If the fight against terrorists is WWIII (and I am not willing to concede that it is a war or even qualifies as such) the Bush administration has done the worst job in US history of conducting the effort.
First, the effort to eliminate terrorists is no more a war than the failed war on poverty, or the war on drugs. All 3 are doomed to failure because we are fighting the symptoms and not the root cause.
Second, just like the war on drugs, there are no specific borders or physical battle lines in the conflict. Nor is there a specific cohesive enemy.
Third, I find it astonishing how many people believe that the lack of attacks on US soil shows that the efforts against terrorists have been successful. As I recall, when the details of the 9/11 attacks were revealed, they had spent 8 years from the time the attack was conceived.
I suspect that some mastermind has selected the next US target, and the plan is in the process of being implemented. I am just as sure that part of any new attack on US soil will include decoy cells who's sole purpose is to sacrifice themselves so the main mission can survive.
The fight against terrorists needs to be handled more as a global police action than a war.
Yes, we did need to take over Afghanistan. In part to clean up the mess we left from the way the US supported the effort of the rebels who fought the Soviet troops in the 1980's.
Now, what to do?
First off, we should not and cannot appease the existing terrorists. We do however need to do a LOT to stop helping them recruit new terrorists.
1. Drop the concept of the enemy of my enemy is my friend. We should not be aligning ourselves with, or supporting governments that do not adhere to our beliefs of freedom and opportunity.
2. US related companies need to do a better job of respecting local customs when operating in foreign lands.
3. The US needs to be the first to step in when a government abuses it's citizens. We should have stepped in at the first sign of the ethnic problems in Rwanda and Darfur.
4. The US needs to be more willing to share our wealth with nations in crises. By any measure other than total dollars, the US gives the least to all forms of disaster relief. And, too much of our aid has tight strings attached.
Yes, we need to prevent aid money from lining the pockets of corrupt officials. But, we need to give the aid agencies and the aid recipients the ability to use the funds for what is needed, not what we want to provide for them.
5. Speaking of corruption, we need to stop using the rebuilding of Afghanistan and Iraq as a method to build profits for US companies.
Only when we eliminate the unjust actions of the US government and US companies, so that the terrorist leaders no longer have a simple easy message to draw in recruits, will we start to end the cycle of terrorism.
Unless we turn the entire world into a fascist police state, we will not bring an end to terrorism by military means.
Chas