Discussion Locked

Anti-Virus/Anti-Spyware software of choice

0 helpful
156 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

156 replies

by visionbender

After using Symantec Enterprise, and client versions of McAfee, we decided to go the Trend Micro route. It has served us well for about 2 years now without any major issues. They even have a beta version that works with Vista.

by apotheon

You open with insults and close with an admission that your imagination is so impoverished it can't handle reality.

My primary desktop system is running FreeBSD. I live more than a thousand miles from my mother (who, by the way, doesn't have a basement). I'm a published author, working IT consultant, and fairly well respected member of the TechRepublic community. I've been referenced as an authority by a Second Life FAQ, and I was the first paid employee of the Wikimedia Foundation. I have Microsoft certifications and have probably forgotten more about Microsoft Windows Registry hacking than you will ever know.

FreeBSD is in many respects more "powerful", better performing, and easier to use than Microsoft Windows. It's also, of course, [b]far[/b] more secure and stable.

It'll be a while before I need to say "hi" to my mother again, anyway. I talked to her around Christmas -- that should tide her over for a while.

by jeffkillam88

well if i was you i would go with Trend Mirco's Officescan. Why you ask? well a couple of reasons. 1 its is lighter on the system than Norton or McAfee. 2 less services to start up for in all in one suite. 3 your clients dont have to rely on a server to hand out updates if it is not avalible. 4 its an all in one suite spyware, virus, phishing, and email scanning. i bet my bottom dollar that if you tried it you would like it.

by lindfalas

Well its seems fine, but dont use to much in one product.. There are always product thats better on one thing..
Antivirus -one progg.
Antispyware- one progg.
And so on..

Greetz

by deepsand

While a given suite may have 1 component that is "best of breed," the same cannot be said for the others. I've yet to find a suite that is better than a good selection of individual components.

If you want a job done right, use the right tools, not a Swiss Army Knife.

by mb.burkhart

I like the idea of a suite, an all-in-one solution. But, where the suite falls short (and I believe they all do at some point), supplement it with a best-of-breed product. For example, I have used ZoneAlarm Internet Security Suite (personal firewall and anti-virus, etc.), but supplemented it with Webroot Spy Sweeper (anti-spyware).

by deepsand

If a standalone product duplicates functions contained within the suite, one or both could consider the other to be an intruder and seek to counter its actions, particularly those which involve use of the Registry.

by zoner57

Sophos has a great Exchange plugin (well actually a whole different product) called Puremessage that scans the stores continously so if you got something befor eht edefs hit your server it will get it on the next sweep. It also is the second layer of my SPAM (Oops UCE) filters as well. They also have Linux and Mac clients.

by lindfalas

Norton sucks big time.
I have also seen computer have alot of virus, but Norton( all versions) say it?s virus free.
I did use Norman, Nod32 or f-secure to scan the system and almost everytime they found virus that they also removed.
I would give my worst enemy norton only :-)

Greetz

by lindfalas

Why would they do that??
Virus in firmware of CD??? no way..

Just buy Nod32 and get all virus out.

GReetz

by pforce76

On my recommendation (so who do you think feels like an idiot?) my flatmate - who has been searching for a suitable substitute for NAV - has just installed NOD32. I don't know if she did something wrong or what, but her system now will not start up - even in safe mode. :-(

I know it's not part of this thread so feel free to contact me some other way if necessary, but how do we now get her system back? It freezes - no HD activity at all - before getting to the stage of showing the task bar after informing her that certain software products have been damaged.

It didn't do that before she installed NOD32. Not even when she was using that pathetically unfriendly Norton

Any help would be appreciated.

by pforce76

It's OK - a little lateral thinking and creative use of Task Manager allowed us to get the NOD32 uninstalled and reclaim our computer.

Later, when we have a spare system (we have a retired laptop we're not using at the moment) we might re-try NOD32 just to see if we can get somewhere ... but not yet.

by viviane_dagosto

Hello,

Here are the products I recommend to secure your network.

