Discussion Locked

Why taser a 72 year old woman?

0 helpful
145 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

145 replies

by av .

Late '60s - early 70's. A real turbulent time. I know it will never change, but I hate to see it get worse. I think they need better police training in how to effectively handle rude people without using force. Non-threatening routine traffic stops should never result in someone being tasered or roughed up by the police.

Today we are all "those people". Sad, but true.

AV

by dhcdbd

I do not justify the police and do have issues with them; but lets be honest here. The first police forces in this nation were composed of the criminals that the police were to protect you from. The theory comes from "It takes one to know one" and coming from a criminal background, at the time, the new Western Sheriff would supposedly know the players in the game. Take a good look at western history if you need verification of this bold statement.

The police have come a ways, but there is a long ways left to go. Unfortunately, from the historical days on, the political powers usurp the role of the police to enforce their position. The position of the police of any genre is not to protect and serve but rather to collect evidence and support prosecution. [U]The police are not, have never been, and never will be your friend in their official capacity.[/U] Some have empathy and will try to help you, however the police job has always been to bust you. Remember the 'Miranda' warning: [B] Anything you say can [U]and will[/U] be used against you.[/B]

by tonythetiger

[i]Although I did get ticketed for blocking my own driveway about a year ago.) [/i]

I got ticketed for parking on the wrong side of the street (the two hoods up and the big wire thingee stretched between the batteries should have been a big hint, but...)

by thechas

I would suspect in both instances one of 2 things were going on.

You either had a neighbor who was continually complaining about illegally parked cares.

Or, the local department had a non-quota ticket quota system in place.

I town I almost had to drive through instituted a program where the city police officers got to the top of the job assignment and time off lists based on the number of tickets they wrote. It was not a quota because their pay and promotions were not affected by the number of tickets.

Trust me, the suburbs of Chicago are very good at finding ways to make strange laws and creative ways to enforce them.

Chas

by tonythetiger

[i]and become the basis for a multimillion-dollar lawsuit.[/i]

we have every right to demand perfect behavior from our public servants. When they screw up,THEY'RE not the ones paying the consequences... WE are!

by dr dij

Perhaps the law now needs to be changed,

or perhaps if we let people get away without signing the ticket they then tend to endlessly claim that they never got the ticket, etc like the idiots who claim the irs doesn't have a right to tax them.

Maybe in this day and age of video recordings we could get away with not having them sign the ticket. On the other hand why make it more complicated meaning we then have to keep video of them being handed the ticket if they can simply sign for it

I mean if you don't like taxes get rid of them don't pretend you are special and can magically ignore htem.

by santeewelding

A morality play of the absolute here...not that you would get it, pushing as you do for the "better" in the way of the stupid and obnoxious.

by maxwell edison

Whichever. It makes no difference.

Everyone has the right to be stupid and obnoxious without being thrown to the ground and tasered by a police officer.

by techaaa10

I agree fully that the officer has a duty to behave correctly and work toward diffusing the situation. I could *almost* justify his actions if it had been a 24 year old male that was high on crack or something, but a 72 year old woman that is a real hard sell.

As a citizen, you most certainly have the right to act any way you want AS LONG AS YOUR ACTIONS DON'T IMPACT OTHERS. That is why you goto jail for yelling "FIRE" in a public building, when there is no fire.

As a citizen you have to be willing to pay the price too. In this case refusing to sign the ticket means you get to go to jail, normally until a judge sees you to enter a plea.

by techaaa10

I would not say we are paying them to behave perfectly, no one can do that 100% of the time. How ever, we certainly hold the officers to a different standard than the public at large and I stated that in both my original post and my reply to you.

I merely pointed out that as the person being pulled over, your actions do have consequences. However, that does not justify the behavior of the police officer in this case.

by tonythetiger

that I think we'll actually GET perfection... but we have every right to demand it... If the woman behaved stupidly (and she did) the consequences are hers, but if the public servant behaves stupidly, the consequences are the taxpayers'. And it's not right that we should have to pay for something we have no control over...

In other words, if I am consciously breaking my organization's (be it a business or the government) rules (not saying that the officer did... just talking in general), my organization should not be responsible for the results of that rule-breaking.

by cmiller5400

The LAW states that if you don't sign the ticket, you are arrested. Period. End of story. It even states that by you signing the ticket it is not an admission of guilt. This ticket was NOT a civil citation, it is considered a CRIMINAL warrant. If you don't agree, then wait for your court appearance and explain it to the judge or magistrate.

Yes, things could have been handled better, but as soon as she pushed, it's all over in my book.

Edit to add:

Even though the tazer may have been a bit overkill, it still boils down to the fact that she assaulted the officer (pushed by him) to try to get into her car and leave.

by techaaa10

The way you act in an interview, which is what the police are doing when they pull you over, can have a direct impact on what happens after you are pulled over. If you are combative or non-responsive you are much less likely to have a favorable outcome, either at the scene or in court later.

While it is true that the police officer is not your friend, he is also not necessarily your enemy. By refusing to answer certain questions such as "Where are you going in such a hurry?" you can virtually guarantee a citation. I have gotten out of many a citation by talking with the police officer and explaining myself to them.

Since I normally don't do things without a good reason, for instance "Sir, I was stuck in traffic a few miles back and am trying to avoid missing my flight." It was true, and got me out of a citation or a warning.

The response: He looked at my drivers license, didn't even run it then handed it back to me and said, "Please slow it down and be careful, have a nice day." I thanked him and drove off, and I made my flight. If I had not been responsive, I would have been there for another 15 or 20 minutes and would have missed my flight, and had a $120 traffic violation too.

I am not saying you should lie, and you should never answer the question "Do you know why I pulled you over?" If you are planning on fighting a ticket, should you be issued one.

The bottom line is, if you act guilty, or nervous you will raise suspicion and your chances of being cited. If you can clearly justify and truthfully explain yourself you may well get off with a warning or just a "Be more careful.", though that is of course at the officers discretion.

by beoweolf

You do not have to sign a "red Light" camera ticket either, and it isn't even issued by a Legal Police officer - its still valid (although this matter is undergoing increased contention as well as court review).

At ticket is a summons, not an admission of guilt. The fact that the defendant was present when the ticket/summons was issue is sufficient to be considered "delivery/notification", if offered in the presence of a trained observer (by definition, a police officer is an official, trained observer - by law). This is why it is expected that in any given situation, the observation of a Police officer is given more weight than that of a regular citizen - unless there is overwhelming proof to the contrary.

This official bias, that a sworn police officers version of situation is deemed to be more credible than that of others is the heart of my personal anger with police corruption and the often "light" consequences of malfeasance. The burden is on a regular citizen is to disprove the LEO's testimony rather than for the officer to prove that it did happen. His "word" is, generally, accepted as sufficient.

If you find that he lied, then everything he says is often colored by that one act of indiscretion. One "bad cop" can ruin your reputation, your life even cause your death... its no wonder that trust in "The law" once lost, is lost for a lifetime. If you have kids; have you ever looked in their eyes after you punished them for something they "really, really" didn't do "it", whatever "it" was? They will never again give you that same degree of unwavering trust in the fairness of life, the parent - it a hard lesson to learn - trust; and so easy to lose. You can explain all you want, but once found fallible, its impossible to regenerate "trust" in the system.

I'm only human, is the claim of many disgraced LEO's. Unfortunately, the rules and privileges they work under delegate to them extraordinary powers. We expect, demand more ... I guess, If you can't stand the heat" .....

by techaaa10

and they probably should be. Because if the company (police department) doesn't correct you for breaking the rules, then by default they are encouraging that activity and therefore should be held accountable for your actions (at least while you are on the clock). That is why most companies would fire you, or discipline you for your actions. Most public servants can be sued individually if it can be proven they knowing acted outside the law. The problem here is the police department is supporting the officer, and thus will most certainly end up getting sued, and lose, costing the taxpayers and letting the officer off.

In this instance, I think the officer needs to be removed from street duty and forced to take a class on the proper use of force and the proper ways to diffuse a situation. If he has already taken these courses, he should be let go.

