Discussion Locked

Thanx for the tips to promote more Outsourcing

0 helpful
393 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

393 replies

by dazhig

I am sure we can find a President in another country that does not need a jumbo 747 and a fleet of SUVs and chefs, etc. A lot cheaper, isn't it?

by ahickman

So they tax big corporations that outsource more money. The big corporation passes on the cost to consumers.

Boycott a retailer is the only way to stop this.

Hit them where they live....in the bottom line and public relations

by peteg

You can't be thinking in the right groove! The Fed should tax each Corporation $10,000 per outsource employee in India or wherever per year they do that, and THAT corporation will probably listen and do what's right!

What do you think?

by ahickman

If passed, the new tax law will go into effect on January 1, 2006 and a grandfather clause will state that all jobs sent off shore prior to 1/1/06 will not be taxed.

Nice..............by 1/1/06 there may be little or no IT in the USA

by american_it_guy

the fair playing field thing.

....The cross sections of our economy must be compatible. That is what the trade policy was supposed to do, keep things fair.

If we have not seen "close up and personal" human populations grasping for a life and food for their family, then we can't say much about what we do not understand in the reality of it all.

by ahickman

Ok....find a retailer and boycott them. Put them out of business and say....If you outsource your IT out of the country, you better move cause no one is going to buy your products anymore.

Go sell your goods in India, China and Mexico...if they will let you

by injun_cowboy

I think the current IT outsourcing uproar has to do with a form of racism. Yes, that's what it it. Tell you why. 'Cos it's jobs going to places like India, Mexico & China. No one cried foul when techie jobs went to the factories set up in Good Ol' Ireland, or Poland, or Germany or Holland or England. No sir! Those guys are OK. C'mon folks, you know it!

by huh?what?

Germany, UK, Canada and so on basically have the same standard of living as the US. If they can beat us on price/quality then so be it. Also, the trade with them is two-way.

by ramrhein

first manufacturing goes away and we're told don't worry knowledge jobs will take over. now that the knowledge jobs are going away whta next, service jobs? ther's only so many mcdonalds and walmarts out there. if there are fewer decent paying jobs, who will have money to buy the products?

by peteg

I've been out of work since April 2001! I was a successful System Administrator, but there hasn't been any work in the New York City area for 3 years. Certainly 9/11 made it a lot worse.

Some people say "Why don't you move to where jobs are?", to them I say "Who is going to pay for it?" My unemployment ran out two years ago. There are also those who say "Upgrade your skills!" To them I say the same thing "Who is going to pay for it?" I have no savings left, no IRA left and my wife is only working part-time. Do I understand why I can't get a job? NO! I'm 59 years old, have a mortgage, and a working life left of about 10 years or less. Who would hire me? Age discrimination? Hell yes!

If this is a recovery, where are the jobs? Why doesn't the Fed count the long-term unemployed? Because they don't care, and the Democrats are just as guilty as the Republicans.

Why doesn't the government give assistance to the long-term unemployed? See above.

I'm mad and can't take it anymore.

by ahickman

Maybe us baby boomers need to start a ground swell movement against outsourcing. Look what we did in the 60's and 70's.

By the way, first one to boycott is CNet.

Write them and tell them you will no longer read their articles, or support their advertisers.

And tell TechRepublic to take the HP Ad's off or they are next to go the way of the dinasour.

by peteg

Maybe all of us IT people need to start a drumbeat against Federal policy allowing Outsourcing. We need for EVERY IT person to send email to President Bush, Vice President Cheney and all their Congress people demanding they do something about the problem. If we do that in LARGE numbers, they will listen.

by rmuldavin

Outsourcing IT jobs to lower wage people in other countries, losing a job here in USA, pain, pain, pain.

I'm to the far left-(out), in my 70th year of age, from Berkeley in the Sixties (1951-1969), so you might quess my views.

Uniting workers is no overnight venture.

Corporate mogols have the upper hand on force, unfortunately mostly male money managers if progress towards a fair and decent world is a goal.

It might be argued that "outsourcing" makes sense towards such a goal, but not by "democratic" means since the "masses" are not up to it.

Well, we're not: we're "designed" to live among smaller groupings of peoples, thus our large popuations exceeded our initial evolutionary capability.

My take is this: mate, don't hate, nor hesitate to procreate, work any vocation of conscience, organize and love locally, reach globally, the world is complex, and IT is a tool, as was cuneform, alphanumberic, paper, printed writing, ... as well as computer assisted communication.

Get to the root causes, get "radical", communicate with the "outsourced" workers of the world, unite, you have nothing to loose but your Cheneyes, and others lost in the hypnotics of money management, parading as "believers" while acting as decievers.

Pace yourself, long live the loving workers of the world!

Best, rm

by ahickman

Is there an out of work web site developer that would want to work on a Boycott Companies that outsource jobs out of the US?

If so, contact me. Plus the Liberal Press will eat this up and bring this site out to the world.

And as we know, most of the press in this country is very Left Wing.....

by injun_cowboy

"Liberal Press" ... what are you a commie-pinko? A "liberal press" is what makes America great - else, we'd all be "unfair and imbalanced" like Fox (god forbid!). Liberal is NOT the left - Liberal means "fairminded and accepting". Something old Bill claims to be, but is not.

by ahickman

What I meant is that the liberal press will pick this up. The conservative press will not want to touch this as they feel the real focus of the elections is American Security and Defeating Terrorism. Listen to Limbaugh and Hannity. This subject hardly ever comes up

by the_gnome

The whole point of outsourcing is to get rid of the _American_ worker, not to get rid of the _office_ worker. The real difference in cost to the company depends on the country in which the worker sits, not the building.

by jfoster

The POINT of outsourcing is CHEAPER LABOR... the RESULTS are certain level jobs being lost to another market... typically outside the US at this point.

There will be many IT jobs that CANNOT be outsourced and those are the ones IT folks need to retool and focus on.

by peteg

Maybe you don't realize it, but US expertise. productivity and resourcefulness was the best in the world until the 1990's when Outsourcing began. US Productivity is still the best in the world, but expertise is now in the hands of the rest of the world.

What we don't want to happen is a total collapse of the economy, which will happen if the US doesn't stem the tide of outsourcing quickly. In our country, we don't have a Socialist government with free health care and education for all citizens. In this country, if you are unemployed, you have NO health care, NO education money, and will lose your housing if unemployed for very long! Where does that leave us? Out of luck totally! THINK ABOUT IT.

by altekmg

I have been a champion of work from home for more years than I would like to admit. I started a campain with my then employer in 1988 to have systems analysts and support personnel work from home.

It took almost 7 years but when we finally received approval the results were amazing.

I (and every other manager willing to try it) sat down with our direct reports and negotiated what constituted 40 hours of work. The amount varied with the individual. I had twice weekly meetings with the work at homes to review work schedules and assist with any obstacles.

After about six or eight weeks I was finding I needed to suggest to the analysts that they might want to spend a little less time logged on. Yes, I was seeing connect times in the wee hours of the morning and late at night. Productivity went up a little over 27%.

People will meet or exceed your expectation of them. And they will put as much effort into the work as the management pays attention to the goal.

Just my experience with work from home.

