Discussion Locked

Iraq is out of control

0 helpful
525 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

525 replies

by garion11

Heh, its only the negativity that gets the media's eye and deceives naive people like Aldanatech.

by thechas

The problem is that even with the amount of work that has been done, there are fewer Iraqi's in school or employed than there were before Bush started this unnecessary war.

Prior to the US destroying the Iraqi army and police force, Iraq had virtually no terrorism.

The US occupation of lands that are sacred to the Muslim religion has made Iraq and the US presence a target for terrorists.

Also, don't blame the media for not reporting the "good news"!
Good news does NOT sell papers or increase ratings.
The media has to have bad news, scandal, and controversy in order to stay in business.

I'm not saying that there isn't bias in the US commercial media. Just that good news stories have little commercial value.
Until the public starts buying papers and tuning in for "good news" stories, we will continue to be bombarded with bad news.

Even in non-war news, good news does not make the cut.
Would you watch a news story about the 300,000,000 travelers that made it home safe?
The 5,000 fender benders that happened?
Or the story about the major accident where 5 people died?

The commercial media spread doom and gloom simply because it sells.

Chas

by oz_media

This is a common right wing argument. 'The news is left biased and only shows the negtative sides and not the positive', in the same sense though, if you only watch or pay attention to the positive right leaning news, everything looks peachy.

Or

If you keep your head in the sand and just plug your ears when bad reports are aired then it is fantastic.

Dismiss or ignore the reality and only focus on the pretty side. Happy times but not realistic at all.

Do the LEFTY BS media that you hate so much actually make this horrible footage on a Hollywood set or do you think perhaps that RIGHT biased reports will ONLY show the positive side, just as you claim the left is only negative?

How can they show so much negative news if it isn't a reality?

Why DOESN'T the right wing media speak of these issues and give you a balanced opinion so as to PROVE the left wing has a negative agenda, instead of only showing how great things are going?

Because the right is as corrupt as the left but afraid to face the facts, you cannot ignore one side just because you don't like what they say or show. That is just sticking your head in the sand.

I think aldanatech has seen all the positive rosy reports but can't so easily dismiss the atrocities, as many of us have. It is ignorant to dismiss the horrid realities to only accept the fair weather reports.

by hal 9000

Stations in Iraq who are constantly being bombed and killed are not attempting to obtain work?

Then there was the mini van full of Police Recruits all of whom where killed in a hail of gun fire as well. Also there was the photo coping shop targeted because potential recruits for the Police force where using the place to fill in their recruitment forms. Naturally all of these places where attacked at the "best" possible time killing as many as possible and maiming a lot more as well.

If these people killed and injured are not attempting to find work or the Police who are killed are working exactly what do you think they are doing? Holding up placards saying come kill us now!

Col

by garion11

Are they some sort of authority in deciding how American policy has to work and apply? I do not and have never elected the General Secretary of the UN. What I have done (and will continue to do) is elect the President of the US. Kofi Annan and his corrupt communist group called the UN can go fuck themselves. They do not represent the international body of government, in fact, they are nothing, they are not even a government. They are a self serving organization with no accountability to anyone else. Understand that very clearly. When you vote in the Canadian elections, you vote for your Prime Minister, not the UN nor anyone else in that mess of an organization.

by garion11

or perhaps blow up commuter trains, or behead people, or or kidnap children at schools and shoot them up so they would see our point of view?

Since Bush went against our allies wishes and since EVERYONE hates US around the world (because of that), maybe we should do these things so the world would see our point of view and like us better?

Whose with me? Oh wait....

by oz_media

Sure every other country was against the NATURE and REASONS behind what was considered a necessary invasion of Iraq.

THey are still united and actively working to help the USA in other countries as well as forming aliances with each other (France and China for example) where common interests may help fight terrorism. Nobody has turned thier backs on you as you would so like to think.

Poor old America doing the world's dirty work for no thanks, don't flatter yourself. Iraq is but one MINISCULE conflict to be fought on this global effort with no end in sight.

I guess it's much the same as when the USA was not interested in sending troops to Eurpoe during WWII, until they were attacked on thier own soil.

Yet they were STILL participating in WWII, or would you like the rest of the world to forget your efforts based on the same theories you proposed?

Did they turn thier backs on you for it?

Did they speak about cutting you off in future if you didn't jump in?

So as I said before, when London IS attacked (they will most likely be the next 9/11, not the USA and not because of your increased security)and France, Germany and other European allies enter Iraq (if necessary) and help win the war; are they not entitled at THAT point to say they saved the US from being taken over by Iraqi's and saved you Americans from speaking Arabic?

Based on US WWII history.

by garion11

You seem to do that quite a lot. In fact I think you should major in it. My point was referring to the Muslims and their stupidity. But since you turned this into a US thing, I must respond.

We did help England and Europe during WWII. Logistically and unofficially. It wasn't until 1941 we didn't "officially" join the war, but Europe certainly had our full support, intelligence, and logistics. Don't EVER forget that.

There is a difference between what "YOU" (especially France) did post 9/11 to our mission of dealing with this mess that announced itself that morning and what we did to THE MESS THAT RACIST EUROPE CAUSED ON ITS OWN.

USA didn't go to the league of nations or UN or whatever the hell they had back then and being secret deals with Hitler and backstab the British. Neither did we have protest parades in each of our 50 states condemning the Allied bombings of Germany and equate Winston Churchill to a terrorist.

See the difference? Or Are you so blind in your hatred of US's power that you will say anything to not give us when credit is due? From your past posts I say YES.

by hal 9000

Exactly which Allie did GWB go against? I thought and from listening to his speeches that the USA did have Allies who went with the US and invaded Iraq from my befuddled memory I think GWB called them the "Coalition of the Willing COW for short" and every newspaper around the world reported this but obviously I'm incorrect as you've said so.

by que257

No offense highlander, but i believe that anyone that things invading iraq is pretty much brain dead to all the facts about why we did it in the first place. This is something that a hand full of men in power called neocons wanted to do for ten years. They just got a willing participant in George Bush. The facts are out there for anyone who will take the time to do the research. I don't knock anyone for there views but I do knock them if there views are uninformed.
And it is quit obvious that this administration believed there on hipe, thinking that the Iraqies would be rejoicing in the streets for us. You see the president and his men really didn't expect us to still be there at this point in time. So no they didn't plan for the aftermath. You keep hearing the ads about Kerry voting against the 87 billion, denying body armor to the troops. Lets not forget the troops were sent over there without the body armor before that 87 billion vote came up. So whos fault is that really. I'm not a Kerry fan, but I do believe in putting blame where it really belongs.

by oz_media

Nice rant, hardly even remotely applicable to the conversation at hand though. Try following the topic next time, I don't remember saying ANYTHING about UN's authority OR voting for ANYONE in Canada.

The UN is not the issue at hand, you need to back up.

Where did you predetermine all your conclusions?

Were you reading another thread or something?

by garion11

You quote the UN "leaders" and whatever the hell they say like it actually means something. Aren't you implying that we should follow or obey their wishes? Cause in all your past posts you certainly have, so my point to you is (and has been for the last several threads) that the UN is nobody. They have no authority over the US, Canada, or UK, or whatever country you pick. That was the point I was making. They act like they do and some trolls around the world think they should be followed blindly.

by oz_media

I wasn't the one who even brought up the UN, I just found the articel I thought COlin was referring to. Max asked him to provide a link, as I was looking for it myself (as i'm sure Max could have just done instead of calling someone on it only to pick it apart anyway.) I decided to post the link myself.

YOu then go off on some bizarre tangent about who I vote for and who I think should have control?

If that's the case the exact same sentiment applies to the USA making such decisions. Why should YOU be alowed to just place NOrth America under greater risk of attack that before?

Why should America's president be able to increase the hatred for western civilization and not JUST America?

Why didnt' HE consider that he was placing Canada closer to attacks, England, Australia?

What gives some yankee doodle clown with a record of miserable failure able to make such decisions?

Did you not also see last week's speech where the YOu also show complete ignorance to Canada's stand with UN responsibilities.

The Canadian government believes the UN is necessary for good reasons such as those due to international differences which the current US administration has proven it hasn't the first clue about.

Canada is asking for UN reform, [i]"Our common humanity should be a powerful enough argument, and yet that is precisely what is missing. Put simply, there is still no explicit provision in international law for intervention on humanitarian grounds. The ?Responsibility to Protect? is intended to fill this gap. It says that we should have the legal right to intervene in a country on the grounds of humanitarian emergency alone when the government of that country is unwilling or unable to protect their people from extreme harm as a result of internal war, repression or state failure."[/i]

Canada's PM is actually sticking up for your right to intervene on a humanitarian basis (if you pretend that WMD were never talked about)and intervene where the country has proven it is unwilling to resolve the issues itself.

So this makes your insinuation of Canadian's sucking a little UN tit completely wrong as they actively confront the UN on the issue of structural reform.

I was watching Chris Rock's latest standup special the other night, one point he raise is that a black guy can't get a job anywhere but MacDonald's even with an A/B average. A black guy can't get into university without a huge GPA or a basketball scholarship. Yet a white guy can become president og the USA with barely a C average.

Bush is not the best man for the job, he is not the most able man in America, he isn't even above the middle class as far as education goes, he is BARELY an AVERAGE American, yet he stands to be elected for another 4 years! He doesn't even have the credentials to be class valedictorian yet alone president of a whole nation for god's sake!

by oz_media

I watched the main part of a 1 hour documentary on Al Jazeera Satellite TV and the real stories of those in Iraq.

The MAIN concensus between a group of VERY educated Iraqi men, is that Bush had no business invading Iraq and while even they at one time didn't support Saddam, they now feel they were much better off before the "US War machine came in and took away our freedom while Mr. bush said he was giving us freedom."

