Discussion Locked

Individual Liberty in America - Is it a thing of the past?

0 helpful
384 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post

384 replies

by montgomery gator

However, I would remove the "progressivity" and make it completely flat, with no rebate.

Also, instead of continuing Social Security and Medicare, I would phase them out. Current retires and those who are about to retire (age 55 and older, maybe?) would still get full benefits, but future retires would have the amounts gradually reduced until the programs would be eliminated (those in their early 20s currently would get nothing, and in exchange, they would see their tax burden reduced over their lifetime). I am against transfer of wealth programs, but since people have planned their retirements based on Social Security and Medicare, that is why I would phase them out over a period of years, to give younger people time to plan for their retirement.

by maxwell edison

.
I agree, I would also phase them out. In fact, it might take 40 to 50 years to "fairly" phase them out.

However, as I said, those kinds of things can be addressed later, after the fact. Changing the way the government collects taxes, and doing it in a less intrusive way, has nothing to do with the things that taxes pay for.

- Eliminate the IRS.

- Repeal the 16th amendment.

- No more filing deadlines.

- No more payroll withholding.

- etc.

This FairTax plan makes a lot of sense to me.

Let's get this in place first, and then we can work on reducing the percentage of tax, making it more inclusive, and eliminating the transfer of wealth programs.

by tonythetiger

I hope you have 10 different social security numbers too. And even if you did, that's no worse than what you can do now.

As far as not taxing essential items, someone has to define essential, and that definition could vary by person/family. To an older person with a respiratory ailment, oxygen tanks could be an essential item for example.

Perhaps no method is fraud-proof. You're still going to have to fill out a tax form to get the rebate, and put your spouse and/or other dependents on it.

"Or we could implement a simpler plan that relies only on retailers' honesty & interest in not being prosecuted: charge no taxes on items necessary for daily life. Groceries obviously, household cleaners possibly, air conditioners for old people in Arizona maybe, and now you see where I'm going. Instead of making some income untaxable, make transactions of poor people untaxable. It's still a tax exemption for the poor, but it's less of a drain on the system."

How's the retailer going to be able to tell who's poor and who's not? I've seen people on Welfare who dress better and drive better cars than I do!

Several years back, there was a rash of people accepting foodstamps for everything from beer, cigarettes, and clothing, to rent and car payments. Many were caught and imprisoned, but I suspect many more weren't, and are still probably out there.

by absolutely

I propose exemptions on necessary [b]items[/b], not for people, [b]except[/b] for things like oxygen tanks, in the rare cases that those are also necessary. But only people with unique needs would have to prove those needs, and to get an oxygen tank they would already have to see a doctor, so the doctor just signs one more form. Deciding essentials is easy. If you can live without it, it isn't essential. I would have nobody pay taxes on groceries and other essential items. Since people poor enough to in need of such complete exemption would buy only the essentials, they would not be taxed. OK?

Finally, it's true that letting people prove low income for a tax break does not invite fraud [b]more[/b] than the current arrangement, my idea is just a little bit better because it eliminates the necessity of proving poverty completely, and only a few items have to be proven necessary in a few rare cases. The same goal is achieved more simply, with less regulatory overhead. That makes it better.

by maxwell edison

.
You fail to see that you are, or should be, comparing ONLY two things. What we have now versus what is proposed.

You can spout off as much as you want about how things "should be". (And I also do it {spout off, that is} myself.) But there's a time to spout off, and there's a time to see things as they are, and to consider what can be realistically done to improve them. It may not be perfect, but it just might be better.

And guess what? The ideal scenario that you desire is not on the table. It is simply not an option at this point in time.

You have two choices. Keep what we have, or support the FairTax plan.

Which is the right choice?

And if you choose to keep what we have, I must wonder.

by absolutely

The "Fair Tax Plan" is likely the best. But until taxes are truly uniform, I will point out that such a situation is still unfair by calling this proposal the "Fair" Tax Plan. To be literal, it is less unfair than what we have, but not truly fair, only a [large] step in that direction.

btw, beads has an interesting article quoted. It has been several years since I was reminded that income tax is voluntary...maybe we should not reform after all! j/k

by maxwell edison

.
beads is wrong -- dead wrong -- in "pointing out" that paying taxes is voluntary. Just try to not pay them, and see how "voluntary" it really is. As long as we have a 16th amendment, it IS NOT VOLUNTARY!

But shift the tax collection system to a NST, and it will indeed become voluntary. Don't buy, and you don't pay.

And please, "POINT OUT" the problems along the way.

This is only a first step, not the final step.

The system we have now just has to go. IT HAS TO GO!

by absolutely

He just provided a link to it, and described the rant as "interesting" or "thought-provoking" or something. You may also disagree with that, but beads didn't make the claim that income tax is presently optional, only relayed it to us for comment. I'd like to stop paying my income taxes, and never file again, but I don't know of any employers that will hire employees who don't provide a SS card.

by tonythetiger

Different people have different ideas of what is necessary (for themselves AND for others). Is this going to be a self-determined thing, or something imposed on us from above?

by tonythetiger

How much can there be, cutting a check for 1/12 of poverty level for your family size every month?

Looking at the fairtax proposal combined with my current habits, I'll actually lose a few thousand a year until I retire (I work for a govt agency and do not currently pay into Social Security or Medicare), and will lose a little afterward (I already paid income tax on part of my retirement), but the cool thing is that I have more power to mitigate those losses. It's not perfect, but overall I think it's a huge step in the right direction.

by absolutely

"Different people have different ideas of what is necessary (for themselves AND for others)."

That statement is equally true of the definition of poverty, and disagreement is equally inane in both cases. It is possible to live without filet mignon, but it is not possible to live without some protein.

"Is this going to be a self-determined thing, or something imposed on us from above?"

The determination would be made just the same way that the determination of poverty is made, by elected representatives.

Do you have any [b]intelligent[/b] questions yet?

by absolutely

I agree fully. I hope that it is understood that the fact that I can call this proposal "a huge step in the right direction", yet still criticize it, means only that I believe we need to move even further in that direction.

As a first step, I support it.

by maxwell edison

.
I, too, support it as a first step. Can't ask for much more than that.

Write your congressman and tell him/her to support it as well, or when the next election rolls around (in 15 months), you'll vote for someone who will.

by tonythetiger

is, from my POV, any question for which I don't know the answer.

"It is possible to live without filet mignon, but it is not possible to live without some protein."

So "someone" is going to decide for us which groceries are taxed and which are not. And if someone gets an exemption because he's alergic to the "officially sanctioned protein-containing material", how is the grocer supposed to know whether an alternative is to be taxed or not?

Sounds like a cheap Orwell knock-off to me!

by tonythetiger

Just to let you know I didn't miss it (the medicine is starting to work). I'd add something I thought was witty, but what would be the point? You obviously have spent a great deal of time thinking of demeaning comebacks for every occasion, and if there's ever an award for that, I'll be the first one to nominate you.

by absolutely

You make it too easy.

