Discussion Locked

Windows End of Life Support (MS Bandwagon)

0 helpful
333 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

333 replies

by jackie40d1

I even had Microsoft people trying to hack my firewall or thats where the back trace went to
went right up their lines to their front door . . since I have gone to Broad Band I do not get hackers trying to hack me its like having a router out there in front of me !

by jackie40d1

If your happy with it why not say there until they get the patches/fixes in to what ever you want to up grade to. . . I am only running Linux and Win 2K pro now and as soon as I get 2 drivers for 2 things I am gone for ever from Windows as I will not need them any more . .
Might get your self a hard drive like oh say a 120 gig and add one of the versions from http://www.linuxcentral.com to it and see how you like it ! They got the newest greatest Debiun ( sp ) on 3 DVD's for like $50.00 delivered to your door and it's got a ton of stuff on it, anything and everything you could want to run is there ! Add Code Weavers Pro to it and you can run a lot of your old windows stuff on it like Microsoft XP OFFICE with all that junk that comes with it ( I have loaded it onto 4 Linux Machines and it runs good there . . NO BLUE SCREENS either )

by underground_in_tn

I haven't seen a BSOD since Win2K, and only once then. I've never seen one on XP. Ever. Bashing MS on the ancient history of BSOD is like bashing the Chicago White Sox for not having won a World Series since 1917. (They finally won in 2005.) In both cases, it's a moot point.

by jackie40d1

There are a lot of different desk tops / back grounds for KDE in Linux 2007 mandriva ( 6 CD's ) and tons of stuff there I even made it with different back grounds per desk top so they would know what desk top they were on

by jackie40d1

You get to buy the O/S over again their WMA stuff will bite you on the A - - ! I figure a few times of buying that over and over will drive people to either MAC or Linux ! So I Welcome "VISTA" with open arms hehehehehe like go ahead and up grade I have your version of Linux waiting for you . .

by jackie40d1

It gives me something to do in my spare time fixing the problems people have with it and puts money in my pocket . . So come to mama with those problems and bring MONEY !

by hal 9000

Have I got a customer for you. :D

They are a small Government Department who has just moved to Vista and I made the mistake of supporting XP from the word [b]GO[/b] so M$ recommended me to fix the mess after the initial install on the small LAN that they have only 2,500 Workstations and the salesperson back then had sold XP Pro as not needing Servers so when the Governments IT Section had installed the LAN to the design that was handed to them they refused to have anything to do with it again. M$ in a fit of helpfulness recommended us to this Government Department and we fixed the mess installed the required Servers which where supplied by the Government and just setup the system correctly. Originally I thought that was the end of things but every time that a new System Admin came on board we got called in to fix something that they had broke. [i]This was about once every 2 weeks.[/i]

The trouble was that staff change over was horrendous and by the time that SP1 came out insisting that the Volume License Product Key for XP Pro was invalid the then current System Admin rang M$ Anti Piracy Hot Line and reported us as we fixed things so we must have supplied it all.

I've now had 3 reports of this kind to M$ Legal and I'm not the slightest bit happy with a single one of them particularly when the last System Admin insisted on Ringing M$ Again and reporting us when they pushed out WGA and the system failed again 2 weeks after pushing out SP2.

I was trying to dump that place like the plague but as no one else was silly enough and the complaints to M$ kept pilling up it was better to fix than to drop them.

Now that they have Introduced Vista Section Wide I no longer offer any service support as I don't support Vista and hopefully I'll keep a clean nose with M$ from now on but you are welcome to this one customer if the money is all that is important to you. :D

OH BTW I'll still be getting paid in about 2 years time for work already done prior to them introducing Vista they are slow payers as well as nasty customers. I'm sure that you'll really enjoy working with them. :^0

Col

by jackie40d1

The only reason I had to up grade to Win 2K Pro was the ability to write big files ( Movies ) to DVD's and as soon as I get 2 items to work in Linux I am gone never to return to Windows !
Only for people still stuck on the Windows Barge will I run windows again to fix their stuff ( it will be on a hard drive and put on a shelf )

by jackie40d1

Some of the stuff I seen about it made me wonder if it was based on Win 2K and not a re make of XP . . As XP was a sorta ME thing patched and fixed til ? ? ?

by samirk

Till the better OS arrives I think MS has the credit to make PC revolution possible. 80 out of hundred are in Windows...

by hal 9000

If there is 1 single company to blame it's IBM who took a small failing Software Business and turned them into a monster.

If you look at what where PC's before the IBM PC hit the streets you'll find that everyone but M$ was a successful Company. M$ was failing badly and issuing Stock Options in Lieu of Salary to it's few staff. That is how those few got so rich as when IBM approached M$ they couldn't afford to let them slip through their fingers.

Then when MS was on a much more stable financial footing they turned around and bit off the hand that feed them as they saw IBM Costing them way too much money at the original deal that had been structured to save M$ from Bankruptcy.

If you want to blame anyone place the blame where it belongs right at IBM's feet as they made everything in the current PC possible and M$ into what it is today.

Col

by w2ktechman

IBM had no way of knowing that they were awakening the BEAST (your #'s went up again too, stop it!).
At the time that you referred to, this was a good descision for IBM. However, I beleive that at a later time would have been more appropriate to blame IBM. Look at the whole OS2 thing. MS was already becoming an issue, and instead of going elsewhere to write IBM's new proprietary OS, they went to MS....bad descision, very bad.

by jackie40d1

I remember everything had to be IBM compatible
When software/hardware came out And Windows is based on IBM's Dos 7.2 or some thing like that says so right in the help file way back when . . And then IBM did not keep their O/S 2 up dated past the Warp 4 version . . It WAS the last GOOD O/S made since then its been a pain. I had OLD Linux Mandrake 8.1 for a long while as my other system then went to 9.2 as it was the up date ( was to be best one out there )

by ghostbrowser

Apple Atari Commodore Did it all beefore Microsoft
The fact that microsoft was a minor software
house at the time is easy to forget
Microsoft software on these computers was often larger and contained bugs
Nothing has changed
Ibm Made the pc before Ms dos
Windows vs Linux Same thing ms larger and full of bugs

by rkuhn040172

His basic premise is that MS made the PC revolution happen.

I have to agree.

Sure, lots of people and lots of companies did a lot of the leg work in order for it to happen, however, MS finally put all the pieces together.

And not all the pieces are technical.

But MS was the first company to essentially put a PC in almost every home (at least in the US and other more economically advanced countries).

I would equate MS more along the lines of Henry Ford. Mass production, cheaper prices, standards, consistent quality, etc.

Because of MS, and a lot of other factors, PC's became a commodity that everyone could afford instead of a high tech piece of gadgetry that only a few could afford.

by jackie40d1

ALL software had to be IBM compatable ! Way back when I was using Atari Computers and writing programs in GW Basic and IBM Dos for the freeware group of people . . Went from Atari to IBM XT was a whopping 10 megahertz speed with 640 megs plus extra board with 4 rows of it filled with 9 pin chips was faster then my sisters 286 Radio Shack with less then 532 megs of memory . . I put a different hard drive in her computer when the other one died got a ISA IDE board and ribbon and she ran it for another few years ! Its where I really learned about computer guts and how to get them running plus programming them. . SELF TAUGHT since there were no big schools then in computers

by aran99

I'm no fan of MS and use XP just because it came with the machine, but regarding your question (why can't MS use an online verification system similar to that used in secure banking to verify and validate their software ?), well it's already there and you can activate XP online. That's what I've always done and never had to call M$.

by danlm

I assumed it was GNU, and one should never assume. Especially when posting about a topic.

Again, thanks.

Dan

by countupir

The classic mode you are referring to is for the users (layouts and anti-candy/gel/fluff). You still get useless wizard when modifying settings. Meaning you still have to drill down to get to things that were right upfront in Win98 and even Win2k.

by hal 9000

Admittedly not on the Play Toy side of the business it was only a natural progression for IBM to get M$ to write the code for OS2 as they already had a working relationship with M$.

If IBM had never of approached M$ for cheap software to put on their PC's M$ would have died a natural death long before they had a chance to become the monster that they are today they would have been nothing more but another failed Start Up Company which came along much latter with the . COM Bubble. So many people had missed out on M$ Shares that they just had to grab whatever was on offer as they all believed that what was being offered to them had the potential to become the next M$ so anything vaguely related to PC's where the stock to buy.

However since then M$ Stock has been devalued by a considerable amount with no signs of it improving in the short term at the very least.

What many people fail to realise is that IBM is still a big monster with massive cash flow and they have not been relegated to the back waters but are still the giant that they always where and are constantly at the Bleeding Edge of Development on the Big Iron which things currently seem to be heading back to.

Col

by jackie40d1

I think they should have gone to LINUX this time and had less problems to deal with load the Code Weavers Pro to the linux so they could run the Windows programs most business's use like the MS Office with the entire pile of stuff it has ( I use 3rd party stuff my self like Corel Word Perfect 12 office and Graphic's Suite 12 ) has less problems and always works

by rkuhn040172

So, how exactly is running Linux going to fix their problems?

One of their original problems was no servers. How would Linux on the desktop fix that?

How would Linux fix their problem of incompetent Sys Admins?

How would Linux fix their problem of high turnover?

How would Linux fix their problem of paying support late?

This is laughable at best. I never really realized that Linux was so powerful, so feature rich, so complete that it was able to fix non-technical issues like these.

If I convert to Linux on my PC at home, can I stop cutting my grass? Stop doing laundry? Will it wash my car?

Your comments are silly and make you look like a fool.

by neon samurai

"
I never really realized that Linux was so powerful, so feature rich, so complete that it was able to fix non-technical issues like these.
"

But then, you where being funny and haven't actually taken the time to learn anything about the OS outside of what your Microsoft Get the Fud pamphlet told you right?

Seriously though; That avatar icon. what's with the blind hate? You couldn't find an avatar that depicted the benifits of what you like so you had to pick one too denegrate what you don't understand? Your my hero.

by jackie40d1

1. fix their problem of incompetent Sys Admins?
The Above is a MAJOR problem for any company which if they DO NOT FIX they will not get the rest working . . But Linux helps get some of that done with its security . . Makes the IT person not look quit so bad . .

by jackie40d1

I had to reinstall XP on several machines as the person did not have a Internet connection . . kinda hard to do a online with no way to get there ( there are about 7 or 8 copies of same windows XP ) out there for that reason ! Since they will never go on line and do not want to .

by jackie40d1

I was really piss off when IBM stopped upgrading it . . I had HPFS for files and was much better than windows ever was or could be and a ga-zillion times more secure . . OS2 was the bankers choice for security till IBM stopped supporting it . . And since windows has taken over banks they have become more a place hackers like to visit . .

by mwradio

Ubuntu Live 6.10 "Edgy Eft" Desktop
Gateway PII 300Mhz 128Mb
Dual Boot with XP

To install from the live CD I had to go to 192Mb of memory and kill the fancy GUI. After Ubuntu was installed I returned the extra 64Mb back to the machine I borrowed it from and am running nicely in the 128Mb

1) Make sure to use a partitioning software to make free space on the drive for the Ubuntu to install to, unless you are going to wipe the entire current contents of the hard drive. Use the auto partion when you get to that point. I could not get the manual partioning in Ubuntu to work. It always locked up.
2) Put the CDROM in the drive and boot.
3) Once at the Ubuntu boot screen move to "Safe Graphical Mode"
4) Press F6 to get to the startup parameters and flags, use the left or right arrow keys to move to the end and remove the "Splash" option completely. Then delete the "quiet" and replace it with "verbose".
5) Wait for the system to boot fully and get into Gnome,(25 minutes on mine!)
6) Then kill the GUI and start a limited GUI with a terminal window.
Ctrl+ALT+F1 (to switch to tty1 terminal)
Hit enter to get prompt (You should see the Ubuntu command prompt on a black screen at this point, note your system will probably still be running slow.)
Type "Sudo pgrep gdm"
You will get an output with two PID #s something like:
5098
5074
of course the numbers are varied and most likely yours will not match.
Type "sudo kill " for each of the two numbers, this will kill the gdm (or Gnome Display Manager).
Type "xinit" this will start a very basic x with a terminal and there is no need to run any more programs.
Now your ready to start the install. Your Live boot should run somewhat better now that you don't have the fairly bulky display manager running.
7) Type "sudo ubiquity" at the prompt and wait for the install to appear. Insert your information for the first 4 steps. (Time zones, user names etc.)
8) Now your at a possible trouble point. I am going to recommend that you either:
a) erase the entire disk (if you backed up your data) and let Ubuntu do the partitioning, (You can always resize partitions later to get the partition table how you want it.) Let the installer run, follow the wizard and read through the output the program gives you to make sure its correct.
b) Auto install to the largest availble space. If you partioned like I suggested in step 1.
You can try a manual partitioning, and may have luck but my PC constantly froze.

