Discussion Locked

Survey: Are Big Trucks and SUVs really necessary?

0 helpful
324 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

For an English Project, I have to do a survey, gathering YES / NO information from at least 100 people.

This is my question:

"Do you think that oversize cars, vans, SUVs and trucks for personal are necessary?"

Please answer only with YES or NO. Long explanations really don't help me!

Thank you for helping me with this!

324 replies

by deadly ernest

Most sedans and similar style cars are now designed for young trendies and are so low to the ground it is actually damaging to the back to get in and out. Only the SUVs and trucks are at the correct ergonomic height for safe entry and exit. Thus bad design of other models make them needed.

by deadly ernest

If I can not buy a ergonomically sound sedan because the designers are making them to suit the wishes of idiotic wankers then you have to put up with people choosing to drive SUVs and light trucks instead of getting into badly designed cars. If the SUVs and light trucks were not available you would see an increase in the number of mini-buses and medium trucks as I would rather dribe them than gave to drive in an unsafe manner because the car was badly designed - which applies to the majority of sedans today.

by hockeyist

...my pants getting up into one so they are not ergonomically designed for my fashion type, also, I tore my shirt once when I got out of one.

by deadly ernest

I could see that happening if you are a midget, then it wouild make sense for you to buy a normal sedan. More likely you were getting in and out of one of those units where they set the suspension at a ridiculous height and expect you to use the step (like a running board) to get in and out.

I can sympathise with your problem either way.

by amcol

Many arguments both for and against, but at the end of the day I'd say yes.

by jamesrl

I know many tradespeople for whom a big pickup or fullsize work van is necessary. I know people who tow trailers, for whom a big truck or SUV is a reasonable choice - but towing travel trailers for most people is a choice not a necessity.

I do think there are a lot of trucks and SUVs on the highway that carry one person and perhaps a briefcase back and forth to the office. Many never tow anything, or ever get taken off road or used anywhere near their potential. For those people its a luxury, not a necessity.

I drive a large car, instead of a mini van or SUV, despite the fact I have 3 kids. Its in convenient sometimes but we get by. In my parents day, with 5 kids, they only drove full size cars.

So the answer to your question depends on who you are asking about - necessary for myself, no. Necessary for some people, yes. Necessary for all the people who drive them? No.

James

by tonythetiger

If you can't buy the things you want, you might as well get a $7.00 per hour job and save yourself the stress.

by jamesrl

It was an episode of Marketplace, a Canadian consumer affairs show, and it focused on buying used cars. It had two experts, one a used car salesman, the other a automotive consumers rights advocate, work with one couple and a single person to help them learn the ins and outs.

The couple, in their late 30s or early 40s, have lived in Toronto all their lives and never owned a car. They don't need or want to drive to work, the live and work close to good transit. They only intend to use the car on weekends.

For them, owning a car is not a necessity. For them, I would strongly suggest they do a cost comparison with renting a car. In a city like Toronto, the payments on a 10,000 used car(what they were looking for) and the insurance(Toronto is very expensive place for insurance) will easily run over 400$ Canadian. You can rent a brand new Corolla for $35 a day.

If you need a car to get groceries once a week - use cabs.

I drive 40 kms each way to work every day, and it does work out to be slightly cheaper than using transit - I live in the suburbs where housing costs are cheaper. But when I lived in Toronto I didn't own a car until I got a job in the burbs.

James

by jdclyde

1) live in Michigan and good for the economy to pay us to build them.

2) try pulling your boat or camper with your hybrid car.

3) ever try having sex in the back of a hybrid?

4) families traveling. The closer the kids are the more they pick at each other.

5) need to have room for the dog. Ever take a Black Lab in your hybrid car with your family to go camping?

by jamesrl

On a working farm, trucks are needed. Can't say the same for an SUV.

I've spent time in rural areas in Quebec, Ontario, Manitoba and Alberta. I swear I see more trucks per capita in the city. And SUVs are more common in the city for sure.

Most people in the country don't have 4 wheel drive, but they manage in the snow without a massive SUV.

James

by jdclyde

It is becoming more of a status symbol than a necessity.

If you look at the average "suv", they aren't. They don't have the power or clearance to do anything but suck down more gas than the two wheel drive version.

There are places where you NEED 4 wheel drive in Michigan. Snowmobiles are NOT optional either.

I always laugh to see the Hummer2's and Cadillac SUV's on the highway and city. People with LOTS of disposable income.

by sleepin'dawg

Pick-ups for work related stuff are okay. SUV's are also good for moving people around in rough country but to use them just for hauling your butt to the office, get a motorcycle. They get through traffic faster, pollute less and are more economical, although they are a bitch to ride in winter.

Dawg

by dr dij

SUV's are safer than smaller cars, also since I live only a very short distance from the office I don't feel too bad about driving a big car there. I'll bike in sometimes too.

I need a big car for off work tasks like hauling displays to talks. I keep my gardening gear in it and it is a great place to relax at lunch time. No my company does not provide a lounge where you could crash out, only a lunchroom.

I don't bitch about high gas prices, as the other people pointed out, they are 3x as hi in Europe. And will only go higher. $6/gal in US soon. It is inevitable, as 1 billion Indians and 1 billion Chinese all want to use lots of energy and cars. The Chinese are investing heavily in Canada's tar sands. Most major oil supplier countries lie about reserves as their share to pump out of ground and sell is based on reserve sizes they declare.

I make other lifestyle choices to reduce my pollution. I agree we need to find alternate energy sources for them.

And face it, how many guys drive those big huge gas guzzling pickups because they are cool? They would feel inadequate if they showed up in a shoebox 3 cylinder fiesta or something. They are great for weekend use for hauling recreation gear.

I think those hybrid cars are neat but they cost more, and are too small for me.

I've now found that the Los Angeles area trains are really great. On weekends we drive to Long Beach and take the train from there all over LA to see the sights, alot cheaper, safer and less energy than driving there ourselves.

What we need to do in US is more mass transit other than buses. It is more expensive but consumers like it and use it alot more than busses.

by jessie

Considering I'm pregnant with my husband's and my 5th child, 7 seats are very necessary.

Trucks are awfully handy when you're moving a friend's furniture.

SUV's are good for pulling stuff... but too many people who don't have anything to pull, and don't need 4 wheel drive, have them just as a status symbol.

by jamesrl

Minivans are much more fuel efficient and can handle 7 passengers.

Trucks can be rented. I see a lot of trucks running around with one passenger and no cargo. Thats a waste. When I renovated my bathroom, I rented a full size cargo van for $20 for 90 minutes. I've always rented for moves.

James

by jessie

My family getting an SUV is akin to cruelty to animals as far as I'm concerned... I always feel so bad for those SUVs that are designed to handle so much MORE than hauling the kids to soccer practice... I keep thinking, "Come on, at least take it up on the sidewalk! It NEEDS to go offroad!"

It'd be a minivan for us... the status symbol of the 80's... maybe we're just behind the times.

by sleepin'dawg

How long will it be before the "status" starts to lose its charm and becomes a symbol for stupidity.

Dawg

by Member 25348569

Gas over here is ?0.82/litre or $5.55/Gallon (both US) and it is NEVER going to go down.

