Individual Liberty in America - Is it a thing of the past?
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by absolutely
...how pirate has never clearly, concisely, and briefly described his position on anything. He spouts off about "civic duty", but is unclear as to what that really is. On one hand, seeing how he applies such rhetoric, it seems that it's capitulating to collectivism; but on the other hand, he's not a collectivist, or so he claims. He further labels himself as a federalist, but failed to explain exactly what that is in today's political reality. Being very familiar with the Hamiltonian flavor of federalism, I have to wonder how it compares and/or what the differences may be 200 years later. Regardless, I've personally never seen anyone, today, identify himself as a Federalist. There is no Federalist Party, per se, and there is no "federalist movement" (not to be confused with The Federalist Society), where one might get a glimpse of some semblance of core values on which opinions are built. So it is, in my opinion, another silly ploy he uses in playing his evasive games.
And he writes his messages in the most nonsensical way. One might surmise that he's simply trying to come across as some sort of intellectual, which he's not. Others might deduce that he's simply being evasive, which he is. I've concluded that it's both. I've further concluded that attempting any reasonable dialogue with him is a waste of time. He argues for argument's sake; he's obviously, as evidenced by his messages, filled with hate, contempt, and vile; and he's admitted to having "an issue" with some unknown guy (me) for posting messages on an Internet message board. Talk about someone being in la-la land.
He is, at this point, a total waste of my time. Of course, he'll spout off some more stupid rhetoric about how I'm not "up to" debating with him. But more accurately, I'm not really willing to go "down to" him.
After all, I have better things to do than waste my time arguing with the computer guy in an auto parts store.
by absolutely
"I don't recall saying that you are mandated toward that end. I have said that the entire issue of addressing the tax and re-distribution issue is minimalistic."
Are you or are you not here suggesting that I remain mandated to give charity in a less "minimalistic" solution? If you want charity cases to be weaned off their dependence, that means charity remains a mandatory act for me.
"Without address to the greater issues involved there will be no lasting solution."
What greater issues?
by absolutely
of the Welfare system.
Whether the government requires me to pay $250 of every $1000 I earn to "help" people who don't earn their own livelihood, or just $0.25 really doesn't matter. Such use of taxes is only consistent with the premise that my livelihood, my time, my very life are at the disposal of the recipient.
.
For the first half of the USA's existence, there was no federal government support of people, per se, as it wasn't considered an appropriate role of government. The earliest reference to it that I've seen is when President Theodore Roosevelt supported providing aid to single mothers in the early 1900s. And the Social Security Act of 1935 had provisions to provide aid for dependent children as well. And then, in the 1960s, when President Johnson declared his "war on poverty", dependence on the federal government really took off. Up until then, people were rising out of poverty on their own in amazing numbers. (Part of me has to wonder if President Johnson actually wanted to create a dependent class of people in America.) But to be sure, there have been no winners in the "war on poverty", only losers -- and that's everybody. (I guess Johnson wasn't successful with ANY of his "wars".)
In the days before the federal government got involved, the poorest of the poor were aided by individuals, churches, private charities, and, in some cases, local and state governments. My primary assertion, however, is that the federal government was never designed to provide such aid. Moreover, the federal government's transfer of wealth boondoggle has grown to levels that are exponentially more intrusive than simply "helping the poor". If only it were that small.
by absolutely
The "war on poverty" has manufactured more poverty, by enabling the very behaviors that lead to and perpetuate poverty. Without welfare, poor people miss their rent for two months, get evicted, and learn a very difficult lesson through extreme invonvenience. And they learn it thoroughly. With welfare, people miss payments, apply for government aid, and become habituated to a means of survival that gradually removes their self-esteem, and all will to work, but gradually enough that only outsiders notice "aid recipients just don't care." If they did, [i]they[/i] would be outraged!
The "war on drugs" has actually [b]spawned[/b] a thriving, international, multibillion-dollar drug industry!
God help us now that our brainless leader has declared "war on terrorism"!
by absolutely
that I perceive that you also disagree with the premise he presented. I'm going to try to avoid posts that either of you make to the other, and see if I can get a clear understanding of your views of the actual issues. Of course, Max posted that originally, too, so if you want to make a clear statement, it might help to address the rest of your audience, not Max.
"Civic duty does not equal charity and I resent your implying that I am attempting to draw an equality there Absolutely. Civic duty does, whether you like it or not, require you to take active part in your community."
Not to feed, clothe or shelter anybody who I did not personally bring into the world, agreed?
"In the management and admistration, whether in as little as a vote or as much as an office. It does require you to be responsible and thoughtful of the decision that you ultimately attempt to exert through your vote as well as demanding your understanding and assent to the principles upon which this nation was founded."
What law requires that I be responsible and thoughtful? Why did it not require the same of the people who established the welfare state?
"In the whole of this diatribe I have not once demanded that you take up the act of charity toward your neighbor, that, agreed is a choice."
"I have however, made statement that the current predicament is our responsibility to deal with. Whether we like it or not, our decisions do impact the populace as a whole and our careful consideration and just action is utmost importance. Whether it is desirable or not, to simply flip the switch is asinine and will lead to a situation far worse."
Describe a solution that is not asinine, then.
"Furthermore, to act in a manner that only feeds the selfish desires of the one leads to infighting and chaos as everyone attempts to "get theirs". The preservation of the union is not something that comes at the cost of the preservation of the self. If you disagree with that then I would ask you to please justify the Civil War."
Dangle [i]that[/i] bait for somebody else.
"It is a tenious thread that holds our nation suspended above chaos. On one hand we have the importance and preservation of the individual liberty. On the other is the preservation of the union which is the guarantor and defender of that liberty. Ultimately, selfishness is a stab to the very heart of our union as selfishness always demands that the self's interest be met at the expense of the other."
Rubbish. Henry Ford and Andrew Carnegie and every other industrialist provided jobs that their employees would not have had without them. They are hated only by people who expect somebody else to provide heaven on Earth [i]for them[/i]. Selfishness is not a stab to the very heart of anybody or anything. A stab to the heart is a stab to the heart. Selfishness means a primary concern with oneself, aka minding one's own business.
If we flip the welfare switch off, the charity cases will be deprived of their option to be un-selfish. They will be left with the option that their current benefactors exercise: to concern themselves primarily with themselves, beginning with their own livelihood. That would be justice. Mandated charity is not.
I'm willing to settle for reducing the tax burden, and the payout, over the course of 4 years, by 25% of the current level each year. No more. It's not my job to make life easy for anybody else, nor to provide any benefit to anybody else that is not repaid with equal benefit. In relation to the state, that means keeping the peace, and nothing more.
.
Which includes the following excerpt:
Let us now pause and look at some conclusions from all of this. Obviously Welfare Reform has been a great success, especially for African Americans. But more vexing problems emerge when we examine the reason for it's success. After all, what did Welfare Reform do? The funny thing is that it didn't specifically do anything to help poorer people! It didn't give poorer people anything of value - it took away things of value, by setting strict time limits. Sure, there was some childcare and job training money mixed in, but it was more or less just a substantial repeal of the old Welfare system. The next obvious question is - how in the world can poor people benefit when a program designed to help them is taken away? The ironic truth is that the Lyndon Johnson and the Congressional Democrats of the 60s, in the throes of liberal compassion, subsidized poverty and created what they sought to eliminate. [contrast Group 1 charts to view this]
What about the rise of single motherhood, especially in African American families? Where did all these single mothers that needed support come from? Isn't it a good thing we increased welfare spending at this time - so no single mothers would fall through the cracks? Well.... the research I have done has led me to the sad and horrifying conclusion - they came, in large measure, from nowhere. That is, they did not exist in any significant number before the very programs that were designed to help them, created them. They were molded from the most vulnerable; the youngest and poorest girls and mothers in society. As seen by Chart 14, it is a simple matter of cost/benefit economics. As the government raised the payment per family, loosened eligibilities and proliferated spending, the most destitute teenage girls became enticed to participate in a short term windfall, which would become their long term ruin, creating an underclass of dependency and poverty. Let's more closely compare six of our previous charts. Chart Group 3:
http://www.neoperspectives.com/welfare.htm
Disclaimer and Credit: That is one paper written by one guy voicing his opinion, although it certainly is very well supported.
by beads
This is also one of the many postulations found in: Freakonomics : A Rogue Economist Explores the Hidden Side of Everything by Steven D. Levitt, Stephen J. Dubner.
Likewise the authors also make a case that shows how abortion reduces crime in general as well. Its an interesting read, nonetheless.
Just throwing this out there.
- beads
Would you care to specifically address this?
(Credit given to the writer of the previously linked article.)
Let us now pause and look at some conclusions from all of this. Obviously Welfare Reform has been a great success, especially for African Americans. But more vexing problems emerge when we examine the reason for it's success. After all, what did Welfare Reform do? The funny thing is that it didn't specifically do anything to help poorer people! It didn't give poorer people anything of value - it took away things of value, by setting strict time limits. Sure, there was some childcare and job training money mixed in, but it was more or less just a substantial repeal of the old Welfare system. The next obvious question is - how in the world can poor people benefit when a program designed to help them is taken away? The ironic truth is that the Lyndon Johnson and the Congressional Democrats of the 60s, in the throes of liberal compassion, subsidized poverty and created what they sought to eliminate. [contrast Group 1 charts to view this]
What about the rise of single motherhood, especially in African American families? Where did all these single mothers that needed support come from? Isn't it a good thing we increased welfare spending at this time - so no single mothers would fall through the cracks? Well.... the research I have done has led me to the sad and horrifying conclusion - they came, in large measure, from nowhere. That is, they did not exist in any significant number before the very programs that were designed to help them, created them. They were molded from the most vulnerable; the youngest and poorest girls and mothers in society. As seen by Chart 14, it is a simple matter of cost/benefit economics. As the government raised the payment per family, loosened eligibilities and proliferated spending, the most destitute teenage girls became enticed to participate in a short term windfall, which would become their long term ruin, creating an underclass of dependency and poverty. Let's more closely compare six of our previous charts. Chart Group 3:
----------
What is it about those specific conclusions that you take issue with?
by absolutely
Humans [b]choose[/b] our actions and words based on goals we seek to achieve. In the context of this thread's topic, which is [b]very[/b] clearly defined in the origniating post, what is the purpose of "throwing [b]this[/b]"(emphasis mine):
Likewise the authors also make a case that shows how abortion reduces crime in general as well. Its an interesting read, nonetheless.
"out there"?
How exactly does abortion, or any correlation of it to crime statistics, relate to the premise that welfare is beyond the jurisdiction of the federal government?
by jdclyde
that is the typing of a drunk man at 1am in the morning after just getting home from a full day at ozzfest.
For the record, I don't say "them there" either except for when trying to make a point of being pointless. :)
Main point was, the REAL Michiganders don't talke the way jck said. Rent "moonlight in escanaba" and you will see how the yuppers talk and yes, that IS how a lot do talk up there. That is about a 10 hour drive from where I am.
by absolutely
"I believe you are addressing an outward expression of a deeper problem, a symptom if you will. Any doctor will tell you that you can treat the fever, you won't cure the patient until you identify and address what is causing that fever to begin with."
I'm not getting into the middle of whatever personal disagreement you two have, only trying to understand your difference on the economic and political issues Max asserts -- and, as you know, I agree with him completely. Absolutely, you might say. ;)
Also, eminent domain would have as its acronym ED, not ID, which got me wondering if you had misplaced a post intended for the Evolution lie. Imminent means "about to happen", eminent means "prominent" or "standing above others in some quality or position", which is obviously what the government purports to do when it takes your land away from you, paying a fee that it [i]calls[/i] "fair market value", but which is not subject to any bidding process to prove such a claim.
Ironically, in the case of construction workers, employed [i]voluntarily[/i] by the government to build -- including on land seized by the "eminent domain" exclusion -- the government has very strict rules about paying [b]at least[/b] the prevailing wage in the locality of that construction! Those rules have the effect of increasing prevailing wages in those fields by paying the highest wages reported in all neighboring jurisdictions instead of subjecting labor to competition, as is done in [b]every other industry![/b]
You are right (we are right, actually), the "War on Poverty" has created MORE poverty and MORE dependence.
The war on drugs is a sham. It has created a drug under-culture similar to the Al Capones of the 1930s. And it is being waged against the behavior of, otherwise, law abiding citizens. Drink a beer or smoke a doobie -- no difference.
Regarding the war on terrorism, however, has it created more terrorism? I think not. (But let's not go there.)
The only reason a war was declared on "terrorism" is that the enemy resides in no particular nation state. Moreover, the war on terrorism is being waged against an outside enemy intent on inflicting harm upon the citizens of the USA and the free world; whereas the war on poverty and drugs is aimed at changing and/or controlling the behavior of the citizens within.
