Discussion Locked

World War III - Yes, President Bush is right

0 helpful
262 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

262 replies

by maxwell edison

Your own words provide a window into your mind. Do you really expect people to take you seriously after spewing such nonsense?

by deepsand

either lack, or choose not to use, as suits your purposes.

You really must stop looking in the mirror; you'll only hurt yourself more.

by x-marcap

He must have been an intelligence officer, which is of course different than an intelligent officer...

by jardinier

Recently I participated regularly in discussions at two American websites:

[b]meetchristians.com[/b]
[b]christianmingle.com[/b]

My understanding of the attitude of evangelical (born again -- the terms have become synonymous) Christians has come from extensive discussions at these websites.

You may care to read this entry in Wikipedia:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evangelicalism

And note this excerpt:

[b]A 1992 survey (Green) showed that in the United States and Canada evangelicals make up both the largest and the most active group of Christians (surpassing both Catholics and Mainline or non-Evangelical Protestant groups).[/b]

I have received emails from persons I have met through other American Christian websites -- notably crossdaily.com -- expressing these same feelings which I have described. [b]HATRED !!!![/b]

Sydney charismatics are also following this line of thinking -- that the terrorists represent the true Islamic religion. And yes this includes people I know well and have spoken to and I was horrified to hear this bigotted and untrue idea being disseminated.

by tig2

Sometimes I just can't help myself.

I think that we are heading into the territory that we will inevitably end up in the moment the generalisations start.

I am what is considered to be an evangelical Christian. That doesn't, by definition, mean that I am conservative- I am and am not, depends on the discussion. That doesn't mean that I love Bush, I have mixed feelings about the man. It doesn't mean that I am intolerant of other faiths, I have no problem with your beiefs as long as I am allowed to have mine. In short, the only thing that you really KNOW about me is that I am considered to be an evangellical.

Intolerance doesn't get you closer to God. A relationship with the God of your understanding does. I have never heard the kind of hatred you speak of preached from the pulpit.

I think that lumping folks together by your perception of their faith is a bad plan. I much prefer to be judged by what attitudes and opinions I personally bring to the table.

Regardless, I don't see how hatred brings me closer to God so I don't choose to indulge in that particular drug. One of the things that I struggled with after 9/11 was staying out of hatred because I wanted so badly to hate. And realised that in hatred, I would be giving up my place in any intellegent discussion. As far as I am concerned, you can't debate intellegently when you bring hatred to the discussion.

Jardinier, I have read many of your posts. You don't strike me as being a black and white thinker. Surely I have misread the absolute tone???

by jardinier

which gets me into a lot of strife in religious discussions because my beliefs do not fit into any established mould.

So I have over-generalised. This was in response to Absolutely?s remark: [I]"Evangelical" Christians are a lunatic fringe.[/I] Absolutely, being a devout atheist, probably has little personal contact with Christians and wouldn't have a clue what they believe.

However my point is that from my personal observation and experience the "hate Muslim" Christians may well be lunatics, but they are not a fringe group. They are many and widespread.

No I doubt very much that you would have heard hatred towards Muslims preached from the pulpit.

But on what basis can you contradict my personal experience of what certain Christians have said to me, either directly in person, or in posts in discussions?

Please do us both a favour and sign up free to [b]meetchristians.com[/b] and ask what a Christian's attitude should be towards Islam and Muslims.

Don't rely on my second-hand word. Find out for yourself or refrain from contradicting me.

I will repeat myself. I have received "hate" (towards Muslims) emails from members of the American website [b]crossdaily.com[/b] whom I had come to know as friends.

I spoke to a very decent man I know (a pharmacist) who attends Sydney largest charismatic church. When I said to him I was alarmed by this attitude that the terrorists represent the true Islamic faith, to my surprise and horror he replied: "Well probably they do."

I will not enter his shop again. I do not wish to associate with people who hold this belief and spread the lie.

As for your tolerance of other faiths, that is very reassuring but would definitely put you in a minority group amongst Christians worldwide.

by deepsand

There is more than ample evidence that Bush decided that he "knew" more than those whose job it was to know, that he brushed aside the advice of those whose job it was to advise (including his own father), that he was determined to take on Saddam no matter what.

As a result, he failed to properly plan for & execute the mission that he undertook, resulting in the quagmire that we now find ourselves.

Commander-in-Chief? He's such a joke that even his father would'nt publicly support him in the election past.

by x-marcap

Then he went skydiving as 1/2 of a tandem.

Did GHWB support GWB? I don't care.

Did the plan to eliminate the military go well?
72 hours and the organized military resistance was over.

The real quagmire is this: We didn't have a MacArthur to administrate Iraq.

by maxwell edison

But how about answering the question as intended?

I do, in my opinion, have the "facts" as much as I can possibly have them. Since I'm not privy to what goes on behind top-secret doors, I must rely on, to some degree, "who do I believe". Moreover, in my opinion, I'm very well read on the issue. Have you, for example, read General DeLong's book? I have, and he makes a strong case to suggest what I mentioned in my previous message.

Therefore, in my opinion, he is right, while you, and others who claim there were no WMDs, are wrong. Are you ready to suggest that you know more than General deLong? And are you ready to suggest that he is wrong? If so, why?

by deepsand

it remains unclear to me precisely who it is that you would have targeted, and where.

In particular, who is the "tyrant" to whom you referred when you said "[i] if I knew the US would have accepted a tyrant 6 years ago[/i]"?

by mjwx

Which leader was elected about 6 years ago? Like I said it was a bit below the belt

My strategy is a war plan not a battle plan, so obviously I can?t put names next to objectives but I can clearly define strategic objectives which are to weaken the enemy's organisation by eliminating their leaders by subtle means.

And of course by enemy I mean terrorist. But before the infiltrators can be sent in we first need to 1. Who we are dealing with 2. What kind of organisation we are dealing with 3. Who is leading this organisation 4. What do we need to do to get close to their leaders and we will need to know in great detail (This is an area which the US civilian and military leadership has failed in miserably). Like Sun Tzu said "know your enemy, know your self and victory will always be yours".

by deepsand

And, you're still stuck on relying on a single source. That hardly qualifies as all the facts.

This you know, and yet you persist.

And, given that you have stated that you require "100% proof", in the form of "total agreement" from "all the scientists and climatologists" before you would accept that global warming might be at least in part owing to mankind's activities, why are you here not requiring the level of proof re. the existence of WMDs?

In short, you are being logically inconsistent, as and when it serves your purpose.

by Member 25348569

He would say that, wouldn't he? It is in the interest of both US and UK governments and, by association, all senior military figures to occupy as much of the moral high ground as possible.

Whilst I do not in any way suggest that my military knowledge is even a fraction of the good General's, my rather well-defined streak of cynicism and finely evolved bullshit detectors have been registering a few warning signs.

1) They STILL haven't found anything.

2) There are insurgents and other anti-US elements (and precious few friends) all over Iraq and sympathisers all over Syria - where DeLong suggested that the weapons had gone. If they exist in either place they would have been found by someone and would have been used against out troops. They haven't.

To suggest that the mainly Secular Sunni-based Baath party would move their precious weapons across the border to Islamist Shia Iran? Well, if the General did say that then he's an idiot.

The Good General doesn't "know" anything of the sort. He's hoping. He does, at least in your estimation, have better credentials to make a guess than the likes of Sandy or myself AND he's giving you the answer that you want.

Just because he's a General doesn't make him right; it just makes him good at killing people.

Neil

by deepsand

It was Bush who claimed that an invasion of Iraq was justified owing to Saddam's alledged culpability for 911.

by x-marcap

Funds came into the country with Atta. He left for Iraq with $300.00 and came back with $9875. $125 less than impoundable... He met with the head of Iraqi security in Baghdad... He also had accounts to draw from after his return from Iraq.

Could I get an appointment with the head of the CIA and get money?

Does 1 + 1 = 0?

Don't be, or act stupid. Atta had contacts with Iraqi security. He went to Baghdad, he came back with more cash than he left with, and he was Al Qaeda...

I realize you went to Annapolis so I'll draw the lines very noticeable...

The $9875 cash - local travel costs -300 -food cost that he returned with, is more than a couple of nickels more than when he had left New York. Someone in Iraq was supporting Atta and thereby Al Qaeda.

It only takes minutes to get someone's bank records, once they are identified. Once identified as a terrorist suspect, the monetary information can be gotten with simple SQL statements. If you know the source of the funds, you have a contact.

One of the biggest problems in the US is: how intrusive do we want the government to be in our lives... Do I want the government to know I bought a chain saw with my debit/credit card? Do I want them to know how often I buy gasoline?

The problem is that the purpose of the constitution is to limit the power of government.
Liberals who want to do more hate the limits placed on the government by the constitution.

As a Navy officer you swore an Oath. Didn't it follow the following form: "I, ______, do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic; that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same; that I take this obligation freely, without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion; and that I will well and faithfully discharge the duties of the office on which I am about to enter. So help me God."

Apparently, you didn't see the problems with Carter dismantling our military, or Clinton doing the same. Clinton retired more capital ships than any President after the WWII bubble was cleaned up. That I assert, was stupid, and potentially treasonous. Was he deliberately weakening the USA?

I actually think that if the truth be told everyone should swear a similar type of oath that you swore as an Ensign, before being allowed even to vote. Rather than mention UCMJ, mention the laws and statutes of the USA...

If you really believe Bush is an enemy, do your duty. I may disagree with the tactics and strategy of our government, but he is the President. Ex-President Carter, I believe, fits this criterion of an enemy, currently. This isn't partisanship, but observation.

by deepsand

is one of important difference.

Being "convicted" does not, at law, mean that one is "guilty."

Again, I believe that you do in fact know the difference, but choose to ignore it.

by deepsand

To be "scientific," a hypothesis must be both restable and deniable.

I summit that this most assuredly meets the latter requirement.

by deepsand

What I [b]am[/b] upset about is the fact that GWB, like Hitler did, acts as if he knows more about prosecuting war than does the military.

For example, why did he commit but 6 troops/1000 population when he was advised that 20 would be required?

by x-marcap

There was a huge difference in opinion.

Colin Powell said 20-30... That was an enormous amount of manpower. Now one of Bush's biggest detractors thinks we can reduce forces, and that things are doing well, he went over there to see for himself...

I think that the best option is to use the least force necessary. You can always use battleships and turn them into a parking lot from nearly 20+ miles with the 16 in guns. (23 for the US North Carolina WWII vintage battleship.) Sorry, but there will be need of missles not gunnery. Iraq is mostly too far from the water...

by deepsand

You seem to be missing the point; the issue is not how many troops would be required to topple the government of Iraq, but how many would be to act as an interim government, as required by the Geneva Convention.

Or, would you have the country simply revert to anarchy?

by x-marcap

Since that is a mathematical equation that no Marine would ever question with all those Marines over there, the numbers show we could reduce our troop strength without jeopardizing the mission.

It would still be mathematically equivalent to the 20/1000... with normal troops.

by dawgit

Now I'll tell you this, I've served with some fine Gunnys, and I've also stood with some fine SGMs in the Army, but NONE better than the SeaBees I've served with. It would take 100 Jar-Heads to even put on one boot of a SeaBee. Enuf already. (& yes, they are in Iraq too.)

by jardinier

even if, hopefully, it was meant in jest.

I think you have been watching too many American Marine propaganda movies.

If all marines carried on like yourself -- adulating themselves at each and every opportunity -- I don't think they would notice that a war was taking place.

A lot of TR peers have served in the military in one capacity or another. NONE have bragged about the fact, but only mentioned it when it was pertinent to some particular discussion.

NONE has continually blown his own trumpet as you feel compelled to do.

I would venture to say that you are a disgrace to that arm of the military in which you have served.

by deepsand

He insisted on "proof" that Saddam had no WMDs.

One cannot proof a negative.

Bush then used the logical fallacy that "absence of proof constitutes proof of absence" as his "proof" that WMDs did exist!

by deepsand

The Army & Air Force have 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 Star Generals; in the Navy, they are called Admirals.