They admit Saddam was wrong for invading Kuwait, but say he was not the threat and horrible man to his own people that he is said to be.

AlJazeera news was actually banned on several Middle Eastern TV networks as it was said to promote anti Muslim beliefs. GWB then delclared Al Jazeera News 'the mouth of Osama Bin Laden'.

Since GWB delcared his dislike for Al Jazeera TV, it has gone from being a banned news agency, to the most popular news agency in the Middle East. They claim this because they aired Bush's statements over and over again, people despise anything GWB says so they have ignored the religious issues with Al Jazeera News and now support it as they will go against anything Bush says. Not radicals, not Taliban, not al-Qaeda, just local citizens.

They say he had no right in bombing and killing them, he ahs destroyed thier country "and now says he is making it better, yet it is far worse."

Thier views are that, people died that Saddam would have never killed and he killed more Iraqi's than necessary. NOW even those that welcomed the occupation say they are completely against it and Bush has no right to invade thier country. One man asked the reporter, "How would you like it if I kicked you out of your house and then moved into it?"

Yeah, all rainbows and lollipops! They are so much happier without Saddam, they all lived in fear.

The before and after footage of Iraq was interestng too, what were once beautifully maintained lawns in downtown areas, huge trees, fountains and great architecture, are now broken down rubble, dirt all over the streets, big holes where intricate landscapes once were. They BLAME the US for ALL of this.

They had a US soldier (some form of public relations personelle) was speaking with several members in a board room and he was saying that his commander has asked him to have the Al Jazeera News intro changed ! Here you have an AMERICAN dictating how IRAQI news is reported IN IRAQ?!? Now THERE"S censorship!

His complaint is that the 30 second news trailer shows US planes, US tanks and ends with an injured Iraqi child crying but they aren't showing how Iraqi's have been capturing and killing Americans. Thier response was that they have no photos or footage of Iraqi attacks on Americans.

The soldier said that Saddam has killed so many and yet they are defending him. Al Jazeera representatives defend it by agreeing he was awful, but it is the Americans who are destroying thier power plants, bllowing up thier buildings and fighting in the streets, not Saddam.

So I guess in the minds of Iraqis' they too agree that IRAQI IS OUT OF CONTROL.

Sure returning military personelle say it's better, better than what when you first blew the place up, I should hope so.

Sure GWB says they are rebuilding (not that they have also destroyed) and are barely getting things back to where they were.

I think GWB needs to have one of his his little pep rallies in Iraq, they sure as hell aren't buying it either. Maybe he can pop out of a big Saddam Cake or something.

One American woman who has been living in Iraq for many years says that if there was no agenda behind US news, there would be a much fairer and open report of actual reality from all sides.

The soldier who was originally assigned to get AlJazeera to change the news intro, said he was disgusted when he first saw photos of the mangled, dead American soldiers, then he started to see how equally destroyed Iraqi soldiers were by US fire and said he would never participate in such a war again. He is disgusted to see how one sided the US has been reporting the horrors in Iraq by not showing how they have equally harmed Iraqi citizens.

Al Jazeera TV has gained credibility worldwide, it has even got a better chance of making it into a Canadian sponsored TV, they showed a much reater acceptance to broadcasting 30% Canadian focused content than even FOX news as they both looked to eneter the Canadian broadcast network at the same time. I think the poeple IN Iraq are beginning to realize that just how FOX plays to US 'Americanism', Al Jazeera plays equally to Iraq's side. He said that the balance of seeing both had really opened his eyes to exactly HOW the Iraqi's REALLY feel about the USA. And he was "pretty amazed" when he realized it too.

by thelastword

Al Jazeera is the news agency showing all the beheadings isn't it? On equestion. How are all these Iraqis suddenly becoming trained in terrorist tactics? Most of this violence is from car bombings and suicide bombs. Is that something everyone and anyone does over there or is that some kind of trained terrorist mentality. I mean the 'insurgents', are they not terrorists or you feel they are Iraqis? How can theses insurgents say they are fighting the occupation when they are killing as many or MORE of their own people with car bombing? I heard, seriously that when the US attacks, what happens is that the terrorists COPY. Thats what I heard.

by legalease

Hard to imagine any news media being more biased than US news, particularly the major networks, but the "credibility worldwide" that you claim Al Jazeera has gained is misleading. Merely displaying stories not broadcast on US networks or approved by US soldiers doesn't mean Al Jazeera is any more credible or unbiased that the western sources, it's simply bias from a different motivation and agenda.

An Al Jazeera news producer was interviewed on NPR recently and asked very direct questions about several stories that were covered by Western media and Al Jazeera. It was clear from the substance of the reports (all negative depictions of US presence in Iraq) and the stammering responses of the AJ producer that 1) Al Jazeera network clearly has a biased agenda and 2) they are not telling the truth anymore than the western media are.

Al jazeera is profiting from the war like every other major media outlet. They like the increased viewers, viewers who are looking for ANY source of media other than western media. Al Jazeera is playing to their primary audience, an audience that would turn away from them if they showed any true fairness or balance in their reporting because any fair treatment of the US presence in IRAQ or Afghanistan would be perceived as pro-US and they can't risk alienating their primary audience.

If a US network began airing the same material Al Jazeera broadcasts do you think they would be able to retain their audience? Of course not. They would lose viewers, then advertisers then they'd be relegated to broadcasting on public access TV in some local market (imagine Peter Jennings broadcasting from a basement studio ala "Wayne's World").

Al Jazeera is no less a proproganda machine than the western media. AJ viewers would abandon them in a heartbeat if they aired anything that depicted the west or the US in a positive light no matter how fair or accurate the story was.

It's ironic: a media outlet exhibits an increasing bias in it's coverage of important events which then expands the number of viewers (who also share the bias) and this increase in viewers is mistakenly equated to a commensurate increase in credibility of the media outlet. Deliberate omission or misrepresentation of the facts is lying, regardless of how many people are listening.

by hal 9000

Any business only responsibility is to their bottom line and profits. Plain and simple nothing more nothing less.

Col

by oz_media

No they are not unbiased in fact, they ae VERY biased in favour of Iraq (to Western Eyes) however in Iraq, they are seen as catering to US interests. They promote many things that are considered to be going against Muslim religion or putting aside thier faith.

So I supose it is reletive, if all you want to see is the good side, you can easily find US news that will suport it. If all you want to find is the bad side, you can also easily find US news to support it.

My point being that this once hated source of Iraqi news has now become the most popular as people are THAT set against the US cocupation now, that ANY news not supporting the US is welcome.

The underlying issue is that this shows just HOW MUCH dissent Iraqi's have towards the US occupation. so anyone saying how it is all wonderful and these people are happy and much better off, needs to give thier head a shake, IRAQI'S DO NOT WANT THE US IN IRAQ. End of story, the rebuilding stats and power consumption figures are completely irrelevant. In Iraqi eyes, there was no problem there before the US intervened, now they want you out.

"Yeah but some people want us there and appreciate it" - Joe Pro-War supporter

True, but MOST do NOT want you there and feel you have no business being there to begin with, so how can you say you are helping people when they don't want to or feel they need to be helped?

It's like giving mouth to mouth o a person who hasn't stopped breathing, pinning them down and telling them it will all be okay if they just let you do this.

by oz_media

Whatever makes you feel better about the whole thing I suppose.

YOu are obviously not interested in discussing the topic it is just a lead in rant.

Have a great day, you'll need to find someone else to fuel your fire.

by hal 9000

But most likely for different reasons. While I didn't see the need to invade Iran in the first place once we went there we have to prevail and quickly as well.

Anything less will be seen as weakness and leave us all open to future attacks. If the terrorists, insurgents or whatever else people like to call them see us being bogged down they will take every opportunity to attack us and not necessarily in Iran but anywhere in the world where they think they can get away with it. The longer it takes to settle Iran no matter what type of Government the people want to more likely we are to suffer the consequences of our need to rush in without sufficient forethought about what we would do after we had successfully routed Saddam Hussein.

I do however realize why the invasion had to start when it did as they needed to be well underway before Winter in the area started because if they weren't they would have been slowed down considerably and the initial conflict would have dragged on far longer.

Col

by hal 9000

You do live in a country who's Government appoints people to the UN as well as having "Permanent Status" on the Security Council with the right to Veto any proposal that they don't like.

Perhaps you would like to see the USA withdraw from the UN and allow someone else to have their seat on the Security Council perhaps North Korea?

Col

by hal 9000

The USA did nothing to stop Nazi groups forming on the mainland USA either. There was a case where a German POW escaped from a Canadian POW Camp and managed to cross the border into the USA where he got asylum from the British/Canadian Authorities and eventually he managed to return to Germany and continue his fighting for Adolf Hitler in the German Air force driving a fighter plane.

So while you claim that the US did offer support to the British and Allies of the time they did nothing to prevent the German aggressors from building a solid base on American soil either and I'm sure if it had not have been for the bombing of Pearl Harbor by the Japanese that is how the USA would have stayed until they realized that they had to involve themselves and by then it would have been anyones guess which side they would have supported.

Col

by maxwell edison

.
The murderers commit their dastardly deeds because they don't want Iraq to to join the world of free and democratic nations; they don't want to recognize certain peoples' right to exist; they don't want to lose their "Saddam-like" strangle-hold on the citizens of Iraq; they don't want Iraqis to be in control of their own future; and they certainly don't want Iraq to hold free and open elections in January.

by jamesrl

And therefore the Iraqi government was secular.

Which put him at odds with Bin Laden.

But given the deep religious divisions in the country - kurds, shia and sunni, perhaps the only way to retain power was to be secular.

