Individual Liberty in America - Is it a thing of the past?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by tonythetiger
by absolutely
then we may as well go all the way, and begin discussing facts, rather than the speculated merits of one ideology versus the other.
Now that I think about it, I think that's a great idea!
Let's compare the administrative overhead of government wealth redistribution to the administrative overhead of purely voluntary wealth redistribution via bona fide charity. How many cents of each $1 gets to the charity case when distributed by welfare, compared to private charities? Since a variety of charities to help the poor exist, it's only fair to use a weighted average, ie take the total money given to all such charities, and compare to the percentage of that total that makes its way to individual charity cases.
I bet the efficiency of private charity beats that of government at least 2:1. Does anybody care to make it interesting?
by m_a_r_k
by absolutely
:8}
I don't claim to know who specifically will be Chosen to own the operation that will drill the oil that will drive the caribou extinct. Or interfere with their mating habits and diminish the population of the herd. Or just annoy them and make their meat tougher for the Gwitch'in (sp?). Or have no effect at all.
Right now, ANWR is public property, with a unique protected status. Consider that status the "will of the people who are its owners". Now consider transferring that ownership to a single individual or corporation, which includes members of the public, but are also a vanishingly small subset of the public. Finally, consider that such a transfer has already been proposed and rejected by the people's elected legislative body by the same executive who is making another proposal to do the same, but now hiding that proposal in other bills that are known to be of great importance to those legislators. You should now understand my position fully. That is why I see the proposal to drill in ANWR as welfare: it transfers property from the public to one or more selected individuals. In welfare the recipients are selected because they are "needy", in the other case the recipients are selected because they are "necessary to the economy" (but they are not!).
by absolutely
the entire dollar goes to various people, none of whom deserve any of it.
If 17 cents makes its way to the "end user" or whatever, that's 17% percent efficiency in pursuing a goal that I don't care to support in any amount except through totally local charities. My reason is simple. Local people who run local charities know the difference between the town hard luck story and the town drunk. Some ideology-addled college dropout imported from 1500 miles away to work as a social worker...
by tonythetiger
I can't argue with that. The person who gets the 17 cents is the supposed reason for the $1.00 "contribution".
As far as social workers go, the ones I've had the misfortune of having to deal with (and have had to resort to hiring a lawyer and suing to get them to do their jobs!) seem to have as the number one item in their job duties "Maintaining a steady or growing customer base".
I see it specifically in Children's services and the police department.
Children's services will swoop right in to snatch a child from a wealthy family on the merest rumor, but a poor child has to have broken bones before they'll do anything, and even then they just tell the parent to "get therapy" and don't follow up on it or anything. THen when an interested citizen gets involved, to the point of spending thousands of his own dollars to try to make them do their jobs, they run back-room deals with the judge so the citizen doesn't even get a chance to tell his side of what's (not) going on.
The police... They will ticket you for parking an inch too far from the curb in front of your house, but they stand around talking to the hoodlum with a dozen warrants out him and just let him keep committing more crimes. I even heard one of them say "Well if we get rid of all of the criminal element, we'll be screwing ourselves out of jobs." (personally, I'm just glad he doesn't work for the FIRE department!)
Of course, maybe this is just a local phenomenum. I sure hope so.
by tomsal
The thing is a balance has to be struck. I have several brothers and a couple sisters. All but one (my oldest brother) is married and with kids. Two of my siblings live in not the greatest of neighborhoods -- where an "expensive" house is $50,000 if that gives you any idea.
Everyone has health problems, and my family is no different -- hell of all my siblings I have the most health issues. But I'm not gonna list them as to be honest no one really cares, and its not my point.
But to cuteELF's credit - I do understand situations where "welfare like" (I say it that way, read on to understand why) programs are needed by some.
But to Max's credit - I have first hand knowledge, from the people who actually collect the checks, that the current "checks/balances/req's" of existing welfare programs are in fact PATHETIC!!! My my sister-law (the one married to my bro who is in the less than desirable neighborhood) her side of the family abuse the living hell out of such programs. They are lazy they are arrogant about it and they laugh about it from time to time as well. They try to work (like $10 an hour type jobs) but their excuses are the lamest ever for why they quit. Supposedly one can't work because his back keeps him out -- oh so that is why I see him riding his motocycle, dancing at "family" functions and playing frisbee with his nephews?
Then just people around here that I work with, tell me stories how they get subsidies and yet in the same breath how they are blowing money each weekend going out to clubs and to AC to gamble.
How the hell is that supposed to make us - those who are part of the American work force feel? It gets under my skin when my sister-in-law's sister who is WHOLLY SUPPORTED by welfare programs, yet she goes dancing, shopping at the mall, sitting on her lazy ass watching tv all day long -- she has a daughter..so you think the money would go first to her right? Nope you actually hear her say "well when I get my paycheck" YEP she calls the checks from the welfare programs her PAYCHECK...I'm gonna buy this or that...and its often nothing to do with food or things for her child. Its stuff for her..mostly non-neccessities.
So my thing is yeah I see the value in welfare programs..but the current system has to be utterly and complete trashed and then re-designed from the ground up and even given a new name, one that is more clear in its purpose that its for short term only.
I think the req's should be VERY strict to get on these programs. And once on you have to demonstrate a vested interest in progressing off the program in order to stay on the program in the meantime.
--you say you have back problems. Ok fine...you have to be checked out by a doctor sponsored and verified by the new program..NOT one of your doctors.
--perhaps even issue unique checks that can ONLY be used by the person they are for (therefore there is no value to sell them for cash, since only the original person can redeem them anyway)..these "checks" would only be redeemable for specific items..mainly food, essential clothing (ie. saving up for a fur coat is not "essential" clothing, neither is a leather coat), utilities (power, gas, water, sewer, etc.) and the like.
Further more if you remain on the program for too long without getting off of it -- you would be thoroughly investigated as to ascertain if your reasons are legitimate or not.
But that's just my 2.23 cents
by absolutely
I agree fully with your description of who ought to receive help and under what conditions, but as you illustrate with your proposal to investigate this and verify that with a supposedly trustworthy doctor, finding the truth from liars is a major task.
The goal of helping only people in need who [i]will try[/i] to provide for themselves and stop being in need ASAP is to leave the helping to their acquaintances, extended family, and maybe local charities if anyone cares to form such a thing. You, for example, don't need a scheduled visit with a licensed doctor to know that in-law is faking back pain and the other is a lazy slob, you can see it with your own eyes. And if the government wasn't forcing you to pay them, you could tell them yourself, "No more free ride. I help you keep a roof over your head and food on your table, and only for as long as you are completely unable to do so yourself. I see you've been playing me for a fool, so you're cut off. Inconvenient? You should have thought of that when you decided to treat me like a sucker."
The government does not [i]allow[/i] you to make that decision, which is obviously the right one. That is corrupt.
by dmambo
"--perhaps even issue unique checks that can ONLY be used by the person they are for (therefore there is no value to sell them for cash, since only the original person can redeem them anyway)..these "checks" would only be redeemable for specific items..mainly food, essential clothing (ie. saving up for a fur coat is not "essential" clothing, neither is a leather coat), utilities (power, gas, water, sewer, etc.) and the like."
How about biometric smart cards that will not be eligible for redemption in liquor stores, bars,...ski areas, etc.?
by dmambo
You say "Are you suggesting that we should all have equal outcome? How about this. You earn $1,000; and I earn $500. You send me $250, and we'll all be even. That, my friend, is a sure recipe for mutual destruction."
Clearly you know that our (flawed) welfare system is a loooong way from being a system to totally equalizing wealth. VERY few advocate that. However, good people may disagree over the need to provide no or some level of minimal benefits to hardship cases. Personally (flame away), I believe that we're all a little better off if we can minimize the number of shanty towns and people out on the street begging. Providing a small fixed income to do that is OK in my book. I'm to cheap and lazy to do it for others, so I find the government an acceptable vehicle for it.
I agree that those who can should repay as much of that benefit as practical with in-kind services, but there are always ways around that by finding a sympathetic doctor, or spitting out a few more kids. Those with gumption and ability will use welfare systems as a temporary crutch until they can extracate themselves from the need for it. For those who can't or won't, I rather have them sitting on their front porches than on my corner with their hands out. Visit a country with no wealth distribution benefits and tell me what you think of the quality of life there.
.
No, of course I'm not suggesting that our current system strives to equalize outcome in the absolute sense of the word. (Although that certainly is the true intent of many such advocates.) The comment of mine that you quoted was specifically directed at one person, discussing one circumstance, and was clearly intended (at least it should have been clear) to only make a point. However, our system does indeed take one person one way, and the other person the other way, so that "the outcome" is closer to equal than it otherwise would have been -- just as it is designed to do. And my assertion is, even that is too much.
Welfare: Why is it that whenever any such discussion takes place, that all social transfer of wealth programs are lumped into the "welfare" category? (And please answer this question.) That is what I call disingenuous, whether it was intentional or not. I'm talking about ALL transfer of wealth programs, not just welfare, as we know it. Welfare, per se, is only a fraction of the problem, and it makes up only a fraction of the distribution of wealth system.
And (no flame is necessary), just because you think that ".....we're all a little better off if we can minimize the number of shanty towns and people out on the street begging.....", doesn't mean others agree. Define "better off"? And then I'll find someone who defines it differently. I'll give you just one example to illustrate. You might think that giving the stereo-typical homeless vagrant (we used to call them bums) a meager sustenance allowance will make him and/or society "better off". Well, I can't disagree more. In fact, I would call such a thing enabling his destructive behavior, and is actually contributing to him becoming WORSE OFF. I would further suggest that the most compassionate thing to do in such a case (compassionate in a "tough love" kind of way) is to literally force him to choose between life and death. By interfering, we deny him the opportunity (and yes, I do indeed mean opportunity) to make that tough choice for himself -- the best, and possibly the only, way out of his despair.
If people are on the streets "begging", and there are laws against it, as some would argue there should be, then arrest them. Send them to jail. And by "supporting them" that way, we can at least cut-off the supply of their juice or whatever else ails them and drives their self-destructive lives.
Besides, the whole point of my position is that there isn't, or at least shouldn't be, any justification or legal authority for ANY transfer of wealth programs written into our system of government, i.e. the constitution. How we've gotten away with it truly does baffle me. What would Jefferson and Madison say about the state of government today? Jefferson might actually support a total revolution against this current form of government. Having government forced transfer of wealth programs was not the intention, nor is it clearly enumerated in the constitution. And if it's not specifically allowed in the constitution, then, in theory and intent -- and by design -- the government should not be able to do it.
You said, "Visit a country with no wealth distribution benefits and tell me what you think of the quality of life there". Well, name one for me to visit? I can't think of any. Unless, of course, you're talking about some third-world nation in central Africa where the people are oppressed by some brutal dictator. Rephrase the suggestion to include a nation with built-in safeguards against such things, and with some semblance of freedom and a democratic system, and then you couldn't find one.
How about this suggestion as an alternative?
In nations where total freedom and individual liberty is the greatest, and where the government interferes in the lives of its citizens the least, the greater the chance you will have for those citizens to succeed (define success however you'd like). The less you see of various "social engineering" schemes, the more you will see the citizens prosper. And as yet another illustration, to whatever degree "social engineering" takes place in the USA, it's much greater in both France and Germany. And did you know that a family living in "poverty", as defined by the powers that be, in the USA has about as much as the normal "middle class" family in Germany? Did you know that the unemployment rates in both Germany and France have almost never been under 10 percent? And in the USA, we use 5 percent as a benchmark for concern. They have more social engineering, but yet their people are less prosperous. And if we do LESS of it, our people will have a greater occurrence of prosperity. Freedom does not oppress. And total freedom will "not oppress" even more.
"Visit a country with no wealth distribution benefits and tell me what you think of the quality of life there." On second thought, one actually does come to mind. The United States of America -- BEFORE 1964.
It was one of the most impressive examples the world has ever seen of how people can reach great heights and/or rise up from nothing to something. But since 1964, it's been a steady move backwards. Did you know that the numbers of families living in poverty in the USA declined steadily every decade of the 1900s? Until, that is, 1964 when "the war on poverty" started. Since then, up, up, up. The "war on poverty", the "war on drugs", the "war on people exercising true freedom", whatever the social war you want to wage, the people will be the sure losers.
When the government just gets the hell out of the way, and gets the hell out of people's lives, they will prosper in much greater numbers and to a much greater degree. And I challenge you to show me an example that suggests otherwise.
by jck
Fact is, I don't care if they're driving a Yugo to the golf course. The cars weren't the point...they were one example of what the men who were executives at a corporation for which I worked were driving, and details of their lack of focus on work while on the clock.
It'd be different to me if they were in a meeting with facts and figures mulling over them and putting thought into it...but...how much productive work and planning and number crunching can happen when everyone is swinging clubs? How many reports have you seen pulled out in a golf cart and looked over, in all your golfing outings, by execs on courses?