The Marines lack the 5 Star rank, as they are part of the Navy, and ultimately report to a Fleet, or 5 Star, Admiral.

A Lieutenant General is a 3 Star General. Properly speaking, only those with 4 Stars are Generals.

by hal 9000

But the PLO is no longer considered as a Terrorist Group since it has gone Political although some of its members retain their old ways.

Was Saddam involved with the PLO [b]YES![/b]

Was Saddam involved with Bin Ladden I don't know but it's unlikely as he already had enough trouble to deal with without getting the US's back up again.

As for offering Rewards I really don't think so in the Strictly Legal Sence but he certianly did offer assistance to families of those who killed themselves for the PLO's basic cause.

Exactly where do you draw the line between offering humitarian support and Aiding Terrorists?

If you consider giving money or food and weapons to people who are suffering then isn't the USA guilty of this as well? They aided the Overthrow of a Lawful Government in Afaganstain and brought about the rise of the Talaban so from that prospective the US is as Guilty as Saddam was of Aiding Terrorists. The Russians who where asked to come in to solve the problem of the Afaginstain Government certianly saw the predecessors of what was to latter become the Talaban as Terrorists.

What most people are forgetting here is that the Muslun are not just targeting the US they also hate the Russians and are currently in a [b]State of War[/b] with them. Saddam most likely provided funds and other support to these people as well. If this had of happened before the end of the [b]Cold War[/b] he would have been called a Hero. But in actual fact he was just a dirty little thug with Delusions of Grander just like most of the Leaders in the Middle East and North Africa.

What made him so different to all the others there Maxwell?

By the exact same reasoning that you have used above the Saudies where just as guilty if not more so of supporting Terrorists as just about all those involved in the 9-11 attack originated from that country and all of the original money used to setup that Terrorists Orginasition originated in Suadi as well. And that money was not only used to buy arms and train participants but a lot of it was used to support these peoples families so why not invade Saudi Arabia first?

by hal 9000

[b]Don't think to hard[/b] as you most likely will not like the outcome of doing all that thnking and what's even worse you just might start to ask questions that some people don't want answered.

But go look up where Singer Avaonics gets all its parts made and which type of aircraft they go into.

That should at the very least give you a good case of the [b]Runs![/b]

Col ]:)

by hozcanhan

Yeah ! Keep on dear Americans ...You are on the route to create the second monster : Nuke Ahmedi of Iran .

by deepsand

To which "democratic authorities" are you refering.

Diatribes will not suffice to persuade minds of reason.

by absolutely

Why, if they're so certain that these weapons are in Syria now, have they not either seized them from Syria, or been attacked with them by Syrians?

by x-marcap

That means you are admitting the circumstances, and the actions involved.

He committed perjury.

Word games aside. Don't pull the semantic based left wing Bull with me. I respect you too much, even though I disagree with you, to try that kind of crap.

He was guilty. He did misuse his office of both POTUS and Govonor of Arkensas.

He tried to avoid the situation. "Justice delayed is Justice denied." as per Thomas Payne, and Alexander Hamilton. That is enumerated as the right to a speedy trial, in the constitution.

The slander that was used that came out of this situation was incredible. Both sides slandered, but the government should have never been involved.

Did he look straight ahead and say Yes sir, or no sir? He said that depends on your definition of what the word is is.

He is lucky that it wasn't my daughter. I would have corrected the problem.

by x-marcap

1. Saddam did use WMDs against the Kurds, his own countrymen.

2. He didn't comply with supervised destruction. It is understood world wide, that when WMDs are destroyed, or dismantled that non-partisan observers are present to confirm the destruction.

3. He refused to cooperate with any supervision.

4. He stated that he was in defiance to the UN resolutions about WMDs.

5. He claimed he was going to use them, he had in the past, and if you don't have them you can't use them.

6. 480 Iraqi scientists, engineers and technicians were working on the project Ghaddafi turned over to inspection teams. He stated that they were no longer being paid by Iraq, and were never on his payroll... Do I believe Ghaddafi? No, but I think that fear motivated him. If the ship with components hadn't been captured, would he have taken over the Nuclear project in Libya? You bet your life and mine on the answer.

by Member 25348569

some things are so obvious that they need not be stated. :D

As an aside, tell me how, in a technical forum where we will be discussing Microsoft products [i]ad nauseam[/i], the moderators could think it acceptable to deny us the word bull$hit?

Max has been fairly quiet in answering criticism of the General. He's either hiding or preparing a metaphorical or literal smoking gun...

by x-marcap

(FYI --> Most Marines call Annapolis grads, Ring Knockers since they tend to punctuate their points with the Stadium rings that they wear.)

The problem is I used to have a lot more info about what was actually happening in my theatre when I was in the Corps.

I know that the government isn't letting out all it knows. If fact I suspect that the disinformation that happens, is not accidental. Misinformation is accidental. I believe that Saddam hid or shipped out his WMDs, but that he had them.

I believe that Bush has had people tell him what he wanted to hear. Not because that is necessarily what he wants, but because it will get him to act in the manner they desire.

Control the information and you control the situation. Sandy, you know that...

by absolutely

[i]Max has been fairly quiet in answering criticism of the General. He's either hiding or preparing a metaphorical or literal smoking gun...[/i]

I've noticed recently that when he does post, he often evades the subject of disagreement with expressions of fatigue.

"And for my full reply, see the scores of messages I've posted in the past. I'm tired of repeating the same things over and over again, only to see the same replies over and over again. I'll never change your opinion, you'll never change mine, so we'll have to settle to simpy agree to disagree."

He pulled the same stunt on his global warming threads, where he quickly retreated to the argument that he associates global warming with liberals, therefore all who believe the scientific evidence of global warming are liberals, and since he believes all liberals must always be wrong about everything, global warming must also be a fallacy. He has no argument, no independent capacity for reason, and no accurate knowledge on any topic but economics. He is a punk.

by x-marcap

Most of today's generals aren't really currently warriors. They are good paper pushers. The bulk of the warrior class is gone.

Generals and Admirals are usually great administrators. I pesonally was "a great combat commander, but lacked the administrative skills for permanant rank" So with those wise words from an Annapolis grad who ran like a scared little girl in the face of fire, my career was basically over. That man wears 2 stars 25 years later.