Agree with the Bush tactics or not, you surely see the distinction?
by absolutely
I meant that as a warning against complacently assuming, based on the use of the word war by our president, that the problem is therefore "automatically" being addressed in the most efficient or thorough manner available. Recent history shows the opposite to be the pattern.
But war is the appropriate response, on that I agree completely. If I were President, I would have tried to convince Congress to declare war specifically on Al Qaeda and all its allies so that documented proof of assistance to Al Qaeda would be clear, legal justification for military action against any such country. I know GWB made statements to that effect in a speech, but he didn't get it in writing from the Congress. I wish he would.
You said, "If I were President, I would have tried to convince Congress to declare war specifically on Al Qaeda and all its allies so that documented proof of assistance to Al Qaeda would be clear, legal justification for military action against any such country. I know GWB made statements to that effect in a speech, but he didn't get it in writing from the Congress. I wish he would."
You know what, so would I. That would have also passed through Congress. But it's always easier to make things better with the benefit of hind sight.
by absolutely
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=178840&messageID=1823525
And I have decided to honor that request and stay out of exchanges between you and ippirate, except where I have something to contribute to the basic issues.
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=178840&messageID=1823514
There is obviously personal animosity caused by something far more than what ippirate describes as a small difference in the focus of your treatment of a problem whose essential nature you both agree to be its deviation from the principles on which the United States was founded.
That description of your difference on political economy is based on the following excerpt from ippirate's "Happy Birthday Max":
"I understand your premise, I agree, but only in part. In truth, so that you don't have to assume, there are two things that I take very serious issue with. First, your incessent raising of this subject and your limited to non-existent presentation of solution. Second, the selective intent of the sources, quotes and defenses that you present. You address what is directly beneficial to you but never do you address the whole of the picture. Case in point: Above you quote Madison, Jefferson and Franklin and their statements on the "welfare system" while foregoing mention of the quotes of these same men regarding civic duty and education, individual responsibility and community integration. Furthermore, you forego any mention of other of our nation's greats and their statements to the same...I believe you are addressing an outward expression of a deeper problem, a symptom if you will. Any doctor will tell you that you can treat the fever, you won't cure the patient until you identify and address what is causing that fever to begin with."
I believe the cause of the problem is the premise that one man's poverty is another man's responsibility, which can be described by the single word "collectivism". I know where you stand on that, I'm still waiting for ippirate to clarify what he thinks "civic duty" entails.
I'm interested in owning my property and having that recognized and protected by the government, not ignored and violated by it. That is why I participate in these discussions, not personality conflicts. Some of those will inevitablu result from expressing unpopular opinions and not compromising, but I will try to limit myself to my own disputes, because I expect to find enough of them to keep me busy.
by absolutely
Otherwise, why bother trying to be other than poor?
Elf, will you try addressing the premises, as presented in the original post?
I'll allow that the removal of government handouts should be done gradually enough that honest, working people can adjust, but not so slowly that dishonest, manipulative abusers of the current system can produce five generations of leeches, but [b]only if[/b] you'll admit that the current welfare state is incompatible with individual liberty, negates property rights, and is an immoral solution -- to a problem that I agree deserves attention, just not government attention.
That final statement is based on the government's legal power to coerce, which inherently makes it the wrong vehicle for charity. The power to tell others "Do as I say or you go to jail" is inappropriate to apply to any situation other than dealing with criminals -- meaning people who have violated others' [b]rights[/b] by taking their property of causing physical harm, not people who have violated others' [b]ideals[/b] by withholding charity.
by m_a_r_k
.
Absolutely, I will continue to speak out on this abomonation of the American system of governance, which literally strips people of their civil liberties, either until the trend is reversed, or until the day I die, whichever comes first.
Change is not caused by silence, but by being outspoken. People cannot hear those who remain silent, but only those who speak out. Just ask Martin Luther King. Just ask Susan B. Anthony. And just ask Maxwell T. Edison. (I had to throw that in; it has kind of a nice ring to it, don't you think?)
I HAVE A DREAM!
.
To the contrary. I have proposed a solution - 300 million of them.
The government of the United States of America was not designed to solve each and every individual's problems, but rather guarantee them the opportunity to solve such problems themselves.
How can a baker in New Jersey possibly solve the problems of the apple grower in Washington, better, first and foremost, than that apple grower himself, and/or better than the state of Washington itself as a last resort? The answer is, he can't. How can a lifeguard in California possibly be better suited to solve the problems of the subway worker in New York City better than that subway worker himself? The answer is, he can't.
Who among us has the audacity to presume that he knows better how to solve the individual problems of ANY American better than that very American himself? Speak out if you make such a presumption!
Who dares to set goals for others? Who dares to define dreams for others? Who dares to interfere with the God given wherewithal that each and every one of us has been blessed with?
Who dares to presume that others do not deserve to be given as much credit for self-reliance as we give ourselves?
What do you mean I offer no solution. You speak nonsense, man. Utter nonsense! No Solution? I offer 300 million of them!
It's worth repeating:
Who among us has the audacity to presume that he knows better how to solve the individual problems of ANY American better than that very American himself?
Speak out if you make such a presumption! Go ahead - speak out and openly admit it if you feel that way.
by absolutely
How long would you give the charity cases to find a beneficiary other than the government? I have conceded on the medical care thread that after offering welfare checks (immorally) the government and respective society does have an obligation to remove that promise gradually (not slowly, but not like flipping a switch), and with warning before beginning to do so.
I have colleagues who have only completed a two-year degree at the local community college, and whose jobs pay their bills comfortably, with promising opportunities in the future. On that basis, I propose that to begin the repeal of all transfer of wealth programs in two years is at least sufficient for anybody who is really trying to provide for themselves, that total payout is frozen at present levels for those two years, and that at that time, all government wealth transfer is reduced by 25% of its present level each of the next 4 years.
.
How dare you suggest to another American that he cannot have his cake and eat it too.
That's fool's talk, I tell you; fool's talk.
The cake of opportunity afforded by the American system is not a finite entity. To the contrary, it is dynamic; and it grows to accommodate the appetite of all freedom loving people who strive to achieve their dreams.
We can all eat from the cake of opportunity, except for those who are held back and held down to lowest depths of dependency. And who among us has the audacity to suggest to another American that he cannot have cake? And who among us is so mean-spirited as to deny us all a feast of cake -- especially the cake that we, ourselves, bake?
Yes indeed, we can all have our cake and eat it too.
by absolutely
.
.....please take the last word on Iraq/Terrorism.
I believe that there are things that you (and I) don't know and/or understand to the fullest (and rightfully so). For example, I believe that Saudi Arabia is more of a player in this thing than we (the U.S) have publicly acknowledged; and behind closed doors there are more considerations than we'll probably ever know. For all we know, this might be one of the most delicate operations in American history, if all considerations were actually known. So consider these things.
Considering that the USA gets 17 percent of its oil from the Saudis; and considering that any interruption in that supply would have a very significant and negative impact on not only our economy but the world economy, not to mention our national defense; and considering that the Saudis were unwilling to cooperate in the early efforts to cut-off funding to Al Qaeda; and considering that most of the 9-11 terrorists were Saudi citizens; and considering that Saddam Hussein DID INDEED support terrorists, including Al Qaeda, to at least some degree or another; and considering that Saddam Hussein WAS INDEED in violation of numerous UN resolutions; and considering that the Saudis didn't believe that the United States would really hold ANY and/or ALL nation states accountable if they supported terrorists in any way whatsoever; and considering the United Nations was not willing or able to do a damn thing about it, as usual; and considering .......... (fill in the blanks) .......... it's very easy to see how having a large presence -- an EXTREMELY LARGE presence -- of US military might and resolve parked on Saudi Arabia's northern border and anchored in their southern seas might "convince" the Saudis that, yes, we really do mean business. And it's equally easy to see how declaring war on the Saudis, either directly or indirectly, might not be the best approach.
And considering that my scenario is probably more true than not, to that I say, well done, President Bush. Very, very well done.
I'm truly baffled at the number of people who presume to armchair quarterback every little detail of something so huge and significant, especially considering that you don't have all the information at your disposal, information from which a logical conclusion can be reached. How can you possibly presume to "know better", for the lack of better words, if you don't have all the information? And before you stretch that to the point of suggesting that I'm saying you shouldn't voice your opinion, that's not at all what I'm saying. What I'm saying is that it's okay to not have all the facts. And as long as the actions advance an underlying principle, I'm okay with it. And my underlying principle is this (and/or based on this), some of which are very well known facts:
Fact: For the past forty or more years, the entire world, including the impotent and corrupt United Nations, and including the United States, has been paying no more than lip-service to the threat of terrorism. From the 1972 Olympics in Germany, to Jimmy Carter's debacle in the desert (Cover of a 1980 Time magazine that is forever burned into my mind), to Ronald Reagan's running from Lebanon, to the United Nations doing nothing, to Bill Clinton's insignificant cruise missile up a camel's butt, to you name it. Nobody has responded in any significant way -- until President Bush in 2001. I will admit that he was forced into it by the circumstances, but so be it. At least he addressed the totality of the issue, instead of paying the usual lip-service to only part of it.
Fact: Terrorism against the freedom loving west was conceived, born, and has been incubating in the middle-east. Personally speaking, I'm fed up with those thugs. Talk about "having your cake and eating it too", these middle-east thugs have grown enormously rich selling the west its precious oil, and then they turn around and turn a blind-eye to the terrorism that breeds on their own soil. Well F&^% them, I say.
Conclusion: It's about time some significant measures are being taken to turn things around in the middle east. And just like our own transfer of wealth system, it's taken forty or fifty years to create the mess; and it might take forty or fifty years to clean it up. But it's better than the alternative, which is not doing it. We can all presume to second guess whomever is making the tough choices. But we don't have all the facts, so we certainly don't have all the answers. And, as I said, as long as it advances an underlying principle, I'm okay with it. And in this case, it certainly does, at least in my eyes.
But you know what? I probably won't change your mind, nor will you change mine. You may disagree, but I want to hear a disagreement that's based on an underlying principle, and not some "made up" bit of nonsense that only serves to support a desired conclusion (such as "Brainless Bush").
But this thread isn't about Iraq and/or terrorism, so let's not do too much more to take it there. If you want to have the last word, please fell free to comment; in fact, I truly hope you do.
And although one of the things we hope to accomplish in Iraq (specifically) and in the middle-east (generally) is the establishment of individual liberty (as yet another weapon against the terrorist cause), this thread is supposed to be about re-establishing it in our very own homeland.
I hope we can figure out that we need to follow the very model that we are attempting to plant elsewhere. What we have now is not a model that we would design for others. So why in the hell do we continue living under it ourselves?
by absolutely
by absolutely
I'm uncomfortable knowing too little to make the right decision, and too little to know immediately whether the decisions made on my behalf are the best ones, but I have to acknowledge that in reality, the media I use to get my news are also fully available to enemy spies, so that isn't an option.
You're exactly right to ask for a more articulate response than "brainless Bush" because I do dislike him, in a personal way. He smiles at inappropriate times, seemingly making a mockery of life and death issues, and I just do not trust him. But something definitely needed to be done, I completely agree with that.
And to get back to the original topic of this thread, I put the origin of our troubles with the Middle East in the Truman administration, when wells owned by US and British interests were "nationalized" by one theocratic despot after another.
(Someone suggested that I never present any "solutions".)
To the contrary. I have proposed a solution - 300 million of them.
The government of the United States of America was not designed to solve each and every individual's problems, but rather guarantee them the opportunity to solve such problems themselves.
How can a baker in New Jersey possibly solve the problems of the apple grower in Washington, better, first and foremost, than that apple grower himself, and/or better than the state of Washington itself as a last resort? The answer is, he can't. How can a lifeguard in California possibly be better suited to solve the problems of the subway worker in New York City better than that subway worker himself? The answer is, he can't.
Who among us has the audacity to presume that he knows better how to solve the individual problems of ANY American better than that very American himself? Speak out if you make such a presumption!
Who dares to set goals for others? Who dares to define dreams for others? Who dares to interfere with the God given wherewithal that each and every one of us has been blessed with?
Who dares to presume that others do not deserve to be given as much credit for self-reliance as we give ourselves?
What do you mean I offer no solution. You speak nonsense, man. Utter nonsense! No Solution? I offer 300 million of them!
It's worth repeating:
Who among us has the audacity to presume that he knows better how to solve the individual problems of ANY American better than that very American himself?
Speak out if you make such a presumption! Go ahead - speak out and openly admit it if you feel that way.
.
