World War III - Yes, President Bush is right
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by deepsand
Some of the biggest assholes that I've ever met were at USNA, including the aforementioned nephew. All too many of them thought that they were God's gift to the world.
As for myself, the experience was eye-opening in 2 regards.
1) During my prior school experiences, owing to my IQ and inate curiousity & desire to learn about so many diverse subjects, I was held up, by my teachers, as the resident genius. When I arrived at USNA I quickly discovered that the world was full of "geniuses."
2) Having grown up during the 50's and early 60's, which saw the Berlin Blockade, the Cuban Missile Crisis, etc., I had, by the time I graduated from high school, been quite well brainwashed into accepting without question the party line that the US was the essence of all that is good; the Soviets, pure evil. At USNA I quickly learned that the real world was more gray than it is black and white; that all which I took to be so simple was, in fact, exceedingly complex.
by deepsand
I've just noticed a series of exchanges between Jules and yourself, but have not yet had time to read them.
I'm assuming that such are in some way the basis for you reference to him. Care to fill me in; or, must I start from scratch?
Bear in mind that while I can see the general Date line, I cannot see the precise Time line, so I've no idea of the precise order of ths posts by either of you.
by deepsand
No surprise, given that his persistent disregard for logical consistency is his only real constant.
To him, logic has no "substance."
No, unlike some of you other "blow-hard, military chest pounding experts", I don't claim to be one. However, I'm not exactly ignorant of all things military, either.
I spent six years in the military, the last two serving at NORAD, not exactly a "know-nothing" post. My brother was a Marine in Vietnam. And I've been around military people, some of whom are very high-ranking officers, for most of my life.
But no, I'm not a self-proclaimed "expert military war planner" like you ,. That's why I rely on what the REAL military experts might say, Marine Lt. General Michael DeLong, for instance, and I dismiss what blow-hards, like you, might suggest.
by deepsand
It was sheer folly to expect that the long warring factions of Iraqi would quickly and easily come together to form a united democratic government simply owing to the removal of Sadam. This was an issue that Bush failed to properly address prior to settling on a strategy for dealing with Sadam.
It was this failure that directly led to an insufficient force being committed. For more, see
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=194380&messageID=2008969
....and he is squirming like a little boy who has just pissed his pants. You make no sense, dude, and you've offered nothing of substance.
You lose.
by deepsand
The disrepect seems to run in both directions. I noticed that, upon the return of the rest of the Brigade of Midshipmen following my Plebe summer, "Gyrene" jokes would be regularly heard coming from the Secundos and Firsties. This surprised me for 2 reasons.
Firstly, my family had more than the average share of men who had served in the military; most had been Army, several Marines, but I was the first to go Navy, after having decided against going Air Force. I can remember no times when any of those who served before me made any disparaging remarks about members of a branch other than their own. Remarks, some of them vigorous and vulgar, about stupid officers, yes; about an entire branch, no.
Secondly, I was quite aware of the historical fact that the Marines were an integral part of the navies of the world, and that that relationship was born of necessity rather than convenience. And, in any symbiotic relationship, where each party depends on the survival of the other, for either party to harm the other is suicidal; to do so with knowledge and intent, wholly illogical.
Aside from the usual problems arising out of superior-subordinate relationships, it may be the case that technological advances made Marines seem to be superfluous to some. After all, ships don't often come into close quarters combat, resulting in hand-to-hand fighting, as was once the case. As a result, some may view the Marines as being naught but ordinary soldiers, of which the Army can supply as needed.
For me, a Marine is a brother who merely wears different clothing.
by deepsand
by deepsand
Who went off the deep end.
And you even admit to relating to the guy? He's a friggin joke. Remember this, tjsanko@..., you're known by the company you keep. And you are keeping "strange" company.
What a joke! God, the guy is a loony tune!
Who went off the deep end?
And you even admit to relating to the guy? He's a friggin joke. Remember this, tjsanko@..., you're known by the company you keep. And you are keeping "strange" company.
What a joke! God, the guy is a loony tune!