They are my favorite "top-guns".

The three first are the anti-viruses. Security suites including an anti-virus, an anti-spyware and a firewall are also available from the same makers. However, I would advise you to use a separate solution for every need. The two last are the anti-spywares.

Sophos - anti-virus and anti-spam software for businesses

http://www.sophos.com

Kaspersky Lab - Antivirus software

http://www.kaspersky.com

F-Secure - F-Secure Corporation protects consumers and businesses against computer viruses and other threats

http://www.f-secure.com

Ewido Networks - Ewido Anti-Spyware

http://www.ewido.net/en/

Sunbelt Software - CounterSpy Anti-Spyware

http://www.sunbelt-software.com

I never recommend products like McAfee Anti-Virus and Symantec Anti-Virus. They are far from the level of protection of the three anti-viruses listed above. Forget what computer magazines say. McAfee and Symantec especially are a huge source of revenues for magazines as they heavily advertise their products in these magazines. Other products I don't really like are (Microsoft) Windows Defender and Spyware Doctor from PC Tools (www.pctools.com). Both are afflicted by the bad habit to grab system resources to a point even high-end computers look completely frozen. In Addition, Windows Defender has a very poor detection rate, which makes it really unreliable. Spyware Doctor has a good detection rate. The version I tried was version 4, which is still the current one. This product might improve over the time.

I hope this will help you in making the right choice.

Best Regards,

Viviane D'Agosto

by tachyon

"FreeBSD

'nuff said"

Is the typical mom's basement zealot type of unhelpful, answer this guy doesn't need.

THe poster was asking for help, not a smart ass "convert to my religion" response from someone not living in reality. Sure, everyone should stop using Windows. But given that this is the real world where that's not going to happen any time soon, some people have to deal with Windows systems.
Given your grand claims to be mr expert..
"I'm a published author, working......have probably forgotten more about Microsoft Windows Registry hacking than you will ever know."

Then next time use what you _haven't_ forgotten (mom's basement must have brain damaging fumes) and help the guy or shut up.

And I stand buy my belief that only a drugged up zealot would seriously tell someone to use FreeBSD as their business desktop OS. If you were any kind of decent consultant, you'd have half a grasp on the realities of the business environment mean that "best tool for the job" doesn't always equal "my personal favourite tool".

by dv8cowboy

May I add that the topic is [b]ANTI-VIRUS[/b]/[b]Anti-Spyware[/b].

Not Suites, Systems, and God forbid whatever else.

It is not hard to miss what the topic is!

by apotheon

Using FreeBSD, I don't have to worry about virus and spyware security very much. That's about as anti-virus and anti-spyware as it gets. If the original post were more specific in its requirements, maybe we'd know for sure whether suggesting different OS choices is appropriate to the circumstances. If a new network is being set up, OSes other than MS Windows may in fact be a viable option for dealing with many security concerns.

by deepsand

Well, you can stand by your [i]belief[/i] for so long as you choose, [b]but[/b] that will not make it become [i]fact.[/i]

And, [i]ad hominem[/i] arguments are never going to win the day here.

Next time, try to be a bit more well mannered.

by tig2

I DO happen to know Apothenon well and have learned to trust his judgment.

Before deciding that those who champion lesser used tools are "drugged up zealots", ask yourself why so many of us are choosing to move away from Microsoft as a primary tool of choice. Could it be that we started in this business using a better OS?

Your language takes you to the level of a flamer at best. Perhaps you should re-consider your preferred communication style?

by apotheon

Clearly, you haven't much ability to address others with respect or to maintain your own dignity in the face of disagreement with your myopic worldview. It has been a good long while since I've seen someone fly off the handle like that over a three word statement. While you're at it, take the advice of people like Deepsand and T2: lighten the hell up.

1. Others had already covered most of the bases by the time I found this thread. I didn't want to cover ground already well-traveled, since it wouldn't add much to the discussion, by posting suggestions without reading the rest of the thread. I didn't have time to read the whole thread at the time, so I skimmed it to see if anyone else had suggested the *BSD solution, then posted that. Now that I've gotten around to reading the rest, I think I can provide a little more in the way of suggestions -- and I will when I'm done with you.

