Porn on boss' computer--the Ethicist speaks
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Hardware
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by deathjester
canIberichnowplease I salute you.
You make some very good points. I'm 37, the father of 3, and have inherited 3 more from a second relationship. I've worked in IT for nearly 2 decades. You name it, I have seen or dealt with it.
The thought of anyone touching any of my six children literally makes my blood boil, and I have no doubt that I would exact a fathers justice if anyone laid a finger on any of them.
In the past I have had to forensically recover pornography from user profiles that have been deleted as evidence in case a worker sued for wrongful dismissal, and this sort of job isn't pretty in the workplace.
This is my soapbox rant to anyone reading this post - If reporting your boss for looking at child porn gets you sacked, but saves the innocence of a tiny 3 year old girl there should be no moral dilemma whatsoever.
You can always find another job, but a little girl will never get back what has been taken from her - if she survives.
Most of us working in the IT field are on good salaries, have all the tech toys, nice cars, big houses, loving wives etc and can sometimes forget what is important in life.
At the end of the day when I walk in my front door, I can't wait to hear the pitter patter of many sets of feet and, "Daddy's home!".
If your CEO or workmates are into child porn, think of your own children and you'll soon be calling crimestoppers on 1800 333 000. Anonymous tipoffs get these people out of our society too.
Several cases where illegal materials were found on company computers have been thrown out because of this "expectation of privacy".
I don't have the specific cases at hand, but if you search back through the records for the 9th Circuit Court you should find them.
These days, with the US becoming a police state, there is no place to put anything. Even entering or leaving the country can result in your notebook computer, mobile phone and USB sticks being confiscated and searched at the leisure of the DHS.
And by the way, no suspicion of guilt or 'reasonable grounds' for the search are necessary. Neither is a court order or any form of judicial oversight.
Someone can lie bleeding to death by the side of the road in the USA and not a single person will stop to help?
In the USA, everyone is more afraid of being sued than the moral consequences of closing eyes and walking by.
by ontheropes
by jdclyde
The Bible is not the foundation for his twisted sexualization of children, nor his sick fascination with it.
I wonder though, from some of the posts, if this isn't a female instead of male? The "all porn is evil" sounds like some of the radical flannel wearers that no one would ever want to see naked in the first place......
by oz_media
I mean, where do you even start with someone so completely full of complete garbage, misinformation, false facts etc. It would be like trying to untangle one of those spiderweb knots of wiring from behind a 15 year old entertainment system. Good luck!
He is obviously throwing his choice of religion out as if it is the cure of all evil, and not simply a book of misguided delusions that see everything non-Christaian as being evil. But even then, there are many Christians who look at porn, yet I suppose they would not fit HIS description of being Christian.
As for being a broad, well the evangelistic style fits more with a man, yet I agree that the 'blind man's view' of pornography certainly does echo eating granola, crocheting skirts and making pottery, doesn't it?
by jdclyde
after all, who can argue that we need to protect "the children"?
I am really surprised myself of what is classified as "Art" instead of child porn, but there have been legal marriages to 12 year olds for centuries before it became illegal (in most places).
A few years ago, there was another discussion on here where a member was outraged because "a ceo" had pictures of very young girls in swim suits and he was disgusted by it. The guys disgust does not make it illegal, but the outrage is all emotion without thought.
Follow the company policy, and play it by the book and leave your personal preferences out of it.
by doug
You know people, if you don't snoop around
on your superiors' computers you don't run
into these ethical problems.
This is only one of many reasons why it's a
very bad idea to go anywhere on a
superior's computer you're not supposed to
go. I don't even open up documents they
want me to work on, I have them open the
document. I don't want them to see me
looking at their recent document list or
the files in the documents folder.
I really don't get why this concept of not
snooping around is so difficult for IT
people to get.
by jdclyde
I have the ability to go in and see what everyone makes, but I don't. If I DID and got caught, I could and should be fired for abusing my position.
Unless there is a set policy that the IT department is to be the Nazi's, he should be fired.
Company property does not equal a tech snooping through other peoples files.
I haven't got any superiors. :p
Nowhere did I see that the tech in the original article was snooping, that's your desired assumption.