And if you read carefully you'll see that in answer to your ridiculous question about filet mignon and lobster, I answered that whether tax exemptions are afforded to people who are poor, or to everybody for the purchase of necessities, the definitions involved must be defined by the same political process either way. So when you described the implementation of one method as Orwellian, you include the other equally.

by absolutely

adunlap: [b]So "someone" is going to decide for us which groceries are taxed and which are not. And if someone gets an exemption because he's alergic to the "officially sanctioned protein-containing material", how is the grocer supposed to know whether an alternative is to be taxed or not?[/b]

Absolutely: "Someone" decides our tax brackets right now, and by your scheme, "someone" will decide who is poor enough to pay no taxes at all. There is no difference in that. And my Modest Proposal does not require any "officially sanctioned protein-containing material". By the way, who were you quoting when you originally put that phrase in quotation marks? Not me.

All groceries would be exempt, with the exception of a relatively small number of easily defined luxury items, such as the ones you named. Add to that the most expensive caviar, fugu sushi & sashimi, and you're almost done! A consistent definition could easily be established at a $/weight ratio that is significantly beyond the price of standard sustenance. The important advantage of my small revision to the Fair Tax proposal is that grocers or clerks do not have to ask for ID or any kind of government certificate that could be forged, they just apply the exemptions to their merchandise, which it is already their job to know.

by tonythetiger

to make things easy for others. Glad I could be of service.

I (now) think defining anything as exempt is wrong. By telling poor people what their necessities are, you are micro-managing, as well as robbing them of some of their freedom (the government does not currently tell people what kinds of food they can buy with their foodstamps, nor, for another example) does it tell them they cannot use some of the money they receive cannot be used to take the family to the movies).

FairTax makes the assumption that everyone is going to make sure their necessities are going to be provided for first. I see nothing wrong with the assumption.

Indeed, there are going to be some idiots who blow their necessity allotment on filet mignon, or on twinkies and chips for that matter, but deal with them one at a time (only if you have to, though I suspect the condition will be self-correcting). Don't punish everyone else. That policy has been tried for decades (if one kid gets caught chewing gum in class, the whole class stays in from recess) and has been a dismal failure (primarily only managing to create a generation of bullies who think they know what's best for everyone else).

by absolutely

who encourage poverty by rewarding it, taxing only the rich. Taxing me but not taxing other citizens, who are still treated as having equal rights under the law, is also bullying. That isn't unique to the simplified mechanism I suggested for favoring the poor, which seems to still be an unavoidable feature of any tax scheme I'm likely to see in my lifetime.

by tonythetiger

Telling someone they have to pay tax on steak but not on hamburger is bullying, no matter what their income level.

There are a lot of control-freaks in this country. I have even heard it suggested that people on public assistence not be allowed to use the money they receive to drive to church! (and try to justify it both on the "essential" aspect and the "separation of church and state" aspect)

by absolutely

...and vice-versa.

Since financial assistance from the government is anti-capitalist it is un-American. "Welfare" checks should NOT be used to get people to or from chuch, or for any other purpose. The Welfare system is unjust, regardless of what is purchased with the money stolen from salary- and wage- earners, investors and business owners.

by tonythetiger

So what do you suggest, deporting people when they become unemployed?

Maybe we should do away with all insurance as well. After all, if you buy a new car and wreck it two days later, you are using other people's money to fix it.

I would be missing out on a lot if I thought that capitalism was all there was to being American.

by absolutely

You invented that. I never said "that capitalism was all there was to being American", nor did I suggest deporting anybody for poverty or unemployment. I have said, and will continue to say, that the federal government has no authority to reward poverty, including exempting the poor from all taxation. The Tenth Amendment's restriction of the government's powers to those defined by the previous amendments to the Constitution, the protection of personal property guaranteed by the Fourth Amendment and the absence of any wealth re-distribution clause in the Constitution or Declaration of Independence, [b]prohibit[/b] Welfare & Social Security unequivocally, along with S&L bailouts & any other handouts to failing or failed corporations.

by absolutely

The question originally posed is not whether or not some people are worthy of help. The question is whether the federal government has the legal authority to help everybody who is poor, as is the case now, or to provide [b]economic[/b] assistance to anybody, for any reason. I say no. According to the Fourth Amendment we have the right to be safe and secure in our persons and our property -- not in other people's! According to the Tenth, the government has [b]only[/b] the powers delegated to it by the previous nine Amendments and the original Constitution, which does not include any provision for redistributing wealth. If we are all equal under the law, then the mention of the general welfare must mean to protect everybody's rights equally, to protect our persons and our property from unlawful search and seizure, regardless of differences in amount and quality of such property. Welfare discriminates illegally against success.

by tmcclure

Our government is stripping us of our rights. It has declaired that the single most important right is really nothing more than a privlege. That is the right to property. Property rights are so fundamental to freedom, that freedom cannot exist without it. Yet our governemnt confiscates our homes, and our income daily. We do not even have the right to our own bodies.

by tonythetiger

"You invented that. "

I wasn't accusing you of saying that, it was a question. If the government is not supposed to help these people, then they can deport them, or simply do nothing and allow them to perish, or more likely do what they have to do to survive which will in all likelihood involve the violation of someone else's rights.

"I never said "that capitalism was all there was to being American""

Well, I was talking about me, not you, but... Perhaps I read it wrong...

"Since financial assistance from the government is anti-capitalist it is un-American."

a=b and a=c so b=c. b=c so -b=-c

My observation is that no "ism" in its pure form will ever work for any large group of people. The worst aspects of human nature will kill it every time.

by maxwell edison

.
Although I can't follow all your disagreements (it gives me a headache), I thought I'd interject a few things.

First of all, there's a difference between espousing something in principle, and supporting it in reality. All too often, the distinction gets lost in these discussions (including with my messages.) I have a sneaking suspicion that you guys might be arguing from a different premise, one from principle, and the other from reality, and then you are switching back and forth yourselves.

And actually, I believe that ippirate was playing the "principle versus reality" game with me, switching back and forth, prodding me to switch back and forth, and before too long you just want to say, stop; let's start over. In ippirate's case, I believe it was intentional game-playing. In other cases, however, I believe it's simply a difference of basis not being understood by the other.

Personally speaking, in principle, I believe that we are taxed too much, and, by definition, the government spends too much. In fact, in principle, I would cut the level of citizen taxation and government spending by about 75 percent, cutting our 2 trillion dollar budget down to about 500 billion. In reality, however, considering today's political climate, I might as well wish for a free trip to Mars for each and every citizen -- it just ain't gonna' happen, especially overnight. (Although I would support a program to pay for a one-way trip to Mars for a lot of people!)

In principle, because I don't like the way taxes are being spent and inequitably assessed, it might be easy for me to dismiss that FairTax plan because of its particular exemptions. But in reality, it's a no-brainer to support, at least the way I see it, considering the only alternative, at this time, is to just keep what we have. And with the FairTax plan, it would be easier to steer it towards "my principle" than it would be under the current system. To say, no I'm not gonna' support it because it's not my ideal plan is not seeing reality. And to suggest that the government should be in the business of redistributing almost 2 trillion dollars each and every year from one citizen to the other, is ignoring a bigger underlying principle.

