Why is IT nearly all male?
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by gadgetgirl
Say what you mean!
I'm right behind you with this one!
Let me know if you need back-up!!!
:D
GG
by maecuff
Because no matter how you package this discussion, it comes down to the misperception that females just don't measure up. Which is ludicrous. People either are or are not suited to technical jobs. This smacks of that IT elitism that seems to run through this industry. We're technical, so we are smarter. You wouldn't understand, it's an IT thing. Which again, is bullsh*t. It's a job. A skill that CAN be learned. If you have the interest, and you are of reasonable intelligence, you can do the job.
But then again, what do I know? I'm just a girl. :)
by surflover
The original post (which I dont think Oz was referring to a few posts back), was a question based on MY experience (I even said "It may just be where I have worked)...
I had no thoughts about women not measuring up... I would like to have more women in IT, but that's just because I'm chauvenistic :^O
by m_a_r_k
by maecuff
by surflover
by jdclyde
[smartass]
prove it..... ]:)
[/smartass]
Even if it were true, people GETTING a job based on their looks and people KEEPING a job based on their looks is two separate things.
I don't recall you taking about job hunting every few months?
Either your good at what you do, or really really hot!
by ltheodoru
I once worked for a white male who spent hours trying to get a PC to connect to the network. I took my laptop, and discovered that the network jack was not connected at the IDF in about 5 minutes.
I am not a social person, and am happiest alone in a room with a computer.
This kind of job often requires being on call 24/7 and traveling. As a single mother, I did not start in this profession until my daughter was a teenager. Now, after more than a decade in the corporate world, I work for a school system. Gone are the long hours and missing holidays (for projects that needed to be done while everyone else was gone). Gone also are the high salary, the 50% matching 401K, and the bonuses and promotions. But I do get to be an active grandmother for my grandchildren, and I have my life back.
by dgrissom01
by jdclyde
Nice to see another Michigander moving on up. Sure, it took time to de-program women from thinking that there lives are complete by being barefoot and pregers, to being ANYTHING that they have the desire and will to go out and become.
Do many men feel threatened by this? It is adding to the competition in a very competative field, so you bet they are. (or at least some are)
Welcome out of the kitchen and into IT! :D
by czarina_ote
by surflover
Here's some additional fodder for your argument...:^O
Reasons why its great to be a woman
Free drinks.
Free dinners.
Free movies.
Speeding ticket? What's that?
New lipstick gives you a whole new lease on life.
If you have to be home in time for Melrose Place, you can say so, out loud.
If you're not making enough money you can blame the glass ceiling.
You can sleep your way to the top.
You can sue the President for sexual harassment.
It's possible to live your whole life without ever taking a group shower.
No fashion faux pas you make could rival The Speedo.
Brad Pitt.
No one passes out when you take off your shoes.
Excitement is only as far away as the nearest beauty-supply store.
If you forget to shave, no one has to know.
If you're dumb, some people will find it cute.
You have the ability to dress yourself.
If you marry someone twenty years younger, you're aware that you look like an idiot.
You'll never have to punch a hole through anything with your fist.
You can quickly end any fight by crying.
Your friends won't think you're weird if you ask whether there's spinach in your teeth.
There are times when chocolate really Can solve all your problems.
You've never had a goatee.
You'll never regret piercing your ears.
You can fully assess a person just by looking at their shoes.
You know which glass was yours by the lipstick mark.
You get to hate Kathie Lee in the way only another woman truly can.
by surflover
by surflover
by jdclyde
that this could be the "real" Oz. There is no way he could have transformed his posts so dramatically!
Or maybe that is the anwser that was missing all along. He was gone because he was off taking typing lessons! :^O
by tmbrwlf
I've worked in the IT/IS field since 1999, in all the companies I've worked for I have been the sole female programmer and more often than not the sole female in the department unless you count non-technical positions like admin. assistants or those working on Help Desks (no offense meant - typically Help Desks are entry level).
Often women have to work harder than their male counterparts, and yet are still paid less and are not considered for promotions. A lot of women in the higher positions in the field did not get there from a technical background. Many women I've worked for have gotten those higher/executive positions because they came from Accounting. Perhaps some of it has to do with my working in the manufacturing industry which typically is male dominated. Perhaps another reason is the midwest culture (people tend to get married and start families young ... contrary to my European upbringing).
I've known several women who have gotten a taste of the field, are more than capable and decide not to pursue a career simply because things are still so unequal. It's not just the technical aspect. Women have a better chance of moving ahead, getting respect and making money in other professional fields that still require strong math and sciences (Medicine, Engineering, Scientific R&D).
In my educational career I generally exceeded most of my male peers in math and sciences. However, I too am questioning my future in this field. Frankly I'm tired of having to work harder than my peers only to constantly play "catch up".
by rexydog
A whole lot of discussion about something that is pretty obvious and depressing...
There will always be room in IT for smart, articulate, politically-astute women (and men) who care about what they're doing. Of course, they'll have to shove aside the good ol' boy drones who are there because they snuck in and stayed...
It's a job, and it can be very interesting and challenging, even with low pay and little respect. Lighten up!
by jdclyde
when your pummeling someone for being a clod! Almost as good as a good cat fight! :D
I would tell you what I think about this whole "where is the women" discussion, but as a male I already know my opinion is irrelivent. ;\
and if nothing else, I can out arm wrestle you!
by jdclyde
if it means I get ring side seats!
give em he!!
;)
by maecuff
by maecuff
by oz_media
You guys are great at pointing out typos!
In REAL life, I have an intern copywriter go over all of my personal copy, so I can be lazy and just pump out pages while someone else fixes them for me. For my actual day to day work, I am a little more careful and attentive and get paid to proof read my own copy. For this place, I couldn't give a damn. :)
by oz_media
Maybe I've been bangin' Mavis Beacon for a while.
You'll never know.
by maecuff
by oz_media
I don't believe that an adult simply wouldn't understand that first hand. Most people know it while they are in school, that's why people choose to work toward acceptance in certain social groups. To see an adult (at leat I assume an adult) coming up with these prepubescent questions is just ridiculous.
As I said, too much time in the dark basement on Friday night to develop social skills or realize what's going on in the world around him.?
by oz_media
by jamesrl
At my first IT job twenty years ago, I was working long hours (60 or more) for no OT and pretty meagre wages. I was learning a great deal though. Without me asking for help, they hire someone who had been a salerperson selling grey market satellite systems.
She wasn't extremely pretty, but she had considerable assets from the neck down. Soon a long line of men found excuses to huddle around her cubical. She didn't work hard, but she did manager to wrap a number of guys around her little finger. She tried the same tactic with me, and even though I was single I resisted going any farther (you dont sh!t where you eat).
She turned out to be charming, and lazy, never helped me reduce my workload much but schmoozed her face off. It got really bad when I discovered she was lying about the work she had done. Someone mentioned how much more money she made than me.....
In the end I got her fired for incompetence. Even though I was right, I think that and a few other matters darkened management's opinion of me and eventually I was laid off.
I learned some valuable life lessons there.
James
by jdclyde
by jeffhunta
Yes. Admittedly neither a funny nor original joke. The title was meant more for shock value and as a hook. Guess it worked to some degree.
I am not sure you completely understood my point of view though. Maybe my choice of words could have been better.
Basically, I am saying that there are fewer women in IT because it is not an appealing career for MOST women due to the way MOST women think.
I understand that men have the potential to be "emotional" and women have the potential to be "analytical." Of course these traits can be overlapping and are not gender based. Humans are complex creatures.
But the topic at hand really addresses humans as a whole, not the individual, hence my many references to "MOST women" and "MOST men".
Men and Women are different. We have different body parts. We are raised differently. We are taught to think differently. We perceive the world differently. Why do you think that there are more female nurses and teachers? Why is it that there are so few female engineer students? It is because men and women do not think alike and are motivated by different incentives.
As far as the stereotype is concerned, I call ?em like I see ?em. There is always some amount of truth behind a stereotype otherwise it wouldn?t become a stereotype. If you and your team have fun everyday and are doing something ?creative? everyday then my hat is off to you. (I am always surprised how freely we IT folk use the word creative. I would never consider finding new and exciting ways to manipulate electrons as a creative process).
Maybe I am just a bit cynical after 10 years. Maybe it?s a matter of perspective. When I compare a career as an IT manager/developer to the career of a Record Label manager, IT looks a bit dull, don?t you think? But compared to the Lead Fry chef at Burger World, I guess IT doesn?t sound too bad. Nah! I think I?d take fry cook.
by maecuff
Does dungeons and dragons have to do with anything? And no, I prefer real life over any role playing games. (not to offend any of you evercrack addicts out there). Or was that another attempt to shock? You know, if you want to be insulting, have the cajones to stand by your insult. Don't try to play it off as a joke.
Yes, I am aware we have different body parts, I have actually given birth more than once and am familiar with the process involved in procreation.
I don't know where in my post I said my staff and I had fun and were creative. What I said, is that we were rarely bored and that one day is usually diffent from the next (paraphrasing, but it's in the ballpark). I'm not sure how that translates to 'fun' and 'creative'. We do occasionally have fun at work and we're always finding creative solutions to our issues. We're smart that way. By the way, I don't know if it is intentional or not, but you come off quite smug.
My son is in grade school, there are as many male teachers as female at his school. Granted, there are more than likely more female than male nurses, but I know there ARE male nurses. And where do you get that there are 'so few female engineer students' Have you studied all the rosters?
I, like you, call em like I see em. And from what I've seen, there are quite a few women in IT. I'm basing this on my personal observations. As I have posted elsewhere in this thread. I've worked as a consultant and have been in and out of many different shops. In all those shops, except for one, there were at least as many, if not more, women than men in the department. And no, the women weren't administrative staff. They were network admins, programmers, operators or management. On what do YOU base your comments? On the fact that we have different body parts? That men and women are raised differently? No kidding. That means exactly dick when it comes to this issue.
by jeffhunta
Is the tension rising in your responses? Is my original title the real issue here?
If you perceived my initial title as an insult, then I apologize. It was never intended as such. Any man who believes that a woman is less intelligent simply based on her gender has no "cajones."
