Discussion Locked

Survey: Are Big Trucks and SUVs really necessary?

0 helpful
324 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post

324 replies

by davidjohn36

I own a SUV and it is the best vehicle for the snow and ice in New England that I have owned. If the big trucks were gone, most of the goods that you find in the grocery store would not be there. Imagine trying to feed the people in a big city without trucks to bring the food in.
WAKE UP

by antikythera

I don't think he meant that kind of big truck.

As for the original question, SUV's and big trucks have a place and purpose, but I don't think everyone should be driving one around.

by deepsand

we did, and still do, get along just fine without SUVs.

And they call us dumb hicks?

by x-marcap

Some of them buy tiny vehicles.

Even when they can afford more substantial vehicles. They value discretionary spending over safety, or economy. Personally, I see it as false economy. I was rear ended, and physically unable to work . I was driving a Full sized Buick. The person who hit me was driving a Chrysler. We were better off, but I
wish I was driving my '96 Roadmaster.

by x-marcap

And that there were no weapons in the governmental hands, I'd be happier.

The 2nd amendment was intended to be the reset button on the constitution. The problem is that we aren't doing what we should be doing by the constitution itself. We are doing far,far more. I see no reason that taxation without representation like we currently have is just as intolerable as the time of the framers of our constitution. We also are much closer to a police state than was ever anticipated by the writers of the Federalist papers.

by hlhowell9

I don't own one (but I do own a windstar) but for safety, for cargo, for kids and for people who can afford it, they meet a need far better than the Prius, which is just now beginning to see the issues of supplying elecrical power from batteries as the batteries and cables (motors, magnets, switches and circuits) age.

Later fires, perhaps even explosions may ensue until all the bugs are discovered and eliminated.

Japan gave us pathetically designed little cars that are death traps at speeds over 55.

Regards,
Les H

by deepsand

For the vast majority of Americans, SUVs are neither required nor beneficial.

As for your "logic" re. vehicle mass, why not then have everyone drive a tank?

by daniel.muzrall

I own a mid-size pickup (dakota quad cab), which I need to tranport equipment to and from work on a daily basis. It also makes transporting my canoe and mountain bikes a lot easier.

On a related note, I feel that auto manufacturers need to put more effort into designing and building (and hopefully at a reasonable cost) more environmentally friendly engines for trucks and SUVs. While I applaud them for making hybrid and super-efficient engines for small cars, I also look at it and think wouldn't it make more sense to improve the engine for something that gets 9-14 MPG than bumping up a small car from 30 MPG to 40 mpg? That alone would go a long way to reducing petroleum needs (gas, diesel) and emissions.

My 2 cents anyways,

Dan

by bkoch_709

I really think these big trucks should only be bought for ranches, construction, etc. I know so many people with big SUVs or diesel trucks that don't haul anything. A mid size SUV should be able to handle most family loads. The whole "gas guzzler" tax isn't much of a deterrent.

by rkoenn

I can see a few cases where they might be but for most folks it is a status and social thing, SUVs are cool and everyone has one so I need one also. Absolutely no thought to what kind of condition and state of energy usage they are going to leave their kids.

by rclark2

Family of 5. When we bought it we had 2 in carseats. Requires 7 passenger vehicle since two car seats will not fit in most vehicles and allow a third in the middle.

Now they have minivans that allow for 7 passengers. When I bought my SUV they didn't.

My wife was setting in a turn lane waiting for traffic to clear so she could turn off. An older gentleman driving a DodgeRam 1 ton pickup, pulling a 22 foot bayliner hit her doing 55 mph. My oldest daughter suffered a slight bump on the head, my younger daughter didn't get hurt, and my wife only suffered anxiety from worry about my kids. Our vehicle, a Jeep Laradeo had to have the rear frame straightend, the back hatch and glass replaced, and the dents popped out and one quarter panel repainted. By the way, the Dodge Ram wasn't hurt to bad either.

When our 3rd child came along, it was time to move up to an additional seat because in our state, any child under 6 years and 60 pounds must be in a car seat, and any child under 18 must be secured by a shoulder restraint device. So we looked around and the GMC Yukon was our only choice. It has a bench seat in the back with 4 captains chairs in the front. That allowed us to put one car seat in the back, one in the front, and allowed us to load and unload the children without having to crawl in and out. It also allowed us to double up when grandma and grandpa rides with us, or when we have to pick up the extra's at school. (Even if they have to have car seats.)

American life includes sleepovers and bunking parties. Occasionally, we still have to take two vehicles, but that is the price we pay for raising our kids to be active members of the community, with friends, envolved with church activities, school, and youth sports activities.

The reason we have the paradigm of "Soccer Mom" is that it is part of our way of life.

If it is any consolation, my SUV is a small Jeep Liberty Renegade. I don't race it at Baha, but could I think. It only gets 21mpg, but it will go when the power lines are coming down and has 16 inch tires. I carry a double set of tire chains in the winter, and I can go in just about anything.

We live on a hill in rural Arkansas. (So far back in the sticks we still pump sunshine in and moonshine out. ) When it ices, we have to have 4wd to get to work. And we have to go since both my wife and I work at a hospital. Sick people need us even when it's inconvienent to go. So we both drive SUV's and will, no matter what the price of gas. Long before we have to give up our SUV's, the rest of America will have gone to some form of electric cars. Then we will trade our SUV's in for Hummers or whatever the Army is using then.

Yes that means that we will be a menace to the rest of you, and I'm sorry about that. But we drive carefully, and don't run in to many people, yet anyway. So if you hit me and my bad old SUV tears up your little Honda, I'm sorry, but you shouldn't have hit that big white SUV with your little bitty car.

by webbfeet

But what about people who have families,I own a mini van and suv, suv takes five adults and mini van more, I hate the van, but some people use them for work like carry tools and stuff,large trucks also are used for hauling,pulling, etc,,anytime you go to buy something if you had no way of hauling it you would either not buy or pay someone else to haul it for you.. they are not necessary to the ones who do not use them

by tryten

I would like to see someone open a landscaping business without a big truck or SUV.
Better yet have you seen what 4 300 pound people do to the suspention of a Mini, Civic or ANY small car?

by ibanezoo

...becuase to deny them to anyone would be to deny freedom of personal choice.

I personally hate them... but others like them for whatever reason... so....................

by ibanezoo

I live in "The O.C." and it is definately a status symbol here. Nothing but broads yacking on cellphones in their land barges cutting off everyone one and leaving paths of chaos/destruction.... nevermind the fuel consumption.

by rjacobs1

You want to dictate to others how to live?
Then a "NO" means tyranny. Who will enforce it?
You value freedom?
The only possible answer is "YES".

Takes a totalitarian bent of mind to even
ask such a question.

Sheesh.

-----------------------------------------

Democracy is two wolves and a lamb voting on
what to have for lunch.

Liberty is a well-armed lamb contesting the vote.

- Benjamin Franklin

This discussion is closed to new replies.