2. The original post wasn't very long on details for specific platform needs. It just asks for suggestions to deal with virus and spyware security issues, and specifically mentions that we all have our favorites (and least favorites) -- so my statement about FreeBSD fits a liberal interpretation.

3. You seem to have no sense of humor, or at least not a very sophisticated sense of humor.

4. Sometimes, an answer that doesn't exactly fit the common assumptions of the majority is precisely what's needed to jog someone's mind and get him/her thinking outside the box. I tend to aim for that sort of effect from time to time. Once in a while, some wacko like you takes offense to a nonstandard answer and goes berserk, but I guess that's the price I have to pay for not being a slave to my certifications.

5. "[i]And I stand buy my belief that only a drugged up zealot would seriously tell someone to use FreeBSD as their business desktop OS.[/i]" You're welcome to be dead wrong. I've worked for corporations where the majority of desktops ran free unices (Linux predominantly), I've been involved in small business migrations to free unices, and I use FreeBSD as my primary desktop OS in part because it's a far better development platform than Windows could ever aspire to be. If you were at all in touch with reality, you might realize that not every business in the world is exactly the same as your employer (and I'm assuming you're employed, here -- I could easily be mistaken).

6. "[i]'best tool for the job' doesn't always equal 'my personal favourite tool'[/i]" No sh*t, Sherlock. When the guy gives us enough information to actually provide more detailed responses than wild-ass guesses, maybe some of us will start providing better-targeted responses. In the meantime, as things stand, I'd accept "unplug your computer from the Internet and uninstall all removable media drives" as a response, since we don't know from the original post whether Internet access or removable storage media is even needed. I get the impression you tend to make your way through life relying on the hope that half-baked assumptions will work in your favor.

by comphelpnj

To settle this whole OS debate, let me just say that I'm not up to the task of "experimenting" with an OS that I'm not familiar with at this time. I'll stick with M*soft, but that's a WHOLE different topic that I do not what to even address here at all. Thanks.

by stuart

My personal choice is spyware doctor from www.pctools.com
This prog when compared to symantec/Norton
and Mcafee finds more spyware that the other two progs have missed.
pctools also make a pretty good registry repair
prog , they also more recently developed their own antivirus prog but i have not tried it yet.

by lonnie_heston9

Both free home editions. I also have Lavasoft Ad-Aware but only run it once every few months.
I usually demand run Spybot and Avast after the Grandkids spend part of the day IMing...

by mb.burkhart

I recommend AVG, ClamWin, Ad-Aware and Spybot as a temporary solution, but I also warn that for long-term protection, get something that has corporate $upport, like Trend Micro suite, Zone Alarm suite, Webroot Spy Sweeper, and other quality products.
Also note, just because a product is popular doesn't make it good. For example, Norton/Symantec is currently near the top of my "most hated" list, followed by McAfee.

by deepsand

For example, free AVG [i]is[/i], for all intents and purposes, the same as the paid version; it's the same engine, but without the management capabilities needed for administering an enterprise system.

As for Spybot S&D, it is an extremely well seasoned open-source type product, that is supported by some of the best-of-breed hackers in the origianl sense of the word.

On the other hand, Webroot Spy Sweeper is a pain in the rump, owing to its slow speed and the occurence of too many false positives. Of particular annoyance is its over zealousness with regard to cookies, insisting that many [i]essential[/i] ones are threats.

by mb.burkhart

I recommend AVG, ClamWin, Ad-Aware and Spybot as a temporary solution, but I also warn that for long-term protection, get something that has corporate $upport, like Trend Micro suite, Zone Alarm suite, Webroot Spy Sweeper, and other quality products.
Also note, just because a product is popular doesn't make it good. For example, Norton/Symantec is currently near the top of my "most hated" list, followed by McAfee.