The logistics of this would be easier than getting the green light (from the voters) to do it. There's an old Arab proverb that applies, "If the camel once get his nose in a tent, the body will soon follow", which is actually based on an old Arab fable. I've heard slightly different versions of the fable, but the moral of the story is quite consistent. Here are a couple of versions that I found to cut-and-paste.
---------- The Camel and the Arab (version 1) ----------
One day an Arab and his camel were crossing the desert. Night came and the temperature became colder. The Arab put up his tent and tied the camel to it. The Arab went to sleep. The temperature became slightly colder and the camel asked the Arab if he (camel) could just put his nose in the tent to warm up. The Arab agreed that the camel could just put his nose in, because the tent was small and there was no room for 2. So the camel's nose became warm and after a while the temperature went down even more. The camel asked the Arab again, if he (camel) could just put his fore legs in because they were very cold. The Arab reluctantly agreed that the camel could only put his fore legs in and no more. So the camel moved in his fore legs and they became warm. After sometime the camel asked the Arab again that he had to put in his hind legs or else he won't be able to make the journey the next morning with frozen legs. So the Arab agreed and once the camel moved his hind legs in, there was no more room in the tent for the Arab and the Arab was kicked out.
---------- The Camel and the Arab (version 2) ----------
The camel in the desert was cold and he stuck his nose under the Arabs tent. The Arab said, Get out of here. The camel said, "I am so cold and my nose takes such little room, just let me hold my nose under your tent to keep it warm." The Arab said, "Okay, but just your nose only." The next night the camel stuck his head in the tent, and the Arab did not complain as there was still plenty of room. The next night his shoulders came in, and again the Arab raised no fuss. The next night the whole camel was in the tent and the Arab told the camel to get out there is no room for you. The camel said, "I'm staying, you get out."
--------------------
I'm afraid that the true and total notion of individual liberty has already been kicked out of the American tent. The camels have literally have taken over, and the inmates are running the asylum.
Consider this. The American Socialist Party of 1932 has been successful, albeit a half-century later. And I'm absolutely serious about that. Read the 1932 American Socialist Party platform, and virtually every one of their positions have come to pass. And when Soviet General Secretary Nikita Kruschev banged his shoe on a table at the United Nations in 1960 and declared, "We shall destroy you from within" during the infamous Kitchen Debate, he must have understood human nature.
It is said that a rose by any other name is still a rose. And I submit to you that socialism by any other name is still the oppressor of liberty. So congratulations to all you politically correct, compassionate, environmentally conscious, outcome based, collectivist thinking, class envious, race baiting, big-business bashing, and frightened little people out there. The socialist cause has won - you have won; and Lady Liberty has lost. Or at least she is on the brink of defeat.
But in the famous words of Sir Winston Churchill, who found himself and the British on the brink of defeat at the hands of the Nazis, "Victory - victory at all costs, victory in spite of all terror, victory however long and hard the road may be; for without victory there is no survival."
And John Paul Jones, "'I have not yet begun to fight".
And Patrick Henry, "Is life so dear, or peace so sweet, as to be purchased at the price of chains and slavery? Forbid it, Almighty God! I know not what course others may take; but as for me, give me liberty or give me death!
And Maxwell Edison, "I will continue to speak out against this abomination of the current American system of governance, which literally strips people of their civil liberties, until the trend is reversed, or until the day I die, whichever comes first."
To be continued........
.
The original ten planks of the Communist Manifesto, written by Karl Marx in 1848, and how you people (and you know who you are), made them part of the American system of government:
1. Abolition of private property and the application of all rents of land to public purposes.
Americans do these with actions such as the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution (1868), and various zoning, school & property taxes. Also the Bureau of Land Management (Zoning laws are the first step to government property ownership)
2. A heavy progressive or graduated income tax.
Americans know this as misapplication of the 16th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, 1913, The Social Security Act of 1936.; Joint House Resolution 192 of 1933; and various State "income" taxes. We call it "paying your fair share".
3. Abolition of all rights of inheritance.
Americans call it Federal & State estate Tax (1916); or reformed Probate Laws, and limited inheritance via arbitrary inheritance tax statutes.
4. Confiscation of the property of all emigrants and rebels.
Americans call it government seizures, tax liens, Public "law" 99-570 (1986); Executive order 11490, sections 1205, 2002 which gives private land to the Department of Urban Development; the imprisonment of "terrorists" and those who speak out or write against the "government" (1997 Crime/Terrorist Bill); or the IRS confiscation of property without due process. Asset forfeiture laws are used by DEA, IRS, ATF etc...).
5. Centralization of credit in the hands of the state, by means of a national bank with State capital and an exclusive monopoly.
Americans call it the Federal Reserve which is a privately-owned credit/debt system allowed by the Federal Reserve act of 1913. All local banks are members of the Fed system, and are regulated by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) another privately-owned corporation. The Federal Reserve Banks issue Fiat Paper Money and practice economically destructive fractional reserve banking.
6. Centralization of the means of communications and transportation in the hands of the State.
Americans call it the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) and Department of Transportation (DOT) mandated through the ICC act of 1887, the Commissions Act of 1934, The Interstate Commerce Commission established in 1938, The Federal Aviation Administration, Federal Communications Commission, and Executive orders 11490, 10999, as well as State mandated driver's licenses and Department of Transportation regulations.
7. Extension of factories and instruments of production owned by the state, the bringing into cultivation of waste lands, and the improvement of the soil generally in accordance with a common plan.
Americans call it corporate capacity, The Desert Entry Act and The Department of Agriculture? Thus read "controlled or subsidized" rather than "owned"? This is easily seen in these as well as the Department of Commerce and Labor, Department of Interior, the Environmental Protection Agency, Bureau of Land Management, Bureau of Reclamation, Bureau of Mines, National Park Service, and the IRS control of business through corporate regulations.
8. Equal liability of all to labor. Establishment of industrial armies, especially for agriculture.
Americans call it Minimum Wage and slave labor like dealing with our Most Favored Nation trade partner; i.e. Communist China. We see it in practice via the Social Security Administration and The Department of Labor. The National debt and inflation caused by the communal bank has caused the need for a two "income" family. Woman in the workplace since the 1920's, the 19th amendment of the U.S. Constitution, the Civil Rights Act of 1964, assorted Socialist Unions, affirmative action, the Federal Public Works Program and of course Executive order 11000.
9. Combination of agriculture with manufacturing industries, gradual abolition of the distinction between town and country, by a more equitable distribution of population over the country.
Americans call it the Planning Reorganization act of 1949 , zoning (Title 17 1910-1990) and Super Corporate Farms, as well as Executive orders 11647, 11731 (ten regions) and Public "law" 89-136. These provide for forced relocations and forced sterilization programs, like in China.
10. Free education for all children in public schools. Abolition of children's factory labor in its present form. Combination of education with industrial production.
Americans are being taxed to support what we call 'public' schools, but are actually "government force-tax-funded schools " Even private schools are government regulated. The purpose is to train the young to work for the communal debt system. We also call it the Department of Education, the NEA and Outcome Based "Education" . These are used so that all children can be indoctrinated and inculcated with the government propaganda, like "majority rules", and "pay your fair share". WHERE are the words "fair share" in the Constitution, Bill of Rights or the Internal Revenue Code (Title 26)?? NO WHERE is "fair share" even suggested !! The philosophical concept of "fair share" comes from the Communist maxim, "From each according to their ability, to each according to their need! This concept is pure socialism. ... America was made the greatest society by its private initiative WORK ETHIC ... Teaching ourselves and others how to "fish" to be self sufficient and produce plenty of EXTRA commodities to if so desired could be shared with others who might be "needy"... Americans have always voluntarily been the MOST generous and charitable society on the planet.
Source and Credit: "Overheard" at Liberty Zone Cafe.
http://www.libertyzone.com/Communist-Manifesto-Planks.html
------------------------------
A rose by any other name is still a rose. And I submit to you that socialism by any other name is still the oppressor of liberty.
by thechas
Max,
Have you stepped back and taken a look at what your vision of society would bring?
As I read through your vision, I see one country that exemplifies what you propose. Brazil.
Do you really want a society where the few that have are forced to cower behind locked walls in order to protect themselves from thieves and kidnappers?
Every time I read your thoughts on "freedom" they seem to boil down to who controls the money.
I am more worried about the effects the Patriot Act, the war in Iraq, and the growing political power of Fundamentalist Christians have on our personal freedoms than what the impact of government spending has on my financial freedom.
I think that Karl Marx had a good basic concept in his "From each according to their ability, to each according to their needs" philosophy. He just did not take into account that human kind has not yet evolved to the point of general altruism.
I would modify Marx's concept to encompass the reality of human greed.
From each to the full extent of their abilities.
To each, no less than there needs.
I believe that you would agree that anyone working to the best of their abilities should be compensated at least enough to cover the basic necessities.
As to taxes themselves, yes our tax system needs some changes.
I don't agree with a flat tax, or primarily a national sale tax as being fair ways to fund our government.
I agree with no tax on business income so long as the business operates in a socially responsible manner.
The progressive income tax structure does need 1 significant change.
Rather than taxing all of ones income at the tax rate for your total income, tax each step in income at the rate for that income level.
If the tax rate changes at $50,000, and you earned $51K, the first $50K would be at the lower rate and only the final $1K would be taxed at the higher rate.
As to the inheritance tax, that too should be revised not thrown away.
Any family member (or minor) who contributed to the family should not have to pay any tax.
A family member who did not contribute should have to pay the gift tax on their inheritance as it was a gift and not earned.
On education, if you want to revamp the education system, run for your local school board and change the system from within.
Anyhow, chill out a bit and calm down. I don't want to see you getting a coronary or some other trauma from things that cannot be quickly or easily changed.
Chas
.
No, Chas. There's no coronary in my future. I'm perfectly calm. And I'm perfectly "chilled".
I just call em' as I see em'.
And if you really believe, as you said, "...that Karl Marx had a good basic concept in his 'From each according to their ability, to each according to their needs' philosophy. He just did not take into account that human kind has not yet evolved to the point of general altruism...", well, enough said.
If you think I've gone off the deep end, it's only because of your particular perspective. And in this case, I'm glad to be on the end that I am, deep or otherwise.
.
You once told me that you don't trust your fellow man, or something to that effect. (I could find the exact message, if you'd like.)
Well, Chas, I DO trust my fellow man. And although I did indicate in a different message, "that today's Americans are too foolish, to frightened, too greedy, too gullible, and too ..... (fill in the blank) ..... to vote any other way", I really blame those who lust for power over them. People are gullible. They believe anything, especially when warned to "fear" something.
However, when left to their own devices, I DO trust people. I trust that a person will not let his mother, his father, his brother or sister fall by the wayside and perish. I trust that people DO have compassion for their fellow man. I trust that people DO want to help others. And I'm very sad that you don't feel the same way.
I feel that people would make those choices on their own; while you, on the other hand, obviously feel that they must be forced by the strong-arm of government.
I believe in God, Chas, just like you. And I believe that God gave people their dreams and ambitions. And I further believe that if God gave people their dreams, He also gave them the capacity to achieve them. I think it's too bad that you don't.
Yes, Chas. I do indeed trust my fellow man. I trust him to find the wherewithal -- the God given wherewithal -- to find a way to determine, to seek, and to achieve his purpose on Earth. And I give him enough credit to determine for himself what that purpose is. And for you to interfere with that is, in my opinion, a travesty.
By your own admission, Chas, you don't trust your fellow man, while I do. And you suggest that it is I who paid a visit to "the deep end". Okay, whatever you say.
.
I edited the message to which Chas replied with the proper source and credit for the writings I posted. The ten planks of the Communist Manifesto are, of course, and as indicated, the words of Karl Mark. The author of the comments, however, should have been given proper credit and source.
by absolutely
[b]I[/b] am most worried about the government's [b]ability[/b] to declare such nonsense as the Patriot Act, or any other "visionary's" tyrannical implementation of idiotic ideas (especially Marxism), funded by deficit spending. Liberty is more easily infringed by a government that does not fully recognize individual property rights in the first place, and claims ownership of all wealth via the money it coins. I know that's one of your tenets, Chas, and it's false. The government owns the paper, the ink, and even the bills, but the citizens own the [b]wealth[/b] their money represents.
Similarly to Max, "I would modify Marx's concept to encompass the reality of human" [b]ability[/b]. Except for a minute fraction of the population, nobody is so lacking in ability that they have any valid excuse to not be "making it". Those that are truly unable to produce sufficiently to support themselves do not have the [b]right[/b] to pretend, with the assistance of the government's power, that they have the ability to [b]produce[/b] equal to what they must [b]consume[/b] to survive. The claim that without mandatory re-distribution of wealth, imposed by the government, shows the individual hypocrisy of all Marxists. What you mean by the claim that the government must be involved for your vision to work is that you, personally, are not willing to do [b]your part[/b] to achieve [b]your goal[/b] of universal subsistence, regardless of [b]effort[/b] or [b]application[/b] of ability. Admit it.