In principle, I don't believe that net tax receivers should be able to vote themselves the right to other people's money; actually, no one should be able to vote themselves the right to take other people's money. In reality, however, that's exactly the state in which the system has found itself today; and it ain't gonna' change overnight. In today's political reality, we have to play the system, so to speak, and hope we can get it to lean towards one side or the other. In reality we can try to change people's expectations of government, but we can't force the change to happen quickly. So what's the solution? Try to pass a law suggesting that net tax receivers can't vote? That might sound nice in principle, but in reality it would never fly.

Quite frankly, I don't know what the answer is. Considering we are starting from here, where we are today, I'm not sure if it's possible to reverse the trend and take us back to the days where the government didn't play nanny to each and every citizen, and back to the days when most citizens didn't expect it.

And I really do pity the poor sap who thinks the government exists to see to his each and every need. What a friggin loser that person is. And what a friggin' drag that person is on all of society. We're in a sinking ship, and these poor saps are not only making the leaks larger, but they're not doing a damn thing to help bail out the water.

My principle dictates that I'm against the practice of the government taking a dollar from the person who earned it, only to give it to a person who did not. That's how the USA operated, for the most part, before 1930, and they got along just fine. (Now is when the transfer of wealth proponents will start citing the child-labor factories and slavery and all that other crap that's not related to the core issue.)

In my opinion, here's what it would take. We need a constitutional amendment that clearly states that the federal government is prohibited from providing money for any reason and in any form of social program to any citizen. And earned money is the key issue here, because we still need to pay for military personnel and other vital government services, but we don't want a loophole to be the creation of a myriad of government agencies to use quasi-work programs as an excuse to transfer the money. But in reality, that simply wouldn't pass congress, at least not today.

Here's what I predict.

Thomas Jefferson actually encouraged revolution in cases of egregious government infringement on the individual liberties of the very citizens whose liberty it was entrusted to protect; and this was his primary motivation (at least one of them) in supporting the second amendment -- the right to keep and bear arms. However, I'm not predicting a bloody revolution, but a revolution nonetheless. I am predicting an economic revolution where extremely large blocks of citizens will simply refuse to go along any longer. Moreover, I believe that states' rights might be the vehicle to advance the revolution. I can see a scenario where a state like Texas, or Utah, or Idaho, or Kansas, or Nebraska, or a number of them in concert threaten to secede from the union. But I don't see it happening for another 50 or more years, maybe 100.

The day will come when the citizens of the net tax-payer states will get fed up with supporting the citizens of the net tax-receiver states. On one hand the federal government forces Utah, for example, to pay the dollar, but Utah might only get three quarters or half of that back -- and that's under the threat of getting nothing if they don't do it the "feds" way! Do your schools this way, or you don't get the education money that you paid to us in the first place, the feds now say. The same with highway funds. The same with almost anything. And then, there are states like West Virginia that get two or more dollars for every dollar they pay!

The way for it to stop is actually, perhaps, at the state level. The states will have to reclaim their sovereignty, especially their economic sovereignty, refuse to pay the feds, and perhaps even threaten to secede from the union. And instead of a bloody war between the north and the south, this one might be an economic war between the east and the west. (Of course California and Oregon would be isolated and quasi-easterners.)

This is kind of a rambling message, a lot of it just thinking out-loud, but there ya' go. Let's see where it takes us.

by tonythetiger

The feeling that we are obligated to help people who need it versus the feeling that the government is too big, inefficient, and expensive.

by absolutely

...from singular first person pronoun "my" in adunlap's Title, to the plural first person pronoun "we" in the body.

Does the Constitution permit that obligation that you feel to be mandated? If so, what part of the Constitution grants that power to the [b]federal[/b] government?

by maxwell edison

.
.....who's stopping you? Help people all you want; I certainly won't do anything to stop you.

But does this mean that you feel obligated to force others to "help people" as well? If so, therefore what? And if so, what gives you the moral authority to force people to "help", as you define "help"?

If not, again, therefore what?

Call it what it really is. Your message is too vague.

by tonythetiger

I think this is a state issue. However I think the feds have stepped in under interstate commerce provisions (in this case, people moving to other states for better benefits).

by absolutely

I have been talking about the federal Welfare, Social Security and other wealth transfer programs, and I believe that those were the intended topics of the thread. I do not understand how that is a state issue. I am unfamiliar with any argument that the federal government's authority to regulate interstate commerce includes the right to redistribute wealth among the states. What is your basis for that conclusion?

by tonythetiger

What I meant was the whole shebang should have been left to the states (with the possible exception of Social Security), because I don't think the fed had the authority!

Also, I hope you are not confusing Social Security with SSI.

by tonythetiger

In fact if the government would take less from me, I could do it more! Not only that, my voluntary contributions are far more effective than the governments involuntary ones. First, because more of my dollar will reach the intended recipient, and second, because I am closer to the problem, I am better equipped to determine if, what kind of, and how much help is needed. Seperate but related, I am also in a better position to determine how much I can AFFORD to help.

"But does this mean that you feel obligated to force others to "help people" as well?"

I think everyone who can should (and I am confident that most people who can will), but no, not forcing.

by robpellucid

This problem of wealth sharing is really a case of missinformation. I'm sure your stereotype for a welfare recipient is an ablebodied woman with 4 kids working on a 5th who blows her money on crack and needs more cash so she shoplifts at Wallmart. Harsh sounding eh? There is a small fraction of these folks in the big cities, but there are many other people who could not survive without the taxes that you and millions like you pay. Do you have any disabled relatives Max? Mny of the disabled are unable to work because of physical limitations beyond your imagination. Without taxes the US would degenerate to a Charles Dickens like world of orphans and child labor. The way to put this in perspective is to think about ways to make enough money where taxes become insignificant. You have an opportunity to become more than you are because you live here in America. The odds that you would be born here in America are a feable 5% leaving some fraction, a large fraction I suspect, of the remaing 95% of the world's population that would like your place. Anybody can see faults and complain, but it takes brain power to forge new ideas that become solutions to complex problems. More later.....

by maxwell edison

.
First of all, whenever I discuss the harm inflicted by the myriad of transfer of wealth social programs, harm to both the country and the individuals to whom the transfer is targeted, proponents of such programs ALWAYS pigeon-hole everything into the "welfare" category and cite the worst case scenarios of the most destitute. Why is that? Is it because you actually believe that 100 percent of these transfer of wealth social programs actually target the most destitute of our society? Do you really believe that? I might estimate that 10 percent or less of these transfer of wealth social programs actually find their way to the most destitute of society, with the remaining 90 percent going to people who could otherwise get along just fine. Why do you cite the exception to justify your preferred rule? (And yes, before you ask, I could support my estimated numbers. Moreover, if you disbelieve them, give me numbers of your own before challenging mine.)

Secondly, you seem to imply that all of these transfer of wealth social programs actually make things better. To the contrary, I suggest to you that they actually make things worse -- much worse. For example, the number of people living in poverty in America, both in real numbers and percentages, was in a steady decline every decade of the 20th century, until, that is, the "war on poverty" was declared. Ever since then, the numbers of people living in poverty have been rising. And when money was made available for young and single women with children, the instances of out-of-wedlock births to very young women (girls, actually), increased dramatically. I believe that giving money to habitual drug users actually enables their behavior instead of helping them overcome their destructive life-style. I believe that when the government mandated their control over everyone's retirement program, the very people it was supposed to help actually found themselves worse off than had they managed their own retirement funds. Shall I go on? Sure, there are the exceptions; but government should legislate based on the rule, not the exception.

Thirdly, you misstate my intentions. While it seems apparent that you prefer to create any number of dependent classes of people -- dependent on the government, that is -- I espouse creating (or more accurately, returning to having) classes of people independent from government. I believe that, left to their own devices, most people could get through life and be better-off without being burdened by the shackles of government dependency. But I obviously give people more credit than you. I obviously believe that most people are perfectly capable of assuming self-responsibility, while you obviously do not. Why do you deem so many people unworthy of deserving credit for having the wherewithal to care for even themselves? And remember, I'm talking about the rule, here, not the exception. Moreover, the intent of the US government was to protect INDIVIDUAL liberty, not to create a collective of people dependent on government -- dependent from the time they are born until the day they die.

Fourthly, you presume to suggest that I would (and do) turn a blind-eye to the challenges presented to people who are faced with assuming self-responsibility. To the contrary, I make it one of my missions in life to help people reach their potential and to believe in themselves, and I actively teach and mentor young men who are entering adulthood to go forth with such an approach and outlook. Moreover, if I had my way, the "touchy-feely" crap that's being spewed, and the political correctness crap that's running amok in our public school systems today, would all be scrapped so room could be made in the day to actually teach our kids some thing much more useful. Things like how the business model in America is supposed to work. Things like long-term financial planning. Things like how to balance a checkbook. Things like the proper approach to using credit wisely. Things that could actually help them get through life in a self-responsible manner, rather than the "everyone's a victim" B.S. that they're exposed to now.

Fifthly, ......... I could go on, but is my argument simply falling on deaf ears? If so, what's the point?

by absolutely

"I'm sure your stereotype for a welfare recipient is an ablebodied woman with 4 kids working on a 5th who blows her money on crack and needs more cash so she shoplifts at Wallmart."

How sure are you of that now? I'm glad Max has spoken for himself, because I've been eager to add my opinion of this inane assumption that the recipient's drug habit is the basis of every argument against communism. It doesn't matter if the recipient is "an ablebodied woman with 4 kids working on a 5th who blows her money on crack" or a broken-bodied war veteran, or any other member of society. If military pension funds are insufficient, that shortfall needs to be remedied by the military budget and by correcting the lack of foresight responsible for that shortfall, not by treating that one very specific case as the conceptual basis for a system of government support for all, including "an ablebodied woman with 4 kids working on a 5th who blows her money on crack and needs more cash so she shoplifts at Wallmart", nor even a nice person like CuteElf, who certainly describes more difficulty than I have, but who nevertheless is not [b]entitled[/b] to have one red cent of my paycheck. If I meet her, like her, and believe it will help her improve her situation, I would share with her some of my material abundance, and far more importantly, the knowledge and insight that empowered me to [b]earn[/b] it.

"There is a small fraction of these folks in the big cities, but there are many other people who could not survive without the taxes that you and millions like you pay."

How small is that fraction? Having lived in small towns, I can say definitively that economic leeches are not restricted to urban environments either.

"Without taxes the US would degenerate to a Charles Dickens like world of orphans and child labor."

If it weren't so morally repugnant, it would be hilarious how often the [b]fiction[/b] of Charles Dickens is cited as the [b]only[/b] basis for foolish communist tax and spend schemes. But it [b]is[/b] repugnant, because if facts are considered instead of fiction, it will be undeniable that introduction of industry gave [b]starving[/b] farm children the opportunity to [b]subsist[/b] in cities or coal mining towns. An intelligent question to ask is whether those workers were in better or worse situations than they had been previously, not whether they were in better or worse situations than somebody else.

"The way to put this in perspective is to think about ways to make enough money where taxes become insignificant."

That is not possible. Just ask Donald Trump whether he had the option to stop trying to increase his net worth while all "his property" was subject to tax. There is a widely believed fallacy that it is possible in the United States to become wealthy enough to escape the need to continue to earn. That is only possible with the tax benefits of retirement.

"Anybody can see faults and complain, but it takes brain power to forge new ideas that become solutions to complex problems."

That is a truism, and one which does not back your check.

"More later....."

I can't prevent you from posting, but I will continue to refuse your so-called "reality checks" until you argue with reason and fact. A good first step would be to quote an economist instead of a novelist when trying to make a point about economics.

by maxwell edison

.
Anyone who thinks that the United States would revert to a stereo-typical "Charles Dickens" type of society if the government quit funding people's lives, should check himself in for a reality check. Are you serious?

First of all, Charles Dickens experienced, and wrote of 19th century ENGLAND, not the United States. (He actually "looked down his nose" at the USA, but admired the independence, nonetheless. Read American Notes by Dickens.) While Great Britain was struggling with such social circumstances because of the LACK of individual liberty, across the pond in the newly established U.S. of A. (which split from G.B., in case you need to be reminded, because of the quest to secure individual liberty), we were achieving levels of individual success and prosperity never before seen in the world. You and others might try to explain away or invalidate America's meteoric levels of achievement, both as a nation and as individuals, but it happened because we enjoyed unprecedented levels of individual liberty, not in spite of it, and certainly not because it wasn't valued or protected. We did it without government, except inasmuch as government protected individual liberty, not infringed on it, and then got the heck out of the way.

Secondly, it's the very government interference that CAUSED the stereo-typical "Charles Dickens" type of society that you fear would return.

Thirdly, are you that unsure of yourself that you have no faith in your own gumption and sense of self-responsibility, and your own ability to get through life without being dependent on government? If you're not, have more faith in yourself, man. And if it's not you in whom you have no faith, why don't you think others are just as capable as you? Do you think that you're so much better than others that you have to espouse your elitist attitude of superiority over others? Give others as much credit as you give yourself, for Pete's sake.

Oh ye of little faith -- in either yourselves or in others. How sad.

by giannidalessismo

I do agree with your remarks. Per the issues you point to, andper
the post and replies that brought me to your post, that a client in
possession of putative 'kiddie porn' has no right to presumptive
innocence, or many rights at all - all pointing to an abstract
collective good - it does appear, in many aspects, that as an
essential ideal, individual liberty is becoming or has become a
thing of the past.

by tonythetiger

"I might estimate that 10 percent or less of these transfer of wealth social programs actually find their way to the most destitute of society, with the remaining 90 percent going to people who could otherwise get along just fine."

Thats why I said I would be more effective at it than the government.

"While it seems apparent that you prefer to create any number of dependent classes of people -- dependent on the government, that is -- I espouse creating (or more accurately, returning to having) classes of people independent from government."

