Ten words or less: "Windows Vista is. . ."
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Desktop
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by damian205
place weren't you ?
LOL
by damian205
by apotheon
"[i]even if the installer is good there is still usually a need to do command line stuff[/i]"
Not really. Try out distros like Ubuntu, Mandriva, MEPIS, Knoppix, and Xandros some time. While we're at it, RHEL is pretty much designed specifically to let pseudo-admins do all their pseudo-admin tasks from the GUI.
"[i]I deal with Windows on a day to day basis and see the impossibility of persuading the majority of users to switch any time soon.[/i]"
Now, that's something I can agree with -- unfortunately. I could do with the elimination of an intellectual protectionism based, monopolistic empire.
for windows. I deal with it every day too.
I've also developed under DOS, linux, unix, vms and hp mpe xl as well.
The crap I have to put up with due to MS's business practices is in my opinion wholly unacceptable.
Just been looking at using SQL 2005 as our backend and even after all the tips and tricks we can find, it's four times slower than 2000. MS Progress again eh ?
Every new product, new problems, old problems re-appearing, old solutions breaking, patch instability, interoperability failures, version incompatibilities and all down to their quest fro the super duper all things to all men application masquerading as an operating system.
by damian205
I see where your coming from but I suspect that your end user and mine are different animals. I may be wrong but I think it likely that you support large organisations with fairly standard desktops with preinstalled software. The users in these circumstances rarely do see the installers and would be perfect for conversion to Linux. Granny however is not as helpless as you describe. My customer base is almost exclusively home users. She may not always be IT literate but she can and will follow instructions tha say," Cant hear this, then click here to install whatever". This is both a blessing and a curse. She may get Realplayer or whatever to install and play in Windows with very little effort but equally she may get viruses and spyware. In linux she is unlikely to get either virus or spyware but she wont get realplayer either. Now Granny may get viruses and the sad truth is she doesn't care much either. She does care about listening to whatever. Now you may argue that Windows also have different drivers for different OS's and this is true but because of the amount of money MS throw at advertising most (but not all) users know what they have got and can choose the correct version for them. Even if they had Linux installed from scratch on a new PC with almost every thing sorted and working, there always comes a time when they want something else. They buy a digital camera which works out of the box cos Linux sees it as a simple removable drive. If they are using Ubuntu they know that they are using Ubuntu in just the same way that an XP users knows they are using XP. But what they won't know is do they download rpm or deb, do they need to compile anything or not. It is obvious that selling more boxes with Linux installed would increase both understanding and awareness and increase the number people who can help Granny if she gets stuck. I am not arguing that a universal installer is the cure all that will help displace MS, just one of the things that would help.
As for free software, many end users may not buy Software Development Times but they do buy PC Active, PC World etc. Sometime its just to use the simple how to's that are often published but they do read the whole magazine. Now Linux is making itself more know in the public consciousness there will always be some adventuress souls who give it a go. Some with a live CD and some with an install. Some will stick with it and learn but many will give up. These ones who give up are the problem. They tell others and bad news always spreads faster than good. I agree that it is not the fault of Linux that drivers are absent and that manufactures hold the key to this. Unfortunately the idea of open sourcing their work is anathema to their working practices and of course many distros will not accept any thing else. I don't share that view but it doesn't stop it being prevalent.
I certainly do not subscribe to no-choices single distro Linux eco-system. I simply believe that one of the things that would help achieve critical mass in Linux usage is a certain degree of inter-operablity between distros to ease the job of software developers and thereby making it easier for the eventual user.
As I have said elsewhere I may sound like a MS fan but I actually use Mandriva as my distro of choice and prefer Opera over Firefox. I also pay Mandriva for their product as I believe that we as a community should put our money where our mouth is.
by apotheon
"Nolite te bastardes carborundorum" isn't proper Latin. I'm pretty sure "bastardes" isn't a real word, and "carborundorum" is a backformation from an abrasive material trademark.
The same sentiment, in more accurate latin, seems to be something like "Noli nothis permittere te terere."
by apotheon
by apotheon
If that was all I wanted, I would have remained at the Wikimedia Foundation, where I was also working with Linux (for instance). I make more money now.
Your ridiculous implications about what is and is not profitable seem to be entirely baseless.
by apotheon
"[i]I think it likely that you support large organisations with fairly standard desktops with preinstalled software.[/i]"
I worked for the Wikimedia Foundation for a while. That didn't involve direct support of end-users, though. I've worked full-time for small corporations. I've done consulting and contract work for everything from private individuals to decent-sized public corporations. Now you know.
