Discussion Locked

Thanx for the tips to promote more Outsourcing

0 helpful
393 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hoorah! and a round of applause for techrepublics netnote email which must have reache a couple of million people. Now I truly understand what happened. When you give MIS's resources (excel spreadsheets woohoo!) on how to go about outsourcing to cut costs and reduce budgets, the jobs are not outsourced outside the American companies to other consulting firms in the US- THEY'RE LEAVING THE COUNTRY!!! US consulting operations in the Tech Supp industry are at a screetching halt and have been closing up shop since 2002. Have you not heard the cries and woes in the general world of American IT professionals at the blue and shade-off white collarlevel ?????????????????????????????!!!!! We're bankrupt here - Some of your fine members and subscribers have not had a job in months, some since 9/11!!!!! I think it was utterly irresponsible and slightly foolish to give the executive powers such a destructive tool to continue destroying our IT workforce(or what's left) and our general economy!! Did you know that IBM has a VERY VERY LARGE training center in INDIA!! which tutors the already veteran Tech Support department there on the American accent and lingo so that IBM's customers won't distinguish them and recognize this tragedy already in transit for four and a half years???!!! We're too busy here trying to keep ahead of India in learning technologies and discovering research and dev which have been built and already implemented in overseas tech-labs. Now we're sending emails to more US based corporations to 'tip them off' on how to cut more corners in their IT depts and 'outsource' more jobs away - WHAT'S WRONG WITH THIS PICTURE?!?!?!?
How about sending an email to some wives and children around the country explaining why they're cost of living or mortgage is not in great harmony with their breadwinners' industry and suggest they move to Bombay/Mumbay??!?!?!?!

393 replies

by orpheum

Evidently I?m not the only one who feels this email hit too close to home. I wish more of you would stand up for our future or at least challenge corporate America?s suicide in the IT field. We owe it to ourselves to win back our common goals of expecting our stressful (at times nearly impossible) labor and constant recertification be a little more rewarding and secure than the guy/girl who pours your coffee at the local starbucks(btw, thank heaven for starbucks ? they?re keeping our unemployment rate from breaking records ?single-handedly).
Can?t blame CNet any more than IBM or Cisco though.

by yelt62

I've been working in the IT world for more than 15 years and have watched the transformation of the industry. I have seen the 'outsourcing' of many functions over time and have been able to adapt or change with the reality. The majority of the work I have seen go to outside 'partners' is mundane or inconsequential to the true function of the corporate objective of provisioning information to decision makers in an organization. If it came down to it I wouldn't be adverse to moving to were the work is if I had to.

by ahickman

Pack your bags, and try and get a work permit for India. I don't think really want forgien workers in India.

by sagax

"Work from Home" is an alternative to sending out the work (often to foreign shores). If the work can be sent to India, it can be sent to the employees home. And many, many Americans would be pleased to make the personal investment in adequate PCs, space in the home, broad-band internet and such (if they have not already done so) to facilitate home work.

SAVINGS: expensive office space, costly office equiptment, operating expenses (heat, light, janitorial, etc.)

RISK: Poor work ethic. I have spoken with employers who have "tried" work-from-home. Because of failure to get the work done, the programs were cancelled. The worker must be committed to being at their workstation and taking care or business at least as consistently as if going into the employers workplace.

TO DO: C|Net should do surveys of both sucessful and unsuccessful work-from-home programs. OK, that has been done, but do it again because things have changed since then. Then add that to the spreadsheet as another alternative.

by dc_guy

Isn't it the information technology revolution that made offshore outsourcing of "knowledge workers" jobs possible in the first place?

All it takes is a workstation, the internet, and a good cheap long-distance carrier, and every company in America can move its service department to any place where lots of people speak English.

We in IT gave the world workstations, the internet, and good cheap long-distance service. We even gave people all over the world a good reason to learn English.

It's a little late to start complaining now. Just because the offshore outsourcing that OTHER workers have been complaining about for years has finally hit OUR profession.

by wordworker

Wow you really know how to boil it down to the essentials. Now how do we take it to the next level, the one those outsourced help desks will aspire to next?

by orpheum

I apologize for not taking more time and elaborating on this topic. You are absolutely right DC_GUY. There is a huge list of technological advancements which is clearly viewable on a simple timeline as you noted. The 'Big Guns' were eager to make a buck. Hardware manufacturers were eager to sell more workstations. Carriers were eager to gain bandwidth usage, and software companies were raking it in with shrink-wraps that made it all come together. So in conclusion, CNet is not at all entirely responsible for leaking the secret that offshore outsourcing will save your average corporation sized 100-1000 users a cool million or two over a couple of years. However, I was pointing out that pouring salt over these labor force wounds was a HUGE slap in the face for many of us like myself to witness. Would anyone be so bold as to speak of Vietnam and say 'we should have let them kill each other and not get involved' in the presence of a veteran who lost his platoon over there? That was the gist of my reaction, man. You can't imagine the disappointment I felt upon opening this email yesterday. Felt like a sword had just gone through me, and I hope someone was conscious enough to forward my initial string to the editor in chief at CNet, and also hope to see the higher ups take this as a wake up call. There's an abundance of content to write about in our wonderful, hyper speed industry ? they should refrain from topics like this in the future. I hope this falls on the proper ears as well - funny how there?s no one mentioned in these emails or even the links to take credit, at least Dvorak is brazen enough to wear his label on his advice in PC Magazine and accept our criticism (not that there?s a whole lot).

In the meantime it would be nice if by some miracle there would be an evolution which would force jobs to be regenerated on our home turf with/without necessarily taking away these much adored offshore incomes.

God Bless
-Orpheum

by dc_guy

It's predicted that the nanotechnology sector will be larger than the entire planetary GDP is today. And this is expected to happen in about fifteen years. It will keep growing from there. Look for an inflation-adjusted GDP with two or three more zeroes in your lifetime if you're under 40.

If IT brought about a more equitable distribution of that GDP among nations (and a certain shock among some of us at learning what the world's per capita GDP is), nanotech is poised to bring it down to the level of the individual while massively increasing the total available for distribution.

I'm not enough of a scientist to give you a digest of the articles I've read on the subject. But a Google search will flood your screen.

There are two camps, to be sure. The optimists look to nanotech to complete the Paradigm Shift that IT started, which (Bill Gates notwithstanding) has already gone a long way to correct the aberrations of wealth and power concentration caused by industrialization. The pessimists worry that with science we've already created a world that our brains, bodies, and spirits can't adapt to, and call for a complete moratorium on research in the field.

(See my posting on the "Obesity" thread for more on that subject, which would admittedly appear to group me with the pessimists.)

But one thing about IT: it makes it hard to keep any genie in his bottle. Nanotechnology will undoubtedly advance with or without the blessing of governments, churches, the Nimrod Conspiracy, and organizations who purport to protect consumers and the environment.

By definition, nanotechnology is small-scale. The Apple of nanotech may be created by two physics grad students and a 12-year-old computer whiz in a clandestine lab in a cave with a diesel generator in the outback of Uruguay, Zimbabwe, or Kyrghyzstan.

by american_it_guy

Whether we need to have a secret online force unionized is yet to be seen.
But there are thousands of us 100% in agreement with you.
We have been fighting the battle for years now, so perhaps a bit jaded and ready for new levels of success.
Now this topic is the central issue in the major political event of our time. Thank goodness.
There has never been more at stake.