Also, whether it's this tech, or one with a bit more clout, someone has to a least be able to see what files you have on any kit plugged into the company network.
If you have porn, you could have a virus. If you are into forms of porn that you would rather your peers not be aware of, you are a security threat. An increase in trust, which is what you are trying to imply by your continual 'but I'm a manager toss' means you are also a greater threat.
I really don't get why this concept is so difficult for the technically ignorant...
by doug
You were told to look at media files to make
sure they're not porn. So this
ethical "problem" the ethicist talks about
doesn't apply to you. You were told to look
for porn, you found some, so you report it.
He was snooping. Virus checkers don't
require you to look at jpegs.
Like most ethical problems you get the
problem by first performing an unethical
act. Snooping around the boss's is
unethical, and dangerous. You could get
caught. Or you could find out other stuff
that puts you in an ethical bind. What if
you find a file called "List of Layoffs",
when no one knows layoffs are coming?
by hangtown man
Keywords child/"early teens" Your Boss is Sick. these Children are Victims.
Silence makes you an accomplice!
Part of my job is looking for Non Work related files. IE: Jpg's, Mp3's and such.
Don't Load Non-work related files on a work machine. Keep your Porn at home.
Unless your afraid your wife might find it.
by oz_media
First of all, the writer clearly shows that he is not very aware as far as porn goes. Then goes on to ASSUME..."including some of young children ? clearly less than 18, possibly early teens."
This is what I question. A lot of porn is SOLD on teh basis of teh girls appearing to be under the age of 18, yet they are legal, have signed a release and been paid for their work.
An example is girls gone wild, while these girls APPEAR to be just a bunch of slutty teens on spring break, they are ALWAYS ALWAYS ALWAYS over 18, consenting (they ALL sign a waiver) and have been paid well. They aren't just hanging out and drinking underage, showing their boobs because some fool with a camera asked them too.
Or else there are Sanchez's BangBus films, where he SUPPOSEDLY picks up young girls at malls, etc. and drives around in a van with friends before conning them into sex and finally dropping them off and laughing as he rips them off. (not too appealing sounding is it?)
But he also pays an average of $1000.00 per shoot, the girls are all over 18 and have signed a legal release, the rest is all for film.
No I am not a pedophile, or porn filme maker, but I know a couple of people that do make a good living from porn films and it is all just fake, a la "the MOVIES"!.
by hangtown man
by oz_media
by oz_media
by public8
by oz_media
First of all, not all duct tape is silver, in fact black, red, green and brown are very common, especially in the more expensive, clothy duct tapes (also called gaffers tape as it is used for stage matting).
But the thing that I don't get is that prison bars are black, I don't think I 've ever seen black prison bars.
Your point?
by oz_media
by hangtown man
Job Role: Executive Management (Chairman, CEO, CFO, Partner)
Yours foremost
I was referring to that one who would shout in public that he is not (some reviled thing or another).
I don't quite get your reply, unless you negate my role as a thing to be reviled, as well.
by ontheropes
by ontheropes
by ontheropes
by ontheropes
we get sacked if we watch it at work...
Huh ?
That's a seriously dumbass generalisation.
Would a lingerie catalogue be pornography, what about a female manikin in only underwear. It would have been once, in fact it probably still is in some societies.
Engage your brain before you post.
by hal 9000
When I was younger it was normal to stop and help those who had broken down particularly when in the country here at least. Maybe it is wrong to say that people are scared of being sued as I don't know if that's right but there has been a massive change in attitudes since I was younger.
The last time I was driving way out where there was no one I stopped to offer help to some people who had broken down and they seemed to think that I was going to Rape, Plunder, Kill whatever. Apparently it was OK as far as they where concerned to die at the side of the road rather than have someone offer them a lift into town or see if they could help fix the problem.
Even in town I stopped for someone just up the road from where I live to see if I could be of any assistance and they locked themselves in their car and where on the phone calling for help. But the guy who walked out of his house to offer help was OK. Go figure. :0
Mind you he only walked out because I stopped. :D
Col
by ontheropes
by ontheropes
by hal 9000
is quite often made for race teams in Team Colors so that when they tape up a car there is no noticeable different color on it.
Holds very well in all weathers but is a sod to remove once you are back in the workshop.
Col
OK, maybe there is ONE good samaritan out of thousands out there somewhere.
Google it. Here's one to get you started, but there were hundreds of thousands of hits, so you'll have a lot of reading to do...
http://observers.france24.com/en/content/20080613-hit-and-run-torres-connecticut-united-states
aren't you?
If you were say there looking at the dialog of a virus checker and it came up scanning
Amy 3yo takes it up the ass.jpg, WTF would you do?
Tbe real ethical test is not should a tech snoop, it's not should a manager keep porn on a company Pc. It's not adherring to some moral standard about porn.
It's if you were snooping (or not) and if you did find child porn, would you keep you gob shut to make it easy on yourself?
The ethicist says you should, apparently you are saying you should. Me I'm saying, I'd risk being fired, prosecuted and jailed, before I let a paedo breathe comfortably for one more second.
That's my base ethical position, I'm more than content with it.
by doug
I can see what you're saying. It's actually
the old ethical issue of a person who
discovers a horrific crime while in the
process of committing a relatively minor
crime. He wants to report the horrific
crime, but he knows that by reporting it
he'll be punished for his minor crime.
From what I remember it's normally told in
context of a burglar who discovers a
horrific murder while in the process of
burglaring a house.
by jdclyde
someone stole a safe. In that save was a flash stick that had a video of the person molesting a child.
It was turned in.
I don't recall what became of the thief. That part never makes the follow up headlines, ya know?
by jmccardl29
In my last post I stated I would do nothing.
Years ago I had a rental property and I observed many cigarette burns on a five year old child's arm. I asked her how did the burns occur. She told me that "Mummies man friend did it". I was appalled and reported it to the Victorian Police "Community Policing Squad" and was assured that my report would be in strict confidence. Imagine my shock and horror when the girl's mum and her friend went off their face at me telling me that the Seargent had told them that the landlord had made a complaint. These people were members of a bikie gang and realy mean critters. They threatened me with severe physical violence. Assuming I could have called the cops (mobile phones were not around then) there would have been at least 10 minutes before I would have received any help. I could easily have been dead by then.
Maybe only in Australia the whistleblower gets a raw deal (I do not think the raw deal occurs only in Australia).
Anyone who has seen "Underbelly" (which is a pretty true factual tv film about the Melbourne underworld killings of 20 or more criminals) soon convinces anyone about being too heroic. Some of these crims loved killing for the sake of killing. (This film is so accurate that in Victoria it has a court order preventing it being Telecast until several criminal trials are conducted including a Tony Mokbel and others)
If you spill the beans your name will make its way into the public domain.
In Victoria we have an assistant Police Commisioner facing trial for "leaking information to inappropriate people."
Your name will allways be available from court records.
I have asked a copper and my solicitor what they thought and was advised to forget it, it would bring more heartache for me than the villain.
It really sounds nice to be so self rightous and do the correct thing. It would be great if the baddies got smacked and the goodies got given the chocolates. Maybe in our next life!!!!
by deathjester
Crikey, there's been a lot of posts to this one since I dropped in last time.
Our company has a well documented IT policy that all employees are made aware of during their induction. This includes sections on pornography, excessive use of the internet for personal use, running a business electronically, gaming, gambling and the distribution of spam through company servers.
Whether as individuals we agree with company policy regarding pornography due to our moral stance or work ethic, a company computer is for doing company work on, and policy is put it place so employess don't waste too much time surfing for porn, playing counterstrike and buying stuff on ebay whilst they should be working.
Policy also protects a company from legal smacks, as ultimately, they are responsible for the use of company assets.
Management should know better than to keep porn on their PC's.
The IT elite in most companies can hack, crack, attack and ransack any PC they choose - a fact that most employees and employers quite often forget. This power is in our hands and it is up to us to wield it responsibly and wisely.
If you find questionable material on your bosses PC when you weren't meant to be in there in the first place then you are going to get a smack for snooping.
If you find it during routine operating system maintenance, then as an individual you must decide if you want to risk your career and possibly your mortgage and marriage by ending up at the unemployment office because of "moral high ground".
When faced with the reality of losing your job over a couple of pictures, is there any wonder that most people turn a blind eye when faced with this situation?
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending