Discussion Locked

Survey: Are Big Trucks and SUVs really necessary?

0 helpful
324 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

324 replies

by maxwell edison

.
There may be a part of you that actually believes SUVs are "bad for the environment", or "bad for whatever", but it's become quite obvious that a bigger part of you -- a much bigger part of you -- just doesn't like the damn things on the road. And you're intolerance towards the rights of others is quite troubling.

You may not like SUVs on the road.

You may not like bicycles on the road.

You may not like the sound of your neighbors lawn mower.

You may not like kids skate boarding on the sidewalk.

You may not like a lot of things.

But just because you don't like it, doesn't mean you have to try to force your will -- your intolerance -- on others.

Just live and let live. And if your elitist attitude doesn't like the way other people choose to live, it's you that has the problem, not them.

Yea, yea, I know. You're going to now say that you're not trying to tell other people how to make personal choices. Well I say horse-hockey. That's exactly what you're doing.

by jkaras

They are not necessary, but offer optional needs to large families or people that need to tow things. I cant comment either way whether or not they are truly hazzardous to the environment because there is so much disinformation to support agendas. These are merely status symbol vehicles that think because they got one somehow they are above others, that it makes them smarter, sexier, or more macho. It's called selling the dream and they bought into it, its their right as much as their stupidity. My only problem with them is insisting to get into the fast lane going slow as if that lane is for the elite and not for flowing traffic, and not able to drive them properly, and their headlight height at the worst level that blinds me at a stop light. Waste gas all you want it doesnt bother me.

by maxwell edison

.
You cite Christian beliefs as support for your argument?

I seem to remember another discussion when you advocated preventing Boy Scouts from using public property because of their acknowledgement of God.

What's wrong with this picture?

by jamesrl

I agree with the idea of stewardship. I do think we need to do more than just let the market take care of it. I look at how the market dealt with fishing stocks - there are no more cod off of the east coast of North America because we let the market or individuals decide the process.

I agree with gas guzzler taxes. Vehicles that use more gas pollute more, and I agree that there should be some additional compensation, hopefully the tax finds its way to measures that improve the environement(but the cynical side of me says, I doubt it).

But guess what -not all SUVs fit into that category. Small SUVs like the RAV 4 or CRV have 4 cylinder engines and get better mileage than some minivans. And while you are picking on vehicles, why not mention sports cars?

I beleive there is a role for the government, but I don't believe that the goverment should direct, but instead influence. If vehicles pollute more, tax them more, if vehicles cause more wear on the road, then tax them more. Use financial incentives and disincentives, not restrictions.

We can't dictate government policy in a modern democracy based on religious principles.

You do have the right to try and use non-governmental means to get this message across, and I would support you in that.

James

by maxwell edison

by jamesrl

Four wheel drive is not a replacement for common sense. As I have stated many times, without exageration, the first vehicles you see in the ditch are usually the 4x4s.

Why? Because similarly to the studies regarding ABS and other new technologies, some drivers(not all) seem to feel empowered to go faster than common sense would allow because they feel that the technology will save them.

I lived in the country growing up and there were very few 4x4s. People put on snow tires and/or drove slower.

I've never owned a 4x4 and I have driven in Northern Ontario, at times 50 miles from the closest village. Good tires and common sense got me safely to my destination, despite being caught in a storm.

James

by thechas

When I used to travel the freeway back and forth to work, I saw many more SUVs and pickup trucks stuck and stranded in the ditch and median than I did cars.

In the 30 plus years that I have been working, only once did I stay home from work because of snow. Even then, it was not because I could not get through with my car, it was because the company closed for the day.

I would go so far as to state that the irresponsible SUV drivers make the roads unsafe for everyone when it snows.
(Not all SUV drivers, just the vast number of bad drivers.)
They somehow think that their SUV is not encumbered by the laws of physics, and they can continue to drive 10 over and wait until the last possible second to hit the brakes.

It makes little sense to choose a costly vehicle based on one or 2 days a year when a prudent person would stay home.

Chas

by computer dude

people who are opposed to large vehicles because of fuel consumption do the logical thing and lobby for alternative energy sources? My guess is that whatever the next big fuel source is will be the next big boon to the world economy. A hydrogen economy could concievably ignite the world's economy like information technology did at the end of the 20th century.

by jck

I have done things to cut back on fuel usage, including buying a more fuel efficient vehicle.

I also have spoken to my elected representatives in the past about exploring other energy sources. Most of them give you the "Well, we're looking into that.." or "Well, I'm all for that.." line.

Truth is political campaigns are run on money from big contributors, i.e.- corporations, SIGs, etc. If BP, Exxon and Mobil saw that a candidate was going to move in Congress to fund alternative energy research that would possibly ruin their industry, do you think they'd give the guy a penny 2 years later for re-election?

I've lobbied. It really does no good. It will take market demand to make the supply change. Oil/fuel use in this country is like the drug use problem. Until we cut the demand, the supply will keep coming. It has to be unprofitable for the supplier before they quit shipping it.

by computer dude

But there are a very select few hydrogen refueling stations in this country now. It's all more or less experimental, not to mention highly expensive.

But it's a start. Shell and BP and Exxon and others are eventually going to have to dive into the alt. fuels market. It's only a matter of time.

Baby steps.

by dr dij

fairly quickly, prices are going to double.
Why: one billion chinese are quickly industrializing, building roads like no tomorrow, and buying cars.

Don't forget the Indians. Another billion of them and they all also want to drive cars. Problem is not only do they want to drive cars, there are very lax pollution laws in these countries so one car is equivalent to 10+ here.

They allow cars without pollution controls, they probably have very little in way of smog testing, and they allow 2 cycle engines for vehicles still in many developing countries. (Anyone know if this has changed?)

At $60/barrel, the canadian tar sands are just barely becoming profitable to extract. While a huge amount of oil will come from there, it will be sold to the Chinese, as on March 15 or around that time they signed deal to invest 49% of the fields or something like that.

EVERY OPEC producing country lies about available deposits as their export quota is based on declared reserves. So we will be running out long before all the oil 'on the books' is gone.

The good thing: at higher prices, we will be 'encouraged' to reduce usage and drive smaller cars, and alternate energy will come more into play. Wind power is now on par with regular generation for electricity for example.

by montgomery gator

Computer Dude wrote: "A hydrogen economy could concievably ignite the world's economy like information technology did at the end of the 20th century."
...
Sorry, but when you said this, I could not help but to thinking of the Hindenberg airship (inflated by hydrogen) blowing up. Seriously, I am all in favor of developing alternative energy sources, including hydrogen, which with today's technology can be made a lot safer than the old hydrogen inflated airships. At the same time, we need to increase oil exploration and development to keep us going until alternative energy sources are plentiful and cost efficient, along with promoting more energy efficient vehicles, like the hybrids. (I happen to like the Ford Escape (although I do not have one, I own a Saturn), you can have a SUV and a hybrid at the same time, and really confuse the enviornmental lefty whackos :-) )

I prefer to let the market and free enterprise develop and promote energy alternatives, instead of mandates from government. The best way the government can get energy alternatives developed is to get out of the way, lessen regulation, and reduce taxes on R&D and development of alternative energy sources.

by computer dude

The Hindenburg blew up in I think the 20's. There's over 80 years of progress between us now.

Gasoline is higly flammable as well, but it seems to do okay as a fuel source.

by computer dude

Instead of hurling our vitriolic hatred towards the gas-guzzling mini boats on the highway, why can't we do something about the big bad bass cars. Is anyone else sick of hearing someone's earth shattering bass from 17 blocks away, all day every day. I mean, I know these kids are really super cool, but why must they remind us every waking hour of every day how unbelievably cool they are?
You guys from Canada and the UK: do you have a problem with the boom-boom-I'm-compensating-for-other-shortcomings kids and their loud cars?

by Member 25348569

Cars fitted with twin 15 inch bass speakers! The cars that have these are usually "hot hatchbacks" - very small cars with 2litre injection engines, blacked out windows and, I assume, drivers with very small dicks and brains!

We still get SUVs on our tiny roads as well, though. Gas is $5.60/Gall!

Burn 'em all!

by computer dude

Every time I hear one of these arrogant pissants I want to ram a pair of scissors into his tires and his speakers and his jugular and then piss on him

by jck

Having dabbled in electronics, I'm workin on a way to squelch their sound systems. heheheh...just gotta make sure it doesn't deafen them :)

by thechas

Max,

I was a Cub Scout once upon a time.

My son was a Cub Scout until he attempted to justify not doing his schoolwork because his Scouting work (which he was not doing either) took up too much of his time.

I think the Scouts are a great organization. Every young man should be encouraged to give Scouting a try.

I don't give to The United Way for a variety of reasons including the fact that they have stopped supporting Scouting.

As I recall the older thread, all I did was show my understanding of how the series of events that lead up to the Scout Troop being banned from using a public owned building could be justifiable.

A Scout Troop that some friends of mine are heavily involved with was booted out of a church in part because the church was being pressured to allow other groups to use the facility.

Chas

by thechas

First, a preface:

I expect a lot of flack from what I am about to post.

I also expect that my post will astonish some of you.

Max, I have stated before that many of your comments sound like school assignments and leave me feeling like I have a test coming. I know that you want me to re-evaluate my opinion and position on some topics. I suspect that you are not prepared for the result your comments in this thread have had on me.

Thank you for ripping away the last pieces of the conservative Republican veneer that had built up over my inner Liberal in the 1980's.

To wit, here are some key beliefs and positions I hold dear:

Protecting the environment takes precedence over profits, convenience and personal desire.

Unless you can prove that industrial activity has either no impact or the least possible impact on the environment, it should be stopped until a new method can be implemented.

Unless you can prove that global warming is not happening, you MUST proceed as if it is a looming threat.

Urban sprawl must be stopped and farm land must be preserved.

Al Gore has it wrong. The internal combustion engine is NOT the threat to the global environment, the personal motor vehicle IS!!!

While I still don't accept the concept of the ends justifying the means, I do sympathize with ECO-Terrorists.
While I may disprove of their methods, be it tree-sitting, or destroying a SUV dealership or new subdivision, ECO-Terrorists should at least be lauded for following their convictions.

I still refuse to accept that George W. Bush is the legitimate President of the USA.

Further still, GWB should be tried by the World Court for his crimes against humanity and the global environment.

With the high cost of living we have in the US, Medicare, Medicaid, Social Security and Welfare NEED to be fully funded until such time as we are willing to tackle the core problems and eliminate poverty.

It is not only proper, it is our Christian duty to tax income and redistribute it to our brothers and sisters in need.

A graduated income tax is by far the fairest means of taxation.

The Bush tax cuts not only failed to revive the US economy, they triggered the growth of China's economy, leading to the current high energy costs.

$10 per hour is likely still too low for a minimum wage.

In most instances, I trust the government much more than I trust corporations or the average American consumer.

Strict gun control is LONG overdue in the US.

Universal health care MUST be implemented in the US.
While it may cost a little bit more, a government run program will be more fair and effective than a private run program.

No person or corporation should be profiting off of the suffering of others.

The US government works best when no single party controls all 3 elected bodies.

Well, theres a start on elaborating my continuing process of recovering from being a Republican.
I think I will stay registered as a Republican for a while. That way both the NRC and the NRCC will continue to waste money on me.
Also, I can vote in primary elections as a spoiler.

Besides, I'm not really a Democrat either.

The party that comes closest to matching my positions is the Green Party.

Thanks again for liberating me from the cold hard shell of conservatism.

Chas

by Member 25348569

As long as there is oil to burn, they will keep on selling it so we can burn it.

What Hydrogen represents for the forseeable future is an expensive niche fuel, high-priced and profitable for the oil companies. There will always be enough for the richer ecologically-minded mugs to pay top dollar but there won't be enough to drop the price so as to make me or you switch for a very long time.

We have a fuel-cell bus trial in London at the moment. Our Mayor is a bit of an ecology nut so I expect more, quickly, if the trial is a success but I'm not holding my breath for a fuel-cell car, though.

Neil

by computer dude

There are motives behind any kind of new enterprise. But people were skeptical before fossil fuels became cost effective. I rememember reading a quote by some Congressman, his name is unimportant, as saying sometime during the 1800's something to the effect that people were never really going to dig for oil out of the ground. What a difference a century makes.

by computer dude

Make it so that it NEVER turns off, and on top of that, rig it so that it never comes down from its peak volume. Let them go EVERYWHERE blasting that crap. Shouldn't take long for that fad to go away.

by nd_it

I saw more bigger SUV's and trucks in the city that people used to drive to work everyday, and now since I moved to a smaller town, the farmers and people that lived in the country drive cars back and forth between the farm and town, and use trucks on the farm.

by nd_it

How people say that SUV's are safer, but their insurance is higher?? At least that's the case around here.

by dr dij

they are bigger with more parts and cost more to fix if they get in an accident.

or maybe people who drive them are more reckless overall :)

plus they've gotten rid of the 5mph bumpers,
and the tires on back door make any slow rear end accident VERY expensive to fix as the spare tire pushes in the back door, not the bumper.

by nd_it

A 4 x 8 trailer that I can pull with my Olds, and stores nicely behind my garage.

by dr dij

you could do what the noise cancelling headphones do: they have a mic that picks up ambient sound, then to the headphones they play that same sound 180o out of phase, which cancels most of the sound.

Instead have a shotgun mic, to point at other car, and speaker that blare anti-sound. Would be interesting to see what the people in the car making all the noise would hear (or not hear).

Those big stereo's save money on music tho. They just have one song, I call it the 'Boom-Boom' song since that is all I can hear.

by dr dij

Florida is flooded by sea water due to global warming caused by the humvee the same person is driving.

And the coke dealer need something to spend their money on.

Q: Why is the average driver in Miami looking distracted?
A: His pit bull has just spilled his cocaine onto his submachine gun.

by mjd420nova

I drove a full size van for more than 25 years. I needed it for work and a family with four children. YES YES YES I put over 500,00 miles
on it without a major problem. try that with your car of any model or type.

by jck

a 2000 Kia Sportage I've had 4 years. 105,000 miles so far. Only thing I've had to replace are tires, brakes, fluids and windshield wipers.

