Discussion Locked

Should you have to be legal to vote?

0 helpful
224 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

224 replies

by jdclyde

I believe it currently is illegal to pay someone to vote, as it would be too easy for someone to buy an election.

Of course no one stops Dems from rounding people up and giving them smokes to vote for the second candidate..... (unless there is a butterfly ballot being used and you forget! :0 )

by jdclyde

First rfink.

There was never an intention to be locked into a two party system. The fewer the parties, the less options we have, and more chance of abuse. A two party system encourages people to vote for the lesser of two evils rather than vote for the best candidate. It also has the elected officials working to keep the party looking good, instead of doing what is the best thing for us. The party out of power does everything they can to obstruct progress, because the worse things are for the country, the better it is for the party out of power. The Dems are currently playing that part to the hilt, just as the Reps, did when they were in the minority.

Tony. If the cities had the power, they would just vote your food away. They do it now with money and the redistribution of wealth. "it isn't FAIR that they have all the food that they worked hard to grow......". The soldiers would march in and take it. The new tax.

Nick. [i] "He didn't receive a majority, he shouldn't be there! He wasn't really elected, he stole it, it was given to him, whatever excuse they can come up with."[/i] These people are too stupid and lazy for any intelligent person to care what they say. Give them their meds, lock the padded room, and be done with it. Oh yeah, slap them and tell them to shut up. problem solved.

by tonythetiger

Right! You can't even cash your welfare check without an ID. My objection isn't based on income, it's based on a right to be free of government intrusion if you're not doing anything wrong.

Asking for my ID every time I vote to see if I'm a legal citizen is [b]exactly[/b] the same thing as being pulled over every time I drive to see if I am a legal driver.

by nicknielsen

There is no right to operate a motor vehicle. When you are operating a vehicle, government is allowed to intrude in specific ways. In fact, you [b]agreed[/b] to allow this when you signed for your driver's license. If they want to check your license every time you drive, they may. You aren't required to like it, but you must allow them to do so.

As for voting, I see positive identification at the polling place as preventing my vote from being negated by somebody who is not entitled to vote.

Edit: clarify

by maxwell edison

Driving and voting are not the same, not even close.

Why don't you just admit that you're willing to let illegal voting occur unabated just so your rights are not infringed upon? Sure, Tony, you have a right to vote -- and maybe even without the "indignity" of being asked to provide proof that you are a legitimate voter. But you also have a responsibility to do what you can to make the system legitimate.

There's only one way to keep illegal people from voting, and that's to verify the legality of those doing the voting. You seem to scream an awful lot for all your rights, but you aren't willing to take a little responsibility to help protect the overall system. It's said that with rights comes responsibility. Are you not willing to take even one iota of responsibility for maintaining a legitimate system? And turning a blind-eye to voter fraud just to "protect your rights" is not taking responsibility.

You take your libertarian principles to a ridiculous extreme, at least you are in this case, and that's one reason why libertarians fail to make inroads into the political system. And we libertarians are in such a minority -- because of that ridiculous extreme -- that we, in essence, capitulate to the whim and will of others. We keep ourselves outside the arena, content to merely rest on our libertarian principles. As such, we let others trample all over them.

by delbertpgh

When you make a political movement based on a threatening problem, it becomes a hammer that can be used by all kinds of guys for lots of purposes. The fight against immigration is just one opportunity.

"Voter fraud" is just one kind of election fraud. The kind of election tricks that got Lyndon Johnson elected senator by 200 votes had little to do with fraudulently registered voters. It was a crooked count, managed by crooked election officials. That kind of stuff would not be protected against by strict voter identification laws. Tougher I.D. at registration and at the polling place would reduce the number of people who actually do vote, though, below our already low numbers.

So, before you give your support to this kind of thing, you might want to consider what hard evidence there is that election fraud is a big problem, and that this kind of restriction on voters is the solution. Is the fact that somebody was able to register with the name "Jive Turkey" proof that Jive Turkey, and a lot of others just like him, cast actual votes?

by av .

You didn't mention illegal aliens in your original post.

For myself, when I think voter fraud, I think of illegal aliens influencing our elections. 12 to 20 million people. Wow. I think I'm still in shock over how many illegals marched in our streets during the "day without immigrants" march in May and at their sense of entitlement. Seeing that made me realize the enormity of the problem.

Aside from dead people and illegal aliens, what do you see as other ways voters are defrauding the system? I'd say the fraud extends beyond just the voters.

I recently watched Hacking Democracy on HBO about how easy it is to alter the electronic voting machines. http://www.hbo.com/docs/programs/hackingdemocracy/index.html. Just the fact that some voting machines have no paper trail makes me ill.