With any luck you will reboot into a freshly installed Ubuntu desktop on your old hardware with minimal difficulty.

This guide based on info generously supplied by Magic-Ninja on the Ubuntu help site.

by jhecht

If you want to bleed - and make your customers bleed - on so called 'cutting edge" software, go ahead...

All five computers were brand new, fresh out of the box, supposedly 'optimized' at the factory.

Four out of the five (now five out of six) gave me problems with really basic operations, like setting up DSL with Verizon. Or don't you think MS should test its new OS with a nationally used ISP's install CD?

One guy had a digi-camera that Vista would not eat the 4 GB flash card from - known Vista bug - this is the multi-media OS of the future? 4 GB cards are common today, why didn't MS catch this?

I'm sure Vista has better 'security'. My point is, WAY too many things break on it for a commercial OS that costs $400 for the full version. And MS is pushing this cr@p down everyone's throat, by forcing computer makers to install it on all new boxes, instead of allowing a choice of XP/Vista.

Go run Puppy Linux - it loads entirely in ram, is blindingly fast, sets up for ethernet in five minutes or less, is FREE, and was coded from GNU linux by basically one person, with some 'help from his friends.' Whole distro is 85 MB, and includes FREE MS compatible word processing & spreadsheet software, along with a ton of other excellent programs. Yeah, it has its speedbumps, too.

My point is that distros like Puppy are made by small groups of underfunded people, who typically run rings around Micro$oft when it comes to 'bang for the buck'.

Then we have MS itself, which has zillions of bucks, tons of people, and somehow manages to create OS's that require ever faster/bigger/more hardware, instead of LEARNING how developers like Barry Kauler (Puppy) make lovely, tiny, highly functional, and intuitive OS's, that still run (even better) on the latest hardware.

Do you think it both right and inevitable that everyone should buy a new computer every three years? That this is the natural order of things? Let me clue you - not everybody can - especially worldwide...

And speaking from a worldwide perspective, it is much more ecological to re-use older computers AS computers, than it is to try to 'recycle' the wire, gold, etc.

Whole provinces of China are now so polluted by such 'recycling' of US computers, that drinking water has to be trucked in from 30 miles away.

Workers move through clouds of carcinogenic smoke unprotected. This is the dark side of the consumerist newer/faster/better throwaway mentality...

We do not have to throw away functioning computers to accommodate the latest bloatcode.

OS's CAN work with smaller resources - if they are designed properly - Vista is (IMHO) not so designed. Rather, I think it is more designed to FORCE yet another round of hardware upgrades. Thus, I call it a FAILURE - it does NOT run well/fast on TODAY'S hardware. Clear now?

by rkuhn040172

1) I don't believe in cutting edge but I also don't believe in anything right now under a 3.0 Ghz processor and/or a dual core, minimum 1 Gb of RAM. If you can't afford that, fine, then lower your expectations.

2) "'optimized' at the factory" is crap. Do your job and optimize it. That's not MS's problem, that's whomever you bought the PC from such as Dell, HP, genericware, etc. They don't optimize, they bloat and put on crapware.

3) If you are setting people up using the Verizon install CD instead of putting a router/firewall between them and the modem, you're fired. If you install a hardware router/firewall between them and the modem, you don't need the crappy Verizon install CD.

4) My guess is your 4 Gb card is crap. Can you provide specs, brand, etc or are you saying all 4 Gb cards are bad?

5) Vista doesn't cost $400. Not even close. Upgrades are less than half of that, OEM is about half, and with a new PC, well...a lot less! You cherry picked the most expensive way too go, namely, Vista Ultimate full install no upgrade...few people will go that route.

6) If you go to the major PC manufacturers right now, you can select XP on many of their business product lines. Again though, not MS's fault, it's the manufacturer not offering it. MS still offers it.

7) Puppy Linux. Let's see, blindingly fast because it is loaded entirely into RAM. Unless and until you want more than Puppy offers and/or don't have enough RAM to load it entirely into RAM.

If I could load XP entirely into RAM, it would be smoking hot too. Fortunately, XP is a full suite OS offering many times over the functionality and features that Puppy can't even touch.

That's a crap argument. Of course, anything that loads into RAM only is going to be faster than an OS that requires a hard drive.

How about comparing apples to apples next time? Or, what happens if you run Puppy with say only 256 Mb of RAM? Open 10 or more programs while surfing the web and editing a photo?

8) Thank God you trust an OS written by one person and with the 'help from his friends.'
I sure don't. I hope he never packs it up and goes on permanent retirement.

9) The best open source office suite is probably OpenOffice.org. And first off, it won't fit on a distro that is only 85 MB. It is probably 2-3 times that itself.

Second, it chokes on MS compatibility on anything but the most basic features. Try writing macros, advanced charts or tables, or VBA code. NT.

I don't just give my people a word processor or spreadsheet, I give them a word processor or spreadsheet, ask them what they do, and then automate the crap out of it.

10) I'll give you the bang for the buck argument. Hey, Linux is free and you get what you pay for. That's pretty simple.

11) Chicken and egg here. Does MS really constantly require faster hardware or does companies like Intel keep producing it and therefore MS just puts it to work?

Give me a break. Do you really think that even if MS's newest OS ran on a PII 300 that Intel would just sit around and keep making PII's because they're profitable?

12) I could care less if people can't buy a new PC every 3 years or so. They do have alternatives, as you have so rightly pointed out here.

What I want is the latest, greatest, resource hogging, eye candy that I can get my greedy little hands on. I'm can pay for it so go back to your socialist/Democratic/Hillary Clinton loving hole you live in and leave me alone.

I'll put MS on my PC because I want MS and even if I have to fork out 2,3,4 times the cash that you do, I have it so that's not a point of consideration.

13) Recycling, well, you have a point but soon, very soon, with the whole "greening" of IT, that'll change. The newest, latest, greatest PC's will use a fraction of the electric of older PC's and still be exponentially faster.

14) Not clear at all! Tell me, so, you want to continue to reuse instead of recycle PC's. I want to play the latest, greatest version of Doom with super realistic graphics.

How are you going to give me that with Linux on a PII or PIII?

Or, since I work for a home builder, how exactly are you going to enable my CAD designers to draw 3D representations of homes on these old POS's?

You can have the fastest OS in the world, but if the applications designed for it and consumers want are resource hoggy themselves, games over.

Thanks for giving me a fast OS, too bad none of the apps I need are as fast.

by jhecht

>1) I don't believe in cutting edge but I also don't believe in anything right now under a 3.0 Ghz processor and/or a dual core, minimum 1 Gb

>of RAM. If you can't afford that, fine, then lower your expectations.

So you "don't believe" in the majority of installed computers in the world? Just because you think them inferior does not make them go away.

The difference between us, is that I try and fit the OS to a user's needs and budget. You just say "get a bigger budget, or you aren't worth my effort to help you."

>2) "'optimized' at the factory" is crap. Do your job and optimize it. That's not MS's problem, that's whomever you bought the PC from such as

>Dell, HP, genericware, etc. They don't optimize, they bloat and put on crapware.

Agreed, computer makers load up new boxes with crap, to con customers into thinking they got great value. FWIW, I am not the one typically buying the computer - I do a lot of work for companies like CompUSA, where people are often pathetically mis-advised by ignorant/indifferent salespeople to buy inappropriate computers.

I then go out to install the new box, on a fixed fee call that gives me very limited time, and typically zero budget for cool stuff like a router/hardware firewall. My job is to get them maximum functionality in a very short time. To start, I turn off all the XP/Vista eye candy crap, turn off as many TSR's as I can, disable unused devices (like infra-red connect when there are no i-r devices), and in general, try to pare down what's running to a more efficient configuration.

>3) If you are setting people up using the Verizon install CD instead of putting a router/firewall between them and the modem, you're fired. If

>you install a hardware router/firewall between them and the modem, you don't need the crappy Verizon install CD.

Please see above. What part of no budget/no time don't you understand? My job is (often) to take it out of the box, and make it work RIGHT NOW! No trips to the computer store, no money for extra gear. And you want to fire me for dealing with a f----d up situation? Sheesh!

>4) My guess is your 4 Gb card is crap. Can you provide specs, brand, etc or are you saying all 4 Gb cards are bad?

The card worked in the guy's camera, worked at Kinko's, and did NOT work on his spiffy, new Vista computer. It is a HP, when I called HP tech support, they said the 4 GB Vista bug was biting them. No, I don't think 4 GB cards are bad, I think MS quality control, and beta testing are bad...

>5) Vista doesn't cost $400. Not even close. Upgrades are less than half of that, OEM is about half, and with a new PC, well...a lot less! You

>cherry picked the most expensive way too go, namely, Vista Ultimate full install no upgrade...few people will go that route.

Uh, Mr. System Administrator, which do you think is the better install - an 'upgrade', or a 'clean' install? No, most won't go for Vista Ultimate, PRECISELY because it costs $400 - but they SHOULD. All the lower versions are variations on the word 'crippleware'.

>6) If you go to the major PC manufacturers right now, you can select XP on many of their business product lines. Again though, not MS's fault,

>it's the manufacturer not offering it. MS still offers it.

This shows EXACTLY your narrowness of viewpoint. On the BIZ lines, maybe. On the CONSUMER lines, XP is rarely an option - but it should be...
And I kind of think there's a lot of arm-twisting by MS to push Vista in every way possible.

>7) Puppy Linux. Let's see, blindingly fast because it is loaded entirely into RAM. Unless and until you want more than Puppy offers and/or

>don't have enough RAM to load it entirely into RAM.

Puppy works very well from a hard drive install. As for features, see below.

>If I could load XP entirely into RAM, it would be smoking hot too. Fortunately, XP is a full suite OS offering many times over the

>functionality and features that Puppy can't even touch.

This is what is stock, or downloadable, for free, for Puppy.
And it's a LOT more than you get on a stock Vista box!
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Wordprocessing Web page editing Personal accounting

Abiword, imports & exports MS Word documents, embedded image editing
Composer WYSIWYG editing. Bluefish code editing and Amaya are packages
Xfinans personal accounting, Grisbi and Qhacc are packages

Instant messenging Addressbook, Calendar Web browser

Gaim, supports IRC, ICQ, Jabber, MSN, Yahoo
Ical, Gaby, Agenda
Seamonkey, with Flash and Gxine multimedia plugins

Spreadsheet editor File manager Desktop publishing

Gnumeric, imports & exports MS Excel
Rox-Filer, uXplor, MToolsFM, GTKSee
Scribus, on CD or as a package

Vector image editing Outliner, organiser Bitmap image editing

InkLite. Sodipodi, Dia, Figurine and Inkscape are packages
DidiWiki, (VYM, Tuxcards are packages)
mtPaint. Xpaint & Gimp are packages

Audio Video Games

Gxine to play local & streaming, XfreeCD, ripperX, Sweep
Gxine to play DVDs, local & streaming Internet video
Gemgame, Bubbles, GTKfish, Rubix, tkMines

Conversion, printing, scanning Package management Network

GsView Postscript & PDF viewer, PDQ printing, etc
PupGet, DotPup, point & click download and install lots of extra applications
GKDial, Xeznet, Wvdial, Roaring Penguin, RDP, VNC, Superscan

Window manager Database Help

JWM. Fvwm95 & IceWM are packages
Sqlite. Quisp SQL database is a package
Many megabytes of help pages in the Puppy CD
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

>That's a crap argument. Of course, anything that loads into RAM only is going to be faster than an OS that requires a hard drive.

So why doesn't MS work on a more scale-able approach? Load the minimum needed for the tasks you're doing. As opposed to Vista, which from what I understand, is DESIGNED to use ALL the RAM available.

>How about comparing apples to apples next time? Or, what happens if you run Puppy with say only 256 Mb of RAM? Open 10 or more programs while

>surfing the web and editing a photo?

