Discussion Locked

Is it legal to restrict what language is spoken at your workplace?

0 helpful
520 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 5 of the discussion. Read the opening post

520 replies

by jamesrl

It is considered by Quebecois to be polite to try and speak french - but if they have some facility in English and they hear you fracture french, they will usually switch for you.

You will find even in very bilingual Montreal a few waitpeople who don't speak english at all. It helps that many restaurants have english menus as well as french.

Beer is biere(B air), Molson Canadian/Canadienne is popular in Quebec, so ask for "une Canadienne, si vous plait" and when you want another "une autre". The restroom is "le salle du bain", so you would say "ou est le salle du bain".

Apologies if I mess up my masculine (le) versus feminine (la). You can make that mistake and still be understood.

I don't know the appropriate terms for the strip clubs but I am sure that you could make yourself understood easily enough....

James

by computer dude

You have a point. White is a race, not a ethnicity per se.

But, in regards to non-whites, why would you suggest that they are encouraged to have blanket celebrations of their race? Asian-American this(Oriental), Hispanic this, African-American that (black) and Native American something or other. I see the distinction you've made about race, but it seems contradictory when every other person is practically encourgaged to celebrate their race, not merely their 'ethnicity'.

by prana7

guys and gals

how about sign language? American Sign Language? will it allows?

by cactus pete

"European-American" just sounds bad.

But I *DO* hear people say Irish-American, Spanish-American. Scottish-American...

As for "African-American"...That's as close to the region as some people can get for their genealogy.

Since the US is supposed to be a melting pot, why not allow those who are proud of their heritage to announce it? Who cares?

No one is thrusting those labels upon you. No one is telling you to celebrate them - they are simply celebrating themselves. That's rather American, if you ask me. Something like "the pursuit of happiness" which I don't believe you should begrudge them in any fashion.

And believe me, there are PLENTY of people in this country who proudly profess "I am an American."

by jck

as long as the policy does not delineate human characteristics protected under law, it would be legally non-discriminatory...especially in racial aspects.

Whites, blacks and asians can all learn to speak Spanish as well. As long as the policy blankets everyone, it's not racially discriminatory.

However, there's a hitch. If your company services Spanish-speaking customers, how do you provide them with your business if Spanish is the means of communication with that client base? How do you tell if they're really talking business or bad-mouthing you to a Spanish speaking client?

I agree...it's silly...let them speak their native tongue...if you're so worried, go to a public service course at the local uni, learn the language, and learn what they are saying...then, reprimand them for it if it's defamatory to the company image or co-workers.

I'm wholly in support of ideas such as the U.S. government not printing documents in 20+ languages and declaring the official language as English simply as a cost savings for the taxpayer. However, restricting what language people speak to other people is silly. If it gets your panties in that big of a bunch, personally handle the issue...take initiative...and see if there is some coversion occuring of something that is bad for the business. Then if not, you're more educated, more informed, and most importantly not worrying yourself over something/nothing.

by jck

If you are openly conversing in a public area, it is not "private" under the law. Neither language nor dialect determine the privacy of communication. Just like a letter placed on a table in an open area, conversation at that table is too open to the public.

I think free speech should not be hindered...so long as it is not a detrimental infringement on the welfare of others and is not legally in the wrong, i.e.- in the original case...damaging to the image of the company, in violation of a contractual clause, etc.

I just commented on racial discrimination because it was the sub-thread I replied to.

by stwpc

To solve the problem, why don't we speak the language depending on where we live? When in Mexico learn Spanish, when is America learn English, when in Paris learn French. Why not respect the country you are in at that time.
A whole lot of problems in this world would be solved by do this.

by wooish

I work for a city agency in NYC. We have to attend a special workshop every other year about these things. I was told that anyone working in this agency are allow to talk in their language of choice. It's a discrimination/harrasment if management tell u that you can't speak your language.

by skywalker_al

Oz, I think you have WAY too much time on your hands to be posting this much.....I have traveled internationally for the past 3 years and I speak English wherever I go when I have people traveling with me. The way to stop this is start giving Spanish lessons to employees who want them. This would alleviate any issues with these employees having the upper hand (so to speak) when talking amongst themselves.

by backleftpin

United States Court of Appeals,
Ninth Circuit.
Priscilla GARCIA; Maricela Buitrago; United Food and Commercial Workers
International Union, AFL-CIO, Plaintiffs-Appellees,
v.
SPUN STEAK COMPANY, a California corporation, Defendant-Appellant.
No. 91-16733.
Argued and Submitted Nov. 3, 1992.
Decided July 16, 1993.