I can't go to a golf course and take my laptop with VS .NET 2003 on it and work in between strokes...or take it to dinner with me and talk to people from other companies and write it off and call it work. I'd be called a slacker...or ineffective...or unproductive. You see...it's because...I wouldn't be focused on my *duties*.
My boss couldn't do that. My director couldn't. My chief administrator couldn't. My board of commissioners can't. And, my chief administrator and board are over a $7.2B budget.
Tell me this...would your company let you remote your job and go to golf with clients in the middle of the day? I think not.
The point is: They are *not* working to their full potential when they are at a golf course all the time. You can not convince me that out on the golf course they are focused at utilizing their skills to earn those shareholders the optimum profit at the least cost. And, that *is* their legal obligation as executives of a corporation...accountability for profit to shareholders.
And as for earnings comparison...I could almost guarantee you that in net revenue, I was far more profitable for shareholders than that CEO solely in relation to individual effort that secured revenue vs compensation...if I remember right, he made over $12M that year in pay and bonuses alone...I made $38k and I brought in $7M single-handedly...that means he would have had to single-handedly secured revenue of at least $19M for that corp. I don't think that happened. He was too busy, at that time, working with the PR department to spend $2M+ re-branding the corporate logo. Can I count that against his net too?
In short, CEOs are not (for the most part) cost-effective.
Kind of reminds me...of politicians....
BTW...I want to make it CLEAR:
I have all the respect in the world for a guy who runs his own company, does his own business management, etc. Those guys deserve the big paycheck because often they are doing the management, the sales, the oversight of accounting, etc. They put in the effort, have to manage their time wisely, and only make profit if they do.
On the other hand, execs at corporations often negotiate contracts for large salaries with a board of directors that are loaded with business acquaintances of theirs, but guarantee no increased profitability for the corporation.
Nonetheless...I don't care if it's an "accepted practice" to take clients to golf or watch a NASCAR race or to a strip bar during business hours. That is not working...it's politics and schmoozing and it does not guarantee work for the corporation or profit for shareholders. Taking them to a nice lunch...fine...taking them to 3-4 hours of golf with drinks afterward...not productive work.
Bottom line: It is not focusing their attention to detail and process and making sure the work gets done right in a timely manner when they take these excursions...which is what they often expect via employee ethics standards of any other staff employee at their corporation.
There are executives in this country who are worth their paycheck and actually get things done. But, they are few and far between. They get my salute.
Others like P.F. (initials of that CEO who was always heading to golf) deserve a swift kick in the arse, and for a 12 year old hacker to drain their investment accounts into the coffers of the Sisters of Most Divine Ascension nunnery's bank account. :D
by jck
Well I don't know where you've worked...but, I can vouch that so far I've only worked on place that I worked 40 hours a week on a regular basis...and that's when I was computer services section head.
I made sure we didn't work overtime...and it wasn't because I didn't want to pay OT to my employee. It was because my belief is if you do your work effectively...and do solid preventative maintenance...you eliminate most big problems in a tech setting.
I never had my employee work 1 hour of overtime that I can remember. I would only work long hours if I was travelling to a remote site to do work. And then, those were once every couple of months.
At the other jobs, I've often been asked to stay late or kept late to meet about things or finish things...and without compensation for it.
And...there's a big difference between travel taking your time away and being made to work late. Which is work: being in a meeting at 8pm when you don't know when you'll get back to your kids, or being in the car on a 2 hour drive home knowing you can call them and tell them when you'll be there for them?
Travel is not work...if it was, I'd be rich right now for billing for drive and flight time when I've consulted. It might be part of the secondary action facilitating work (shopping for clothes is too...), but it involves little (if any) involvement in business operations.
And besides that...when you get a job, it's generally standard they tell you that you'll have to travel. If you're not smart enough to figure out this means they can over-do the travel on you, you don't need to be accepting jobs with travel involved. So, they're choosing to take the big check and time away rather than to guarantee being with their families...they make the *choice*. So, I won't weep for anyone. I've been there...done that...Delta gold medallion skymiles member and all...travel isn't that bad...and I did it weekly for months on end. It's inconvenient...but, it's not work.
by tomsal
.
My real answer would be to acknowledge that every individual has inherent rights to live their life free of interference, from me, from government, and from any other individuals, as long as they refrain from interfering in or with the lives of others; and I'd simply let those chips of total and absolute freedom fall where they may.
Yea, I know. It's not an original idea; and it may not even result in perfection. But it certainly is the best idea.
by jck
by jck
and move there, I will build where my family and relatives own hundreds of acres in Cherokee County?
Don't worry...I won't bother you...even if I would be the 6th generation of my mothers family to have lived there...hahahahaha :)
The stars at night...are big and bright...
hahaha...I sang that drunk on the riverwalk in San Antonio...and did you know, you could tell who was Texan (and drunk as me) when they sang back to me!
I love that state...it's like going back to family when I get to go there.
oh well...don't worry...I'll have other places to go in case you're driving through and don't want to risk meeting me ;)
by jck
when I say "should not receive special favors", I do not mean having use of facilities which provides her a level playing field to gain entrance.
I am saying she should not get an automatic through into college because she has an impairment. If she needs a wrist-strap to hold a pencil because she can't grip to use it to fill out the entrance exam...give that to her...but to say "Well...we'll just let her in because..." would be wrong.
But no...facilitation is different than favors. She, like anyone else who applies, deserves a level playing field...not an advantage.
by m_a_r_k
From jck:
>>In short, CEOs are not (for the most part) cost-effective.<<
I definitely and whole-heartedly agree with that. Salaries in excess of seven figures. Stock options for pennies on the dollar. etc etc Their perks increase year after year regardless if the company is going up or down. And even when they do lead the company into a sinkhole, they get bought out with millions of George Washingtons. Hell, even the crooks at Enron and WorldCom raked in gazillions after defrauding the company for quadrillions.
by m_a_r_k
by absolutely
OK, the clubs are in, I've rolled the windows down so you guys up there can hold onto something - ready?
It seems like you're overlooking somet very important facts, jck: the first of which is that execs don't answer to you. Another is that your "individual effort" is [i]not[/i] worth $12M [i]without a company[/i] that includes other people, who do [i]other[/i] specialized work to facilitate the delivery of whatever part of the process is your specialty. The last inaccurate statement is about travel not being work. It's true that commuting -- at the beginning and end of the day -- is not work. But unfortunately I've spent some time delivering pizzas, and I know that it is not standard practice to clock out for travel time [i]that is required as part of work duties[/i].
Finally, I feel your pain. I'd like -- maybe more than anything -- to live and work in a world where success meant production, and sales were decided strictly by competition according to performance. But all consumers are not strictly rational, so there are marketing departments. Whatever CEO's do, they have each worked their way to the tops of their respective ladders by showing ability in their previous jobs. Maybe some of them even brought in [i]more than[/i] $12M when they were working for $38k or less.
To relate this to our main topic, if you think the CEO of your company is a drain, you can apply for his job or work someplace else where administrative overhead is lower compared to its contribution to revenues. In the case of supporting poor people through welfare, and corporations through price supports, tax breaks and outright gifts, you can be audited and imprisoned if you try not to support government largesse.
by ippirate
It took me a bit of digging but my necromancy skills seem to be up to par. I've recovered the exchange below from the 2nd of the four conversations where you and I have actually interacted.
In light of your accusations and assumptions of my leftist ideology and my huggy, touchy, nurse-maid mentality I would like to point out a few items of interest.
First, I am a Conservative.
Second, I am neither Republican nor Democrat, I am a Federalist.
Third, I unfortunately have to vote for the Republican party because they are the nearest resemblance to my ideologies. They are still neo's and I don't trust them.
Fourth, I am a citizen and a veteran, trust me, I know and understand the Constitution. I further have a firm grasp of liberties, rights and privilege.
As prelude. I understand your premise, I agree, but only in part. In truth, so that you don't have to assume, there are two things that I take very serious issue with. First, your incessent raising of this subject and your limited to non-existent presentation of solution. Second, the selective intent of the sources, quotes and defenses that you present. You address what is directly beneficial to you but never do you address the whole of the picture. Case in point: Above you quote Madison, Jefferson and Franklin and their statements on the "welfare system" while foregoing mention of the quotes of these same men regarding civic duty and education, individual responsibility and community integration. Furthermore, you forego any mention of other of our nation's greats and their statements to the same.
Again, you cannot have your cake and eat it as well. More importantly, crying over it isn't going to do anything to resolve it. Work it or pound sand pup, your choice.
Should you conclude that you are man of caliber and enough fiber to actually undergo peer criticism in pursuit of a solution then by all means, read on. If not, well, we'll just let that dog lay.
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=167939&messageID=1722715
Max,
I am going to attempt to respond in one. I've taken your headers and body where necessary, otherwise just the header and added short comment. If I have used your comments, please find the italicized (maybe you could get apotheon to spellcheck that for me?)
Paragraph One
.
[i]Just because an issue may be complicated, it doesn't mean that it can't be viewed or explained in simple terms. Moreover, when people try to make a simple question more complicated than it really is, my suspicion meter registers off the charts. Besides the whole intention of my question, which was only understood by a few, was that there is absolutely no constitutional authority for the creation of a socialist society in the United States. There is absolutely no authority that gives the government, for example, the right to plan for our retirement, which is exactly what Social Security has become. And there is absolutely no constitutional authority that gives one citizen the right to sieze, or the right to expect to be given the property of another. So when you contend that it's a complicated issue, I won't necessarily disagree with you. But my question can still be answered with one simple word - nothing. If you want to discuss a "therefore what" conclusion, that's all fine and dandy. But in the very least, let's either agree or disagree on the premise.[/i]
Very well, I agree with your premise, in part, but I agree. I think that the question that now needs to be answered is whether your premise addresses the whole and that is what I am driving at.
Look max, I understand what you are driving at in the original. No, I do not believe that the founding fathers, the writers of our Constitution, had any intention of creating any type of governmental society. I do however believe that there is more to this than just that one statement. In order to qualify your side, you have to validate the same to mine, being, that they did not intend our society to become a pack of jackals, lusting after our own and shunning all others.
Three principles that our nation was built upon
1. Government, as it needs exist, was given to do so only in so far as necessary to ensure foreign relations, structure for war and the preservation and review of the second principle..
2. The Law, which is what our nation was truly built upon. Every right, liberty and privilege is hung on this, the responsibility and standard of the nation. Infringe upon it and lose the previous. In the preamble to our Declaration of Independence the founding fathers mention Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness. The whole of the document itself identifies Justice as the heart of concern. This same theme is revealed continually in all other documents as well.
3. The civic duty and the moral responsibility of man. This is the expressed by Adams, Madison, Washington, Franklin and the list goes on. In fact, this is the facet which they each worry over more than anything else (with the exception of actually taking on public civic duty, which, oddly enough, each of them seems to anguish over in face of the responsibility and magnitude of the task, unlike our eager candidates of today) as it is the one thing which everything else hangs. If one is not willing to submit to the authority of the law and is not willing to act in good conduct toward their neighbour, then one or the both of the first two will (and in our case) have failed to attain the ideal set forth in original documents declaring and forming the Union.
I understand fully where you are coming from max and I do not minimize it but I still think that it doesn't address the heart of the issue. I believe you are addressing an outward expression of a deeper problem, a symptom if you will. Any doctor will tell you that you can treat the fever, you won't cure the patient until you identify and address what is causing that fever to begin with.
Paragraph Two
.
[i]Yes, I do indeed support a concerted effort to reverse the social engineering aspect of our federal government. Let's either agree on that premise and try to discover ways to make it happen, or simply agree to disagree.
But first of all, I try to avoid using "welfare" or "welfare state" as a catch-all for the myriad of transfer of wealth programs. All too many people make that assumption -- or that leap -- but it only serves to cloud the real issue. Welfare, as accurately described for what it really is, is only one such transfer of wealth program. Anything that takes a dollar from the pocket of the person who earned it, and puts it into the hands of a person who did not earn it, fits under the umbrella of creating a "socialist society". And the people who incorrectly include police and fire protection, the military, et al. into this definition are either extremely naive' or extremely disingenuous and/or manipulative.
Fine but please, refer P. 1
You said, ".....then it is necessary to identify and address each and every contributing factor".
Sure it is, but first, like I said, let's agree on the premise. There is no constitutional authority that gives the government the right to always act as a broker; and there is no constitutional authority that gives the government the right to take a dollar from the pocket of the person who earned it, and put it into the hands of a person who did not earn it. So let's seek solutions other than ones that involve such government behavior.[/i]
Again, refer to P. 1
You said, "Until the citizenry of the US is willing to act in the manner they were originally meant and drive the system (House, Senate, Presidency) rather than allowing the system to drive them, there will be no resolution."