Maintenance 90% of the time determines how long a car lasts.

by hockeyist

...size. I was wet after a fishing trip and my pants sagged a bit. I was also afraid of wetting the precious upholstery.
We have an advertisement on out TV here at the moment for a 4WD SUV. The "hero", after rescuing a stranded calf from a mud/bog in torrential rain, hesitates to get back in the cab. He then proceeds to wash himself with soap in a creek before getting back in.
The advertising industry taking the piss out of their demographic I guess.

by itgirli

NO. NO. NO. NO. NO. NO. NO. NO. NO. NO. NO. NO. NO. NO. NO. NO. NO. NO. NO. NO. NO. NO. NO. NO.

by itgirli

I don't know where you live, but with gas prices the way they are, I doubt that you'd be able to afford to make it down here. Tell you what, I'll meet you half way. hahaha. With my car I can get to Delaware and back on one tank.

by computer dude

64 near VA Beach is incredibly confusing unless you've driven it about 45 times. It loops around the city so you have to go east to go west to get to the rest of the state. If you take it west from VA Beach you end up on 264 then 664 then 460. That makes sense, doesn't it?

by computer dude

The tunnels are a cool place to hang out in for about 45 minutes during rush hour. Nothing like sucking down a big rig's exhaust 100 feet under the water with no escape.

by maxwell edison

.
Why is it that people use time to describe distance?

How far is podunk from here? About three hours, might be an answer.

Three hours? Is that by car, by train, by bike, by foot, by camel, or perhaps by super-sonic jet fighter?

Time should not be used to describe distance. If time is an accurate measure of distance, then by definition, distance would be an accurate measure of time. How long will it take to get to Pudunk? Oh, about 200 miles.

Just a pet-peeve of mine.

by computer dude

from Norfolk to Richmond in front of me...

It should be self-explanatory. How far can you got on the Interstate in an hour and 15?

by itgirli

according to expedia.com the distance from Norfolk, Virginia, United States to Richmond, Virginia, United States is 93.5 miles, or 1 hour and 30 minutes @ approx. 65 mph. Or would someone like that in kpm? anyone?

by jck

oh dear...you hate me

Oh well...that's how it usually ends up...my foot in my mouth, someone else's foot up my arse.

by itgirli

I don't hate you yet, but that doesn't mean I won't eventually. Hey! that means we both have something to look forward to!! great! My day just keeps getting better.

by maxwell edison

.....in an hour and 15 (minutes)?

Well, driving at a posted 55 MPH, it would be 66 miles.

Driving at a posted 75 MPH, it would be 93 miles.

But if I decided to drive my classic 1953 Nash, which might struggle to keep pace with the 45 MPH minimum speed, I'd be lucky to go 50 miles.

And if the posted speed limit was like Montana, which has no posted speed limit at all (at least it didn't used to), it all depends.

Being rather bold, driving my Berlinetta V-12 powered, 540-horsepower Ferrari Superamerica, I could cover well over 200 miles in that time, maybe as many as 240 miles if I really push it.

But on the other hand, if I drive my road hoggin', accident causin', gas guzzlin' SUV, considering I'd have to stop to fill out the various accident reports because of the all the accidents I'd cause; and considering that I'd have top stop several times for gas, because I'd burn up so much; and considering I'd have to stop to get my respirator filled up, because of the pollution I'd be emitting; well heck, it might take me a couple of days to go even 90 miles.

And of course it's self-explanatory. But that doesn't make it accurate. Regardless, time is not an accurate measure of distance. But don't take my pet-peeve too personal. You're not alone; a lot of people do it. But the post was supposed to be funny, not intended to call anyone to task.

By the way, another one of my pet-peeves is the guy who turns right on a red light and obstructs the normal flow of traffic in the process. Probably one of those time-distance people getting the two confused.

by computer dude

...people who YIELD to you when they have the right of way. That's more irritating than being cut off, at least then the guy's trying to get the hell out of your way. But people who just stop at an intersection and look at you when they should be getting out of my way really piss me off.

by jck

only one person ever earned the distinguished honor of me labelling him "The person I hate." It took him 15 years of him badgering me, harassing me, defaming me, and even calling the police on me for something his "friends" did to him (he didn't know at first) to try and get him to swing at me at a party one night.

Nonetheless...I guess if you want it, you can try to get me to hate you. But, it takes a lot of work.

by jck

I'm not much of a workaholic myself...

As for who hates me...I don't work for or against it. I just tend to be me and let whomever figure out how they want to feel about me.

by itgirli

I hate people who complain too much about people complaining or people who think they are funny by giving more information than is necessary about all the different ways you can look at a single topic or when looking at that single topic give you the same way to look at it over and over and over and when you finally finish reading it you hate that person for making you read all of that for no reason. and then I hate those people that hate people that hate them or other people because they hate... wait. I'm lost. Was it people that hate people or people that hate themselves? whatever, the point is ... I think I would find that I hate myself if only I could figure out what I mean. oh well.

by jck

ITgirli is really Suzanne Somers...only younger and cuter, of course.

God...that sent me into 1970s TV sitcom flashbacks...quick...where's my Guinness! ;)

by maxwell edison

.
You're right, people who YIELD to you when they have the right of way is another one of my pet-peeves. Especially at a four-way stop. When that happens to me, I usually just sit there and insist that he/she goes first. It could, after all, actually be a set-up for an accident - he causes it ON PURPOSE, but then lies about it and, as the law says, when there are no witnesses, the person on the right has the right-of-way at a four-way stop.

That "set-up" is as common as someone pulling in front of you then slamming on the brakes to avoid "the dog" running across the street.

by deadly ernest

for when the hurricanes and tornadoes go through each month, Hummies allow them to reach the residents despite the weather - at least that is the assumption.

by deepsand

why should such be an overarching issue, of such magnitude that it supersedes all of those issues which argue against the mass use of such vehicles?

by deadly ernest

Being seated properly and comfortably means that I am more alert and in a better position to respond in an emergency than if my mind is distracted by a painful back, and my long term health etc. But more importantly the manufacturer's should be reviewing the needs of all customers and making a range of cars to suit, not designing the majority around the needs of a small group and then forcing everyone to take that - people object to Bill Gates doing it so why should we accept it from Ford and Holden and co.

At present this is not so bad as the SUVs and light commercials offer an acceptable alternative, remove them and many people are reduced to buying bigger vehicles like vans and trucks.

by deepsand

Every day I observe far too many drivers of SUVs, who neither evidence any need for them nor even know how to handle them, causing risk of harm to many others on I-95.

These greatly outnumber those who know how to drive them.

by deepsand

who are totally clueless as to how to drive them.

They frequently are the cause of many accidents and near ones.

In the winter, the medial strips and burms are literred with them.

by deepsand

both knows how to drive that SUV and follows the rules of the road, etal..

On I-95, in the Philly area, that's not case!

by deepsand

i.e. for the masses, based on my daily observations on I-95, I-295, I-76, I-476, PA/NJ Turnpikes, etal., I maintain that the vast majority of those who drive SUVs neither evidence a need for nor know how to drive such.

As such, they pose a persistent clear and present danger to themselves and others with whom they, in name only, "share" the highways.

by deadly ernest

My first answer is within context in that it ascribed a need - further responses elaborated on that and responded to additional comments.

The way people driver education and enforcement issue, not a vehicle design or use issue.

The main point of my post is that the tendency of sedan designers to lower the ground clearance and seat heights to make their cars more like race cars etc is forcing many people away from normal sedan types and their next alternative is the SUV, if you remove those then they will only go for other vehicles that are bigger again (eg delivery vans and the like) as the low slung shit is no good for them.

by deepsand

Ergonomics is one of the least considered factors considered by the average buyer.

Furthermore, most SUVs require that one CLIMB UP to enter, and DOWN to exit. This is ergonomically desirable?

by jamesrl

The only problem with that is that in a real hurricane or tornado, there is a big danger of roll over. And which vehicles are most likely to roll over? The ones with the most ground clearance. They actually do tests for these things - I see the Chrysler Pacifica bragging it has the lowest rollover rate of all SUVs.

I once had a ski partner who owned the original Toyota minivan - before the Previa - in the 80s. It had very high flat sides, and it was quite dangerous in a snowstorm with high winds. When the winds picked up it was difficult to keep the van in the lane. Most SUVs have an even higher centre of gravity.

James

by jamesrl

On SUVs and accident rates.

The one incident that happens alot and causes accidents is the over correction accident. An SUV driver will find themselves hitting the rumble strip or the soft shoulder, panic and over correct, sending them too far into the next lane. They realize they have gone too far and over correct back, onto the shoulder. In a vehicle with a high centre of gravity, if you do too much side to side rocking, you can tip, especially if two wheels slide down a soft shoulder. Cars don't have better drivers, they are just less likely to tip in this situation.

The other reason is over confidence. Many people with SUVs don't feel the need to lower their speed in bad conditions. They don't realise that ice and snow and rain lengthen an already long stopping distance - exponentially. Four wheel drive helps you accelerate, not decellerate.

James

James

by maxwell edison

.
You want to stop all industrial activity. That's interesting. I wonder what the full impact of that would really be?

And you want proof that global warming is not happening. (Something about proving a negative comes to mind.) Okay, unless you can prove that society is not being infiltrated by invaders from outer-space, you MUST proceed as if it is a looming threat. Your comment makes about as much sense as mine.

You said, "Urban sprawl must be stopped and farm land must be preserved." Okay, do you have some extra rooms in your house for the growth in the population, or should we just start killing people? Let's see. Congested cities are bad; growth away from cities into urban "sprawl" areas is bad; yep, we gotta' start killing people since we have nowhere to put them.

You said, "Al Gore has it wrong. The internal combustion engine is NOT the threat to the global environment, the personal motor vehicle IS!". Okay, let's mandate that everyone either walk or ride bicycles. But wait, since we already stopped all industrial activity because they couldn't prove a negative, there will be no bicycle industry to make bicycles. And even if there were a huge surplus available, all those industrial workers who lost their jobs because all industrial activity was stopped, including the automobile industry, couldn't afford to buy the bicycle if they wanted to. I guess we can then "fund" a massive bicycle give-away program, and the government mandates that everyone use one.

And you want to admire and commend terrorists? Really? Well, whatever. Don't let that get out, though. That's probably an extremely unpopular view.

If George W. Bush is not the legitimate president of the USA, who is?

And you think that, "GWB should be tried by the World Court for his crimes against humanity and the global environment"? Interesting. Perhaps Fidel Castro, Kim Jong Il, Saddam Hussein, and Osama bin Laden should be on the jury.

You said, "Medicare, Medicaid, Social Security and Welfare NEED to be fully funded." Well heck, let's just throw everybody's earnings (except all those industrial workers who don't have any) into a big pot, and we can all share and share alike. Yea, that's the ticket. Let's all suffer, I mean be happy together.

You said, "It is not only proper, it is our Christian duty to tax income and redistribute it to our brothers and sisters in need." Okay, let's repeal the First Amendment, do away with that silly religious clause in the Constitution, issue a mandate that we now live in a "Christian" nation, and (being redundant, here) let's just throw everybody's earnings (except all those industrial workers who don't have any) into a big pot, and we can all share and share alike, and all be good (suffering) Christians together; and we can even worship at the alter of environmentalism. (Maybe we can even canonize those ECO-Terrorists you admire.)

You like the graduated income tax? Well heck, let's just graduate it all the way to 100 percent and take ALL of what those greedy rich people earn.

You said, "The Bush tax cuts not only failed to revive the US economy, they triggered the growth of China's economy, leading to the current high energy costs." And how's that?

You said, "$10 per hour is likely still too low for a minimum wage." Yea, let's make it $20 per hour. No, $30 per hour. Heck, let's just make it $50 per hour. By the way, are we going to be paying those jobless industrial workers a higher minimum wage for not working?

You said that you, "trust the government much more than you trust corporations or the average American consumer." But what if an American consumer or a corporate-type person decided to go into government? You wouldn't trust that person as just the average every-day citizen, but when that person suddenly gets into government he suddenly becomes trustworthy? Is it something in the government water, or what? And I guess this doesn't apply to any government person with (R) before his/her name; and I guess it especially doesn't apply to President Bush. Or is it "government" you trust, but just not the people running it? Or some of the people running it? Or......this is all kinda' confusing. Could you elaborate?

You said, "Strict gun control is LONG overdue in the US." Sure, we don't want a population that could protect themselves from an overly-oppressive (but trustworthy) government who will come to seize all your personal property and force you to ride bicycles. And while we're tampering with the first amendment to make our society a mandated Environmentalist-Christian nation, we can just do away with that nagging second amendment as well. And how about that silly fourth amendment? You know, the one about people being secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable seizures? If we're seizing all the property (income) from people, we can't have a fourth amendment to get in the way. Hell, let's just do away with all of them; let's just abolish the whole Bill of Rights. That'll make things much easier.

You said, "Universal health care MUST be implemented in the US." Sure, and let's just replace that freedom of religion clause with a free health care clause.

You said, "No person or corporation should be profiting off of the suffering of others." Okay, but should the government profit off of the suffering of people who are really no more than indentured servants working to pay taxes to pay for all these give-away programs you espouse? But wait, we don't have to suffer by working. The (trustworthy) government will provide for us all. We can just all quit our jobs, except those industrial workers, of course, who already lost theirs (they have no job to quit from), and the government will provide.

You said, "The US government works best when no single party controls all 3 elected bodies." Okay, so let's just do away with free and open elections so we can make sure that never happens. We can just appoint people. By the way, who does the appointing? And what if someone disagrees with the appointment?

You said that you, "can vote in primary elections as a spoiler." Not if they start appointing, you can't.

You said that you're not really a Democrat either. Oh heck, I knew that. The Democrats are way too conservative for your views. You're way left of the Democrats, just as your Green Party sentiments indicate.

A couple of words come to mind, however, upon reading your rant: deep end.

by deepsand

They are either, as you noted, overly confident of both the vehicle and their driving skills, or they find themselves so intimidated by the vehicle that they become exceesively timorous, thus causing much frustration to the drivers of the surrounding vehicles.

Both cases result in an increased risk of accidents.

by deepsand

The HUMVEE has a MUCH lower center of gravity than do either the Hummer 1 or 2.

The Hummer 2 in fact is VERY easy to roll over.

by thechas

Max,

My post was not meant as a rant.

It is the result of soul searching from the questions you posted to my other posts in this thread.

I thank you again for helping to free the liberal spirit that had become suppressed and hidden inside me.

What I would really like to see is for the entire United States to become a 1960's style commune.
Hippies and all!

Free love should reign supreme!

Chas

by deepsand

I trust neither the government nor big business to hold the best interests of mankind in high regard.

I'm seriously considering returning to the Appalachians of central PA, to live in a cabin in the mountains near an stream with excellent fishing & a flow sufficient for generating a useful amount of power, and with an abundance of game about.

It may not help mankind, but it will distance me from its problems.

by jamesrl

Both the Humvee and the Hummer H1 have 16 inch ground clearance and are 86.5 inches wide and 185 long. Originally they used the same engine and drive train, but for 2006 the H1 has a different engine.

The H2 is a different beast altogether - it looks like a Hummer, and is built by the same AM General Factory, but raids the GM Truck parts bin rather than the Hummer one. It is as high, but narrower, making it more tippy.

James

by maxwell edison

.
What you described in your "rant" (or whatever it was) was neither "free-spirit" nor "hippie-spirit" sentiment. It was tantamount to espousing forced socialism. About the only thing you left out was the make-up of the firing squad that dealt with people who did not comply.

Hey Chas, whatever you want for yourself is all fine and dandy. If that's what you want, go for it. But if that's not what someone else wants, don't try to force them to go for it as well.

The difference between your world and mine is that I can live in mine just fine without infringing on your rights or the rights of another. But in yours, you must infringe on the rights of others in order to achieve your desired outcome.

The "true spirit" of the 1960s hippies wanted neither interference from nor influence on government, at least as it pertained to their own lives. The only "influence" they wanted, per se, was the influence to make the government leave them alone. Sure, the Vietnam war protest was a popular hippie cause, but only because they didn't want to be drafted to fight it.

All I really want is to be the manager of my own outcome, in its entirety, and in absolutely every sense of the word. If I want to be a charitable Christian, I want to make that choice for myself, not to have someone else make it for me. But don't try to force your desired outcome on others. That's not keeping with the hippie spirit.

You can have all the peace and love you want. Just go smoke a bowl and have an orgy -- and rest assured, I won't do a thing to try to stop you. (Heck, I'll even vote to make smoking weed legal so the government leaves you alone.)

by thechas

Yes Max, I suppose that my concept of utopia does border on socialism.

Even in my youth, I wanted a society free of money, where everyone would be able to get what they needed as they needed it.

I do think it is a very good concept that everyone should give to society all that they are able, and get from society at least all that they need.

The only reason that capitalism fits better with us humans is that we all have some level of greed.

We all want more than our fair share of the Earths resources.
And, with the exception of a few great people, we all are not willing to share all of our talents freely with others.

I admit to being just as greedy as the next man.

I don't want the changes to society that I desire to come by force. I hope that our society will evolve away from the greed that prevents us from achieving all that we are capable of.

Perhaps my 60's commune concept of utopia is incorrect. A better concept would be more in line with that attributed to "The Federation of Planets" in "Star Trek".

For the record, the only mind altering substance I have ever partaken of is chocolate.
I get high enough on life to not need anything more potent.

Chas

by deepsand

You mention the same horizontal dimensions and the drive train.

What about the vertical dimension, their wheel bases, masses, & centers of gravity?

by deepsand

Firstly, Maxwell is correct in that what we wanted was nothing more than to live free of interference from others. In that we were not only idealistic, but quite unrealistic as well. We had not yet accumulated sufficient worldly experiences so as to be able to realize that mankind had not yet advanced to the point where our utopian visions could for long survive, even given a minimally sized commune, with any reasonable degree of certainty.

Nonetheless, ideals are important; they provide goals sufficiently worthy of achievment such that we are induced to reach for them. And, although we are perforce doomed to fail, in having made the effort we have improved the general lot of all.

The dichotomy of ideals vs reality is not unlike that of emotions vs logic. The former is the wind that fills our sails; the latter, the hand upon the tiller of our ship.

So, in this sense, Chas is also right, in that he envisions a future in which mankind, freed of the need to devote his daily energies to providing for his sustanance, will, not unlike the future portrayed in Star Trek:NG, instead be able to turn his attentions to those activities, such as the advancement of knowledge through research and exploration, the arts, etc. - i.e. avocations rather than vocations - which enrich the spirit rather than the body.

Oh, that I should live to see such a time.

May the future be kind.

by maxwell edison

.
Just so you know, Chas and I are of similar age, both having experienced the 60s first hand as well, and as "very aware" adolescents. (I was in high school in the late 60s.)

And You're right, ideals are important. In fact, in my opinion, a life without ideals is simply a life just drifting about like dead leaves in the wind. And if a person wants to convince others to live by and adopt his or her ideals, that's fine as well. But the line is crossed when one person tries to force them on others, especially if the ideals conflict with those of the person on whom they are forced. Freedom of choice means much more to me than just about anything, and I don't want the choices of others forced on me.

And the Star Trek analogy is interesting; but the opinion of this Star Trek enthusiast is that it's similar to seeing the whole world through a key hole. Sure, the societal structure of a crew on a deep space star ship is one thing, but how did a society of billions of people back on 2500 Earth interact?

Quite frankly, I believe that any "ideal" of living as one big happy family, from all according to his ability, to all according to his needs, is not now, nor will it ever be achievable. And to even try is to put yourself on the road to failure. And my ideals will not allow others to make that doomed choice for me.

It was individualism and individual liberty that transformed the United States into a great nation. And it's the collectivism mentality that will destroy it.

by computer dude

"It was individualism and individual liberty that transformed the United States into a great nation. And it's the collectivism mentality that will destroy it."

Dead on.

Chas, first of all, congratulations on freeing the inner liberal. It takes a strong man (wait, that's a contradiction of terms). Who's up for a group hug?

What you describe, however, is communism. Sounds good on paper, no doubt, but look what it did to the USSR. And red China, do we even need to go there?

"Greed" is what has led men to create some of the world's greatest inventions, greatest empires, and greatest civilizations. What has "free love" ever created (other than VD)?

Incidentally, how do you propose that we enfore 'strict gun control'?

And BTW, never, never, never suffer from enforced guilt.

by computer dude

Chas, in your utopian society of free drugs and free love, would rape still be rape? I mean, it's all free, after all.

by jamesrl

The original Hummer H1 is the Humvee. The first models used the same drivetrain, and upgraded the interior. Newer models replace the original deisel with a gas engine. Mind you now there are many variants of the Humvee now.

From the Hummer site http://www.hummer.com.lb/h1specifications.html
Curb Weight 6.814 lb. 7.154 lb.
Payload 3.486 lb. 3.146.
Maximum Towed Load 7.986 lb. 7.646 lb.
Gross Axle Weight Rating
Front: 10.300lb GVWR
Rear: 10.300lb GVWR
4.100 lb.
6.800 lb.
Length 184.5 in.
Maximum Height 77 in. 75 in.
Width (without mirror) 86.5 in.
Wheelbase 130 in.
Ground Clearance 16 in.
Track Width 71.6 in.
Grade Capacity 60%
Side-Slope Capability 40%
Brake-Over Angle 35o
Approach Angle (Without Winch) 72o
Approach Angle (With Winch) 47o
Departure Angle 37.5o
Runflat Capability at 30 MPH 20 mi.
Turning Radius 26.5 ft.

From military vhicle website
http://www.fas.org/man/dod-101/sys/land/m998.htm

Manufacturer: AM General

Dimensions:

Length:
M966 / M998 / M1025 / M1035 / M1043 / M1045 / M1097 - 180"
M1026 / M1036 / M1038 / M1042 / M1044 / M1046 - 185"
M996 / M997 - 202"
Height:
M998 / M1035 / M1037 / M1038 / M1042 - 69"
M966 / M1025 / M1026 / M1036 / M1043 / M1044 / M1045 / M1046 - 73"
M996 - 86"
M997 - 102"
Width: 85"
Vehicle Curb Weight:
M998 / M1035 / M1038 - 7,700 lbs.
M966 / M1025 / M1026 / M1036 - 8,200 lbs.
M1043 / M1044 / M1045 / M1046 - 8,400 lbs.
M966 / M1037 / M1042 - 8,660 lbs.
M997 - 9,100 lbs.
M1097 / M1097A1 - 10,000 lbs.
M998A1 / M1035A1 / M1038A1 - 7,880 lbs.
M966A1 / M1025A1 / M1026A1 - 8,380 lbs.
M1043A1 / M1044A1 / M1045A1 / M1046A1 - 8,580 lbs.
M996A1 - 8,580 lbs.
M997A1 - 9,280 lbs.
Ground Clearance: 16" Loaded

Performance:

Maximum Speed: 55 mph Governed @ Gross Weight
Range: 275 - 337 mi.
Maximum Grade: 60%
Side Slope: 40 deg.
Fording: Without Kit: 30", With Kit: 60"

Equipment Specifications:

Cab: Crew Seating: 2-4 Man
Seat Design: Fore/Aft Adjustable
Steering Type: Power Assist

Engine: Manufacturer: General Motors, Diesel, 8-cyl, 6.5 L, Naturally Aspirated
Rating: 150 hp @ 3600 rpm, EPA-Certified
Fuel: Diesel, DF-2, JP-4, JP-8, VV-F-800
Cooling: Water, Radiator
Fan: Engine-Driven, Clutch Type

Transmission: Manufacturer: Allison, Fully Automatic
Speeds: 3 Speeds Forward/ 1 Reverse

The H2, as I mention in the other post, is a look alike with GM pickup truck parts. The H3, is even less like the HUMVEE.

James

by thechas

It has been stated that the difference between rape and rapture is salesmanship.

Still, rape is not possible in utopia. To force one's self upon another would violate the spiritual aura of both.

As to another comment, many people confuse socialism with communism.
Communism is a perversion of socialism with fascism mixed in.

If you read what I posted closely, I did modify the standard socialism credo.

I look at the social democracies of northern Europe as better examples of what society could be than the USSR or China.

The problem with communist style socialism is that it suppressed the individual.

What transpired in Russia after the breakup of the USSR is an excellent example of free enterprise run amok.

As to gun control:

Eliminate all "assault style" weapons. Not by appearance which the flawed expired legislation did, but by capabilities.

Require all purchasers to take and pass both a gun safety and shooting skills course.

Have a reasonable waiting period with a thorough back ground check.
Perhaps, the longer of 10 days, or when the back ground check is complete.

Go back to requiring a demonstrated need for a concealed weapon carry permit.

Build locking mechanisms into guns. Preferably biometric style.

Chas