Should you have to be legal to vote?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Windows Forum
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by av .
Everyone that votes in this country should have to prove they're a registered voter and present an ID. Why isn't this a given? I don't have a problem with that and I don't think any other legal citizen would either.
Isn't the integrity of our voting system compromised enough by electronic voting machines with no paper trail? No, lets have all the illegal aliens vote too so they can swing our elections in their favor.
In New Jersey, we have a voter ID card and you have to sign a voter registration book (not sure what its called) that identifies you. I had to present identification to get that voter ID card.
Whats happening in Ohio is just so ridiculous. I think Subodh Chandra, the lawyer representing the homeless and service employees union is just trying to make a name for himself.
Homeless people don't pay property taxes like I do.
by tonythetiger
by av .
But I'm talking about the 12 to 20 million undocumented illegal people already in this country. Thats quite a sizeable voting bloc. Why should they have any say in our elections? They're here illegally! Voting should be for legal citizens that can present a valid ID only.
Illegals don't pay taxes like I do and they break our laws everyday. I'm tired of funding their American Dream.
PX the first point wasn't anti- or pro- the GOP vs Dems (or Conservative vs Labour parties in other lands)) more that "power corrupts" and with little effort you can find books full of examples of horrific or humorous examples everywhere.
The prev. writer's assertion about one party or the other is reasonably inane because, with such examples, you can generally alternate the party name and have at least an analogous, if not a straight factual, swap that still is pretty accurate.
And the second point I think you actually underline.
The challenge with an imposed system of government is exactly that. You only have to look at many ex-USSR cities, states and nations where people have reverted for whatever reason back to the "old boss".
What you genuinely have to beleive in, is that if you give them the democracy, you have to commit 100% to the result even if (and maybe not now but at some point in future) they vote against any semblance of sensibility or rationality.
Empowering the Palestine, letting them vote for Hammas, and then letting your lap dog jump in and kill, take back land and knock down houses in a pre-emptive strike (what, to remind them "who is the boss"??) doesn't seem that dedicated to the real democratic cause to me.
Democracy has its problems but it is the best we have. But I'm not sure that you can't half believe in it.
All power to you in Iraq and I can imagine the emotion of that day will never be lost on you.
But as for your government, the fact is that for every single Iraq, there is at least one example of non-democratic soveriegn states guilty of the most horrible crimes on their citizens, powered by US arms, run on US money and trained by US staff. And the challenge is that it happens today.
Really, that was funny. And actually, I liked the way you acknowledged my libertarian principles. (As a side-note, I also find it funny, but in a sad sort of way, when others accuse me of toeing the Republican line. You apparently know more about what drives me than those people.)
Nonetheless, in a perfect world I would agree with you. However, we don't live in a perfect world. I'm sure you're just as principled as I am, but it's becoming apparent that you're applying your principles either as though we do live in a perfect world, or in your desire to create one.
I think that's the problem with the libertarian cause, per se, such as we might see in the Libertarian Party. They're too absolute in their positions. And I don't think such absolute positions are reasonable to either expect or pursue, unless everybody else is willing to go along, or unless they could be pursued separately. But others aren't willing to go along, even in as much as leaving all us libertarians alone and separated, so to speak. There is no libertarian state to which we can flee, per se, and sticking to our guns regardless of which way the political wind is blowing is like pi$$ing in the wind.
I don't like sobriety check points either, as they're a gross violation of one's civil liberties. I don't like all the laws the infringe on what a person does in the privacy of his own life. I don't a lot of things about today's social climate and government management of that climate -- including the notion of voter ID. But I don't like the huge influx of illegal aliens more. I don't like voter fraud more. I'll even say that I don't like today's Republican Party, but I don't like the Democrat Party more. That's one reason why I don't vote the Libertarian ticket, because in today's reality, that vote will only help the Democrat Party -- like that pi$$ing in the wind thing.
So I think it's not necessarily a question of principle, but rather how that principle can be best applied in today's reality. And in today's reality, I often find myself asking not what I really want, but what I really don't want more. And in today's reality, I don't want voter fraud and non-citizens voting MORE than I want to be able to vote myself without showing my drivers license. And it's a small political chip to pay in the overall scheme of things.
by tonythetiger
not exactly "create". "Move toward" would be more accurate. I am well aware that reality is different. That's why this subthread was titled "On principle". I am not convinced that "near perfection" is unattainable as long as enough well meaning people are willing to continue to strive for it.
(corrected grammar)
by rob mekel
Municipal voting => resident of of Municipal
Provincial voting => need to be Dutch
2nd chamber ((USA parliament)=> need to be Dutch
1st chamber (USA senate) voting => need to be Dutch
In all votings you dopn't have to do anything. Your voting card will be send to you. That is to your home adress. If not recieved a voting card before 7 day's of an election then you can get a card from the townhall but you will have to prove that you live at the adres that you say you are. Just an simple ID-card (passport or a like) isn't enough provement.
Rob
It's one of those misconceptions that "Republicans" were the one's most associated with the KKK. To the contrary, it was the Democrats. In fact, Democrat Senator Robert Byrd was an actual, card-carrying member of the KKK in his early political career; Democrat Senator Al Gore Senior actually voted against the civil rights act; and George Wallace was a segregationist Democrat.
It's also Democrats most associated with voter fraud. Just ask anyone familiar with the Chicago, Illinois political boss, Richard Daly. That phrase alone is synonymous with rampant voter fraud; and that alone is what elected a Democrat president, John Kennedy.
I could go on pointing out your errors, but what's the point? You've certainly proven yourself to be an ignorant foreigner who wants to come-across as an expert on all things American. Too bad you don't have a clue. What is it with you people anyway?
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=196585&messageID=2045855
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=196585&messageID=2045581
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=196585&messageID=2045854
And this one (I actually consider it one of my best efforts in these "off-topic" threads):
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=196739&messageID=2046986
(Although on second glance, I see that you did not miss them. Worth linking to, nonetheless.)
By the way, I wonder what Walter Williams says about the voter ID issue? Do you know? Nonetheless, keep trying, Tony. You might get me to change my mind if you can connect today's reality and basic libertarian principles. But it appears as though I'm not gonna' change yours -- which is fine. I certainly understand.
by rfink
Since when? Last time I check we voted for the people who voted for the President. All the Presidential election is a non-binding advisory vote.
The Electorial College should be scrapped but that's another discussion.
by tonythetiger
by rfink
We will always have election fraud. Here are my suggestions to reduce election fraud.
1. Purge the voter registration list every four years. Just like you have to renew your driver's license you should have to renew your voter registration. That would solve the problem of dead people and non-residents voting.
2. The people who run the elections benefit from them. That is a huge confict of interest. Elections should be run by a neutral non-government body.
3. Require votes to show ID.
4. Elimitinate Congressional districts. With all the "gerrymandering" that goes on, I lost my faith in the election process. Congressional elections should be on a state by state basis. Have people for the party not the candidate. If a party gets 40% of the vote, it gets 40% of the seats. That way the "will of the people" gets implentmented. Another benefit, since the seats are appointed by the party, the person is held accountable to the party's platform. The voters know what they are getting. If a person does his own thing contrary to the party, he won't be reappointed. This would also encourage more parties to form because they would have a chance of getting elected.
5. Anyone convicted of election fraud should be sent to jail for life without parole.
6. Scrap the electional college. It violates the principle of "one man, one vote".
Of course I realize that since the people getting elected are the same people doing the cheating, I doubt any thing will change.
by tonythetiger
4. Doesn't that assume that people will always vote straight party line? I know I sure don't. I know some Democrats who are more conservative than some Republicans, for example.
5. That's probably a little harsh. How about making it a minor felony, 18 months max, and change the law so that a felony conviction bars one from holding public office?
by x-marcap
by jdclyde
If you read into the purpose of the electoroal college, you would see that it really IS a good thing. It is how you allow individual states to maintain their own voice.
If it really were one-man/one-voice then NY and CA would make all the decisions for the rest of the country and we would be toast.
This is one of the counters to putting too much power in too few hands. Independent states is an important part of our society, and that would strip the smaller states of any say.
Please read up on this, and the more you learn about WHY it is there, the more you will agree that it is needed.
Would you want the Feds, controlled by CA to come in and take over water rights to the great lakes? It would happen.
by rfink
JDClyde,
I am familiar with the history of the Electorial College. My beef with it is the "winner take all" approach that is used.
Canidates winning a state with < 50% of the popular vote winning 100% of electorial vote.
The founder fathers created the Electorial College because they wanted the states to elect the President, not the people. The Federal government was supposed to answer to the states. That is also why Senators were appointed by the States. It was all part of the checks and balances the founding fathers wanted because they were aware of the evil a big corrupt central government could cause.
The federal government was suppose to handle interstate issues while the states handled everything else, thus the 10th Admendment.
Instead thanks to the weakening of the Electoral College and the 17th Admendment the states are mere puppets to the federal government.
by tonythetiger
What if a person fills out their absentee ballot and mails it in, but dies before "Election Day"?
:)
by x-marcap
by java_ho
by java_ho
http://phoenix.about.com/b/a/257364.htm
Am I the only one who thinks this is, not only a dumb idea, but a dangerous one?
by jamesrl
You can't improve the democratic process simply by increasing the number of ballots cast.
If people are not voting based on a somewhat informed opinion - then how does that help?
If people are showing up to win a lottery and not thinking about who they vote for......you could get some very bad results.
So no, you aren't the only one.
James
by tonythetiger
[i]If people are not voting based on a somewhat informed opinion[/i]
... maybe in addition to proving you are a legal citizen, you should have to prove you are an [b]informed[/b] citizen. :)
by rfink
by av .
Maybe they'll even have a quick pick for the uninformed.
What a bad, bad idea.
by jdclyde
should never be catered to.
Working to get the stupid and lazy to vote is a bad idea because they are the ones that have no idea who they are voting for anyways. They will be like the rest of the democrats and vote for who ever has the nicest hair or something dumb like that.
by x-marcap
The other issue is that in the US, the poorest, and the most likely to vote for the give aways are those who are underpriviledged.
Illegals tend to be less financially rewarded for their work. A certain party sees the illegals as a way to swell their voter base. They want the law to be circumvented, or changed.
Since that requires a change to some state constitutions this party wants Federal Judicial action to override State laws and constitutions.
I guess I am sick of the subject. They should be removed from the country whenever found.
by x-marcap
by x-marcap
The Republicans have always been for a level playing field. The Democrats want to affect the outcomes. This is the same as whrn the Southern Democrats were preventing Black people from Voting in the 1930-1960s.
The Democrats have been the party that elects a Grand Klegel(sic)of the KKK, Robert Byrd. The Democrats, including Al Gore Sr. voted against the civil rights bills. It is amazing how you are trying to rewrite history. Look up the congressional record. See the Southern Democrats vote to maintain segregation (separate but equal) in block.
Quit lying, Mr. Clinton. Oh I am sorry, I recognize the spirit of the innner Clinton, not the person, my (not) apology.
by x-marcap
by protiusx
I don't know why and since I can't talk to the dead I can't find out. I'm sure Shirley McClain could channel some of the voters to see why they feel voting democratic is the way to vote once you've kicked off.
There was an investigation and the consensus was "oh well to bad". I think she's going to be a one term wonder.
by x-marcap
It isn't difficult to understand that the immigrants should speak English.
Until we say enough! We will continue to see the BS.
by x-marcap
by x-marcap
by x-marcap
Read the Communist Manifesto. See the social engineering of the taxation philosophy. Look to Mein Kampf, See the Democrats follow socialism. See the Republicans do nothing to stop it.
What we need is for people to vote American.
Stop illegal immigration Now!!!
Build a fence, and electrify it.
Next comes the Canadian border.
I would love to keep OZ out forever!!!
by jdclyde
They take the first amendment to the extreme, but couldn't give a rip about the second.
Keep Oz out? But he loves coming here making money in the place he hates so, as he has so often admitted.
by x-marcap
by x-marcap
They should have been sent back to serve time either in prison, or in the military.
The Canadian Premier defied international law and allowed and welcomed fleeing felons into Canada by executive order...
He should be welcomed to the US and then put on trial at the Hague. (aiding and Abetting fleeing felons)
by jamesrl
I was specifically referring to the Vietnam era draft dodgers. Many of them became Canadian citizens. And draft is the operative word - they didn't have a choice to serve.