"I believe that you would agree that anyone working to the best of their abilities should be compensated at least enough to cover the basic necessities."
Compensated by whom, Chas? I believe that anyone working to the best of their abilities ought to be compensated by their employer, according to the market value of the work they perform. I suppose you would have us take you at your word when it comes to the definition of "the best of their abilities", just as you would like to decide for us all what it means that a "business operates in a socially responsible manner."
I don't trust others in the sense of counting on general benevolence of strangers. I do [b]believe[/b] that acquired ability is the result of personal integrity, specifically of [b]honest[/b] recognition of the fact that human life is sustained by human effort, and that such effort ought to be one's own. Failure to understand that fact is not explainable as an intellectual shortcoming. It can only be the result of dishonesty at the most basic, personal level, hypocrisy.
.
In order to even get the process started, we'd need to have a significant presence in Congress. That would mean a revival of the circa 1964 Republican Party that existed under Barry Goldwater, or the rise to prominence of a third party, namely the Libertarian Party, or some other party that values the true notion of individual liberty and/or is an opponent of the current system of democratic-socialism.
But, as Benjamin Franklin warned, "When the people find that they can vote themselves money, that will herald the end of the republic."
And I fear that today's Americans are too foolish, to frightened, too greedy, too gullible, and too ..... (fill in the blank) ..... to vote any other way.
.
For the record - my views on taxation
Contrary to what others have suggested, I've never espoused the abolition of all taxes. And to suggest such a thing is utter nonsense. I am in favor of reducing the size and scope of the federal government. It's simply too big, too intrusive, and too controlling in the lives of the individual. And I am in favor of abolishing the state and federal tax on income, including social security taxes. For the typical wage earner, this would mean a net pay that is equal to his gross pay -- no taxes withheld at all, and no filing a federal and state tax return each and every year. (A waste of ~250 billion each and every year.) And I am in favor of abolishing all corporate taxes because, as we know, corporations don't pay taxes, they simply pass on the cost to the consumer in the form of higher prices. If corporations' tax burdens were removed, prices could be reduced by about 25 percent -- and they would be reduced because of something called competition in the market place.
I would replace the current tax system with a national sales tax that is applied equally across the board, 20 to 25 percent, for example, on all new purchases, not used, whether that be in the form of goods or services. The more a person purchases (in goods and services), the more taxes he pays, but the percentage is consistent. And a rate of around 25 percent would result in the government taking in the same amount of money as it currently does. (The cuts in spending is a different issue, and could come later.)
Let me preempt your first objection. (Yes, I'm guessing as to what that might be.) I would exempt ALL persons who earn UNDER a certain amount of money, say the $27,000 range, from paying any taxes at all -- none, zero, nothing. If a person makes that amount or less, he pays no taxes whatsoever. Many such people today don't pay income taxes anyway, considering the various tax credits and such, but they do pay social security taxes, and they do pay sales taxes. I would propose that they don't even pay those. And such a person's employer pays an additional 7.5 percent on his behalf in more social security taxes, and I propose that be eliminated as well, which could, and probably would, result in a 7.5 percent raise.
How can a national sales tax on purchases exempt certain lower wage earners, you ask? Go ahead and ask, if you're wondering. I do have an answer. (I want to see if anyone is listening.)
by thechas
None of us can tell if someone has a hidden talent or skill that they are not using.
However, one can tell if a worker is giving their full effort to the task at hand.
Anyone working at even the most menial full time job should be paid enough to survive in society.
A living wage!
One of the problems that keeps people on welfare is that welfare provides a better standard of living than an entry level job.
Every company that I have worked for has begrudged every penny paid to employees.
Only when a shortage of wokers significantly affects the operation of the company do they start to consider raising compensation.
I have in prior discussions outlined my thoughts on what would constitute a socialy responsible business:
All workers including those locally subcontracted are paid at least a living wage for the area.
The business offers health care coverage.
(Note, offers not provides)
The company meets or exceeds current polution standards and does not lobby for relaxing those standards.
CEO compensation is capped at a fixed multiple of the lowest paid workers salary.
200X might be low, 1000X sounds high.
(at a $10/hr living wage, the above works out to between 4 and 20 million)
Chas
by absolutely
It [b]is[/b] possible to determine whether or not a worker's performance is at least equal to the requirements of the job. Whether that is the employee's "best effort" is 100% irrelevant, as well as impossible to determine by anybody but that worker.
"However, one can tell if a worker is giving their full effort to the task at hand."
Full effort that fails to meet the requirements of the job does nobody any good. A more talented employee who can do the same job, regardless of untapped potential to do even better, is still better at the job. Profit is the purpose of business, Chas, employment of workers is only a necessity that is lucky for the employees. We would all do well to remember that.
by beads
Its called a tangent. Perhaps you can grasp the idea. Maybe you've heard of such? Now, you come accross all fire and brimstone like a Southern Baptist after a good Sunday revival. Since the basis of the thread deals with loss of individual freedom I would indeed consider a woman's right to choose an idividual freedom. Or is that as long as you agree to with what she is allowed to choose as her option or freedom? No, that would be your right to choose for her? Got it. I didn't see anything in the title of this thread that narrowed or limited the topic down to: Those ideas or thoughts that Absolutely and Maxwell Edison find appropriate and entertaining. All others will be drawn and quartered upon entry.
Yes, there have been two studies identifying the link between abortion and violent crime. One, I remember was broadcast on NPR so I do not have a specific biblio as it had to be last summer. Just one of those things that sticks in ones mind.
The other is buried somewhere in Freakonomics. An oddly twisted look at correlations of seemingly unrelated events. Haven't finished the book yet but I am sure I'll find it for ya... Okie? What I suspect is that its the same study presented twice in different ways. At least thats what I am hoping to find.
Again, I appologize for the "wild" tangent. Not saying I agree witht the hypothesis but worth following up on. Unfortunately, there is always a fair amount of reading I'd like to do or want to do but I'm really a tech management expert not theologian or professional debate devote!
- beads
by absolutely
on everything!
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=174908&messageID=1819668
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=178781&start=0
I'm also very confrontational.
I don't challenge your right to state an opinion, but the phrase "just throwing this out" strikes me as evasive, and I'd like to know what you think is the relevance of the study you cited. Relate it to the welfare debate or not, I can make the connection between two variations on the theme of personal liberty. As a matter of fact, I think the connection between legal abortion and crime deserves very close attention, but I don't have [i]Freakonomics[/i], so I'll wait patiently for you to share whatever details you connect, tangentially or otherwise.
.
Absolutely and I don't always agree. In fact, one case in point is that he wants to hug nonexistent trees in ANWR; while I, on the other hand, want to totally destroy the Earth by drilling at that very spot. Moreover, he doesn't like the oil companies getting free government handouts that would be the result; while I, on the other hand, would love to see those greedy oil executive bastards line their pockets even more. (Dripping with sarcasm and humor, in case you didn't notice.) And we see the abortion issue differently as well, at least I think we do. I won't presume to speak for him, but my stance is this (since you brought it up).
I believe that a woman has a right to choose whether or not she becomes a mother; but that choice should be made before she becomes a mother, not after. And I further believe that the scientific and medical communities should clearly define when that is -- when life begins -- period. All we have now is the very subjective and ambiguous......it's generally accepted that after blah, blah, blah.....and it's different for different people. And no mincing words with embryo, fetus, etc. When does life begin? Period. And laws should be based on that one answer. And if a person can be prosecuted for ending that life in one context, then it should be applied equally to all. If Scott Peterson can be convicted of murder, for example, for taking the life of an unborn child, then so should everybody. It's not a life of convenience or a life of circumstances. It's either a life or it isn't - period.
So I don't see it as only a woman's issue, or exclusively a woman's issue, but rather a human rights issue. And actually, I believe the best way to address the issue is to somehow get that very precise question, when does life begin, in front of the courts to be argued by all sides. Moreover, I believe it's even more important to clearly answer that question now that we are beginning to see the growth of cloning and such. If "a life" is created in a test tube, for example, can it be systematically snuffed out at the discretion of the person and/or people who facilitated it? And the same question applies, regardless of the incubator of choice -- a test tube or a womb.
But I'm just a simpleton (more sarcasm). I don't claim to be smart enough to answer that question myself, when does life begin? (Part sarcasm, part honest question.) But I would think that all the collective genius of the combined scientific and medical minds could come pretty close (serious opinion). And whatever that answer is, so be it. And any time before that, abortion is okay. Any time after that, it's not.
But I digress. The question before the court today, I mean before the forum, is whether or not you side-stepped an issue by creating a tangent of a different flavor. We all love these tangents, even Absolutely and I, but not at the expense of addressing the original question.
Absolutely and I have seen too many cases of people answering a question with a question, merely as a ploy to avoid addressing the original question. And apparently we are both curious as to how you would address the points made in that original message.
So would you care to indulge us by giving your opinion on the original points made? After that, we'll follow you down any tangent or road that you'd like to pave.
by absolutely
...by the implication that disagreement with me is a source of validity or acceptance on this forum, I fully agree with your statement that we do not agree on abortion nor ANWR. I will assume that you intended at least a small portion of sarcasm for your comment about hugging trees...
As succinctly as I am able: because this [I don't claim to be smart enough to answer that question myself, when does life begin? (Part sarcasm, part honest question.)] cannot be done, this [And actually, I believe the best way to address the issue is to somehow get that very precise question, when does life begin, in front of the courts to be argued by all sides.] [b]should[/b] not be done. I believe science must provide the evidence on which the populace first decides when [b]exactly[/b] life begins, then, when near-consensus is reached, only then let professional legalists apply the accepted definitions to law.
I do not agree with giving the courts, or any branch of government, power to re-define words and concepts, such as life, to fit the prejudices of any religion, or religious interpretation of science, for example. The courts should be constrained to use popular, objectiv definitions of words, as those words are popularly used. I know that they already have a vast, convoluted vocabulary of Latin and English words that mean very different things to lawyers than they do to people, but I'm talking about how things should be done, not the pragmatic compromises that are currently in effect. Laws, enforced by a government of the people, [b]by[/b] the people and [b]for[/b] the people, must be [b]comprehensible[/b] to the same people.
I do agree that once the beginning of life is truly defined as certainly as the power to punish morally requires, and with the precision and accountability to science and the people that I described above, then "whatever that answer is, so be it. And any time before that, abortion is okay. Any time after that, it's not."
I also agree with the rest of what maxwell said in the remainder of his message, but with one [b]caveat[/b]: roads or tangents leading nowhere, passing through rabbit holes, or paved with yellow bricks make me impatient, and I reserve the right to become surly if I encounter any of those. But I know you wouldn't waste your time with [b]irrelevant[/b] tangents.
by itgirli
by ippirate
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=178840&messageID=1824159
It would appear that from the above post that two points come to the front.
First, max feels compelled to challenge me.
Second, max you are blind, senile and possessing a short-memory or you are just plain inept as I have already presented you with at least part of my socio-political mindset at the link following:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=178840&messageID=1822402
I think it the last.
Please, spare me the "Who dares attempt to force one American" posturing. It is laughable how you spin in order to evade the simple questions that I have put forth on more than one occasion. Let me now line those out for you one last time so that there is no doubt.
You present 300 million solutions to your proposed problem. Please, pray tell, how is it that you would effect change in this nation? How is it normally effected? Would that be the vote? The answer to that question, in my ever so ignorant mind is yes. Or would you suggest something a little more drastic? Say, revolution? If the vote is your answer then the question now begins of how to best influence that vote. Perhaps numbers? Seems reasonable.
So you're solution is to fix it? How? You and many others are grandstanding in the crevices of your existence, "sharing" your view and disgust with the current situation. How will you influence this situation? THE VOTE. ELECTION TIME. Tell me, just how do you propose to do that when:
1. The voting population has no concept of their civic responsibilities.
2. They have no idea what this nation was founded on besides the occasional blurb from the History channel whilst flipping to Comedy Central.
3. The many voters right now have a vested interest in keeping the social structure in place and as they are the active ones, they push their policy, right or wrong.
4. The majority of Americans DON'T VOTE and these are comprised primarily of individuals of a similar ideology to yourself or at least capable of being influenced to vote in a particular fashion. Sadly, you can't get them out of the house on election day.
5. Candidates to election have no responsibility to the constituency today. Only to the party. It is no longer the voter's ideals that are presented, it is the party's. That is what is pursued in Washington. That's right, I believe that parties have gone south. They present a method by which a given group can unduly control the government. It is very difficult to call it a choice when there are only two and they resemble a lot more than differ.
