try to indicate clearly where you're using terms carelessly.
6. I used the self-censored string of characters "bulls**t" because it summed up in one word what it would otherwise have taken three paragraphs to express fully. Sometimes, succinctness is a positive, even if your delicate sensibilities are bruised by it.
7. I was, indeed, intending a condescending tone in the one instance where I said I was being patronizing. I was not at any other time intending anything of the kind. Get it?
8. I'm not offended by you. That would require me to care about your opinion and, frankly, I don't know you that well.
9. Who is the greater fool, the fool, or the fool who gets sucked into an unending argument with him or her? On that note, I'm done here. You may respond with lengthy rants about how uncouth I am if you like, but this is all I have to say on the matter. Offended or not, I'm a bit worn out by all this bickering from you.
by ldyosng
by apotheon
No argument here. Geek girls rock.
Of course, it's difficult to [b]not[/b] rock, when your competition is so slim. Genuine geek girls are one in a million, or fewer, it seems.
by ldyosng
by carbynel
Entitling your post as "parting shots" does tend to cause one to think that something agressive ("due to the terminology "shots") is going to take place; so if you're trying to prove you're not insulting me, it's probably best if you avoid such antagonistic language from the offset.
I will respond to point 3, where you say I simply para-phrased you as a ?nationalist bigot?. This just goes to show you how important it is you don?t over analyse everything (as you seem to be accustomed) and at least try to take people at face value. You seem to think that my only mission is to insult you, and are offended by anything no matter how reasonable or polite I might be. I originally said you seemed dismissive of a concept you had not heard of, this could be due to arrogance on your part; just as much (if not more so) as it could be due to any nationalist views. I don?t see why you keep suggesting I?m making you out as a ?nationalist bigot?, except for the fact that you read on wikipedia that the psychologist was British!! However, I must say that in my experience, people that act as if they?re being attacked when its obvious they?re not; often do have something to hide!
Point 5 ? ?worthy?. For starters. The initial point was that you didn?t understand what a ?valid opinion? was. Now I?ve proven that it?s correct to use this term in the context I used it, and if you had bothered to consult a dictionary sooner, you would have been able to understand me earlier. You are now continuing this baiting by telling me my definition of ?worthy? is wrong! Look that one up too!! You might get a surprise!! Www.thesaurus.com comes back with ?true? as a possible synonym, which obviously is a synonym of ?correct? which is a synonym of ?valid?. Got it now? I?ve never known someone so arrogant as to constantly correct people on things they don?t even know enough about in the first place!!
?I was, indeed, intending a condescending tone in the one instance where I said I was being patronizing. I was not at any other time intending anything of the kind. Get it??
Its not that I don?t ?Get it,? as you so charmingly put it. It?s that I don?t agree with it. I found nothing patronising about the sentence. Most others wouldn?t either. I also ?Get? that you don?t believe other sentences in your posts were patronising; even if they were.
?On that note, I'm done here. You may respond with lengthy rants about how uncouth I am if you like, but this is all I have to say on the matter?
Thank you for permission to respond to you!!! LOL.
From what I?ve seen of other posts that you make on this forum, I must conclude that you just enjoy bickering; and will try not to take your words too seriously.
by carbynel
Look, this was a simple comment that I made. It is one that I have established from talking with people that are actually experiencing the scenarios discussed. I can only tell you that. If you disagree for the simple reason of wanting to yet again have a ?war of words? with me; then I?m afraid I find it difficult to take any of your arguments seriously.
?Every single day is absolute hell, filled every second with the squalling of infants, without a moment's respite ever, because morning noon and night there is nothing else going on but care for children, who never sleep, and babysitters are essentially nonexistent.?
Such sarcasm is obviously just intended to continue the bickering, so I will try not to respond to it too seriously. However, I will say that babysitters for single parents that usually have a small income are essentially nonexistent, as most of my friends say they can?t justify the unnecessary expense for their own leisure time. I never said they would have NO time, I just said it would be DIFFICULT.
by jck
I tried clamming up before...and just not talking to her and Jessie. Jessie actually has been on socialable terms in the few times we've exchanged since then.
However, ITgirli piped up again and made little slights against me and inferences in relation to me. So, I'm not feeling guilty in one bit of minutia thinking what I do about her and expressing that. I stopped firing and she kept taking cheap shots. She broke the peace.
So, let her think what she wants about me. Just because I make little sarcastic quips or try in earnest to enlighten her to different points of view, she always takes it as a personal affront and that I'm just attacking her for no reason. But after all the personal indignations she's said about me that she has, I don't feel at all bad about the occassional banter I throw back at her. Humble pie is hard to eat, and she evidently has a really bad "gag reflex" in relation to her ego.
Anyways...I've spent enough time talking about her. I'd rather get back into talking to Maxwell about climatology or neilb about beer or gadgetgirl about Britain. I came here to enjoy myself, not have to fend off typographical suicide bombers.
by jdclyde
I was an innocent by stander!