That doesn't mean the people weren't fervent, but the authoritarian government kept them in check. Note that the only place where Al Qaeda had any influence in Iraq before the war was in an area that Saddam no longer controlled, because the Kurds had achieved a level of autonomy, but had no interest in pushing out the dozen or so Al Qaeda(enemy of my enemy).

There are parrallels in Yugoslavia. Another strong man who kept it together, until his death.

I have no doubt that although the sunni and shia radicals are co-operating now, if the US pulled out rapidly, they would fight each other for power and it would be a civil war.

James Linn

by tomsal

Actually Iraq *IS* out of control...

I don't have a quote from some news site to copy and paste to prove as my source.

No...I have the tears and the 4 am phone calls from a friend of mine whose husband's team (Navy Seals) just got orders to go back to the middle east (they just got back from Bahrain in April after 8 months there).

No the news tells the truth though, Iraq is fine and so is the rest of the middle east, its all nice and orderly there and pleasant.

The stories I've heard from my friend or her husband directly....would probably make some folks sick to their stomach.

You someone believes Iraqi's really want us there and really care about the US....god you just believe whatever the press says don't you?

by hal 9000

I really think they do want the elections to be held but are currently working on scaring the general population into voting their way to bring in a Fundamentalist Islamic Government. Sought of like the elections under Saddam Hussein you can vote for anyone on the ballot paper but there is only ever one candidate.

Actually I think that they are not the slightest bit concerned about Iraq but they want to show weakness in the USA and its allies by doing this they will have won as they are exposing just how venerable we all actually are. No matter what steps we do take we can and will be attacked and if any weakness can be shown it will only serve their own ends by increasing recruitment to their organizations. So instead of only having to look out for a few thousand terrorists we will be looking for millions.

Remember that this whole thing started off in Afghanistan when the old USSR tried to retake the country for the then Government of Afghanistan and a hand full of poorly armed men managed to over whelm the might of the USSR's military. That was where the rot began and everything since has stemmed from that single incident.

Col

by oz_media

Your closing argument was actually the center focus of a documentary on Bin Laden and his building the Taliban that I watched last week.

Apparently, ater his parents and family had disowned him, he was on a mission to show just how powerful he could be. Bin Laden has lots of mental issues with how he was accepted and treated while being educated, these are spurred his need to prove his power.

After the Taliban were deemed afective for fighting of Russians, he was quoted (translated) as saying "Well, now it is time to prove to the OTHER super power that we will be in control of the Middle East, not Westerners. we will attack and show America that we canot be beaten."

So yes, once he had taken down what he suspected was a formidable force from Russia, the US was his next target to show just how powerful have was.

So this in iitself says a couple of things.

1) The USA was a target due to size and power, not Western Democracy or FREEDOMS (even though hgained through democracy and feedom).

He has a bone to pick with a country that expresses and claims it's power, (overly patriotic flag waving around the globe)which I have also said is the main reason anyone dislikes the USA. Not jealousy of not being an American, just sick of those that flaunt being American as if it is a secret society that nobody can join unless invited.

2) Considering that the Taliban and al-Qaeda have recovered, are said to be bigger and stronger than before and even regained thier territory in Afghanistan, do you not think that in essence, the USA was PROVEN to be easily defeated? Do you think that the war in Afghanistan that was ignored WAY too early was actually anything other than PROOF that the Taliban could not be stopped and just like Russia, the 'other super power' was ineffective against the Taliba too?

This has just proven Bin Laden as the hero in the middle ast, it has proven him to be the stonger man, the most clever, it fuels his propaganda about how pitiful America is.

Now they are going to prove once again, that a terror organization has the ability to bring the worlds dominant super power to her knees by simply playing a smarter game.

Suer power gets outsmarted and out played by a terrorist organization?

by hal 9000

Currently we have not had a good record in Afghanistan and even though it doesn't get any coverage the situation there is deteriorating. No matter how much I disliked the Talaban they did at least stop the growing of the poppies in Southern Afghanistan.

This is something that the COW was only too willing to allow by getting into bed with those warlords in the south responsible for its production. From where I sit we are currently fighting a war on two fronts and we hear nothing about what is going on in Afghanistan which to me is even worse than what is going on in Iraq.

Personally I think we did the wrong thing by allowing the war lords to become involved in the removal of the Talaban but then again it was a quick removal even if we did not catch the ring leaders. I can see the whole thing starting up again with another radical religious leadership starting off in Afghanistan even though it may be called something different it will effectively be the same as what was there previously.

This in essence is where we are going wrong as we are attempting to fight the "War on Terror" like a conventional war in which the taking of land is the single aim but in this conflict we are not fighting a country or countries but an idea and I think our military leaders are unprepared for this as they do not know how to fight this type of war. About the only way we could win in these two countries is to embark upon a complete genocide and then it would bring in the rest of the Muslim countries to defend their religion and the whole powder keg would explode.

What is even worse we would look like the Germans in WW11. Currently I can not see a way out of this mess and can only see it getting worse and taking a terrible toll on our troops.

Col

by oz_media

Who killed them is irrelevant. People seem to take these things and reduce them by saying it was insurgents who killed them, of course it was.

THAT's the whole point though, these 'insurgents' have been growing in number more and more daily since the US invaded. Are they just shippig more in, or are so many new recuits now stepping up to the plate to protect Iraq from American's?

The Iraqi's on last night's special were sayig that even though saddam was a bad leader, they stil had more faith in him than they do i America. So yes, they wated him removed, but if it means America moves in, they would rather be living under Saddam. HE is a Muslim, not a Chistian and they will always defend thier own LONG before even considering anything the USA has to say.

It's no diferent tha in Pakistan, where your most valued ally has explained that they will not expect thier police force to arrest people (al-Qaeda) for practicing the Muslim religion. The chief of the police said openly, he just turns his head in these situations, he cannot expect his men to arrest thier own kind, epsecially when some are even close friends. So do we start charging this police force for not dealing with thier own kind in thier own nation as outlined by US law?

So whether it is the US troops, which I am sure nobody has even insinuated, or Iraqi insurgents, th bottom line is [b]AMERICA IS NOT WELCOME OR WANTED IN IRAQ.[/b] You never were, you never wil be. The rest of the world sees this already, but the US pushes on in some valiant attempt to try and save face.

by thelastword

Basically, the 'insurgents' have killed MORE locals than the Americans. It was better under Saddamm because these 'insurgents' hadn't been unleashed on the people to kill them. Now they have been. The tactic, I believe, was to initimidate the general population into thinking that they will never have any freedom and that Saddam is coming back or something along those lines. The insurgents are fighting the US - maybe - but they are intimidating and killing the people there more. THe people there WANT the insurgents GONE. They are the one causing all the hell, on a high level you can say that yes, the US caused the insurgents to attack the people, on the other hand you can see that the insurgents were already there and now are carrying out what they were trained to do. They insurgents arent killing americans, they are killing Iraqi citizens and police so they can't be with the people. They don;t stand for muslijm either, they stand for the old Saddam training camps

by thelastword

it can be proves from this then that the insurgents have a DIFFERENT political agenda than the people or the US. Now the question of the day? WHAT IS IT? If they wanted the US OUT, then that would be one thing, if they just simply do not want democratic influence and elections than that is another thing. If they don't want democratic elections then what do they want?? Mayhem and the privelege to bomb the s**t out of everything in sight and kill whoever they want right? Can this be allowed in the world>?

by hal 9000

Perhaps I didn't make myself plain enough but I never intended it to be taken that any of the COW forces where involved in these killings/murders!

It is the "Normal" Iraqis who are suffering at the hands of the insurgents and because it is impossible to tell an insurgent from a civilian our troops must treat everyone as a possible terrorist. While not good it is a fact of life and makes it that much harder to get out of the mess we currently find ourselves in.

In all honestly it is impossible to tell friend from foe in these situations and unfortunately it tends to make a lot of civilians unhappy with what is going on.

Col

by onbliss

Oh, you must have definitely heard about the 10-40 Window that some of the Chrisitian Missionaries are crazy about :-)

Well, those folks scare the living daylights outta me too.

by oz_media

Honda claims a top speed of 170MPH, now there would be mods needed, turbo induction, possibly nitrous assist.

The kid actually DID work for a bike manufacturer/customizer so it isn't too far fetched to assume he may have modded it, but even still 205 is pretty damn quick for a professional on a track yet alone some kid on a street.

A few things that offer credibility. The bike MAY be faster than the original build of 170 (yet not without obvious and very expensive mods. unless Colin's got some intake valve tricks up his sleeve.) The kid DID work for a mod shop.

Against it, expensive mod for a STREET bike.
anyone with ANY concern for thier life would be absolutely ghost white at that speed if not on a track and under perfect condistions, a kid on the street makes me wonder.

I think it is VERY possible he was NEAR that speed, even if at the top speed of 170 MPH this may be esily tured into 205 by a cop or even the reporters themselves.

That's my two cents anyway, possible but not bloody likely.

by oz_media

reports from Iraq, show that Iraqi citizens killed DIRECTLY from COW allied fire is betwen 12,000 and 14,000.

So no matter how many citizens insurgents kill, they would have to work petty damn hard to top the 12-14 THOUSAND killed by allied coalition fire.

I wasn't trying to be rude in my last response but it didn't fit the segue in the thread. We wre discussing how there is no ability for police to do thier job as they are being terrorized, it will be impossible for them to gain control while beig constantly killed. I thought your question was to detract from the issue, sorry.