Perhaps "Expect Perfection" would be more accurate, it is not reasonable to "Demand" something that you know can not be achieved.

We really aren't that far apart here.

by tonythetiger

is your promise to appear to answer the charges. If you don't promise to appear, you can be arrested (for the original offense), charged, and required to make bail (or sit in jail until you can see a judge)...

It's your freedom to choose, however.

by techaaa10

Parking tickets are different as they are not assessed against a person, but rather the vehicle (Vehicle's registration).

In my state, unless the law has been recently changed. For a moving violation, failure to sign means they take your license and tow your car, at your expense, and optionally book you depending on the offense.

It says on the ticket something to the effect of "Your Signature is not an admission of guilt, but a promise to appear in court at the date and time indicated on the citation."

If you refuse to sign, then they suspend your driving PRIVILEGES until the matter is resolved. They tow the car, at your expense, unless you have another driver willing to drive.

Much easier to sign the ticket. Refusing is just begging for trouble, not only with the officer who could arrest you, but also later with the court, who will wonder what you were trying to hide from.

We don't yet have "Red Light" Tickets, though many locals are pushing for them in an effort to increase revenue. But it is my understanding in states that do have them they don't add points to the drivers license, like a speeding ticket does. It is more like a parking ticket and charged to the vehicle registration, which is the main reason a signature is not needed. Again to be clear the Signature is a promise to appear, not an admission of guilt.

Police officers are generally considered to be more reliable than most of the people that are pulled over, because they don't have a reason to lie, they have little to gain, and more often than not they are more observant and have a more detailed recollection of the events, because they have to complete a report that they can then use to refresh their memory.

When I was young (17), I was stopped by a 'friend' who was an off-duty police officer (At that time an off-duty police officer had no authority) for driving un-safe in a parking lot. I had a bunch of friends with me and decided to show them what a smart @$$ I was and said something like "You aren't on duty you can't touch me." then drove off.

Well the long and short of it is in the next 3 days I got 4 traffic tickets from 4 different officers and 3 different departments. Was I guilty of what they said? No. Did I deserve the tickets? yes. I had to park my vehicle for a month.

If you feel you are being charged falsely it is much better, at least in my experience to remain calm and have a discussion with the police officer than to be combative . . .

I have also successfully fought several citations so the system, at least in my experience the courts do not apply undo credence to the police officer. Of course it helps if you have documentation, like the police officer to back up your facts. So I always make notes. I have even had a policeman not the Max speed indicated on my GPS before.

Of course if I lose my cool and start calling the policeman names or get upset, then when it goes to court my testimony will be viewed in a less than favorable light. So best thing you can do is, be honest, remain calm, and provide the requested information, supplemented with any reasoning you may have had for your actions. In my experience (Driving nearly 80,000 miles a year) most policemen will treat you fair if you don't start 'Going off'. . .

But that's just my experience, YMMV

by techaaa10

No, in most states the law is written so that if you refuse to sign a citation you are arrested. The police officer may or may not have discretion, but the law says if you don't sign you go to jail and your car is impounded. Don't like the law? Write your representatives, but don't blame the messenger.

That is not to say that some police officers don't step over the line. I will say it yet again. In this case they were both wrong. Though the police officer was not wrong to place the woman under arrest for refusing to sign, the way he handled a 72 year old woman was incredibly stupid. The fact that the police department is standing behind him is idiotic!

Yes, you are expected to do as instructed when you are pulled over. I have no problem with that. They need to keep you safe on the side of a busy highway. They need to keep them safe, and make sure you aren't going to shoot them, or drive off in an effort to get away. And they need to keep the public at large safe. Of course you are expected to tow the line.

If a police officer goes overboard with his instructions you should ask for a supervisor on site, make a complaint that you think what is being requested is not fair, and then comply. If the police go to far the system and courts can always be used to reign them in and if needed gain compensation.

Remember driving is NOT a RIGHT! Driving is a PRIVILEGE. If you want to keep that PRIVILEGE then you tow the line, if not then don't. Your choice.