It doesn't matter whether you're a Democrat or Republican or Libertarian. Our election system is terribly broken.

Personally, I'm for a strong ID system and paper audit trail. Not being able to verify votes is not acceptable. Not counting anyone's vote is unacceptable too.

I don't mind having to present documentation to be able to vote. I don't feel discriminated against either. If thats what we have to do to fix our broken system, its ok with me.

I don't see this as a partisan issue. Every party has something to lose in this situation. Americans need to take a good long look at what is happening in this country. Our Democracy is slipping away because of voter apathy.

by jdclyde

you see people that have a vested interest in keeping the system broken.

And thank you for taking the time to re-read my post and the intent of it. Illegals was and is not the main problem we face today. That will be soon, but it is just something to distract from the real corruption, and it saddens me that so many people follow it.

by delbertpgh

It doesn't make sense to blame illegal immigrants for vote fraud. Illegals are not likely to volunteer to show up before a government official and sign papers. That kind of thing gets them in jail and shipped back to Guatemala. Illegals hide from government.

by jdclyde

and because it benifits the people in power, they are unwilling to take away a large section of their own voting base.

by jdclyde

I agree that at this point, they are not the basis of the majority of voter fraud.

I completly disagree with the rest of your statement. Illegals are in our schools, on the welfare, as well as filling the hospitals. The majority have been part of the great "catch and release" game.

Not sure if you noticed, but there was a little national day not long ago where illegals too to the streets. Nothing was done to them and they were far from hiding. It was an "in your face" deal. Where was the INS then? It has actually been the government hiding from the illegals because nutcases in our country might accuse the officials of being racist if they were to uniformly enforce our laws for a change.

by tonythetiger

but they commit fraud in many other ways. The most significant in my opinion is the medical care arena.... they go to ERs, get treated, and don't pay.... guess who does?

Off topic, but maybe we should determine their couintry of origin and send the bill to their government.

by delbertpgh

I don't see the need to get excited by the illegal problem. They come, they work like hell, they do stuff ordinary people do. They pay FICA and Medicare taxes, but cannot collect Social Security. I don't know about the cost of benefits we provide them, but it's partly or entirely balanced out by the benefits they are afraid to collect. Most of them are poor. They are trying for a good life.

The biggest thing is, they are unstoppable. We have about 2000 miles of border with Mexico and 3000 with Canada. Every expensive defense we can create against the flow, they will find a cheap countermeasure. They're desperate, and if crossing a line in the sand is the difference between dirty water, corrupt cops, and $5 a day and a clean life making $50 a day, they'll come. If they can't come across the Mexican border, they can go to Canada and cross there. But it will always be cheaper to cross from Mexico, no matter how many billion dollars we put into it.

I grew up in Northwest Colorado. A quarter of the town was Mexican. 25% of the kids in school had names like Ramirez and Gallegos. Working class families. They were okay. Probably almost all were legal, but I'm sure some weren't. Didn't bother me then, doesn't now.

by jdclyde

who will make that decision then on which laws have to be respected and enforced, and which ones we can ignore because it is inconvenent or unpopular?

Unstoppable? That is just stupid. We are one of the few country that does NOT protect our borders. Even Mexico has a harder stance on illegal aliens then we do.

Drones and electronics can monitor, and gunships patroling would take your "unstoppable" problem and stop it in it's tracks.

People being to stupid and lazy to do something about a problem is not the same as not being ABLE to do anything about it.

And if case you haven't been paying attention (clearly), in the Senate they WANT to give citizenship to these criminals, so they CAN collect SS and other benifits.

by delbertpgh

Fancy technology (and the manpower to react to it) will only stop people who don't subvert it. Take a lesson from the war on drugs. Once you have a billion dollar system in place to catch smugglers, they come up with a hundred dollar workaround.

The border with Mexico is protected in a lot of places. Where there's a fence, they go over it, around it, or tunnel under. Some parts of it are protected only by impassible 120-degree desert, that's true. Plenty of people figure out how to walk over that desert, too, risking death. Keep in mind that your trouble rises in proportion to their determination, and people ready to risk death are as determined as they come.

Gunships patrolling? To machine-gun refugees from poverty in the open desert? That's not a solution for my America. Don't know about yours.

As far as citizenship goes, if they get here and don't get thrown back, and work for years and don't break the law, then why not? They have to get their green cards first and wait seven more years before they can take the test. This is a nation of immigrants. I'm happy to have more in the family. I'd be generous with amnesty.

by jdclyde

just in the opposite direction.

No gunships, but the reason the "war on drugs" is such a failure is we do not have closed borders. When you don't watch the borders, all kinds of crap comes right on in. (crap = drugs, not people)

I do not agree with allowing anyone from anywhere to sneak in here. There are many that just want to improve their lives, but that is only because their own corrupt government used dumping the workforce into Amercia to keep the money flowing. Allowing criminals to do as they please just sets the next law up to be ignored by people that don't agree with it either.

And yes, every single illegal immigrant is a criminal, and had they broken that same law in their own craphole country they are trying to escape from, they would be thrown in a cell for years. They have done NOTHING to earn their keep, in supporting the expenses of the country they are taking advantage of. They are NOT contributing to anything but themselves and then pumping the majority of what they earn out of the country. By not even spending that money HERE, they weaken us and our economy.

Amnesty should NEVER happen in our lifetime.

We SHOULD have a more streamlined method of becoming a legal citizen, but it can not start out by being a criminal. If someone is applying for citizenship and breaks a law, they are revoked and thrown out because criminals are NOT a benifit to this country.

So, as every law indicates, and all logic supports old fellow, erasing the borders is bad for the country. Heck, not even CANADA lets just anyone come in and stay there.

by danlm

[i]As far as citizenship goes, if they get here and don't get thrown back, and work for years and don't break the law, then why not? They have to get their green cards first and wait seven more years before they can take the test.[/i]

If they are WILLING to go this route. In other words, the same route that other immigrants have gone. Green card, take the test(learn English) and pass. Then I agree.

But if these immigrants feel they shouldn't have to because they are already here. I agree with JD. Ship them back to Mexico, and I don't care how it's accomplished. I feel the hispanic immigrants feel they are better then other immigrants that have come to this country. And they don't think they should have to do the same things. They claim discrimination. Which is just BS. They are being lazy and asking for a free ride. Send them home.

I acquire this attitude from the Hispanic writer on MSNBC. He is so arrogant with regard to people that think the hispanic immigrants should abide by the same rules as other nationalities that became citizens. He claims discrimination and bigotry. Want an a$$hole. Guy doesn't have the balls to post his email or ask for blog response's. He knows he couldn't stand the same heat that he dish's out.

Dan

by tonythetiger

I don't think highways should have speed limits. If I go seven years without getting caught speeding, do I get a lifetime pass?

Likewise I don't agree with the voter ID law, but I'm not going to break it because I disagree.

I don't have a problem with immigration either, but there are laws attached. If you don't agree with the law, I would suggest that you lobby your congressman to repeal all immigration laws and gut the immigration department (Think of the billions in tax dollars we'd save), but until those laws are repealed, they must be enforced as strongly as is necessary.

by delbertpgh

You can't beat all illegal immigration. You can pour money and people into policing the border and the people, many times more than we do already, and I have no confidence that the problem will be licked. You can be like Ahab, chasing the great whale to your doom, but forces of nature will prevail over literal-minded legality, or inflexible principles. The want of people for a decent life is as powerful as a force of nature.

(How about that? You probably thought that reading Moby Dick was a waste of your high school junior year. Now, you can argue useful metaphors based on American literature. How cool is that?)

We need immigrants' cheap labor and work ethic in this country, and without it we couldn't compete with countries like Chile for fruit and vegetables. We couldn't package chicken legs so cheap; household budgets would feel the change without it. Cheap discount stores would have to pay a lot more to sweep their floors. We pull these people in like a magnet. They're willing to work their butts off, and they do a good job for cheap money. They make a difference to our economy. Legalizing some of the people who do this is not going to hurt us economically. Actually getting rid of them would.

After you make a decent effort to keep the illegals out, and you have them anyway, and you get years of work and taxes out of them, then make 'em legal. Not the lawbreakers, not people who are going to flop out on welfare, but workers and their families. It's compassionate. It's pragmatic. Having government that honors practicality and humanity is okay with me.

by delbertpgh

Being pragmatic and a little generous is extremist behavior? Good grief, Hannity and those other clowns have really got you dittoheads cross wired. Step back from the edge, and take a breath.

by jdclyde

And every illegal alien in this country is a "lawbreaker". That is why they are called "[b]illegal[/b] aliens".

Giving all of these "lawbreakers" a free pass will NOT continue to give the cheap labor that you mentioned. As soon as they are legal, they no longer HAVE to take the field jobs for the low wages. They could take any middle-class unskilled labor job they wanted to. There goes what is left of the middle class.

You are being overly generous with something that is not yours to give away, and this total disregard for this law is extreme.

All of your "cheap labor" benifits you claim we need will all be gone.

Ethics, do we really want people here where the first thing they do is break the law? (being here without going through the proper process is illegal)

A decent effort to keep them out has NEVER been done in the history of the US, and it is about time that we did.

You are not looking at the big picture, and basing your arguement on emotion instead of logic.

This discussion is closed to new replies.