The number of people driving 4WD (SUVs) or other huge "people-carriers" is still increasing.

And that's on UK roads!

We haven't got many pick-up trucks on our roads yet but I'm beginning to notice a few.

Brrrrrr!

Neil

:(

by aldanatech

If your only choices are yes or no then I would say no. Many of us often drive by ourselves or with few passengers and maybe a briefcase or some grocery bags. Unless you absolutely must tow something or carry a lot of material of any sort, there is really no reason to drive big trucks or SUVs.

by thechas

No, large SUV's and trucks are not "necessary"

The choice of driving a SUV or large pickup is a personal choice. Less than 5% of the people who own these vehicles "need" them.

Even among those who have a reason for a SUV or full size pickup for towing or hauling, they make use of the heavy duty features so seldom that it would make more sense to rent a large vehicle when they need it.

Chas

by maxwell edison

.
When you said, "Less than 5% of the people who own these vehicles need them", will you please explain either how you arrived at that specific conclusion and what particular statistics you used, or what source you used to cite it?

Moreover, will you please define "need"?

by thechas

Max,

My 5% figure is derived from my observations of commuters around the area where I live and work.

Who "needs" a pickup truck:

Construction workers who need to haul tools and materials.

Farmers who needs to haul supplies and equipment.

A home-owner who is actively remodeling or building their home.

My point is that if you use a pickup to haul materials of pull a trailer less than once a month, you don't "need" a truck.
You would be better off financially having a "reasonable" sized vehicle and renting a truck when needed.

Any SUV is even harder to "justify" an actual "need" for.
A SUV is nothing more than a mini-van on steroids.

Even for those who own a SUV so they can tow the boat on vacation, if they tow the boat less than once a month, they would be better off renting a SUV for vacations.

My point is that for the VAST majority of people who own either a pickup or SUV, the choice was based on desire not need.

The US is past due for a cultural shift where large vehicles and high powered engines are frowned upon by society rather than worshiped.

Chas

As to those who choose a SUV to haul people or computers, a mini-van can haul as many people and as much computer equipment as all but the largest SUV.

A SUV is a personal life-style choice not a needed item.

Chas

by maxwell edison

.
Almost 1,000 people are killed annually while riding a bicycle. And how many children are left without a parent because one of them was killed while riding a bicycle? That child will obviously become a burden to society simply because his parent wanted to go joy-riding. And more than a half a million people are treated in hospital emergency rooms every year because of bicycle related accidents. How many real diseases and illnesses go untreated because of this unnecessary strain put on our health care system? How many people DIE every year because of the strain those greedy bicyclists put on our health care system? It's an absolute travesty, if you ask me.

Moreover, the bicycle deaths cited don't include the bicycle caused deaths. How many people die, for example, in head-on automobile collisions caused because a motorist had to swerve to avoid hitting a road-hog bicyclist? It's hard to know for sure because the perpetrator of the crime can easily 10-speed away while others lay in the road bleeding and perhaps even near death.

And hey, those bicycles don't pay license registration fees or consume fuel from which road taxes are generated, so they don't pay for the very roads they hog, the very roads on which they cause thousands of deaths each and every year.

And then consider this. How many natural resources are wasted because of the manufacture of bicycles? If it's any at all, it's too many. After all, this is the fragile Earth we're talking about here. We can't be too careful. And the pollution - and the contribution to GLOBAL WARMING - that it causes. The plastics and burning and all that yucky stuff polluting the air and water in the manufacturing process while making those millions and millions of unnecessary bicycles. And then they buy new ones, often times throwing the old ones in the trash, only to go into a landfill. We're running out of landfill space, for crying out loud! And those old bicycles are only making it worse.

Besides, nobody "NEEDS" a bicycle -- not even 5 percent of those who have them really "NEED" them. You have your own two feet you can use to get around. And if you like the feel of the wind blowing in your face, get a fan.

Therefore, since they are not a real necessity, and since banning them would obviously save lives and save the Earth, and since it would also save health care money that is needed to treat others with REAL needs, and since it would be good for the environment, they should be banned - BANNED, I say.

And even if it would save only ONE LIFE, it's well worth it.

by thechas

Every able bodied person "needs" a bicycle.

No one truly "needs" a car, truck or SUV.

People feel the need for a car because US society is designed around motor vehicles.

Even in the frozen hinterlands of Michigan it is possible to get everywhere one needs to on a bicycle year round.

You can't get everywhere you need by just walking or public transportation.

As to your example, I am one of those "road hogging bicyclists".

It is NOT the cyclists fault that the motorist is unwilling to slow down and wait until it is safe to pass.

In fact, it is the cyclists duty to move toward the center of the lane if there is not a safe margin for a motorist to pass.

I don't remember the authors name, but the book Effective Cycling explains why "taking the lane" and other tactics are safer than staying at the edge of a narrow road.

Interestingly, it is my experience that the drivers of small cars are more accommodating to cyclists than the drivers of full size vans, SUVs, and pickups.

Chas

by thechas

Max,

Thinking about this further, the issue is more of need versus desire.

For "personal use" hardly anyone "needs" a large vehicle. Many people desire a large vehicle to show off just how far in dept they are willing to go to satisfy their ego.

Americans for years have been confusing need and desire. Just as Madison Avenue wants them to.

If you make actual use of the capabilities of a large vehicle at least once a month, then you likely have a need for one. However, if you seldom make use of the vehicles capabilities, your choice to own the vehicle switches from need to desire.

I myself DESIRE to drive an econobox. I end up in a mid-size sedan because the econoboxes I have looked at do not accommodate my height.

Perhaps the right answer is for people to own multiple vehicles. With the ever rising TCO for large vehicles, it makes sense to park the SUV or truck in the garage except for when you need it, and have a small car for daily use.

Think of how much switching the paradigm from having 1 vehicle to 2 or 3 "specialized" vehicles would boost the US economy.

Chas

by thechas

Max, I do get your point about making choices for others. I did not call for a ban on SUVs or a needs test before allowing people to buy them. I just stated what I believe to be true that they are NOT necessary.

I do think that your example is less than I would normally expect from you.

Look at the need versus desire issue this way;

I desire a $2000 titanium or carbon fiber road bike. I don't need it, and doubt I will ever buy one.

The used bikes I do own fulfill my needs.

Very few people have a "need" for their large SUV and pickups. They have given in to the desire to fit in with a social group or "macho" image. Their "need" was created by the automotive and advertising industries.

Even back to my first car, while my friends where tuning their cars for performance, I was tuning mine for maximum gas mileage.

When I chose a vehicle, fuel economy is much more important than style or brand.

Chas

by tonythetiger

Thank God I am not a communist, where all I could have was what somebody else thought was necessary.

by thechas

Did you read all of my comments in the sub-thread?

While I personally think the SUV is the latest scourge on mankind, nowhere in the thread do I call for a ban or for preventing those who want them from owning them.

Do I want people to change their vehicle buying habits? Yes indeed.

I want the person who just thinks they need / want a SUV to take a moment and think about ALL of the impact that their decision has on both their life and the lives of those around them.