Spanish-speaking employees brought action against employer, alleging that English-only policy violated Title VII. The United States District Court for the Northern District of California, Robert H. Schnacke, Senior District Judge, granted summary judgment for employees, and employer appealed. The Court of Appeals, O'Scannlain, Circuit Judge, held that: (1) disparate impact claim may be based upon challenge to practice or policy that has significant adverse impact on "terms, conditions, or privileges" of employment of protected group under Title VII; (2) employees who spoke both Spanish and English failed to show that employer's requirement that bilingual workers speak only English while on job had significant adverse effects on terms, conditions, or privileges of their employment; and (3) genuine issue of material fact existed as to whether employee who spoke no English was adversely affected by English-only rule.

by deepsand

Said ruling, if it remains in force, applies to Title VII claims only, and then only within said Federal District.

by jck

have to read the filed complaint and see the basis of what their claim was and how it applied to Title VII.

However, I think if they'd have filed in federal court on the basis that it restricted their constitutional freedom of speech, they would have won.

It would be similar to telling someone who is a DSP designer that when he talks tech to other people in his DSP group at the office, he has to describe things as "Well, the doohickie makes the thingamajig go beep beep." because they need to speak a commonly understood venacular.

Silliness if you ask me. Lady across the cubie wall from me is Puerto Rican...doesn't bother me when she speaks Spanish...of course, I catch about every 4th word...so, I know if she mentions certain things usually...today, she was talking to her daughter about their bathroom.

by deepsand

All too often, when in public places, I do wish that those around me were speaking in "foreign" languages, so that I would not be party to their inanely boring, trivial, stupid, offensive, etc. conversations, particularly when they are using their cell phones.

by pka

It sounds to me like the employees in your company need something to do. In fact this whole thread indicates a surplus of idle time. :-)

by tek

I'm a foreigner and I live by the rule that if you are in a different country you learn the language and you speak the language. I feel that I am rude to my co-workers if I run around speaking german, spanish or sweedish in my office(Yes I do speak those languages). Besides it keeps me from coming up on "weired" situations among my colleagues when they have no clue what I talk about. I got 2 kids one born in germany and one here in the US and none of them speak my native language. They live here, they speak english. If they want to learn another language they will have to aask me to teach them....

by deepsand

It seems to be that you adhere to the maxim that, if you can't dazzle them with brillance, baffle them with bullsh*t.

Would you care to try again, this time with a logically sound argument?

by computer dude

The only thing I'm trying to say is that there is a very obvious double-standard with race and what's acceptable and encouraged for different races. I don't think that anyone can live in this country and disagree with that. Look at the way race bias crimes are reported on the news for example.

And don't fall back on the 'we've had it so good for so long' excuse. That's a completely hollow argument.

by dr dij

There was a show on NGC about a north sea ferry catching fire and killing 100's of people.

Problem is much of the staff was from third world countries (Nigeria for example) and spoke little or no english or scandanavian languages.

I think for some jobs there should be a requirement that they are ABLE to speak the prevailing languages.

Also the freighter that crashed into the dock in the Gulf of Mexico (new orleans?) had same communications problems. The pilot who boarded had problems communicating with captain and crew.

While I don't think they should be able to restrict what they speak to each other, I think it is reasonable to test for proficiency in certain languages.

by dr dij

Then the paranoid boss would find out that they REALLY WERE saying bad things about him and he could fire them!

by dr dij

a supervisor says something to a person, perhaps disciplining them, or any other work related thing that they might not necessarily like but is work related..

perhaps telling them they cannot have a certain day off etc. then they immediately turn around and speak to a co-worker in language they presume the boss does not know in his presence. Lets say it is something that if in same language as boss would be insubordination.

I'm not paranoid but foreign language speakers (people who are not speaking a language that the boss understands) I'm sure sometimes do this kind of thing. What many do not realize or do not care is that much communication is by tone of voice, gestures, etc.

In some cases they may actually likely be talking about their displeasure or the boss etc.

So the end result is that some bosses are not dealing with this correctly. If they did understand it, it could be seen as insubordination.

If they don't, my feeling is too bad for the boss, he should deal with it. It is not necessary for him to understand their snide comments. Only thing required is work related communication. It is not necessary that the people like him but that they get the job done.

So I guess it still boils down to:
1) learn the language,
or
2) ignore it

by deepsand

The former deals with the content, in this case, of speech; the latter, with whether of not the content becomes known to others.

The venue is irrelevant to the former; with respect to the latter, it defines the reasonable expections of such remaining unknown to others.

by oz_media

I think I meant 'handbag'. If I had a nadbag I would also like to see it used as a hand-bag of course.

I would think it would be warm, VERY protective and rather flattering, comes in one size, XXXXXXXL. :)

by dr dij

Speak English, or maybe Spanish since spanish speaking peoples are now the majority in US!

by chrystoph

First off, your response is horridly emotional and not at all helpful to the discussion. I am speaking of legal realities, not some Orwellian scenario. Regardless of how you feel about the situation, the fact remains that a company has an obligation to all of its employees.

Secondly, you assume, wrongly, that I am not polylingual. Whether I can speak the language in question is not the issue. The issue is whether or not there is just cause and legality in enforcing one language.

Third, you insult both me and the country I live in. A sound arguement is based on logic and evidence, not belittling your opponent. Your entire statement is nothing more than harassment behind the shield of internet anonymity and emotional rhetoric.

Try this, give a good reason why multiple languages should be allowed in a work place. By good reason, I mean one that has a basis other than, "Americans are blind and lazy". I'll even help with an example: Our help desk needs to support Spanish speakers because we sell our product in Mexico, which has Spanish as its national language.

by psifiscout

The U.S. Military has a strict policy of "English only" when dealing with operational matters. Many hispanics challenged this policy in my units over the period of 1976 to 1998, none were successful. If they want to speak spanish they can but not on the job.

by jck

also publishes many documents in over a dozen languages and have office staff in some locations that speak a variation of languages, including Spanish, German, Russian, Japanese, Korean that I know of.

So...it's not all the government. Just the (sometimes) well-disciplined ones.

Besides, I can forgive the military for that. Imagine a commander in the heat of battle trying to give orders in 3 languages? Half his unit would be shot before he got done.

by deepsand

Their private speech is not regulated.

Only that speech which goes to the "business" of soldiering is regulated.

In civilian business operations, it is proper to require that employees speak a common language to the extent that such is necessary for the bussness to perform its intended function(s), but no more than such.

by psifiscout

I agree, if it is not business related it should not be a concern. But it is just plain rude.

by eric-barnett

A radio talk show host said it well: "Words mean things." The company has every right to demand that all conversations held on company property or at company sponsored business events or dealings be held in any language they (the company) chooses. As previously mentioned, this is HR nightmare.

Employees could be giving out corporate secrets, talk about others sexually, or, describing how they plan to do illegal acts. Think I am going too far off the edge? Wait til it happens; how will you feel about it then?

by deepsand

The issue at hand is the civil right of "private speech."

You may not value your civil rights enough to defend them, but there are still many who do.

If you do, you are obligated do defend the rights of others to exercise the same.

And if not, you have no right to require that others relinquish their's.

by dev-null

I dont know about anywhere else but in California:

"Employers are prohibited from adopting English only policies unless two conditions are met:
1 - There is a business necessity for the policy.
2 - The employer has notified its employees when the restriction should be observed and the consequences of violating the policy."

#1 seems awfully vague.........

FEHA does the enforcement according to the report I got (Business and Legal Reports 1-55645-001-X/83)

by deepsand

There are any number of well established tests for deciding what is or is not "necessary."

Most common are the requirements that such must be neither arbitrary, capricious, nor unjustly discriminatory.

Furthermore, such must pass the "reasonable & prudent man" test.

Note that burden of proof in matters such as this lay with the employer; the employees do not need to prove the absence of necessity on the part of the business.

by deepsand

NO one has the right to regulate PRIVATE speech, regardless of where and when it occurs.

In this country, the underlying principle is that that which is not prohibited by law is allowed.

To qoute Ben Franklin, "Any man who would give up a small essential freedom for a little temporary security is a scoundrel, and deserves neither freedom nor security."

by justjoel99

Any business has the right to regulate the speech of its employees while they are on the company clock. While you are being paid to perform a job, your speech ceases to be private and is now representative of the company that you work for. This is why a company can be held liable for sexual harassment made by a manager under its employ, and why a person can be fired for insubordination for "telling off" a superior or a customer.

Off the clock, you have every right to say whatever you want; the First Amendment gives you that right. What you are not entitled to is to be employed by any company that finds your words and/or behavior disagreeable or unprofessional.

In the case of the Spanish-speaking employees, it is simply a case of rude, unprofessional behavior. Since these employees are able to speak English, yet choose not to in certain situations, it can be inferred that they are trying to hide information from the employees (and potentially customers) that are unable to understand Spanish. This creates a divide between the employees that can erode team morale.

by cactus pete

So, do you think that the company can prevent me from scratching myself at my own desk? What about personal phones calls, if they are allowed at all, in a language other than English?

There are nuances that other languages have that simply can't be expressed teh same way in English. Besides, this isn't really about language... It's about supressing those that are different than you.

If someone has a problem with another person speaking a language they don't understand, they should either learn that language (!) or ask them, politely, to not do that in the former's presence.

If it's rude to speak a language someone else doesn't speak, then isn't it rude to go behind their backs, over their heads, and generally around the issue to regulate this without their input?

Hey, maybe they were talking with each other about the soccer game, broadcast on a Spanish chanel, and felt the context was best expressed in the original language.

Sheesh, I'm tired of the holier than thou attitude from so many people in this discussion... Go read the bible in the original language.

by deepsand

1) Your speech while "on the clock" does not automatically constitute that of an agent for the principal, i.e. the employer. Such is true ONLY when dealing with 3 parties, on behalf of the principal, and within the scope of one's authority as an agent.

2) The principal has no legal right to regulate private speech.

3) The principal has the right to regulate public speech only to the extent that such is necessary to advance a necessary purpose of the principal.

by mentzel.iudith

I'm living in Israel, so what I'm saying is maybe
a new point in this discussion.
Here, since the very moment I entered this country, the first thing I was taught was that
without speeking WELL hebrew, I cannot have ANY CHANCE to find a work.

I took this to my attention, I learnt it and I
speak hebrew perfectly.

But afterwards came the wave of the russians,
at my work we have lots of them, and they are
speaking ONLY RUSSIAN in their work relation
among each other, not to speak about their private
discussions.
And why ?
Because they don't know hebrew so that to be able
to face a professional discussion.
However, they DID FIND A JOB, not as I was told
when I came here from Romania ...

I'm not a rasist, I respect every nation and every
country and each language, but since I was a child
I was told that there is a lack of elementary
politeness to use a language that is not understood by all those present.
It is an offense.
Therefore I NEVER use any other language in work
relations except hebrew, even with the few romanians that I know they do speak my language.

The russians have become kind of a "party" inside
the working place, I have a strong feeling of
they being preoccupied to help each other only
and to leave intentinally out all the others from their society, so that they "as a group" be able
to achieve professional statuses inaccessible to
the others, in spite of their being superior as
professionals, besides the hebrew knowledge.

This is injust !!!

I think that in every country and every company
it's a natural requirement that the national language of the country be the only one spoken,
no matter what and no matter whether this is
convenient or not to anyone.

From a "discount" made to the hebrew knowledge
as a gesture of "good-will", this has very easily
become an "arm" of defending "the russian party"
in the work relations, and this is equally unacceptable both for native hebrew speakers, and for non-russian immigrants.

Iudith

by deepsand

It is important to make the distinction between the two.

Public speech must, as a natural matter of course, be in a language understood by the public body to be addressed.

Private speech, being NOT intended for the public, is not so constrained.

No one has a right to demand that they understand the private speech of others. If someone chooses to use a "foreign" language, signing, codes, etc. in an attempt to maintain privacy, such is their right.

by mentzel.iudith

Yes,it's ok to use any language in private relations, but any such private discussions
should not take place in a public place, and even
less in the working place.

I talked about using a "group private" language
with the clear purpose of excluding the non-speakers from the group, where group is A GROUP IN THE WORKING PLACE and its discussions are
work-related.

In any case, no matter what the subject is,
speaking inside a room at full volume in a language that not all those present understand
is definitely a lack of politeness.

Private discussions should take place in private
places, where ANY language can be used without
disturbing anyone.

by mjd420nova

I was once employed by a company as a test director testing manufactured control panels for
nuclear power plants. The process ran 24/7 and
shifts overlapped to allow for the exchange of
information regarding problems and where in the process we were. Initially the shift change was verbal and written in Vietnamese as the inspectors and testers were predominatly Veitnamese. This came to a screeching halt when
the then AEC (Atomic Energy Commission) wanted
to reveiw these logs. I know I wouldn't be happy
trying to decipher the logs or had to sit in on
meetings that I couldn't understand. During
personal times, breaks and lunches I could care less, maybe they aren't happy with the english
speakers that they couldn't understand us. First, how do they get these jobs if they barely speak the language?? In California there are
so many languages spoken, Spanish, Vietnamese,
Tagalug, Farsi only to name a few. This has even
reached into the DMV tests and voters ballots.
An example I see all the time is how few immigrants understand the meaning of YEILD and MERGE. Few born and raised here understand the difference and comprehend their meaning.

by oz_media

Nice story, but the topic isn't about what language is used to communicate while working or when sharing business information between employees.

This is about people using their native language while speaking amongst themselves, at lunch, on coffee, in the halls etc.

As for the California's acceptance of ethnic diversity, congratulations. Canada is very much the same, in fact I would say there is probably a more noticeable population of NON-English speaking residents in BC as the population is far smaller and more condensed into Vancouver.

Isn't this also what makes out country's the great, diverse and free places we have always bragged them to be?

by deepsand

What has this to do with the issue of an employer trying to regulate private speech?

by computer dude

I'm a white male. I don't qualify for Civil Rights.

And it's not my duty to protecy anyone else's anyway.

by jbaker

Texas labor laws are slightly different than elsewhere in the country. One thing that Texas says is that when a company defines a labor policy, it must stick to that policy, no matter what it is. So, if a company wanted to make its employees work 20 hours with one fifteen minute bathroom break, and no lunch, then as long as they observe that policy throughout the company it is okay. On the otherhand, if that was the policy, the company would have no employees, so it balances out. Companies define what is basically a balance between them and the employees to establish an acceptable workplace.

by deepsand

There is nothing in either our laws or our heritage that even suggest, let alone supports, your position.

And, talking excessively loudly in ANY language can be uncivil under certain circumstances. That, however, is NOT the issue under discussion here.

by deepsand

And, all citizens have a duty to defend such; to do otherwise is to ensure their erosion.

by computer dude

I can be legally disqualified for a job or a University position because I'm a white male.

As I said, I don't qualify for Civil Rights. Wrong skin color.

by deepsand

Such is a violation of the Civil Rights Act you refer to.

However, successfully prosecuting a case of such very much depends on the venue in which it is tried.

by deepsand

they should not have been hired.

However, the issue here at hand is private speech, not that publicly required for the purpose of executing necessary business functions.

by computer dude

Someone here in VA didn't get the memo, because every time I turn around Affirmative Action is still being crammed down everyone's throat. We have policies on the books here to indicate that AA is still alive and well. I don't know how it is in PA. Please show me some documentation stating that AA is against the law.
I was probably dreaming last year when the US Supreme Court upheld racial discrimination on US campuses, so long as the person being discriminated against was white.

This is why I say, again, that I do not qualify for Civil Rights.

In fact, if you are opposed to AA you are a racist bigot.

by deepsand

Proving reverse discrimination based on race is no more easily done than is proving age discrimination; and, in each case the burden of proof rests with the claimant.

Only recently has there been any move at the Federal level to lower the bar in the case of the latter; unless and until such happens for the former, we White Niggers are sh*t out of luck.

Very interesting; the "N" word escaped TR's PC police!

by computer dude

Is not something that needs to be 'proved'. It's policy written in black and white. We have people whose job duties revolve around enforcing it. Deepsand, I'm not sure you and I are from the same country because AA is the law down here (yes I'm bitter about it). Are you from PA in the US or somewhere else?

by flyers70

I think this issue is a non-starter. As long as the employees in question can speak the language that business is conducted in, it shouldn't matter what they speak at other times, whether at lunch or chatting with friends at work.

That said: I agree with folks that it is rude to speak a different language in the workplace around people who don't know that language. But I write it off to just that; rudeness. I don't believe workplace legislation is necessary to combat it; you just need to get over it. It's really no different than if there are 3 people in a room and two of those people start whispering to each other.

by tomsal

Firstly I was just checking back in or this post right as I head to lunch. I agree with you. Like I said to someone else earlier on...I posted this for discussion value. Btw, if anyone cared to know how this turned out -- the company didn't move forward with this policy.

Flyers70...I'm also a Flyers fan, can't wait for the NHL to get their act together and have a season!

Don't know where in Cherry Hill you are, but I'm literally straight down the road from the Cherry Hill Comcast office -- about 12 minutes away.

Small world.

later man.

Go Flyers

by deepsand

Note the distinction that I make here between civil & Civil.

We all have civil rights under our Federal & States' Constitutions.

There is also the Federal Civil Rights Act which, in its application, frequently makes a mockery of Constitutional law, as do all too many Federal laws.

So, while we have civil rights, the Civil Rights Act & others make it difficult for some to exercise their civil rights at all times and in all regards.

And, since Federal laws & Regulations are enacted & implemented by the Federal government, which represents the Federal Sovereign, we can sue only in the Federal courts, and then only if the Sovereign waives its immunity.

The only other way to prevail is for the US Supreme Court to agree to hear the matter & overturn those portions of the Law and/or Regulations that violate the US Constitution.

So, we have civil rights, but they are often of little or no use to many of us.

The irony is that the Civil Rights Act was intended to ensure that minorities were not denied the exercise of their civil rights, with the unintended consequence that some non-minority citizens subsequently found that they has lost the ability to exercise theri civil rights.

Hence my reference to White Niggers in my previous post.

by computer dude

and more emphasis is actually given to someone's merit and skill instead of their skin color and their minority status, then I'll come around to your way of thinking.

As it stands now, reverse discrimination is the law where I live.

by deepsand

, as practiced, not intent of the law itself.

In case it's not clear, I do concur with you re. merits vs. entitlement.

by computer dude

Is precisely the reason that I'm apposed to AA. But I think that some politician with some good sense will eventually lobby against it and the ball will be set in motion.

I do not accept responsiblity for things that happened to others in the past, and I will not be held accountable for it.

by computer dude

Is precisely the reason that I'm apposed to AA. But I think that some politician with some good sense will eventually lobby against it and the ball will be set in motion.

I do not accept responsiblity for things that happened to others in the past, and I will not be held accountable for it.

I do have to object to deepsand's point number 4. In this nation and others, you are asked to deny your ethnicity if you are white; if you are a minority then you are encouraged. I also resent that.

by deepsand

reparations.

Actually, if we are going to do it objectively, based on economic effect, and if we get the accounting correct, many of them will end up owing us!

by deepsand

"Would you be better or worse off than you are now, assuming that you would even be alive, were you not a descendant of a slave?"

by computer dude

....you can't ask if they would be better off or not. That question would require a common sense answer and it's not fair to ask that from some people.

by deepsand

That they may lack common sense does not at law make them part of a protected class.

Therefore, their inability to to provide a substantive response does not discharge their obligation to so do.

Bottom line - the burden of proof is on them.

by deepsand

Common examples of such classes are groups defined by race, ethnicity, age, gender, religious beliefs, etc..

Not all such classes have equal protection at law.

Each law that provides for one or more protected class both defines & enumerates such.

For example, under the Americans with Disabilities Act, one's religious beliefs have no legal standing. Only those who meet the definition of being "disabled" fall into its protected class.

In instances where neither the empowering statute nor the implementing regulations provides for a sufficiently well defined definition of the protected class(es), it falls to the courts to determine the intent of the legislature which wrote & approved the statute.

A present example is the as yet to be decided issue of whether or not a smoker, by virtue of his addiction to nicotine, a legal drug, shall be considered a member of the protected class, as are those addicted to illegal drugs.

by computer dude

...by virtue of some unchosen physical characteristic or some silly little idiosynchrasy, can be part of some sort of protected class. I assume this is where hate crimes laws come into play.

Sounds a little overly-bureacratic to me.

by deepsand

Your deduction is correct.

So called "Hate Crime" laws are naught but an attempt to punish one not only for the ACT committed, but also for committing the act against a specific CLASS of persons.

So, given that such occurs in a jurisdiction with the appropriate statute(s),if you beat the crap out of, for example, a homosexual, you face a stiffer punishment than if the victim were heterosexual.

Personally, I find such laws exceedingly offensive, because:

1) They are unnecessary, in that the penalty phase of a trial is supposed to determine any mitigating and aggrevating circumstances germain to the determination of just punishment; and,
2) Just as do mandatory sentencing laws, they usurp powers that are to be reserved to judges & juries.

They are not unlike Statuatory Rape laws; she may have consented, even lied about her age, but the law says she's too young to legally consent. Result - you get screwed again.

by elliottlynne

Just learn some choice Spanish derogatory terms, and only become concerned if you hear them.
You can not force them to speak english to each other.You can force english as the workplace language.
But always check with your local laborboard fist.

by jaimergonzalezh

I don't think speaking other languajes at the office is wrong. I agree with TomSal about the fact that if somebody is going to talk bad about me he/she should just go and say it instead of hiding behind a languaje barrier. Besides, multicultural businesses is the way the world is going, any person that doesn't speak at least two languajes will be left behind having tons of other people that do being a menace to his/her work. Instead of banning people from speaking in other languajes, HR should promote the study of new languajes as a company's benefit. I think it is a step back for people's professional growth not to do so.

by jdclyde

If you need to converse with a client who only speaks something other than English then this is a boost for the company.

It just randomly having people around the office talking in any language is NOT a benifit to the company in ANY way.

If it doesn't benifit the company, it shouldn't happend in the company.

Breaks and off time is the employees personal time to do as they wish.

by joe mctroll

People from the USA are usually very ignorant of the world's reality outside their country. They expect you to speak to them in English whenever they get out of their country, and they want US to speak in English if we get into theirs...

By the way, calling "American" someone from the USA is blatantly incorrect. "American" is someone who comes from "America", and last time I saw the map, "America" is the name for no country at all, but a whole continent.

Thus, Mexicans, Brazilians, Peruvians, etc. are as "Americans" as the people from the USA ("gringos" or "yankees" or whatever) I don't care if the USA hasn't developed a right term for describing it's own people, I do care for them hijacking the term applied originally for the people from this continent

by chipmicro

On my laptop I have a wireless network adapter, and a network card for a wired connection. With both, I can hook into whichever connection presents itself.

In business, strategy is everything. My suggestion which, by the way, I have done, is for the management of the company to learn Spanish. If the managers know Spanish, then what is being paranoidly referred to as treason will become a touchstone for closer employee relations, since learning another's language is a sign of respect.

Hard work? Sure is! So is dealing with Microsoft patches that lock you out of your own box, or budget meetings, or user one-on-ones. In a business sense, saying, in effect, "My card doesn't hook into this protocol," is a surefire way to know you're on your way out of the market. Just a thought...

by mdiaz

In my company here in Puerto Rico, two guys are English-speaking only. Do you think they are willing to learn Spanish to comply with such an insane and racial-oriented proposition? Not think so...!

by peon

How is it living in the 18th century ? You sure miss those boat rides to Africa and back, don't you ?

I appreciate that I live in a civilized state, not the US or wherever you are !

HERE in Germany breaks are part of my work contract with a US outfit. Business language is English and yes, when someone makes derogatory remarks about me talking German to coworkers, I just tell them to learn German if they want to understand me. If I deal with them directly, I'll speak English.

And no, the company DOES NOT OWN me. I will not jump off the bridge, just because a moron manager tells me so. ;-(((

If I ever should encounter SUCH an employer as you describe it, I'll tell them what I think in plain English and leave.

by chipmicro

Ein Paar gute Punkte, aber diese Ideen wegen 'Zivilisierung' und wie es in den US geht (bzw. nicht geht) sind ganz und gar vom Pferd!

Wenn Sie in Deutschland den T?rken richtig behandeln, und denen aus Jugoslawien, und nicht mehr Gift gegen alle Amis ins gesamt plaudern, DANN d?rfen Sie von Zivilisierung jammern!

Passen Sie mal auf - egal ob es unglaublich ist, ohne uns gibt es keine EU mehr. Und eben so f?r uns mit euch! Wir sind Geschwister-Staaten - daher wurde den EU erst als Wirtschafts-verbund geschaffen, um mit den US-Dollar egal gemessen zu sein.

Der Mensch soll mindestens lebenslang das Beste von anderen erwarten. Falls jemand verarschung macht is das von denen gemacht, nicht ihren Land oder Kamaraden! Wir sind im Form ?nhlich, vielleicht eines Tages werden wir auch in gleichrechtigkeit so sein!

I am the sum of my parts, not the lowest common denominator of where I live. True civilization cannot exist where lines on a piece of paper are allowed to confer significant quality differences, either positive or negative. In other words, don't hate me because of where I was born, or the hard work I do, and most definitely don't judge me when you don't know me.

Sweeping generalizations have caused mass pain and suffering throughout global history, gell?

by cyberoptiq

nor should it be. When we visit other countrie's like Japan, the japanese do not tell us to speak japanese because we're in their country. Same applies to any other country we visit. I once had a manager tell me to speak english in the workplace because I was speaking to someone in Spanish and I told him that the United States is a free country, I was born here, a veteran of the U.S. Navy, and that I have a constitutional right to freedom of speech. He turned red, did an about face, and I never heard anything more from him concerning my speaking a language other than english in the workplace.

by saher

En primer lugar en Latinoamerica y el Caribe se habla CASTELLANO no ESPA?OL. Y realmente a ti te falta mucho para entenderlo y mucho mas para escribirlo correctamente. El hablar un segundo idioma es beneficicio no solo para el individuo sino tambien para la compa?ia en que trabajas. El hablar mal de un compa?ero de trabajo o alguna politica de la compa?ia no es nada nuevo y se hace en cualquier idioma. Lo que pasa es que la curiosidad e interes de enterarte de lo que pasa es bien grande. Asi que el aprender uno o mas idiomas es bueno.

by jonathanpdx

Canadians are Americans. Mexicans are Americans. Venezuelans are Americans. Chileans are Americans.

Perhaps you meant to say that you are a citizen of the United States of America (note that our nation has no official "name" per se, only a description of what it is, namely a collection of States united under a centralized government.) More correctly, you could say you are, for example, an Arkansan or Texan or Washingtonian, but still an American, too. Or perhaps you could call yourself a United Statesian of America!

As far as a language, I speak English and a smattering of a few other languages as well. I'm not so ignorant to think that everywhere I go, everyone should speak my language. But if I were to go to Spain to live, I would be expected to learn Spanish. In France, to learn French. In Thailand, to learn Thai, etc.

Why should we be any different here in the United States? Our official language should be English. It should be incumbent upon anyone seeking to gain citizenship or to do business within our borders to learn our language, as we would be required to do elsewhere.

As far as inthe workplace, if two people can communicate better with each other in Spanish or Chinese or Mongolian, who cares? So long as they can comunicate with me in my language when necessary. If we're afraid they're talking about us behind our back (or right in front of our face), then perhaps we should not give them anything to talk about. Better yet, learn their language so we know what they're talking about. They don't have to know you know...and just think how fun can that be!