Discussion Locked

World War III - Yes, President Bush is right

0 helpful
262 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

.
http://www.breitbart.com/news/2006/05/05/060505220719.qnjzncm8.html

There are too many Neville Chamberlains in the world, and we are stuck in 1936. When will the rest of the world WAKE UP and see this for what it really is?

UNCONDITIONAL SURRENDER should be the ONLY acceptable outcome. (And I don't mean the kind of surrender the French and the Democrats are suggesting.)

262 replies

by jardinier

You have to find them first. I assume you are referring to Muslim terrorists and not the whole Muslim population of the world.

One good thing that 9/11 bred is highly increased security measures to locate terrorists before they can perform their dastardly deeds.

A major terrorist plot was nipped in the bud in Australia not so long ago, and I am assuming that the primary reason there have been no follow-up attacks in America is attributable to the same factors -- highly increased surveillance and intelligence.

Increasingly some people are talking about a major winner-take-all jihad with Muslims in general. This would never be feasible as the largest groupings of Muslims are basically peaceable. The four largest groups of Muslims are in Pakistan, India, Bangladesh and Indonesia.

Of the top ten Muslim populations in the world, only one is in the Middle east -- Iran.

I don't know if I have addressed your question in the manner you were seeking, but will be more than happy to approach it from other angles if you could be more specific.

by maxwell edison

I really do agree with all you said, and it illustrates the difficulty of it all. It certainly does, at least to me, seem like a damned if you do and damned if you don't scenario. But I think we're at least on the right path, if for no other reason, it's a path that's different than any failed approach of the past.

I read an interesting article (editorial) in one of yesterday's newspapers. I'll try to find it on-line, and link to it; I think you'd like it. It gave me a somewhat different perspective, but not a different conclusion, and led me to draw an analogy, both of which I'll explain later. So stay tuned....

by absolutely

"Surveillance" or "espionage" are more accurate. Intelligence is an attribute of the manner in which information is [b]used[/b], not just the purpose for which it is gathered. From a current reporter, I could understand the vested career interest in using the vocabulary of the Pentagon. But from a former/retired journalist, who by all indications knows better, I feel you deserve a stern reprimand!

by deepsand

No amount of intelligence in the "intelligence community" can suffice to overcome the absence of such in the office of the Commander-in-Chief.

by km8295

I know this is the popular line, but I really want to encourage thinking and rational digging of the facts. If you think the President is not intelligent in his approach to the war on terrorism, then you made the allegation and you prove it. I hear a lot of rhetoric, but little hard-core data and proof. Yes, plenty of mistakes were made and many by a garbage CIA, State Dept. Clintonites, and others the President can only slowly root out. He blew it on the weapons of mass destruction thing, but still shook up the terrorist world badly, deflected attacks from this country, and put the terrorists on the defensive in their own back yard. These are not people to be reasoned with -- they are extremists (look at any extremist, and you'll know what I mean.)
So, prove your point, and we can fact-check each item. Forget mindless allegations.

by jardinier

but not with me. To the best of my knowledge, "intelligence" has been the only word used in connection with the gathering of and dissemination of information gained by surveillance and espionage in the current scenario.

Well of course we now know that the "intelligence" wasn't disseminated "intelligently," but please don't hold me responsible for repeating the only term that has been used.

by km8295

There is still sense out in the world. We have a real problem -- the extreme and fundamental reading of the writings of Mohammed particularly lead to violence, but the majority of Muslims take a moderate approach to the Koran. Therefore, we have peppered throughout the Muslin world the fundamentalists. If we erradicated them all, more would appear because the hardcore writings are still there and held in honor.
If we show that we will take no garbage at all from the extremists we have a chance in this war. Iraq may yet prove to be the smartest thing we ever did, if it works, because we transformed them. We need to take a strong approach with Iran. But will we, with all the whiney complaining we've had to endure? If we consistently take a no-nonsense stand, including military as needed, we will save the most lives on both sides and show that extremism has no chance to practice it's garbage.
The closer a follower gets to Muslim, the closer he gets to violence. The closer a follower gets to Christianity, the closer he comes to a peaceful, giving, self-sacrificial approach. We have moral superiority in this country -- we are better than many countries of the world because our ethic is better. I said better, not perfect. We have the best model to give the world. Let's continue to throw our weight around -- intelligently.

by jardinier

"The closer a follower gets to Christianity, the closer he comes to a peaceful, giving, self-sacrificial approach."

Well I guess you're pretty much out of touch with American evangelical Christians. Almost half the population of the USA comes under this umbrella.

I have a lot of interaction with them. They [b]HATE, HATE, HATE, HATE ALL[/b] Muslims, and continually perpetrate the lie that the terrorists represent the true teaching of Islam.

I also have almost daily contact with Muslims from Pakistan, India and Bangladesh. I accept these people as viable spokespersons of their respective countries. [For the most part they are in Australia for the purpose of studying at University].

They [b]ALL[/b] say that Islam as practised in their home countries is a peaceful religion. They abhor and dissociate themselves from terrorists.

So what do I deduce from this? That there is a lot more hatred by (predominantly) American Christians of Muslims, than vice versa.

I am aware that it is easy to read about violence in the Koran. But check your Old Testament and see how many atrocities -- including genocide -- were committed at the COMMAND of Jehovah.

by hal 9000

In the past we had States/Countries to carry on a war with to claim land and resources but with the current [b]WOT[/b] we are trying to fight Stateless people who are experts in hiding and only exposing themselves when it suits them to do so. This is unforatntly something that our miletary isn't setup to fight against just like the Russians failed in Afaganistian against basicly the same people.

In this war we need new taticts to counter the tatics of the enemy who has nothing to loose as they don't represent any State/Country they only represent an Idea which is the [b]Most Dangerious[/b] enemy that we have ever seen.

The Poms where supposed to learn from Northern Island but they failed there as we appear to be failing now by not being mobile enough and being [b]Easy Targets[/b] because of that very lack of mobility. This is something that we [b]CAN NOT AFFORD TO LOSE[/b] and something that is almost impossible to win. Currently we are all between a [b]Rock & a Hard Place[/b] in this situation with no answer appearing on the Horizen yet.

Our actions are not stopping the problem only feeding it as the enemy is constantly growing stronger by every action that we take to eleminate them we make more enemies than we had previously and what's worse are [b]Easy Targets[/b] by our inability to blend into the background and disappear. And to make matters worse the Internet is now being used to spread this rubbish against us to encourage more people to join the fight to liberate their fellow men & women from the oppression of the [b]Infidel.[/b]

We can't stay and we can't walk away it's an impossible position to be in and our own infrastructure is what is working against us the most.

God I wish there was some form of answer that didn't involve invading countries to achieve our objectives and then be stuck there to clean up the mess. We need to be highly mobile and invisible to finish this off and that is exactly what we are not!

Col

by hal 9000

Trying to copy Max and worse still attempting to hijack one of Maxwell discussions all in the same post. All I can say is.

:^0 :^0 :^0

by mjwx

Your enemy:
Adept at hiding,
has no regular forces (poorly or untrained),
does not engage in open combat,
adheres to no rules of war (Geneva convention, etc...)
Hides amongst civilian populations,
no war industry (no installations to protect),
small in number,
reliant on secrecy,
uses non-conventional tactics,
[b]extremely[/b] dedicated,
moves in secret, mostly slow but that depends on the level of secrecy

Your forces:
Large in number
Regular (trained) troops.
large war industry (a lot of installations to protect),
engages mostly in open combat (does not rely on subterfuge),
must adhere to Geneva convention on war and human rights (this is what makes us better than them right?),
autonomous of civilian populations,
operates in the open,
uses conventional tactics,
fast moving,
undedicated (relative to enemy),

This is like trying to perform surgery with a battle axe.

The answer is to fight the enemy where they stand because they will not come out to fight us (they have no army to fight with). You can not fight an [b]extremely[/b] dedicated small force that can hide anywhere with a large relatively undedicated force that sticks out like a barn door on a whale.

Point in short, the US does not need an entire army but instead needs only half a battalion of very dedicated men and women. Once you find your enemy this number of combatants will be more than adequate, [b]once you find your enemy[/b] which so far your are not very successful (Saddam doesn?t count he was a dictator not a terrorist). Your enemy does not possess overwhelming numbers but they will never meet you in the open.

Your PR campaign can best be described as "Sucks". My advice to the worst administration in US history (AKA the George W Bush Administration) is to go to Vietnam, find the people who made the propaganda for the North Vietnamese and hire them (they were damn good at their job) because the current PR people are useless. If you lose a war in the hearts and minds of the people you have lost it on the battlefield.

by hal 9000

But the only valid reason to invade Iraq was so that you have a base of opperations in that area to strike from.

But did you notice how [b]World Opinion[/b] swung against us when we did this? In Afaganstian there where many countries willing to support the WOT and look at the number now.

I submit that because of some silly actions the war has already been lost and unless the so called Terrorists do something else on different shores it will stay that way. If they maintain their current tatics of only attacking in Afaganstain and Iran they will be the [b]Freedom Fighters[/b] that the French Underground where in WW11 even though Germany called them [b]Terrorists.[/b]

Unless thr US, UK and AU invade the entire world we are only feeding the problem and addressing a symptom not treating the [b]Root Cause.[/b]

Fundlimenst anything are always dangerious remember Jonestown?

Col

by deepsand

1) Saddam was not about to let a "small" foreign military force have access to his country, even if there [b]had[/b] been terrorists there; therefore Saddam needed to be deposed. And,

2) Once having deposed the government of Iraq, the US, as an invader, is [b]legally[/b] responsible to the administration of the entire country, until such time as a new & capable indigenous government is installed.

You're not going to accomplish any of this with "half a battalion."

by deepsand

Invading Iraq, a country with no demonstrable role in said war, was not an effective use of our resources.

Furthermore, the failure to enlist the willing co-operation of the American public, only to have the stated rational for such invasion turn out to be mere rationalization, with the result that the public is becoming increasingly skeptical of either the need for or the value of our involvement in military action abroad, can only serve to make it more difficult to now get such.

This is precisely what happened re. the Vietnamese war.

by jardinier

Apart from the developing public skepticism, I don't think you can make a fair comparison between Vietnam and Iraq.

I started a discussion on Vietnam recently, only to find that it was a topic which most people were reluctant to talk about.

As you have raised the issue of the similarity of these two wars, perhaps you would care to elaborate.

The first difference that comes to mind is that the North Vietnamese communists had not made any attack on US soil.

by deepsand

The most important part of the parallel that I drew is in reference to the failure of the administration to enlist public support prior to the initiation of military action, followed by a period of time during which it was steadfastly claimed that we were "winning" a "necessary war" to stem the tide of Communism, and ultimately to the administration scorning the naysayers as being "unpatriotic."

by absolutely

Both were [b]associated[/b] with a group [Comintern & Al Qaida, respectively] that are actively attempting to undermine the United States. In both cases, there is an argument that the connection, if any, is less relevant than more immediate threats. I think the comparison was useful a & appropriate.

by dawgit

Vietnam, the Republic there of, Had a lot more trees than Iraq.!. And Iraq still hasn't attacked the US. In fact the Iraqi people used to admire the US.

by km8295

Yes, the Iraq war has turned public sentiment and made it almost impossible to go after Iran even if they go nuclear. This is the first valuable point you've made. However, our loss of life in Iraq has been tiny compared with any other real war, and we have get terrorists running into their own backyard instead of ours. Iraq was a calculated risk and the best we could do given the data available at the time and the 18 months we took trying to solve it diplomatically with the U.N. We took a shot. I hope we haven't lost because public sentiment has turned. But perhaps good sense will still reign before Iran becomes a nuclear blackmailer.

by hal 9000

It?s one thing to have the ability to enrich Uranium and another thing completely to call them a Nuclear Power. Currently the US enriches more Uranium than any other country around the world but the majority of it is used for peaceful purposes like generating Electricity or Doping Silicon so that you can have all our Silicon based technology.

Recently even the Weapons Grade stuff has been converted to Industrial purposes in the US.

But there is one obvious thing that I have to point out here it?s one thing to be able to make a [b]fission weapon[/b] and it?s entirely a different thing to be able to develop a [b]Delivery Platform[/b] at the moment Iraq has the ability to enrich small amounts of Uranium it?s a very long step from there to developing any form of fission weapon let alone a delivery system. And even if they could manage to produce both they still need a Trigger substance to actually make a fission weapon which they currently do not have the ability to obtain in the foreseeable future.

If all you are worried about are [b]Dirty Bombs[/b] Iraq doesn?t need to produce any enriched Uranium at all there is enough low yield stuff dumped every year improperly in countries like Mexico and just visiting the local dump would yield the necessary substance for a weapon like that.

Col

by deepsand

We did not enter Iraq because the terrorists were there. The terrorists went to Iraq because we were there.

GWB knew that the terrorists were not in Iraq, knew that there was no susbstantive evidence of WMDs in Iraq, but was determined to go to war because Saddam had defied him. Even GWB's father advised against such.

GWB ended up squandering our military & diplomatic capital, and should be impeached.

by deepsand

That fly was so very carefully designed & tied, with just one fish in mind.

Do you think he'll notice?

More importantly, do you think he'll rise to the bait?

by deepsand

It's nearly 01:15 here, I've been up since 05:30 yesterday morning, I'm nearly out of coffee, I opened my last pack of smokes an hour & a-half ago, and my typing is going to hell, which tells me that it's time to pack it in, grab some grub and get some shut-eye.

Keep the fire going 'till I get back.

Enjoy.

by jardinier

I think (just an idea) that the USA has become too dependent on military hardware as a way to fight wars.

The hardware was essential in WW II, but the big "Shock and Awe" at the beginning of the current incursion in Iraq appears to have achieved nothing more than the destruction of a lot of buildings which will earn income for the companies which rebuild them.

I have a clear recollection of an interview with an American fighter pilot in the first Gulf War. He was in awe of the sophistication of his weaponry but did not seem to equate it with killing people.

I also think something is amiss when the country with 5 per cent of the world's population, accounts for 50 per cent of military spending world-wide.

I think Colin has made a particularly clear and sensible observation on the discussion topic.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=194380&messageID=2005837

by tony hopkinson

I loved him. Did he ever deviate from his script ?.

If he wouldn't say it was WWIII, that means GWB wouldn't say it was WWIII.

I was over in Holland for 9/11 and picked up all my news through CNN. Us brit's used to sit entralled watching Ari stay on message, don't have anyone near that good in british politics. The american who we were stopping didn't like him anywhere near as much.

The only way to get unconditional surrender from an enemy is to win, neither 'side' have even approached winning. View this conflict on a material basis and neither side ever will.

by hozcanhan

When I was in the States, 25 years ago , I said to my American friends : "Behaving the way you are , you are making enemies and creating monsters!" . The years have proved me right . Monsters ? Taliban , Bin Ladin , "nuclear Ahmedinecad" ....You see ! bigger every time. Solution ? Stop being a "bully" , "policeman" , "god" of the world , and help local democratic authorities to beat the monsters by providing better living standarts to their citizen ; so that they have something to lose , if they decide to become a suicidal terrorist: A nice home !

by deepsand

Of the countries named by you, none qualify as such.

You seem to overlook the fact that the living conditions which you so rightly decry are [b]not[/b] the product of [b]democratic[/b] regimes, but of [b]totalitarian[/b] ones. These are regimes that, by their very nature, will [b]not[/b] co-operate with the outside world other than to the extent required to insure their survival.

by thechas

If the fight against terrorists is WWIII (and I am not willing to concede that it is a war or even qualifies as such) the Bush administration has done the worst job in US history of conducting the effort.

First, the effort to eliminate terrorists is no more a war than the failed war on poverty, or the war on drugs. All 3 are doomed to failure because we are fighting the symptoms and not the root cause.

Second, just like the war on drugs, there are no specific borders or physical battle lines in the conflict. Nor is there a specific cohesive enemy.

Third, I find it astonishing how many people believe that the lack of attacks on US soil shows that the efforts against terrorists have been successful. As I recall, when the details of the 9/11 attacks were revealed, they had spent 8 years from the time the attack was conceived.

I suspect that some mastermind has selected the next US target, and the plan is in the process of being implemented. I am just as sure that part of any new attack on US soil will include decoy cells who's sole purpose is to sacrifice themselves so the main mission can survive.

The fight against terrorists needs to be handled more as a global police action than a war.

Yes, we did need to take over Afghanistan. In part to clean up the mess we left from the way the US supported the effort of the rebels who fought the Soviet troops in the 1980's.

Now, what to do?

First off, we should not and cannot appease the existing terrorists. We do however need to do a LOT to stop helping them recruit new terrorists.

1. Drop the concept of the enemy of my enemy is my friend. We should not be aligning ourselves with, or supporting governments that do not adhere to our beliefs of freedom and opportunity.

2. US related companies need to do a better job of respecting local customs when operating in foreign lands.

3. The US needs to be the first to step in when a government abuses it's citizens. We should have stepped in at the first sign of the ethnic problems in Rwanda and Darfur.

4. The US needs to be more willing to share our wealth with nations in crises. By any measure other than total dollars, the US gives the least to all forms of disaster relief. And, too much of our aid has tight strings attached.
Yes, we need to prevent aid money from lining the pockets of corrupt officials. But, we need to give the aid agencies and the aid recipients the ability to use the funds for what is needed, not what we want to provide for them.

5. Speaking of corruption, we need to stop using the rebuilding of Afghanistan and Iraq as a method to build profits for US companies.

Only when we eliminate the unjust actions of the US government and US companies, so that the terrorist leaders no longer have a simple easy message to draw in recruits, will we start to end the cycle of terrorism.

Unless we turn the entire world into a fascist police state, we will not bring an end to terrorism by military means.

Chas

by deepsand

It found that, unlike Clinton, Bush [b]failed to become adequately involved[/b] and [b]failed to exercise leadership[/b] in the efforts to thwart terroristic attacks prior to 911.

And, since then, we've come to learn that his rationale for invading Iraq was but smoke and mirrors, and that he knowingly and willfully ignored the advice of experienced and knowledgable military personnel.

These are [b]not desirable[/b] traits for a Commander-in-Chief.

by x-marcap

Why did he time his activities to coincide with his grand Jury testimony, his perjury, and other nefarious acts???

Clinton used Military action to draw attention away from impeachable crimes...

by absolutely

911 Commission: "Bush failed to become adequately involved and failed to exercise leadership in the efforts to thwart terroristic attacks [b]prior to 911.[/b]"

Before 9-11: Bush took too little action to thwart terrorist attacks.

After 9-11: Bush took the [b]wrong[/b] action, against the wrong country, on behalf of a country that was given information that was known to be outdated, except for what was simply false ("Curveball").

As long as tjsanko has started the conspiracy theory game, let's suppose Bush also had a motive before 911 for ignoring terrorism. Let's suppose that his motive was to start a war, conquer Iraq, and give lots of money to his pal (blackmailer? What the hell, blackmail makes a more tangled web, thus a better conspiracy theory, right?) Richard Cheney, who has oddly insisted on never attempting to become President. If Bill Clinton was trying to divert attention from one extramarital affair when he fired one missile at one chemical plant, what might GWB be trying to divert from our attention by firing all forms of ammunition all over Iraq for years?

by absolutely

In order to prevent making more messes, we should establish a more exact policy of providing support abroad only to groups whose leaders pledge a firm commitment to the principles that government exists to protect individuals' rights, and that civilization requires that even the rule of the majority is limited to respect the rights of individuals.

by tomart

Let me stress this point. Iraq never attacked us, and wasn't about to. There was never any proof that Saddam supported the 9/11 terrorists. Please don't tell me you still think there was. Do you think he had WMDs ready too?
Any wonder why the rest of the world disagreed with our unnecessary, illegal invasion?

And as for Unconditional Surrender - who do you envision signing the surrender documents? Bin Laden? Even if we capture him and he recants and sees the error of his ways, there's no stopping new cells forming, as long as [see TheChas' 5/07 post for how to start fixing things.]

by deepsand

I'm assuming that your post was intended as a reply to Jules, rather than myself.

by x-marcap

Iraq had Al Quaida ties. The Iraqi intelligence agency made contact with Atta...

Don't be stupid, Saddam had control of Iraq. It wouldn't have happened if he didn't want it to happen. Atta was known as the exchange student...

by absolutely

Who remembers what he said about nation-building in the debates in 2000 when he was campaigning?

by andy goss

The current situation has more in common with the Cold War. Not the MAD confrontation but the attempts to foment revolution around the world. The methods are the same, and the Muslim foot-soldiers probably have no greater grasp of Islamic theology than their Communist precursors did of Marxist theory.
Unfortunately the US seems to have learnt nothing from their grotesque failures of the Cold War, from which Latin America is still suffering.
The US should take a look at how the British were able to keep Malaya out of Communist hands without installing a corrupt and bloody dictator.
Even if it is done well it is not going to be easy, and from their track record I can't see the current administration even trying to do it well, they would sooner fail than admit they have stuffed up.

by dotxen

Important stuff yes, but this can't be the forum to discuss this kind of topic.

People who visit this site (present company excepted of course) are far too anal to even know who President Bush is.

So, what do you think about Pacifica?

by absolutely

We're all off-topic and should thank you for showing us the error of our ways.

Or, maybe, this topic is correctly being discussed in "Miscellaneous" and you made an a55 of yourself.

by dawgit

are you refering to the car (Chrysler) or the Radio Station (Pacifica.Org) ??
Actually this has a lot to do with IT. Correct and acturate information is important to any free people who intend to stay that way. IT helps achieve that (or doesn't). Hitler and the Nazis of the 20's and 30's got the power they did with effect use of IT (or what is was in that period of time).

by deepsand

Main Entry: mis?cel?la?neous

Pronunciation: "mi-s&-'lA-nE-&s, -ny&s

Function: adjective

Etymology: Latin miscellaneus, from miscellus [i]mixed[/i]

1 : [b]consisting of diverse things[/b] or members : HETEROGENEOUS
2 a : having various traits b : [b]dealing with or interested in diverse subjects[/b]

by ang2006

I have read many of these statements and the one by Maxwell is the closest to the truth. Always with the goody two-shoes it is questions like, Was Iraq a threat? blah blah blah. With a rabid dog like Saddam you put a bullet in his head the same as you do with a Hitler. The man was evil and only a fool would say otherwise(gassing his own people). Way too many Chamberlains in the world spouting wussified statements like if we just give them a fair chance then maybe they will play nice like us---I for one am tired of playing nice. I believe in total all consuming war the way Patton, Alexander the Great, & Julius Caesar believed in it. Every other major power which has ever existed on this earth not only had their own way but literally subjugated the rest of the known world. Now I don't think we should do that but if we decide no Saddam; he has to go; bad guy; whatever--then so shall it be. Patton said that War was dirty business and that is why it should be exercised with overwhelming flowing destruction to such a point that the fear of God is put in the hearts of those who would dare to resist. Rather than go on and on here--I will just say that when real men try to do something right, they almost always have to restrain themselves from the total war thing because of cries of injustice. So what is the result of restraining themselves---more complaints about how badly the war is....can't win for losing. The only way we could possibly not win this war is if all the candy behinds in this country prevent it by whining! Now I admit I have come on real strong here but I am just tired of all this pacifist crap--Good thing I am not President cause I don't care about the next election only the next generation!

Some Quotes:

Dorothy Thompson: They have not wanted Peace at all; they have wanted to be spared war -- as though the absence of war was the same as peace.

John Stuart Mill: War is an ugly thing, but not the ugliest of things. The decayed and degraded state of moral and patriotic feeling which thinks that nothing is worth war is much worse. The person who has nothing for which he is willing to fight, nothing which is more important than his own personal safety, is a miserable creature, and has no chance of being free unless made or kept so by the exertions of better men than himself. (all the whiners kept in freedom by the better)

Albert Einstein: The world is a dangerous place, not because of those who do evil, but because of those who look on and do nothing. (after all Iraq isn't hurting us)

Holocaust Museum, Washington, DC: Thou shalt not be a victim. Thou shalt not be a perpetrator. Above all, thou shalt not be a bystander.

And it still rings true 230 years later----

Patrick Henry: It is in vain, sir, to extenuate the matter. Gentlemen may cry, Peace, Peace--but there is no peace. The war is actually begun! The next gale that sweeps from the north will bring to our ears the clash of resounding arms! Our brethren are already in the field! Why stand we here idle? What is it that gentlemen wish? What would they have? Is life so dear, or peace so sweet, as to be purchased at the price of chains and slavery? Forbid it, Almighty God! I know not what course others may take; but as for me, give me liberty or give me death! March 23, 1775

by hal 9000

There are a lot of nasty people in this world and some of them are even currently in power some are no longer but I still see nothing at all being done to stop them.

Rember Lockerby that had no connection with Saddam it was another current Leader in the Middle East who was responsible for that but he's still there and considered as a [b]Good Guy[/b] because [b]He Promised[/b] he would destroy all of his Nuk Ambitions.

Or that guy from Uganda who couldn't be bothered even shooting his victums as bullests cost money so just rip a branch off the nearest tree and club them to death.

Col

by maxwell edison

You're not exactly right, Colin, when you suggest that he just [i]"promised he would destroy all of his Nuk Ambitions"[/i].

Just after we took out Saddam (with the help, of our British, Australian, and other allies, of course, but not Canada), the leader of Libya, Moammar al-Ghadafi, publicly confirmed his commitment to disclose and dismantle all weapons of mass destruction programs in his country, and he agreed to immediately and unconditionally allow inspectors from international organizations to enter Libya -- things that have indeed happened. And he did it via direct contact with the leaders in London and the United States.

You make it sound less significant that it really was, and that's being neither fair or accurate.

http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2003/12/20031219-9.html

Come on, Colin. Don't make a molehill out of a mountain.

by Member 25348569

A quote right back at you...

Tony Blair - "Well, George, this is another fine mess you've gotten us into."

Ok. So tell me. What are you going to do and how are you going to do it? You're the one with most of the nukes, the ones with the ability to bomb the wrong building with inch-perfect accuracy from 40,000 feet up, the ones with more of the military might than your enemies, friends (if you have any) and the neutrals put together. Who are you going to shoot with all of that next? France?

You're an idiot. I'd nick Maxwell's URL but it's his thread and I'm not really on the same side.

Haven't you worked it out yet? YOU CAN'T WIN THAT WAY! There is nothing to "win". Your real victory will consist of them leaving you alone. You can either do that by reducting Pakistan and the Middle East to a glassy plain, killing a billion people, or by getting involved in some form of dialogue and converting the governments of these countries to - if not friends - at least to people whose best interests are served by helping you (openly or otherwise) deal with the nutters. You won't achieve that at the point of a gun - you just get more nutters and more finance for the nutters.

I'll make the point that I've made on this subject before. The bombings of London were a [b]direct[/b] result of the UK's involvement in the invasion of Iraq. That is something that we [b]have[/b] to take on board. If we do, then those 52 people won't have died for nothing. We either talk or - using your solution - we wipe out all the Muslims in the UK just in case. That's 1.6 million.

As for how well you're doing so far, the current status of Iraq is - to put it simply - shambolic and it isn't getting better.

Just my twopennorth.

by maxwell edison

Your quote: [i]Tony Blair - "Well, George, this is another fine mess you've gotten us into."[/i]

Context and source, please.

by mjwx

detest the way this war was being fought. From my understanding of history nothing frustrated him more than not being able to face Rommel on the open battlefield. We do need another Patton, someone to pull your leader's head out of their arse and tell them what a p1ss poor job their doing.

More Quotes for you.

"War is not nice" - Barbara Bush

"I do not know with what weapons World War Three will be fought with but World War four will be fought with sticks and stones" -Albert Einstein

"It is well that war is so terrible, or we should grow too fond of it." - Robert E Lee

"I have never advocated war except as a means of peace." - Ulysses S Grant

"You can't say that civilizations don?t advance, however, for in every war they kill you in a new way." - Will Rodgers

"What difference does it make to the dead, the orphans and the homeless, whether the mad destruction is wrought under the name of totalitarianism or the holy name of liberty or democracy?" - Ghandi

"There is no kind of dishonesty into which otherwise good people more easily and frequently fall than that of defrauding the government." _ Benjamin Franklin

"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety." - Benjamin Franklin

I threw those last two in, in the (vain) hope you may think about the actions of your own government.

by absolutely

[i]"What difference does it make to the dead, the orphans and the homeless, whether the mad destruction is wrought under the name of totalitarianism or the holy name of liberty or democracy?" - Ghandi[/i]

It makes no difference once we're dead, but it makes a great deal of difference to the living. Of course, life is the primary value, without which no other values can be achieved or even pursued. Still, other values exist, and [b]quality[/b] of life is worth pursuing also.

by deepsand

None of the persons that you quote would have advocated the course of action chosen by GWB.

And, had they been forced to, they would not have chosen to execute it in the manner that he has.

by x-marcap

I don't have enough information to know if the war in Iraq has been pursued in a logical, methodical, well executed plan.

I do know that the Iraqi Tank units were dealt with in a magnificent manner; the Republican Guard was handled decisively.

What I do know is that we have not got a MacArthur to administer the post war. There were pockets of resistance by the Japanese post WWII.
They were eliminated effectively.

The war was over because those who instigated it had surrendered. Until we decide that the Ones who call for Jihad have changed their minds, or been neutralized, this will be a long slow bleeding attrition.

The catch is, the total of dead and wounded is miniscule in comparison to WWII. We'd need 50 years of action to match the Gettysburg battle alone.

Col was right in one thing; we would be hard pressed to fight WWII over. He is correct about the offshore manufacturing.

However, he doesn't realize that we have Steel plants ready to be fired up in many cities. We have three steel plants in Canton OH alone that could be fired up... We could ramp up for a real war in a month, and then look out...

But he is wrong in other issues. 1/2 of all the worlds military spending is still a smaller % of GDP than the other countries spend as an average. But that isn't true anyway. China is spending a bunch as is the Russian Federation...

The US isn't 50% of all economic activity is it?

The US is fighting the war with 1% GDP. Or is it .1% GDP? NAZI Germany used 80% GDP in WWII. Japan over 90% GDP. The US used 20% GDP in 1945.

I haven't been asked to cut back on driving, plant a victory garden, recycle steel and aluminum etc for the war effort.

This isn't a war. I am more against this than Vietnam or Korea, but it is time Sandy and other disgruntles realize that most of the US won't ever vote for a traitor like John Kerry.

If I had been a Military prosecutor when his book came out, I'd have indicted Kerry. And if what he said/wrote was true he should have been tried in military tribunal, and then executed.

There is never an excuse for an officer allowing atrocities. There is no excuse for an officer not preventing atrocities.

Rocks and Shoals still is the basis for our USCMJ.
The actions Kerry described should have merited action on the part of the DOD.

by dawgit

"they are extremists (look at any extremist, and you'll know what I mean.)
So, prove your point, and we can fact-check each item. Forget mindless allegations"
Ok, but which side are you talking about here?

by absolutely

What is? I think you misplaced your post, because it doesn't address what I said.

[i]If you think the President is not intelligent in his approach to the war on terrorism, then you made the allegation and you prove it.[/i]

If you think I made that allegation, show me when & where I made it, [b]then[/b] I'll prove it.

by dawgit

Shoot we left enuf of that stuff (low grade U) laying around all over the place (in Iraq) from the first Gulf War.

by hal 9000

Was picked up and used to enrich they would at the very best only have a few ounces of the stuff which is next to useless for anything at all.

And that's not allowing for any of it being destroyed in the explosions that they caused as all of the DU was used as Amor Piercing Shells and Bombs so the vast nojority was destroyed or at the verl least atomised to such a point that they would ned to dig up thousands ot tones of soil to recover a very small amount.

While I personally don't see DU as [b]Harmless[/b] when it comes to weapon grade stuff it nothing more than a drop in the bucket. Anyway I wasn't aware that there was any DU actually used in Iraq I know that there was lots of it used in Iran but from my limited memory wasn't there a war going on between Iraq & Iran that was never really settled? They just ran out of things to throw at each other and the thoguht of throwing stones wasn't such a good idea as they could be picked up and thrown back.

Col

by dawgit

A whole lot of uninformed people can be fooled with just a little bit of useless DU, or even a sick chicken (yup, Here comes the bird flu)

by Member 25348569

the last time that GWB was over, I was invited to Chequers for tea with George and Laura and Tony and Cherie. I think Jack and Alice were there but who remembers the riff-raff. I think they were all setting up a bit of matchmaking for Condoleezza and that's why they invited me.

GWB expressed a desire for some intellectual stimulation and Tony put on a tape of "Are you Being Served?". We all saw that George was wrinkling his forehead at Mrs Slocum's "pu$$y" jokes so Cherie suggested Laurel and Hardy.

It was at [b]that[/b] point that Tony quipped with his paraphrase of Oliver's immortal line. George took it in good part and scratched the top of his head and burst into tears exactly as Stan Laurel would have done.

Oh! How we all did laugh...

by maxwell edison

Thank you, Neil, for clearing that up.

By the way, how did the matchmaking effort with Condi go? The last time I was at the White House chatting with her, she didn't mention it to me. And as long as you're not threatened by an extremely intelligent woman...... who knows?

by Member 25348569

She didn't mention you when talking to me, either.

That's it! She had her chance and she blew it!

It's probably better if she gets it together with a fellow citizen, anyway, being a potential Lady President in a few years.

Neil :(

Tell you. That Laura's a bit of a tease... :8}

by hal 9000

But he's still a nasty piece of work who is just as bad as Saddam ever was along with many others who are still doing as they please.

But this is exactly why we have to be careful, we have to root out these people and inprison them but at the same time not look as if we are starting another Crusade along the lines of Richard the Lion Heart.

This should always remain a [b]War On Terror[/b] and never be allowed to look as if it is some Rabid Fundilmanst Christian attack on Islam like it is currently being portrayed in the Middle East.

And no I'm not saying that I believe it is, but unfortantly that is how it is being portrayed in the Middle East and all Islamic Countries. They also only have to look back on History to believe this as well. Neither side previously has [b]Covered Themselves in Glory[/b] in this area and they have traditions that streatch back a very long way. We on the other hand have gathered all our Ideas of what we now call Chilivery from a Islamic King who was responsible for returning Jerusilum to the Islam Faith's control and he allowed the Christian Population not only to live under his occupation but move about freely and work and live with their Muslum Brothers & Sisters. Richard on the other hand put all of his prisoners to the [b]Sword[/b] an act of Brutality that is very hard to live down.

Unless you live in the area you will never fully understand just how badly we in the West are thought of and it is reasons like the above and the constant lies that have been told by the Western Leaders to the Arabic World that promots this mistrust that continues till today. So you can easily see how some rabid fundilmenst can gather such a large group around him to do his bidding.

We've seen it previously with the Radical Christian Sects so why is it so hard to understand that it can happen with other religions as well?

But the main point of the above post is [i]Why should we trust Ghadafi now with his previous track record?[/i] He wasn't a nice guy all those years ago and I very much doubt that he has changed any he's just looking out for his [b]Self Interests.[/b] The people in Libia certianly don't have a better standard of living that anywhere else in the Middle East and I really don't trust him not to bite the hand that feeds him if it suits his needs at that point in time.

Col

by maxwell edison

Saddam could have done the very same thing; he was given every opportunity to do the very same thing; and if he had done the very same thing, he'd still be sitting in one of his many Baghdad palaces.

by hal 9000

Saddam said I don't have any WMD's The Inspectors are welcome to come in and look for them but it was the US who veted these documents before allowing them to be presented to the UN in an Abridged form and then went on to insist that there where in fact WMD's in Iraq and Saddam was telling [b]Lies![/b]

I seem to remember photos of trucks and being told that they where in fact Mobile Labs which just plain & simple they where not.

There have been no WMD found in Iraq and for that matter none of the other items that he supposedly had.

So your point is what Maxwell?

Was he and [b]Evil Bastard? HELL YES[/b] but no more evil than many of the other Leaders in the surrounding Countries if he had of been anything less Iraq would have ceased to have existed a long time previously as it would have been invaded by one of the neighbouring countries and taken over completely.

The only thing that even comes close to using Iraq & WMD in the same Sentence would be the interpurtation of [b]Words of Mass Deception[/b] used on both the Citizens of the US and to the United Nations and there fore the entire populatyion of the world in general. I can still remember Colin Powel statment to the UN about just how nasty Saddam was and all the photos provided to prove the point. Now we hear some silly story that they where transfered to Jordon, Iran or where ever which is laughable if it weasn't taken so serriously by some people. Thesimple fact is that Jordon has remained netural and wouldn't wish to incure the wrath of the US by accepting these items and Iran is still or was still at war with Iraq just prior to the invasion.

If you remember my very first posting here I asked then [b]Who Got to decide who a Rouge Nation Was?[/b] Well if it's the UN I don't have a problem even with their limited powers and the right of different countries on the Security Council to Veto any action propossed by the UN. This is what is [b]Wrong[/b] with the UN nothing more and nothing less one country can have a [b]Vested Interest[/b] and prevent the UN doing what it was orriginally set up to do. The moment that the Right to Veto is removed from different countries the better off we will all be and just maybe that orginasition might even function the way it was intended and not go the way of the [b]Legue of Nations![/b]

If a single country gets the right to decide who they consider a [b]Rouge Nation[/b] we will constantly be in a [b]State Of War[/b] as there will always be countries who dislike another and believe that that have the right to use the [b]First Strike Option[/b] as a valid reason to defend themselves. While this may be fine for what are called Third World Countries with fanatical Religious Leaders I would have hoped that we where better than this.

Can you point to one action that has been sucessful where we where responsible for instigating [b]The First Strike?[/b] Lets face the facts in the hard light of day [b]We've already lost this one by forgetting our Morals and Decending to their Level![/b]

Col

by x-marcap

The balance of the Philippinos seemed to love the US Marines, US Military in General.

This is Pre independence Military experience. One civilian visit since left me with no difference in opinion. The problem was with the Marcos regime. We shouldn't have supported him, but found another pro-US leader to support.

The MacArthur's Pere, & fils (WWII general) were revered in the Philippines. Arthur, Douglas's father was the Military govonor of the Philipines, Douglas held dual Military positions Field Marshal of the Philipines, and US General.If we had let Douglas's son (in the late 1950's) be the Govonor there when the Philippino people requested it, this would be a much different world... Eisenhower had no love of Mac, or his son, and on Presidential Order, Mac's son was refused to visit there even as a civilian... MacArthur's son changed his name and is a pianist in NY city...

by mjwx

Not all Muslims hate the west, some only hate the US. Take Palestine for example, when an Australian and a German were taken hostage about two or three months ago. Once these "Terrorists" realised that their hostages were not Americans they were released with an apology which went something like "Sorry, we thought they were Americans". This is a PR problem you yanks have to work on.

And to clear up my position on the Palestine issue, the Palestinian authority should accept the 1967 borders. Israel should uproot any settlers on the wrong side of the border.
Israel should be a state
Palestine should be a state
Kurdistan should be a state
Because all three are trying to modernise

by x-marcap

In fact the Iraqi intelligence agency had contacts with Muhammed Atta...

The Iraqi government also provided $$$ to Palestinians who committed suicide-homicide bombings... As did the private Saudis... I hope The family Saud takes notice of the difference.

Most of the 911 hijackers were Saudi, but weren't supported by the government.

by hal 9000

The actual thing that happened was that the Iran Government provided funds to Arrafat head of the PLO [b]Another Terrorist and head of a Terrorist Orginasition who where accepted by the WEST[/b] to help the families of the dead suicide bombers.

As for funds while some did come from rich Saudi Families the majority came from th West in the form of wrongly Donated or Diverted Aid through NGO's.

Col

by maxwell edison

Saddam did indeed offer rewards to terrorists; and Saddam did indeed have ties to terrorists. (Now is when you might take my simple comments and suggest that I said something that I did not, like Saddam was responsible for 9-11.)

Did Saddam offer rewards to terrorists? Yes or No? I say yes. Do you say no?

Did Saddam have ties to terrorists? Yes or No? I say yes. Do you say no?

It's pretty simple, Colin. How do you answer those simple questions?

by deepsand

Osama had been in Iraq.

The fact is that Saddam did not trust Osama, and declined to have any part of him.

by x-marcap

The Iraqi's don't want the USA to leave until the foreign terrorists are gone. The Iraqi's like what we have done for them. Especially women appreciate the new respect they get in both Afganistan and Iraq...

Now that we have the extremists mostly in one place it is easier to fight them, when you can find them.

They still hide and don't wear uniforms, and should be executed as per Geneva convention... They aren't soldiers, but saboteurs...

by Member 25348569

All of the US forces and international personnel, journalists, etc in Baghdad are in the "Green Zone" and only venture out in heavily armed convoys. They only travel to the airport in convoys at the dead of night or by helicopter. The only news-gathering is by Baghdadi reporters and cameramen as any westerner unaccompanied by a major military presence would be kidnapped or killed immediately on venturing out past the blast walls.

To reiterate - You (and we) do not have the slightest idea what is happening in Iraq. There is probably a civil war going on but nobody really knows because there is no way to find out!

As for "The Iraqi's like what we have done for them", on what do you base that sweeping statement. Considering the continual breakdown of law and order, infrastructure and just about anything else, I would think that they hate us. You only have to look at the changing attitude of the population around Basra. The British troops used to patrol in berets and were appreciated by the locals. A couple of short years on and they hate us.

And for what? Because your President wants to show what a big d:ck he's got! At least Clinton only shagged at home.

by x-marcap

I am planning to join some Marines in Iraq for a brief time. If the powers that be allow me to join in with some of the Marines out there I will be traveling with a squad size patrol...

Don't get me wrong there is nothing wrong with large forces, but LRRPs don't travel in groups...

From what my old Colonel told me the people are very welcoming, but they live in great fear of the terrorists. They fear we will leave with the terrorists still there... That is their great fear...

by x-marcap

Shaped charges and calculus give you enough information... The trigger can be made with a simple set of switches...

The catch is calculating a critical Mass... Once you do that, the rest is simple engineering...

by absolutely

Only with the necessary equipment can the weapon be built. I haven't checked around because I know GWB will make the wrong decision regardless of the facts, but at least one news source concurs with HAL9000 -- Iran cannot enrich [b]enough[/b] Uranium to produce a nuclear reaction in less than a decade. If you care, you can do the research. I do not.

by x-marcap

Depleted Uranium is U238 predominately. For normal fission you want the more unstable U235.

To separate you need crushers, High speed centrifuges, and a bit more knowledge that I won't detail here... To make the H bomb you need H-2, but that is a whole 'nother ball of wax. The Fission is but a fuse...

H injection causes a real big bang if you can remember to do it right... The HE that results acts as a Modulator as does stable H...

When you start "enriching" which is simply centrifuging off what you don't want, you only need time and materials before you have enough fissionable material for a bomb...

by deepsand

I think you already know this, but decided to pretend otherwise.

And, we're not here to debate the merits of the [b]failure[/b] of the Republicans to win an impeachment conviction.

by hal 9000

But you are missing the point any high school student doing Phyiscs is capable of making a Fission weapon like those used on Japan at the end of WW11 Hell I could do it with my eyes shut but there is one fly in the oitment and that is getting the material to make the bang. That's slightly hard to come by and you need other things than just U235.

For a Controlled Implossion Devcice which is much harder to make as you need shaped charged to get the result that you want and have them go off in order you don't need the same quantie of materials but you do need access to special equipment that you [b]CAN NOT[/b] buy off the shelf. If you like I can give you the designes for the hardware required to make the U235 into the correct shape and you can try to get the proper equipment.

Long before you even get close to being able to shape the mold you would have the Feds crawling up your A$$ as there is only one ue for this type of thing and it certianly isn't a peaceful use. With the current [b]Home Land Security Act[/b] in place you just might get out of jail within the next 90 years. :^0

Remember that U235 has other uses as well they use it to generate electricity and make medical componds as well as dope Silicon for all that Silicon Technology that we just must have. There are far more Peaceful uses for U235 than there are Miletary uses.

But lets play the Devils adovacte here for one minute without U235 how is Iraq going to generate enough Electricity for their curent needs? They lack any [b]Natural Resources other than Oil[/b] which isn't a good heat source for Electricy Generation even the Natural Gass Power Stations are far more expensive to run than a Coal Fired Station and a U235 Station is even cheaper if you don't take into account the need to dispose of used material.

Col

by absolutely

made a big deal out of marital infidelity. Secondly, you do not know that Bill Clinton's response to the bombing of the USS Cole was a diversionary tactic. You do know that the USS Cole was bombed, by terrorists, and that some action was better strategy than no action would have been.

He timed his activities to coincide with two attacks: political, by Republicans; and military, by terrorists.

by absolutely

Just because your Prime Ministers and Chancellors say nasty things about our President for publication, doesn't change the fact that all our countries benefit immensely from international trade, including Australia and Germany!

by maxwell edison

......a former Naval Officer (very former, I might presume), over recently retired Marine Lt. General Michael DeLong, former Vice-Commander of CENTCOM, who said that Saddam DID have WMDs, but they were either buried in the desert and/or taken across the borders into Syria and/or Iran in the weeks leading up to the very public build-up.

General DeLong is anything but President Bush's flunky. And he is someone who was in the loop to really know. So why should we "no-nothings" believe you instead of him?

by deepsand

What has this to do with "involvement" and "leadership" within the context of the 911 Commission report?

by deepsand

You don't suppose that they were "abused" in any way, do you?

While that cannot be ruled out, a more likely possibility is that GWB is impotent, and is not their biological father. If such were the case, and became public knowledge, I believe that the damage to his Texas pride would be more unbearable than the allegation of child molestation, which in Texas is just boys being boys.

Given that Cheney came of age politically during Gerald Ford's tenure, he's the odds-on favorite to know where all the skeletons are.

by absolutely

Any good hypothesis must at least be plausible and testable. Although it's within the realm of scientific possibility, I'm afraid this one will never be tested due to political expediency.

by mjwx

which to make my self clear should be fought clandestinely (in the military sense, PR/propaganda should be quiet open). There is no need to take over countries because once an area becomes occupied by friendly forces the irregular enemy forces go to ground (and the good civilians of the occupied countries aren?t about to give up and cooperate with the invaders). Now the irregular forces have many targets to attack, distributed about territory which they can hide in easily (this is what makes Iraq similar to Vietnam).

Point 2, administration. Lets call a spade a shovel, its an [b]occupation[/b] and Iraq is under military dictatorship which is doing little to curb sectarian violence.

There should have been no need to take over Iraq,

1. The US has bases in Israel, Afghanistan, Saudi Arabia and Turkey (not sure about Saudi and turkey now but you did have them). A base of operation already existed.

2. All that needs to be done is to eliminate enemy leaders? in short sharp movements. To clandestinely take out a single unsuspecting al-Qaeda leader in his comfort zone (where he feels safe) would do more to destabilize the organisation and curb its growth than all the bombs that have been dropped since Oct 2001. Terrorist organisations depend on hiding, you need to demonstrate that they can?t hide to make them feel unsafe where they are safest. This can?t be done with a bomber at 35,000 ft. We need commandos, spies and infiltrators as opposed to a military or war in the traditional sense. I think it is far more effective to spend six months positioning an assassin to take out one man than to successfully occupy 6 nations because in the end I?ve got a better chance to take out a leader which the organisation is centred on. Killing 600,000 foot soldiers is not worth one general in the war on terror.

As you can see I would have run the war quiet differently and if I knew the US would have accepted a tyrant 6 years ago I would have put my hand up for the job (Cheap shot, yes I know).

by hal 9000

If all the Muslum nations of the world simply refused to have any dealings from tomorrow with the US where would you be?

Currently the US makes next to nothing on its own shores it [b]Outsources[/b] to the cheapest parts of the world which has it's merits but also its disadvantages particuarly when you have very expensive equipment to fight with, with a very short life time between major services. Do you think that the US Airforce could keep aircraft in the air for more than 6 months without replacment parts?

Do you think that Intel or AMD would still function at all? They could push out a limited number of CPU's from their [b]Prototype plants[/b] but only that as all their major manfacturing plants are [b]Off Shore![/b] Actually I don't think that the US could even supply bullets to its solders after the current stock pile is drained.

This really needs to be addressed before you even consider Peving anyone else off.

Lets look at the 9-11 fisaco the people involved where trained to fly in the US without question in almost every case as they only wanted to learn how to fly an aircraft, take offs and Landings where not taught to them this alone should have rung [b]Alarm Bells Violently[/b] but for some reason it didn't. Then through what can only be described as [b]Poor Security[/b] these people could get weapons onto the aircraft without a problem. This wasn't the first time that an airliner has been hijacked so why was it so easy for them to do?

I can give you the answer and it's easy [b]Greed[/b] the companies involved where only interested in taking money to teach and there where bribes paid to allow this to happen. In the form of over payments for lessons on flying with no concern as to what these people would ever be doing with this knolledge. These where not light aircraft but heavy Comerical Aircraft that they where taught on.

Here if I want to get even a Ultra Light Aircraft License which is the most easily got I still have to go through riggerious screening and medicals and that is for something that can only carry the pilot and is under a certian weight fully loaded with fuel and oil. If I was to approach a flight school for lessons on Comewrical Aircraft the very best that I could get would be a license to fly a 28 seat plane and even then if I only asked to be taught to fly and no attention to take off or landing firstly I would be thrown out and be reported to the Feds and this was prior to 9-11 it's much harder now.

Even then I don't believe you statment that [b]All Muslums[/b] hate the US but even if there is a high proportition you should be asking [b]Why?[/b] And not just burring your head in the sand complaining there is a reason for this if it actually exists and you should [b]Know Why It Is So![/b]

Personally I don't think that it is the indivuals who they hate but the country for its actions previously by supporting the Pre Demorcratic Leader and things like that. You really need to understand that, you [i]As a Country[/i] can only tread on people for so long before they bite back. I believe there is an old saying that goes along the lines of [b]You Reap What You Sow.[/b]

So instead of looking for enemies which previous administrations have made generally with the blessing the the People of the US of A you need to start trying to rebuild your relationships with these countries and you'll never do this with the barrel of a Gun.

This is something that I really find ammusing the massive complaints by the US Population in General about the amount of Foregin Aid that the US issues and then the constant unbelief that they are doing anything less than the most that can be done when complanits are actually made.

Currently the Middle East is a Total Mess and so is most of Africa and what are we doing about it? Nothing at all.

Is it then surprising that these people feel used and abused when they see well fed foreginers come in and take what they want while leaving them hungry?

If any country wants the [b]Tag of World Policeman[/b] they need to earn it not bully others into accepting it!

After all you should know what happens to the [b]School Bully[/b] so why should things be any different in the rest of the world? America isn't the center of the world and nothing at all actually revolves around America even though some of the population believe this.

What I find miost funny is that it's nearly impossible to get a few Million $ in aid but the easiest thing in the world for the US Citizens to accept a Multu Billion $ war that is open ended and a constant drain on their limited resources.

Col

[i]Edited for [b]Maxwell[/b] Yes I can feel the steam coming out of your ears now but I'm only trying to make a point and I don't necessarly agree with all of the above.[/i] :p

by absolutely

[i]I don't believe you statment that All Muslums hate the US[/i]

Your rambling diatribe strikes me as too emotive to warrant more elaborate response.

by absolutely

[i]Well I guess you're pretty much out of touch with American evangelical Christians. Almost half the population of the USA comes under this umbrella.[/i]

No, not half. "Evangelical" Christians are a lunatic fringe.

by x-marcap

As far as I can tell Bush has committed no crime or misdemeanor. I dislike some/most of his policies. Especially the non-stop spending...

The war in Iraq is outside of the Congressional control. They don't tell him how to fight it. They can fund it or not. If they don't fund it, he can't fight it.

The problem was the resolution that was passed was too vague. Any contact with Al Quaida or cooperation with any other known terrorist group could leave that country open to attack.

Technically HAMAS is a terrorist group, and that means the Palestinians need to be very cautious.

The people who think that Bush is Israel's toady are wrong.

The people who assert that there weren't/aren't WMDs or weren't need to listen to translations of the tapes coming out now... They were busy hiding or destroying materials and evidence.

If a Lt. Gen. took off out of his office to check on the situation, then it was important, and they had and hid or were destroying WMDs and evidence up until the last moments...

I haven't met a Lt. General who wanted to go out into 120 degree heat for any reason...

by x-marcap

In fact they are so afraid that they won't denounce them in public. In private they are willing to lambaste them.

We have had a local IMAM sent back to Saudi. He was preaching insurrection and had a weapons cache. The weapons he had were legal to be owned by a US citizen, but not by a foreigner. We have the leaders of quite a few Mosques being deported... Mostly to Saudi Arabia...

I am relatively neutral. If you treat me right, I don't care if you are black,yellow,white, or pink with orange polkadots. (Wife has freckles). It is how you treat others.

The terrorists have declared Jihad on my country, and my people. That is holy war. War isn't holy, but I am willing to do my duty... If we don't take the war to them they will bring it to us. All they need is the opportunity. Let them do it in their own back yard, when we are ready to respond.

by Member 25348569

I look forward to hearing your first hand report! Try not to get hurt. :D

I posted what I did as we had a TV program last night given by a very respected reporter. He reckoned that we don't really know what's happening with the general population - even to the extent that there's a civil war going on under our noses simply because we can't get any impartial, professional reporters out into the population. I'd be interested in anything you can find out as it's wholly relevant to US, UK and Aussie peers to know if our troops are in danger.

Neil :)

Keep your head down!

by x-marcap

I know the congressional Democrats have been lying through their teeth... Do you want the Katrina lies about deliberate inaction?

Do you want the liberal lies about the worst economy? We have 4.7% unemployment and the Dow is headed for record territory.

The conflict in Iraq... Do you believe the men who have come back from Iraq, or the Journalists who pay Arabs to take footage while sitting in hotels. Then they do the voice over... Why do they catch the terrorists in action if they aren't in league with the terrorists?

I love the Joe Wilson Lies... Valerie Wilson Plame outed herself in 2000... Joe Wilson may end up indicted. The CIA is a sieve as you would know the intelligence from the CIA is often best guess.
If you have been an officer you know intel often is questionable. You must go with the best guess...

He is one of the most damaging liars out there...

Bush may have been mistaken, but the jury is still out on that. You sound like one of the boat Commanders who were Clinton men that got peeved that they had no real part in the conflict..

When I was in the Marines, I knew that many Senior Marine officers recgnized the real enemy as the Air Force and the Army... The Navy Brass you just avoided whenever possible. I LOVE RINGKNOCKERS.

by maxwell edison

And for my full reply, see the scores of messages I've posted in the past. I'm tired of repeating the same things over and over again, only to see the same replies over and over again. I'll never change your opinion, you'll never change mine, so we'll have to settle to simpy agree to disagree.