Who went off the deep end??
And you even admit to relating to the guy? He's a friggin joke. Remember this, tjsanko@..., you're known by the company you keep. And you are keeping "strange" company.
What a joke! God, the guy is a loony tune!
Who went off the deep end???
And you even admit to relating to the guy? He's a friggin joke. Remember this, tjsanko@..., you're known by the company you keep. And you are keeping "strange" company.
What a joke! God, the guy is a loony tune!
Who went off the deep end????
And you even admit to relating to the guy? He's a friggin joke. Remember this, tjsanko@..., you're known by the company you keep. And you are keeping "strange" company.
What a joke! God, the guy is a loony tune!
Who went off the deep end?????
And you even admit to relating to the guy? He's a friggin joke. Remember this, tjsanko@..., you're known by the company you keep. And you are keeping "strange" company.
What a joke! God, the guy is a loony tune!
Who went off the deep end??????
And you even admit to relating to the guy? He's a friggin joke. Remember this, tjsanko@..., you're known by the company you keep. And you are keeping "strange" company.
What a joke! God, the guy is a loony tune!
Who went off the deep end???????
And you even admit to relating to the guy? He's a friggin joke. Remember this, tjsanko@..., you're known by the company you keep. And you are keeping "strange" company.
What a joke! God, the guy is a loony tune!
by deepsand
I can understand how someone who is not part of the immediate family may not recognize the true nature of the interplay witnessed; but, rest assured that at no time did I perceive tjsanko's remarks to be of the nature that you here take him to task for.
Equally important, it must be understood that such remarks, although made in a public forum, were not intended to be fully understood by all here present.
I would urge that you accept my judgement that this is truly a case of "no harm, no foul."
by deepsand
by absolutely
by absolutely
Some dictionaries specify the first recorded instance of a word's use in a new sense, or of a new word. I wonder how many months ago it was that the "Meaning 4" you cite was first published in a printed dictionary.
Sorry to have called you "former/ex journalist" incorrectly. Being a freelance journalist rather than a salaried one, you nevertheless ought to be free of political necessity to choose words whose [b]primary[/b] dictionary definition is inaccurate in the context you use it.
by absolutely
[i]Equally important, it must be understood that such remarks, although made in a public forum, were not intended to be fully understood by all here present.[/i]
I would have expected you two would have fought out your differences if you ever saw each other in person! Now, you're telling me you're pals? Your remarks definitely were not "fully understood by all here present!"
by x-marcap
Since he is in Australia, and not really a capitalist I would feel safe. Plus he seems to be anti-gun...
If you have to kill me, have him do it for you...He would be my choice. I might just die from old age, or laughter at any attempt he might try... (Cluseau anyone?) If he got around to making an effort, I might even notice... (after he ran into the wall...)
by x-marcap
I ususally disagree with him. I am not in 100% agreement with you either. I'd say closer to 85%. I thought Tenant should have been gone on 9/12...
Sandy shows the egotism I associate with Annapolis grads, rarely earned. He also has the abusive nature of a smaller boat captain O-4 --> 05.
I am not and would not curry favor with him, but he did agree about the administrator/warrior in the military today. He was right, for once. He did agree with me.
I had hoped his sense of honor would compel him back from the unreasonable hate he has for Bush.
I don't even know the current strategy in Iraq. Nor, do I know the tactical situation. The public has very little real, hard information. The non-embedded jounalists are a joke. At least the embedded jounalists see what is happening. The news media doesn't play much from the embedded journalists. Not much bad news...
by x-marcap
It is just like when one of my best friends, the late Danny McFadden a zoomie of the finest kind said he always wanted to fly for the Marines, but wasn't qualified His parents had been introduced...
I had always heard this reusable line as married, or sober... I laughed. An officer's humor fortunately is not mainstream, or PC. I strive to keep it PG.
Jules and I are old antagonists, so he takes a swipe whenever he can. He carries his soul to market. I carry mine. Although we disagree, he is too ignorant (lacking any experience) to understand. Although Sandy and I don't agree all the time, he understands the nature and probably appreciates the humor.
