"a government-run insurance plan"
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by jck
is nice.
But it won't buy you a box of Cheerios.
Food stamps do.
BTW, the unemployment where I live is almost as bad as Michigan. 13.8%.
Yours isn't the only state.
by jdclyde
I wasn't aware that you also ran the routers, switches, and firewall for where you work. That is normally done by people that specialize unless it is a very small business, like back in days of old when the Accountant was IT by default.
So, are you really Network Administrator as well as Programmer? Sweet.
by jck
doesn't change that, in most peoples' eyes, Sarah Palin was not a strong candidate and did not help McCain's chances.
And maybe they weren't "pro-Obama". Maybe they just saw less of a chance of more damage by Obama-Biden than they did McCain-Palin?
Anyways, you didn't stick to your party. By your own criteria, you're weak candidate for office, jd. Never run.
BTW, Barr is in no way a fiscal conservative nor for minimal government. Go look at his track record. He only voted for the Patriot Act after they voted in his pork on the bill.
He's a scam artist like most of the rest of them...no matter what party he suckers into supporting him.
by jck
Just like not all Republicans are against the plan.
Such as Olympia Snowe.
I guess that you'll have something negative to say about her though, since she's a weak candidate for not being "strongly" with her party.
Doom and gloom...fire and brimstone...the earth will come to an end if we have anything other than companies running things for a profit...oh doom and gloom...
by jck
No, I don't "run" them.
I help troubleshoot them, including the scripting languages and configurations for them.
Just like I optimize databases, yet I'm not a DBA.
I wear a lot of hats.
I also do my own home improvements. I guess I'm Bob Vila too now.
by jck
I have provided you proof now in an above post.
I can even get you the SEC filing by Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., if you so desire. It's public record.
I didn't talk bullshit. I didn't talk non-sense.
I did my research before I speeled out.
So, thank you kindly. But, you are wrong. I am right. I provided the numbers.
BTW, I make under 6 figures and post-refund I still have paid about 22% in federal tax.
Considering Wal-Mart's federal taxes in that SEC filing from gross profits was 7.4 percent, I don't think they pay enough.
As for theft, Wal-Mart not only gets a huge break on taxes on their profit...but, they also get big tax breaks from counties and cities and pay little or no property taxes as well as buy land/space with their realty arm and rent it to their store arm and write it off.
Hence, yeah...I bet Wal-Mart when you figure all the incentives, breaks, rebates, etc., they get back...pays closer to zero than you think, Max.
Why don't you go now and research all that for me and bring me back that figure and prove me wrong.
Got the time? Got the inspiration? Can you do it?
by jdclyde
The people in the party moved away from me, not the other way around. Once you move away from the big two parties, it is nothing more than a symbolic vote to try to get peoples attention, but since you don't have, nor believe in core principles, you would never understand.
And it was Mae that brought up fiscal conservative, not I.
One more chance of you trying to argue instead of converse, and again, you shoot and miss. Doesn't that ever get old for you?
by jdclyde
you are not even honest enough to see there is a difference between someone that is working to improve their situation and having a hard time, vs someone that doesn't try?
you are sad.....
by jdclyde
by jck
[i]Wrong again, jck.[/i]
That is your opinion. Again, not a fact.
[i]The people in the party moved away from me, not the other way around. Once you move away from the big two parties, it is nothing more than a symbolic vote to try to get peoples attention, but since you don't have, nor believe in core principles, you would never understand.[/i]
So, you gravitated from John McCain who is not a fiscal conservative, to Bob Barr who is even less of one?
Exactly what about Bob Barr's belief system distances him from John McCain and not the Republican party values that you hold in such high regard? Please give me definitive examples.
[i]And it was Mae that brought up fiscal conservative, not I.[/i]
And, you made a definitive, absolute assertion that "no fiscal conservative" would do something. You don't know what all fiscal conservatives would do. In fact, you are not the absolute authority on what the term means and stands for in America. Therefore, you are trying to project your beliefs on everyone else. How liberal of you.
[i]One more chance of you trying to argue instead of converse, and again, you shoot and miss. Doesn't that ever get old for you?[/i]
How did I miss?
a) I pointed out that you went to Bob Barr
b) I pointed out how Bob Barr does not hold more close to Republican values (or any other for that matter) that you supposedly hold so dear.
c) I point out that, as Oz and Mae have told you, you make incredibly blanket, generic, inaccurate assertions about things as if you know everything without presenting proof.
d) I pointed out the hypocrisy of Bob Barr.
How is that shooting and missing?
I'm right on target. Barr is a man who jumped ship, went to another party, says what they want to hear, and has been a hypocrite for over 20 years all along in his political career.
You are the one leaping to conclusions and pretending that you have all the answers when your basis for doing things is founded on conjecture and knee jerk reactions.
by jck
I am saying if you're poor, you're poor. If you have nothing, whether you work or not to improve, poverty and all the good efforts in the world still gets you nothing.
Achievement (making that money) buys you food, not effort...not good will...not going to church.
That is, of course, within the parameters of "doing for yourself", and not "taking a handout".
Besides, what's wrong with food stamps and welfare? Hm? Please explain how having take that is wrong?
by jck
by jck
I already do independent consultancy part-time on the side, as well as holding a full-time job.
See, I am working HARD for what I have and to have a good future.
In fact, I might be making the move "up the ladder" soon.
I'll let ya know if I do. Maybe I'll have a job for a network tech. ;)
Gross profit is the difference between revenue and the cost of making a product or providing a service - before deducting overhead, payroll, taxation, and interest payments.
Gross profit minus overhead, payroll, and interest payments equals taxable income.
You forgot to list the deductions for overhead, payroll, and interest payments. What are those numbers, by the way? It would be interesting to see.
Wal Mart's 2008 net income: 13.30B
http://finance.yahoo.com/q/ks?s=WMT
I'll take you at your word that Wal Mart paid 7.18 billion in taxes - but it's much more than the 7.4 percent you mistakenly calculated.
Only in Japan do corporations pay taxes at a higher rate than in the United States - 39.54 percent versus 39.27 percent respectively. Your adopted home-nation of Ireland, by the way, only taxes corporations at 12.5 percent.
Corporate tax rates worldwide:
http://www.taxfoundation.org/publications/show/22917.html
Besides, corporations don't really pay any taxes at all. The cost is merely passed onto the consumer in the form of higher prices.
by delbertpgh
I didn't like Palin a bit, even less than I liked GWB, whom I abhorred. She was an information-free goofball who knew how to do a few things well, like run a campaign that played up to popular paranoia. She has also turned out to be a complete publicity hound and self-serving narcissist. Of course, people who are in love with her don't see these things as problems.
If Obama had chosen a VP who acted like her, I could not have taken him seriously. I didn't think McCain was untrustworthy until he picked her. Given that he was in his 70s, if he had become President there was an excellent chance of him dying in the saddle, and Caribou Barbie taking over.
by jck
I overpaid for the past 15 years.
You figure if I get to take my revenues from all sources, subtract maintaining my holdings, paying for facility maintenance, laborers, utilities, etc.
I must be paying around...90% of my net profit.
Don't see the issue with that yet?
You pay tax on gross income minus a small subset of exemptions.
They pay tax on a fraction of their income due to writing off "operating expenses".
I'd take the corporate tax scheme any day. I have to pay people to maintain my place, fix my sewer, etc.
Why don't I get to consider that an "operating expense"?
The day I see a corporation take 20-25% of their "gross adjusted income" like I do for the IRS and pay that, I'll be fine with what their paying.
Until then, yeah...it is screwing the American working people.
by jck
by jck
I said:
[i]Considering Wal-Mart's federal taxes in that SEC filing from gross profits was 7.4 percent, I don't think they pay enough.[/i]
I was speaking in terms of what they get in gross profit, which is before operating expenses are taken out.
That's the big flaw in corporate taxation. That's how Americans end up dishing out 20-35% of their income, and corporations end up paying far less.
Compare apples to apples, not two different tax codes.
Otherwise, corporate America will have you snowed into thinking their paying their power bill is more of a critical expense than you paying yours.
God knows, they've already paid the politicians to write the tax law that way.
by jdclyde
how happy are you with the VP we ended up getting stuck with?
Is he there for comic relief or as a distraction?
I admit to not being up on his life, but he was supposedly brought in because of being such an expert?
by jdclyde
I am not talking about if people should or shouldn't get government assistance, I am talking about what I PERSONALLY do, and who I am willing to do it for.
YOU are bringing up welfare/foodstamps.
YOU are bringing up success/failure.
If you have a point, make it.
Are YOU saying regardless of effort, phuck'em all?
by jdclyde
we have an administration, along with a bunch of supporters of his, that are he11 bent on punishing success.
by oz_media
You are right, I should have said health care insurance.
You didn't seem to have a problem figuring it out though, well done.
by oz_media
I often get props in PM's for actually calling you out on your comments. You then say things like, it makes me look stupid or that it is disingenious or whatever to simply dismiss my comment, that others notice are accurate observations.
Then, with your lack of a valid reply, you just reiterate my views and make yourself look stupid and my point more accurate. That is of course unless you feel everyone reading here agrees with your point of view and doesn't see the invalidity of your comments, ridiculous and overly exaggerated analogies and double standards.
You are almost as bad as when JD points out a flaw in Obama or his policies,everyone knows JD is bitter about Obama and is hell bent on proposing his personal bias instead of reality and it detracts from what he is saying, however he doesn't seem to see it himself. (sorry for dragging you into it JD).
Your constant double standards and extreme exaggerations that you use to support your claims, actually detract from what COULD have been a valid observation that desrves consideration. Instead, you turn it into a ridiculously exaggerated blast against total control on the Borg ship and remove any credibility from it.
by tonythetiger
[i]We need affordable healthcare for everyone in this country and it's going to cost us.[/i]
by av .
One day, they will take it right out of your pay via higher taxes. Mandatory. Thats how its going to cost us.
Now for the devil that we know. Private insurance. Every year your health insurance premiums go up 10-15% on average. People with insurance pay in their premiums to provide some kind of coverage for the 47 million people with no insurance. We pay for the illegals too. Insurance companies have benefited for years through the anti-trust exemption that allows them to fix prices.
I can't decide which way I will pay more, but I know I'm going to be paying.
AV
by tonythetiger
Currently, I can choose not to be insured, or not to be insured as much as some else thinks I should be. Why is it anybody else's business.
I'll say it here and now. If I cannot afford my medical expenses, I am WILLING to accept the consequences of not having them.
by oz_media
I promise you that the only product assembled at the RBH factory in Utah is Signature series, I've been there, I know the builders. They don't have the space nor manpower to handle the production numbers of the other models.
The benefit of RBH though is that they don't buy assembly line products. For example: q lot of other manufacturer's such as Polk, Klipsch, JBL etc. will se the same factory as other companies. Theu don't do the R&D themselves, very costly and they just 'create' a product based on what is available in that factory's bins, crossover components etc. They will often design one or two crossovers, from the same parts and use them for all models too.
In contrast, RBH was a desinger and builder before manufacturing. They actually spin their pwn aluminum cones in the Utah factory. They design their own crossovers and have th R&D department to do so for each model independently and even upgrade it over time to the point of near perfection.
They then send those plans and designs to their custom shop in China where they are assemled to meet extremely tight standards that RBH sets out, they don't make other products, juts EMP, RBH, Destination Audio and Status Acoustics (all RBH products). They are then shipped back to the US for distribution.
This allows for much greater R&D more time spent developing the correct components and assembly under much stricter quality control and factory standards than are found in north American factories.
And voila, damn nice speakers come out of it.
Glad you are happy, now get some real critical listening down, shut down tone controls (flat settings) and EQ', turn off any effects, as I assume you already do. If you have the option, play with the large and smal front speaker settings, you'll probably find that a large speaker setting sounds best.
by oz_media
How can you flip flop that way? It boggles the mind really.
As me not understanding how some people fall on hard times, I have used that exact same argument here many times (especially regarding the reasons I see a need for welfare support) and people just don't get it.
So if the government offers cost effective insurance plans, you see that as simply giving free medical to people out of your pocket, and you thus assume all people collecting such a plan would also be people who simply decide not to work and collect your dime instead. What a moron!
There are MANY people "making the effort and just not making ends meet" that simply cannot afford insurance premiums, perhaps they are in entry level jobs or have had cuts at work and don't get a partial subsidy from the employer, that is another part of the plan is to make offering such support more affordable for smaller businesses.
In your world there is only YOU and everyone else should be just like YOU. People who are trying to BE you are worthy of support.
But what if a person is working full time, has a mortgage, has children a car and everything else that any hard working person could have, however they can't afford such high premiums because they don't get partial support from an employer? NOW they have options that were not available before.
What about the poorer neighourhoods where employers pay very little for people to do menial jobs and THEY can't afford nor get benefits from the employer? they work just as hard if not harder than you, they pay taxes, they raise families and they get screwed with premiums? I suppose THEY qualify in your mind.
So where's the line of division?
Anyone SHOULD be able to afford insurance if they are actively working or looking for work and all others should not? Kind of like welfare? But you don't like welfare either as there are people that scam the system, just as they will medical.
So in essence, a flawless and perfect system would be okay but one that can be challenged or circumvented should not be put into action. Unfortunately ANY system is beaten and exploited, and usually the only people that added restraint stops are the people who are actually the ones who need and deserve such support.
Sorry JD, there ARE no perfect systems, but that doesn't mean they have to ditch them all because some punk will get stitches and fractions of a cent come out of your tax dollars.
As for me being a dick to everyone and not helping those around me, f**k your fat hole you ignorant c**t.
I'm very confident that I do more to help people in a week than you do in a year.
Last week I got together with a friend and we went to three different local coffee bars that sell cakes, sandwiches and muffins. We found out they are throwing away food everyday, they can't give it to the food bank because it's perishable. So we took it upon ourselves to take the unsold products, twice a week to Main & Hastings (core of the drug addicted and homeless in Vancouver) and hand them out. they don't earn, they don't work, they are addicted to drugs or alcohol, once had families and have children, once were upstanding citizens and just fell on hard times that got worse to the point where the world gives up on them. THEY STILL DESERVE TO EAT, even though they don't fit your criteria of who needs help.
Will you also be spending thanksgiving with your family or will you be at the homeless shelters serving them their Thanksgiving dinner? In other words, throw some money their way and let them take care of their own needs. You do realize that volounteer help is needed more than money with most such organizations.
When was the last time you and your family decided to participate in giving someone else Christmas? Buy and decorate a tree for them, take them dinner and presents, spend Christmas day with them? There's more to it than donating money.
When was the last time you collected all of your old jackets and blankets and went to the streets to hand them out to people who look cold? Have you walked down an alley littered with drunks and junkies to help the few that are in need of warmth, a cup of coffee or a hot meal?
Don't even TRY implying I don't reach out others around me all the time, it's not an annual event it's a commitment to helping people. I don't qualify people to see if they deserve my help, everyone is a human that had a mother and father, everyone deserves help where help can e provided.
I don't believe you actually had the audacity to even suggest that, you ignorant f**k.
by delbertpgh
Biden's problem is that he can easily come up with good-sense practical-sounding ideas, which tend to be at odds with each other (or with the president) from one day to the next. Joe does like to hear himself talk.
He was actually my first choice for prez.
I think I'm happier with Obama, but I am starting to think that Hillary would have been best of all. However, unless Obama gets lung cancer and has to drop out of the 2012 race, we're not likely to see Hillary make the push again.
by jck
You're so against them, jd.
Unless of course, you deem them okay.
When I had a mother in the hospital sick and lived on $20 for a month, did I get anyone giving me money? gas card? free trip to the salon? gift certificate for a bottle of scotch?
Nope.
The most I got was crashing at a buddy's house or a cup of coffee if they were having one, or one of mom's co workers would bring me a cake (just what my ass needed).
If a cop doesn't pull you over for 5mph but will for 25mph over...is going 5mph over not breaking the speed limit law?
Taking a handout, whether from a food pantry, a neighbor, the US Dept of Agriculture cheese bank, etc., is a handout...no matter what its source.
My mother and father called taking things from others without absolute need or doing something for it "mooching".
Saddest thing is though, I have a family in my neighborhood.
The one son comes over to bum money and stuff. I finally quit answering the door. I figure if he can get off his butt to come beg, he can take and put a nail on a broomstick and get a trash sack and go around and pick up aluminum cans and cash them in.
I tried to talk to him, and tell him he could do odd jobs. Guess it didn't sink in.
You probably thought I would say it's his right to get handouts, huh?
Welp, you're wrong. Never ever said welfare (in its current form) was right. Never said begging was right. I said they have their times they're needed, but never said they were right.
You just assume because I voted for Obama that I'm some bleeding heart extremist.
Well, I bleed for some people. But, I'm not extreme.
I just don't let a bunch of weenies in a "think tank" or "party" tell me what my value set should be.
I'm my own person...at least, til I get married. Then, the wife will tell me how to behave. :^0
by jdclyde
the point was that the whole focus for what the current administration is doing is on the wrong target in the first place.
You are talking about people getting the care they need, but CARE is NOT part of the plans they are trying to hush through.
THAT is where a lot of us have a big problem, of throwing a lot of feel-good money at a problem, knowing full well they are not addressing the real issues.
by oz_media
I know you are on about the level of care,m which most Americans seem to feel is the est care in the world.
YOu seem to e missing teh point though, if care is increased, cost is increased, private premiums are increased, fewer people can afford such care than today.
Step 1: Make CARE of any sort, affordable.
Step 2: Increase the level of care available for those people.
Who cares how excellent care is if you can't access it?
by oz_media
But they are too hard to divide to consider ditching programs that many are worthy of receiving.
There will always be welfare scammers, there will always be a majorty of welfare recipients who actually warrant collecting it.
There will always be people who scam permanent disabilities and soak insurance companies, then there are the majority that are truly permanently disabled and warrant such support.
People even scam food banks when they don't need to, that doesn't mean we should do without food banks.
Just because peopel can and will scam ANY system designed, it doesn't mean such systems are bad or have failed us. There HAs to be some leniency offered in such systems of else people with valid reasons may be excluded from benefits. Those tiny openings and allowances are easily exploited.
If we tighten them down, as they trie dwith wlefare here in the late 80's, we end up cutting off people who are really in need and warrant such support, meanwhile the ausers just continue to abuse the system.
All that happened here was people who are valid recipients were cut off and the scammers kept getting checks.
So yes, lets take care of those in need, lets help the people who really deserve ou support, but unfortunately, handouts like that DO and always will e handed out to people who don't warrant such support. It's a small and insigificant sacrifice in my eyes, in order to see those worthy of such support get support.
