Discussion Locked

Porn on boss' computer--the Ethicist speaks

0 helpful
339 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

339 replies

by anindependentintherepublic

I don?t care how child porn is discovered. The right thing to do is to make sure the proper authorities are notified. ANYone that suggests any other course of action is a fool. To not report the offense(s) ASSumes you are living in a vacuum, i.e. let?s say you don?t report it to the police or FBI and simply notify HR who will assuredly have as much to lose as you will if the offender is a ranking officer in the company or worse, could conceivably be interested in the same type of material. The HR person could choose to not only notify the offender but also disclose who found the material in the first place. Then the next day the FBI raids the office because of an ongoing investigation in to the actions of the perpetrator. The IT person?s computer will certainly be confiscated so any information you have saved about the offender is in their hands. What would you say? ?Uhhm, I meant to turn him in, honest I did?? Good luck. Even worse, if the pedophile is somehow tipped off, it would give him time to pull the hard drive and destroy it before disposing of it. It takes about ten minutes of easy manual labor to quarter a hard drive with a vise and a hacksaw.

True story: The owner of a local pawnshop wanted to contract me to give incoming computers a going over and make sure no traces of anything illegal could be recovered from said computers. When I told him I would be obligated to call the police if I found child porn. He said ?Noooo, just get rid of it, I don?t want the publicity for my shop.? When I told him that was not an option, he got pissed and picked up the first computer he brought to me and left my office. His wife later told me that she didn?t want me to think ill of her husband because he really would turn over anything illegal to his friend the local county cop, just as he told me he would. Problem of course is that he never told me anything of the kind. Which even if he did intend to give it to the police, by giving the computer to a middleman, wouldn?t I also be guilty of distributing child porn? He lied to his wife and he knows I know he lied to his wife. I have no respect for the guy who in retrospect could have been hiding something. What could be a better cover story than to take a used computer to a technician and profess no knowledge of its contents? Is he into kiddy porn? I don?t know but I can?t say I?m not suspicious. Is there anyone I can or should notify? No. Am I a hero? No. Am I out a little pocket change? Yes, but I don?t lose any sleep over not doing the right thing.

by tig2

A corporate policy generally exists to help people understand what kinds of information may be accessed, saved, or viewed on a corporate asset. I agree fully with the posters who have said to check your policy... and if one doesn't exist, write one and start through the approvals process.

Child pornography is reprehensible and should be prosecuted. The problem that the tech faces is chain of evidence. Touching those files in any way simply provides an opening that a defense attorney can exploit should the case go to trial.

The correct answer is to take the issue to HR or other ranking staff- Director, VP, etc. This puts the issue back into the hands of someone who can actually do something about it.

Many years ago I was installing an application throughout the enterprise. I had to have a certain amount of space available in order to complete the install. I was directed by my senior to look through image files and delete as necessary when space was an issue. Over the course of that effort, I ran onto a LOT of porn. The policy was to remove it ONCE and leave a copy of the policy manual page that dealt with acceptable data types. It was understood that at any time, an administrator could log on to a "dirty" box and check for additional images. If any were found, the PC was removed from the network and the individual removed from the company.

I'm not saying that any one approach is the ultimate "right answer". I do think that the decision of when and how to engage authorities outside of the company is one that will be made above my paygrade.

The question is not a simple one.

Edit typo

by w2ktechman

What I have done in the past, of course it was not child porn, was to inform the person that this kind of material is not tolerated and to re-check that they completed the proper training courses.
The items that I have found were less porn related, but things like an Ebay store, filling 40 of the 60 GB HDD with every post and item description that they ever sold. Then complained that they needed a bigger HDD because all of the space was used up.
Mild porn, excessive photos, several video games (person gave her work system to her teen every weekend to do whatever, every Monday, new spyware/malware needed removal), and things of that nature.
I only once brought the manager into things, and that was with the lady that kept letting her kids use her work notebook and install/do whatever. After 4 cleanings, enough was enough. Each time I told her of the policy, and informed her that if it continued, her manager would be notified. After I finally did notify, the problem stopped.

I do not disagree at all that in a child porn case, the authorities should be involved, but, it is not the tech's responsibility to call the police. It is the responsibility of HR, Security, or a manager. I strongly recommend a manager to take it out of your hands. But I work in a place where open relations with managers and feedback is a good thing, and we are oft. told that no reprocussions would happen from these communications.

by jamesrl

Having a person in a company arrested for kiddie porn, or having the company be accsued of covering up or protecting a criminal?

So if you are the risk manager at the company - what would you decide? I know what I would do.

How can you convince the police to go after his home unless you have some evidence in hand? Do you think your word alone is convincing to a judge?

One bad egg (unless its at the top) doesn't usually bring down a company. But if the company is caught in a coverup, hiding a kiddie porn user - can you imagine what that does to public confidence, let alone the stock price.

James

by halvbria

Reading through all the posted options, most of the replys say the same thing: Take it to HR or police or at least someone higher as well as consult company policy. All this is well and good and no matter who you ask you will get similar answers.
Are we missing the point of this discussion though? It was stated that a tech wrote to a newspaper and someone reading the newspaper started the discussion here. More than likly the author of the newspaper article is not going to read this discussion, and it's doubtful if the tech that submitted the question to the paper will read this discussion either. If he were reading this, would it not have made more sense to ask the Techie community rather than a local newspaper?
I think the main point of this entire situation has already been met: The topic is out and being discussed. The situation originally submitted may or may not be real, but it does happen. Discussing it beforehand lets people know what their best option is IF they ever do run into the situation.

Sorry for the book.

by servicetech

Lets say an individual brings his laptop in for service. It won't boot they say. One of the first things I look at is if any Malware/Spyware was installed. Then any unauthorized programs. During this checkout process I always try to get rid of temp files, cached info and other junk that piles up. Let's say that during this process, I discover porn photos. The very first thing I would do is to get my supervisor involved. I then document the existance and if possible determine if this was a result of the users actions or something else.
I have seen accidental downloads and I've seen intentional downloads but I can tell you this; if it was intentional and a minor was involved they would be in court defending themselves!

As for your statement that it wasn't his data to check out. If it's on an agency laptop or desktop PC then I have the authority to view any files on any PC that I have access to. Our equipment and data is owned by the agency NOT the individual.

Now I've seen personal data that should not be on our systems. I've seen programs installed that should not be there. Most of the time I'll let the user know that it will be removed. Sometimes it gone as soon as I see it and then I'll let the user know it's was not supposed to be there. I sometimes let them decide what to do, we're all adults. However, there is no excuse for child porn!

by mickster269

If it's between a Job, and a Child...

There's not a question in my mind.

The safety of a child, and upholding the law takes precedence over any employment.

by anindependentintherepublic

I don?t care what they are accused of; I want them to have the best lawyer possible. I don?t want them to be able to drag out appeals for years and years because they had a shoddy defense team. The system is not perfect and surely some guilty will go free (see Orenthal J. Simpson for a perfect example) but that is the price we pay for a more or less good criminal justice system. If someone set you up by placing child pornography on your computer, you would appear morally bankrupt but I am sure you would want the best lawyer available and that is the whole point of the presumption of innocence.

by tony hopkinson

photo's while being being abused.

If you want an example of how much covering up child abuse does you when you get found out, look at the catholic church. None of them are allowed to be with a child unsupervised now.

The cover up tarred them all with the same brush.

by peter_chajka

It is the responsibility of whoever finds child pornography to report it, at the very least to their supervisor. By not taking any action, you become involved in the crime.

Plus, it's just the right thing to do!

by tony hopkinson

To represent either side in a court case you must suspend all PERSONAL judgement. The only issues are existing law, current precedents and potential new ones. Right wrong, good and bad are arguments for the jury, both sides use, they are not inherent in law though.

A lawyer with professional ethics will get a known paedo off, they will put an innocent man in jail. That's their job. To manipulate the law, short of the emotional coin toss of depending on a jury, the law is the only factor.
So consult lawyers PROFESSIONALLY on legalities not ethics.

Why is this so hard a concept to grasp?

by yanipen

Here's a suggestion. Give some courtesy first in a way that both of you will benifit.

With all the powers that be on being an IT, we sometimes forget some basic things about our relationships with our coworkers. Giving courtesy is the same for everyone, whether you are a "C" level or a janitor.

I understand there are policies to be uphold. I agree. But life will be much better if you approach this humanely rather that being stri ct to the letter about policies.

Did he had those by accident, or intentionally? Did you come to know about this intentionally, or by accident? A lot of factors are involved. The outcome will depend on your approach. For example, ask admin or hr to re-post a company-wide memo regarding this issue such as porn. A subtle approach, but it will definitely work. Or, you can you come by to him in a hallway, just talked to him with a low voice that you accidentally saw some porn and that you are concenrned. This way, the problem may be resolved without escalating.

Everybody makes mistakes once in a while. I have said my piece.

by tony hopkinson

It's a choice.
Getting caught is a mistake.
Not being prepared to pay the price is.

If it was a few images in the cache it could be a mistake, you don't mistakenly save images and or videos in a separate area on your drive though.

I'm known for being about as subtle as a kick in the teeth, which would be a good start for a nonce.

by yanipen

But I am not contradicting myself.

It will always comes down to the one who did took notice of the porn in the boss' pc. And the steps he will make.

We know we have to uphold the policies in place. But there should be several degree's on offenses one should make. One example, a few years ago, there's this big multinational construction company wherein one of the managers bougth from overseas a nude painting, although it is artistic in nature (it is a version of adam and eve, and not porn) and displayed in his office. After a few days hr noticed it and gave him a verbal warning. two days later, the painting is still there. That was the time hr took action. It escalated to some degree and the end result was that the manager was not with us anymore. And the so-called friends of this manager (also "C" managers) gave those hr people a hard time after that, even though they have no fault in everyway. Had that manager returned the courtesy the hr's giving, everyone will not suffer the headache everybody had. I know, I was there.

That is why my point was to give some courtesy first. Like a friend or a family giving some advice. If that person did not listen, then its time for some action on the company's part.

by tony hopkinson

In terms of child pornography there are no degrees. 'You' are either one of us or one of them. Having one picture of child being abused is no different to having a 1000. As soon as you can cross that line in your head, in my book you are dog food that hasn't been diced into manageable lumps yet.

by jdclyde

you would see I never said their was.

I never said there was an excuse, nor made justifications for leaving it there and not reporting.

I don't know about your world, but I am NOT the IT Nazi, and I do NOT get paid to snoop through my bosses computer looking to see what he has on it. There was NOTHING in the original story to indicate a reason to be looking at his personal pictures, but you probably were too lazy to read the artical, huh?

Both should be fired, the person with what MAY be child porn AND the tech that is snooping around without cause on pc's in a clear violation of his position.

My MAIN point is that I don't believe for a second that the story is real.

by servicetech

When you say "Maybe, Maybe not" to something must be done. How is that not making an excuse?

When is "maybe not" an acceptable response to pornographic photos of children that are "clearly less than 18" years old?

You are implying the article is false. How do you know?

How about an intelligent answer without resorting to pseudo profanity.

BTW, I read the article.

by hal 9000

Define Child Pornography.

Some people will say that Naked Pictures of a child is Child Porn. I saw a case where a Photo of a 3 month old baby sitting on the floor was reported as Child Porn. The Social Disease who came out was a complete rat bag and went off the deep end. Apparently this Little Girl was going to be scared for life and so on.

Did I personally see the Picture [b]Hell Yes[/b] when it is 30 x 40 Inches and hanging up framed on a wall it's very hard not to I even looked at the picture to see how well the place that I sent him to processed the picture as I had only seen the 4 x 6 Happy Snap that it came from and it was a Brilliant Picture.

OH and the Girl that the Social Worked was Bitterly Complaining about was a boy but the Social Worker was insistent that it was a girl as no one would take a photo like that of a boy.

Was it in any way Pornographic [b]NO![/b] That entire complaint arose because of some Idiot who knew better than anyone else and was offended by it. It was a photo of a 3 month old baby who was not only much loved and wanted by the Proud Parents but was also heavily protected by those parents.

Even the Judge was less than favorable to the Child Services who are Charged with Protecting Children from Abuse but apparently it seems that if it is a small 4 x 6 inch photo it's acceptable but you enlarge it and it's suddenly Porn.

Anyone who thinks like that is completely Insane and we need to be protected from their Insanity.

OH and the Boy was not removed from the Parents or the Mother who took the photo but the father was charged with Abusing a Girl who was unknown on the Strength of the Social Workers Complaint.

Col

by manwethegreat

If this company has a technology policy like most businesses I have worked with (which, I will admit, is not many, as I am still young), than nothing on that "boss's" computer is "private". The computer & everything on it, is owned by the company, not the individual, as has been stated before.
So why do you keep going back to whether this story is real or not, & keep saying that what this tech was doing was illegal?
It doesn't really matter whether it's real or not, we can discuss the principle of the matter. It might help someone when they really encounter a situation like or similar to this one.
This article is not specific about the exact circumstances, so we are left to speculate. Maybe he had business that brought him to those pictures, or maybe he was "snooping", but the point is that
1) The activity is illegal, so this "boss" has no leg to stand on.
And
2) It is company property, & the whole company could hang if an outside party discovered that stuff. Better the IT guy turn in the boss, than let the whole company go down if it ever comes out later.

by jdclyde

If you did, you would have clearly seen in my other posts where I said they President of the company should be turned in to HR and get witnesses before doing ANYTHING. If this were a real case, that is how it should be handled. You do NOTHING without a witness or you will end up having to PROVE that it wasn't YOU that put the pics there in the first place.

Now as to why I go back against the fairytail of an article is a few reasons.

Yes, the computers are company property. This does not give a pee-on tech the authority to go snooping through the computers without just cause. There are confidential documents on the computer that a tech has no business helping himself to and is a clear violation of the trust that is given to techs. ANY tech that sits down at all the computers and just starts randomly looking at everything should be fired on the spot.

Even the worst of IT NAZI's know better than to snoop without a reason. If there is network traffic showing up to point to this, that WOULD be a reason to go looking, but NEVER alone.

And yes, it clearly is a BS story. The clown is clearly picking an emotional topic to get people stirred up so he can get some attention.

So unless you come up with a number three that has ANYTHING to justify HOW the alleged pics were found, the tech will be fired, and the president will go to jail.

I have NEVER said to look away. ANY tech that "just snoops" on ANY computer should be fired on the spot. And yes, walked out the door right then, and have security gather their belongings and box them up. If you are such a tech, I hope you are gone before you make the rest of us look bad. If the president is downloading this, the net admins will know.

by morrisntex

implies it was a "private" share on the company network not the bosses computer. I have seen instances where for whatever reason someone else was able to access a supposed private directory on a network share and went in a deleted files. I was involved in investigating another instance were stuff was put in a former employee's private directory several days after the employee left the company.
I think the original articles answer was mostly correct, I don't have a better answer at this time but I think getting an outside law enforcement agency discretely involved as to the origin might be a good start.

by georgeou

Porn on a home computer is very unlikely, but it's very easy for someone who doesn't like you to plant porn on your machine.

by dr_zinj

You report your suspicions to the police, right now.

1. The person committed/is committing a felony.

2. The person is contributing to harm to children/minors.

3. You have knowledge that such an act is being committed.

4. Failure to act to prevent such an act means that at best, you're a spineless coward, and at worst, you approve its occurrence.

5. If you can be shown to have known of the occurrence of such an act, and failed to report it, you might be able to be prosecuted for conspiracy to commit the acts.

6. If you can be shown to have known of the occurrence of such an act, and failed to report it, it may also open the company, and all employees in it, up to prosecution for supposedly supporting an institutionalized conspiracy to commit the acts.

***

To put a different spin on this issue. You're afraid of the wrong things. You're afraid of losing your job for not reporting it, or for deleting the files.

If the boss is the owner of the business, or is your supervisor in a business; his justifiable removal may open a business opportunity to you to step in to fill the void.

And who's more deserving of that job? You, or some sleazebag child pornographer?

by brucewebs

I have been caught up in situtations like this in the past. There should be a bit of analysis first.

1) PC assigned to an individual was used for demo and placed in a conference room for a week. On day 3 it was discovered that it was used for illegal purposes on day 2. Further analysis showed it was done in "off hours". Other facilities were used to detect the "who done it" and take appropriate action.

2) After leaving work on weekends, the PC was returned "non-functional" on Monday. During corrective action illegal info was found and removed. On the FIRST occurrence the individual was warned (management option). Since then occurred again, Human Services was advised, and spoke to the individual. In addition, corrective $$ charges were applied for the failure to secure the laptop, and any further infractions would result in discharge.

The difference between the two is the ON SITE use by a third party (PC assigned to was not responsible), and the off site use by the assigned individual.

In either case, the offending material just has to be NOT RELATED to the business use of the PC.

In either case, your supervisor or personnel should be of assistance in situations such as this. It also helps to have a company policy to rely on.

by Former member

It is a crime, now you are an accomplice
Silence is for the weak

by fbuchan

The field of ethics sometimes strikes me as a swampland.

Regardless of whether the original article's author in the Times was answering a real letter, or a manufactured one, it shows a whole lot about his qualifications to advise silence, doesn't it. I would be apt to can him for making me (if I were his editor) look stupid. Since when has ethics ever proposed that the easy way out was the ethical way?

For consideration of anyone who wouldn't report this to authorities, especially the poster who used the phrase "if the boss was in the pictures" as some differential guiding principle: As a parent, if you would even hesitate to report it, you're in need of a self-check. Every child is basically your kid with superficial differences. I would spend less than a second thinking at all, because I would hope if my kid were ever lured into such a state, someone would stand for them. My job be damned at that point; I'd rather work for someone with principles anyhow.

As well, if you start to differentiate the viewer from the producer with these sorts of images, you miss the market value issue entirely. While I have no direct experience with child porn in any way thankfully, I am aware that folks exchange these things often for a fee. That means the viewer might have paid for the abuse to happen, and if that is the case, then a secondary crime is evident even to a casual observer.

On a more technical point though, the best advice the ethicial monkey could have given the technician was to isolate the machine, involve company staff, and observe to them they should call authorities. Then, simply protect that machine from interference. If the boss is guilty, let the authorities decide; if it is some other issue, let that be decided by them too. A technicians job is not to judge the law, or the guilt of an individual, but to protect the company. How can a company network be safe if this kind of material made its way inside? If a zombie, then there is a security issue; if an individual browsing risk-enhancing sites, you're still protecting the company by removing them. No matter how you look at it, the company is potentially at risk by the behaviour. Silence protects no one who deserves consideration.

Alas, this is all conjecture, and I do sincerely hope the the ethicist was somehow making a joke, albeit one I can't understand.

by dawgit

You would also have to consider physicle security in the area of that particular computer. If a machine is in an accesable area, it is vunerable to any wanabe cracker with a Linux-live-CD. This whole string is realy about 1 thing, -Security. Having Porn on a firms computer is a security problem. Having 'kiddie'-porn on a computer is a major problem to the company where it's Located. ANd what's worst, is that with out good total security it is extreamly hard to fight.
Somewhere in this string, I posted another problem, one that can be fixed. Ond solves the predicument that started this whole post. There must be a written Policy that address this situations, as well as others. With such, there is no question as to what to do. One just follows the policies, simple, no judgements involved. And it could save the firm $mil$ in potential legal costs.

by georgeou

Most users think nothing of sharing their passwords with coworkers.

Even if it's someone who is careful, nothing prevents any one in IT (desktop support even) from planting things.

by dawgit

A well written policy should place an emphasis on their responsibilities, and by doing so remove any doubts as to the "ah gee, What do I do now" syndrome. It would also protect someone from possible reprecusions when they do do their job. (when in the scope of what they were supposed to doing.)
So, in answer to your question, NO, it should NOT do that. It should re-enforce their legal responsibility. -d

by computab

Did you never hear the greatest ethic of all time, Love your neighbour as yourself? YOU are the ignorant one.

by tony hopkinson

There was no christian ethic then, perhaps if you believe that the christian ethic was created whole cloth out of a void.
Which of course it wasn't.

Then of course there is the fact that the old testament and new testament ethics are different.

Then there are non christian ethical systems.

One of which is mine, of course some of my ethics do derive from christian ones, as I didn't invent my system from scratch.

Do you know what ethics are by the way, I suspect not.

by tigre_one_99

Tell your boss that "some employee" has porn pictures in his computer, and ask him (your boss), what is his opinion about it?, if He wants you to block all porn websites for "all" company computers because of the companys security policy, also ask him what does he recommend to do, because he is the boss and "he should know the best solution for this problem"

by tony hopkinson

Respond to the point !

You said there were no ethics before the bible.

I pointed out that that was self evidently not true.

Your response I'm ignoring the best ethic love thy neighbour.

So by your own lights, calling me an idiot you have not 'loved' me.

You don't practice what you preach, so you are either lying to me, to your god and to yourself.

On top of that I'm not a christian, so how would I ever agree that love thy neighbour is the greatest ethic ?

by jdclyde

Do you REALLY want him to love you? :0

I mean, far from me to judge or anything, but geezeohman! Maybe you had better hit Mae up for some of her "Social Lubrication"? :D

by yanipen

"As soon as you can cross that line in your head, in my book you are dog food that hasn't been diced into manageable lumps yet."

Hey, I think there's no need to call other people like that. It just make you like a "boil" that's about to be ruptured. The kind that hurts when touched. That's who you are in my book.

Please dont get me wrong about my post, since everbody is entitled to their opinion. I gave my views based from my experience and from where I am. I learned a lot in this discussion, and I appreciate a lot of views from other people in your country. It amazes me about the way people adhere to the policies in place. And the reaction to this sensitive topic.

Now I wonder about the views from other members who does not come from well-developed, first world countries.

by tony hopkinson

My apologies if I gave that impression.

As for experience, I know several victims of child abuse very well. That might have made my reactions a little more extreme than most, but I really don't care.

What I want to do is stop it. These people can't be cured, they can't be forgiven and they don't meet my definition of human, which is like me.

That's got nothing to do with colour, religion or creed, number of arms, haemoglobin in the blood stream. It's do you get a hard on looking at pre-pubescent kids.

If 'you' do 'you' ain't like me.

by awhite

it is a couple oz. of lead right between the eyes problem solved. If it was someone I cared for getting hurt the person(s) would never make it to trial.

by martinplatt

bit off the subject there mate.

What has Jesus got to do with a tech finding porn on a boss's computer?
From what i know about the bible, I've not read anything about Jesus surfing the net, or writing it in his little diary.
It's down to values and common sense. If you lived by the little book, you'd be slapping each others cheeks, poking each others' eyes out and throwing stones when you feel you're right. I'm glad you did not have any input into the laws that we're talking about.
Why do you have to make everything about religion, if it isn't to alienate yourself?
Can't you make your own mind up, based by all means on experience such as your belief in a bible and what was written in it, but abstracting your thoughts into the current day, and what is right?
What I don't get is that you come on here all hoity toity and start digging into people? This was once a serious conversation, but alas, that is ended. The boss should be reported, end of.

by tony hopkinson

I like people who say what they mean and mean what they say.
I like them even more if they think before they open their gob.

The greatest ethic of all time, sheesh.

by awhite

I take care of our company computers in a small feed company. We have some policies about porn and such but several of us pass around emails containing porn or nudity, but we never abuse such things and if I found out one of the people where looking at child porn first and for most I would call the law and then confront the person face to face. Jobs are a dime a dozen when compared to integrity and honor. Lose my job who cares do you really want to work around someone that does such a thing I dont, WONT. Myself I would not get fired for turning someone in but would get fired for kicking the shit out of them. Where I am from it is a $150 simple assault charge, and that would be well worth it. I am sure some of the other people here would chip in on it if they knew why it happened. Here is some advice from a nobody call the FBI someone if any one elese in the company complains then they are guilty by association. Now ask your self this question do you want to be one of those people. Not me.
As for framing someone Id like someone to try it on me as I keep a very close eye on my computer and know things that most techs dont know about their own computers. A friend told me once if you are not paranoid then you are not paying close enough attention and I live by those words, because someone is always out to get someone else I prefer not to play that type of game but can and will and usually come out ok.

by tony hopkinson

a large bunch of gooders who think people with our attitude are more dangerous to society than a 'reformed' nonce.

I always remember one in the UK who was judged cured, they let him out on a weekend pass, first day out , raped and killed an eleven year old girl. I'd shoot the f'ker responsible for that decision as well, might teach a few of the others what their real priorities are.

by yanipen

But from where I am, people castrate them, as in they mug you first, and when you are unconscious, drug you so that you won't feel anything, then they remove your family jewels! Both of them! And then they let you keep them as souvenirs. And then they anonymously tips the police. This is, if they caught you in the act. Thats the cure.

If not in the act, and otherwise proven guilty. You go to prison. At the prison, you will not wear any manly clothes everyday of your life.

Going back to the porn on the boss's pc. We poeple here are not stupid, but we are cautious. And we also react the same. As in react the same especially when it comes to child porn. We take into consideration some details first. Like, what if it what we saw, is an evidence that the boss is holding against an employee who actually did that, that is why we want to extend some courtesy first. If the boss have done it unintentionally, we extend courtesy. If he is guily, its time for some action.

by girlgeek12

It's illegal, it's wrong, regardless of your religion.

If you have a high moral standard, you would stick your neck out for something that you believe to be wrong. I have a hard time with society these days for really just turning their heads to things that they know are wrong. We need to protect the innocence of children.

I am deeply saddened and offended by anyone that would say that ethics do not come from the Bible. The Bible is the foundation of how a Christian should live their life. The Ten commandments are the very building block of ethical and moral standards. These ten statements show how a Christian should live their lives. That is the code of conduct. Whether you chose to live your life in that way or not is your choice.

For once in your life, stand up for something you believe in, something you know can make a difference. This would be one less guy exploiting these children. Somehow, someway, when you live your life with standards, things always work out. He can also lay his head down at night and know that he did the right thing. If he does believe in God, God always helps you out when you are in need so I have faith that he will find another job.

...at least he can live life with a clean conscious.

by tig2

That there are not ethics taught in the Bible. Only that non-Christians have ethics too- obviously not necessarily from the Bible.

We had a poster suggest that we not blame (throw stones) as we are all guilty of sin. As a Christian woman, I am offended by this viewpoint. In order to preserve the law, we must step away from the Christian ethic and towards the societal ethic that tells us that pornography involving children is wrong and potentially damaging to our society overall.

(NOT potentially but in fact damaging... but I am trying to be "correct" here)

Me personally? I would really just rather rip the "boys" off the scumbag with my bare hands and feed them to the filthy bastard that thinks that exploiting children is a good thing. The job isn't even a part of that consideration. Fired? Not before I can quit, thanks.

Realistically? Next stop would be HR. If nothing is done, the next one is the TV news. Job be d@mned, these are lives at stake and I cannot bear the thought that I could be instrumental in allowing this kind of damage to be done or continue.

It has been opined that this is not a real case. Perhaps not. What this discussion has done is provide a ground where we can discuss the situation. And perhaps be ready for it should it occur.

by tony hopkinson

Depends on where you put the emphasis.

To say the bible is without ethical content would be stupid.

To make the claim that ethics feature nowhere else but the bible, dumb.

To make the claim that the bible invented the concept of ethics, would indicate a frightening level of ignorance.

I'm not even sure you could make the claim the bible was progenitor of the christian ethic, certainly the guys who wrote it would have some big time problems with large sections of current christian society.

Me of course they'd burn at the stake.

by jdclyde

After the King of England received his position from God himself. It the "good ol' days" they would have just stoned you. Very comforting, I am sure?

by w2ktechman

I will disagree completely that ethics came from the Bible. Ethics were around a lot longer than the Bible. Although, the Bible and fear of GOD has helped spread ethics, it was not the beginning of it.

I hope that you dont honestly believe that there were no ethics whatsoever before the bible.
I cannot say where they started, or even if some very ancient religion was partially responsible in some way (fire god, sun god, volcano god, etc.). But it seems that ethics are a big part of every religion, many of them are older than the Bible. And to have Ethics followed, they would have had to exist first, before they could be written and expanded upon.

by girlgeek12

As a christian this is where you learn of ethics, not to say that some of the same ethics were there before the Bible or because some other religion has spread them. Just that if you are Christian, that is where you turn to.

by servicetech

I thought he was installing an application?

I guess you've never stumbled across anything while configuring software?

Why is he a "pee-on" Tech?

Where does it state "just starts randomly looking"?

Stick to the facts presented please.

by tony hopkinson

Our criminal and investigatory procedures probably differ. Holding evidence against someone else , will probably put you in jail longer than the paedo over here.

Not sure how to explain the cultural difference without insulting you in your terms or worse still mine.

THe courtesy you refer to, we feel should not be a factor. It's the way we are, but in a vague, wow that's strange, kind of way, I get what you are driving at.

Nice to clear that up, my aplogies if I gave any offence in ignorance.

by dlmeyer9

I once needed to use a subordinate's computer and noted a
"strange" bookmark while browsing for hardware. I asked
him about it, later, and he said he'd grabbed the whole thing
of another (recently departed) person's system. What was it?
Said he didn't know but was willing to look. It was pretty bad.
He seemed quite shocked. Either a great actor or totally
innocent. 'Recently departed', OTOH, had a reputation that
would make him a perfect fall guy.

by jdclyde

Installing an application on the President of the companies computer. Please tell me the last time you were required to look at the pictures someone has saved on their computer, in order to "install an application".

If you can think of an example on the last time YOU HAD to go through someones pictures when you are only doing an upgrade, I will consider your position. If you can NOT give me this example, then you should start considering mine.

Why are you all worked up? Do you feel guilty because you regularly betray the trust of the company, and do the same thing?

We are placed in a position of TRUST. TRUST that we will not use our godlike abilities to go through payroll and see what everyone is making, or get into databases and read how much the company REALLY spent on a project. We do not go in and read evaluations that are saved on the systems, nor hundreds of other sensitive documents. The alledged tech in the "story" betrayed that trust, and is a disgrace. Sure, after he DID find it, report it as I have said all along. But now he has to pack his bags unless he can come up with a damn good reason for WHY he was looking around the Presidents computer in the first place. And IF they turn out to NOT be illegal pics, depending on the company, the Pres MIGHT get in trouble for having porn on his system, but the tech would be toast for sure.

You do NOT go through a computer without reason. Installing a new appliation is not a reason. You can not just "stumble" across data in personal directories unless you CHOOSE to.

So, ServiceTech, be of a service, and tech. It is not your job to go through all the directories of a computer just because your installing an application. You HAVE installed an application before, haven't you?

by nicolaides.nikos

Well if you must do something,go ahead and delete the folder of the child porn. I dont think that anyone would dare to ask you "Dude, where is my child porn?" So, the boss would be scared and would be more careful in the future

by w2ktechman

I can see doing that for some things, and I am not going into the wrongness of your post. Obviously, you are either trying to get a lot of responses, or you should be one of the jailed.

by tony hopkinson

Seeing as you've just deleted the evidence without reporting it, you're buggered.

Probably a few kids will continue to be, so said person can get hold of some more material.

You know people keep telling you to think before you speak, they meant think before you communicate.

by w2ktechman

I'm There, please tell me where and when!

JK.

In the Bible writing days, many religions had parts of their text re-written to appease the current King/Lord. From what I understand, most have also been re-translated several times as well, and that the translations made them a little different for different languages/versions.

by w2ktechman

now, but I dont mind being around stoned people, cause they are funny!. So I will watch, but not bring anything (or toke).

by tony hopkinson

you want to apply, seeing as you aren't going to turn the other cheek in this case.

How about an eye for an eye and impalement?

by w2ktechman

Yes, religions do teach ethics. And I agree, in this day and afe, ethics are mostly tought through religion, and at home.
Thank You for the clarification.

by jdbwar07

Since this recommendation was made by someone who happens to work for the NY Times, I bet it's only a matter of time before a Fox news pundit like O'Reilly starts saying that an "evil, liberal" newspaper wants people to look at this type of porn!

by wrzfamily

I asked talk radio host Dori Monson to help me kick Cohen's ass. Cohen refused Monson's invitation to defend himself on his show. Cohen told Monson he'd talk about anything but child porn. Are we surprised that a coward would advocate cowardice? what devastates me is that Cohen literally advised "silence"; that silence surrounding child abuse/pornography is exactly what child advocates have been working to break all these years. If anyone wants to see the column, my rant to Cohen and his pathetic reply to me, just ask.
Laura Wrzeski
wrzfamily@centurytel.net

by wrzfamily

Below are column, rant, & pathetic response from Cohen:

Q: I am an Internet technician. While installing software on my company's computer network, I happened on a lot of pornographic pictures in the president's personal directory, including some of young children ? clearly less than 18, possibly early teens. It is probably illegal and is absolutely immoral. Must I call the police? I think so, but I need my job.
S.M.N., Vancouver, British Columbia
A: It is a crime to possess child pornography, and understandably: The sexual exploitation of children is reprehensible. Yet you have no legal obligation to contact the police, nor should you. The situation is too fraught with uncertainty. These photographs might depict ? legally ? not children but young-looking adults. The images could be digitally altered. Your boss may have acquired free (albeit illegal) images rather than bought them and provided a financial incentive to those who harm children. Someone other than your boss may have downloaded the pictures.
In any case, while protecting your job should not forestall your calling the police, the consequences of doing so should. Even if your boss were acquitted of criminal charges, the accusation itself imperils his job, his reputation and the company. If convicted, he faces years in prison. (Arizona recently sentenced a man to 200 years on similar grounds.) Since you have no reason to believe your boss has had improper contact with children, you should not subject him to such ferocious repercussions for looking at forbidden pictures.Douglas A. Berman, a law professor at Ohio State University and an expert on sentencing, describes the rationale for these laws: "We punish the kind of possession many concede is not inherently harmful but which contributes to behavior which produces much harm." That is, by stopping buyers, even those who have had no contact with an actual child, we hope to stop sellers, who do exploit children. Is this effective? Tough to prove. Berman observes that: "The criminalization of child porn consumption is premised on contestable utilitarian calculations." Why not target child-porn producers directly, much as we differentiate drug dealers from drug users? We try, Berman explains, but it's not easy: "A lot of these Web sites are offshore. And the domestic ones are good at covering their tracks." But if the intent of the law is estimable, its effect in this case would be too destructive to your boss and too ineffectual in protecting children for you to abet.You do have duties to your employer. Because this material is on its computer, the firm risks prosecution. But short of calling the cops, your options are few. Nor would deleting the pictures eliminate all legal risk; that could be seen as destroying evidence. Your best recourse? Alas, silence.
Readers can direct their questions and comments by e-mail to ethicist@nytimes.com This column originates in The New York Times Magazine.

Below is my first response:

Randy Cohen:
Your Dec. 3ird column was horribly disappointing. All the people I?ve asked about what they thought of it could hardly believe that you wrote it. The writer was not asking for any of the legal advice, but guidance on what would be a moral decision. Legal or not, those images were created for the gratification of pedophiles. Only a trained investigator could make a judgment of legality. You are not a lawyer. You are also absolutely unqualified to judge whether or not unknown consequences to the boss justify protecting him from an investigation that may well be protective of his business. The boss and law enforcement (we the people) have a 100% right to a full investigation. Additionally, neither you nor the writer knows whether or not the images may be vital to an ongoing investigation. In spite of your unconvincing acknowledgments regarding the unforgivable crimes of child abuse, it was clear you favored covering for a perpetrator, whomever he happened to be or do, over the rights of children not to be violated and exploited. It was ridiculous to propose the fact (?) that the writer did not himself know whether or not his boss or anyone else had abused a child as an excuse for ?silence?. The writer cannot be expected to personally investigate such a possibility. Legal or not, we are all morally obligated to report child pornography, whether you disagree with the laws and consequences of downloading child pornography or not. If the writer indeed uncovered the boss's ugly little secret, and then got canned for it, there are very good legal remedies to protect and compensate the writer from the vengeance of whomever the pedophile is. Mr. Cohen, you?re a dad. You should be passionately advocating any and all methods used to identify and persecute pedophiles, even the ones who ?only? view child pornography.

Below is Cohen?s response to my letter:

Thanks for the interesting note. Of course the sexual exploitation of children is vile; I wrote as much in my first sentence. The more difficult question is how to respond to those who do not produce but consume it. I believe that child porn producers should be vigorously prosecuted but that its consumers should receive a more therapeutic response. Sadly, that is not the case. Reporting this in-house amounts to passing the buck, letting someone else send the boss to prison for looking at an illegal picture. However, in S.M.N's particular case, this is a very small company owned by the person who seems to have the child porn, so that limits the options S.M.N. has and obviates those measures you suggest. But even if this were a larger company and there were higher-ups to whom he could report it, he should still be reluctant to do so because the consequences to the boss and his family are, as I wrote, likely to be wildly disproportional to any actual harm he?d done and would have a vanishingly small chance of protecting any child. If you can think of another action S.M.N. could take that might do some genuine good, I'd be happy to hear about it. But to me, the unwise laws concerning child porn consumers foreclose any action on his part. It is demoralizing to do nothing in such a situation but worse still to do harm.
RC

by yanipen

Apology accepted.

Well, actually, I enjoyed this discussion. It gave new perspective on the moral and ethichal side from different IT counterparts around the world. And I learned a lot.

One thing I have not noticed though in this discussion. When all the policies have been adhered, and the laws have been followed. I noticed that nobody discussed corporate politics in connection to this issue. I am sure this is connected especially when a boss, or a "c" level manager is involved. Or maybe I should open a discussion about this.

Hmmm.

by fullseptic

Make the bosses computer part of the next presentation and be sure everyone knows its the boss' computer, then feign "oops..." in a power point presentation in front of the company.

by tony hopkinson

as a criminal act is in corporate political mode. After all suggesting that you risk your job or your career, by doing so buys into the idea that those who 'control' us at work have more juice than than society outside of work. An argument I have no time for.
One of my biggest problems with the fuedalism writ large that is the corporate world is the idea that most of our legal rights go straight into the bin, the moment they infringe on a company's.

by w2ktechman

Cheetos, or beer.

But I will still laugh at your stonedness... while you laugh at everything (including my drunkness).

by tony hopkinson

A whole catalogue of self serving assumptions to justify a graceless lack of spine.

It's an easy question to decide, all you have to ask yourself, is if it was my kid in the pictures what would I want someone who discovered them to do.

The guy worries me, and now I'm worried for his kids as well, in my opinion he's not fit to be responsible for them.

by wrzfamily

Religion sux. All of 'em. There is research that identifies 'spiritual' fancies as biologically hardwired. Theorists suggest that the evolution of religion helped to coordinate and control the efforts of early humans, creating a more effective entity.
We have the internet, now, so what is with the twaddle that keeps interfering with thinking? Religion is as vestigial as one's appendix: when those backward anachronistic bastards flare up, people die.

by jdclyde

Intolerance from scum such as yourself is just as bad as intolerance from any religion (accept Islam, which will kill you).

I am glad to live in America, so I have protections from losers like you.

by sjmilne

If it is child porn not only is only recourse ethically, legally and morally to report it to the authorities - let the police sort out how it got there.

You get a reputation as a straight shooter and a decent human rather than abetting and aiding a perverse criminal.

by doug

Here's an IT guy who relieves the boredom of
software installations by hacking into his
bosses computer. Like most IT techs, he
probably has specialized software that
searches the computer for image files, then
loads them into grids where they can be
sorted in various ways so that the "good
stuff" can be found.

Let's face it people, the boss didn't have a
directory off of "program files"
called "child porn" that this tech
accidently got into while modifying
configuration files.

While most techs do this, obviously using
your access to the administration password
to invade a superiors privacy it pretty much
the ultimate violation of IT professional
ethics. This tech was trusted with the admin
password because he is an IT professional,
and he violated this trust.

Hence the irony. A man without ethics is
requesting the ethical response to finding
pictures of young teens on his bosses
computer.

by dearmoree

As a tech at a large community college I have had several instances where while running disk clean up or just deleting temp Inet files the subject lines provided indications of porn on the computer. Part of my job description is to ensure compliance with the colleges acceptable use policy which does not include porn. If I fail to take the appropriate action my job and credibility are put on the line. If some one wants to view this type of material they should use their own computer. I have and will continue to report any violators I discover, and based on prior experience if I believe it to be kiddie porn will notify the police and not hr.

by ysue

There's illegal porn that sends you to jail and then there's regular, everyday porn that would get a low-level person fired but not prosecuted.

Randy Cohen is wrong. If the boss has child porn on his computer, by not acting, you are enabling.

The other kind? Depends on your own moral code. I wouldn't say anything.

by debposton

I had to terminate an employee because of this same issue and HR called the local police. Why should we keep silent because he/she is the boss??? I was quoted chapter and verse of the law...I was told terminate or be terminated. He (x-employee) was a hell of worker..just during downtime ...he like to look. I am not condoning his behavior but we all have issues.

What is good for low-level staff should be good of upper-level management!

by williamvolterman

If it was your child/young teens picture would you act differently?

If you would your a scumbag... and even if it was your kids pics... you did nothing either way (your even more of a scumbag)

Hippocrites.

by jmccardl29

In view of how little support "whistle blowers" get I would do nothing. What is going to be achieved? Yes it is very wrong, but you will get beheaded, and the upper management level will close rank and kapow you are stuffed forever. Ask any whistle blower if they would do it again.

You would get fired for "snooping on his computer". Management would say you have breached privacy laws, citing that you may have been looking for salary or personal data etc.
Never EVER EVER rock the ship. In an ideal world maybe, but NOT UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES
in the real world.
I know it sucks but this is the course of action I would take.
I am a comp Tech and I think I have seen mostly more hard core porn on accountants and lawyers computers, they seem to love porn, they feed on it!
Lawyers become judges who then love porn so whatever you do you will lose badly, you will never win.
Also remember you do not really know who is sleeping with whom in a company, just guard your back!

by rcfoulk9

yours is a life without principle. You ultimately stand for nothing if doing so puts you at any risk. While taking on risk for risks sake is foolish a real, mature person must stand for something other than simply self preservation. You, sir, are a very week person. Grow a spine.

by sjford

I would like to reply to this article. I have experienced a similar situation first hand in a family-owned brokerage house in NYC. I was a contractor helping out with a network connectivity issue. We discovered that the three company owned firewalls were
saturated with traffic. Not knowing what happened, logs were review and we found a constant flow of traffic to XXX sites. When I asked my immediate manager about this situation it was brushed off as these are brokers who are bringing in $500,000 a month to the company. No one was think about the possibility of a lawsuit or aby reaction to someone seeing this on a PC screen.

A second occurance occurred at a famous NYC hospital. I was called in to a printer problem at 3am and when I arrived I went with a manager to a location inside the hospital to find a printer tied up printing a stack fo porno pictures. Since this was a academic environment , no action was taken...

Others places it was an instant firing...

by pgit

Are you a Sith, or a Jedi?

If you are a Sith, your ship has just come in. Go to the boss and explain to him you have already imaged the drive and deposited copies with several third parties who will release the info should anything bad happen to you. Then you lighten up, let him/her off the hook because all you're after is a more cushy job and a little bit more money... in a word, blackmail. It's the prime lubricant of politics and business.

If you're a jedi, it's a heck of mess you're in. Depending on how "big" this boss is, you may end up being charged yourself, for maybe trying to set up the Sith scenario above.

I can tell you most of my small town 'movers and shakers' would circle the wagons in support of most of their big wig brethren, even if they got caught being the subject of the images themselves.

In light of how business "ethics" operate, (Siths) I would anonymously tip off the Sheriff's office and be done with it.

If the individual is on the outs with the local powers that be, you'll see the orange jump suit slow-mo perp walk on the nightly news. If he/she is one of the local darlings, or a rising star, your best hope would be that the offensive material quietly goes away.

Ultimately, my conscience would bear the brunt of such a disturbing discovery, I doubt I'd ever recover. My bottom line would be to walk away from the job, if nothing were done about it. At that point I might contact someone like the FBI, but in another city where local politics weren't going to be a factor.

by lewisd3

This may be a liitle of the point, but I think it gives a good example of Company or Gov policy.

Some years back my son was at a PUBLIC SCHOOL daycare center. He is one of the A.D.H.D. kids (6 - 7 yrs old) who was always in trouble, whether he was guilty or not.

We were called into over a situation where he supposedly was asking littel girls to play doctor (curiosity type stuff).

We were told that BY LAW, our son had to be reported to Protective Services. The principle also said that he would have to be removed from the daycare and that he would be watched very carefully during school for any other such activities.

We know our son and knew that he is no angel but we had our doubts on this.

We enlisted the help of a prof. independent child counsoler. and found out was that it was very likely that another "older" boy who was not even mentioned by the principal all, who was behind it.

After we brought back the "official" written report to the school, the principle was floored. Her comment was "This is impossible. I know this family personally."

Nothing more was said about our son's involvement. In fact, he suddenly was a model student.

We pulled our son from that school system shortly after all of this and sent him to a private school.

What we found out later was:

1. Someone called the private school to warn them about our son.

2. Through a relative who works for P.S. we found out that NOTHING was ever reported about the other boy involved.

So much for responsibiblity, policy and the law.

by morrisntex

And we often see it matters "who you know" as well. Look back at what happened in that case at the Mass. Law school where those 2 third party contractor's tech's were canned for things supposedly not related to them finding child porn on a Senior professor's computer.
Both tech's had top performance reviews until they reported what they found, then they were fired within months for supposedly "bad" work performance...

Both Tech's were basically "blacklisted" from IT related work around the Boston area (I think it was partly due to the publicity surrounding the case).

Something I've noticed in some of the other posts here is folks calling the tech "nosy", but for many service organizations it is common to make a backup of any personal & company related data off the computer being worked on. That's how the above techs came across the pictures in question. The backup procedure flagged a hidden directory full of JPG files and just from the names on some of the pictures the techs became suspicious after confirming what they were they called their supervisors who told them to keep it to themselves, then the techs called the FBI.

by ganyssa

not my boss, but management. I was not snooping, I was running a virus scan, as the PC had given warnings, and I was searching for anything further. As it ran, the names of the files it was running were passing across the screen. The file names made it obvious that they were not something you'd want on a corporate PC.

I verified the files matched the names, then went to my boss with the information. I was asked to explain how I'd come across the information, and also my boss tip-toed around the question of whether or not the women in the photos appeared to be underage. As they did not, the PC was reimaged, and the person in question was re-informed of company policy.

But had I not had a business reason for searching his PC, I would have been disciplined as well. Or not, as I would have never said anything, because I would have known better.

*Edited to add - I would have said nothing in this situation, because this was adult pornography. Had it been child porn, I would have taken whatever career damage came of being unable to explain myself, had I not had a good reason to be looking on his hard drive.*

by brian

Are you the judge in the case or not? No.
Are you the policeman? Yes.
What references do the police use? The letter and the spirit of the law.

We are in positions of Trust and Integrity. If this person weren't your Boss, would you have reported it? The difference is merely your personal impact?

If it is obvious to you that it is child porn, you NEED to tell, even if you lose your job over it. Personally, I'd sue the company and the employee for wrongful termination if that ever happened.

What's more important here? Your job, OR your self respect, honesty, and integrity? Even if it were the Depression, I'd still choose to report it. You have to do what is right, not just what is best for you.

Even CRIMINALS see this crime as one of the most hideous of offenses. A number of these people who go to jail for sexual child abuse wind up with multiple visits to hospital and worse. Many offenders lie about the crime they are in for, as they don't want to wind up dead.

My exposure to the reality? Worked for a state agency who had to deal with the results of the crimes.

by sforkner

You must self report the the authorities. If you fail to do this, someone else finding the data can make you liable.

by rcfoulk9

But it will always be the right thing. If it's porn involving adults, straight, gay or otherwise, I'm not about to pass judgment. I'm a management by objectives type so if the work's getting done I'm not so much concerned about what interests someone. I would however let the person know that they might want to remember that porn on a work computer can present a sexual harrassment issue and in all likelihood it would be better to reserve such browsing to a home computer. Once so discussed the behavior tends to become self corrcting. Child porn is a totally other animal however. If it was clearly saved JPGs or videos rather than something dug up in the cache, which could be the result of an unexpected redirect, both the authorities and HR must be notified. There should be zero tolerance of this type of behavior.

by farrell.lawrence16

As a budding 'tech' who is also a social worker and a psychologist (and the father of two boys), I am very pleased to see this conversation happening among my (soon-to-be-colleagues). The range of emotional responses to this issue are to be expected (full disclosure; I find child rape/porn reprehensible). I do believe that there should be a clearly spelled out policy at every workplace (corporate or not) that takes the moral dilemma out of the hands of the IT person and puts it where it belongs, with the management of the company involved. And yes, I have been 'back-stabbed' by HR and terminated for acting in what I thought was an 'ethical' manner.
At any rate, I repeat my gratitude to those who submitted, especially those who seemed to be thoughtful and respectful of others. A lot of education clearly still needs to happen in this issue. Child predators need to be stopped, period.
The range of opinions definitely was an eyeopener for this 'newbie'.
By the way, Randy Cohen should be fired.
Thanks again.

by chris.taylor

Ok, this is kind of funny but this was the first post in this thread that had any mention of religion that I have seen. Secondly, why do the "anti-Jesus" crowd show up so vehemently with just one mention of the work "Bible"?

Some said that the were so glad to live in America, well so am I. Thankfully we can all use free will to determine our path and all are protected. Even those who trash everyone else who does not believe as they do (Christians, Muslims,Jews,and Athiests alike).

by jwildhair

Make up a new email address & send the details regarding where to locate the alleged illicit files to whatever link in the chain of command you deem appropriate.