Ys insurgents have spoken out on Canadian news that they wil cease terrorizig local police as soon as the USA is gone. It is just thier way of showing the US how pissed off they ae that you ae there to begin with. A sho the other night showed MUCh unrest in the general population towards America being in Iraq. Many had said that ven though saddam was wrong for invading Kuwait, it was NOTHING in comparisson to what the Us has done to destroy Iraq. They said that even though by western standards thier infrastructure was weak, it was STILL far beter than it is now since Americans "bombed our families and homes".

They just aren't too damn happy about it, unlike the predictions of happy, smiling, welcoming Iraqi's.

Here's a quote from another private US website: U.S. IRAQ WAR CASUALTIES TOP 9,000, WHILE IRAQI DEAD/WOUNDED DON'T MATTER

It is THAT mentality that keeps America on the world's most hated list.

by aldanatech

On September 21st, Bush made the remark that "It's very important for the people of the world really to know that we are winning, we are making progress in Iraq." However, Powell said yesterday on ABC that it is getting worse:

George Stephanopoulos: Is it getting worse?

Colin Powell: Yes, its getting worse and the reason it is getting worse is that they are determined to disrupt the election. They do not want the Iraqi people to vote for their own leaders in a free, democratic election. And because it's getting worse, we will have to increase our efforts to defeat it, not walk away and pray and hope for something else to happen. [ABC "This Week", 9/26/04]

by oz_media

A collection of one liners from TV's hottest late night hosts;

10. "What's the difference between Hurricane Ivan and President Bush? We know for certain that Ivan was in Alabama." -Jay Leno

9. "There was one embarrassing moment for President Bush. When he heard there were forged documents that had been discovered he said, 'What? You mean they found my diploma from Yale?'" -Jay Leno

8. "Over in Russia, Russian President Vladimir Putin is using terrorism to increase his power and erode his people's civil liberties. It's nice to see the American way of life catching up around the world." -Jay Leno

7. "A law banning the sale of assault weapons has expired, which means it's now legal to buy Uzis and AK47s. The NRA said that now its owners can protect their families from up to 200 burglars at once." - Conan O'Brien

6. "President Bush addressed a national meeting of the National Guard in Las Vegas this week. Bush told the crowd he's proud of his National Guard service. He said, 'It was the best weekend of my life.'" -Jay Leno

5. "Dick Chaney says the economic numbers don't take into account all the people making money on eBay. Yeah, if you lose your job, you've go to sell your car, your clothes, your house." -Jay Leno

4. "Now the candidates are arguing over the exact format these debates will take. Kerry wants to stand behind a podium, Bush wants to stand behind Dick Cheney." -Jay Leno

3. "John Kerry criticized President Bush for not renewing the ban on assault weapons. Well, you can understand why President Bush doesn't want to renew the ban. These are the first weapons of mass destruction that he's been able to find." -Jay Leno

2. "The Republicans are now accusing John Kerry of using rich friends to help him get into Vietnam." -David Letterman

1. "It's been reported that a record made by a band that John Kerry was in during college has been bought for $2,500. Meanwhile, the White House said that President Bush was in a college band, but that all the records have been lost." -Conan O'Brien

by oz_media

Well while I do agree with many of our points, I think this was taken SLIGHTLY out of context.

I think teh quetsion is too brief to be a quetsion on it's own and is a result of the preceding qustion, powell did actually 'technically' disagree with Bush's statemetn but WHAT exactly is getting worse is not detailed. It may hae referred to the insurgent attacks as the election nears, or it may be based on Iraq in General, either way it isn't better anyhow.

But note Colin Powell did close by saying that mroe bombs and more troops would fix things.
errr......yeah....okay Mr. Powell, you have proven that your resolution was flawed at best, absolutely insane at worst. So the next idea is to USE MORE BOMBS AND SEND MORE AMERICANS TO DIE!

Is war like telemarketing in that it is a numbers game? Just like WWII, the civil wars etc.? Or have we actually developed better technology and increasd intelligence to avoid the one for one trade off?

Noting that more than 10x the number of Iraqi civilians have been killed by the COW than the US has had killed by the insugents. We consider insurgents to be cold blooded terrorists for killing over 1000 men, yet the west has killed more than 12,000 citizens of Iraq.

by thelastword

ok, 19,000 well that makes them about even then, the insurgents have killed about the same number. How many of the 19,000 WERE insurgents. I am simply saying get the numbers right and who's killing who. The insurgents are killing the people, the police and blowing up the infrastructure. Why? TO get the US Out, well the US wont get out until the insurgents stop killing the police, the people and blowing up the infrastructure.

by delbertpgh

Juan Cole is a professor at U. of Michigan, who appears on a lot of TV interviews as a Middle East expert. He posted the following at his blog at www.juancole.com.

9/23/2004 06:01:30 AM

Wednesday, September 22, 2004
If America were Iraq, What would it be Like?

President Bush said Tuesday that the Iraqis are refuting the pessimists and implied that things are improving in that country.

What would America look like if it were in Iraq's current situation? The population of the US is over 11 times that of Iraq, so a lot of statistics would have to be multiplied by that number.

Thus, violence killed 300 Iraqis last week, the equivalent proportionately of 3,300 Americans. What if 3,300 Americans had died in car bombings, grenade and rocket attacks, machine gun spray, and aerial bombardment in the last week? That is a number greater than the deaths on September 11, and if America were Iraq, it would be an ongoing, weekly or monthly toll.

And what if those deaths occurred all over the country, including in the capital of Washington, DC, but mainly above the Mason Dixon line, in Boston, Minneapolis, Salt Lake City, and San Francisco?

What if the grounds of the White House and the government buildings near the Mall were constantly taking mortar fire? What if almost nobody in the State Department at Foggy Bottom, the White House, or the Pentagon dared venture out of their buildings, and considered it dangerous to go over to Crystal City or Alexandria?

What if all the reporters for all the major television and print media were trapped in five-star hotels in Washington, DC and New York, unable to move more than a few blocks safely, and dependent on stringers to know what was happening in Oklahoma City and St. Louis? What if the only time they ventured into the Midwest was if they could be embedded in Army or National Guard units?

There are estimated to be some 25,000 guerrillas in Iraq engaged in concerted acts of violence. What if there were private armies totalling 275,000 men, armed with machine guns, assault rifles (legal again!), rocket-propelled grenades, and mortar launchers, hiding out in dangerous urban areas of cities all over the country? What if they completely controlled Seattle, Portland, San Francisco, Salt Lake City, Las Vegas, Denver and Omaha, such that local police and Federal troops could not go into those cities?

What if, during the past year, the Secretary of State (Aqilah Hashemi), the President (Izzedine Salim), and the Attorney General (Muhammad Baqir al-Hakim) had all been assassinated?

What if all the cities in the US were wracked by a crime wave, with thousands of murders, kidnappings, burglaries, and carjackings in every major city every year?

What if the Air Force routinely (I mean daily or weekly) bombed Billings, Montana, Flint, Michigan, Watts in Los Angeles, Philadelphia, Anacostia in Washington, DC, and other urban areas, attempting to target "safe houses" of "criminal gangs", but inevitably killing a lot of children and little old ladies?

What if, from time to time, the US Army besieged Virginia Beach, killing hundreds of armed members of the Christian Soldiers? What if entire platoons of the Christian Soldiers militia holed up in Arlington National Cemetery, and were bombarded by US Air Force warplanes daily, destroying thousands of graves and even pulverizing the Vietnam Memorial over on the Mall? What if the National Council of Churches had to call for a popular march of thousands of believers to converge on the National Cathedral to stop the US Army from demolishing it to get at a rogue band of the Timothy McVeigh Memorial Brigades?

What if there were virtually no commercial air traffic in the country? What if many roads were highly dangerous, especially Interstate 95 from Richmond to Washington, DC, and I-95 and I-91 up to Boston? If you got on I-95 anywhere along that over 500-mile stretch, you would risk being carjacked, kidnapped, or having your car sprayed with machine gun fire.

What if no one had electricity for much more than 10 hours a day, and often less? What if it went off at unpredictable times, causing factories to grind to a halt and air conditioning to fail in the middle of the summer in Houston and Miami? What if the Alaska pipeline were bombed and disabled at least monthly? What if unemployment hovered around 40%?

What if veterans of militia actions at Ruby Ridge and the Oklahoma City bombing were brought in to run the government on the theory that you need a tough guy in these times of crisis?

What if municipal elections were cancelled and cliques close to the new "president" quietly installed in the statehouses as "governors?" What if several of these governors (especially of Montana and Wyoming) were assassinated soon after taking office or resigned when their children were taken hostage by guerrillas?

What if the leader of the European Union maintained that the citizens of the United States are, under these conditions, refuting pessimism and that freedom and democracy are just around the corner?

by maxwell edison

.
If you're going to compare conditions and apply them to the USA, at least be real and tell the whole story.

Before any of what you listed, there would have been this:

1. A madman would have taken power thirty years ago - without free elections - killing anyone and everyone who got in his way.

2. He would have killed the family members of anyone who opposed him.

3. He would have ordered the invasion of Canada, taking over their oil fields, killing any Canadian who resisted.

4. He would have killed his daughters' husbands because they did not follow his orders.

5. He would break both hands and every finger of every member of the Olympic basketball team because they failed to win the gold medal.

6. He would deny rights to women - shut up and sit down and serve your husband.

7. There would be arranged marriages - and as many as a man would want.

8. Women in America would be publicly stoned to death because she "looked" at a co-worker.

9. Wait, a woman wouldn't have a "co-worker" because she would not be allowed to work.

10. Millions of people would be killed and buried in mass graves because they didn't believe in the right religion.

11. At election time, if you didn't vote for this person in power, you would be shot.

12. We would have a president who won with 100 percent of the vote.

13. The courts would be under the control of one man.

14. You would always be presumed guilty, and would have to prove your innocence.

15. The illiteracy rate for American males would be 45 percent.

16. The illiteracy rate for American females would be 75 percent.

17. About 60 percent of Americans would not have access to safe drinking water.

18. About 70 percent of Americans would not be living in even minimal sanitary conditions.

19. American children would not be vaccinated against a myriad of childhood diseases.

20. The GNP, per capita, would be about $1,600 (compared to the "real" $40,000 range).

21. America's economy would be growing at a rate of - - wait, it would be falling at a rate of twenty percent per year.

22. Only 5 percent of the population would have telephones.

23. The Internet -- What's the Internet?

24. Only 40 percent of Americans would go to High School.

25. About 20 percent of all children never go to school.

26. The 80 percent of the children who do attend grade school, only 20 percent would be girls, and they'd all be taught to hate and kill people.

27. Only 3 percent of the population would live beyond 65 years of age (compared to the "real" 13 percent)

28. The life expectancy at birth would be 65 years (compared to the "real" 77 years).

29. There would be no "minority" population, to speak of, because they would all be killed by the "majority" population.

30. A full 97 percent of the population would be Christian (or some other dominant religion).

31. The remaining 3 percent would live in fear for their lives.

32. America's legal system would be - wait, there would be no legal system.

33. The political parties in America - wait there would be only one political party.

34. There would be no EPA (Environmental Protection Agency) because there would be no measures taken to protect the environment.

35. There would be no local police departments, to speak of. The gang leaders would maintain "order" within their own turf.

36. The percent of people living below the poverty line would be - almost everybody.

37. The unemployment rate would be around 75 percent.

38. America's birth rate would be 33 per 1,000; America's (natural) death rate would be 6 per 1,000; but the population growth rate would be only 2 per 1,000 (think about it).

39. Television and radio stations would all be owned or controlled by the government - one madman.

40. The rest of the world, through the United nations, would place sanctions on America because of the atrocities committed.

41. Almost no one would have a computer.

42.....I could go on and on and on.........

But one more.

We would be watching various gang members fighting diligently, blowing up our homes, killing our brothers and sisters, attempting to keep all these conditions in place, trying to keep "liberators" from achieving their goal of providing freedom and liberty for our nation; and we would be watching the Democrat Party (in some liberating nation) attempting to undermine those efforts.

And comparatively speaking, since you are "comparing", who, in your estimation, would these "insurrection" people be? (I called them "gang members".)

by delbertpgh

Saddam was a number one crudball, not equalled by many in the world at this time. No question. He was much more of a problem to Iraq than he was to us. Now, Iraq is much more of a problem to us than Saddam was in 2001.

Did we fix anything with this war, that won't get even worse? Too early to tell. There are lots of bad signs, though. Could be civil war ahead, or permanent terrorist-friendly anarchy.

Did we fix any security threats, to the U.S.? I'd say there's no question the threats we live under today are worse.

Since we did all this primarily for the benefit of Iraqis, instead of for the benefit of ourselves, do you have any other places you'd like to offer the charity of our liberation treatment? North Korea, Burma, Iran, Sudan...? As soon as we can shake loose of Iraq, that is. Gonna take us five, ten years, maybe more. And we can't afford to cut and run, can't let ungoverned hell break out in the middle of the world's oil reserves... we're stuck.

By the way, the status of the rights of women in Sunni Iraq was better than in most other Arab countries, and in Shia Iraq, it was as bad as it is in Iran. What prevailed under Saddam has not changed. You're mixing up Iraq with Afghanistan, where the status of women has definitely improved, so long as you are measuring only the capitol city. Not much improvement yet outside of Kabul, sad to say.

by jamesrl

I don't disagree with your premise, but not sure where all your facts are coming from.

Denying rights to women - very true for Afghanistan - but not so true for Iraq. Iraq had many women in the work force, including professionals such as doctors, professors and scientists. My understanding of education is that it was fairly widespread.

As to killing millions, outside of the confines of the Iran/Iraq war, he didn't kill millions. The estimates for the Kurds gassed in the one village are 5,000 to 8,000, depending on your source. And it was during that war - the Kurds were taking advantage of the fact the war had distracted Saddam to try and assert further autonomy, and Saddam had them gassed. Shameful and dreadful yes. As to the millions killed, a large number - 10s of thousands of them were killed by chemical weapons - mustard and chlorine gases. I don't minimize any lives lost, just some people may infer that this was a genocide of civilians, which it was not.

I am not suggesting for a moment that Saddam was a nice guy. I am suggesting that certain facts have been exagerated.

James

by nd_it

From what I have been reading in the local papers here, I am sure his lawyers will get him off because there is no way to prove that he was going 205, unless they take the bike to a track and put it to the test. The patrol officer was in a plane and timed him from one line on the highway to the other, I think it was something like 4.69 seconds in a 1/4 mile? (I will have to look it up again), but anyway, even if the state patrol was off by a 1/2 second for human error factor, he would still be going roughly 180, which is still 115 mph over the speed limit, and anything over 30 mph over the limit is considered reckless. So, even though I am not sure he was going 205, he was still going plenty fast to get a ticket for reckless driving, not to mention he didn't have a motorcycle license, he will get off on a technicallity because the cop wrote 205 on the ticket, and unless they can prove he went that fast, he will probably only get something for riding without a license if that.

by thelastword

F**k thats insulting. I would venture to say that any point I try and make is just as intelligent as yours or you will see it that way after being plundered with it. Basically, you are making a very rude assumption all the time and its really insulting as you are not coming from any position of superiority on it except that maybe you research your statements on the internet, I, on the other hand dont have time to do that as I am working on a 'document' right now, but I have a pretty good memory and can recall a few basics, perhaps you lose your perspective and get caught up in details here and there. IT HAPPENS, but 'detract' from 'the issue'. There is only ONE ISSUE, this thread is all about THAT issue so saying detract from the 'issue' is obviously some kind of a personal issue youre having, with me talking about 'the issue'. Ok? So, you need not feel threatened by my little old view point, unless you feel it might change yours I guess. Pointing out that the deaths you are counting have actually been caused by terrorists within IRAQ is relevant in many ways. So far, I have seen no numbers to reflect the division between the deaths caused by american soldiers and the deaths caused by the 'insurgents', those number make the picture clearer and without them you cannot make the statement that the 'US has killed 19,000 in Iraq'. The statement is false or goes on false logic which is 'the US started the war, therefore the US caused all the deaths since the start of the war'. That is the logic of the terrorists in IRAQ, or the logic that they have you believing anyway.

by hal 9000

Well if an RC51 could pull those speeds they would be winning everything in their path so unless he had a jet fighter shoved up his arse on after burn I doubt very much that it would be possible to achieve those speeds.

But then again I suppose if there was a very long straight road and he was only caught when the bike reached terminal velocity it might have gone close. After all with enough run up it may be possible to get near those speeds.

But I would love to be in the court to see exactly how the police proceed and what evidence they offer as I personally don't think under normal circumstances it would go quite that fast.

Col

by hal 9000

I actually think that the insurgents do not want Saddam back as he was far too moderate they want to see a fundamentalists regime in place that oppress the non Muslim population the way it was done in Iran and Afghanistan.

Col

by hal 9000

Exactly the people responsible for 9-11 actually came from?

I was under the impression that none of them where Iraq citizens so exactly how does your comment apply?

As the majority of those involved where Saudi Citizens wouldn't it be a more likely scenario to invade Saudi Arabia?

Sure Saddam was a nasty piece of goods but I've yet to actually see any proof that he had any involvement in what transpired on 9-11 or was in any way involved. Actually because of the way he ran that country it is far less likely that any of the fundamentalists would have arisen in Iraq as they would have been considered a threat to Saddam and done away with.

Col

by thelastword

Maybe they dont want Saddamm back, maybe they worked for Saddamm, maybe they are actual terrorists with no cause but to make the US look bad and keep the place scre*ed up. Obviously, if they are using the citizens as tools then they are h*llraisers, maybe you are right, they just want to keep the place a wreck so there can be no organization of any kind. Thats why I think they need to register and ID people who 'choose' a side or something to that affect. All I am saying is that because of the methods used by these terrorists (where were these methods learned?), the death toll in Iraq is high. They have either directly bombed Iraqi citizens or used the people as shields when fighting. My other point is that these people do NOT reflect the majority of the CITIZENS viewpoint at all so both points OZ is making are WRONG. Not to get personal, but to keep it on track. The US is not directly responsible for all the deaths and the insurgents DO NOT Represent the voice of the people. What needs to be determined is WHO these people are, what are their motives and how to isolate them as a group somehow.

by oz_media

Maybe Iraqi citizens WON'T fly planes into your buildings, in fact I don't think they did, did they? Perhaps they knew this in advance.

Pretty anal and ignorant response Garion.

by oz_media

Well if you are talking to me, no need to be so defensive and start flaming people. I never did anything of the sort. I just mentioned that the topic is not about how many Iraqi citizens have been killed by insurgents, yes there is a WAR going on and people will be killed.

So here's pretty much the only stats I could find that separate how many deaths are suspected to be from COW fire, NOT Insurgents, this does NOT include insurgent actions, insurgents were not factored into these stats, they are insurgent free.

[b]Reports from Iraq, show that Iraqi citizens killed DIRECTLY from [u]COW allied fire[/u] is betwen 12,000 and 14,000. [/b]

This does NOT include insurgents, no insugents stats are here.

by oz_media

YOu mentiond that the insurgents do NOT represent Iraqi citizens and therefore I am wrong in saying what Iraqi citizens say.