I believe this is such a hot button issue because the majority of SUV owners do respect the environment and have a guilty conscience because of the negative impact their choice has on the environment.

Does anyone who wants a SUV have the right to buy one? Sure.

Do I have the right to question that persons judgment? Sure again.

Do I have the right to stop anyone from buying a SUV? NO!

Do I have the right to work toward a change in the social conscience so that people stop thinking a SUV is a good transportation alternative?
Yes!

In response to the simple question are SUVs and large pickup trucks necessary for personal use?
My OPINION is still NO!

Should we ban the SUV or limit sales to only those who have a proven need?
NO!

Finally, I am not a communist.

At the moment, I consider myself to be a recovering Republican.

Chas

by liame

Yes they are necessary but a more telling question would be something along the lines of "Is the use of environmentally devastating fashion accessories acceptable in the modern world?"

Many people need SUV's, vans, pickups etc because of the job they do, where they live or their lifestyle etc.

Some people just think its cool to drive something big.

And the rest are just too fat to get in anything smaller I guess.

by jamesrl

I used to have staff in Northern Ontario, in an area quite similar to Northern Michigan. Extended periods of time at close to 40 below, times when the plows were infrequent even on the main roads etc.

I didn't see that many 4x4s. I did see a lot of snow tires. 4x4 aids traction - but in many cases, so does slowing down. Snow tires provide a big improvement, and so does front wheel drive, over a rear wheel drive car with all seasons. Traction control also provides some assistance, especially at stop lights.

There may be a few souls in the north who have to be somewhere regardless of the weather, and there are times when they need a 4x4. But most of the people up there manage without it.

The big joke is that when we do get a big snow storm in Toronto and area, the first vehicles that we see stuck in the ditch are SUVs. They may have more traction, but they don't handle as well and they take longer to stop. In an emergency situation that may be the difference between being in an accident, and avoiding one.

James

by jdclyde

When you get some dumbass thinking because they have 4 wheel drive that they can drive like normal in a storm you get that. And yes, I see the same thing.

FACT, one of the HIGHEST domographs for getting into accedents these days in the middle to upper class WOMAN in her SUV. As these women have busy lives and get they easy life (sarcastic) of playing house keeper, day care provider and full time driver they tend to be in more of a rush.

Then don't even get me started about doing your make-up on the highway!

by tomsal

I believe it was a survive in Motor Trend Magazine about a year ago, that revealed that of all the SUVs bought in the USA less than 8% of them ever leave paved roadways.

Yet we see all these huge 4x4's selling like "hot cakes" (though that in itself is another discussion -- do hot cakes really sell that well?).

I think if you have a huge family or you need to tow or truly go off-road frequently, then you have a legitimate need (that would be a "YES").

Anything other than those reasons its just ego and status symbolitis that folks buy them (that would be a "NO").

PS. How can you possibly think you won't get any commentary on a DISCUSSION forum? LOL

by dr dij

I think there's no alternative to letting people vote with their wallet. Large cars are safer, roomier, more comfortable. If we banned large SUVs they'd switch to large cars of other kinds.

Let supply and demand dictate their choices. In a few years gas will be sky high and many will get smaller cars. smaller cars are already cheaper and cost less to run. so many people drive them.

by deadly ernest

First of all the phrase selling like hot cakes is very old and comes from the situation of food vendors in old time market places - the hot cakes refered to were thick pancake type foods (like what the USA people call hot cakes but thicker)and we sold VERY hot, straight from the cooking surface. Just scooped up and handed over. As they were so hot the vendors would take your money, scoop up a hot cake, flip it into their other hand and hand it to you so fast it seems like teleportation - the hand off was extremely fast (remember no paper plates etc in those days, hand food was carried in the hand. Because of the speed anything sold with a fast hand over was - selling like hot cakes.

OK - generally I agree with your comments re SUVs, I absolutely hat 4WDs - even when going off road (a high clearance 2WD can do most offroad if well driven). However, when buying my latest car I ended up having to buy a 4WD SUV as it was the cheapest thing that I could buy in which I could sit and drive in a proper position and enter and exist without problems, or a crane. Please see other post for full details.

Whilst the car makers design sedans that are not ergonomicaly safe people will buy the other styles that are. Just compare a modern sedan with one from 35 years ago, look at the differences in ground clearance and internal headroom when sitting upright.

by maxwell edison

.
....on which to tread when people presume to define what may or may not be "necessary" for someone else, especially personal property.

But keeping in the spirit of your English project, I would have to answer yes. After all, if a person didn't consider it "necessary", he or she wouldn't have acquired it in the first place. And who am I do define what his or her "necessities" should be?

P.S. I answered this question before looking at any of the other answers. I shudder at the thought that some people may have presumed to define what may or may not be "necessary" for someone else. To that person, I would ask, why stop at SUVs? Why not also be presumptuous enough to define someone else's "necessary" housing, or diet, or leisure habits, or perhaps even how much money is "necessary" for someone else. (Man, you people scare me. Because you're the epitome of what it means to trample upon other people's individual rights -- and you have absolutely no justification except your elitist attitude that presumes to know what's best for others.)

by liame

I agree with your answer but have to disagree with your reasoning there Maxwell. Shall we examine where this 'elitist attitude' comes from that presumes to know the best for others.

Take housing for example, no one tells you what house to live in or where but ALL houses have to be built to certain standards which include efficiency of insulation in every developed nation in the world.

Take leisure activities, no one tells you how to enjoy yourself but if you choose to shoot children for fun the law will come down on you pretty hard.

How about your diet? Well you can eat what you like, but if you choose to eat endangered animals you can expect a visit from the boys in blue.

The same is true for just about everything in society - reasonable limits are imposed for the benefit of society as a whole.

Some limits have to be put on the consumption and activities of the individual to protect the rights of the population as a whole. These arent an individuals rights being trampled, this is everyone's rights being protected. The rights of the population of the world or a country take precedence of the rights of an individual and so they should.

The problem seems to stem from the people (largely in the USA but increasingly elsewhere) that seem to still have their heads in the sand with regards to the environment and truly believe that their right to drive a big car supercedes everyone elses right to live in a world free from the dangers of rampant global warming and respiratory illness due to emissions.

People driving big cars simply dont acknowlege the damage they are doing to the world, its time they wake up to it and start to do something about it. Its not such an easy area to legislate for as, say, shooting children or building regs for new homes as some people genuinly need big vehicles so just tax the snot out of em. That will sort out the 'needs' from the 'wants' soon enough.

Big cars are a habit for most, not a necessity. Habits can be broken and this one needs to be for the good of mankind. How many of those 400 cubic inches do you really need to get the groceries home? To me its a question of the right tool for the job.

Frankly, if an SUV is the answer, you were asking some pretty silly questions.

by Member 25348569

I'm not trying to kick of an argument. These are my views from a UK perspective. We have gas at $5.55/gallon, narrower roads, many more autos/mile of road, no snow (mostly) and very little potential off-road driving. Yet we still have SUVs and the number is growing. We have no anti-SUV legislation or taxes (other than gas) but there are the first signs that these might come in and I don't think they would be unpopular. They would fine with me when I'm trying to drive around a Range Rover stopped at the school gates while mother unloads little Tamsin!