by mb.burkhart

I generally enjoy reading these, but the flame wars really turn me off.
First, the original post was asking advice about anti-malware programs, not what operating system may or may not be more secure. Please keep the discussion on topic.
Second, personal attacks will never get the point across. Give opinions about the products, not each other.

by mb.burkhart

I ran a machine with ZoneAlarm Internet Security Suite, supplemented with Webroot Spy Sweeper. This machine also ran AVG and web-based scanners from Trend Micro and others. None of these programs conflicted. I turned off the anti-spyware component of ZoneAlarm suite because that function was covered by Webroot. AVG and the online scans never conflicted, because they never ran as passive scanners.
Yes, if a machine has multiple applications trying to do the same thing at the same time, they'll fight for resources, frequently with "undesirable" results. (Ever run an AVI with two different media players simultaneously? Or run two competing web browsers? It may work for a short time, but at the risk of system stability.)
Short story: know what your programs do, and see that they don't fight each other to get it done.

by jeffkillam88

First off deepsand do you what you are talking about cause i dont think you do.first go with an all in one, less services less overhead and then its ok to use a couple of freeware programs or pay one like doctor spyware, one of the best out there. look at what the clients are going to be are they p3 500. cause if so multi programs for av and as is wrong. it will drain the system. even if the pc is new it is still a bad idea. multi services are going to slow down the system cause now you have to wait for the services to start up in order to have protection... remember KISS Keep it simple silly

by deepsand

1) You're contracting yourself, by defending both suites and standalone applications.

2) Multiple services? Meaning what? Applications, Processes or OS SVC calls. In any case, a suite does [b]not[/b] necessarily result in reduced [i]over-head.[/i]

And, yes, I do know exactly of that which I speak; this, from many years of experience. If you've never had multiple apps mis-interpret each others' Registry entries you're either been quite fortunate or you've not yet had enough time under your belt to have seen such.

by deepsand

If you've never had multiple apps mis-interpret each others' Registry entries you're either been quite fortunate or you've not yet had enough time under your belt to have seen such.

by mb.burkhart

Yes it's an over-used cliche, but consider...
AVG is a corporate product, supported by investors and clients. If the majority of their customers are freeloading their product, they'll stop providing it. If you like it, $upport it. If you're not going to pay for it, then stop using it as a long-term solution.
Spybot S&D started as a hobby project, and I witnessed it going weeks without updates. In the meantime, spyware continues to be produced, with no means of catching it with this program. They may be better at it now, but with that history I can't trust them as a long-term solution.
Okay, so Webroot may have false positives. That's better than missing something that sends your credit card information to an identity thief. I'd rather learn how to configure Spy Sweeper to ignore certain cookies than have to put a fraud alert on my bank accounts. Besides, I listed it as one of several possible solutions. If you don't like it, use something else.

by deepsand

While you and I may be able to spot such, most users cannot; and, even if they could, most likely they will not, but simply rely on the app to do the "right" thing.

Bear in mind that many AV/AS products [b]deliberately[/b] cry "wolf" at every opportunity, so as to impress the user with their "thoroughness."

by apotheon

"[i]not what operating system may or may not be more secure[/i]"
Are you absolutely certain, based on the original post? CompHelpNJ said that there's a new network that needs to be set up, and that an anti-virus program is needed. People sometimes make unnecessary assumptions when asking such questions -- perhaps what's needed is rethinking the network architecture, choosing the right operating system for the job rather than just the default OS for most of the world and six metric tons of security software. How do we know without questioning the apparent assumption?

Considering an OS is as much "a program" as most AV solutions, OS suggestions even fit within the literal word-for-word interpretation of the original question.

by apotheon

Assuming for the moment that you are speaking of a necessarily Windows-based network (which isn't firmly established by your original post), I have some answers for you with some pretty hefty caveats.

It seems likely that you're talking about using a per-system AV and anti-spyware solution alone. I'm not sure that's actually the approach you should be taking. Depending on your needs, you should probably consider using gateway security solutions as well. Firewall, web proxy, and email gateway antivirus and antispam software may all suit your needs.