It is not the killers who get promoted, but the political, and the administrators. Sandy must have been O-5, or he got several stars and then began to express his opinion.

However, Sandy the Sailor is right. One general is not the same as the other... A lower half Admiral wears two stars and a salty old Brigadier General will salute the stars, and then find out this is a newbie and fume for days.

The real people who do the killing in the Corps are the captains and down. I wouldn't cross a old gunny for any reason. He may have trained the Commandant, and still may recall when he was a lousy 2nd Lt. And the gunny still may call him by first name in private...

Many senior Navy officer has never came close to hearing a bullet wheet past their ears. In Vietnam, They would sit in the boat, three miles from shore and pound the coastal areas with 16 in. guns. Then they walk to the officers mess and dine off fine china. Now they do it with missles from 150 - 3000 miles away...

The Navy pilots were the only Navy personnel to be in constant risk. Attack and fighter pilots, I salute you. The sacrifice that men have made for other's freedoms should not be forgotten.

by x-marcap

He reminds me of the type of Annapolis officer who expected all lower ranks to request permission to speak. If they merely communicated information, the Annapolis grad would ignore them... "Duck the enemy is targeting you!" wasn't proper

The answer is that he has his axe to grind... He wants to sharpen our opinion with the same grinding stone.

Many Navy officers I know despise Bush.

Another point is, the non-liberal truth is suppressed by the mass media... or, as he indicates in another post, irrelevant. His mind is made up, don't confuse him with facts.

by maxwell edison

I actually thought Absolutely was going to post an honest and reasonable suggestion that I was just tired of posting the same replies to the same rebuttals in response to the same questions because of the same comments posted the same way to the same people on the same issues, but only in a different discussion, to get the same thing.

But no, I was mistaken. He just can't seem to rise above ____________ whatever it is that's possessed him.

See ALL of my other discussion comments in ALL of the other discussions in which I've participated, and you'll have my reply. I have better things to do than repeat myself over and over than repeat myself over and over than repeat myself over and over than repeat myself over and over than repeat myself over and over than repeat myself over and over -- like participate in that OAW discussion. Now there's something worthy of my attention. Where else can I be called an idiot and a moron by so many people because I spoke the truth about an idiot and a moron? (By the way, I initially thought it was YOU, not Julian.)

by maxwell edison

If you're interested, I have a proposal. Read Lt. General DeLongs book, [i]Inside Centcom: The Unvarnished Truth about the Wars in Afghanistan and Iraq[/i], and then we'll open up a new discussion to dissect and discuss what he actually writes about and what he's actually suggested.

After all, how can two reasonable people reasonably discuss a book that one of them hasn't read?

by maxwell edison

The answer was obvious. And he couldn't answer it honestly because it would undermine his position. And he couldn't answer it dishonestly because it would discredit him.

So instead, what we got was ...... one, two, three ...... one, two, three ...... one, two, three ...... one, two, three ...... one, two, three......

by oz_media

Ties to terrorists, as we all know there is only ONE terrorist sect in th emiddle east...Al Qaeda.

by Member 25348569

and I had a little run-in early on where I posted a comment in her blog in which I threatened to hound her if she posted about me - rather than to me - again. That same incident was referenced in her early posts to Julian that he published. After that, she gave the odd post answer to me and vice versa - all very calm and civilised since.

As for the General's book, I take your point and, as it's unlikely that I'll read it, will refrain from commenting on that particular source again again until I can find some viable reference material by him or someone else authoritative. At which point, I reserve the right to kick your butt
should I be able.

by maxwell edison

For reference, Deepsand said, "He insisted on "proof" that Saddam had no WMDs.... One cannot proof a negative.... Bush then used the logical fallacy that "absence of proof constitutes proof of absence" as his "proof" that WMDs did exist!"

Actually, in this case, it WAS possible to prove WMDs did not exist. The reasoning is as follows.

Point: Saddam DID INDEED, at one time, posses WMDs. After all, he did use them on his own people.

Point: After the first Gulf War, it was also known that Saddam had WMDs, as verified by UN weapons inspectors.

Point: A condition of the cease-fire after the first Gulf War was that Saddam destroy those WMDs, and provide conclusive proof of their destruction to UN inspectors. Saddam failed to do that.

Point: Another condition of the cease-fire after the first Gulf War was that Saddam allow UN inspectors unrestricted access to all facilities to verify said destruction. Saddam failed to do that. In fact, he kicked them out of Iraq for an extended period of time.

Point: Every person in the USA government, Democrats and Republicans alike, knew that Saddam still had his WMDs. Were they all wrong, including President Clinton?

Point: Every intelligence agency in the world knew that Saddam still had his WMDs. Were they all wrong?

Point: As suggested by numerous military sources, during the build-up to the war, activity to conceal and move WMDs was observed.

Point: An attempted chemical terrorist attack in Jordan was thwarted by authorities a year or so ago. Where did those come from?

Point: It's very likely, in the name of maintaining geopolitical stability, that there are things you and I are not privy to.

Point: Nothing can vanish into thin air.

Bottom line: It's almost as simple as providing a bill-of-sale to prove you don't own a car any more. And unless you can prove to the state that you don't own your car anymore, you just might still be held liable.

Saddam couldn't produce, as required by UN resolutions, the bill-of-destruction, something he agreed to do. The burden of proof, as established by the United Nations and agreed to by Saddam, was on Saddam.

Again, Deepsand, you are wrong.

But, of course, Deepsand knows all this. It's all old news. It was replaced, however, with the new lie about the lie, which became the new news. But seeing and admitting reality would undermine his predetermined desired conclusion. So he repeats the lie about the lie.

by x-marcap

I am one of the Few US Marines, who has been drunk under the tables at Morries, and told that if I ever want to become a British subject I merely have to learn to drink...

by x-marcap

I appreciate the concern. I'll be traveling with two Marine Chaplains.

The squad leader I'll be traveling with is a LRRP (Long Range Reconaisance Patrol) Master Sergeant, I had as a private 1st class. I only worry about anyone who would bother him....