My position on the original discussion is based more on a theory, backed up with examples from my personal experiences. No matter how vast your experience in IT has been, it is clearly not enough to make a judgment-call on a topic that encompasses millions of people all over the world. Your experience is such a small slice of the pie when compared to the rest of the IT World. And you're calling me smug? Did you read your last paragraph?
I've been around (maybe not quite as much as you). I too have been a consultant and worked in a variety of different shops in the US and other countries. I also have friends who are engineers and I have worked in aerospace. So I think I have an idea of the gender base in engineering. As far as more female than male teachers, the following quote was taking directly from the US Census Bureau website:
"20.1 million (as of August 2004)
Number of female workers in education, health and social services industries. More women work in this industry group than in any other. Manufacturing was the most popular industry among men, with 11.8 million workers."
Again, to the question ?Why is IT nearly all male?? I say that in GENERAL, men and women think differently and are motivated by different incentives. At a very basic level, our gender influences the professions we choose. This can be proven if we look at stats across different industries. Not to mention that there are more men in the work place to begin with. IT is just another example. This is the point I have been making. All I am getting from you is that, there are an equal number of men and women in IT. That maybe true IN YOUR WORLD, but when we take a huge step back and look at the industry at a whole, we see many more men than women.
by jeffhunta
Is the tension rising in your responses? Is my original title the real issue here?
If you perceived my initial title as an insult, then I apologize. It was never intended as such. Any man who believes that a woman is less intelligent simply based on her gender has no "cajones."
My position on the original discussion is based more on a theory, backed up with examples from my personal experiences. No matter how vast your experience in IT has been, it is clearly not enough to make a judgment-call on a topic that encompasses millions of people all over the world. Your experience is such a small slice of the pie when compared to the rest of the IT World. And you're calling me smug? Did you read your last paragraph?
I've been around (maybe not quite as much as you). I too have been a consultant and worked in a variety of different shops in the US and other countries. I also have friends who are engineers and I have worked in aerospace. So I think I have an idea of the gender base in engineering. As far as more female than male teachers, the following quote was taking directly from the US Census Bureau website:
"20.1 million (as of August 2004)
Number of female workers in education, health and social services industries. More women work in this industry group than in any other. Manufacturing was the most popular industry among men, with 11.8 million workers."
Again, to the question ?Why is IT nearly all male?? I say that in GENERAL, men and women think differently and are motivated by different incentives. At a very basic level, our gender influences the professions we choose. This can be proven if we look at stats across different industries. Not to mention that there are more men in the work place to begin with. IT is just another example. This is the point I have been making. All I am getting from you is that, there are an equal number of men and women in IT. That maybe true IN YOUR WORLD, but when we take a huge step back and look at the industry at a whole, we see many more men than women.
by maecuff
by oz_media
Okay I can't leave this one alone:
"My position on the original discussion is based more on a theory, backed up with examples from my personal experiences. No matter how vast your experience in IT has been, it is clearly not enough to make a judgment-call on a topic that encompasses millions of people all over the world. Your experience is such a small slice of the pie when compared to the rest of the IT World."
okay, so YOUR comments are based purely on YOUR personal experience. Yet you then minimize HER comments by saying they are just a small part of the pie, as are your own, are they not?
"That maybe true IN YOUR WORLD, but when we take a huge step back and look at the industry at a whole, we see many more men than women."
Not from my experience either, in fact I see more women in IT, nowadays, than men. Then again that is from MY personal experience, in several countries and in literally hundreds of companies.
I work with IT departments all day every day, no I am not in IT myself anymore, but all of my contacts in IT are women who are IT managers etc.
So if YOUR opinion from YOUR experience is that there are more men.
Maecuf's opinion from HER experience is that there are less men.
MY opinion from MY experience s that there are more women, NOW.
I don't see how you can contest HER point against your own.
My overall feelings from reading your posts is first you made some comments to raise a few hackles, then you backpeddled realizing how "awf" they were. Maecuff is NOT a person that has 'female issues' so to speak, she is definietly not irrational or hot headed and most certainly anything BUT emotional, she's probably one of the coolest individuals on TR.
Your comments on the other hand have been inconsistent, hypocritical and just plain WIERD.
I know you're tryin gbut at some point you just have to give up, you lost the ability to make your point without simply conceding and agreeing with maecuff.
But hey, like you say, this is just my opinion. But in my case it is one of experience, I have read MANY of maecuff's posts and you seem to have stereotyped her incorrectly, believe me, she is one woman that doesn't fit your mold (or is it mould?).
by maecuff
Once again the PC crowd rears it's head where the real answer is obvious as h***.
Most people agree that men use certain areas of the brain more than women, and women use cretain areas more than men. This is why more men are mechanics and IT professionals. It also explains why more women are teachers, counselors and nurses.
If you get off your high horse and look around at the real world you might see that.
from Knoxville, TN...hmm, bet you didn't like that. The high horse you talk about, is it the same as me saying that in Knoxville there are only male chauvinist red-necks?
Opportunity and society are largely responsible for who holds what kind of job. Since when are women who are mechanics looked at as sexy women? Would you fall in love with a female covered in motor oil and grease? You, yes, you personally, probably EXPECT your woman to hold a "femenine" job, thus crapping all over what you just wrote.
by debitaylor
Yes, you are SO dead right. It is obvious as h*** that you have a part of your brain that you don't use at all; namely the part knows how to spell or know when it's appropriate to use apostrophes.