6. Lobbyists and corporate influence present the only other avenue of influence, unfortunately, they two work through the party and their goals are definitely not yours.
Now, tell me max, just how do you propose to get the social system out of America? By whining incessantly on TR? Perhaps by lambasting me and attempting to color me something other than what I am for having the audacity for pointing out that your statements and your 300 million bloody solutions are empty, ignorant, half-truths and complaints?
You just don't get it. The problem is NOT rooted in the social programs. It is rooted in the complete lack of civic knowledge and sense of duty on the part of the individuals charged with managing the nation, the voting population. It has nothing to do with the Presidency, the Senate or the House as they have only enacted what the voting population has overwhelmingly declared they wanted. You live in a nation where civics is taught by a group of half-baked fruit loops in LA and NYC, sung in the concert halls and flashed on the big screen. On the rare occasion that it is actually taught in a public forum or educational institution, it is so biased and blatantly socialist, it really doesn't amount to more than propaganda. Shamefully, the right is just as guilty. Rather than sitting down and actually attempting to understand the subject matter (that requires thought and thought is both painful and bad) We The People, would prefer to be spoon fed what we should "think", leaving the decisions to that bunch of self-interested nitwits inside the Beltway.
Yes, I think you are completely wrong max. There is a sharp contrast between the your 300 million solutions and the reality of the subject. Unfortunately, those 300 million solutions are just one big bloody obstacle to real change, due in no small part to the ignorance advanced by opinions and soapboxes such as yours.
So there you have it max. That is why I find your argument both ignorant and offensive. Well, that and the fact that you think it wise to try and play me as liberal rather than actually answer the problems in your argument. Of course, that would entail actual contemplation on your part, a quality I don't perceive you as fostering.
Enjoy!
.
I suggest that there are 300 million solutions.
You suggest that there are 300 million obstacles.
Leaving your condescending attitude on the back shelf of that auto parts store, and without your usual long-winded and hard to follow tirades, tell me if this is a correct "in a nutshell" conclusion to what you just said.
(Hint: a one word answer will suffice.)
by ippirate
.
When you said, ".....those 300 million solutions are just one big bloody obstacle to real change, due in no small part to the ignorance advanced by opinions and soapboxes such as (mine)", it made me wonder. How can my opinion and my soapbox cause, in no small part, such a big bloody obstacle?
by ippirate
by absolutely
Exactly by expressing better [b]ideas[/b] than the ones currently shaping "debate" in "politics".
I fully agree that voter ignorance and apathy are [b]the[/b] ongoing problems responsible for initiating and sustaining government-sponsored wealth redistribution programs.
I don't presume to speak for Maxwell or anybody else, but I am outspoken in order to meet other like-minded people, who not only disdain ignorance, but its side effects, including poverty, complacency, and disrespect for principles like personal responsibility and respect for others' property.
The entire welfare "argument" is no more complicated than kindergarten morality. In the presence of moral authorities, stealing a peer's toy (or taking a peer's income to give to somebody else who didn't earn it) ought to be punishable. In the absence of authority, or in the presence of immoral authorities, stealing a peer's income (toy, security blanket, whatever) is ignored, or condoned, respectively.
I think the problem is rooted in lack of a sense of responsibility for self, not lack of responsibility to others, to society, or to any other entity, real or imagined. The problem is welfare recipients, who, for whatever reason, haven't enough pride to insist on self-sufficiency, which in reality is inseparable from independence, despite any minor variations in definition. There are, luckily, fewer than 300 million welfare recipients in this country. There are, unfortunately, a vast number of people who consider charity "honorable" and "virtuous", forgetting that a gift requires a recipient, and that their largesse is somebody else's free ride. They forget that the pride and virtue they experience in giving is incompatible with ever being on the receiving end of money taken by force, against the will of the benefactor. If it is good give, what is the moral status of recipients? And considering the obvious answer to that rhetorical question, is it not inevitable to conclude that being a party to charity, either as giver or recipient, is [b]immoral[/b]?.
by ippirate
Absolutely, I do not agree with forced charity. If it has to be forced, it isn't charity at all. Does it become immoral? Is one mandated by the Constitution to regard and be mindful of the lives and welfare of others? Yes and no, it isn't a question of morality that is being chattered about here. It may be convenient to make it such to advance the cause, but it is not a legitimate inquiry. The question is whether it is lawful or not.
As far as I can see, by the Constitution, as well as a myriad of other documents that pertain or address, forced charity is not lawful. The catch is taxation though. There is no legal bar to taxation as long as it is introduced and ratified in the manner prescribed within the Constitution, House, Senate, OaP approval or veto with ratification by 2/3's majority vote. The issue of what is done with this tax money is hazy in so far as the Dec. of Ind. and the Constituion go and this has left the track open for "interpretation". The whole "living document" argument. With this considered, I don't see where it is forbidden either. I believe it so because of my own study of the foundations of our nation, and therein lies the problem at the root. "My study". It isn't taught anymore.
All argument of virtue, morality, etc. goes to the wayside. It is a question of reading and specifically, reading for author's intent, two disciplines that our populace has gotten away from, not surprisingly though considering the drive to disengage active reason in this country.
Fact: Active criticism and reasoning are the two most dynamic and dangerous forces in any society. If the people apply these two disciplines a hard line is made for a deception and tyranny to cross. We don't do this in America any longer as it is just to difficult to think. But enough of my soapbox.
My point was and is that moral, immoral, lawful, unlawful is beside the point really. Civic activity is what lies at the root of your problem and until the people wake up and begin to be active participants and take on their responsibilities again, the debate over law, ethic and morality of re-distribution will be nothing more than that, a debate held on some backwater discussion boards by a bunch of guys that really have nothing better to do with there time than to send comments back and forth.
"I fear that we have awakened a sleeping giant and filled him with a great resolve"
Admiral Isiroku Yomamoto
December 7th, 1941
Will that giant awaken again? Honestly? All indications are no, he's to heavily medicated on propaganda, newsspeak, consumerism and entertainment. I think we're done for, with no small thanks to syndicated media and the Democrat/Republican party. Yes, I know I used the singular, I meant to. Same goal, different spin.
.
You surprised me. I thought you were going to say yes -- and then I was going to agree with you (and elaborate, of course). Go figure.
You said, "Yes, I think you are completely wrong max. There is a sharp contrast between your 300 million solutions and the reality of the subject. Unfortunately, those 300 million solutions are just one big bloody obstacle to real change, due in no small part to the ignorance advanced by opinions and soapboxes such as yours."
Gee, I read that as though I was suggesting there were 300 million solutions, which I was, but you saw the "sharp contrast" and called them "one big bloody obstacle" (or 300 million obstacles?). Okay, I guess I'm just stupid and ignorant, or you're just...........
But I've yet to see you take any of our disagreements and/or miscommunications and/or whatever they are, and form some sort of clear and rational, simple and easily understood conclusion. Maybe you'll surprise me again and give it a try.
Call me stupid, call me ignorant, call me whatever you want. But.....
".....what we have here is a failure to communicate. Some men you just can't reach. So you get what we had here last week. Which is the way he wants it. Well, he gets it. I don't like it anymore than you men."
So get your dirt outta' my hole.
I'm gonna' go to lunch..........50 eggs, of course.
by ippirate
stupid,
I'll put it like this, I've answered you honestly, according to the "single word answer" system that you wanted.
As I cannot find it within myself to oversimplify the argument to the ignorant proportions that you desire, I answered "nope".
I find it extraordinarily ignorant on your part to limit me on a response and then bemoan an answer other than what you had hoped for. Further, in doing so, you censor me and then complain that I haven't made my position clear. Bravo!
I think your quote very suitable. This portion in particular "Which is the way he wants it. Well, he gets it.", being quite descriptive of your seemingly argitrary methodology in discussion, debate, etc.
Congrats!
I was merely pointing out, contrary to his suggestion that you and I are in lock-step with each other and/or something else, that we do disagree on occasion. It had nothing to do with validity or acceptance or anything else, only to challenge the pigeon-hole into which we were both being characterized.
And as for my sarcasm about your "hugging trees", it was along the same lines as me wanting to "destroy the Earth".
by absolutely
But I edit enough of my posts for grammar, spelling, format and clarity. I'll let a poor choice of words remain.
I understand why you pointed out our disagreements, and I'm really not bothered by it. I should have appended a j/k there.
What truly [b]disturbs[/b] me is how many people claim that stealing from producers to give to consumers who do not produce is a morally valid decision.
Now, let's get back to the task of trying to establish de facto property rights in this anarchistic collective formerly [b]governed[/b] by the Constitution of the United States.
by absolutely
[i]"In my opinion, we abdicated our individual liberties long ago.
Sometime between Presidents Lincoln and T. Roosevelt.
When we made the transition from an agricultural to an industrial economy, the average citizen was no longer self reliant and independent.
Once you are dependent on the efforts of others (even when you compensate them for their efforts) for the basic necessities of life, you have abdicated your personal liberty."[/i]
Farmers [b]depended[/b], long before Lincoln, on blacksmiths to forge their tools. Deprivation of liberty means loss of life, liberty, or property without due process of law, meaning for any other reason than conviction of a crime. [b]Abdication[/b] of liberty would mean [b]voluntarily[/b] declining rights. I have not done that, but I am still required to pay taxes to feed people who don't work, and to enrich people whose work is counter-productive and/or whose ability to produce would not survice competition in a free market.(subsidized industries).
[i]"As to private investment versus social security, I think this debate is filled with false assumptions:
1. It is wrong to assume that those on the mid to low end of the economic scale would invest even 1/2 of the income that presently is deducted for social security. Unless required to do so by law. (more infringement on liberties)
Likewise, the average low wage employer will simply pocket what they now pay into social security.
2. Personal savings will provide more money than one gets from social security.
This concept is "conditionally" false.
On the assumption that the average person will invest in low risk funds, and that social security does not go broke, the financial analysis that I have heard put the break even point at 10 years after retirement.
Live less than 10 years after you retire, and you are better off with personal investments.
Live more than 10 years, and the present system provides you with a greater return."[/i]
These assumptions, whether true or false, are not pertinent to the central question posed in the originating post: how does one construe the fact of [b]not having earned money[/b] as an [b]entitlement to somebody else's earned wealth?[/b]
by absolutely
While corporate news media are congratulating the government not for eliminating the deficit, but just narrowing the monthly budget shortfall compared to the same month of last year
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/8897852/
analysis of the Bureau of Economic Analysis' data shows the real culprit behind this chronic debt problem: taxes have been increasing faster than GDP consistently with only brief relent, since at least 1929.
http://www.taxpolicycenter.org/TaxFacts/overview/receipt_chart.cfm
Are there more needy people? Is it more difficult to make a living than in 1929?
by ippirate
by absolutely
by ippirate
I think that what you would find is an inverse bell rather than converging trends. The nearer you approach middle class in America, the more you pay whether measured cost/return, actual percentage (not booked), etc.
The entire point of the original post was this. If income tax was actually implemented as a national sales tax, businesses included, at roughly 12-14%, there would be plenty of tax revenue generated, especially when you start to tack on non-income taxes like import/export taxes. Additionally, if you consider that with doing so, the responsibilities of both Congress and the IRS would go down, giving one more time to actually do their job and the second a leaner infrastructure. If you really wanted to get creative you could even go so far as to say that police and court costs would go down as you would no longer have as much need to chase tax felons.
Immediate benefit? Your property comes one step closer to actually being yours. No more tax liens or threats of seizure.
.
You said, "If income tax was actually implemented as a national sales tax, businesses included, at roughly 12-14%, there would be plenty of tax revenue generated, especially when you start to tack on non-income taxes like import/export taxes. Additionally, if you consider that with doing so, the responsibilities of both Congress and the IRS would go down, giving one more time to actually do their job and the second a leaner infrastructure. If you really wanted to get creative you could even go so far as to say that police and court costs would go down as you would no longer have as much need to chase tax felons.
Immediate benefit? Your property comes one step closer to actually being yours. No more tax liens or threats of seizure."
Was that you suggesting such a system or were you paraphrasing someone else's proposition?
If it was you, I assume you support the idea.
If it was someone else, do you support it or not?
And if it was either your suggestion and/or your support of someone else's suggestion, how does it differ, in principle, than this one?
"For the record - my views on taxation":
--maxwell edison
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=178840&messageID=1824705
And if it was either your suggestion and/or your support of someone else's suggestion, how can you reconcile your reply to my suggestion with this:
"For the record: Why I think max's proposition is an obscenity"
--ippirate
And why am I having such a hard time understanding where you stand on various issues?
by ippirate
If you suggest that I borrowed that position from you then the answer would be no. In fact, I haven't even bothered to read that post, nor will I until you actually establish a reason why I should pay any attention to it. You are far from this as you have still failed to meet two criteria:
1. Show beyond your arbitrary and ignorant pitch of insults that you in fact have identified the root issue and that my proposition is either in error or blatantly false.
2. Actually take the time to respond to the questions that I have posed you. I have extended you the courtesy of answering your questions and quite frankly, I already have three plus one children at the house full of questions enough, I haven't taken you to raise nor nurse and you can either extend me the same courtesy or take a hike. As I have come to hold your theories and your politics in such high regard, one is just as good as the other. I'm giddy with excitement either way.
Oh, and while you?re at it, could you please grammar and spell check this post? I really wouldn?t want to present a less than pristine image. It is unfathomable the effect that such might have upon my credentials or standing professionally or academically.
My warmest regards.
.
Regardless of what I say or how I say it, it's obvious that you have a bug up your butt towards me, and you will continue your condescending, silly, and childish attacks, and continue to dance around anything I say and/or ask.
Well, knock yourself out. It's your problem not mine.
.
In a previous message, you indicated that you would not comment on these exchanges between ippirate and me because he asked you not to. You said that you would honor that request. My opinion on that, however, is that it's tantamount to taking the chicken-s%$^ way out, and that you fear offending "somebody", so you say nothing at all. But without comment from you on the issue, that's pure speculation, of course.
But what if I, myself, asked you to do just that -- comment on these exchanges between ippirate and me? You would then have to choose which request you would honor. That would pose an interesting dilemma, wouldn't it?
Well, I won't ask.
I'm content to let ippirate's tone and attitude speak for itself. But your silence also speaks volumes, as far as I'm concerned (see above).
by absolutely
They hate each other.
But I'd like to get back to discussing the income tax and whether the Constitution permits the federal government to pay people to be poor.
I speculate that pity is the primary reason that all income earners do not insist that the IRS be eliminated, or reduced to implementing a flat tax. So, I will examine the argument based on pity, as presented by "CuteElf".
[b]"Quality of life is important to people's overall health and wellbeing.
That stated, it costs money no matter what to live. Whether you are a working citizen or a person who's unemployed, it costs money to have a roof, food, clothing and transportation (either shoes bus or car..take your pic.)
Now, what about people like me who are disabled? I qualify under ADA and EEOC as a person with a disability. I have it under control, and am lucky. (epilpepsy.)
What about the people who have this certain illness,uncontrolled, who are unable to work, feed, clothe, and walk outside safely?"[/b]
People with serious physical disabilities will not be able to work in construction. A benefit of the specialization that has accompanied industrial development is that people whose bodies are less functional can still pick a specialty that does not require the use of the parts of their bodies that function inadequately.
[b]"What about the people with a temporary disability, such as double broken legs, or even a nervous breakdown?
Those can be repaired, but at the same time, those people would not be able to bring in /work for the same $ and same tasks previous to the injuries. So should their quality of life decrease as punishment? Should mr. nolegs not eat for 6 weeks and take twice as long to heal due to nutrition issues? Should mr. breakdown not go to a counselor and have treatment /therapy to get over his problems?"[/b]
Does Mr. Nolegs have no friends? Has Mr. Breakdown already alienated his entire circle of acquaintances? If so, if everybody who knows them refuses to help them, by what right do they claim help from anonymous taxpayers who have no reason to care about them?
The rest of CuteElf's post descends into disu|sed vulgarity and personal assault on Max, but in the next three days, I will also address the minor points hidden therein. And in case she decides to respond, Elf: please relate your position to the Constitution, and describe why you think the two are consistent, or why the Constitution is irrelevant in your particular case and your suffering entitles you to ignore the general public's inalienable rights. Or paraphrase, but please don't ignore the request in the originating post to address maxwell edison's premise, and explain why it is either incorrect or applied incorrectly to this topic. If suffering is a trump card in your value system, explain why that is so.
.
I don't hate ippirate; but I think it's obvious he hates me. (If not hate, then something else such as despises, dislikes, loathes, has malice towards, etc.)
I will admit, however, he does have me scratching my head wondering what this is all about.
When I see a possible area of agreement (like the NST), and I attempt to bring it to the surface, he continues with his .......... whatever it is. And I don't really have the words to describe what it is he's doing. And when I see an apparent disagreement and try to debate the issue, he just .......... whatever it is he does. And again, I don't really have the words to describe what it is he's doing.
Even Oz and I can step back and call a truce, so to speak, and have some rational dialogue. But in the case of ippirate, I just can't seem to see the rational coming from him; and when I try to start over, so to speak, he refuses.
I have no idea what this guy's all about. But I sure don't hate him. Heck, I don't hate anybody. That's one thing that separates me from a lot of radical Democrats.
by ippirate
Three points. Actually one and two subpoints and I bet that even after this you'll claim ignorance.
First - Loath would in fact be the correct response.
a.) You're premise is shortsighted and does not address a problem, it address a symptom
b.) You incessently bring it up, acting confused and confounded when you get the same response, moreover, becoming combative and petty when presented with any serious criticism.
By the way, would you make up your mind, up above you were hinting you wanted him in the middle of our little foray and now you are telling him to get out!
by cuteelf
I dont read the const.
I'm not here for a political debate, I have no time for it.
I am standing up for me and my friends, thats all.
by absolutely
You had time to curse Max for suggesting that nobody is [i]entitled[/i] to a free ride, but [i]now[/i] you don't have time for a political debate.
"I am standing up for me and my friends, thats all."
If you were industrious and inquisitive enough to consider this subject honestly, you'd notice that if less money were taken from productive people, there would be more money in the private sector spent on projects such as what Rotary Clubs and Doctors Without Borders do. Or maybe you like having the government diminish the efficiency of every effort to help you and your friends.
.
The way I see it, you and/or your friends have two options. (Correct me if I'm wrong.)
One: Rely on the government to meet your needs (or paraphrased however you'd like).
Two: Find (or wait for) another way to meet your needs (or paraphrased however you'd like).
It seems to me that you would actually have MORE options (by way of sub-options) if you selected option two rather than option one.
Consider this:
If you and/or you friend really do rely on outside help, then if the government is in charge, so to speak, ALL the people who would otherwise help might not, simply because "the government will take care of it". I believe that our population has become extremely apathetic to those in need because they think, and some even expect that, "the government will take care of it". I think this is a trait of many liberals -- willing to give the shirt off someone else's back, so they "feel good" about their stance.
You and/or your friend, in my opinion, could actually have MORE OPTIONS and MORE HELP if you quit relying on government, that is if it wasn't an option.
And then consider this:
Look at the reality and morality of the totality of such transfer programs. You may think that "your cause" is worthy, and maybe it is; but what if the giver (giver by force) does not? For example, I truly believe that hard-core drug addicts should not, under any circumstances whatsoever, receive any monetary aid at all -- none, zero, zip, nada, nothing. Not only from government, but not from anybody. And it's not because I lack compassion, but rather because I'm overflowing with it. I think it's MORE compassionate to practice some tough-love, in this case, and force them to make the choice between life and death, rather than actually enable their self-destructive behavior by facilitating it. And absolutely every reputable drug rehabilitation center in the nation would agree.
Now I certainly understand that behavior by choice is different than circumstances by birth or accident; but how many "causes" fall somewhere in-between? How many are on the fringe? It's all a matter of definition, and/or opinion, and/or political expediency. The number would fall into the thousands, or even tens of thousands, I would surmise. When you start relying on government to, not only define, but facilitate "the needy", you'll get an entire population defining "needy" to their benefit, and you'll get an entire population turning a blind eye to them -- because "the government will take care of the problem".
In short, I don't take my position because I hate you, but rather because I love you (so to speak). And I truly mean that. I truly do believe that you and/or your friend could be better off without government dependency than with it. And I also truly believe that God gave you and/or you friends the inner strength and courage to find that way, whatever it may be.
I don't believe that God ever gave a person a dream if He didn't also give that same person the capacity to achieve that dream. And I also don't believe that God would give a person an obstacle without also giving that person the wherewithal to overcome and/or cope with that obstacle. I don't think God is that cruel. You have to have faith. And you have to believe -- not only in yourself, but in the goodness of others.
Some people might say that they will believe it when they see it. But in reality, the opposite is true. You'll see it when you truly believe it.
.
Not only do I truly believe the citizens, as a whole, will be better off without being dependent on government, as I described in my previous message, but I believe such dependence is contrary to the intent and the spirit of the U.S. Constitution.
It's for these combined reasons that I take the stand that I do.
I would love to discuss it further if you feel so compelled.
by ippirate
That in all your rambling and circular attempts to redirect inquiry that you expose the shallow depth of your argument.
Are my comments to you condescending and derogatory? Yes, I make no bones over it. Could someone make a judgment concerning me on that alone? Oh yes, but unfortunately (and contrary to what you want to be the case) that would be more an indication of their character and ignorance than anything concerning me. In doing so they would have to assume mountains with no regard to the actual reason why. They would also have to dismiss one of the very first posts in response to your soapbox, which expressed an equally disgusted sentiment, although, perhaps not as colorfully.
Moving on.
A better question would be why do you cause me such angst? Oh, but anyone that is attempting to be the least bit objective may be able to find answer to that right here in the thread itself. Absolutely has contradicted me and I didn't flame him, so then why you? Must be more to it, no?
Perhaps they go a step further and read what I have actually posted on my position. That would be of tremendous revelation. Perhaps they might even discover that I have answered your ignorant questions whilst you have again and again ignored what I have posed to you. Instead, you have resorted to accusing me of playing games and being a liberal socialist, both of which are amusing to the point of being pathetic.
If I were viewing this from the outside in, I might arrive at the place where I would say that I am being very argumentative and perhaps even highly condescending. I would also have to say that you max, are being evasive and seem to have something to hide. My guess would be that the object you are attempting to veil is in fact the point that you haven't the ability to address the issues and questions I have raised in response and therefore, you will resort to attempting to discredit me through empty character shots rather and whining about my jabbing you. The same thing you always do with anyone that dares to contradict you.
Me thinks it is more an issue that you have met someone that doesn't care about your condescending, holier than thou, word from the mount way of presenting your propositions and responding to criticism. If you were half the sage you believe yourself to be I would be quite enamored. Pathetically you are not and your assertions and ludicrous attempts at defense make that clear.
Well, that and the fact that you are now attempting to weasel/guilt Absolutely for abstaining from our interchange. Is your argument that weak that you can't get it to stand on it's own two feet, you need the support of someone else?
Yes, I think there is a lot being said about character and individual logic. Volumes.
Of course, I'm just a liberal idiot. What do I know?
Again, with warmest regards...being roughly the same temperature as the bovine fecal matter you keep presenting as a "sound position".
by absolutely
by ippirate
I have stated my position on tax and spend, tax and distribute government. I will spare the repeat. I do not however see the core issue being the re-distribution. I see it as the lack of civic responsibility. We, as a nation, sit quietly by as fabrication and fraud are enacted as "Constitutional". Every year, our children learn less and less in the school system that they are forced to attend (whether private, public or home) or be in danger of "protection by the state". The curriculums that are being utilized are sanitized and then slanted to promote whatever view is deemed "correct". Critical thought is dying, if not already dead. Active understanding of basic principles and fundamental truths is replaced with an onslaught of theories presented sooner and at an accelerated rate.
There are two truths about propaganda and re-education. First, feed it regularly and consistently from as early as possible. Second, say long enough, loud enough and it will become true. The school system was one of this nation's greatest virtues. Unfortunately it is now our Achilles' heel. Education doesn't occur in those hallowed halls, indoctrination does.
That is your first core issue.
The second is the sloth of the voting populace. It's easier to complain than to get out and be active. No, please don't upset the status quo. We are all being systematically, methodically, meticulously and intentionally lied to. We know we are but we just want to go along with as little fuss as possible.
We can rail and scream over the tax and distribute system as we want. We can even work to change it. Doing so though, makes as much sense as attempting to wake someone up who's heart has failed. It's treating the symptom, not the cause. Until you attend the heart, you can scream wake up all you want, you might even get a glimmer of response but you will inevitably be left with the same result. A festering, putrid, maggot ridden, lump of decomposing flesh. And the absence of the grander thing that was; if you are lucky, a distant memory for the days that follow.
To direct the attention and effort toward tax and distribute is vanity, and as all vanity does, it will end with just as much dust at a much higher price.
by absolutely
I apologize for the plagiarism and probable inaccuracy of same, but I hope you'll understand why I don't sift through that entire thread for the exact quote!
I agree on the nature of the propaganda- & indoctrination-machine, and I really believe the only solution is to open education to economic competition. I've always seen public education as an un-Constitutional entitlement program anyway. Am I in the minority in that?
Oh, and I would have to make two edits to your comments to be in total agreement with them. First, strike the final sentence about vanity. Unless the entire populace has been [b]totally[/b] brainwashed, they ought to be capable of making correct choices about taxes as well as education. And if they are, they will make both choices badly. Second would be your second truth about indoctrination: "Second, say long enough, loud enough and it will become true." Which I would restate: Say long enough, loud enough, and it will be believed despite all evidence to the contrary.
.
My premise is this: In the United States of America, both by design and as guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution, one person does not have the power, the freedom, the prerogative, etc., to infringe on the rights -- i.e. the individual liberty -- of another person. And, by definition and extension, the government of the United States (a government of the people, by the people, and for the people) also does not have the license, the authority, the prerogative, etc., to infringe on the rights of an individual person. And one individual may not use the vehicle of government to exercise and propagate such infringement on another. Moreover, it is the primary role and responsibility of government to protect that right to individual liberty, not infringe upon it.
Do you agree or disagree with my stated premise?
If you disagree, will you please share with us your reasoning? And if you disagree, will you please support your assertions within the constitutional structure of the United States?
If you agree with the established premise, do you then agree with the following conclusion.
1. Taking a dollar from the person who earned it, so it can be given to a person who did not earn it, is tantamount to infringing on the individual liberties of that person who earned it; it is infringing on the rights of that person who earned it; and it should be abolished in the United States of America, as there is no intended Constitutional authority to legitimize it, nor has there been a Constitutional amendment passed that would specifically allow it.
And before you cite the "general welfare" clause, consider the words of the person who wrote them, James Madison, and the people who agreed with and/or approved of them, as they were intended within the context of defining the powers of government -- i.e. the Constitution of the United States.
"I cannot undertake to lay my finger on that article of the Constitution which granted a right to Congress of expending, on objects of benevolence, the money of their constituents."
--James Madison
"Congress has not unlimited powers to provide for the general welfare but only those specifically enumerated."
-- Thomas Jefferson
"When the people find that they can vote themselves money, that will herald the end of the republic."
-- Benjamin Franklin
"The government of the United States is a definite government, confined to specified objects. It is not like the state governments, whose powers are more general. Charity is no part of the legislative duty of the government."
--James Madison
"A free people ought not only to be armed and disciplined but they should have sufficient arms and ammunition to maintain a status of independence from any who might attempt to abuse them, which would include their own government."
-- George Washington
My conclusion:
No, I don't think it would be a realistic expectation to cut-off all transfer of wealth programs overnight. Moreover, to attempt such a thing would be political suicide for anyone attempting to advance such an agenda. However, the dialogue must change; the expectations much change -- expectations of both government and self; and we need to start turning back the clock to a time when the notion of protecting individual liberty in America trumped any and all collectivist desires.
And then let's consider property rights........or more accurately, how they have been taken away as well.
More to come.....
.
Which includes the following excerpt:
Let us now pause and look at some conclusions from all of this. Obviously Welfare Reform has been a great success, especially for African Americans. But more vexing problems emerge when we examine the reason for it's success. After all, what did Welfare Reform do? The funny thing is that it didn't specifically do anything to help poorer people! It didn't give poorer people anything of value - it took away things of value, by setting strict time limits. Sure, there was some childcare and job training money mixed in, but it was more or less just a substantial repeal of the old Welfare system. The next obvious question is - how in the world can poor people benefit when a program designed to help them is taken away? The ironic truth is that the Lyndon Johnson and the Congressional Democrats of the 60s, in the throes of liberal compassion, subsidized poverty and created what they sought to eliminate. [contrast Group 1 charts to view this]
What about the rise of single motherhood, especially in African American families? Where did all these single mothers that needed support come from? Isn't it a good thing we increased welfare spending at this time - so no single mothers would fall through the cracks? Well.... the research I have done has led me to the sad and horrifying conclusion - they came, in large measure, from nowhere. That is, they did not exist in any significant number before the very programs that were designed to help them, created them. They were molded from the most vulnerable; the youngest and poorest girls and mothers in society. As seen by Chart 14, it is a simple matter of cost/benefit economics. As the government raised the payment per family, loosened eligibilities and proliferated spending, the most destitute teenage girls became enticed to participate in a short term windfall, which would become their long term ruin, creating an underclass of dependency and poverty. Let's more closely compare six of our previous charts. Chart Group 3:
http://www.neoperspectives.com/welfare.htm
Disclaimer and Credit: That is one paper written by one guy voicing his opinion, although it certainly is very well supported.
by absolutely
I don't want to pick sides in the [b]personal[/b] aspects of your..."exchanges" with ippirate, which are none of my business. You have both been TR members longer than I have, and I am not interested in researching who started what with what kind of hostility.
If you ask my opinion on topics of economics, politics, ethics, or even information technology(!), I'll gladly state it on this public forum. If you ask me to tell you my opinion of a person, I'm more likely to publicly tell you where to shove your...well, I don't think we need to go there, do you?
I have done a bit of flaming in the past, and I have also gotten bored with it. I'd rather discuss ideas. Of course, when somebody uses another's pity as a weapon against us, I can make an exception and dust off the old flamethrower (see my response to "CuteElf").
I agree it would be cowardly to withhold my opinion of the issues that do concern me, out of fear of being flamed by either of you, but I haven't done that, and don't plan to do that.
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=178840&messageID=1823880
My question to ippirate remains: What greater issues?
.
I've never espoused the abolition of all taxes. And to suggest such a thing is utter nonsense. I am in favor of reducing the size and scope of the federal government. It's simply too big, too intrusive, and too controlling in the lives of the individual. And I am in favor of abolishing the federal tax (and state tax?) on income, including social security taxes. For the typical wage earner, this would mean a net pay that is equal to his gross pay -- no taxes withheld at all, and no filing a federal and state tax return each and every year. (A waste of ~250 billion each and every year.) And I am in favor of abolishing all corporate taxes because, as we know, corporations don't pay taxes, they simply pass on the cost to the consumer in the form of higher prices. If corporations' tax burdens were removed, prices could be reduced by about 25 percent -- and they would be reduced because of something called competition in the market place.
I would replace the current tax system with a national sales tax that is applied equally across the board, 20 to 25 percent, for example, on all new purchases, not used, whether that be in the form of goods or services. The more a person purchases (in goods and services), the more taxes he pays, but the percentage is consistent. And a rate of around 25 percent would result in the government taking in the same amount of money as it currently does. (The cuts in spending is a different issue, and could come later.)
Let me preempt your first objection. (Yes, I'm guessing as to what that might be.) I would exempt ALL persons who earn UNDER a certain amount of money, say the $27,000 range, from paying any taxes at all -- none, zero, nothing. If a person makes that amount or less, he pays no taxes whatsoever. Many such people today don't pay income taxes anyway, considering the various tax credits and such, but they do pay social security taxes, and they do pay sales taxes. I would propose that they don't even pay those. And such a person's employer pays an additional 7.5 percent on his behalf in more social security taxes, and I propose that be eliminated as well, which could, and probably would, result in a 7.5 percent raise.
How can a national sales tax on purchases exempt certain lower wage earners, you ask? Go ahead and ask, if you're wondering. I do have an answer. (I want to see if anyone is listening.)
by tonythetiger
How can a national sales tax on purchases exempt certain lower wage earners? :)
I like the idea, but I think your rate may be a tad high. I would also exclude the first "poverty level for the taxpayer's family unit" dollars from being taxed for everyone. I also would not tax medical care.
It would get rid of the effects of "under-the-table" earnings, as well as nearly eliminate the need for the IRS.
.
Disclaimer and Clarification:
This is somewhat of tangent from the original intent of the discussion, but certainly related.
Government spends WAY too much money, especially on its myriad of money transfer programs; and to add insult to injury, their tax collection system is not only an abomination, but it infringes on the privacy and individual liberty of the citizens by causing undue waste of time and money. This divergence will address the tax collection system.
I support the creation of a new tax collection system which will result in the following:
? Repeal the 16th amendment.
? Eliminate all federal income taxes for individuals and corporations.
? Eliminate all federal payroll withholding taxes.
? Abolish estate and capital gains taxes.
? Replace all federal income and payroll taxes with a simple, progressive, visible, efficiently collected national retail sales tax, which would be levied on the final sale of newly produced goods and services.
? Provide a rebate to all households each month the federal sales tax they pay on basic necessities, up to an independently determined level of spending (a.k.a., the poverty level, as determined by the Department of Health and Human Services), which removes the burden of federal taxation on the poor and makes this plan as progressive as the current tax code.
? Collect the national sales tax at the retail cash register, just as 45 states already do.
? Eliminate all filing of individual federal tax returns - NO MORE APRIL 15th DEADLINES!
? Enable workers and retirees to receive 100% of their paychecks and pension benefits.
? Set a federal sales tax rate that is revenue neutral, thereby raising the same amount of tax
revenue as now raised by federal income taxes plus payroll withholding taxes
? Continue Social Security and Medicare benefits as provided by law; only the means of tax collection changes.
? Eliminate the Internal Revenue Service (the IRS) and all audits of individual taxpayers; only audits of retailers would be needed, greatly reducing the cost of enforcing the federal tax code.
? Allow states the option of collecting the national retail sales tax, in return for a fee, along with their state and local sales taxes.
? Collect federal sales tax from every retail consumer in the country, whether citizen or
undocumented alien, which will enlarge the federal tax base.
? Dramatically reduce federal tax compliance costs paid by businesses, which are now
embedded and hidden in retail prices, placing U.S. businesses at a disadvantage in world
markets.
? Bring greater accountability and visibility to federal tax collection.
? Attract foreign equity investment to the United States, as well as encourage U.S. firms to
locate new capital projects in the United States that might otherwise go abroad.
? Not tax spending for education, defining expenditure on education as an investment, not consumption, which will make education about half as expensive for American families as it is now.
? The current U.S. income tax code is widely regarded by just about everyone as unfair, complex, wasteful, confusing, and costly. Businesses and other organizations spend more than six billion hours each year complying with the federal tax code. Estimated compliance costs conservatively top $225 billion annually ? costs that are ultimately embedded in retail prices paid by consumers.
Let's do the best first step and change the way we collect taxes. Then we can address the greatly needed spending cuts.
All of the preceding reforms are included in House Resolution 25 and Senate Bill 25. If you support such a change, voice your support here, in this thread, AND THEN call or write your U.S. Senator and U.S. House Representative and ask them -- no, tell them -- to support House Resolution 25 and Senate Bill 25, or, when the next election rolls around, you will vote for someone who will.
More to come.........
by absolutely
a flat national sales tax on purchases cannot be evaded by higher wage earners.
I would exclude nothing, for anybody. All transactions must be taxed identically, or we all violate the principle that all are equal and treat our rights as a variable based on circumstance, not an [b]inalienable[/b] attribute of humanity itself.
.
My attempt to get the original discussion back on track.
.
Disclaimer and Clarification:
This is somewhat of tangent from the original intent of the discussion, but certainly related.
Government spends WAY too much money, especially on its myriad of money transfer programs; and to add insult to injury, their tax collection system is not only an abomination, but it infringes on the privacy and individual liberty of the citizens by causing undue waste of time and money. This divergence will address the tax collection system.
I support the creation of a new tax collection system which will result in the following:
? Repeal the 16th amendment.
? Eliminate all federal income taxes for individuals and corporations.
? Eliminate all federal payroll withholding taxes.
? Abolish estate and capital gains taxes.
? Replace all federal income and payroll taxes with a simple, progressive, visible, efficiently collected national retail sales tax, which would be levied on the final sale of newly produced goods and services.
? Provide a rebate to all households each month the federal sales tax they pay on basic necessities, up to an independently determined level of spending (a.k.a., the poverty level, as determined by the Department of Health and Human Services), which removes the burden of federal taxation on the poor and makes this plan as progressive as the current tax code.
? Collect the national sales tax at the retail cash register, just as 45 states already do.
? Eliminate all filing of individual federal tax returns - NO MORE APRIL 15th DEADLINES!
? Enable workers and retirees to receive 100% of their paychecks and pension benefits.
? Set a federal sales tax rate that is revenue neutral, thereby raising the same amount of tax
revenue as now raised by federal income taxes plus payroll withholding taxes
? Continue Social Security and Medicare benefits as provided by law; only the means of tax collection changes.
? Eliminate the Internal Revenue Service (the IRS) and all audits of individual taxpayers; only audits of retailers would be needed, greatly reducing the cost of enforcing the federal tax code.
? Allow states the option of collecting the national retail sales tax, in return for a fee, along with their state and local sales taxes.
? Collect federal sales tax from every retail consumer in the country, whether citizen or
undocumented alien, which will enlarge the federal tax base.