I did see a need to speak up about the "sucking up" post that was thrown my way. Some "jokes" sometimes have a barb and as that wasn't the first time jck has said this directly to me as a way to make a slam back at someone else, I had to speak my mind.
The same happened when he got his panties in a bind at MAX. I agreed with Max on a few things so I am a suckup.
Just didn't see the humo(u)r in this joke, emoicon or not.
Maybe a peer mail would have been better, maybe ignoring it would have been even better. I just feel that people that suckup are people with no integrity and some things like that I take very seriously.
[b]
Joke about my (lack of) hair, weight, age, wife or whatever. All in good fun, right? But my work ethics, personal believes and standards, boys and dog are all out of bounds for it to be a "joke" to me.[/b]
I get along with jck just fine, even if he is a liberal in conseratives clothings. Most of his political beliefs are very different from mine as I AM NOT "liberal" nor "progressive" in anyway.
The war between jck and girli is theirs alone and I want nothing to do with it. I tried before to broker a peace but it didn't fly. I am out of it.
by apotheon
1. Anyone that uses a thesaurus as a substitute for a dictionary, trying to use word relations to "prove" definitions of terms, surely cannot be blamed for the inability to note causality correctly; that sort of ability to make precise relational connections between discrete objects seems to be beyond you. You disagreed with me, here. Don't blame your own argumentative attitude's results on me.
2. I never said that finding leisure time was easy: I just said that everyone does find some leisure time, and that someone really interested in the subject matter of the IT industry will spend some of that leisure time learning and maintaining related skills.
by itgirli
by jaqui
I've found that when the boss is perceived as "part of the team" productivity is higher.
the team doesn't see the boss as a force to contend against, but as part of themselves, so they respond better when you have to push for deadlines or for improvements in any area.
by apotheon
At first I thought your post simply spoke for itself and didn't require a response, but after having been ambushed by someone trying to hijack another discussion in which I'm involved with bickering, I need some respite from acrimony. So, I'm responding to you.
It sounds like you're exactly the sort of girl that IT needs if it's going to see a sustainable increase in the female to male ratio: someone who would "do IT" whether getting paid for it or not. Correct me if I'm wrong.
Those who pick IT out of a hat as a "career" are "power users" of their own computers at home, configuring them to run computer games better and adding doohickeys like rotating screen savers and nifty new mouse pointers. Those of us who fall into IT as a "calling" are system administrators even with our own personal computers: we might do something like alter background images, change Windows themes, and so on, but often only after we've done things like hack the Registry to turn off the Desktop process, replaced Windows Explorer with an alternative file manager like Total Commander, and installed network monitoring software (and perhaps a Cygwin shell environment). The administrative functionality and system internals tend to be more important than the wiz-bang color schemes and browser toolbars (I shudder at the thought of browser toolbars, really).
At least, that's what I seem to see as a major difference between a natural and a careerist. And yes, I have indeed hacked the registry to turn off the Desktop process on Windows systems I've had to use.
NOTE: It's not about what changes you make to a system to configure it for personal use. It's about how you regard the system you use. Is it a desktop system, or is it a human interface server? Are you "using a computer" or are you your own system administrator? I think these are differences between the few and the many in IT that most don't even realize are there, even if they're among those few. It also helps to notice that "sysadmin" isn't the only IT natural that's out there: hackers (people drawn to programming just as some are drawn to administrative tasks; not referring to the popular media's misuse of the term) view their computers more as collections of source code and development platforms than as "computers" with little clicky things. If you think in code, you're a hacker; if you think in mouse clicks, you're an end user who may also be able to program. Ultimately, a "power user" is just an end user who knows enough to be dangerous, and has managed to turn that into a way to make money.
I don't disagree that, statistically, women do seem to tend more toward a "work/family/life balance" than men in professional career fields. You're probably right about that. This seems to tie in well with what makes women more a rarity in IT than men, though. With a man, it's more likely that computer system and network administration is a passion than with a woman, I think. For the woman, it's more likely to be a job, and maybe an "interest". There's no heart and soul poured into it, most of the time, and even women who are dedicated IT professionals usually have trouble understanding the care and attention that some men lavish on their privately owned computers at home when they're not at work.
Here's another, perhaps more superficial, means of differentiating between the natural and the mere careerist: Does your computer at home usually have the side panels attached? It's not a universal characteristic, of course, but often someone really involved in computers for reasons of a natural love for the field of knowledge will not bother to reattach the side panels most of the time. I currently don't have side panels off anything in my home, but I just moved into this apartment less than two months ago. Give me time, and I'll be back to my old ways.
I think my favorite way to get women into IT would probably start with getting them to attend LUG meetings. Never have I seen such a den of wonderful computer geekery as LUG meetings, and the male to female ratio at these things is unfortunately sky-high.
Pardon the lengthy ramble. I just found myself nattering on about what came to mind after re-reading your post.
By the way, I said a lot that I think applies at least tangentially to this subject in another thread, where I commented on the differences between introverts and extroverts. I've used tinyurl.com to shrink URL length so it'll all fit on one line in this post:
http://tinyurl.com/82qhp
Sort by Trending