Discussion Locked

Individual Liberty in America - Is it a thing of the past?

0 helpful
384 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

.
My premise is this: In the United States of America, both by design and as guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution, one person does not have the power, the freedom, the prerogative, etc., to infringe on the rights -- i.e. the individual liberty -- of another person. And, by definition and extension, the government of the United States (a government of the people, by the people, and for the people) also does not have the license, the authority, the prerogative, etc., to infringe on the rights of an individual person. And one individual may not use the vehicle of government to exercise and propagate such infringement on another. Moreover, it is the primary role and responsibility of government to protect that right to individual liberty, not infringe upon it.

Do you agree or disagree with my stated premise?

If you disagree, will you please share with us your reasoning? And if you disagree, will you please support your assertions within the constitutional structure of the United States?

If you agree with the established premise, do you then agree with the following conclusion.

1. Taking a dollar from the person who earned it, so it can be given to a person who did not earn it, is tantamount to infringing on the individual liberties of that person who earned it; it is infringing on the rights of that person who earned it; and it should be abolished in the United States of America, as there is no intended Constitutional authority to legitimize it, nor has there been a Constitutional amendment passed that would specifically allow it.

And before you cite the "general welfare" clause, consider the words of the person who wrote them, James Madison, and the people who agreed with and/or approved of them, as they were intended within the context of defining the powers of government -- i.e. the Constitution of the United States.

"I cannot undertake to lay my finger on that article of the Constitution which granted a right to Congress of expending, on objects of benevolence, the money of their constituents."
--James Madison

"Congress has not unlimited powers to provide for the general welfare but only those specifically enumerated."
-- Thomas Jefferson

"When the people find that they can vote themselves money, that will herald the end of the republic."
-- Benjamin Franklin

"The government of the United States is a definite government, confined to specified objects. It is not like the state governments, whose powers are more general. Charity is no part of the legislative duty of the government."
--James Madison

"A free people ought not only to be armed and disciplined but they should have sufficient arms and ammunition to maintain a status of independence from any who might attempt to abuse them, which would include their own government."
-- George Washington

My conclusion:

No, I don't think it would be a realistic expectation to cut-off all transfer of wealth programs overnight. Moreover, to attempt such a thing would be political suicide for anyone attempting to advance such an agenda. However, the dialogue must change; the expectations much change -- expectations of both government and self; and we need to start turning back the clock to a time when the notion of protecting individual liberty in America trumped any and all collectivist desires.

And then let's consider property rights........or more accurately, how they have been taken away as well.

More to come.....

384 replies

by jdclyde

and I am sure that comes as no suprise to anyone who has ever read any discussion I have been in regardings this topic.

I am big on personal responsiblity. It seems too many people find it easier to cry that they are a victom and collect a check.

I also see a lot of the problem is that subculture is allowed to flurish and be glamorized. When you have drug dealers/rap "artists" set up as role models, there is a big problem.

The educational system also needs to be overhauled, not just mended here or there. This is run by the Teachers Union, a DEMOCRAT run group. The only way our educational system could be as bad as it is and still resist reform is if it is that way on purpose. If we expect less and less out of students so they can't get gainfully employed after graduation (provided they make it that far) then you are setting these people up to fail. This is done to create a peasent class that will be subservient to who ever will GIVE them money to live.

In a gift society people gain power buy giving more to people than anyone else. If the people are self-reliant then they aren't interested in trading power for their own money back.

I did notice as regards to property rights, all of a sudden when the courts SHOW how nuts they are "it isn't a matter of Right or Left". Bull it isn't.

Government should be there to keep the boarders safe, make me a few nice roads, and stay out of my way so I can succeed or fail depending on my efforts or lack of.

by ippirate

I would just like to say brrreeep..

"(*#%& @(# *%&^^ %#"

click CLICK Clack click

I would just like to say......
that I am highly opposed to the current methodology utilized in Washington in which I am taxed so that my money can be transferred to someone without. No, I have no a realistic answer and each time that I am pressed on this issue I will be sure to become hostile and attempt to discredit my opponents in an attempt to hide my own ineptitude and lack of profitable consideration as it pertains to the issue. I do this because I have little to know interest in actually attempting to promote a solution, it is far easier for me to whine about it and play the part of the victim. My name is Max Ed, please excuse my inferiority complex, Oh, and I just want my money dirtbag, get a job.

Oz, just let him sing his mantra. Really, if you ignore it, it'll stop itching. Besides, he will never get beyond his premise. He has been posting it for ages now. A solution would be nice but he would have to get his spine out of that knot first.

Cheers!

by maxwell edison

.
1. Instead of addressing the issue and answering my questions, you chose to attack me (while saying that I will only attack others?), side-stepping the core issue on which my opinion is based.

2. You resorted to the usual -- and predictable -- ploy of lumping everyone who is on the receiving end of such transfer of wealth programs as being "without". That's a grossly exaggerated suggestion. Did you know, for example, that Warren Buffet (and millions like him, albeit not quite as wealthy) is the beneficiary of various transfer of wealth programs? That means that some poor schmuck who's making $15 an hour, or $12 an hour, or $10 an hour, or even $7 an hour, is having money taken out of his paycheck each and every month so that it can be paid to Warren Buffet, and others like him, as some sort of payment for some sort of program. And the cost of his goods and services is higher so that even more taxes can be collected, only to be transferred to Warren Buffet, and others like him -- including Ted Kennedy, the "champion" of the little guy?

3. Speaking of Warren Buffet, if people followed his methods of providing for their own retirement, they would do much better for themselves than what the current Social Security program provides -- even the guy making 10 bucks an hour.

4. You assume that I have no solutions. You assume incorrectly. And you must be resistant, for some reason, to discuss those solutions in a reasonable manner. One of my solutions, for example, would include making all income under a certain amount free from all taxes of any kind whatsoever -- federal taxes, social security taxes, state taxes AND sales taxes. (And at this point in time, that amount would be around $27,000 per year.) The way the current system works today, especially with social security taxes and sales taxes, it makes the deck stacked against the little guy, because a bigger percentage of his income is taken away every year in the form of taxes. So if a guy makes $25,000 to $30,000 per year, I would suggest that he pay NO TAXES AT ALL of any kind. And yes, I could discuss this plan in-depth and in-detail, if you would care to have some constructive dialogue on the subject. (And this really is a great plan -- at least it's a good start.)

5. You attempt to give the impression that I'm taking my position for a self-serving reason. See the above point to dispel that false notion.

6. Moreover, I'm taking this position because I feel it's in the best interest of America. Did you know that since the 1930s, the percentage of people receiving some sort of benefits as compared to the people paying into "the system" to pay for those benefits, has increased steadily year after year? This percentage of increase also applies to the amount of money being paid out versus the amount of money paid in. So regardless of how you look at it, it's only a matter of time before there are more takers than givers. What happens to your personal budget and financial state when you consistently spend more than you earn? And what kind of future are you providing for yourself? And what kind of future does that mean for America after we are dead and gone? Environmentalists claim to act only as stewards of the Earth. I wonder why you can't consider that some people might also want to be stewards of the idea that our forefathers called America?

7. You assume that being made dependent on someone, or some system, is being compassionate. To the contrary, I suggest to you that it's cruel to make people dependent, and that the compassionate thing to do is to encourage self-sufficiency and self-responsibility. Perhaps you're raising your kids by teaching them to become dependent on government, which in reality means that they'll be dependent on other people; but I choose to raise my kids teaching them to be self-sufficient, and to avoid being a burden on society -- and by definition, on others.

8. You avoid discussing the intent of the Constitution. Perhaps you don't understand it enough to discuss it. And perhaps that's part of the problem.

by jdclyde

that this and his in the clueless post was showing a very imature side of both of you?

"I can be as childish as you can, so there", type deal?

I guess it isn't all that bad, it makes the rest of us look twice as cultured and sophistocated! B-)

by oz_media

All I did was note that while Max changes the wirding slightly, he has raise this issue more times than I can remember in the last 4 or 5 years, it seems like a biannual complaint from Max these days. it's like posting about Win vs Linux again.

by cuteelf

Quality of life is important to people's overall health and wellbeing.

That stated, it costs money no matter what to live. Whether you are a working citizen or a person who's unemployed, it costs money to have a roof, food, clothing and transportation (either shoes bus or car..take your pic.)

Now, what about people like me who are disabled? I qualify under ADA and EEOC as a person with a disability. I have it under control, and am lucky. (epilpepsy.)
What about the people who have this certain illness,uncontrolled, who are unable to work, feed, clothe, and walk outside safely?

What about the people with a temporary disability, such as double broken legs, or even a nervous breakdown?
Those can be repaired, but at the same time, those people would not be able to bring in /work for the same $ and same tasks previous to the injuries. So should their quality of life decrease as punishment? Should mr. nolegs not eat for 6 weeks and take twice as long to heal due to nutrition issues? Should mr. breakdown not go to a counselor and have treatment /therapy to get over his problems?

I'm FSCKING lucky that i have control over my seizures. But you know what? Due to the ep, there are other, secondary, shadowing problems. Those cause me problems all over within my life. Sometimes I've been on food stamps. Dammit, I've seriously thougth about it this time after school, because I'm not working at a rate to pay rent/elec/bills ON TIME.

I have a friend who has more illnesses than you can shake a stick at. She's on welfare. She's trying VERY HARD to finish her edu/ged and get 2ndary education.
Her quality of life is SHIT. State doesnt cover long term problems like mine/hers. It covers broken legs. She gets migraines. Cant get a doc to prescribe because, well, nobody covers that and nobody covers the pills. (we're finding some places are working w/ us, but its DIGGING LIKE A FUKIN RAT TO GET THERE)....she's deaf in one ear, nobodoy would get a hearing aid for her..kinda hard to work with this crap. Food stamps barely covered her food needs. And it doesnt pay rent.
How's she paying rent? A$$ hole roomy is paying rent (while eating her food).

So, Max, dont be pulling this bullshit here.

She, illnesses and all, costs more to take care of in a month than you do in a year.
She's still worth having on Earth, and dammit, you sob, she's worthy of living just like you and I do....roof/food/clothes.

So dont go saying that it should all be taken away. Dont be saying that there are people here on it that are lazy. Dont be judging all this stuff.

I dare you: LIVE IN HER SHOES FOR 6 MONTHS.
Deaf, seizures, migraines, bad knees, food allergies, mulitple mental problems AND no money.
The place she's at is a rat hole.
The clothes she wears are handme downs with holes. I cant afford to get her new clothes - we do everysooften..but I cant atm.
No education along with learning disabilities.

You go off and live in a shitty situation like that and realize, dammit, welfare is ok to have..

People like you max, are allowed to live on earth to give it spice.
Go jump off a cliff some time soon, tho.

Cute VERY PISSED elf

by maxwell edison

.
1. How do you know that I don't or haven't "lived in her shoes"? How do you know that I don't already take care of someone else in such a position? You don't.

2. Did you consider that all of the money she now receives is taken away from someone else to begin with? If you simply eliminate the middle-man, i.e. the government, and break it down to the lowest common denominator, then by definition it's really some individual somewhere who is providing for her. What if that individual is also struggling to make ends meet? What if that individual has also had a bit of bad luck? What if that individual can't save for his kids' college education because half his income is taken by way of taxes? Why doesn't she just go over there and demand that she be given the property that belongs to someone else?

3. It costs money to live, you say? Sure it does. Either yours or somebody else's? If you want to espouse taking someone else's money -- by force -- to pay for your friend's needs, then at least call it what it is.

4. Life isn't fair, I know. But is it up to government to make it fair? I think not.

5. I'd rather give a person like that $200 of my own free will, than to have a government force me to give her $100. And you presume that I don't care about such people, nor would I give anything to help. To the contrary, I do, and I do. But forcing it is wrong.

6. The problems you describe are real, that's for sure. It's the proposed solutions where we might disagree. There's the old saying about the many ways to skin a cat. Personally speaking, I believe that when the government gets involved, everybody gets scalped. I'm not suggesting that the problems be ignored, but rather addressed in a manner that's more conducive to maintaining the spirit and intention of the U.S. Constitution.

7. I'm not suggesting that such people be left to die, nor do I believe that would happen. I'm simply trying to define the role of government. And when the government gets into the business of defining "needy", then there will eventually be more needy people than those who are forced to pay for them. And then the whole system will collapse under its own weight; and just like the goose that laid the golden egg, there will be nothing left for anybody.

8. What would you say to James Madison?

"The government of the United States is a definite government, confined to specified objects. It is not like state governments, whose powers are more general. Charity is no part of the legislative duty of the government."
-- James Madison, speech in the House of Representatives, January 10, 1794

.....or Franklin Pierce:

"I cannot find any authority in the Constitution for the public charity.....(to approve such spending).....would be contrary to the letter and the spirit of the Constitution and subversive to the whole theory upon which the Union of these States is founded."
- President Franklin Pierce:

.....or Professor Alexander Tytler

"A democracy cannot exist as a permanent form of government. It can only exist until the voters discover that they can vote themselves largesse from the public treasury. From that moment on, the majority always votes for the candidates promising the most benefits from the public treasury, with the result that a democracy always collapses over loose fiscal policy, always followed by a dictatorship."
-- Professor Alexander Tytler

"When men get in the habit of helping themselves to the property of others, they cannot easily be cured of it."
-- The New York Times, in a 1909 editorial opposing the very first income tax

by cuteelf

Because all of us deserve to live in a decent place.

Should I NOT contribute to people who need it?
Should I hold my money back and only distribute it to people I deem worthy (smacks of snobbery)?

Should I say that only white/pink/green people are allowed to ask for help? Dont think so.

I dont mind contributing to the better quality of life of my coutnry, because we're equal. Because we deserve a chance, same as the guy driving a porche.

Life isnt fair, true, but who said that one person has to bear all of the weight? Its distributed equally (hopefully by taxation brackets) to people who can bear it.
If we stopped taking moneys away from EVERYONE (money meant to help state/govet welfare programs) and said OK Everyone: you're on your own. No foodstamps, no bennies, ZIPPO.
Do you have any idea what would happen?
Greed and competition would grow, and so would corruption: the people with the money would grease the palms of the ones in power to connect.
The people with no skills/medical/phys problems would run out of food/shelter/water/clothing, and would be literally kicked out of developed areas. They'd be reduced to begging.
WE'VE FOUGHT FOR YEARS TO SAY WE DESERVE AN EQUAL QUALITY OF LIFE.

You've had the chance to vote no. So, shut your trap.

And to james madison:
Sir, you are now fertilizer in a large field. Let us do the thinking. Go be worm food.

Cute

by maxwell edison

.
First of all, you're suggesting that dependence on the government is the ONLY way to address these issues. That's a false assumption. There are other ways.

Second of all, you're suggesting that this discussion is about the merits of helping the needy, generally speaking, which it is not. It is about the best role -- and the intended role -- of government.

Thirdly, you're basing your entire opinion on specific instances rather than a general across the board application.

And fourthly, you're letting your emotions overtake your reason. Because, taken to its logical conclusion, you have to suggest that someone, rather than individuals themselves, get to define "needy". And that is where we are treading on some extremely dangerous waters.

Then you might want to consider this. The US government transfers about 1.4 TRILLION dollars (give or take a few hundred billion) each and every year from one American citizen to the other; and considering that a big percentage of those people receive nothing, and further considering that we have a population of only 300 million, if you do the math, you'll find that the amount transferred each and every year is much more than many people even earn in an entire year. (Gee, let's just support the entire population!)

If you think this is an efficient system for a society to care for its needy, let me tell you about a bridge I have for sale.

by absolutely

No, not as punishment. As the hand that was dealt them. As the (expletive of your preference) situation that chance, society, and their own choices have placed them. Sequence intentional. I know some people are [i]born[/i] into lousy situations and that their own choices have less power to improve their situations because other factors are more pronounced for them than for a lot of other people.

I've worked at soup kitchens and tried to find out why poverty continues. Like drug abuse, poverty continues [i]because[/i] government has declared war on it!

In soup kitchens I saw only despair, defeat and total resignation in the eyes across the tables, and that is not a worthy use of my money, yours, or anybody's. When money to help unlucky people has to first be skimmed by the astonishingly lucky likes of GWB and Ted Kennedy before it gets to the unlucky people you have in mind, it's getting pissed away.

We're not saying it should all be taken away. We're saying that you and your "friend who has more illnesses than you can shake a stick at" should be helped [i]instead[/i] of Warren Buffett, Ken Lay, Ted Kennedy and all the other manufacturers of need in the various parties and NGOs because frankly my dear, I know that conspicuously charitable people just don't give a damn! They pretend to care then get into office and sign NAFTA. Or pretend to be compassionate, then sign a "tax cut" without cutting spending to match, making real conservatives blush.

At present, your plight and that of the friend you mentioned are made worse by the fact that everybody in your vicinity and everybody who knows you and knows you really [i]are[/i] just unlucky, [i]not[/i] trying to bilk the system, are [i]compelled by the unique power of government to legally use force[/i] to take from all those people to give [i]some[/i] to ADM, energy monopolies, oil companies, and every other lazy, indulgent, scheming, dishonest, worthless waste of skin you can name. Oh, granted, there are good causes buried in there, but would the truly good causes be ignored if the government did not spend $30,000 on a hammer and $20,000 on a toilet seat? And $30/hr for minimum-wage skill-level construction labor? Government does not have rights not specifically named in the Constitution, up to and [i]ending with[/i] Amendment 10.

Government's legal monopoly on the use of force means that the tax collectores don't have to ask permission. They don't have to prove to me that the people getting my payroll deduction are needier than me, more worthy according to my personal standards, or [i]even consider my personal standards[/i]. Such power is appropriate only for [i]defense[/i] of my rights against [i]aggression[/i] -- the initiation of the use of force [i]by another person[/i]!

If deprivation of personal property without due process doesn't move you, consider that your goals , including helping the needy, are also being defeated because government, holding this monopoly on force, isn't responsible to prove any results except to report how many billions have been spent on welfare. The tax collectors then observe that the problem grows, and conclude that the solution is to take more money from the people who create [i]productive[/i] work to give directly to people who do not, primarily the politician dirtbags, secondarily the panhandlers.

Panhandlers at least ask. Sh|t, even muggers take a [i]risk[/i] of getting caught, shot, or jailed. That's not courage, but it's at least less cowardice than taxing me without representing me.

Maxwell, bless him,

by cuteelf

remember:

If you make X $, and govt takes Y%, and I as a needing group ask for Z% of Y,

All needing groups have the right to ask for that help.

Even the oil companies.
Even the rich people.

You know, there has been due process: bills and acts for special interest groups being passed.

If you have any issues with that: you should have voted or made your voice heard.

I know that there are people saying "I'm needy. Help me."
But there are ohter groups saying, "Hey you .....Help me too, and I'll do this..."

Thats the way this is, at the moment. I cannot do anything to fix it; everyone has a right to ask. It wouldn't be fair to citizens if only one group or interest was served/helped/given. So I dont mind that www.efa.org may get less than NAACP or more than BassAckwards Special Other Group.

Its not fair for me to say: nobody should get anything.

I'm willing to give up some of my money because I know it does go to people who need it.
I give to charities also, but when doing so, I make sure that not too much goes to the executives and marketing.

Cute

by itgirli

"Deaf, seizures, migraines, bad knees, food allergies, mulitple mental problems AND no money."

I am deaf in one ear. you know what? I don't need a hearing aide, I just don't use that ear.
seizures? nope.
Migranes? suffered for years. gets better if you lay off chocolate and alcohol.
bad knees? nope, I have scoliosis and kyphosis (not sure of spelling) both are back issues with my spine being malformed.
Mental problems? I have been diagnosed with a few.
no money? I have a job. I got work. I get on with my life and raise my child and do just fine. I don't need to whine about it. I seem to have more wrong with me than your friend, yet I go to work everyday and pay my taxes so that lazy ignorant b@stards can live for nothing. So my fat cousin and her fat husband and their 4 fat children can get by on welfare while I work my ass off. Get off the box and get a clue. It's the disabled veterans that deserve that money, not these people who rattle off a "poor me" story. You have NONE of my sympathy. Get over it.

by jck

you said you didn't whine about it...then did...hahaha ;)

BTW...sorry you got so much going against you...really I am...however, compare against this:

Legally impaired vision in both eyes
acromion impingements in both shoulders
malformed knees and ankles from birth
petit mal seizures
hearing impairment(5-10%) in both ears.
mentally abused from age ?-15
sexually abused from age ?-8
physically abused from age ?-15

You're not the only that's had problems in life...trust me.

Elf...stay on your soapbox. You're in America. Speak your mind.

by maxwell edison

.
.....Gloom, despair and agony on me. Deep dark depression, excessive misery. If it weren't for bad luck I'd have no luck at all. Gloom despair and agony on me.....

(Credit to M. J. Wingard)

Hey ITgirli, did ya' hear 'bout the guy who lost BOTH his legs and BOTH his arms in a farmin' accident, and then he fell into the well?

We just call him........Bob.

by m_a_r_k

ITgirli, are you shaped like a question mark? :D I'm sorry. I'm not laughing at you, I'm trying to laugh with you. I have a license to do that cuz my mom and brother have scoliosis and I have a screwed up spine too. (It's like only a bald guy is allowed to laugh at another bald guy's dome). My mom has to wear a specially-made heel on one shoe so she'll be able to stand straight. As for me, I've had two blown discs inmy neck that are now held together with a titanium plate. Have had a couple of bulging discs in lower back. Last week found I out have two more blown discs in neck that require medical attention. All of these near-death experiences occurred at different times through my own recklessness so I can't complain. Oh, I almost forgot...I've had knee surgery, a broken ankle and torn ligaments in both thumbs. I guess I need to cut back on my daredevillish ways and live an easy life in the suburbs.

by cuteelf

You have done well with yourself: picking up where you fell down and kept going. I myself know thats hard to do.

My friend, on the ohter, hand is not lazy. She literally is unemployable. She's a smart cookie, but with the problems she has, those override/contradict her current skills.
Like, PTSD. Almost dunked someoens head in a fryer for that one. So, no more fast food jobs.
About 6 months ago she was so unstable health/mental wise I was taking her to the ER about 2x a month. I told her myself, I wouldnt hire you- you're smart, but all these make you such a liability, it just contradicts itself.

See, my point in this whole scheme is this:
people say, dont say Poor Me.
Well, the ones needing /wanting help to better themselves need a hand up. To treat these problems costs money. To treat problems will make a person employable.
After treating problem, person is employed.
Person treatED will now contribute to the next person needing help.

I see people whining, yeah. I know there are ones who are moochers, yeah.

But I see people with long term chronic problems, who need "little things"...knee braces..hearing aids...special shoes...and I know some of them are being whiney, but some are still actually needing it. I'll take the goods and the bads all together- karma will get them in the end.

So I help my friend fight for the little things that help her live a better life. I told her about DVR(div. of vocatation rehab) and she was leery..but tried it..she's now going for a ged and planning school after.
I've taken her for so many dr. appts my car has a spot for her :).
I have to speak for her some days, as she CANNOT assert herself to an authoritative figure.
Girly, your view is to help vets, right?
Well, mine is to advocate for handicapped/disabled.

And because we're 2 separate special interest groups (just here), this goes back to Who Gets How Much and Who Gets It First, and How Much Can We Take from Everyone to Give To Some.

How is there a way to even this out?
Is it possible to, oh, deduct X% from ALL WORKING BEINGS, and spread that X EVENLY (not fairly..evenly) between ALL asking?

And push the nonworkings to either:
volunteer their time in a place to assist others
find a job of some sort
up their education to be a better skill set
reduce their bennies by (X-5)% and contribute THAT chunk back to the pool of $$.

We're doing just that.
She babysits.
She's upping the edu.
She may start a business in the next few years, and contribute.
I'm advocating for her.
I've upped my edu
I contribute my taxes back to the pool.

If karma beats me up in this life, its not gonna be for these I've done for her and I.

Cute

by tonythetiger

But there are far more people who "don't want to" than there are those who "genuinely can't". Unfortunately, the government doesn't know how to tell them apart so we end up paying much more than is truly necessary.

There are also those who are in predicaments because of their own voluntary assumption of the risks. I would much rather see public aid for the man who was born with his legs missing or non-working than I would the man who got two broken legs skydiving. The latter should have insured himself against the risk.

by m_a_r_k

I disagree with the part about "the government of the United States does not have the authority to infringe on the rights of an individual person." The govt does have this authority. In some situations, your two premises are opposed to each other. For example, an individual may be raising pigs in his back yard in the middle of a city. he may feel it is right to use his private property as he pleases. The law (not to mention his neighbors) will intervene and remove his pig farm. Another real and recent example that just so happens to also involve private property--a few weeks ago, the Supreme Court upheld, and extended, the rule of eminent domain. As it stands now, federal law allows for any private enterprise to forcibly take ownership of private property if doing so will provide economic benefits and growth to the community as a whole.

by maxwell edison

.
Of course they "do it". My point is that they shouldn't be able to do it. And paraphrasing Yogi Berra, Thomas Jefferson would be rolling in his grave if he was alive today. The recent eminent domain case is a great illustration. There is no constitutional authority that gives the government the right to seize the personal property of one individual so they can give it to another individual. However, I suppose there are five Supreme Court Justices who disagree with me. How would Thomas Jefferson or James Madison have ruled? (And I might also add that money IS ALSO personal property, except to the people who want to justify the practice.)

And by the way, as point of clarification concerning your pig farm scenario. In my metropolitan area we have quite a few ranches and farms right in the middle of the city and/or surrounding suburbs. Their use is "grandfathered" in, and as long as the property is owned by the same family, ranching and/or farming is allowed. But once the title changes hands, the common zoning will apply, and the new owner may not operate such a ranch or farm. So if this guy in your scenario has had his pig farm since he or his family homesteaded the land, then the farm would remain. But if he just all of the sudden wanted to put a pig farm in his 50' x 50' backyard, the zoning ordinances that existed at the time of purchase would have to be enforced. If he wanted a farm, he should have bought a property zoned for farming.

And we also need to make the distinction between federal and local government. I was really talking about the feds.

by m_a_r_k

Well, "shouldn't be able to do it" is a subjective term. In any disagreement, such as those involving eminent domain, each side feels they're rights are being violated if they lose the battle. Regarding constitutional authority, that level of authority exists for a very few of our laws and they are narrowly defined (and most were defined 200+ yrs ago). That is why we have appeals courts and laws enacted by federal, state and local governments. They fill in the gaps. And they have been filling in gaps in numerous ways regarding eminent domain for many years. I may be wrong, but as long as a law does not blatantly go against the constitution, it will be put into place and enforced. Then anyone can sue the govt to try to get the law overturned by the court system.

On the pig farm scenario, it can go the other way too. Laws can and do change. Even if grandfathered in, there is no guarantee that a local govt will not enact a new law that overrides the grandfathered regulation. Two examples that happened near where I live. WalMart "convinced" a city council to give them a special waiver to build a store smack in the middle of a residential district, which overrode the existing zoning laws. You think the neighbors saw that coming when they built expensive homes near there? The Dallas Cowboys football team did the same thing in Irving. They got a waiver to build a 100-ft tall monstrosity of a 150-yd long white building, complete with big blue star painted on the sides, in a residential area (as an indoor practice facility). That eyesore is visible from miles away. You think the neighbors are happy with that surprise? I suppose that whether or not the local laws can suddenly illegalize your currently legal backyard pig farm depends on the local laws about grandfatherization.

I don't necessarily agree with or like the eminent domain law, buy I haven't ever been on the side that wants to take away the land. But I do understand that there are two sides to every coin. Here is an example where eminent domain is affecting me in a hugely negative way. In April, my parents put 100 acres of prime real estate for sale along a major highway five miles from the 3rd largest metropoliatan area in Texas. You can probably guesstimate how much that land is worth. Damn close to six figures. A month later, the local electric utility announced plans to "someday" run high-voltage power lines right smack through the property. Complete with those huge ugly metal towers. Do you think that land is still worth close to six figures? Not only no, but hell no. Can we do a damn thing about? Not much. This isn't just a federal law. When the Supreme Court made their eminent domain decision in June, many states immediately began talk of enacting their own legislation to bypass the fed ruling. I'm not an expert but I'm thinking state and local govt laws can contradict fed laws as long as they aren't in the constitution. I didn't pay attention in my high school Government class.

And finally, you want to make a distinction 'tween federal and local govt. Why? Why are so many people ao fearrful and loathsome of the federal govt? As in the WalMart example, local govts can screw you around too. I don't agree with all the feds do but in general I'm OK with our federal laws. If I weren't, I'd move to Costa Rica or Mozambique. Or if I were a Muslim terrrorist, I suppose I'd blow up a train station. Ten years ago wacko Timothy McVeigh blew up the federal bldg in Oklahoma City and slaughtered 168 mostly law-abiding citizens like you and me simply because he felt the feds were out of control. That's a helluva way to go about changing something when most of McVeigh's fellow citizens apparently did not feel the same way as he did. We too easiy forget that we have a governmentt by, for, and of the people. Seems like if a law seems bad to you or me or anyone else, then it must still meet the approval of at least half the states. Otherwise, it would hopefully and eventually be overturned (by constitutional amendment if necessary).

by absolutely

"The govt does have this authority."

Show me what US law supports your conclusion. You won't find it in the Constitution. You won't be able to defend your citation if you consider the Constitution. I'll bet you what's left of your guarantees of life and liberty!

by m_a_r_k

Well, I dropped out of law school before I ever even thought of applying but I am sure there are thousands of cases. Read my other post where my family's rights as a landowner are likely to be violated in favor of some other bigger, richer taxpayer's rights. Here is a CNN article about eminent domain: http://www.cnn.com/2005/LAW/06/24/scotus.property/

And the constition DOES NOT contain every federal law or regulation. If it did, what do you think the Congress would do? The legislative branch makes laws, the judicial branch interprets laws and the executive branch enacts laws.

by ippirate

In an effort to assist you in your limited ability to grasp this finer point of conversation, please allow me to direct you to the small fact that I was not responding to you. If you will, notice that the thread marker arising from my post attaches immediately to Oz's and not your's. This means that I was commenting to Oz, who, I notice, you haven't found the gumption to respond to, only mine. Perhaps that detail escapes you.

Now, in later responses I will address the remainder of your ignorant and superficial post. Please take note that I will be primarily focusing on your asinine assumptions. Humorous, you raise several issues that I haven't said a word about, could this mean that your soft belly is already showing? Fine and well, we will see. For your own benefit, it would be to you advantage to go back and study the questions and points that I put forth to you the last time that we went around about this topic.
Of course, I fully expect you to shirk them again, just as you have before, but we will see.

All the same, thank you for reinforcing my statement concerning you and smear tactics, I hear that MoveOn.org is hiring that skillset. Of course, that would mean that you would have to climb out of that Republican blanky you snuggle into each night. That's just as well, you wouldn't be missed, most of us are sick of toting your dead weight.
All the same, I'll reply as I get time. I fully expect you to begin your diatribe now on how I always act and what I do, those followed with the threat to take your ball and go play with someone that doesn't challenge you to qualify and justify the half-wit spurge you pour on the rest of us. Of course, perhaps this time you'll actually set a record and disappear before it even gets going. It's okay to run away max, I'm getting quite used to it, that's why I didn't bother responding to your post to begin with. Ooops, gotta go, I think I hear the Reds comin' Pa!

by absolutely

"Must have hit it pretty close to the mark to get her all riled up like that, eh Chewie?"

Han Solo, Episode # who cares?

by absolutely

2. You resorted to the usual -- and predictable -- ploy of lumping everyone who is on the receiving end of such transfer of wealth programs as being "without". That's a grossly exaggerated suggestion. Did you know, for example, that Warren Buffet (and millions like him, albeit not quite as wealthy) is the beneficiary of various transfer of wealth programs? That means that some poor schmuck who's making $15 an hour, or $12 an hour, or $10 an hour, or even $7 an hour, is having money taken out of his paycheck each and every month so that it can be paid to Warren Buffet, and others like him, as some sort of payment for some sort of program. And the cost of his goods and services is higher so that even more taxes can be collected, only to be transferred to Warren Buffet, and others like him -- including Ted Kennedy, the "champion" of the little guy?

This is the Trump card! It proves that the old bromide about absolute power applies equally to schemes disguised in the pretense of "generosity" as to any other pretense used to advance a wish for unearned influence. [Edit: It's also what is likely to convince "generous" types who think that wealth transfer "helps" anybody. I am skeptical that anybody who understands the dynamics will have the patience to explain it to the voters that don't, but I do think the shenanigans you outline above are the most persuasive argument to people who are not already convinced of free market principles, aka, most people.]

Enron deserves mention as well [i]de[/i]-regulation is often mentioned in [i]myopic[/i], journalistic accounts of the Enron bankruptcy scandal because of their temporal proximity. What is ignored is that the players in the energy market were determined previously, during the era of regulation. So Kenneth Lay and all the other crooks stepped into a situation where people [i]were not surprised[/i] by the excessive price of energy; similar fluctuations had occurred in recent memory. But there was no real competition, and the scandal was not more blatantly obvious sooner because private price-fixing bears such close resemblance to governmental price-fixing.

[Edit: changed the title because I'm not sure the original expression means what I thought.]

by maxwell edison

.
My forefathers already did that a couple of hundred years ago, and all I want is to live under the same set of rules that were intended. And if "America" was the last bastion of freedom two hundred years ago, then there's no place left on the face of the earth where a person could possibly go. It might be more plausible to suggest that any and all "collectivist type" thinkers go somewhere else, because virtually every other nation on earth believes in collectivism (and/or oppression) to one degree or another; and America was supposed to be a refuge from such oppression, and/or was intended to provide an individual the opportunity to escape from it. And just because one person may have, what might be considered, insurmountable obstacles in achieving the things they desire, it's not justification enough to deny others the opportunities they strive for. Moreover, our Constitution guarantees the freedom to pursue happiness, not to achieve it. It guarantees equality of opportunity, not equality of outcome.

"Should (you) NOT contribute to people who need it?", you ask?

Well, only you can answer that. If you feel so compelled, as I do, then certainly you should contribute, as I do. But you should contribute how you see fit, not as some faceless bureaucrat sees fit, not as some other citizen sees fit, and not as I see fit. What if I were to say to you, for example, to GIVE three-fourths of your income to the "cause"? (Define "the cause" however you'd like.) What gives me the right, you might ask. Well, what gives you the right, I might ask? You define contributing to the needy as you see fit, and you should give others the same consideration.

"Should (you) hold (your) money back and only distribute it to people (you) deem worthy," you ask?

Yes, of course; that's absolutely true. The alternative is that you distribute it to people that OTHERS deem worthy.

That, "smacks of snobbery", you say?

Well, what is more "snobbish"? Defining the "worthy people" for yourself, or defining "worthy people" for others? In my estimation, it's the snob who suggests to others how they should live their lives, and it's the tolerant who will simply live and let live.

You said, "Life isn't fair, true; but who said that one person has to bear all of the weight? Its distributed equally."

Oh how wrong that is. Society should not be dragged down to the lowest common denominator. Are you suggesting that we all suffer equally? Are you suggesting that we should all have equal outcome? How about this. You earn $1,000; and I earn $500. You send me $250, and we'll all be even. That, my friend, is a sure recipe for mutual destruction.

"Greed and competition would grow", you suggest?

Well, I suggest to you that greed and corruption is literally running amok in the current transfer of wealth system. And if you call it greedy for an individual to want to take self-responsibility, I think you need to reassess your way of thinking. It's the "greedy" who want something that doesn't belong to them, not the ones from whom it's taken. (Sorry, 7-11 clerk. Don't be "greedy". Give me your money.)

You said that I've "had the chance to vote no. So, shut (my) trap."

That's interesting, to say the least. There were people who voted no, women should not have the right to vote. There were people who voted no, blacks were not entitled to anything. There were people who voted no, people didn't have a right to tip a cold beer. And those NO votes defined the law of the land for decades. Perhaps you think the people on the other side of those issues should have just "shut their trap" as well?

Personally speaking, I'm glad they didn't. Because, thanks to the "worm food", Mr. Madison, we've come to accept the notion that the oppression of the majority is just like a snake -- it doesn't have a leg to stand on.

Here's my deal. I won't presume to tell you how to live, and you don't presume to tell me how to live. What can possibly be wrong with that? And I won't force you to contribute to "my causes", and you don't force me to contribute to "your causes". Again, what can possibly be wrong with that? Go ahead, try to convince me all you want. You might even win me over. But don't try to force me.

The bottom line is this. I can live my desired life without infringing on you; but you can't possibly live your desired life without infringing on me. And it is you who presumes to tell another person how he or she should live, how he or she should "care", and even how he or she should think. Now tell us again, who's the snob?

by jck

in about 30-50 years, go 350 miles south of Guam...I hear there is a mountain growing underwater there...should be ready for your retirement time...

claim stake to it, man!!!! it's your chance to pioneer!!! Be the next Joseph Smith or Jim Jones!!!! hahahaa :D

by absolutely

Also, there is exactly one correct answer to any question of fact, while the set of incorrect answers is infinite!

by m_a_r_k

However in legal cases there are too many facts get muddled and contradict one another. Then personal feelings and values come into play. That is why nominations for Supreme Court are such a political battle.

by absolutely

"However in legal cases there are too many facts get muddled and contradict one another."

There is an important principle for dealing with the appearance of contradiction: reality, by its nature, does not permit contradictions, because reality is real and cannot be contrary to itself. The appearance of contradiction is [i]always[/i] a result of misinterpreting observations according to faulty premises. The answer is [i]always[/i] "check your premises". One or more will [i]always[/i] be found in error.

"Then personal feelings and values come into play."

True. Is that as it should be? Is there something that can be done?

"That is why nominations for Supreme Court are such a political battle."

Is that the only reason?

by absolutely

"And the constition DOES NOT contain every federal law or regulation."

The Constitution was created to [i]define the parameters[/i] of all subsequent laws. Its purpose is to forbid any number of the citizens -- even the vast majority -- from violating the "inalienable rights" of any other group, even the smallest minority, the individual.

by m_a_r_k

You may be right though I can't see anything in the Constitution that explicitly states its reason for existence. And I can't find anything in the document about "inalienable" rights. It's a thought-provoking question though. Made me glance over the Constitution for the first time since junior high school.
http://www.usconstitution.net/const.html
http://www.usconstitution.net/const.html#Amends

The Bill of Rights might give us our inalienable rights but they aren't even part of the original document. And the other 17 amendments (I'm not Roman but XXVII minus X = 17, I think) that have been tacked on after that aren't necessarily our inalienable rights, are they? Is it my inalienable right to be forced to pay federal income taxes (amendment 16)? The "manufacture, sale, or transportation of intoxicating liquors" was outlawed then relegalized. Which is my inalienable right? From 1919 to 1933, why couldn't someone whip up moonshine in the privacy of his own home?

by absolutely

Also, the first ten Amendmenst (the Bill of Rights) were ratified at the same time, December 15, 1791. Finally, the tenth of those clearly states that all powers (to govern the citizens) that had not -- at that time! -- been granted to the federal government, were to remain the [i]rights[/i] of citizens, or to be regulated only by the states, but never by the federal government.

Beginning with Amendment 11, the rights previously granted to individuals have been revoked, beginning with the right to redress of grievances, when such grievances are committed by another of the United States than the victim's residence.

by m_a_r_k

Are you a philospher or an IT guy? I'm still trying to decode your 1st paragraph. :D

>"Personal feelings..."
True. Is that as it should be? Is there something that can be done?<

I'd like to say NO to the first question but what are you supposed to do when they're is no strict past interpreation of a law or a judgement you can rely on? I doubt if, in most cases, any appeals court judge is 100% for the side for which he/she decided on. So personal feelings have to come into play. I hope its not other motivations but you never know. Judges are human too.

>"That is why nominations for Supreme Court are such a political battle."
Is that the only reason?<

No. But it seems to me that it's the biggest issue. Look at all the talk about John Roberts political beliefs. He's a bit to the right side of moderative conservative. Sandra Day O'Connor was an enimgmatic in-the-middle moderate. The Democrats are severely worried that many on-the-fence issues will have a conservative outcome. That's just about all the pundits have talked about. Not race, religion, age or gender. I'm a white male but I personally would have liked this nominee to be female and/or of a minority race to add some balance and to give a more representative "of the people" thinking to their decisions. Diversity is a very important aspect of decision making.

by maxwell edison

.
You have absolutely no idea how much of my time and money I literally give to others. I'm reluctant to say such things, for obvious reasons, since "beating one's own drum" is rather distasteful to me. But you are coming across as though I'm the scourge of the earth, which couldn't be further from the truth. And, quite frankly, that's the very reason so many remain silent -- they don't want to "appear" to be, or be accused of being uncaring. I give my time; I give my money; and I give much more.

I truly believe that you and your friend, and others like you, could be BETTER off without government dependence than with it. I see too many caring people who simply wouldn't let such things happen. My mother is well over 90. When she's unable to care for herself, I'll care for her. The alternative is that I put her in some home, and let other people care for her. (And such "care" as defined by them.)

Sorry, you have me pegged all wrong. You are addressing a very caring and a very compassionate person. I just believe that caring and compassion is an individual issue, not a government issue. Moreover, I believe that when government takes over the "compassion department", that even MORE people magically become "needy", and all the more fall through the cracks. And it's much too easy for people to say, someone else is taking care of it. Quite frankly, I believe the "compassionate left" is anything but. They all suffer from the "someone else is taking care of it" syndrome, at least most of them.

Give me the benefit of the doubt, here. And consider that I might want to help MORE people, and in a MORE significant way. And if that's true, what then?

by cuteelf

You want your way of doing things..thats fine.

I just am vehemently against "undoing" any welfare systems in the fear that my friend, who was born with so many problems..would not be able to have a decent life.

I see people out there, disabled, mentally ill, handicapped: who work their asses off and are happy to do so. The people THANKFUL to be working are usually the ones who contribute the most to the other people in need. I see those handi-working people giving back to the ones like them. Like a batch of kids w/ Down's syndrome, a few work here in fast food places, and have a home/apartment. They still have some assistance for living, and are very thankful for that. They're also more vocal for programs that assist needy/elderly/handicapped.

I'm also apprehensive of revamping, because, well, you know what? The people that DONT contribute and are UNABLE to contribute, need the help. Like, lets say, my friend.
She is unable to work at the moment. No employable skills. The skills she DOES have are contradicted by her handicapps. She's literally stuck. She's the one who makes no money and pays no taxes. She is the one who needs money from your taxes.

I'm saying there are people out there in our country who are unable/impaired and they deserve the same quality of life as a working person does.
Not the EXACT same thing...no no..I dont think a person driving a BMW should be mandated to give a BMW to a person like my friend.
But food, shelter, clothing and a chance at education, to get OUT from this.

I'm not on this stuff. I dont want to be, because you have to be under a certain line to get in, and I'm past that atm, making piddle wage as it is. Doing computer related jobs.

I will take time out of my day, though, to help the people who are handicapped and stuck, but trying to get somewhere. I take my friend out for "getting out". I take her shopping and buy her clothes. A guy @ school was in a wheelchair and paraplegic; he couldnt afford PC help, so I gave it to him free. (I charged students a lower rate than shop rate).

Here in AK we have a problem with homeless people who are panhandling, on the corners. Literally holidng a cardboard sign asking I NEED MONEY NEED FOOD.
I do not give these people money. Because I see them drinking it. I see the people standing, pooling their moneys together, and splitting a few fifths. Not eating nutrition (they had to walk through a grocery store to get to the liquor) or purchasing new clothes to get a job. They drink it.

This is another reason why I'll let programs/associations/orgs do the handing out. Its controlled so that people like the homeless drinkers dont go rampant.
One day I bought too much at Taco Bell, and was at an intersection. I asked the homeless guy@ the corner; Hey, you want a burrito? I got an extra one. He said sure. Took it, put it on his backpack, and stood with the sign, waiting for money from the next car.

I got mad.

Why? I'm helping this man, eat something...he wants money. Gah. Fine.
So, I give to food banks, I give to my EFA, I give my effort and help to my friend. At the same time, I know that someone else is getting a few pennies off my dollar, and someone is getting paid at least a buck or two for work. hey..it's all good.

Max: so far, I dont think you're scourge. I think you're WAYYYYYYWRONG in wanting to undo welfare, because my friend needs food/clothes/education.
And that she's entitled to a better quality of life than she would have without being on fs/medicade. Show me exactly WHAT you would do to GUARANTEE to MEET OR EXCEED the current quality of life for people- and be equal to all- and i wont yell.

cute

by jck

I don't want to incur your wrath...but...I have to ask one thing:

Should your friend be *guaranteed* an education? i.e.- be guaranteed the right to pursue a college degree?

Last I heard, you had to earn college entrance.

I think your friend should be given assistance in doing for herself as best she can...however, I don't think she should be *given* the right to pursue things such as higher education without having to establish the same basic competence to enter a university like any other student.

Otherwise, her treatment would *not* be equal to able-bodied students.

Remember your words: "...and be equal to all..."

That means not only should she be treated the same as any other applicant, but that she should receive no special favors above those for which she would compete for entrance to a college because of her physical impairment.

On second thought, maybe I do want to incur your wrath...it'd be nice to be picked on by someone cute for a change ;)

by absolutely

"A guy @ school was in a wheelchair and paraplegic; he couldnt afford PC help, so I gave it to him free. (I charged students a lower rate than shop rate)."

Lots of people do things like that. But being [i]forced[/i] to pay a higher percentage of their wages than ever before makes people less able and less willing to help the people they see in need near them.

Taxes have increased as a percentage of GDP, steadily for about 100 years now. There are occasional reductions, but always followed by later increases that exceed the reductions. With all the technological advancments, and in particular with all the automation, making it possible for people with very limited mobility to be as productive as anybody else by using their [i]minds[/i], how is it possible that need as compared to production has increased to justify the increase in taxes?

"Show me exactly WHAT you would do to GUARANTEE to MEET OR EXCEED the current quality of life for people- and be equal to all- and i wont yell."

I would not be equal to all, I would be [i]fair[/i], which means that the drunks you ignore would also be ignored by the welfare system. They would not get special treatment -- a night in jail to "sober up", they'd be treated like criminals if they committed a crime, and like garbage if they die in a ditch.

Your friends would not have to rely on a system that treats such waste as their "equals".

by absolutely

"I give to charities also, but when doing so, I make sure that not too much goes to the executives and marketing."

When you give to charities, what percentage is your standard? Is it identical to the standard you use in the case the taxes I pay?

"If you make X $, and govt takes Y%..."

Suppose for the sake of discussion that X<=$20,000. What is a fair value of Y? Why?

by absolutely

And I'm sorry if that first paragraph was unclear. To clarify:

[i]Real facts[/i] cannot contradict one another. Facts can contradict a person's [i]impressions or beliefs[/i], aka their premises, but contradictory [i]facts[/i] do not exist. They never have and they never will. So whenever facts [i]seem[/i] to contradict what you think you know, the logical first step is to question what you think you know. "Check your premises". I'm sorry for quoting from Atlas Shrugged, some others who know me already won't be surprised, and if they were confused, they would just flip through that book!

[b]"Personal feelings..."
True. Is that as it should be? Is there something that can be done?<

I'd like to say NO to the first question but what are you supposed to do when they're is no strict past interpreation of a law or a judgement you can rely on?[/b]

Before all else fails, consider principles.

[b]I doubt if, in most cases, any appeals court judge is 100% for the side for which he/she decided on.[/b]

You know the exact nature of the internal [i]conflict[/i] that you mean here. I could speculate that a judge's emotions conflict with their mind, or that their personal beliefs conflict with what they know about their duties to uphold the principles of the Constitution and their jurisdiction. Whatever personal turmoil you have in mind for these hypothetical appeals court judges, does it truly require this:

[b/]So personal feelings have to come into play.[/b]

The United States is built on principle, not whims.

[b]>"That is why nominations for Supreme Court are such a political battle."
Is that the only reason?<

No. But it seems to me that it's the biggest issue. Look at all the talk about John Roberts political beliefs. He's a bit to the right side of moderative conservative. Sandra Day O'Connor was an enimgmatic in-the-middle moderate. The Democrats are severely worried that many on-the-fence issues will have a conservative outcome. That's just about all the pundits have talked about. Not race, religion, age or gender. I'm a white male but I personally would have liked this nominee to be female and/or of a minority race to add some balance and to give a more representative "of the people" thinking to their decisions. Diversity is a very important aspect of decision making.[/b]

I do not know very much about John Roberts. He does not have a very distinguished record. Are pundits unable to notice that, or are they just too cynical to raise the more conspicuous point: exactly why is this man nominated when he has so little on his resume? He has made very few challenging decisions, so it is very obvious [i]to me[/i] to wonder whether there are many more qualified candidates, who do have substantial records to analyze.

by jck

It'd be nice if we all got to keep every penny we made. However, that government which you say has no right to infringe on your rights is established to take part of your money to maintain the country and "promote the general welfare".

Is it realistic to stop all social programs? Hell no. Otherwise, you'd have rioting and what not.

Now, let's define something you've brought up: rights of an individual person.

What are these rights? What delineates "infringment" upon those rights? Is it taking your money from your check? Is it claiming right of way to your land to build a highway? Is it giving police the power to yell "Police!" and half a second later bash down your door because they got a tip that you sell drugs? Can you delineate legally how taking money out of your check is an infringement on your rights when it is totally legal under law, US tax codes, etc?

I believe you're guaranteed the right to "Life, liberty, and the *pursuit* of happiness." No one every guaranteed your happiness or your satisfaction of the government establishment.

In your point 1, you advocate the abolishment of the practice of "Taking a dollar from the person who earned it, so it can be given to a person who did not earn it...". Well, that would cause the downfall of your government. That is, in idealistic terms, a treasonous suggestion.

And that infringing act you want to abolish is called *taxation*, and it is totally legal. There are legal tax codes on the books which establish them. It is the Congress' duty to duly budget those monies collected into programs which are established under law to fund them.

And whether you know it or not, you are a recipient (in one form or another) of that "infringement" on someone else's rights. You benefit, like all other Americans, from the aggregate monies collected by the government system.

As for Madison's quote: It was focused in 1792 at the expenditure of $15,000 to assist French refugees...not those used to fund the "general welfare" of American citizens. Since then, the constitution has been amended, under law, to allow such expenditures...so, even they are now *legal*.

Jefferson's quote was actually this:
"Whereas, our tenet ever was, and, indeed, it is almost the only landmark which now divides the federalists from the republicans, that Congress had not unlimited powers to provide for the general welfare, but were restrained to those specifically enumerated; and that, as it was never meant they should provide for that welfare but by the exercise of the enumerated powers, so it could not have been meant they should raise money for purposes which the enumeration did not place under their action; consequently, that the specification of powers is a limitation of the purposes for which they may raise money."

He's basically saying...Congress doesn't control the money (and the discretion of spending it) for everything, and the specification of their powers is the tool to limit how they might tax and how they might spend those monies.

Ben Franklin also said: "The Constitution only gives people the right to pursue happiness. You have to catch it yourself."

As for your last two quotes: Go tell Congress. They've passed the laws violate your rights.

I, for one, am more for the type of life that existed in Jamestown, Virginia in the 17th century. If you were able bodied and refused to work, you didn't eat unless your family gave you a hand-out. If you were infirmed, your family took care of you. If your family couldn't, then relatives and friends and neighbors helped.

Nowadays, we pussy-foot around and dole out money to those "poor, helpless souls" on the streets without insisting they work to support themselves. We're raising a nation of people more exhaustively that is condemned to a life of contentment in mediochrity and stagnation.

I can see having social programs to help those who can *not* do for themselves. But, I see these homeless guys who can ride a bike 30 miles a day to go beg. In my opinion, let them be bike messengers. You know they have the ability. Or let them deliver paper routes. But, letting them stand on a corner to collect a welfare check is absurd.

BTW...did I mention I'm back? :D

by jdclyde

It was how much of what is take is used.

Yes, taxes are neccesary to take care of the things our government was empowered to do. The problem is, the government has taken on more than it has any legal authority to do so.

When Bill Clinton was cooking the books claiming a surplus (turns out it wasn't) people acted like it was a good thing. The government is a non-profit organization and is not allowed to make a profit. They can take money as needed for what government is intended, and anything over that is an over taxation and not legal.

My tax dollars should go to infrastructure and defense. General welfare was never intended to mean support. Social programs were never part of the intended government and are not supported by the constitution.

Anytime the government is in charge of running something, there is great waste and inefficincy. A government run healthcare system would be better than medicad is now? You know better than that. More people on it would mean it would run even worse. Not a system I ever want to be a part of.

by jck

that it is an infringement on individual rights to take money one man earns and give it to another who didn't earn it. That is *exactly* what taxes are in every sense. Your taxes pay for welfare, medicaid, medicare, low-income housing, etc., on a daily basis in some small part.

Evidently so far, it isn't legally an infringment on rights. No one has sued to overturn it and proven their case, and it is legal for Congress to expend that money by Congressional enactment.

Like I've said many times...if you don't like how the government works, vote out the smilin-jack crooks and put someone in there that has actually had to work for a living rather than taking the handouts from the corporate bigwigs or their rich families.

BTW...I don't believe in handing out money to able-bodied people for nothing either...at a minimum, I believe they should be placed in work to get the check...whether it's picking up trash on a highway, cleaning a toilet, being a mail messenger, etc.

Protecting the general welfare of the country is a duty of our government, but it should not be one that is given carte blanche...per Jefferson's quote. The laws that define Congress' power should also be what limits its power...i.e.- to tax and spend among many other things.

But to make a blanket statement that the collection of tax revenues ( or as it was phrased, taking a dollar from a man who earned it, and giving it to a man who did not) to improve the country (whether in providing jobs, housing assistance, medical assistance, etc) and it's "general welfare" is an infringement on your rights because you're not getting every dime you pay in back is just absurd.

I'd worry more about the abuse of Congress spending millions on pork barrel projects rather than how much they spend trying to house the poor and elderly.

by m_a_r_k

You are right about John Roberts. Very little experience as a judge. Only a couple of years. I read a news article a few days ago that said this is the ideal type of candidate. With a short history in dishing out verdicts, critics (and liberals in this case) have less ammo to use against him.

"Atlas Shrugged" -- I heard that is an excellent book. Destined to be a classic. I want to read it one of these days. Haven't had the time yet.

by m_a_r_k

In general I have no problem with income taxes because we all benefit to one degree or another from them. At times we as indivduals benefit more. At other times we benefit less. However, social security taxes are where I have a real problem.. That is the primo case of taking from me to beneift someone else. I've worked my ass to get a good education, to get good jobs that pay relatively well, invest in my retirement and manage my finances with common sense. Why should 13% of my income go to the lazy foolish schmucks who can't do any of those simple things?

by jdclyde

to want to put 2% into an account that will do something other than support the current pyramid SCHEME?

Democrats solution to "fix" the solvency of SS is to raise taxes, cut benifits, and raise the age of retirement. None of these three are a working solution and it takes a dolt to go along with it.

SS will not be solvent when/if I retire unless it is overhauled. It is too hot of a topic that too few understand for Dems to want it fixed. I remember in the 80's people saying SS was in trouble, and nothing has been done to do anything to CHANGE a system that can not sustain it's self.

by m_a_r_k

>>I remember in the 80's people saying SS was in trouble, and nothing has been done to do anything to CHANGE a system that can not sustain it's self.<<

Just like the oil crises we occasionally have. Lots of talk about what to do to fix the problem, but then no action. We won't have any action until the last of the Baby Boomers retires and finds out the previous 20 years of Boomers sucked the SS account dry. Then it will be too late.

by m_a_r_k

Try topping this! I went to the dentist last week and I found out I have a cavity that needs a filling. ;)

by jdclyde

I found out the video card on my play system is burning up and will need to be replaced! (it should still be under warranty).

