Discussion Locked

Iraq is out of control

0 helpful
525 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

525 replies

by thelastword

I don't think it would be a religous war at all. I think with the US in this weakened position, you could easily get countries taking advantage of that situation. OR in the event that countries participate in Iraq, that could put them at risk from Iran or something and you could get a nest going on, someone could carry resentment as to how the whole thing got started or some other conflict could arise putting someone else at odds with someone. ie. China or Russia could get involved or something. It would be gross but if they are trying to rally international support that might not necessarily improve the situation so much as everyone thinks, or it could get worse before it gets better. The situation is gross and the world community wants no part of it. Maybe it should stay that way.

by hal 9000

A few days ago GWB addressed the UN and asked for more countries to become involved in rebuilding Iraq. On the AU news his case was described as a "Frosty Reception" from most of the members of the UN.

The fact that countries are not willing to get involved is a sign that things are not alright in that area and these countries don't want to get involved in the mess that has been created.

Col

by voldar

Anyone saw Goya's painting???

I don?t think that a prophecy must be fulfilled...anyway, the socio-economical-political environment is far changed from that period. Is true that humanity didn?t change...and every period has its up and down, but studding a bit history we'll find out that the worst atrocities are made in the name of a religion! I was stunned when someone wrote something like...21st without Muslim religion!...boy you have guts!...If the war against terrorism is absolutely understandable, a religious war...will be the end of the world, or as Einstein said: 'I don?t know how will be the 3rd world war, but the 4th war will be with rocks' (back in stone age bro!)

Maybe this is the single prophecy I am accepting!
The rest are just coincidences and can be avoid with a more responsible understanding of our era!

by aldanatech

Deterioration in Iraq continues to spread:

* Attacks are increasing on an average of almost 80 times per day by insurgent strikes. Three dozen cities and towns are now in hostile hands, reports USA Today.

* In Baquba, 11 policemen were killed when gunmen opened fire on their police van.

* In Baghdad, 47 killed, 114 injured outside a police station by car bomb.

* Civilian abductions: two Americans and a Briton, boldly kidnapped from a guarded upscale neighborhood, bringing the total number of foreigners kidnapped to well over 100 since Saddam's fall, and chilling contract westerners in Iraq.

* The Green Zone, the sealed enclave housing the U.S. embassy, suffered a five-hour rocket barrage.

And the ghastly sight now inflaming the Arab world with television replays is that of an Arab TV correspondent, Al Arabiya?s Mazin al-Tumaisi, shot to death in Baghdad on air by a U.S. helicopter coming to the aid of a disabled Bradley fighting vehicle on Haifa Street, one of the city's busiest.

Can we consider that the American presence is the cause of the insurgency, either directly or indirectly?

Source: PBS

by litefite7

The US has the people on the ground they need to deal with terrorists in Iraq, however as time goes on and many different middle eastern countries keep sending into Iraq their terrorists and great sums of money. The international response should be the same as the middle eastern countries who do not want Iraq to stand on its two feet.If the European Union dosent get off its ass, they can fight this one at home, Up and personnel. Stand back and watch the Americans with little, or no support deal with the issues in Iraq. Mark my words as I take a two week break back in the good Oh'll USA before heading back into combat for my third tour, you are going to recret not stepping up, your children will regred it everytime they get scanned by a metal detector entering the local grocery store two blocks from your house, next to the play ground that hasn't been checked for land minds. It will become very apparient that you should have done something. By the way this shout out is only for those countries not stepping up, and the posts that talk about a peacefull solution, you do not know what your talking about.

Platoon Sergeant

by oz_media

This goes without saying.

To the best of knowledge:

French troops are supporting the US efforts in Haiti as well as Canadian troops, the French and Chinese governments hae decided to get together and work on the terrorist threats building in Asia, and Eastern Europe. There seems to be MANY countries participating on what was once considered a global war on terrorism that must be fought in MANY different places and not JUST Iraq.

I understand YOU views as a soldier who as returned from Iraq and only seeing US soldiers and a few scattered support civilians from other countries out to rebuild the infrastructure.

I also understand that this war is fuelling terrorism by encouraging more resent from terrorists towards Americans, that's not YOUR issue of concern though, you have a job to do. al-Qaeda's ranks are said to be swelling at unfathomable proportions ALL oer the world, including our allies in Pakistan who admittedly will not expect Muslim police to arrest Muslims, no matter what thier terrorist intents.

I know you have a hard war to fight, from what I understand and what you have implied, it's not all going as well as many seem to want to believe.

I think the point people are trying to make here about a peaceful resolution is that these wars on terrorism hae never been shown to end issues in the past, yet peaceful resolutions have proven efective. It's not the flower power age of the Nam days, it is just a realization that this just may not the solution needed.

Respectfully, as a Sergeant in the US forces I know that you won't agree at all, and that is understandable.

I just think you are being a little personally effected and that is what has brought out such feelings against people who are not at your side in Iraq.

I am confident that MANY nations are working in many different ways to protect thier own countries and thrwart the growth of terrorism, however it's growth does not seem to be even slowed at this point and is said to continue growing in ways we cannot even fathom.

England is preparing for an certain attack, al-Qaeda has made it very clear the next target is London's Tube and other monuments tha have stood through two world wars (including the London Blitz)already. This is of great concern to the British and they are working on every angle to reduce the damage that could be done, gain intelligence on the issus and prepare for the worst while still working to stop it all together.

I don't think anyone has turned thier backs on terrorism, it's just that they all play a different role and have different positions in the fight to counter it.

May your god be with you and your fellowmen in Iraq.

by hal 9000

When in Iraq are you on full combat pay since the US President has stated that "HOSTILITIES HAVE FINISHED" I was under the impression that your combat pay rates had been reduced as you where no longer fighting a WAR?

Col

by hal 9000

But when I see no way of directly contacting you and only one entry in any TR discussion with an unwillingness to answer a simple question.

I begin to wonder just how sincere you actually are or if you are nothing more than a political plant placed here to serve some ones beliefs and gain sympathy.

So I'll ask it again Since you claim to be a Sergeant who has recently returned from Iraq and will be returning soon.

ARE YOU STILL ON FULL COMBAT PAY?

Col

by voldar

Hummm..I have one, but is just theory...cause is for the first time in history when things like these r happening...
In modern history I mean!

1.How u fight against terrorism?
2.How u can handle the war in Iraq?

How u can fight with good results against warriors who think that killing an enemy will open the door to heaven?...just by not giving him the reason to come after U! but if u r in...u must be smarter than him...Don?t go for 'eye for eye'...you'll loose, you cant win with a desperate fearless religious enemy. Use your diplomacy in your favor, make allies in the high rank peoples from the countries that can/are favorable/or are presumptively open to support you. After u gained your allies ...u can go for 'hunting'...cause u will be in friendly forests...otherwise...u r lost! TALKING and HOW u r talking IS VERY IMPORTANT when u r negotiating with nations who have same religion with your enemies! It?s a very important ADD this line because, with my humble knowledge in world religions, The Muslim is the single one who can gather people with same religion but located in different countries! Without disrespect for my religion, a Christian is not going to war for his Christians fellows from another country just because they have same religion! but Muslims are!

The problem in Iraq is like Pandora box, because, even if from point of view strategically Iraq has the best position in the middle east...from point of view population...u have a nightmare in terms of resentments between the 3 major groups of habitants. Is a rhetoric question...with what u replace a dictator? When the country?as it is appearing now non-gouvernable? or may I ask: at the end ..will be Iraq as state or...will be disintegrated in 3 parts? I have no clue but a new Laurence of Arabia is not born yet!

This is what I think...to answer to your question...just theory!...If u want a straight answer...I just have one rhetorical: how nice would it be if we would leave the people to handle by themselves their dictators...and go after terrorists!

The capture of bin laden would be 1000s times stronger as impact in the terrorism world than 10 Iraq wars!

by olprof67

When a less-advanced culture, encumbered by mysticism and superstition, and making less-efficient use of land and resources, is displaced by a more efficient and progressive one, the results can be particularly cruel.

If the over-sensitized are offended by this comment, I can't offer an apology. Those who cite the displacement and subjugation of the native peoples on both of the American continents should view those events in the shadow of the cruelties in Medieval Europe from which the settlers fled.