Ultimately, however, you do need per-system user-level AV and anti-spyware software on Windows systems to remain relatively secure. When considering solutions at that level, however, you need to be aware not only of the technical concerns but also the legal. For instance, while Avast and Grisoft both offer free AV softare, both are offered free only for personal, non-business use. To legally use AVG (the Grisoft AV software) for a network of business systems, you need to use the Pro version -- which means paying for it.

That having been said, as long as you're willing to pay, AVG is excellent AV software -- among the best. It's certainly head-and-shoulders above the quality of certain more popular solutions such as those provided by McAfee or Symantec. Another option is to make use of open source software, free to use regardless of whether it's for personal or business implementations. In fact, ClamWin is, like AVG, one of the best AV software offerings available for the Windows desktop, and is open source software. On my own Windows systems (which are, frankly, turned off most of the time) I ensure that both AVG and ClamWin are installed. You may consider the same approach (though, as I said, for business use you need to pay for AVG).

Avast's technical virus protection capabilities are excellent as well, but the resource usage overhead is tremendous in comparison with anything but the most bloated alternatives (again, such as McAfee or Symantec AV).

With Trend Micro, you really have to examine the reputation of the specific product: quality varies wildly from one security product to the next in the Trend Micro lineup, from somewhat crappy to truly excellent.

For anti-spyware, I recommend a combination of Spybot Search & Destroy with AdAware. I haven't kept up with the state of the art quite as much with spyware protection lately as I have in the past, so there may be new anti-spyware applications arising that are worth using, but neither of these have let me down in the past. Unlike AV software, however, active spyware protection software tends to be resource-intensive enough that running more than one at a time is not always the world's greatest idea. That's unfortunate considering the necessity of multiple spyware protection applications to be able to get complete protection. You really have to weigh your security needs against your performance needs when making a decision about how to implement spyware protection.

While you're at it, you should look into getting desktop firewall software installed on these systems. Two such applications that top my list of favorites free or cheap use include the iSafer Firewall (formerly known as the iSafer WinSock Firewall), which is open source software that provides socket-level firewall capability, and ZoneAlarm, which provides application-level firewall capability. Like AVG and ClamWin, these can be used concurrently without putting undue stress on most systems' resources. ZoneAlarm can create a greater resource demand than the above AV solutions and the iSafer Firewall, however, so be aware of your requirements for resource-light operation.

ZoneAlarm, like AVG and Avast, is free for personal use -- but, also like them, you must pay for the Pro version to legally use it for a business network.

Hopefully that helps somewhat. You can also greatly reduce your vulnerability, as I hinted with my FreeBSD post above, by choosing an operating system other than Windows -- MacOS X is somewhat better, Linux-based OSes are far better still, FreeBSD and OpenSolaris are incrementally better than Linux, and OpenBSD is the most secure of all (though OpenSolaris is not well suited to desktop use for most purposes for a number of reasons and OpenBSD suffers some shortcomings of its own with regard to hardware support, high-load system performance, and paucity of available software).

by mdonald

Avast is topped ranked anti-virus suite. I have 2 small companies that I have setup with Avast & it works great. I feel employees should also use the some type of AV software on their home pc's as well to truly have a protected network system. Avast allows for this by offering a free or moderate priced personal version. They also have a server management module so you can have a central update source. This product won?t break your bank either.

by comphelpnj

Yes, the original post was somewhat vague, but for a reason. I wanted to get some opinions on the various anti-virus, anti-malware, and anti-spyware products that are in use in the corporate world.

In my particular case, I am installing a new server and setting up a small office network. I'd like to start it off with a decent security package to keep the server and workstations clean.

So far, most of the posts have been very helpful. I'm also happy to see that I'm not the only one with bad experiences with some of these top name packages such as Norton.

Thanks for your input so far...

by drbwaugh

I am running a small network that deals with Medical information and needed a solution that was flexible and effective, without going to the enterprise software level (adding zeros to the price tag). Originally I was a fan of Symantec, but after 2003 had too many problems with it. Tried Panda, seems like a nice product, but I did not like the GUI- just a personal thing. Tried TrendMicro and have been very satisfied; low resource hits, good interface, including a "network Monitoring" option that allows centralized monitoring of PCs on the LAN from one workstation. Had one occasion to call customer support, and it was a good experience--they had a bad update and admitted and corrected it right away. Only issue so far. Also they make it easy to but multiple licenses. Check it out

by apotheon

. . . and thanks for clearing that up.

I figured you probably weren't looking for a different OS as the answer, but that it might be worthwhile to bring it up anyway if only to get you thinking about the future (beyond this particular task).

by liquid_danno

I've used McAffee and Norton/Symantec for years then I switched to ZoneAlarm Security Suite (virus/spyware/firewall). I was already using ZoneAlarm for firewall. It's light weight unlike McAffee and Norton.

by deepsand

Their Firewall is best-of-breed! It is quite superior to those of either McAfee or Norton

Yes, their AV/AS components are not yet up to the quality of their Firewall; but, that's no reason to throw the baby out with the bath water.

That's why I advocate using best-of-breed apps for AV, AS & Firewall, as opposed to suites.

by jterry

I can't say which product is better but we are using Panda right now. We have had problems with it but we are working through them. There tech support sucks. We switched from McAfee because with the new version we had trouble with e-mail. We have a couple of agencies that send us attachments that are executables. They are necessary for our job. McAfee will block all executables or no executables. You cannot specify certain addresses to accept executables from. We had the same problem with zip files. McAfee said they had no intention of changing this so we had to switch.

by pgparlikar

At last i could find someone putting faith in Indian Antivirus. Quick heal is really fantastic and I have been using it since 2005 and there has not been asingle incident of breakdowns. Their latest version 9 is equipped with afirewall which is just fantastic.I use it for home purpose only but it is worth for an organisation.

by jtaylor75

If you are using a Windows based operating system, I have found that McAffee, CA, and Norton does not provide good potection. All delete some operating files, including the .dll fills which cause instability in Windows XP. After using many solutions, free and paid programs, I now use Windows One Care (developed by Microsoft for Windows) for anti-virus/anti-spyware. Since Microsoft does not have a good solution for anti-spyware, I also use MaxSecure Spyware Detector and Regestry Cleaner which is very fast. I have not had any problems since using both products together.

by dv8cowboy

Running Avast Pro, and if you have Spybot Search&Destroy Beta 14 run Spybot - SD Resident. And maybe Arrowvax 2.0.70 and you WILL be 99% protected.

You will NEVER be 100% protected, as there are Blachats with a lot of weapons out there.

Best to practice safe browsing habits (I know personally some very capable and knowledgeable IT Experts who have done this for years without ANY problems).

- Terry Mathis

by deepsand

Many seem to the wholly unaware of the wealth of features available in SB's "Advanced" mode.

For example, using the resident features, "SD Helper" & "TeaTimer," will not only provide real-time protection against a mytiad threats, but also provide you with a log of all Registry changes Allowed & Denied.

Additionally, for example, one has easy access to all BHOs and ActiveX apps currently installed, along with the capability of removing them or toggling them between being active and inactive.

Another particularly useful feature is the System Startup tool, which provides an all-in-one view of all apps that get launched at boot time, regardless of whether it's from the System.ini file, the Registry or the Startup folder. This feature is quite useful when troubleshooting, including problems with suspected malware.

by kymerd

I have been using the corp. version of Trend for about 4 years and love it. I was using Norton Antivirus at home and have really mixed feelings about it. I used to love it, but last year I had to deal with Tech Support several times and was extremely disappointed in their service and responses. My Norton at home expires this month, so I am dumping it and trying Trend at home. No thoughts about the home version of Trend as of yet.

This discussion is closed to new replies.