Going through it right now with my x-wife's neice. They took her kids, we ended up raising the baby for 16 months, all the time begging them to get her the help she needs, then when we gave up and took THEM to court, they did their backroom deal saying all they had done for the mother, etc, and the kids are all right back where they started... albeit with a more cunning mother... better able to take advantage of her "victimhood" and milk the system (26 with 5 kids and pregnant with twins). She mistreats the older kids horribly (they're not by her "new" man) and it's breaking our hearts. Children's services is a joke, merely around to make sure they have future clients, but they have the judges in their pockets, and if they don't want you to interfere, you won't!

by tonythetiger

Another possibility (or probability) is that there are people in this country who benefit from keeping other people down. I have subscribed to that notion for quite some time... that a group of people exists that believes that the average Joe cannot successfully handle his own affairs and that a few, capable people (them) should do it for him.

by Member 25348569

For most of our species? existence on the planet we have lived in small groups organised around mutually beneficial social relations, with scarce resources held in common as social property. The emergence of dominant classes such as chiefs, kings, aristocracies of birth and wealth is a very recent event, 10,000 years ago, or less, depending on which culture is considered. These usually begin with the emergence of wealth in the form of a surplus beyond subsistence with settlement agriculture where individuals first coordinate the more complex agriculture and then seize this social surplus. This surplus then provides the material means for creating a "palace guard" to enforce the relations of domination and finally institutionalize the ownership of that stolen social surplus. The Native American, for example, never reached this stage in societal ?development?.

The most recent version of this process, capitalism, is around 500 years old in Britain and newer elsewhere. Capitalism took control from feudal estates and their lords and started the ongoing trend for buying, selling and owning to become the primary determinants of human life. Capitalism?s need for capital accumulation then led to the conquest and colonisation of most of the rest of the world by Britain over the subsequent five centuries.

Dickens might well have envied the freedom of the US citizen and, in his day, he was right to do just that. The population density and social conditions in England during the early days of the industrial revolution ? when you were still a colony, by the way ? were tailor made for capitalism?s excesses that made Dicken?s time look like Paradise.

You?re going down a road that will not allow the freedoms that you seem to believe in so deeply. You had them once and you pissed them away. Less than two hundred years ago, nearly ninety percent of the U. S. labour force was self-employed. Today only about nine percent can avoid going to someone else for a job. There is now monopoly control of the means to work held by two percent of the population. This came about, not by democratic consensus, but by the totalitarian structures of corporate capitalism. These systematically exclude the majority of people from any significant role in economic decision making.

As for your Constitution, it was derived for and by wealthy white males. Initially, only wealthy white males could vote, and then only for even wealthier white male candidates. Political parties were ? and still are - in competition to see who would win the right to represent the wealthy in office. You, like we in the UK, now have two parties equally committed to transnational corporate capitalism.

Industrial capitalist development with its inevitable succession of economic crises - boom and bust - forced people to urban centres, shattering previously stable communities, removing self sufficiency of families and communities and replacing it with implicit dependency of urban life. Most people now depend entirely on systems of energy, food, clothing and shelter that are centralized under corporate control. Most people no longer have the resources - land, tools or skills - to employ themselves and are forced to compete with one another for chances to sell their ability to work. Offshore outsourcing now means that this competition between people who must work in order to live has become global, forcing them to sell their labour ever more cheaply.

I?d like to believe that we are a social species, and social species survive by cooperation. Our current problems are rooted in the forced competition required by the structure of market society with its carefully crafted artificial scarcities of opportunity for cooperative and mutually satisfying activity. This forced competition for scarce educational, work, housing and other opportunities is the basis for dividing the majority of people against one another by sex, race, age and ability. A ruling minority depends on a divided majority for its security and continued privilege.

People have become mere objects to be manipulated for private advantage. It is not the pathology of all human beings but the pathology of some humans that I worry about. Predatory personalities among us are often in positions of control, ideally suited to the structure of advanced industrial capitalist institutions. A socially concerned corporate manager who puts human interests ahead of profit maximisation quickly joins the ranks of the unemployed.

It may not be strictly necessary to be a sociopath in order to be in a position of power in our society, but the rules of the game require doing a good imitation of one.

Your original post is smack on the money. I wish you luck in changing your society but I don't think that you will.

The sheep will inherit the Earth.

by absolutely

While Asia was still ruled by monarchs and Africa was full of the tribal warfare that supplied the US slave trade. The United States is imperfect, and has been since its inception. And bad things have been done for the profit motive. But there has never been any nation better for its citizens than the United States, nor any economic system better for the poorest workers than capitalism.

Examine the United States' rate of taxation and growth of wealth transfer programs, then compare to the consolidation of more wealth in the United States into the control of 2% of the population. The result of undermining the right to own property, replacing that with a privilege to hold property as a favor bestowed by the government has coincided with a less even distribution of wealth, not with Marx's pipe dream of universal plenty. Blame human greed if you like, but human nature will not change to suit anybody's vision, however generous. In fact, when it is legal to give property to some citizens which was taken from other citizens who have not been proven guilty, not even accused, of a crime, some will take advantage. That number appears to be approximately 2%, plus the unknown fraction of people on Welfare who think of their publicly-funded subsistence as their success in pulling a scam.

Money is not the root of evil. Economic competition defines the value to society of all commodities and services traded, telling students what skills are most profitable to acquire, and investors what businesses are most profitable to begin. When government takes a role in the economy beyond protecting the right to property, preventing and punishing fraud, and enforcing contracts, the harm it causes exceeds its utility.

There is much more to the States' financial success than population density. We also did not have a worldwide empire of unwilling subjects, on which the sun was boasted to never set. It is strictly necessary to be a sociopath to simultaneously have any understanding of economics and history, and to believe that some degree of socialism is better than a government that absolutely respects property rights and allows laissez-faire capitalism. The poor suffer the worst in a command economy.

by robpellucid

Is a homeless man free? Just imagine the heady euphoria of cowtowing to no boss. No bills, no taxes [don't forget that one!] no responsibilities, no car, no gasoline headaches, no roadrage, no astronomical healthcare insurance, hell no insurance at all weeeeeee a free ride. Sleep when you want, where you want totally free to come and go as you please. Free food somewhere at a church or shelter. A guy told you about fast food restaurants tossing out their hour old burgers after midnight, wow free. Yep, free to be homeless. Free to be hungry. Free to be sick. Free to be forgotten. In America freedom is the greatest.

by robpellucid

Here in America, we yanks think freedom means, the right to live and interact in any way we desire. Of course this is a complete delusion as in any society there are taboos and mores to limit unacceptable behaviors. Murder, incest, theft and many others. We gladly accept these limitations for the group's benefits.

This idea of taxation goes way back before America. I think in the forest near Nottingham there was a myth of a bandit who robbed from the rich to give to the poor. This altruistic philosophy has continued to exist until this day. The problem is the rich don't want to give to the poor. Oh they'll sponser an art museum or fund a hospital wing, but giving money to the poor is a never ending black hole. This is a matter of conscience.

Another problem, is the gov't struture for creating taxes. Every legislator wants to appear busy so dozens of projects are submitted to ride a new law about funding baby health research. Since no legislator in their right mind would vote no to baby health research, all of those fat project ride along increasing our tax burden. A line item veto is one solution. Nice to hear from you Neil!

by maxwell edison

.
You said, " The problem is the rich don't want to give to the poor. Oh they'll sponsor an art museum or fund a hospital wing, but giving money to the poor is a never ending black hole."

What an idiotic and absolutely absurd thing to say?

The truth is:

- 89 percent of American families give charitable contributions.

They do it for the tax deduction, you might claim? Well, since......

- 86 million tax filers (more than two-thirds of all filers) do not itemize their taxes.

.....I don't think so.

- Total private giving reached $203.45 billion in 2000.

- John D. Rockefeller's charitable contributions added up to $540 million (in the dollars of his time). His $32 million gift in 1907 to the General Education Board, for the promotion of education without the distinction of race, sex, or creed, would be the equivalent of $640 million in 1999 dollars. The charitable gifts of John D. Rockefeller Jr. are estimated to have totaled $537 million.

- The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation is the world's largest charitable foundation donates over 1 billion dollars per year.

- Corporate giving is expected to reach about $12 billion this year.

You're nuts.

by sleepin'dawg

It galls me when my so called peers refer to my successes as luck. Whatever I've achieved in life came about because I've applied myself to it and received damn little encouragement along the way. I chose to be what I am and have worked bloody hard to get here. Along the way, I was so fixated on my goals that I probably sacrificed my marriages to my goals; definitely my first. I chose my path just as I chose a position of leadership and looking back I've lost count of the number of times well meaning friends and acquaintances have tried to divert or dissuade me from my chosen course. Now they tell me I was lucky. Well that is just so much crap.

I'm at where I'm at because I was self-reliant, worked hard, worked smarter and only sought help from individuals who thought like myself and even then it was more on a synergistic basis or level. What I've done can be achieved by anyone provided they have the desire and ability or balls to study and focus their thoughts and skills to achieve their goals. Have I ever exploited those who were less driven than myself??? Probably but only because they permitted me to do so. I have never forced anyone into doing something they haven't wanted to do. I've recompensed my people more than adequately not out of charitableness or kindness but out of my self serving awareness that if I didn't somebody else would. Whatever you may think, that is leadership and that is what success and winning is all about and without it society will in a sense, reach entropy. So by the measure of my peers, I've got to where I am at through pure dumb luck; forget any sacrifices I may have made along the way. Does this make me a predator??? Maybe, but I'm reminded of an old adage,"The world is made up of two kinds of people. Those who take and those who get taken." It lies within each of us which he'll be; taker or takee. Most abdicate their responsibility for their choice to people like me. Do I abuse these people??? Some might think so but I feel I have a certain responsibility to my people. When I gain or win; so do they but the funny thing is that when I suffer reverses or losses none of them will line up or volunteer, to take cuts in their acquired benefits, short or long term. Its always left up to me or people like me to support them and protect them against the ravages of their misfortune and if I don't, whatever will become of them???

Not all predators are vicious exploiters; a large percentage are rather benign, not out of kindness but more out of a lack of awareness. Genghis Khan, upon having to select a new man for leader of one of his battalions was asked why he didn't choose a certain individual. It was said that this man was loyal and hard working and would work from sunrise to sunset to achive an objective or goal, sometimes working through the night and forgoing meals to get there. The great Khan's reply is somewhat illuminating. He stated that while he appreciated the mans efforts and loyalty he also knew that not all of the people that he would be leading were capable of the same expenditure of effort although they might be equally loyal. He felt that he would be better served by choosing someone else who would recognize the limitations of the people he was leading. The fact is, that if you wish for success you have to recognize the aspirations and limitations of the people you expect to help you achieve your goals. In nature we see something similar. In a wolf pack there is a leader who has achieved his position by fighting the other wolves off but he can only maintain his position by leading the pack on successful hunts that will ensure the survival of the pack. Of course he only does this to fill his own belly but when he is successful, the whole pack benefits. The offshoot benefit for him is that he gets to impose his genes or DNA on the pack's females. One day, as he ages, he will falter and will then be challenged for the leadership role. When he is defeated, he won't be driven away from the pack but will continue on but with none of his previous perks as leader. It should come as no surprise, the similarities between wolf culture and that of humans. Many wolves will run with the pack and never challenge for the role of leader and yet the leader accepts them and provides for them.

The sheep will inherit the earth??? I hope not or humanity will have reached a true state of entropy and the only thing that will inherit the earth will be rats and cockroaches. As long as man strives to achieve, he will succeed but to succeed leaders will be required, if only to motivate and provide focus. Without motivation and focus man will end by sacrificing everything to a bare bones existence and a very uninspiring status quo. Witness the Great Depression and the war that was necessary to get society out of it. Maybe that's what we're seeing now with the terrorist threats. We need new leadership and not of the milquetoast variety we've been receiving lately.

That is what we are seeing today. Too many damn sheep and not enough wolves. For good or ill, the sheep have been led to believe that they should be allowed to put limitations and obstacles in the way of the wolves, thus creating an imbalance of nature. Limit the wolves and you will have so many sheep that they'll graze the land into dust, at which point they will be left with a lot of starving, bleating sheep. However, once we get new wolves, the sheep will be culled and balance will be restored. Sheep are not self-reliant. They can be lead astray or chased over cliffs but wolves are self-reliant. They only hunt and eat when hungry and don't do anything stupid like the sheep by totally killing off their source of food. Wolves are efficient; sheep inefficient and in the end it may be said that wolves are necessary to preserve the balance in nature.

Likewise with man. Without the leaders or predatory wolves amongst us, who will provide the jobs and salaries for the rest or the ovine amongst us. With no jobs, who will pay the taxes to support the welfare system that the sheep keep demanding. Yes we wolves are pretty damn smart and have taught ourselves ways and means to avoid the worst effects of taxation but we are smart enough to not get caught evading taxes, at least most of us are, otherwise, that might bring down a stampede of sheep upon us.

Currently I am in the process of expanding my business and I'm probably going to here lots more garbage of just how lucky I am. There is really no luck involved but the willingness to take some risks, the recognition of an opportunity and the ability and balls to push it through. Presently my payroll is 522 employees; by this time next year, if everything goes as I've planned, the payroll will have expanded to over 800 jobs. That will mean approximately 300 more sheep paying taxes and for what its worth we pay on the top end of the scale for our industry.

I'm not a genious and am not particularly lucky but I have studied and learned to recognize niches of opportunity and have strived to my utmost, you may say like a ravening wolf, to achieve them. If that's luck, then all I can say is, we need some more lucky people or wolves out there.