I would love to see all the leeches get cut off and sent to work, I would like nothing mroe than to see only those who deserve a helping hand get a helping hand. BBut then there is reality, and the two just don't mix.
by jck
According to some folks:
If care increased, then parts of the cost for it should go down.
At least, some people think that as demand goes up and more needs to be produced that manufacturers and suppliers will always lower their prices to match.
I'd like to be smoking the pipe they're on. As the banks got money cheaper and cheaper from the Fed during the housing boom here, you didn't see the banks dropping their rates to match.
Capitalism impedes fair practice of business.
by jck
[i]But they are too hard to divide to consider ditching programs that many are worthy of receiving.
There will always be welfare scammers, there will always be a majorty of welfare recipients who actually warrant collecting it.[/i]
Yeah. Thing is, I saw a system that Unisys made and San Diego county CA was using back in 1995...it used a card with a 2D barcode, which stored info on the card holder, including a fingerprint ID.
They put the card reader and fingerprint reader in grocery stores. Your chance to be able to scam the tech? 1 in 1.5B.
That's what we need to implement with the US welfare program. Eliminate foodstamps, and put it on a card that requires the fingerprint of the person whose card it is.
[i]There will always be people who scam permanent disabilities and soak insurance companies, then there are the majority that are truly permanently disabled and warrant such support.[/i]
Yeah. I knew guys riding the system of "severely disabled" in college, then when they got the free grad degree done, they went and had a surgery and had it fixed and live normally now.
Then I knew people who were really disabled in school, who needed special equipment but were waiting on it because of budget shortfalls...cause...people who didn't really need the help were milking the system.
Again, go figure.
[i]People even scam food banks when they don't need to, that doesn't mean we should do without food banks.
Just because peopel can and will scam ANY system designed, it doesn't mean such systems are bad or have failed us. There HAs to be some leniency offered in such systems of else people with valid reasons may be excluded from benefits. Those tiny openings and allowances are easily exploited.
If we tighten them down, as they trie dwith wlefare here in the late 80's, we end up cutting off people who are really in need and warrant such support, meanwhile the ausers just continue to abuse the system.
All that happened here was people who are valid recipients were cut off and the scammers kept getting checks.
So yes, lets take care of those in need, lets help the people who really deserve ou support, but unfortunately, handouts like that DO and always will e handed out to people who don't warrant such support. It's a small and insigificant sacrifice in my eyes, in order to see those worthy of such support get support.
I would love to see all the leeches get cut off and sent to work, I would like nothing mroe than to see only those who deserve a helping hand get a helping hand. BBut then there is reality, and the two just don't mix.[/i]
Yeah...you can never get rid of the idiots in the world. Genetics allows for deficiencies to arise just as superior traits.
Too bad I can't figure out how to eliminate losers. Then, I could finally be considered a bottom feeder when all the perfect people were around me. :^0
by oz_media
Of course they will get free medical, so will the con artists and other bottom feeding scammers, always have, always will regardless of program.
Now lets ocnsider the lower middle class, the working peple who just arely make enough to pay rent, get some food, take a bus to work etc. They often work jos where sch subsidy is not available to them.
If THEY could afford insurance, THEY would be paying into the pool too and would also be helping to cover costs of the scammers that you already cover yourself.
Right now, they are the ones who simply don't go to a doctor, suffer unnecesary pain and still go to work because they have no choice, no insurance plan, no way out.
Again there will ALWAYS be scammers, there always has been since the dawn of time, there always will be until the end of time.
You don't seem to pick your battles too wisely, you focus your energy on something that simply cannot be stopped in a humane society.
It's like anythign else, don't focus on the trash and get on with it.
At work, there are people who ride others coattails, they don't EARN promotion ut they often get i anyway. Are they worth focusing yoru energy on, bitching in the staff room about, whining around the water cooler? OF course not, they will sink sooner or later, just keep your head down, work with the workers and the job gets done. All you end up doing is making yoruself look bad for focusing on them instead of just doing your job and letting the company weed them out in due course. They will never last too long, they always get seen for who they are and let go. Does that mean teh company will never hire another slacker? Of course not but that's for them to sory out, not you.
In the case of government scams it all catches up to them in the end and they will have one hell of a time getting out of it and getting ahead with their lives. Let's say the DO make it in life, get married, start a family. Welfare then catches yo to them, unemployment inurance finds otu they scammed extra checks and puts a hefty fine on them so they have to wait for months before qualifying for UI again.
Now, with a wife and children and a decent job, that person can't get ahead ecause of all the past behind them. They can't get a nortgage because they are repaying Welfare costs from 10 years gao, they lose their job and can't collect UI because they have HUGE fines that UI is going to recover efore issuing a check.
Some peopel call it karma, it's just the way such systems work, they may take a while but they do catch up and ususally at the most unopportune time.
by jdclyde
I will not support one more bandaide on the open festering wounds cause by our politicians, and then made worse by our politicians.
Remove the restrictions that keep insurance companies from competing across state lines. I have yet to hear a reasonable reason why that is in place.
Tort reform, never happen with lawyers in charge of these "reforms".
and of course the thing that will never happen, is Obama and his group offering to go on the same plan they are trying to rush down our throats.
Good intentions and talking points will not improve health care or access to it, in the USA.
by oz_media
I actually started a thread about how I gave McCain credit too. Both him and Obama were fair candidates for each party, far better choices than have been seen in a long while.
I had doubts about Obama as well as McCain, but say that they both had merits.
I think I had concluded that, IF I was American, I'd have voted for McCain based on his internal policy campaign. As a non-American, I supported Obama due to his campaigning on global affairs.
What I thought a bit odd was the running mates, I saw Palin as more toward Obama's side and Biden as more republican. However THAT was also a good play on the part of the parties too, both seemed to offer a little more middle ground to their respective party and that would sway the voters still on the fence, one way or the other.
I've watched quite a few US presidential elections and the campaigns that lead to them and must tell you that this was one of my favorite, a real head scratcher at times too. But i think Palin blew it, the old age smear campaign against McCain was effective and yet the racial slurs and religious attacks on Obama just made him look even better to his part followers as THEY are the people that really don't care about race and religion. All it did was make republicans look bad in the process.
McCain and Biden would have been interesting to see together, Obama and anyone else but Palin would have been interesting to see too.
by oz_media
Gotta love how this happens with us lot.
[b]FOODSTAMPS[/b]
First of all, Foodstamps, not used here. Here they issue a check for your rent, food, bus fare, etc. Between $550.00 and just under $600.00 a month (think of the cost of living in Vancouver and suburbs). And we're supposed to have the highest welfare rates in the country.
While a nice, yet very expensive, idea, ID cards and fingerprint readers will not stop such scams though.
Even with food stamps, the scam isn't necessarilty from people selling stamps to others, it's the people APPLYING for the support that are scamming it, it's VERY easy. So even with a card and fngerprint system, if they are the authorized recipient there's no way of stopping them. The problem lies in the office where they are applying and beigng accepted for support to egin with. Once again though, if you tighten those restrictions too much, the poeple who really DO need welfare won't be able to get it and scammers will just better their scams and still get away with it. The card and fingerprint are irrelevant if you are scamming to get that card to begin with.
I've seen guys work two jobs, under the table and collect unemployment AND welfare at the same time, in addition to two paying jobs. THAT'S a scam.
[b]ID CARDS AND BIOMETRICS, THE HOPELESSNESS[/b]
The card ID does help reduce the number of such stamps that are actually sold, but even then they can presell the purchases, go and buy the stuff for the recipient and sell the merchandise to them at a cut price, instead of the stamps.
I have known guys that do that with electronics, instead of stealing CD players and DVD's then looking for a fence that may not want them, they just took orders from the end users and then stole presold electronics for them instead. Think of cutting out the middle man, steaking direct for the end user.
While a nice idea, and an expensive one at that (I used to sell such ID and access control technology too) the card ID does nothing to stop the scams it just changes the scams.
[b]DISABILITIES[/b]
Ow, my back hurts so bad I can't walk. While there are CAT scans and MRI's to confirm spinal misalignment, they usually cannot determine the degree of pain or disability someone will suffer. So any stiff back, or a night of sleeping in an odd position, will show up on an MRI or CAT scan as a spinal injury, which is generally very painful and doctors rely on the patient to tell them if thy can continue to work or not. Mental deficiencies, such as depression adn being bipolar are also VERy easily fakes and thus the disaility continues, problems such as acute sciatica is a common scam too. These people scam pain or mental dosease that cannot be proven either way. (just look how many perfectly sane people get off of murder and robbery charge sdue to mental disorders. This all adds up to people in REAL need not getting the level of support they need.
The bottom line here is that neither of these programs, disability and welfare, have any effect on subsidizing health insurance costs. It is just pople who are bitter about such scams that feel that if they offer insrance support that there will be another avenue for scamming. Insurance scams are there already, it just makes it available to more valid recipients too.
[b]STEM CELL RESEARCH[/b]:
If we could create a perfect world full of perfect poeple, we wouldn't have such issues, we wouldn't need medical at all either. If we could follow Hitler's lead, we'd all be happy. :)
I think this is the fear that some people have towards stem cell reearch, that cloning is around the corner. However, so is appendage regeneration for inured workers. If someone loses a few fingers or toes and loses their union job and is forced to collect permanent disability checks, then stem cell research could see their appendages replaced and them back at work, paying taxes and off of the taxpayers back.
Fewer sick or deformed children means a healthier future workforce, fewer people in need.
People with spinal injuries may find relief also, getting THEM back to work and paying into the giant tax hole too.
[b]CONCLUSIONS[/b]
See the difference between my thought process and the thought process of those who fear giving something for nothing, is that you cannot possibly avoid poeple scamming ANY system and getting something for nothing.
However if you look at the OTHER side of the equation, the positives generally far ourweigh the negatives. Okay, so every system gets scammed, so lets see what benefits each system brings instead and focus on the reality that it holds for the future, not how it may effect my pocketbook in the short term, to the effect of fractions of a cent at that.
by oz_media
To each his own, if you are in my face and want me to help you with something, you'd better speak English, or you are SOL.
If I am in Quebec City and need directions, I better find an English speaking person or else I fumble through with a combination of Parisienne French I learned in Europe, Canadian French I learned here etc. If I end up at the gay bathhouse, that's my issue.
To each his own is how I see it, you don't have to speak to me or in my language, but neither do I. Either way it is my or their personal loss in such situations, that's all.
In Vancouver between East Indian, Punjabi, Chinese, Vietnamese, Korean, Thai, Japanese, Persian etc. There just no hope for a universal language anymore. We just all live together and speak what little we can when we are not fluent.
In that same sense though, due to such cultural exposure, food is more interesting and authentic instead of Canadianized. My son can understand SOME (a little, Hindi) as do I. I understand SOME Mandarin and can actually hold a VERY basic conversation in Chinglish. I have spoken to Vietnamese men and women (mainly at the race track) who, through very broken English, have told me their stories of how they ended up here. Some having parents slain in front of them as children as they fled for their lives.
It really exposes you and helps you to understand the world and the cultures around you. I think it has made me a more accepting person, a more understanding person and a much more AWARE person as a result.
But ow is it you say dat dere,.... Tabernac! LOL ;)
by delbertpgh
by oz_media
They spent time focusing on the fact that he probably wouldn't last a whole term, and two would be a real stretch. Which would of course make Palin president; yes, I cringe at that thought.
It was also brought up here a few times when it was being pushed through the various media outlets. You have to remember also, this it the USA and people don't live as long in America, despite having what is purported to be the world's best health care system. :D
by jdclyde
by oz_media
Capitalism impedes fair business.
There, about as useful and correct as your irrelevant slagging.
by oz_media
States have different laws, states have differen governors, think of the USA as you see the European Union, a collective with a similar mindset but very different participants.
Go to your desert island and get over the rest of teh world choosing to be governed already.
Your worse than Tony, yuo want government only of what you personally deem worthy of governing. What a mental midget.
Lower cost alternatives will indeed improve access ot health care for millions of americans. D
oesn't directly benefit you? Tough sh*t, think yourself lucky and move on to the next thing Obama says he'll do.
Just take anything he says, it doesn't matter what, and create an argument for it, you do it anyway.
Give up on flogging this dead horse and try killing a new one.
by av .
I don't feel sorry for private insurance companies. Yes, they operate under laws, but the laws have always been in their favor, especially the anti-trust laws. They've been fixing their own prices for years. Its about time they had a comeuppance.
A public option and an end to the anti-trust exemption that protects them, would force insurance companies to compete. Too bad if they have to compete against the government. It might be the only way to force them to become more competitively priced. Otherwise, its business as usual. Prices go up 10 to 15% every year and I pay more and more for less. Denial of coverage for pre-existing conditions. I could go on forever. Its obscene. A couple of years ago I had a $5000 MRI. I can't imagine what it costs now.
I wouldn't like government involvement in other industries, but its a different story with healthcare. If 47 million people don't pay for it right now and still use the services, then who do you think is footing the bill? Not them. Its the rest of us with insurance.
Everyone should pay. We all use it and we all need it.
AV
by jck
Who made the businessmen and businesswomen running banks loan money out to people they *knew* couldn't pay?
Who made the businessmen and businesswomen running banks give their loan officers directives to increase loans out?
Who made the businessmen and businesswomen running banks push their people to increase quotas of loans given?
NOTHING in the law said they had to put out a number of loans. It said they had to help...not give out stupid loans.
It was the collective greed in the capitalistic minds of bank management who caused them to see the bonus clauses in their contracts that made them do stupid things WE had to bail out...not government law, rule, regulation or oversight.
THEY were greedy. They screwed our country.
No matter how you slice it, capitalism-fed greed caused it. Pure and simple.
Just like the greed of the autoworkers unions broke the auto industry when times got tough.
Capitalism is capitalism, whether it's a person, union, management, or whomever, trying to siphon off all the money they can rather than reinvest it into their industry.
Deny that if you can.
The only thing the government didn't do right is throw all the bastards in jail.
by jck
You can't convince people like jd and Max that, in their use of company paid country club memberships and company paid vacations and company paid lunches, that corporate management work together to control rates and force increases in profits by reducing coverage and increasing policy premiums.
You are right though in what you said. But convincing those who trust business to do right are placing all their eggs in the egg basket that the wolves in business have been raiding for decades.
by jck
There was no mention of anything but Utah on the box.
I'll look at the speakers.
by jck
[i]Remove the restrictions that keep insurance companies from competing across state lines. I have yet to hear a reasonable reason why that is in place.[/i]
I live in Florida.
I was sold a policy from BCBS-Michigan.
There is no restriction placed in all states.
Blame your own damn MI politicians. If you can't get out of state insurance, it's not anyone else's fault...including the federal government.
That block you claim exists in our country at a national level is a falsehood.
Nuff said.
by jck
I'm proof. I had a Blue Cross Blue Shield-Michigan policy for 2.5 years living in Florida.
jdclyde is just spouting the lies of the idiots he listens to.
If anyone wants proof, I'll find my check stubs and provide the 88.00-some per week I was paying to BCBS-MI from July 2002 to December 2004.
He's full of it, but is just too ignorant of the facts to realize it.
by av .
Anyone that thinks there is a free ride with healthcare is kidding themselves. Everyone will pay, not just the rich. Thats for sure.
Maybe the cultists of Obama will willingly step up to the plate and pay like the rest of us have for many years supporting the uninsured. I'm not holding my breath, but it could be mandated that they pay in the future.
AV
by jdclyde
but the supporters are not honest enough to admit what you just said.
Of course, if I had said it, jck and a few others would be all sniveling about it.... :)
There is very little honest discussion going on in this "discussion". Just people attacking others because they don't agree with them.
And no, people do NOT have a "right" to free healthcare or free health insurance.
Discussed the demographics of "The Enterprise" just this afternoon offline with a TR person.
Upshot of that is, so far, as holder of an EIN, there is in my circumstance outside The Enterprise another repercussion: nobody gets hired. Forget it.
So far, they are talking about 50 or more employees. That lets me out. Screw them if it eventually doesn't. Nobody gets hired.
I won't, but others will, think of drawing more from the illegal pool.
Other visions swim in my head. How about abolishing all minimum-wage statutes? Can we afford that, given what passes now, and surely worse to come?
This thing spreads to everything.
by tonythetiger
between "can't" and "won't". There's also a difference between misfortune, laziness, and stupidity.
I know that you know this, so your comments aren't based on ignorance. That leaves disingenuousness.
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
Indeed it does... Did you see what credit card companies are doing... Adding fees for people who use credit responsibly... to make up for the government intrusion into rules for people who don't.
Few see the pattern... The government is systematically making people less responsible for their weakness or stupidity... the result will be an increase in both.
by jdclyde
Minimum wage? Would you believe there are people that still think it helps instead of hurts? People that FEEL something is or isn't FAIR.
Minimum wage is the greatest assault on Middle class America. They do not see the increase in wages, but they DO see the increase in COSTS of everything they purchase. THEIR income is worth less, closing the gap between low income and middle income.
With the last feel-good raise of the minimum wage, did that make it so I can walk into a burger joint and make a living? Friggen hardly.
Thanks Democrats for undermining the middle class, again.
by jck
by jck
[i]Few see the pattern... The government is systematically making people less responsible for their weakness or stupidity... the result will be an increase in both.[/i]
And, it's been happening long before Obama even went to college.
If I remember correctly, FICO became prevalent during Reagan.
Personally, I've started moving my money out of American banks and into overseas investments.
I can't trust American companies to do what's right, or the US government to pass laws to keep them honest.
by oz_media
All RBH boxes except Signature Series were changed to say Made in China. Sales plumetted instantly. I work with a few retailers from various parts of the Orient, they can't sell a Chinese made product to Oriental customers, they just won't buy anything Chinese.
With EMP designed for the online market segment, they have to appeal to an even wider audience, so it's possible they wiggle around a way of tagging them as being from Utah. I have a pair of their 35" on-wall models in the sounds room, they offered us a good deal on a HUGE shipment when they cleared them out. We never took them up on it due to the large number we needed to commit to. They are okay sounding, not their best product by any means, but the tag on them clearly states made in China.
Due to needing to buy a lot of them in order to get a good price and havign RBH in the soundroom, we cannot sell them so we just have the one pair here. A distributor agreement states you cannot sell other RBH made products with them, nor can I sell them and add an RBH sub in the package (they do need a sub).
These are not the same speakers you got at all, not even close.
Yours are all but RBH, same crossovers and even use the TK series drivers, that's why they were such an exceptional deal. EMP's, as a brand, are usually rather low end.
by jck
Well, there are people I would choose not to help that others would.
You might think one person deserves help, and I might not.
How do we decide who gets the help? Vote on every person?
My solution to all this was simple: revamp welfare. Make it WorkFare. You turn down flipping burgers or mopping floors to earn your check? You get dropped. You starve. You get no insurance coverage. Good luck, goodbye and God bless.
My parents never took a hand-out, and they both grew up poor as hell. Mom lived in a house with a dirt floor and washed other peoples' clothes. Not many people even on welfare know that feeling nowadays.
Of course nowadays, working your way up through hard work isn't a given. You also have to contend with the boss' friend's relatives and his kids' significant others too.
That's why I keep my options open. My loyalty is first and foremost to me anymore, and no one else because no one else does anything in my best interest anymore.
by oz_media
That's the entire problem. We have no way of really determining hwo is worthy and who isn't, not in a timely and accurate fashion anyway. With thousans of recipients per office, a general weeding is about all they can do without refusing support to many of those in real need in the process. In fact it's the scammers that will get away with it and the real needy will be punted out of the system for not creating a good enough con game.
they did it here, they tried to tighten their grip and the result was people started turning up in the newspaper dead. People in real need were left behind but the welfare scammers had no problems getting checks.
There had to be some allowance in teh system so that people who actually need help get help. Due ot that, others will abuse the system. ANY systsem EVER designed for ANY purpose is just as easily beaten.
Even contests are scammed out in the same way, they write ruls but they can' te so tight as to make it impossible to qualify, thus people scam contests and win unfairly.
It's a fact of life, it's like arguing about breathing.
No system will be completely secure and if it is it will not see to all those who actually need the system in place.
by jdclyde
I never had a right to it.
I GOT it, but that isn't the same thing as having a RIGHT to it.
Just like people don't have a RIGHT to food stamps, but still get it when in need. That is what compassionate people do, they help those in need, despite knowing there will be those that will abuse any system they can for their own gain.
People today don't realize just how few things in life they actually have a RIGHT to, vs the ability to get if they work for it or are helped by others in a position to help.
I know, you are just looking to argue, so why am I trying to be logical with you?
by jck
You had the personal right to accept what was offered.
You had the legal right to get it because you qualified under the program's guidelines.
You had the individual right to apply for and collect it.
In every way, you had every right.
You even had the right to refuse it.
My question is this:
If you needed it and got it and used it, then who is to say your use was any more right than anyone else to use it?
Sure, I've known people who didn't do squat. Their wives lay on their backs and push out kids. They go sit on the post office steps the first day of every month waiting for that check. Then, they go spend it on booze or cigarettes.
But, who's to say they can't live homeless and be drunk if that's their preferred lifestyle?
As I've said over and over. If we just made welfare into workfare, it would solve about 1/3 of America's issues including labor shortages, unemployment, and tax deficits.
by oz_media
Do you HONESTLY think that I advocate losers and scammer collecting welfare?
DO you HONESTLY think I advocate anyone getting something they don't deserve?
Do you HONESTLY think I am someone who hasn't grown up learning that you get NOTHING you haven't rightly earned?
Fact of the matter is there is no effective way, beyond measures already taken, to ensure that people who need help are separated from those who simply want handouts.
In order for any system to see to the really needy, the really not needy get through too; it's life, deal with it or watch even more people go without and suffer than you do today.
Your theory is based on an ideal, and ideal which does not exist.
Max once said that if people took care of their own, there would be no problems. However it's people who DON'T have people of their own to help out that make up the majority of such benefit recipients.
Genuine, real, hard poverty, exists in your country too. In fact there are more valid recipients than invalid. It's just that KNOWING some people scam checks makes it so hard for people to accept that most are warranted and actually NEED such help.
How many people living on the bottom do you know? I mean homeless or all but homeless, living in small rental rooms in skid row? How many people do you know that were once upstanding high paid employees of national companies that are now living on skid row and addicted to intravenous drugs? It happens FAST, it happens easy, it happens constantly.
Once you realize what lack of programs there are to help such people get back on the straight and narrow, get their lives back together and become part of a functioning society again, you might just have a tiny hint of an idea of the real problem.
We piss away so much tax money on failed rehabilitation programs that don't see it through properly, landlords that help people scam welfare so that the so called residents can buy crack it's ridiculous.
Landlords will offer rent receipts to junkies saying they pay $400.00 month for a room on skid row. The landlord gets a check sent directly from the government to cover the guys rent each month, meanwhile he is living in the alley (not the landlords scuzzhole of a building) the landlord gives him 50% of his check as cash and the guy ends up using it to buy drugs.
We have a large building, ex-department store, in Vancouver (right in skid row now) where the people of Vancouver had campaigned for it to be converted into affordable housing, it stayed dormant for over 10 years until a private development company finally bought it and said they will be offering what they consider affordable housing. By "affordable" housing they meant BUYING a suite for less than $100,000.00, yeah I'll start collecting my pop bottles right away.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Woodward's_building
We get REAL poverty here in Vancouver, REAL hardship, people with NOTHING at all, no reason to live except the determination to at least exist for a few more years if possible.
There are no real pictures that show the bad parts of skid row, this picture shows a tent city. Of course in the core fo skid row, tents are not allowed so it is shopping cart road instead. The stench of feces and urine carries into gastown (one of Vancouver's most famous tourist stops) just one block to the North.
http://farm1.static.flickr.com/92/282585428_7f15e3d467.jpg
This oe is right beside the old Woodwards uilding, of course the photos shown on their website are photoshopped very well.
http://www.wendellphillips.com/images/vancouver/drugs.jpg
Until you've seen it, you just can't possibly fathom how many people with real needs go unseen to. And how do you determine those people from con artists who live in teh same area, don't work and sell drugs for a living?
The problem is far worse than these much older photos show, the shopping carts run thick from store to streetside now, all the way down East Hastings, about 5 blocks, both sides of the street.
http://nimg.sulekha.com/Sports/original700/canada-vancouver-homeless-2009-9-21-21-10-3.jpg
The Vancouver Olympic scomittee has decided to spend a few million on banners to place on light posts so that it destracts tourists form looking at the streets, they are also hiring actors, to look like normal folks walking down the street in skid row to detract from the reality of it.
No, welfare is a rip off, nobody needs welfare, all these poeple could have been getting help from those nearer to them.
Give your head a shake and get a grasp on reality for once.
by tonythetiger
[i]Well, there are people I would choose not to help[/i]
Why would that be?
[i]You might think one person deserves help, and I might not.[/i]
I'm not telling you how to spend YOUR money. Help whoever you want. I'll do the same.
by jdclyde
Don't confuse [b]Ability[/b] with [b]rights.[/b]
If it is not in the Bill of Rights, it isn't a RIGHT.
A drivers license is NOT a Right, but you can still get one from the State.
And going on about welfare queens is not a topic I give a ratsass about discussing with you, as we both already agree about workfare. There is always trash along the road that needs to be picked up, or parks that need to be worked on.
by jck
how do we decide what to spend money on as a nation? Do we vote on everything? Does majority win? 2/3? 3/4 vote?
Seriously, this whole individual empowerment thing is unrealistic. You'd be caught up in more rhetoric and red-tape b/s deciding what highways to upgrade, and what runways need upgrade grants.
What you may find a "key issue" or "need", I might think is "poppycock" or "waste".
That's why we have representatives.
Anyways, you see community efforts and programs as collectivism and socialism.
I see your "freedoms and liberties" as separatist.
One of the things that made America great was that it was a melting pot, not a bunch of seperate pots on different burners.
by jck
[i]Don't confuse Ability with rights.[/i]
Don't confuse rights with choosing to do the right thing.
[i]If it is not in the Bill of Rights, it isn't a RIGHT.[/i]
Then show me in the Bill of Rights were it specifically states:
a) you have a right to conceive children
b) you have a right to breathe air
c) you have a right to eat
Please show me specific references.
[i]A drivers license is NOT a Right, but you can still get one from the State.[/i]
You can get arrested too by the state.
[i]And going on about welfare queens is not a topic I give a ratsass about discussing with you, as we both already agree about workfare. There is always trash along the road that needs to be picked up, or parks that need to be worked on.[/i]
Welfare queens? Actually, most of the people I knew on welfare were men. I was speaking of the ones who had wives that they let stay home and make babies while they went to the bar and drank or went to get their check every month or to the USDA office to get their food stuffs.
As for workfare...
Rest stop bathrooms to be cleaned.
Houses in Detroit to be renovated and sold for a profit.
Taring the roof on a building.
Sorting recyclables.
etc etc etc
Starvation is a big motivator to get people to work. I guarantee it gets them off their butt faster than anything.
by jck
by tonythetiger
[i] THere is no discerning who is worthy and who isn't. [/i]
I am perfectly capable of discerning such of people who ask me.
by tonythetiger
(sorry, missed it)
[i]"...secure the blessings of liberty..." I guess means the right to screw someone else over as long as a law hasn't been written against it?[/i]
Securing means protecting. If I am doing something to unjustly harm you, the government has the obligation to stop it. If I am doing something which interferes in your practicing your rights, they have the obligation to determine which person's right take precedence (for example, you have the right of free speech, but you do not have the right to trespass onto my property to exercise it).
[i]Of course back then, "...establish justice, ensure domestic tranquility..." included public hangings.[/i]
Sure cut down on serial crimes :)
[i]Besides that, Tony. If this whole thing cuts $829B out of the total federal spending for medical over a 10 year period, isn't that really gonna make you happy?[/i]
Trouble is, you believe that...
by oz_media
You don't.
Either way, who is correct? nobody of course.
So how can you be so firm in your assertions? belief.
How can others be so firm in their own assertions? Belief.
Kinda like religion, shall we debate that farcical mess of science stepping on folklore now?
by tonythetiger
[i]And, it's been happening long before Obama even went to college.
[/i]
even before he was born! Say, about the time the Federal Reserve and the income tax were created...
by av .
Its a very contentious issue, but party lines aside, no one can deny that we are in deep ship when it comes to healthcare and something has to be done.
Obama promised to reform healthcare, but its easier said then done. Yes, the rich will pay, but the enormity of the cost will mostly be covered by all of us. How else could Obama say the plan is deficit neutral?
I hope its mandated that everyone pays for themselves. There should be subsidies for the poor, but I'm sure those will be exploited. Every system is always gamed by criminals.
There are no free rides when it comes to healthcare anymore. It costs too much and that money has to come from everyone. The free days of healthcare are coming to an end soon. They're unsustainable.
AV
by oz_media
I like the concept and in simple terms it is a great solution. However, what happens when people are forced to work to earn food stamps or a welfare check? Are they now being abused as employees? How about others who do similar tasks and are paid minimum wage? The only result will either being workfare rates would soar and everyone earning minimum wage would bitch because they had to earn their job or, much to Tony's delight, they would have to do away with minimum wage and people would be working for sweat shop wages and still restricted to the number of hours they could work. It would also effect unemployment insurance as fewer people would be able to secure full time positions, resulting in fewer qualified weeks and a shorter term, lower UI rate. It would most likely increase the level of low wage or workers below the poverty level even moreso than now. Sure, fewer would be out of work, but more would be living below the poverty line.
To every action there is an equal and opposite reaction. To think that a system of economics, which has been tweaked and developed over hundreds of years, would take a turn in a different direction, far more positive all around is just hard to see.
We'd ptobably end up with even more illegal Americans up here and entering European countries looking for work
With water and food pellets?
With respect to a warm place to stay, they and their children are on their own. 'Cepting, the kids get full medical, and, get taken away if they can't handle it.
by tonythetiger
you cannot prove, by any common principle of ethics, what obligates me to be beholden to anyone else except perhaps for the offspring I sire.
Suppose we're on the open seas in a wooden boat and it breaks apart. There is only one life jacket, only one of us can survive. What ethical principle decides which?
by oz_media
Nobody is in a wooden boat with one liferaft, such an extreme example is not worthy of debate as it doesn't reflect the situation at all, except in some distant principle.
The whole mentality is that people, fellow Americans, many who have fought wars for you, many who help still others even though they have nothing themselves, are in need and your CHOICE is to say that you have no obligation to help them. Nice one, Tony.
You treat your own citizens as people in third world countries, even worse most Americans have undying support and pride in how American taxes support the poorer nations and third world countries, yet refuse to have their tax dollars used to support their own.
Face it, due to some ridiculous ingrained rights that are the same in any free nation, Americans feel they shouldn't have to support others. People in other nations see the benefit and need to support their own, whether by birth or citizenship.
Why is it that soldiers feel they have a need to support and protect ALL Americans and yet citizens feel a need to only support their own and complain that their elected government spend tax dollars supporting others?
It is a very selfish and self centered mindset, no matter how you slice it.
Just because Americans are raised spewing their right and lkiberties, as if the same doesn't apply elsewhere, they feel unique in that they were promised that they don't have to help others unless they choose to, which they don't.
In other nations, people have the exact same freedoms and liberties as you do. However they CHOOSE to allow the government to spend their tax dollars helpign the nation's citizens as a whole, not as individuals.
The American mindset of MY money, MY choice has crippled your nation, justlook around you and see how high and mighty you really are these days. Even people in third world countries have more respect for their fellowman and help their neighbours more than Americans do.
What bragging rights do you have these days? None, nil, diddly squat. In fact you have become a paradigm of what a country should avoid becoming. No wonder more and more Americans are leaving due to disgust in The American Way.
by tonythetiger
[i]I hope its mandated that everyone pays for themselves. There should be subsidies for the poor, but I'm sure those will be exploited. Every system is always gamed by criminals.
p/i]
The ones that are too large to properly manage. Plus, there's no incentive for government to investigate fraud... it's not their money.
by tonythetiger
[i]Do you HONESTLY think that I advocate losers and scammer collecting welfare?
[/i]
you don't seem to be in favor of expending the effort to stop it, it wouldn't be a wild assumption.
by jdclyde
There are always "the rich" who should be paying for everyone else.
When that runs short, hell, let the damn smokers pay for it.
Lets be real scumbags and put a health tax on soda. What a grand idea?!?!
Oh, I know, lets sue hostess for making us eat that box of twinkies!
oh oh! Fast food! For making their fries too good, and the sodas so big!
There are plenty of villains around when you are a politician trying to buy influence.
Of course, at some time, they will run out of other peoples money to be generous with.
And then the people that just like to argue come along, and mix in with the Obama fan club and have a gleeful time of making sure their isn't an honest discussion.
Remember two years ago, Obama saying the reason the Clinton healthcare reform failed was because it was done in private, and HE thought it should have ALL been on cspan? Where is it now? Hiding in backroom deals, like usual.
by oz_media
And you think that will see that all the needy people are seen to?
Not bloody likely, Tony.
Again, those with friends and family to help out will get help.
Everyone else gets left in teh dark, no support whatsoever increasing and perpetuating the poverty level.
by oz_media
If you refuse everyone, your poverty, crime and drug levels soar.
There is no system that is foolproof, the system in place has flaws but it works as good or better as any system devised to date.
You like your safety and protection, however you don't support the foundations of it.
by oz_media
However it costs far mroe to push a person through court than they will ever get in foodstamps. They just cut them off, let them go rob you and your neighours and sell drugs for their money instead. the really incapable BUY drugs from those same people and rob you or others to pay for them. Your end up paying in the long run anyway, insurance costs soar, more police are needed, more people are in hospial on yoru dime getting their stomache pumped etc.
Poverty just doesn't go away when you stop supporting it, it grows to immense proportions and takes over your life in other ways that are far less desireable than the government taking a few cents from your taxes to pay for their support.
Your entire mindset on this suject is so skewed that it's nearly impossible to explain just how senseless and blind such a concept really is.
by oz_media
by notsochiguy
21% cut in payments? Assuming not every doctor bids adieu to Medicare patients, and assuming that most doctors don't care to operate with a loss, that revenue has to be made up from someplace else, right?
Seems like Congress is piling onto the problem they propose to rectify. I saw that in a cartoon once...someone tried to put out a fire with a bottle of vodka; having mistook it for water.
by jdclyde
the people that are not a part of that plan get charged extra to make up for the part the government is shorting them.
Just one more expense added to the evil private insurance.
Tell me more about "competition"?
by jck
[i]I like the concept and in simple terms it is a great solution.[/i]
Thanks.
[i] However, what happens when people are forced to work to earn food stamps or a welfare check?[/i]
Regular people are forced to earn a check. They would be doing the same thing that others who work for a living do.
They would, in essence, become contributing members of the citizenry.
[i] Are they now being abused as employees? [/i]
No more than anyone else who goes to a job to work.
[i]How about others who do similar tasks and are paid minimum wage? [/i]
If minimum wage falls below the poverty standard for which a person needs to gain public assistance (welfare), then so be it. People making minimum wage could get that assistance to supplement their income from work.
[i]The only result will either being workfare rates would soar and everyone earning minimum wage would bitch because they had to earn their job or, much to Tony's delight, they would have to do away with minimum wage and people would be working for sweat shop wages and still restricted to the number of hours they could work. [/i]
Actually if minimum wage was the wage at which poverty is not imminent, Welfare would no longer be just a free-ride system.
Workfare would be a system where you work, you earn monies, and the government provides a supplement to that income...if needed.
[i]It would also effect unemployment insurance as fewer people would be able to secure full time positions, resulting in fewer qualified weeks and a shorter term, lower UI rate. [/i]
Why would people be able to secure full time work? Are businesses going to exploit this if there's no benefit to them to do so?
If you took welfare, and integrated its constituency's unemployment to the something like America's Job Bank and filled the job with welfare people, you would have less unemployment, less welfare expense going out, and more employers would have the staffing they need.
[i]It would most likely increase the level of low wage or workers below the poverty level even moreso than now. Sure, fewer would be out of work, but more would be living below the poverty line.[/i]
Not if the minimum wage were elevated to a livable standard, much as it is like in Ireland. You don't see tip jars in pubs even in Dublin where the cost of living is 2-3 times what it is in Clonmel or Donegal.
And when you have decreased payouts in Welfare (which is in the $10Bs), you can lower those taxes that Tony and Max and jdclyde bitch about all the time.
That would serve to offset the amount in minimum wage increases that employers would incur.
[i]To every action there is an equal and opposite reaction. To think that a system of economics, which has been tweaked and developed over hundreds of years, would take a turn in a different direction, far more positive all around is just hard to see.[/i]
If you drive the truck the right direction, you'll get where you need to go. :)
[i]We'd ptobably end up with even more illegal Americans up here and entering European countries looking for work[/i]
Maybe you'd get the Mexicans we've been getting for 50 years. :p
by jck
[i]There are always "the rich" who should be paying for everyone else.[/i]
Funny. I pay taxes. I'm not rich.
[i]When that runs short, hell, let the damn smokers pay for it.[/i]
Your smokes costing you too much?
[i]Lets be real scumbags and put a health tax on soda. What a grand idea?!?![/i]
That's been proposed already. Sorry. Not original.
I know. How about a tax on scotch and golf! :p
[i]Oh, I know, lets sue hostess for making us eat that box of twinkies![/i]
That's been tried...oddly enough.
[i]oh oh! Fast food! For making their fries too good, and the sodas so big![/i]
Irish cities have already banned fast food from their populous after showing the detrimental health effects of high sodium, high fat meals.
[i]There are plenty of villains around when you are a politician trying to buy influence.[/i]
Actually, the special interests buy the influence. Politicians "peddle" it.
Get your misbehaviours right :p
[i]Of course, at some time, they will run out of other peoples money to be generous with.[/i]
Hm. Let's see.
Politicians are making the rich pay.
Most well-known politicians in Washington make over $1M a year.
They're taxing themselves then.
I'd say it's damn fair when you write legislation that's going to hit your own pocketbook...wouldn't you?
I see no favoritism there to themselves, their constituency, or their elite bretheren. They will be paying more taxes just like other wealthy people.
[i]And then the people that just like to argue come along, and mix in with the Obama fan club and have a gleeful time of making sure their isn't an honest discussion.[/i]
Kind of like people such as yourself who like to argue come along and stir the pot with aggressive rhetoric, inciteful tone, and acidic commentary?
[i]Remember two years ago, Obama saying the reason the Clinton healthcare reform failed was because it was done in private, and HE thought it should have ALL been on cspan? Where is it now? Hiding in backroom deals, like usual.[/i]
You mean when he said this:
[b][i]"But regardless of what combination of policies and proposals get us to this goal, we must reach it. We must act. And we must act boldly. As one health care advocate recently said, 'The most expensive course is to do nothing.' But it wasn't a liberal Democrat or union leader who said this.
It was the president of the very health industry association that funded the 'Harry and Louise' ads (Bill Gradison) designed to kill the Clinton health care plan in the early nineties."[/i][/b]
He was spot on about that. Republicans and Libertarians, in conjunction with the HIAA, set out to kill it point blank.
by jck
This is the United States of America.
Not the United States of Tony.
Whenever you become a country of 1 person, you can then decide what programs are and are not beneficial to your citizenry.
Until then, America is a country where people work together for a common good. Not just for that of one person, one religion, one sector, one race, or one income level.
by oz_media
Again I think in concept it is a great idea but I don't see it panning out quite as nicely as you do.
[i]"Regular people are forced to earn a check. They would be doing the same thing that others who work for a living do."[/i]
Okay so even for a rather menial, minimum wage job where high school education gets you in the door, it would now need to allow people without such qualifications.
Simply turn up at America's Job Bank and get a job that someone else had to work toward and earn based on their own merits.
Why would anyone at the entry level of the employment world, see to actually look for work? Just get fired, walk down the to the job bank and they get you another job. In essence it would make the government an unemployment "union", screw up and they get you another job. Late for work too many times, get fired, the job bank slaps you on the wrist ut has an obligation to find employment for you again.
[i]They would, in essence, become contributing members of the citizenry.[/i]
I must say that you have high hopes and forgive me for beign pessimistic ut I know people that have scammed welfare and UI I know peoplethat live below the poverty line that could very easily be working, they don't, they don't want to and they wouldn't ecome anything more than a burden passed on for a business to suffer with. It' sbad enough with senior union memers, "they can't touch me, I don't give a rats arse what I do, they can't fire me without giving me another job."
Raising minimum wage would e a greater deficit to the company, making them seek even more cheap, illegal labour and offshore workers.
Here for example, students are turning once reputale companies into sweatshops. There is little to no low income, full time work these days (Burger Thing, McCrapples etc.). They only offer part time shifts, pay less money and don't have to offer benefits etc. as they just hire P/T students that andare only oligated to offer limited benefits for part time workers. Adults workign in such places need to work three or four jobs in order to fill a full time card. adding more low end workers to teh mix would increase that need for even more part time jobs but not full time work. Poeple once workign full time would find hours cut back or they'd be fired to be replaced with lower cost, P/T employees, and would need to find another job to pay the bills.
[i]If minimum wage falls below the poverty standard for which a person needs to gain public assistance (welfare), then so be it. People making minimum wage could get that assistance to supplement their income from work.[/i]
But now you have created MORE people living on Part Time, minimum wages and more subsidy would be needed from the government. Not to mention tah added administrative costs, sick time, holiday pay, annual raises etc. for the government workers at the American Job Banks.
[i]Actually if minimum wage was the wage at which poverty is not imminent, Welfare would no longer be just a free-ride system.[/i]
Minimum wage goes up, companies outsource, we've all seen that first hand. If you can't hire someone for minimum wage, offer no benefits due to their working part time, they'll find workers somewhere else, wther illegals or imported workers.
[i]
"Workfare would be a system where you work, you earn monies, and the government provides a supplement to that income...if needed."[/i]
Why would anyone aspire to seek their own entry level job at minimum wage then? Just line up at the Job Bank and wait for an easy job, handed to you, and supplemented by the government.
[i]Why would people be able to secure full time work? Are businesses going to exploit this if there's no benefit to them to do so? [/i]
Employment standards for full time workers ensures greater benefits than for part time workers, such as holiday pay, termination notice, unemployment qualification and more. Companies prefer to hire part time workers ecause they have fewer obligations to them, can arrange spotty shift schedules to meet traffic demands. In Vancouver a couple of years back, unless you were qualified and experienced, a student or entry level worker could not find full time work. Today it's not much better, young workers work several jobs not just to make ends meet but because they need to work full time somehow. Employers WANT more part time workers in such menial roles, not full time workers.
if the minimum wage is raised, those qualified for job placement would whine that the subsidy needs to be raised as they are expected to work for less than minimum wage, which is not within employment standards regulations, thus costing the company AND government more money.
[iTony and Max and jdclyde bitch about all the time.[/i]
You now governments well enough to know that IF they saved money they woul dallocate it elsewhere, nobody sees a dime back. The government is in a deficit, always will be, and will always have an excuse to reallocate your tax dollars. That's why I don't care about social programs being paid for out of tax dollars, my taxes don't go up nor down, they get their money one way or another, we get nothing back if we save the government money.
And Tony, Max and JD would still bitch all the time anyway. (cheap pot shot, sorry guys ;) )
[i]"If you drive the truck the right direction, you'll get where you need to go."[/i]
But it will always wind up in the same place and never get farther ahead. (AHA!)
Mexicans are NEEDED in teh USA. Corn is your largets resource of all, more than oil, or any other product america produces. It is controlled y ONE company that has a patented seed taht all growers must use and is used in EVERYTHING and I mean "EVERYTHING". Probaly 80% of teh products you use, day in and day out have some form of corn product in them.
Companies hire Mexican corn farmers to keep costs down and appease Monsanto and fill their contracts on time. The government then goes around every few years and fines and returns them to Mexico, making room for new illegal immigrants to enter. Almost any product you touch in a day, was made from a product touched by an illegal worker, who works for low pay, ridiculous hours and in horrific conditions that any normal worker would not allow. Americans are cost driven consumers but want good pay for working. ut that's a different topic altogether.
Again jck, I see your vision and it's great, a Utopia even but we all know there is no Utopia and reality is very different from what we see in our dreams, no matter how much sense they make.
by oz_media
The reason such food items are not taxed is because they want to keep them cheaper than real food.
Consumers eat hybrid corn in everything they eat, that's why corn production fuels America (well a handful of corporations anyway) and fast food is cheaper than real food. They have you by the nuts and if everyone started eating healthier, cattle farms would suffer, corn production would suffer (feeds the cattle, since when did cows naturally eat corn?), and the major corporations that control most of America would suffer losses (heaven forid!).
When your labelling system was challenged and they wanted a list of health indgrediants added, as they do in Canada, listing saturated fats, calories etc on ALL food labels (and rightly they should), two massive corporations in teh US saw it paid to rest.
They don't WANT helthy Americans, they want yuo to pay less for crap than for real food and they WANT you to support eating garbage instead of healthy foods. It also in turn perpetuates the health industry, which ALSO relies on corn by-products for most drugs.
Face it, your government is out to make money, lots of it. If you actually think taht completely abolishign ANY services would return money to your pocket, think again.
You are far better off having the government spend your tax money back on society than sticking it in their pockets and paying off the handful of corporations that actually run and rule America.
This whole 'I pay too much in tax' business is complete crap. If they need more they will take more, if they need less you won't pay less. Don't you understand how governments, even America's, operate yet?
People have to stand up and demand SOMETHING for their money, such as health care, otherwise nobody gets squat.
by oz_media
The reason such food items are not taxed is because they want to keep them cheaper than real food.
Consumers eat hybrid corn in everything they eat, that's why corn production fuels America (well a handful of corporations anyway) and fast food is cheaper than real food. They have you by the nuts and if everyone started eating healthier, cattle farms would suffer, corn production would suffer (feeds the cattle, since when did cows naturally eat corn?), and the major corporations that control most of America would suffer losses (heaven forid!).
When your labelling system was challenged and they wanted a list of health indgrediants added, as they do in Canada, listing saturated fats, calories etc on ALL food labels (and rightly they should), two massive corporations in teh US saw it paid to rest.
They don't WANT helthy Americans, they want yuo to pay less for crap than for real food and they WANT you to support eating garbage instead of healthy foods. It also in turn perpetuates the health industry, which ALSO relies on corn by-products for most drugs.
Face it, your government is out to make money, lots of it. If you actually think taht completely abolishign ANY services would return money to your pocket, think again.
You are far better off having the government spend your tax money back on society than sticking it in their pockets and paying off the handful of corporations that actually run and rule America.
This whole 'I pay too much in tax' business is complete crap. If they need more they will take more, if they need less you won't pay less. Don't you understand how governments, even America's, operate yet?
People have to stand up and demand SOMETHING for their money, such as health care, otherwise nobody gets squat and you don't save a dime anyway.
When you make sterling sense.
This is one of those times. Your brief treatment about the nature and quality of food, its relation to agribusiness and government, and the sickness of the system coincides with the sense I have made of it.
by av .
Thats not what happens. If you have no insurance, I pay through my private insurance premiums for your being uninsured. You're paying too, but I'm picking up the rest. Who really knows? I don't.
I understand how you feel and you're entitled to that but I don't want to bear the cost.
AV
by jck
[i]Again I think in concept it is a great idea but I don't see it panning out quite as nicely as you do.[/i]
And again, thanks
[i]Okay so even for a rather menial, minimum wage job where high school education gets you in the door, it would now need to allow people without such qualifications.[/i]
Most jobs in this country require a high school education or GED. Even convenience store clerks in some cases are required to have a high school education, or be working on it.
[i]Simply turn up at America's Job Bank and get a job that someone else had to work toward and earn based on their own merits.[/i]
No, jobs would still be given out by the employer...not the job bank. The job bank just sends qualified candidates.
[i]Why would anyone at the entry level of the employment world, see to actually look for work? Just get fired, walk down the to the job bank and they get you another job. In essence it would make the government an unemployment "union", screw up and they get you another job. Late for work too many times, get fired, the job bank slaps you on the wrist ut has an obligation to find employment for you again.[/i]
No, that's not how you make it work right.
Anyone who abuses the system that way should be treated like someone who scams it. You do it, you get punished. Lose your benefit. Then, you have to go look for work on your own. The government doesn't help you.
You make your own bed, so lie in it...basically.
[i]I must say that you have high hopes and forgive me for beign pessimistic ut I know people that have scammed welfare and UI I know peoplethat live below the poverty line that could very easily be working, they don't, they don't want to and they wouldn't ecome anything more than a burden passed on for a business to suffer with. It' sbad enough with senior union memers, "they can't touch me, I don't give a rats arse what I do, they can't fire me without giving me another job."[/i]
Well:
What companies negotiate with unions is a whole other story.
As I said above, someone who does the constant getting fired would (if shown to have done so repeatedly) lose their benefit.
[i]Raising minimum wage would e a greater deficit to the company, making them seek even more cheap, illegal labour and offshore workers.[/i]
Well, that's where the USA needs to:
a) enforce immigration law, rather than hmm-haw at it.
b) make it non-beneficial for companies to offshore the work and reduce the tax base.
[i]Here for example, students are turning once reputale companies into sweatshops. There is little to no low income, full time work these days (Burger Thing, McCrapples etc.). They only offer part time shifts, pay less money and don't have to offer benefits etc. as they just hire P/T students that andare only oligated to offer limited benefits for part time workers. Adults workign in such places need to work three or four jobs in order to fill a full time card. adding more low end workers to teh mix would increase that need for even more part time jobs but not full time work. Poeple once workign full time would find hours cut back or they'd be fired to be replaced with lower cost, P/T employees, and would need to find another job to pay the bills.[/i]
Well, that's where government could draw the line. Only working to help employers place full-time individuals.
Otherwise, make companies pay a recruiter or go through day-labor referrals to get their pool.
When it hits their pocket more to use a recruiter/headhunter, they will look to staff people more. Companies understand bottom-line more than anything.
[i]But now you have created MORE people living on Part Time, minimum wages and more subsidy would be needed from the government. Not to mention tah added administrative costs, sick time, holiday pay, annual raises etc. for the government workers at the American Job Banks.[/i]
No, you don't necessarily need that.
And if someone is working at a job where they make more than the poverty line, then they are earning that money. Your government output of subsidy drops immediately.
Plus as I said, it's in the best interest of business to employee full-time people. If not, then their taxes go up and they still have to pay folks.
[i]Minimum wage goes up, companies outsource, we've all seen that first hand. If you can't hire someone for minimum wage, offer no benefits due to their working part time, they'll find workers somewhere else, wther illegals or imported workers.[/i]
Actually, most of the outsourcing here was done at technical facilities where the average worker was making $23k-36k a year (which is above poverty line for most, since most were younger people) and were in non-urban areas, e.g.- call centers.
Corps outsourced them to places like India because their cost per employee was 10-20% of that in the United States.
It had nothing to do with minimum wage. It had to do with corporate profits and what US law didn't forbid them from doing.
[i]Why would anyone aspire to seek their own entry level job at minimum wage then? Just line up at the Job Bank and wait for an easy job, handed to you, and supplemented by the government.[/i]
Cause you'd have to compete for that job. It's not just a "here you go" deal. You would have other people there to get jobs too.
[i]Why would people be able to secure full time work? Are businesses going to exploit this if there's no benefit to them to do so?[/i]
Exactly. Hence, what I said above about getting employers to offer full-time work to people via assistance placing people free.
You place a welfare person in a job and don't have to pay them welfare, it saves government money which means less taxes.
You save a corporation from having to go to a recruiter for talent, it saves them money and they like that.
[i]Employment standards for full time workers ensures greater benefits than for part time workers, such as holiday pay, termination notice, unemployment qualification and more. Companies prefer to hire part time workers ecause they have fewer obligations to them, can arrange spotty shift schedules to meet traffic demands.[/i]
Hell, you don't even have the right to termination notice in Florida. Florida is a "right to work" state which means an employer has a right to let anyone else do your work at anytime. Your employment here for a regular job is always stated as "at will".
That's why I don't sweat about moving jobs. It's part of my legal right here, and the company's too.
[i] In Vancouver a couple of years back, unless you were qualified and experienced, a student or entry level worker could not find full time work. Today it's not much better, young workers work several jobs not just to make ends meet but because they need to work full time somehow. Employers WANT more part time workers in such menial roles, not full time workers.[/i]
So, make it less appetizing for employers. Don't help them place part-time or day labor. When it hits their pocketbook, they'll start to change their tune.
[i]if the minimum wage is raised, those qualified for job placement would whine that the subsidy needs to be raised as they are expected to work for less than minimum wage, which is not within employment standards regulations, thus costing the company AND government more money.[/i]
If minimum wage is raised in the United States, that would in theory keep the person above poverty line and no subsidy would be needed.
[i]You now governments well enough to know that IF they saved money they woul dallocate it elsewhere, nobody sees a dime back. The government is in a deficit, always will be, and will always have an excuse to reallocate your tax dollars. That's why I don't care about social programs being paid for out of tax dollars, my taxes don't go up nor down, they get their money one way or another, we get nothing back if we save the government money.[/i]
Well if enough people said "pay it back or get voted out", a lot of politicians would make sure taxes did get lowered.
They like their nice $130k+ a year paychecks.
[i]And Tony, Max and JD would still bitch all the time anyway. (cheap pot shot, sorry guys wink )[/i]
JD: yeah
Max and Tony: maybe depending on if it gets them an extra nickel
[i]But it will always wind up in the same place and never get farther ahead. (AHA!)[/i]
If you get a driver that isn't on the sauce, it will get somewhere.
Don't drink and drive: you might spill your drink! :^0
[i]Mexicans are NEEDED in teh USA. [/i]
No they're not. That's a fallacy.
With 8-15% unemployment, do we really need foreign illegal labor here?
Nope.
[i]Corn is your largets resource of all, more than oil, or any other product america produces. It is controlled y ONE company that has a patented seed taht all growers must use and is used in EVERYTHING and I mean "EVERYTHING". Probaly 80% of teh products you use, day in and day out have some form of corn product in them.[/i]
I thought wheat was the biggest domestic product here.
[i]Companies hire Mexican corn farmers to keep costs down and appease Monsanto and fill their contracts on time. The government then goes around every few years and fines and returns them to Mexico, making room for new illegal immigrants to enter. Almost any product you touch in a day, was made from a product touched by an illegal worker, who works for low pay, ridiculous hours and in horrific conditions that any normal worker would not allow. Americans are cost driven consumers but want good pay for working. ut that's a different topic altogether.[/i]
Actually, most of the stuff I get is local when it comes to foods...unless I get delivery. Then, it's prepared by a local.
I also don't shop at Wal-Mart if avoidable. I don't believe in supporting a corporation that a) has treated women poorly in the past, b) blatantly has hired or contracted out jobs knowingly to illegals, c) pushes (with other major corps) to get the H1B level raised to bring in more, cheaper labor in the tech sector when there is 10% unemployment here.
Trust me, I sat in Wal-Mart ISD HQ in Bentonville, AR. I would say about 30% of the people entering the building were probably H1B "cost-effective" foreign labor.
[i]Again jck, I see your vision and it's great, a Utopia even but we all know there is no Utopia and reality is very different from what we see in our dreams, no matter how much sense they make.[/i]
I don't think it's Utopia, and I don't think it would be easy. But, I think it's possible.
All the USA would have to do is make a few changes, set a few rules, then enforce the laws we already have in place that no one gets off their ass to enforce.
Then maybe, our tax base would grow, unemployment would be minimized, the welfare system would be shrank, taxes on business could be reduced, more money would be available to grow their industries, they could employ more people, etc etc etc.
Anyways...thanks for thinking it's a good idea.
Sort by Trending