Have you ever thought women might just avoid the IT industry so they don't have to deal with chauvinistic guys on soap-boxes who think they are god's gift to the IT world? Instead they choose vocations such as teaching and nursing where they make a difference, where they get to interact with people who appreciate what they have to offer.
by ldyosng
Wow. Ten whole years. That must be about a third of your life . . .
It has nothing to do with how we think - it has to do with how we are socialized.
Women are taught from childhood to play well with others, share and nurture. These things are rather counter to sitting by ones' self and tinkering with something. It doesn't matter if the "something" is a watch or a computer or a wood carving. Women are socialized to NOT do solo activities. Intelligence and logic process are not the qualifiers. But if you want to break it down into gender, who made the intricate tapestries, lace and embroidery that were once so highly prized? Or how about a hand made quilt. Do you presume to say that these things are not painstakingly specific and precise? FYI, the best wire bonders at any microchip factory are women. I couldn't begin to tell you why, it's just a physical fact.
We don't go into technical fields because it just doesn't occur to most of us. Besides - have you seen the guys in the computer/gamer/anime club? They're not exactly attractive. So I was a statistician for the track team instead. Get the drift? Take a shower, brush your teeth, wash your hair, stop picking at your face, look me in the eyes - no, they're up here, near my nose - and talk to me as if I just might be human. There, that wasn't so bad now, was it?
And now for the big secret - us dorky chicks like dorky guys, 'cause they treat us like gold and they don't mind that we just might be as smart as (or smarter than) them. Just tonight my sweety and I were talking about Citrix servers and thin clients over dinner . . . .
by jdclyde
the dorky guys don't talk to you in full Klingon dialect?
The social part is changing, and future generations are moving into business and tech instead of being the stay-at-home moms they were told they had to be.
On the other hand, there are many women LEAVING the workforce and going back to being a mom because they decided that the feminists sold them a bill of good that they need a job to be complete. Both are a bill of good that no one has any right imposing on anyone else.
Some people are geared towards raising that family, others are go-getters that want that fast paced job as badly as any man could.
I just hope everyone here is happy with their decision and made it for the right reason. Educate our little girls now, so they can CHOSE for themselves what it is that will make them HAPPY. How many really successful people do you know that are truely happy?
by jeffhunta
haha... junior... I liked that.
ok so maybe there are fewer females than males in IT because of the way we are "socialized." But it seems to me that our socialization has a heavy influence on how we think.
And who knows who really made those tapestries. But consider all of the brilliant scientists and mathematicians. There are definitely more men than women on that list.
So I've showered, brushed my tooth, washed my comb-over, popped all my zits, but I still can't stop staring at your sagging breasts because after all, I am just a raging hormone incapable of holding a civilized discussion with a member of the opposite sex.
by ldyosng
Gee - maybe I've got muscles I didn't know about. I can lift a 19" monitor, or a server, or a workstation, or a deskjet printer or small laser printer or a fax machine - all by my little 125 pound self. And you don't have to check my shorts. I will admit that I ask someone to help me lift the color laser printer, but since it took two men to put it ON the desk, I don't feel too bad about needing one to help me lift it off.
If you see my @$$ under a desk, there's either an air raid, an earthquake, or I'm running cable and plugging in wires. And, I might add that no man has EVER complained about the view.
Please see my posting above titled "try this on for size, junior" for the rest of the reply.
by ldyosng
by jdclyde
Tell me all you independant women out there, if that boat is going down are you going to say your an equal to a man and not take that seat on the boat?
At that point, are you going to complain about sexual discrimination and generalizations?
Somehow, I doubt it?
While I think women are great (barring my ex-wife of course). They can be smart and funny, and there are even a FEW that like Monty Python and South Park!
On the other side of the coin, I see just as many STUPID men with no sence of humo(u)r at all.
I would say, the more logical PEOPLE go towards tech, and the more emotional go for a liberal arts degree and wear a paper hat when they serve up your fries.
Girls are being told it is alright to be smart. I concure.
by maecuff
by jdclyde
would or have I ever defended women being treated poorly.
Pay scales should not be based on your gender, build, ethnicity or any outside factor other than how well you perform your job.
Tall men with a full head of hair are the most likely to succeed and advance.
From the sound of things, I thought you DID get the respect you deserve? Sure, maybe I wouldn't always be able to look you in the eye, but that just means I like a nice set, not that I am being disrespectful of you or your ability.
As I said in the rest of the last post, I think women that are there based on ability are great and I wish them the best.
But on the other side of the coin, the women that think they should get a pass on skills because they can show cleavage take the whole group down. Like in everything else in life, it is the few bad apples that ruin the pie.
I would still save a spot on that lifeboat for you.
by acp2g
It would be nice to be paid the same as other professional men in the same field, but, I'm not going to loose sleep over it.
As for taking the seat on the boat, I think the situation would dictate the choice.
by czarina_ote
by jdclyde
Thank you for asking, I would LOVE some fries.
For someone that didn't need anyone to tell you that you were smart, you sure didn't take a compliment well.
Find someone that isn't saying women are just as good at what they set their minds at to jump all over. You have nothing to gain by going after me.
Toss you a little bone? you take that little bone and tell yourself who is stopping you from loving your job or doing it well. It wasn't me.
by gadgetgirl
We're also smart enough to take everything you say with a pinch of salt!
We're smart enough to know that there are some things that we can't do, that you can - it's been medically proven that you're stronger than us.
But there are some things we can do that you can't - having babies is one, I think that's been medically proven too!
When it comes to careers, though, we have to think things through more thoroughly, especially these days. We have to consider offspring implications - do we want any, can we afford not to work and bring up the kids, can we rely on our other halves to provide EVERYTHING? That's why we need to ensure we have a career that suits both us, and our lifestyle, whether single, married, with kids, without kids.
This is where the stress factor has to be taken into account. We all know that working in IT is not the most stress free job in the world. Add to that the fact that in most places (IMHO) women in IT are treated with some level of condescention. There are many reasons for this, not the least of which is the fact that we are inequal to you in your eyes.(Not all men, just a lot of them - TR guys exclude yourselves where appropriate!) In most places here in the UK, IT jobs for guys pay more than for women.
We get stressed out by the fact that some men can't comprehend that we can be technically minded. Men have a dig at female logic and say you can't understand us, yet those of us working in IT, for the most part, can't work without the application of both logic and common sense (which we have in abundance, btw, unlike our male counterparts....!)
I'm not entirely technical myself, and have deliberately kept myself so. It's what I wanted. It works better with my job. I need to explain to my users in THEIR language why I, as security, will not let them do something. In turn, the engineers can explain a technicality to me as to why something will not work, and I can translate that into something my user will understand, and not just ring the helpdesk and state that the engineer was no use at all.
Women in IT have to put up with jibes not just from colleagues, but from users too - like others, I'm often found cabling and wiring, and lugging kit around various buildings. At the last place I worked, my female colleague and I took a lot of stick when we moved out of the main building, with she and I uncabling as we went, to users making allegedly smart remarks about cleaning up the building for its next use.
So smart remarks, constant belittling, constant justification on top of other halves, kids, house, home, pets... Same as men, not all women are built to withstand the stress and pressure of a career in IT.
I agree with all the women who have posted here and said that we have to prove ourselves to our male colleagues time and time again. I've had to do that again this afternoon. But just one final statement in this rambling: my head of team is female, and knows nothing about ICT Security, which is why she employs me. So why do I have to justify every move I make to her, as well as the men in here?
One final comment - IT is my career, but it is not my life. I work to live. I don't live to work.
GG
by jeffhunta
I think your 3rd paragraph supports my theory that men and women select careers based on gender, but I don't think you ever answered the question of "Why is IT nearly all male."
And thank you for not taking my posts as personally as others here.
I hope you understand that I think women are intelligent and capabale in many ways.
by ldyosng
by blueknight
I think you're correct in that there are some places where one can find more women in IT than others. My observations over the years are that there are more women in IT in the public sector than in the private sector.
This may be because the public sector is much less discriminatory toward women. I currently work in local government and there are far more women in IT here than anywhere else I've worked, and a number of them are quite sharp, especially the supervisor of our network services group. The best COBOL/CICS programmer I've had the pleasure to work with was a female, and I wish I knew where she is these days because we may have an opening and I'd love to work with her again.
I think, like one post said, that women typically aren't encouraged as youth to study math and science which puts them at an early disadvantage when they enter the labor market.
I have worked with a number of women in both private and public sectors and those that weren't very good seemed to lack critical thinking, and to some degree, patience -- not unlike those males I've worked with who were lousy programmers. So, in my view, it's not related to sex, other than the encouragement/nurturing males get in math/science that females typically don't.
My wife is one of those who is fair at math, but not real good in science. She said she'd love to work on IT kinds of things, but by her own admission, she lacks the patience and desire to tackle a challenge. I think those traits are learned in the study of math and science.
That brings me to the curiosity part... how many of you ladies in IT were encouraged to study math and science in school and how many weren't?
by ddgeekgrrl
People who love logical challenges may end up in math and science simply because that particular passion can flourish there.
I was definitely not encouraged to study anything. I literally had parents who believed that college was a waste of money for females, so I put myself through. It was my own pig-headedness that got me where I am today, not encouragement from an outside authority.
This topic is one that I have tumbled over in my brain for a long time. I am definitely a minority where I work, and I have more experience, and more responsibility than some of the people that are currently earning significantly more than I am. Occasionally, I take time to wonder about that (without allowing myself to get too bitter) ...
There are so many things that I believe play into this. Although I do believe curiosity or pats on the back for math well-done play a role, I think it is more complex than that. For example, I know some young women who still seem to believe that their problems will be solved by an outside entity (father, brother, spouse), and therefore they have no force driving them to tackle things on their own (troubleshoot). This dependance on others for our solutions and happiness is part of a very old paradigm ... and it is very difficult to shift at the society level.
It also seems to me that girls are less likely to be permitted to take things apart. I have heard parents tell their girls that it isn't allowed, because they might break them. Yet, the same parents I see refusing their daughter, react to their son breaking something (to see how it works) as just him "being all boy."