I agree. It seems that all too many people in the USA are either unwilling or unable to "govern themselves". With self-government comes an enormous amount of self-responsibility, and people have been literally brainwashed into thinking that the responsibility for everything that ails them and/or society should fall into the hands of government, especially the federal government. What frightened and/or foolish people I consider them to be; what greedy people I consider them to be; and what dangerous people I consider them to be. When people realize that they can vote themselves favors from the public coffers, democracy is doomed to fail.
I agree, it is worrisome and fearful but in all honesty, it is all very understandible when we examine the degree to which we have gone to allow an attitude of ignorance. We, as a people, have allowed it to be taught in our classrooms for years. We have been so concerned with the "Police State" that we never noticed Stalin fulfilling his promise to bring us down from within. We have done this by re-writing history, primarily early U.S. history by exerpting, misleading, failing to mention and most often, outright lying about what this nation was created on. We have our national documents in a huge museum, million look on them each and every year and only a few have ever taken the time to actually read them. Prefering instead to listen to the commentary of another, often in full view of shading political agendas.
We're Americans. Fat, Lazy, Witless Slobs and we are getting exactly what every other boastful sluggered and fool has gotten in history. The real shame is that we just don't seem to care. The entirety of the nation is screaming that there is something horribly wrong but no one wants to "think" for themselves, we just want to be spoon fed because Freedom and Liberty and Hope are all hard work.
[i]You said, "Our first and foremost responsibility, after ensuring our own education and awareness of civic duty, is to our children and our families. Next the push must be moved into our neighborhood and ultimately our communities at large."
Well, I both agree and disagree. I agree, of course, with our responsibility to ourselves, our children, and our family (including extended family, aging parents and such). But when you start to expect someone else to "be responsible" for neighborhoods and communities, we delve into dangerous waters. I agree, in principle, that good people reach out and help others, but then you get into the area of differing expectations, different levels of effort -- including efforts of others to "help themselves" -- and different preferences for implementing whatever solutions or fixes may or may not be needed. This might be worthy of a "therefore what" question back at you, assuming we agree on my aforementioned premise. [/i]
That is a shame. We expend no end of energy toward educating folks on their "rights" but we will shirk the "responsibilities". That is not justice. As to the rest of the statement above, how an individual reacts is not what can be dictated out, nor should it be but to what the expectation is, well, that is a mandatory to this subject. How can a person be expected to know the truth unless he be told?
Paragraph Three
.
[i]You said, "In my opinion, although the above concern may be valid, it is limited in scope and address, voicing only the desire to recoup what is viewed as unjustly taken. This in turn creates a perception of selfishness and a lack of desire to address the whole in the civic forum and to simply leverage the argument of "expectation" to the opposite side of the spectrum."
Yes, it is indeed limited in scope. I will admit, it addresses a general problem, and not necessarily the "best" solution to whatever "specific problem" you may want to address. But if you are travelling across the country in your automobile, and you suddenly discover that you're not getting to where you want to go, the first step is to look at a map, and make the determination that you should not be going in this direction and certainly not on this road. If we can agree on step one, then we can seek a proper step two. But if we don't agree on the proper step two, it's no reason to keep going the wrong direction on the wrong road.
And if people see this as "selfish", that only shows their ignorance, not mine. Besides, even if a person DID want to be "selfish" with what he's earned in America, he's certainly within his rights to do so; and it doesn't give anyone else the right to force him to be charitable. [/i]
I know that you are going to hate this argument but I think it needs to be made.
The problem doesn't begin with the car or the map. The car begins with the driver. There is a myriad of reasons why we aren't getting were we wish to go. What if we're out of gas? What if we have the wrong map? What if we don't have keys? The point is, to call it our directions immediately is shortsighted. The true solution again lies in logically, honestly and accurately diagnosing the root problem(s) and then addressing it/them. Until you do that, you can pick a new route all you like, you are going nowhere fast and you are no more the better for all the calculation, you've just made a bad situation worse.
Paragraph Four
.
[i]You said, "To make my position clear, so that we don't have to play the left/right game, I fully support the abolishment of a majority of, if not all, systems currently in place. I further support the transfer of the responsibility for these functions to local private and/or faith based chapters whose funding is generated through civic contributions with limited govermental regulation/oversite."
We agree. Enough said. [/i]
Very well, moving on
Paragraph Five
.
[i]You said, "The transfer of this responsibility to organizations rooted in the communities provides significant benefits to the current 'way things are done'. It removes the bureaucratic slowdowns and 'processing times', delivering assistance in a timely fashion and when it is needed instead of far after the fact. It focuses areas of responsibility by narrowing the ratio of potential recipients to the number of workers/assistance centers. It strengthens accountability of the recipient and standards enforcement by placing the point of accountability and responsibility in nearer proximity to the recipient. It also greatly reduces the need for tax money to fund not only the assistance but the associated personnel costs as well by making obsolete the government departments tasked with supporting and managing the current systems."
Again, we agree. And again, enough said - except that it was very well said. [/i]
Very well, thank you and I appreciate your compliment.
Paragraph Six
.
[i]You said, "It does not, however, remove responsibility from each of us as citizens. It compounds it by placing us in a position which necessitates active interest in our communities and our neighbors, which is a constitutional responsibility fulfilled in civic duty."
Well, as I stated earlier, when we start defining what the civic responsibility of others may or may not be, we're treading on dangerous waters. In such cases, we have only one thing to fall back on. We are a nation of laws based on a constitutional authority. And as long as a person is behaving in a law-abiding manner, and is not violating anyone else's constitutional rights, he or she should be able to do whatever he or she damn well pleases. It's not up to you or me to "decide" that some John Doe is not taking an active enough interest in his community or is not giving enough to charity.[/i]
Again, refer to earlier statements above
.
[i]You asked, "What are the hurdles?"
1. You said, "Civic responsibility."
See my previous answers.
2. You said, "Another is unionism. It is not to the benefit of the unions for social assistance to be removed from governmental hands. It is not as easily manipulated when funding is handled from 1,000's of offices versus just a couple. This in turn adds a layer of complexity to contract negotiations that would not be met with enthusiasm by union members, officials and advocates. (My one sarcastic jab - My heart bleeds for them)."
Hey, if people what to unionize, that's their deal, not mine, as long as I'm not forced to capitulate to them or their desires. And if a business wants to be a non-union shop, and if it can be made viable in doing so, that's just fine and dandy.
But in my opinion, people who place their fate in either unions or government, still relinquish personal responsibility to some degree, either large or small. But the unions in America today perfectly illustrate how something once conceived with good intentions, has found us on a paved road to hell. The circumstances that led to the creation of unions in the first place no longer exist; but the unions live-on as though they do. The same could be said for the myriad of government programs. If you listen to the "transfer-of-wealth" proponents, they conjure up images of the Great Depression to make their case. Both unions and government have grown too big for their britches, and certainly too big for their intended purposes.[/i]
Unions present a significant hurdle to the entire process. Unions, as they exist today, depend on unemployment benefits to soften the load of "striking". What this creates is an arena where strike is used as a weapon for leveraging of "more", not necessarily better. In other words, unemployment benefits creates a safety net for a person to fulfill their gluttony and greed at the public expense. If that safety net were to ever be removed most unions would crumble under their own weight as they would not be in a position to leverage the public to their demands.
Paragraph Eight
.
[i]You said, "One other large item that must be addressed would be regulation and standards, on all counts, but specifically Quality of Life expectations."
Well, I suppose so. I agree that some regulations and standards have been good for society, and that unfortunately some "bad apples" of business require such regulations and standards, but the line of government "control" of business has indeed been crossed. I don't want to see good businesses punished for the actions of the bad.
However, your regulations might be my obstacles, and my standards might be imposing on your preferences. And my quality of life might be defined different than yours. So therefore what?[/i]
My point was and is this. Minimum standards of acceptable living are very difficult to put in place by a society if that society is not willing to accept at least some degree of reponsibility for those that find themselves unable to achieve such standards.
Paragraph Nine
.
[i]You said, "Other areas that I see as stumbling blocks, in increasing order are: 1. Big business - possibly, 2. Globalization and the global economy, 3. Consumerism, 4. The European Union".
1. Big Business: The business of America is business - Calvin Coolidge. I agree with President Coolidge 100 percent. We should create the most business friendly environment possible, which means as little government control as possible, and only enough as necessary. This might be a "moving target", and it might be a cloudy area of debate, but the first step is to stop this silly daemonization of "big business". That's utter nonsense. And that's extremely dangerous. For every "bad business" a person can point to, I could point to a thousand good ones. And we should legislate for the rule, not the exception.
2. Globalization and the global economy: All the more reason to take the posture as defined above. We need to compete with these countries, and American business should expect an environment conducive to that competition.
3. Consumerism: Consumerism drives the economy. Without it, capitalism would fail. And without it, business would have no customer. Consumerism is the engine that drives people to achieve. What exactly is your point?
4. The European Union: See answers one and two.[/i]
My point is quite simply this. Capitalism is not the form of government which we currently reside under. Now, with that said and agreed upon we must address points 1,2 & 4. Business is the operative word, not big, in Mr. Coolidge's statement. However, I have no issue with big business on the level that seems to have been taken. I do think that it is definately not to the interest of big business to have a non-competitive arena. In other words, an exceptionally low or non-existent unemployment rate. When businesses have to fight for labor, individuals win, which is the central point of our Constitution, the person, then the Union. Never does it mention the business winning. I am not alluding to the disolving of big business but I do support the make it join the dead concept. In other words, quality has to come to the front again and our businesses have to really compete on the world market if that is where we are going to compete, no government subsidies(corporate welfare check) allowed and let the best man win.
This bring us to globalization, the global economy and the EU. I'll make this short, as socialized as Europe is and as much as many of them believe they have the corner on truth and right/wrong, you had better believe that there will be huge trouble the minute that you start to make any of these moves. Pick your loyalty, American or European? My family stepped of the boat and became American. As proud as I am of my Irish descent, I am American, red, white and blue. I hold no loyalty or fealty to the "old country".
Paragraph Ten
.
[i]You asked (and said), "Does the opening post present a valid problem? Yes, I fully it believe does."
Thank you. And, of course, I agree.[/i]
You are welcome. Again, lets move on.
Paragraph Eleven
.
[i]You asked (and said), "Do I feel it is the root? No. We are. We the people, remember us? The last couple of generations have cast of their responsibilities. Responsibilities which must still be met. When we made ourselves unaccountable, the government followed the natural course."
This doesn't make sense to me. For example, I might have phrased it like this. Do I feel it is the root? Absolutely Yes, because we the people, remember us........
I don't understand exactly what you are saying.[/i]
When you look at the situation and ask how? why? Look at yourself. You have no further than yourself to look for the reason, the blame. I have met very few people in my lifetime which are willing to take the Constitution at face value, *** for tat and without arbitration. Most of us want this part but not that part there because it is to hard, to difficult. I've tried to spell this out in the rest of my statements above so I will refer you to them again if need be.
The short is this, there were responsibilities to be met, things that had to be done and when we wouldn't do it any longer we got lazy and allowed the government to take it over. They just did what came natural, just like us. If we do not expect restraint and responsibility on the part of the individual, just how are we supposed to expect the same from a group of them? Liberty is work. Freedom is work. Hope is work. Anything worth having is work, hard work. However, none of that is worth having if you can it up inside your house and hoard it to only yourself, thereby the reason for civic duty.
Paragraph Twelve
.
[i]You said, "To clarify one last thing, I don't support the idea of a person being on 'social support' for an extended duration, much less indefinitely. I believe in accountability and that where it is not taken-on voluntarily it should be mandated actively and with enthusiasm."
Good. Again, we agree. But how would you propose we do that. Personally, I feel that if a person is literally faced with "life or death", so to speak, he will find a way. (Except for Packratt. He'll just let his family suffer while he goes on the Internet and complains to people about other people.)
Moving on. [/i]
Paragraph Thirteen
.
[i]You said, "As a society, we are responsible for aiding our neighbors, this goes without question. The question at hand is what and where are the limits."
No, it does not go without question. And I addressed this in my previous answers.
I try to stay away from the pie-in-the-sky and Polly-Anna type platitudes. Something might sound nice, but to try to put such sentiments into practice is another matter entirely.[/i]
I do not agree and this I have addressed above. Every human being knows that there is somethin inherently wrong with human suffering and neglect. That is why we have made laws and institutions to address them, that and the fact that we don't want to have to get our hands dirty to do so. It is high time that people take on the responsibility of their neighbours in need and take it from the government. It would be wholly cheaper and much more effective at the local, community level as I have stated before. No, platitudes don't work and neither does trying to have your cake and eat it too, therefore the reasoning behind actually addressing the root, rather than the symptom. If a man can work and he won't, he's wrong, no arguments for him and no need to give him a handout. Period. If he can't, that's another thing and needs to be addressed differently. To take one half of Justice and not take the other is arrogant on our part. Justice must be coupled with Compassion, and the two must balance or else you end up with one of two things, a commune or an oligarchy. If you lean one way or the other as a society you will carry government toward that end as well.
Paragraph Fourteen - And LAST Paragraph
.
[i]You said, "So, there is my position. I've spelled it out as clearly as I can and if it still isn't clear enough, try reading slower."
I think we probably agree more than we disagree. Where your "spelling" gets confusing, however, is when it appears that you are trying to apply a libertarian-type solution, but while holding onto the liberal "good for society" type platitudes. One should either believe in government forced social engineering or not, base their actions on that principle, and just let the chips fall where they may. It sounds as though you want it both ways, and it simply can't be done.
And if you haven't made it clear enough, try typing a little slower.[/i]
I'd take offense to your directing the libertarian and liberal in my general direction but I am hoping that the above will help to refine that opinion. I don't believe in government forced social engineering but I do believe in societal.
Our forebearers worked hard to give us something wonderful to start with. It is our responsibility to make the most of it and preserve it. In order to do so we must be willing to take up our position on the front lines of liberty and fight for it's vitality. Funny thing, we always here about how fragile liberty is, and how sacred, but we have this tendency to treat it as self sufficient and forget about it underfoot until it's aroma starts to change with all the garbage we pile on in it's name.
Good Day
.
You said that you understand my premise, but take exception with my absence of providing solutions. I must wonder if you really do understand my premise? I can't possibly presume to provide a solution to your problems. That's up to you. Your medical problems, your retirement problems, your child-rearing problems, whatever. You name it; it's your problem. It has to be that way, because if not, you must presume to assign the problem solving to someone else.
No thanks. I'll solve my own problems; and I give you (substitute "you" for just about anybody) the credit for having the wherewithal to solve your own. Moreover, I don't believe it's the role of government to solve everybody's problems. In fact, I further suggest that when they attempt to do so, the problems actually multiply.
Now being as brief as possible, and leaving the snide remarks, insults, assumptions, and name-calling behind, what about that do you not understand and/or disagree with?
by ippirate
To answer your question as presented, just as I have stated before. Government (In the US, that means you and I like it or not) has created this problem. That makes it our mess to clean up. In short, I completely disagree with everything that you just said aside from the appointment of individual responsibility.
To run out the door with a passing comment that it is not "my"(substitute my for the first person possesive of whoever is trying to skip) is unethical, immoral, irresponsible and ignorant. No two ways about it. You said it yourself, a government by of, for and by the people. That means the individual. It also implies a responsibility for that government of, for and by those same people.
Nope, I don't agree. Not with the current state of affairs at all. And I don't agree with you either max, you can't just pick and choose where you will apply your "civic duties" and "liberties". As I have said, independence is a national institution, interdependence is the method by which we aspire to, achieve and maintain that independence.
.
You said that I, "address what is directly beneficial to you but never do you address the whole of the picture. Case in point: Above you quote Madison, Jefferson and Franklin and their statements on the "welfare system" while foregoing mention of the quotes of these same men regarding civic duty and education, individual responsibility and community integration. Furthermore, you forego any mention of other of our nation's greats and their statements to the same."
I challenge you to find one instance of such people espousing advancing such "civic duty" as a forced function of government. In fact, I've shown time and time again just the opposite. Sure, they were advocates of exercising one's "civic duty", and such, but as individuals, not as something to be defined as a role of government to be forced onto individuals.
by absolutely
by ippirate
You skirt a very important ideal in our republic and that is the balance of the individual around that of the nation. It is very much so the right of the government to make demands upon the individual. If you don't agree then you will have to condemn the self same men you so hurriedly hold up as you standard. Why? The draft. You seem to propose that it is the individual that matters more than the nation. Really? Please explain why succession is illegal then. In fact the self same men that you point out are quoted on more than one occassion as having stated this simple fact: That in order for the nation to survive, we the people of morally and ethically obligated to participate in the process of our government. In other words, civic duty is not an option. That is exactly why voting was such a big deal. So was the chair of public office. Still, you don't have to refer simply to the three you quote above, why not bring in Washington, Jefferson, Hamilton and Lincoln. These men as well are just as outspoken on the issues at hand.
So then do we now turn to an argument of the government not having the position to enforce a moral or ethical choice? That is really the only other option left to pursue isn't it? In response to that I will again direct you to the era of the Civil War, the issue of slavery instead. Or perhaps Women's Suffrage? Perhaps something a little more recently? Segregation. Each of these is addressed by the Constitution itself. Perhaps we should look at an earlier document? Perhaps the Declaration of Independence will do? A quote then: "WE hold these Truths to be self-evident, that all Men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness -- That to secure these Rights, [b]Governments are instituted among Men, [u]deriving their just Powers from the Consent of the Governed,[/u][/b]" I underline that last as it again presents the responsibility of the individual in the whole. If it is of consequence, I suggest that you read the articles sighted within this document for the declaration of succession. Over and over it derides George for failure to enforce the moral good and the wanton enforcement of the moral wrong or evil.
by absolutely
"Clearly you know that our (flawed) welfare system is a loooong way from being a system to totally equalizing wealth. VERY few advocate that. However, good people may disagree over the need to provide no or some level of minimal benefits to hardship cases."
[i]Good[/i] people will continue to provide help in true hardship cases. They'll do it themselves, skiping over those who abuse the coercive system that treats hardship cases and manipulative cases as equals.
"Personally (flame away), I believe that we're all a little better off if we can minimize the number of shanty towns and people out on the street begging. Providing a small fixed income to do that is OK in my book."
Then do so with your own money.
"I'm to cheap and lazy to do it for others, so I find the government an acceptable vehicle for it."
I am not too cheap and lazy to do it, so I do not find the government an acceptable vehicle for it. Periodic, automatic deductions from your checking account are [i]incredibly[/i] easy to initiate, in a few minutes, to continue for as many years as you care to support the charity of your choice. So your cheap laziness is your most disingenuous argument. People who are really cheap are also too thrifty to accept the government's documented inefficiency at creating welfare via the vehicle of the deceptively-named Welfare system. People who are really lazy resent the effort of filing with the bloated IRS.
What is your real motive?
"Visit a country with no wealth distribution benefits and tell me what you think of the quality of life there."
Like Monaco? I hear there are only rich people. No shanty towns. It sounds like Paradise! But wait, you're probably going to name some banana republic and claim that they don't have wealth distribution [i]benefits[/i]. But they do redistribute wealth, according to political power not productive achievement, [i]exactly the same as is done here[/i], just in a greater extreme. Oh, also, they're honest enough to not call it "Welfare".
by ippirate
Oblique?
Not that it matters. If you care to fall in line with max's ignorant assumptions and panicked attacks then by all means, align yourself with him. He has done exactly what I said he would.
And to reveal the mystery for you, it was episode 5, Empire. And the comment was to luke, not chewB.
BTW, if you would like to actually get a relative grip on my political and governmental notions, perhaps you should read my post at the bottom of the thread. Then you could have it straight from the horse's mouth rather than relying upon the paranoid reactions of max.
by absolutely
by absolutely
by tomsal
Yes I hear what you are saying -- its not the same as completely being on your own free time and doing things not related to work.
But no -- when an exec is obnoxious about how "hard of a week he had down in Cancun" smoozing with a prospective client...I don't care to hear that crap when the same exec gets on a rant about me or someone in my department "should just work later" that night -- after we already put in 50 hours AND the problem to "just work later on" is *NOT* critical and can easily be addressed in the parameter of normal working hours.
Finally, its also different because many rich CEO's / exec types have no life anyway -- even on personal time they talk business 24/7....so in their mindset the trips ane dining out is just "normal".
So in conclusion....while I see half of your point, I shed no tear of concern about the poor CEO or exec who has to endure "working" to close a business deal at a 4 star restaurant or some exclusive beach side resort.
by dmambo
that Max's example of wealth distribution ($1000 + $500 = $750 + $750) is not remotely what we have in the US. The average earner keeps far more than the average person on government assistance receives. I have enough respect for Max's intelligence to believe that he can do better than his hyperbolic example, despite the fact that I do not personally agree with him.
As far as my motives, I find the idea of people starving in the streets or children going hungry or being denied a basic quality education repugant. I'm glad that as a society we have enacted laws that help to mitigate these things. In a sense, it's the same reason I support laws against hard drugs. It's a "personal choice" that's too dangerous to tolerate. Despite your desire to be free from any government interference, I guess I'm arrogant enough to believe that while I'm able to resist the temptations surrounding me, not everyone can. I'm glad my government helps maintain a safety net for those that can't.
I also think we should increase the minimum wage. How non-free market of me. :)
Thanks for your opinions on the matter.
BTW - Please don't copy and paste quotes in which I have made grammatical errors. Or if you must, I give you permission to correct them. - Mambo
by absolutely
by absolutely
You still aren't right.
"Randian, I meant to emphasize...
that Max's example of wealth distribution ($1000 + $500 = $750 + $750) is not remotely what we have in the US. The average earner keeps far more than the average person on government assistance receives."
Define far more. As an earner, what is important to me is that I keep less than I earn, and the average charity case keeps more of my money than it provides to me in value, which is nothing. It's very easy to forget that wealth re-distribution only became part of the government's activity after the Great Depression, a singular economic disaster brought about mainly by uninformed investment on a colossal scale. We do not need the government to tell us how to invest, only to notice that putting all of our net worth into a speculative investment is personally and collectively disastrous.
"As far as my motives, I find the idea of people starving in the streets or children going hungry or being denied a basic quality education repugant."
So do I. That's one reason why I oppose government's inefficient approach to charity.
"I'm glad that as a society we have enacted laws that help to mitigate these things."
That was the intent of some who voted, and continue to vote for the laws, we're discussing, not the real effect of Welfare and Social Security and mandatory Workers Compensation deductions and corporate subsidies. Those are all illegal programs, because they all hand to some Chosen Ones money that they did not earn, from people who did earn it, without proof of committing a crime, and that is what "due process of law" means, as used in Amendment 5.
Do you give me permission to leave your grammatical errors as you typed them?
by dmambo
who was run over by a car.
His name was Jack.
by dmambo
who was flattened bt the steam roller leaving nothing but a stain.
Guy's name was Mark. (JD, give you any ideas??)
.
Please point to, what you consider, "ignorant assumptions".
And
Please point to, in this discussion, "panicked attacks" directed at you.
by dmambo
" But, I can attest...working your ass off...very VERY rarely gets you anywhere in the hierarchy anymore."
Working your ass off in most places is still appreciated and will, in most cases, still bring that worker to a decent lifestyle. Working hard, working smart and being a good employee ARE enough to move up, at least to a certain level.
This is not to imply that there are not those who have it all, but don't deserve it. There are and some folks are just lucky enough to be born into the right family.
by ippirate
Max
Okay, I'll play.
Just above.
Oh, and is this a
Freudian slip?
"Please point to, in this discussion, "panicked attacks" directed at you."
I think so.
.
I guess you're just too smart for me.
by m_a_r_k
by ippirate
I've answered your questions and responded to your tripe. As I have stated previously, your statements in question are above. If you can't remember what you said, review them.
Need me to spoon feed you? Here is a link:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=178840&messageID=1820975
Need more?
You "[i]1. Instead of addressing the issue and answering my questions, you chose to attack me (while saying that I will only attack others?), side-stepping the core issue on which my opinion is based.[/i]
Correction nitwit, I wasn't speaking to your post at all, I was responding to what Oz had posted. It's hard but I trust you can get that through that thick skull.
"[i]2. You resorted to the usual -- and predictable -- ploy of lumping everyone who is on the receiving end of such transfer of wealth programs as being "without". That's a grossly exaggerated suggestion. Did you know, for example, that Warren Buffet (and millions like him, albeit not quite as wealthy) is the beneficiary of various transfer of wealth programs? That means that some poor schmuck who's making $15 an hour, or $12 an hour, or $10 an hour, or even $7 an hour, is having money taken out of his paycheck each and every month so that it can be paid to Warren Buffet, and others like him, as some sort of payment for some sort of program. And the cost of his goods and services is higher so that even more taxes can be collected, only to be transferred to Warren Buffet, and others like him -- including Ted Kennedy, the "champion" of the little guy?[/i]"
And you are guilty of now attempting to say that I, making a comment concerning one person's incessent complaining, am now attacking a whole group. As to the rest of your comment, it and point three, they amount to little more than pompus posturing in an attempt to hide your own ineptitude. We've been around this block before and it is for this reason that it gets so bloody old listening to you complain. You have got to be senior management. If not, you should apply.
"[i]. You assume that I have no solutions. You assume incorrectly. And you must be resistant, for some reason, to discuss those solutions in a reasonable manner. One of my solutions, for example, would include making all income under a certain amount free from all taxes of any kind whatsoever -- federal taxes, social security taxes, state taxes AND sales taxes. (And at this point in time, that amount would be around $27,000 per year.) The way the current system works today, especially with social security taxes and sales taxes, it makes the deck stacked against the little guy, because a bigger percentage of his income is taken away every year in the form of taxes. So if a guy makes $25,000 to $30,000 per year, I would suggest that he pay NO TAXES AT ALL of any kind. And yes, I could discuss this plan in-depth and in-detail, if you would care to have some constructive dialogue on the subject. (And this really is a great plan -- at least it's a good start.)[/i]"
Amazing, that is the first attempt I think I have seen you make toward a solution. I think it lacking but hey, I'm just a leftist idiot remember? Bravo all the same. Sure fire the conversation up but constructive discussion involves criticism. Post it, I'll read it when I get back from my ACLU chapter meeting and my affirmative action rally.
"[i]5. You attempt to give the impression that I'm taking my position for a self-serving reason. See the above point to dispel that false notion.[/i]"
Did I? I don't remember taking that point, may have though because I do percieve that of you. Please note that one attempt to post a solution, and that with a philanthropic twist, doesn't quite dip scale away from the fact that every other comment I have ever read of your's concerning this and similar subjects has been little more than personally bemoaning the problem and crying about how you have been wronged. Just in case you forgot, existence is not about you alone. Now where did I put that invite to the ADL dinner tomorrow.
"[i]6. Moreover, I'm taking this position because I feel it's in the best interest of America. Did you know that since the 1930s, the percentage of people receiving some sort of benefits as compared to the people paying into "the system" to pay for those benefits, has increased steadily year after year? This percentage of increase also applies to the amount of money being paid out versus the amount of money paid in. So regardless of how you look at it, it's only a matter of time before there are more takers than givers. What happens to your personal budget and financial state when you consistently spend more than you earn? And what kind of future are you providing for yourself? And what kind of future does that mean for America after we are dead and gone? Environmentalists claim to act only as stewards of the Earth. I wonder why you can't consider that some people might also want to be stewards of the idea that our forefathers called America?
[/i]"
You raise a good point. Sadly, unless you have made changes to your philosophies since our last constructive conversation, you are definately just as much part the problem. By the way, there are those out here who care about the nation. Unfortunately the Republicans and the Democrats are not part of that group. You didn't happen to see where I put my Green Peace hat did you?
"[i]7. You assume that being made dependent on someone, or some system, is being compassionate. To the contrary, I suggest to you that it's cruel to make people dependent, and that the compassionate thing to do is to encourage self-sufficiency and self-responsibility. Perhaps you're raising your kids by teaching them to become dependent on government, which in reality means that they'll be dependent on other people; but I choose to raise my kids teaching them to be self-sufficient, and to avoid being a burden on society -- and by definition, on others.[/i]"
Oops, there you go assuming again. I'll ask you not to do that again. Not only that but your later words are a blatant lie. Co-dependence is unavoidable in life. Sorry, just an observable reality. I have to re-budget my welfare tonight, having another baby, big raise.
"[i]8. You avoid discussing the intent of the Constitution. Perhaps you don't understand it enough to discuss it. And perhaps that's part of the problem.[/i]"
Now that is an intelligent comment. Anyone ever tell you that you have a serious issue with assuming? Cowboy up chucklehead. I'm betting you'll run off and not see it through again. Na, you'n'll jus have ta scuse my po ole ignorant sef boss. I's just po ole gradiat of da pubic skool sysm.
By the way, I won't be responding to your ignorance on this little string any further. If you want to continue to post to it, feel free I suppose. If you really are serious about discussing the problem you presume, then start with reading and responding to.
Seeya max, probably not until you start another one of these threads and I respond to Oz in it again. Of course, what's funny is that Oz and I are definately a lot more idealogically divided than you and I. It's funny, he and I can actually hold an intelligent conversation. Of course, he doesn't assume what my thoughts or positions are, he actually lets me express them. At least then he has a legitimate target.
Seeya Strawman
.
I first posted my "What are you talking about" message in this particular thread as a reply to yours, of course; and I then saw your "Happy Birthday" message below. I have been dwelling on that "Happy Birthday" message, even making a few notes, so I could reply in kind.
But this new message of yours really takes the cake. I must ask, what in the hell is your problem? You accuse me of doing all sorts of things including insulting you and name-calling, none of which I've done. My words are there for all to see. I've simply not done any of the things you claim.
So you say that I've been name-calling and such? Site just ONE example -- just one.
But here is what you have been saying:
".....responded to your tripe"
"Correction nitwit....."
".....you can get that through that thick skull."
Man, you really should get a grip. And I must ask again, what in the hell is your problem?
by absolutely
by dmambo
by thechas
In my opinion, we abdicated our individual liberties long ago.
Sometime between Presidents Lincoln and T. Roosevelt.
When we made the transition from an agricultural to an industrial economy, the average citizen was no longer self reliant and independent.
Once you are dependent on the efforts of others (even when you compensate them for their efforts) for the basic necessities of life, you have abdicated your personal liberty.
I still believe that the only way to reduce our wealth transfer programs over the long term is to significantly increase both wealth transfer and education spending over the short term.
The extra spending on welfare is needed to fund a requirement that every person receiving government aid MUST be working toward their high school diploma and / or job skills training. With strict attendance requirements.
For this to happen, day care and transportation will need to be provided.
Mandatory drug tests must be part of any welfare program.
Fail 3 drug tests, and your choice is drug treatment or no aid.
Drop out of rehab, or fail drug tests again, all minor children go into foster care and you loose your welfare.
Of course, effective rehab takes more time and costs a lot more than we have been willing to spend on welfare recipients.
Public funded education needs to extend from the present K-12 to include the first 2 years of college / trade school.
To give more meaning to a high school diploma, require having a high school diploma / GED before one can get a drivers license.
As to private investment versus social security, I think this debate is filled with false assumptions:
1. It is wrong to assume that those on the mid to low end of the economic scale would invest even 1/2 of the income that presently is deducted for social security. Unless required to do so by law. (more infringement on liberties)
Likewise, the average low wage employer will simply pocket what they now pay into social security.
2. Personal savings will provide more money than one gets from social security.
This concept is "conditionally" false.
On the assumption that the average person will invest in low risk funds, and that social security does not go broke, the financial analysis that I have heard put the break even point at 10 years after retirement.
Live less than 10 years after you retire, and you are better off with personal investments.
Live more than 10 years, and the present system provides you with a greater return.
I still cannot comprehend the concept that an instrument of public commerce that is the property of the US Treasury can be either yours or my property.
On property rights, the recent Supreme Court decision is not the earth shattering event that many are seeing it as.
For years, if not decades, the majority of major developments in our country have had the property acquired via eminent domain.
I believe that some form of eminent domain was used to acquire the land for the World Trade Center.
This was just the first case that a property owner choose to fight all the way to the Supreme Court.
The preponderance of existing state and Federal case law on eminent domain sided with the local government authorities.
Further, I don't believe the ruling is as wide as some have taken it.
As I understand it, in order to take an individual property, the property has to needed to complete a larger development.
And, fair compensation is still required.
I still don't like it. But I don't see it as a change in the law or an erosion of personal liberty.
Chas
by ippirate
On eminent domain first. The government retains the rights and powers to subdivide, confiscate or re-allocate properties within it's borders at will. Though it must show reasonable cause (i.e., increased tax revenue) it does not have to show such by zoning the property in any particular fashion. Case in point. In the late 70's, early 80's highways 84 and 82 were being widenened in S. Ga. Property owners were offered a "fair dollar amount" for their property. Those who refused the offer found their land forcibly divided with the state claiming xfeet of frontage. Two points, these individuals found themselves compensated by force of state, in a dollar amount dicated by the tax assessor's office. Secondly, the assessment was based on the current value of the property, not the future, although the potential value of the property was the reasoning for claiming ID to begin with. There were no buildings and the land has not directly generated a single cent in tax revenue, if anything, it has consumed such, as roads are tend to do.
The best point I have ever heard about ID is this. Every square inch of property in the US is owned by the government and can be obtained at will. The proof? Miss paying your taxes a couple of years.
On the other issues you raise. I understand where you are coming from but I do not agree with your suggested strategy but I also don't agree that what is being pointed at as a problem above is, in fact, the problem. I believe that each of the issues that you point out and more importantly, those cited in the thread opener, are indicative of a deeper problem. Until we address that issue, these others will continue to arise in whatever mutation is handy at the time.
The one thing that I do fully agree with you on and applaud you on pointing out is your point raised concerning the dollar and it's ownership. It is in fact the government's property and therefore, rightfully taxable at will. What is done with that tax money is the governments decision. That is the price of doing business in this free-market economy. If I want to buy or sell here, I have to utilized accepted bartering terms and notes. Should I desire to avoid the interference of taxation, I must resort to an alternative bartering device. If I am not willing to do that, I am obliged to pay whatever taxes are levied against the accepted note. If I do not like the level of taxation or the distribution of the government's funds, it is my obligation to take active measures to install elected officials who share my views in order to promote and implement them on the national level.
.
.....an alternative bartering device?
Think again -- there are none. You can't even barter without being subject to taxes on the value of goods and services traded. If you paint your neighbor's house in exchange for him giving you a side of beef, you will be obligated to pay taxes on the value of that side of beef. (And he will be obligated to pay taxes on the value of that painting job.) And since no money changes hands, but you would still be obligated to make a payment of money to the government, you would then be forced to work (forced to work = slavery) in order to earn the money to pay the government.
And (surprise), we agree on privately owned property, or lack thereof. How can something be fully "owned" if it is subjected to paying royalties to someone else forever and ever and ever and ever? And if you don't pay, you lose it or go to jail or both.
There are no property rights in the USA.
There are no rights to just live in the USA.
There is absolutely NO aspect of one's life in which the government does not assume control.
And that is contrary to the intentions of the founders. This is NOT what America was supposed to become. And if people aren't totally outraged, they're about as stupid as they can be. But they've cooked their own goose. They got exactly what they asked for.
by jdclyde
Him big medicine man, take white eyes scalp!
Trade you some shiny bead for some beer jck! :^O
by jdclyde
every where I go, I have seen the same thing.
People on one side of a fence think someone on the other side has it so easy or better than they deserve. Bet the same people look at you and wonder why you haven't been replaced yet.
Department to department, shift to shift it is always the same.
It is also the same when people find out someone else is making more money they are, it is a big deal. Perfectly happy with a job until then, and then they hate the job because of their petty jellousy.
When a client is taken out and that ceo or whoever comes back with a multi-million dollar contract, that playing around has made more in one day than you will for them in a life time. If you want that kind of a life then go get that kind of a job. Otherwise just enjoy the life you DO have.
by jck
That CEO doesn't deliver a contract.
He or she can get a big fat promise (or "commitment" or "contract", as it is often termed in shareholder reports) from someone else at a potential client...but, his product guys and sales people have to get the customer to agree on price, prove proof of product delivery capability, etc., before that becomes concrete.
BTW, I could have been making 6-figures years ago...got offered to head to Kuwait after Desert Storm by friends whose company in Tulsa was looking for people to do C programming, systems config, etc.
I opted to finish college because the money was not the important thing. And as I said, it has nothing to do with what they make, drive, etc.
It is the fact that they are paid, as salaried employees, to work their duties like anyone else and maintain office hours. Lunches are acceptable and even compensatable if they are a "working lunch". But, 3-4 hour golf excursions during work hours is an abuse of their position and not work-oriented. They could well take those customers golfing at 4:30pm rather than shortly after lunch (as they often did where I used to work).
A lot of executives abuse their priviledge and it's an obvious fact, and get overpaid for it.
Deal with it. It has nothing to do (for me)about money and everything having to do with them not maintaining the same work standard as they enforce on everyone else at their business.
BTW...if it had anything to do with money...I wouldn't have taken this job I'm at and the 40%+ paycut that it involved.
You seem to think I'm some money-hungry gnome...if you want one of those, I suggest you go to look in Congress. Otherwise, realize execs are basically (for the most part) smiling-jack car salesmen.
I'm happy where I am at as well. My boss isn't an idiot, my co-workers are not backstabbers, and the people are friendly and not all politically-correct (which was my worst fear coming to work for a government department).
It gets boring here, but it's far better than having a boss who doesn't know anything other than rumor, co-workers you can't trust, or people who will use any little thing in the rulebook to try and bring you down.
Anyways...you think what you want about CEOs...I just hope the scenario doesn't happen to you described in someone else's post about company buyouts...and your position gets obsoleted because some executive wants to increase bottom-line to make his bonus fatter.
And btw, I have been through that too in 2001. Hundreds laid off...the next year when the numbers came in, CEO took a $800k bonus.
by tonythetiger
"I do not give these people money. Because I see them drinking it. I see the people standing, pooling their moneys together, and splitting a few fifths. Not eating nutrition (they had to walk through a grocery store to get to the liquor) or purchasing new clothes to get a job. They drink it."
That's the difference between you and the government. You can see it, they can't. That's the main thing that's wrong: telling the difference between can't and won't.
by dmambo
Thanks for responding, Max. (Although I would have been very surprised if you hadn't, as from reading your posts, I surmise that you're not one to let a question go unanswered. ;) )
-- In regard to arresting the bums, is it not someone's right to panhandle if that is his life's choice? If we were to allow them to starve because they're just too damn lazy to work, how can we prohibit them from begging as a matter of survival? The transfer of aid to them (I won't say transfer of wealth as, even though it is a net loss of wealth for the givers, it certainly does not accumulate for the receivers) prevents those people from reaching the point of desperation.
-- Jamaica is one place I've visited where there is a nominal democracy, but the poverty is rampant. Perhaps the fact that other examples are hard to find is because the social safety nets help to protect against the dictatorships that we see in the Middle East and Central America.
-- The USA before 1964. I had parents that had extended stays in that country. Listening to the horror stories of 1929 through 1939, I can only believe that we're better off now. The percentage of those living in poverty has gone up as our definiton of the standard of living has gone up. Little things like central heat, indoor plumbing, access to health care have been added to lives below the poverty line. These were not included in the early part of the last century.
I'm not at the point with my kids where any "tough love" is necessary, and I hope I never get there. I don't think I have the strength to do it. I'm trying like hell to imbue them with a sense of values that will obviate the need for it. But if that time comes, I'm sure I'll end up supporting them and/or their kids. I'm glad my government does the same. From your perspective, and I realize I'm making a leap here, maybe I just don't have the spine to watch the results of the liberterian society on the lazy, weak or unlucky. And as I exercise my right to vote for this government of the people, by the people and for the people, I'll choose candidates who support what I feel are important programs. Like Bernie Sanders!!!!
by jck
Indeed they aren't.
When I worked at my last job, I read a report about CEOs and their salaries and their growth between the 1970s and today.
Here's a list of the top compensated CEOs in 2004:
2004 Top 10 Most Highly Paid CEOs on Executive PayWatch
Yahoo Inc. Terry S. Semel $109,301,385
Apple Computer Steven P. Jobs $86,315,789
Coach Inc. Lew Frankfort $64,918,520
TXU Corp. John C. Wilder $54,960,893*
Occidental Petroleum Ray R. Irani $52,648,142
NVR Inc. Dwight C. Schar $51,058,500
KB Home Bruce Karatz $47,288,228
Toll Brothers Robert I. Toll $44,240,611
Allegheny Energy Paul J. Evanson $40,543,354*
Motorola Inc. Edward J. Zander $38,851,374
http://www.aflcio.org/corporatewatch/paywatch/
(I added the asterisks...those are CEOs whose companies lost money for at least the past year, if not longer.)
Total: $590,126,796...not too shabby for 10 people to get money, bonuses and options totalling almost $600M for one year of service.
Also, check out the chart from 1980 to 2003...CEO to worker pay used to be about 50:1 ratio or so. In 2000, it peaked to over 500:1 before the tech crash. In 20 years, CEOs pay increased at 10 times the rate of their average employee. Just sickening.
http://www.aflcio.org/corporatewatch/paywatch/pay/index.cfm
Oh well...The Golden Rule lives:
He who has the gold makes the rules.
by tomsal
That's just it, though at least here anyway. The CEO doesn't bring in the big deals. 90% of the "big deals" (which btw haven't been that big for a while now) are brought in by our sales executives. And they aren't not "real" executives -- just the company thought it look more impressive to have that title on their business cards. The sales guys are cool at my company - they are for more easy understanding "normal average joe guys".
Anyway, and I'll argue tooth and nail with ANYONE on this ENTIRE website about CEO's being paid WAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
more than they are worth.
Its BS, plain and simple.
And spare me the jealousy crap too.
When a company is going through rough times, laying off people some of which whom are barely making ends meet as it is (single parents)..and the ceo still has the nerve to not only pull up in a brand new fully decked out BMW but they spread word through the company that he's buying a new vacation house...that just doesn't wash with jealously as the reason.
Also, is it being jealous when the same year what little bonuses we got (if you can call it that even) is mysteriously striped out the same year the big wig has a multi-million dollar house built?
No I'm sorry its greed and ego...PERIOD.
by ippirate
by absolutely
I had already guessed that Max's ultimate goal (& mine) of personal responsibility for all [i]is[/i] consistent with your beliefs. What I do not understand is the vehemence with which you criticize his strategy, and to me it looks like you're pretty personal about it.
In that post alone, I note phrases "highly offensive", "the [i]habit[/i] of complaining about it" (emphasis added), "lip service" & "Smacking lip and tongue".
So, as long as we're discussing issues, I take issue with your statement that "those same documents imposed a responsibility upon the people to be both active and outspoken in the preservation of the defense, maintenance and governance of the government." Those documents [i]described[/i] a requirement, they did not impose or [i]prescribe[/i] it, and it is very clear from a complete review of the years shortly before and after the Revolution, that the purpose of government is to secure [i]individual[/i] liberty from all forms of tyranny, and that the means of active citizenship were intended to serve that end: to keep the government in check, small, nimble and efficient, being the best at what it does (keeping the peace), and doing only what it does best.
by ippirate
Absolutely, in all sincerety, I don't expect you to approve or like the issue between max and I. I would appreciate it though if you would kindly detach from that point though as there is a history here beyond what I would propose you perceive.
On the matter of the documents not prescribing such, I disagree. A review of all the associated literature - The Constitution, The Declaration, The Federalist Papers, Franklin's pseudonym letters, etc. - there is a repeating thought. The responsibility of the government to govern rightly AND the responsibility of the people to be active. That is the very reason we are founded a republic and given a vote. To say that civic duty is not implied is quite inaccurate in my opinion. If it is not then why create a constitutional amendment allowing for the people to take civic action with there governing officials?
I agree on the purpose of the elected and appointed government but you must remember that technically, each of us is a member of that body in some small way. That is the vote and thereby the voice and the means to act. Civic Duty.
.
It's said that in order to reach a goal, it must be clearly defined, one must stay focused on that target, regardless of how far in the future it may be, and that a plan to reach it should be clear and concise; and if you don't have your eyes on some target, how can you possibly hope to hit it? It's further said that a journey of ten thousand miles begins with one step.
What is my goal -- my target? I think you know what that is, at least I think I've been pretty clear defining it. What is my plan, and what is my time-frame for reaching this goal? Well, I've never espoused the elimination of all transfer of wealth social programs with one fell swoop. To the contrary. I've said on many occasions that it's taken us 50 years to get into this mess, and it will likely take us another 50 to ultimately get out of it. But the first thing that has to change is expectations -- expectations of one's government, and expectations of one's self. And in order to change the expectations, we simply have to change the focus of the dialogue.
Someone else in a different message said something like this.....to reduce the scope of government programs in the long term, they should be expanded in the short term.
Well, I would have to respectfully disagree with that. Because, as it is also said, one definition of insanity is doing the same things over and over again, but expecting different results. And I submit to you, and all Americans, that it's time to stop the insanity by at least acknowledging the problem, establishing the long-term goal (50 years?) to solve the problem, and to take that first small step on the journey to reach it by changing our expectations.
And if you think that a person can't just "pick and choose where you will apply your civic duties", I must wonder who gets to decide those civic duties. Sorry, pirate, that dog won't hunt. You might want to raid my civic duties treasure chest and spend it the way you see fit, but I resist being the target of piracy. I certainly can -- and do -- choose when and how I perform my civic duty.
How about if you just volunteer to drive the "civic duty" truck, and you decide what everyone's "civic duty" should be; and then, with the help of government thugs, I mean agents, you can just round up a bunch of people, throw them in the back of the truck, and take them somewhere where they must spend some time performing your definition of "civic duty". And if they resist, just throw them in jail. And if they really piss you off, just shoot the bastards and throw their dead carcasses into a mass grave.
EVERYBODY WILL PERFORM THEIR CIVIC DUTY OR THEY WILL BE SHOT ON SIGHT!
And consider this:
In order for me to support myself, I must work for a living, as do most people. And most people give an honest hour's work for an honest hour's pay. (And consider that I can't even barter without having to pay transfer of wealth taxes on that transaction.) So if I have to give my time to earn a dollar, and if my dollar is taken away from me against my will, then by extension, my time is also taken away from me against my will. And that, my friend, is either indentured servitude at best, or slavery at worst. And I believe there's a constitutional amendment prohibiting that.
But what do I know? You seem to presume to know best for everybody as to how and when they should perform their civic duty. And please enlighten us. What would you propose we do with people who don't want to perform your definition of civic duty?
PREPARE TO BE BOARDED! ..... GIVE US YOUR CARGO! ..... EVERYBODY WILL PERFORM THEIR CIVIC DUTY OR THEY WILL BE SHOT ON SIGHT! ..... THE PIRATE HAS SPOKEN! ..... KABOOM!
by ippirate
Now that is funny. You made all your little overtures to civility. You really do get defensive when you are challenged don't you?
Strawmen and inconsequential. You bandy about your argument as far as it is convenient. Now, when faced with the demands of public and civic responsibility you scurry to the shadows and begin your overtures of tyranny. See, we can both play these games maxi.
In other words, you want your way, your way. This isn't BK max. Hate it for you. The United States of America is not about max. It is about the citizenship of this nation. It is about ethics and rule by law. You proposed in an earlier thread that the problem with health care is that someone else pays for it. BS but useful. The problem with the US is that no one has had to earn their citizenship and the privileges that come with that. Because of that there are myriads of irresponsible and asinine folks running about making law and imposing that law upon others. Not from Constitutional charter but from a majority strength. It doesn't matter that you want fix one of the minor symptoms of the greater issue. You are still one of those folks. You do not value your liberty, if you did, you would defend the very core of that liberty, your civic duty. Why? Because my idiotic friend, you would realize that it is the foundation from which all the rest springs. You sing the same song as the welfare recipient, just a different key and a different choir.
You are very good at issuing challenges. I challenge you, your self-righteousness, to prove me wrong in my proposition that civic duty is exponentially more important than the personal liberty you cry about. In the course of that please remember that you will have to show how the founding fathers ever made motion apart from it. They acted upon theirs and they much appreciated their new found liberties, they earned them. You are what they would have been had they never acted.
You quote greats, it would do you well to actually study those men rather than attempt to utilize words they spoke to justify your own self-centered complaining. You want the privilege and despise the duty, politicizing not for the betterment of the union but rather a tweak to the system for your own self-serving interests. Your limited and short-sighted view is indicative of your disregard of for the principles established other than to warp and twist them to your own selfish bent. You are just as bad as the people you rail against who recieve that check every month and the politicians that serve them.
Oh well, I figured as much on your part.
.
You said, "I challenge you, your self-righteousness, to prove me wrong in my proposition that civic duty is exponentially more important than the personal liberty you cry about."
It's simply in the definition of "civic duty".
I suggest that it's everyone's "civic duty" to be self-responsible, strive to become self-reliant, not become a burden to others, and to refrain from infringing on the rights of others. To presume that I am not at least responsible for myself is, by extension and definition, suggesting that another is responsible for me. That is a very simple thing to understand, whether or not you agree with it.
Contrast that to your, "In the course of that please remember that you will have to show how the founding fathers ever made motion apart from it."
What? What in the heck does that mean?
You try to be too "smart" for me. You can never explain things in a simple and concise manner. you're coy and evasive, and try to put up this aloof front. I guess you're busy making motion apart from it. (Intentional nonsense.)
I call it taking self-responsibility. You call it being selfish.
And you just insist on continuing the flaming and name-calling, don't you? Such as, "....my idiotic friend....." and "....your own selfish bent....." and ".....your self-righteousness.....". Why do you insist on continuing the snide remarks when none are returned? The worst thing I called you was a "pirate" -- and that's what you call yourself!
Speaking of "self-righteousness", dude, look in the mirror. I don't make the aloof presumption to suggest how you live your life, but you can't possibly say the same thing in return. Self-righteousness, indeed.
by tomsal
The *sigh* being that you know it'll NEVER be the way that you just presented. Thus the cycle of certain members of our society esentially defrauding us of our money will continue forever more -- unchecked, unabated.
The first person to ever say "life isn't fair" could well of been talking about this issue.
by ippirate
So in all of that you bring it to the point of not being able to realistically present an answer. Is this correct? Or are you now attempting to flip?
I find it odd that you are again stating that it is un-ethical at least for one to impose upon another but you insist that your theory be imposed on others. Doesn't wash. Not one post back you were barking at me about the imposition of responsibility to civic duty but you are now saying that your pet theory is dependent upon it. Please, make up your mind max.
You call it taking self-responsibility. I call it selfish. I do so because your self-responsibility is derived simply from selfish and self-centered motivations which demand that all things be enacted only in so far as they benefit, please or do not negatively impact you. Sorry, that isn't responsible, that is selfish.
In being to smart for you. I don't really think I have to try max. To clear the haze for you, there never would have been a Decalaration, much less a revolt or Consitution if the founding fathers hadn't acted in the interest of the whole and subjected the individual to the collective governance to begin with. In other words max, they realized that the welfare of individual was dependent upon the welfare of the state and that the success of the state was dependent upon the successful representation and implementation of civic duty. Shall we pull out the dictionary max? Civic duty is immediately and wholly defined as duty to the whole, the community, not the self as you seem to warp it to. Yes it begins in individual responsibility. Individual responsibility to the preservation and advancement of the union and the promotion and defense of the liberties affirmed by the Constitution.
As to your last lie. You have in fact made, on more than one occassion, both overtures and direct accusations of my ideologies, philosophies, opinions and ethics. From nothing short of your lacking of anything more rational or intellectualy viable to say. Remember, I'm just a leftist, touchy feely, hug and kiss, nut case who believes that it is my public duty to take your money and give it to someone who hasn't job.
Whatever.
.
You said, "I find it odd that you are again stating that it is unethical at least for one to impose upon another, but you insist that your theory be imposed on others."
When you consider that my theory is to not impose on others, your argument would suggest that your theory IS to impose on others because you refute my theory of NOT imposing on others, and round-and-round we go.
We can all see what you do when faced with an argument against which you have no reasonable rebuttal.
You are simply being faced with two choices. You will have to either agree with me, heaven forbid, or admit that it's your desire to impose your will on others, neither of which is acceptable to you. You're faced with a lose-lose situation; and your attempts to talk your way round-and-round-and-round the issue results in the obvious and nonsensical circular logic -- or circular illogic, I should say.
You just do not make any sense. It's no wonder you are forever making motion apart from it. (Sarcastic nonsense intended.)
by jck
Working can get you somewhere sometimes...but, I'd wager that at most corporations...and a lot of privately owned companies...you're not gonna be a manager of a department after 20 years of service...unless you're related to someone, married to someone's kid, friends with someone, you're someone who'll "do it for the company" 100% of the time even if it's immoral or unethical or cruel, or no one else wanted the job who was one of the things listed above.
Like in my case:
I've been programming computers since a week or two after I got my first C-64. My parents hated the fact I was only starting to play games on it rather than learn or do something productive, so they started by asking me to write them a phone/address keeper program. I did that in a short time in Commodore BASIC.
Since then, I helped people with computers through junior high, high school, and college, plus worked jobs with computers in high school and college doing consulting...so to speak (makin $10 here and there showing people how to use Bankstreet Writer, Wordstar, etc.).
In my career, I've worked some tough ass jobs...including my first one out of college where in a year there my *average* week was 56 hours...and, I was salaried at a *gross* pay of $11,400 a year...no benefits...no paid vacation...and that was 1994. That's what I get for growing up in rural Oklahoma.
My next two jobs weren't bad after that, but I had to move up by transferring positions within the same organization...went from being senior computer programmer for the main office, to computer services section head at the housing authority. Again, I had to transfer jobs to move up.
When I left the supervisory job, it was because all I was doing was PC maintenance and doing datafile changes when they keyed in a AP or AR entry wrong. My brain was rotting from lack of use.
I came to FL because (besides the beach and no snow) when I interviewed they said I would be promoted quickly from Software Engineer I to Software Engineer II because of my experience. After my first year came and went without thought about it (as I asked my "mentor" about it and he told me just to be patient), I waited patiently for the next 6 month "review" and when I asked again, he looked at me funny and said "Why do you want to move up?" and my reply was "Because I don't feel I am at the skill level of a college graduate coming here." and he chuckled at that answer. Plus, new grads that had not even finished a project who were hired after me were getting promoted after 1 year. That's when I realized it was a sham.
So, then I went to a company after I'd been there for over two years that I knew there was no chance for advancement. I was simply a hired gun for them doing IT stuff for their customers.
Needless to say, that ended up being the company at which I was laid off after the tech boom.
Nonetheless, the story goes on and on. The job I currently have is one that, if I wait about 10-12 years, I have the probability of filling my boss' job when he retires because I'll have seniority, experience, knowledge of all the systems, and 2 of the other 3 guys will be retiring as well.
Needless to say...if Miss Right doesn't show up outside of the county here...I'll be staying here until I retire...then, Ireland is probably where I'll go to get old.
by jck
Mine was $7M+ that it brought in...not $12M...and...other than the IT guys setting up the hard drive and the network connection for my PC...I did everything else...from loading Microsoft Visual C++ 5, to the architecture and design of my software, to researching and reading EVERY IETF RFC on the Internet, to all three volumes of TCP/IP Illustrated back-to-front, to learning about ATM, SONET, and FDDI and 802.x and a sundry of other network things.
I wrote the proposal for the IR&D.
I wrote the specs for my project.
I did the research.
I came up with the project plan.
I came up with the DFDs, SDD, ERDs, User Manual, Technical Spec, etc.
I wrote all the software.
I tested all the software.
I documented all my software.
I sales pitched it to potential clients.
I demonstrated it.
I answered their questions.
I gave them *my* card to call for questions.
So yes, other than it getting mentioned to some customers who were on site and having them take 15 minutes to review it as one of the many projects that were created...
About the only thing I didn't do on that project was set the price.
So yeah...pretty much...I created, promoted, designed, implemented, and sold that software by *myself*. How many execs can do that?
Who says effort gets you anything...got me nothing other than overworked and ignored.
by jck
I'd rather be an injun than someone who lives in a hoos in Misheegin eh.
(And yeah...I've been to Michigan and Minnesota and they talk that way...)
by ippirate
max said it, it must be true.
I've said my part and in my perception, you are still tapdancing.
Have at it.
by cuteelf
Arent on welfare, mostly.
Being homeless, you cannot be on welfare, because you need a physical and mailing address BOTH to qualify..along with the needs etc.
Most of the corner people are summer homeless vagrants who camp out in the parks and many wooded groves here in Anchorage. They literally live in the woods.
Many of them are Alaska Native ethnic group- who can also recieve a dividend from their corporation if enrolled. Whites dont.
I've said before:
I see people needing help
I see people using help
I see people abusing help
I'll take all kinds, because karma will get them in the end.
Cute
by cuteelf
Your quote:
Your friends would not have to rely on a system that treats such waste as their "equals".
See, Ab, this is where you and I really depart.
I see good in all people, various amounts of good per person, but its there.
The people who drink away their lives are making their own choice: and are here on earth for a reason..that reason is out of my jurisdiction.
It is not my job to say to a person You are not worthy of being here, you're garbage. That's not very good- reminds me of being a bit too judgemental: judging a person by who they are (whehter black, white, asian, drunk, stoned or handicapped)
A govt. cannot treat some as better and some as worse, that is what we left! We left Europe to leave the class structuring. Royalty vs. Peons..etc.
This is why our govt. will help people asking for it, while using criteria to match needs, and fundings, while not saying, Uhm, You're in a Wheelchair, I dont give X Y or Z to wheelies. Same for blacks. Same for Asians. Same for all.
by ippirate
You are not obliged to surrender tax revenue on anything other transaction other than those in which the open market monetary medium - the all mighty dollar bill - is utilized. In instances of barter and exchange of services, no taxation applies until a dollar passes hands. Property taxes are levied against lands temporarily assigned to a possessor. Vehicular taxes are only levied against those which utilized their right of privilege to possess.
No, there is no need to pay taxes max. You can argue it but there are completely legal ways to not do so. You may not like the life which it affords but that doesn't mean they don't exist.
As to this not being what America was supposed to become, just what should it have become max? Should we have stopped somewhere around 1790? Perhaps 1840? 1900? At what point did America quit "becoming" what it was meant to be? I'm betting that you cannot present an equitable and sound argument to defend that statement beyond it becoming other than what you think it should be. I'll wait and see what kind of BS you through out before I call you completely on it though.
.
You asked, "At what point did America quit "becoming" what it was meant to be?"
February 3, 1913.
You said, "I'm betting that you cannot present an equitable and sound argument to defend that statement beyond it becoming other than what you think it should be."
The significance of the date should speak for itself. And you lose the bet.
You said, "I'll wait and see what kind of BS you through (sic) out before I call you completely on it though."
In other words, you'll just argue with me regardless of what I say. That's exactly what I thought you'd do. In fact, that's all you do.
by beads
From Nationmaster.com/encyclopedia....
The Income Tax Act of 1894 attempted to impose a federal tax of 2% on incomes over $4,000. Derided by its opponents as "communistic", it was challenged in federal court. In the case of Pollock v. Farmers' Loan & Trust Co. (1895), the Supreme Court declared it to be an unconstitutional "direct tax", forbidden by Article I of the Constitution unless apportioned by population. Such apportionment was impractical for income taxes, since the rates would have to be set differently in different states depending on their population and total incomes. In response, this amendment was passed by Congress (and ratified by the necessary fraction of the states in 1913) in order to make federal income taxes constitutional.
Evidently, the American people didn't have a say in this amendment. Requiring 3/4ths of states to first ratify and all that.
I stand corrected. First I said 2/3rds not 3/4ths. Also there is some confusion about the ratification of the 16th Amendmant in general. It seems that according to our own law only 2 states fully ratified the admendant. One did not vote on the bill (California) or failed to ratify the Amendment (Kentucky, Minnesota and Oklahoma). Well, it seems that Oklahoma passed the opposite of the intended legislation stating that the Federal Government can not enforce the 16th Amendment.
Because I am not a lawyer, let alone a constitutional lawyer, I really can't comment on the constitutionality of such without sounding like a complete fool. There may be proof that the Federal government is in violation of its own Constitution!
Score one for Max! And thanks for the civics lesson.
- beads
Ahhh... such a slipperly slope
- beads
by ippirate
I take it then that you would have supported slavery as much as Madison and Jefferson then? Perhaps Davis? Maybe you feel that it would have been more equitable to have continued to deny the vote to women?
Is the problem on this side of the date then? Does that mean that you support segregation?
To correct you misguided notion max, I argue with you because I disagree with you and I can. Something you outright solicited at the top of your post. I disagree with you because I am repulsed by the methodology and motives of your position. You cannot even bring yourself to admit that we agree on the ends but not the means or motivations. Even now, you still have not replied to the post at the top of what you are currently reading besides your trivial aside that led in this direction.
You have on more than one occassion aluded to my "liberalism" and confronted me on a supposed lack of knowledge concerning our founding documents only to shuttle to abject silence on both counts and bemoan me responding in kind. You've even managed to get Absolutely involved as your ally to tell me how evil I am for going at you. Unfortunately he doesn't seem to be aware of two small facts. First, this subject is a repeat performance for you. Two, you hate to be contradicted with the least amount of strength and mercy to the person that dares to call you wrong or mistaken to your face.
No, I argue with you because I think you are wrong and contrary to what you seem to believe, if you propose that you have the right to post here your philosophy in an attempt to spread a wrongheaded ideal then I have an equal right to post against you and point out your flaws.
Why not just admit it max, you don't want debate, you want acceptance and proliferation. At least then you would be being honest about at least one of your reasons. So post away max. I'll call 'em as I see 'em and if no one else feels compelled to read, agree or disagree with me, I can at least rest knowing that I voiced my disagreement and objections against an ignorant proposition presented by an equally ignorant man. That, dear politico, is a root foundation of liberty and civic duty.
Good day!
.
"Business people who want to get involved in trading should remember that there is no tax advantage to bartering. Barter and cash transactions are the same in the eyes of the Internal Revenue Service--both are taxed equally. In fact, bartering exchanges must report goods and services sold through barter to the IRS."
http://www.sideroad.com/Bartering/bartering.html
And, of course, just like any other IRS rule, there may be exceptions. But, generally speaking, and in the words of the IRS:
"Bartering occurs when you exchange goods or services without exchanging money. An example of bartering is a plumber doing repair work for a dentist in exchange for dental services.....(Or a painter and a butcher, as in my example). The fair market value of goods and services exchanged must be included in the income of both parties.....Income from bartering is taxable in the year in which you receive the goods or services. Generally, you report this income on Schedule C....."
http://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc420.html
So you are WRONG, again, pirate.
Unless, of course, you're speaking of some sort of underground economic transaction, which goes on anyway, bartering or otherwise. But you couldn't be talking about underground transactions, could you? Because we would then have to ask, under which part of "civic duty" would that fall?
by beads
The opposite argument would be 'civil disobedience'. Not unlike witholding your taxes until 11:59 PM, 15 Apr XX. Or protesting in a "non-violent" manner against the government (local, state or Federal).
Many examples of people not paying thier subjective taxes and I hear there is a good number of web sites advertising bartered services over a certain dollar amount of value. The tricky thing is to declare your services for less than market value unless your a professional in that field (Dentist, Physicians, et. al.) have a very difficult time getting around Schedule C. Other non-professionals can easily get around this by declaring less than market value than the "professional."
- beads
by ippirate
In the example given by the IRS we are shown a dentist and a plumber exchanging goods. The goods? Plumbing repair and a root canal. Are those taxable, perhaps, but not necessarily.
If those services are attached as a gift to say a pencil, then the pencil is taxable ($.10) and the gift is not, as long as it does not exceed $11,000 in value for the year.
Oh, the word gift grits you does it? Then exchange it for the word "promotional item". There, nice, tidy, legal.
Hmmmmm. In response to your question about what part of civic duty would black market fall under. I will refer you to the opening of the Declaration of Independence and put forth that in the same times as described therein. How is it worded? "When it becomes necessary to shake of the yoke of tyranny"?
Please, play again.
.
Bernie Sanders is the ONLY admitted (and, at one time, registered) Socialist in Congress.
You really do know how to hurt a guy.
When Bernie was mayor of Burlington, Vermont, it became known as one of the most "homeless friendly" cities in the nation. The epitome of, "build it and they will come". In this case, provide it, and those that need it will fall like leaves in a New England autumn.
On the panhandling comment, I didn't say that I advocated arresting them, but that some people do. Personally, I'm undecided on that particular question, and it would depend on the particulars of the proposed law.
by absolutely
They do not choose their ethnicity, and poverty resulting from slavery followed by Jim Crow laws and other segregationist measures that withheld opportunity from Blacks [b]by force[/b] are not morally equivalent or even similar to my [b]valid choice[/b] to withhold [b]my[/b] money from drunks. You undermine all moral principles when you equate immoral choices with unfortunate circumstances that are not chosen. You did that, not me. I never said I would not be willing to help a "wheelie". You said that on my behalf, without any basis in anything I said, and in contradiction of all my beliefs. I have never read anything more offensive.
It is not evil to judge people. Whatever job you hold is yours because somebody [b]judged[/b] you to be the most qualified candidate. The principle of political liberty is based on the [b]judgement[/b] that normal people have the ability to [b]judge[/b] on their own behalf what is best for them.
Judgement of people according to traits that they [b]did not[/b] choose -- race, gender, or handicap -- is evil, I agree, and an entirely different scenario that you equate with judgement of people [b]according to the quality of the choices they make[/b].
Where we depart, Elf, is not in seeing the [b]potential[/b] for good in everybody, I can see that as well as you can. Where we depart is in your willingness to [b]sacrifice[/b] the good to the bad. By supporting the status quo -- inefficient government charity -- you're depriving every deserving, honest recipient who suffers only from bad luck, of at least 83% of the money available to help them. And that only counts administrative overhead, not addicts and deadbeat frauds.
If food, clothing, shelter, and every other commodity that is traded for money -- the symbol and medium of exchange of competent effort -- then it would be perfectly just to distribute all those things according to need. But all those things are not free, they all cost somebody their competent effort, so justice requires that they be distributed according to the ability to produce. I am sorry if you know some people whose best efforts are less productive than mine, but I assure you that they would all be better off without a system that treats them exactly the same as people who aren't trying at all, or whose only effort is to steal.
by absolutely
If I remember, you said you brought the company $7M and were only paid $38k. You know that the exec gets $5M and said he should therefore bring in at least $5M+$7M=$12M. If I were his superior, and thought I could get the same productivity out of each person, I'd be looking for $5M*$7M=$35T! That figure makes me skeptical that you'd be only making $38k if that $7M was really "all you".
I have no doubt that you did your entire project single-handedly, that's the best way to write a program, or to solve the majority of purely technical problems. Teams come into the picture (very generally) when grunt work is required.
But without your employer's reputation, how much could you expect to be paid for doing the exact same tasks? The corporate entity does give you something: relative security compared to entrepreneurship's 85% failure rate -- in exchange for much more limited advancement opportunities.
C'est la vie.
by ippirate
To say that civic disobedience is the inverse you would have to then propose that civic obedience was what is required.
Though breaking the law or rallying against the government may be "civic disobedience" it might also be "civic obedience" as in the case of the government having lost the public interest.
The opposite of civic duty, I would say, is civic disregard. In other words, the rejection of any responsibility to the community and/or the function and caretaking of the governance.
by absolutely
I have only participated in Tech Republic a few months, and am neither privy to nor interested in any previous disagreements causing your animosity toward maxwell edison. I think it's undignified of me to interject myself into that exchange, and such action diminishes me as a person, and as a participant. My views will tend to be dismissed out of hand the more I participate in such a squabble, and rightly so.
Briefly, on civic duty. I have never found justification for the premise that some citizens have more civic duties than other citizens, except those that willingly accept it by pursuing public office. The very idea reminds me of Orwell's Animal Farm, in which "some animals are more equal than others."
How do [b]you[/b] reconcile the difference between civic duty as involvement in one's own governance -- as described by the founders -- and civic duty as mandated charity? I cannot.
.
Whatever the "issue" is, it's one sided. Pirate came into this discussion attacking me, I never returned any such attack, but he continued. He's got a personal problem. Do you need proof? He's got "an issue" with some unknown guy on an Internet discussion board. Enough said.
Get a life, loser.
"...the issue between max and I (sic)"
...and he tries to come across as being so friggin' smart. What a joke.
And while you're at it, get an education.
by absolutely
"The opposite of civic duty, I would say, is civic disregard. In other words, the rejection of any responsibility to the community and/or the function and caretaking of the governance."
Separated by and/or, you present first, the premise of collectivism, and second an action that [b]is[/b] motivated by rational self-interest: maintaining the government's role as protector of liberty by keeping it limited to that role. My interaction with the community -- all of it -- I choose in my self-interest. Beyond that self-interest I have no further obligations. Beyond that self-interest, any further interest I take in anybody else is a [b]gift[/b] to that person.
I second everything. Not only does welfare burden the working man, but it just makes the person receiving the money even more lazy. It stifles the personal drive and motivation to work and support yourself. Another situation that exemplifies this is a 30 year old man living with his parents. Why move out, pay bills and other expenses when you can get it all free from your parents. I've seen cases of this and its pretty pathetic. Another example is seen in nature, when you feed the animals they become dependent on the food given to them by humans and eventually die because they can't fend for themselves. The reason why many naturalists and such tell you not feed wild animals.
Welfare collaboratively with other reasons was the reason for the fall of the Roman Empire. Many Roman citizens had become dependent on the soup and bread lines and it had become to much of an expense for the Roman government.
However I'm not completely discrediting welfare, there are some cases where it is essential. When welfare had first came out it was for the Vietnam War Widows (I believe, correct me if I'm wrong)and it played a critical role for finical support for those widows. However there are some people that take advantage of the system ( people I know, including family which utterly disgusts me) and these cases should be looked into. The government shouldn't be a charity fundraiser, there are separate programs for them. There are also plethora of churches in the U.S. that provide support to those in financial predicaments.
by absolutely
If Welfare did begin as assistance for Vietnam War Widows, that should embarrass recipients who are [b]not[/b] Vietnam War Widows. But it doesn't, does it?
I think you ought to completely discredity welfare. In all those cases of predicaments, there are enough compassionate people around to be helpful in cases of true bad luck and emergencies. There would be even more helpful people if taxes were reduced by the amount of all government transfer of wealth programs!
by jdclyde
once you get down to the lower penissula, we are regulare folk. Go north of the Mackinaw bridge and you hit people like that. Pretty goofy, probably from being so close to them there canadians!
Good thing I am bald already so I don't have to worry about you trying to scalp ME! ;\
by dmambo
by jck
the comparative analysis was this:
I made $38,000 at the time.
The IR&D I produced from inception to presentation by myself brought in $7M+ total from 3 customers...ok?
Now, the CEO where I worked was paid $9M in compensation plus a $3M bonus that year...which totalled $12M, and that for him to be as productive (albeit financially...no business-focused CEO is ever going to write thousands of lines of code like I did) he would have to have brought in $19M+ to bring back as much to the corp as I did financially and compensate for his pay.
The point was made by jdclyde that CEOs bring in multi-million dollar contracts that justify their compensation.
I then made the point that CEOs didn't develop projects or deliver them to bring in revenue like I had done. In fact, there was no salesman, product line manager or consultant involved in the project. One department had budget to fund proposals, so I wrote it up based on the arena they wanted it for...and I was one of 4 that was accepted.
How your math makes sense I don't know. $35T? hm...this makes more sense in comparative analytical terms:
I made $38k. My direct revenue generation was $7M+. The ratio of revenue to expense for myself was about 189 to 1.
If P.F. made $12M in total compensation that year, his direct revenue generation for that company by himself would have to have been in excess of $2B that year to have been as profitable based on arevenue-to-compensation comparison.
And if memory serves me correctly, we were only awarded around $350-400M that year total in new projects (1998).
So although I'm sure he served some purpose (other than laying people off every 4-5 years to fatten his bonus), there was no way he was more directly beneficial, or comparatively profitable as I was.
In fact, I'd rather have had a team of sales guys like the former Army colonel I worked with on another product. He might have been out playing golf on occassion with a client, but he'd come back in the office other days and make the time up and spend time with all his projects to make sure he knew what their status and capabilities were.
Anyways...enough rants about CEOs. I've got bigger concerns at the house. Wireless network and satellite feed problems to resolve this weekend.
Have a nice weekend.
by jck
Um...Indians might not have scalped you for the trophy hair...
But, some tribes would have let their dogs eat you up after you died.
At a minimum...you'd have been stripped naked and your clothes taken for trophies.
Don't think they'd have much use for your Linux servers though...but, they're not Cherokee like me...I dig Linux... :)
by ippirate
Just who did say anything about mandated charity?
I don't recall saying that you are mandated toward that end. I have said that the entire issue of addressing the tax and re-distribution issue is minimalistic. Without address to the greater issues involved there will be no lasting solution. For myself, or anyone else for that matter, to address the tax and re-distribution and not take steps and action to address the place from which it springs is ignorant and irresponsible. What I have essentially done is pass on my responsibility to someone else, which is exactly what is being cited as the perceived wrong in question and the very thing that is being noted as needing correction.
by ippirate
Civic duty does not equal charity and I resent your implying that I am attempting to draw an equality there Absolutely. Civic duty does, whether you like it or not, require you to take active part in your community. In the management and admistration, whether in as little as a vote or as much as an office. It does require you to be responsible and thoughtful of the decision that you ultimately attempt to exert through your vote as well as demanding your understanding and assent to the principles upon which this nation was founded. In the whole of this diatribe I have not once demanded that you take up the act of charity toward your neighbor, that, agreed is a choice. I have however, made statement that the current predicament is our responsibility to deal with. Whether we like it or not, our decisions do impact the populace as a whole and our careful consideration and just action is utmost importance. Whether it is desirable or not, to simply flip the switch is asinine and will lead to a situation far worse. Furthermore, to act in a manner that only feeds the selfish desires of the one leads to infighting and chaos as everyone attempts to "get theirs". The preservation of the union is not something that comes at the cost of the preservation of the self. If you disagree with that then I would ask you to please justify the Civil War.
It is a tenious thread that holds our nation suspended above chaos. On one hand we have the importance and preservation of the individual liberty. On the other is the preservation of the union which is the guarantor and defender of that liberty. Ultimately, selfishness is a stab to the very heart of our union as selfishness always demands that the self's interest be met at the expense of the other. The self-benefit becomes the measure of "health".
by ippirate
That's four posts in a row in which you have slung more of your insults. At least you are screwing up enough guts to be open about it at this point.
Let's see.
You posted. Oz commented. I replied to Oz. You jumped at me. I still don't think you've said word one to Oz about his comment, I could be wrong there.
I replied and called your game, making my standing observation of your arguments: repetitive and vain self-interest which you cleverly attempt to hide in patriotism.
You made your comment that I don't know anything about the Constitution, I responded in a manner sufficient to show your incorrect.
For a change, we went a round about tax law, in which you prematurely declared yourself the victor, when shown incorrect, you call me a game player. I challenge you to point to when the nation went south, you point to when federal taxation was amended. I assumed that from your statement, that we were wrong to implement income tax. I therefore ask you if your position is that we were then wrong to abolish slavery or grant women the vote. I am a game player for asking those questions as well.
***As an aside to our little timeline I would like to make two other points on taxation. First, you will recall that one of the rallying calls of the Revolution was "No taxation". Wait, there was more wasn't there? It went something like "without representation". max, taxation is legal and was legally implemented, through your friendly elected representative. Second, on the matter of individual taxation. You are guaranteed only the following inalienable rights - Life, Liberty and The Pursuit of Happiness. Nowhere in that does it say that you will live tax free. It can be done but that is a question of what makes YOU "happiest". In the event that two things arise in your life that make you happy but they oppose each other, that is your problem to straighten out, not the government's to capitulate and make you happy.****
And so we arrive back to our timeline. At this point it has been several posts since you have actually addressed any of the points that I raise.
Begun throwing insults? Check.
Started correcting my grammar? Check.
Has begun making allusions to ma educachun? Check!
And can no longer present a rational answer or counter-argument to the debate? Check, check, check.
I'd say it won't be to much longer and you'll hit me with the big whammy - "You're an idiot (or something on those lines) and I'm not talking to you any more". Translation, "I can't rationally defend what I propose so I will instead insult you and take my ball and run away :P Fppppppt!!!!".
That's okay max, I'll still be sure to point out the flaws in your proposition.
Sort by Trending