The deserters that are currently in Canada are being shown the door. They have run through the refugee claims process, exhausted all the appeals and have no where to go. Two that went back to the US recently had served one tour in Iraq, and both were given less than honorable discharges(someone want to enlighten me as to the nuance?).
As to shipping felons.....
Recent case where an American citizen married a Canadian and moved to a border town. He got a job teaching at a girls school in Buffalo. He was caught "petting" with a 15 year old girl in a mall parking lot in Buffalo - one of his students. Initially the judge gave him probation, if he would go back to Canada and only return to Buffalo to see his parole officer.
You can imagine this went all the way to the ministers of Justice in Ontario and Canada. The prosecuter in Buffalo worked to rescind the deal, just as Ontario authorities were getting ready to deport him. He will now serve parole in Buffalo.
If you have a cite for this, please provide. My understanding of the Hague conventions and criminal extraditions is that there has to be a number of conditions met before an extradition will happen, and one of those is that there must be a similar crime in Canada, which is eligible for at least a one year sentance. Since there hasn't been a draft in Canada since WWII(and even then it was late in the war and small scale), a Vietnam draft dodger who hadn't reported for duty would not meet those criteria. On the other hand a deserter who had been inducted would since there is a law for that in Canada.
If you are talking about the Vietnam era, you would have to exhume his corpse, Trudeau the Prime Minister (provinces have premiers) has been dead for some time.
Most people either loved Trudeau or hated him. I campaigned against him for several elections. I did like his "the state has no place in the bedrooms of the nation" quote. He was extremely intelligent, arrogant and exasperating kind of guy.
But if you want to play that kind of game, Canada should have had LBJ arrested for assault. When Lester B Pearson(Trudeau's predecessor) met with LBJ one time in Washington, Pearson had made some comments about the scale of the bombing of Vietnam and the killing of innocents. LBJ grabbed him by his lapels and lifted him up of the ground - the lapels came together and Pearson went red in the face. If that had happened in Canada, the Prime Minister's protective staff would have pistol whipped LBJ.
James
by x-marcap
It is simple you fill out a absentee ballot request and fed-ex the ballot back...
Simple isn't it...
by onbliss
by x-marcap
Obviously you are a liberal.
If I can't wriote a check without ID and that is just about money, I shouldn't be able to vote without it, that is the execize of sovereignity.
by tonythetiger
[i]Obviously you are a liberal.[/i]
And obviously I'm going to have to wear out "the link" on you.
by x-marcap
IMHO this is a true return DALY=`Voter Fraud`
echo $DALY
by x-marcap
by tonythetiger
by x-marcap
by x-marcap
by x-marcap
Be a Felon. Be under a suspended federal drug sentance, house arrest, or under appeal of a felony.
If you prove you are OK then you should be able to vote.
by x-marcap
by jdclyde
a straight vote would fix anything?
As our neighbors on the coast have clearly shown they are quite insane, this would be a horrible place to live if they controlled the country.
NY let Billary move in and become their senator. How much more proof do you need to see that these people can not be trusted to run things?
We also saw what Davis was allowed to do in CA. And the biggest accounting scandels in our lifetime were where? And they got away with it for how long?
No thanks. The Electoral College is not perfect, but it is much better than the alternative. And you DO get your congress reps based on population.
by danlm
And I can't remember which, that split how the electrical votes are decided? What I mean is, they can actually vote different candidates with their electoral votes?
Ie: You have popular vote in these specific districts that want a democrat elected. The electoral votes from those districts that way. And say, the other districts had all the popular votes go to a republican. Which is where the electoral votes go.
I remember reading something on this. And I do apologize if I have this wrong. Actually, I thought that Colorado had it on their ballot during this election. 2000? 2004???
Dan
by tonythetiger
Those states are Nebraska and Maine. However, although they could do it, they don't do it. I'm not sure if they ever have done it; and if they have, I don't know when that was.
It was a ballot issue in Colorado in 2004, but it failed. It failed for a number of reasons, one of which was because the measure was a transparent ploy to influence the 2004 election. It was actually supported and financed by a Democrat Party interest based in California. Had it passed, it would have applied, in essence, retroactively to that very 2004 election; it would have FORCED the vote split, and not made it optional as it is in Nebraska and Maine. Considering the way it was written and proposed, a court challenge was an absolute certainty had it passed.
by danlm
My understanding of the electoral college is to not allow more populated states lead the rest of the nation around by their gonads with regard to who is elected.
I had always thought that allowing a state to split it's electoral vote would be a good idea because it would allow for a better representation of the popular vote across the full state.
Now, if a state has huge rural area's with say one or two major cities. If the popular vote of the cities completely outnumbers the rural area votes preference, doesn't the state cast all it's electoral votes that way anyway? Ie, the populated area's lead the less populated area's around by their shoe laces again with regard to how the vote is officially made? If a state did a split of the electoral vote(allowed for only, not required). Wouldn't this better represent the feelings of the whole state, and not just one or two specific areas?
But, then again. Which area's have a better voter turnout? Chuckle, the rural area's? Or the heavily populated cities?
I don't know, just a thought process. That's all.
Dan
by nicknielsen
This is not the first time that New York has elected a "non-resident" as a Senator. They elected RFK in 1964. This was a source of humor at the time. Tom Lehrer quipped on one of his live recordings that Massachusetts was the only state to have [u]three[/u] Senators.
And you are correct, JD. It could be much worse than the Electoral College. I vaguely remember reading a story back in the 70s where demographics and polling were used to determine who the pivotal voter would be. Since that person was the pivotal voter, there was no point in anybody else voting. Imagine being the only voter and the focus of all that energy... :(
by x-marcap
By supporting the rightr to commit the fraud you declare that it is wrong to certify voting accuracy and you are for fraud.
IMHO you are a bad loser.
Did you sue companies who were using SSNs that were not involved with collecting income taxes in the i970's and 1980's?
I did.
by x-marcap
I was stopped for 44 in a 45 on a clear 80 degree day. I had to go to court to get ithe ticket dropped and the three hours of waiting cost me more than the cost of a ticket.
I did it for the principle...
by x-marcap
The point is that a small state and a larger state have 2 EC votes just for being states.
Since populist states scream about that not being fair we also have a segment of the EC based on population.
Together it balances the city give me culture and the rural give me culture...
The EC is fine, but we need many better candidates.
by x-marcap
by x-marcap
They should have been sent to prison. In Canada for fleeing prosecution or the draft.
That is international law. Since Pierre Trudeau flaunted the international laws, Many countries have done the same including all the UN resolutions that I remember him stopping myself and some Marines from returning with a captured prisoner. When he claimed he was a draft dodger, (Marines have always been volunteers) he was separated from us and released. He wasn't a draft dodger, but AWOL. He was freed and we were not allowed to capturee him on foreign soil. Canadian sovreignity and all that.
The PM of CANADA started the general ignoring of UN resolutions. In the 1950's we went to N. Korea over less. Trudeau should have been tried in the Hague.
by tonythetiger
one needs to prove that a problem exists. Are illegals actually voting or trying to vote?
Next, of those who may be voting, is an ID law going to deter them (Fake IDs are not that difficult to come by)?
Actually, by making a voting ID law, you're telling illegals it's OK to come here, just not OK to come here and vote! Is that the messsage you want to send?
It's a knee-jerk reaction at best. And it's going to be far more costly than anyone realizes.
by av .
Of course they vote, but yes, proving it is another problem because of fake IDs (licenses). It would be better if you had to present your social security card to vote and it was checked against the government database. Illegals don't have social security numbers, unless they're stolen.
In NJ at least, they're finally implementing Digital Drivers License and ID verification programs that will validate information in their database against information in the Social Security Administration files. I'm sure its just a matter of time before this is the norm across the country.
Voting is just one part of the problem. Its time for Americans to take their country back. Making a voting ID law is just one small step in the fight to do just that. Its worth paying for to me.
Heres the message I want to send Tony: My idea of what to do with the illegal immigrants in this country is to send them back one by one no matter how long it takes and fine the employers that hire them and the landlords that house them. Thats comprehensive immigration reform.
The immigrants that made America great were law abiding people that came to this country the right way. Illegals are leaches on society and its time for them to get out.
by danlm
Is the most legitimate argument that I have heard about not having voter id requirements.
Your right, ask any college student who goes to the bar on a regular basis about fake id's.
Dan
by tonythetiger
you don't have to worry about them voting, therefore the ID law is unnecessary. Conversely, the ID law is not going to deter illegals from entering the country.
It should be as simple as: Use the solution that solves the problem you are addressing.
by jamesrl
Today deserters are not granted status, and though it takes some time for them to exhaust the appeals process, they are being turned around.
The UN (including Canada) went into Korea because the North invaded the south - a little different situation.
We used to have lots of scenarios where the US would shelter Canadian men who kidnapped their children in violation of Canadian custody orders (US and many other countries), so now there are new laws and its been added to the Hague conventions.
The sovereignty thing works both ways. When I was living in Ottawa, a young guy cut off an off duty Marine guard who was part of the embassy security detail. The Marine chased him, and at a red light got out of the car, pulled the young man out and beat him severely. Canadian law couldn't touch them because the marine was embassy staff. The state department has the option to waive that provision, but they chose not to. Instead, the marine was moved to another post.
Of course you couldn't arrest someone on Canadian soil (US embassy/consular office/US military base excepted because they are considered US soil).
Canadian police do work with US law enforcement and when they make arrests at the request of the US (with sufficient evidence) often a US officer will come along. The FBI has offices in several Canadian cities.
James
by tonythetiger
You could deliberately mow down a pedestrian with your car at any time. How is a "law" going to prevent that? It doesn't. It can only punish you if you DO (or in some cases punish you even if you don't)!
By your logic, every driver is potentially driving without a license, so the police must pull over every car they see and ensure that the driver is legally allowed to drive!
[i]Did you sue companies who were using SSNs that were not involved with collecting income taxes in the i970's and 1980's?[/i]
No, as I am not in the habit of suing someone unless (A) I have some actual damages, and (B) the responsible party won't settle the matter honorably.
...then the electoral college is their only ace in the hole. To take away the electoral college is to take away about the only remaining remnant of "states' rights". And if it's not winner -take-all, you just weakened states' rights as an independent entity.
If you have a problem with the electoral college, it's only in how you perceive it to be. The PEOPLE of the state decide how THEIR state will cast its allotted votes. In EVERY election, it's a winner take all. Why should this be any different? Your state elects one governor, and your state "elects" one president -- or in this case, stands behind one presidential candidate.
Think about the definition of "state". What other nation has "states". Or asked another way, what other nation-state has "states". The name alone implies a certain sovereignty -- something we do not want to see vanish.
by rfink
My biggest beef is the "winner take all". If a majority (50+%) of the popular vote was required to receive the electorial vote I could live with that. What I have a problem with is a candidate winning a state with say 45% of the vote and getting all of the electorial votes when 55% voted against him by voting for someone else. How is that "the will of the people?".
A run off should be required. Better yet, do what the founding fathers intended. The states appoint the electors and the people don't vote. Think of all of the headaches that would save.
Gore won the popular vote and the State of Flordia held the rest of the country hostage.
That is how not to run an election.
by jdclyde
states like California, New York, and Texas would run the country. This would completely take away all say in government YOU have right now, living in Michigan.
The majority of the votes in a state gives that independent state that many electoral votes.
Keep in mind that the states with higher population get more electoral votes, so it is still weighted heavily towards the bigger states.
Straight popular vote would be a disaster, no matter what liberals have been telling you.
Oh yeah, Bush had popular vote last election, and it still didn't stop the dishonest from crying about it. They just moved on to something else to cry about.
by tonythetiger
[i]the State of Flordia held the rest of the country hostage.[/i]
I always thought the tally should be kept absolutely secret until every vote was counted. People where polls haven't yet closed could be discouraged and not even bother to vote if counts were released too soon. This hurts more than just the legitimacy of presidency, it hurts the will of the people on every issue and candidate on the ballot.
by tonythetiger
That's why I think law abiding citizens going about their constitutionally protected business should not be unduly harassed by the government.
I wonder what your principles would tell you if that same cop pulled you over every day for a month. How long would it take for you to find another route to work?
by tonythetiger
to question me unless I am reasonably suspected of wrongdoing.
You really should avoid adult conversations for a few more years.
by jdclyde
than just illegals, although they are becoming more and more of a problem to the citizens of this country.
But this is all besides the point. We will all soon have our implanted microchip, so IDs will not be required.
by nicknielsen
At least it did in the 80s; I don't know if it still exists. Tourists could apply for a partial rebate of the VAT by completing some forms and presenting their receipts. If I remember correctly, it was limited to souvenir items that were returning to the home country. Meals, lodging, and transportation were exempted.
I think Americans who itemize tax deductions can also deduct taxes paid to foreign governments from their income tax.
by nicknielsen
The vote is one of the rights of citizenship. Not a citizen, no vote. How do you prove you are a citizen? Valid identification.
I'm surprised that naturalized American citizens aren't coming out of the woodwork over this. They had to wait to vote and they were here legally; now you want to make it possible for some guy that came into the country inside a cargo container to vote?
by rob mekel
Most European countries have such a program but only for leaving from EU to non-EU countries.
Then on the other side you will have to pay VAT to the country that you will be entering. :) If that ever happens??
Well on im/export by company's it will be enforced but on private persons ??
Rob
by nicknielsen
by delbertpgh
Here's a little thought experiment:
Imagine a district where a lot of elderly people live, who don't drive or get out much, many of them in nursing homes. They tend to vote overwhelmingly Republican. Now, a voter ID law comes along that requires them to have a current (not expired) photo ID issued by the state or the federal government. Before, they had to simply walk or be bussed to the polling place once every two years, where they could present their old voter registration cards or 1972 driver licenses, but now they have to make another trip every few elections to get a fresh photo card. Many rent cabs or otherwise find ways to make a trip downtown to get their IDs, but thousands just decide the extra work is not worth it.
Local Democrats start finding themselves much more competitive in local elections. Instead of warning about the "disenfranchisement of the poor" the voter I.D. requirement could cause, they fall silent, or say a few words about the importance of protecting our democracy against illegal aliens and vote fraud.
I don't think this is an unlikely situation at all. Thoughts, please, ladies and gentlemen.
by rfink
by rfink
by delbertpgh
Or, would you also propose a "DMV on Wheels", to go around house-to-house issuing photo IDs?
For sure, if you make people travel across town to the DMV to pick up a free ID, a lot of them (especially the elderly and crippled) will blow it off, and then won't be eligible to vote. Although you could say if they're that lazy, they don't deserve the vote. Harsh, maybe, but if you're more concerned with defending against fraud than with getting people to vote, then it's a valid policy.
by tonythetiger
[i]There are most issues than just illegals, although they are becoming more and more of a problem to the citizens of this country.[/i]
... to be terribly worried about it before now! I think it's just the control freaks using illegals as a reason. We can rarely even get half of the citizens to vote (and voter turnout in Mexico isn't any better!). What makes anyone really think that illegals are flooding the country to [b]vote[/b]?
[i]But this is all besides the point. We will all soon have our implanted microchip, so IDs will not be required.[/i]
Scary thought.
The union here (I'm not a member, though they get my money anyway due to the collective bargaining law) negotiated a "no timeclocks" rule into the contract some time ago (I don't know why... they just did). After 9/11, they put swipe-card access to the building, which
records who and when someone enters. Now you're not going to tell me that if they really had a hard-on for somebody, that they wouldn't use their "entry time" against them.
I wouldn't be surprised if the voter ID requirements end up with similar opportunities for misuse.
by nicknielsen
Driver's license, military ID, passport, state or sheriff's ID, etc.. If you wish to exercise your right to vote, you should take the responsibility to make sure you meet the requirements: knowledgable about the candidates/issues, proper ID, etc.
As to obtaining the ID, if going slightly out of your way to get is such an "inconvenience" that it would put you off voting, then voting must not be very important to you.
The traveling DMV is not such a bad idea. Send a computer, camera and printer out with the voter registration drives or into community centers. Verify eligibility, take the picture, obtain signature, print the IDs out and there you are.
by oldbag
I have been watching this discussion and have noticed that a lot of the comments turn into rants about illegal immigrants.
This discussion started with should non-citizens be allowed to vote in the upcoming elections whether the congressional elections in the US or municipal elections in Ontario.
There is, of course a big difference between those immigrants who have gone the legal route to enter the country VS those who come illegally but I do not see that as the point here. The question is should non-citizens be allowed to vote. I am on the side of keeping the right to vote to citizens only. Otherwise, what is the incentive to take citizenship of the country where they reside?
Immigrants should be encouraged to become citizens as soon as they are able. What bothers me is when someone comes to this country but never take citizenship even after years of being a legal resident. Illegal immigrants should be shown the door.
by jdclyde
First about splitting the vote. When you do that, you delute the power of your state. If a candidate knows on average he can never get more than 2/3's of the electoral votes, then the smaller states that do this will be not worth wasting their time on.
As for rural vs heavily populated cities. Because of the volume of people in the cities, they will always have more people vote and lead the state. That is why Detroit has as much influince as it does. They carry the bulk of the Democrat vote, and if Detroit were given to Ohio, it would be a big turn around for this state.
The percentage of turnout is MUCH lower in the cites though.
by tonythetiger
electoral vote, you might as well do away with it and go with the popular vote.
The idea is that the electors be "learned men" (a debatable term, I realize) from the various districts within a state who come to a consensus as to who should be supported by that state (it's always been as far as I know, but not necessarily required that it be in line with the vote of the people of that state) and speak to the nation not with the multiple voices based on party affilliation as with the house of representatives, nor with an equal voice as with the senate, but with a single unified voice.
by rfink
What's wrong with requiring a majority of the state's vote to earn its electoral vote?
What say do I have now? Michigan's EC votes went to Kerry who lost. In our system there's no difference between voting for the loser and staying home. The end result is the same.
by tonythetiger
by rfink
by tonythetiger
by jdclyde
I NEVER mentioned illegal aliens in the original post, ever. Yet except for a few (very few) post that do discuss the dead almost always voting for Democrats, the rest has been side tracked into illegals (criminals) voting in our elections.
Some are willing to make pathetic excuses for not wanting to fix fraud in our voting systems, and others are focused only on illegals.
Why is it not a priority to stop ALL voter fraud? Yes, I understand it is mostly Democrats that are cry about fraud the most, but are the ones that want nothing to do with fixing it. I don't know why the Republicans and Libritarians are not up in arms about stopping the efforts to win by committing fraud?
Oh well, go back to carrying on about illegals.....
by tonythetiger
by jdclyde
by av .
by nicknielsen
He's just not explaining it too well.
His problem is with the three-way race where candidate A receives 48% of the votes, candidate B receives 45% of the votes, and candidate C receives 7% of the votes. Candidates B and C together received the majority of the votes cast (52%), but Candidate A gets all the electoral votes because he received more votes than the others did individually.
In the history of the U.S., this has happened almost every time there is a viable third party candidate for President. It happened when George Wallace ran, it happened when John Anderson ran, it happened when Ross Perot ran, and it happened many times before that as well; the majority of voters cast their ballots for somebody other than the candidate who received the electoral votes. Since no one candidate received a majority (>50%) of the votes cast, states gave their electoral votes to the candidate who received the plurality. (http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/plurality) Then the whiners start with "He got less than half the popular vote, how did he get in to office.
Personally, in these cases I'm in favor of a run-off on the Saturday following. My reasoning is that many people (on both sides of politics) are too ready to jump with "He didn't receive a majority, he shouldn't be there! He wasn't really elected, he stole it, it was given to him, whatever excuse they can come up with." They then use that as an excuse to obstruct the process.
A two-candidate run-off election will ensure that the winning candidate is also the candidate with the majority of popular votes cast. With modern vote-counting techniques (those outside Florida ;\ ) complete and accurate results can probably be obtained within 48 hours after the election. With electronic voting machines, it takes less time than that to prepare for a two-candidate election.
Edit: emoticon
by av .
Nothing is that simple if you're talking about 12 to 20 million people, now is it?
In the meantime, they need to present valid ID and proof of citizenship or they don't vote. I'm willing to bring my social security card to prove I'm legal.
You gotta start somewhere. If we fine employers that employ illegals and the landlords that house them, we won't have to throw too many of them out. They'll leave.
The only reason they're here is to live off the taxpayers anyway. They don't give a rat's a$$ about America. We're just the cash cow.
Pardon me, but it p*sses me off that they are making a mockery of the laws of this country.
Sort by Trending