ObamaCare: It's not about medical care; it's about control over your life
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Networks
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by jamesrl
I saw them on a Buffalo ABC affiliate, one of the only US TV stations we could get with an aerial back then.
They were fun.
James
by puppybreath
Did he really just say what I thought he said??
http://www.breitbart.tv/shocking-audio-rep-dingell-says-obamacare-will-eventually-control-the-people
by tonythetiger
we pay a (varies by state) number of cents per gallon.
Next question. What is that tax used for? Seems a lot for only road construction and maintenance.
by tonythetiger
[/i]If I see all citizens as equal and worthy of the same privileges I am, then I also see all citizens as peers.[/i]
If they are worthy of the same privileges, are they also worthy of the same responsibilities?
by tonythetiger
I advocate making the CONTROL more local.
I'm not too worried that this will last long... think "unintended consequences".
by oz_media
If it was a public meeting to decide, you would still moan abou it.
Unless YOUR ideals on each and every matter see the light, it is not worthy of your support.
by jck
you want local control
So your state Dept. of Revenue instead of the IRS then?
Or, maybe your local town council and every little burg and rural county can handle the taxation?
That model breeds inefficiency, not to mention tons of in-fighting.
Good luck with that. I hope you get what you want.
by tonythetiger
by jmgarvin
Since that it the case, it could very be easily argued that personhood of corporations leads to the ability to do things that would make Adam Smith roll in his grave.
Welcome to the new age of Robber Barons.
by jmgarvin
We are on the same page:
1) Single payer makes the most sense
2) The insurance industry is screwing us
3) This bill does a way with a lot of the screwage that the free market couldn't.
That's it.
by tonythetiger
[i]1) Single payer makes the most sense[/i]
SELF payment makes the most sense.
by jmgarvin
by jck
It is the status quo for business to maximize profits at the expense of image, customer satisfaction, and employee satisfaction.
The only thing business is required to do is return a profit to its shareholder(s).
So yeah, you're right. Most are robber barons.
e.g.- executives in the industries of mortgage lenders, equity traders, car manufacturers, insurance firms, etc.
And then there's the oil companies. All making record profits.
Yet, ExxonMobil (the biggest in the world) had to only pay $500M to the residents of the bay in Alaska that still to this day has not recovered and their fish are still deformed and tainted because they didn't clean the beaches up right.
Gotta love "free enterprise". Free to screw anyone who'll take it.
by oz_media
A settlement from 1991 required the company to pay $900 million; however, the case included a provision allowing the government to pursue as much as $100 million more for additional unforeseen damages. The US government is nowseeking an additional 92 million.
[i]"When asked how Exxon intended to pay the massive cleanup costs, one Exxon executive responded by saying it would raise gas prices to pay for the incident. These attempts to evade responsibility and defer blame angered consumers. Ten days after the spill, Exxon spent $1.8 million to take out a full-page ad in 166 papers. In the ad, the company apologized for the spill but still refused to accept responsibility."[/i]
I used to live on the NOrthern Top of Vancouver island, a good 15 years after the spill, and yet oil damage was still VERY noticable along the coast.
It's our government's reaponsibility to oversee the Envorniment Minister and this US responsibilty for shipments travelling Canadian waters bound to the US and China. So it's not all the US government's fault, but moreso Exxon's. However they are merely ybound by US laws even when in International waters it seems. The US government can't even make them pay to clean up Alaska, expecting that support Internationally is a pipe dream.
This one really pissed me off so I'll leave it on the surface and not dig into the real issues.
by jck
I watched a documentary on Planet Green Channel the other day about Cordova, Alaska which is on the bay that the Exxon tanker Valdez spilled in.
They were picking up rocks on the beach, and you could still see oil under them.
They were showing all of the settled, oil-covered materials on the floor of the bay.
And, they showed how over a 15 year period how that spill had cost the community of Cordova and the other communities in that sound about $2-3B.
US Supreme Court's final decision:
Lower the cost to Exxon from a $4.5B payout to $500M payout.
That's 2 days of Exxon's operating income as of 2008.
It amazes me. Exxon for well over a decade kept that money in their pocket, earned more money on it.
Makes me sick.
by oz_media
Of course they are. However, many fall short not due to their efforts but due to circumstances beyond their control. Many fall and climb back up again, that is what we call "society".
Do some people abuse such privileges and systems? Yes. Is that a reason to cease such systems? No.
You, as do many other Americans, deem worth on value, as if people have become a commodity of sorts.
Not evryone contributes what you do to society and MANY people contribute far more than you do to society.
So who are you to judge others suitablity when it would be just as fair, by other people's standards, to deem you as a slacker not worthy of any support either.
Have you built a mulitnational corporation that pays millions in taxes each year? No.
So how do you detrmine YOUR efforts to be 'enough' and others to not?
While people here often consider me arrogant or self centered, the truth of the matter is that I see every man woman and child in Canada as an equal. Do they earn as much? Maybe not, maybe far more. Do they pay as much in taxes? Proportionately it's close but not every one does and I also don't pay even a fraction in taxes as othrs do.
So if I accept people as equals, and you (and countless others) except only those that meet what you (they) feel are your criteria of worthiness, who the hell is arrogant and self centered here?
by oz_media
by oz_media
Who's socialist?
Last I checked, we have a conservative government and you have a democratic government.
by oz_media
As I noted, it varies by state, therefore an average percentage of the pump price and how much of that is tax is actually correct.
Your pump prices vary by state, our pump prices vary by province, or even municipality.
Your included taxes cover road construction and even transit in some states.
Ours included taxes cover road construction and even transit in some provinces.
I don't know why you always seem to think America is structured so differently from others when you are virtually the same as everyone else, in most areas, save Health Care.
by oz_media
As I said, it's not worth further discussion as you clearly can't grasp such alien concepts.
You affirmed that by offering what you feel is 'the best you can say'; offering nothing or relevance or validity.
by oz_media
First you say you are not worried about how it will effect you.
Then you say I'm concerned with how it will affect the future of freedom and liberty in America.
BECAUSE THAT EFFECTS YOU! DOH!
You have proven countless times that you really don't give a rat's about others, just the well being of yourself and those you deem wothy of your support; everyone else should team up and find their own support group.
Now all of a sudden it is for the greater good.
Sure. Maybe some people, who don't read what you say before agreeing with you, may see your view but anyone that knows better won't.
by oz_media
by oz_media
I applaud your conceot of having an over controlling government out of your life. However at the same time you are insisting it stops helping others in the process.
Unfortunately, or perhaps fortunately, governmets are not an opt in system. You reside in a democracy that see government support THE people, not individuals.
You can always move to an ungoverned nation, if you can find one or find one that offers the lifestyle you expect. In fact it has been done before...in cartoons, just look at Petoria on Family Guy, he had a moat to keep away the evil black knight and everything...until the US army invaded him for doing it on their land.
by dwdino
"Fact is, there are people in the world who worked way harder than you ever have, and gained nothing to show for it and not because of mismanagement or lack of responsibility."
And that means what exactly?
"Get over yourself. You might have worked hard, but not everyone gets the breaks you did or is able to earn a better spot in life."
Again, the point?
Remember, equal opportunity not outcome. I may work 5 minutes and earn 5 bucks. You might work 10 minutes and earn 1000 bucks. So what. We each do the best we can.
The best solution would be the removal of insurance all together.
by oz_media
Okay perhaps it was an exaggeration. Drugs cost NOTHING in hospitals here, not one red cent. A prescription will cost you the bottling fees though, through a local pharmacy, which averages less that $15 for common medication but can cost up and around $60-$70 for medications that are only partially covered or not covered completely.
Tyleno 3's with codeine runs about $11 for a bottle of 30 at a pharmacy, which is a private pharmacy that bills the government.
by oz_media
I think nations could solve a lot of problems with internal unity. However, as most are politically divided, the US being a paradigm of such internal division, I think you are better off building a spaceship in you backyard so you can populate another planet.
I think the biggest prpaganda farce in US history is the preamble to the US Constitution "We the people".
It should read, "Those of us in power feel..."
by av .
Its really sad because no one benefits from the partisan politics. Personally, I think the healthcare bill is a major improvement over what we had. People will see some of those improvements immediately.
The Republicans want to repeal the law instead of trying to improve it. Sure, lets stay with the status quo where I end up bankrupt because I got sick. And so it goes on.
AV
by tonythetiger
by oz_media
Forced to buy a less expensive product than you choose to buy now.
If you were being forced to pay more or even the same exorbitant amount that you pay now, you may actually have a point.
Just as users are not FORCED to use Windows, you are not forced to reside in America, you choose to. (You know there are planes and boats that go to other nations, right?)
by jmgarvin
Boats and planes...You must live in some kind of sci-fi world.
Next you'll tell me I can go from San Francisco to London in less than 3 weeks! :-)
by tonythetiger
the cost is merely shifted to something or someone else.
If a doctor submits a patient's bill to the government for $100, and they only pay the doctor $50, what should the doctor do? cut staff? use lower quality supplies? squeeze in twice as many patients? what?
[added: and we weren't "forced" to buy any product... until now.]
by oz_media
by oz_media
I always wondered why you had nothing relevant to respond with when called out on your own BS.
Even when quoted, you simply dismiss it. Now that's laughable.
by oz_media
by oz_media
It could be like medievil time even, have them sit on top of the wall with big cauldrons full of boiling tar to dump on people. Or fill the upcoming yards with pitch that can be lit on fire as they approach the wall.
Damn, I'd get US citizenship just to go play on the wall for a bit and roast some beans.
by oz_media
by puppybreath
referring to human beans?
:-)
Oz said to me, [i]"You have proven countless times that you really don't give a rat's about others, just the well being of yourself and those you deem worthy of your support;"[/i]
That, Oz, is what I consider intellectually dishonest. If not dishonest, it's extremely naive.
First of all, you have no idea how much I actually care about others, how much I actually do for others, or how much I actually give to others. Although you don't know much about me - which, in itself, should show that your mean-spirited charges are unfounded - I somehow suspect that you know those charges are untrue, and you spouted them only in a lame attempt to attack me for the sole purpose of simply attacking me. (It's what you do around here.)
Nonetheless, let's take your mean-spirited charges against my character at face value and explore exactly what you said.
[i]You have proven countless times that you really don't give a rat's about others....[/i]
I have proven? Really? You have no [i]proof[/i] of anything. Other than engaging in discussions in which we've found ourselves at opposite ends of political issues, you know very little about me. All you can fall on is playing the "compassion card", something often employed by collectivist-type thinkers. But it's an empty, baseless, and dishonest argument.
[i].....just the well being of yourself.....[/i]
Okay, let me get this straight. If I care about the well-being of myself, that's a bad thing. That's a bad thing? Really? The only alternative is to not care about the well-being of myself, in which case I'd either be a candidate for the padded room or I'd be willingly relinquishing responsibility for myself onto others in society - both of which are bad things. If there's another option, please enlighten us as to what it is. Otherwise, you should acknowledge that, in the very least, a person should look after his/her own well-being - OR, admit that you believe a person SHOULD NOT look after his/her own well-being.
[i]..... those you deem worthy of your support.....[/i]
Taken as you presented it, you acknowledge that I DO give a rat's, and I DO care for the well-being, but only [i]of those I deem worthy of my support.[/i] Okay, that's exactly right. There are two key words, here: worthy and support. Something and/or someone is either worthy or unworthy. Are you suggesting that I should support something and/or someone that/who I deem unworthy? That would be silly. Or are you suggesting that I should support something/someone that/who another person deems worthy? Who is that person I should follow? You? Barack Obama? Al Gore? George Bush? Jck? Jmgarvin? What if we disagree? What if Person-A deems something [i]worthy[/i], while Person-B deems that same thing [i]unworthy[/i]? Who's right? Maybe both are right. As such, maybe I should follow my own convictions. Or are you suggesting that I should follow YOUR (or someone else's) convictions? How about we do this: Let's let Person-A support those things/people he deems worthy, and let Person-B support those things/people he deems worthy, and both agree to not force the other to support those things/people the other deems unworthy?
Let me give you an example. Personally speaking, one of the causes I [i]deem worthy[/i] is helping chemically (drugs or alcohol) dependent people who have hit rock bottom, and have found themselves homeless and hopeless (note: I didn't say helpless). However, I'm adamantly opposed to providing government funds (yours and mine) to provide housing to those folks. My community actually bought several hotels, and it houses these folks. Sure, it got them off the street, but it only enables their own destructive behavior. It does nothing to solve the underlying problem. But I suppose some people feel good with the sense they're doing something. Maybe they are; hell, I don't know. But I don't think so; in my opinion, they're actually enabling destructive behavior; they're actually co-dependents, themselves. Enabling destructive behavior is, in my opinion, anything but help.
Instead, I choose to support an organization (that takes NO tax dollars, by the way, so it doesn't have to comply to government rules of enabling and co-dependency) that actually works to break the self-destructive cycle of dependency.
I've volunteered my time to teach computer skills to these guys.
I donate dollars and goods to support their expenses.
I've hired people from the shelter (many, many times), so they can not only earn dollars, but regain a sense of self reliance.
Bottom line: If I don't help and support those I [i]deem worthy[/i], then who and/or what should I help and support? Those people and things I DON'T deem worthy? Or those people and things someone else might [i]deem worthy[/i]?
You're argument, Oz - and mean-spirited charges - simply fall apart under the slightest bit of scrutiny.
Will you recant? I doubt it. You're purpose on this site started out in a lame attempt to attack and challenge me, and so it continues.
Conclusion: In the context of a FORCED collectivist medical delivery system, I truly believe that some things/people ARE [i]unworthy[/i] and/or the methods destructive, and as such, I simply cannot support it. Such things should NEVER be forced. Instead, they should always be a matter of free choice. What YOU deem [i]worthy[/i], and what I deem [i]worthy[/i] might be different. How about this? You support yours - and I won't interfere - and you give me the same courtesy for me to support mine, without interference.
Speaking of [i]worthy[/i]. You are definitely not [i]worthy[/i] of getting the amount of time I spent writing this message. You've shown yourself, time and again, unworthy of my serious consideration. When are you going to grow up and find some sense of intellectual honesty? You often show signs of hope, but then you go and spoil it all by saying something stupid.. (A Frank and Nancy moment, there.)
Intellectual honesty, Oz. You are in serious need of it.
P.S. Damn, did I really give that much time to Oz?
by jck
[i]P.S. Damn, did I really give that much time to Oz?[/i]
You did. I'm jealous. :p
See, Oz. He really does care about you. :D
by puppybreath
The article lists each section of the bill in its determination of the effect on the citizens based on the wording in the bill.
Please provide documentation showing the CBO referring to these sections in its report and showing how their findings differ from the article.
by jck
Their report on the legislation was pretty conclusive. It was going to save $150-200B between the savings of the legislation and the reconciliation combined plus additional adjustments later that were undefined but know to save more within the first 10 year window.
Then within the 20 year window, it estimated up to $1T(rillion) in savings overall after inefficiencies and waste were eliminated.
I'd say that's a pretty good plan fiscally.
by dwdino
by jmgarvin
Short version
http://www.politico.com/livepulse/0310/CBO_numbers.html
DIRECT FROM THE CBO
http://www.cbo.gov/ftpdocs/113xx/doc11379/Manager%27sAmendmenttoReconciliationProposal.pdf
If you decide to stay willfully ignorant, I can't help you. There is a world outside of what Rush Limbaugh and Sean Hannity say....you do know that, right?
by puppybreath
I asked you to provide documentation that showed that the CBO disproved the findings in the article and all you've done is provide a link to the report of PROJECTED costs and savings.
You're the one that stated that ALL of the findings were proven false in the report. But from what I've seen, the CBO report doesn't specifically address each section of the bill.
So either provide the CBO report that specifically addresses each section of the bill and proves the article totally wrong, or just admit that it's only your opinion that the article is wrong.
by tonythetiger
by jmgarvin
The CBO provided a report and the article "feels" like the CBO is wrong, but provides no backing to what they are saying.
READ THE CBO REPORT. Now, explain, why the CBO report is wrong (as you are claiming).
by tonythetiger
[i]You, as do many other Americans, deem worth on value, as if people have become a commodity of sorts.
[/i]
Making them part of the infrastructure of the country that the other slaves, er, I mean citizens can use?
The fact that there are those who believe another's liberty is subject to the whim of the government (via the majority's will in this particular country) is distasteful enough!
by jck
Removal of insurance is anti-American. Didn't you learn that from Max? It's Socialism.
Anyone has a right to maximize profits as much as possible, while diminishing their service to their paying customer as far as the law allows.
See, American capitalism is now at the level just above criminal. You are allowed to screw someone as long as it *technically* is not illegal.
So, I see it as this: you can make as much as you like, save all you want, and have insurance.
You run into $900,000 of medical debt, you have $300k saved and a $500,000 expenditure limit on your policy...you're SOL no matter how hard you worked, how responsible enough you were to save, etc.
My point to Max is this: his way of thinking is that if you do as he did, worked as hard as him, invested like him...that there is no reason for you not to have what he does.
But, you are exactly right. The same opportunity doesn't produce the same outcome in every case. That's the point I was trying to relate to Max.
Personally, I think insurance should only be for supplementary things such as non-necessary stuff. I think medical care (basic, extended, emergency) should be part of a national network.
If you don't know about it, look into how Australia's healthcare system works.
Their cost per person was about AU$487.
I'd like to see any American get an annual medical coverage for what is about US$445 per year.
The only way you'll get something that cheap is to quit your job, go on welfare, and get Medicare/Medicaid coverage.
by jck
And neither is Obama.
So, why blame him for the stupidity in the legislation?
Why paint hitler-style moustaches on pictures of him??
Because...right-leaning weenies are fear mongering absolutionists who think anything that doesn't follow their life creedo is some type of Satan-sent, burn in hell type of sin.
Go back and look at all the "socialist" things Clinton did for jobs and the budget and what it did for our country.
Then go back and look how Bush and 6 years of Republican controlled congress unraveled it all.
But again, Obama put a good idea out there. Health care needs reform. But, putting it on "Democrats" or "Obama" is wrong. Not all Democrats wanted the idiocy that is in the legislation, and Obama probably didn't either.
And again, Max. What's wrong with saving about $150-200B in the first 10 years, as the CBO is forecasting it will?
Aren't you for reduced spending? Less taxes? More diligent and efficient government?
So why is it so wrong to provide more and better services at less cost to the taxpayer?
I'd like to know your reasoning behind that.
by tonythetiger
[i]And again, Max. What's wrong with saving about $150-200B in the first 10 years, as the CBO is forecasting it will?[/i]
That's disingenuous. The states will have to pick up $150-200B in extra costs [b]PER YEAR[/b] due to the mandate that Medicaid add 15 million people to the rolls. It's just more smoke and mirrors.
by dr dij
I love it how somehow health care is a 'right', yet this sounds riddled with flaws.
In Romania there is free health care for everyone, but good luck finding a cat scan.
If I can't afford a 52" plasma screen does that make me a 'substandard citizen'?
Shouldn't a huge TV and broadband access be free for all?
I worked at a Dr office in my class. One of the medical assts was 8.5 months preggy and was earning $9/hour.
She and husband were kind of living in decrepit old van and renting room to cook. (husband unemployed)
Some would say she should get free health care (dr didn't offer coverage)
Others would ask why is she having kid when she can barely afford to feed herself?
I feel bad when those taking advantage of govt handouts get mad when govt tries to raise cost, e.g. UC schools raised costs for students. But 2/3 is already subsidized, keeping me too poor to attend so the students are piggy like those in france who riot since they are paid to goto school and weren't getting enuf allowance.
Somehow making it free seems to denigrate the value received from health care prof'ls. We are people too, not health janitors. The goods and services take alot of effort to do. Esp since much takes years of training, expensive instruments and tests, and you are dealing with people with sometimes complicated problems.
Oh well. The govt has spoken. We've been brainwashed by the euro zone which has been basically stagnant for last 20 years. The problems with portugal, spain, ireland and greece spending too much on retirement, healthcare and other govt services is symptomatic of the overspending this will now cause in the US.
by jmgarvin
We aren't focusing on education, we aren't attracting the best and brightest, and we have a society that is producing less because they are less healthy.
It only makes fiscal sense to have a healthy work force.
by tonythetiger
by jck
...is wanting to help people be healthier making us "good little slaves"?
Are you advocating that we stop spending tax dollars on anti-smoking campaigns? After all, should we care about anyone's health if it costs us each $1.25 a year in tax money?
Hm. Where my ball and chain? I needs to get backs in da fields.
by jmgarvin
Think of it as working for the greater good
Think of it as spending a little extra money for someone to have health care that can't afford it.
Man needs to be less selfish in order to survive this life and man will be in time (evolution).
Man has been working for himself far too long and has lost the idea of working for someone or something else other than self and has further rooted himself into a twisted perversion of ME ideals and thinking.
You know, men like Castro have just implemented the system the wrong way. If man was more selfless socialism would/will work.
by dwdino
"Removal of insurance is anti-American. Didn't you learn that from Max? It's Socialism."
Not when it is out of pocket. You assumed that someone else would pick up the tab instead of insurance companies...
"You run into $900,000 of medical debt, you have $300k saved and a $500,000 expenditure limit on your policy...you're SOL no matter how hard you worked, how responsible enough you were to save, etc."
And this is known as life. But, two questions - was the actual service denied?, what caused the high cost? I'll give you a hint; it starts with ins and ends with urance.
"My point to Max is this: his way of thinking is that if you do as he did, worked as hard as him, invested like him...that there is no reason for you not to have what he does."
I believe your view is flawed. Granted, my understanding of Max is limited, but I believe he is communicating the ideals of individual outcome and respnosibility. I see no equality presented, simply the idea that each is responsible to make the best of what they have and not be dependent on a government system for their provisions.
Another question, does everyone understand that insurance is simply a for fee cost sharing apparatus?
Everyone that buys in agrees to commit capital, from which a management fee is drawn, and through which services are paid for. Part of the responsibility of managing this fund is limiting risk.
Put it this way, if you sold hamburgers and charded 3.50 for a hamburger. After some time you have made some money. Then, customers start demanding an extra piece of meat and cheese. They demand larger patties. The cost naturally rises. Now, throw in the fact that there are persons filing law suits because the cheese is Cheddar instead of American and claiming 1 million in damages.
Now you are charging 15.00 for your hamburger.
Am I absolving the insurance companies? No, not at all. But why add another cog to a machine just for risk management?
There are a few new clinics in my area that are beginning to follow this trend. All services are rendered out of pocket. Insurance is not allowed. The benefit is that the procedures are much more focused, quicker, and most importantly - about 1/4 the cost.
Edited for typos
by jck
there's a lot of legislation that is found to be inappropriate and/or illegal that is usually removed in committee or adjudicated as such by the court system.
Besides, there were expenditures found to be wrong too, such as "...language in the bill that relates to grants for low-income college students."
It's not all just savings they are having issues with in the bill.
I just don't know why it is so hard for 535 (mostly highly-educated) people to sit down and go "Okay...we need to form a section that tracks down and litigates fraud in the system which saves $8B...and that more than pays for the people and facilities. Then, we need to establish a system of basic healthcare for people from that fraud savings so that people get free basic care within that money we have left over."
Wow. So hard to do.
And hundreds of legal graduates can't figure out how to do that? Go figure.
by jck
And even then, I think both sides started trying to get their own little language in it that pleased their "constituents" (aka-special interests that finance their campaigns).
There are some things Republicans are trying to do to improve the bill, but most things they are attempting are just politicial posturing for hate ads in the upcoming elections.
Totally sad. You would think educated adults would be able to work together for the betterment of their nation.
by jck
Most people in congress I didn't vote for. I have a rep in the house I voted for. She's a Republican who doesn't tow the party line and votes by common sense...not stupid lemming-like party affiliation.
My 2 US Senators? Didn't vote for either of them. One is an idiot (Martinez) and left office (thank God) late last year, and the other one is there to grin and agree and try to be cuddly nice (Nelson).
As for the delegation from Colorado. They're your responsibility.
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
[i]Drugs cost NOTHING in hospitals here[/i]
Oz thinks it's free. Did you also know that "gullible" isn't in the dictionary?
by tonythetiger
[i]And this is known as life. But, two questions - was the actual service denied?, what caused the high cost? I'll give you a hint; it starts with ins and ends with urance.[/i]
Of all of the medical related industries, insurance has the LOWEST profit margin.
If anything, the GOVERNMENT created the problem... by not paying the full amount of claims submitted, plus forcing providers to provide a certain amount of "free" services, they add the amount they're not getting to the bills of paying customers. The insurance of these paying customers is covering the higher cost, so it's only natural that their price would increase as well. It's not unlike what merchants do when they've experienced loss due to theft.
If a $200,000 life insurance policy costs $100 a month, should a $400,000 life insurance policy cost the same?
[added:]
There ARE ways to reduce the cost of insurance, but forcing everyone to buy it is not it. The consumer should be in control.
by jck
"The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people."
- Tenth Amendment to the United States Constitution
They can't mandate states pay for insurance and/or medical care. That's just Republican spin.
Medicare and Medicaid are not guaranteed constitutionally.
Otherwise if that mandate were in there, you'd have more than a dozen States' Attorneys General filing a federal suit.
You'd have 50.
by jck
[i]Others (including me) see it as being to the detriment of the nation. [/i]
What is a detriment?
You getting health insurance cheaper than you do currently?
That all people can now get vaccinations and what not free or cheaper?
That fraud will be reduced that is currently costing US $500M+ in money as taxpayers?
So, what are you more against.
You having to pay $50 more per year in taxes??
Or the array of issues that the legislation fixes, including making all Americans have access to appropriate medical care?
Personally, I pay enough taxes on my primary and secondary income (especially the secondary) to make people choke up.
But if it means that babies are kept healthier and that people can get a free flu shot or medical checkup that might detect a disease in the early stages and get it treated and possibly cured?
I'm all for paying $50.
Oh but that's right. This bill is deficit negative.
It won't cost you anything....doh!
So...where is the detriment? If it doesn't spend any of your tax dollars (in fact, it's projected to save you tax dollars), what exactly is the detriment again?
How is no-cost-to-the-taxpayer, non-deficit government programming a detriment to the nation?
Because Blue Cross or Aetna or UnitedHealth can't make $100Ms of profits a year to pay their executives?
Please. Outline it for me simply. What is the detriment.
by jck
Let's make this real easy.
Do you think 50 states will employ fewer people to collect and disburse those monies the IRS currently does?
Not me. They will all have to have a "secretary" or "director", so that's 49 additional new, executive level positions paying 6-figures plus a year.
So...how again will that save you anything?
by jck
But, we don't have it yet.
Like I've said...the US senator(s) up this time...I will vote against both of them.
This partisan crap has to stop, and Americans have to learn to work together...that includes the ones making $140,000 a year sitting and writing bills and voting on them and stacking up their post-Congress funds/jobs.
by ic-it
You do not have to buy insurance that includes pregnancy and prenatal care. If the insurance company offers a policy that includes those, than yes, should you desire the other benifits of THAT plan and still desire it.
Otherwise you sign up for a different policy package.
by jck
[i][b]"Removal of insurance is anti-American. Didn't you learn that from Max? It's Socialism."[/b]
Not when it is out of pocket. You assumed that someone else would pick up the tab instead of insurance companies...[/i]
No, I was being sarcastic about what Max has called it before. Any program he doesn't like that the government tries to institute is "big government" and therefore "socialism".
[i][b]"You run into $900,000 of medical debt, you have $300k saved and a $500,000 expenditure limit on your policy...you're SOL no matter how hard you worked, how responsible enough you were to save, etc."[/b]
And this is known as life. But, two questions - was the actual service denied?, what caused the high cost? I'll give you a hint; it starts with ins and ends with urance.[/i]
1) Yes it's life, but if it happens to you it's not what should happen and therefore it doesn't matter...at least to Max...cause, it didn't happen to him.
2) Was service denied? No, they kept operating on my brother's malignant glioma in his brain and expecting my parents to pay whether insurance did or not. That's why they had to take out a six-figure loan after he died to bury him and pay off the medical bills.
3) What caused the high cost? I don't know. I was 2. I didn't go over the bills yet. Although, I think my parents still have all the documentation with my brother's stuff.
[i][b]"My point to Max is this: his way of thinking is that if you do as he did, worked as hard as him, invested like him...that there is no reason for you not to have what he does."[/b]
I believe your view is flawed. Granted, my understanding of Max is limited, but I believe he is communicating the ideals of individual outcome and respnosibility. I see no equality presented, simply the idea that each is responsible to make the best of what they have and not be dependent on a government system for their provisions.[/i]
No, he expects everyone to do as he did and have what he has if they do. If not, then it's not his fault or his job to help anyone he doesn't deem fit for it.
It's welfare if it's not approved by him.
It's generosity if it is approved by him.
[i]Another question, does everyone understand that insurance is simply a for fee cost sharing apparatus?[/i]
No, it is a fee for profit. Fee for cost would operate near/at expenses for operation/maintenance.
[i]Everyone that buys in agrees to commit capital, from which a management fee is drawn, and through which services are paid for. Part of the responsibility of managing this fund is limiting risk.[/i]
Actually? I didn't agree to commit. My employer told me "You either take the insurance or get nothing. You can't get the cash we use to buy it."
Hence, I was forced.
Should I have recourse? I have none now.
[i]]Put it this way, if you sold hamburgers and charded 3.50 for a hamburger. After some time you have made some money. Then, customers start demanding an extra piece of meat and cheese. They demand larger patties. The cost naturally rises. Now, throw in the fact that there are persons filing law suits because the cheese is Cheddar instead of American and claiming 1 million in damages.
Now you are charging 15.00 for your hamburger.[/i]
Only if you run a $hi++y business.
Advertise the meat weight and content of the burger, and that will nullify the lawsuits.
QED
[i]Am I absolving the insurance companies? No, not at all. But why add another cog to a machine just for risk management?[/i]
Cause right now, there is nothing keeping the insurance companies from being in passive collusion.
For instance, my neighbor lost his job. 57 years old, worked since he got out of the Army from doing 3 tours in Vietnam.
He tried to get health insurance. He is slightly overweight (maybe 10-15 lbs?), and relatively healthy.
No insurance company had a policy for him; none. He even tried through AARP. None.
The only place that will give him discounted medical care: The VA Hospital in Tampa.
If not for that, he'd have no medical care.
[i]There are a few new clinics in my area that are beginning to follow this trend. All services are rendered out of pocket. Insurance is not allowed. The benefit is that the procedures are much more focused, quicker, and most importantly - about 1/4 the cost.[/i]
Like I said, I think insurance should only be for optional or unnecessary things.
Basic care should be a national thing. Getting a flu shot, getting antibiotic for an infection, etc., should be covered.
And if we eliminated insurance for standard care and made it a national medical effort with a "medical czar", imagine all the money saved simply from not having to pay 15+ major insurance executives billions in compensatory wages under their contracts.
Hell, in 2001 I believe the CEO oh UnitedHealth got a 1.1 billion dollar bonus?
That's enough to fund the healthcare reform for a month, I bet!
Sorry. To me, standard medical care is just as important to this country as having safe roads, safe food in your stores, and safe drugs to take to make you better.
Government needs to oversee healthcare, because insurance is making a cash cow out of reducing peoples' care and increasing premiums.
It's sickening.
by jck
That would be impossible.
Sometimes the establishment of an office or function takes 3 or 4 sections or more.
Therefore, your request is, in part, impossible to fully supply.
The CBO report (I put a link somewhere in a post) showed not only overall savings but broke down the estimated cost to do so.
And, all you can ever do with a budget is estimate cost.
you never know what it actually costs until it is done and paid for.
by jmgarvin
How would they possibly know any costs other than projected costs?
Where did I state all the findings were false?
by puppybreath
Just because YOU say the CBO disagreed with the entire article doesn't make it true.
by jmgarvin
Oh and here:
http://www.cbo.gov/publications/collections/health.cfm
Seems like a simple fix to me...Rather than spending $0.50 of every $1.00 on the military industrial complex, we spend it on our citizens.
50% of the budget on the military?
Prove the accuracy of that number or admit you were wrong.
by puppybreath
What I'm saying is you dismissing the article using the CBO report as your source is wrong.
And the article wasn't using the CBO report as a source, it was using the actual bill.
And yet you call me ignorant......
by tonythetiger
It's for a greater good
Read my post further down and you'll understand.
Well, I'd no idea whether this was hyperbole or not but I assumed that it was but took a wander on the Net, anyway. I don't know if this is relevant...
http://www.cdi.org/issues/budget/fy%2702/ but there is a line "With the new funds, Pentagon spending now accounts for over half (50.5%) of all discretionary spending". Maybe where the number came from. I cannot comment on the authoritative status of the website but I have to say that any numbers for 2002 are going to be far below those of today.
For the total tax take, I found myself on CBO.gov in the Budget Review and military-related spending last year in total seemed to come in at around 40% of your tax take.
OK, it's not 50c on the dollar but it's a LOT of money. It's a HELL OF A LOT.
Unless I'm widely off the mark, jmgarvin is guilty of little more than slight exaggeration.
:)
I'll put down my spoon and await your reply...
by jmgarvin
by jmgarvin
by tonythetiger
and since the ones who are receiving the services are consumers, that is exactly as it should be. The problem is when consumers who DON'T want or need those services are forced to pay the bill for those who do.
Additionally, inserting an extra layer of bureaucracy is only going to make the total cost higher than it would otherwise be.
by jmgarvin
by tonythetiger
[i]
Medicare and Medicaid are not guaranteed constitutionally[/i]
No, but while the program exists, its rules must be adhered to. Failure to do so can result in the withholding of federal funds. This is one of the ways they sidestep the tenth amendment.
by jmgarvin
But I thought you did, considering how you post?
Military spending (total) both direct and indirect makes up about 22%-25% of our budget.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Military_budget_of_the_United_States
Anyway, the point being you are using bogus rhetoric and lying, so I figured I might as join in...
by jmgarvin
How hard is that to understand? Where do you think the CBO got their numbers?
In the article, I saw very little analysis and mostly fluff. Where did they divine this information out of the bill?
by tonythetiger
How do you thing they collect state and local taxes now?
If you go to the store and buy a tube of toothpaste, the cashier collects your payment. Do you think if you bought ten tubes, they'd have to have ten cashiers to collect your payment?
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
by puppybreath
Each section of the article included the section of the bill that it was referring to.
Did you even read the article, or were you too busy thinking of ways to dismiss it because it differed from your opinion?
by jmgarvin
by jmgarvin
The CBO report is completely orthogonal to the article you linked.
I can't access the article, as it is pointing me to an error page now....
Anyway, the point being that the CONGRESSIONAL BUDGET OFFICE wrote and extensive report, with math no less, explaining how the bill will work.
Your article cherry picked points it didn't like and ignored the bill in its entirety.
by puppybreath
You keep bringing the CBO report up as a smokescreen instead of addressing the exact content of sections of the bill.
This isn't about what the total cost of the bill is going to be. It never was except in your mind. This is about sections of the bill that are not in the best interest of the citizens.
But instead of addressing those sections, you keep pointing to the CBO report like it's some magic solution with all the answers. Since the report doesn't address specific sections of the bill, it's ridiculous for you to keep using it as a source for disproving any of the points brought up in the article.
Would caps help?
THIS HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH THE CBO REPORT. IT HAS TO DO WITH THE CONTENTS OF THE BILL AND HOW IT IS WORDED.
by tonythetiger
business can't stay in business without customers. Prices would self-adjust, if the customers would use their power, dickering, and word-of-mouth. People who don't have insurance can actually negotiate for a lower rate. People who HAVE insurance can too, but usually don't, since their "co-pay" is usually the same anyway.
Since we're mandating restaurants put up nutritional information, perhaps we should mandate that service providers provide their charges up front, before the services are rendered. That might wake up a few consumers.
by tonythetiger
which "medical related" industry has the lowest profit margin?
It's not big pharma (16.5%)
It's not medical equipment and supplies (6.8%)
It's not healthcare REITs (24.6%)
It's not healthcare information services (9.3%)
It's not medical laboratories and research facilities (8.2%)
Surely it's generic drugs, right? ... Nope (6.6%)
It's not hospitals (3.6%)
It's medical insurance! 3.3%
And if your insurance "cancels you", well, you chose a company whose contract with you allows it. (What? you didn't? shouldn't you have that right? why don't you?)
Identify the REAL problem!
by tonythetiger
"A greater good" is an illusory concept. It is an imaginary creature, conjured up by a spoiled child who jumps up and down screaming until it gets its way.
Its use is fraudulent. It is ostensibly something people ought to "self-sacrifice" for, yet, since self-sacrifice is by implication voluntary, and voluntary is never enough to satisfy the spoiled child, it inevitably turns into a subterfuge used to steal power. Tyrants throughout history have used it effectively.... for a time... usually ended when the burden causes intolerable resentment.
The worst thing for society... far worse than what now exists, is to punish those with the means to help until they decide they are no longer willing to help. Once you treat them like they have no rights except to serve, they will soon decide that they no longer have a reason to serve, and they will revolt. Workers do this when they go on strike. Companies do this when they send jobs overseas. Wealthy people will eventually feel so used and unappreciated (for the money they spend or invest, which creates opportunities for others) that they will pick up their toys and leave, hiding their wealth from society's influence until they think it's safe to participate again.
Then what? Poverty, hunger and disease will grow far worse, that's what! We'll have another Great(er!) Depression, that's what!
When will we learn? There are too many factors outside of anyone's control to achieve perfection for every member of society (whatever the definition of THAT is...). The closest we can come... the "best outcome" will be had if we foster conditions conducive to building and keeping trust and loyalty among people, and to encourage success (as any parent knows, encouraging success breeds success, and success breeds generosity). That means not coercing compliance with some rule of the day or other created because someone's ox got gored. I mean, think about it. If a particular idea really was "best for society", would you really have to force it on them? I don't think so.
To borrow an old saying, you really can attract more flies with honey than you can with vinegar (a saying I admit I should pay heed to more often myself).
Sort by Trending