? Dramatically reduce federal tax compliance costs paid by businesses, which are now
embedded and hidden in retail prices, placing U.S. businesses at a disadvantage in world
markets.
? Bring greater accountability and visibility to federal tax collection.
? Attract foreign equity investment to the United States, as well as encourage U.S. firms to
locate new capital projects in the United States that might otherwise go abroad.
? Not tax spending for education, defining expenditure on education as an investment, not consumption, which will make education about half as expensive for American families as it is now.
? The current U.S. income tax code is widely regarded by just about everyone as unfair, complex, wasteful, confusing, and costly. Businesses and other organizations spend more than six billion hours each year complying with the federal tax code. Estimated compliance costs conservatively top $225 billion annually ? costs that are ultimately embedded in retail prices paid by consumers.
Let's do the best first step and change the way we collect taxes. Then we can address the greatly needed spending cuts.
All of the preceding reforms are included in House Resolution 25 and Senate Bill 25. If you support such a change, voice your support here, in this thread, AND THEN call or write your U.S. Senator and U.S. House Representative and ask them -- no, tell them -- to support House Resolution 25 and Senate Bill 25, or, when the next election rolls around, you will vote for someone who will.
More to come.........
.
I agree in principle.
However, the reality in today's political climate is this. If this thing has any chance at all of passing both houses of congress, it has to provide tax relief to lower income people, and it has to have some element of being progressive.
Moreover, nothing else has been presented to congress; and nothing else will garner the necessary support to get passed. And this bill does indeed have co-sponsors from both sides of the aisle.
So the choice we have, at this point, is either this plan or to keep what we have.
One step at a time, Absolutely. One step at a time. Or consider it the camel's nose theory in reverse.
by absolutely
I'm sure you're right about the political climate. See, for reference, my agreement with ippirate's dismal assessment of the intellectual ability of the average citizen. But waiving a tax for "the poor" just invites fraud. If there is to be any exemption, it ought to be on the bare necessities, which is all that truly impoverished people ought to be buying anyway: non-alcoholic & tobacco-free groceries, rent, utilities, state & community colleges. Not gas. Where there is no public transit, there are bicycles and shoes.
When the party who is correctt compromises its right on a moral issue, the [b]only[/b] result is concession of that right to a party that is [b]wrong[/b].
This mess was made one step at a time, by small compromises over several decades. The essence of the problem is absolutely clear: the premise that CuteElf's need is a legal claim on my achievement. I'll leave the pragmatic compromises to the politicians whose job is to do that, and I will not agree that a proposal is [b]right[/b] when I know that it is not.
.
First of all, let me say that I don't really think I'll change your mind. (But you might surprise me.) You've obviously taken a very firm, principle-based stance, which I certainly understand, because I often do the same thing myself.
However, I would like to think that I'm open minded enough to listen to reasonable arguments; and I'd like to think I'm open minded enough to be swayed by those reasonable arguments. In fact, when I first bought into this FairTax plan, I was indeed swayed by reasonable arguments, even though the plan isn't 100 percent consistent with my principles, and even though it's not the exact system that I would prefer.
Moreover, I also realize that there's a difference between starting over from scratch and starting from where we are now. In fact, people probably misunderstand a lot of my messages because they fail to see, or I fail to articulate (or both), when I'm suggesting what I prefer if I were to start over from scratch, so to speak, and what I would do starting from where we are now. And I'm not suggesting that you're not open minded either. Quite frankly, I don't know you well enough to make such a statement.
Nonetheless, I believe that you're overlooking some very important considerations, and especially one very important consideration -- and that is something called control.
One thing that I often say, which is based firmly in principle, on which I'm pretty unwavering, and which is probably the one thing that my ideological opponents can't really address with a reasonable argument of their own is this. It's wrong for the government to take a dollar from the person who earned it, only so it can be given to a person who did not earn it. (And they're hard-pressed to defend against it because they have absolutely no reasonable argument of their own to present other than admitting that they espouse government forced collectivism, at least to one degree or another, and regardless of what they choose to call it.)
Well guess what? This FairTax plan would address part of my "principle based" stance -- and a BIG part of it. In fact, I would even have to modify my axiom as follows: It's wrong for the government to take a dollar from the person who spent it, only so it can be given to a person who did not earn it.
Well hold the phone there, Maxwell, people might say. After you spent that dollar, it's not yours anymore. But it's part of the price of goods that I buy, I might reply. Then if you don't like it, don't buy it, they might say. Well, okay, I might say.............but, I might say..........
Do you see the distinction? And the distinction is who controls that dollar. I don't have to spend it if I don't want to, so the control is placed back into my hands; whereas before, the control was in the hands of the government. Unless, of course, I choose to not earn any money. And when they included bartering as "taxable income" I really had no control at all. (And we don't really live in a bartering society.) It was either earn something or die.
You and I do, in fact, agree on one thing. And I know we do because we've both said it, at least in one form or another. It's taken us a long time to get ourselves into this transfer of income mess; and it will take a long time to get out of it. Define "long time" however you'd like; the point being is that no one is going to snap their fingers and make the mess disappear overnight.
This FairTax plan gives a big portion of -- if not all -- control back to the person who earned that dollar. And since it also includes the provision to make sure basic necessities are not taxed at all, I could, in theory, earn a million dollars, never buy anything "new" again, and never be taxed a dime on any of those million dollars that I earn. Sure, we could go on and on about how they might later change the rules to expand the goods and services that are taxed, but so be it. I would rather have debates over how money spent is taxed rather than over how money earned is taxed. And this plan would indeed shift the debate from earned income to spent dollars.
And looking even further down the road, if enough people get fed up over how the government is spending the money it collects, which would be the easier tactic to employ? To stop earning so the government has nothing to tax, or to stop spending so the government has nothing to tax?
This may not be perfect, and it may not be my most preferred system, but it's certainly better than what we have now. AND it's possible to get passed in Congress. AND it's a great first step back to the track where "my principle" believes we should be -- because I will have CONTROL over the money I earn.
So there ya' go. You can either see this as a viable first step, or you can decide to stay stuck right where we are until your most preferred plan is both presented and is able to get through congress. But just ask yourself this. Which would give you the most control over your own future, at least considering we're starting from where we are now, and not starting over from scratch?
by tonythetiger
I don't know how it's going to invite fraud... if you spend money, it is taxed! If anything, it would bring in additional funds due to spending of unreported (or even illegal!) income.
You can't lie to Walmart's cash register :)
by absolutely
We are all [b]compelled[/b] to pay our taxes to feed, clothe, and shelter CuteElf and her friends.
CuteElf will respond if she is so [b]inclined[/b].
I know you didn't mean to suggest that her response would depend on the threat of physical force or any other form of compulsion, but the word compel sometimes carries that connotation. In this context, I urge very precise use of the word "compel" or any derivatives.
I don't mean to suggest that people with a narrower range of productive abilities get no specialized training to utilize the abilities they do have, but her examples of Mr Nolegs and the other one in no way justify the massive array of wealth redistribution schemes that our government commits under the guise of "assistance".
.
.....thank you for the vocabulary lesson.
.
Read all about it at www.FairTax.org
by ippirate
I hope you will reconsider. Here is the point. It is a vain activity to focus on the issue of tax and distribute when it is an outward display of a deeper issue. We, in agreement, can discuss it all day and even share our sentiments with others. Two points, if those others have no idea what you are attempting to discuss with them because they have never, 1. heard it beyond social engineering 101 and 2. learned to THINK, then our total effort is lost as it falls on deaf ears. To speak to someone that has the capacity to understand is good, but you still have to shake them from apathy and get them to the polls. The polls being a major step forward but not a cure all. The cure all is civic duty. In this I mean guarding liberty actively. This means that people are active on more than one day a year at best. If not? We end right back where we started. No good to address the problem if we aren't going to treat the cause.
I will also point out that you introduce an important point, one should be able to make correct choices absent complete brainwashing. Tell me, and in sincere frames here, actively listened to 1. How people respond to questions during interviews, both Joe on the street and the politicians? 2. Engaged a stranger on the subject of the Constitution and liberty? It is staggering, the responses you will hear and the blinding degree of ignorance and applied mis-information you find trotted about. Are they brainwashed? Perhaps not, but the foundation they are building on definately isn't helping the plumbing.
by absolutely
I concur, and want to add to your closing paragraph, flippancy, nervousness & glibness characterize the willful evasion of fact you note in interviews, and I have noticed it often.
Brainwashing is the wrong term because the brains are sullied, not cleaned, with eagerness to accept whatever framework validates their trained complacency. I repeat, CuteElf: disgusting!
by m_a_r_k
by cuteelf
Is really how we're filling in the gaps.
ATM I'm employed, covered etc no problems.
My friend depends on government at the moment to get her through this spot in her life. She is going to DVR to finish her GED and start a secondary education, with a career goal in mind.
I've thought about all of this and I wonder:
Lets say there ISNT any welfare or government controlled handouts for food/shelter/clothing.
Lets say the ONLY thing the govt does is take taxes and use $ to build roads sewers etc.
Lets say the ONLY handouts for food/shelter/clothing are done by private organizations.
If so, how would the priv orgs get the $ to give out? As you say, by citizens donating directly towards priv orgs in the benefit of people.
So, would be, Me --money to shelter--shelter hands out food--person fed.
Or you --money to group--clothes for people--happy.
Thats fine. But with our culture/socieity saying Every Person For Themself, the only times people will donate are when they themselves are fed/clothed/sheltered to their expectations. AND many times people will FORGET about other people, literally wearing blinds. Only when it serves a personally important purpose will someone assist others. THIS may not have been the attitude back when the Constitution was written, but at this time and place here in America, its ME ME ME and I'll Help You If You Help Me.
Selfless gifts are few and far between.
Anohter thought is that if there is no govt controlling, and only thru donations, it would be sporadic and irregular, and the influx of assets would not fit the needs. Spotty is a word that comes to mind.
I understand your "When you start relying on government to, not only define, but facilitate "the needy", you'll get an entire population defining "needy" to their benefit, and you'll get an entire population turning a blind eye to them -- because "the government will take care of the problem"." quote, because I do see some of that happening.
At the same time I still stand strong on the concept that people who are fully unable to work and provide for themselves should have help, to live a decent quality of life. (no rat holes, no crappy clothes, no spoiled food).
I see programs all around run by NON Govts to help those disabled/needy people find work or something to do. As I've said before, many truly truly WANT to work and would love to do something else with their time.
But the help from non gov is sporadic, unreliable and would cater to reallly realllly realllllllly specific issues- and would be able to discriminate.
Like a food bank for only people with Green Eyes who go to church every 3 days.
Or a doctors clinic for only Certain Ethnic who are Certain Religion.
I am not advocating that needy people STAY on govt help. I am not for people WANTING to mooch while still able to do something with themselves.
I am advocating for people that need the help to have the help - steadily.
cute
by absolutely
Except for govt employees? Is there a surgical procedure that exempts them from the flaws of humanity? Having been to numberous DMV offices and post offices, I claim just the opposite: give a petty person a bit of power, not even absolute power, and in many cases the result is absolute corruption.
"I am advocating for people that need the help to have the help - steadily."
In effect, though not by intention, I am too. There are moochers, and they aren't going away. In order to finance them, honest people in time of need, however long that may be, have access to a smaller share of the whole, and are less able to seek help from private concerns, including their own acquaintances, because we're all getting taxed to subsidize drug addicts who don't even want to quit and never wanted to earn their own living.
by absolutely
"I would also exclude the first "poverty level for the taxpayer's family unit" dollars from being taxed for everyone."
That depends how that exclusion is implemented. I have been assuming that it is connected to a person's identity, so that [b]anything[/b] they buy is untaxable. It would be simpler to exclude the things that the poor have to buy to survive, taxing only non-essential items that only people who aren't poor can afford.
If I can get a tax exemption by being poor and I think I can beat the system, then instead of reporting $100,000 annual income as a consultant, I might use 10 aliases to report income from various consulting jobs. Each alias claims $10,000/year, and receives the equivalent of the Earned Income Tax Credit. The IRS, in turn, would spend lots of money to make that sort of fraud more difficult, and hopefully more costly than just paying taxes honestly.
Or we could implement a simpler plan that relies only on retailers' honesty & interest in not being prosecuted: charge no taxes on items necessary for daily life. Groceries obviously, household cleaners possibly, air conditioners for old people in Arizona maybe, and now you see where I'm going. Instead of making some income untaxable, make transactions of poor people untaxable. It's still a tax exemption for the poor, but it's less of a drain on the system. The only necessity to prove anything would be in cases like the old ladies in Arizona who would probably die by early June without A/C, and other needs that are luxuries to most people. They would have to prove their age and place of residence, but not get a doctor's note for such an obvious need, in Absolutely-Land.
Sort by Trending