Enough,

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by tonythetiger

Do I have to have one? Well how about, "that anything that works to lessen or at least expose said corruption is probably not a bad thing."?

by robpellucid

Aint freedom grand? Milk is wholesome, nutritious, versatile, sweet and delicious but you can drown in it. Too much freedom can kill you.

by robpellucid

The problem with armchair quarterbacks is they talk of vast socioeconomic groups lobbying for chunks of money from the Federal Gov't and the rampant corruption that always tags along making things worse. The problem is you are talking about individual Americans with life threatening problems like the homeless, the disabled and the jobless. The charities can't house and feed them all. These poor people are caught in a trap, some in a trap of their own making, some in a trap of fate or sstatistics, but a trap regardless. Let's have a specific example. You are doing well today; good health, good job, good house maybe even a nice family. Today on your way home, BLAM out of nowhere a car wreck. It wasn't your fault but there you are waking up after 3 weeks in the Hospital. You are now a functional quadriplegic and in a year in the rehab hospital and $3 million of hospital bills your medical insurance is gone due to $1 million max clause. You can't get any gov't assistance because your meger disability insurance + wife's salary push you over the max. You can't make ends meet. Your lawyer advises you the only way to save your house is to get a divorce and sever your financial situation from your wife's. 5 years later your wife ends the relationship saying 'I did not sign up to be a nurse 24/7. Now your alone. What's holding you back now Max? All you need is to get out of bed, bathe, brush your teeth, get dressed, get into your wheelchair, eat brunch because now it's about 11am. Try to type 10 min on your computer until 5pm. Then it's dinner time. Only 3 hours till bedtime. You have to pay for all of this care unless there is some ferderal program. Only 100,000 Americans are paralysed every year Max and the average lifespan is 10 years. Bad things happens to good people and when they do pray that you live in America and not in S. America or China or Africa.

by robpellucid

Sounds like I touched a nerve. I don't read books by economists because they are trying to predict the future. If I want to learn about the future I consult the masters of science fiction. Comunism is dead and socialism will collapse under it's own weight. A free society is the only form of gov't that has a chance of surviving in the long run. I'm talking Chinalike time 3 thousand years. The thing is free time, what does a society do with it's free time. Americans have always invented things which has pushed our culture far ahead of all the rest on earth. If you want to lower an individuals taxes, why not lobby for a flat tax on individuals with incomes greater than $30k of 15% with no exemptions. Then levy a 20% corporate tax on profits over $1 million. Now that's a solution. The 'NOT 1 RED CENT' people are dinosaures hermits and don't live in the realaties of the 21st century.

by robpellucid

Faith in oneself is nothing but a delusion that many cannot afford. Many people live from day to day literally. They don't read Dicken's notes et al. You can't eat gumption. If you depend on faith to bring food to your 90 year old greatgrand mother, I feel sorry for her.

by maxwell edison

.
I neither agree or disagree with your "solution", but to help sway me one way or the other, will you please answer one question?

You suggested that we institute a, "flat tax on individuals with incomes greater than $30k of 15% with no exemptions. Then levy a 20% corporate tax on profits over $1 million.".

How would that impact the total revenues collected? Would it result in a surplus or a deficit, as applied to FY 2005-2006? And if it resulted in a surplus, what should be done with the additional money? If it resulted in a deficit, would you propose operating with a deficit or cutting spending? If it's the latter, what would you cut? If it's the former, how high would the deficit be, and how long would you budget deficit spending? And how does your corporate tax suggestion compare to what corporations are taxed today, both in percentages and total dollars?

And who is proposing "NOT 1 RED CENT"?

Okay, that was more than one question, but all related, nonetheless.

Since you suggest that you're such an "Intellectual" (by criticizing others for the same), I'm sure you've thought these things out, and could answer all of these questions to an acceptable degree of accuracy.

By the way, do you know what tax reform measures I support? If yes, what do you think of the idea? If not, would you like to know?

I will wait for your answers.

by absolutely

Political freedom does not mean freedom from responsibilities and the consequences of one's own actions. People everywhere are responsible to make choices that preserve and improve their lives. Bums are only fat in the United States.

by maxwell edison

.
You did mention taking a "reality check", didn't you?

You said, "...why not lobby for a flat tax on individuals with incomes greater than $30k of 15% with no exemptions. Then levy a 20% corporate tax on profits over $1 million."

Okay, YOU can lobby for that all you want. Who are YOU going to lobby? Are YOU going to do anything to advance YOUR suggestion?

Reality check:

1. YOU aren't going to do a damn thing. I could be wrong, of course. Perhaps you already have contacted your representative to "lobby" for this, but color me skeptical. Tomorrow, you say? Yea, that's the ticket; you'll do it tomorrow.

2. Lobby all you want. Getting something passed in congress is "reality".

3. Name one congressman or senator who has sponsored or co-sponsored a bill that presents legislation "for a flat tax on individuals with incomes greater than $30k of 15% with no exemptions. Then levy a 20% corporate tax on profits over $1 million."

4. Do you have those numbers yet? How would that impact total revenue?

You said, "Now that's a solution."

No, that's not in-touch with reality.

by maxwell edison

.
Name one person who has lobbied for and proposed similar "flat tax" plans?

Never mind, I'll do it.

Steve Forbes and Dick Armey come immediately to mind; and there were many others as well.

How many of those "flat tax" plans have failed to gather enough support to have even made it to the House as a proposed bill, much less made it out of a House committee?

The answer: Steve Forbes' and Dick Armey's and any other that's been proposed.

Who's carrying the banner today? And who's going to lose steam tomorrow?

Another reality check:

If corporations are taxed 20 percent, do they simply take it in the shorts, or pass that cost on to the consumer?

Never mind. I'll answer that one as well.

It's the latter. They pass it on to the consumer as a cost of doing business.

Therefore, who really pays that corporate tax?

You can answer that one.

by absolutely

Faith is belief without, or contrary to, evidence, when I use the word. Faith in oneself is therefore an oxymoron to me, since of all the phenomena in the universe, myself is [b]the one[/b] of which I have direct experience. Of course, I agree wholeheartedly with what you say about "faith in oneself", with the exception that I would replace that phrase with self-confidence.

The point to which I'm sidling is my disagreement with RobPellucid's claim that "Faith in oneself is nothing but a delusion that many cannot afford. Many people live from day to day literally. They don't read Dicken's notes et al. You can't eat gumption. If you depend on faith to bring food to your 90 year old greatgrand mother, I feel sorry for her." Self-confidence is not an article of faith, it is a by-product of consistently making an [b]effort[/b] to achieve one's goals. Of course, some people quit after the first failure, or the first sign of difficulty, but they do not have a [b]right[/b] to my taxes. Evasion of the results of one's own actions or inaction is not a right under the Constitution. Enjoyment of one's own success, and only one's own success, is the meaning of the right to the pursuit of happiness. The price of that right is the responsibility to experience the results of one's own failure, but only of one's own, not anybody else's. Your ninety year old great grandmother had decades to prepare for her retirement. If she failed to use that time adequately, she does not thereby acquire a [b]right[/b] to my help. The Constitution grants her the right to [b]ask[/b] for help, and I have the right to grant or refuse that request. But your generosity is not unique. She will be assisted, even by people like me, who simply resent having the choices of my ability and inclination to assist others made for me.

by absolutely

Same situation RobPellucid outlined, but acknowledge that without the crackhead tax, aka Welfare, all of the new quadriplegic's acquaintances are wealthier than they were under communism, and are much more willing to help. That was the case in the United States before communism, and will be when communism bankrupts this country as it did the USSR.

by maxwell edison

.
You said, "Faith in oneself is nothing but a delusion that many cannot afford." The only alternative, however, is to NOT have faith in one's self. I'll choose the former, you choose the latter, and I'll get anywhere before you. (And the same applies to ANYONE!)

What a sad outlook on life you must have. You do realize it's all a matter of choice, don't you?

by maxwell edison

.
You said, "If you depend on faith to bring food to your 90 year old greatgrand mother, I feel sorry for her."

My good man, let me tell you about my grandmother, God rest her soul. (I never knew my great grandmother)

My grandmother told me about the time she actually met Charles Lindbergh and sat in the cramped cockpit of his plane, The Spirit of St. Louis. I remember that conversation like it was yesterday, even though it took place decades ago. She told me about the times she experienced being a young lady and young mother during the Roaring 20s. She told me about the struggles she and my grandfather had raising a family during the Great Depression. She told me about how she felt when all three of her sons (my uncles) volunteered to join the Army in December of 1941, and how they all came back alive in September of 1945. She told me about a lot of things; she had ample opportunity since she lived with my family for the last 10 years of her life.

My family took care of my grandmother (my mother's mother) when she was no longer able to care for herself. I remember how we didn't really have room in our little house, considering the fact that there kids all over the place; but who really needed a formal dining room anyway? That became grandma's room for 10 years. Sure it was hard, but she was our grandmother and my mother's mother? We had to take care of her. If not us, then who? But even though it was hard, it was also a win-win situation for everyone.

So no, we didn't depend on "faith" to bring food to our grandmother; we depended on faith in ourselves to make sure we could do it. And do it we did. But we weren't alone. A lot of my classmates in school had grandparents who lived with them as well.

Who do YOU depend on to bring food to your 90 year old grandmother (or great grandmother)? If she needs such care, why don't you do it? Why don't your parents do it?

I think my generation of kids were, perhaps, the last to experience living with aging grandparents. And I think my grandparents were, perhaps, the last generation of the elderly who, for the most part, were cared for by their kids (my parents). I think it's one of the saddest things that's happened to our society that people no longer care for their own aging parents. They throw them out to be institutionalized, and rely on strangers to care for them; and they rely on other strangers to pay for it.

My mother and father are still alive, and pushing 90 years. They are still able to care for themselves, which is pretty amazing considering their age. But they're sure slowing down. They live about a day's drive from me, and I actually do, literally, bring food to them. I visit them for about 5 days every other month. I cook for them; I freeze stuff for them that can be easily prepared later; I shop for them; I paint their house; I do whatever they need. So do my other brothers and sisters. And when they are no longer able to care for themselves, we won't make the decision to throw them out in the streets or into some institution for strangers to care for them -- or neglect them -- in their dying days. They cared for us when we were young, and that's the least we can do for them. It's actually a conversation I've had with my brothers and sisters. But it's never been a matter of IF we can take them, only a matter of who and when. But we'll all continue to contribute to their care, regardless of who becomes the primary care-provider; and it may, very well, be me.

Life does indeed go full circle.

And in my opinion, from what I've seen so far, you have a pitiful outlook on life.

by maxwell edison

.
Having faith in yourself is a figure of speech that's used all the time by a lot of people. Call it faith; call it confidence; call it effort; call it whatever you want; it's all the same thing.

If you want to nit-pick it apart, knock yourself out. But I'll make no apologies and/or corrections in this case.

(I have to wonder, however, why you so often feel "inclined" to make such observations?)

by maxwell edison

.
You asked, "Is a homeless man free? Just imagine the heady euphoria of cowtowing to no boss. No bills, no taxes [don't forget that one!] no responsibilities, no car, no gasoline headaches, no roadrage, no astronomical healthcare insurance, hell no insurance at all weeeeeee a free ride. Sleep when you want, where you want totally free to come and go as you please. Free food somewhere at a church or shelter. A guy told you about fast food restaurants tossing out their hour old burgers after midnight, wow free. Yep, free to be homeless. Free to be hungry. Free to be sick. Free to be forgotten. In America freedom is the greatest."

He is free to make whatever choices in life he wishes. He is free to experience the consequences of those choices. And he is free to forget about his own responsibility to both himself and to society.

by tonythetiger

"- Total private giving reached $203.45 billion in 2000"

...that includes only "on the books" giving!

by sleepin'dawg

For what it's worth, every year since 1970 I have allocated 10% of my income for charitable purposes, mostly in the areas of research on childrens diseases. If I were a church goer you might call it tithing but seeing as I'm somewhat agnostic you may look upon it as a nice fat tax deduction. BTW I do this in both the US and Canada. I always make my donations near the Christmas period as it seems to be in the spirit of the time but this year it may be a tad different as I'm establishing a foundation for this purpose. Then again, if i were a real SOB, I could keep it all for myself and forgo the tax break. Hmmmmmmm??? I wonder if old Rob does as much on a proportionate basis??? Hmmmmmmm??? Who knows; maybe he does.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by robpellucid

Alas I don't have the luxury of giving to charitable causes. I help quadriplegics by mentering them to maximise their legal rights for federal and state funded programs to help them remain independent. I work one on one with people that are in dire need of info the keep them out of warehouse facilities where the life expectancy is very short. Since I've been a quad for 30 years, I am an expert in navigating the system. It's not easy, especially when healthy philosophers want to monkey with the system. Sure fix the waste but big cuts will take the freedom to remain independent from quads. Not nice! Isn't this topic about disappearing freedoms?

by tonythetiger

That's taking the governments mentality... that the solution to every problem is to throw money at it. I wonder if it's just some people's way to ausuage their guilt over not DOING something.

by absolutely

The word independent does not describe somebody who [b]depends[/b] on "federal and state funded programs to help them".

This topic is about whether one citizen has the [b]right[/b] to take property from another. Do you believe that your [b]need[/b] entitles you to take my property? Misuse of the word [b]independent[/b] will not change the [b]fact[/b] that tax recipients are [b]dependent[/b] on tax[b]payers[/b], who are perfectly capable of surviving and thriving without tax recipients. If your survival depends on another person, it is your responsibility to request their help, thank them if they are willing to give it, and ask somebody else if they are not. Poverty, whatever its cause, is not a license to others' property.

by absolutely

In this case, it was necessary to counter Rob's misuse of the phrase "faith in yourself", which he turned to equate self-reliance with a leap of faith. It's no such thing, but the word "faith" gave him that opportunity. The main point I tried to make there is that trusting one's own ability is not a matter of blind faith.

In general, if I am nitpicky it is because inexact meanings tend to provide the appearance of validation to inexact ideas and inexact thinking.

This discussion is closed to new replies.