It is the stereotype I am joking about...
Actually, When Marines do the calculating it is 10 to one.... (reference to previous jokes to illuminate the ignorant. it is just easier to add a 0).
The old saw about the Huey...
It was called a Hellicopter Utility Vehicle by the Air Force. A Whirlybird by the Army, a Chopper by the Navy, and a by the Marines...
by x-marcap
by x-marcap
I would go out find the Meth Lab, and lead the FBI to it. I have already done that with large Pot growing operations.
Those things are dangerous with the Hydrogen gas used in the cooking of it. There is no reason for that stuff to be made outsdide of a phamaceutical lab.
Since deepsand said I was being redundant, I thought I'd oblige. (Silly, yes. But I don't care.)
By the way, I believe that deepsand was either:
1. Never in the Navy, much less an Annapolis grad.
2. If he was in the Navy, probably washed out as an E3 or O2.
by absolutely
by deepsand
I believe very strongly that the condemned should be afforded the demise of their choice; to do otherwise would be most uncivil.
Is it ok if Jules borrows my Luger? And, no, it's [b]not[/b] a Naval model; it's Luftwaffe.
by deepsand
Main Entry: in?tel?li?gence
Function: noun
Etymology: Middle English, from Middle French, from Latin intelligentia, from intelligent-, intelligens intelligent
1 a (1) : the ability to learn or understand or to deal with new or trying situations : REASON; also : the skilled use of reason (2) : the ability to apply knowledge to manipulate one's environment or to think abstractly as measured by objective criteria (as tests) b Christian Science : the basic eternal quality of divine Mind c : mental acuteness : SHREWDNESS
2 a : an intelligent entity; especially : ANGEL b : intelligent minds or mind
3 : the act of understanding : COMPREHENSION
[b]4 a : INFORMATION, NEWS b : information concerning an enemy or possible enemy or an area; also : an agency engaged in obtaining such information[/b]
5 : the ability to perform computer functions
by deepsand
Opponents need [/b]not[/b] be disrespectful of each others; and, being respectful does [b]not[/b] make them, as you say, "pals."
Tjsanko has not, as Max continues to do, resorted to ad hominem arguments when faced with opposition. Tongue in cheek humor, yes; character assasination, no. What you are witnessing is not a friendship born of commonalities, but mutual respect between 2 who take opposite views on certain matters only.
And, that he/we have at times posted messages that may not be fully understood by all is hardly unusual here. Were it required that no such posts be made, this board would have little use for the Miscellaneous forum. And, given that so many members do not accept peer-to-peer messages, there would be little said, either in public or in private.
by hal 9000
Or I'm going to have to bring out the [b]Belt[/b] that Bill Cosby refered to on one of his Records. :p
But if you would like to know the real answers all you have to do is ask a UK Citizen called Gary McKinnon apparently hes managed to infiltrate all the US Conputer networks looking for any UFO info but along the way he's most likely seen the real facts so he should know all the correct answers. That we [b]Plebs[/b] are not allowed to know.
Col ]:)
by x-marcap
The real issue is identifying the combatants. This real issue is HUMINT- Human intelligence. Why won't the locals help us against the terrorists in their midst?
Because unlike us, they do believe the enemy of my friend is my enemy. They consider their terrorist brothers still brothers. The radical Islamists control many of the schools in Saudi, but that is changing. The same may be said in Iran. But, that isn't changing. The real issues are human ones, and we need a human solution.
I don't know what it is. Maybe some enlightened moderate will explain live and let live successfully to the masses in the Mid-East.
by deepsand
It was not too long ago that globes and maps showed dotted lines, fading into nothing, as the boundaries between many of the Mid-Eastern nations, owing to the fact there were large regions governed only by various and feuding tribes.
And, of those with firm borders, many of such were imposed by Western powers, and quite recently, as was also the case in the Baltics.