Puppy runs quite nicely (in RAM) on 256 MB. It will STILL run MUCH faster than ANY MS OS on as little as 64 MB o' RAM, with a HD install.

>8) Thank God you trust an OS written by one person and with the 'help from his friends.'
>I sure don't. I hope he never packs it up and goes on permanent retirement.

I am not (unlike you) saying that any given OS is the Holy Grail. I use them all, and appreciate the strong points of each. Too bad MS doesn't give us more to like... If Barry K. (Puppy's developer) dies/retires, there is a worldwide, highly supportive, Puppy community - many of whom are expert Linux heads. No solution is perfect...

>9) The best open source office suite is probably OpenOffice.org. And first off, it won't fit on a distro that is only 85 MB. It is probably

>2-3 times that itself.

That's why Puppy uses Abiword & Gnumeric.

>Second, it chokes on MS compatibility on anything but the most basic features. Try writing macros, advanced charts or tables, or VBA code. NT.

Please TRY Abiword & Gnumeric. Find out how far you can go with them and post the data. That would be USEFUL feedback!

>I don't just give my people a word processor or spreadsheet, I give them a word processor or spreadsheet, ask them what they do, and then

>automate the crap out of it.

All your BUSINESS clients, who can AFFORD your prices, right? I applaud your expertise, now how about doing something for the home users? For poor people who can't afford the latest/greatest, but who could use a computer very creatively - if they had one...

>10) I'll give you the bang for the buck argument. Hey, Linux is free and you get what you pay for. That's pretty simple.

Not all Linux is free - and if you bothered to TRY it, you might be suprised. An 'amateur' (comes from the Latin for 'love') is someone who does something out of love, not because they are paid for it. An 'amateur' OS may actually be more polished than a commercial one. And we all know what a 'professional' woman is called, right?

>11) Chicken and egg here. Does MS really constantly require faster hardware or does companies like Intel keep producing it and therefore MS

>just puts it to work?

'Puts it to work'? More like squanders it, wastes it, and pisses it away. If you don't know that chickens hatch from eggs - well, you haven't been around many chickens.

>Give me a break. Do you really think that even if MS's newest OS ran on a PII 300 that Intel would just sit around and keep making PII's

>because they're profitable?

>12) I could care less if people can't buy a new PC every 3 years or so. They do have alternatives, as you have so rightly pointed out here.

>What I want is the latest, greatest, resource hogging, eye candy that I can get my greedy little hands on. I'm can pay for it so go back to

>your socialist/Democratic/Hillary Clinton loving hole you live in and leave me alone.

>I'll put MS on my PC because I want MS and even if I have to fork out 2,3,4 times the cash that you do, I have it so that's not a point of

>consideration.

Please don't assume that I love Hillary, I think she's far too much of a fence-sitting politician. My vote will go to Obama. You go right ahead and play Doom on your mega-PC. I'll go back to finishing my (contracted) technical book on wiring home recording studios. I started it on a 450 MHz P2, with 256 meg of RAM. I could have finished it there, but moved up to a 1.6 GHz / 512 MB unit that I was given for free by a grateful client.

In a year, I'll have a commercial book on the market, and you'll need a new computer.

Go drive your SUV five blocks to the corner store, swill some beer/Coke/Pepsi, sit back, joystick in hand, and enjoy Doom. Some of us actually use our computers to create things, and have no need for the massive firepower so craved by elitist gamers...

>13) Recycling, well, you have a point but soon, very soon, with the whole "greening" of IT, that'll change. The newest, latest, greatest PC's

>will use a fraction of the electric of older PC's and still be exponentially faster.

That will do NOTHING for the HARDWARE recycling problem!

>14) Not clear at all! Tell me, so, you want to continue to reuse instead of recycle PC's. I want to play the latest, greatest version of Doom

>with super realistic graphics.

>How are you going to give me that with Linux on a PII or PIII?

I'm not even going to try. You are happy with how you use your computer. Be happy. But don't assume your way is right for everybody.

>Or, since I work for a home builder, how exactly are you going to enable my CAD designers to draw 3D representations of homes on these old

>POS's?

>You can have the fastest OS in the world, but if the applications designed for it and consumers want are resource hoggy themselves, games

>over.

>Thanks for giving me a fast OS, too bad none of the apps I need are as fast.

Ah, a fellow CAD user! I use Vectorworks instead of AutoCAD, but do 3D work myself. I once installed VW under Win4Lin on a Linux box, and used Win 98SE for the Win OS. Vectorworks did 3D redraws under emulation, faster than it did in 'native' mode on a Win 98 SE box. Does this give you a clue?

However, I DO agree, it's not just on the OS maker to create lean, clean code. It's also on the program makers.

And the next time you get paid for overtime, collect unemployment, get Medicare, or take a vacation, please thank all the Socialists, and Democrats who fought to get all of us those perks. Or do you think they came by themselves?

by jackie40d1

I put a full version of Linux 2007 ( 6 CD's ) of stuff on a 700 megahertz P II with a whole 640 megs of PC-100 ( 1 512 meg and 1 128 meg chips )memory and it ran really good it had even Code Weavers Pro and Windows Office XP Pro running it was not fast but it could do it Also had the OPEN Office set of programs and they would open all the same stuff that the XP Office would open . . So either your not up to date on what you talk about or your not so great ! Oh yeah had an old 5400 rpm hard drive in it too and some old CD and an OLD CD burner I put a DVD burner in it to replace the CD-Burner for them so they could back up or save stuff to a DVD or a CD

by neon samurai

First, that icon you chose is just asking for a fight. Couldn't find anything more generic or possibly even *gasp* complimentary to what you prefer rather than opinionated against what you hate?

Second is this bit here:

"
7) Puppy Linux. Let's see, blindingly fast because it is loaded entirely into RAM. Unless and until you want more than Puppy offers and/or don't have enough RAM to load it entirely into RAM.
"

Dos is fast as lightning when run from a ramdisk too. The problem with your point though is that Damn Small Linux is a full OS suite including office suite, network suite and techie utilities. Does winXP come with a complete compliment of office software, network software and utilities? Last I looked, it had the basics for network software but I've not seen winXP pulling msOffice during the install or including a complete suite of technical tools such as memtester.

I'd have kept reading past point 7 but I suspect your only cherrypicking to make your own point. You read like any other Zealot, Cult of Apple or (and here's your title) MS Fanboi.

by hal 9000

It doesn't matter how right you are and how wrong Rick is you are going to get an abusive E-Mail anyway for someone claiming that they are disgusted by your actions which make the Hardware Sites look much better and that they have seen better actions in a Kindergarten where the young children refuse to share their play toys.

These foolish people seem to think that their opinion has some weight which it doesn't so keep up the good work.

Cheers

Col

by rkuhn040172

But I'm pretty sure PII's didn't go up to 700 Mhz.

I see your point, but that may have been either a typo or a stretch of truth.

by neon samurai

He keeps talking about how all he wants to do is play Doom on his mega-ultra-whamowonderful power-monster.

That's still ID Software right? Think we should point out to him that it will also be avaiable natively on Linux? Should we also point out that many games actually perform better on Linux machines even when written for Windows. Would it be too much to point out that his prised Doom servers are all running on Linux/BSD servers because the Windows versions run slower meaning longer ping times?

Nah.. he sounds like a twelve year old who just read a book on computers that mentioned Windows in a few places so he's decided that it's the be all and end all of computing.

Nice responses Jhecht

by tony k

Sigh, you were so wrong in two posts, I figured I'd just condense them..

All five computers were brand new, fresh out of the box, supposedly 'optimized' at the factory.

As others have pointed out, computers aren't "optimized" at the factory, they're made worse. If it's your job to optimize them, then you should know that. You would also know that the best route to take is to start with a retail copy of Windows to install, not an OEM if possible.

Four out of the five (now five out of six) gave me problems with really basic operations, like setting up DSL with Verizon.

Then, what's that tell you? I tells me you're trying to install the OS fresh on every machine and going through the whole process rather than setting up one machine and creating an image to use on the other five. Even the least technical person I know doesn't do full manual installs when they've got multiple machines to set up.

Or don't you think MS should test its new OS with a nationally used ISP's install CD?

Nope, I don't. I think that's the job of the thousands of people who did the beta testing to find things like that and report 'em to both MS and Verizon. If Verizon was that popular an ISP, it would've been found in beta testing. Regardless, if you had problems on all but one of the machines, then the problem isn't with the OS or the ISP software which didn't change from machine to machine. The only thing that was different was the steps you took to build the machines beause you did full manual installs on all of them. Therefore, the problem is with you.

4 GB cards are common today, why didn't MS catch this?

Really? They are? I only know one person who has one, and all of my friends are geeks. That one just happens to be a photography geek, too. As for the "bug", a quick search turned up nothing, could you point to some docs that this is a known bug?

I'm sure Vista has better 'security'.

Security isn't a function of the OS, it's a function of the admin. The admin uses the tools provided by the OS to secure it, it doesn't do it itself.

And MS is pushing this cr@p down everyone's throat, by forcing computer makers to install it on all new boxes, instead of allowing a choice of XP/Vista.

Nobody's pushing it down anyone's throat. MS doesn't supply the OEMs with XP anymore because they don't want to continue to support old software.

Then we have MS itself, which has zillions of bucks, tons of people, and somehow manages to create OS's that require ever faster/bigger/more hardware, instead of LEARNING how developers like Barry Kauler (Puppy) make lovely, tiny, highly functional, and intuitive OS's, that still run (even better) on the latest hardware.

That's because MS doesn't concern itself with the past like *nix geeks do. The focus on what's going to be available in the future when their OS finally ships, and build towards that. Why? Because most OS sales happen on new PCs, not upgrades. When people want a new OS, they generally just buy a new PC. They also do it when their old PC has bit the dust or can't do what they need it to anymore.

Do you think it both right and inevitable that everyone should buy a new computer every three years? That this is the natural order of things? Let me clue you - not everybody can - especially worldwide...

You're right, the whole world should slow down so everyone can hop on. Please, no one's saying they have to buy a new computer every three years. The specs for "premium" call for a machine that's five years old, so your "logic" doesn't apply. Even if it were true that the specs were excessively high, Word 2007 runs on XP, so a computer too old for Vista can still run the latest apps. Or, perhaps Word 2003? 2000? If the computer they have today does what they need it to, they're not going to upgrade anyway. And, let's get one more point straight: if it weren't for MS (who makes the OS used by 90+% of the computers in the world) "pushing the envelope", computers today wouldn't be $2-300 for a reasonably high-end system. I just recently put together a machine that got a relatively new Athlon, a gig of RAM, 300G hard drive, 128M video card for $250. If I were to trim it back just a little to minimum specs for Vista Premium (and with hardware I didn't have to go to a surplus store to get), I could've probably done it for $150 and still had enough to pay for a copy of the OS. Or, one can go to a computer recycling store and get a good one, with OS, for under $100 (there's at least 4 of those places within a 5 minute drive from where I am right now). Is $300 a lot of money for a person to pay for a computer? It can be, but if you're trying to better yourself or your family, isn't it your responsibility to make those sacrifices? How many of these "poor people" you champion have an Xbox or Playstation, but not a computer? Cable TV?

Now, outside the US, the situation is vastly different, obviously. However, in countries where most of the population doesn't have electricity or running water, getting a computer is probably the very least of their problems. I know there's programs like the "One computer, one child" $100 computer, but to think you can walk up to someone who's starving and offer them a computer as a panacea is...well...irresponsible at best, reprehensible at worst.

And speaking from a worldwide perspective, it is much more ecological to re-use older computers AS computers, than it is to try to 'recycle' the wire, gold, etc.

Most people do. The old computer becomes the kid's computer. Since recycling computers is now mandatory in the US, most companies do, too. Mine pays recycling companies to come and take them away. They're rebuilt and resold to lower-income families so they can have access to one. The ones that are so bad they can't be rebuilt, those are scavenged for their bare components. Seriously, get a clue before making these kinds of statements. They don't reflect the world.

Whole provinces of China are now so polluted by such 'recycling' of US computers, that drinking water has to be trucked in from 30 miles away.

Yeah, they also produce infected wheat glutin products that are killing US pets, so I have no sympathy for them right now. Sure, it's offtopic, too bad.

We do not have to throw away functioning computers to accommodate the latest bloatcode.

