Survey: Are Big Trucks and SUVs really necessary?
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by deepsand
They were Socialistic. There is a very important difference between the two.
Socialism is controlled by a centralized command structure; communism, a democratic one.
It is important to understand that those we now call the Bolsheviks (the majority) were actually a minority who seized control of the Social Democratic party thru parlimentary trickery, declaring themselves to then be the majority, & stole the revolution by force. The result was the civil war between the Reds & the Whites (after the color of their respective flags), as portrayed in "Doctor Zhivago."
Unfortunately, the Reds won.
==================================================
Main Entry: Bol?she?vik
Pronunciation: 'bOl-sh&-"vik, 'bol-, 'b?l-, -"vEk
Function: noun
Inflected Form(s): plural Bolsheviks also Bol?she?vi?ki /"bOl-sh&-'vi-kE, "bol-, "b?l-, -'vE-kE/
Etymology: Russian bol'shevik, from bol'shii greater
1 : a member of the extremist wing of the Russian Social Democratic party that seized power in Russia by the Revolution of November 1917
==================================================
Main Entry: Men?she?vik
Pronunciation: 'men(t)-sh&-"vik, -"vEk
Function: noun
Inflected Form(s): plural Mensheviks or Men?she?vi?ki /"men(t)-sh&-'vi-kE, -'vE-kE/
Etymology: Russian men'shevik, from men'she less; from their forming the minority group of the party
: a member of a wing of the Russian Social Democratic party before and during the Russian Revolution believing in the gradual achievement of socialism by parliamentary methods in opposition to the Bolsheviks
by deepsand
Correct not all buy due to ergonomics, but I am willing to bet the ease of entry/exit and sitting comfort (ie ergonomics) is a bigger consideration with many more than you realise.
Things may be different in the good old US of A where everything has to be bigger than the rest of the world; but downunder in Australia 95% of the SUVs available do not require you to climb up into them, and most of those that require you to climb up have specially requested boosted suspension. Most have the seats at normal adult arse level, unlike the sedans that have the seats at, or below, knee cap level and require you to drop down into them and climb up out of them..
I meant that the vehicles should be safer to use after the event whilst water and crap was still on the roads. The higher clearance would enable them to go places where other vehicles would get drowned etc.
Only a fool would go out during a hurricane or tornado. And I take my hat off to those brave emergency services fools who do that to save lives.
what else do you need for - at least - the material things?
Neil
by deepsand
by deepsand
.
It is not. That's a silly "assumption".
See:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=170980&messageID=1752552
.
All this crap that's being spewed around here presuming to know other people's intentions is just that -- crap.
SUVs are simply convenient for the people who have them. Having to transport the kids, the kid's friends, the kid's stuff, groceries, and so on, makes an SUV the vehicle of choice for a lot of families.
If the government wouldn't have meddled in the auto industry in the first place, placing unrealistic emissions controls on vehicles -- complete with loopholes, of course -- the family station wagon would have never died.
For the most part, absolutely every SUV owner I know uses it in a manner, and for the same reasons, that made the family station wagon popular in the 50s and 60s. No more, no less.
To those who call it a "status symbol" you simply don't know what you're talking about - get real.
And ALL of you "anti-SUV zealots" are simply judging others in one way or the other. Get off your high-horse, and just live and let live.
by deepsand
Most here are NOT owned by families with kids.
Many here ARE owned by those who are retired.
The vast majority on the roads here are occupied by one person only.
Exceedingly few on the roads here show any signs of bearing cargo.
Very few owners here require 4-wheel drive.
Many here are purchased owing to the perception that they are "safer"; yet,
The vast majority here do NOT know how to properly or safely operate an SUV or any type of 4-wheel drive vehicle.
My observations lead me to conclude that SUVs are not generally purchased as the result of a rational decision making process.
.
If we could agree on my premise, I think I can show where my assertion is much closer to reality than yours; and my premise is this. Advertisers and marketers spend millions of dollars determining the optimal "target audience" for a product. And advertising is targeted to those audiences most inclined to buy the product. That's why you'll see beer, potato chips, and fast food type advertising when you watch a football game, none of which you'll likely see if you watch a day-time soap opera. (Well, maybe you'll see the fast-food, but not the beer.) And to whom are these SUVs marketed? You don't see the SUVs marketed to retired folks, but rather to families "on the go".
But don't take my word for it. Do a little on-line research about the demographics of SUV owners, and prove me wrong.
For example, here's a little something that I found from MarketResearch.com:
".....Perhaps most of all, the rise of the van and SUV market is a measure of the comfort provided by a larger vehicle to American families spending more time in their vehicles, in the commute to work, to school, to leisure activities, and on vacation. Given more time in their vehicles, issues of space and functionality have increased....."
by jamesrl
If its transporting the kids, then a minivan is a better choice - more room and more fuel efficient. I will give you the example of the Toyota Ciena and the Toyota Highlander. Both have the same engines. The Highlander seats 5, the Ciena 7. The Ciena is about 10% more fuel efficient. 10% may not seem like a lot to you, but if we all reduced our consumption by 10% the price would be reduced as would emissions.
Emission controls - I am sorry Max, but I totally disagree. Whether we own a car or not, we all share the same air. In many urban areas, 50% of the pollution comes from automobiles. This in turn directly affects peoples health. In Toronto, the Board of Health estimates that over 1000 people a year die from the negative affects of air pollution. Even if that is an exagerated number, it far supercedes the number of people murdered in Toronto every year(60) and yet we put huge resources into solving those crimes.
I would argue that minivans are the real successors to station wagons.
If driving an SUV had no impact to my life, I would be happy to shut up. But it increases pollution in the air that I breathe(for no good purpose), and drives up the price of gas. That does impact me.
James
When a 4WD/SUV crashes into my little Ford Focus, those nice safety devices - bumpers, crumple zones, seat belts, air bags, side impact beams, etc, becomes totally irrelevant when the SUV slams into my passenger compartment from ANY direction. The conservation of momentum during a collision basically assures that any vehicle of about two tons - such as a medium to large SUV - will get the better of a vehicle averaging about one ton (my Focus). At the immediate collision point, the heavier vehicle will slow down and stop. My Focus will be bounced backward in the direction it came, probably leading to serious head, neck, and chest injuries. At least in the UK I would have the NHS to fund my medical bills.
I accept that heavier cars will cause similar results, although the larger SUVs are considerably heavier than the largest passenger cars. The larger cars still have the crumple zones that would absorb some of the impact.
However, SUVs ride higher than passenger cars and this would result in a misalignment of load paths during a collision. In a frontal collision, the SUV would ride over the bumper and crumple zones of my car and head directly for the passenger compartment at eye level. Every safety device engineers have spent the past decade designing into cars is circumvented! In a side collision, the SUV would tend to override the top edge of the door and once again plough into the passenger compartment at head or chest level.
Check the statistics out for fatalities in car vs SUV or LTV accidents. Who dies most?
How do we deal with this? You said in an earlier post that "When the freedoms enjoyed by one person actually infringes on the rights of another, it's up to the state to protect the rights of that other."
Possibly a levelling out the playing field by reducing the numbers of such "killer" vehicles falls into that category.
No judgement here. I just think that "Live and let live" is pretty inappropriate. "High horse"? Not me.
by deepsand
It has been oft said that one's right to swing his fist ends at the other guy's nose, and rightly so.
And, as the purpose of government is to collectly do that which we cannot do individually, it falls to the government to keep our air clean & our highways safe.
by dr dij
by deepsand
On this side of the pond, escalating gasoline prices have resulted in the sales of new SUVs declining 15%-20% from those of the previous quarter, and lots overflowing with used ones with rapidly declining resale values.
As SUVs account for roughly 1/4 of all vehicle sales, the manufacturers are not amused.
No electrons were harmed in the production & presentation of this message.
by deepsand
.
Okay, so shoot me. I posted it in the wrong place. But either place was the end of the thread, so I started a new one.
It was intended to answer this:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=170980&messageID=1752525
.
Star Trek is science fiction to the extreme. So is a lot of the stuff spewed from the mouths (or fingers) of the anti-SUV zealots.
are there for the taking the moment we get PROPERLY into space rather than the blind alley we wandered down because of the politically inspired race to the Moon - serious rant on US Moon programme on request. There are unlimited resources on the asteroids and Saturns rings and comets for metals, carbon compounds and water.
Food is only Carbon, Hydrogen, Nitrogen and Oxygen with a few trace minerals thrown in for good measure. We can make steaks out of comets with the right molecular synthesisers.
All those stupid sci-fi films with aliens taking over the Earth for raw materials? Bollocks! If they can get into space then they don't need our pitiful little planet or anything at the bottom of its gravity well.
Neil
(Sorry, MAJOR hard sci-fi buff who wants to see some of it come true and thought it had started when the US made it to the Moon. 30 years on and we haven't been back.)
by deepsand
While such a conclusion seems reasonable at first glance, under close examination its veracity comes into question.
Given that it was the LACK OF DEMAND for station wagons that resulted in the severe curtailment of their production, to conclude that the SUV has become its functional successor inplies that there has been a recent dramatic increase in the demand for station wagons to the extent that such far outstrips the supply of same, and that the suppliers have chosen to not increase the supply.
Furthermore, if these assumptions are correct then it also true that the suppliers deliberately decided to meet the demand for the capacity that a station wagon provides with a product that is both more dangerous and costly.
Lastly, that the demographics of BUYERS of SUVs might suggest certain kinds and levels of use, they are not in fact a reliable proxy for the actual USERS of such.
.
You are really one for pulling something out of your (whatever) and spewing it forth as fact, when, in reality, there's no basis in fact at all. (As illustrated in my vehemently disagree message.) And here, you do it yet again.