WRONG

Actually the 1hr news report I watched was focused ENTIRELY on Iraqi citizens, not a single insurgent or protestor was interviewed. Just ma and pa with baby Ben, just like you and I normal citizens living in a country. Not radicals or insugents, IRAQI CITIZENS.

by oz_media

Actually you would be hard pressed to find ANY women in central Afghanistan who say they have freedoms. I watched a documentary on Afghan women after the war, and whilst it was SOMEWHAT better in central Afghanistan, they still wouldn't go outside without thier head covered up or they would be spit on and stoned by local men.

They are too scared to attend trainaing and schools, because the former security have been replaced by Taliban fed thugs.

Th eTaliban are even in government positions and are allowig Taliban to vote in the upcoming election, stating only 50 or 100 woud be stopped for having blood on thier hands.

So yes, Khandahar is completely oerrun with Taliban and is actually reported as being much worse now than before the war, yet things in central Afghanistan are no better for women, they speak out against the lack of forces and funding for security and now have been repressed to cease liberating themselves and get back into thier place where they belong. They are simply too scared to stand p and don't have any support or protection.

by thelastword

I believe the insult was 'detract from the thread'. Secondly, as you say, the sources are FEW and you could only find one. Thirdly, the show you watched did NOT say that the IraQI people support the insurgents or that the insurgents speak for or in support of the Iraqi people. There's that logic again, the people want the occupation to end, therefore the people support insurgent terrorism. Quite the contrary must be true, if the people want the occupation to end then surely the people must want the insurgents to stop bombing thew s**t out of the people.

by thelastword

Is that the US is LOSING THE War, not based on the number of US DEAD but based on the nUMBER OF Civilians DEAD that the US CANT Protect from the insurgents, that is how they are BEATING THE US, by killing the people.

by thelastword

Is that the US is LOSING THE War, not based on the number of US DEAD but based on the nUMBER OF Civilians DEAD that the US CANT Protect from the insurgents, that is how they are BEATING THE US, by killing the people.

by oz_media

It says NOTHING about "ALL OF THE DEATHS ARE CAUSED BY CAR BOMBS AND INSURGENTS".

In fact the VERY first [aragraph states :
[i]This database [b]includes up to 7,350 deaths which resulted from coalition military action[/b] during the "major-combat" phase prior to May 1st 2003. In the current occupation phase the database [b]includes all deaths which the Occupying Authority has a binding responsibility to prevent under the Geneva Conventions and Hague Regulations.[/b] This includes civilian deaths resulting from the breakdown in law and order, and deaths due to inadequate health care or sanitation.[/i]

Out of ALL the listed causes for each death(s), there are only a COUPLE related to car bombs, those would be insurgents, I don't think the US has began car bombing......yet.

With nearly 100 deaths ON THE FIRST PAGE OF MANY, being directly related to US Air Strikes, how can you make a comment such as "ALL OF THE DEATHS ARE CAUSED BY CAR BOMBS AND INSURGENTS"

You claim holds water about as good as fishnet pantyhose.

"Reported civilian deaths resulting from the US-led military intervention in Iraq as of Sunday, 26th September 2004"

So can you agree now that the unrealistic claim that "ALL OF THE DEATHS ARE CAUSED BY CAR BOMBS AND INSURGENTS", is simply false?

by thelastword

Basically with the number 7,350 you can probably say then that HALF of the deaths were caused by the initial attack. The other HALF are pretty high with regard to being CAUSED BY THE INSURGENCY. Look at the targets of ALL THE OTHER entires, target: Iraqi police, target Iraqi police, I would say, without putting this into a spreadsheet that HALF of the deaths in total have been caused by the insurgency. Of those, some number are the actual insurgency themselves as is some portion of the first number. Given the initial attack, minused off, the remaining part of the war has been the insurgency killing the people and obviously this is true since they have not been successful at killing US soldiers. Also, it is obvious they are killing the people directly. SO my only argument is that sitting there saying the US has caused all the deaths because the war is wrong is basically giving a free ticket to the insurgents who are actually the ones killing the people. PERIOD. Thats where the damage is being done now. That is the war and generally it was known that it would be. The question is are these people enemies to the people and shoudl be taken out by the US, now that they have started this or should the US Now just let the people face them alone or what. Saying the war is wrong is old news.

by maxwell edison

.
......was, as you said, to establish the premise by outlining the circumstances that existed before. I wasn't trying to be 100 percent exact, but merely trying to make a point.

However, the "killing millions" was a comparative number, just like that other guy did - by multiplying by a factor of about 12 to make-up the difference between the two countries populations. (Saddam killed hundreds of thousands - multiplied by about 12 because of USA's greater population - just like he did.)

The rest of the numbers, although they are certainly generalizations, came from the CIA factbook. (It's a pretty good Web site for research and such.)

http://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/factbook/

So they are all kinda' close, but I didn't take the time to make sure everything was 100 percent accurate, as that wasn't necessary to make my point. At least I didn't think it would be.

(By the way, how about nit-picking that other guy's post as well?)

by maxwell edison

.
(Not my words, but cut and pasted)

The movement for women in Iraq has greatly suffered due to sanctions and anti-women legislation imposed by Hussein's regime since the mid-90s. Under Islamic law, the punishment for a women who commits adultery is death. But women in Iraq are also being murdered for fighting with their husbands, having a relationship with a man outside marriage, and for being raped, because this brings shame on the family. Women have been stoned to death in public, disabled, disfigured and/or kidnapped. Women have even been kept hostage in their own homes.

According to the Iraq Foundation Web site "The rights of women in Iraq are going down the drain, along with everything else ... In 1998, Saddam ordered all women secretaries working in government agencies be dismissed. Now there are new laws barring women from work altogether."

Many women feel that once Saddam is removed from power, women's rights will return to Iraq. Recently a group of Iraqi women met in a Foreign Press Center Briefing to discuss Human Rights and Women in Iraq. Esra Naama stated "Saddam, right now, is terrorizing women, Iraqi women. He's using the excuse of infidelity. He's using the excuse of women being unfaithful to their husbands and the honor killing -- he's actually allowed honor killing to come back into society, where something that really, for a long time, was not in Iraqi society and I'm sure these ladies here can correct me if I'm wrong. But, once Saddam is gone, I believe that these are all things that will disappear from our society again."

Source:

http://womensissues.about.com/cs/iraq/a/iraqi_women.htm

by oz_media

Well Max I also saw that article SOME time ago while looking into womens rights in the middle east. At that time, about 3 or 4 months ago, I deemed it far too old to be relevant and also it speaks speculatively about the war AFTER Saddam but was quoted before he was removed.

So here's some updated info on Women in Iraq to put it into a more current day perspective.

As with your's this is cut and pasted, however a little more is included to retain context.

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
[b]Iraqi Women Coerced Under the Veil[/b]

"Almost two months after U.S. President George W. Bush declared major combat in Iraq over, the country is far from secure."

"On a dusty street in Baghdad, a woman named Sanaa is desperately looking for help.

She said her sister was wounded in a shooting last week, and her 15-year-old niece was killed. U.S. military officials nearby say they took her sister to a local hospital, but now, no one seems to know where she is, and Sanaa is desperate to find her.

One of the neighborhood boys, Ali, says he saw the attack. He says a man came up carrying a sports bag, asked Sanaa's sister if she was still working for the Americans, and then took out a rifle and began shooting."

"What was really behind the attack is still not clear.

But there have been numerous reports that women are being warned against working for the Americans and pressured to adhere to Islamic tradition and wear the veil. Sanaa says some religious leaders, imams, at local mosques are issuing such warnings.

On the streets of Baghdad, almost all women are wearing at least a head shawl, or hejab. That was not always so. Sanaa says she used to wear western-style clothes, but now she, too, wears a long black cloak and a hejab.

She says aside from pressure from Islamic groups, she has also heard of women and young girls being kidnapped and raped, and she is afraid for herself and for her 13-year-old daughter. She says it is just safer to wear Islamic dress."

Full article here:
http://www.voanews.com/article.cfm?objectID=2A56C25E-AF47-4E26-B7E92F0C8C166D8E

So while they PREDICTED a nice clean end and freedom for women after Saddam, just as in Afghanistan, they are still repressed as a result of religion and conformity to western ways, not saved by democracy. Leaders gone, but religious beliefs adhered to...'religiously'.

by oz_media

The first information I provided was also over a year old, however newer than the first post.

So here's a recent, small snippet from what is SUPPOSED to be a positive article about new womens right centers in Iraq.

"For their new women's center, the women of Karbala chose the name of a warrior: Zainab al-Hawraa. Sister of the Shiite martyr Imam Hussein, Zainab fought alongside him in 680, saving his young son and his legacy for future generations.
When Fern Holland heard the story, she laughed and told the women, "We want all Iraqi women to be just like her."

...But today, the women carrying on Holland's and Ourmashi's work are afraid.

Over the past few months, Iraqi women in public roles, especially those who work with Americans or in promoting women's rights, have increasingly become targets of death threats and assassination attempts."

Link: http://www.csmonitor.com/2004/0401/p01s04-woiq.html

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

"Iraqi Women Council Members and Officers Face Discrimination
Iraqi women continue to face discrimination in the aftermath of the US invasion of Iraq. Only three Iraqi women were appointed to Iraq's Governing Council and none serve on the constitutional committee. Dr. Raja Khuzai, a female member of the Governing Council, states that men avert their eyes when she talks and the leaders ignore her reports. They even wait until the female council members have left the room to make important votes, reports the Rocky Mountain News. In addition, one of the three female members of the council who was a champion of women's rights was killed this past fall. "

http://www.feminist.org/news/newsbyte/uswirestory.asp?id=8237

It must be time for the Partidge family to break out in song and make the day seem sunny again!:D

by oz_media

No I wouldn't suggest as much.

You are in there now, against the wishes of the rest f the world, I guess it ia also your responsibility to stay until order is restored. Nobody asked you to go there, you just did against everyone's wishes. So what would give you the right to stir the pot, realize what a horribl mistake it was and then run away. Sorry we already had Vietnam ad it didn't look too good.

I think you should HAVE to remain in Iraq until the wars and terorist actions are resolved, perhas the rest of the world might be able to get on with the war on terrorism in the meantime.

If it costs 500 Billion and takes 12 years, crumbling the US economy as many predicted, then that's how it should be. You don't get to just back up and start somewhere else, because you can be DAMN sure that if you aren't in Iraq, your troops wil e rushed off to fight another one of GWB's little wars on th world.

I am not the one sitting here saying it is wrong and you are killing everyone, as you suggest.

I also didn't say the INSURGENTS are responsible for ALL the civvilian deaths in Iraq, that was YOUR incorrect assertion, not mine, just remember who misquoted or made the untrue comments here before you segue to another persective.

Many of the ordinary people in Iraq have said they would rather put up with Saddam ad tehse terrorists than to watch the US do it. That tells us that NO the Iraqi's do NOT want the insurgents removed at THIS cost. Yes anyone in thier right mind would wat the bad people out, but at what cost I am sure they had no idea of what ws about to b done.

Now just think back a bit, if you had another 8, 10, 20 countries armies and intelligence supporting you, do you think you would be i such a mess right now?

If not, was it a good idea for YOUR presidet to act alone and for the people of america to spit upon those who didn't join you? Noting that these same countris many slam, ae the same countries that ARE hjelpig these eforts globally, have nowhere NEAR the numbers of troops you do and have supported the US actions in the past?

Fine mess you got yourselves into, fine mess you AND the insurgents (Better?) have made of Iraq.

now I am hearig, well what are we SUPPOSED to do?

Don't you think those questions SHOULD have been asked before telling the world to FO while you saved your country from Saddam's atack?

you say it is old news, yes it is, and yet you STILL went ahead with only YOUR best interests in mind, now that people's words have come back to haunt you, the response is THAT'S OLD? No sh*t, too bad it didn't sink in when everyone was here saying how wonderful and righteous America was and how others just don't understand.

I think the term is FULL CIRCLE? Now it has come back to bite you in the butt.

by thelastword

Its the Sunnies causing all the problems!!!! They are the ones who should be taken out then. Can there not be some way of identifying them?
The IRaqi 'people' consist only of a few sunnies and the remainder are the *urds and the sh**ts. LOLOLOLOLO sorry the whole thing is getting the best of me at this point!!!LOL

by thelastword

Except the part about them staying. Do you think if they stay, things will improve faster than if they leave? I am just wondering. I mean having the election and then getting out is one way to do it. You are on one hand saying their very presence is causing all the deaths (insurgents(sunnies) reactions, on the other hand you are saying they should stay. What the h**l should they do at this point? I am not from the US btw, remember?? or havent you been keep track of my aliases???!!!!

by voldar

You are right James, Saddam was 'secular' but at one point he was 'allowed' to be secular by some countries (here I can include also USA, USSR, etc).

I am wondering WHY in that time these countries allowed Saddam to be ?secular?...Maybe in that period they knew more about the realities from Iraq????...and now they decided to not allow this because they lost that information????

Strange!!! I don?t want to enter again into a discussion about the reasons that made the switch...what is done is done! Problem is in our face and we have to deal with it.

You are right about the civil war, but, at the end of the day...They maybe will return to the 60's stage, when Iraq was not a country yet!...Is bad? Is good? I don?t know, but in my opinion, better let them to deal with their willing in their way, than enrage all the Muslims toward you!

The parallel with Yugoslavia is 'almost' good, because in Yugoslavia was not a genocide or they were living in terror...actually, back in 80's-90's in Yugoslavia life was much better than life in the rest of eastern Europe countries!...which is far away from the reality of the life in Iraq under Saddam...but you are right when you said that that man kept the Yugoslavia in one piece :)

by voldar

Sorry for my English. Is hard when is not the first language, not even the second...and when I am saying Muslims I am not including also the terrorists...these guys must be hunt all over the world...by all nations...but I am making a difference between terrorists and the others! And in my opinion, terrorists are coming from two ways:
- People with major comportment problems
- People attracted by the idea of terrorism because they think that their way (terrorist way) solve the things that are fulfilling their anger! (This must be eradicated or limited as it is possible first! -without support in persons, the groups of terror cant gain in number...and once the number is limited, much easier is the hunt)

by hal 9000

Far to often people here are getting mixed up in the idea that the current crop of terrorists are Muslims therefore all terrorists are Muslim and all Muslims are terrorists. This is clearly incorrect!

I can not agree more with the idea of limiting at the very least the way that these organizations make themselves look attractive to those dispossessed or otherwise feel put out.

Until we can begin to work out a way to do this we are loosing and will continue to lose this current conflict. To my way of thinking we are trying to use conventional warfare techniques against an unconventional enemy so we need to have a different approach than what we currently have to win the "WAR ON TERROR!"

Col

by thelastword

I agree that the terrorists are not following any ideal that would make sense to the rest of us, or can be justified by the rest of us ie. anti-US, that is just one angle they take and I believe they will take any angle that appears to support their cause so we shouldn't say that the US has caused terrorism nor is it solely responsible for it in any way.

by oz_media

Well firstly, I don't track aliases. I have no reason to. If someoe want to change an alias daily, ev yourself with the issues you have explained, I couldn't care less. It's not my job to make sure I keep up with everyone's changes though.

Lets just pretend you're new again, WELCOME!

Well you raised areally good question, if they aren't helping now, and thy make it worse by being there, why would I expect thm to stay?

Well because I still believe that a large enough occuation for a long enough time, even if permanent, may actually prove to be effective in th end. MANY Americas will die, MANY already have to save the good name of Bush.

I think America either needs to admit they were wrong ad bit off morethan they can chew, this getting th rest of the world involved. Or they need to just keep sendig troops and sendig more taxpayers money in order to stick to thier intent.

Either way, even by laving now, they have destroyed the face of America right in front of the world for all to see. Will ayone trust America again, not for a LONG time. Should America be allowed to sae face, no I don't think so. For over 60 yars now, Americans have been the self proclaimed healer of everyone's problems. The people of America think they have done nor could do anything wrong. They think they are the good samaritans, if you will.
america is right, the rest of the world is wrong and would let thier families die,

"If it were not for the US ...(the list is too long)."

france sucks, England sucks, canada, sucks Australia sucks, Spain sucks you name it, if it is not American, it sucks ad everyone there is just jealous because they don't live in America.

the term, "you made your bed, you can sleep in it" comes to mind. istead in THIS case, they made thier bed ad said everyone else was wrog for not helpig them. Now they want everyone to help out again or they will start calling everyon names for not standing by America who has always helped others.

It makes me sick, it makes MOST people sick, this is why they get called names like arrogant and uneducated.

Well, you dug your hole, now climb out of it, you are the SUPER POWER, fix it and show the world how you are always right and righteous.

When I doubted the reasons for war here and said Canadias wouldn't support a government who acted on a NOTION, I was called every name under the sun ad said to be a cowadrly immigrant for not supporting my country. (whereas that's not at ALL what I had said). I was told I was a loser that would let my family die, that Saddam had stockpils of WMD and had used them ad WILL use them on the USA if he's not stopped (this was all in between patriots and the confused few who kept referring to planes and the WTC).

So hey, put your money where your mouth is America. The world was wrong for not helping out, yet again you don't need therest of the world as they are all just hanging onto your coat tails.

have at er, get the job done. If not they will not be humbled by the issue at all, they will just continue to blame the world for thier own failure to elect a sane leader.

by dwdino

You don't see the cockroaches till you flip on the light; then they become very active.

Someone earlier wrote that "there was less terrorism before the war". Well, when the lights are out the cockroaches are happy; and, more importantly, we don't see them.

Iraq has been a dark cesspool for at least 3 decades. When the USA ripped the dictatorship out and let some light in, the cockroaches became apparent and sprang into action.

Also, enough with the "Holy sights"! Level them and the cockroaches in them and rebuild later.

by hal 9000

To destroy the Holy Sites would start off a religious was the likes of which we have not seen since the Crusades ended all those centuries ago. And I might add one that we would loose as we are unable to withstand the combined might of the Muslim Nations.

This is what is the scariest thing that I've read here because the author lacks all respect for the normal religious followers of Allah most of who are not involved in this conflict.

You are however right on one thing the removal of Hussein has allowed these people to rapidly expand their following in Iraq as if they had of tried this while Saddam was still in power they would have been destroyed utterly and because it was their "Dictator" we would not have to suffer any adverse consequences. Now we have removed that dictator we have to put up with what we have allowed to happen in the name of religious freedoms.

Incidental I do not know if this has been reported in the US but apparently two Italian women aid workers who where kidnapped along with others about 3 weeks ago have been freeded after the payment of $1,000,000.00 US to the kidnappers and they have been taken to Rome. While it is a happy ending for the people directly concerned it sets an unholy precedent by buying back the countrymen/women and dealing with the kidnappers as they have not only derived funds to continue their current course of action but now have the idea that they can do what they want to when they like without any repercussions as well as attract more people to their cause.

I'm betting that the ransom isn't used to feed anyone but to buy more weapons to continue their destructive ways!

Col

by thelastword

Are of value to more than the muslim religion, I might add, they are of great historical value to the rest of the world. So much history was destroyed in the war that was of great value to everyone in the world, it should have been respected far more.

by garion11

LOLOL. That was quite funny Colin. Who are these Muslim nations that are more powerful than USA, Israel, India, England, France, Australia, Canada??

I agree with you on the Italian government negotiations. You do not negotiate with terrorists. If it wasn't for the passive attitude of people like these around the world (yes including the posters on Techrepublic) this crap wouldn't be happeneing right now.

Some of you are so blinded by anti-Americanism that you can't see who the bad guy really is. This appeasement to terrorists is what let Saddam and these terrorists continue their way for years. Now when USA is trying to do something about it, everyone is against it and blaming Bush. Strange and distrubing thought process.

by thelastword

That is simply stopping to their level. It makes the country doing it look bad. Going to any lengths to rescue is humanitarian, making THEM look bad. Fighting kidnappings by giving money doesnt work in the long run, it exposes that they have won and that people are out of tactics. Theay HAVE been successful in exposing that, the answer is not to turn your back on prisoners. Noone in history has been that cold. The answer is to seriously review the tactics. Its a sign that its out of control adn they have the upper hand or a good hand. Turning backs on prisoners is not a humane answer that solves anything. I don't think letting them kill off a few people will make them STOP doing it, it will show they can get away with and that the world is becoming terrorised by them. I disagree with you on this

by jamesrl

Destroying the Holy Sites would turn allies like Saudi Arabia and Pakistan against you. You would also alienate moderate muslim nations like Indonesia and Malaysia.

If you turn the whole Muslim world against the west, we run out of oil. We also destabilise Russia, India, much of Northern Africa, parts of China.

Be careful about being too proud of military might - they don't want to fight a conventional war.

James

by thelastword

Alot of them have been destroyed already. Alot of other valuable history has been destroyed without a second thought as to its value or its value to the people who cherished it as part of their ancient culture AND also their religion. We can't identify with that over here as we don't have ancient culture. It would p**s the muslims off, and it has I'm sure already. There should be no question about themm being destroyed. They shoudl not be destroyed and neither should any other countries national treasures and culture. I wouldnt be so sure Saudi is an allie. They might sell oil but thats about as deep as that relationship goes. I wouldnt trust saudi with anything or consider them and allie, thats probably why bush wanted iraq so he wouldnt have to deal with saudi and Al-Qaida, maybe thats where his logic was, get an oil country nearby so I dont have to negotiate and can therefore CUT OFF a country who harbours terrorists against the US. Hey I think that was it!!!

by thelastword

I cant understand that logic at all. Destroying the monuments by non-relious people woudl start a religous war? Nope. If the shiite monuments were destoyed by the Sunnis based on a religous premise, that would start a religous war.

by delbertpgh

Many muslims are very tolerant, but quite a few have been driven nuts with fundamentalist fever. The Shia (half the population of Iraq, and 90% of Iran) have always been crazy faithful, passionately ready and eager to die for the glory of Allah and for sake of his realm on earth, but the Sunni crackpots out of Arabia, Pakistan, and Egypt have taken the lead in extremism lately. Most of the world's Muslims are Sunni.

The division between Sunni and Shia started with Ali, who was Mohammed's son-in-law. Ali's crowd, who became the Shia, thought he should become the leader of all Islam. The Sunni faction supported other associates of Mohammed, and murdered Ali in a mosque. Ali's tomb is in Najaf, and it is pretty much the most revered place on the planet. Pilgrims come from Iran and break into tears when they see the place. They see a bullet hole in the wall, and you'd swear they were looking at a wound in their favorite son. And conspiracy theory? You've never seen anybody like Shia for believing any weird rumor.

Imagine if Mary, mother of Jesus, were buried in a tomb in Nazareth. You could go there and touch the stone around her body. That's how special this mosque is. Except, not to the Sunnis.

If we blow the place, it will be just another thing the Christian crusaders did to the realm of Islam. For a lot of muslims, Sunni and Shia alike, the crusades are something that happened last week, and they're ready believe our greatest desire is to humiliate Islam further.

Sunni crackpots would be happy if we demolished the holy sites in Iraq, because it would unify the muslims against the infidels. But, if the craziest of them were in power and was sure of himself, he would blow the mosque of Ali, just like they blew up those ancient Budda statue in Afghanistan. Because they hate Shia, as practitioners of a false kind of Islam.

So, yeah, they'd take it very badly if a bunch of Methodists from Indiana blew up their mosque.

by oz_media

I hate to keep bringig up Bosnia but it is a good example of this issue.

in Bosnia, Muslims have erected over 1200 mosques since the Bosnian war. This has gien thm nice landscapes, lawns, and beautiful monuments to replace the beaten down and bombed out stone buildings that once littered the streets.

Bosnians ae lining up in DROVES to atend al-Qaeda recruiting meetings and are 100% behind the al-Qaeda movement for many reasons including;
Cash payments to set up the families
Promised security for thier families etc.

Bombing out mosques will just encourage MANY more Iraqi's to join the ranks of al-Qadea. Al-Qaeda is recruiting in ways that would make the US recruiting offices jealous, the numbers are great, the ropaganda is everywhere and all they are seeing is footage of more Muslims being killed to further fuel thir growth.

No wonder Bush's mother is pro-choice and he is pro-life/pro-war (what an oxymoron, 'moron' being the operative word).

by ippirate

I am pseudo reposting this question from one of the other threads here on TR.

In light of this post and all the traffic it seems to be getting I would like to know why Iraq is a huge issue now. Aldantech points out the number of servicemen who have died since we officially invaded and that is something that I believe each of us should take a moment to grasp and really let sink in. However, I also have to wonder why this is a big deal now but it wasn't for the past 12 years? Servicemen and women have been rotating in and out of that region since Desert Shield and not one word has been said contrary to it until now. Thousands have left family behind to endure being shot at, having water supplies poisoned, etc. as well as having incidents like Khobar Towers. Not one word has been said and it seems to have been a-okay for the American people. Now, with an election coming up it seems to have become quite the hot topic. Could someone please explain to me why the servicemen there now are more deserving of all this attention and desire to come home versus all of the ones that spent time there over the past 12 years?

I am not looking for some half baked pseudo political rant on this and if that is the best you can give me then please don't even waste your breath. I am looking for an answer that is formulated reasonably with an honest look and inclusion of the ethics involved.

Thanks

by aldanatech

According to the New York Times yesterday, British Prime Minister Tony Blair offered an apology for his mistaken judgments about the reasons for going to war in Iraq:

"The evidence about Saddam having actual biological and chemical weapons as opposed to the capability to develop them has turned out to be wrong," Tony Blair [New York Times 9/28/04]

"In a contrite tone, Mr. Blair said he was as "fallible" as "any other human being" in his mistaken judgments on the war" [New York Times 9/28/04]

"Military action will be futile unless we address the conditions in which this terrorism breeds and the causes it preys on." Tony Blair [New York Times 9/28/04]

"I know this issue has divided the country," Tony Blair [New York Times 9/28/04]

After acknowledging the reality of the mess in Iraq and the wrong reasons to go to war, I wondered if Bush will finally take responsibility and show some sense of leadership by acknowledging this reality any time soon.

by oz_media

I have always said that BUSH just ignores that he lied/deceived the people of the world into following his beliefs.

I was reading through some old transcripts on the White House site today, he DEFINITELY assured America that Saddam was a threat to the USA and that he had ties with al-Qaeda (the hot button following 9/11). CONFIRMED reports that Saddam had WMD and was working to develop the technology further his tortures.

Bush was SURE that Saddam was the man behind the missions, he was sure that everyone was getting arms, info and support from saddam, he was sure that he had done MANY things that are now unproven.

Does GWB apologize to the people for his misinformation? No.

Did the American public DEMAND an explanation or else he would be impeached? No.

Did Bush just go on his merry way and kep up his charade? YES.

Did Blair admit to having false information and misleading the British people, YES, a long time ago and now very publicly yesterday.

He all but apologized for the war as a whole openly admitting the faults and preconceived notions were incorrect.

What has Bush done, has he been a man about it? NOPE not at all. He has slithered and slipped, pointd the finger at HIS intelligence providers being wrong, it is ALWAYS someone in The Administration that lies or deceives people, never the man in charge.

Even in cases where Bush ISN'T in control, he is still at the helm and must expect to be the fall guy, that's just the way it is.

HE screwed up, Blair came clean, Bush hides in his soiled White House and points the finger at the world around him.

Yeah, great leader, just great!

by aldanatech

Last week, both Bush and UN Secretary General Kofi Annan addressed the United Nations general assembly with speeches that sharply diverged on global policy.

Bush told UN members the world was enjoying a time of "tremendous opportunity," and praised new freedoms in the Muslim world:

"Today the Iraqi and Afghan people are on the path to democracy and freedom. The governments that are rising will pose no threat to others. Instead of harboring terrorists, they're fighting terrorist groups."

In contrast, Annan voiced a solemn warning that international law was unraveling around the world. And he took a less rosy view of Iraq:

"In Iraq we see civilians massacred in cold blood, while relief workers, journalists and other noncombatants are taken hostage and put to death in the most barbarous fashion. At the same time we have seen Iraqi prisoners disgracefully abused."

One week prior, Annan agreed with a BBC reporter that the Iraq war was "illegal." Do you think it was payback time as far as Annan was concerned? What kind of impact do you think this brings to the overall view of the war in Iraq?

by oz_media

GWb has no right to even be in office, yet alone STILL be in office.

He has a BARELY mediocre reputation as a student (C avg.), responsible citizen (DUI's), National Guardsman (AWOL and runnign scared), business man (more than one company sank under his thumb) and now is elected president with a possiblity of a second term.

As the old saying goes: "Only in America"

I think 'God Bless America' is almost a needed prayer these days.