Ok, bad example. I really don't have much to complain about. My family (what is left of it) is healthy and happy. My dog is healing up nicely. Internet porn is still free (if you know where to look) and I have a case of beer in the fridge and I go to Ozzfest in two daze.

Really could use more of my money right about now to pay for my lawyer. Will also get screwed on applying for finacial aid for finishing up college as my income will be based off the joint income that is no longer available. "sorry, you make too much for us to spend any of YOUR money on YOU. That is just for people that don't work."

by m_a_r_k

The A/C and the radio in one of my two autos don't work! I can get by without a radio. But it sometimes get a tad warm down here in Texas and we cool folks here like to stay cool, so we need to use the A/C. So I have to drive my 3-year old pickup every day in the summer instead of my 12-year Explorer. Damnit!

by itgirli

I was making the point that everyone has problems. You never have anything worthwhile to add, do you?

by jck

your rant about fat ass relatives added anything?

Why don't you go jump their asses instead of CuteElf's. She's not the one making them lazy...and you're not helping them by telling someone else they're lazy.

Christ...pot calls the kettle black again...news at 11.

by jdclyde

he agreed on the premis of government taxing for what it is intended to do.

It is the excess money that is leached off that is the point of contention.

No one will get rid of the pork or social programs because it would not be popular. There are just too many people with their hands out making it political suicide to do the right thing.

Years ago our governer Engler took a lot of flack for it but he did cut the able-bodied assistance. He didn't touch ADC (adult and dependant children), just the people that ARE able to work that up until that point some scumbag had setup this general welfare program to just hand out money. It is called buying votes from the peasent class that is intentionally created by the public educational system.

In NY, Guliani cleaned up the streets by making hard decisions and coming down hard on crime. When is the last time we say anything like that in Congress or the Senate?

When redistribution of wealth is an intended goal, it is wrong and stupid. When we hear "it isn't FAIR they have so much while these other people have so little". Let the people that have so little put in the hours that the people that have so much put in. Your average EXEC puts in 60 to 80 hours a week. When is the last time you was a "poor" person put in that kind of time EVERYWEEK? People advance or fail based on their effort or lack of it.

How many "poor" people do you know that own a cell phone? Cable tv? Multiple Tvs? At least one car in the household? Eat out SEVERAL times a week?

Yes, I have always maintained that there really are SOME that need HELP. But it should never be a free ride for anyone. There are always parks that need to be cleaned, slum neighborhoods that could be cleaned, painted, renovated. If you are paying people, get benifit for the "general welfare" out of that by making them do something to earn their keep.

redistribution of wealth is not a justifiable endevor.

by jck

Yeah right...I regularly saw executives from Directors to the CEO of the places I used to work leaving regularly at noon and not returning because they were going to "host some perspective clients"...which meant, they were taking other businessmen golfing as a tax write-off.

Private company owners might put in that kind of time, but very few above the director level in a corporation put in more than 50 hours in a week of dedicated work, i.e.- golf, lunches, driving time, flight time, dinners and drinking at the hotel bar don't count as work.

As for the "People advance or fail based on their effort or lack of it."...I can tell you, that's absolute bulls**t. I've worked my ass off all my life working from the time I was in elementary school. The people who have been related to someone, kissed enough ass, or backstabbed have jumped the ladder over me. I've had to go job-to-job to move up the ladder.

I don't know what country you live in, man. But, I can attest...working your ass off...very VERY rarely gets you anywhere in the hierarchy anymore. You gotta kiss ass, step on someone, or be related to or marry someone's child to get up the ladder.

I hope your company has let you work your way up. That'd be a big change from where I've been before...if I stay where I am, I'll see if they promote me in about 10-12 years when my boss retires. If not, I'll stick it out here and retire early with 25 years of service and start fixing PCs for a living.

BTW...I worked for well over a year doing better than 60 hours a week...and I was salary...and I got no bonus compensation like executives do. So, I was a poor guy working 60-80 hour weeks...when the executives were home on the weekends in their $2M-9M houses on Tortoise Island, FL., or out "working" on the golf course or at the Black Lotus restaurant by taking out "perspective clients" as a "business expense" and getting a bigger tax refund from it.

by jdclyde

I do not subscribe to the notion of if I do a job well enough you will promote me out of that job and into a different job that I don't know.

I found a "job" where I make a decent wage to support my boys and myself that I ENJOY doing. If I "advance" I would spend my time in meetings that put me to sleep instead of playing with all the cool toys.

Making it. Make a decent wage that you can live off of. I didn't say everyone would be rich. Most people just WANT too much and so what they do get is never enough to make them happy.

I get tackled when I get home by two 13 year old boys yelling "DAD" every night. I am a very wealth man, based on what I feel is important.

And I DO see people in upper management put in the long hours regularly.

And I do see mostly sales and marketing taking clients golfing or on trips or whatever. Looks fun until you see they do this all the time starting at 7am and don't finish until after dinner with a client. How much do you think they ENJOY going out to eat on their time off? How much time are they getting to spend with their kids? Not a trade-off I am willing to make, even if they do get to play more golf. Golf without my boys isn't nearly as fun anyways.

by absolutely

I wonder how many of those 60-80 hours per week were productive, jck. You seem to have a great deal of knowledge of the time worked by executives, which a "poor guy" would have no opportunity to meet.

It was said that "People advance or fail based on their effort or lack of it." Does effort to get along with people count? Effort to lure prospective clients -- even holding meetings in surroundings those prospective clients find conducive to the type of conversations that happen there -- is still work.

Just because some people don't resent what they are doing does not mean they are not working. The measure of work is not dislike of the task, it is [i]productivity[/i]. If more is produced after the president of my company brokers a deal to purchase a company that makes related but not competing products, and the result is a single company that is stronger and better able to compete in the general software market, I have an increased probability of being moved from temporary to permanent employment, because that acqusition made the whole organization more [i]productive[/i].

If the execs enjoyed the negotiations, and holding some part of those negotiations on a golf course helped that happen, I have no complaints. I like what I do. I don't like golf. I would rather leave that distasteful chore to somebody else who minds it less or wants the money and status more.

by absolutely

Some of them -- abuse -- are within the federal government's charter. The rest are not.

The power of government is the power to coerce, a power that is necessary for the sometimes-violent work of "keeping the peace". But [i]there is no armed resistance against charity work![/i] There never has been. There is no justification for using the power of government to enable transfers to assist people except as punishment for crimes.

by maxwell edison

.
Since I would be KING of my own country, I would hereby bequeath to all citizens of my country, the following:

1. You have the right free speech. You also have the right to get pissed off because somebody else might say something that you don't like. But that's just too friggin' bad. You have the right to just deal with it.

2. You have the right to keep and bear arms.....and legs.....and necks.....and fingers.....and heads.....and whatever else suits your fancy.

3. You have the right to earn, own and keep your property. But you don't have the right to take somebody else's property.

4. You have the right to take full and total self-responsibility. You also have the right to not do that, but you then have the right to die.

........I should give this some thought. We might be onto something, here.

by montgomery gator

If we were to start a new country, and that was your platform. However, since you want to be King, that reminds me of the saying "Absolute power corrupts absolutely", so what would guarantee you would continue to rule wisely, item #2?

by Member 25348569

That's the UK and the US together again. Let's face it, if you're successful it will show up both of our current governments.

We won't have to justify it to the UN, either, because I'm pretty sure that [b]you[/b] won't join!

:D

by maxwell edison

.
I'll be the 21st century version of The Mouse That Roared.

That way those stupid Americans will be paying taxes so that I can get foreign aid.

But before you invade, just be sure to pack the beer.

by jdclyde

because after the accident (minor) the AC would have run me about $800 to get going again.

So now I am FORCED to ride in my Concorde with the climate control.

do you know how hard it is to carry four sets of golf clubs in a Concorde instead of a pickup? Now we have to drive carts when we golf because there isn't room for the pull carts in the trunk! Woe always me....

by jck

injured in the same accident...they found him in a pile of hay...called him Russell.

by jck

who had a heart attack raking leaves...fell into the pile...they found him 2 months later...

His name was Pete...

by montgomery gator

Tried to get into the house after the accident, but did not make it inside. Found him lying in front of the door.

His name was Matt.

by absolutely

I don't get that one. Oh, rustle the hay. Well, screw it, I already started typing so I'm just going to submit.

by m_a_r_k

Wow that IS bad! Ok how about this one? My neighbor is from Iraq and I think he might be a terrorist because, like all monsters, "he's such a quiet, friendly chap". Hell, he's likely to blow up the neighborhood any day now. If suddenly I disappear from TR, you'll know that my suspicions have been confirmed.

by jck

I started out as a "programmer"...I've been a " computer programmer"...a "software engineer"...an "implementation analyst"...now I'm "senior programmer"...even was a "section head" when I was 27 years old in my hometown (small pond).

And besides that, my supervisor is not a hands-off meeting-only type of guy. He does programming and tech work and the lot just like the rest of us in the department.

Fact is, I never said I wanted to be a CEO. I said I wanted to climb the ladder, not take the elevator to the penthouse.

But, I could never have stayed at any of my previous companies and been a senior tech, senior programmer, or senior analyst. They all wanted the smooch-ass, backstabbers that could smile good and be "yes men" to be the "senior engineers". I guess asskissers write better code in the corporate world.

I'm the same as you with respect to family and moreover people in general.

I was once the computer services section head at an old job. I told the woman working for me (who'd been there 13 years) "You probably know my job better than I do. I'm not going to even try to pretend I know more than you do here." I'm not pious because of my title...I like to work *with* people...not against them. I let her know as long as she had her work done...I didn't care if she left an hour early to go get her kids. She was salary and that meant she was to do her job for an amount of money...not punch a clock. I made sure my employee knew that family was first...not the job.

Anyways, I am not talking about going from the gutter to the penthouse...I'm talking about getting moved up within your respective field. I've had no promotion at a job since 1995. Every other job I was at they left me in the position with the same title the whole time.

I'd figured by now you'd have realized I wasn't all about the big paycheck. If I get it...I'll earn it...or I will win the lotto.

And if I win the lotto...I'll be posting here from either Ireland, North Carolina, Florida, Australia or Texas.

Screw Fiji...too many mosquitoes! :D

by jck

Hmmm...let's see...

I single-handedly saved the project from ruin (like its sister project ended up tanking) because I was (toward the end) working around 85 hours a week to make sure it came through. I got no bonus. The bitch (and...she was a lying bitch) manager got a $15,000 bonus because it got finished on schedule.

On the project before that, my ideas for a specific analytical communication technology scored a combined total of over $7M for the IR&D project...my stuff alone...from 3 interested "customers" who wanted fund continuation of the tech researched for their own purposes and projects (yes...I used to work for a government contractor in "black box" projects). I wanted to stay there, but they didn't get the customer funding in time to keep me on, so they had to move me for budget reasons and had already put me on another project.

My work on that project is now part of a software product used by a couple branches of the US military to secure their networks and computers.

So yeah, I've had productive work. A lot more than those club-swinging executives who get a tax write-off for schmoozing with their "perspective client" buddies.

Oh...and...BTW...in my 2+ years at that one company...only about 14-15 months was spent in 60-80 hour weeks, and before that project I was in the same building working in an area that the VPs for 3 sectors were in. So, I got to see them come and go. That's how I knew...especially when I used to regularly see the CEO pull his Ping clubs from the back of his green mercedes sedan and put them in the VP for Comm Systems's silver Jaguar and head toward the beach (which had 2-3 really ritzy courses).

But how I knew for sure what they were doing was when my department secretary (who ends up "adopting" me when I moved to FL) told me what they do according to the executive secretaries who work for the execs.

I'm not saying all execs are lazy, but I can tell you..."most execs" don't put in 60-80 hour weeks. I've seen it in all the corporations I've worked for on a regular basis. Groups of execs getting into the Escalade or Yukon or Land Rover and heading toward the beach. You know they're not going out there for field comms testing because...we had no location out there.

Oh...and as for 7am? I worked for over 2 years...up between 4:30am and 5am every morning...driving 70-90 minutes to work...working 7:30am-4:30pm...then driving 90 minutes back home and not getting home til around 7pm. I know what long days are like. So...big wah for salesmen...like I said before...at least they get bonuses for good performance.

The only ones I feel sorry for are the kids...they had no choice in how non-existent or material their parents might be.

P.S- At least I can see paying the salesmen for bonuses bringing business in...at least they go out and get the work.

by jdclyde

Your not all about the pay check, but your complaining because you haven't recieved a promotion? I don't understand, sorry. Is it about the title?

FACT, the pretty boys and the a$$kissers will climb the ladder quicker than someone that shows up, does there job and then leaves. Nothing wrong with a "little" a$$kissing if it means just being nice to people to get what you want/need.

And there will always be employees that will be taken advantage of by managers (like you have been). Remember they did their job by getting that project done with as low of a cost as possible, so they earned their bonus. The fact that you were willing to go the extra distance so they could achieve THEIR goal only helped THEM.

I started as a programmer using Cobol, for the Y2K rewrite. I then worked into system administration and then into network administration. (note, I added titles, but never let go of the old ones). My current title is "Computer Systems Administrator" because I am the Sys/Net/Securty/Contectivty/Hardware/Software/Training administor. And I love it. Would like my boss's paycheck but not his job.

by cuteelf

doesnt always mean college :)

she's going to finish ged, Yaayyyy (i should loan her my grad robe)
and she's planning a vocational school- massage therapy. Double yaayyyy I'll be a guinea pig for her to beat up on.

So, no college as of yet.

your quote: "That means not only should she be treated the same as any other applicant, but that she should receive no special favors above those for which she would compete for entrance to a college because of her physical impairment."
Are you saying a handicapped person should NOT recieve any assistance for a test?
Like, a blind person. Who needs either braille or a speaking PC to talk to him...is that ok?
Or a person who has no arms- would you give that person some extra time to fill out a test?

I'm not disagreeing, actually.
I think some of the MORE handi'd should have some help..but not a person whispering A B D D A in their ear for a test.
Hey, me, I had no driving at all..I had to specially plan my classes so I could walk, and plan where I lived so I could catch busses. Most of us, when challenged with defective hardware or software :P will either create drivers for it or replace as needed. I had to be creative.

I saw a kid who was paralyzed from neck down. He has to have someone change diapers on him, carry his school books, wipe his drool :) and he still is doing ok in highschool. He has a person with him 24/7. Is this a person who should not have any leeway in testing/classes?

What do you think? I'm curious.

Cute

by jdclyde

You see someone flashing around and call that lazy. That flashy lazy person generally brings in more money for the company in a month than you earn in a year. The more money someone makes for a company, the more slack they get cut to keep them happy.

A business is about one thing and one thing only. Profit. A managers job is to secure dividends for the share holders, not to get so many widgets out. If they secure that profit for the share holders, they get their bonuses. Note, a manager will focus on what ever aspect that they are evaluated by.

by absolutely

If so:

"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion..." any religion, in any way!

by montgomery gator

If you were made the Supreme Dicatator, are you sure that you would not get corrupted ;-)

I am the only one that can be trusted with absolute power!! Only Me!! Me Me Me!!!

by m_a_r_k

If you win the lotto, you'll move to Texas? What makes you think we'll let you move here? :D

by absolutely

Are you saying that waiting for crises to occur is not as effective as employing intelligence to anticipate them and take action in advance?

Bizarre.

by m_a_r_k

>> "most execs" don't put in 60-80 hour weeks"

Hmm, I don't know about that. Maybe not 60-80 hours but I'm pretty sure all the execs at all companies I've been at were putting in more hrs than average Joe Employee. Travel, evening dinner meetings, golf outings at the country club...sounds like fun but if they take away from my 40-45 hour work week and prevent me from my pursuit of happiness and from enjoying what would otherwise be spare time, then I call that work.

by tonythetiger

"1. Taking a dollar from the person who earned it, so it can be given to a person who did not earn it"

Actually that should read:

1. Taking a dollar from the person who earned it so that 17 cents can be given.... :)

by jdclyde

the fact that all they do is say "don't do this", or "don't do that" without allowing ANYONE to make improvements, one day will catch up to them too.

when they can't own a car because the only solution they saw was to stop making refineries, stop drilling for oil, and cry because all of a sudden it is the President of the United States Of Americas job to get the rest of the world to use alternative fuel sources.

After all, we can't use nuke plants. We can't build more hydroelectiric plants without lots of opposition and a few years of envirormental impact studies. Can't put in the wind farms because they kill birds and people don't want the sceinery messed up. Solarcells have disposal issues. It isn't ever a matter of "this is better than that so lets do it". It is, "no, go back and find a DIFFERENT solution that fits every wackos wants/needs/desiers".

by absolutely

just light-hearted

the premise that a non-existent will-o-the-wisp entitles elves, goblins and trolls to take my money against my will should be taken as a joke -- a sadistic joke. Good one, Tom.

by jdclyde

is from Canda and is always in the way hugging my trees everytime I try to mow my lawn! :^O

But he does bring over some GOOOOOOD maple syrup! ;\

He is also glad the wife moved out taking the cat with her. My bird feeder WASN'T a [b]BIRD[/b] feeder, it was BAIT. LOL! B-)

by absolutely

Bush's intentions vis-a-vis ANWR are just another form of welfare: for the very rich! Instead of paying money as tax, we're paying with public land, to a private individual. What do you think is different about those two cases?

by jdclyde

Enlighten me with the details of the dealings on who will be the choosen one to do the drilling.

How the decision is made on who drill where should be a part of discusion. Or at least informational from the people that know (you?) to the people that don't (me).

So far I haven't seen anyone present in the environment discussion anything more than half truths and lots of emotional blah blah. For every point there was a counter-point.

No one posted anything to make me be against drilling for our own oil.

by tonythetiger

"I dont mind contributing to the better quality of life of my coutnry, because we're equal."

When less than 20% of your "contribution" actually finds its way to those in need, wouldn't you really rather do it yourself?

"If we stopped taking moneys away from EVERYONE (money meant to help state/govet welfare programs) and said OK Everyone: you're on your own. No foodstamps, no bennies, ZIPPO.
Do you have any idea what would happen?"

Well, I can't speak for everyone, but the sudden increase in my income would make me more effective in what I can do to help my family and my community.

"WE'VE FOUGHT FOR YEARS TO SAY WE DESERVE AN EQUAL QUALITY OF LIFE."

No way! We DESERVE the opportunity to persue the quality of life we want, and that opportunity is available to almost all of us. What we DON'T deserve is to have the quality of life WE have fought for and earned taken from us against our wishes!

Read the link I posted earlier.