Thomas L.Smith Jr.

by peteg

Melanie,

The problem is, for every 10 companies that Outsource, only 1 out of 10 is rehiring. The rest won't even consider rehiring at a lower wage; they'd rather keep it overseas.

by init

What you thought of just a temporary worker to come to USA for no more than 3 years is no longer true, these individuals are now finding companies that would hire them and resolve their immigrations status permanently. All the employer has to do, is to demonstrate that the skill set required to fulfill that opening wasn't available from the pool of unemployed. However, and as we all know it, companies cheat when they do this. They post jobs with ridiculos salaries and requirements, so that very few people apply for it, thus, eliminating any other possible candidate.

Then there's also the multitude of freelancer, filling up all of the contract positions, with rates as low as a school teacher. And how are these folks able to afford anything? Simple, these folks move from town to town to where the projects are, they leave on apartments without buying a house, thus, paying taxes. So not only they take our jobs, our money, but they make use of our highways, schools, parks and others, and don't pay the properity taxes, that you and I pay.

This is why the government implemented the so called "Compensatory Tax", but just like anything else, these folks have found ways to go around it.

by injun_cowboy

What we really need, folks, is less whining about offshore outsourcing, and more thought into how to make your next contract absolutely water tight. Just 5 years back, when companies were dying to attract talent, why, the frsh faces out of college asked and got everything. But they did not have it in a WT contract. That's what we need. Then it will cost your bosses more to lose you! And if they still op to do that, take your money, honey, and go retire in Sunny Goa! Yeah!

by ahickman

As we all know, labor contracts are hard to enforce. Especially if you do not live in a right to work state.

by youraveragemanager

Keep spreading your message, I have no problem with how any message is presented, form is less important than substance.

Those of us involved in technology have an affinity toward attributing logic assuming that well conceived strategy and objectives motivate our organizational leadership. Technology people are creative, and this allows us to paint a logic-based model in our own minds as to why anything happens. This is great when applied to systems development, but less useful when applying it to people, the decision-makers.

I was challenged by a friend to try this rationalization out for a while. Stop thinking that the decision-makers are using higher thought processes or a rational plan that contributes to success of the organization and the people within it. Advised that if I simply attribute their actions to plain old stupidity the results are the same.

Ouch!

In IT, we can all remember back to where a few of our end-user customers practically accused us of deliberately creating a bug, or system failure just to make their life miserable. We would push back the question, "so you think we planned to enjoy the opportunity to have this type of relationship with you?"

Ladies and Gentlemen the problem is larger than just BPO.

by dilbert_envy

Outsourcing today (and yesterday) is greed for the sake of quick individual _personal_ profit. It occurs at the management level without thought, or care, as to the long term impact, or harm to the coropration, the overall economy, or the national interest.

Many of us in the US and UK are already working at jobs that pay "offshore" wages -- when we can find them. The deliverables from those jobs other jobs exported to the mythical "well educated" Indian workforce are of often of sub-standard quality, causing the true overall production rates to sink, and final product to fall short of end customer expectations.

Quality dosen't cost, it pays -- and it's never going to be found by going to the least expensive method.

by dilbert_envy

Outsourcing today (and yesterday) is greed for the sake of quick individual _personal_ profit. It occurs at the management level without thought, or care, as to the long term impact, or harm to the coropration, the overall economy, or the national interest.

Many of us in the US and UK are already working at jobs that pay "offshore" wages -- when we can find them. The deliverables from those jobs other jobs exported to the mythical "well educated" Indian workforce are of often of sub-standard quality, causing the true overall production rates to sink, and final product to fall short of end customer expectations.

Quality dosen't cost, it pays -- and it's never going to be found by going to the least expensive method.

by tags

What?? You think that blasting off email to this technical newsletter alias is "standing up for your future"? You're just venting. What are you REALLY doing to fight this problem? Are you voting in the primaries? Are you writing letters to your senators and congressman? Are you telling the people who can do something about it? Are you leading demonstrations? This isn't new since 2001. When I was starting a new project at my company in 2001, we were taking over software development from a team in India. When I was interviewing for a job 2 years before that, that team was using people in India. This is not new stuff. It's just growing - maybe because it's working. Maybe because it's the last straw for companies trying to make a buck. No, it's not good for us IT people. But, stop venting and get your butt out there and vote. Make yourself heard by the people who can do something about it.

by johnnysacks

The same story with blue collar workers in the 80's and 90's. Now it's white collar. Begs the question how many out of work in IT voted Republican. What was the last Bush generation that had a friggin' clue about what it's like to live paycheck to paycheck? Has anyone in house or senate ever had the pleasure of needing Cobra?

1. Corporate influence buys politicians in DC
2. Politicians allow freedom to outsource and provide incentives like capital gains and income tax reductions and subsidies for the people who directly benefit from American job loss.
4. Reduced taxes = less money available to aid the Americans now out of work. Little things like health care, unemployment. Dump it in the states' lap where taxes MUST increase for the remaining employed to offset the Federal fund reductions.

At what point does the glorified ponzi scheme that our economy is beginning to resemble collapse?

by ahickman

So, lets build a WEB Site and advertise it via every means possible and let people click on a button and send a note to Politicians....

by lrsprague

I must concur with Orpheum on this, TechRepublic! Last year, I worked at Intel as a contractor in Oregon, along with several other NQL Test Engineers, and sadly, the building I was in was 80% vacant. You know where those jobs went? INDIA, that's right: INDIA. Intel laid-off most of their permanent workforce since 9/11 and sent those jobs overseas, just like Orpheum mentions that IBM did. Now, I understand that high tech companies need to invest in and develop markets where they foresee the next generation of sales going to, however, it's very short-sighted to do so at the cost of those American jobs and innovations which made these companies great in the first place! I am not prejudice. INDIA has one of the lowest costs of living in the world, while maintaining a free education system that provides high tech learning at low or NO cost, to their citizenry. The result is that graduates from INDIAN universities can live on $10,000/yr. versus an avg. of $70,000 - $90,000/yr. for the equivalent American IT professional. No wonder that companies are flocking to INDIA, Pakistan, Taiwan and the Phillipines for lower cost labor!! The problem is my friends, that in being concerned for their current quarter's results, greedy executives have damaged their country's long-term ability to compete in the world with made in the USA products & services. I am another statistic in the post-9/11 job loss tragedy, and I'm but one of millions in the same boat! When are American executives going to wake up to the long-term damage they are causing and when is our government going to intervene so that people like US will have an opportunity to return to work at a reasonable wage?

by rfdemond

I've read this thread and never have I been more ashamed to be an american. Greedy corporate executives, uncaring management... Get a grip - Corporate executives are in their roles to minimize costs and maximize profits period! It appears that many of you feel that your employer's owe you a job, guess what ...they don't. You owe them, you owe them quality, dedication, loyalty and a days work for a days pay.