One way or another, Islamic barbarism will likely destroy itself. The only question is how many innocent people will be caught in the crossfire. The most enlightened of the Arabic peoples are those who leave for a better life in a freer society. A handful died by the actions of their own self-proclaimed "brothers" on 9-11.

by oz_media

For a guy who's first language isn't English, you are very good at getting your point across.

Based on your thoughts, one would say that Iraq was simply a diversion to create SOME effort to retain integrity, or attempt to.
Aghanistan had gone quite well as far as wars can go. They conceded with little resistance and there was much fanfare. I think this was construed as some sort of welcome to western democracy when in actuality, it noew seems it was just happiness for slamming the Taliban with some global might. The locals who were under repression from Taliban would cheer and hail the Allies heros.

Unfortunately, they haven't accepted the ideals of western democracy as hoped, perhaps it was all a ruse by locals just like when you are being bullied by a larger group and friends show up to turn the tides and even the score. You'd be thankful no matter WHO came to your aid, it doesn't mean you want to hang out and play games together though.

So given THAT, the fact that Bin Laden had disappeared into hiding and probably protection of SOMEONE's government, even someone considered an ally. -Just as Pakistan is now allowing al_Qaeda to promote and recruit, with even the chief of police saying he can't expect Muslims (police force) to arrest Muslims (al-Qaeda) for standing up for thier faith.

-Quick easy (easier than expected) war little resistance.

-The world's most wanted man can't be found and your friend may be helping him hide.

Is it not easy to just turn on Iraq and go prove your point somewhere else? They CAPTURED Saddam, well done!! And then everything started to look 'not so great afterall'.

So perhaps (as agreed by Bush) this war was underestimated on many aspects, but in a MUCH bigger way than admitted or expected. Perhaps this was 'intended' to be a rather quick display of power and resolve.

Perhaps someone has made this big mistake as an effort to at least rid the world of ONE terrorist and hopefully find something else, al_Qaeda operatives, WMD or anything else that would justify Bush's reelection, as he would be considered a hero for ridding TWO countries of terrorist cells.

by cmate

Unfortunately the US now has a major problem with most of the rest of the world and sadly has had its reputation tarnished because of Bush. Bush obviously was totally blind to the situations preceeding Iraq e.g. Ireland, Bosnia, Isreal-Palestine, India-Pakistan and so on. All of these conflicts were based on religious differences or the want of one side trying to impose its idea of "civilisation" on the other. It is particularly ironic in Iraq because of its abundant history of biblical significance. The last thing anyone wants to hear is Bush espousing that his illegal invasion (yes invasion ... not war ... the US has never declared war on Iraq) is being done in the name of God. Since when did Bush's god differ from the God most Christians pray to ... to Bush his god seems to be superior.
Everyone on earth has there own idea of God regardless of what name they call God by.
Bush has not made himself popular in Australia, dragging the Aussies into this fray and the encumbent government is about to get a stinging lesson at our soon to be elections. Unfortunately, for no good reason, Bush has successfully created rifts not only amongst the American people but also in most other nations.
The Iraqis, like most Arab nations are besically tribal people and have been fighting each other since time imemorial ... Bush's invasion has done nothing to bring these people together as we can all see from recent events and sadly the innocent on both sides pay the ultimate sacrifice. My idea although radical, is that it would be best to pull out and let the locals sort themselves out ... they are not complete idiots. And why is the US Govt so hated, because they persist in imposing their will on others under the guise of helping them. I'll be glad to see the day when the Aussies pull out of Iraq. The Iraqis need help to rebuild their homeland not bullets and bombs blowing their places away. As Dave Allen the Irish comedian always said ... may your God go with you. And so be it ... don't impose him/her on others.

by dimitri

The Crusades were a military reply to the slaughter of millions of people at the hands of the Muslims. Just ask the Greeks and Armenians how many people were slaughtered. The Muslims hate everyone who is not Muslim. Have you heard one peep from the millions of United States citizens that are Muslims? NO. That's because deep down they like what's happening and hope one day we will also be a theocratic state ruled by the Imas in the local mosks. God help us all.

by maxwell edison

.
Do you "choose" to believe some partisan zealots, such as aldndntech and others? Or John Kerry, who's contradicted himself over and over? Or someone who's been there, day after day, seen and heard for himself, and who has a real stake in the issue?

Things are indeed getting better in Iraq, regardless of what the partisan zealots may contend. (Why do they lie so much when lives and futures are on the line?) And where there are still difficulties to deal with, we cannot let them cause us to lose focus on the ultimate goal.

Yes, I believe John Kerry is doing a grave disservice to our nation, to the soldiers in Iraq, and to the Iraqi people who deserve to know the taste of freedom and liberty. John Kerry is putting his own self-serving political ambitions ahead of doing the right thing, something that's contrary to the spirit and ideals of his very own hero, the late President John Kennedy, who spoke of such things in his book, Profiles In Courage.

The real story from the one who really knows, Iraqi prime minister, Ayad Allawi, is summed up when he said, "It's very important for the people of the world really to know that we are winning, we are making progress in Iraq," he said in New York. "Unfortunately, the media have not been covering these significant gains."

Prime minister Allawi is in the United States right now, and he will be speaking before the U.S. Congress. If you want to hear the real story from the real source from the nation who has the most on the line, I suggest you hear or read what the prime minister, himself, has to say. Please enlighten yourselves by hearing that speech for yourselves, or reading the full text of that speech after it's delivered.

Then ask yourselves, who do you believe? The zealot aldndntech? The self-serving candidate John Kerry? Or Iraqi prime minister, Ayad Allawi?

by thelastword

at least someone will listen to Kerry. That might be a good thing. I guess. The reality of it is, BUsh is a liar and not a leader. Kerry blathering on about Bush is a political thing, not a disservice to troops. The disservice to troops is LYING That there is a war.

by oz_media

I am not sre what your final commet meant really but I would say that if anything, Bush mislead people (general citizens, not insiders such as Maxwell)by inferring that the main conflict was over.

That's why the Iraqi police and newly recruited troops are being killed every day. Ever since Saddam was caught, the war was over. It has been just planting flowers and helping them water thier lawns every since.

All happy families, it's MUCH better now than it was before.
Just like Afghanistan and how they seized democracy with open arms and all the women are now free to attend schools and work in the hospitals, they kip down the strets humming the US national anthem as the people wave and smile at them. Taliban are a thing of the past, al-Qaeda's main operatives were captured ad now the few remaining little 'motley crew' cells will be dead in no time.

And then they woke up.

by aldanatech

Almost everyone was all ears back when Bush insisted that Iraq had weapons of mass destruction, but now he has virtually no credibility at all.

by onbliss

...and felt it was written by US administration's speech writers. I swear really that's what I felt :-) It look like 2004 campaign speech.

I agree, I am not comfortable with Kerry. He seems so...words fail me.

As far was contradictions goes: Don't you think contradicting is part of human nature. Unless we are hypocrites, we all contradict ourselves. We merely put it nicely - 'case-by-case basis' that is what we call it.

Say, Kerry took a stance A, realizes that it was not the best, takes the stance B; then realizes that C was better or a modified form of A was better, should we hold it against him?

by maxwell edison

.
I didn't hear the speech, but I'll read it later today.

On your "contradicting" point, I'll say this. I agree, it's perfectly understandable to change your mind over an issue, especially when it's based on experience. But that's different than changing positions to simply accommodate a different audience.

by hal 9000

If we where to involve ourselves in every matter which we consider as inhumane we would constantly have troops stationed in many countries around the world and would be running very short of manpower and machinery.

If we where prepared to intervene in every case we would very quickly run out of available troops and equipment.

Col

by hal 9000

We hear the exact opposite. There are multi denominational religious groups including Muslims who are constantly praying for an end of war. Maybe it isn't the Muslim population that isn't speaking out against this but the lack of the media to cover it!

And if you really want to get technical the first recorded terrorist in what we now know as "Christan Times" was Mosses who was according to the bible directly responsible for death and destruction in Egypt. Or maybe that was "Jewish Times" but never the less it is covered in the Old Testament of the Christian Bible and is thought of as a good thing!

On a very well reported series on Terrorists it ended with the saying "Remember one mans terrorist is another mans freedom fighter!"

Maybe we have to change our outlook to see the real picture and work out a real solution.

Col

by thelastword

The natives made more efficient use of land and resources. NOT LESS. How about your thinking on CHINAm who is making more efficient use of land and resources, taking over the less advanced and less effective north american culture, payback for what we did to the indians, how would that fly. It isnt the middle eastern nations to worry about, its the conflict that could show weakness in the US and allow china to gain control economically of the US.

by olprof67

Then apparently, your idea of efficiency is to keep the growth of the population down through a high infant mortality rate, as is always the case in primitive societies.

When a culture begins to industialize, the "social cost" changes, often to the form of industrial accidents. Note that this nation hasn't had a major (>50 fatalities) industrial accident since the late 1960's (Mannington, WV).

(And by the way, how often do you encounter an industrially-related amputee in this nation? In the industializing nations, they're a lot more common.)

And finally, when we advance to post-industialization. the human toll, while still there, becomes harder to spot, It's now ususally stress-related, or due to the inablity to find someone else to do the really dirty, dangerous, or unwanted jobs.

If any of the touchy-feelies want to go back to nature, I'll be happy to help 'em. I just want them to try it in the dead of winter.

by onbliss

..measure everything with efficiency as a core metric. We are humans, a species with evolved thinking that brings due share of worries :-))
Emotions do need to be given higher spot in the metrics. And, I understand by giving that leads to other problems :-)

by thelastword

There is a lot to be said for native american culture and alot more that will be said, obviously you are in the US. China is far more efficient in its use of resources than North America. What exactly is efficient here?

by oz_media

I thought it would me more of an issue with them feeling extremely embarassed by how RADICALS are acting. They have sought a new home in America and may have become upstanding contributors to society. Knowig that everyone is looking down thier nose at them now, I think it is safer to say that they simply feel disgusted at what thier people have done to America, and to thier friends or families that may be directly or indirectly effected. Most of these people have CHOSEN freedom and liberty over what they used to have, it must truly be gutting them to see the atrocities a twisted group of radicals have done while waving thier religion in the faces of America.

To suggest they are laughing inside just reiterates my point regarding WHY they wouldn't speak out. One poster on TR has even gone as far as saying he doesn't trust ANY Muslims or people that MAY be Muslims as he doesn't know who is a terrorist and who isn't.

Well what about the WHITE Muslims, what about the hoards of Bosnians who are lining up to join al-Qaeda in Bosnia, which is mainly Muslim controlled as it is Muslim money that has rebuilt the landscape, added gardens and parks surrounding the 1200 new mosques built since the Bosnian war.

The whole point if this is KNOWNING the ENEMY, which nobody including the US administration has proven they understand. New obstacles have been popping up to thwart progress each day, mainly a result of poor understanding of what the enemy is all about.

by jandrewgadd

Those of us that have a paying job come here for "Technical Reference" not community chatter. Even worse the information provided in the message is INadequate. We lost "1000 a week" in Vietnam and 53,000 dead. I was there... Lets get back to TECHNICAL INFORMATION in this forum

by oz_media

This is a general discussion forum.

Recently the staff at TR mentioned that it can be used for ANY subject at all, ANYTHING our little hearts desire, as it always has been.

To resolve your issue of possibly wasting time wading through this stuff, go to the MAIN discussions page and select the topics you wish to participate in. New and Hot discussions will include ALL topics. That's why the filter is placed on the Discussions hompage.

Hope this helps,
OM

by hal 9000

Isn't!

Secondly this is "Water Cooler Talk" so if you want hard technical support limit yourself to those topics that do not involve any thing remotely related to off technical topic discussions. We've already had one technical discussion pulled for no good reason other than some fools crying because some of us where discussing the then current SPAM problems that we had been facing.

Perhaps if you complain that you don't like the way that someone is talking about Microsoft and their new SP2 you can complain to TR and have that discussion pulled as well. While it would be a pity as some of us are getting some good information from that discussion it would at least be more understandable that any complaints here!

So do as OZ said and use the filter so you only see what you're interested in.

Col

by onbliss

Thanks for your explanation. I agree I have sounded vague.

Ok, here is my take: If the global powers mess up the situation in the Middle East, during the cleaning of their earlier mess let them not glorify the cleaning operation. That is all that I am asking.

One more analogy :-) Say I go to my neighbour's house, and play a small part in increasing the animosity between the already quarelling husband and wife; later if I attempt to bring peace between them I would'nt want to glorify my peace efforts. Because, all I am doing is penance for my earlier actions.

I am all for brining middle east to the mainstream world.

So, when I spill the milk on the kitchen floor, I just wipe the milk and don't claim how by cleaning the floor I have prevented my siblings or parents from falling down :-))

Why do you think Iran or SA were'nt more viable? Iran's students look like they just need some catalyst / backing. Iran has a history of reformist movements and failures. And USA could have easily arm-twisted SA. Iraq was one of the most secular regions in that part of the world. Why could'nt US back the Kurds to create a separate country? There was the no-fly zone, there right?

If there was the will, US could have achieved anything. US is the mightiest country.

Hey what about our dear rougey rougue Pakistan?

by onbliss

...in the previous WWs, most of the regions were either colonies or had colonies close by. The people did get affected if the colonial rulers went to war.

Now the world has shrunk...and technology has helped people to reinforce all kinds of meme.

by onbliss

...show me the muslim moderates please :-)

Are you saying people believed that moderate muslims were equally bad?

I think he was right, if Islam does not want to set it's foot in the 21st century...it's gonna be a headache for the rest of us. Sad but true.

by onbliss

But that's different than changing positions to simply accommodate a different audience.

Very true. Unfortunately that's what many of us do.

Kerry might be the noblest soul on the planet, but somehow to me he appears as a person who just wants to become the President. Call it opportunistic or ambitious.

Max, you should listen to the speech. There is an element of truth in what he says... But I am sure you will come to the same conclusion as of mine. Man, I was almost rolling with laughter at the same time annoyed. I just did not change the radio dial for I wanted to hear him for some more time.

by oz_media

You must admit that ANYONE running for president does it just so they can be president. I am positive that was GWB's motivation. I don't think he dug into politics and worked hard to be elected president just so he could help people.

So perhaps Kerry has the exact same motivation is Bush, just like anyone else aspires to be the boss in 'real' life. He's a politician, this is without doubt the greatest accomplishment, the gold medal shall we say, of politics.

What I feel is that all these politicians are not actually the most qualified and able leaders of the country at all, just the most proficient at convincing the country they are the best, a top sales rep for thier party perhaps.

At one time, leaders were elected because they had proven to all the people that they were capable.

Then they invented fire and it all went downhill from there. :p

by onbliss

..but somehow I don't feel uncomfortable when I see Mcain or Dean. There seems to be some reality. They look human. God, something must be wrong with me...I am fascinated by straight-talking, eccentric, maverick, whatever people :-)

Another way of looking at it is that maybe Bush's campaign worked on me :-)

Oz, did you read or hear Iraqi PM's speech? Is it OK for a foreigner to campaign in US Presidential elections :-)

Hmmmmmm seriously, US playing such a major role (positive and negative) in the global affairs, and being the lone super power, rich, mighty; it should surprise no one if the different countries of the world play active/passive role in electing US Presidents. I am not a conspiracy theorist. But does'nt that seem logical?

by oz_media

I response to the threats to Mr. Bigley, who was captured along with the two American hostages who wre beheaded, the US government as NOT agreed to release the two female prisoners said to be held in an Iraqi prison.

After hearing that the USA was not willing to negotiate release of prisoners, he has pleaded to Tony Blair, whom he feels is the last person he is able to plead with to spare his life.

Muslim and Christian Leaders hae plead with Iraqi's to spare Bigley's life;
[i]"We're appealing to them on the grounds of their own faith and their own faith in the God of mercy to be merciful, to have compassion in this situation and to release Mr. Bigley," Jones said." [/i]

Now what I see hapening is GWB FINALLY beginning to realize he can't play into THIER game on THEIR terms. They use these horrors to get what they want, as I mentioned before, I think that failing to comply or show the typical compassion for human life will in turn remove a bargaining chip from terrorist hands.

This is a surprising and valiant move on behalf of GWB, even though it is NOT an American citizen we are talking about. ( I wonder if the response would be the same if it was a US sodlier?)

I don't think ANY life should be wasted or not fully apreciated, yet we MUST be prepared to sacrifice lives if the war is to be at all effective. We cannot accept thier terms and thier 'game'. This is like having them capture weapons and not having ammo for them, it starves them of thier abililty to use them as a way to succeed.

Now uderstandably, the family - Mr. Bigley's brother in fact, has begged Bush to follow the lead. Well that is only understandable, but Mr. Bigley is said to b wanting to HELP Iraqi's and simply got caught up in this issue. With all due respect to him and his family, when you eneter a war with no morals or rules to be found, you must be ready to accept the consequences, even if death.

It sounds absolutley HORRIBLE to say this and it is so hard to put delicately, yet this just needs to be accepted as they way the enemy operates.

It's a SMALL stand, but a huge one too.

All bias aside, GWB you made the right call for once!

by thelastword

You can look at it that but the reality is, the war is being fought WRONGLY therefore these terrorists have gained control through these measures. Whether Bush agrees or not, its obvious that is makes no difference to the terrorists and they will kill anyway. WHy. for the media exposure which gives them control. They want it to appear like they are in control and this is how they do it. If George Bush released the chemical ladies it wouldn't make it appear that the US is NOT in control. IT would make them appear HUMANE instead of on the same LEVEL as the terrorists. By allowing this to go on with no acknowledgement is emphasizing that Bush is on the same level actually. Using the same tactics, allowing their tactics to be used. I applaud the phillipines for getting the guy out. I think these attrocities expose that the war is out of control and that the US Is not currently successful in their strategy. They should go to ANY LENGTHS to save these lives, ANY lengths. That exposes the terrorists far more. I am surprised you would take this stance Oz as a proponent of peace. Anyway, the terrorists ARE being successful in showing the war is in their control by being allowed to kill these people. If Bush was able to root them out like moles then they wouldnt be able to kill people. How to win? Well, first of all, they have to have more compassion and understanding of that culture and second of all they should insitute and ID SYSTEM Over there that everyone should comply to and they should basically start managing the people in some way in order to figure out who is who and protect the good ones from the bad ones. They have to manage it from a people perspecitve. Blowing the S**T out of everything is not helping at all. There needs to be management and security in some organized way or something!

by thelastword

By not acknowledgin..BUSH'S favorite tactic... ONCE AGAIN, he is letting the worst of the worst go. This is precisely what HE Should be acknowledging and using this to gain sympathy for the US and its cause. By not so much as acknowledging his own people over there, he is basically saying to everyone, we did it, we are repsonsible for it and I will let the people die in whatever way as a result of it. He should be lookign at drastic measures at this point and I hope they will be. I mean, security, intelligence, certainly this is an area that someone can get creative in and start to deploy over there. They are managing the entire population of whatever million people and will have to start somewhere. obviously the people themselves cant do it with the roads and buildings blown out.

by onbliss

...the terrorists/insurgents, totally. From their view point, are'nt they actually fighting for their land by opposing occupying forces.

Every sane person in the world knows what they are doing is playing terror tactics. What is there to be exposed? Being compassionate is not going to soften them and nor going to save any lives.

But I do agree when you say, their culture should be understood better. Infact it should have been understood before the war began. Some miscalculations could have been avoided and lives could have been saved.

by hal 9000

Would be a good idea for every Allied Person in Iraq that way if they disappeared we would start to know where to look for them and make them far less tempting targets in the first place.

After all if they could be pinpointed down to a few mm's it would be an easy thing to know exactly where they where and how to get them back. If something like this was used it would be far less attractive to the terrorists to kidnap and kill people after all al Jassera showing Terrorists being caught wouldn't be good for their image would it?

Col

by aldanatech

Is that so? Well then there is a shed of hope that Bush will finally come to his senses sometime soon. Still, I consider that this kind of maturity that should at all times be reflected on a U.S. president develops too little, too late. That is because he still considers the future of Iraq is brighter than the future of America. Yesterday, he actually said "I saw a poll that said the right track/wrong track in Iraq was better than here in America." This only further confirms me that his not fit for this job, unless of course he was only kidding.

by maxwell edison

.
That quote is currently making the rounds on the Democrat blogs, Democrat underground, and partisan sites.

But interestingly enough it's taken out of context and misinterpreted to a horrible degree. And then aldanatech, himself, puts his spin on it. I have to wonder, is his "spin" born of disingenuousness, ignorance or partisan blindness - or all three?

>>>>>>>>>> The full context <<<<<<<<<<

Setting: President Bush and Visiting Prime Minister Allawi Press Conference in The White House Rose Garden
.
.
.
.
Q Mr. President and Mr. Prime Minister, I'd like to ask about the Iraqi people. Both of you have spoken for them today, and, yet, over the past several months there have been polls conducted by the Coalition Provisional Authority, by the Oxford Institute and other reputable organizations, that have found very strong majorities do not see the United States as a liberator, but as an occupier, are unhappy with American policy and want us out. Don't the real voices of the Iraqi people, themselves, contradict the rosy scenarios you're painting here today?
PRESIDENT BUSH: Let me start by that. You said the poll was taken when the CPA was there?

Q One poll --

PRESIDENT BUSH: Okay, let me stop you. First of all, the Iraqi people now have got Iraqi leadership. Prime Minister Allawi and his cabinet are making decisions on behalf of the Iraqi people. Secondly, I saw a poll that said the right track/wrong track in Iraq was better than here in America. (Laughter.) It's pretty darn strong. I mean, the people see a better future.

Talk to the leader. I agree -- I'm not the expert on how the Iraqi people think, because I live in America, where it's nice and safe and secure. But I talk to this man. One reason I'm optimistic about our ability to get the job done is because I talk to the Iraqi Prime Minister. I'm also optimistic that people will choose freedom over tyranny every time. That's what I believe.

But, Mr. Prime Minister, you might answer the question on the polls. There's a lot of polls; sometimes they show you up and sometimes they show you down, as you might remember.

PRIME MINISTER ALLAWI: Let me -- let me take a minute to explain to you something, a factual event. I meet, personally, every now and then with the fringes of the so-called resistance to try and talk them into respecting law and order and withdraw their arms. And I ask them in a very honest, very open way, I say to them, "What do you want to achieve? Could you know exactly what you want to achieve? Do you want to bring Saddam back from the hole in the ground, living like a rat? Do you want to bring him back to rule Iraq? Or do you want to bring bin Laden or similar persons to bin Laden to rule Iraq? If you want to do this, we will fight you room to room, house to house. If you want to be part of the political process, you have to be part of the political process, you are welcome.

If you do not want the multinational force in Iraq -- I was talking to Fallujah people recently, to tribes, ex-army officers, ex-Saddam loyalists -- if you want the multinational force out, win the elections, go to the United Nations, talk to the Security Council, and tell them we don't need the multinational forces. But I tell you what is going to happen. If you ask the multinational force to leave prematurely -- this is me talking to the Fallujah people -- your country will be in ruins, and we cannot now, on our feet, stand and fight terrorism and global terrorism.

These are realities. And once you are in Iraq, I will be my (sic) host. I can put you together with these people in my home and you can talk to them. And you can find out yourselves that the Iraqis, tremendously, by and large, respect the United States, and respect the other partners in the coalition for helping Iraq, not only in liberation, but now in helping Iraq to rebuild itself and to rebuild its institutions.

PRESIDENT BUSH: Let me -- let me say one other thing about why I'm optimistic we'll succeed. By the way, you can understand it's tough and still be optimistic. You can understand how hard it is and believe we'll succeed.

I remember when some were talking about the possibility of success in Afghanistan in pretty stark terms. I don't know if you remember that period or not, but there was a period where some were saying that it wasn't possible for democracy to come forward in Afghanistan. Today, 10 million citizens have registered to vote, 41 percent of whom are women. It's a phenomenal statistic, I think. I think it shows what's possible if you believe -- if you have certain beliefs from which you won't waver. And I believe people yearn to be free.

Again, I think if you look at polls -- which, sometimes I do and sometimes I don't, admittedly, Moran -- that, by far, the vast majority of Iraqis want to vote. They want to live in freedom. And the fundamental question is, do we -- is this: Do we have the will to stay? Do we have the will to put smart strategy in place? I've laid out the strategy; we're implementing the strategy. But really, do we have the will to complete the mission? And my message to the Iraqi people, and to the enemy, and to our troops in harm's way, and to our allies is: We'll complete the mission.
.
.
.
.
.
The link:

http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2004/09/20040923-8.html

by maxwell edison

.
Hey, just like everyone else who posts messages in these threads, I'm no foreign policy expert. I'm not privy to the national security briefings. I don't know what goes on behind the closed doors of foreign embassies. I don't get to review the intelligence information. And dag nab it, Tom Clancy just won't return my phone calls. So I don't know all the details of the various foreign policy intricacies and considerations.

And while I certainly voice my general opinion on the "bigger picture", when it comes down to the nuts and bolts of it, I'll leave all the little details to the ones I hired to act on my behalf. However, to "generally" answer your questions, at least as best I can, I will say this.

You ask, "Why not Iran......the students look like they just need some catalyst / backing......?" I think the same as you in the sense that Iran may be primed and ready for some major reforms - and from within. It seems to me that if the seeds planted in Iraq today do indeed sprout some semblance of a democratic nation, with free market economics, with free and open elections, with this and that and all that democracy brings, then the neighboring Iran could change - almost overnight - without a single shot being fired. (But we need to get the Israelis to take-out their nuclear facilities first.)

Could we have "arm-twisted" Saudi Arabia? It seems to me that Saudi Arabia is "somewhat" contained and "somewhat" accommodating to U.S. interests. Sure, reforms are in order there as well, but given time, things may change - especially if Iraq and Iran change first.

Syria - look out folks. There are ~ 150,000 "armed and dangerous" U.S. soldiers right at your border and the U.S. Navy, complete with fully loaded and fully armed aircraft carriers, within easy range. It's highly suspected that Iraq's WMDs, at least in part, were transported to that nation. They support and harbor terrorists. And if they don't capitulate to the inevitable, they may be the next "Iraq".

Pakistan - what a potential powder keg. It'll take diplomats a lot smarter than me to walk the delicate walk and talk the fastidious talk necessary to bring about reforms and get them in-line to help eradicate world-wide terrorism without igniting a regional disaster. However, Pakistan has been, from what I've been reading, fairly helpful and accommodating in our efforts, at least to some degree. Actually, I believe that Osama bin Laden is in Pakistan, in a fairly isolated region that's both difficult to traverse and populated with Osama supporters, and the Pakistani government may be finding themselves between the proverbial rock and hard place. I further believe that hundreds, if not thousands, of U.S. intelligence agents and special forces are currently operating on the ground in Pakistan, as inconspicuously as possible, of course, ready to pounce at a moments notice. And speaking of Tom Clancy, this is one novel I'd love to read - especially if it's a somewhat covert operation that finally captures Osama bin Laden and his gang of thugs.

My bottom line, however, is that the results, regardless of the order in which they're addressed, are what's important. And it won't be an effort that will happen overnight. Heck, this is a 20, 30 or 40 year plan in the works. And another answer to the question, why Iraq first? Well, regardless of the rhetoric that the United Nations isn't "with us" in this effort, the United Nations has, over the past dozen or more years, unanimously passed various resolutions against Iraq - resolutions ignored or violated by Iraq - which gave the U.S. the legal authority to act as we did. So the stage was set. The time was right. And the goals were noble.

There ya' go.

by maxwell edison

.
If you're fooling around with your neighbor's wife, perhaps you want to select one of those "other" forums to discuss it.

by thelastword

yes, lying that there is no war anymore. Further, he tried to pull just what you said but the conflict was over his head so he couldnt pull it off. Another way it exposes him as stupid! He probably really did think it was over!!!LOL

by hal 9000

If you actually take the time to read the Koran you'll find a reference to a person described as the "Nazarene" who went about uniting the differences between Islam and Judaism but because their calender doesn't conform to the Roman Calender which we use today not many will realize that this person suddenly appeared in the Islamic nations at 33AD on the Roman Calender.

As far as what most people call moderate Muslims these are the common people who follow that faith. By the reasoning that there is no such thing as a "Moderate Muslim" it could equally be said that there is no such thing as a "Moderate Catholic" and they are all murderous mongrels just like their religious brothers and sisters who are in the IRA!

Do you see the point?

Col

by thelastword

you are operating and making this statement still under the pretense that the war in Iraq is a war on terrorism. In fact, it is a territorial war, in some way Bush's logic may at some point lead to the idea that a democratic presence will help to fight terrorism in the area. That may be true in the long run, but the territory had to be taken first and that is the stage the war is at right now. Not related to to war on terror yet. Terrorist tactics are being used to fight the occupation of territory, some terrorist tactics are being used just for the terror of it and to take advantage of the media. Those are terrorists who are oppressed and have nothing else to live for. You can see that terrorism itself is embedded in middle eastern culture as a tool of terror and as a tool of war. But Bushs immediate intent was to win the territory. Fighting terrorists is basically fighting to gain the territory, those are the weapons they use over. The world would be better of that culture changed, there is no doubt. Will other countries step in to help with that cause? Thats a question that remains to be answered. Only if the value to the world can be exposed and clarified. That hasn't been done yet. Bush has failed to articulate that to the world community but someone should try. With a clearer vision, the world community might help but why would they when apparently the US is controlling the gains from the contracts etc.

by oz_media

I only see one argument actually, everyone is saying the world is not participating because they did't go to Iraq.

The rest of the world is VERY actively working to form alliances and gain intelligence, they all have troops scattered around, trying to stop the growth of al-Qaeda, gather iformation, protect and rebuild cities that have been terorrized etc. They just aren't at your side in Iraq.

Anyway, the world was at war full bore for several years before the US showed up in Europe too. The USA was still fighting WWII but not in the European theatre by sending troops.

Perhaps now people are starting to see the other side of the coin.

Now to take this even further, if in 2006, the UK sends out forces, France does, Germany does etc., and the war is ended and the territory regained, can Europeas then say they saved the US from losing the war and speaking Arabic? :p

by thelastword

The US MUST look at itself in terms of humanitarian effort and revise its strategy to fit in with the rest of the world as it has exposed itself as non-humanitarian and uncivilized in its ability to see the bombarded territory as a culture with people.
The other question is, who rightfully owns the territory and its resources if the other countries have to foot the security bill.

by onbliss

---
"So I don't know all the details of the various foreign policy intricacies and considerations"

Awwwwww, I thought you knew everything :-)
---

---
"neighboring Iran could change - almost overnight - without a single shot being fired."

Hope your words come true.
---

---
"(But we need to get the Israelis to take-out their nuclear facilities first.)"

LOL
---

---
"accommodating to U.S. interests."
You see that is one complaint that rest of the world has. You may see it as accomodating to U.S. interests, but the world sees it as closing your eyes to their deeds. And the citizens of those countries think they are just being used by their rulers and US. They have loads of other problems, would'nt this add to their frusturations. Obviously they take the easy way out.

---
"Syria - look out folks." and "they may be the next "Iraq".

Do you really think the world would appreciate that? Why not Syria in the first place. Irrespective of they have the WMD or not, they were causing trouble, right? Why not start there?
---

---
"Pakistan has been, from what I've been reading, fairly helpful and accommodating in our efforts, at least to some degree."
I am not going to say US has been selfish, because I expect every country to safegaurd its own interest. That is so logical. But did'nt US keep helping Pakistand day in and day out, just because India was pals with USSR? Everybody knew Pakistan's terror activities in Kashmir. It was so obvious that the world looked the other way around. The deaths in Kashmir valley is about 30,000 people.

That being the case, though the world thanks that a sleeping giant (US) is awake now, it does bring bitter taste to the mouth every now and then, when US proclaims that it is going to get rid of terrorists in the world.
---

---
"regardless of the order in which they're addressed, are what's important."

Order does play a part. A wrong order would just prove to the world that U.S. is merely after its interests (which is legitimate), but no longer can it be clothed in words of liberating Iraqis, spreading democracy and its benefits.
---

---
"the United Nations has, over the past dozen or more years, unanimously passed various resolutions against Iraq - resolutions ignored or violated by Iraq - which gave the U.S. the legal authority to act as we did."

U.N. is a puppet whose strings are pulled by the five permanent members.
---

---
"So the stage was set. The time was right."

How do you say the time was right? Does it make sense to spread the butter thin? WHen the war on terror was going on constructively in Afghanistan, and the financial network was being monitored and tightly controlled, nearly the whole world was on U.S. side ready to do their part in curtailing terrorism, why topple the cart?

I think the stage was set, but not for a war. But one for a PROXY-WAR. U.S. had the world, the world could have slowly and steadily squeezed the life out of terrorism. Like friction can never be removed only reduced, terrorism would have been reduced.

Instead of spending $80-100 billion, few billions used appropriately could have left its mark. We could have continued to engage M.E. people. And the list goes on and on...

---
"And the goals were noble."

I have provided atleast three analogies :-) to that argument.
---

by maxwell edison

.
"We know we can't count on the French. We know we can't count on the Russians. We know that Iraq is a danger to the United States, and we reserve the right to take pre-emptive action whenever we feel it's in our national interest."

by oz_media

It actually sounds like something Paul Martin said in front of the UN the other day.

I know it sure as hell doesn't soound like BUSH. He said France is a valuable ally in the fight against terrorism, as well as Russia.

It's kind of a mixed comment though, I agree with some of it but not the whole context, I'd have to see the original context to understand the focus properly, this just doesn't cut it as a solo quote.

Can I assume Kerry said it?

by onbliss

Does'nt this happen.........

IT Manager1: Hey, we need to create this Sales Automation System.
IT Manager2: Yeah, you are right. The company needs it.

ITM1: This is gonna be a BIG Project for us. We know we can't use XYZ Consulting. And ABC Consulting is no good either. We got to create this and by being proactive...I think IT could save bunch of money for the company.

ITM2: Yup, I agree we need to get this system done, and XYZ Consulting and ABC Consulting would not be much useful.

ITM1: So, what do you say I propose this application to the business, will you back me up?

ITM2: Oh sure, ofcourse we need the application. Go ahead. You have my word. Oh by the way, I think we could cut some costs by not building the entire system from the scratch. Let's buy some components from XYZ and ABC.

ITM1: Hmmm..I will try talking to them. I think, we should do it inhouse without looking for integrating components from outside vendors. You know the Camel and the Arab story [how topical :-)]

ITM2: I don't think so...

[After few days]
ITM1: Hey, the managment liked it. I am going full steam ahead.

ITM2: What did XYZ and ABC say?

ITM1: Na...they are not going to be helpful.

ITM2: Ok... letz follow these .... methodologies and use these ....technologies.

ITM1: I think ....these are better than what you say.

[ITM2 meekly protests]

ITM1: Hey, the project is going great with the methodologies and technolgies I used.

ITM2: Hmmm, but the system does not have so and so features. And we went over budget and time...

ITM1: Hey man I did say this was a BIG project, did'nt I?

ITM2: But if we had used the things suggested by me...then we could have saved some money. Now we have just annoyed all our Consulting partners. In future when we need them they are gonna jack up their prices.

ITM1: What was the gauarntee that your methodologies and technologies would have benefitted....

ITM2: Yeah....but.... if at all.....

And so the discussion goes on...........

by hal 9000

"we reserve the right to take pre-emptive action whenever we feel"

Smacks of the Japanese actions prior to the involvement of the USA in WW11. But maybe I'm wrong and Japan had the right to launch a pre-emptive attack on Pearl Harbor to protect their interests against the USA.

What do you think Maxwell?

Col

by maxwell edison

.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but the reasons (in simplistic terms) for the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor were twofold. First (without the benefit of review), the U.S. placed an oil embargo on the Japanese as a reaction to the Japanese invasion of China, or parts thereof, and this was the Japanese retaliation to that embargo. And second, the huge American fleet parked at Pearl was a potential obstacle to the Japanese expansionist plans in the Pacific.

Now if the Japanese had valid reasons to believe that the American fleet at Pearl Harbor was there as part of a plan to invade Japan - or in today's world, to wreak havoc and kill Japanese civilians just because we don't like them (or similar terrorist type reasons), then you'd have a valid comparison. But that's not the case.

by onbliss

...site www.faithfreedom.org

I know its wrong to blame ALL the people belonging to any faith. But when the fringe elements raise and start occupying the top posts and brainwash the followers...you can not help in wondering what the sane and moderate people are doing?

by thelastword

He would use the current situation as a way to further embed and take over the territory as there are no other methods that can work, if he truly wants to make it a democracy there then he will have to really occupy it to get it under control, all this terrorist outbreak is a good excuse to do it. Get an ID system in place and even put up protected shelters with medical compunds in place where people can go. This is a refugee situation in the making. Thats where they'll end up anyway. DISPLACED. And then they end up over here as refugees and we end up with MORE TERRORISTS. He has not come up with one single different solution or anything that is working at all.

by oz_media

No sir, I do NOT think it' alrigt for other oficials to pfr comments based on elections or the perties runing for president, at least NOT during active campaigning and while nearing an election anyhow, the public is far too easily influenced at these times as everyone is seeking reason to either confirm or detract from thier choice.

It is the same as BUSH making his comments in Australia during thier campaigns, it was not right. Hee we see the othe side of the coin again, everyone defended Bush's right to speak out about the Ozzie's PM, now it is wrong for Iraq's president to speak out as the US election nears.

I don't think any nation's leaders should be able to make such possibly influencial comments as the race is on, after elections they should be allowed to speak thier minds though.

by oz_media

Well just like flies they are all over the world.

There seems to be some form of single focus on Iraq and al-Qaeda or some reason. Yes al-Qaeda is strong and growig in cells all oe the world including Iraq, just as it is in Afghanistan STILL, Pakistan, UK, Egypt, Canada, the USA, Germany, Bosnia, Africa, etc.

The terrorists,thier leaders, new recruits and recruiting propaganda, books, schools etc. are EVERYWHERE.

In fact, the whole issue with capturing and stating how 2/3 of the operatives have been caught just fuelled an intense rush to support al-Qaeda, they have been recruiting FAR faster and stronger than they were before, just to spit back in the face of those who captured thier former leaders.

It ws HOPED to bring an end to al-Qaeda, but the reaction was the absolute opposite, they have gown because of those who once stood for thier cause.

by thelastword

They are taking advantage of the war to further their cause through the media exposure and to gain control of Iraq through Bushes exploitation of the country using their tactics and they will probably be successful because basically Bush has handed the country over to them and/or plans to directly do so.

by thelastword

Basically, I think terrorist USE this line to further their cause too. They are basically only hate mongers. They arent complaining of the uS taking over their territories at all!!! Why woudl they complain when it gives them free land. They basically run around copying the US and bombing the CRAP out of everyone themselves. That is true too, someone I know from egypt said basically the terrorists just go in the beaten down territories for something to do, copy and dog the US when they can and torment everyone. That about sums them up doesn't it? They have no political gain or anything else, they are the scum of the earth basically trying to see if they can outthink everyone or get power from somewhere to justify themselves

by thelastword

Maybe they are fighting for the land. But for what reason? not for the people really but to occupy it themselves I'm sure. As far as moleing them out, those were bushes words not mine, obviously he has been unsuccessful in this tactic as they are winning. What is being exposed is that Bush has no plan to fight them. Every time they kill someone through kidnapping, that gets exposed.

by oz_media

But only if they are good enough to occupy it I suppose.

If they are being bad, then it is up to the world to reoccupy the land and hand it to the good people. :)

by thelastword

They have no cause as far as fighting the US in terms of a noble cause for teh IRaqi people ANY More than the US does by thier methods. That is the point they are trying to make I believe.
I don't believe they are fighting for their country, more just fighting for their cause, to blow s**t up which they believe is EQUAL to the American cause there. GET it? Do you think this is a bunch of IRaqis doign this? It's not the Iraqi police, it's not the Iraqi civilians, it's a bunch of terrorists who are trained in these tactics and trying to blow s**t up the same as what they 'think; the US is doing. To match violence with violence, thats all. No other reason.

by hal 9000

The current crop of Evangelical Christians the same way?

This is where it starts getting hard to deal with when you have apposing sides who bash their holy books claiming that they have a God given right to act they way that they are.

Currently the AU Prime Minister thinks it is justifiable to launch a preemptive strike to protect AU's interests. However to me that is like the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor unnecessary and most likely to cause more trouble that you where trying to prevent in the first place.

It's a great idea to offer help to fellow countries and extend the hand of friendship all the time but a totally different thing to bomb the crap out of a place that is a friendly country because you have been told a pack of lies by someone so they must be true. I'd be the first to say if assistance is asked for supply it by all means but never NEVER be the first to ACT as you are running the risk of looking exactly like what you are trying to prevent!

Col

by oz_media

Just feling tired and silly after a lOOOOOng week away from home.

Oh well, Chivas at the track tonight and then FINALLY going home tomorrow! :) I never realized just how annoying it is in the city, damn is it noisy! Even just standing outside for a smoke or something, just the general noise level is outrageous! Makes you just want to scream SHUT THE HELL UP DAMMIT!!!!! That would be cool, no voices, no planes, no cars, no trucks, no NOTHING!, Birds and wind, mmmmmmmm.

by hal 9000

Why are so many of the current administration getting killed off?

What was once a more or less united group against SH has turned into a grab as much as possible at any cost. The Kurds have to fail because Turkey can not let them declare a homeland because the Turkish Kurds will justifiably want the same in a greater Kurdistan and the rest will descend into internal bickering with each other which would be alright if every second person wasn't caring an AK47's or RPG launcer's.

Col

by hereinoz

Max, by reference to the previous quote, you did imply that Oz had said that he thought it was right, but he did not.

Your implication that Oz had said it was right, by your reference to that previous post, means that you did ascribe statements to Oz that he did not make.

I don't always agree with you, although I have in the past, but I always have respected your research and knowledge. Please don't spoil your reputation by getting this one all arse about.

Cheers,
Alan

by maxwell edison

.
Oz said, "No sir, I do NOT think it' [sic] alrigt [sic] for other oficials [sic] to pfr [sic] comments based on elections or the perties [sic] runing [sic] for president.."

Oz also has said, "So what gives these people the right to speak out about it you ask? The same right that you have to speak out about their political affairs."

by olprof67

Those who aren't oriented toward productive enterprise fight over territory.

That's true for insurgents in Iraq or gang-bangers on any inner-city street in America.

And outgrowing this predisposition usually takes generations. The entire Middle East is near the back of the pack.

The barbarians are still with us, and may be forever.

by oz_media

In the first comment "what gives them the right...?"
It was a simple comparisson of recent arguments and how they would apply to that particular discussion. It had been pressed that US leaders had a right to comments, SARCASTICALLY (sp?) it implied that if the US can do it, so can others. It is taken completely out of the context of the discussion, you would know if you backed up a bit.

Hey, if you can do it, so can anyone else. THis doesn't mean I think thay should though.

by hal 9000

The question here is "Did the Japanese Government or Emperor think that the US Fleet in Pearl Harbor was against Japans interests?"

Using what has currently been used to justify invading or attacking Sovereign Countries was Japan wrong in its attack on Pearl Harbor to protect their interests in the Pacific Region?

I've noticed that no one here has brought up the UN vote on the Iraq war or the fact that when President Bush addressed them last week he didn't receive the reception that he expected or maybe wanted I'm not sure which as I'm not involved in the US Administration.

In WW1 Germany had a valid target in sinking that ship which the then US Administration knew could be sailing into troubled waters but Pearl was a different story I'm just wondering how you would feel if it was your country that was attacked by another nation under the pretext that they where doing it for their own good.

Surely Japanese expansion "which they where forced into" would have been in jeopardy if the Pearl Harbor attack had not have happened and would have been far more effective if they had of caught the Pacific Fleet Aircraft Carriers in port.

That day "That November day that will live in infamy" can be seen in hind sight as being in Japans best interests can't it? Even if that isn't accepted the result should be it brought about the downfall of the Japanese Empire that the Emperor Aspired to.

Do you see any parallels going on now?

Col

by maxwell edison

.
Colin, I disagree for the reasons I stated. I don't think anything else I can say would change anything.

If you want to find parallels, I suppose you'll find them. If you want to find "proof" that aliens from outer space have visited Earth, you'll find it. If you want to find the parallels between a horizontal and vertical line, you'll find them.

Quite frankly, I don't know if your serious or just jerking me around. If it's the former, no amount of reason on my part will change your mind. If it's the latter, I don't really want to play.

by hal 9000

Pre-emptive strike wording that worries me. It can be used to justify anything.

Nothing more and nothing less.

No chain jerking or anything else only pointing out how one country can justify their actions to suit their own ends. At least in Japan of the time the Emperor was considered a God so was unquestionable but the current US Administration and I might add the Australian Administration believe in this action. I just don't find it the best way to make or keep friends if you are willing to threaten them with forced invasion or attack if you do not like what some of their citizens are doing. If they ask for help to stop them then thats a different matter but to just take it into your own hands to decide {And I do mean a country any country here!} Really scares me.

Currently the UN has declared the current situation in Iraq as Illegal and I'm just hoping to hell that it doesn't unite the Muslim world against us in the mistaken belief that what is currently going on is not a "War on Terror" but is actually a "War on Islam".

That is how things in Iraq are being portrayed in some of the Muslim Religious institutions and it is why so many are joining these terror groups. I'm just hoping that the whole mess doesn't blow up in our faces as we can not afford to either be on the loosing side or show weakness. If we do either it will result in an open invitation for all these religious fanatics to justify their attacks on us.

You are an intelligent person who should be well aware that in every case where one country has instigated any attack they have ended up loosing the "War" this goes beyond politics to what is common sense and right. Currently we have a diminishing number of supporters and even those that openly support our actions are in jeopardy of losing office {Pakistan} and even though they may support our ends there are still areas in that country where their troops are unable to go without being attacked and in all likely hood killed. Remember that operatives of Al Quedia have been captured in Pakistan and it has caused the Government there more trouble than it is worth to them. While they wish to support our ends a lot of their citizens do not and when that occurs the country becomes ungovernable and a bigger threat to us than what we have been previously fighting.

Col

by thelastword

You are calling them Barbaric when they are calling you that and laughing at you. If you are not barbaric then come up with something other than violence to better your argument. The central argument of the terrorist is simply - "if you can bomb 30,000 civilians so can we". Get it?

by maxwell edison

.
You said, "the UN has declared the current situation in Iraq as Illegal."

No they haven't.

Would you please provide the details of the UN resolution that did?

by oz_media

While a 'resolution' has not formally been passed, the secretary general of the UN, Kofi Annan HAS declared the war in Iraq is illegal.

I believe I am right in assuming that Colin was referring to Annan's comments when he said, [i]"Currently the UN has declared the current situation in Iraq as Illegal" [/i].

Well maybe not formally, but a key UN voice and representative has 'declared' it illegal.

[b]The World Today - Thursday, 16 September , 2004 12:22:00
Reporter: Catherine McGrath[/b]
ELEANOR HALL: The Prime Minister has found himself again defending his policy on Iraq, after the United Nations Secretary-General, Kofi Annan, said today that the US-led invasion was illegal and that the elections planned for Iraq in January would not be credible in the current security environment.

Campaigning in Western Australia, John Howard said he rejected the UN chief's comments and declared that Australia's involvement in the war on Iraq was valid.

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

[b]Sept.16th, 2004 - Iraq war illegal, says Annan[/b]
United Nations secretary-general Kofi Annan says the United States decision to invade Iraq in March 2003 was "illegal".
Australia was a key supporter of the war on Iraq and sent troops to joined the United States-led invasion last year.
Mr Annan's comments are likely to reignite debate over whether US President George W Bush, Prime Minister John Howard and British Prime Minister Tony Blair acted within the bounds of international law by failing to get a final UN Security Council resolution on Iraq.
Speaking in an interview with BBC World Service radio, Mr Annan says the UN Security Council should have issued a second resolution, if a US-led invasion of Iraq was to be allowed.

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Splitting hairs again. Is this actually some sort of war crime that Bush and Blair should be facing? Should this not actually go under review and sworn testimony of what exactly caused the action, how and why the decision was REALLY made? Under what undeniable proof was it decided that this was neccessary as all attempts at inspections had failed?

Sorry I didn't save the links but any simple search will find it, it is recent enough.

by maxwell edison

.
Geesh, Oz, there was no need to post those quotes. I know what Kofi Annan has said.

And it's not splitting hairs. It's a very vital - and very important - distinction.

The secretary general of the UN, and in this term it's Kofi Annan, does not speak for the United Nations. His words were political rhetoric just like John Kerry's - not to mention extremely irresponsible.

Passing resolutions is what speaks for the United Nations, not the "opinion" of the guy who temporarily holds the secretary general spot.

So while Kofi Annan did say it, the United Nations did not.

by maxwell edison

.
Your lies, aldanatech, are a horrible reflection on both the Iraqi people and the Americans who've sacrificed to help them - ABSOLUTELY HORRIBLE.

You should be extremely ashamed of yourself.

--------------------

"The Iraqi government now commands almost 100,000 trained and combat-ready Iraqis, including police, national guard and army. The government have accelerated the development of Iraqi special forces and established a counter-terrorist strike force to address the specific problems caused by the insurgency. Our intelligence is getting better every day. You have seen that in the successful resolution of the Najaf crisis and in the targeted attacks against insurgents in Fallujah.

Finally, our economic plan is to improve the everyday lives of Iraqis as we deliver both political and security progress. Here, thanks to a large extent to the generous security and reconstruction funding approved by the United States Congress, work is underway. Oil pipelines are being repaired. Basic service has improved; streets and homes rebuilt; schools, hospitals and clinics reopened. Thousands of Iraqis have new jobs. Salaries have been increased dramatically -- in many cases, five or four times over. Iraq's economy, freed from the stranglehold of a failed Baathist ideology, has finally started to flourish.

Mr. President, we also discussed the importance of holding free and fair national and local elections this coming January, as planned. I know that some have speculated, even doubted, whether this date can be met, so let me be absolutely clear that elections will occur in Iraq on time in January, because Iraqis want election on time. In 15 out of 18 Iraqi provinces, the security situation is good for elections to be held tomorrow.

Here, Iraqis are getting on with their daily lives, hungry for the new political and economic freedoms they are enjoying. Although, this is not what you see in your media, it is a fact."

- Iraqi Prime Minister Allawi

--------------------

aldanatech, take yourself to the woodshed - you certainly deserve it.

by hal 9000

The constant attacks on the oil pipelines and the kidnapping and killing of foreigners and here I DO NOT MEAN Westerners but Muslims from Turkey and Jordon.

Your right!

I for one certainly hope that the elections are held and they result in a workable system in Iraq but when it is accepted that there may be large areas of the country that will be unable to vote for "Security Reasons" How can anyone begin to even consider that there will be a Democratically elected government in place after the elections. Maybe things will be great {I sure as hell hope so} but with only certain areas of the population being allowed to vote will it be any better than the Baath Party of Saddam Hussein?

Quote "The Iraqi government now commands almost 100,000 trained and combat-ready Iraqis, including police, national guard and army. The government have accelerated the development of Iraqi special forces and established a counter-terrorist strike force to address the specific problems caused by the insurgency. Our intelligence is getting better every day. You have seen that in the successful resolution of the Najaf crisis and in the targeted attacks against insurgents in Fallujah."

While this is correct just how many people where there in the Elite Forces loyal to Saddam Hussein that buckled in a few weeks under a constant COW assault?

Quote "Finally, our economic plan is to improve the everyday lives of Iraqis as we deliver both political and security progress. Here, thanks to a large extent to the generous security and reconstruction funding approved by the United States Congress, work is underway. Oil pipelines are being repaired. Basic service has improved; streets and homes rebuilt; schools, hospitals and clinics reopened. Thousands of Iraqis have new jobs. Salaries have been increased dramatically -- in many cases, five or four times over. Iraq's economy, freed from the stranglehold of a failed Baathist ideology, has finally started to flourish."

While this is exactly what is planed how do you expect it to be impelmented when the critical infrastructure is under constant attack? Currently it has been reported that citizens in Bagdad normally have electricity for only 4 hours per day. This is a basic need. Not to mention that there are currently "No Go Zones" even in the capitol Bagdad for both US troops and the new Iraqie Police forces!

Quote "Here, Iraqis are getting on with their daily lives, hungry for the new political and economic freedoms they are enjoying. Although, this is not what you see in your media, it is a fact."

And on a daily basis we see reports of these very people being killed by bombs as they attempt to join the Police Force who will be responsible for carring out the current and hopefully freely elected new Governments wishes. Not only are these very people unsafe at the recurting offices but they are also comming under attack while being driven to the training courses that they need to undergo to be effective Police men. It makes quite a lot of people sit back and think again when they see so many killed needlessly or gunned down in a hail of bullets while being driven to their new positions!

I'm the first to admit that I sure as hell do not have any answers but I'm also not blind enough to believe completely any political statment held close to an election either. Politions always p[aint a picture that they want us to believe which may not be the real situation.

Col

by hereinoz

See you here in 12 months or a couple of years, Max, then we will know who was correct.

This is one situation where I sincerely hope you are right.

We cannot know whether Iraq is in control or not yet, let us be realistic about this. It has not been long enough.

There are many people getting killed, kidnapped, assaulted, etc, and it would appear that it is getting more common for people to be killed, kidnapped or assaulted, so that certain interest groups can achieve their own goals.

This may be part of the plan to control Iraq. It could be part of the US administration's strategy to lull the insurgents into a false sense of security by allowing them to do these things for a time, then hit them hard to bring them under control.

I have no idea what the US administration's strategy is, but I sincerley hope that they know what their own strategy is.

And if their control strategy is to tear the infrastructure of Iraq to bits, and then make it look like the insurgents are gaining the upper hand by killing heaps of innocent Iraqis and coalition troops and foreign aid workers, then I guess they have a hand on that strategy and know what they are doing.

At least we know they have their hand on something, even if it is not their strategy.

See Ya

Alan

by hal 9000

If the current "Interim Administration" in Iraq is so popular just why are they being murdered as US sympathizers?

These are the very people who are supposed to be the leaders if even only in a temporary fashion and they are getting murdered at an alarming rate even faster than US Presidents are killed off!

Also just how do you have "Democratic Elections" if it is accepted that large parts of the country will be unable to participate?

Col

by maxwell edison

.
If you could ask the murderers themselves, who would they be and how do you think they'd answer?

And don't forget, you are the one who called them murderers, and I agree.

There ya' go, Colin. If you try to answer those questions very honestly, I think you'd agree with me and support the war in Iraq.

by hal 9000

Speak for the UN.

But what about the rest of the post?

What is it that I do not understand?

Where am I misunderstanding the current position with the Muslim community?

Col

by oz_media

On one hand I will agree that much good has been done in Iraq.

On the other hand, you cannot deny that much BAD has also come out if Iraq, if not far outweighing any good done.

If you limit yourself to only the positive news, you will see a fairweather report of a country being rebuilt.

If you ignore the realities of the bad issues, Iraq is looking just fine.

Again though, in order to see the good side, you must first ignore the bad.

SWhile it is said things are looking up and the bad views are lefty propaganda, I see this as such a stupid view, because it is only accurate if you put your head in the sand.

If you close your eyes every time there is a starving child shown on TV in a fund raiser for Unicef, there is no hunger in the world either.

So I agree that maybe the left wing does only show the bad side of things, isn't that what we need to see though ? Otherwise everything looks just fine, but it's only a fantasy.

by hereinoz

When the Japanese did it, it was to assist their expansionist policies in the Pacific, but when the US does it, it is merely to protect the poor little USA that never needs to otherwise step beyond its borders.

Where the hell is the emoticon for a derisive laugh!! I need one right now.