The result is that many of the peoples in that region have yet to develop true national identities, clinging instead to their old tribal allegiances. (It is interesting, and in this instance most appropriate, to note that M-W lists the following definition first : "the obligation of a feudal vassal to his liege lord.")
The problems are further compounded by the facts that Islam is the youngest of the major world religions, it was birthed in the midst of tribal feudalism, and molded by a myriad local customs. Despite the claims of many Muslims, their culture is not dictated by their religion; rather, their culture has shaped their religion.
These are people who, by virtue of still very much living in the past, do not yet possess the character required for either self-governance or participation in world affairs as an equal of all others.
They can be led out of their Dark Age only by ruthlessly strong leaders who will force change upon them, and keep them in check until such is completed.
by x-marcap
I prefer that he merely continue to piss me off to the point I have a stroke...
He comes closer nearly every week... I usually merely read for a week or so until he gets me so pissed I have to chime in...
He is igmorant, but thinks he is intelligent and wise. I think he is smarmy at his best.
by x-marcap
It is the egotism that boat drivers get. That has me convinced. That and the DFAS in NJ that was the USN IT center. I strongly suspect one of 5 names. He is most likely all O4-O5. All were in planning and Logistics for a DFAS at either Cleveland, Indianapolis Data Center, Huntsville, or New Jersey.
I think he was in New Jersey. If he is the guy I have uncovered, he's been trying to get out of logistics and into command for 30 years.
If He is the most likely person, he was in Planning and logistics... And he had been involved with logistics for a long time. He was AT at O5 for 15+years.
Colonels are chosen by merit. I suspect the same for Navy Captains. O5 is a Mile away from O-6.
He has a personal hatred for Bush. I think he was a logistics officer who had a TOC and a command billet to get himself out of IT, back to a boat, and He and the plan got dumped.
That is why I have it narrowed down to one of five people. He was a swift boat commander in Vietnam, and was wounded, they found he had a flair for accounting and plans, and he got stuck in a non-combat role. He got stuck at O5. Personally I think that if it is the man that my DFAS Cleveland buddies think it was. He was shafted by circumstances, and then by deliberation. He was never selected for Captain. His last chance for promotion was when Clinton left the door...
by x-marcap
--- edited to direct the comment ----
I consider chlorine gas a WMD, but it isn't on the list of baddies that are considred to be WMDS. I think that is becuase it can be used in cleaning products, and there was evidence that the mobile labs were producing solvents and cleaners at the time, the announcement of WMD lab was out of line.
That it doesn't prove they weren't ever used for gas production, or intended for later gas production.
However, there wasn't commercial lettering on the vehicles, but that may not be as common in the Mid-East as it is in the US, where every commercial vehicle is a moving billboard for the business. The problem is saying something definite was not wise at the time.
Sometimes I think we have to wait until they are actually using the WMDs, and we can catch them in the act to make liberals happy. That way we'd be 100% sure, and we'd have been bloodied at the same time. The latter is the most important to the liberals who hate the military.
by x-marcap
The government that governs best governs least...
It is trite, overused and true...
by deepsand
Main Entry: [b]rep?e?ti?tious[/b]
: characterized or marked by repetition; especially : [b]tediously repeating[/b]
--------------------------------------------------
Main Entry: [b]re?dun?dant[/b]
1 a : exceeding what is necessary or normal : SUPERFLUOUS b : characterized by or containing an excess; specifically : using more words than necessary c : characterized by similarity or repetition d chiefly British : no longer needed for a job and hence laid off
2 : PROFUSE, LAVISH
3 : serving as a duplicate for preventing failure of an entire system (as a spacecraft) upon failure of a single component
by deepsand
with regards to what is the optimum.
Far too many either believe that governments do and/or should have powers far in excess of that actually granted them under the various constitutions, or hold that government should be the provider of last resort in all matters.
Much of this has been facilitated by Supreme Court rulings which gave credence to the claim that the phrase "to ... provide for the common Defence and general Welfare of the United States" gave the Federal Government implicit powers over and above those specifically enumerated in the US Constitution; and, once this door was opened, the States were not long in following suit.
The result was that both States' and individual rights, along with the commensurate responsibilities, began to wither.
We've now reached the point where all too few know what freedom truly is, and fewer still are capable of living free.
by absolutely
:D
Such an error is a matter of form only and does not obscure the substance (at least, only for the short time it takes me to remember what is close to "r" on a QWERTY keyboard!), and I still consider deepsand data to be high quality overall.
Bush and the "adversarial" party that [b]should[/b] do a better job of keeping the GOP honest (& vice-versa) will probably rest, rather than test this or any other hypothesis that is consistent with fact, but evil enough to qualify as a "conspiracy". Isn't it odd how easily nowadays suspicion can be deflected from the individual suspected to the one who suspects, by use of the mystical incantation "conspiracy theory"?
by deepsand
I'm certain that this tactic was one of the very earliest devised by thinking man.
It certainly appears often enough in both historical and contemporary writings, both fiction and otherwise.
And, be assured that I have properly chastised my left hand for being so careless; however, in light of the fact that it is also quite dim witted, I should not be surprised to see similar behavior from it in the future. At least it does'nt cost too much to support, and is ever so handy at other tasks.
by absolutely
I remember that chlorine gas kills, but is it really an [i]efficient[/i] weapon?
If not, is it believable that it was produced for cleaning? Even killers want to be clean.
by hal 9000
It's what is used most often to keep [b]Swinning Pools[/b] safe to use isn't it? :^0
By that defination my local [b]Primary School[/b] had [b]A WMD[/b] when they first built their swimming pool and they certianly had a problem within the first three years when they had a Clorine Gas Leak that necessated the clearing of the entire school so we all had a day off even if we had to walk the long way round to get home. :(
Col ]:)
Going by his own profile, he's had 48 years experience in all thing computing, including things that only college level people might have had access to 48 years ago (kids 48 years ago had no such computing access), which would put him in the age bracket of pushing 70, which would have put him out of the Navy decades ago (if he was ever there to begin with), because there are no 60-something year old O-4s, only 60-something year old O-10s and O-9s, maybe a few O-8s, or O-7s.
The guy's blowing smoke, and you're sucking it in.
by deepsand
by x-marcap
Max,
His claim to access to computers at 12 isn't impossible espeecially if his Dad was a professor or such...
IF he was class of '68 and 22 in 68, he is 56. If he has been retired for the last 6 years he was ~48.
Yes, there are occasional 0-5's that are ~50. especially if they have the right connections. In peacetime rank is slow to gain. He could have been stuck in a place that they give him the three shots from Ensign to Lt ~Age 31. As many as 9 years later, He is now 1st Lt. 0-3 ~40. He now has 3 chances for promotion across another 9 years. Dang he is an O4 with 4 years as a middie, 9 as 2nd LT. 9 as 1st Lt. and he is now eligible for retirement. At that point it is 9 more years to Lt. Commander. 31 years in uniform and 9 more as Commander. nearly 40 years in uniform and O-5...
That has happened to several Marine officers that I know. They were APA members. Annapolis grads.
I have only seen it happen with USNA grads. They get special treatment. APA Annapololis Protective Association. Their goal is making sure the grads get the goodies, and a retirement...
by x-marcap
Sunni VS Shiite.
Yuck!!!
by tonythetiger
by absolutely
"revert to anarchy?", Deepsand. It is already anarchy except in the little pockets of Baghdad enclosed by blast walls and cleared of the original population. We've no idea what is going on as the only reports come from cameras surrounded by overwhelming US military force.
You think that we would have picked up on the fact that sectarian civil war might break out once we took away the stable (OK, so it wasn't nice) government that they did have. We might also have picked up on the fact that both sides in this war would unite in hatred of us every so often and kill a few more.
However, as we invaded the wrong place for the wrong reasons at the wrong time to do the right thing, we have only ourselves to blame.
Still. The first few weeks when were running project "shock-and-awe", it sure did look good on the TV. Looking pretty crap now, though. Do we have any plans on how stop the civil war? No? Can we get out with any honour? No? O-o-oh, sh:t.
The invasion of Iraq was one of the most stupid acts in either countries history.
Never mind. Killed a few muslims so it can't be all bad.
by absolutely
Good work, neilb.
Your points really don't require any further comment, but it's evening here on the US west coast, and I was impressed by nobody having anything more to say all day about your evaluation of the war.
...it doesn't concede anything. It's more likely that, just like dealing with you, people don't want to attempt to reason with the unreasonable or delusional. It's pointless, something you have yet to learn. You have a LOT to learn, dude.
You really are delusional, you know. You're young and ignorant and , like I said, you have a LOT to learn. Everyone knows it, except you, of course.
.
And they both thought the same thing:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=192945&messageID=1998765
Man, you-are-a-loser BIG TIME!
by x-marcap
by absolutely
to get Max all riled up like that.
Of course I have a lot to learn. There is a lot to know.
by absolutely
when his best critique of me is unsubstantiated likening to somebody else I don't know, who uses the name "oneamazingwriter".
I didn't find the thread that spawned the thread "OK I'll say it OneAmazingWriter is..." but what I saw of THAT one was enough to tell me that OneAmazingWriter is not the one who should be most ashamed in that exchange. Have fun with your yes-men, you pathetic follower.
by deepsand
by thechas
Max,
I had hoped to post this in your thread about how "good" a President GWB is. But could not find it.
Here is a link and the comments from a conservative talk show host who now regrets voting for GWB.
http://www.kabc.com/mcintyre/listingsentry.asp?id=432586&pt=mcintyre+in+the+morning
AN APOLOGY FROM A BUSH VOTER
By Doug McIntyre
Host, McIntyre in the Morning
Talk Radio 790 KABC
There?s nothing harder in public life than admitting you?re wrong. By the way, admitting you?re wrong can be even tougher in private life. If you don?t believe me, just ask Bill Clinton or Charlie Sheen. But when you go out on the limb in public, it?s out there where everyone can see it, or in my case, hear it.
So, I?m saying today, I was wrong to have voted for George W. Bush. In historic terms, I believe George W. Bush is the worst two-term President in the history of the country. Worse than Grant. I also believe a case can be made that he?s the worst President, period.
In 2000, I was a McCain guy. I wasn?t sure about the Texas Governor. He had name recognition and a lot of money behind him, but other than that? What? Still, I was sick of all the Clinton shenanigans and the thought of President Gore was? unthinkable. So, GWB became my guy.
For the first few months he was just flubbing along like most new Presidents, no great shakes, but no disasters either. He cut taxes and I like tax cuts.
Then September 11th happened. September 11th changed everything for me, like it did for so many of you. After September 11th, all the intramural idiocy of American politics stopped being funny. We had been attacked by a vicious and determined enemy and it was time for all of us to row in the same direction.
And we did for the blink of an eye. I believed the President when he said we were going to hunt down Bin Laden and all those responsible for the 9-11 murders. I believed President Bush when he said we would go after the terrorists and the nations that harbored them.
I supported the President when he sent our troops into Afghanistan, after all, that?s where the Taliban was, that?s where al-Qaida trained the killers, that?s where Bin Laden was.
And I cheered when we quickly toppled the Taliban government, but winced when we let Bin Laden escape from Tora-Bora.
Then, the talk turned to Iraq and I winced again.
I thought the connection to 9-11 was sketchy at best. But Colin Powell impressed me at the UN, and Tony Blair was in, and after all, he was a Clinton guy, not a Bush guy, so I thought the case had to be strong. I was worried though, because I had read the Wolfowitz paper, ?The Project for the New American Century.? It?s been around since ?92, and it raised alarm bells because it was based on a theory, ?Democratizing the Middle East? and I prefer pragmatism over theory. I was worried because Iraq was being justified on a radical new basis, ?pre-emptive war.? Any time we do something without historical precedent I get nervous.
But the President shifted the argument to WMDs and the urgent threat of Iraq getting atomic weapons. The debate turned to Saddam passing nukes on to terror groups. After 9-11, the risk was too great. As the President said, ?The next smoking gun might be a mushroom cloud.? At least that?s what I thought at the time.
I grew up in New York and watched them build the World Trade Center. I worked with a guy, Frank O?Brien, who put the elevators in both towers. I lost a very close friend on September 11th. 103 floor, tower one, Cantor Fitzgerald. Tim Coughlin was his name. If we had to take out Iraq to make sure something like that, or worse, never happened again, so be it. I knew the consequences. We have a soldier in our house. None of this was theoretical in my house.
But in the months and years since shock and awe I have been shocked repeatedly by a consistent litany of excuses, alibis, double-talk, inaccuracies, bogus predictions, and flat out lies. I have watched as the President and his administration changed the goals, redefined the reasons for going into Iraq, and fumbled the good will of the world and the focus necessary to catch the real killers of September 11th.
I have watched the President say the commanders on the ground will make the battlefield decisions, and the war won?t be run from Washington. Yet, politics has consistently determined what the troops can and can?t do on the ground and any commander who did not go along with the administration was sacked, and in some cases, maligned.
I watched and tried to justify the looting in Iraq after the fall of Saddam. I watched and tried to justify the dismantling of the entire Iraqi army. I tired to explain the complexities of building a functional new Iraqi army. I urged patience when no WMDs were found. Then the Vice President told us we were in the ?waning days of the insurgency.? And I started wincing again. The President says we have to stay the course but what if it?s the wrong course?
It was the wrong course. All of it was wrong. We are not on the road to victory. We?re about to slink home with our tail between our legs, leaving civil war in Iraq and a nuclear armed Iran in our wake. Bali was bombed. Madrid was bombed. London was bombed. And Bin Laden is still making tapes. It?s unspeakable. The liberal media didn?t create this reality, bad policy did.
Most historians believe it takes 30-50 years before we get a reasonably accurate take on a President?s place in history. So, maybe 50 years from now Iraq will be a peaceful member of the brotherhood of nations and George W. Bush will be celebrated as a visionary genius.
But we don?t live fifty years in the future. We live now. We have to make public policy decisions now. We have to live with the consequences of the votes we cast and the leaders we chose now.
After five years of carefully watching George W. Bush I?ve reached the conclusion he?s either grossly incompetent, or a hand puppet for a gaggle of detached theorists with their own private view of how the world works. Or both.
Presidential failures. James Buchanan, Franklin Pierce, Jimmy Carter, Warren Harding-? the competition is fierce for the worst of the worst. Still, the damage this President has done is enormous. It will take decades to undo, and that?s assuming we do everything right from now on. His mistakes have global implications, while the other failed Presidents mostly authored domestic embarrassments.
And speaking of domestic embarrassments, let?s talk for a minute about President Bush?s domestic record. Yes, he cut taxes. But tax cuts combined with reckless spending and borrowing is criminal mismanagement of the public?s money. We?re drunk at the mall with our great grandchildren?s credit cards. Whatever happened to the party of fiscal responsibility?
Bush created a giant new entitlement, the prescription drug plan. He lied to his own party to get it passed. He lied to the country about its true cost. It was written by and for the pharmaceutical industry. It helps nobody except the multinationals that lobbied for it. So much for smaller government. In fact, virtually every tentacle of government has grown exponentially under Bush. Unless, of course, it was an agency to look after the public interest, or environmental protection, and/or worker?s rights.
I?ve talked so often about the border issue, I won?t bore you with a rehash. It?s enough to say this President has been a catastrophe for the wages of working people; he?s debased the work ethic itself. ?Jobs Americans won?t do!? He doesn?t believe in the sovereign borders of the country he?s sworn to protect and defend. And his devotion to cheap labor for his corporate benefactors, along with his worship of multinational trade deals, makes an utter mockery of homeland security in a post 9-11 world. The President?s January 7th, 2004 speech on immigration, his first trial balloon on his guest worker scheme, was a deal breaker for me. I couldn?t and didn?t vote for him in 2004. And I?m glad I didn?t.
Katrina, Harriet Myers, The Dubai Port Deal, skyrocketing gas prices, shrinking wages for working people, staggering debt, astronomical foreign debt, outsourcing, open borders, contempt for the opinion of the American people, the war on science, media manipulation, faith based initives, a cavalier attitude toward fundamental freedoms-- this President has run the most arrogant and out-of-touch administration in my lifetime, perhaps, in any American?s lifetime.
You can make a case that Abraham Lincoln did what he had to do, the public be damned. If you roll the dice on your gut and you?re right, history remembers you well. But, when your gut led you from one business failure to another, when your gut told you to trade Sammy Sosa to the White Sox, and you use the same gut to send our sons and daughters to fight and die in a distraction from the real war on terror, then history will and should be unapologetic in its condemnation.
None of this, by the way, should be interpreted as an endorsement of the opposition party. The Democrats are equally bankrupt. This is the second crime of our age. Again, historically speaking, its times like these when America needs a vibrant opposition to check the power of a run-amuck majority party. It requires it. It doesn?t work without one. Like the high and low tides keep the oceans alive, a healthy, positive opposition offers a path back to the center where all healthy societies live.
Tragically, the Democrats have allowed crackpots, leftists and demagogic cowards to snipe from the sidelines while taking no responsibility for anything. In fairness, I don?t believe a Democrat president would have gone into Iraq. Unfortunately, I don?t know if President Gore would have gone into Afghanistan. And that?s one of the many problems with the Democrats.
The two party system has always been clumsy and imperfect, but it has only collapsed once, in the 1850s, and the result was civil war.
I believe, as I have said countless times, the two party system is on the brink of a second collapse. It?s currently running on spin, anger, revenge, and pots and pots and pots of money.
We?re being governed by paper-mache patriots; brightly painted red, white and blue, but hollow to the core. Both parties have mastered the cynical arts of media manipulation and fund raising. They?ve learned the lessons of Watergate and burn the tapes. They have learned to divide the nation for their own gain. They have demonstrated the willingness to exploit any tragedy for personal advantage. The contempt they have for the American people is without parallel.
This is painful to say, and I?m sure for many of you, painful to read. But it?s impossible to heal the country until we?re willing to acknowledge the truth no matter how painful. We have to wean ourselves off sugar coated partisan lies.
With a belated tip of the cap to Ralph Nader, the system is broken, so broken, it?s almost inevitable it pukes up the Al Gores and George W. Bushes. Where are the Trumans and the Eisenhowers? Where are the men and women of vision and accomplishment? Why do we have to settle for recycled hacks and malleable ciphers? Greatness is always rare, but is basic competence and simple honesty too much to ask?
It may be decades before we have the full picture of how paranoid and contemptuous this administration has been. And I am open to the possibility that I?m all wet about everything I?ve just said. But I?m putting it out there, because I have to call it as I see it, and this is how I see it today. I don?t say any of this lightly. I?ve thought about this for months and months. But eventually, the weight of evidence takes on a gravitational force of its own.
I believe that George W. Bush has taken us down a terrible road. I don?t believe the Democrats are offering an alternative. That means we?re on our own to save this magnificent country. The United States of America is a gift to the world, but it has been badly abused and it?s rightful owners, We the People, had better step up to the plate and reclaim it before the damage becomes irreparable.
So, accept my apology for allowing partisanship to blind me to an obvious truth; our President is incapable of the tasks he is charged with. I almost feel sorry for him. He is clearly in over his head. Yet, he doesn?t generate the sympathy Warren Harding earned. Harding, a spectacular mediocrity, had the self-knowledge to tell any and all he shouldn?t be President. George W. Bush continues to act the part, but at this point whose buying the act?
Does this make me a waffler? A flip-flopper? Maybe, although I prefer to call it realism. And, for those of you who never supported Bush, its also fair to accuse me of kicking Bush while he?s down. After all, you were kicking him while he was up.
You were right, I was wrong.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending