Encryption concept
Image: jijomathai/Adobe Stock

Choosing an identity and access management solution is no trivial task. CyberArk and BeyondTrust use best-in-class technologies to protect systems, manage passwords and otherwise control and protect the use of sensitive data.

SEE: How to recruit and hire a Security Analyst (TechRepublic Premium)

Featured partners

What is CyberArk?

CyberArk is an information security company that provides IAM, PAM and security solutions. These solutions prevent unauthorized access to essential systems, manage passwords and track the use of sensitive data.

Some key features offered by CyberArk include password vaulting, session monitoring, file integrity monitoring, secure remote access and threat detection.

What is BeyondTrust?

BeyondTrust is a security company that provides vulnerability management, privileged account management and data protection solutions. Its products aim to help organizations secure their systems and data from internal and external threats.

Some key features offered by BeyondTrust include asset discovery, vulnerability assessment, patch management, password and credential management, and privileged access control. They also offer solutions for cloud and virtual environments and mobile devices.

Image: BeyondTrust

CyberArk vs. BeyondTrust head-to-head chart

Both CyberArk and BeyondTrust are powerful, highly rated systems trusted by users. Both will provide best-in-class IAM management and they have also both been labeled leaders within the industry by the Gartner Magic Quadrant.

CyberArkBeyondTrust
Security focusAccountsAssets
Password vault
Multi-factor authenticationTwo-factor
Password management
Account management
Session recording
Privileged access management
Proxy/VPN
OrganizationAccountHost
Gartner classificationLeaderLeader

CyberArk vs. BeyondTrust features

In general, CyberArk is account-focused, whereas BeyondTrust is asset-focused. This difference in philosophy represents two notably different security paradigms.

CyberArk’s account-focused approach relies on privileged access management, account user behavior and account privileges. For companies whose users carry accounts across multiple devices, CyberArk’s approach may be more appropriate. The agentless asset discovery can quickly identify all assets (including devices, operating systems and applications) within an organization’s network. CyberArk will recognize as accounts sign on to new systems or devices, to quickly manage access.

BeyondTrust’s asset-focused approach relies on environmental scanning to secure the organization’s digital assets. This platform, which supports remote access, offers agentless asset discovery to help organizations inventory their systems and understand where vulnerabilities may exist. BeyondTrust is asset-based—concerned with the security of individual assets.

Otherwise, both CyberArk and BeyondTrust have similar feature offerings and advantages. Which solution is best for your organization depends mainly on the assets you need to protect, the size of your organization and your organization’s potential security risks.

Simplicity and ease-of-use

For beginners, CyberArk has a substantial learning curve. Many small- to mid-sized organizations may find themselves hiring a professional to deploy the solution rather than deploying it internally. While documentation is available, it can be incomplete and inconsistent. A managed services provider may be needed for an organization to transition to CyberArk.

Comparatively, BeyondTrust’s solutions are fairly straightforward to use and deploy. BeyondTrust has a variety of features such as Smart Rules, Smart Groups and Direct Connect, all intended to make the overall user experience of BeyondTrust easier, thereby improving overall productivity.

Audience

Although CyberArk can theoretically manage up to 100,000 endpoints, the maximum implementation in the real world is 57,000. Nevertheless, CyberArk is more likely to be used by enterprise-level organizations, whereas BeyondTrust is more popular with small businesses and mid-market enterprises.

CyberArk’s features, functionality and complexity lend themselves better to an enterprise-level organization. Meanwhile, BeyondTrust’s simplicity, ease of use and painless deployment make it a better option for smaller companies and mid-sized organizations.

Interfaces

CyberArk’s web interface is wanting and the features and functions provided through the web interface are not always the same functions that are provided elsewhere—potentially leading to confusion, especially in terms of API configuration.

BeyondTrust provides a clean, attractive HTML5 interface, although some users find it lacking in more advanced features, such as group approval. While the BeyondTrust interface may not have as robust a feature set as CyberArk, it’s easier to use.

Choosing between CyberArk vs. BeyondTrust

CyberArk and BeyondTrust are fairly evenly matched IAM solutions that have a lot going for them. Today, BeyondTrust is the leading competitor within the field, but CyberArk is close behind.

Choose CyberArk if:

  • You need a comprehensive IAM solution that can support on-premises, hybrid and cloud environments.
  • You need an IAM solution with built-in privileged access management capabilities.
  • You’re interested in an IAM solution that puts account management and account security first.
  • You aren’t afraid of an IAM solution with complexity.

Choose BeyondTrust if:

  • You need an IAM solution focusing on secure remote access and compliance with regulatory standards.
  • You need an IAM solution with robust vulnerability assessment and patch management features.
  • You’re interested in an IAM solution that puts asset management and asset security first.
  • You need a solution fast and easy to deploy.

Ultimately, CyberArk and BeyondTrust are powerful IAM solutions that can help organizations manage their critical assets and protect against data breaches. When choosing between CyberArk and BeyondTrust, consider your organization’s needs, requirements and resources first.

Leading IAM Solutions

1 Semperis

Visit website

If your Active Directory isn’t secure, nothing is. Avoid single points of failure with comprehensive hybrid AD protection. Modernize your AD. Get lifecycle defense for identity-based attacks before, during, and after an attack, all supported by a dedicated incident response team.

Learn more about Semperis

2 NordLayer

Visit website

NordLayer revolutionizes security through seamless IAM integration, featuring advanced authentication protocols - 2FA, SSO, biometrics. This creates a Zero Trust environment, ensuring secure, verified, and permission-based user access. IAM enables precise content and app segmentation, aligning seamlessly with modern security standards. Elevate your security with NordLayer's IAM integration, a cornerstone of modern security practices.

Learn more about NordLayer

3 Twingate

Visit website

Twingate helps fast-growing companies easily implement a Zero Trust secure access solution without compromising security, usability, or performance. We believe that “Work from Anywhere” should just work. Twingate’s secure access platform replaces legacy VPNs with a modern Identity-First Networking solution that combines enterprise-grade security with a consumer-grade user experience. It can be set up in less than 15 minutes and integrates with all major cloud providers and identity providers.

Learn more about Twingate

4 ManageEngine ADManager Plus

Visit website

ADManager Plus is a unified AD, Exchange, Teams, Google Workspace, and Microsoft 365 management solution to simplify tasks such as provisioning users, cleaning up stale accounts, and managing NTFS and share permissions. It offers 200 built-in reports, including reports on inactive user accounts, Microsoft 365 licenses, and users' last logon times. You can build a custom workflow for ticketing and compliance, delegate tasks to technicians, automate AD tasks such as restore and backup AD objects.

Learn more about ManageEngine ADManager Plus

5 Dashlane

Visit website

Dashlane secures your data with a patented security architecture and AES256-bit encryption, the strongest method available. Employees can securely share encrypted passwords with individuals or groups- instead of sending them unsecurely over email or Slack. Try Dashlane Business for free

Learn more about Dashlane

Subscribe to the Cybersecurity Insider Newsletter

Strengthen your organization's IT security defenses by keeping abreast of the latest cybersecurity news, solutions, and best practices. Delivered Tuesdays and Thursdays

Subscribe to the Cybersecurity Insider Newsletter

Strengthen your organization's IT security defenses by keeping abreast of the latest cybersecurity news, solutions, and best practices. Delivered Tuesdays and Thursdays