.
Of course not; I'm not afraid of discourse at all. But I want honest, open and FULL discourse, something I actually believe others are afraid of.
For example (not to go off on another unrelated tangent), I believe it is extremely evasive to talk about funding ANY government transfer of wealth social programs without first setting the premise that it's tantamount to taking the personal property of the citizen who earned it, for the sole purpose of giving it to another who did not. Let's talk about what it is we're really doing here before we start arguing about the particular merits of the program. (By the way, I've never seen anyone in these threads concede that it's proper for a government, especially the US government, to take the personal property of the citizen who earned it, for the sole purpose of giving it to another who did not.)
And all this SUV nonsense is the same thing. Before you can suggest that a person doesn't "need" one, or need anything else, for that matter, you have to first establish the authority to make such a determination.
As far as your whole argument on SUVs costing other people money, well, you said it yourself. You said, "It would be very difficult to find facts to support (your) presumptions." But then you go ahead and base your entire argument on those presumptions, not facts, and they simply won't hold up under even the slightest bit of scrutiny.
Here's a real fact for you. Compared to the rate of inflation, and to almost all other consumer goods (excluding technology-type goods), gasoline is cheaper today than it was in 1975 -- at the height of the gasoline shortage. (Remember those long lines and gasoline rationing by most stations?) The increased cost of gasoline has simply not kept pace with inflation. In fact, the cost of a gallon of milk has increased more than the cost of a gallon of gasoline. (And let's not even talk about the cost of a gallon of bottled water!) And if we could make a wager on these threads, I'd bet $1,000 that I could easily prove it.
Here's another fact. The primary reasons for increased demand on the world-wide supply of crude oil are twofold, neither one being SUVs. One is tied to political strife around the globe, including in the Middle East, Africa and South America, and current production is being disrupted and/or future production targets are becoming threatened. And the second is China's increased demand for crude. It's absolutely incredible the way China has increased its demand for oil. In fact, a few short decades ago, China was not a major oil consumer at all. Now they're number two behind the USA -- and at their current rate of increased demand, they will soon be number one.
On higher insurance costs, your health comments, and congestion assertions? Well, again we are going to have to look at the premise of your arguments and make sure we discuss "only the facts", not presumptions. For example, the premise of no-fault insurance is flawed. In fact, the whole insurance industry is flawed. But lets save those things for another day.
And on your public school comments, let's save those, as well, for another discussion. I'm sure we could go on and on about that. Besides, most public (and private) school teachers and administrators are among, what I could easily call, the NPR crowd - a crowd you rub philosophical elbows with quite frequently. (On a side note, my son's civics teacher, actually used the words freedom FROM religion when discussing the first amendment to the constitution. There's simply no escaping it - the NPR crowd, I mean.)
By the way, and for the record, I am certainly on the "alternative fuel" bandwagon. But I don't need false presumptions and scare tactics to support my position. I want to reduce the US trade deficit. I want to reduce, or eliminate, our dependence on foreign oil. I want to become an energy independent nation. And I simply want to tell the middle east thugs to take their oil and shove it up their tail-pipe. But I don't need to demonize SUV owners to do it.