From what I can tell, we rarely give our daughters kits to make things, unless it is fiber crafts (sewing, knitting, etc). We generally don't surprise them with an electronics set or a barrel of Lincoln Logs. I don't think it is a conscious thing. I think many \ most people just don't think of it. That's how ubiquitous the gender-assigned roles are.
We humans are amazingly complicated social creatures. I can't help but find that totally fascinating as well.
Anyway, there's my nickel's worth ... LOL!
Didi
As for math and science, I was an often mocked liberal arts major, and I still contend that a good liberal arts education teaches you to think more than anything else. The field of your major is of secondary importance. I did study computers (programming) in college, though it was not my primary focus. I didn't get very deeply into computing until it became interesting to me. That was when the Internet kicked in, and networks became commonplace.
by jeffhunta
I'm one of those invisible women sitting in a server room, behind a tall rack, supporting a WAN of 55. I am an I.T. department of one and I do everything from SQL design to exchange to help desk to blah blah blah.... if it plugs in (practically), they call me. I work for a non-profit, in the quasi-public sector. I'm glad I work alone, I keep the user-interaction down to a minimum. As a matter of fact, if at all possible, I will remote control their desktop from within the building to fix the problem. Sometimes, I work from home, and that is wonderful. Been at this place for six years. While it does have it's drawbacks like no room to move up- I'm already the I.T. Manager, it is my own world to do with as I see fit and they always listen to me. Occasionally, I do miss the interaction, but only with other techies.
Maybe I should go work in a room of grateful geeks like CuteElf (-You crack me up!). I bet they are appreciative to have a woman who knows her stuff and looks good.
I'm suprised there aren't more women in IT. I can see where there would be more men than women simply because men are more drawn to gadgets, machines, etc. But not at this rate. I, like CuteElf, couldn't have been happier that math and science were encouraged and supported for me in my early years. I just didn't know what to do with it until I "found" technology. Whew, thank whoever that I'm not a nurse, teacher, or secretary.
Fef
by stomfi9
The opposing part of the brain to the logic quadrant is creativity, emotion is in the rear quadrant and corresponds to list processing, another "normal" male attribute.
This is why so many accountants are also male, a similar occupation.
Any intelligent "normal" male will realise that if they want to use a whole brain approach to solve higher level problems, then having a one to one "normal" female partner is a mandatory requisite.
There are a very few of us of either sex who have equal abilities in both sides of the brain. These are the socially aware geniuses.
So you can glean from this that creativity by the majority of IT workers is not a requirement of the job.
by maecuff
mold or mould? Bob Mould?
I've given up on the whole discussion. It's not that there are more or less women, I'm sure it varies and there probably ARE more men than women in IT overall. That isn't really what I take exception to. It's this whole, ridiculous emotion versus logic thing. And as I said somewhere else here, you can't make that comparison. Logical people can also be emotional, how are they mutually exclusive? They aren't. It seems that it's just easier to fit women into this neat little stereotype that insists we are all nurturing, emotional beings who aren't as capable when it comes to a technical job. I have 4 kids, and I like to think of myself as nurturing. That has ZERO to do with my abilities to perform my job.
It's meaningless though, isn't it? Kinda like trying to talk to my mother in law.
by jeffhunta
...what the topic of discussion is? Let me clue you in, Oz. We are debating the number of men versus the number of women in IT.
My stance is that there are more men in IT. I don't think I ever wavered from that point. And judging by Mae's response to you, it looks like Mae agrees with me. There are more men in IT.
For some reason Mae thinks that I believe that women aren't QUALIFIED to work in IT. I never said that. I simply said that women tend to choose other career paths over IT. I used my personal experience and statistics to back up my theory not to formulate my theory.
You ladies have a monster "chip" on your shoulders. The proof is in these posts. Not one of you could respond to my post without explaining extensively how smart you all are. Please. Did you really read my posts? Not once did I claim that women aren't smart enough for IT. Yeah. You have to prove yourself day in and day out. You know what? So do the rest of us. Get over it.
And no. My theory is not based on my personal experience. My theory is based on logical deduction. I explained that neither I nor anyone else in this post could have enough experience or statistics to have a real answer to the question. So I developed a theory (a best guess) as to why and used my personal experience and stats to back it up.
None of you have provided a theory as to why there are more men in IT. In fact, none of you even endeavored to answer the question at all. You all just went off the handle at my initial title and began explaining how smart and qualified women are. That alone might be proof that women are "emotional" thinkers. You hardly can stay on topic when distracted by a silly comment. At least the old lady with the "junior" comment attempted to rework my theory. Come back when you have a theory to the real topic. Or go start another thread about how smart and qualified women are. Hell. After working for "hundreds" of companies, you're probably too busy looking for your next job.
by maecuff
by pmandros
by jamesrl
Here is one site to look at - there are many:
http://www.pbs.org/teachersource/whats_new/math/tips398.shtm
Its not intentional, but we may have gender biases in our teaching that favour men verus women.
Of course socialization has a huge impact on how we think. This is the whole nature versus nuture debate. There are enough studies about twins being raised in two different houselholds to prove that nurture(socialization) is more important than nature (genetics). And its in socialization that we learn the traditional roles and stereotypes about women in science and math.
James
by jeffhunta
I agree that you have made a clear comment but on tangent topics. Your comments were insightful and appreciated but did they answer the question of the thread? Did your comments attempt to solve the problem at hand? Can you tell us why you think there are more men than women in IT? No. Not yet.
And please, please, please, please... There is no hostility here from me. There is nothing behind my jokes and jibes. They are just that, jokes and jibes. I figured that all of your years of experience in IT would provide thicker skin than this.
It could be that you are projecting your own hostility and insecurities onto my comments. I did find a couple of offensive terms in your past post. Things like "WTF" and vulgar references to the male anatomy. Pretty hostile if you ask me. Is it time to take a look inward, Mae? :)
by apotheon
"[i]Would you fall in love with a female covered in motor oil and grease?[/i]"
I just might. I'm probably not normal, though.
by maecuff
Just a SMALL break here. Yes, I use the 'F' word..yes, I made vulgar references. It's my standard mode of operation and feel absolutely no need to change it for the sake of this forum. My skin is thick enough, perhaps you should check yours.
As far as the problem at hand, I didn't realize the original post WAS a problem. My only comment is that I haven't seen many shops that haven't had an equal number of men to women. What I do take exception to, is the archaic belief that women aren't built to think logically, that logical thinking is more the man's domain.
by oz_media
There's no way to walk away from this one. Just too many horrendous mistakes and assumptions being made, this is just good, healthy TR fun if you ask me.
First of all "Us women haven't been saying how smart we are (shhh Maecuff, I'm having fun here!).
My comments to you, which you seem to have had comprehension issues with, was regardng your comments that Meacuff was speaking from personal experience and YOUR personal experience proves otherwise. Yes there are some shops that have more men in IT than women, however there are others who have mroe women than men. In fact one of the US's largest portals and IT teams was managed by a woman who now lives in Vancouver and has since started several EXTREMELY large and successful IT departments for major web based services. now that's just one woman you say, but she also had MAINLY women on staff, again at a VERY large and globally recognized Internet portal, mainly women.
The last time I was in England, I was doing some work with a company who ONLY hires women for their IT department because they feel that women made the best staff, they DO use different parts of their brain than men, they are better at noticing DETAILS than men (these are just common psychological facts that everyone knows of course) and they were seen as being more rational than men in the same position.
So there's ANOTHER example from personal experience.
Whilst YOU have claimed that maecuff's comments were from a limited range of personal experience, you also state that YOUR claims are supported by personal experience. Obviousy, personal experience is valid in your own mind as well.
My comment was that MY personal experiece echoed maecuff's experience.
So are we having a pissing contest or are you man enough to admit that to make such a blatant and blanket statement based on YOUR observations is purely YOUR opinion and not fact of any sort?
(as you have claimed you offered facts in your last post, but without the actual FACTS being presented your only supporting argument was from personal experience).
It's like me saying he price of eggs is skyrocketing, because th estores I have been to raised the price. When someone else says they are actually going down in price in their neighbourhood, I can't say it's BS because eggs ARE skyrocketing and that is proven by my experience. Get real!
As far as why women wouldnt CHOOSE to take an IT position, again we resort to human psychology, women are more focused on developing social skills than men, it's an instinct that predates time. So if women are social beings and IT is NOT a field for those with strong social skills , then would it not explain WHY fewer women CHOOSE an IT career? As for WHY companies hire more men than wommen or vice versa, this is only obvious, if 100 men apply and 50 women apply, do you not think that by the mere odds that you would have more men on staff than women?
Do you REALLY think there are more men than women in IT? If so, perhaps the comments above will help you understand that there is more than ONE reason that women CHOOSE to find careers outside of IT, I don't think it's the company's preference at all, as my experiece shows they prefer their female IT staff, but it's more along the lines of what women choose for a career, women (in general)prefer more socialy active career choices...by nature.
by maecuff
by oz_media
by ldyosng
by surflover
Did you read that post from Gretz below?...
If you're that hot, I want your number ;-) (of course, this funta clown posted something droll after it) :^O
they are experts in math and science
every IT dept should have women like this
by gadgetgirl
http://www.nycwebstore.com/detail.asp?PRODUCT_ID=TP-FDNY_2006
so, why me worry, are you worried yet???!!!!
]:)
GG
some geeky guys are lucky to have a women "under" them or on "top" of them or simply anywhere near them
LMAO
sorry ladies if I offended anyone of you
by jdgretz
by jdgretz
by jeffhunta
If not, just ask her out.
No one is questioning Ldy's physical attributes, social skills, or mechanical abilities here. Perhaps we should start another thread to determine whether or not IT women are attractive or not? I am sure that one would go over well.
by jdgretz
Let me quote your own words...
>>I still can't stop staring at your sagging breasts because after all, I am just a raging hormone incapable of holding a civilized discussion with a member of the opposite sex.<<
and then
>>No one is questioning Ldy's physical attributes, social skills, or mechanical abilities here.<<
Do you not see some inconsistency in these two posts or are you truly that much of an idiot?
I do hope you are not a programmer as your ability to follow a simple thread appears seriously flawed.
by itinstructor
by acp2g
but your reply just sealed his statement.
Are you under the age of 30, Denise?
by maecuff
If we're ever in a boat together, I'll poke a hole in the bottom and see if you'll save me that seat or not. :)
I have gained respect over the years. It's just been a long hard journey. Paywise? Well, I don't do too bad, however, I KNOW how much the person (male) made in my position before me. I've been in this position longer than he was, and I do a better job and I'm still not making close to what he was making.
by gadgetgirl
Started in this position in Feb, and found out in April that what they had actually done was to cut and copy the spec from the managers job, and paste it into the spec for the position I now hold. And, of course, minus-ed about ?10k off the salary. Their excuse? They couldn't afford to pay me the going rate...... Funny how the security person before me was a guy, innit?
As for the lifeboat - you'd be better off with me than jd, Mae, I already know about boats! :p Besides that, being women, we'd stop and ask directions to the nearest island - jd wouldn't! (y'all!) :D
GG
]:)
by maecuff
because I know dick about boats. Other than I usually get motion sick if I'm on one.
I'm making about 15k less than my old boss. Because I went directly from a programmer/analyst into a director's position, I accepted less money because I lacked experience. Well, I've gained a whole boatload :) of experience in the past 3 years, but the money still ain't here. I'm just going to keep racking of the experience and take it elsewhere in a year or two. Y'all.
by czarina_ote
by jdclyde
would explain your crash in the first place? :^O
I know, (shovel shovel shovel) just digging it deeper and deeper, but I just couldn't resist that one, my sweet!
Besides, after seeing your baby, like you would get on anyone elses barge? B-)
(yes, yes, just a touch of sucking up :p )
by acp2g
by apotheon
The Tech Q&A section is just technical question and answer, which seemed to be what you were looking for. There are discussion areas for technical topics, though, and they tend to lean more toward technical matters, but there's usually going to be opinions involved as well.
Of course, what I have to say is just Right, so it could also be called "technical", even if it looks like opinion at first glance. Heh. My superpower is Being Right, after all.
by jeffhunta
by jeffhunta
Or read all of my other posts in this thread.
"As far as why women wouldnt CHOOSE to take an IT position, again we resort to human psychology, women are more focused on developing social skills than men, it's an instinct that predates time. So if women are social beings and IT is NOT a field for those with strong social skills , then would it not explain WHY fewer women CHOOSE an IT career? As for WHY companies hire more men than wommen or vice versa, this is only obvious, if 100 men apply and 50 women apply, do you not think that by the mere odds that you would have more men on staff than women?"
Your paragraph basically sums up my entire point. Looks like we agree. Thanks.
by maecuff
by xalorous
by cburgess
by ladyreader
You said you aren't a feminist. Why not? What does being a feminist mean to you? To me it means, among other things, that women get equal pay for equal work. Would you want to be paid less than a male manager doing the same work with the same experience? I am a feminist. And proud if it.
I have been in IT for 24 years, mostly as an applications developer. I don't make a lot of money compared to what I see on those salary-comparison web sites but I don't know, and have never known, how my salary compares to that of my coworkers, as in our society we consider it rude to ask. And, of course, no management wants folks comparing notes lest it lead to vocal dissatisfaction and demand for more pay.
At my last job, my IT team had more women then men.
by xalorous
As a geeky man who loves gadgets, I can appreciate your comments.
I'm also a sensitive, married man and father. I grew up with my mom and my sister, and I've always abhorred discrimination (of any flavor.)
There's an interesting dichotomy, that I thought was resolved in the 80's. A man can hold the door, show deference to a woman and still not be discriminatory or harassing. In other words, deference is not discrimination.
You (male, female, indeterminate something somewhere in between, black, white, or other) want to impress me? Want me to treat you with the respect due to you and your skills? SHOW me.
I am an equal opportunity believer that anyone I meet is inferior (in my chosen field) to me until proven otherwise. No matter what certs or degrees you have.
Oh, we had 3 girls in our mechanical engineering class while I was there. 3 out of about 20. The minority female was the first hired upon graduation, and had the best grades, but I wouldn't bet money on her being able to engineer her way out of a wet paper bag. That was my introduction to affirmative action (aka reverse discrimination.) Oh, and by the time we graduated, it was 3 out of 12. Not bad for a small private school.
As for schools pushing girls towards "logic/thought/technical skills," I think that is the wrong answer. I believe that schools should offer all students the same thing and equally push girls and boys to math, science, grammar, history, home ec, etc. Why? Because, carry it to the extreme. If you consistently, over say 2 generations, push the girls towards math and science, you might find the tables reversed.
Instead, schools should teach equality and demonstrate it by teaching EVERYONE the basics of reading, writing, math, science, art, psychology and history. Thus the preconceived roles will not hold.
In the end, I would end up in a technical field, no matter my gender or race, because I excel at spatial/geometrical thinking. I greatly appreciate logic and problem solving.
Cuteelf. Thank you for entering the IT field. And I thank every person who works in the field of their choice when the 'traditional/conventional' wisdom says they should work elsewhere. Damn the conventions! Do what your muse guides you to.
by ladyreader
Sort by Trending