Lou Dobbs cares about America too (if you have missed his series)

by melanie.denyer

"We in IT gave the world workstations, the internet, and good cheap long-distance service. We even gave people all over the world a good reason to learn English"

You know, that just may be an over-simplification. While I won't downplay the role of IT in developing the world's economy, suggesting it's the main reason for people around the world speaking English is a bit rich.

Even before IT took off, lots of people around the world spoke English, largely due to the previous existence of the British Empire. At the heart of the creation of the British Empire was trade. And that's the issue today, too.

I subscribe to the principle of free trade, but I likewise deplore the 'blind' outsourcing practiced by so many companies, whether in the US, the UK or wherever. But it strikes me that if the outsourcing is taking place, it's because domestic firms can't always fulfil the requirements of the companies who outsource. Sometimes, of course, the companies are just being plain cheap, but other times we should be treating the outsourcing phenomenon as a wake-up call.

The first industry in the UK to be hit by outsourcing to India was the call centre industry. Cost was the relevant factor here, and even more so in a post 9/11 world. But, while more Indian contracts are announced, many others are coming back to the UK, or reaffirming their intention to stay local.

The domestic companies winning this war are those who have focused on quality, and allied it with cost control. Oddly, they are paying their workers more than previously, but are retaining their competitive edge with the quality of their offering. And this is bringing back the big brands.

In the same way, the IT industry needs to reassess how it competes with the international competition. Quality will surely be an issue, but cost control will be another. If you can get those aspects sorted, a little market research should be all it takes to bring companies back into the domestic market again, as they have in the UK.

In conclusion, I would say that sometimes you have to let the corporations make their mistakes and learn their lessons. Just make sure your industry learns theirs.

by american_it_guy

The US government addressed manufacturing offshore outsourcing to a degree everyone bought in. With I/T, US Gov. and many are in denial. Big difference. (Although the Gov. was involved in the manufacturing exodus I agree that their effort was too little)

Most folks never understood I/T or the dedication/skill required, not to mention the knowledge base of staff. The biggest difference (pointed out by many here) is the logistics. Instead of planning and building a plant, just simply flip a switch on a router and shazaam! - IBM India tech support at your service.
That is where the un-easiness we all feel comes from. My job can disappear during the night.
Oh yeah, that brings confidence in our system.

I don't think we will loose this war but it is unforgivable what has happened already. The pain imposed unnecessarily on hard working Americans will have me very involved in these matters the rest of this life.
There is something *very* wrong with how outsourcing has had a free hand to destroy careers and erase history of employments.

Also, remember guys, flipping burgers is manufacturing now. I suppose working at home depot or starbucks will become I/T.

by aaron

The answer is simple - vote politicians out that do not look out for Americans. Offshoring is a mild form of espionage.

by aaron

Hey, DC guy.... I think that ALL jobs can be offshored. I think that management and for that matter government elected and appointed officials can be sent offshore... why not? Most of your work is done remote to the areas you represent anyway, right?

You are apparently either a spy for India or China, or a damned communist. Leave my country, you are polluting it.

by amar_prus

After 9/11 when major business houses are keen to save more money for the rainy day,outsourcing will rule.

Technology is an enabler along with knowledge.

by amar_prus

After 9/11 when major business houses are keen to save more money for the rainy day,outsourcing will rule.

Technology is an enabler along with knowledge.

by charleshagen

Now here is what REALLY is happening. The GLOBAL ECONOMY is coming to roost here.

It means that our prices for consulting will drop to compete with overseas. My company's pricing has dropped by 40%!

My labor costs have dropped drastically to stay competitive. Of course the last MCSE I hired I found working a register at a gas station. I hired him at $9/hour and he was GRATEFUL to be working in his field again.

This is the truth of it all...with more competition we have to make clear the significant reasons for choosing domestic consultants...these reasons are geographic (we are local), communication (Americans communicate well with Americans in general) and price.

The net result is a general lowering of the standard of living. This is unavoidable as governments historically have never been effective at stopping this type of trend (ask someone in manufacturing about that).

SO WHAT IS THE ANSWER? Compete or get out of the business. Hard, cold truth. I do not like it but what can I do? I keep my $$ here anytime I am able. That is all I can do.

by niezen

To even think that the US IT industry would never change is kidding yourself. In this global economy the search for the cheapest is going on and on.
It is done while shopping for groceries, or clothing,
and it is also done for labour.
The outsourcing has taken place already for years here in Europe in all branches.
If US IT experts would be on par with others there would be no need to outsource.
And with on par I mean not only the salary but also expertise and production rate.
Think global, the world is not US only.

by raghu

If I remember right, some one preached for open trade, free
markets etc. Now, when some one is beating you in your own
game with your rules, you want to change the rules.

NOT FAIR.

by ahickman

Raghu,

You Said:
If I remember right, some one preached for open trade, free markets etc. Now, when some one is beating you in your own game with your rules, you want to change the rules.

And I say to You and everyone else:

Fair Trade, Free Markets are the wave of the future. Along with population control.

As to the current Outsourcing of American Jobs. This is an inevitable part of world wide growth.

However, for thoes of us who are unemployed or under-employed currently, and are faced with minor issues like losing our houses, being unable to send our kids to a good college, no longer have medical insurance and are unable to purchase new cars, etc.; the ramifications are enornmous.

Plus its not about beating anyone at anything.

So next time you want to smart off about how Americans are being beat at their own game, remember for every Indian who gets a nice outsourced job, there is some American who just lost their job, maybe their house and car, medical insurance and probably a good dose of self esteem.

Advancement in Science and Technology always comes with a human price. And watch your back, don't you think that some of the countries that are even poorer than India are looking at ways to take the business away from you?

Thoes that fail to learn from History are doomed to repeat it.

by asisi

The world is evolving into a global village and while Indian and other programmers are taking increasing pieces of offshore application development, other players in US are benefiting too. Take the education and training part for example. Millions and millions of IT related books are exported abroad every year. Amazon has witnessed unprecedented global growth, so is e-bay and many mores. The name of the game now is to build a business for world-wide growth and not only for local consumption. If we don?t play now, we will be out of the game sooner than what many may think.

by averroes3000

Well, the companies are scraming overseas and that is bad news for the U.S and especially for California (Bush team wake up call). The companies in the U.S have an obligation to U.S stockholders and as taxpayers. Which means that tax them out of it. You guys who support outsourcing would not laugh if it was your job even if you are in Europe.

by aaron

You are one to talk - you are paid by a U.S. company... you BETTER hope that your employment is "US only"... Get on par with something else....

by raghu

Indian backbone is made upon 4 generations of sacrifices. Its
now that we are learning to capitalise it. Once a dear friend of
mine, one of the high ups in an FI, told me that if we could just
calculate the intellectual capital value of indians in India, we
would be the richest country on earth.

We missed bus on semiconductors, then superconductors but
with IT we have learned to catch the bus and so has Indian govt.
Definetely we will capitalise on NANO. I already know 3 research
groups working in this field for past 5 years and are about to
productify.

India was once considered " sone ki chedia", a bird made of gold
and like every one says, "What goes around, comes around". Well
! people its about time.

by Member 26101237

Ok everybody let's face facts! There is actually more blame to go around, and some benefits as well. First the additional blame; much of the blame can be placed on you and me, the American Consumer. We shop by NOT by quality NOR by country of manufacture, YET by price. Admit it, when you're have two products side-by-side, what do you base your buying decisions on??? Of course, price. How do you get cheaper goods, by letting the sweat shops oversees make them. That goes for computers also.

So if corporations can save a buck by outsourcing a low paying IT job, so it can afford to purchase more computers to get more workers on them, then the same corporation can higher a more skilled IT worker.

So, here's the Solution; study more, get more certifications, become more highly skilled than any of our India counterparts!! Set up your own lab at home. I know IT guys who go home after work, and ... watch TV. Come on guys (and girls)! Your day is not done! If you want YOUR job to remain in the USA (where you are), then YOU should be working on it at night.

Employers are NO LONGER WiLLING to pay for On The Job Training.

So, go learn NANO, get you CCNE, MCSE, MCSD, CCE, ETC. :-)

And God Bless the USA!!!

by jimgon

You are right. Companies are purchasing thier IT based on price. Not quality or country of origin. That also applies to certification and knowledge. Indians can get certifications too. You have to compete on their level, which is not certification or training, but on price. Personally I can't live in the Northeastern US making what an Indian IT person makes. So certification and training won't be enough, I still can't compete on price. Or I could, but I could work retail and make the same wage and not have to pay for training or carry a beeper.

by pilotslu

Though I believe that training will improve your chances of landing an IT job, I don't believe it will increase your chances of keeping your job. When we become more skilled than our Indian counterparts we require greater compensation (well I do anyway). The problem isn't a lack of training, the problem is that most IT people here in America (me included) can't and do not want to compete with the lower paid people of India. It appears that the people not getting outsourced are the people in charge of doing the outsourcing and in my experience they usually don't even have a technical background. So maybe if you want to keep your IT job you need a business degree.

Sincerely,
-Probably Getting Outsourced

by mattyb_aus

I have always believed a well resourced and well supported insourcing team will run rings around an outsourcer. I have worked for Unisys & HP in the outsourcing field.

I have seen the lack of resouces, the "up-sell" but NEVER an outsourcer that understand the customer's business. In reality they only do it for profit.

Insourcing is not about saving money, it's about being able to control the environment and respond quickly to changing business needs.

The project I am involved in now is exactly that, returning IT to the company because the oiutsourcer could not match the pace of change and provide high quality services to meet the business needs. The project is well finded, well communicated, well resourced and will succeed.

Spending the money on local resources instead of giving it to somebody else is a responsible way to support the community and the country.

by haruss

The main problem is that we (the tech population) put our boss's in the position of replacing us with people with better "soft skills". We find our self complaining about the person on the other floor that can not get the computer turned on with out help. In stead of ?teaching? them how we ridicule. Our own fault!

How do we turn this around? Repeal NAFTA? Good Idea. Make our self more responsive? Maybe. Learn to be a better server, (as in ? would you like fries with that?) Yes that works too.

As a whole we have spent untold millions of dollars in training our self on our own time and during company hours to be the best hamburger flippers in the world. That is what it boils down to. Hi tech hamburger flippers.

Yes after 19 months trying to convince someone who has no clue what I do I?m flippin burgers.

by inxale

Though , the reasons to outsource are very clear, to save money. The long term effects a company suffers because of the broken promises of deliverance , the lack of understanding of IT by the company looking to outsource and the lack of knowledge of the business model of the company proposing outsourcing actually means that over a wider time zone the cost to the business is actually more ( say 5-10 years ). I concur with MattyB. A finely tuned IT internal team will always deliver a cheaper and more efficient support for a company. Also you get a more loyal unit who is prepared to put that little more in for the business. Trouble is we have directors whose knowledge of IT is limited making a decision which will affect their core business at the end of the day. Though fingers do need to be pointed at some within IT though. When you have senior IT staff waste money for 'personalised' projects ' then a company re-acts. I know we have to do business cases , but its easy to present your business case to non-IT senior management. Remember the outsouce company has to prepare something similar to show how it can save a company money. All your bosses look at is the bottom line. I admit I am being generic but I haven't yet seen it any other way.
If your job is to go offshore. Well can you go :) , if not don't loose your skill sets. It will be back. Its happening already within certain sectors. Its just an evolution of IT.

by gulo

Reminds me of the arguments from typographers and compositors at newpapers and publishers some decades ago: Against computers - killing jobs!
Or some centuries ago: Against bookprinting - killing jobs!
Since when does protectionistic behavior improve the own power?

by dilbert_envy

You missed the point -- by a long way. If those in India had built a _better_ mousetrap, and US/UK companies changed accordingly then your point would be valid. Nothing got better, no products or processes improved. In fact quality and delivery got much worse.

What has happened is that greedy managers and corporate moral bankrupty have combined to create a situation where for a few pennies of personal gain, national social responsiblities have been ignored and national interests have been subverted.

That's Treason, and it's high time we started treating it as such.

by bluegill

This sort of thing was part of the first George Bush's White House run for re-election in 1992 when it came to lost manufacturing jobs to Canada, Mexica and to Asia. Ross Perot addressed the discontent and split the electorate enough to put an unknown in the White House (Bill Clinton). It was ddressed again the next time around and we got another fractured elctorate. In 2000 it was close again but folks were pumped to believe that service jobs would save us and that every thing would be okay. Now the service jobs are leaving. What will be the effect of an angry electorate this time? It will be a call for change, now matter how much all other factors are changed with it. Folks are justifiably angry and have a huge sense of betrayal by those that should know better. The party in power just doesn't get it again! It's sad in many respects.

by ahickman

Your right Bluegill. This issue will cost the Republicans the White House this year. They think the issue is about Irag. It's not. When American Voters go to the polls and vote, they are going to ask the classic question: "Am I better off today than 4 years ago?" For about 20 million people who are unemployed or under employed, the resounding answer is going to be no. And the talk show pundits and the White House better wake up to the fact that we are not better off.

Just to be clear....we are not better off economically, however, in the area of world peace, we are.

God Bless America

by michance

Fundamentally unscrupulous corporations like IBM and HP--and their shareholders--couldn't care less about the jobs of American workers. All they care about are profits and keeping their own jobs immune to foreign placement. Their collective greed will keep them on this path until a greater power stops them, or at least slows them down. Unless the Federal Goverment steps in to smooth the transition to foreign outsourcing, the very real pain and suffering inflicted on American professionals by corporate management will remain unconscionable.

by aaron

The government is no longer looking out for our "pursuit of happiness". It's time to replace them. All it takes is one good candidate, and several million votes, and it will all stop. I will run for President for the sole purpose of stopping all exporting of US jobs.

by erniev

The advantage of offshore outsourcing is reduced expense,
however the cost of this savings can be fraught with caveats in
the form of sacrificing quality, effective communications, dealing
with time differences and cultural incongruities. Some services
are naturals for outsourcing, call centers is a good example,
however other services, where value lies in a company's ability to
retain knowledge, will be difficult to outsource to strange
bedfellows.

Americans are industrious, when faced with challenges they have
invariably risen above the fray and created new markets, new
technologies, new jobs. They must suck it up and reinvent
themselves and keep with the tradition of leadership and
innovation. In this challenge lies opportunity. Americans and
other industrious nations must figure out how to capitalize on
this emerging resource and connectivity. I don't see any other
solution, other than compete or fade away.

Perhaps this is the impetus for a more dynamic and mobile
workforce, virtual organizations, open source knowledge, that
allows people to compete with lower overhead through
fleetness, trust relationships and collaborative tools. This
appears to me to be the great opportunity, the dawn of a new
area in our work force evolution, the net-commuter will be the
next big thing.

by bhaan

Where were the automobile, the light bulb, television, computers and space travel invented and perfected?

HINT: Not in INDIA and Not in CHINA.

Let's help the trashbags at IBM and all the other Outsourcing idiots with their transition out of the USA. I think ORACLE and SQL Server are much
better products than the trash that IBM promotes.
We especially need to our government to use these Great American products and Great American Engineers.

The morons in charge of IBM will get what's coming
to them. Go ahead and pay half the wages for 1/100th of the EXPERIENCE.

by homaee

When a majority of people lose their jobs who will buy the houses, cars, pay the utility bills, buy the new computers, pay the taxes. Already people have lost their new homes and are driving 2nd hand cars.

Sending jobs abroad who will control the personal information that is handed to companies that aren't subject to our laws.

by ahickman

Since it is obvious to everyone that IT Outsourcing is about increasing profits for corporations.

One way to maybe stop Outsourcing is to set up a WEB Site, list the companies Outsourcing, and recomend that you do not buy products from them.

If there are 15 to 20 Million people who are unemployed or under-employed out there, that is a large block of consumers.

Such a boycott might make a much better point than all of us whining about Outsourcing. Bankruptcy and Lower Stock Values send a very vivid message to Corporate America.

by rjlambird

I generally agree with the comments from Orpheum. The long term damage to U.S. workers is just now being realized. The last recession demonstrated that the largest component of the Gross National Product is being contributed by U.S. consumers. Unemployed and underemployed consumers cannot and will not contribute to the next recovery. The private market research analyses we provide do not predict a happy future.

by ahickman

Actually the only product we produce in this country that people want is food. Maybe all of us IT People out to go to Ag School and become farmers. Out with the Industrial Revolution. Out with the Technology Revolution and In with the Agrarian Revolution.

At least you can make booze out of corn, wheat and potatoes.

I guess it's time to open up a new buiness:

Art's Farm and PC Repair.

Eggs, Honey, White Lightening, Fresh Produce and PC Repairs.

At least they have not figured out how to export America's Grain Belt oversea's.

by ahickman

Actually the only product we produce in this country that people want is food. Maybe all of us IT People out to go to Ag School and become farmers. Out with the Industrial Revolution. Out with the Technology Revolution and In with the Agrarian Revolution.

At least you can make booze out of corn, wheat and potatoes.

I guess it's time to open up a new buiness:

Art's Farm and PC Repair.

Eggs, Honey, White Lightening, Fresh Produce and PC Repairs.

At least they have not figured out how to export America's Grain Belt oversea's.

by shalako

In this like eveything else what goes around comes around.

In a large part it is all driven by price. India, China, and other asian countries have become the Wal-marts in the labor world.

These cheaper products drive small companies out of busines just as Wal-marts have caused thousands of small Mom and Pop operations to cease to exist.

In the long run we the consumer are to blame. We continue to support companies that take our jobs out of the country and we continue to elect people who support tax laws that are benificial to these companies who do so.

In a large part we have to blame our own greed and complacincies as we have become quite lazy in a lot of areas and seem to think we have a supreme right to have all the best with the smallest amount of effort.

Not only is these jobs being out sourced but many are being taken in our own country by immigrants. (both legal and non-legal).

I beleive that what will bring these back in the long run is IT security.

Good Luck and Live Happy
Panama Red

by gought

Certainly if one looks at outsourcing from a strictly corporate viewpoint as a financial alternative it is to be embraced. A java prgrammer in India for $10,000.00 is cheaper than a java programmer inthe U. S. for $50,000.00. All of the financial institutions including Wharton business school would say that is the thing to do.

Are thses corporations NOT U. S. A. companies? Loyalty, support of ones country, opportunity, are all issues. The myth about tchnical competence has been spread by the MEDIA which likes to create rather than report news. We, the american worker are just as knowledgable, far more inventive, reliable, and yes more expensive. The cost is mostly due to living in a society which has a great standard of living, a really good middle class, and no free education. Most of these countries, India, China, etc have free colledge and training programs. The very nature of the Capilistic system which promotes the succes of thes corporations drives the process which creates the American Engineer and Programer. Why is it that most of the intlectual propety is found IN the U. S. A.

by aaron

You are dead on!! Also, do these p*ckerh*ead media folks understand where ALL of this technology originated from???

by outsourcedagain

I had been in Engineering for 18 years when I lost my job to Free Trade in the early 90's. While being out of work for those 3 years I went back to school and got a costly IT education.
After 7 years in IT I lost my job to outsourcing. I was lucky enough to find another IT job for the past 3 years but just got outsourced again.
I have decided to learn a trade like auto mechanics. Nobody is going to send their damn car to India for service.

by ahickman

Right on Brother. I am considering selling the house and buying a farm and at least being able to grow my own food.

by kevin.thomas

I hear from shops that it is hard to find good mechanics and when they do they have to give a good salary. Mechanics salaries are on the rise.

by peteg

Don't get your hopes up that our technology edge isn't gone too! Between outsourcing, legal and illegal aliens and technology transfers, now India, China/Taiwan, Japan and Korea now own most of the technology developments from this country. In the 1970's and 80's we allowed residents of these countries to go to schools in this country and to work in businesses here, due to Liberals in government that made those people a majority in schools. Then most of these individuals took their knowledge back to their home countries, and proceeded to open consulting firms of their own and take away the work from us in the US.

What we need to do as workers is to convince corporate America that our skills are MUCH better than theirs, and be willing to accept lower salaries for now.

Of course, when you are long-term unemployed, more than one year, it is extremely difficult to convince a future employer that your skills are better!

by em dubyah

I'm sitting here thinking of how much I *USED* to be against workers unions. However, looking at history I realize that unions started for a very good AND legitamate reason.

Reasons like this going on. I've had this sinking feeling since 1996, that management has wanted to reduce the IT worker to the level of a hamburger flipper. I hate it when I'm right.

There MUST be a stop to this nonsense. I have 6 certifications with a degree, and it commands absolutely ZERO in the job market. I've been out of work since 12/19/2001.

The games afoot in the IT job market are absolutely PATHETIC.

Case in point.

I used to live in Cary, North Carolina. I UPROOTED my self for a contract position with the No. 5 bank in America, in Charlotte, 200 miles away.

Spent 500 bux in moving expenses and luckily found a roommae situation. Well, all is well and good, then ONE and a HALF weeks into the job, I'm fired because:

1. the "chemistry" insn't right.
2. I patted someone on a shoulder.
3. I ATE SOMEONE'S ONION RING!

Outsourcing and managerial assininity are KILLING the IT industry. I'm sick of it. We're all sick of it.

We NEED....*NEEED* to unite, band together and become a political voice, a POLITICAL FORCE to guard our jobs, out livelyhood. The politicians are selling us out and management is making us grab our ankles, it has to come to a screaching halt, we need to assemble to protect ourselves, our jobs, and our futures.

by aaron

What can we do? Lets get organized... we need some hardcore American-Only companies to lend us support. Any takers?

We need to fight back, and our first confrontation will be from lawmakers.

Aaron

by charleshagen

Let's not get into an outsourcing witch hunt. I own an outsource IT company.

I hire here.

I create jobs here in the US.

I lower company costs here in the US.

I see a witch hunt here at Tech Republic.

Outsourcing to a domestic company is a good thing.

Charle

by ahickman

No one is complaining about internal Outsourcing. It is the only way I make any money these days as a contractor on projects that were outsourced.

Keep up the good work Charlie

by aaron

It all comes down to greed. They utilize their financial woes from 9/11 as an excuse... but it isn't strong enough foundation to send our jobs to India or anywhere else. This is one of those problems, where, if politician's constituents do not hear the cries of their IT workforce fellow citizens, then the result will be unrecoverable. We have already sent our technologies to the rest of the world through one means or another.

Any company sending work or advantageous technology ideas offshore is, in my opinion, participating in espionage, and should be tried as such. The companies that offshore work are saving money to sell their product BACK to US citizens. What is wrong with THIS picture??? If US Citizens would stand up and for 5 straight years BUY AMERICAN, we would be propelled into a new era. Until then, get ready for catastrophic entry into national nothingness. All the money they make in savings, will be utilized quickly in the years of coming corporate starvation. Ultimately, we will no be able to compete with other countries. And the people to blame are those in charge right now, in the Corporate and Federal offices.

by colebme

I agree that we as a nation should work hard to keep business within our nation but outside of helpdesk work what else can they outsource in another country? When the network goes down the people in India can't put there hands on the system. They can't show up at the front door of a business to repair a desktop! I believe Dell computers outsource some of their helpdesk services to a company in India but when they send a technician out to repair the computer I?m sure they didn't fly someone in from India just to repair the computer.

So if more and more big companies are outsourcing, go work for the companies that get the outsourced contracts. There?s more to IT then helpdesk work.

by fdohle

Many large service providers (IBM, CGI) have already opened divisions in India and abroad to actually DEVELOP SOFTWARE.

This is high value add stuff - not help desk - which many of us were well paid for. In the current scenario, this work is never coming back.

Have you ever check out how many software developers are out of work!

by jimgon

As long as corporate America and Wall Street are focused on short term profits and not long term growth outsourcing will continue. The fastest and easiest way to reach short term profits is further cost cutting. In IT that means either machines or people. Right now we are witnessing the people. If companies felt safe in data warehousing offshore I'm sure they would go for that too.

by aaron

Hello, there... nice idea - clandestine online force.... where do we begin??? I am all for it... sign me up - I'll testify before Congress if you want. No problem - anyone, donate time to us in this regard. It'll be worth it.

by tnwilliams53

Its very easy to complain about corporate outsourcing, but lets face reality. Its economics. As long as our tax structure makes it sound and other companies have a lower cost of living it will continue. This has been happening to manufacturing for a long time. How is it really different from automation coming to factory. The IT industry is just getting what its done to others

by winnielorson

Having been made redundant (by a US corporation taking the work back to the US!!)at the tender age of 46 a couple of years ago, and with little prospect of finding another job anywhere near as well paid as the one I was in, I feel that I can speak with some experience.

The whole point of a company is to make money for the shareholders and therefore should keep it's costs ot a minimum. By outsourcing IT, and other disciplines, to India, it follows the golden rule of economics that it is trying to maximise profits thereby making the company, and the general economy, stronger. This is the basis of how the US economy has been built up over the last few hundred years and has made it what it is today, the worlds richest and most consumer orientated. It is called "free trade" and what makes the global economy richer and generates profits for the consumers of other countries to buy more US goods, whatever they may be.

So ends the economics lesson !!

by mikalos

Let's not forget that as we increase the knowledge of and access to our data and systems management infrastructure, we make ourselves more vulnerable to terrorism. It seems ironic to me that as we are tightening the physical access to certain groups and individuals to our country, we are at the same time making the 'doors' to the technological framework, upon which ALL Americans rely upon for all our needs, potentially more accessible to those same groups and individuals. Can we truly rely upon foreign enterprises to protect our interests and minimize our security risks? And getting back to the original question here - why should we when we have qualified, unemployed Americans?

by the_gnome

Security is laughable in all levels of government IT. The only reason security budgets are growing in the private sector is people are suing over data exposure. The same companies that have no problem turning their IP over to persons they never met and that are outside US legal jurisdiction will have no problem handing over the keys to the kingdom.

by yelt62

I actually have a friend who worked on a major project for me that is there. If I wanted to work in a call center or write code, then sure I would go there. I prefer working with the customer and being a solution provider, not necessarily doing the coding.

by ahickman

Voting a Pol out of office is not the answer.

What we want to really do is to bankrupt a company that purchases services from an IT provider that Outsources.

I wonder if WalMart purchases services from a company that outsources IT Jobs....

WalMart, or someone like WalMart would be the perfect target for a anti-outsourcing boycott.

WalMart is running these ads on how WalMart went into Los Angeles and helped rebuild an inner city neighborhood.

So, the new slogan for WalMart would be; "Once we have ruined your neighborhoods economy by outsouring the IT Jobs, then we will come in and save you, buy giving all the out of work IT Professionals jobs in our WalMart for close to minimum wage."

On the bright side, our $300,000 + houses will only cost us $30,000 to repurchase when we move back into the hood. And there will be a ton of used SUV's for a couple of thousand for us to purchase so we can re-live the halycon days of IT.

If this were not so serious, it would be funny.

by ahickman

Voting a Pol out of office is not the answer.

What we want to really do is to bankrupt a company that purchases services from an IT provider that Outsources.

I wonder if WalMart purchases services from a company that outsources IT Jobs....

WalMart, or someone like WalMart would be the perfect target for a anti-outsourcing boycott.

WalMart is running these ads on how WalMart went into Los Angeles and helped rebuild an inner city neighborhood.

So, the new slogan for WalMart would be; "Once we have ruined your neighborhoods economy by outsouring the IT Jobs, then we will come in and save you, buy giving all the out of work IT Professionals jobs in our WalMart for close to minimum wage."

On the bright side, our $300,000 + houses will only cost us $30,000 to repurchase when we move back into the hood. And there will be a ton of used SUV's for a couple of thousand for us to purchase so we can re-live the halycon days of IT.

If this were not so serious, it would be funny.

by kevin.thomas

I went back to school full time in 1998, wiped out my savings and aquired a student loan in the process, to make a career change into this field.
I was told by schools that it was a good field and could make 40K right out of school. Well after graduating 20K was the figure if you were lucky to land a job. It just went downhill from there. I did my part of wiping out my savings to survive while in school ($35,000 No this is not a misprint: 35K). If a company is not willing to give me some training to benefit them were is the loyalty supposed to come from, overseas? You say get all the certs out there to stay on top. I have bought many books to try to stay educated at $80 to $100 a pop and there are hundreds more to buy. You cannot learn everything and expect to be prficient at all of them. There are so many certs out there that if you were to try to do this you would be cert rich with no real experience, and new ones pop up every couple of months.

I have a family life after work and cannot afford to neglect that. There has to be a balance. That is why there are so many problems with society today because no one takes the quality time to be with their families, TOO busy with work. Maybe you are single and work is your life but as you get older and have a family hopefully that will change for the sake of your family.

by kangdan

Anyone can emphathize with Mr. Orpheum but facts are facts. Its a world economy now so everyone is competing at the global scale. Your not vieing for a job with your neighbor or your countrymen, your vieing for it with those in China, India and any other cheap labor nation. And of course, that competition is hardly fair when countries such as China have a population of over a billion people and the labor regulators seems to enjoy a "hands-off" approach letting wages fall to the extreme. Supposedly the advocates say that this will only lead to a better wealthier America. With the export of "menial" jobs overseas there will be greater jobs here at home. But these greater jobs require greater education and soon the prerequiste will be at least at the Master degree level. How is that going to happen with the state of our educational system? Workers that are disenfranchised should get assistance from the government. Career transitions at the post-prime part of anyone's life is anything but a cakewalk. Those that say "just get another job" are insensitive and ignorant to the plight of the working man.

Even though these are the growing pains of a new economy there must be the role of government in all this to smooth out the transitions between one economy to the next.

by dilbert_envy

As long as corporations are allowed to export American jobs for profit our standard of living -- in fact even our very lives themselves -- are in serious danger.

No job = no benefits = no medical care = death. It's a slow process, but if you have been out of work for over a year (like many in IT) you have a good picture.

If I were somehow able to get a job in India (fat chance) I would still have to pay US taxes on my "offshore" income. American corporations that operate "offshore" seem to have multiple tax breaks. Since we have the best government that money can buy, this is no surprise.

Acting against the national public interest for personal profit is close enough to the formal definition of TREASON to start treating it as such. It is certainly time those of us in the industry that are adversely impacted (almost all of us that are US citizens) started calling it TREASON in public. Maybe then the news media would start listening and the nest of political rats in DC would start to leave the sinking ship of corporate moral decay.

by wolfen357

I don't understand. How does this help the US economy? Were paying wages outside of the country that will not be put back into our economy. Oh! I forgot the propaganda. That the money saved by companies will lower the price of consumer goods. Name me a couple of companies that made a profit and past it back to the consumers by lowering their prices. If they did that then a CEO might only make 19 Million a year instead of his normal 25 Million. The same "Top Brass" that makes the big bucks are the ones laying off their own people sighting "Economic Forecast Concerns". If every high level exec. and board member took one million less in salary per year. Think if how many jobs that would save. Better yet, take some of that salary and reinvest it in your own company. I think they call it helping to "stimulate the economy".

by fwheels

RIGHT ON!
In the long run outsourcing will not have an effect, but as Economist John Maynard Keynes said, in the long run we all be dead.
It is time to discourage outsourcing the way we encourage and discourage economic behavior, the tax code. Disallow deductions for outsourcing expenses, provide credits for keeping jobs here in the USA. Encourage anyone who has had to deal with a customer rep outside the US, who often speaks poor and broken incomprehensible English, for a US product to complain to the BBB, their Congressman, Senator, any appropriate federal agency, etc.

by bwinters

Outsourcing does lower the cost of doing business and may benefit shareholders, company profits, and consumers - at least in the short term. However, consumers are a mixed bag as many are now unemployed or have taken jobs for significantly lower pay, forcing them to buy cheaper items made/outsourced from/to foreign lands. Vicious circle from a consumer's perspective. While we live in a global economy, let's not forget that America?s economy is still very frail.

If we take a company that decides to outsource some of its jobs and lay off a thousand people, then continue to give that company tax breaks while removing tax-paying jobs from the U.S. workforce, who is the beneficiary? The government will need to pay out more for welfare, unemployment, and other programs to help the unemployed. Let's not forget about Social Security and Medicare - there is a huge baby-boom population moving into retirement at the same time jobs are being outsourced. We also can't forget about the mounting defecit - mostly from assistance abroad. So the large baby-boom generation (taxpayers) is moving into retirement while the smaller workforce (taxpayers) that follows is losing jobs. Who is going to pay for all of this? Tax increases surely can?t be far behind.

With the Bush tax cuts, new jobs are indeed being created but many of the better jobs are not being realized in the U.S. How does this benefit America's economy? There are companies in India now constructing large office buildings for call-centers, IT, etc that will employ over 10,000 people based on jobs outsourced from the U.S. alone. Not only did America lose these jobs, but imagine how it effected peripheral jobs like construction, engineering, telecommunications, and various suppliers. Imagine what it could have meant to the U.S. economy.

Outsourcing has been around for a long time - just look at the auto and electronic industries. To some extent, I suppose it's a natural evolution of business, but at a time when the U.S. is recovering from a recession, it makes no sense to me. The tax cuts were supposed to spur business into action and help the economy, not give the jobs away. Somewhere along the line, that purpose was lost. In my opinion, the only ones who truly benefit from this strategy are the foreign companies, U.S. companies doing business this way, and possibly their shareholders. I believe that if a U.S. company is going to outsource jobs, they are taking away tax-paying opportinities from the U.S. and should therefore either not enjoy any related tax breaks or be taxed more. Nothing comes without a price.

by ahickman

Again...we need to pick a target retail company that uses the services of IT Provider that Outsources and do a boycott. Lower Stock Prices and falling revenue send a very strong message to business about the effects of Outsourcing.

by ebanksto

I have been without a job for 6 months. Partly because I sat in place too long (mea culpa). I agree that outsourcing is indeed having an impact on industry. I think we need to consider it dangerous for other reasons, not because of the I think outsourcing is loss of jobs, but because it is placing the US in a precarious position from a security perspective.

First, indulge me and let me have a general discussion of perceived economics. Outsourcing is actually not new. It has been occurring in out life for years. How many times have you walked into a store and picked up something that had a "made in China" sticker? Check out the clothes you wear, they are probably made in Mexico, or the Philippines, or Egypt, or somewhere outside the US. In the 70?s there was an outrage about textile manufacturing being sent to ?sweat shops? or international spots of manufacturing to improve corporate profits. Have you ever played in the stock market? If you have you, your goal is to make some cash along the way. You hope that the company will reduce costs and increase profit so that the shares of stock you hold will grow in value and give you high dividends. The top executives are trying to comply.

I was angry at first with the outsourcing. However, is that just like clothes manufacturing went across the water, so will other jobs. It is inevitable. Many companies today are being forced into finding cost efficient alternatives so that they can stay competitive in their respective marketplaces. Driving this is the large retail corporations that are demanding lower process from the manufacturers and suppliers so they can then pass them on to you. Since most profit is percentage based, the lower prices mean lower dollars on the same item. In some cases, the products cannot be made fast enough in the US. Buy a set of CD?s lately for burning copies of whatever? I bet you are happy when the prices drop. Most people are. This means WE have to decide what OUR future holds. We need to decide how we can affect the thoughts of those making the decisions that if we keep making Americans poorer but reducing their income levels and reduce the available spending dollars.

Now, back to the security issues, I feel that are rising. Currently, the FBI is attempting to get the FCC to make changes to the infrastructure that will allow them to tap ANY internet connection. The FBI is pressuring the FCC to go around the normal investigative process. Do they have something to hide? This could introduce methods that could be exploited for corporate espionage, open a lot of personal information as it gets carried across the expanse of the internet, etc. oh sure there is that encryption thing, but the technology must exist to get around this if the FBI is desiring the internet taps. I could get into religious implications, but that is another subject. Think about it.

On the last note, I want to leave you with something else to ponder. How much has gasoline gone up in the last 4 years? And now with the demands of China on petroleum imports, we could see the cost go to $3/gallon. Hmmm. Sound more like a great reason for telecommuting and, of course, using the internet to do business. Hmmmm.

by jwschull9

Orpheum has a right to be angry. Mark my words... Come election time, the current administration (and congress) will pay dearly for the lack of foresight into the cause of this problem. Come to think of it, their hindsight is pretty bad also.

I predict a backlash, and corresponding income tax laws enacted that level the playing field.

First thing that needs to be done is to take the corporate tax incentive out of exporting jobs and importing labor.

Good corporate citizens have a responsability to create jobs. Congress and (current and) past administrations have given corporations tax advantages because they wanted to enhance their jobs creation ability. It worked in the past. It's called "trickle-down economics". Trickle-down economics no longer works because it relies on a good faith "implied" contract to produce jobs. Because of the lack of corporate integrity, we can no longer expect corporations to respect any "implied" contracts... Recent history proves this fact.

Tax laws need to be revised to address these BAD CORPORATE CITIZENS!

by buschman_007

There's no way to stop outsourcing of jobs, but we can certainly make it a less desirable option. Just like taxation on imported vehicles, the government needs to enact laws that more heavily monitors and taxes companies that want to go the outsourcing route. What does this accomplish? Well the only reason to outsource is purely finiancial, there's no other advantage. Like has been said this is a global econ and everyone wants a piece of American $$$. Let's make em pay for in the form of taxation! So if companies do choose to still outsource money is funneled back into the country(unless, god forbid, Bush is still in office) which can support programs for training and education to make our workers stronger, smarter, and more desirable.

I've spoken to a couple people that have tried to outsource IT, and more than a few penny pinchers have lost their job over the debocale outsourced IT turns into. I'm the IT Manager for a company which outsources it's programming to Inida, and I'll tell you I don't like it one bit. When I have friends that are programmers and out of work and you got these guys working for next to nothing and the company is saving a bundle... Where's the incentive to change?

Hopes and dreams aren't going to change this outsourcing trend. But taxes could.

Mike

by charleshagen

Government is interesting. Our politicians talk the talk, but fail to walk the walk. Here in WI we had a capital seed bill that would have allowed me to hire about 300 employees and expand my business competitively.

It never passed through the State Assembly because one politician said they could not afford it.

My only question is can they afford NOT to pass it?

My motivation is to create jobs profitably.

They look else where. Let's outsource our government...Perhaps Indies can do a better job than who we elected.

Charles

by richard.mandanici

This Email is great!!! I would like to echo this gentleman's remarks, STOP SENDING AMERICAN TECHNOLOGY JOBS TO INDIA FOR THE SAKE OF CORPORATE AMERICA'S BOTTOM LINE. A mesage for corporate America CEO's, STOP SENDING TECHNOLOGY JOB'S OVERSEAS OR THE NEXT JOB TO BE OUTSOURCED MAY BE YOUR OWN!

by clintonroane341

When I first saw the article on Tech Republic I too was disgusted that TechRepublic would publish this information. Why can't America see the big picture. Our economy is already a mess and our job market is being ruled by Asian, Indians and other countries. When America becomes a third world country then we will realize the mistakes we've made. What will you tell your children/grandchildren???

by charleshagen

We DO NOT need a Union. Unions are the primary reason China manufactures today the way they do.

We DO need an Underwriters Laboratory type of organization that people can be a member of. It would insure quality among the American IT workforce and hence people would choose it for the Quality in Work it represents.

Everyone sound off if you like the idea.

ITQ (IT Quality) Certification and membership would possibly help?

by american_it_guy

help the job picture.
ISO = International
It is us against them, not where do I sign up to be a part of the big team.
If it was fair, it would be different.
Can you survive on $1.50 an hour in our economy?
I can't.
The way we are going now, there is sure to be a collapse of the dollar.

by dscapuano

As one who has seen two of my jobs outsourced to India, my gut feeling is to agree. However, the fact that you published such a story only shows that you are oblivious to the plight of the very people that subscribe to your service.

I also feel, however, that this is not a fight to be taken up at this level. This must be taken up at the political level. Two successive administrations of our government (that I know of) have contributed to this problem, one democrat and one republican. India, and other Asian nations have the most restrictive trade barriers in the world. We can't sell our goods to them no matter what we do. But we have purchased consulting contracts from them with great abandon. I would not mind sending jobs to India if they would be willing to purchase consulting services from us.

They won't, and why should they. All of the major tech companies have subsidiaries in India. They do not need to go out of their own country to purchase IBM or HP services and they do not need to hire American workers no matter what.

It is the politicians of both parties that have sold out the American worker. However, the press (tech republic) should not play a hand in it. Please put on you editorial thinking caps before publish.

Dave Capuano
On Unemployment in New Jersey after 27 years in the business.

by ejmuller1

In general I do agree with you. I think that companies are being incredibly short sighting by shipping so many jobs overseas. The American public soon won't be able to afford the goods and services here because all the jobs will be over there.

However, I do take exception to your last paragraph. Breadwinners are not exclusively male. In fact, in my family I have always been the one who supported the family. Please be aware of sexist comments like that. Thanks.

by jfoster

Globalization is here... to stay. Complaining about the U.S. IT worlds lack of foresight is ridiculously passe and makes "Orpheum" look like chicken little!

This trend is not just an IT concern. Every service based component in the US food chain is and will continute to be affected by this "evolutionary" trend. Just as you cannot stop your chess opponents hand from moving his/her piece into check or check mate position... the train has left the station!!!

Now, what are we going to do (other than whine about it) to shore up, re-tool, strategize and make good on what we do best?

That is what this topic should be discussing... not "history"!!!

by sageadvice

Do not let anybody try and magic you, the job losses and long term impact on our economy is significant. What is worse from a customer standpoint is terrible service you get if you need to have help with a legitimate problem. In a significant number of instances you get sent to India or some other place for customer service. At some point the customer representative runs out of scripts if the problem is really difficult and one of two things happens. First and most frequently they hang up on you and you have to spend 30 min to an hour trying to get through again. Second, when at at dead end they tell you to reboot (microsoft) and call back. Click. In the case of AOL they tell you reinstall AOL or go to the next bug filled release. Service down profits up. Greed wins again.

by injun_cowboy

OK, this may sound old, but I feel your pain. Yet, having been there (am a telecom veteran), I've realized that muzzling the free press (like the good folks at TR) ain't the answer. The execs aint't depending on TR's reports to make their decisions - there are numerous other sources.

by jfoster

Great move... let me add that what is missing with work from home model is the "new" employment contract that comes with the territory. It basically compensates the home based employee on his/her productivity... not just a 40 hour work week. There need to be measures put in place that track/report/incentivize, etc. an employee and make them responsible for their work deliverable.

This concept is coming and will eliminate managements concerns of "Is John really working while he is at his home office and not doing personal activities?"

by fdohle

I've Been in IT for over 20 years and have never seen such an erosion of jobs in almost any industry! In simple economic terms, the connectivity of the internet has now allowed these emerging ecomomies to "Dump" labour in our markets.
- Try dumping a ship load of steel or automobiles in North America! - Customs agents will be on this like a dirty shirt - laying tarrifs left right and centre - why then are these economies allowed to dump labour?
- The big issue I see is that the IT industry has never had any "political representation" (aka unions) Unions have never really established themselves since we have always been well paid. I've never been one to "cotton up" to unions - but at this point - without any political representation - how will the net "outflow" of employment stop.
- Remember, at this point, with out political representation - these jobs will NEVER RETURN!
- Finally - these "reduced" salaries which have now been moved "off shore" is money which will never be really spent here. China - which has pegged it's currency to about 10% the value of the US Dollar has insured that they will almost never purchase any "manufactured" products from us or Europe(remember - as an ecomomy thrives, it's currency should increase in value -making some of our finished goods competitive!). As they have now "commoditized" what was previously "high value add" service, we will now be relegated to supplying nothing but Raw matierial and commodities to these players.
- Yes, it may be a bit of an exageration - but we will again be relegated to being nothing but hewers of wood and drawers of water
- Write your local political rep and let him know how you feel! At this point, only political action will level the playing field and re-patriate this significant piece of our economy

by ahickman

Bring one retailer to his knees over external outsourcing will get more results than writing the politicians.

by jim.azeltine

I was totally pissed when I saw that Tech Republic was HELPING to outsource our jobs. I and my coworkers are facing layoffs, and we have been asked if we would accept a pay cut or reduced hours in order to save the jobs of coworkers. Recently, my company has opened a development center in India, and while I understand the financial reasons for this, it doesn't help how I feel. They are forced to do it because the others are doing it. The morale where I work is dismal.
It is my opinion that this will eventually result in the next (and much worse) recession. All will appear to be ok, as profits rise due to lower overhead. Once enough people lose their jobs due to outsourcing and moving maufacturing jobs overseas, the housing market will start to go down as more people lose their homes. Profits will evetually fall as sales decline and growth becomes negative.
I know that if I lose my job, my 26 year career will be over. Two of my friends lost their jobs, neither found another. One lost the house, the car, everything.
The only thing we can do now is to convince the American public to boycott the big companies that are responsible for most of the outsourcing, they are making it impossible for other corporations not to follow along.

by dazhig

No laws, no campaign promises will stop the trend of outsourcing. Only the American consumers can stop it by boycotting whoever that does outsourcing, including those that helps and prmotes outsourcing such as M. & C. Otherwise what you predicted will happen: worse recession and housing market free fall.

by drmemory

The U.S. economy has a long history of pioneering industries and paring them down to highly efficient producers. To do so means that what was once rare and specialized becomes a commodity, a transformation that creates economic value. Yes, it also means that the employment picture changes and often quicker than the employees can adapt in todays world. Although adversely impacted by the changes in IT, I refuse to be seduced by 'victim's rhetoric' and bemoan the very system that has brought me so much opportunity in the past. I choose to believe that my future is not constrained by the past.

by mrwassermann

Hello,

Most people who think outsourcing is a good thing,
are either in management or just intreated in the bottom line.

I feel the american worker is being punished for making america what it is today. You can allways
find someone who is willing to work for less. So
why not offshore the high paid exec? Or the Doctors, I bet we can get a bunch of cheap lawyers
for over seas to boot! So if we offshore all the jobs, we can all be burger flippers!

Let's look at history to see if it makes sence to
offshore manufacturing and IT, not to mention other important jobs.

Lets look at WW II: We manufactured equipment for
the US Army, Navy and Air Fource, but also supplied, England, France, Russia and at least a dozen more. Germany could never hope to keep up and thus they were over run.

Then looks at the cold war with Russia, we forced them to spend huge amounts of money trying to keep up with our technology. We won because we had superior technology.

What would happen if after time, our technical edge were lost and China or India or Pakistan became the world tech leader?

We were nearly 50 years ahead of them, but they are fast catching up.

We educate and train their people at the expense of our own. Then they talk what they have learned and go back to their own country and start building the same products, but now they don't need us.

Don't say it can't happen, because it did, just look at the oil industry, we go in set things up and then they host nation takes over. It was our technology that got them out of the stone age.

So my advice, keep giving things away until America is no longer a world leader.

I am sure everyone would like a job flipping burgers.

Michael

by peteg

Michael et al,

You mention burger flipping -- if all of us lose our jobs, who is going to buy the burgers? I eat out once every two months because I lost my IT job 3 years ago and can't get another. Some people say "Update your skills!". Who is going to pay for that? I don't have any savings left. I even had to spend my IRA and pay the penalties for that! And the Federal Government doesn't even know I exist any more, because I'm off unemployment (it ran out 2 years ago).

This is what galls me the most.

by ken_yoshimoto

Not only are IT jobs being outsourced overseas to India, but H1B IT engineers from overseas are taking our jobs here in the US. After my company went belly-up, even with 20 years as an IT engineer, I was left jobless. Mid-level managers from overseas who don't understand what it takes to be a successful IT engineering manager were hiring young just out of college H1B applicants while I struggled to make ends meet.

This used to be a good profession, but found myself out of work for 14 months. For the last year and a half I have worked at 40% of my old salary with no benefits. I do 50% more work than my H1B co-workers who are making more twice what I make. They ask me job-related questions I learned in the "school of hard knocks."

I am now contemplating a career change just to support my family. I see a large skillset being permanently lost from our workforce because of H1B Visas and off-shoring.

by todd

How many times have we, as consumers, called a company that has outsourced their customer service department and received poor customer service? How many times have we called about a defective product only to be told, it will be taken care of in the next version. You know, the one where the price doubles because they had to hire someone that actually earned all the certifications instead of making them up to get the job and no body bother to check the credentials.

Yet, most of us still tolerate it for various reasons.

Until we say enough is enough, and stop doing business with companies that are trying to find a way to cut cost at the expense of customer service, or product quality, we have no one to blame but ourselves.

I firmly believe in the old adage, ?You get what you pay for.?

by injun_cowboy

Sorry, but I find that the Indian at the other end of the phone is more likely to be nicer and caring than I have seen coming from our cus-serv folks here in the USA. Really. Why, just a year back there were articles galore about how bad our cus-serv had gotten! Fact is, the 1st step to good CS is having a caring tone - not typically found in our CS folks.