Sorry about this but it's Friday and I'm bored.

I'd be interested in the answers from the perspectives of a US citizen and a libertarian and if you see any conflict.

Is there any point at which you believe that the state should interfere? And to what level?

For instance, it's obviously beneficial for the US's trade deficit (I won't mention the environment for fear of being bitten) if you import and use less oil. If you can do so without decreasing the miles driven by your citizens and - in most cases - without restricting them in any tangible way other than denting their fragile egos, should you? Should your government campaign for smaller-engined cars? Legislate in favour of smaller cars? Sh:t. Get outta your face?

The wearing of seat belts is compulsory both front and back seat over here. It demonstrably saves lives and reduces injuries. Should it be compulsory?

Drink driving?

I can work out where I, personally, draw the line on the nanny state. Can you see ANY place for it?

Neil

by maxwell edison

.
You asked, "Is there any point at which you believe that the state should interfere? And to what level? "

Yes, there is indeed a point at which the state should interfere (in one's life), and I can break it down into three basic reasons:

1. When the freedoms enjoyed by one person actually infringes on the rights of another, it's up to the state to protect the rights of that other.

2. For the purpose of national security.

3. For the "common good".

Disclaimer: I absolutely hate it when people can rely ONLY on "for the common good", or "for the good of mankind" argument as sole support for a particular position. It's very subjective, at best; and almost by default and definition, it will ultimately lead to irreconcilable differences. Moreover, this could really be a catch-all for just about anything. Therefore, I approach this with extreme caution. When the "common good" violates the freedoms and liberties of the individual, especially large numbers of individuals, red flags should start popping up all over the place. In such cases, generally speaking, I would favor erring on the side of the individual, while other, more collectivist-type thinkers, would err on the side of the common good.

If you can understand how I approach those three "reasons" for government intervention in individual lives, you could probably predict my position, quite accurately, on just about any issue. I've continually challenged people to state some similar core beliefs as support for their positions, but very few even attempt it. My hot-button issues would be when someone espouses a law, a program, or whatever, that actually takes away an individual's liberty. For example, I think it's absolutely abhorrent for a government to take the personal property away from one citizen (personal property equals money), the citizen who owns it and/or has earned it, for the sole purpose of giving that property to another citizen who did not earn it. After all, money is no more than the means with which to value goods and services, and by taking a person's money, the government is actually taking goods and services from that person -- and today, it's almost to a point that it might even resemble indentured servitude. It doesn't matter how noble the intention; it's just not right as far as I'm concerned. Our very own Social Security program is a perfect example of how a government supports a program in the name of a "common good", but then must infringe on the rights of the individual in order to advance it.

Your specific examples:

Drinking and driving is an example when a person might take his rights too far (his right to drink) by infringing on the freedoms and rights of others -- perhaps even killing others. And where a person drinking and driving might result in the death of another, I can't think of one single way that forcing a person to wear a seat belt could save the life of another person. Drinking and driving can kill other people; not wearing a seat belt can only kill yourself. Having laws to prevent the former is acceptable; having laws to enforce the latter is not.

On the nanny state question - never. A "nanny" takes care of those who can't take care of themselves -- i.e. children. There is no place in government for "nannyism", at least no place in the U.S. government. And consider this. Whereas other nations' governments were actually created to care for and ensure their "common good", the U.S. government was actually created to guarantee and protect individual liberty. The whole premise of our government is different than most, and unfortunately, all too many people are unwilling or unable to see it or accept it -- even too many Americans don't understand it.

(I'll get to your trade deficit/SUV points when time allows.)

by jck

asdfoui (i think) said "for personal" reasons.

If it harms your back, sue the car company. Products which can be proven to cause bodily harm to consumers are usually recalled for modification or replacement.

If you're American, take a look at somewhere like Ireland. I was there for 10 days last year. No one drives a personal car that's large that I saw...in Tipperary...or Dublin. The only large vehicles I saw are transportation or commercial. I'm sure there are exceptions, but it is FAR less common than in the USA.

I'm 6'6, 325 and drive a Kia. Size won't be an excuse either kids, unless it's a case of *extreme* size. They make cars for big people too.

Stop being indulgent, sell that tank you drive, and get a smaller more economical car...then, buy more beer and computer stuff with the money you save on gas :)

by deadly ernest

When I bought my current car (abt 18 mths back) I went for a test drive in several vehicles. I found that most sedans were such that when getting out my knees were higher than my arse, this is ergonomicly unsound. Also at the Holden dealership the salesperson drove the sedan around, all 6' 2" (188 cm)of him in an almost recumbant position. When I sat in the driver's seat and put the back upright, I had to slide it all the way back, put the whell at its highest setting and was only just able to get in the safe driver recommended position of upright, elbows and knees at right angles - mind you my head was rubbing against the roof of the car and I am only 5' 9" (175 cm. When I pointed this out to the salesman he explained that since most people today drive almost laying on their back that the designers build them that way.

Real safe to drive - on your back, neck bent forward at an odd angle and arms at almost fullstretch. No wonder the local police have switched to mostly dualcab ute and light commercial designs with hotted up engines. Easier and safer to sit in.

SUVs and light commercials are a cheaper and better option than delivery vans and the like.

by jck

Well as I said before, I'm about 6'6. I drive a 2000 Kia Sportage 4-door mini SUV. It gets about 21-24 mpg depending on what way the wind is coming from, and I have no problems getting into it and I sit in the position you've explained as being what I should be. My head is near the roof of the cab and the seat is all the way back, but I have plenty of room in that position.

I think the key words in the original post involved "oversize" and "personal use". I would think this would apply to vehicles such as Hummer, Cadillac Escalade, Lincoln Navigator, Chevy Suburbans, etc. None of them are *necessary* for personal use. You can get vehicles in any modernized country on the planet which is elevated enough for you to enter and exit comfortably, have sufficient leg room, and allows for proper posture. It might not be what you want to see in your driveway, but they can be purchased. My Kia is proof. I wanted a different vehicle, but this one was more economically feasible and met my *needs*. I would have much preferred the BMW or Mitsubishi I looked at.

But, back to the original thread topic: Oversized vehicles are not necessary for personal use. Vehicles of smaller proportion are manufactured that meet 99.9% of the dimensional and ergonomic needs of people (sans people like Shaq and pro wrestlers). The oversize vehicles are simply a creature comfort, much as luxury vehicles are. The function of a vehicle is to safely transport passengers from an origin to a destination. Anything above that is not necessity...it's indulgence.

As for what police drive...that can be indulgence as well. Most of them have Crown Victorias or Caprices...but, a sheriff's department near to where I live (a different county) has a couple of custom police-equipped Hummers. Why police needed an unarmoured Hummer, I'll never know. They already had an armoured personnel carrier and 4-wheel vehicles for use on the beaches. Tax dollars hard at work, I guess.

Oh well...two more cents added

by Member 25348569

if a bit alien. No insult intended!

"Nanny-state" over here just marks the boundary whereby sensible state intervention goes to far. It has a different meaning for nearly everyone as you would expect. I've getting a fairly good idea, now, where you draw the line.

As for seat-belts, there are significant numbers of front-seat driver/passengers killed by unbelted back seat passengers nutting them in the back of the head. Even a child at 50mph is quite a dangerous missile - and not only to itself! That's why the law was not unreasonably extended to back seats over here.

Theoretically, then, you would be less against rear seat belt legislation than that for the front seats.

Hmmmm. :)

by montgomery gator

...they piss off the envioronmental whackos and other socialist and class-envy nutters who want the government to regulate everything to the extreme. I do not own one, I drive a 4-cylinder Saturn SL2, but I have no problem with other people driving large SUVs and trucks (even when they piss me off because I can't see around them in traffic, but that is not a good enough reason to infringe on the rights of others to own the behemoths.)

by hockeyist

By "big" I assume that you are talking relative size as there are small trucks and large trucks.

I was in the U.S. last year. I visited 6 states and Canada and the thing that stood out was the size of the personal vehicles used. There didn't seem to be a need for all that space as most of them seemed to be polished to a mirror finish and not used commercially. Some of these trucks looked like they should belong on open-cut mining sites. As soon as I crossed the boarder into Canada the trucks shrank back to useful proportions (including the cars) and the pace slowed down a bit.
I also think that it's an inate genetic thing left over from the cave-man days, some people just feel that they need to impress others with the size of their clubs (trucks).

by oz_media

"some people just feel that they need to impress others with the size of their clubs (trucks)."

I couldn't begin to count the number of SUV's I've pulled out of ditches and spinouts that were brand new, or STILL looked brand new, and had never been offroad. The one that kills me is people who buy a 4X4 that is lowered....uhhhhhh, yeah.
Or the new SUV's that will simply snap in half and little pieces of fibreglass get shattered when they go over s speed bump.

Where I live you need a pretty tough truck, and a 6-pack of primer to fix any dings while waiting for the ferry. The clear coating and ground effects they put on thse "SUV's" these days are laughable. Even the new Hummers are just show cars compared to their original counterparts.

You cant 'pretend' to be rugged when you have a fibreglass running board on a 4X4, no matter how big your er.....truck is!

by hockeyist

...was supplied by one auto manufacturer about 10 years ago. It was especially formulated to not scratch the finish.

by jck

I'm an American, but I realize most people get the huge "tanks" like Hummers and Navigators as status symbols or a flashy "ride". The practicality of them is non-existent in most cases, as I see most of them only occupied by men obviously on their way home from an office, or by a couple of young people who obviously have no family to transport and their parents bought them a birthday present.

Personally, I don't see a need for them. If you're taking a vacation, they make these really big things called buses and airplanes that get you where you need to go. It was really refreshing in Ireland to get off the plane in Dublin, take a bus to Heuston station, catch the rail to County Tipperary, then bus to my friend's radio station. And...I did that all in less than 6 hours...off the plane at 9am...in County Tipp before 3pm...and for less than US$90.

Honestly...Americans are generally too into themselves nowadays, and almost have to be considering how the economy and job market is. But because of how the economy has forced society to become here, it's generally not about doing what's right for the common good anymore...but what's good for yourself. And, that's a sad statement.

As for me...I'll never own one of those huge, overpriced vehicles. $40-70k for a car is just ridiculous. Once I get married and have a family...mini-van, here I come!

Two more cents thrown in...I'm running out of change.

by jamesrl

In many types of crashes SUVs do absorb impact better than small cars. Trouble is that SUVs are also much more likely to rollover.

SUVs are more likely to hurt the "other" driver - if two cars hit, its much less likely to kills someone than if a car and an SUV impact - its both the mass of the SUV and the height differential that do it. SUVs weight much more than cars, making stopping distances proportionately longer. SUVs also block the vision of other drivers.

Newer smaller cars, especially those with side curtain airbags, are safer in most crashes than older SUVs.

Dedicated eletric streetcar right of ways are 1/10 the cost of subways but faster and less polluting than buses. I used San Diego's to go to Tijuana - very convenient.

James
James

by dr dij

Not sure I'd call it a street car as for most of the run isn't it off the streets? I know they intersect streets in portions on the LA Blue line.

I guess Light Rail is the proper term.

We camped out in Santee, east of SD (last stop) and took trolley into towne then to Mex border and walked across. Real glad we did despite the beggars, it was fun. All day pass for a couple bucks.

And we saw the lines for inspection of cars coming back into states and was real glad took the train. The only time we were slightly bothered was a noisey drunk on the train. And at the next stop an undercover cop whisked him off quietly.

Subway was a generic term. In portions they have to be underground, but large portions are above ground and of course that's way cheaper.

I used to think they should buy fleets of new busses for the cost of light rail but operating costs are way lower and people use them alot more than busses as they like 'em better.

The short car thing goes both ways, small cars are harder to see so less visible.

And I think in general people take anger out on SUVs but in a generic sense of gas mileage that includes large vans, luxury cars that are also big and heavy. Large cars ARE safer according to consumer reports. Best crash car a few years ago was a Volvo and then a humongous Lincoln town car.

Semi trucks block vision too but we don't ban them. Like big cars they serve a purpose. And luxury cars have larger heavy duty (and better disk) brakes usually so they don't take proportionally longer to stop compared to the increase in weight.

by maxwell edison

.
.......but this time, read it knowing that it was an exercise in extreme satire. (An unsuccessful attempt, apparently.) But I think you may see it in a different light.

But in short, when any one person starts dictating, or even suggesting, what another person "needs", too many lines have been crossed, and too many presumptions have been made.

by dr dij

I disagree.

Take this example:

Joe Worker (an average guy, average looks, etc) works in an average place.

He trades decides NOT to buy a sleek powerful gas guzzling humongo pickup. He gets a wimpy little car.

Instead of getting 'looks' from the gals, they just ignore him. He goes somewhere and meets a nice gal but she thinks he's bland and unexciting and doesn't go out with him again.

Joe Worker never gets .., never gets married or has a family and kids.

My point is that having status symbol cars IS important to some people and even if we don't think that way, who are we to judge. Ok, so that guy who teased the nerds in high school about short trousers is himself 'expecting a flood' in his raised 4wd.

And there are alot of pickups that are smaller and equivalent in mileage to regular cars. Americans like the versatility of being able to haul stuff.

Any feature that might be considered bad such as rollovers has compensating reason in eyes of buyer. The economy will sort it out, when gas prices rise they'll get smaller cars.

by liame

Tell me Dr Dij, is the size of your car all you can offer to a prospective mate?

by dr dij

If you would have read my post fully you'd realize I was saying I don't agree that people should get large cars just for that kind of reason, to be cool.

However that is what society promulgates on us. That is what Joe Average believes. He picks up an issue of Road&Track or 4WD or Pop. Mechanics and wants.

And while it is none of your business what I have to offer my prospective mate and bizarre of you to ask, my prospective mate happens to think people with large SUVs are 'compensating'.

Frankly it is not my biz to judge them, and anyone who does not 'consume' an SUV may well make up the same energy use in form of airplane use, domestic use heating the home or electricity, etc.

I happen to have a large vehicle (not an SUV) because it is comfortable, handy to carry everything I need to carry around and several other reasons, none related to 'how it looks' to others. If I got into situation where I commuted long way I'd probably get something smaller.

(no problem, Liam, I guess if you were being facetious I'm not p**d)

by jck

I need an aspirin...

Can I define what a "necessity" is for any human? probably so...

Are *any* motor vehicles *necessary* for *anyone*. No.

We have 2 legs, and for the infirmed we have other means of transportation. It is that we desire to be somewhere faster or with less exertion, but it is *not* a necessity.

Food, water and shelter from the elements. That's all we *really* need.

Now, where's my club? I need to go find me a wife. :D

by dr dij

slap some fake mud on your fake hummer
and you never need to go near a dirt road

by maxwell edison

.
How can you possibly justify defining what another person's needs are? Why shouldn't they respond to you the same way you responded to me when I suggested that you don't "need" a bicycle? Who the hell am I to suggest what you may or may not need? Conversely, who are you to suggest what another person may or may not need? Who elected you (or anyone) the referee of needs? How can anyone be so presumptuous to suggest another person doesn't "need" something that he has? I might be able to say that I don't "need" this widget that I just bought, but how can anyone else suggest such a thing?

As far as wanting to interfere with their "life-style choices", what other individual "choices" do you presume to be able to make better? And how about other people making your personal choices for you?

I just can't relate to such a thought process, especially in a context such as this.

by thechas

Max,

Respectfully, one of us is not understanding the original question.

As I read it, the question asks are large SUVs and pickup trucks necessary for personal use.

The simple answer to that is no.

Are they desirable to some people, and should they be available to those who desire them?
To that question, the answer is yes.

The "need" for SUVs and large pickups is a fabrication of advertising and peer pressure. If people made a detailed analysis of their actual vehicle needs, the SUV and pickup market would dry up overnight.

Perhaps my opinion is tainted by being too close to the automotive industry. When I talk with people who just bought a new vehicle, especially a large one, the choice almost always was driven by emotion and desire. Little if any thought enters the process.

It is their right to buy what they want and can afford.

Do I think it is dumb to spend many thousands of dollars extra and $10 to $20 more per week in fuel just so you can avoid an occasional $10 delivery fee?
Yes I do.

Do people have the right to do stupid things with their money?
Yes again.

Yes, I believe that SUVs and large pickup trucks are not necessary for personal use.

What I would like / hope to see is people start to review and weigh their needs and desires when purchasing a vehicle.

I agree that we should not legislate or make the final choice for others.
However, if no one voices the negative aspects of SUVs, we are not apt to bring about a change to the present paradigm that drives the perceived need for them.

Chas

by maxwell edison

.
I think I understood the original question perfectly. Here's how I answered it:

--------------------

It's dangerous territory on which to tread when people presume to define what may or may not be "necessary" for someone else, especially personal property.

But keeping in the spirit of your English project, I would have to answer yes. After all, if a person didn't consider it "necessary", he or she wouldn't have acquired it in the first place. And who am I to define what his or her "necessities" should be?

--------------------

And then the tangents began.

I don't believe that a simple yes or no answer is possible without considering the premise of the question -- especially if you disagree with the premise. And if you answer no, your premise is built on the assumption that one person is justified in defining and determining the "needs" of another person -- a premise with which I wholly disagree.

These leading questions, or ones that presuppose something, are asked all the time. In the case of politicians or political activists asking them, they are no more than traps designed to sway public opinion. In the case of many individuals asking them, they are probably not very well thought out, or they are really a predetermined conclusion in search for justification, or they lack a basis in core principles.

To illustrate my point, let me rephrase the question. How should someone answer the question, "What does Chas need"? (Chas, Maxwell, John, Mary, or anyone else.)

Well who am I do even suggest what you, or anyone else, may or may not need? Need for what? I tried to show how misguided that notion is by my satirical message on "not needing" a bicycle. Of course a person doesn't "need" an SUV to survive; a person doesn't "need" a bicycle to survive; and short of air, water, food, and warmth, a person doesn't really "need" a dang thing. Everything beyond that is subjective at best. And when one person starts to presuppose that he is justified in defining someone else's needs, like I said, we're treading on dangerous territory. And whether it's for the purpose of legislation or to engage in simple discussion, we should at least recognize the premise on which the question is based.

Let me ask you this. Do you think one person is justified in defining the needs of another? Based on your previous messages, I would have to guess that you'd answer yes. And if so, on what authority do you make such a presumption? And where does it stop?

by computer dude

What business is it of someone else's what somebody wants to drive? If that person is willing to pay for the car, the insurance, the maintenence, and the gas, so what?

by jamesrl

....larger vehicles burn more gas, which causes more pollution, and we all share the air.

Because

....there is not an infinite amount of oil and squandering it reduces the amount the next generation can use.

Because
... huge SUVs are a traffic hazard for those of us in cars, blocking our view of the road.

Because

.....if one of those huge behemouths T bones my car, I am more likely to die.

And thats just off the top of my head.

James

by computer dude

...are more dangerous to their occupants in case of a crash.

...there are alternative energy methods in their embryonic stages of development (albiet slowlly).

...are harder to see, easier to hide out in a blind spot.

And what about tractor trailers. Everyone who bashes big trucks never says anything about tractor trailers clogging up the highway and burning fuel. Do we really need all those cheap plastic Wal Mart things?

by av .

Looking around on the highway everyday, I see lots of people that can apparently afford them. The problem is SUV's are gas hogs.

Manufacturers need to make a more energy efficient SUV. Many of them are just used as todays station wagon anyway. I have a car and its one of the only cars in the parking lot at my food market whenever I go.

For those people that like to camp or need to tow something, SUVs are perfect. For everyone else, buy a car. Most of them use less gas.

So what? When gas is $3.00 a gallon, will you pay more to support your SUV? Heres another side to it thats not about the money.

In the early 70's there was a gas shortage and people had to sit in long lines for gas. Gas stations would run out of gas so not everyone got gas even after sitting for hours. I owned a gas-guzzling car that got 8 MPGs. Thats all they sold back then. I found gas, but the gas station was rationing and only pumping so many gallons per car. I was only able to get a small amount of gas that night, so I had to just go home and try again the next day.

Now certainly, I would hope that this scenario would never happen again, but it could. If it does, I'll be praying for a Yugo.

by tomsal

I agree tractor trailers are huge polluters as well. But you see, the vast majority of all goods moved within the US is still from truck fleets over any other kind of transport -- including aircraft.

This is especially true within cities and the counties immediately surrounding big cities - they largely don't use planes to deliver goods 60-100 miles away. It would not be cost efficient. Particularly when with a truck the driver can deliver one trailer or load at one location and pick up another trailer or load on the way to yet another location.

A lot of our goods would be in short supply if you magically made all tractor trailers disappear.

In other words, they serve a purpose to society as folks don't just buy $80,000-$300,000 tractor trailers for joy riding..they serve a business function.

Many folks who buy SUVs just buy them because they want to. Which largely is fine by me, the problem is I have to drive next to a lot of these folks on the highway who think they can drive a huge suv like a sports car.

Sorry I have this thing about death...its just not me. ;)

by thechas

Max,

With all due respect, I think you are taking this specific question far too seriously.

In answer to your primary question, NO, no one can define another's need.

However, one is free to question what another thinks they need, and why they think that they need it.

I look at the original question as part of a healthy discourse in the effort to change the paradigm that a SUV is a good choice of vehicle for everyday personal use.

I admit that I would like to see SUV production come to an end.

That does not mean that I think we should ban them.

I want people to take an objective look at their choice of vehicle. To look at just how much more they are spending for the perceived benefits of a SUV. To even consider the impact of their choice on the planet.

I would even go so far as to say that the average SUV buyer is guilty of at least 2 of the 7 "deadly sins". Lust and Gluttony.

Lust comes in play when part of the decision is based on keeping up with the "Jones".

Gluttony comes from the fact that a SUV (as normally used) uses a significantly larger share of the earths resources than is necessary.

Even considering that my father and father-in-law, both of whom I respect, own SUVs, I think that at least 95% of the people who own SUVs are selfish morons. At least in their choice of vehicle.

My first thought when I see someone commuting alone in a SUV, is "there goes someone with more money than brains".

My second thought is how can I take advantage of that.

My third thought is the realization that I could not sleep at night knowing I was taking money from people who are gullible.

So, there is my rant against SUVs for this thread.

May each SUV go quietly to the crusher and become the 3 reasonable sized vehicles it was meant to be.

I did think of 1 small positive attribute of the SUV. Without the SUV, the big 3 automakers, and along with them Detroit and Michigan, would be bankrupt.

Chas

by maxwell edison

.
Consider this. The question was conceived by an English teacher. So it becomes clear that we have a teacher instilling such thoughts into the heads of his or her students. There's a political agenda behind the question, it's based on a foregone conclusion in search of support or justification, and I believe we both know it. Moreover, at the risk of being redundant, we have one citizen attempting to determine whether or not another citizen needs the property he or she has acquired. If the mere thought of such a thing doesn't repulse you, then we are indeed operating from totally different mind-sets. I can't even imaging such a thing.

We have one citizen trying to tell another that he doesn't need an SUV.....theater popcorn.....fast food.....sporting event tickets.....cell phones.....the school of choice for his children.....the bigger house.....and on it goes.

As each year goes by, more and more individual liberties are trampled upon; and as each year goes by, less and less emphasis is placed on the value of protecting individual liberties.

If you're not concerned about these things, and especially the mind-sets that advance such thoughts, you're losing your country right out from under you and you don't even recognize it. Of course, I believe you've bought into all the rhetoric that's taking away individual liberties.

Are your opinions based on the concepts of individual liberties or the common good? Mine are all based on the former; yours, I would presume, are based on the latter. However, I believe that protecting individual liberties is what's ultimately best for the common good. How can a collectivist-type thinker possibly say the same thing?

Question: Do you think that ____________________ (fill in the blank) for personal use are (is) necessary?

It's the thought process behind the question that scares the heck out of me. And to think that our teachers are instilling such a though process into our students scares me even more. And it should scare you too.

by thechas

No, No, No, a thousand times NO!
SUV's and other large vehicles are NOT necessary for personal use.

As Christians, are we not called to be "good stewards" of Gods gifts to us?

On ANY level, can you show that these large vehicles and their housing companion the "McMansion" make prudent use of the Earth's resources?

For many people, the purchase of a SUV or McMansion constitutes of at least 1 of the seven deadly sins.
For some people, a single SUV purchase would violate 4 deadly sins, Pride, Lust, Greed and Gluttony.

Sorry, as a Christian, I cannot reconcile a SUV as a valid let alone a necessary transportation choice.

Chas

by jdclyde

A nice station wagon. Don't forget the wood pannels on the sides!

I like my Concorde, actually. Gives lots of foot space, a big trunk and 29 to 32 mpg depending on how hard I get up on it. Not bad for a full size car. Lots better than the 12 mpg I get with my truck.

Five kids huh? I think I would learn quickly why animals eat their young if I had that many....

But then, everyone is different. Congrats on the new one! Happy and healthy!

by thechas

Max,

Are you afraid of discourse?

I admit, it would help us both if we knew more about the assignment.

My children had a very positive experience with the local public school system. I have so much faith and trust in the teachers my children had that I would not be concerned about any question or subject they were asked to research.

My line on personal freedom versus public good is when someone's freedom costs me money out of my pocket and / or impacts my health and safety.

SUVs and large pickups impact all 3!

Money: It would be very difficult to find facts to support my presumptions here.
Anyhow.
At the present pump price of $2.39 per gallon, I suggest that it is reasonable to assume that 25 cents of each gallon of gas comes from the increased demand caused by over sized and over-powered vehicles.
Assume that $100 of my semi-annual car insurance is from the increased cost of repairing damage from SUV related accidents. (Michigan is a no-fault state, so we all share in increased costs from higher claims.)

Further, since 2 SUVs take up as much space on the road as 3 compact cars, add in some cost for traffic congestion and delays.

Health: Any way you look at, a larger vehicle produces more pollution. Both in production and operation. Which at a minimum impacts my length and quality of life.

Safety: Any SUV, especially when driven by someone on a cell phone, is a risk to every other person on the road or sidewalk.
Don't neglect the "perceived" safety factor of a SUV.
Drivers who perceive their vehicle as being "safer" for them take more risks and drive more aggressively than they otherwise would.

(For proof of the above, research what happened when anti-lock brakes first became standard. Rear end collisions climbed dramatically because drivers assumed that they no longer needed a safety gap since anti-lock brakes would stop the car quicker.)

How much should we have to pay out of our pockets to support someone's choice?

If it is acceptable to pay increased costs to support a persons choice to drive a SUV, why is it not acceptable for your tax dollars to support someone who can achieve a better quality of life on welfare than from working?

Chas

by liame

I hear they are giving away a free sense of humour with a gallon of fuel these days......

by maxwell edison

.
Of course not; I'm not afraid of discourse at all. But I want honest, open and FULL discourse, something I actually believe others are afraid of.

For example (not to go off on another unrelated tangent), I believe it is extremely evasive to talk about funding ANY government transfer of wealth social programs without first setting the premise that it's tantamount to taking the personal property of the citizen who earned it, for the sole purpose of giving it to another who did not. Let's talk about what it is we're really doing here before we start arguing about the particular merits of the program. (By the way, I've never seen anyone in these threads concede that it's proper for a government, especially the US government, to take the personal property of the citizen who earned it, for the sole purpose of giving it to another who did not.)

And all this SUV nonsense is the same thing. Before you can suggest that a person doesn't "need" one, or need anything else, for that matter, you have to first establish the authority to make such a determination.

As far as your whole argument on SUVs costing other people money, well, you said it yourself. You said, "It would be very difficult to find facts to support (your) presumptions." But then you go ahead and base your entire argument on those presumptions, not facts, and they simply won't hold up under even the slightest bit of scrutiny.

Here's a real fact for you. Compared to the rate of inflation, and to almost all other consumer goods (excluding technology-type goods), gasoline is cheaper today than it was in 1975 -- at the height of the gasoline shortage. (Remember those long lines and gasoline rationing by most stations?) The increased cost of gasoline has simply not kept pace with inflation. In fact, the cost of a gallon of milk has increased more than the cost of a gallon of gasoline. (And let's not even talk about the cost of a gallon of bottled water!) And if we could make a wager on these threads, I'd bet $1,000 that I could easily prove it.

Here's another fact. The primary reasons for increased demand on the world-wide supply of crude oil are twofold, neither one being SUVs. One is tied to political strife around the globe, including in the Middle East, Africa and South America, and current production is being disrupted and/or future production targets are becoming threatened. And the second is China's increased demand for crude. It's absolutely incredible the way China has increased its demand for oil. In fact, a few short decades ago, China was not a major oil consumer at all. Now they're number two behind the USA -- and at their current rate of increased demand, they will soon be number one.

On higher insurance costs, your health comments, and congestion assertions? Well, again we are going to have to look at the premise of your arguments and make sure we discuss "only the facts", not presumptions. For example, the premise of no-fault insurance is flawed. In fact, the whole insurance industry is flawed. But lets save those things for another day.

And on your public school comments, let's save those, as well, for another discussion. I'm sure we could go on and on about that. Besides, most public (and private) school teachers and administrators are among, what I could easily call, the NPR crowd - a crowd you rub philosophical elbows with quite frequently. (On a side note, my son's civics teacher, actually used the words freedom FROM religion when discussing the first amendment to the constitution. There's simply no escaping it - the NPR crowd, I mean.)

By the way, and for the record, I am certainly on the "alternative fuel" bandwagon. But I don't need false presumptions and scare tactics to support my position. I want to reduce the US trade deficit. I want to reduce, or eliminate, our dependence on foreign oil. I want to become an energy independent nation. And I simply want to tell the middle east thugs to take their oil and shove it up their tail-pipe. But I don't need to demonize SUV owners to do it.

by jck

that lost me...I'm not sure if that's statistical mathematics, secret code, visual basic in need of an implicit type conversion of char to int...hehehe

encryption? rot 1?

j/k...gotcha :)

by maxwell edison

.
Chas, my guess is that we really want the same thing, but we only have a different way of looking at it and/or different methods of hoping to achieve it.

If the goal were to reduce both automobile emissions and our dependence on foreign oil, what would be a more effective way of achieving that?

1. Demonize SUV users as oil-hogging polluters, and try to implement even more controls and regulation on the auto industry and/or on personal use.

OR

2. Issue a bold national challenge, with a deadline -- not unlike President Kennedy's challenge to send a man to the moon -- and complete with tax incentives, to transform our automobile industry into one that can economically and effectively create and produce alternative fuel source automobiles for personal use -- including trucks and SUVs if there's a market for them. This would be an absolute HUGE boost to the economy, as investment dollars would literally pour into the efforts like an Oklahoma oil gusher, and jobs would be available for anybody who wanted one. And to become less dependent on foreign oil would not only reduce, if not eliminate, our current trade deficit, but would also be extremely helpful to ensure national security, as oil wouldn't be as big a factor as it is now. Not to mention the national pride that could also be a driving force, it would be easy to get people to buy-into the idea. (And don't retort with the "Bush is an oil-man" nonsense. President Clinton didn't do it either.) If a serious and capable presidential candidate were to do this, regardless of the party, and could come across as sincere and resolute, he or she, in my opinion, would win in a landslide.

So there's two possible band-wagons, number one or number two. Why not abandon the first and hop on-board the second? The first one has taken us nowhere for years, nor will it get us to where we want to go.

Great things are not achieved by implementing even tighter controls and regulations, and/or increasing taxation on something. To the contrary, those things stifle creativity and are a barrier to success. Great things will be achieved when all barriers to succeed are removed and incentives to do so are made available. With reason, and with purpose, and with rewards, absolutely anything is possible - anything.

by jck

I displayed a character...it's just not "viewable".

God bless the Alt key

However if there's any prize for what I did, I'll gladly give it to CuteElf. I like cerebrally creative people...the algorithmic stuff was a neat twist :)

ok...back to ADO.NET!

two more cents just tossed in...

by tonythetiger

They subsidize the rest of us by paying more fuel taxes. If every vehicle got 30 mpg, the government would have to triple the fuel tax to keep the same money coming in.

by deadly ernest

SOrry wjen you said Kia I was thinking of the ones I have seen around here, kind of like a modernised Morris Mini-Minor that comes up to my belt.

I hate 4WDs asa general rule but ended up buying a Nissan X-trail as the cheapest comfortable car to enter, exit and drive out of the modern cars; next style would have had to be a mini bus like the Toyota Tarago.

I agree some are too large and have never understood why they are made that way when I see them in the movies etc. Yhey seem to be very restricted to the USA/Canada as we don't see many of those like you mentioned here in Australia.

As for your local police vehicles, I wonder if the downtown night shift over there is a bit more dangerous than here and they need the armour. Our police cars have improved performance motros and handling but start life as standard dual cab utes with a cage on the back or as standard sedans.

by jck

Nah...it's Florida...they wanna be fancy down there...I could see the need for armoured vehicles for S.W.A.T. usage, but a *non-armoured* Humvee is about as practical as them buying a wingless plane for a highway patrol cruiser.

by thechas

Since this is the good old USA, let's fund your tax incentives for alternate energy sources with a significant surtax on inefficient vehicles used for "personal use".

Start at say $5,000 at the purchase of a vehicle that gets less than 15 MPG. Rising to $15,000 on those that get less than 5 MPG. Tack on a transfer fee of 1/5th of the surtax when a title is transfered.

I agree that we do need alternative energy sources. Preferably renewable sources like bio-mass.

I just do not buy into the panacea of the hydrogen fuel cell.

I agree that we can solve the safety and storage issues for hydrogen. We can even get to the point where the fuel cell has enough power and efficiency to be practical.

I just cannot conceive of being able to produce hydrogen economically at the volumes required.

It is a basic chemistry and physics issue. Hydrogen is just so darn reactive that it takes a lot of energy to separate hydrogen from any other element or molecule that it has attached itself to.

The "hydrogen economy" has as much chance of happening as "cold fusion". In fact, some form of fusion energy would be needed to produce enough electricity to crack hydrogen.

I know that we cannot conserve or drill ourselves out of the current energy crisis.

However, the US in particular needs to change it's energy wasting habits.

Chas

by maxwell edison

.
Geesh, why is it that government has to "fund" everything? For crying out loud, this is not supposed to be a nation where government controls business and people, but rather the other way around.

When there's a need, and when there's a market, American business ingenuity will provide the solution - WITHOUT GOVERNMENT. And you wonder why people see you as a socialist and/or communist.

And quit trying to FORCE YOUR WILL ON OTHERS. Just because you don't like SUVs on the road doesn't mean they don't have to be on the road. If you don't like it, well that's just too friggin' bad. I don't like bicycles on the road, either. But you guys are a PITA I have to live with, so move over and share the road with an SUV. And for the record, I don't own an SUV. So your motives are selfish, while mine are based on principle.