Police officers don't suspend your Civil rights, and if they violate them that is a matter for the court system. No different than if I violate your civil rights.

by sleepin'dawg

was [b][i]The Democratic Party National Convention of 1968[/b][/i]. The excessive use of brute force by the Chicago state and municipal authorities sort of pushed society over the edge. Abby Hopffman, and his ilk came to the fore and North American society went into your proverbial hell in a handbasket. As far as I'm concerned, it's still there. I say North American because this isn't a problem peculiar to the USA. Misuse/abuse of police authoity is rampant in Canada too.

Prior to that, police forces had become increasingly affected by what I call the "Kojak Syndrome" which led to them being "Badge Happy" and increased the misuse/abuse of their authority and powers.

Police have a troblesome job. Who do you call first in the event of any emergency, and I do mean any. The police respond in most instances, in a timely fashion, but they never know when they ring a doorbell just what to expect, on the other side, when the door opens.

A lot of them are capable of performing as temporary EMTs, or giving CPR, until the real ones arrive on scene. Many a time a life has been saved by the quick thinking of some cop.

However, this does not mean the police are perfect; far from it. In too many instances the hiring standards for police have been lowered; policework doesn't require PhDs, and consequently too many bad apples make it under the wire. The media has been no help here, seldom portraying the police in any positive light. There is also a prevalent air of police corruption which, thanks to the various police unions, won't go away.

The physical fitness of far too many officers has been allowed to slide due, in part, to the unions and budget restrictions. As a consequence the police have developed an "Us vs Them" mentality. The "Them", being the ordinary citizens, are viewed as a threat to the maintenance of good order and discipline. They forget that the reason for their maintaining good order and discipline is to insure the safety of "Them", the ordinary citizens, siociety, the people who pay their salaries.

Is there an answer to this malaise; how can we correct it? Who knows but unfortunately I seriously doubt their is sufficient civic distress at the situation. Society is just too damn apathetic. We had an event involving Tasers which resulted in a death of an immigrant at an airport, The testimony of the police at the ensuing "public enquiry" was disturbinglgly farcical if not outright barefaced lying. It seems that the perjury laws are suspended or not applicable to police testimony. BTW their lawyer was supplied by their union.

[b][i]Dawg[/b][/i] ]:)

by tonythetiger

[i]We really aren't that far apart here. [/i]

I intentionally used "demand" instead of "expect" to assert my (most often ignored) position as his employer :)

by thechas

Max,

Many States and many local jurisdictions are running near zero tolerance enforcement of speed limits and traffic safety in and around construction zones.

While the dash cam footage did not show the initial violation, the news footage did at least imply that the infraction took place in a construction zone.

The decision to make it a ticket and not a warning was made long before the accused declined to sign the ticket.

As far as stopping with just writing the ticket or a second ticket, without the suspects signature, I would bet that even a mediocre lawyer could get the ticket thrown out on a technicality. In fact, I would not be surprised if the woman or at least some friends of hers had gotten out of tickets by refusing to sign them.

Further, I do not apologize for my stance that all traffic laws should be strictly enforced. Aside from making our roadways safer, I believe that strict enforcement of traffic laws lowers the general crime rate. Heck if you cannot get away with speeding or running a red light why would you think you could get away with robbery or other crimes?

I see far too many people driving in a reckless and unsafe manner every day. I typically observe 5 to 10 serious moving violations every day. Most are improper turns and improper use of the center left turn lane. Then there are the tailgaters and the ones who drive more than double the posted speed limit.

The answer to outdated laws, laws we don't want enforced, or laws that we want enforced differently is to get them changed through the legislative process. Not by asking our law enforcement professionals to ignore the law or only enforce it when it is convenient.

Chas

by thechas

Max,

I fully agree that the way the US is handling the drug problem is ineffective and a huge waste of money and resources.

The only way we are ever going to get rid of the drug lords and traffickers is to take the profit out of the equation.

As a side comment, the drug trade might just be the last true free market economic force in the US.

Yes, the cheap way out would be to stop enforcing the drug laws that are on the books.

The better way would be to legalize recreational use and find a way to fund programs that would effectively treat addiction.

But, the conservative candidates that have any chance of getting through the primaries and party conventions have to stand on law and order platforms that include being tough on drug crimes. So by supporting the Republican candidates you help perpetuate the drug problem.

Chas

by jackofalltech

In this day and age, 72 is no longer a guarantee of frailty. My father-in-law is 79, goes to the gym every day, and is in better shape than I am!

Other people also may not know that Police stun guns have variable settings and this one used the lowest one.

by tonythetiger

is an attempt or threat to physically harm someone. The only way words could be assault is if you are threatening physical harm.

Being loud and obnoxious COULD be disorderly conduct...

Insults fall under freedom of speech.

by beilstwh

I have no problem with someone not wanting medical insurance. However I dont want to pay for you. Sign a legal document that you will not go to an ER without cash or a credit card. That you will seek no medical care without sticking the public with the bill and I have no problem with you not having insurance. To me it is no different then requiring car insurance. If you get in an accident, the other side needs to be paid. If you get sick, I don't want to pay your bill.

by cmiller5400

I have to say that I missed the first few seconds of the tape, but from what I saw, I was appalled. There is plenty of fault to go around.

The ambulance was not running as an emergency vehicle (lights and siren) so they should have pulled over for the police vehicle that was responding to a call. The officer wanted to speak with the driver but the EMT in the back just could not follow the officer's instructions, to get back into the ambulance. I'm sure that the driver could have handled the situation by telling the officer that he was carrying a patient to the hospital, but that "supervisor" had to assert his "power" that he thought he had and try to stand up to the officer.

Again this comes down to the fact that you must follow the instructions the officer gives you. It wasn't like he was asking a lot of the guy. Just to get back into the ambulance. It would have been much simpler to just say yes sir, and go sit down.

by jck

That is when its citizens aren't being held responsible in obeying those who are given the power to enforce its laws.

He asked the woman several times to step back. She refused his order.

She attempted to move to re-enter her vehicle.

She refused his order to put her hands behind her back to be taken into custody.

What should an officer do? Throw her to the ground or onto the hood of a car? Break her arm? Give her a concussion? Shoot her with a gun?

She had no right whatsoever to refuse his orders, swear at him, etc.

He never once used a profanity toward her, nor did he ever raise his voice until she became beligerent with him and refusing to do as he ordered her.

A country going to hell in a handbasket is when anarchy is considered more of a freedom than justice is.

BTW, did you notice the woman wanted to be taken to jail at first...even demanding it?

Then when he tried to place her under arrest, she fought him from handcuffing her?

Also she doesn't have to be a "threat" to use a tazer or place him in "emminent danger".

She made a choice as an adult to do what she did. She reaped the consequences of her actions.

by onkel gunnar

An officer sees so much sh*t during the work of day. drugs, legal and illegal weapons, mad men, potential killers.

He/she has to be wary in every situation and be prepared for assault.

If you treat him wit respect, he will treat you with respect. Even though he migt be tired, it's damn hot and hes hasnt got his luch yet.

Be patient, don't use obscene language and leave out the F-words.

The police are our servants and they have a job you and i wouldnt take for money.

Of couse in evere proffesssion there are some assh*les, but they are exceptions.

G

by onkel gunnar

Coffe, tea ,tobacco, LSD, GHB, angel dust, cocaine, amfetamine ,pot, ethanol and several legal medicines are drugs.

They all change the way your brain and nervous system works.

Some are old some are new,some are legally and socially accepted.

Drugs have been around for thousands of years, and will be along as long as people are dissatisfied.

Perpettual happiness is not a goal. There will always be ups and downs.

G

by techrepublic.com

She was informed she was under arrest. She resisted arrest. She was tased. She could have been shot. When your ass is arrested, right or wrong, obey the idiot with the gun... if it is a wrongful arrest your laywers will get rich and you get off the hook with a few bucks... watch the video... the cop behaved VERY professionally.

This discussion is closed to new replies.