Of course it was a "LACK OF DEMAND" (your emphasis, not mine) that led to the demise of the family station wagon. But why was there a lack of demand? The reason is twofold. One was the gasoline shortage that resulted in long lines at the pump; and the other was the fact that unreasonable emissions standards forced auto makers to make them smaller and smaller and less powerful. (The same fate met by those fabulous muscle cars.)
Here's an interesting article on the station wagon:
http://www.stationwagon.com/history.html
Prove what you say, or at least back it up with some semblance of factual reality.
by deepsand
All you've done is agree with one of the assumptions that underlie your position, and then claim that it proves me wrong.
You've both failed to refute my statement as to the assumptions inherent in your position, or offer any proof for the said assumptions.
And, ad hominem arguments will hold no sway with me.
by thechas
Neither emission standards nor fuel economy killed off the traditional station wagon.
Smaller families and the invention of the mini-van is what lead to the demise of the station wagon.
The SUV is nothing more than a mini-van on steroids.
A "macho" man does not want to be seen driving a family sedan, mini-van, or station wagon!
Instead, to appease his macho ego, he goes out and wantonly disregards the environment and common sense by buying an over sized overpowered vehicle.
For nearly everyone I have talked to, the choice of which vehicle to buy is based on emotion and instant gratification. NOT a logical review of their vehicle needs.
I did rethink my $5000 per SUV excise tax concept. The emotional reaction of the SUV buyer would cause them to not hesitate to pay any extra fee or tax.
A much better way to limit the oversize vehicle market would be to require a speed governor in every vehicle.
Those that get more than 1/2 of the current CAFE standard would be limited to 80 MPH.
Those that get less than 1/2 of the CAFE mileage would be limited to 60 MPH.
Watch how fast the "macho" man moves to a more fuel efficient vehicle to feed his need to speed.
Chas
.
The mini-van was created as a result of the need that was begging to be filled because the auto makers were forced to "down-size" the station wagon. If you consider the time-line, the station wagon pretty much died in the mid 70s. The mini-van started to come onto the scene in the early to mid 80s. There was probably a 5-10 year gap in-between for the need to percolate.
The need (real or perceived) always comes before the product, not the other way around. (At least generally speaking. There are, after all, the occasional "pet rocks".)
Marketing basics:
Find a need and fill it.
Or
Build a better mousetrap, and they will beat a path to your door.
Not:
Build it and they will come; that only happens in fields of dreams.
by deepsand
"Tim, the Toolman."
For some, it's machismo, with SUVs being the new "Muscle Cars."
And for others, it's the adult version of playing at being "GI Joe."
.
...is that as opposed to a girlie-man?
.
You said, "the purpose of government is to collectively do that which we cannot do individually." How strongly can I disagree with that? The purpose of government, at least the US government, is to protect and guarantee the rights of the individual.
By what authority do you think the US government presumes to "collectively do" anything? Okay, put the same question to me. By what authority do I think the US government presumes to protect and guarantee the rights of the individual? My answer is the U.S. Constitution. What's your answer?
The only "common" anything mentioned in the US Constitution is to provide for the "common" defense. And "collective" or "collectively" is never mentioned, while "individual" (the people) is often repeated. And the Tenth Amendment clearly states, "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the states, are reserved to the states respectively, or to the people." That means if it's not spelled out specifically in the Constitution, it's the individual rights that trump all else.
The USA, by design, is an individualist nation, not a collectivist nation.
(By the way, I really hate debating domestic US issues with those who live elsewhere. First of all, the issue is usually none of their business. Second of all, very few of them either understand or agree with our particular form of government, whereas the people grant rights (or give up individual right) to the government, not the other way around, as usually is the case in their own country.)
by deepsand
Read the Commerce Claus.
The States too are Sovereigns, each with its own Constitution and its own Rights. Furthermore, the peoples of each are free to request that their respective States to collectively protect them from the actions of others, both within and without, in matter where they cannot individually do so.
Lastly, I would suggest that you read some of the letters of the time re. the principles of government as held by those who gave us our Federal & State Constitutions.
.
I have indeed read the early papers. I've probably read the Federalist Papers several times over, as well as Paine, Franklin, Jefferson, Adams and Madison letters and/or biographies. I'm absolutely certain that I'm much better read on the subject than you. (Of course I can't prove it. It's just a sneaking suspicion.)
Go ahead, find the "collectivist" clauses in the papers you mention. Find reference to "collectivism". (And don't ask me to prove something that's not there. It's up to YOU to prove that it is there.)
.
State Constitutions are also structured the same way the U.S. Constitution is, in that powers are granted to the state by the people, not the other way around. If you want to try to cite a particular state constitution that doesn't, knock yourself out. Go ahead and post it. (And I should assume by your post that you consider as legitimate those state constitutions that ban gay marriage. Glad to hear it.)
.
Collectivist-Type thinkers never use the early writings of the founders as support for their position. Why? Because it's not there.
Are you for real?
Go ahead, find the "collectivism" sentiments in the writings.
by deepsand
My point is that one's rights end at the point they infringe on the rights of others.
The Constitution does NOT give anyone unfettered rights, only limited ones.
by deepsand
As you may recall from other discussions, I attended the USNA; it was not my first choice.
I had been accepted to MIT, but applied much to late to get any of the meager finacial assistance then available to those who were not residents of Massachusetts. I alos had a full scholarship to Penn State, and a competitive congressional appointment to the Naval Academy.
Lacking the funds required for MIT, I opted for USNA, with the intention of opting for Naval Aviation, with the hopes of becoming a test pilot, thereby gaining access to what was then the only entry point into the corp of astronauts. I was ever so disappointed when, owing to the vision in my right eye being but 20-25, I was disqualified from flying jets; multi-props only for me.
Like you, I had expected that by now man would have colonized the Moon. So, for some time I continued to hold onto my dream of someday venturing into space.
I've since consigned that dream to the dustbin of enrealistic expectations.
Still, one can hope.
by deepsand
From experience, I can tell you that as a lot they are rather unconcerned with, if not oblivious to, realities.
They ARE convinced that they can divine the hidden & pent up demand that only they can tap.
.
You said, "All you've done is agree with one of the assumptions that underlie your position, and then claim that it proves me wrong".
That's exactly what you've done, deepsand. The difference, however, is that I've included some support for my assertion, while you've offered no support whatsoever. Now granted, my support wasn't the most technical, but it did have some semblance of legitimacy as a research paper on the subject. Certainly better than your pie-in-the-sky and hollow claims. Can't you offer at least something as support? (I didn't think so.)
Believe whatever you want. You can even believe in the tooth-fairy, for all I care.
by deepsand
Max, at no time have I impugned either your rational for wanting to drive an SUV or your driving skills & habits.
Stop taking my general observations as being personally directed at you.
by deepsand
"Collectivism?" Your term, not mine.
Just what do you hold is the purpose of government?
by deepsand
Constitutions based on Common Law do in fact take the form you note; and, I've said nothing to the contrary.
Those based on Codified Law, however, are different, in that Codified Law attempts to address every conceivable issue that may be of concern in advance.
Roughly speaking, Common Law can be thought of as being of the form "that which is not forbidden is permitted," whereas Codified Law is of the form "that which is not permitted is forbidden."
As for gay marriage, I've made no statement that would support your assumption.
by deepsand
by deepsand
I've made general statements based on my personal observations of the habits of drivers in that area of the country which is home to over one-quarter of the population of the US. That this empirical data may not support your contention, or may not hold true at your location, does not serve to invalidate it.
The data which you offered up is about buyers, when in fact the issue is the drivers. The two are not one and the same, and the former does serve as a faithful proxy for the latter.
Furthermore, you claimed that the SUV was the successor to the station wagon, while failing to offer any proof of such.
And, you've failed to address the logical conclusions that can be deduced from said position.
.
You said, "Stop taking my general observations as being personally directed at you."
First of all, I wasn't taking anyone's observations as being personally directed at me. I was just wondering what the alternative to a "macho man" was. (Perhaps a girlie man, I suggested.)
Second of all, I wasn't replying to your message. I was replying to Chas's message and his use of "macho" man. That's why it was directly under his as a reply, and not under yours. (If we reach the end of a thread, which we didn't, I would have addressed a message to you, as I did in this case.)
Geesh, stop taking my specific observations made to others as being personally directed at you.
by thechas
Sorry Max, if you take a close look at how the US automakers develop and market cars, they do follow the build it and they will come model.
Just look at 3 cars that made major impacts:
1964 Mustang
Dodge Caravan
Ford Explorer
All 3 had no defined market when they were introduced.
All 3 were nearly quashed by upper management as a waste of time and effort.
All 3 had a major impact on what the US public drove.
All 3 only made it to market because they had a person with a dream behind them.
When a new idea makes it to market and catches on, the other 2 manufactures follow suite with similar offerings. That is the closest the big 3 come to allowing market forces to influence design.
What killed off the full size station wagon and the basic full size sedan was market forces. Not government regulations.
In the late 70's and early 80's, we had both stag-flation and the children of Earth Day coming of age.
When they bought their first cars, gas mileage and low pollution were priorities.
Many took career paths following their passion for the environment that did not pay enough to buy and feed a full size car.
Couple that with smaller family size and delaying starting a family until in their 30's, and the market for the full size car disappeared.
By the way, up until just a few years ago, you could still buy a full size Chevy station wagon.
The US automakers only do well when the US public desires the type of vehicle that they wish to build.
GM in particular is almost arrogant in what they wish to build.
One need only look at the Chevy Vega (GM's response to Japanese imports) to see just how true this is.
Part of the problem is that most of the design engineers in the US auto industry have a passion for cars. (not that that in itself is bad)
Designing a big powerful car is looked on as a plum assignment.
Working on an affordable small car is looked upon as punishment. Possibly even a career limiting assignment.
For that matter, look at nearly any successful product. Most are discovered and developed by accident. Scotch Guard and the Post-It note are prime examples.
Market forces do drive supply and demand.
Market forces are a poor source of new product development.
Chas
by thechas
Arnold's "Girlie-man" remark was designed to belittle the California Democrats who were not willing to go along with gutting state programs to balance the budget.
My "Macho-Man" is a (predominantly US) male who is so insecure about his manly persona that he cannot do anything that would be perceived as less than manly.
In the context of this thread, an appropriate description of a "Macho-Man" would be a man who lives near L.A. with his small family. He drives his SUV alone on his 30 mile 2 hour commute back and forth to work.
His SUV never goes off-road, never tows a trailer, never hauls a load.
He bought his SUV because his buddies would harass him as being feminine if he drove a mini-van.
His choices in products and entertainment are carefully chosen to maintain and improve his position in the social pecking order of his "friends".
His primary research for cars, gas grills and tools is to find something bigger and more powerful than his buddies have.
Chas
Hey! Hey! Hey, hey, hey!
Macho, macho man
You've got to be, a macho man
Macho, macho man
You've got to be a macho! (all right)
Macho, macho man (yeah, yeah)
You've got to be, a macho man
Macho, macho man
I've got to be a macho! All Right!
Ugh! Macho..baby!
Body, body, body wanna feel my body,
Body, body, body gonna thrill my body,
Body, body, body don'tcha stop my body,
Body, body, body it's so hot my body,
Every man ought to be a macho macho man,
To live a life of freedom, machos make a stand,
Have their own life style and ideals,
Possess the strength and confidence, life's a steal,
You can best believe that he's a macho man
He's a special person in anybody's land.
Hey! Hey! Hey, hey, hey!
.
Of course there was a defined market for those vehicles. There weren't people clamoring and being persistent about specifically wanting a Mustang, of course, but there sure was a defined and targeted market.
There was intensive market research done in the early 60s. Lee Iaccoca, himself, described the market demographics as "a market in search of a car" as the primary driving force behind the Mustang's creation. Market research indicated that the automobile buyer wanted a sporty alternative to the Ford Falcon or Chevrolet Corvair. The Ford Mustang was created to fill a need (or a want) in the market that was already there. The mini-van was no diffferent (another one of Lee Iaccoca's successes); and the SUV is no different.
You should read Lee Iaccoca's book. He discusses this in great length.
by thechas
All 3 vehicles were perceived as catering to niche markets much smaller than they ended up achieving.
The most market researched car of all time was one of the biggest flops. Remember the Edsel?
GM in particular makes product decisions based more on internal politics than the market. One example is the Pontiac Fiero. It was killed off because it was perceived as a threat to the Corvette.
I suspect that the next GM brand to disappear will be Saturn. Not because there is not a market for a US brand small car, but because GM has no real interest in making small cars.
Chas
by ismgr
by deepsand
by jmgarvin
That is the crux of the problem. What do we do about smokers? What do we do about those that drive a SUV/Truck that don't need one? What do we do with those that wish to kill themselves?
Lots of questions and no good answers because at some point you infringe on their rights as much as they infringe on yours.
.
"Your rights end at the point they infringe on those of others."
I've said that many times myself.
That's why it's wrong for the government to take a dollar from the person who earned it only to give it to a person who did not. The "right" of the person to keep his own property (money) trumps any other argument.
So I can assume that you agree with me that absolutely every transfer of wealth social program is wrong since it infringes on the rights of people who want to keep their own property.
And my right to own an SUV should also trump your right, or better described as a desire, to prevent me from owning one.
.
When you asked, "Just what do you hold is the purpose of government?", you showed that you apparently don't read my messages. I answered that question here:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=170980&messageID=1753324
But here's the answer again:
You said, "the purpose of government is to collectively do that which we cannot do individually." How strongly can I disagree with that? The purpose of government, at least the US government, is to protect and guarantee the rights of the individual.
By the way, when you said that collectivism was my term and not yours, you are again mistaken. I got that word from YOUR very own message in which you said, "the purpose of government is to collectively do that which we cannot do individually".
Are you playing games, or is your retention level at about a zero? When you can't remember what I said, I could attribute it to simply not reading, but when you can't remember what YOU said.........Geesh.
.
What words am I putting in your mouth? Collectivism? You said it. Do I need to point to it again?
when hit by an SUV or LTV.
So, if everyone has an SUV, don't you think that those urban drivers who regard an SUV as a status symbol would go for something BIGGER or more powerful? Then off we go again.
I'm going to buy a Ferret Mk 4, good British car. 4 tons, armour to .30 calibre, 6mpg off-road and a creditable 9mpg on-road (thats 8mpg US). Crumple-zone? No, that's the other vehicle.
:D
by dr dij
short story where supreme court in US declares the police can't protect everyone all the time so is OK to have arms on the road; story is about fellow in Pasadena who gets his car ready to cut down thru San Clemente on Fwy to SD, and had 'previous trouble' where armored car took out his friend.
Starts off with his 'mechanic' (actually armorer). YOu can imagine the rest. Total gas. Esp since I live in the greater LA area.
So we might have a car size race, assuming people want to hit each other; pretty soon everyone will be driving Damnation Alley size tank trucks. (I guess all the water in the movie came from the oceans overflowing from global warming)
So, if someone wants to buy and own one of these vehicles, whats the problem? Let them have freedom of choice as long as there is an auto manufacturer willing to manufacture these vehicles. It is their choice to pay for them and to pay for the extra gasoline it takes to run them.
BTW: I do not own a "macho" car, I have a 4 cylinder Saturn SL2.
by dr dij
the Toyota Highlander SUV gets 30MPG.
And probably made in america.
they'll overtake GM in next two years.
by deepsand
If you will read my prior posts re. the drivers of SUVs, you'll have your answer.
Were it the case that their behavior on the road affects no one but themselves, I've have no issue with their presence there. However, such is far from the case.
by deepsand
I decline to accept your misuse of "collectivism" as defining my position. See definition below.
Furthermore, you've failed to state your position re. the proper role of government.
Main Entry: col?lec?tiv?ism
Pronunciation: k&-'lek-ti-"vi-z&m
Function: noun
: a political or economic theory advocating collective control especially over production and distribution; also : a system marked by such control
by deepsand
Main Entry: col?lec?tiv?ism
Pronunciation: k&-'lek-ti-"vi-z&m
Function: noun
: a political or economic theory advocating collective control especially over production and distribution; also : a system marked by such control
by deepsand
not the station wagon.
The SUV provides proportionally less cargo space, human or otherwise, than does either a station wagon or a mini-van, at a much lower fuel efficiency than either.
Like many products, vehicles are designed & marketed to maximize profits, not utilitarian value to the customer.
NO. Speaking of the urban class here. Rural people who feed us and tradespeople use trucks for work, that's different. Another exception is a larger family. If you've got a 5 person family, a minivan may be the way to go. The topic is SUVs, but the often get lumped together.
I have a 91 4-door 5speed 4x4 drive suzuki sidekick 10km/l city, 14 hiway. Still runs great and reliable on 273,000 KMs. It goes to about 130-140km with an 8 valve 1.6 litre. That's pretty good for a SUV compared to those new hybrids that get 24 km/l and I could never sit in (I think, never tried).
I'm 6-4 300lbs. One sits normally and comfortably. You're out of the cornea burning headlights and glare 3 feet above road level.
4x4 city: No problems hilly city snowed roads even on really old tires. Not tippy with new large AT tires. Goes any and everywhere.
You don't need the supply line of the US 8th mech infantry division and a Project Managers' salary to procure fuel. One 40 litre tank will get you 320KM in 4-low, over 500-600KM in 2-high.
You may want the big SUV for psychological and social status issues.
You need the big SUV if you will spend your driving time:
-on the cell, blackerry, PDA, personal grooming,
-watching TV and generally do anything but pay attention to your driving.
Then the big SUV is then mandatory to protect you when other vehicles fail to evade you hurtle at them:
-driving through red lights,
-driving on the wrong side of the road,
-cutting across multiple lanes of traffic
-cutting them off
-hammering down, set ram course to express your indignation at the person in front for not pulling over to yield their place in line to you.
by deepsand
Funny how so many of the older vehicles are so much more fuel efficient than their successors.
My 1962 Chevy, 6 cyl., 3 speed manual trans., which got 26-27 mpg in town, and 30+ mpg in the open, would be today envied by many for its thrift. And, it carried 6 in relative comfort, with a large trunk to boot.
I forgot about all the six cylinders that we didn't care about as we lusted after the V8s, most were in the high 20-to mid 30mpg's as you say. Some of the older Broncos were supposed to be good.
I like my "zook". It's my first 4x4 and first suzuki but third japanese 1.6 liter. I had an 83 toyota corolla with similar mileage and an older totota crown. The cars were carburetted, the zook's EFI witha computer that only handles fuel. Toyota and Suzuki did it right by the 1.6
I've got a neighbour who hunts and 4x4's blew his clutch (familiar stories-it's not uncommon to see logging roads littered with with guys who try to go straight through curves or imitate tumbleweeds) Anyway, he gets his buck and we tie it up on top of my zook with it's tongue hanging out. It looks like one of those perfect "bad day at the office" shots. If you like I'll send it to you.
I'm be inclined to have this motor rebuilt when the time comes, isn't showing signs. I hear too many horror stories of $50,000 dollar cars, $1,000 dollar a year warranty maintenance contracts and people still being shoved non-warranty covered repair bills especially on VW and domestic product - not to mention reliability.
What are you driving now?
by deepsand
I had to give up my '81 Datsun 310 wagon. The drive train was in excellent condition, but the body finally fell apart, owing to the massive amounts of salt on the roads here during the winters.
My favorite 4WD vehicle was a '58 Willeys Jeep wagon; gas mileage was crappy, but it was a ball to drive & handled exceedingly well.
The great thing about the old straight 6's was that they were so easy to work on; open drive shafts with plenty of space under the hood. Need to replace the clutch plate and/or throw-out bearing? No problem; do it yourself in less than 2 hours, with time for a couple of cigarette breaks.
by andrej
by anykey???
In some cases they are necessary.
My biggest problem with them is that they have become a status symbol.
The chevy S10 blazer really started off this whole debate way back in the early 80's, actually if you want to go further back, international, willys, and gm have been producing an "SUV" for a very long time.
The S10 blazer was filling a niche in the market where people needed the extra seats of a minivan and the functionality of the S10 pickup because of terrain,or weather but they did not need the size or lack of seats associated with regular pickups or other fullsize options.
I absolutely despise the term "SUV",I despise what the american car buyer have done to that market.
The "SUV" market is packed full of truck wannabes because the more affluent buyers demand a soft ride,low step in height,all kinds of electronic garbage,push button automatic everything,leather this and heated that, all of this crap makes me sick.
SUVs are turning into station wagons right before their eyes, because they demand what a wagon can offer but refuse to buy one.
This mentality has even invaded my beloved fullsize truck market, it is a GODD@MN truck, if you want a GODD@MN cadillac go see you local cadillac dealer.
I have owned fullsized v8 powered trucks from just about every american manufacturer to ever build a truck.I currently own a 99 1 ton 4x4 that makes almost 14 mpg and that is better than every other heavy duty pickup that I have owned.
I had to buy it used because I cannot afford to go order a new truck without all the power option garbage that I do not need,apparently americans are now so weak that they can no longer roll down a window without an electric motor helping them.
I drive my truck because, I use my truck, not all the time but I do use it for it's intended purpose,unlike most of the people that demand their a truck be more like a caddy.
I also drove my truck close to 400 miles a week until the price of fuel leveled off at $2.00 or more per gallon.
I would rather feed my kids than spend $75 dollars a week on fuel.
The argument that the high horsepower engines pollute more is horsesh!t,they are making more power through efficiency. An internal combustion engine is nothing more than an air compressor,the better it breathes the better it burns the fuel,more efficient combustion leads to less pollution and more power so don't try that crap with me.
I do agree that most "SUVs" are not used as intended which is sad, but that is their choice not mine.
That statement raises a good point,the "SUV" market is so overpriced that people buy 1 vehicle to serve as a daily driver,tow vehicle,family truckster,and whatever else,because they cannot afford to buy or rent multiple vehicles to serve all purposes.
The fuel mileage on most "SUVs" is better than most mid sized cars of 15 years ago,and the mini"SUV" is a great compromise between econobox and "SUV" but might not fill all your needs,and the choice is still theirs, but they need think about that before dropping 40 large on an overpriced STATION WAGON.
By the way if some envirowacko ever confronted me about my truck,I would take my fur coat out of my TRUCK, pull it over his head, grab my wooden stick, and beat him like a baby seal,
Why, you ask.
BECAUSE IT'S MY CHOICE
by deepsand
The current SUVs are successors of the Jeep.
However, to say that the Willeys Jeep wagons were SUVs is a stretch. While they certainly utilitarian, and were used by hunters & fishermen who did more than road hunt/fish, they were far from sporty.
If you review my other posts here, I think that you will find that we concur re. their now being mainly status symbols, operated, for the most part, by the unskilled and/or unthinking.
by anykey???
if you ask me.
The problem with saying the JEEP started the "SUV"market is, that it never gets lumped in with the rest of them, it is almost in a class by itself.
The S10 blazer is probably the vehicle that started the current trend,it did the same thing for the "SUV" market that the chrysler minivan did for that market
I absolutely agree with you opinion about most people that drive "SUVs".
I was in shipping and receiving before coming to IT,and if you talk to a career trucker he will tell you,when the snow flies the median strip becomes littered with "SUVs" because of untrained drivers.
New "SUV" buyers should be offered an offroad driving course just like new ATV buyers(they paid me to take one)just to get them familiar with operating a large vehicle in less than ideal conditions.
I have lived in rural Indiana all my life,and learning to flog a big 4x4 is a right of passage where I come from.The first time it snowed the year i got my license, dad took my out to an open lot, and taught me how to control a vehicle that seemed to be out of control. That type of training should accompany any new "SUV" purchase
When I was 17 I owned a 3/4 ton 4x4 suburban with 38" tires. When it rained or snowed I would find a big open parking lot and nail the GO pedal,once the back tires started spinnning I could turn that truck completely sideways and drive it like that.The things I could do with that truck even impressed the officer that ticketed my a couple of times(because he said so).
You put a city dwelling "SUV" owner in my truck when there is snow on the ground and I'll make him crap his pants within 10 minutes, but once he learns that kind of control he will no longer be danger to others on the road.
by rhenrys
by jmgarvin
I have a 4 door Toyota Tacoma. I didn't want an SUV as the back has a camper...I need an open bed.
I'm restoring a 1970 Bug, so I need a bed that can take some abuse. I also need to haul stuff around (like the brand spanking 42" LCD TV I'm picking up in a couple of weeks.) Not to mention that camping, driving to certain places in New Mexico, and just getting "stuff" from point A to point B would be impossible with out a truck.
While some in the US don't use their vehicle for anything more than a status symbol, some of us actually use them for what they are made for...
Plus, I'm doing my part for the environment...my other car gets 35mpg (and the Bug gets about 30mpg).
by deepsand
As i've noted elsewhere here, based on my voluminous observations during my travels in the Eastern Megalopolis, the vast majority of SUVs on the road are greatly underutilized, and are driven by those who are wholly unskilled in their operation to the extent that they represent a clear and present danger to all others on the road.
In short, for most they are but a status symbol.
by jmgarvin
Today I saw a lowered dually. What is the point of that!!?? I mean, come on.
I also have noticed that the "SUV" is not really more than a Sports 4 wheel drive Vehicle. People do try to drive them like sports cars and they tend to not use them for anything but hauling wet ware (usually at most only one plus driver).
While most people in New Mexico need a truck/SUV, there are those that don't know that they are getting into. What really kills me are the folks that bought into the H2. My Bug does better off road than a H2. Arrggg!! I just wish they'd bring back the contractor license scheme for large trucks and not sell mid-size trucks without a IQ permit ;-)
by deepsand
compromise is the best solution.
Unfortunately, people generally seem to be becoming less and less willing to so do.
by deepsand
1) When I return to central PA, where I grew up, which is mountainous, with large farmed valleys, I consistently see that those who might have use for 4WD vehicles don't; and, that the SUVs are driven by the wealthier urbanites.
2) During winters here, the medial strips, etal. are littered with SUVs!
by jmgarvin
It is pretty sad that my little Bug doesn't get stuck, but some soccer mom in her Cadillac Mosteraide is on the side of the road STUCK.
'Course the same lady was chatting on her cell phone, sipping on Starbucks and putting on makeup.
by deepsand
by itgirli
by deepsand
I take no issue with you in that regard. Big, little, 2wd, 4wd, etc. all too many drivers live in their own little worlds once they enter the cockpit of their craft of choice.
However, it is my overwhelming experience, from many miles & hours on the highways of the Eastern Megalopolis, that the majority of SUV drivers (as opposed to owners) fall into 2 classes.
One is overwhelmed by their vehicle, and drives with undue timerity. The other is so certain of both the abilities of the vehicle & their driving skills that they drive in an exceedingly aggressive manner.
I have personally been the victim or near victim of the latter far too many times, with the accident reports, repair bills & insurance claims to prove it.
by deepsand
.
What a stupid thing to say. Just because you say it's logically flawed, doesn't mean it is. Moreover, it's logic that not only contributed to the creation of the USA, but worked just fine for 160 years before Roosevelt started screwing it up.
by deepsand
by deepsand
The SUVs merely succeeded the Jeep.
I wholehardedly concur re. mandatory training for SUV drivers. Hell, even the old Willeys wagons, which had a much lower center of gravity than do today's SUVs, still required some "training" time.
I've elsewhere noted that I too see the bodies of SUVs all over the place during winter. It's funny to see the Yuppies ranting & raving by the road sides.
by jamesrl
I would refer you to http://www.snopes.com/autos/law/airstrip.asp
This one is fairly commonly passed on.
On alt.folklore.urban newsgroup this one has been extensively discussed, and the newsgroup includes some ex military and NASA pilots, the problem is really simple. Planes need to land near fuel, mechanics tools and parts. Most military aircraft require many many hours of maintenance per hour of flying time.
James
by kevaburg
by absolutely
by teapotty
by x-marcap
by teapotty
by ytvette
by sumjay
It all depends. It could be a Yes or a No.
Give me a break. We don't live in a Ford T Model era. We have plenty of choices.
In winter my AWD Toyota Highlander does a beatiful job of taking me safely up a hill to my home and also gives me around 30mpg - which is higher than many cars. On long highway trips it is as economical as a Toyota Camry. Carrying stuff from Home Depot or Costco is a breeze as it does not strain my back. In winter I also use snow tires which do help a lot. Summer I use the All Season Radials which are less noisy.
Recently, as the gas prices have escalated to a level which is somewhat breaking a tolerable ceiling, specially in Canada where prices are closer to $4 per gallon. I decided to try out a Smart car in a showroom. Man my knees alomost hit my stomach/chin. This baby is cute but good only for 2 grocery bags and very short trips around town, even it gives around 40 mpg. It may be good as a second car. I believe it is coming to the States soon. It may be great for NY city. It look like a Golf Cart to me.
by nitra matsoc
We are free to choose whatever we like. Our choices are influenced by our preferences, if we prefer to drive around with a bus or large truck and are willing to pay the cost, so be it. But we should also keep in mind that the cost ist not only the price of the vehicle, insurance and gas.
If the gas would be at $5.- a galon, like in Europe, our preferences might be different and we might choose the little european cars.
What other reason should there be that there are only a few SUVs and Trucks in Europe and so many over here?
by x-marcap
Sort by Trending