He is the kind of steely-eyed hero that war stories are written about. He has done two tours in Iraq, and one in Afghanistan. MacLuaghlin saved my butt in the Honduras many years ago...
"Captain, You gotta learn when to keep your head down"

by x-marcap

Then the US went to the UN for one last resolution, and the bombs started to fall... Iraq could have cooperated, but they didn't.

Iran's premier and the 12th Imam is my current worry... Iraq's problems are staying over there...

Now we have John Bolton as US Ambassador to the UN. That was like putting Kerry in charge of PR for Bush. Much animosity directly earned.

by deepsand

He was USNA '68, my class.

In fact, USNA supplies officers for both the Navy & the Marines; it is a choice that each midshipmen is required to make.

And, some USNA grads are allowed to opt for the Army or Air Force, based on their family's military history. One of the guys in my company was a nephew of Air Force General Curtis LaMay, with 3 options open to him; Navy, Marines or Air Force. He probaly could have gone Army if he'd really wanted to.

by deepsand

Leaders and Managers are distinctly different, and both are necessary.

Leadership has been described as the art of managing change; management, the art of dealing with diverse complexities.

In times of conflict, Leaders are the better qualified for prosecuting the war, particularly at the tactical level. But, at the strategic level, the Managers are the better.

In times of "peace," there is no immediate need for Leaders, with the result that they languish, as the Managers alone are sufficient for the tasks at hand. Consequently, it is the Managers who see the more rapid promotions.

It is the rare person who possesses the abilities to be both a Leader and a Manager. That is why so few good military leaders succeed at politics. The closest that we've come in the US, in recent history, would most likely have been Ike, and even he struggled as President.

by deepsand

which all Plebes were required to attend, where the daughters of Beltway socialites were regularly served up as dance partners, ostensibly for the purposes of teaching us how to be Gentlemen.

PS - How many know the the phrase "An Officer & a Gentleman" is a Navy term? Naval Midshipmen are the only military cadets that are Commissioned Officers. From that arose the saying that such were "Officers, by Act of Congress; Gentlemen, by the Grace of God."

by deepsand

He was advised that the post-war administration would require 20 troops/1000 population; he commited but 6.

by deepsand

1) Let's dispense with the Clinton vs Bush issue; it's not germane to the matter at hand.

2) Likewise for the invectives against "liberals."

3) As for Saddam's alledged ties to Osama:
...a) Transcripts of Iraqi records of Saddam's own statements, which have been made public, show that he was exceedingly distrustful of Osama, to the point of refusing to commit to any alliance with him;
...b) It was this alledged alliance which Bush touted as the reason that Iraq was to be treated as a co-conspirator in the 911 plot, thereby giving us "just cause" for our invasion; and,
...c) The best that Rumsfield could come up with recently, in defense of such claim, was that "Osama had been in Iraq!"

4) With regards to Sadam's "defiance" of the UN:
...a) Bush had made his mind to invade, no matter what the outcome of the UN's efforts, as evidenced from recently released notes of meetings between Bush & PM Tony Blair; and,
...b) Bush set an impossible task for Saddam in requiring "proof" that Iraq had no WMDs; it is impossible to prove a negative. When no such "proof" was forthcoming, as none could be, Bush employed the logical fallicy that "absence of proof constitutes proof of absence" by claiming that failure to provide such proof constituted proof that Saddam was in fact hiding WMDs.

5) Finally, it must here be noted that Bush signaled his plans to topple Sadam long before any of the above transpired, when, upon being advised that Sadam had attempted to have his father assassinated, that he would seek revenge for such.

by deepsand

A Nolo plea means that you are not contesting the [b]charge[/b]; it is [b]not[/b] an admission of anything at all!

And, while such allows the Court to hand down a conviction, the Court is [b]not required[/b] to do so.

As for the issues re. Clinton's impeachment, such was naught but political bullshit. But, that's another issue, not one to be re-debated here.

If you like, we can debate the merits of impeaching Bush, as such does relate to the subject of this discussion.

by deepsand

1) What Sadam might have had or done in the past is irrelavent to the issue of what he had at the time in question.

2) It remains impossible to prove a negative, no matter how much you persist in claiming otherwise. Any good logician or scientist will tell you so.

Here's a problem for you both. Think of an item that you could physically possess & hide from view of all, but in fact do not. Now, devise a proof that you do not possess such item.

by absolutely

not with you.

We've disagreed vehemently enough for me to appreciate your personality and convictions. I also appreciate your concern with honesty and rising above bias. But come on, you don't have a job as a journalist to lose, so why not use a word or phrase that's literally correct, and let custom be damned? Call it "military research", "spy data" or anything else, PLEASE. My way of emphasizing that I take no issue with you is that I just assumed you would personally take umbrage at inaccurate use of the word "intelligence" because I think it's an attribute that you value.

by x-marcap

The way that information is developed is often gossip that is overheard, a look at a proposed TOC, or other speculative possibilities.

Sometimes, someone decides to change their mind, after a plan is agreed upon. That causes counters to be improvised. Rarely is an improvised plan as tidy as a well planned operation.

Our plans can't always be flexible enough to cover all possibilities. Contingency plans aren't perfect.

by jardinier

you have to use language that people can understand.

Perhaps you might check a dictionary. In the Oxford Dictionary the second definition for "Intelligence" is:

[b]2 a "the collection of information, esp. of military or political value. b people employed in this. c information so collected."[/b]

In the Collins Dictionary:

[b]Meaning 4. "Military information about enemies, spies etc. 5. A group or department that deals with such information."[/b]

So would you like to take issue with the lexicographers?

Anyhow your argument is specious as is clearly demonstrated by these two dictionaries.

And you can drop the "former/ex journalist" title. I am a member of the Australian Journalists' Association, and as an accredited freelance journalist I carry a Press Pass which will get me into just about any place that I want to go. In fact my lawyer who was formerly a policeman said the Press Pass will get me into places/functions that a Police badge wouldn't get him into.

by absolutely

But my SAT scores suggested that I infer the essentials of Latin roots well. I guess that "nolo contendere" translates literally (I do) not contest (the asserted facts and/or their legal significance), but that its entire colloquial meaning would be best conveyed as "contesting this nonsense is not worth my time."

by deepsand

USNA Midshipmen (as opposed to NROTC Midshipmen)are, unlike cadets at the other academies, Commissioned Officers, having been sworn in when they accepted their commissions as Midshipmen. Only NROTC Midshipmen are swore in at the time when they become commissioned as Ensigns.

The rank of Ensign and above are know as Senior Officers; that of Midshipmen, Junior Officers.

USNA Midshipmen rank between an E-9 (Master Chief Petty Officer) and a W-1 (Warrant Officer, aka non-Commissioned Officer.)

Commissioned officers hold a commission granted by the President, whereas Warrant officers derive their authority from a warrant granted by the Secretary of the Navy.

USNA Midshipmen are Line Officers. As Line Officers, they are eligible to assume command of ships or stations.

by deepsand

Etymology: Latin, I do not wish to contend

: a plea in a criminal prosecution that [b]without admitting guilt[/b] [i]subjects the defendant to conviction[/i] but [b]does not preclude denying the truth of the charges[/b] in a collateral proceeding

by mjwx

I'm Australian so I dont keep very close tabs on the US electoral timeline.
:)

by sleepin'dawg

Quite some time ago a whole squadron of Mig 25s were found buried in the sand and there were pictures with the article. They had been carefully wrapped in a sort of shrink wrap to prevent the infiltration of the sand.

At first not too much notice was taken of this until some one asked the question, what were a bunch of frontline Russian planes doing sitting in the middle of the Iraqi dessert??? These were some of the fastest planes (+ Mach 2.5)in the Russian arsenal and there had been no indication that Iraq had ever possessed them. Prior to this all indications were that all Iraqi planes were or had been, either American or some other western nation in origin. The discovery of 12 or 16 brand new Russian Migs was surprising. The Russians claimed they had never sold them to Iraq but this was hardly surprising and may have even been the truthbecause they could have come any one of the former Soviet republics, like Georgia, trying to raise cash. The point is that these things had to have been acquired post Dessert Storm which was in violation of treaties.

Still not too much was made of the find since the Mig 25 is an interceptor not a fighter nor, normally, is it a bomber. It wasn't until a Russian aviation specialist pointed that the Mig 25 had the unusual capability of delivering "tactical" nuclear weapons, that much excitement was generated and even then it lasted for less than a week.

I wish I could remember the source but I deleted it long ago, maybe some one else knows where it is. What made it notable for me was the old smoke and fire scenario i.e. where there is smoke there is usually fire. A plane with a nuclear delivery capability; then where are the nukes that could or would have have been delivered. Maybe they didn't exist or were still in development stages, I don't know but I thought that squadron of planes to be of extreme interest. If they had gotten so far as to acquire a delivery capability in secret, then where were the nukes. To date I have heard no answers other than "no comment" and I always take that to mean there is something being kept secret but for what reason I can't fathom. I would have thought publicity of this find would have taken some of the heat off but then what do I know?

This whole affair disappeared inside of a week; why???

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by sleepin'dawg

Coming around aren't you, now that George has admitted some more details. Remember the legend of Casandra??? Mark my words, war with Iran is no longer just a potentiality; it has become a very real possibility and I feel it will now be sooner rather than later.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by sleepin'dawg

This is on excellent authority from a very reliable source, one that I would bet my ass on, the planes were not discovered by "fins sticking through the sand but by satellite geologic ground surveilance radar and this was not all that was found but all that was publicized. Also contrary to the story they were all Mig 25 interceptors not one SU25, a ground support plane, among them.

by sleepin'dawg

I am not in error regarding the Mig 25. In straight level flight it was one of the fastest planes around. It still is for that matter. It is not a fighter and if it was ever used in ground attack it would have had limited capability. It would have lousy dog fighting capability because of its size but would be excellent in the role of interceptor because it would have the capability of out running any attacker.The damn things have beenknown to exceed Mach 3. You would not use this kite in ground attack in what is normally conceived as ground attack unless you had no other option. The SU 25 has a ground attack capability but you will note there are no phtos of any of those there.

I am sorry I am unable to reveal the sources of my information on most of this except to say I know one of the photographers who took those pictures, intimately. Others wrote the stories. I just wonder why more hasn't been made of this because I know of three other sites where similar dicoveries were made and have heard of absolutely no publicity about them, something I find very strange indeed.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by x-marcap

From Quantico to Pensacola to ElToro I can say I may have seen a Midshipman, but not ever spoken with one.

It is true that a Middie is an Officer of the line. and One was executed for leaving his post as Captain when all higher officers were disabled.

My memory is now refreshed after 20+ years of civilian life.

by x-marcap

He listened to two different opinions. He chose one over the other. I see it as senior officers being pissed they can't play in the sand with the other big boys...

I remember Senior officers screaming because they were missing out on leading troops in Vietnam. It would cost them getting stars. I was seriously worried about getting my butt shot off as it was. You can get just as dead in Guatemala or the Honduras as you could in Vietnam. You just wouldn't make the evening news.

by x-marcap

I also know Norwich and Citadel grads. I do know that the trade schools put out some of the best managers, but absolute worst leaders I have bumped into.

Trade school grads ofter worry more about their career and how things will look than how to get things done. When the rest of us are positioned to take the brunt of the action, the WPPA/APPA tries to get the glory... That sounds like I don't respect them, but What I didn't like was they'd get special treatment. Even ones with barely room temperature IQ's.

by maxwell edison

...of two reasons.

One: It would undermine the left's and the main-stream media's attempt to discredit President Bush and the war effort. After all, how can they continue their lie about the WMD lie if they actually report something of true substance? Although these fighter planes aren't in the "WMD" category, these photos and the story behind their discovery should have been plastered on the front pages of every major newspaper in the U.S. But I didn't see it in one newspaper or one news broadcast; not even one. What else is buried out there, in a land area the size of California, would be the obvious question?