Only incompetent twits like you do that. The rest of us know how to use the latest software on the oldest hardware without having to cut out all of the usefulness by going to Linux

OS's CAN work with smaller resources - if they are designed properly - Vista is (IMHO) not so designed. Rather, I think it is more designed to FORCE yet another round of hardware upgrades. Thus, I call it a FAILURE - it does NOT run well/fast on TODAY'S hardware. Clear now?

No, we're not, because it runs fast/well on all of my hardware that I have it installed on, none of which is TODAY'S hardware. It runs from 5 years old to two years old. So, where's the problem? We're both running the same version of the OS, so if you can't get it to run on even the newest of hardware, then the failure isn't the OS. I don't think I need to tell you once again where the failure is.

So you "don't believe" in the majority of installed computers in the world? Just because you think them inferior does not make them go away.

Oh, so 6, 7, 8 year old computers are the majority now? News to most of us, I think.

The difference between us, is that I try and fit the OS to a user's needs and budget. You just say "get a bigger budget, or you aren't worth my effort to help you."

Well, while rigid, it's not the worst mentality to have. When your car becomes too much trouble to maintain, do you go get a new engine, or do you get a new car? Or, even a used car? After all, a 5 year old computer is more than sufficient to run Vista, so it's not like you have to spend a lot.

where people are often pathetically mis-advised by ignorant/indifferent salespeople to buy inappropriate computers.

And are then directed to ignorant/indifferent "techs" who don't know what they're doing.

To start, I turn off all the XP/Vista eye candy crap, turn off as many TSR's as I can, disable unused devices (like infra-red connect when there are no i-r devices), and in general, try to pare down what's running to a more efficient configuration.

TSRs? Really? In Vista? Uh-huh....see how you started with what YOU consider crap, then to something that doesn't exist anymore, then talk about doing what you're supposed to? There's your problem right there.

Please see above. What part of no budget/no time don't you understand?

Whose fault is that? If you're setting the prices, then it's yours. If your working for a company that does so, then it's theirs, but you're the one not working to fix the problem. You've just passed it to Microsoft. Of course, if you knew what you were doing, you could do it more efficiently and be able to do everything you wanted to in a short time and STILL have time to drink that cup of coffee with the customer. For example, if you have a base set of tweaks you do (disabling services, OS tweaks, etc), you could create a reg file and put it on a USB stick. Double-click, done. All of your tweaks are now in place. How long does it take you to do that now? Want to install software for them? Create a custom installer that you can kick off while you do other things. Perhaps just a base, sysprepped image of Vista that you can install across the board? Unless they have some weird hard drive controllers, one image should work on the vast majority of systems. Again, the problem isn't time/budget/OS/whatever. The problem is you.

My job is (often) to take it out of the box, and make it work RIGHT NOW! No trips to the computer store, no money for extra gear. And you want to fire me for dealing with a f----d up situation? Sheesh!

No, I want to fire you because you're incompetent.

The card worked in the guy's camera, worked at Kinko's, and did NOT work on his spiffy, new Vista computer. It is a HP, when I called HP tech support, they said the 4 GB Vista bug was biting them. No, I don't think 4 GB cards are bad, I think MS quality control, and beta testing are bad...

Oh, so it came from HP support. Yeah, that's the best place to get info on another vendor's OS. And, again, beta testing only catches the bugs that hit people. If 50,000 people beta tested Vista (I know it was a lot higher than that), you'd think at least one would have caught that if it was something common. Uncommon bugs get fixed when they're discovered by someone. I know it's kind of hard to grasp: but people actually have to encounter bugs before they can be fixed. BTW, to borrow from the Linux crowd: have you submitted a bug report to Microsoft? Have you called them for support? Don't they offer 90 days of support out of the box anymore? Sorry, I've had Platinum support so long, I don't remember. Too bad your company doesn't bother paying for a support plan for you. You could obviously get use out of it.

Uh, Mr. System Administrator, which do you think is the better install - an 'upgrade', or a 'clean' install?

Depends, did you build the machine or did I? I upgraded my 5 year old XP install without issue to Vista. Granted, I would generally prefer to do clean installs of machines that hadn't been in my control in the past, but you hardly need to buy Ultimate just for that. You also don't need to buy a full version, either. An upgrade is an upgrade.

No, most won't go for Vista Ultimate, PRECISELY because it costs $400 - but they SHOULD. All the lower versions are variations on the word 'crippleware'.

Really? You've been talking home users up until this point. They need bitlocker encryption? Domain support? RDP? Faxing?

This shows EXACTLY your narrowness of viewpoint. On the BIZ lines, maybe. On the CONSUMER lines, XP is rarely an option

Which shows your narrowness of viewpoint. Home users can buy "business" computers. They won't get 'em as cheap, but they'll typically get better support. For example, consumer lines need to be up-to-the-minute to support gaming, business lines need longer "shelf life". Example: Dell claims that desktops on its consumer lines will be available in a specific config for up to three months, compared to 18 months for the business lines. The business lines also typically come with more support out of the box (hence the higher costs). You'll also be much more likely to find an updated driver on a business box than consumer because the businesses are demanding the systems not crash. Home users who encounter these probably usually go through guys like you who wrongly claim the problem is entirely the OS...and thus the misinformation spreads.

This is what is stock, or downloadable, for free, for Puppy. And it's a LOT more than you get on a stock Vista box!

Ahh, here it is, my favorite pro-Linux argument. "Let's list all of the software I get besides an OS when I use Linux..." Nice list you compiled there. The problem is, they're also ALL available in some way or another for use on Windows. That means if I spend the money, I not only get an OS that has wider hardware support, is faster and more stable, and has a better feature set...I also can get all of the software you list, too! "Linux is a kernel, not an OS", we hear that all the time, but it's true. Linux is the basis of a wide range of disparate and, in a lot of cases, self-incompatible OSes with no clear standards for usability or compatibility. On that basis alone, Windows wins hands down. Add to that a much wider support base on the Internet from people who are a lot more approachable than the Linux pinheads and you've just added gravy to that steak!

So why doesn't MS work on a more scale-able approach? Load the minimum needed for the tasks you're doing. As opposed to Vista, which from what I understand, is DESIGNED to use ALL the RAM available.

From what you understand? If you don't understand, you don't get to have an opinion. But, to answer the first question...why bother? Why would buy a machine with any amount of RAM, and then strive to ensure you're always way underneath that value? What's the purpose of the extra RAM, then? Or, are you one of those twits who still sizes their machines based on peaks rather than usage?

No solution is perfect...

True, but some (like pretty much all of your suggestions) are very much the opposite from perfect.

All your BUSINESS clients, who can AFFORD your prices, right? I applaud your expertise, now how about doing something for the home users? For poor people who can't afford the latest/greatest, but who could use a computer very creatively - if they had one...

Your logic is flawed on so many levels. Firstly, one doesn't need the latest/greatest in order to run Vista. Second, you don't need to use Vista in order to be creative. Whatever they can do on Vista they can still do on XP, too. I haven't read all of your posts, but I assume you're one of that crowd.

Not all Linux is free - and if you bothered to TRY it, you might be suprised. An 'amateur' (comes from the Latin for 'love') is someone who does something out of love, not because they are paid for it. An 'amateur' OS may actually be more polished than a commercial one. And we all know what a 'professional' woman is called, right?

And, we know what an "amateur" woman is called, too. As for trying it, I can assure you, I've got more experience professionally with Linux than you and Rick do as amateurs. Having said that...no, it's not more polished. If it could be, it would've been by now. It's getting closer, but keeps stumbling over its own failings again and again. Until there's a default "out of box" experience mandated by someone, Linux will continue to flounder. It never ceases to amaze me how penguinheads will always complain about how MS moves stuff around between versions of their OS, yet you can't sit down at two different, current distros of Linux and find much that they have in common. Some follow the FHS, most don't. Some use the LSB, most don't. Some default to Gnome, some to KDE, some to Xfce. Some install everything open source they can, others will only install it if they like the license. The wide range of variation one gets is bewildering to experts, and you expect home users (who are so ignorant they need YOUR help) to setup their computers will be able to use it effectively? Are you serious?

'Puts it to work'? More like squanders it, wastes it, and pisses it away.

And, what are they supposed to do with it? I've got a gig of RAM in my box, I want to use a gig of RAM. That's what I bought it for. I've got a minimum of 40G worth of hard drive space in my machines, I'm going to use 40G of drive space. That's what I bought it for. Why buy a system if you're not going to use it? That's like buying a car and never using the trunk or glove box.

I started it on a 450 MHz P2, with 256 meg of RAM. I could have finished it there, but moved up to a 1.6 GHz / 512 MB unit that I was given for free by a grateful client.

Why didn't you just give that new box to a person who couldn't afford their own computer? I mean, if the ancient box was good enough for you to start with, how did it cease to be good enough? Do they slow down with age? LOL!

In a year, I'll have a commercial book on the market, and you'll need a new computer.

Considering how well you write, and how knowledgeable you are, we all seriously doubt that. If it's true though, good for you. Having a book about wiring home recording studios (there's a huge customer base) doesn't make you competent with computers.

Some of us actually use our computers to create things, and have no need for the massive firepower so craved by elitist gamers...
...I'm not even going to try. You are happy with how you use your computer. Be happy. But don't assume your way is right for everybody.

Oh, goodness, the hypocrisy. And only a couple of lines apart! I'll clue in on something: my machine can run Doom AND I can use it for creative things, too. See, faster is better, it opens up your options. Tell me, if only elitist gamers need the latest hardware, why did you need such a recent machine to do word processing?

I once installed VW under Win4Lin on a Linux box, and used Win 98SE for the Win OS. Vectorworks did 3D redraws under emulation, faster than it did in 'native' mode on a Win 98 SE box. Does this give you a clue?

That you're lying? Yes, it does. Having used Win4Lin, I'd know you were lying about redraws just from that. But, to suggest that redraws happen faster over the network from an emulated environment with a third-party video driver than locally on a machine that has a manufacturer-optimized driver is really just trying to test the limits of "truth" no matter how you slice it.

However, I DO agree, it's not just on the OS maker to create lean, clean code. It's also on the program makers.

Finally, one more or less intelligent statement.

And, HAL...Rick replied to his last post because he was wrong. Yes, he "disagreed" with Rick, but while you're entitled to your own opinion, you're not entitled to your own truth.

by tony k

Does winXP come with a complete compliment of office software, network software and utilities?

Yup. OpenOffice, Ethereal, Apache web server, Abiword, gcc....You're right, it doesn't come with memtester. Of course, seeing as I've only used it once, it's of limited usefulness to me. I can figure out pretty easily if I've got bad RAM without using memtester.

I'd have kept reading past point 7 but I suspect your only cherrypicking to make your own point. You read like any other Zealot, Cult of Apple or (and here's your title) MS Fanboi.

Actually, Rick reads like someone who knows what he's talking about, unlike you. Cherrypicking? Aren't you the one who touted all of the free software you can run, but forgot to mention it's all available for Windows, too? You mention the performance of DSL, what about the other distros? DSL is fast, but it doesn't provide the breadth of functionality of say a Fedora or Ubuntu. Both of which run a lot slower than Windows on the same hardware.

by hal 9000

Where Time is unimportant and money is no object.

Unfortunately for the rest of us we have time constraint and the amount of time that we can spend installing hardware is limited. Personally I don't do this type of work but I get quite a lot from the Cable companies here who walk in attempt to setup a cable connection trash the OS and then hand out one of my business cards with the advice that they call me to to fix the mess that they have created and that is on XP. Don't know what Vista Support is like and I'm not interested.

I supported XP from the word go and I'll never make that mistake again NO Thank You. I'm sitting Back and waiting till the bugs are ironed out and see if Vista is Accepted by my customers. Currently I [b]Can Not[/b] recommend it to anyone and to be quite honest I've only had the RTM version since the Volume License Stuff was released in November 2006 so I'll bet you $ to Donuts that I've been working with the RTM product much longer that you have and can not recommend it to a single customer of mine. And I don't even have the Cripple Ware Ultimate I'm only playing with the Enterprise Version and to be quite honest that's exactly what I'm doing playing with it a bit of serious testing revealed way too many shortcomings for acceptance into the business community YET.

However what I was specifically referring to was this unsolicited e-mail that arrived unwanted or unasked for but with the person wrongfully self righteously complaining about my actions among others over a discussion on Vista.

[i]Subject: micro screw nux convo
Message:
i just cant believe the three of you rick arron and hal 9000 could be so childish in you comments to each other it is a disgrace to the it community

i have seen better conduct in hardware forums and pirate coves than i witnessed here.[/i]

Now this person seems to want everyone to agree completely on everything sorry but I'm not a Zombie and I do work in my specific field which may be different to yours but it's as equally important to my clients as yours are to you.

Col

by tony k

Sorry to reply to the other post, TR won't let me respond to yours.

Tony K it must be nice to be closeted in your own world

Yeah, I'm afraid I don't think so. For the last 20+ years in this industry I've worked for big players (including numerous Fortune 100 companies) and small players. I've worked with everything from mainframes to micros, running possibly every conceivable OS. I've put in my time, and came to the conclusion that I prefer to work with Windows. Once I figured out that the problems I'd been dealing with the OS were my own doing, I started to wisen up and have been more than sufficiently happy with everything they've put out since. You, on the other hand, live in a world in which you can do no wrong, despite your constant failings. You readily admit the issues you've had with their products over the years, and when I show you over and over again technical reasons why you're wrong, you never have a response and just move to the next conversation where you still blame MS for all of YOUR failings. I work on a team that administers thousands of Windows servers which have 24/7 availability, and you can't even get a desktop OS to work properly. Yeah, it's obvious I'm the one living in a dream world.

Where Time is unimportant and money is no object.

Whoa! When did I say that? In fact my last reply to jhect I specifically stated that if he did things properly, he'd have time enough left over to have a cup of coffee with his customers. Time and money are DRASTICALLY important, which is reason #1 I choose Windows over other platforms: I set it up, it works, I'm done and I rarely (if ever) have to touch the box again. On the other hand, we like to watch the Unix teams (yes, plural) scramble every time someone uses a capital "R" in a command rather than the lower case they were supposed to. I like sitting in project meetings with a *nix rep, and when the PM asks "when can you have that server in?", their response is typically "2-3 weeks after we receive it from the factory and it's been racked". Mine is always "the day it's racked."

Personally I don't do this type of work but I get quite a lot from the Cable companies here who walk in attempt to setup a cable connection trash the OS and then hand out one of my business cards with the advice that they call me to to fix the mess that they have created and that is on XP. Don't know what Vista Support is like and I'm not interested.

And, considering the level of support you must give, let me say "thank you". The fewer people like you we have "fixing" machines, the better. So, what kinds of problems could the techs have made for you? They'd have to work really hard to go in to configure network settings and screw up the OS to the point someone would need to come in to fix it. I continue to find it interesting that you never provide specifics.

to be quite honest I've only had the RTM version since the Volume License Stuff was released in November 2006 so I'll bet you $ to Donuts that I've been working with the RTM product much longer that you have and can not recommend it to a single customer of mine.

How many dollars is it you owe me, then? Again, you didn't provide specifics. As a Platinum partner with MS, I've used the OS since very early betas. And, we ARE confident to recommend to the company to start rolling it out to our 13,000 desktops and have been since the RTM. That project will begin in just a couple of months.

And I don't even have the Cripple Ware Ultimate I'm only playing with the Enterprise Version and to be quite honest that's exactly what I'm doing playing with it a bit of serious testing revealed way too many shortcomings for acceptance into the business community YET.

Such as? I won't lie and say we didn't find issues with it, but we worked with MS and got workarounds or fixes for all of them. As I said, we're comfortable rolling it out to 13k desktops, so whatever issues you claim have either been fixed already or are nonexistant.

However what I was specifically referring to was this unsolicited e-mail that arrived unwanted or unasked for but with the person wrongfully self righteously complaining about my actions among others over a discussion on Vista.

Subject: micro screw nux convo

I have no idea what that has to do with the rest of your post, but I will point out that while this twit is complaining about others actions, they still haven't graduated far enough to know how immature and stupid one comes off by calling them "micro screw".

by tony hopkinson

Aside from a tendency to over generalise from your own experience, I don't have a problem with your key points.

One question though.

Getting ready for a roll out to 13,000 desktops from an MS beta is not what you'd call a low risk small project.

What was the business case for doing it?

Not saying there can't be 'reasonable' ones, just wonder how you sold it to the bean counters.

by rkuhn040172

Before you make a fool of yourself, please educate yourself.

http://support.microsoft.com/gp/lifecycle

Nothing like spreading FUD to scare people into believing what you believe.

Besides the fact that making blanket statements like "Windows XP Support" as opposed to Home, Pro, Enterprise, etc, in addition to SP1, SP2, etc, you only look like a fool.

You do everyone a diservice with your comments. How about discussing the differences between mainstream support, extended support, on-line support, etc.

by rkuhn040172

1) "error-free tree-view drag and drop in Explorer"

Since when? I do it everyday and rarely encounter errors...more FUD.

2) "real scripting languages"

That's pure opinion and preference. In my opinion and my preference is I like MS scripting languages. Score is 1 to 1. It's a tie.

3) "semi-weekly"

That's monthly for most of us. Check Apple's or Oracle's record. Sure, they don't release as often but when they do, wow, it's a long list.

4) WGA was designed for exactly what you're talking about. No one wants people around the world stealing software. If you do steal software, I would hope Linux is more attractive to you instead of stealing other people's hard work.

5) As a support tech, I would hope you are running multiple OS's. Expands one's skills, opens up new opportunities, etc. You should be running Mac's, Linux, and Windows. Hey, we finally agree on something.

by rkuhn040172

1) About the no servers part...

That was a dumbass rep's fault not MS. I don't think anywhere in MS's best practices you'd find that recommendation anywhere.

In addition, what idiot at that government department accepted their word? No multiple bids, no bid process, no second opinions?

Where was their IT staff and why didn't they catch this? Surely, with 2,500 PC's they had at least one technical person who would have caught this horrible recommendation.

Hell, with 2,500 PC's I'd hope they had numerous IT staff.

I simply don't believe your story. You've told it so many times I think you made it up in your head.

2) The problem with their Sys Admin's competency isn't MS's fault either. They need to hire better people. Their turnover isn't MS's problem either. Like Tony K has already said in this forum, don't blame MS for other people's problems. Address, fix and repair the problems, don't pass the buck.

3) Sounds to me if this customer is such a problem, you should drop them or write up a proposal with costs to fix their problems once and for all (and not just technical problems).

You seem too content with putting out fires and never really solving anything. Once the fire is out, you blame someone else and wait for the next fire. I seriously question your motives.

by hal 9000

The Qld Government doesn't accept tenders for work like this they go straight to the makers in this case M$ to tell them exactly what they need and then contract out the supply through their own IT Department which provides the software/Hardware combinations buy direct from M$ at a [b]Special Deal[/b] the Volume License Stuff and then tender out the Hardware provided which generally ends up being the cheapest junk that can be supplied to do the job.

Yes I do agree with you that it's not M$ fault about staff turn over or incompetent System Admins but in this case it was M$ Fault telling them that they didn't need any servers and that XP could be used as a Server, But that's M$ Marketing Department not M$ Technical so you need to understand that when dealing with Government Departments here they work a bit different to normal business and they buy Volume License Stuff always and the hardware comes unloaded so the IT Section creates 1 Image and Bulk Load to all the computers involved.

When the IT Section of the Government insisted that this setup would not work they where overridden and told what to supply then refused to support what wouldn't work. When I was originally asked to look in on this I couldn't even get anyone from the Governments IT Department to talk to me and they pushed it up to some Middle Level Bureaucrat who basically said we supplied what was insisted on and are unable to support this system. I only found out much latter that they refused to support it from the word go.

[i]You seem too content with putting out fires and never really solving anything. Once the fire is out, you blame someone else and wait for the next fire. I seriously question your motives.[/i]

Yes I agree in an [b]Ideal World[/b] this is what will happen but unfortunately when there are Bureaucrats involved they [b]Know It All[/b] and can be told nothing as they are the professionals in their minds at the very least and they are unwilling to admit that they made a mistake it's always the way that something was implemented that's the problem it's never their fault.

But I can quite rightly blame M$ for blacklisting the Product Keys for this Volume License of XP Pro 3 times between the original roll out and the finial time that the WGA was applied as that is defiantly M$ Fault and no one Else's. Though because of the time between the Original Roll out of XP then SP 1 that was a reasonable time particularly as the only decent System Admin there wouldn't implement SP 1 as they had no way of testing the thing properly and when they where transfered sideways to another mess the Substandard System Admin brought in just had to fully upgrade without testing because M$ is [b]Reliable[/b] caused some problems which may have been OK over that time period but the 2 week time frame between providing a new Product Key for SP2 and WGA is unacceptable in anyones book and only a complete [b]IDIOT[/b] would accept this as acceptable. Granted that place in question only rolled out SP2 quite late when a new System Admin was brought in and then as soon as WGA was brought out a few weeks latter rolled it out straight away which resulted in every desktop coming up next mourning as being Pirate software in the form of XP Pro and every system had to have a repair install performed on it as that is what M$ Technical insisted upon though I'm not overly sure that they knew just how many Desktops where involved as that wasn't something that I had any control over I & my staff just had to fix the mess.

As for putting out fires that exactly what we did as we where only ever called in to [b]Put Out Fires[/b] as we couldn't just walk in and demand to do any Maintenance Work and then expect to be paid for the time spent there when we where not requested to walk in. We where never under contract to them in a conventional sense but just involved in [b]Putting Out Fires as they Arose. Because No One Else Was Willing to do this Work.[/b]

In any Government work you need to realise that the Incompetent get Promoted up or as stated in quite a few other places to put it simply [b]The $h1te Raises to the Top[/b] so that they can cause less trouble where they where previously and more where they are now. With Government work competency isn't important it's Time Served that's important and a Government Job once you reach the level of being able to make decisions is a [b]Job For Life[/b] with the only possibility of being promoted for incompetence.

You have obviously never seen a situation like this as it's defiantly not Good Business but then again you can never accuse a Government Department of following Good Business I've seen examples where and entire Years Budget has been blown in 3 months and the person responsible gets promoted up several levels and then someone else is brought in to fix the mess with minimal [b]Emergency Funding[/b] that is to be paid off over the next 5 years. Hell I've even watched as a printer has been bounced down several flights of steps because they couldn't fill up the lift with it as the lift was for the use of the public not the internal staff and no it's a different department. As they had exhausted their Budget that year for new hardware they had the destroyed printer repaired even though it cost 3 times the cost of a new printer but the service costs come out of a different budget so they could keep the printer running by having it repaired and couldn't pay the costs of a replacement.

Personally if I was the one repairing the printer I would just have pulled off the cover with the serial Number on it and placed that on a new printer of the same model and charged them out the repair at about the new cost of a printer as that way you could be sure that the thing was going to work properly instead of attempting to fix up something destroyed in the incident.

That department then paid 1 staff member to stand beside the repaired printer and close a cover when it opened slightly and took the printer off line.

Personally weather or not you believe the above I don't give a RATS it happened and as you obviously have never had any experience with how Government Departments work your opinion means [b]Bugger All[/b] to me as you are not one who is capable of offering an informed opinion so it has absolutely no effect on my attitude to either you or your opinion.

OH Sorry to inform you I'm not alone I run this place and have 10 Techs working for me all of which have worked for me when I was working Big Business some are even from the IBM Main Frame days. Because I always treated my staff right they accepted what I did for them and appreciated just how much I stood between my department and Upper Management but as my 30 + years of experience count for nothing and your 4 years count for everything I humbly concede to your Superior opinion. :^0

Col

by rkuhn040172

That's funny, because at my last job I was a project manager under contract for a State government for 4+ years.

You assume too much!

Once again, blame MS for problems that aren't theirs. The government is to blame, the IT staff is to blame, and you are to blame as well.

I, personally, get tired of you rambling on and on here on TR about how bad this and that is. You seem to never look introspectively and seem to think you're perfect.

Fill me in, please, on just how Linux would have solved this government agencies problem...

I'm waiting because there is no technical fix for what you have described. That much you concede already, just not sure how MS gets so much blame here too.

by rkuhn040172

1) I didn't say I don't believe in older equipment. I just wouldn't even attempt to sell to a customer Vista for a PI, PII, or even a PIII. I don't believe in forcing an upgrade where an upgrade isn't needed or appropriate.

2) A hardware router/firewall isn't "cool stuff". Anymore, it is almost a necessity for even home users and isn't expensive.

Maybe $30-$40 max. And for that, you offload some security functionality off of the PC, you gain a lot more security, typically pick up wireless capabilities, NAT addressing, DHCP, stateful packet inspection, can hookup multiple PC's, etc.

A lot of bang for the buck.

3) I wouldn't fire you for dealing with F-Uped situations. I would fire you for not fixing the F-Uped situations correctly.

4) Like Tony K said, have you tried calling MS yet? Or are you just going to blame them so that you don't look bad in front of your customer? Meanwhile, you haven't helped your customer fix the situation.

5) First off, upgrades do work. I'd rather do a clean install but upgrades aren't as bad as most say. Depends on how properly maintained the system was to begin with.

"Cripplware"? What? Ok, let me get this straight. Linux offers tons and tons of distros that include or don't include some features and to you that's called freedom and choice.

MS does the same thing and you call it crippleware. Nice!

For the majority of people, as you have so elegantly stated, don't need much and have tight budgets. Give them Vista Home or Vista Home Premium...all well under $400.

6) Simply not the case. Call MS and you can order XP.

If manufacturers and resellers only offer Vista that is their choice not MS's. Don't you think that retailers (especially) are only offering Vista to create excitement and therefore sales? Again, not MS's fault.

7) Virtually all those programs also run under Windows. In addition, if you go the new PC route with Vista, the manufacturer typically does throw in lots and lots of software including a office suite like Works, something like Nero, etc.

If you don't like the manufacturer's selection, download some of your open source stuff. Pretty simple!

As a side not, what the heck are some of those programs? Gee, the names are just so descriptive now aren't they?

8) Support for Puppy. First you said his close friends and now it's a worldwide network. Either way, doesn't matter. There's also a worldwide network of support for Windows including MS itself. And that network is 10-100-1,000 fold larger just because of a larger user base.

9) I do support home users. I have a side business, website, etc. Are you implying that I can't write a macro or script or something similar in fast enough fashion that a home user can't afford to pay me to do it?

One, I can. Two, I usually don't charge full price for something like that knowing full well that one day another customer will want something similar and I'll already have it built.

I'm willing to spend a few hours doing something for someone and only charge an hours work knowing that I can charge the next person the same price and spend no time doing it.

Maybe I'm just nicer than you and don't charge exactly what the clock says down to the second.

What I lose in non-revenue generating time I gain in repeat business.

10) What is your point about not all Linux is free? You were talking about saving people money after all.

Besides, I'd bet I have tried out more Linux distros than you. The list is starting to get long and unfortunately, as much time as I have wasted, I still haven't found one that works for me.

But, not being closed minded, I continue looking and trying.

11) Sqanders what? All your CPU cycles and RAM sitting there doing nothing? One of my PC's at home is a P4 2.8 Ghz processor, 1.5 GB RAM, blah blah blah. Do you realize what it does 99% of the time? It sits there waiting for me to give it something to do. I wouldn't call that sqandering anything. My PC is idle 99% of the time.

12) Obama is a joke and so is Hillary. I have played Doom maybe once in the last 6 months. But that's not the point. If I want to, I want my PC to be able to do it.

I don't own a SUV. I own a 2.0 liter V4 car that gets almost 35 MPG on the highway. Nice try.

But let's take the car analogy a little further. My car is also a GTS with a manual override for the automatic transmission. It goes 0-60 in about 7 seconds. So, if I want to punch it and have fun, it will. If I want to cruise and get good gas mileage, I can do that too.

My PC is similar. It does everything and anything I want it to. Your older PC's won't. That simple. BTW, my PC cost $280 brand spanking new. I've upgraded quite a bit over time but I'd bet I still have less than $500 in it.

$500 isn't a lot for someone wanting to setup a home recording studio. If they don't have $500 for a PC, they probably should be thinking about a new line of business.

13) Ok, if it doesn't why don't you? For little money out of pocket, Dell, HP, etc will recycle it for you if it's such a concern.

I know, you'll say tight budgets. Great, sell your service as green friendly and maybe you can get enough additional business to justify the extra $10-$20 per PC to recycle.

14) Sorry, we use AutoCAD and Vertex exclusively because they have features that have been built into our custom ERP software used for estimating, purchasing, etc.

Maybe one day that would be a prudent move, but that's a long, long term project with little payout.

15) I don't make OT (I'm salary), I've only collected unemployment once in my life and that's because I was too damn lazy to work for 3 weeks, at 35 years old Medicare is too far away for me to care and it'll probably be gone by the time I get there just like Social Security, and vacations? What the heck is that? Democrats fighting for my right to go on vacation.

News flash! If my employer didn't offer at least 2 weeks vacation per year plus sick days, other time off, etc I'd quit and work for someone else that did. I don't need a Democrat for that.

And a history lesson for you. Health benefits actually came about probably 20-30 years ago when labor was in tight supply (not by law). It was a competitive edge for companies that offered it to hire someone.

But, just like Social Security which came about in the 1930's during the depression, somehow became permanent.

Not that I'm complaining, just that it didn't take a Democrat to "create" it.

by neon samurai

"
if it weren't for MS (who makes the OS used by 90+% of the computers in the world) "pushing the envelope",
"

Actually, if it weren't for Video Games "pushing the envelope", Microsoft wouldn't have all those extra resources to waste. Games have always been the major driver for bigger, faster, prettier on the local machine. Was the Voodoo 3D chip created to push Windows95 or the games that happened to run on Win95?

I'm still reading the rest of your post so other points may follow in another comment but I think this thread may be dead regardless of how hard we whip it.

by fil0403

As MS roles out new versions of Windows, what I have been thinking is "how can these Microsoft-bashers make ignorant comments, be too dumb to consider the functionality complicated but quick to consider Linux easy to use and come with ignorant statements that you have to double and triple the hardware requirements when Vista runs on a machine with an 800 Mhz processor and 512 MB of system memory, 20 GB hard drive with 15 GB of available space, supoort for Super VGA graphics and CD-ROM drive and I'm running it on a 3+ year old Toshiba Satellite A60-122 laptop smoothly so they can keep bashing MS products? The biggest problem *I* have is Microsoft haters like you bashing MS products by assuming they should support their OS's for eternity. So if you are too ignorant to wish to get XP SP2 when you can get Vista you can always buy it anywhere and have unlimited support forever, even when any person that actually knows something about Vista knows it is a secure system, much more than XP.
Making the interface more attractive does only appeal to people who don't understand or concern themselves with efficiency (A. K. A. Mac users) and that is why that is only one of the many improvements in Vista over XP, along with the following features/improvements:

- Address Space Layout Randomization (protects against return-to-libc attacks, where an attacker uses exploit code to call a system function; randomizes the function entry points for common system calls, so on a typical 32-bit Windows Vista machine, an attacker stands a 1-in-256 chance of getting the address right);

- BitLocker Drive Encryption (prevents a thief who boots another operating system or runs a software hacking tool from breaking Windows Vista file and system protections or performing offline viewing of the files stored on the protected drive);

- DirectX 10 (features enhanced 3-D graphics-rendering capabilities and helps improve computer's in-game and multimedia performance);

- fast Sleep and Resume (combines the benefits of Standby and Hibernate modes into Sleep);

- Games Explorer (list of all games currently installed on the PC);

- high dpi support (up to 144 dpi);

- important security changes in the network stack;

- improved battery meter (for mobile PC's);

- improved built-in diagnostics;

- improved Group Policy (manages Windows Vista networking);

- improved overall security;

- improved Self-Healing System (including boot Self-Healing System);

- improved stability (crashes less than XP);

- improved Tablet PC support (pen improvements, new touch screen support, improvements to Tablet PC Input Panel, enhanced ink erasing, handwriting recognition improvements);

- improved Windows Firewall (outgoing traffic protection);

- improved Windows Media Center (improved user interface with easier navigation and better media visualization, built-in support for archiving TV shows directly to video DVDs, faster overall performance, improved platform, support for digital cable service in the US);

- improved Windows Update (easier, less disruptive, doesn't require/use Internet Explorer);

- improved Windows Security Center (including showing the status of software designed to protect against antispyware, the user's Internet Explorer 7 security settings and User Account Control);

- improved wireless networking (including support for the latest wireless security protocols, like WPA2);

- Instant Search (enhanced desktop search and organization);

- Internet Explorer 7 with Protected Mode (IE cannot modify user or system files and settings without user consent);

- little details (for instance: when renaming a file, Vista only selects the name and not the extension too);

- live icons (thumbnail image of the actual contents of every file);

- live taskbar thumbnails (display the actual contents of both windows that are currently open and those that are minimized in the taskbar);

- multiple clocks;

- PatchGuard* (protects the integrity of the kernel);

- Shadow Copy (helps the user recover a file if the user accidentally deletes it);

- SuperFetch (enables programs and files to load faster than they would on Windows XP?based PC's);

- User Account Control (prevents potentially dangerous software from making changes to the computer without the user's explicit consent);

- Virtual Folders (saved searches that are automatically and instantly run when a user opens folders);

- Vista DreamScene (animated wallpapers);

- Windows Aero (overall improved - better-designed, high-performing - GUI);

- Windows Defender embedded;

- Windows DVD Maker (DVD burner);

- Windows Flip 3D (renders live thumbnail images of the exact contents of the open windows);

- Windows HotStart (enables the user to click a button and immediately start a program regardless of whether the mobile PC is on, sleeping, in hibernation, or off);

- Windows Mail (including Instant Search, improved junk mail filter, phishing filter, improved reliability, newsgroup features);

- Windows Meeting Space (enables the user to share work on computer based projects with other people more easily and comfortably);

- Windows Mobility Center (puts the most frequently used mobile PC settings in a single, easy-to-find location):

- Windows Movie Maker HD (edit HD video);

- Windows Photo Gallery (easier, more intuitive way to view, manage, and refine photos and home movies);

- Windows ReadyBoost (improves system memory and boosts performance);

- Windows Sidebar & Gadgets (pane on the side of the Vista desktop where the user can keep his/her gadgets organized and always available & easy-to-use mini programs that give the user information at a glance and provide easy access to frequently used tools, respectively);

- Windows SideShow (supports a secondary screen on a mobile PC, integrated device on a computer, mobile phone and/or media remote control, with which the user can view information, like reading an e-mail message, whether the laptop is on, off, or in sleep mode).

And I agree with the Wii comment too, your mistake is in comparing the Wii with MS products; you should be comparing to Macs.

by hal 9000

Where did you get the Vista CD Setup Disc's from?

Yes I know that M$ is offering them but I've yet to see them show up on M$ Price Lists. Every M$ listing that I have access to only lists the Vista DVD and not a single listing of the Vista CD Sets.

Col

by jackie40d1

There are a few places I have seen the CD's on sale . . Seems they can't be used by the USA Gov. as its been banned for security reasons hehehe I read this and laughed my A- - Off !
What a slap in the face for MS to have their system banned by the government for security reasons !

by tony hopkinson

Ubuntu for instance is being 'sold' as being as easy to use as windows.

Thanks for the long list of Vista 'improvements'. How many of those more useful thing are only in ultimate.
How many are optional, UAC and IE7 protected mode being a case in point.

I'll use it when I go to management and sell them a corporate rollout.

If I print it out it will give me something to wipe away the tears when they beetch slap me out of the office.

We work in business. Aside from the application of a better security paradigm, which actually increased( at least 2 - 3 times) the cash outlay from taking on the new OS, there is f'all in it for us that we need.
Aero, what do we need aero for, slap

Sidebar don't make me laugh. We're paying ?100s for a jazzier start menu, slap

Easy video editing, slap I

I can make a movies of all the snaps in my work photo album., slap

Boo hoo, sniffle, wimper, whine. But it's really cool and so new and modern.

The only reason we have it inside the business is because we sell software into the appliance market and they will have it.

We can't afford to rely on features like bitlocker and aero, that would effectively double the cost of using our product. Our competitors , one of whom is MS, would crap on us.

Sheesh.

by rkuhn040172

If so, what distro?

Is that distro relatively recent? Why not use something like a 5 year old version of Red Hat?

Surely, most Linux upgrades are nothing but useless features to you too then.

by ghostbrowser

Looks like a large house of cards
The main issue i have seen in this thread
are time in learning the new interface
windows programs dependence on unrelated services and files
The main worry is if there is any problem
that it can cause so many problems
Which do not appear to be related
This is a common theme in windows OSs
I am not saying linux is the solution
But microsoft can do better than this
The wga (piracy) problem is very stupid
People should hold the licences
Not computers
Windows is the most common os only
because it is on the new computers
and people cannot be bothered changing it
and i havent seen computers being sold
in department stores and the like with out it for a long time other people may have

by jackie40d1

It was on sale at Wal Mart for some unreal price like $250.00 for a laptop with Lindows in it ( now Linspire ! ) I have sold some computers with Linspire 5.0 installed in it ( they did not want the windows fight for patches thing so I installed Linspire 5.0 ) and it runs really good and looks a lot like windows but does it better and has gobs of stuff installed with it ( even has about 7 ISP's already to go ) Just click and set up and run dials and does what ever to go on line . . PLUS its gobs cheaper than windows is or will be . .

by tony k

and i havent seen computers being sold
in department stores and the like with out it for a long time other people may have

They didn't sell. People didn't want Linux. It's really not a difficult concept: when people have a choice, they don't choose Linux. Walmart sold PCs for under $200 that came with Linux, they didn't sell. Free software is generally worth the price you pay for it. Narcissists like HAL, for example, don't have a choice. They're incapable of seeing they're wrong, so they pass the buck to MS and so use Linux.

by neon samurai

I was going to say "your both twits" but that would be disregarding the knowledge that you do have about Windows and that wouldn't be fair either.

My complaint is not that you like Windows and use it hapily. It works for you and that's great. It works for me as a gaming platform but I have better options for productivity.

My complaint is that you continue to make statements about *nix based OS which are just flat out rong. I won't take the time to write a full reponse to each point but let me hit a few in passing:

"Linux programs names are so comlicated and undescriptive" - Does Excel scream calculator or excelerator? Access seems to be a database program not a security software. PowerPoint doesn't say anything about presentations too me. Program naming for Windows is no less general and cryptic than program naming on any other platform.

"some distrobution include some stuff, other's don't; what kind of choice is that" - I'd say a hundred or more different distrobutions based on the same commodity parts is a heck of a lot of choice. I'd say an OS that comes with a 3000 title selection of easily installed software to select from is a heck of a lot of choice.

You don't like Linux, BSD, osX or anything else non-Windows; fine. No worries, no hurt feelings. I have what works for me, you have what works for you and we all get to check our email. Just don't try and justify your personal choice by letting so much FUD dribble out your mouths. I'll do the same and continue to limit the amount of Windows FUD that get's past my own checks and balances.

by neon samurai

I believe the scope of the comment was; what does DSL come with and what does Windows come with out of the box?

I stick a DSL liveCD in my drive and all the listed components are there. I stick a Windows install cd in my drive and I have a half day of disk switching to do. Hand me a run-from-disk version of Windows with all the previously listed functions in place and we'l continue that line of discussion.

I didn't mention that the programs listed are also freely (and retaining full user's liberty) are also compiled for win32 because they don't come preinstalled with Windows or any vendor's distrobution of Windows.

If it makes you feel better about your view of the world; I have most of those FOSS applications running on Windows as well as all my other OS which includes more than just the two discussed here.

Again, no problems with you likeing Windows. There are tasks I like it for also. I'm just not going to sit here quietly while you tell me things which are complete crap about [insert any non-Windows OS here].

Actually, an interesting experiement would be for you too isntall Windows, osX and a Linux distro or two. Use them until you are equally comfortable in all of them and *then* come back to discuss, contrast and compaire. Don't come round telling me how some other OS sucks because 90% of your knowledge is locked away in Windows land.

by tihiggins

I have been recently playing with Linux a lot because I refuse to move to Vista anytime soon. It is just too much eye candy for me, without extra benefits. My security is handled by and large by hardware devices and so the overarching security features are more like bloatware to me (though I certainly see the point for less secured systems!). Anyway, getting back to the point, I have tried several different Linux distributions, and if you are looking for one as easy (in some ways easier) to use as Windows, much of the same functionality, and a hidden backend for the user, you should look at Ubuntu and its kin. The way they built it, the GUI appears as the OS, not unlike Apple, while still being separated if you find it unappealing later. Additionally, they provide at least 4 different varients to choose from. Lastly, it is based on Debian's excellent update and installer utility that makes keeping all your software up to date (not just the OS) a breeze. Personally, I am partial to a Ubuntu redistribution out of Ireland called Mint Linux. It is essentially Ubuntu with some customized settings that make it a bit more user friendly for the way I compute, but as most Linux users have learned and lived with - It is personal taste with regard to which distribution you choose.

by rkuhn040172

Has nothing to do with this.

I have, continue to use, and will continue to use Linux. It is an alternative worth looking into.

I just think Windows is better.

For the record since you think I'm a Linux novice. I have installed and used the following:

Mandriva
Red Hat
Fedora
DSL
Knoppix
KnoppMyth
Ubuntu

So, I don't blindly hate Linux. I'm not denegrating anything. And I do understand Linux.

Nice try.

by neon samurai

I'm no Zealot, I can accept that. I think after I posted that comment I actually read an exchange between you and someone else where you mention running Linux.

I am curious as to why your posts read like such an attack on Linux or any alternative OS though. I don't mean that to say that you dared to speak against the holy penguin; I have no issues with valid points. In this conversation alone though, you make claims about Linux which are just not true. You seem to be looking for reasons to tear apart Linux, BSD or whatever while pusing Windows up on a pedistal like it's the Grail.

Hopefully in my own general comments (outside of this exchange) I've been polite and helpfull where questions have been asked. It's the blatant miss-information and intentinal attacks I won't accept happily with a smile. Crap like "Linux needs more hardware than Windows" or "Windows install includes more than DSL" are just flat our wrong. After 30 years of working with Micorosft products, and 10 years with Linux; my experience and the ton of reading I continue to do on both subjects just does not support those claims.

by rkuhn040172

I'm not attacking Linux or any other alternative OS's.

But I am sick and tired of TR being a sounding board for pro-open source and anti-Microsoft.

Face it, we all use whatever tool we see fit. Yours may be Linux and mine may be Windows.

Now, since both are made by human beings, both are seriously flawed. Both have strengths and both have weaknesses.

I accept Windows strengths AND weaknesses. Some Linux zealots on here (TR) never admit Linux's weaknesses.

To pretend Linux has no weaknesses is foolish.

Please point out any statements that I have made that are false. And, I mean false. Not wrong since you disagree with me. I truly mean a false statement. Not a disagreement. You'll be hard pressed to find one.

I never said Linux needs more hardware than Windows and I never said Windows includes more than DSL (the porton of DSL that solely lives in RAM that is).

My bottom line opinion...

Linux is a great OS but still needs some work. I deploy it where it would serve best (just like Windows) but no OS is a one size fits all.

It isn't appropriate for my environment.

The sheer number of choices, applications, and configurations only confuses the average consumer. (Choice is good but in this case, it's overkill).

The naming conventions suck.

It needs a company as big or powerful as MS to help market it, distribute it, consolidate it, etc.

The CLI sucks and is counter intuitive.

Since there aren't as many users as Windows, the number of websites, supporters, stores, etc don't compare and that is a strategic disadvantage.

I could go on and on, but again, Linux has its strengths and weaknesses and so does Windows. I have chosen Windows.

by hal 9000

Why continue with the [b]Stupid Statements?[/b]

Now where did I ever claim that I was perfect [b]Please Enlighten Me[/b] as I'm never one to say something as stupid as that but then again I'm not going to say that M$, Linux, BSD or anything else is perfect either as that is just as Stupid!

You love M$ that's Cool with me and I can accept it but what I can't accept is your [b]Rabid[/b] defence of their Indefensible Business Practises where they outright lie to the customers then after the sale is made expect someone to come clean up the mess. That's the exact reason that I walked out of IBM many years ago as the Sales Staff would sell what they had on hand and not what was required by the buyer then the Techs where expected to make it work when it was never designed for that job that it was being used for. I mean Main Frames here and not the play toys that we deal with today though to be fair I can see the wheel turning back to a replacement Main Frame and Dumb Terminals or as you would like to call them Thin Clients on the desktop.

I just quite can not figure out your work experience as you say that you've worked for 4 years where you are and that you started there after you got out of school and then you throw in garbage like the above I think that you are far less than truthful to begin with or chose to make up stories as you go along.

[b]You are beginning to look Inconsistent![/b]

Col

by rkuhn040172

Where have you seen me saying I've worked at my current employer for 4 years and it's my first job out of college.

Perhaps that's what you want to believe.

I have been doing IT for almost 8 years now. I've been a website designer, project manager and now network administrator.

Hell, I've been a member of TR since 2001 so your math is a bit off.

On top of my IT experience, I have a business degree and several years of management experience.

Perhaps next time you could take the time to read someone's profile.

by jhecht

Anytime I have a Windows computer with important data on it, that won't boot, I either use a Linux distro like Puppy, Mepis, or Knoppix to back up the data, or I use the Ultimate Boot CD For Windows, which is a Bart's PE kind of a thing that you build yourself with an XP install disk & the Bart's files.

I can then bypass the (toes up) Windows OS, copy needed data to an external HD, and then wipe/rebuild the DOA Windows OS with confidence.

Of all of these, the UBCD has best USB support, but the Linux distros work 90% of the time.

Puppy is unique, as ONLY Puppy has the 'multi-session CD' option, which allows you to save data BACK to the boot CD. Assuming, of course, that you have a burner to work with.

To my knowledge NO other OS does this - Win, Mac, BSD, take your pick. I would (of course) LOVE to be proved wrong about this - but I don't think so...

Just out of curiosity, what tricks do you use to do this without opening the computer, and putting the drive in a 2nd machine? I'm always open to new tricks (grin).

And I wish that certain people here would learn to READ. The five (now) six Vista computers I've installed were brand new, pre-loaded, out of the box factory units.
I hooked them up for EU's on CompUSA calls.

So please don't blather at me about how I should re-image them (or not). That's not an option. You keep working with your herds of corporate computers. I work with end users, one at a time. Different game, different rules...

by rkuhn040172

However, while using the live distro disc I will create another partition, move the data to that partition, and then reformat OS partition only.

Moving forward, I show the customer how to save data to the now data partition so that if the problem ever occurs again, one they don't lose any data on reformat, two my job is a lot easier (and they pay me less).

by jackie40d1

Did not know that about Puppy I have a copy of it and all the stuff which comes with it think there were 1,000 files in 2 directories of programs to download . . think it took over a hour to down load . . Will have to burn the ISO's and check it out . . Oh by the way the NEW Protocal of "IPv6" will work in FreeBSD !
Supposed to be like up to 10 gig's per speeds
on the internet when they get it running they did some real fast stuff over a log distance in Japan ! Just read about it today in one of my techie e-mail . . I am presently downloading the above 3 Disks ( freeBsd 6.2 )

by rkuhn040172

Unless you are going to buy me the connection to the internet.

My poor little 6 MB DSL connection just wouldn't make a dent in the new IP stack.

by jackie40d1

The 6 CD version and it only has to make 2 items to work and I will leave Windows completely for ever . . Oh well I got to keep the hard drive with windows on it for just in case some one else needs help with their Windows stuff . . As I can load Code Weavers and run the rest of the stuff I run now like Quicken for money stuff . . Jee trying to think of what is NOT already in Linux That I run now in windows Oh yeah got a few Programs like my Flash program for making banners and stuff but there must be a Linux version of it

by ghostbrowser

How can any os with faults (bugs) be secure
How can people trust an os with faults
Or any software for that matter
As software companys seem unable to solve this problem
Microsoft seems to be the worst of them all
Please count the number of Security Updates for Windows Xp and get back to us

by ghostbrowser

The patches will never be done
Just look at prev OS
If you can get microsoft to say that
any of there OSs have no bugs let us know

by tony hopkinson

but just to potter at the moment, I'm back in windows world commercially.

At the time I was using it commercially it was hot off the press.

There's lot's of of stuff in a distro I don't use, a fair bit I don't like, even more that I don't have need for.

How much extra hardware did I have to buy for these updates to work?

Which of them did I have to pay for because I wanted an other one in the set.

Which of them did I have to buy a new license for?

Which one forced me to rework most of my current investment to take advantage of it?

You shouldn't have gone here.

Something like aero or bitlocker or the sidebar is not linux in a 'nix based environment, they are applications that you may choose to use, that may be commercial, that may be open source that will run on top of the OS.

There is no new version of the OS for such things unless a generic kernel modification is required, merely an extra application.

Monolithic vs modular.... Beuatiful is n't it ?

by jackie40d1

when the prices come down on the QUAD core CPU's I will most likely get an Update to my
P4 hyper threading 3.2 gigahertz and ( the memory stuff to early now can't think, not enough coffee yet )then add the what by then it will be DDR4 memory !. . As its now up to 1066 megahertz speed for DDR2 for the dual core CPU's thats using the 755 pin CPU or is it 775 brains not in full gear yet . . By then it will be what 16 core CPU's ? and maybe $500.00 per

by rkuhn040172

I'll give you the monolithic vs modular argument. That was easy.

Unfortunately, most people just want to buy a PC, turn it on and start using it.

Which they can do with Linux, don't get me wrong, but for 90% of the consumer market, they'd never take advantage of Linux's modular design.

So, is a benefit really a benefit if no one uses it? Kind of like if a tree falls in a forest and no one is there, does it make a noise?

by neon samurai

"Unfortunately, most people just want to buy a PC, turn it on and start using it."

Linux would be better for those people. For Windows or Linux, the computer vendor is putting it on the system. With Linux, they can include a complete pantheon of software and still not touch there profit margin.

Like you sade, the end user doesn't care if they turn it on and it works.

Games, Codecs and specialized hardware drivers are an issue though, but those that don't already exist will come with the users.

by hal 9000

But even on the latest Product Catalogue provided by M$ they don't list the CD version of Vista.

But then again the current model Wireless Keyboards & Mice as well as the M$ Branded Finger Print Readers don't come with Vista drivers either and M$ don't have any drivers available which was a bit of a shock to the system the last time that I looked. :D

Col

by tony k

Does insanity run in your family?

But then again the current model Wireless Keyboards & Mice as well as the M$ Branded Finger Print Readers don't come with Vista drivers either and M$ don't have any drivers available

Firstly...my god, I can't believe I actually have to explain this to someone. I'll try to type slowly, because apparently you learn slowly...keyboards and mice, don't NEED special drivers. The drivers have been available as part of the OS since day one. If a keyboard needs special SOFTWARE (not a driver, software. There's a subtle difference between the two) for things like "extra keys", then you install the software in Vista, just as you would XP. the process is the same, despite the box not specifically saying "Vista" on it. You know they did ship products before Vista that might just be still sitting on a shelf. Should MS come around to your local store and slap a Vista sticker on it to make it easier for you to grasp that? I realize it must be difficult for an end user like you to understand, but if you're going to post on a technical forum, at least try to pretend you know what you're talking about.

So, since the MS hardware site says their products are "Vista-able", was your statement a lie or complete ignorance followed up with a shot of inability to actually Google "+microsoft +fingerprint +reader"? The #1 feature listed for the reader is "Convenience with Windows Vista? Features"

Let me help a little bit: when you start agreeing with Jackie, you should know you're in trouble...

by rkuhn040172

Well said.

And to think most people think only Windows users spread FUD.

Yes, I said the dreaded FUD word. I'm pretty sure it's FUD because while I don't too much like Hal, he at times, is fairly knowledgeable.

Can't believe he'd fumble like that.

Good catch Tony K. If I wasn't at work doing 10 things at one time I might of caught that too.

by jackie40d1

Gee getting really wild there with the security thing . . But since it does not have a "VISTA" driver I would not move to the upgrade . . Wait for a year for the people whom made it to either make a driver for Linux or windows and go with the direction they did with their driver . . I got to go to Linux central and get a book for how to make drivers for 2 items this morning . .

by rkuhn040172

One thought for you.

Let's assume (some will disagree) that Windows is the most attacked OS because it is the most used OS.

Let's also assume it is the most patched OS because it's the most attacked OS.

It would then follow that Windows has had the most number of flaws discovered and then patched.

We have more knowledge of and have patched more problems with Windows than any other OS. The same cannot be said of many other OS's.

Take another lesser used OS. There is not nearly as good an understanding of its security footprint because it isn't attacked as often.

I'd rather use an OS that has been battle tested for many years (including BSD by the way) than an OS like Apple (just an example) that hasn't been beaten on as hard.

For all you know, there could be many more bugs in other OS's but until their usage increases, we may never know.

Take another example. The browser Firefox. 1-2 years ago it was the poster child for safe and secure browsing. Probably still safer than IE in some regards.

However, look at the number of vulnerabilities being discovered with it everyday now. Lo and behold, as usage increased, so did the incentive for hackers to attack it.

I almost guarantee you, if any OS had the market share of Windows, it'd be attacked, hacked, and cracked just as much.

Sure, the inherit design architecture of Linux is supposedly better than Windows. So, even if Linux had the Windows 80-90% market share and attacking it would be harder, it still would be done.

Typical reward/risk analysis. Hackers would go after it like flies on sh1t.

by jackie40d1

I wish I had that much time to count the patches . . I understand Apple put out 25 patches just a few days ago . . Sounds like they are developing MS's habits . .I hope not !
I do good keeping up with Win 2K pro fixes and delete the ones for IE or any other windows programs as I do not use them . . I have been using 3rd party stuff for ever on windows just NEVER trusted their stuff . . They should stick to the O/S and let third party people make programs to fit in ! That way it [b]WOULD[/b] have been a good O/S !

by rkuhn040172

Whether you use it or not.

It is so intregrated into the OS, not patching it, whether you use it or not, is a bad policy.

by rkuhn040172

Software doesn't solve problems. People solve problems.

If they can't hire a competent Windows Sys Admin, what the heck makes you think they are going to hire a competent Linux Sys Admin?

Besides the fact that I don't recall Hal ever saying there was a security problem in his story.

There were problems with incompetent sys admins, no servers, WGA issues, etc.

You are using a hammer where a screw driver is more appropriate. Throwing the baby out with the bath water.

by jackie40d1

I got 2 items to get drivers for in Linux ( means I got to buy a book from Linuxcentral )and make the drivers for them !
I got 2 things which Linux See's but can't get to run yet ! My ADS Tech DVD Express and my Verizon USB720 Broad band Modem . .

by rkuhn040172

Buy yourself a $30 router from Best Buy, put it between your PC and modem and check your Verizon broadband modem off the list.

God, can't believe I'm helping you!

Besides that, the fact that virtually all home/soho routers on the market today are running some form or another of Linux in them should make you happy.

by neon samurai

I rather like the linksys wrt54gs for a router. If you find the embedded OS too limited, OpenWRT makes everything wonderful. For me, it meant 50$ router hardware with completely expandable software. I even issue my dhcp machines with specific IP based on MAC.

by rkuhn040172

Excuse me if I'm wrong here, it's been a while since I've had to memorize a bunch of book knowledge, but Jabbotts, I'm pretty sure that using any router with static IP addressing turned on you are assigning specific IP addresses to PC's using their MAC address.

It doesn't take flashing the firmware in your WRT54G from Linksys and getting all fancy and stuff with OpenWRT.

I'm sure OpenWRT is cool, but I prefer not turning my routers into paper weights.

by rkuhn040172

You clearly can't get your facts straight.

Show me one article proving your assertion that the US gov't has banned Vista for security reasons.

The CORRECT story is most gov't agencies have banned Vista (for the time being) for compatibility reasons.

Essentially the same reason why many companies aren't rushing out to upgrade.

Now, that may be a BIG story to you, but this has been the story since the beginning of time with almost all new releases of Windows (including other OS's too, BTW).

When RH or Apple or anyone releases a new OS, just how many businesses do you know of that immediately start installing it without testing first?

by rkuhn040172

The patches will never be done

The patches will never be done
Just look at prev OS
If you can get Linux to say that
any of there OSs have no bugs let us know

by neon samurai

The Linux people are the first to point out that all software created by human hand is flawed though it will mature.

The "bug free" claim is only in proprietary software where bugs are thought of as negative issues. The Linux croud (being above average in technical knowledge) understand that software updates (patches or new versions) are a good thing. Frequent updates are an indication of ongoing active development usually including new features along with addressing any previous flaws.

The "bug free" claim is just more bunk FUD to benifit those with a vested interest.

by rkuhn040172

A $400-$600 laptop, if I was that budget minded, with Windows and a brand name than some cheap generic brand and Linspire.

Trust me, around here we have Fry's. They sell a brand called "GQ" that is cheap. Really cheap...in more than one way.

There is a reason why Walmart sold those PC's with Linspire. Think about it.

I have no problem with someone who can't afford any better, but please, for those that can, please please please don't buy those. You will regret it.

On the other hand, I make a lot of money fixing those types of PC's, so please please please, go by 3-4!

by neon samurai

Regardless of what your running with it; cheap hardware just plain sucks. You could be running realtime certified software and you'd still be crap out of luck because of the hardware.

She's got the right OS to offer though and as long as she's not using the same budget bin hardware that WalMart would have picked up; her clients are better off for it.

by neon samurai

Hm.. is Bobby six pack going to buy this computer with something called Blah Linux running on it or is he going to by the same hardware with Windows running on it. Well, he got there by subway and all the posters he saw said Windows on them and he doesn't recognize what this other computer is running.

The consumer with choice chooses Windows because of marketing. I suspect it'd be very different if both systems where presented on an even basis of quality, functionality and expandability.

"It's really not a difficult concept: when people have a choice, they don't choose Linux." - That turkey don't fly. Your disregarding the reasons for the outcome of that choice.

Granted, marketing is something that FOSS is weak on. Marketing wise, Microsoft is king. Technically, it just isn't so.

by ghostbrowser

Microsoft can do better
They could be the first company
To produce an os with out bugs
Now that would be something
But very unlikely

I fail to see why microsoft
can not offer a choice of user interface
Eg win98 me xp And so on
As this is a small part of windows
And I mean it in 1 simple action
not 10 or more settings
Also if people know the user interface they are useing they can tell the person on the other end of the phone who is trying to help them
A standard interface makes this easy
Changing it makes it hard
Now heres one for you I heard that microsoft
payed apple for the rights for the first windows os
If you sell someone something that has faults you should have to fix all of the faults before you can say its finished
Or is it allright to sell things with faults in them
I am not talking about improvements
Apple etc did the gui interface before microsoft is this wrong ?????
Microsoft was a minor software house is this wrong ?????
Did you ever use microsoft software on those computers
Ibm Made the pc before Ms dos is this wrong ????????????
Windows vs Linux Same thing ms larger and full of bugs
The bigger the os the more Chance for bugs
And why load everything just incase
this is the os not the apps

by rkuhn040172

Do you really think the average home user (noob) is going to prefer the Windows install of Google Earth or the Linux version:

Windows - double click on the .exe file, click Next about 5-10 times, done.

Linux - open a terminal (cli if you like) and go to the folder where it downloaded

- type "chmod +x google.bin" with the correct google.bin filename.

it should turn green or present a * at the filename's end after

- type "google.bin"

All that and you can't even remember if that is correct!

Jesus, what is it with you guys? Are you really just old, crusty former Unix mainframe operators with no life?

News flash, you have to dumb things down to the level of the user if you ever expect them to use it.

I for one know Google Earth is immensely popular. If that is what it takes to install it, wow!

by rkuhn040172

First off, if OEM's start loading up Linux on new PC's, don't you think the consumer is going to expect to pay less for the PC?

After all, Linux is free and Windows isn't. Therefore, apples to apples, two PC's of exact specs, the Linux PC should cost less.

If you are shooting for a 5% profit margin, would you rather make 5% on a $500 PC or a $550 PC? That extra $2.50 per PC times a million PC's is a lot of money.

Second, related to above, don't you think that MS is so heavily discounting the price of their OS to the OEM that it isn't the most expensive component of the system?

I've heard that OEM OS's to the likes of companies like Dell, HP, etc are in the $30 per copy range, if not less.

I'd bet HP doesn't just say, "OK, charge $30 more". Nope. They say, "charge $30 more plus 5%".

Oversimplification for the sakes of Jabbotts.

by rkuhn040172

Your an idiot!

You are even arguing with yourself.

Not too long ago, you posted that no software is perfect essentially because it is made by humans.

Now, and I quote you, you say "They could be the first company to produce an OS without bugs".

I guess employees at MS aren't human?

Anyways, what gives? Stop typing in limerick form, we're not making poems or songs here and start using some punctuation and proper capitalization.

You're probably using Firefox right now since you hate MS so much...there are spell checkers made for that you know?