ObamaCare: It's not about medical care; it's about control over your life
This is page 6 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Networks
This is page 6 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by tonythetiger
[i]When those taxes go to building a new shelter for the homeless, supporting rehabilitation efforts, encarcerating a prisoner, saving a hooker's life, sending an ambulance to assist someone overdosing on the street etc. you are in turn, allowing the government to take away your money and use it for someone else's benefit. However, these are just things we accept as necessary in society.[/i]
I want to pay for, example, an ambulance to be at the ready. That's infrastructure. When the ambulance is actually used, however, the person using it should pay for that use. Just like water or electricity.
[i]And yet you pick and choose when it comes to the welfare of other Americans?[/i]
Yes I do. Someone who has lost their own legs doesn't have the right to demand I give them one of mine. Why do they not by force harvest organs from the brain-dead, for example?
by jck
You seem to expect Congress to do things right the first time :p :^0
Actually, the easiest thing to do?
Make insurance illegal.
Then, doctors could determine what they need to do to a patient, if a patient thinks they receive bad care they can take it to court and medical experts could render whether or not the process was correct, and 3rd party profit-driven corporations would not make decisions on how to increase bottom line rather than what is proper care for a patient/condition.
I've never understood why profit can be a consideration taken over the well-being of a human.
It just falls outside my valueset.
Sorry.
by jck
There's a difference between what you *need* and what you *want*.
If you don't get a penile implant or a reduction, are you going to die?
Necessary = needed.
No one needs a bigger unit or bigger boobs to live.
Ask my aunt. She has no boobs. She had a dual radical mastectomy. That was necessary to save her life. It killed her sister and her mother (my other aunt and my grandmother).
Did she need implants to continue to be a woman? No. My uncle still loves her as much as he did when they got married 51 years ago.
So there's a difference between "necessary" and "wanted".
What you want is discretionary.
What is necessary is what keeps you a functioning, viable person.
And no, you'll not convince me a less-than-confident woman who doesn't get a boob job can't be functioning and/or viable in the world.
If a naturally flat-chested woman needs a boob job to feel like a woman, she needs mental counseling first to teach her that everyone is different and to learn to be comfortable in her own skin.
...or pay for the boob job herself.
But, I think you are smart enough to know that a necessary procedure is something that saves the viability of a human being...not their aesthetic quality they enjoy.
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
[i]It just falls outside my valueset.[/i]
but the difference is, I can put my value set into practice without infringing on you. You cannot say the same.
by tonythetiger
And I will say it lots more
The federal government should only spend money on those things which benefit every citizen equally. The cost of this should be divided equally among the citizens. If you can't meet your responsibility, you can ask for help, but you cannot demand it.
by jck
You can't justify me shooting my brains out because I couldn't get a box of Cracker Jack when I was 5 because I was $.03 short.
You also can't justify a breast augmentation as a *necessary* medical procedure to maintain someone as a viable person.
Just because politicians makes stupid choices in what they make loopholes for in bills does not mean the rest of America does.
So to cut-off everything en masse because a few dorks take advantage does nothing but hurt the truly needful out of spite for those in dire need.
You stop stupid thing from happening by stopping stupid things from being done.
Not by stopping everything.
by jck
The government makes it law, and then it is no longer an infringement on YOUR rights, but has become a requirement and is therefore a law that as a respectable American citizen that you must follow or become criminal, until such time as you depart the country, expire, or cause change to the law to modify, repeal, or eliminate.
Personally? If I had your same mindset, I'd say why the hell do I have to pay back what your generation ran up on the books during the Reagan era? I didn't vote then, yet you and your generation expect me to bail out your debt and pay for your retirement?
Ha! Stop leeching off me! :p :^0
See? QED. ;)
by tonythetiger
[i]You also can't justify a breast augmentation as a *necessary* medical procedure to maintain someone as a viable person.[/i]
"But I've become so depressed since my girls didn't grow like the other girls' girls that my self-esteem is completely gone..."
"And my nose is so big that interviewers laugh at me instead of hiring me".
or on the other extreme...
"My face was burned so badly that nobody could stand to look at me. When the doctors repaired the damage, they just left two holes where my nose and mouth were and told me I was functional."
[i]So to cut-off everything en masse because a few dorks take advantage does nothing but hurt the truly needful out of spite for those in dire need.[/i]
Who said anything about cutting anything off "en-masse"? I'm more than happy to donate time and resources to the truly needy. Because the government is less selective of who it helps, the truly needy get less help than they otherwise would.
by jmgarvin
You can't debate the issues or the principle, so you fall back on the politics of personal destruction.
Sad
by jck
I thought that video made a very good point:
Most of the people had no clue as to what they were against in the Healthcare Reform bill.
When asked to explain what provision(s) of the bill they were against and why and what those specific provisions were going to do wrong, none of them could quote even one provision.
Hence, the video solidly shows that all those people interviewed were entirely ignorant of the subject matter against which they were protesting.
Quite expository, I must say.
by jmgarvin
Not just the touchy feely crap you keep posting.
YOU think something, but when facts are provided to prove you wrong, suddenly the person isn't worth talking to.
I await your well thought-out, non-emotional, historically correct, and non self-centered reply.
Any professor worth his salt would grade this an F:
by jck
First, the video is quite an example of a well presented, formed, and documenting piece of fact. It shows how the right, who often accuses the left of doing so, has become overly emotional and incoherent in regards to something they claim to know about at the time.
Secondly, your post to which I am replying would be graded by most collegiate English Composition professors as failing. You provided no topic sentence, used broken thought, and did not explain your points past giving references.
Your "pot calling the kettle black" action neither supports your position nor shows you to be any better than that which you have critiqued.
As for historically correctness, I would think a video of individuals being shown who can not give reference to parts of a piece of legislation they so vehemently oppose because of what they say it contains is quite relevant. It serves to show to posterity how the conservative, emotional, uneducated persons on the right will get in a frenzy over something that does not suit their wants...much as they accuse the liberals on the left of quite often.
Therefore, it is a historically correct representation of hypocrisy that occurs on both sides...whether they choose to admit it or not.
BTW, since when did TechRepublic become graded? I already got my degree.
by oz_media
[i]I await your well thought-out, non-emotional, historically correct, and non self-centered reply.[/i]
Such as: https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=327627&messageID=3269708
Very well though out, non emotional reply there Max; it's nice to see you again demonstrate just how completely ignorant you are to the meaning of hypocrisy.
by jmgarvin
"And if the list of rights retained by the people could have been made complete, which would have been impossible, I don't believe the founders would have included one that said one person has a right to force another person to either provide or otherwise pay for goods or services received, medical or otherwise."
You are already paying for it.
Do you have insurance? You are paying for it.
That's it. Period.
You just want to shuffle the money around and not THINK about how you are just shuffling costs.
You are complaining about what? Do you have car insurance? You are REQUIRED to have car insurance. Why aren't you bitching about that?
You still haven't explained your position, but you've parroted Limbaugh and Hannity quite well.
by oz_media
by jck
Not everyone can be a, to quote Jesse Ventura from the movie Predator:
"God-damned sexual tyranosaurus"
Let Max have a pass on this one. For all we know, he could be one of those reformed, retired adult movie directors who found God.
I hear a lot of them live in CO :^0
by tonythetiger
[i]The government makes it law, and then it is no longer an infringement on YOUR rights[/i]
Just like when they made a law authorizing the government to round up the Japanese-Americans and put them in camps, it infringed on THEIR rights.
In fact, that's all a government CAN do to citizens... infringe on their rights. You can certainly argue that some infringements may be justified... but they are still infringements.
by tonythetiger
everybody pays for it for access, but if you use more electricity than I do, you pay more.
The same should be true of government services. We all pay for it to be there, but if one person uses it more, they should pay more.
....... ?
(I thought it might be fun.)
by oz_media
I disagreed with you, what else should I expect you to say?
American ANYTHING is so internationally broadcast that I think most people worldwide get the same info but simply don't interpret it with the same, blind, national pride, regardless of content, that you would.
I don't think your reply surprises anyone, you are very predictable.
If anyone says something relevant that you don't like, they are either clueless, disingenuous, not worth your time etc.
You have come from offering comments of an almost interesting depth and thought to become rather mundane, transparent and predictable with your ever so jingoistic yet paranoid commentary.
by oz_media
Considering only Scotch Whiskey (Scotch actually made in Scotland)
Favorite brand : Glenmorangie
Best brand: arguably Saint Magdalene or Remy Martin (Louis XII rare cask)
Favorite blend: Glennmorangie, Sherrywood Finish or Malaga Cask
Favorite Single malt: Glenmorangie 25 Year old Malaga Wood or Single Highland Malt
by oz_media
Makes a scotch?
Used to drink it long ago.
One time, a defense attorney, officer of the bar, showed up late one night at my door. Handed me a full quart of the stuff. Thanked me in advance of how I might treat his client.
by jck
YOU don't have the RIGHT to determine what is or is not an infringement.
That's up to the legal system.
I can say it's my right to use a prostitute, because its consentual between two adults. Does that make it my right, even though its illegal or morally wrong?
I think your RIGHT to decide what YOU think is okay to be spent by government is an INFRINGEMENT on MY right to have a government that looks out for US.
It's a government of the people, by the people, and for the people...
...not of the Tony, by the Tony, and for the Tony.
BTW, when are you going to write the $16,000 check for your share of your generation's running up the national deficit and expecting my generation to pay off?
Isn't that infringing on my rights?
Your generation took money out of my generations pocket. Your generation obligated my generation to pay for yours.
So...why aren't your reconciling the wrongs of what your generation did to its posterity first?
Just makes no sense. Seems like what's good for Tony is okay, but what isn't good for Tony becomes a human rights travesty.
That's all.
by jck
[i]"But I've become so depressed since my girls didn't grow like the other girls' girls that my self-esteem is completely gone..."[/i]
Wah. Go look at my aunt. Then complain about your "girls".
[i]"And my nose is so big that interviewers laugh at me instead of hiring me".[/i]
Wah. I was over 500 lbs at one point. I lost it myself. I paid for it myself. No one else made me that way, and no one else made your nose that way.
And if someone won't hire you because of your nose, it's their loss. They'll fail as a company because of their stupid decisions.
[i]or on the other extreme...
"My face was burned so badly that nobody could stand to look at me. When the doctors repaired the damage, they just left two holes where my nose and mouth were and told me I was functional."[/i]
Yeah. Sad. But, they saved your life.
I was stared at for years for being over 500 lbs. Again, I paid to fix it and did the work. No one else made me fat.
If someone else burned you, sue them and show their liability for your injuries, damage, and suffering. Then, use that to have done what you want.
Hell, I broke my neck and I have a nasty 9 inch scar down the back of my neck that looks like Valles Marineris. I get looks at all the time like I'm a circus freak when I go out and I'm not wearing a turtleneck or a dress shirt that covers it up.
But, I'm still breating and functioning and working and living my life. That's what matters.
[i]Who said anything about cutting anything off "en-masse"? I'm more than happy to donate time and resources to the truly needy. Because the government is less selective of who it helps, the truly needy get less help than they otherwise would.[/i]
Really? Seems that anything government does that you don't approve of, you want to get rid of.
So...let me get this right...you have personally sat down and interviewed needy folks regularly to determine their true need??
Then, helped them find affordable housing, subsidized their housing, given them vouchers to buy groceries, paid for their childrens' daycare, helped them find a job, paid for them to get job training and/or education, made sure they and their children got proper medical care, gave them counselling on proper nutrition, etc?
Right. You know exactly who is needy and who isn't.
You're practically the Santa Claus of the impoverished.
He's makin a list...checkin it twice...gonna find out who's needy or not...Santa Tony's comin...to help.
Gimme a break. You are far too confident in your ability to determine need. And, even less efficient than government is at assisting those who do need it.
And just for the record: Yes, I have worked on HFH homes, worked in soup kitches, food pantries, battered womens' shelters, etc.
I even made the mistake once of giving a sizable amount to the American Red Cross after Hurricane Katrina. Then, the executives and management were caught funneling off $100Ms into their own pockets.
That will never happen again. Just like I don't give clothing or furniture to Salvation Army anymore, since I saw the hoards of wealthy old women in the store in St. Petersburg buying up all the good discounted items for themselves.
Yes, they were wealthy. When you drive a brand new Mercedes 500-class or Jaguar XJ, you aren't a welfare mom.
And the best thing I tell people to do when a guy comes up and asks for money for food? I go in and buy it for him and make sure he gets fed.
Give a man a fish, he eats for a day.
Teach a man to fish, he eats the rest of his life.
Give a man $5 for fish, 4 out of 5 times he goes and buys a 6-pack of Old Milwaukee.
Anyway...don't assume to think you are the model of determination and efficiency for providing assistance.
There's people who have done it a lot more and have more experience at it than you.
And, some of them actually work for your government.
So, get rid of the problems with the system...not the whole system.
by jck
if a "breaker" on the "grid" goes out, do they say "that breaker isn't worthy of being fixed. let's replace the whole substation."?
And by your analogy, the poor would never have power.
So since they can't pay for it, they must do without?
If you can't pay for the power hookup, you can't get it.
Oops. See, government is not a pay-per-use service. It's not an enterprise.
It's a collective system of services and safeties that provides assurances of function and stabilization for all of America.
Not just those who can afford it.
by oz_media
I was just thinking of a bottle of Louis XIII that I like to drink sometimes when I visit The Cannery, where I get to select from one of my favorite Glenmorangie blends and Single malts. The Cannery is a really nice reseuarant, very secretively tucked away in a corner of the harbour. When you walk in you simply drool at the rare and vintage bottles of scotch they have lining the taster's wall. I often sip a glass of Louis XIII for desert when there on a company or client's tab, so I lumped it in as a scotch.
Of course, the Louis XIII is a cognac and not a scotch though.
In lieu of that I would then add the more popular and common, Johnny Blue or Johnny Swing. Swing is always a fun one when drinking for effect as it never falls of the table. Cool bottles, but more of a popular distiller than a top one in my books anyway.
I remember drinking at the Vancouver Marine Club's lounge when I was younger. When they were down to the last shot in a bottle of JW Blue, you had to play darts against the person who drank the last shot of teh last bottle. Winner gets the final shot and loser pays for it.
The bartender would then tape the winner's name to the empty bottle so people knew who they had to beat for the last shot of the next bottle. (Yeah, kinda like an expensive drinking game :) )
It was an interesting crowd of mining exploration developers, traders, top ad men promoters, etc. Exellent networking fodder to say the least. So, being a hot shot 'kid' at the time(in my 20's and deemed the 'young pup' there), I offered a round to those at the bar one payday.
Around a dozen, that I admired for their welth and success, then all ordered a shot of Johnny Blue. We toasted and played some darts and networked for a few hours as usual. Later hat night I did it again, (hey, I am rich, why not? Playing with the big boys is cool!) So when 2AM rolled around any my bill included nearly 25 shots at $27 each (bar pricing of course), I learned really quick not to order JW Blue at a bar.
The bartender was really nice and the owner liked me. I hung out with the biggest players in town so I earned a passage of rights merely due to association (I was only a facility manager for a massive call center then). That's when I got 'awarded' my running tab. What a mistake that was, I'd be mailed my bill for the month and end up writing them a check that was a good portion of my income. It was still cool to walk into one of Vancouver's most esteemed and exclusive lounges, be recognized and play the game with the big boys though.
Thank god I got over that!
Again. But we all know that.
You used the ninth amendment as support for your argument, yet when I ask you to interpret the ninth amendment as it was intended, you either evade or repeat your already debunked assertion.
by oz_media
AGAIN...as always put in a title to imply onen direction fo your post and offer nothing of substance to support it.
Man, you have slipped to the point of sheer lunacy these days.
What does YOUR completely irrelevant opinion of my intellect have to do with your title, "Oz and Manhood"?
You made a completely baseless comment about manhood, when ut was proven to be baseless, your rebuttal is also completely baseless and irrelevant.
What happend to you? You've clearly lost the plot.
What a 'kin putz!
by oz_media
YOu give him a lot of credit. I don't know about you but Max of 2010 pales in contrast to Max of 2005.
Unless it's just that I have only recently recognized how useless and irrelevant his comments really are and he's always been that way.
by oz_media
We have been to the egde of the world and back,a very looong history. I do actually respect Max quite a lot, I thunk it is mainly due to his tenacity.
Personally, I too would hate to argue with me, I am very stubborn and sure of myself and , for the most part, correct. If I am replying to something I am not completely confident of, Google has always been my friend. Besides that,m I am a seive when it comes to information, I can remember science shows I watched 30 years ago and the information within. No, I am not saying I am smarter than anyone, but merely often understimated, which is frustratibg for many I am sure.
Anyway, mega ramble done, Max is okay but I find his standards and credibility have gone from 10 to 4, which is pretty sad really but I know he doesn't seek my pity,
Either way, and I am positive he agrees here, we both go too far with th personal attacks more often than not but would still happily have a scotch together or see a show at Red Rocks.
by jck
I joined about 2005...I think. :^0
I even remember in 2007 I think that some people on TR actually called for Max's ouster.
Of course, shortly after that was when I left for about a year.
Do I give Max a lot of credit?
Hm. Okay. Here's what I can say about Max:
a) Some of his basic principles are solid, i.e.- minimal government, expecting more of politicians than they give, etc.
b) I think he really does believe in what he says, no matter how convoluted I think his approaches are.
c) I think (at least from what he's said) has worked hard in his life to get what he has. That's more than I can say for a lot of people in America nowadays (especially people my own age and younger...anyone ever start working for other people at age 6 making your own money?).
Do I think he's a bad guy? Mmmm. No. Not morally or spiritually.
I just think part of my issue with him is that he is an absolutist and a hardliner and his approach to most things is so fixated on minutia or single-pointed objection that he doesn't often see the broad scope of things.
Maybe I do give him a lot of credit. I also point out his inadequacies.
But like JamesRL said: everyone has flaws
Yes, that includes me and you, Oz. :^0
by oz_media
that's about the way I see it too.
Speaking of our flaws, to offer an example of us being both being flawed.
I think your last sentence should read "...you and I" not "..me and you".
You typed it but I just had to point it out. :D
But, to stand aside and give you your say.
I am reminded, however, of a story long, long ago. Had to do with two old Irish guys in a Boston hospital-hospice.
The one, bedded in the same end-room with his life-long adversary, survived to say: "I got to watch the SOB die!"
So.
There is more you wish to share?
by plexussage
"I simply love the way Americans miscomprehend and interpret comments to create their own false arguments. That's exactly what got Bush to support war in the first place."
You're argument will carry a little more weight if you leave out the personal attacks.
If you can't resist doing so, at least tell us dumb Americans what it is that allows Canadians to properly conmprehend and interpret all information set before them.
We're all ears...
by jck
My elementary school gym teacher always told me:
"If you don't look out for yourself, no one else will."
So I had to put myself first. That way, I don't forget me. :^0
by jamesrl
I'm sure that its a matter of perspective. Obviously some people thinks its still debate, and others think its "Mr poopyhead" stuff.
You have to read it for yourself to decide.
James
..... and a hypocrite, mean-spirited, selfish, non-intelligible, disingenuous, dishonest, illogical, narrow minded, a hard-liner, an absolutist, unable to focus, irrelevant, I have a peculiar understanding of death, I'm a mere shadow of my former self --- and, it appears that I'm even one of those that lulls around on the bottom and sucks the algae off the rocks --- and on it goes.
Or so say my detractors, who outnumber me many to one - or make that many to four-tenths of one if you listen to one of those detractors!
I still love you.
:D
by oz_media
..... admitting when you're wrong and/or conceding a point. Your childish insistence that you're right - especially when it's obvious you are not - is anything but being manly. Being intellectually dishonest is anything but being manly.
Oz said, [i]"US constitution was a document outlining which rights were to be bestowed upon US citizens.[/i]
Common sense will illustrate your statement to be false. At the time of its writing, there was no United States government. Therefore, if, as you suggest, it [i]was a document outlining which rights were to be bestowed upon US citizens[/i], then it begs the question. Bestowed by whom?
Moreover, it defines both the bestowed and the ones doing the bestowing in the Preamble of that very document:
[i]We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.[/i]
We the people ...... do ordain and establish this Constitution - not the other way around.
Be a man, Oz, and admit you're wrong.
P.S. It seems rather silly to debate the merits and intents of the US Constitution with a Canadian (or are you a Brit?). And it's pretty pompous and arrogant of you to presume you know more about the US Constitution than I. (But then again, jmgarvin and jck apparently know diddly-squat about it, and they're Americans!)
by oz_media
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hsFsn8ekyhw
What must that naval officer be thinking about that congressman?
by oz_media
If he (the naval officer you are referring to) is as stupid as you He'd take it verbatim as spoken and not as a typical line of outlandish questioning to instill a point. Such simple methods or questioning occur daily in courts all over the world. With any luck, an officer in the US navy wouldn't be nearly as dense though.
OBVIOUSLY he is referring to an imbalance of US troops to locals, well maybe not that obviously to one with such inadequate comprehension.
You know your true colours have really shown through with all the complete BS and misunderstoood commentary you keep parroting lately. You seem to completely miss the point over and over and over again. It started as far back as you quoting John Kerry out of context and incorrectly, but now it is just going to ridiculous extremes.
You either think that your fellow, republican supporters are completely moronic and would believe this crap you spew (you might not be so far off there), or else you are demonstrating your own idiocy by believing it yourself.
Man, you go so far that you make me miss my old Stretch Armstrong toy!
[i]"I wasn't suggesting that the island of Guam would literally tip over," he said. . Johnson said he was "using a metaphor" to describe how adding more military personnel to the tiny island "could be a tipping point which could adversely affect the island?s fragile ecosystem and could overburden its stressed infrastructure."[/i]
- Representative Hank Johnson
[i]" For months, speculation has swirled in both Atlanta and Washington about U.S. Rep. Hank Johnson's health.
The Lithonia Democrat's already-thin frame has shed 30 pounds in the past year. His speech is slower than ever, and he regularly gets lost in thought in the middle of a discussion. He is easily fatigued and often impatient and irritable.
Monday, he revealed why.
In an exclusive interview with the AJC, Johnson disclosed he has been battling hepatitis C, an incurable, blood-borne liver disease, for more than a decade.
He was officially declared free of the virus in January, but it has ravaged his liver, resulted in thyroid problems and other health issues, including depression, for which he's also being treated. To keep the disease in remission, Johnson is going through an experimental treatment that he said has been the worst part so far.[/i]
- Atlanta Journal Constitution news story, December 2009
In response to Republican Congressman Wilson who yelled [i]you lie[/i] to President Obama:
[i]"I guess we?ll probably have folks putting on white hoods and white uniforms again and riding through the countryside, intimidating people. That?s the logical conclusion if this kind of attitude is not rebuked."[/i]
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ALoQMzo00rs
Another metaphor?
Deadpan humor, or suffering from the effects of a disease and/or medication?
You, Oz, think the former. I, however, believe the latter is more likely - although the congressman's office has not offered that as a reason for the comments.
Either way.......
by av .
The Congressman should step down and take care of his illness. He is obviously on some heavy-duty drugs and I don't think he has a clear head. I don't know much about him, but if he was in my District I'd vote him out.
Its a very sad display for a Congressman. Not acceptable to me.
AV
by oz_media
Utter horseshit. That's just some fallacy an insecure idiot came up with and more and mroe insecure idiots repeat it. Chromosomes and a penis make me a man.
It seems that, while you can type, you can't read, which may explain your pathetic reading comprehension issues. Which also makes me wonder how you get ahead in life, period.
I already illustrated above EXACTLY who wrote the US Constitution, unlss you are now deeming US history incorrect too, which wouldn't surprise me as you seem to feel you are the ultimate opinion on any such subject, even deeming your fellow Americans uneducated on the matter. Perhaps it was only your school that learned US history? While I didn't have to recite the pledge of alleguiance each morning, we also studied US and WORLD history throughout school too, including US independance and the US Constitution. I am sure that comes as a shock to someone like yourself, who feels that a nation only teaches it's own brand of its own history.
[i]"...it begs the question. Bestowed by whom?"[/i]
Once again, the same people who finally had 'convinced' enough of 'the others' to join them in seeking independance.
'Delegates' from states (which is how 'we the people' were supposedly represented), [i]"12 states answered by sending their most experienced, most talented, and smartest men; Rhode Island, which feared the interference of a strengthened national government in state affairs, sent no one to Philadelphia
"New York lawyer and future American politician and diplomat Gouverneur Morris (1752-1816) who actually took on the task of penning the Constitution, putting into prose the resolutions reached by the convention. Morris had the considerable help of the records that James Madison (1751-1836) of Virginia had kept as he managed the debates among the delegates and suggested compromises. In that capacity and in that he designed the system of checks and balances among the legislative (Congress), the executive (the president of the United States), and the judicial (Supreme Court), Madison had considerable influence on the document's language, quite rightfully earning him the designation "father of the constitution." [/i]
Certainly, people WERE represented, just as Obama now represents YOUR opinions and views. We all know just how well one man represents the views, thoughts and opinions of all. I always thought you were more right wing than that, however by your own admission, one man represents now your views.
Give your head a good shake and wake up already, to believe that the Constitution was written BY THE PEOPLE you have to be off your f'in rocker, mate. Right bloody looney, lost the plot, mad as a hatter....get it? Prim-O Nuts-O!
So no, I won't admit to being wrong when I am not wrong. When I am wrong, I'll let you know, then you can 'pretend' you are a man, at last.
"we the people", my arse! LOL, you'll believe anything they've drilled into your single minded brain over the years.
by oz_media
I suppose you can bastardize the English language all you like.
But if you REALLY want to nitpick and learn grammar, the correct term would be "You and me"
A Simple rule for compound Pronouns (as described for AMERICAN English):
[i]"Keep the following mnemonic sentence in mind: "I" am the Subject but the Object is "me." There are no exceptions."[/i]
So "be a man, admit your wrong", I did and even corrected myself. However, I am confident you will continue to not 'man up' and will blather on with more irrelevant BS anyway. Too predictable, Max, FAR too predictable.
by oz_media
LOL, you're funny! :D
To answer your question, an education resulting in comprehension skills.
It's not as if it way cryptic, it was corrected in the printed transcript too. How can anyone miss what is clearly printed unless;
A) they cannot read
B) a pure lack of reading comprehension skills.
You watch a video and take it at face value, even when the information is absolutely ridiculous?
TIP: If Max is making something ou of it, ALWAYS check it out his false 'FACTS' before buying into it.
He does this all the time, it's his game. He takes some comment and creates a thread out of it. He is also skilled at quoting people out of context and making up false arguments based on terrible reading comprehension skills. It's got to the point that I don't believe word he says until I can confirm it, I'd say he gets these things wrong (purposely perhaps) 90% of the time.
Also, if you read the comments right under the video he linked to, the same question is raised and a correction is made, which would cause any sane person to look further for verification.
As the comment Obama made was CLEALY a mistake, it simply does not make any sense otherwise, it only took a second to find out what was actually meant to be said by checking The White House transcript, which very quickly offers the correction.
It's funny how people can Google to find YouTube videos that suit their agenda but not to confirm facts.
Oh, and if you take a comments about "Americans" as a personal attack, you are in real need of help.
P.S. I'm not Canadian either.
Using [i]you and I[/i] in place of [i]you and me[/i] - when the latter is actually correct in some particular case - is one of the most common mistakes made (speaking and writing).
http://www.yourdictionary.com/library/drlang002.html
Side note: Using [i]it's[/i] (with apostrophe) instead of [i]its[/i] (without apostrophe) in the case of a possessive pronoun is another common mistake (writing).
by ic-it
Consider Max's response, this part;
We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
It would seem that these words;
promote the general Welfare,
Strengthen the arguement for a Health system.
welfare includes the well being of a person.
by oz_media
As with most ancient scriptures, it is up to personal interpretation as to what it really means. Everyone seems to feel that The Constitution is a well defined and precise document, however they all have varied interpretations of what that precision indicates.
That's why it is clearly a document focused on loose political speak and definitely not something citizens would have drafted for themselves, as Max seems to feel.
Maybe it was like a chain letter passed throughout the population and everyone added to it, that would make it a document written BY the people anyway.
Max has just become delusional and believes whatever he was trained to believe in and repeat, yet even the slightest scrutiny shows otherwise.
by oz_media
I'll let you think you have a point on that one, maybe it will make 'them' feel a little heavier and your beard will grow a bit more as the your masculinity gets to grow.
[i]Sometimes you have to let a fool believe in himself, otherwise he simply becomes the village idiot.[/i]
by oz_media
Bush would never have said anything like that, mind you he wasn't a congressman, he was YOUR president.
At least in this case, he WAS clearly speaking figuratively (well clearly enough for most)and it is NOT rare at all in such a setting, not in a court room. It is VERY effective speech in such a situtaion.
Speaking figuratively is illustrating a point using a more extreme example for the sake of effect.
by oz_media
It is entirely irrelevant and makes no point whatsoever.
Once again you try to draw your initial, most ridiculous, post so far off track just so you can seek a point of debate that you can possibly make a point with. Whether it is relevant or related to your opening post, is irrelevant to you.
So getting back to the reason for your nonsense.
Are you now forgetting that you initially used a misread TelePrompter comment and tried to make a case against the health care bill? Or are you still firm that, because he misspoke, that the health care bill will not work?
Man, you claw and scrape and cling and just don't know when to let go and fall to your death.
by oz_media
[i]With respect to the two words 'general welfare,' I have always regarded them as qualified by the detail of powers connected with them. To take them in a literal and unlimited sense would be a metamorphosis of the Constitution into a character which there is a host of proofs was not contemplated by its creators.[/i]
-James Madison
[i]If Congress can employ money indefinitely to the general welfare, and are the sole and supreme judges of the general welfare, they may take the care of religion into their own hands; they may appoint teachers in every State, county and parish and pay them out of their public treasury; they may take into their own hands the education of children, establishing in like manner schools throughout the Union; they may assume the provision of the poor; they may undertake the regulation of all roads other than post-roads; in short, every thing, from the highest object of state legislation down to the most minute object of police, would be thrown under the power of Congress.... Were the power of Congress to be established in the latitude contended for, it would subvert the very foundations, and transmute the very nature of the limited Government established by the people of America.[/i]
-James Madison
[i]Congress has not unlimited powers to provide for the general welfare, but only those specifically enumerated.[/i]
-Thomas Jefferson
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by ic-it
Often times to Promote one thing (Health Care System), one must regulate or establish a system that will provide opportunities for receiving timely, balanced health care. That would promote one's well being.
To actually provide health care is still in the hands of the Medical Specialists/Field.
Boxie, that was a bit snarky of you. I am of the opinion that my comprehension and vocabulary can met your own.
Santee - No bending on my part, perhaps it is in your interpretation as to what the bill actually does or does not provide/promote?
I swore long ago under oath to support and defend the Constitution by force of arms. Behooved then, since, and now, the oath not having expired, I have made certain as I can not to fudge meaning.
If boxy was snarky, you are downright sleezy in what you say the Constitution "seems" to say.
by ic-it
Have you truely lost your mind?
I too took that same oath and it too still means something.
Many in our Congressional Halls took an oath close to that which we did, unfortunately they do not honor it as we did and do.
How is it sleazy to think that the Constitution did not want us to do as it stated. PROMOTE the welfare. Or is it simply that no one can think differently than you.
Edited for one major comma placement (normally I miss quite a few but this was a bad one). :-)
"Sleezy"; not, sleazy. Same reason I said, "boxy", and, not "boxie". As it were, I called you a slithy tove, of which there ain't none such, so how can you be?
My comprehension and vocabulary, too, would seem to match your own.
How do you answer Madison and Jefferson?
They anticipated the misapplication of the general welfare clause.
And before you say something like, that was then, this is now, and it should be interpreted by today's standards; consider they anticipated that as well, and integrated the process of amending the Constitution instead of interpreting it in a manner not intended. If enough people want a government mandated and controlled medical care system, then the constitution should be amended to grant that power to the government - one that should otherwise remain in the hands of the people and/or the individual states.
Nonetheless, Madison and Jefferson anxiously await your rebuttal to their comments.
by ic-it
Do I really need to?
Congress is not fullfilling their fears.
This bill actually returns funds to the coffers and provides a promotion of the general welfare through access.
You could use their very words to argue against the Dept. of Education and more, does that mean you feel such agencies should be abolished?
by boxfiddler Hot topic
One of my pet peeves is the dumbing of the American education. I see it everyday, in the classes I (attempt to) teach. I saw it every day in the classes I took in order to be able to teach.
I was speaking generally, at an opportune moment, to a problem that underlies (probably) all our problems.
Barely monosyallabic students that can't pass multisyllabic classes become barely monosyllabic adults who can't pass multisyllabic life.
Nothing I haven't said before regarding other issues. Why so defensive?
by ic-it
I fear yours is levels above mine.
I also must apologize for slaying Boxys nickname and missing your point.
Boxy, sorry, I seemed to have stepped in front of your shot and mistakenly thought it was your aim, rather than my gait.
by boxfiddler Hot topic
Absolutely yes, I'd be in favor of abolishing the Department of Education.
The Department of Education, as it's known and functions today, was created by Congress in 1979, and began operation in 1980. Before then, the administration of the public school system was a function of individual state and local governments.
By establishing a federal oversight and control department, the individual states and localities have less - and in some cases no - control and oversight over their own schools.
It makes no sense to send dollars generated and taxed locally and within the state to the Federal government, only to have it sent back - under threat of complying to mandates or lose the dollars. The only argument one could make is that it allows the federal government to spend tax dollars collected from one state to pay for less efficient and more costly schools in other states - which really makes no sense at all, because it removes incentives for some states to become more efficient.
Look at America's standing in the world as it relates to academic achievement. We keep hearing about how the USA is dropping when compared to other nations - and we are - when the USA used to be near or at the top in every category. The USA is 15th of 30 OECD (Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development) countries in reading literacy; 21st in scientific literacy; 25th in mathematics literacy; 24th in problem solving; 28 percent of American fifteen-year-olds performed below the baseline level of mathematics proficiency; I could go on.
When, you might ask, were we near or at first place in all these categories? Before 1980, that's when. And since 1980, costs have been going up, while results and quality have been going down. The only thing that's gone up since 1980 is the graduation rate. But we're graduating LESS educated kids, not better educated ones. Before 1980, it was common to hold kids back a grade, once or even twice before they graduated. It's unheard of today. And we're graduating kids who read, write, and have math skills at 4th and 5th grade level. That should NEVER happen.
You bet I'd abolish the Federal Department of Education - in a heartbeat - and go back to a system that operated with less money and better results. Local and state control over ANYTHING (with the possible exception of national defense), will always achieve better results and lower costs.
And now they're taking over the medical care system. How nice.
by boxfiddler Hot topic
...... the answer both you and I gave.
In fact, from my perspective, if one looks at the way the Department of Education damaged public education in America, it's proof-positive that a [i]Department of Public Health[/i], will do the same to that sector.
By citing the Department of Education, IC-IT actually made my point!
P.S. I have a sister who was once an English teacher at an inner-city public High School. Her first year, she issued failing grades to HALF her class; they couldn't read/write at 4th grade level. She was actually fired because she refused to change the grades. The school administrators passed the students and sent them to the next grade - and out into American society as [i]educated[/i] adults. True story.
Thank you, Department of Education.
Next up: Medical care.
by ic-it
expect your response. I believe you have spoken (well typed) a few times on that very subject.
I must admit it is not one of my favorite Depts. either.
Another case of good intentions, poor implementation and Centralized management.
Minimum standards are good and goals were needed, but the plan was/is a fail from the get go.
Perhaps more of a Deeming approach would have brought pride and ownership to individual Districts and resulted in a continual improvement of practices.
..... is paved with good intentions.
I don't know to whom that quote should be attributed, but it speaks volumes to the [i]good intentions[/i] of the leftist - collectivist - big government people in America.
The PRO-Medical Care people might have good intentions, but just like those who favored a federal Department of Education, they're putting everyone on the road to medical care hell.
by ic-it
The jury is out on the first one to coin the phrase, but it may have originated as early as 1150AD.
by tonythetiger
Don't we have the right to [b]Life[/b], liberty, and the pursuit of happiness?
Isn't the government supposed to keep us from dying? No matter the cost?
by tonythetiger
[i]You could use their very words to argue against the Dept. of Education and more, does that mean you feel such agencies should be abolished?[/i]
Whose responsibility do you think it is to educate YOUR child?
by oz_media
" when facts are provided to prove you wrong, suddenly the person isn't worth talking to."
Just keep a mental note of that, it's pretty common.
by oz_media
That stings. And I thought I was too straight up with people, not enough a=candy coating for most.
Loved ABC too, "after these messages, we'll be riiiiight back" :D
by oz_media
So you actually think he meant the island would literally tip over? :D
I thought it was a really clear example of the phenomenon he was trying to illustrate.
Gawd, we see far more exaggerated and more inapplicable analogies offered here that some people even deem credible.
[i]So you actually think he meant the island would literally tip over?[/i]
No, I didn't think that. I initially thought he was on drugs.
I actually feel sorry for the guy. And the more I read about him, the more I see a pattern of similar bizarre behavior, probably because of a disease that's ravaged his body. (And his mind?)
Keeping him in the House of Representatives for a sure-thing party-line vote is one thing, but Speaker Pelosi should keep him off such committees.
You can continue to believe it was deadpan humor or an analogy all you want; but it's obvious to most people that he has a lot of trouble gathering and articulating his thoughts. Personally speaking, I don't want someone with diminished mental capacity voting on issues that have serious consequences.
by av .
I don't know if thats what he was like before, but just describing the dimensions of the island was too much for me.
He's a slug to me.
AV
Sort by Trending