You are all correct, the primary reason jobs are going offshore is due to greed, the problem with all of you is though that you think the greed is on the part of Corporate America, I submit to you that it is your greed that is causing it!!! This is the real world, no one owes you anything, you need to work to get what you want and you need to keep working to keep what you have. Many years ago, we began to lose manufacturing jobs, why, because the worthless unions kept demanding more and more for the same amount of work, the alternative, find another source of labor. After a few years of unemployment, those manufacturing employees woke up, realized that they were to blame for their own destiny, agreed to be more competitive, and the jobs came back. The same needs to happen here, IT salaries are way out of line with their contemporires (sp?), it is imperitive that you get a grip on what you are really worth and what you are really contributing to the Company's bottom line. Let us not forget, no matter how you look at it, IT is nothing more than an expense to a corporation, it does not generate profit no matter how much you would like to think that it does. You need to hunker down and show management how you can reduce the IT budget and show your worth that way rather than sitting on your asses and crying about lost jos. This is America, do what we have always done in the face of adversity, put your nose to the grindstone and your shoulder to the wheel and just get the job done. Then Corporate executives won't feel the need to move jobs offshore. Your biggest problem is that you are not showing what you are worth, you are too busy moaning and groaning about everything and not actually producing a damn thing! What made America great in the first place was good old fashion hard work, too many of you are too busy looking for the easy way out. No one owes you anything, get out and earn it. If that means you have to go flippin burgers, well then do it but do it with pride, dedication and a sense of purpose. If you had done that in the first place you probably would still have an IT job today! America is it's own worst enemy, we are spoiled little brats and most of us need a smack on the ass to get us motivated in the right direction. If you don't want your job to disappear, then show your employer every day that you are worth what he is paying you, otherwise, he is going to do what the stockholders hold him responsible to do; make profits. And lastly, think about it, how many of you own stock, do you not expect it to be an income generating investment? If you do, then do your part to ensure that it happens, demonstrate your worth and you can keep the jobs here!!!

by mikesimov

I totally agree. American IT Pros were spoiled years ago and took their big salaries for granted. The reality is that people will always try to find cheap quality products. One should not cry about outsourcing, but at the same time buy cheaper korean and japanese cars.
Before you start whining think about the billions of people that live with less than $100 per month.

by bwinters

Take a good look at how well owners of some companies have been taking care of their stockholders: Enron, Tyco, Anderson, and the list goes on. You mostly only hear of the big companies, but there have been several smaller ones engaging in illegal practices as well for the benefit of the few at the top. Please explain how this is not greed.

However, I do agree that workers need to show their value - afterall, they're being paid to do their job. However, several of my peers lost their jobs and were outstanding workers. The dot bomb did most of this, but the frustration you're reading about in this thread is not from cry babies and whiners, but from people who want to reclaim the jobs they've lost and get back at what they do best.

by dilbert_envy

Your opinion of the quality work that has always been done by American IT personnel shows that you are neither involved with IT or are ? or wannabe -- part of the myopic management that will sell it's collective soul for a quick metrics or bonus fix.

IT compensation has always been high because the comparative quality is high and the risks associated with failure demand knowledgeable personnel. In short, if the American worker can?t do the job he or she gets fired. With the current policy of ?off shoring?, the American worker gets fired if he or she CAN do the job. Every business case that I have seen that purports to justify sending IT jobs offshore has done so by failing (in many cases deliberately) to recognize and/or report all of the costs accruing to the company as a direct result of that action. These include: diminished Good Will, increased overall delivery times, multiple reworks, quick response to competition, loss of intellectual resource capital; increased security risks; and many others ? they also never cover the alternative that requires that same management to property address general business opportunities and their associated risks. Put simply, most are simply a quick fix for the manager who can?t (or won?t) do their jobs.

Since I do own stocks, and have managed relevant personnel, and served on corporate boards, I can assure you that what most people are complaining about is the failure of corporate management to exercise true due diligence and best management practices. Short-term gain that comes at the very existence of the business is never good policy. In the case of ?off shoring?, it is simply suicidal. It?s high time we started calling it ?Corporate Treason?, simply because the name fits.

by ahickman

That is a great point.....I am willing to work at my old job for a 50% cut in pay. However, the job is gone. So what do I and others do now?

And I do not think we are whining...we are caught in the wheels of commerce and I for one frankly do not want to be axel grease

by spencercarterjr

Yes, we the American worker can stop outsourcing.

Government representatives only have to refrain from spending federal dollars with companies that out source. IBM, Cisco and others are some of the government's biggest vendors. Why not reserve those lucrative federally funded contracts for the vendors who hire American workers in America.

Let's really save some money and outsource top management. Consider, one corporate executive's compensation may equate to the compensation paid to ten technical workers.

The concept of taxing the companies makes sense until we remember that once the government gets the money it doesn't always go where it should go i.e. retraining and new business startup.

How about giving our displaced workers tickets to the countries where their jobs are and see if the outsourcing companies will hire the experienced American worker over their inexperienced worker.

Thanks
Spence

by lrsprague

Yelt62 states that "..I wouldn't be adverse to moving to where the work is if I had to.", in response to the Outsourcing trend. I hate to burst your bubble, but that may well mean you need to buy a ticket and a VISA to INDIA, real soon. They are taking American jobs away by the millions. Aside from gutting the programming market for web design so that what used to pay $75/hr. now attracts $15/hr., I'm aware of only a select few mission criticial, service oriented, on-site jobs that remain, from my observation point --- forgive me: excepting the executives, that is. There'll always be jobs for executives who make these bright 'cost-savings / ROI decisions' which turn out to be penny-wise and pound-foolish. I'll agree with you that much of the mundane has been offloaded, such as call centers and the like; but imagine being a customer of an American-made product, receiving an answer from an INDIAN engineer in New Delhi, about a problem related to a product made in New Jersey?? We're kidding ourselves if we don't believe that this is destroying the fabric of our technical society!

by rodney.beard

well people have finally started to stop complaining about the migrant farm workers from mexico cheap labor for jobs nobody really wants. So I am going to quit complaining about companies who thanks to us are under the gun by thier stockholder to eek out every last penny of profit possible or face a stock sell off and doom. Us the people working in IT need to realize it is not the intent of companies to get rid of American jobs but to survive in a global economy. America is still the land of opportunity so why rely on someone else to make your opportunities for you and go out and make you own

by altekmg

You make several good points in your post.

How many IT managers know how to make a business case for their staff costs. Not many. This failure leads to outsourcing.

When middle and lower managers learn to make a business case for their posistions then CFO and CEO will better understand the roll of IT in their Companies and (at least have a chance to) make the decision not to outsource.

If these managers fail to learn the new paradigm then their staffs and their own positions will be exported to someone who can make the business case.

Tom

by billywade88

If you really want to take some action on H1B and other forms of "legal" immigration/job giveaways, go out to www.numbersusa.com. They have an auto fax program that allows you to automatically sends faxes to your state and national government representatives. The statements are well written and to the point.
At least let them know how pissed off you are about what is being rammed down our throats by the industrial/military/corporate machine that is in control of our economy--and who don't give one good damn about the average American.

by altekmg

The managers and execs may be greedy, but if people spend their "work" time posting to boards like this one then who is abusing the system?

Yes there are greedy people running some of the companies. There will always be greed and corruption.

Pointing fingers does not get the job accomplished. IT professionals need to be a productive as possible. We all (well ok I mean me) are guilty of wasting some portion of the work day in persuits like here.

Another post said it very well. A well run dedicated work force will run rings around outsourcing every time.

Tom

by jasoncctc

For those of you angry about the latest upper management fad (oursourcing), do you still buy goods and services from those companies that offshore outsource? Are you willing to pay a premium for goods and services "produced" in your nation?

Asking the government to do something about the situation is a stop-gap measure at best. The much more powerful solution is to hit offshoring corporations where it hurts most...customer base. Don't buy their goods or services. If IBM or GE loses more money in lost sales than they gain in cost savings shipping jobs overseas, how long do you think they'll continue on that course?

The check and balance to shareholder and corporate greed is consumer spending. Consider that the next time you are comparing products based on price.

by proxcauseny

Our office is actively searching for effective US based customer support in determining our selections for new purchases. Telephone tag around the world does not work. I would greatly appreciate TR's post of suppliers that provide service from employees that are located here in the US. I challenge fellow IP professional to find upper tier support from these far flung outsourced locations, and can understand or make themselves understood by primary tier support staffers in India, The Phillipines or Korea. Outsourcing to these locatiions rips off the IP consumer!!!!!

by altekmg

Governments will never fix this problem. We people will. We need to stop whining and start learning how to, not only do a better job, make the business case for our jobs.

Even in the IT sector most people expect to go to work put in their 8 to 12 hour and go home. It is up to the managers to protect our positions.

Well the managers are mostly us a year or two ago. They have mostly the same talents and knowledge we do. That is not what a manager needs. They need special training and support from us their direct reports.

No, we cannot provide the training but if we aspire to management roles then we can get the required business training on our own.

If we want to solve this problem do not rely on your government to do it. All governments can do is tax us and make intrusive laws that have no chance of fixing the problem.

Wake up IT professionals every where. We are the only ones that can fix this problem.

Tom

by american_it_guy

Government action/inaction created the problem, not business. Business is simply taking advantage of the situation. Most are riding the coat tails of the fortune 10.
Here is your business case:
Example #1: I (and 100 I/T Peers) want to work for 7.75 hourly to match that of your outsourced offer. Forget motivation to accel.
While we are at it, lets live in a shack with no TV or microwave, and you can evacuate California, and all big cities. Playstations will become a toy for the rich.
Example#2: 2 graduates from the local university are hired today. 1 is an American with a spouse and child. 1 is an F-1 Student to become another fulltimne H-1B person and live in an apartment with three others. The parent needs salary $X. The H-1B does not, and will take what he can get before taking his skillset back home.
Before long, the employer was looking for a roomfull of apartment dwellers, a dream come true for the payroll.

by lrsprague

This website's existence depends on IT pros who suffer from this outsourcing phenom. more than any other industry out there. I'm sorely disappointed that TechRepublic would stoop to that level. It means that they [TechRepublic's Mgmt] are motivated more by $$$, than any other reason. Hey, I'm all for cash, that's why we all work, right? But our 'tech resource website' shouldn't bow to the same evil masters that our own managers and executives bowed to, otherwise it's no better than the outsourcers themselves!

by kevin.thomas

You say "compete or get out". Eventually all work that can be outsourced will be if this continues. You say compete. How can you when the prices of things are not going down with "Reduced" salary you say we are supposed to take. Taxes alone keep skyrocketing just to pay our politicians. You say get out. As I mentioned earlier all jobs will be outsourced that can be. Where does that leave me. Try to pay for school again for a new career with a lesser salary or no salary(grateful to work for $9 an hour?). I did it once already after 20 years in a previous career. I cannot afford to do it again.

As you stated, this is lower our standard of living and as mvilla says below you will not be able to relate until our population is starving and scrounging for food and shelter. It is cheaper to live in these other countries. I do not see our politicians or corp execs taking cuts in salary or trying to reduce spending to make it cheaper for us to live. Maybe then we could live on reduced salaries.

by huh?what?

You would think managers deciding to outsource IT are p*ssing off the wrong people.

If you are a programmer, networking guru etc and out of work with lots of free time. Maybe put that time to good use attacking the companies doing the offshoring? As well as the Internet backbones leading to India and China?

You can write all the letters to Congress you want. The big money wants this and will have it whether they have to pay off a Republican or a Democrat, party affiliation makes no difference at all. Remember NAFTA's bi-partisan support.

You may think hey I'll go learn a trade. Well guess what, they are importing cheap labor to drive down wages for jobs that can't be exported.

by cepedajoe

I think one area that is being missed is the willingness of many companies to pay hundreds of thousands of dollars for the outsourced services they get for far less.
We need to make those companies who receive outsourced services aware of how they are being ripped off by the US companies providing those services and maybe then we'll be able to see change.
If I was a company receiving any kind of support services - for which I was asked to pay dearly - I would want to make sure that those services came from local labor.
Unfortunately, in my experience, companies paying for the service don't care where the labor comes from and very often they don't even care what level of service they get.
So, no matter how much we rant here, I don't see this situation changing.
Unemployed and sick of IT employment shenanigans.
God bless us all.
Joe

by hmtattrie

Let's face it, companies have paid lip service to help desks forever. Having a tech support department or help desk is simply one of those ugly things that have to be done to sell software/hardware or electronic toys.

The general quantity and quality of tech support is dismal at best, by design - they don't care if your problem gets solved or not, only that you think someone is there to help you.

It's sort of like when Dad was teaching you to ride a bike and told you that he was running along holding on to the back of the bike - you turned around and realized that he had let go about 100 yards back - it's the perception of help that matters - not the actual help itself.

Having said this, it should come as no surprise what-so-ever that having a cheaper warm body on the other end of the phone line is seen as the way to go by most companies. If the average consumer demanded actual effective help (rather than someone parroting a tech manual) it would not be possible to ship jobs over to countries where the result is sub-standard. Anything that we as a buying public consider important is not left to some cheap third-world knock-off's. Can you imagine the people who run the flood gates at the Hoover Dam, getting the sort of non-answers from tech support that the average Joe gets? I think there'd be a bunch of very pissed off people downstream from there (the ones who survived at least).

So lets not go overboard blaming the Indians or Mexicans or anyone who will do the job for less money - even in this global economy, you get what you pay for and, if it's considered "Worth it", people and companies will pay more to get it.

It's just not that important.

by ppcgm

some of the people who reported to me in the software company we all worked for in the late 90's were replaced by H1B visa people and have never worked in IT again some six or seven years later ... now all those jobs have been shipped out of the country, hasn't anyone noticed that it's not just the jobs that are exported but the entire segment of the economy ? so if they're paying the salaries there they'd best expect to be able to market their products there too because that's where the buying power is now

by vtassone

What makes you people think that burger flipping jobs will be here forever? As soon as someone invents a teleporter those jobs will be shipped overseas also. Though most likly not to India.

I like the DELL ads. They have all these nice Americans working in the help desk all night to answer calls. I wonder how many computers they would sell if the people new where the calls were being answered before they bought the computer.

I worked for a call center for a major computer company. When they went to India I was getting many calls during the transition saying , THANK GOD I'm talking to a person that speaks english. I just got off the phone with a tech I could not understand. I just held my breath and smiled as my job went out the window.

There is a bright side to this. I found a great job. I work for a local internet service from home. I can do everthing I need to do from my PC and I don't have to put up with the corporate B.S.
When a customer calls with a problem that is not internet related they bring the PC to me and I do repairs in my home workshop. It's not a 60K job and I don't have an SUV in the driveway but I pay the bills and I'm happy my family gets fed.

by american_it_guy

I am 40 something and at the top of my game.
They will have to pry the keyboard from my cold dead hands before I capitulate. I am too old and established to start over. The nerve it takes to spew that garbage from an elected office.
I did not serve my country and patrol against THEM! to get this 'free for all" giveaway race to the bottom 15 years later.
Someone is going to eventually pay (a whole party)

We should not give an inch because 'they' say so or some communist country wants to have cable and a microwave in their house too.

I bought a DVD/VCR piece of junk for $98 dollars at Walmart yesterday. That means the materials can't cost more than $5.00; I really don't have a choice. The kids are too needy to tell them no entertainment, we are boycotting disposable electronics. Even the fiberboard box is made in China. That replaced my first I/T job in Manufacturing.

by ahickman

I am willing to pay for the web hosting.....one of the other users is willing to do some programing. Anyone else willing to put their money where their mouth is?

by ahickman

Well for me I am out of work. Have been looking for a job for 6 months now. Working part time at 40% of my old rate...So, I have time to read this board.

Be glad you have a job.....

by savemyboat

My son, an IT professional, has just been notified by his employer, CVS, that within 6 months to a year, the majority of the IT department he works in will most likely be outsourced. At this point, I know of several IT people that have been out of work for a year or more and are surviving on temp or small part time jobs to keep going. While they are in that condition, they will not be buying that new car, or the new house, or much of anything else that fuels the U.S. economy. Sooner or later, the outsourcing will begin to affect other suppliers (e.g., computer supplies) and other businesses. Retail will be affected because of the loss of purchases. When people are in survival mode, they do not buy new stuff. All of this is nothing more than corporate greed. The main concern is the stockholders and to hell with the end customer and/or the quality of the product. Outsourcing will sooner or later flip back on this country in a very big way. There will be short term corporate gains of course, but the base needed to sustain growth will be further shipped away. Also, it is obvious that the condition of the world is pretty bad. If we continue to get into wars here and there (and we will, because we will be sucked into them regardless of who starts them) and the "outsourced" IT functions are suddenly cut off, then what?

by american_it_guy

>>Since when does protectionistic behavior improve the own power?

Yeah, the ole' buggy whip story has merit, but the scenario is different and is just a lame attempt and minimizing the current conditions.

by ahickman

Here is a list.....any one see any company that we should do a trial boycott on?

3Com
3M

A
Aalfs Manufacturing
Accenture
Adaptec
ADC
Adobe Systems
Advanced Energy Industries
Aetna
Affiliated Computer Services
AFS Technologies
A.G. Edwards
Agere Systems
Agilent Technologies
AIG
Alamo Rent A Car
Albertson's
Allen Systems Group
Alliance Semiconductor
Allstate
Alpha Thought Global
Amazon.com
AMD
American Express
American Household
American Management Systems
American Standard
AMETEK
Amphenol Corporation
Analog Devices
ANDA Networks
Andrew Corporation
Anheuser-Busch
AOL
A.O. Smith
Apple
Applied Materials
Art Leather Manufacturing
ArvinMeritor
A.T. Cross Company
AT&T
AT&T Wireless
A.T. Kearney
Automatic Data Processing
Avanade
Avanex
Avaya
Avery Dennison

B
Bank of America
Bank of New York
Bank One
Bassett Furniture
BearingPoint
Bear Stearns
Bechtel
Becton Dickinson
BellSouth
Bentley Systems
Berdon LLP
Best Buy
BISSELL
Black & Decker
Bose Corporation
BMC Software
Boeing
Braden Manufacturing
Bristol-Myers Squibb
Brocade
Bumble Bee
Burlington House Home Fashions

C
Cadence Design Systems
Candle Corporation
Capital One
Carrier
Caterpillar
Celestica
Cendant
Cerner Corporation
Charles Schwab
ChevronTexaco
CIBER
Ciena
Cigna
Circuit City
Cisco Systems
Citigroup
Clorox
CNA
Coca-Cola
Cognizant Technology Solutions
Collins & Aikman
Columbia House
Comcast Holdings
Computer Associates
Computer Sciences Corporation
CompuServe
Continental Airlines
Convergys
Cooper Crouse-Hinds
Cooper Tire & Rubber
Cooper Tools
Corning
Countrywide Financial
COVAD Communications
Crown Holdings
CSX
Cummins
Cypress Semiconductor

D
Dana Corporation
Daws Manufacturing
Delco Remy
Dell Computer
Delphi
Delta Air Lines
Delta Apparel
Direct TV
Discover
Document Sciences Corporation
Donaldson Company
Dow Chemical
Dresser
Dun & Bradstreet
DuPont

E
Earthlink
Eastman Kodak
Eaton Corporation
Electroglas
Electronic Data Systems
Electronics for Imaging
Eli Lilly
Elmer's Products
E-Loan
EMC
Emerson Electric
En Pointe Technologies
Equifax
Ernst & Young
Ethan Allen
Evolving Systems
Expedia
Extrasport
ExxonMobil

F
Fair Isaac
FCI USA
Fedders Corporation
Federal Mogul
Federated Department Stores
Fellowes
Fender Musical Instruments
Fidelity Investments
Financial Techologies International
First American Title Insurance
First Data
First Index
Flowserve
Fluor
FMC Corporation
Ford Motor
Foster Wheeler
Franklin Mint
Franklin Templeton
Freeborders
Frito Lay
Fruit of the Loom

G
Gateway
GE Capital
General Electric
General Motors
Gerber Childrenswear
GlobespanVirata
Goldman Sachs
Goodrich
Goodyear Tire & Rubber
Google
Greenpoint Mortgage
Guardian Life Insurance
Guilford Mills

H
Halliburton
Haggar
Hamilton Beach/Procter-Silex
The Hartford Financial Services Group
Hasbro Manufacturing Services
HealthAxis
Helen of Troy
Hershey
Hewitt Associates
Hewlett-Packard
The Holmes Group
Home Depot
Honeywell
HSN
Hubbell Inc.
Humana
Hunter Sadler
HyperTech Solutions

I
IBM
iGate Corporation
Illinois Tool Works
IMI Cornelius
IndyMac Bancorp
Infogain
Ingersoll-Rand
Innodata Isogen
Innova Solutions
Intel
InterMetro Industries
International Paper
Intuit
Invacare
ITT Educational Services
ITT Industries

J
Jabil Circuit
Jacobs Engineering
Jacuzzi
JDS Uniphase
Jockey International
John Deere
Johnson Controls
Johnson & Johnson
JPMorgan Chase
J.R. Simplot
Juniper Networks

K
KANA Software
Kaiser Permanente
Keane
Kellogg
Kellwood
KEMET
KEMET Electronics
KeyCorp
Kimberly-Clark
KLA-Tencor
Kraft Foods
Kulicke and Soffa Industries
Kwikset

L
Lands' End
Lawson Software
Lear Corporation
Lehman Brothers
Levi Strauss
Lexmark International
Lifescan
Lillian Vernon
Linksys
Lionbridge Technologies
Lionel
LiveBridge
Lockheed Martin
Lowe's
Lucent

M
The Manitowoc Company
Marathon Oil
Maritz
Marshall Fields
Mattel
Maytag
McDATA Corporation
McKinsey & Company
MeadWestvaco
Medtronic
Mellon Bank
Merrill Corporation
Merrill Lynch
Metasolv
MetLife
Microsoft
Midcom Inc.
Moen
Monsanto
Morgan Stanley
Motor Coach Industries International
Motorola

N
Nabco
Nabisco
NACCO Industries
National City Corporation
National Life
National Semiconductor
NCR Corporation
neoIT
NETGEAR
Network Associates
Newell Rubbermaid
New York Life Insurance
Northrop Grumman
Northwest Airlines
Nu-kote International

O
Office Depot
Ohio Art
ON Semiconductor
Orbitz
Oracle
OshKosh B'Gosh
Otis Elevator
Outsource Partners International
Owens Corning
Oxford Automotive
Oxford Industries

P
palmOne
Paramount Apparel
Parker-Hannifin
Parsons E&C
Pearson Digital Learning
PeopleSoft
PepsiCo
Pericom Semiconductor
PerkinElmer
Perot Systems
Pfizer
Pitney Bowes
Planar Systems
Plexus
Portal Software
Power One
Pratt & Whitney
Primus Telecom
Procter & Gamble
ProQuest
Providian Financial
Prudential Insurance

Q
Quark
Qwest Communications

R
Rainbow Technologies
Radio Shack
Rawlings Sporting Goods
Raytheon Aircraft
RCG Information Technology
Regence Group
Rockwell Automations
Rogers
Rohm & Haas
RR Donnelley & Sons
Russell Corporation

S
Sabre
Safeway
SAIC
Sallie Mae
Samsonite
Sanmina-SCI
Sapient
Sara Lee
SBC Communications
Schumacher Electric
SEI Investments
Seton Company
Siebel Systems
Sikorsky
Silicon Graphics
SITEL
Skyworks Solutions
SMC Networks
Sola Optical USA
Solectron
Sovereign Bancorp
Sprint
Sprint PCS
Square D
Stanley Furniture
Stanley Works
Starkist Seafood
State Farm Insurance
State Street
StorageTek
StrategicPoint Investment Advisors
Sun Microsystems
Sunrise Medical
SunTrust Banks
Supra Telecom
SurePrep
The Sutherland Group
Sykes Enterprises
Symbol Technologies
Synygy

T
Target
Tecumseh
Telcordia
Teleflex
TeleTech
Telex Communications
Tellabs
Tenneco Automotive
Teradyne
Texas Instruments
Textron
Thomas & Betts
Thrivent Financial for Lutherans
Time Warner
The Timken Company
The Toro Company
Tower Automotive
Toys "R" Us
Trans Union
Travelocity
Trinity Industries
Triquint Semiconductor
TriVision Partners
Tropical Sportswear
TRW Automotive
Tumbleweed Communications
Tyco Electronics
Tyco International

U
Union Pacific Railroad
Unisys
United Airlines
UnitedHealth Group Inc.
United Online
United Technologies
USAA

V
Valence Technology
VA Software
Veritas
Verizon
VF Corporation
Vishay
VITAL Sourcing

W
Wachovia Bank
Warnaco
Washington Group International
Washington Mutual
WellChoice
Werner Co.
West Corporation
Weyerhaeuser
Whirlpool
White Rodgers
Williamson-Dickie Manufacturing Company
Wolverine World Wide
WorldCom
Wyeth

X
Xerox
Xpitax

Y
Yahoo!
York International

Z
Zenith

by ahickman

I guess you will volunteer to show us how to live in America for $100/month. Let us know what underpass you will be living under.

by redhogrider

I am truly amazed by the responses " Cry Babies", It's all someone else?s fault! Right! My guess is that you men and women have been consumers for at least a decade, maybe several decades. What did you think would happen when we had everyone buying solely on the price? What kind of car do you drive? Where are your shoes, clothes, electronics made? Japan, China, Taiwan, Pakistan, India, Brazil!! Yes it is your hard earned money, but if you don't feed more of it back to the companies that can give wages to our neighbors, then in time we are going to loose. This didn't happen over night. I'm not picking on auto-workers but, Example: The guy that installs the right front wheel on every car or truck that passes by him everyday for his 40 year career, should not have a pension plan that makes him a fat cat the rest of his days, while the scientist that helps cure illnesses has to struggle after he quits working. It just doesn't seem right, but I don't make the rules. Economics, how will this all shake out? We could have 1000 answers to those questions, and anyone of them could be right! Those company officers that have made the choice to move off shore are doing it for one reason, return on investment, the stockholders. What percentage of stocks on the American Stock Exchanges is truly owned by Americans? We even have foreigners that liked seeing the attacks on the USA that even invest in our economy. They have no loyalty to anything but making more money! This is a much greater happening then just tech jobs going overseas.

by rwsystems

Guys, who is the target audience of this site? It apparently is not the American IT worker. I thought this article was a cruel hoax by some offshore hacker. Maybe you should rename, "Tech Republic of India"?

by kevin.thomas

This might have worked if it were only a few companies. I went to the site mvilla mentioned. There are so many companies that are doing this that you would almost have to stop buying everything. Even stop putting your money in banks. I am also sure this list will only grow.

by ahickman

You only need to make an example out of one of them for the others to get the point.

Maybe its time to fire a shot heard around the boardrooms of America.....

by rfdemond

First of all, perhaps I should have given a bit of my own background, I am in fact an extremely technical IT professional with a very accomplished career spanning nearly 30 years. I've done everything from Assembler programming to running my own IT Services Company for the past 10 years. I also spent 15 years working for a fortune 5 Company managing a Corporate Computer Center supporting over 65K users, so I do in fact feel qualified to give an opinion that is based on solid knownedge and understanding of IT.

Your response still indicates a cry baby attitude, it is not an issue of whether you can do the job or can do it well, it is a simple matter of economics, if I can by equivelent talent for 1/10th the price, that as a corporate executive, I am mandated to do so in the best interests of my stockholders. This is not a quick fix, this is a corporate strategy to help companies remain competitive in a difficult economy. What you fail to realize is that failure to do some of these drastic cost cutting steps will only lead to your loss of your job in another year or two anyway because your company cannot compete in this economy. Do not be deluded for one minute, this is no longer a US economy, we live in a global soceity now and Corporate managers absolutely must understand that and develop business strategies that take that into account, the Internet has done this for us (or as you may prefer to say, to us). Competing in a global economy means that it is imperitive for US Management to seek the most efficient way to lower costs or we will lose everything to thirld world economies. Again, look what hapened in the 80's with the automotive market, UAW demanded wages that were so high that we had to sacrifice quality in to stay in business, the Japanese came in and destroyed our economy and we had to fight like hell to get it back. This is no different, get smart, get competitive, demonstrate your worth and you may be able to keep your job. Keep whining and moaning and for sure, it's going to go to India.

by kevin.thomas

Yes companies need to be competitive but in the USA people cannot live on 1/10 their salary. If big corp wants to help stay competeitive stop giving themselves multi million $ bonuses. If Gov't and Corps could make it where Americans could buy homes and support families on 1/10 the salary they would surley do it. But Big Corp USA lobbies to get the politicians in office that will give them the best breaks possible. Example is that all these new tax laws that went into effect benefit the rich and do nothing for anyone else. Gov't deludes that the $1000.00 a year that they gave back to me will fix it all. Hardly, my taxes in other areas ate that up and then some.

by rfdemond

You really think you have tax problems. Let me clue you in to some very interesting statistics about who deserves tax breaks and who does not. Do you realize that the top 1% of taxpayers in this country pay for 36% of the entire US budget and that they top 5% pay for 64% of the entire US budget. That means that the remaining 95% of the citizens of this country pay only 36% of the entire US budget. Does this sound fair to you? Also, are you aware that the supposed 3 tier tax system of 15%/25% and 35% is also skewed to screw the top wage earners, they do that by capping what we are allowed to claim for deductions and a few other nasties. So please don't think you have it so tough on taxes when some of us are paying more in taxes than the majority of you make in a year.

by dilbert_envy

Every time I hear someone say they are "mandated" to act in the interest of stockholders, I ask just how they know what those interests are.

They always turn out to be the same things that allow those making the decision to either hide their own management failures, get a bonus by reducing expenses for the quarter, or achieve some metric allowing them to otherwise look good to those further up the corporate ladder. It seems as though the stockholder interest is always _assumed_ to be lower costs. If those savings were actually passed through to the stockholders, we would be guilty of whining. In reality, they usually go toward the protection of internal incompetents.

Stockholder interests are protected by the production of quality goods and services at a _reasonable_ price consistent with overall corporate goals. If cheaper were better we would all drive unsafe cars, fly on aircraft that sometimes completed their journey, and drink vinegar instead of wine. It's management's responsibility to do what is best for the company, not what is cheapest.

If the assumption is that the true overall cost of using in place, citizen employees is ten times that of outsourcing to a foreign country, then someone is smoking controlled substances. Anyone who assumes, or advances the belief, that management is more concerned with the interest of stockholders than that of their own immediate enrichment is selling those drugs.

by thepctech

Tags, Sounds like you know something here, so if you don't mind post a list of persons who will listen. I really would appreciate it, really : ) Lets build America not India. Im tired of the clueless foreigners we employ overseas, large corporate america is not standing by the americans who got them there to begin with. Outsourcing american work hurts americans. We need more jobs here in america,and to think about Our economy and who spends money Here in america. Yes, Im venting. One way to survive in the american IT field is to work for small/medium sized businesses that appreciate what you do and they give you a place to hang your hat. Small/medium businesses appreciate IT more than large corporate businesses.

Thanks for listening.

by tags

There are those who think that government involvement is bad but others who think it can help. If you believe in govt involvement, laws that limit work going overseas, etc, then write your congressmen, senators, Senator Kerry, President Bush. If it becomes more than just a trickle of email to these people, they will start to realize that in order to get elected/re-elected, they need to listen. You can find the number for your Senator at
http://www.senate.gov/general/contact_information/senators_cfm.cfm

To choose someone from the House of Representatives, go to:

http://clerk.house.gov/members/index.php

I just saw a post for a website at www.brattychildren.com so go there and post your opinion. Maybe someone should create a website with a more professional name that might get the attention of the press and govt representatives. Who listens to bratty children? Also, on this site, provide links to the senate and house and give a sample letter to send. Don't be bratty in this letter. Be rational. Don't be angry. Be rational. Show that you care about this nation and that you are going to keep standing up for your rights as an American Adult.

by thepctech

Tags, this discussion thread is all over the place, as it should be, its discussion. You are shedding some real light on a serious subject. I read thru all the rant and raving here and I love it. Thanks, good stuff.

by johnzakucia

Outsourcing opens up an organization to all kinds of espionage and security issues thatyou would no normally have to deal with otherwise. Every company has a lot of precious data they don't want their competion to get ahold of. If anybody thinks otherwise, they're crazy. "What's in your wallet"

by johnzakucia

Outsourcing opens up an organization to all kinds of espionage and security issues thatyou would no normally have to deal with otherwise. Every company has a lot of precious data they don't want their competion to get ahold of. If anybody thinks otherwise, they're crazy. "What's in your wallet??"

by american_it_guy

they are opening up you wallet via SSN records.
I used to take pride in my SSN, and care about it's safekeeping.

So, we have known for years that our SSN's are residing on computers. Now it is probably sitting in several poorly maintained data centers 12,000 miles from us.
Actually, a major SSN disaster just might be what the doctor ordered.
It sickens me to know that American business has destoyed our number in this manner. It is not worth a dime now.
Of course, we are going broke anyway, so the security part of the social is moot anyway.

Oh gee, now the "fair and balanced" media "vote republican" chant is probably tring to convince us all that 401K is the real retirement plan.

Ummm...'scuse me...I lost my tail on typical 401K planning even WITH outsourcing to supposedly save all this money. Right! The C-level officers took it home friends!

Remember the Enron....

The perfect example of what has happened/is happening to us cry-babies who want our country back.
We want law & order in corporate America.

by ahickman

Even worse is the fact that our tax returns are being done in India. One company set up a business in India to do American Tax Returns. The American Company collects the information from the tax payer and electronically ships it over to India where the tax return is perpared.

They not only know your SS#, they know you address, the names of your kids and how much you make, what charities you give to, and anything else that is on your tax return.

And you worry about your SSN being compromised?

by mrbill-

So when were you appointed emperor? DC_Guy has a good point. He also has the right of free speech, unless you want to take that away from him/us. Is your real name John Ashcroft? I may not agree with some things he posts but he has the right to those posts. On this issue I do agree.

BTW you are more than welcome to remain in OUR country as long as you accept it the way it is.

Awaiting the flames!

by mr_fancy_pants

Here, Here, You hit the nail on the head. We have come too a Paradigm shift in the job maket, just as the big automakers did in the 70's when Japan made a hugh impact shipping cheap, better quality cars to the US.

The short term fix the "Unions" went after was to pressured Congress to raise import taxes on all imported auto's. This did not stop the flow of imported auto's, it caused the big three to retool their thinking and come up with a more Competitive product and service.

This will happen in the IT field as well.

by techceo

Education is needed here. Outsourcing is not the "end of America" or the American IT industry.
See this article published by the Wharton Business School: Puzzling through the Jobless Recovery -- Or Is It a Fundamental Shift?
http://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article/955.cfm
One of my key responsibilities is to accurately predict the future, and offshore outsourcing is critical to the long-term success of the American IT industry. The US comprises only about 5% of the world population. The rest of the world wants the exact same things Americans do. IT is critical to the development of other country's economies. What the US needs to do is become the IT provider to the world. Protectionism won't fly, and now we have some competition, but it is apples to oranges. I use offshore resources because I MUST. Amercian firms are years more advanced in business processes, finance, and marketing, etc. Furthermore, our legal system, for all its failings, is the most equitable, reliable, and predictable in the world. The US is the best place to buy from. Our company is currently developing a product using predominantly offshore labor which we shall resell internationally. The cost of the product would be too high for the market if all American tech labor were used. BUT the product is supported and guaranteed by American tech know-how. Outsourcing equillibrium is reached at 10% - 20% of a firm's labor resources. So the displacement of American IT people is finite. I am also a closet techie--I spent amost $250k and years on my tech ed. Something I find almost hypocritical is that IT has been displacing millions of Americans from non-IT jobs for years. The same effect is now happening in IT. I find it interesting that the source of job displacement (technology) is now screaming about it displacing them. I am sympathetic indeed, but individuals must take responsibility for his/her own welfare. The industry is changing and always will, and individuals must adapt to it. A good book to read is "Who Moved My Cheese" by Spencer Johnson, M.D. Some people may be forced to change careers, but if policy is handled correctly, the US IT industry will rebound and "boom" again. The difference will be "who and where" is the customer. The future includes overseas. The US IT industry should be at the top of the world technology pyramid. We need to embrace, engage, and defeat foreign competition--not run from it. As Americans collectively, that is what we are about.

by flyers70

Rationalize it all you want and keep your patronizing tone to yourself. There is one reason to go overseas: it's NOT quality and don't make a fool out of yourself by yammering about overseas techs being better educated because that is a HUGE myth as anyone who works in the field knows. That reason is low cost labor. Furthermore, it's low cost labor that doesn't seem to mind long hours and won't question authority.

It would be more honest if you would just call offshoring what it is: Greed. Afterall, the first company to do this didn't do it to "keep up with the market place". They SET the marketplace and all of the other CEO lemmings followed with visions of higher profit margins and higher personal bonuses.

I have accepted the inevitable about this situation (you can't put the crap back in the horse), however, I've backed off as a tech lead on some projects to concentrate on getting an MBA. I've already enjoyed project managers grovelling for me to come back and teach incompetant foreign workers and I've refused (and will continue to do so). The die has been cast for me. Afterall, we've all got a price; it's just a question of who you'll screw over to get yours in the name of text book business practices, right "TechCEO"?

by ahickman

Dear TechCEO,

I do not think anyone is running from change. If we hated change in the first place the last place we would work would be in IT. Things change almost hourly it seems like. I have been in IT since the 8086 was introduced and things have certainly changed over the past 24 years or so.

The real issue here is not preventing change, but managing it in a way that the displaced IT workers in the US are given something to transition to. Currently, large companies make a decision to outsource and then hand out pink slips with usually some severence package that is a bandaid, and the government backs that up with 26 weeks of unemployment. After the severence and unemployment disappear what then?

This loss of jobs is not like the ups and downs of employment in the Aerospace Industry in the 60's and 70's. The jobs that are not here are not here in my opinion because:

1) The companies have not recovered enough to hire back IT workers, and frankly that does not seem like it is going to happen quickly enough.
2) The jobs are permanently gone overseas.

So its all well and good to embrace change. However, what do all of us who have or may end up losing houses, marriages, cars, retirement accounts, credit ratings and everything else that goes along with a major downward shift in income?

And where do we get the money to re-train or obtain new training? I know I would love to have $10,000.00 to get more certs and maybe Unix and Linnux training and certs.

But I, like a lot of other displaced IT workers are right now wondering where our next mortgage payment is coming from and where the money will come from to send the kids to college, and what happens if I get really sick, since I do not have any insurance.

Again we are not whining, or whimpering or bemoaning our fate. All most of us want to do is work, pay our bills, have medical, dental and life insurance, feed our families and maybe have a few bucks to go out and have a bit of fun.

So, how long do you think it will be before the bulk of us displaced workers will have a job with a living wage again?

Perhaps your $250,000.00 in education came with a crystal ball. And I say that with no disrespect, since you are just as much at risk as the rest of us.

by infoaaa19

We have already started a call for boycott of all companies outsourcing to India. We are also calling for tax measures, that would not give the ability to write off a foreign source as an expense, at least in California. The Website going up is www.brattychildren.com and would greatly appreciate if you could send us copies of your e-mails so we could publish them there.

by smcgirk

I think that sending ANY job overseas is counter productive to the nations economy. Companies that outsource overseas should be heavily penalized for doing so. BTW: When will information be publish on how to send technical magazine / web site editors and columnists jobs overseas?

by ahickman

Send the over now. Starting with TechCEO. Once the big boys starting losing their jobs, things will change. At heart the big boys are all NIMBY's.

by capabel

Johnny, you make some good points, but your not supporting your own theory. Yes, by nature people will choose the cheapiest "anything" IT included. Bottom line is the bottom dollar period!!
So if I went out and got all of my certs the exact same amount as my Indian counterpart do you think I would actually have a chance???
NO WAY..
Bottom line is they are willing to work LONGER, HARDER and for about half the price!!
So no matter what amount of education I get I still won't be able to work for the same amount of pay because the cost of living here is SOOOOO much more than a third world country!!
Bottom line is the Bottom dollar and there is no avoiding this unless your willing to take the same pay about a third as you normally would.

by rla8998

I totally agree- right on, problem is, it's all about the money- 'show me the money' and as long as companies can cut labor costs, they will, where ever people will work cheaper, companies will go there to get the work done- and the only thing that will stop them are MASSIVE BOYCOTT's of their products and services-

by ahickman

Again, I hear a lot of people stating we need to do something, but no one seems to want to really pursue a real boycott. A real boycott this summer would throw the White House for a loop and gain a lot of national attention due to this being an election year.

We could not only pick a target company to boycott but a few politicians, including the Honorable President of the United States, and if we tossed in a boycott of Hannity and Limbaugh that would make everyone set up and take notice.

And is some respects the boycott does not have to drive a company out of business, or a politician out of office, just flex the consumers/voters muscles and put this issue on the front burner.

BTW - I am a conservative, but like everyone knows there are no atheist in a fox hole.

by ahickman

Again, I hear a lot of people stating we need to do something, but no one seems to want to really pursue a real boycott. A real boycott this summer would throw the White House for a loop and gain a lot of national attention due to this being an election year.

We could not only pick a target company to boycott but a few politicians, including the Honorable President of the United States, and if we tossed in a boycott of Hannity and Limbaugh that would make everyone set up and take notice.

And is some respects the boycott does not have to drive a company out of business, or a politician out of office, just flex the consumers/voters muscles and put this issue on the front burner.

BTW - I am a conservative, but like everyone knows there are no atheist in a fox hole.

by huh?what?

Massive boycotts? Don't count on it friend, Walmart's success shows the US consumer is as greedy, or is it price conscious, as those in the boardroom. Whether blue-collar or white-collar people don't realize offshoring's cost (or illegal immigration's cost for that matter) until it hits them personally right between the eyes.

by dminaz

True, venting is not going to do any good. It can serve to reinforce what a lot of us are thinking but don't have the opportunity to say. I'd like to know what can be done...who are the people that can do something about it? Let me know and I'll surely vote for them.

by eugeney

When I heard Greenspan suggesting more education as the key to solve the outsourcing problem. I just laughed. How much more advanced education do we want our PHD's, MS's and BS's to get ? He and the Republican government just chose to totally ignore the outsourcing problems to India. In fact, I don't remember he even mentioned the name of India once. But I can forgive Greenspan's ignorance of IT industry. I thought Tech Republic deals with IT stuffs. Don't worry, Tech Republic's writers will be outsourced to India soon. Maybe the whole Tech Republic will have to move to India to cut cost. But if they want to sell back to US's bankrupt IT market, good luck. There will not be an IT market here if we don't try to protect our IT base here.

by rpj101

This problem is contributing to the disappearing middle class in America. Just the other day an associate of mine revealed that the CEO of his company aggreed to have an Indian company manage their website for fifty dollars a year -- something that was costing a few thousand, in support of a US worker. The reason I believe that outsourcing is bad, is the fact that the rest of the world is NOT playing by the same rules we Americans are forced to comply with.

by randyc-ics

We would have to vote out every single Federal politian in the government today because they all in favor of these free trade agreements. If trade is going to be free, it must be equal. For example, if IBM is allowed to outsource a job to an other country that is worth $30/hr here, then it should be forced to pay $30/hr to whomever it was outsourced to. Not only are they cutting our throats, but they are taking advantage of those to whom it was outsourced. I understand that their cost of living is extremely low, but this would make it unnessecary for them to outsource. Free trade has not helped us trade with foreign countries, but rather has allowed American companies to become foreign companies; thus allowing them to manufacture their products 75% cheaper and then sell them here in the US for 10% higher than they used to. Bottom line is that corporate big wigs could care less about you or this country's economic future. As long as they are rich they don't give a damn about you and me. If you want to make a difference, then there needs to be a political-independent, grass-roots campaign of American workers protesting free-trade as we know it. Free trade is destroying America and the sad fact is, those corporate big wigs are almost all in favor of it. This is one way in which the international community knows that it can defeat America. They can't do it militarily, but they can suceed in destroying our economy through free trade. China is one of the biggest offenders in this respect, right along with Saudi Arabia, Iran and other middle-eastern countries. Thats my two-cents worth.