Is it legal to restrict what language is spoken at your workplace?
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by deepsand
Is Canada a signatory? And, what of the U.S.?
And, which Court(s) have Jurisdiction for purposes of 1st receiving & trying cases involving allegations of violations of the cited Law?
by deepsand
But, such attitudes are not limited to the iisue of "free" speech.
It seems to be part of the human condition that all too many people expect more liberty for themselves than they are willing to allow others.
There is a saying that "Your right to swing your fist ends at my nose." If only more people would understand this, and apply it to themselves.
by deepsand
Given the contentiousness of the matter, as witnessed by this discussion, continuing to pursue the matter would have been akin to wading into a swamp filled with alligators.
And, remember the adage that, "When you're up to your ass in alligators it's difficult to remember that your primary objective was to drain the swamp."
by warnerit
by oz_media
The MAIN post is regarding whether or not it is LEGAL to stop someone speaking in their native tongue AROUND the workplace.
Well whether or not you agree with how racial discrinimation is defined, it is a matter of international law. The law has CEARLY defined it, even referring directly to language.
It is not debatable whether or not it is legal or racial discrimination. It just isn't, as outlined IN the law.
by oz_media
You cannot discriminate based on language spoken around the workplace. Obviously you CAN dictate what language is spoken to communicate within in the business and to the company's clientele though.
This is a no brainer, I don't believe that some people actually feel you can. Ask a lawyer next time you meet one if THEY would take a case as a racial discrimination suit. Yes, it will be settled out of court, that doesn't make it legal.
by oz_media
As I've said before, it would never make it to court. A VERY quick out of court settlement makes for gravy for most lawyers over these issues.
I have faced this stuff, I have been a facility manager for a major call center, we fired people by the dozen every Monday, this suit is raised ALL the time. People say they were fired for having a foriegn ACCENT, yet alone SPEAKING another language. It never makes it to court, the company quickly coughs up a few weeks pay to help them along and that's that. They KNOW it''s a lose lose situation, the lawyers know it too.
That still doesn't make it legal, which was the initial question asked. If I am in the company crapper speaking in Swahili to another coworker about how horrible the company is, they have no grounds to fire me other than dissention and a negative attitude towards my work.
by deepsand
If you read my other posts here, that would be clear.
I am simply seeking specific information re. the International Law which you referenced.
by oz_media
The US is signatory of international laws when it comes to torture.
Abu Gharib (sp?) is just one such example. Bush acknowleged how wrong and against US/foreign policy this is, Geneva Convention
It is also to see the acceptance of such a law as America doesn't want it's OWN prisoners tortured overseas.
Racial discimination, if the US DIDN'T accept such international law, how would they then claim to support equal opportunity free of racism?
I have yet to see an international law that the US hasn't supported, as it is, these laws are usually fought for BY the US anyway.
So I would have no reason to say that they aen't signatory on ALL international laws, as they do participate in supporting such prectice as international law, without it, they wouldn't be able to 'whip crack' to support their own means of international trade.
TomSal,
Good point to defend the HR person's persona. With my remarks, I qualified the idea, and not any particular person, as "stupid".
I don't think that you may find loads of people chatting in Cajun these days, it was just a florid way to make a point.
But the SAP guys speaking German is a possibility closer to home.
By the way, what would any of the navajo code-talkers make of this idea, being the fact that they made an enormous contribution to America in WWII by not speaking in English?
Saludos, GEN
by oz_media
by oz_media
Will American laws restricting such practice be more understandable then?
"[u]When Can an Employer Require an Employee to Speak Only English at Work?[/u]
The EEOC generally views "speak-English-only" policies as being illegal under the Civil Rights Act unless justified by business necessity. However, a recent case in California refused to follow the EEOC Guidelines on these policies, instead holding that English-only rules must be evaluated on a case-by-case basis. (Garcia v. Spun Steak Co) (16)
This decision came in a case where two Latina meat processing plant workers were disciplined for speaking Spanish on the job. Under this ruling, which applies to California and eight other western states, the court stated that an employee may challenge a "speak-English-only" policy in the workplace under federal law if:
1) the rule is applied to employees who speak no English or who have difficulty speaking English; or
2) the policy creates, or is part of, a work environment that is hostile toward national origin minority employees. Examples of a hostile work environment would include, for instance, the rule being applied in a very harsh manner, or a pattern of harassment in addition to the English-only rule.
If an employee is able to show that either of those conditions applies, then [b]the employer must show a "business necessity" for the policy -- that is, that the rule is "necessary to safe and efficient job performance," [/b]and that there are no other alternatives which would serve the employer's legitimate interests with a less discriminatory effect. (Dothard v. Rawlinson; Griggs v. Duke Power Co; Civil Rights Act of 1991) (17).
[b]The business necessity standard is hard to meet.[/b] Unless an employer can show that the work in question genuinely requires that communications between employees be in English (as opposed to any other language), that all workers must be able to understand all communications between all other workers, and that the consequences of a lapse in communication are serious, [b]it is unlikely that the standard can be satisfied.[/b] "
"as recently as 1991, the court ruled that in some cases, language-based discrimination should be treated as race discrimination"
"Other courts have also protected the right of language minority groups to be free from discrimination. Those courts have reasoned that even if language and national origin were not synonymous, language-based discrimination disproportionately harms national origin minorities and can, for instance, violate Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits workplace discrimination because of national origin."
So whether you view international law or US federal law, it is still viewed as illegal as well as a breach of rights, whether civil rights, racial discrimination or language discrimination.
It is unethical, poor business practice and illegal. Thus the initial question is answered quite clearly. Given the circumstances provided, there is NO grounds for this company to claim it "genuinely requires that communications between employees be in English (as opposed to any other language), that all workers must be able to understand all communications between all other workers, and that the consequences of a lapse in communication are serious,"
This is an issue of employee dissention, nothing to do with business or effective communictaions issues between workers.' Just a dialike for foreign chatter. In the casewe are dealing with here, this is even HARDER to enforce as we are discussing language spoken outside of conducting business with clients or employees. An even weaker straw to grasp than the weak one you MAY grasp in 'specific' situations.
by oz_media
60 years ago we had proven the importance/potential benefits of language diversity in America.
Today we argue it's place in business.
I certainly feel sorry for the minorities that are faced with this mindset daily.
But hey, America is the most multicultural country on Earth, no racism there.
But in this case, it mat NOT be America, just reluctance of accept culture/language/racial diversity by it's citizens.
by deepsand
by rbernal
by bhunsinger
Oz read your post. First there must be these conditions:
1) the rule is applied to employees who speak no English or who have difficulty speaking English; or
2) the policy creates, or is part of, a work environment that is hostile toward national origin minority employees. Examples of a hostile work environment would include, for instance, the rule being applied in a very harsh manner, or a pattern of harassment in addition to the English-only rule.
As sety forth in the rule, the activity being targeted were those with good english skills not using them. The issue is hiding discrimination by saying language.
Please note: I am discussing what is legal, not smart.
Also note, Those of us in the United States DO believe in maintaining sovriegnty. Our Constitution requires that all treaties be viewed on the same level as contitutional requirements, prempting laws enacted by Congress and the various state legislatures. If we sign and ratify a treaty, provisions of it can be enforced in court.
by bhunsinger
Freedom of speech is a limitation on government- the government is prohibited from limiting your speech. Workplace rules are subject to the states as well as federal gov regulation of what a company can dicipline you for. Much different standard.
Also, Freedom of speech is not 'granted' by the various constitutions, It is just a clear statement of what the Government is not allowed to do.
by deepsand
True, US Constitution Article VI states "This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in Pursuance thereof; and all Treaties made, or which shall be made, under the Authority of the United States, shall be the supreme Law of the Land; and the Judges in every State shall be bound thereby, any Thing in the Constitution or Laws of any State to the Contrary notwithstanding." However, the USA has not ratified all treaties that make up the body of International Law. For example, Kyoto and Law of the Sea treaties have not been ratified, and the USA does not recognize the jurisdiction of the World Court in Belgium over citizens of the USA. I do not know if the International Law quoted by Oz was ratified by the USA or not, but our internal laws are sufficient to handle language discrimination in the workplace, and may be in compliance anyway.
The American people need to be vigilant whenever a treaty comes before the Senate, because of the danger they might ratify a treaty that takes away our hard-earned freedoms. I would be in favor of amending the US constitution Article VI so that its provisions apply to US law as long as the provisions do not infringe on the rights of American citizens and the relations of the Federal government with the states, as defined by the constitution, and that treaties ratified by the Senate may only concern international relations and have no power to enforce or overrule internal affairs and laws. Article VI has the danger of allowing the Senate to have a "back door" amendment to the constitution passed by ratifying a treaty. For example, an international arms treaty would be valid, but any treaty regulating what American business can produce and sell within the boundaries of the United States would be invalid under my proposal. Such a change would protect our sovereignty.
by oz_media
I knew SOMEBODY would pick up on that, thus I highlighted the issue about how next to impossible that is to take as a defense.
There are VERY tight and VERY strict rules in place and it is POSSIBLE that they could be ignored but not quite as simply as you seem to think they are. Read it again, that premise, especially in this case do not apply.
The section I looked up was about four pages long, far too much to include here. A link isn't available in this case as I took it from a law library and cannot share login info. Yet I am sure you can look it up yourself and find reference to it, law is law afterall.
Here's the part you failed to take notice of:
"If an employee is able to show that either of those conditions applies, then the employer must show a "business necessity" for the policy -- that is, that the rule is [b]"necessary to safe and efficient job performance," and that there are no other alternatives which would serve the employer's legitimate interests with a less discriminatory effect.[/b] (Dothard v. Rawlinson; Griggs v. Duke Power Co; Civil Rights Act of 1991) (17)."
Unfortunately, a case of telling people they cannot speak a foreign language in the lunch room or halls of a building hardly falls into this. The employer doesn't even have a SLIM chance of having a law BENT to suit his needs unless, they can show a "business necessity" that enatils how this is "necessary for safe and efficient job performance".
In other words unless your company is an Air Traffic control center where a different language would restrict the employee from doing their job safely, or if your company is an ALL English company and ONE employee can't train others due to a language barrier you have no leg to stand on, as in the case cited at the beginning of this thread.
THIS issue is because people don't LIKE others not speaking English AROUND the office, specifically stating that they do conduct their jobs properly.
You'd be sued in a heartbeat and they would laugh all the way to the bank.
by oz_media
You are trying to say that such discriminatory laws as written into US law do not apply in the US?
Are you trying to say that the court does not see it as racial discimination? Which is has and does.
Or are you trying to say that you can decribe the effect of US law in comparisson to national and state laws, constitutional laws?
The bottom line here is, you CANNOT dictate what language is spoken around the workpalce. In MOST cases, save but a few very strict accpetances, you can't even dictate what language is spoken IN the office between employees.
Your own laws show a much stricter standard than those I had originally outlined that protect language spoken away from the office. Your own laws state that you can't even discriminate against what language is spoken INSIDE your office unless in VERY specific cases and those are determined on a case by case basis, in which it clearly states that it is NOT in the employers favour to even try as much.
The only acceptions relate to safety and communication restricting efficient business. This hardly says that you can dictate what language is spoken AROUND the office and even between employees.
So if you wish to argue your own country's laws, certainly you have a senator you can offer YOUR interpretation of what the law means.
by jbalingit
by oz_media
It is not a matter of ethics or concience.
The US has employment laws as well as federal and civil rights and international laws they abide by to ensure equal treatment/freedoms in the workplace.
It's black and white and there's no guess work involved that way.
by deepsand
The ensuing discussion re. treaties & jurisdiction is why I asked the question in my post at
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=168447&messageID=1723307
by oz_media
That is a pretty outlandish question as we are talking law here, not NAFTA or Alliances. It is the same as saying that State law in California and Oregon having the same guidelines would make either signatory of the other state.
Canada is signatory and so is the US when it entails abiding international law, for the most part, if not just by specific laws that are then adopted and ammeded within the country in question. More importantly, when it suits their needs.
I know you all feel that America is a lone outlaw and leader of the world unlike any other, news breif: we are all in the same global melting pot and you are part of it too no matter how well you cover your eyes.
RANT WARNING: It seems that ANY time something is raised, regardless if it is IT related, Business related, ethical or race, Americans seem to feel they are immune to the rules that the rest of the world follows. If that's the case, PLEASE catch your own damn fish and leave our habitat intact, we've lost enough to US greed already.
Forget NAFTA, and forget allied support. It's over...you are one.
Sorry, but I am getting REALLY tired of the 'too good to be you' and the 'holier than though' mentality spewed from America daily. Until it comes to global issues thrn American's want to measure themselves against others to show how much better they are, it's a mental sickness and nobody buys into it but you guys.
HOWEVER, whether or not either is signatory of international law is completely irrelevant. International AND US law states this is illegal and the US follows BOTH in this case.
STATE laws and constitutional laws WITHIN and SET OUT by the US or state, dictate that this practice is deemed illegal and has VERY few avenues for an employer to escape.
As for the Court and or jurisdiction, that is a matter up to the Plaintiff's lawyer.
In the United States laws are really silly in most cases, they vary by state, the trial can be moved to other states for the most absurd reasons just to allow a different application of law.
There is no question, based on what US law states though, that it is illegal to enforce a single language (of the company's choice) be spoken IN or AROUND the workplace unless it would otherwise jeopardize safety or the efficiency of he company in doing business. In which case the topic of this post does not fall into either field, it is open and shut, discrimination.
by deepsand
If you read my various post here, you will see that I do NOT advocate that employers have carte blanche to consider their businesses as personal fiefdoms.
Rather, I maintain they they have far fewer rights than most people believe.
I find it downright frightening that so many of my countrymen are so ill informed on this matter.
I can only hope that they are neither voting nor reproducing!
by oz_media
I did say rant warning, obviously noting I was losing my cool on this subject.
My apologies. :(
OM
by oz_media
by deepsand
So, if I interpret your secretive conversation to be simple private communications, your're not being rude; but, if you interpret mine as being with intent to exclude you, with the result that you take offense, then I'm being rude.
Private conversations occur everyday, everywhere, in public, in the midst of both strangers & intimate friends. From your position, it follows that all of these are "rude."
However, since such are generally engaged in by the vast majority of this world's population, and must therefore be considered by most to be non-offensive behavior, it follows, by definition (see below) that such are not deemed to be rude.
Main Entry: rude
Pronunciation: 'r?d
Function: adjective
Inflected Form(s): rud?er; rud?est
Etymology: Middle English, from Middle French, from Latin rudis; probably akin to Latin rudus rubble
1 a : being in a rough or unfinished state : CRUDE b : NATURAL, RAW c : PRIMITIVE, UNDEVELOPED d : SIMPLE, ELEMENTAL
2 : lacking refinement or delicacy: a : IGNORANT, UNLEARNED b : INELEGANT, UNCOUTH c : offensive in manner or action : DISCOURTEOUS d : UNCIVILIZED, SAVAGE e : COARSE, VULGAR
3 : marked by or suggestive of lack of training or skill : INEXPERIENCED
4 : ROBUST, STURDY
5 : occurring abruptly and disconcertingly
- rude?ly adverb
synonyms RUDE, ROUGH, CRUDE, RAW mean lacking in social refinement. RUDE implies ignorance of or indifference to good form; it may suggest intentional discourtesy . ROUGH is likely to stress lack of polish and gentleness . CRUDE may apply to thought or behavior limited to the gross, the obvious, or the primitive and ignorant of civilized amenities . RAW suggests being untested, inexperienced, or unfinished .
by awfernald
by awfernald
There are several manufacturing plants in/near the city where I live that hire almost exclusively spanish speaking people for their general labor (mostly illegals :( and yes, I DO know they are illegals as my wife (South American) knows many of them)
Just for a grin, I (White Male) went and applied one day, and was told that I may as well not even apply as they had too significant a backlog of applicants waiting. Then when I started talking to the HR rep in Spanish, he changed his mind and took my application.
Of course, when they called 3 weeks later, I wasn't interested in the job.....
by deepsand
by oz_media
Maybe it was a Spanish speaking air traffic control or emergency rescue company! :D
That would then constitute application for an exception based on the grounds that NOT speaking Spanish would create a safety issue! :p
Actually, in his case no language barrier was offered as a reason, people can discriminate CAREFULLY as long as you have some other reason. The reason cited was too many applications, not language spoken, even if that WAS the underlying reason.
This is nothing like telling employees they must speak a chosen tongue around the office because people don't know what they are talking about. The more I think about it, the more ridiculous it sounds! (Sorry Tom Sal, I know it wasn't YOUR idea though).
by deepsand
Sovereigns voluntarily consent to adopt extra-territorial law by entering into a Treaty with other Sovereigns.
In so doing, the Courts of the Treaty Members become obligated to apply said law within their respective Sovereigns.
by oz_media
And right after I posted several thousand words to iterate the same thing!
I used to be breif, VERY breif but was asked to constantly explain everything and pick it apart in detail,thus I have adopted my mass/mess of information style to posting now. LOL :D
by deepsand
It's the same way with clients, too.
Half of them just want the short answer.
Then when the sh*t hits the fan, you're to blame for not fully explaining everthing to them --- as if they gave you a chance to!
by oz_media
First of all it is also written in US law too.
Secondly, international law must be abided by the laws of your nation in order for you to be considered compliant with the law.
Both of these comments outlined already but here's some text for you anyway.
International law states:
[b]The right to be free from racial discrimination[/b]
[u]7.1. International Law[/u]
"Racial Discrimination" is defined in article 1 of the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination46 (hereinafter CERD) as meaning:
Any distinction, exclusion, restriction or preference based on race, colour, descent, or national or ethnic origin which has the purpose or effect of nullifying or impairing the recognition, enjoyment or exercise, on an equal footing, of human rights and fundamental freedoms in the political, economic, social, cultural or any other field of public life.
Reports in 1996 reveal that the PRC authorities continue to directly discriminate against Tibetans in various spheres of life including public representation, education, employment and housing for reason of their race. The rights of Tibetans as a minority group have also been denied. These rights are recognised in article 27 of the ICCPR which states:
In those States in which ethnic, religious or linguistic minorities exist, persons belonging to such minorities shall not be denied the right, in community with the other members of their group, to enjoy their own culture, to profess and practise their own religion, or to use their own language."
________________________________________
Now as someone had already asked, is the US a signator of International Law? Well yes it is in fact, these laws are agreed to and set forth BY the US to ensure equal treatment of it's citzens no matter where they are. As I mentioned before, teh beatings by US military in Abu Gharib were quickly addressed by the US government as THEY comply with international law that states that you cannot torture prisoners, this is also adhered to because the US doesn't want it's OWN prisiners to be torured by foreign captors. So YES, the US abides by international law.
As for international complaince, the same is followed internally, it would be kinda stupid to make a law against torture of prisoners if you allowed torture in your own country.
-------------------------------------------------
Here's one example of how US laws prevent the discrimination of language in the workplace, not just AROUND and about the workplace.
[u]When Can an Employer Require an Employee to Speak Only English at Work?[/u]
The EEOC generally views "speak-English-only" policies as being [b]illegal under the Civil Rights Act[/b] unless justified by business necessity.
However, a recent case in California refused to follow the EEOC Guidelines on these policies, instead holding that English-only rules must be evaluated on a case-by-case basis. (Garcia v. Spun Steak Co) (16)
This decision came in a case where two Latina meat processing plant workers were disciplined for speaking Spanish on the job. Under this ruling, which applies to California and eight other western states, the court stated that an employee may challenge a "speak-English-only" policy in the workplace under federal law if:
1) the rule is applied to employees who speak no English or who have difficulty speaking English; or
2) the policy creates, or is part of, a work environment that is hostile toward national origin minority employees. Examples of a hostile work environment would include, for instance, the rule being applied in a very harsh manner, or a pattern of harassment in addition to the English-only rule.
[b]If an employee is able to show that either of those conditions applies, then the employer must show a "business necessity" for the policy -- that is, that the rule is "necessary to safe and efficient job performance," and that there are no other alternatives[/b] which would serve the employer's legitimate interests with a less discriminatory effect. (Dothard v. Rawlinson; Griggs v. Duke Power Co; Civil Rights Act of 1991) (17).
[b]The business necessity standard is hard to meet.[/b] Unless an employer can show that the work in question genuinely requires that communications between employees be in English (as opposed to any other language), that all workers must be able to understand all communications between all other workers, and that the consequences of a lapse in communication are serious, [b]it is unlikely that the standard can be satisfied.[/b] "
"as recently as 1991, the court ruled that in some cases, language-based discrimination should be treated as [b]race discrimination"[/b]
"Other courts have also protected the right of language minority groups to be free from discrimination. Those courts have reasoned that even if language and national origin were not synonymous, language-based discrimination disproportionately harms national origin minorities and can, for instance, violate Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits workplace discrimination because of national origin."
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
So as you can see, and I can't believe ANYONE thought such an act would be legal, US law follows what they support/impose as international law.
by cou-cou
It's not true fot your statement. Many people in different countries will use American English with Americans visiting their countries.
Tell us how many foreign languages can you speak?
.
To suggest that an employer in the USA is subjected to "international law" as it applies to rules he may or may not set forth in his workplace is ludicrous. All "International Laws" are governed by a law of treaties signed between sovereign nations, either specific or general, and no such treaty exists.
by jdclyde
I have seen people "let go" because they weren't working out. How do you fight that?
Freedom of speach, to say what you wish. Does that really cover saying it HOW and WHERE you wish?
One of our plants (manufacturing) is in a high Hispanic area of Grand Rapids Michigan. I would say 90% of the workers in the plant CAN'T speak ANY english. So I just nod and walk on by when I need to work on the network equipment in the plant. I have no idea what they are saying, but I don't care for the way they point and laugh....
by jdclyde
Where a judge is MAKING a spanish speaking mother learn english because her son is getting into trouble.
Labled as a form of child neglect/abuse because she is limiting HIS oportunities in America because of refusing to become a part of the county.
If you move to ANY country, YOU MUST learn to at least comunicate with the people in their language, not the other way around.
So If I ever go to Quebec I will at least make a point to learn "can you point me to the rest room please" and "yes, I will have another beer" in french.
by tomsal
"Miss, would you like to borrow my razor?"
oooooh...sorry that was wrong...;)
by jdclyde
that some areas of Canada have varying degrees of hygene?
A natural woman, sorry. Can't kiss a woman with more body hair than I have and that mustache is a real deal killer.
by oz_media
You are talking about a monther who's son is unable to learn and participate in school as he is unable to speak or understand a language.
What if the teachers then said he couldn't speak Spanish to a fellow Spanish classmate when NOT in class? What if thye told him he HAD to speak English during recess and in the bathrooms because OTHERS couldn't understand him and thought he was talkingabout them?
All of a sudden the case looks pretty damnweak doesn't it?
The issue in your case was because the young boy is living in a country where he is not encouraged to speak the language, therefore he will never be able to communicate, learn and succeed as an adult.
They are NOT saying the kid CAN'T speak PSanich around school, just that he is being encouraged NOT to learn the language, two VERY different issues.
by jdclyde
Was just something I saw on the news that I thought I would point out as some of the arguments against this ruling are similar to what people have been saying here.
The point that someone is being TOLD they had to learn english SEEMED relevant to me, and I don't feel less relevant just because you said it was?
No, it isn't the exact same thing as being forbidden to speak in a set language as this discussion goes, but it is still about people being told what to speak.
by oz_media
YOu need not learn French for such basic Canadian comments, you would stand out like a sore thumb.
In Canadian bars, you whip out your weenie and point if you need to find the bathroom.
You need a beer, you belch and bang your empty mug on the bar, all the while complaining that the waitress let it empty without handing you the next.
So if you need to pee and get another beer, whip it out, belch and bang your empty pint mug on the bar, you WILL be a true Canadian then.
by bhunsinger
by jamesrl
Its one thing to say people were let go because they weren't working out. But if you are the manager, this doesn't hold water except for contractors(with the right clause in the contract), and people on probation.
In Ontario at least, if you fire someone for "cause" you have to define what the cause is. What often happens is that instead of firing someone for a questionable cause, they will lay someone off instead.
When I was laid off, my director, who I had also worked for at a previous employer, was very quick and took great pains to explain that my layoff was not one of those layoffs that should be firings, in other words no performance issues.
Its kinda of dangerous to have people working in a modern plant with no english, as thats the language that the safety information is in.
James
by deepsand
as grounds for termination, it is not unusual for an employer to use the "lay off" mechanism, so as to diminish the risk of adverse legal action, even if such action(s) would be without merit.
By choosing this route, the employer trades an unknown cost & liability for a known fixed cost.
.
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=168447&messageID=1724121
Show me even ONE case where it's applied.
by bhunsinger
The political philosophy under which the US Declaration of Independence and the US Constitution is written is that the individual has the Natural right to do anything that the individual wants. Government is a compact/contract in which individuals give up certain rights-ie. the right to pludner- in re turn for group action -protection from being plundered. Rights belong to the individual. The inalienable rights metioned in the DofI are never on the table.
Historically, the Bill of Rights (the first 10 amendments) were added to the US Constiturion to get the states to ratify it, spelling out what the government may not do, or which rights the Federal government was not to have.
by bhunsinger
by oz_media
Civil law also dictates this is illegal. As America is considered signatory to international law, you must also follow those laws WITHIN you country, otherwise it would be just a tad hypocritical don't you think?
Thus I posted an excerpt from US law that says the same thing.
You wouldn't possibly be challenging the fact that this is also a Civil RIghts issue are you? As I was probed and prodded by some who feel that language disrimination is legal where the US does as they please, I also posted excerpts from your OWN laws that echo the exact same thing.
You should also notice that I have explained how international law echos your own laws and how anything else would truly be two-faced. The reason I posted International Law was that's what I cam across first in the law library at UBC, after some people felt that the USA is independant and doesn't abide by international law, I then dug deeper to find examples of US law that also prohibit it.
Hopefully between the two, Americans won't be dunb enough to actually think you can legally dictate language in or around the workplace, especially due to the fact stated in the original post where people don't like it because they don't know what the foreign people are saying. That's just laughable and I can't believe ANY company even considered it for more than a split second of frustration.
by oz_media
This splitting hairs is REALLY getting tiring. That the question has been answered with facts from US law, yet you are TSILL trying to hang onto the racial discrimination issue? Discrimination of language due to nationality will be immediately pushed into a racial discrimination charge.
First off, if YOU don't think it will be considered racial discrimination, try it and let eknow when you get out of court just how many times tha racial discrimination card was played against you. I've seen it first hand, I don't need to wonder.
RACE is not JUST color, racial discrinimation is descrimination against the language of a RACE too, yes I know you have friends that speak multiple languages, that is not the case here. WE are talking about someone's NATICE TONGUE, therefore you are deiscriminating against THAT races language.
As I aready outlined and even hightllighted the DETAIL about this RACIAL DISCRIMINATION being broughtin front us the US court (the example cited was 1991) I wil let YOU dig for it as I have already provided it. If you can't read and follow a reply, why should I repost it. In fact that paragraph is repated TWICE in this discussion already, for your reading enjoyment.
"as recently as 1991, the court ruled that in some cases, language-based discrimination should be treated as race discrimination"
YES THE LAWYER WILL PLAY A RACIAL DISCRIMINATION CARD, IT'S PROVEN AND I HAVE SEEN IT. IF YOU STILL DON'T BELIEVE IT, WELL YOU ARE WELCOME TO LIVE IN A FANTASY WORLD BUT TRY IT AND YOU WILL FIND OUT VERY FAST!
by bhunsinger
Excuse me, this is still a melting pot. All yourself an American if you wish, I prefer the title U.S. citizen. And that means government should but OUT. You handled the donut problem... took you business elsewhere. But now you want to demand that peopl speak english to get ANY job?
What about the Vietnamese who came to this country after we ran out on them in the '70. Should they have gone to english classes before hiring out to people who could speak their language?
The National Identity of the country I live in includes the Statue of Liberty and Ellis Island warts and all. Take your 'Amerika" (dam, never thought I'd ever spell it that way) and go hide in your gated community. So went the Romanovs
I've got mine cause I was lucky enough to be born here.
If the economic benifits of knowing English is not enought for some one, they won't learn. That is their choice not yours.
by deepsand
by bhunsinger
by deepsand
people use covert means to communicate in such situations.
The law does NOT require that you be able to UNDERSTAND my private communiques!
by oz_media
International law is abided by the US government. This was just the FIRST example I found while wading through the UBC law library, I thought it would be simple enough to see it was discrimination BEFORE dragging out specific laws. US law ALSO states it is illegal, as I have also provided such information for those who don't think the US adheres to international laws as a result of their own laws.
The EXAMPLE: Bush quickly addressed the distaste in how prisoners were tortured by US military in Iraq. WHY? Because international law states that you cannot torture prisoners and the US advicates it.
WHY would the US abide by such International Law? Because they don't want their OWN prisoners tortured.
Therefore, as an example, the US DOES abide by international laws.
NOW, that then traslates into similar US laws or vice versa of course. IF you allowed your own people to be tortured, HOW could you possibly expect to participate and expect others to follow a law restricting torture of your own prisoners unless you had your OWN laws against it in the USA?
HOW could the USA NOT abide by an international discrimination law if they didn't ALSO have internal laws against it?
That is hypocrisy.
US law ALSO states it is illegal to discriminate based on the language spoken IN the workplace, not just in the halls but in the office too, unless they meet EXTREMELY stringent rules of exception, which is next to impossible. (this is outlined in the excerpts of US law I provided above).
Thus your OWN laws echo the international laws to which you abide.
It's uncontestable Max, the US is a participant and advocate of international laws, thus they are also participants and advocates of those SAME laws on US soil. As I noted before, even if ammended and detailed specifically state by state, they stil have the same premise and outcome.
by jcrobso
Since I work at Spanish radio station and I only speak English this puts me in the minority. The Spanish speaking employes also speak English to varing degrees.
Basicaly if my fellow employes want to communate with me the must use English, spoken or written.
If it is in Spanish I ignore them. If I'm talking with them and they switch to Spanish I will walk away, not with anger or hostilty, I just figure that they are done talking with me so I leave.
Some do not speak very good English so once in while we have to get some one to translate the tech terms. I have told them if they are saying
bad things about me in Spanish it is a waste of time since I won't understand.
I feel that business should be conduted in a language that every one undestands. But two employes want to have a private conversation in
Spanish that is thier right. John
by jcrobso
I am in the military and even there you will not hear that even on a unilingual English or French Unit the only obligation you have is when you communicate officialy with the unit level and outside it and that is not for your personnal case but the unit case you have to use the language of the unit in the occurence English or French or both if this Unit is designated as Bilingual in that case both language must be used but only if you are giving directive.
Would not like to live and work in a place were people are so paranoid that they think that if they talk in their own language it is against them.
My though
by davidg8
by keith2468a
In Quebec Canada they have such laws, mandating the use of French as a working language. This is done for safety (in some occupations) and to "preserve French culture" in others.
I am not sure how Quebec's legislation would affect private converstaions on company time -- but should private conversations taking place on company time be protected by law?
Mostly I feel speaking an alternative language at work is just plain rude -- like passing notes or secret email gossip.
Uni-linigual people tend to only gossip and badmouth behind other people's backs. But I know from various bilingual friends from my time in Toronto that using second languages (various second languages) bi-lingual people can gossip and badmouth in public in their second language.
So I have mixed feelings over this. It isn't good, but is it actually worse that other common impolite practices that we put up with? I am undecided.
by oz_media
When I was a teenager in Vanacouver, there were SO many 'groups' of various races and natyionalities it was hard to remember who spoke what.
You soon learned all the good swear words from your friends in MANY languages and could tell one someone was bad mouthing you though.
Many years ago, I worked with a Caucasian friend, born in Canada, who had been through 7 of his grade school years in Japan. It was hilarious!
We'd go to a regular Richmond strip joint, where it was very heavily asian populated, and he'd be telling me what the drunk Asian businessmen in 'gynocology row' were saying. The dancers couldn't understand them but he would laugh and tell me what people were saying. Pretty gross bunch really, I suppose they knew the dancers couldn't understand them so they pretty much said what they wanted to and could disrespect the girls while getting smiles and plenty of attention.
The first day I found out about his dual language was when we were in a restaurant and a guy bad mouthed a waitress in Asian of some dialect, my friend looked at me and said, "You know what that guy just said to her? ..."
I just said "really." and went back to my meal.
After about 10 seconds I looked up quite stunned and said, "How the hell do YOU know what he said!"
Pretty funny actually, Canadian guy in a Mac jacket and ballcap, drives a Firechicken and says 'eh' all the time. You never know I guess. :)
by jamesrl
I think if people are going to gossip, they will gossip in any language - unilingual or biligual
I have spent a lot of time in Quebec, working with peers. They work with me in English, and they work with their fellows in French(some of their fellows speak English as well as I speak French, which is to say, not as well as needed).
The only difference in Quebec is that all "announcements" i.e. official correspondence must be available in French. Software must also be available in French. But I have never had any grief using english there.
James
I am glad you see the difference and I am glad that not everyone want me to leave a country that I did and defend now and keep defending meaning (Canada) and glad that the "Speak White" is not and issue anymore in most part of Canada.
I think that given the choice of "Independance" that the French want today and what you see in the rest of the world it is easy to appreciate that we are French and English Canadian very civilize about it.
My Father was English from birth and me I am French from Birth and wife too altough my Kids are English go figure :). I got the you can't speak French when I was onboard a HMCS Ships of our Glorious Navy and I stand my ground and did not destroy the career of that Fellow worker and we are best budy today it was a revelation for him to see someone not calling the Language Police and give hime the translation of my insult to him :) in English world for world after I did calm down hehe :). It would have been easy for me to destroy that career in a snap having all the withness I needed at that time.
I will never give up my difference and looking at what you see in the rest of the world our distinction is no more a "pain in the a....ss" so to speak.
:)
My though
by oz_media
I think i get your point, certainly your English is better than my French! :D
Anyhow, I know I have very light feelings when it comes to those who wish to separate, if you want to be alone then you all have my best wishes. But for those such as yourself who truly see several nationalities living in the same country and accepting the differences, all the power to you.
I too am an immigrant to Canada, I am still a full fledged British Citizen (in fact I just received a new passport yesterday). I cannot judge an immigrant, even if I DO speak English first, as I am not a Canadian citizen and many who speak foreign languages in Canada ARE Canadian citizens.
I just enjoy Canada for what it is.....gorgeous and free. That's good enough for me, I prefer to just keep the other issues out of my life as I see them as unimportant. Speak whatever you choose and shout it from the rooftops if you wish, I'm going camping! :)
P.S. We don't get too many Canadian Military peers here, (we don't have too many Canadians in the military either !) :D, so thanks for all you do to keep our country and our allies safe. No matter language you choose to do it in.
Yell 'Tabernac' at a few bad guys for me.
Yep I serve and will continue to serve.
For the separation it is a none issue now unless some dumm Ass in a isolate place burn the Canadian or Quebec flag and proclame this country as only one language yep maybe it will start again but I think we have now reach the understanding.
At least it was never and will never be like Ireland conflict. We should be happy for that:)
Have a nice day.
Sometimes the personal touch is better.
Most people were never taught that is rude to speak a language when all present do not understand the conversation.
Respect and communication can go a long way. How about talking to those involved, explaining the issue and asking for their input on how this should be addressed?
I have lived in a home with an Iranian woman, and her family visits and it is Farsi all around. It is certainly uncomfortable at times, but luckily I am not the paranoid type. A conversation with her helped the situation a lot.
That's my 2 cents - you will be open to lawsuits if you try it your way.
by oz_media
But I would think, as their employer, it is in teh company's best interest to address the issues they are complaining about more than the language used.
It sounds like the employees have a bad attitude about something or someone at work that is becoming a cancer, no matter what language they speak, the real issues that need to be addressed are far deeper than the language I think.
I can swear about my employer in many languages but is the language th eissue or the fact that I am swearing about my employer. Something needs to be sorted out.
by chrystoph
"What they say to each other should not be a concern of the company."
This is horridly bad advice. It lends it self readily to harassment, discrimination and, while not technically illegal, cliques in the company.
It is always the company's concern as to what is said on the property, as, by law, the company can be held responsible for the conduct of its employees.
As an example, what happens when the Spanish speaking men in the company are talking to each other about how sexually attractive they find a fellow employee and that employee speaks Spanish, as well? The management may not even be able to find out what was said, but that will not prevent them from being held accountable.
Regardless of the topic of conversation, the schism of two langauges makes both a perception and a reality of separation. Some party is excluded, either by design or by accident. That causes morale problems and, if one of the speakers is the excluded person's superior in the organization is a defacto case of dicrimination. The reason for this is the perception, regardless of circumstance, of favoritism toward the other speaker.
by hermit47
So at what point will we be seeing the gestapo crashing the break room. Prying open the canteen machines to remove the illegal taco and jalapeno chips, microwave burritos, and French pastries.
Try this scenario.
Learn the second language, it wouldn't hurt you and you could feel more secure around the fellow employees you do not trust. Lets face it folks, at least those people took the time to learn two languages, and seem to get by just fine that way. Why do we Americans need to be so blind and lazy? No wonder they have remarks about us. Look how infantile we can be sometimes.
by oz_media
Generally 6-10 inches, form what I've seen, with a curled blade. Apparently they range from a few inches to as much as three feet though.
I used to live in a an area of Vancouver near a Sikh temple (there are a few of them in The Vancouver Area). Every weekend we would see Sikhs gathering, getting off the busses, walking down main street etc. with large knives on their sashes.
It has been fought MANY times in US and Canadian courts to pretty much no avail and they still carry them freely for the most part. Yet fewer then before as they do get them taken away if caught in public now.
http://www.planete.qc.ca/images/divers/kirpan1.jpg
As for US law,although it does vary from State to state, the following link shows that many States are somewhat accepting of this as a religious item IF carried accordingly. http://www.sikhmediawatch.org/pubs/SMART_Kirpan_Memorandum.PDF
"Penal code 12020 prohibits the carrying of a concealed dirk or dagger. Yet, the provides a 'safe haven'; a knife that is carried in a sheath and worn openly suspended from the waist is not in violation of that code section."
It goes on to add that IF the kirpan is worn appropriately and cannot be quickly removed and used as a stabbing weapon or has a rounded blade that cannot inflict major bodily harm, it will be acceptable whereas it is not if it is not worn according to the law 12020 cited above nd can be quickly drawn and used as a stabbing weapon.
===========================================
by oz_media
I see it more as an attempt to ALLOW a child to speak the tongue of his new home;and.
He is being repressed by his mother as she is not allowing him to grow and succeed in his country, this can have devestating effects on him socially, mentally and throughout his career, by limiting his communications abilities.
I see it is similar to forcing you to send your children to school or enforcing the right to an education upon the mother. Technically she has removed his right to become educated and prosper in the country, which is easily seen as a form of abuse and repression.
The child being to young to defend himself, must then be looked after by those with the legal ability to do so. The child has a right to life and prosperity in a free country, he is having that ability stripped from him by his mother.
THAT's why I see it as irrelevant to the case at hand, and these cases are ALL handled on an indivisual basis as they differ SO much and it is SUCH a sensitive issue to enforce.
In the case cited as an employer having such a right to control language casually spoken because people cant understand it, well that should be a no brainer.
by oz_media
by deepsand
being able to effectively communicate with fellow employees & clients is an ESSENTIAL requirement in any & all instances.
Therefore, denying employment for lack of such skill constitutes neither ILLEGAL discrimination nor a violation of CIVIL rights.
by garret`
by deepsand
no foul.
Besides, on other, equally convoluted threads, I've found myself in the same position.
by deepsand
by bhunsinger
"Freedom of Speech", in the U.S, is a Civil Right granted by Sovereigns (both Federal & States/Commonweals), through Constitutions.
This is a quote I took form your post. The Constitution does not grant freedom of speech, it guarentees that the federal goverment does not have the power to limit speech. The people set limits on the government, not the other way around. It always tries to, but it is important to rember the way it is supposed to be.
by longennamer
Somebody already has banned employee's from smoking. On and off the job site.
http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2005/01/28/eveningnews/main670168.shtml
by deepsand
All civil rights flow SOLELY from the Sovereign; that the Sovereign has granted such so as to secure the fealty of the People is irrelevant.
There is, for example, no legal impediment to amending the U.S. Constitution such that "free speech" can be exercised soley at the pleasure of the Sovereign.
by bhunsinger
Not the Government. Look at the Preamble to the Constitution. "We the people , of the United States, in order to establish a more perfect union,... do ordain and establish this constitution of the United States of America."
or the Declaration of Independence 'That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed, --That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness"
And there are several legal impediments to removing the First amendment- a super majority of both senate and House, as well as ratification of 3/4 of all the states.
Also, the second amandment.
by deepsand
either a tyranny of the majority, which the Constitution seeks to thwart, or anarchy.
1) The Declaration of Independence is NOT Law; it was, and remains, but a statement of intent & the reasons for such;
2) The Constitution is the OLDEST, and therefore, the SUPREME Law of the U.S.;
3) The Constitution established a Republic, NOT a Democracy;
4) While the People enjoy no small measure of freedom, their powers are subordinate to the Constitution, the Republic, and their respective States;
5) That the bar to altering the Constitution was set high with great deliberateness does not constitute a LEGAL impediment to such, merely one of practicalities;
6) While the People do, though their respective States, exercise some degree of power re. amending the Constitution, they are not the ultimate arbiter of such; therefore,
7) Given that the People lack the requisite supreme power of an ultimate arbiter (see definitions below) it cannot be in fact maintained that they are sovereigns.
The People & the Sovereign are not one and the same; this is a very important distinction between very different entities.
==================================================
Main Entry: sov?er?eign
Variant(s): also sov?ran /'s?-v(&- )r&n, -v&rn also 's&-/
Function: noun
Etymology: Middle English soverain, from Old French, from soverain, adjective
1 a : one possessing or held to possess sovereignty b : one that exercises supreme authority within a limited sphere c : an acknowledged leader : ARBITER
==================================================
Main Entry: sov?er?eign?ty
Variant(s): also sov?ran?ty /-tE/
Function: noun
Inflected Form(s): plural -ties
Etymology: Middle English soverainte, from Middle French soverainet?, from Old French, from soverain
1 obsolete : supreme excellence or an example of it
2 a : supreme power especially over a body politic b : freedom from external control : AUTONOMY c : controlling influence
3 : one that is sovereign; especially : an autonomous state
==================================================
by usrules
Hunsinger should read up a bit before throwing thoughts out. Turks have had Armenians live on its nation for 1,000 years. The Armenians, Jews and 30 other ethnicities that lived in Ottoman Turkiye maintained their languages and cultures for 1,000 years, whereas he claims that his ancestors that came from Germany have lost their tradition.
The Kurds and Armenians of today have many hatemongering groups that are mainly supported by Western terror/intelligence circles. They generate fabricated material and propaganda that most "readers" assume as facts. The Kurds for one have three large terror groupds, PKK, HADEP, DHKP and the Armenians have ASALA, ANCA and others that are involved in extortions, threats and even sponsorship of so-called "Historians". They often threaten Kurds/Armenians that reject their mission. The Greeks are very helpful to their cause of the obvious. They started 2 wars on Turkish soil in the last 100 years, and publicize to the world of the BIG BAD TURK that is a potential threat, not emphasizing that the Turks have never threatened the Greeks in 100 years.
One wonders how long the TURKISH patience will last...
Just a correction to the the uninformed statements of Bhunsinger.
by jamesrl
I am neither Turk nor Armenian nor Turkish. I am a reader of history.
I was living in Ottawa during the Armenian terrorist attacks on Turkish embassy personnel and I in no way support that kind of action. It was terrorism.
Are you though denying that millions of Armenians were slaughtered in the dying days of the Ottoman empire(1917)? Yes Turkey has come a long way since, but do you think possibly there might be some justification for Armenian anger?
There is hate mongering and fear mongering on many sides, not just the ones you oppose.
James
Oz, you think everything is racist.
Why does it always have to come down to race?
What if the employees are speaking German or French? Would it be racist to prohibit that?
Why do you left-wing nut jobs have to equate everything to race or racism? What's the hangup?
Indians being the only true Americans is such a ludicrous idea that it doesn't merit further discussion.
But we need all the labels for everyone. How else can we keep the poplulation into easily managed bite-sized pieces that can be easily manipulated into a constant state of quarelling with each other. Isn't that what equality is all about?
by deepsand
As I noted above, you continue to fail to make the distinction between nationality and ethnicity.
Ethnicly, the Amerinds ARE the true Americans.
With regards to nationality, many have dual citizenship, by virtue of being members of their respective Indian nations.
by deepsand
1) There is a difference between nationality & ethnicity.
2) There is no such thing as an ethnic American.
3) One's nationality neither alters nor removes one's ethnicity.
4) A truly free nation will neither ask nor require that one deny his ethnicity.
5) To ask that one refrain from expressing his ethnicity is un-American!
And so on and so forth...
If that were really true then why are only minorities allowed to celebrate ethnic pride. Whites are racists if they do that.
by jamesrl
As for the comment made that whites can't celebrate pride in their ethnicity, white is not an ethnicity. I don't normally beleive in race(social not biological construct to me) but to me when people start talking about white pride they are talking about race.
Every year I go to Highland games to celebrate my "ethnicity". People celebrate irish heritage on St. Patricks day. The fact that I share the same skin colour as someone from Eastern Europe doesn't forge a link to them in my view.
And take the case of some of my friends from the Caribbean. Their ancesters are from China and India, but their families lived in the Caribbean (in former British colonies)for hundreds of years, and now they live in Canada, another former British colony. Do you want to call them Chinese and Indian? It wouldn't do justice to their heritage. They have been influenced by British religion(anglicans), Caribean culture(food, approach to work) - you can't typify them by skin colour or "race" but by all the things that influence their heritage.
James
Sort by Trending