Two: There are a lot of things (and I'm speculating, of course) that have been "discovered" and "known" that are still undisclosed to the public. I'm not stupid enough (like a lot of people apparently are) to think that the public does know, or should know, every detail about waging a war. And unlike the resident military expert, deepsand, who apparently is the ultimate authority on how to wage a war , I'll leave the details up to the experts. I'm amazed at all the armchair generals (including deepsand, the resident military expert, who apparently is the ultimate authority on how to wage a war ) who presume to know more than the real ones. How can those people possibly be taken seriously?

by maxwell edison

.....when confronted with truth that undermines his position. I didn't think he'd reply with a message of substance.

by x-marcap

The Navy abondons marines. At Guadalcanal, They abandon Marines, At Hon Cho Din they abandon Marines. The capital ships are more important than doing the job. UDT/Seals are treated like kings, but are pretty similar to Marines in ability to fight. They may be even superior.

Most Navy commanders treat Marines like a social disease. (Something to be endured and be done with).

Maybe the 5 preceeding generations of officers have passed legacies that include "I was at XXXX and we started to draw small arms fire (.30 cal or less) and there goes the Ship with our food and weaponery." If I hadn't seen it myself off the coast of the Honduras, and had multiple family members see it at Guadalcanal, and in San Jaun, and at ..., I might be more tolerant of the wet ones. It always is a manager type who fears ship repairs, not a warrior type, always Annapolis grads with stars...

by x-marcap

Non-Annapolis grads, who are Marine officers often have their MOS changed and they become LRRPs, infantry or less desirable but necessary specialties.

I hold long grudges against Annapolis grads... It is merely pure muscle memory reaction. Like a golf swing, or a pun you reuse. There I was.. flying along ...

You, I don't like, but I understand your lack of understanding... You think you are intelligent, and wise. I prefer to read 1UAW to you. That is because you remind me of someone I really despised for years, before they got into trouble.

He is still in jail... He got caught embezzling from a church run charity...

If you didn't realize that I am poking fun at other branches of service, and not denigrating them it is your own fault... I have deep appreciation for other's service.

Even Sandy agrees with me about the differences between the warriors and managers and rank and promotion. I was not a manager...

You are a manager type.

by x-marcap

We are not governing Iraq. We don't make their laws, nor did we write their constitution.

I wish their constitution was based on ours. It isn't

The interim government passed into history with the radification of their constitution. That is when Paul Bremer left. They have a provisional government now.

Should it go to anarchy,I think it is already safely beyond that. I think we should round up the terrorists and try them. If they resist, too bad ...

What I want is for our armor to be more mobile and better suited to Urban warfare. Then to take the gloves off when we get attacked. If there is collateral damage, let it be on their side...

by x-marcap

Either of us would probably really screw up the post war. In fact, we are too opinionated to influence policy. We are too opinionated to be allowed to formulate policy. We aren't MacArthur types... Nor have been the people who are in Iraq.

Sandy isn't all bad.

by maxwell edison

...he concedes at least some of the points I've made in this discussion.

Read all of them, and put yourself on the spot.

Do you come closer to agreeing with me or "sandy"?

by maxwell edison

When it comes to matters of policy, politics, and principle, you and (the idiot) "sandy" are probably as far apart as possible, at least from what I've gathered from you two. The only tie that binds you is your past military connection.

Your military claims, I tend to believe. "Sandy's", I have questioned, and still do. Just like the other idiot, OAW and her alter ego the sister-act, just because someone "claims" to be something on an Internet chat board, it doesn't make it so. And when it comes to "sandy's" claim to be an Annapolis grad, color me skeptical -- make that extremely skeptical.

Nonetheless, I find it interesting that you cozy up to (the idiot) "sandy", even though, as I said, when it comes to matters of policy, politics, and principle, you and (the idiot) "sandy" are probably as far apart as possible.

You told me in a previous message that (the idiot) "sandy" isn't all bad. Well, probably not, but he can't carry on a debate worth a damn. The nonsense he's spewed in reply to my comments in this discussion should speak for themselves. Or do you disagree?

Julian, I might suggest to you, isn't all bad either. He and I disagree on a lot of things, but in my opinion, (the idiot) "sandy" couldn't carry Julian's jock strap when it comes to intelligence and common sense, not to mention debating skills. Go ahead, cozy up to (the idiot) "sandy" all you want. But if you slam Julian for your perception of him and his opinions, you should slam (the idiot) "sandy" as well, because Julian's opinions and (the idiot) "sandy's" opinions (in matters of policy, principle, and politics) are probably pretty close.

And I hope you accept my challenge of reading ALL of the messages between him and me in this discussion, and choose which one you believe is more accurate and/or more in-line with your own opinions.

by x-marcap

You bash evangelicals, and you practice intolerance toward those who don't hold to your opinions on the muslim faith. Maybe people should treat you in the same manner?

To what has this man, that you now decry, been exposed? Where are the moderate moslems decrying the terrorists?

You are discerning and discriminating, with a weasel like cunning. You have already determined who is the real problem. Not the killers and terrorists, but the people who are afraid of the killers and terrorists, and recognize what group they come from.

Why don't you your moderate muslim's take a stand against the terrorists and turn them in?

by x-marcap

I think that Sandy is in step most with the general Navy opinion. They can't really play in a land war. Marines will, and are getting promoted. There is a quite often deep dislike and distrust between Navy officers, and Marine officers. Some of those reasons have been stated elsewhere.

The Navy is currently basically left in a support role... The Navy brass hates that.

I suspect he was a 04 --> 05 top, and left after not getting a chance for permanent rank. That is Commander. or Lt. Commander. If he was an Anapolis grad he probably used those contacts and landed a cushy job in corporate management.

Even Sandy agrees that the current group of senior officials are not really warriors. He must have choked and gagged, but he agress that I am right.

That means that if really pushed, he may agree to the truth. But you may have to make it be something that hits his honor...

I try to hope that a Middie can someday not just think like a deep water sailor.

I do disagree with Sandy about policy. I am not quite in lock step with you, but am far closer to your position than his.

BTW, I realize that some of my posts were offensive. They were supposed to be. The fact is that they were also tongue in cheek. See Julian's response ... We really don't like each other.

by maxwell edison

......could probably plan and carry out a battle/war admirably.

You have to be kidding, right? That was a joke, wasn't it?

No, I don't think "sandy" could do any such thing.

If his profile is accurate, and ALL that computer-tech experience is accurate, he's spent the last "48 years" (his claim) in the computer technology arena, not the military war-planning arena. His profile (if it's true) doesn't say how long he was in the Navy, but if it was for a short-term stint of 6 years, he couldn't have developed the military skills in that amount of time to "run a war". If he retired from the military after 20 or so years, he was probably forced out because he didn't achieve a rank high enough to satisfy the requirements to stay in. And it was as a computer geek, not a war planner.

He probably couldn't make it past O-4 or O-5, or else he would have stayed longer. If he did stay longer, 30 years or more, I can't imagine an O-6, O-7, or O-8 (O-8 = Major General or Rear Admiral) posting such nonsense on an Internet chat board, can you?

In short, with all the military chest-pounding he (and you, for that matter) has been displaying, if he was qualified to carry out such battle plans, HE WOULD BE THERE DOING IT! General Tommy Franks, for example, the guy who DID run the war, also started his military career in 1967-68, just like (the idiot) "sandy" claims.

Sorry, it takes a looooong military career, and one in the realm of military war-planning (not a computer geek), and one that takes a person to the ranks of O-8, O-9 and O-10, to qualify him to run a war the right way. Sorry, that ain't deepsand.

Perhaps you should reconsider that silly statement you made.

by x-marcap

We are talking about logistics, Information, and combat basically. Planning the conflict is that difficult. The amount of food averages out daily, the amount of fuel needed for each sortie.
The toilet paper needed. Details, details, details. An accountant may actually be better than anyone else for packing combat loads on a ship.

Combat command is a whole different matter. One of the best combat commanders and administrators of WWII was Wendel Fertig. He was an engineer, who was directly commissioned. He eventually helped push the Japanese off the Philippines.

I suspect he was in IT for DOD - such as DFAS-NJ. Defense Financial and Accounting Services. He has let me know from his comments that he thinks he could do better than the President or Rummy. The point is that everybody has an opinion.

I think I could do a better job, too. Now, I am probably wrong about this fact, and I could do better on on the ground tactics than on strategy... I admit that the strategy is decided at a level with information far beyond what I know from public information. (Every once in a while a Colonel I served under, sends me non-classified, but confidential stuff.) The public is not informed...

Let's say, hypotherically, we have found more than 20,000 tons of pre-cursor chemicals for Serin or VX nerve gas, with the centrifuges, Ammonia, chlorine, and a large lab to cook the chemicals,

I am sure that we'd have all been informed by the mass media... These same chemicals can be made into floor, or toilet cleaners. But this site wasn't advertising itself as the home of Mr. Clean so the jury is still out about what to announce.

It goes up the chain of command, and sits on a guy's desk. It doesn't fit his opinion, and it is never decided to be a WMD site.

I think the vast amounts of discovered chlorine gas should be recognized as the weapons they were used for in WWI.

by deepsand

he was wildly over-optomistic re. the ability & willingness of the various Iraqi factions to set aside age old differences, and unite to form a democratic government; and, he failed to understand that, having invaded a Muslim nation would be certain to attract the attention of outside agitators.

Our Founding Fathers understood fully that having the opportunity to be self governing is not sufficient to guarantee the success of such. They also understood that it must first be within the temperment of the people to be self governing.

This Bush failed to accept, as to accept such would have meant acknowledging that his intended goal was not reasonably achievable during his tenure as President.

A more reasonable approach, assuming that it was given that an invasion would be forthcoming, would have been to groom a successor to Sadam, one who would be both willing and able to command the same amount of fear from the Iraqi citizenry as did Sadam, so as to have a new stopper ready to drop into the neck of the pressurized flask that Iraq was and still is.

In short, his ego got in the way of reason.

by oz_media

And I know a whole load of Hells Angels, it doesn't make me a biker, theif or extrortionist though. I don't have a meth lab nor am I seeking ways to build one.

What some see as an encouragable biker gang, I see as a bunch of REALLY nice guys that are great fun to hang out with.

by deepsand

in this case, experience in the military. He overlooks the fact that the military is a group enterprise, as is any other business; a business, however, which has a purpose distinctly unlike other businesses, using resources that are unique to its industry.

As such, he is not able to make informed judgements re. what is and is not required to run the business of the military, and resorts to seeking qualities and beliefs in others that most closely mirror his own.

This he judges by the extent to which one agrees or disagrees with him in various discussions, overlooking the fact that the purpose of debate is [b]not[/b] to identify likenesses, but to explore differences.

It may come as quite a suprise to him to learn that we agree on more than a few of his positions that he earlier posted; and, in learning such, he may in fact resort to either calling me a liar in that regard, or later disclaim some of his earlier taken positions, so as to distance himself from me.

As for tjsanko and myself, we are more alike than Max realizes, and we are aware of at least some of those similarities; we therefore willing explore our differences

by deepsand

During a Middie's 1st, or Plebe year, the only opportunity that you would have had meet one would have been if you were either an instructor at USNA, a rifle or pistol range instructor at the Severn River Naval Station located across the river from Annapolis, or serving on board one of the several ships-of-the-line that briefly lay anchor in the Chesapeake bay for the purpose of being toured by Plebes during Plebe summer.

At the end of their Plebe year, the now 3rd Class Middies, or Youngsters, go on cruise for the summer, pulling enlisted duties. Similarly, at the end of their Secundo, or 2nd class year, the now 1st Class Middies again go on summer cruise, this time pulling officers' duties. Had you been assigned to a vessel participating in these Youngster and/or First Class cruises, you may have then met a Middie.

At the end of their 2nd, or Youngster year, the now 2nd Class Middies, or Secundos, are assigned summer duties that depend on the career path that they have chosen. For example, those that elected to go NAVAV (Naval Aviation), would, at the time I was there, have been assigned to Pensacola for their 2nd Class summer; a few are assigned to USNA itself to serve as company officers for the new class of Plebes. During this year, you would have had the best chance of meeting a Middie, particulary if you were an instructor in the appropriate specialty.