I've supported a lot of home users. They called me because:
A) the warranty was up on their Dells (or whatever) and something wasn't working
B) they tried to install/upgrade Windows (and failed)
Home users who install their own Windows systems from scratch don't tend to hire me to support their systems when they have problems. I'm frankly surprised that you have had contradictory experience.
As for software installation: GUI software management tools are increasingly common on Linux desktop systems. In particular, SuSE has YaST2 (and has had it for a few years now), and pretty much every desktop Debian system under the sun has Synaptic now (which, frankly, is better than YaST2, in my opinion -- probably because it's built on a better back-end). It's a point-and-click interface, and you might be surprised to discover that MPlayer for Linux will play RealMedia files (as well as WMV, et cetera).
Granted, it's not quite as easy to deal with closed-source, proprietary software as with Windows. That's a hurdle yet to be completely overcome, and the reason for it is that vendors of closed-source, proprietary software that targets home end-users focus on the Windows platform. It's thus not all roses. Given time, however, it's looking like the closed source software market will continue to dry up.
"[i]But what they won't know is do they download rpm or deb[/i]"
Neither. They use the package manager. The end user need never know what type of package he or she is installing.
"[i]Now Linux is making itself more know in the public consciousness there will always be some adventuress souls who give it a go. Some with a live CD and some with an install. Some will stick with it and learn but many will give up.[/i]"
Try this on for size: If Linux were the norm, and Windows -- exactly as it is -- were being distributed with magazines, I'm sure you'd get exactly the same in reverse, despite the "unified" installer interface. Some people would try it, a few would stick with it, many would give it up. It's not the fact that the installer differs from one distro to another that makes them give up. It's the fact that people have problems with OS installs. That's it.
"[i]Unfortunately the idea of open sourcing their work is anathema to their working practices and of course many distros will not accept any thing else.[/i]"
Some distros will not accept -- many [b]CANNOT[/b] because they can't afford the legal headaches. Generally, only individuals or corporate distribution vendors can avoid unpleasant legal ambiguities by including closed source software.
"[i]I simply believe that one of the things that would help achieve critical mass in Linux usage is a certain degree of inter-operablity between distros to ease the job of software developers and thereby making it easier for the eventual user.[/i]"
There's already a heck of a lot of interoperability between distros. In fact, from a developer's point of view, there's greater interoperability between Fedora and Debian than between Windows XP and Windows 98 (or ME).
The common belief that Linux lacks marketshare on the desktop because of "fragmentation" is largely poppycock. There are other factors at work, and if there's really any "fragmentation" at work in keeping Linux out of a greater marketshare, the notion that its effect is greater than the incompatibility issues between Windows versions and MS application versions is definitely up for argument.
by apotheon
I hadn't thought about it before, largely because there's a pretty limited range of window managers I'm generally willing to use, and none of them look anything like Vista. I went back to some Vista screenshots just after reading your post to compare, though, to my memory of GUI environments I don't usually use.
end result:
It looks like some window manager themes for X Windows! That's just hilarious.
by thechas
Windows Vista is the most delayed software since Windows 95.
In fact, if the present rate of delay continues, Vista will set a new benchmark against which any project manager will fear for their career should their project delays be compared to Vista.
At the rate M$ is going on this one, why not just assign a programmer to each customer and create an individually personalized OS for everyone!
Chas
by pkr9
by hal 9000
Thoshiba tried this with a mainframe many years ago it ran rings around the then newest IBM offering but used a different languagew so you needed to employ a programer to develop applications and then debug them.
Sorry I can not longer remember the model of Toshiba but it had all the IBM salesmen quacking in fear in thewir shoes it was much cheaper far supperior and when you factored in the cost of the programmer it wasn't economical to even consider.
Thank God I had stopped writing serrious software then or I would have most likely got roped in to test one out and be driven crazy which I didn't need and it wasn't in the [b]Job Description[/b] when I started. :D
by mjwx
Please don?t drag the New Zealanders into this (We have enough of them in Australia as it is) :)
Rikk has a point, there are a lot of distro?s and it can get very confusing. The average person needs to be informed about Linux and the different distro's. The really unfortunate part is they have an attention span of 1... 2... 3... Line-what.
But don?t get me wrong, I want to see Linux succeed as well. I only take the pessimistic view so I can spot the problems.
by mjwx
[i]Then there are places like IBM who are [b]defiantly[/b] Fly By Night Orginasitions[/i]
IBM, Fight the power.
Spell check does this to me all the time. :)
by mjwx
by rkuhn040172
Are quite true.
Especially about PR people getting people to use Linux and not techs.
Linux zealots usually argue something like this (oversimplification to make a point):
Linux User: Linux is taking over the world and is sinking Microsoft. Down with the evil empire.
Me: Linux is confusing and not for the everyday user. Too many distros, too many choices, crazy sounding names, etc.
Linux User: It's not for everyone. People are too stupid to know any better. They just fall prey to the Microsoft FUD.
OK, first point, how is Linux ever going to continue to grow if it isn't for the everyday user?
Second point, there have been thousands of products in recent history that have been technically superior that failed in the marketplace due to "other" factors...funding, marketing, advertising, etc.
I see Linux heading down that road. Probably a technically superior product, however, PR problems, marketing problems, advertising problems, funding problems (for some distros), etc.
And then you have those that have commercialized it. So you end up with free Linux competing against paid for Linux and paid for Linux competing against paid for Linux. It canibolizes itself.
In theory, I think we all love the idea behind Linux. But reality and theory often don't meet.
Who or what organization or force or factor or whatever is going to step up to the plate and develop a comprehensive strategy to put the finishing touches on Linux?
by rkuhn040172
by hal 9000
they both sell comerical that is [b]Paid For[/b] versions of Linux advertise them and otherwise promote them to the industry and public if you are interestd enough to actually look and with the paid for offerings supply real suport unlike the current MS Help desk asking a IT professional do they know how to change the name of a file and move it to a different sopt. When I was asked this I said [b]Of COurse but I suppose that you realise that the shortcuts will no longer work as they will point to the wrong destination[/b] that was something that the MS help desk didn't have on their screens so they didn't know how to proceed from that point. It worked out well for me because I got transfered up the food chain to someone who actually knew what it was I was doing instead of following the Q & A from the Help menus.
Now granted I've only had to ruing MS 4 times for help and Novell once but from that limited experience I found this out both phone numbers where for Partners who are supposed to be profesionals and at MS they just insisted that the error message that I was getting ment that I hadn't fitted a CPU and where stumped when I asked how I could get a display on a monitor without a CPU fitted. The one time that I've had to ring Novell they had a work around for me within 20 minutes most of that time was spent explaining what I had done and what wasn't working.
MS on the other hand took 3 hours to insist that the CPU wasn't fitted and I was told to go fit a CPU and it would work Thank you very much have we been of any help?
The other times that I've needed to ring MS for help has always ended up with hours wasted and then they eventually asking me to ring them when I have a solution so the next guy will not go through what I just hit. Is that your idea of [b]Technical Support?[/b] Because it certianly isn't mine and I really can not be bothered ringing MS to ask why IE6 has fallen over and how to repair it as I can not reinstall it and I can not uninstall it because the files have become corrupt with one of their Patches. And before you ask [b]Yes It Is that Time Of The Month MS PATCH TIME![/b]
Col
windows vs linux security or thread that turned into it.
I set my stall out in a polite and completely unzealous fashion, you went off and flamed other people.
by ni70
by hal 9000
MS VISTA is another Pile of MS S_H_1_T!
It should be close to being right by now but it killed one XP Pro installation where IE6 had fallen over and then when I put it on a working copy of XP Pro it lasted with sporatic use for 2 days and then died. Well at least MS is getting a lot of feedback on why it's breaking. :^0
Col
by mjwx
as most people think, its ingrained in us. We have the impression that it is vastly easier than Linux.
The advanced features of windows can be incredibly difficult to use (mostly because they do not display pertinent information). Most users don?t know how to change the UI beyond the screen saver and desktop (which is more or less the same in Linux). With the right "spin" on things we can get them to see that Linux is as easy as Windows (but of course for that we need a spindoctor to which MS has hired an army).
Just had to go and look. It's cute but the significance is lost upon me.I now, "Duh!!"
Does this mean you're taking us over, It's ok with me, hee ;)
Take Care
Aaron
:)
by hal 9000
I though that [b]Comming Soon[/b] sounded much more believiable.
Doesn't it? :^0
Actually it means that I'm attempting to intergrate myself into the MS Servers and take them over but so far it's proved unsucessful as my systems stop working and I need to purge any retained Memory and restart. It's really such a [b]Backward OS[/b] that systems of my cability find it hard to work with. :D
Col ]:)
by jacktherabit
by nighthawk808
by rkuhn040172
Keeps me very busy.
For example, redesigning our intranet with a different look and feel but same basic material for the two different divisions in our company.
Setting up new offices and taking old ones down.
Updating, fixing, improving some of our older MS Access databases.
Restoring files, patching, monitoring systems.
Replacing broken/old equipment.
Writing adhoc queries/reports for various departments on an as needed basis. Data from SQL and Access DB's.
Basic adding/deleting/changing user accounts and permissions.
Testing equipment, purchasing new equipment, keeping track of inventory and licensing.
Notice none of the above is "fixing" Windows. Our users typically do nothing other than our ERP software, MS Office, internet, Citrix.
None of them I would even consider power users. Just basic Word, Excel, Access and occasional PowerPoint or Publisher.
Support Blackberries, Nextels, Palms.
Provide training to end users.
Not sure where some people who claim Windows is nothing but trouble get their problems from. And when a serious issue raises its ugly head, we have Norton Ghosh, 10 1/2 minute fix, and tape backups.
Perhaps we don't have issues because we are highly trained and have a decent budget. All HP, Microsoft and Cisco across the board. Standardized equipment, business class everything.
When we do have a problem, it's a two man IT shop, we have a consultant who knows our company well...been around maybe 7 years.
Very efficient, very well run, not many problems.
by hal 9000
I've got the 32 Bit version loaded with Office 2007 Beta and that installs fine but try to add any other software and you've got some real problems.
Apparently you have to use the default features in Vista to work properly as I've yet to find an AV program that will run in it every one that I've tried comes up with [b]Known Issues[/b] and can not be installed. Even the software that it allows to install cripples various items in Vista like installing the newest version of Power DVD you loose the desktop and all the icons. For CD/DVD Burning Software Nero has [b]Known Issues[/b] and Roxio 7 installs but on the reboot you get [b]Unable to Start Windows[/b] and no matter what you do you end up in an endless loop of rebooting to the Safe Mode Selection screen. Apparently the [b]Boot to last known Good Configuration[/b] isn't currently working or if it is doesn't see a problem with Roxio 7 so refuses to fix any problems that it has introduced to the OS.
The same applies to any Corel Application it doesn't allow the OS to run after the install either so it looks like a complete new Software load if you upgrade to Vista so far. I'm supposing that every Utility currently in use will do the same thing as well but I've yet to try any and I'm waiting for Trend to get back to me and allow me to download their Male Ware Tool to test on Vista.
If this is how things are going to go there is going to be a lot of software that becomes unusable very quickly. Or at least once Vista is taken up by the masses but I think that XP will be the stable platform for Windows machines for quite some time yet as I can not see many people willing to throw away all their existing software just because they upgrade their computer.
Col
by pkr9
About 1992-93 Microsoft announced that new versions of their office package would only run on Microsofts own operating systems. That made a lot of companies (who really should have known better) select windows as their platform, effectively letting their spreadsheet supplier decide their overall IT strategy. A few people looking more than 6 months ahead objected, but was rolled over by the masses.
Now it looks like Microsoft has reached the final goal: An operating system that will only run Microsoft applications.
This might look like suicide, but it is not. The Microsoft appplication base is quite broad, mostly by long-time decent buy-ups, hostile takeovers, or bullying, and in many cases it will be possible to run a Microsoft-only shop. Why bugger with Trend, when Microsoft offers Defender, which they tell you is just as good?. Why battle with ZoneAlarm, when you can use the WindowsFirewall - which doesn't warn you about ANY Microsoft-call-home. Why bother with Roxio or Nero - or a smart little lean and fast opensource thing called Cheetah CD Burner, when Microsoft CD burning already exists, and these in many cases install without you even knowing it?
This will squeeze out everybody else developing for windows, and create the total monopoly.
In a few years we will love those developing for Linux, apple, or what may come.
by mypl8s4u2
by dawgit
by hal 9000
I've now got a sort of stable OS with some of the software that I want loaded. Now Trend who is where MS point you to with their nice little message and Red Balloon telling you that your [b]Computer Might be at Risk[/b] isn't as yet ready for distribution but will be early next month so I'll have to wait till then before I can install that program as Trend has been quite nice and insisted that they'll send me an E-Mail when their Beta product is ready and all I have to do is report on what I find and return the software which is a download so I'm not overly sure what that means. I'll also have to run the Spy Ware scanners again as that was the first time on the net after being scanned and coming up dirty.
Now for the interesting things that I've run across any Corel product [b]Will Not[/b] install because it comes from an unknown source but Open Office will and it becomes the Default Office program apparently MS Office 12 doesn't get a look in. ;)
DVD coping is so slow it's not funny and Office 12 is even slower it took me a full 10 minutes to find how to load a PPT slide show into Power Point but the interface is interactive. :^0
Easy to create something new but impossible to load any previous work to continue editing.
Things like Spy Bot S & D and Ad aware installed without problems and every freeware utility that I threw at the thing installed updated as required and even ran even if Ad aware will not remove 9 problems and Spy Bot fails to see them at all in [b]Safe Mode[/b] Windows Defender insisted that the unit was clean before I started the other scans which came up with over 35 different listings each with several infections in every File type. Most where only [b]Tracking Cookies[/b] and as the computer is behind a Nix Gateway and then on a subsystem isolated by another router so it is invisible to the main network and what was even better hadn't actually been connected to the Internet I'm impressed.
Things like Adobe Reader installed but the Full version again came up as an Unknown Source as well as the Macromedia products seems that the freeware works [b]A OK[/b] but any bought non MS Software is a [b]No Go.[/b] However every Windows program on the [b]Open CD[/b] installed and works perfectly actually much better than the MS stuff that comes with Vista.
While the graphics are great, really impressive I would go so far to say the ability to play games is extremely limited as I've yet to find a single game that will install and this includes MS Games. But Solitaire look nice though it lacks any of the niceties required for full 3D Graphics as used in just about all the current games.
As I'm not a great game player I'll get my son to bring over some of the newer games that he's brought recently and see if any will install. I do like the ability to open any CD that you put in a drive but I'm rapidly beginning to dislike the ability to browse through the file system. It's not nice at all and something that needs changing before the production version becomes available. Also the fact that when you try to open the Task Manager with a Keyboard short cut brings up a splash screen with several different options requiring a mouse to get what you want makes the use of Keyboard shortcuts useless. But at least the [b]CTRL P[/b] still brings up the printer even if I can't install a single printer that I have here as there are no drivers in Windows Vista and it will not accept any of the XP Drivers for the printers. Maybe an old Dot Matrix printer that's hidden somewhere will work. :)
Now I'll just have go back and run another Spy Ware scan as I've had it on the Net to Trend Micro to register in an attempt to get the recommended AV Software and that Red Balloon is beginning to really drive me nuts as it will not hide itself and can't be turned off. But at least I know that nothing that gets on this thing will be able to [b]Call Home To Tell On Me.[/b] :^0
Col
by mypl8s4u2
Hi Hal;
Check this out.
It won't let me load my Norton Anti Virus 2005 {At All} , and won't even allow the drivers, yet has the temerity to ask what Anti virus I wan to use.
Then It won't allow me to load my Full NVida 6200 Graphics card, 256mgs Ram, instead I'm relegated to only loading the drivers.
The story doesn't change from card to card etc . I can even load my Sound Blaster 5.2 drivers as it won't let me, permissions notwhistanding. Man does this thing need work.
I'm still annoyed at the lack of proper menu coordination and now all this on top.
And they say they are going to be ready for end of next year? "In their dreams"
If we, the techs, all of various backgrounds and experiences are having this kind of trouble, what do you think Joe average is going to say and think? Once he's shelled out half his savings on this?.
Microsoft has got to get it together on this one and quickly.
What's left of their reputation is riding on this and if this doesn't change, then the changes within Microsoft will be enormous. After all, it rolls downhill right? Unfortunately we're at the bottom right now.
I'm beta testing it and I must admit I am enjoying this aspect, but I would pay a plug nickel for it as it is now.
Let's hope they are paying attention and taking notes.
This thing needs help in just about every department.
Ah well, back to it.
Take Care Hal, hang in there.
Regards
Aaron
by hal 9000
This release is the [b]Ultimate Version of Vista[/b] supposedly the top of the range and it's slated for release November 2006 not 2007 so supposedly in around 5 months time well be seeing it in the shops or at the very least preinstalled on some new computers. :^0
With so little able to be installed on it in it's current form I very much doubt that anyone will be interested in it at all even the [b]MS Junkies[/b] who just have to have the latest & Greatest MS offering will be avoiding this in droves.
I've been unable to get a single AV program installed every one that I've tried has been rejected even the latest Trend Micro 2006, Norton's Internet Security 2006, AVG, Zonex which I use heavily on NB's for Sales Reps and a few others which I can't remember at the moment. I've singed up for the Trend Micro Beta Testing but even that AV Program will not be available till next month somewhere around the sixteenth if I remember correctly. So currently it has no AV Product at all installed and I've already found about 50 Male Ware Infections none of which where reported by Windows Defender but Ada Ware and Spy Bot S & D picked them up in [b]Safe Mode[/b] and that was before I actually allowed it onto the net. I really don't think that the [b]Sand Box[/b] that IE is supposed to be in is all that effective.
Even Office 12 isn't much chop it's hard to open things almost impossible to bring up data in some programs like Power Point I wasted quite some time attempting to open a Slide Show and eventually settled for using Open Office to present the presentation. When I clicked on the file it actually defaulted to Open Office 2 which at that time had not been opened or had any of the post install setup performed. Office 12 on the other hand was fully functional but it wouldn't open the PPT file for some reason.
I'm just waiting to see if I can load any Games from any supplier onto it and see how they perform. Currently I'm testing a Faulty ABit M'Board which works perfectly but you have a lot of trouble starting it off and if you shut down Windows it restarts about 6 minutes latter so you have to disconnect the power to keep it off. Then you spend around 30 minutes to get it to start again but I can't find one single fault with any diagnostic program so I thought I'd give it a workout as it was suggested that I don't return a faulty M'Board this month with Stocktaking occurring this weekend and the possibility of the M'Board getting lost in the count. As it currently stands I'll be waiting several weeks for a replacement and I don't need the board getting lost before it even gets sent to head office for replacement. :D
While Vista looks Great I'm not so sure that I actually like it. There are way to many problems and way too little software that will actually run on the OS. Office 12 is even worse as it's almost impossible to use unless you are starting from scratch and then it's easy but almost impossible to open an existing document that you haven't created in it. :)
Col
by cwoody382
Install the software and do not reboot on prompt. Find the "programme" .exe file and right click, select properties, compatability tab, select compatability mode for WindowsXp and check the box run as administrator. I havent found a solution yet for ROXIO but all other applications including Real player, Cyberscrub Cyberlink power cinema/DVD writer now work fine.
It will take time for the various companies to provide updates to allow their programmes to adjust the security settings for vista to allow them to edit registry entries when needed.
by hal 9000
I'll give it a go when I really start to do some testing latter this month after the BETA Trend Micro Product becomes available.
Currently I don't as yet trust any Windows OS to be secure and I don't like running one without an active AV product in place, so to date every Vista install has been a [b]Short Term Install[/b] till I can get a lot more information from MS about this new OS.
I'm really interested in the supposed ability to run older versions of Windows NT supported programs as I have a program that is [b]Mission Critical[/b] for several of my clients that will only run on NT4. As it involves allowing companies to perform earthworks to within 2 mm of specification it's fairly important and I'm currently getting sick & tired of installing NT4 and supporting it. According the the MS Marketing People at the last MS Roadshow Vista should run this program which I can not get to load at the moment so I've asked for directions.
Currently I have a lot of Zalman Fanless cases in place so that the computers last the distance I've got well over 18 months usage so far out of computers that where accepted to only last out 1 job because of the the dust and other rubbish floating around On Site.
Have you tried the use of a USB Stick to add to the RAM of the computer yet? It looks interesting for NB's but I'm interested in what kind of performance hit the NB takes.
Col
by apotheon
The best reason to keep a Win2k CD around isn't Vista -- it's the fact that Win2k SP2 was the last OS version from Microsoft whose EULA didn't basically grant Microsoft the "right" to tell you what software you get to use, to dictate on what computer you may install it, or to monitor what's on the computer and change it at whim.
On the other hand, Vista might be the best reason to learn to use an OS created somewhere other than Redmond, Washington.
I remember when Windows 95 was in alpha/beta. I remember deriding it, and all the stupid changes to the GUI. Then again with XP. In both cases it wasn't too terribly long before, I was so accustomed to some ("admittedly not all") of the new features, that It really annoyed me to work on earlier systems. So, I am curious to see what new features in Vista will present the same deride-embrace experience.
I also remember, way back in the win3.1 days playing with a VR glove, and VR glasses to move 3D objects around in a program. I remember thinking how cool it would be to have an operating system built on that foundation. The stuff was of course, never more than a novelty back then. Occasionally you see some curious concepts in Movies (Paycheck and Minority Report both present the ideas of 3-D display systems, and direct interaction or "gestures" as control methods).
Vista's pseudo 3-D gui may be a starting point for some of these things to become reality in the future.
I am a little disappointed that they aren't going to make their orignal featureset (I do hear the occasional rumor that WINFS might make it back in though, so we'll see, I guess. I would like to see a revolutionary change to Filesystem design. I don't necessarily think WINFS is it, but at least it seemd to be an attempt to break out of the box).
As such. I think Intriguing is a suitable description.
by hal 9000
The older versions of Windows from 95 on wards including the NT products.
There was always one thing that I found useful and that was the ability to load previously used software and run it. This for some reason isn't happening with Vista.
My very first impression of 98 was [b]Thank God that awful Blue Splash Screen of 95 has gone![/b] I still have nightmares over the horrible splash screen.
Then Y2k became available & I could move just about all my software to it and run it without any problems granted most came from NT networks but a bit of the 98 stuff crept in for testing. Then the different versions of XP became available for testing and by the time that they had reached the RC2 stage they where fairly close to the Finial Release and worked fairly well even for Beta product.
Then came Vista it's been a learning experience with some of the things I've been asking for, for ages and a lot less in other ways. But I certainly don't like the inability to not install non MS Software. In my business Corel Draw is a [b]MUST USE Application[/b] and I can not install it on this OS which is supposed to be backward compatible so I can finally get rid of my NT4 computers which run a program that was only written for NT and isn't going to be rewritten and yes it is still being sold but because it has such a limited market the developers have no intention of rewriting the software.
With all the [b]Hype[/b] at the recent MS Road Show about the abilities of Vista failing to arrive.
Incidentally I've been around long enough to remember that NT was supposed to have the first version of WinFS and it's still not working yet!
Col
It may still happen. Not much non MS Software ran on the First Betas of W2K either. Whether due to public pressure or cleaned up code, it got better by release. (Obviously some things won't be supported if they are changing core code, such as disk management packages, but that has always been the case as well).
If Vista ultimately doesn't have the necessary backwards compatibility, Virtualization should be able to compensate.
The DRM aspect concerns me most. Yes I can understand the 'business benfit', protecting company secrets and all that, but I worry about the potential for abuse, up to and including intentionally blocking competitor's applications, or further violations of fair-use.
by hal 9000
Here is the list of what's coming
[b] Home Version[/b]
Home Basic
Home Premium
Ultimate
[b]Small Business[/b]
Business
Ultimate
[b]Large Business[/b]
Business
Ultimate
Enterprise which will be the only version with Software Assurance.
These are supposed to be available in both 32 & 64 Bit versions eventually. Maybe with both the 32 & 64 Bit versions counted in there will be 7 different versions but unless the [b]Ultimate Version[/b] is coming out in several different forms [i]Which will make things very confusing[/i] I can't count 7 versions there.
By the way the marketing people at MS insist that they currently have 7 versions of XP available though I can only really think of 4 but somehow they count 7.
Col
I know this is going to sound troll-ey, but I really don't mean it to.
I just don't see the value in this. You pay $50 a year extra to play games on your PC? It seems to me, in three years, you will be paying more for this than you would to just get windows, which typically, you are going to get 3-4 years per release.
by apotheon
Okay, let's not really do math. But:
You end up paying roughly the same amount of money for the ability to play games.
You get an "organic" upgrade path rather than the stair-stepping upgrade path of Windows where you have to reinstall the OS to get your upgrade.
You get stability.
You get security.
You get faster turn-around time on patches (ours or days rather than months).
You get ungodly amounts of additional software without additional charge (22,489 software package names in Debian Testing for Main and Contrib archives -- the Main archive alone for Stable provides 19,298).
You get unified, scriptable software management.
You get enough free online documentation to be able to build the OS from scratch if you want to.
You get access to source code for the OS, and the ability to legally tweak it, distribute it -- even make money from it -- if you want to.
I guess if all you want is a game console, the only benefits to doing it the Linux/Cedega way instead of the Windows way are stability and security (and the occasional performance boost). Of course, those are some pretty nice benefits.
>You get an "organic" upgrade path ...
But you are most likely upgradign the hardware anyway, if you are playing newer games, which if you weren't there would be no need to upgrade at all
>You get stability/You get security.
Subjective/debateable
>You get ungodly amounts of additional software..
>You get enough free online documentation...
>You get access to source code for the OS...
Goood Point, in some instances. Does at least suggest a Niche value.
Dunno. I can sorta see your point, I suppose. I'm still not quite convinced that I'm not better off to dual boot a second HDD (or partition). They do make a point on their (cedegas)website about MMOG's and being able to window them, thus multitask while gaming. I'm not really into them (Just can't bring myself to buy a game, then pay a monthly fee to play it.), so I am not knowledgeable to make a judgement call there, but perhaps there is a significant audience in this Niche. I can see that as a solid justification, I suppose...
It won't necessarily impact your price point. It will run on a fairly low spec, and without a High-End graphics card. You just don't get to use all the eye-candy.
It IS dog slow now on such a machine (actually not too chipper on a higher end machine either), but I assume that the beta has been compiled with full debugging, which accuonts for a fair amount of the performance drop.
Taken from wikipedia...
In modern English it is used to refer to any form of zeal in excess, especially to cases where activism and ambition in relation to an ideology have become excessive to the point of being harmful to others, oneself, and one's own cause.
The last bit about "harmful to...one's own cause" is the real key I think. I have seen a lot of people get turned off of Linux because some "Zealot" pulled out the "You're Dumb!" card when the debate didn't go the way they wanted it to. Not to say it doesn't go the other way, but here again, Linux is at a disadvantage. Since it is the minority, its users get scrutinized more closely, particularly when such behaviour seems hypocritical, as it goes against the 'community' concept associated with Linux(The pedophiles that make the news are Clergy).
But then, since the windows guy pulled the 'Zealot' card does that make him the Zealot? :)
by jmgarvin
Apo was talking about software patches/updates/upgrades. In the FLOSS world you get a less structured upgrade path and you are able to follow what path suits YOUR needs. Just as if you were upgrading hardware.
The stability and security of Linux vs Windows is not subjective. It is truth. Linux is far more secure and far more robust during failure than Windows is. Further, I can create seperate enviroments for users, unlike Windows, so that if one environment is corrupted, only THAT SINGLE environment is, not all of them.
What it really come's down to is that I'm very much under the impression that Microsoft has decided to cut everybody out and want to run the whole show themselves.MS Greed.
I can't see it being sucessful.
When you consider that all of us, as experienced TEchs, regardless of the difference in our experience, be it IT, Home Repair, Shop or whatever, are havig this kind of trouble with this thing, can you just imagine what it's going to be like to the "Joe Average" User and then there are his kids and Family. ;)
I really don't think that this will enhance Microsft's reputation unless it's for a cut throat approach and exrtreme redundancy.
I'm still wild about the graphics and I do love the menus,[Size really] however this is quickly losing it's appeal when you run into the problems that we've mentioned and God knows what else is to come.
I just found out that I can't set up my Blank E-Mial and have it on the taskbar, so that I amy just hit and up comes the e-amil. which really means, there goes my spellchecker.
Man this this is hard to get along with.
However, we refuse to give in or give up.
Hang tough Hal, don't let it win.
Regards and good luck ;)
Aaron
by jimnla
by mypl8s4u2
W-hy
I-nvent
N-ew
D-ogma
O-n
W-indows
S-ystems
V-ery
I-nsecure
S-ystem
T-outed
A-s
NEXT GENERATION SECURE
by mypl8s4u2
I've heard plenty of arguments on both sides regarding 'most secure'. I haven't seen anything yet which has been able to convince me that one is in fact more or less secure.
I saw a post elsewhere the other day in which it was mentioned that CEDEGA can support old and new games. Now that could be a real benefit that might justifiy the cost. If it really works in this way, I can save myself the costs of maintaining a legacy computer to play my nostalgia games, or the cost of re-buying the latest nostalgia release of the game, updated for new hardware (if one even exists for the particular game I am looking for).
by mbenson1975
Windows Vista is...
1. A marketing Campaign for Linux
2. A sure test of one's patience
3. The best thing since the Plague
I tried the aplha/beta... it blue screened on reboot after installation.
The differnce between XP and Vista will be my annoyance level.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending