Discussion Locked

Thanx for the tips to promote more Outsourcing

0 helpful
393 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

393 replies

by kevin.thomas

Which goes to show that if your taxes are more than my salary your salary must way over mine. That means you are much better off than me anyway.

by rfdemond

Like it or not, what the stockholders want is good financial results that will cause their inestment to generate a profit. That is what you want when you invest and it's whateveryone else wants as well.

Your major issue is that you just don't like the decision and so you are trying to rationalize why it's a bad decision. I've not seen you put forth one solid piece of evidence that it is a bad decision, just rhetoric and rhetoric my friend does not pay dividends or increase the value of stock.

I do agree with you that cheaper does not necessarily equal better, however, from my extensive experience in the field, I have found that the Indian and chinese programmers to be among the best I've ever seen, and to be honest, they don't whine and cry like you do, they just sit at their desks and work, stay out of office politics and gossip, and at the end of the day produce far more than most of the americans do. Yes, we are losing the war but not because it's being taken away from us, but because we aren't doing enough to show we want to win. Get off you ass and put forth the same effort and passion that you have shown on this board today and maybe you can save your job.

by frappie

HMTattrie may be on to something - its the perception of what is truly the end result of outsourcing that really matters at the end of the game. If companies think they are saving tons of $$, AND that they are getting great service, products, results, etc., then that is the way it will go. However, only when the quality suffers, confidentiality is broken , or the service is poor over some significant period of time will they rethink the outsourcing equation.

Two cases in recent past that illustrate: 1) Legal troubles a San Francisco area hospital got into when an outsourcing medical transcription employee in Pakistan decided to threaten the hospital (and the outsourcing vendor). The disgruntled employee was not being paid in timely fashion (due to greedy Paki outsourcing vendor) so she decided to threaten hospital adminis - she stated she would post patient medical records on the web unless she was paid immediately. Needless to say - the whole issue with the vendor got addressed, and I think that vendor company has since been fired.

2) Ever notice that when you call airlines these days for reservations or ticket changes you may hear a heavily accented voice? (And not like Noo Yawk accent either). I recently had to change an award ticket on Delta - and had to explain to the Bombay-based employee the actual rules of the game for making the changes to my ticket. Scary and frustrating.

Only when companies lose $$, either through market share, inefficiencies, or lawsuits, will some managers have to rethink this situation...

by hmtattrie

Lucky thing you didn't have to change the tickets half way through the trip. That's a bitch to do even with real airline people - imagine what the 3rd party would have done with it. Hell, you might have ended up in his home neighborhood.

by kel_stevens

I am currently working for a large IT company. I happen to like my new employer. I was outsourced from a large American Bank. They outsourced desktop and server support to HP, and network services to EDS. Most people think it was done to remove us from the payroll and save money and the spin is that now they can focus on banking.

One real reason is the pension funds are completely underfunded in most of the private sector companies and public sectors (government) The federal insurance agency for pensions is in debt and the federal government is refusing to fund this agency. Many companies have gone under and the pensions were not properly funded or lost value after the stock market tanked. Now companies are required to provide proper funding for pensions. It is much easier to reduce employees, than put cash in pensions for workers. Outsource the employees and you outsource the pension.

This handy cycle of outsourcing ensures that the working person will not get a pension, and they will continually start over with 401K vesting. This is alarming, as we know many people in our goverment want to reduce or bankrupt social security for the working class.

Outsourcing is also a good way to keep those 40 and 50 year old folks salaries down, or move them out of IT, unless they go into management.
25 year olds are happy to work for far less money.

After we outsource everyone, who is going to buy the goods from american companies?

Kelly

by rfdemond

Wow, I am impressed, finally someone on this board today that actually knows what they are talking about and can say it from a position of knowledge rather than emotion. Your post is right on the money!!!

by underground_in_tn

And there's the long-range forecast of where all American jobs are heading, along with our economy. Currently the global economy is way out of balance, with Americans way up at the top of the pay and lifestyle scale, and nearly everyone else much lower. We are experiencing the beginning of the shift as the scales balance out the global economy. This means that as more of our jobs move over seas, we Americans will have to adjust our compensation (and our lifestyles) downward to become more competative and hold onto our jobs.

Education is not our long-term salvation, because what we can learn, Indians (and Irishmen, South Americans, Iraqis, etc) can also learn.

Just grab hold and get ready for the long ride down. Congratulate the rest of the world for successfully catching up with us as they ride the scales upwards (except for those unfortunate to still live under repressive regimes that hold them back, like Samolia, Iran, Syria, North Korea, to name but a few).

by rfdemond

You know what really irks me about a lot of this, you people are crying that your jobs are going away and yet you have the skill set to do something few other professionals have, get an idea, sit down and code it, get on the web and peddle it and make your own business. Not every problem in the world has been solved yet by technology, find a problem to solve and solve it, that way you don't have to worry about someone else making decisions for you, you get to make them for themselves. Let us not forget this is how Gates, Allen and Balmer did it and look where they are today, and their idea wasn't even sexy or fun, writing compilers sucks but they changed the world.

It all keeps coming back to the same theme, if you don't like the situation, change it, you have the power, just friggin do it!!!

by yelt62

Well stated, but...
If you were an owner of a company and could get the same work done for $15/hr instead of $75/hr regardless of where the work is performed would you? I certainly would. It is all about the bottom line.
Now I do agree about the infamous pie in the sky ROI. When we went through the redesign activity in the mid 90's our department dropped from 150 to 50, we decentralized our developers. Biggest risk identified out of our Risk Assessment was that smaller departments, including IT, would not have the resources to do what needs to be done. And sure enough that is the case. We now have an external company doing our app development over the internet quite successfully.
The fact of the matter when it comes to outsourcing is that it is not necessarily one country over another it is prue and simple economics. I think that is the intent of a global economy.
Just my thoughts,
Rb

by gpernest

This is a community issue where the government should step in but is reluctant. Corporations will do as they will as long as it is within the law. Corporate ethics... let's just say most CEO's would rather see their mothers in a brothel rather than a shareholder losing a buck.

The Dobbs report had an article titled "Answers on Outsourcing" written by Rory L. Terry, an associate professor of Finance at Fort Hays State University, that has summed up the situation very accurately. Bottom line was "the US community as a whole will pay for outsourcing". Here is the link: http://money.cnn.com/2004/03/11/commentary/dobbs/dobbs/index.htm

My intent is to do just as you recommended, write my congressmen. I think most congressman want to distance themselves from the outsourcing issue. Sorry mates, time to make a stand. So with that being said, I will simply give them my opinion and site the above article and ask what there opinoin is. And, also state their answers will be reported in an editorial I will write in two months time in the local paper. I they have no comment by then, that will also be stated. If they have a lot to say, they should state where the community can read more on their thoughts.

I hope I'm not too naive to think a local paper would have the courage to print such an editoral. It'll be interesting none the less.

Here's to "opening the window shade all the way" !

Cheers,
Greg Ernest

by techceo

This part of your statement is key: "workers in the US are given something to transition to." First, the sentence sounds kind of like an entitlement mentality. (No offense intended.) No one has ever "given" me anything and job security is not something given or provided. Life security must be achieved by the individual; he or she must make their own. How to do that is a genuine challenge. Second, my business insight came from my business education and not tech ed. So I can see both sides. My wife and I have worked very hard to secure our personal lives outside of our careers. Back-ups, contingency plans, and disaster recovery are practices not only limited to data. "Managing Uncertainty" should be taught in our public schools. I am at risk but not to the same degree as many others in IT. I have viable contingency plans for every scenario, including changing fields completely. (Most people don't work in IT.) Third, three members of my close family are in IT, and ALL of us have suffered. I personally have taken tremendous shots, and all I can say is that life remains interesting. My wife is a good example. She made big money last year in real estate. (She was a lowly accting clerk when we met.) It took her ten years to get there, but there will always be opportunities for motivated people. A career is not a life. There is sometimes severe pain with change, and I've been through it. The good part is that pain must only be endured once. How long it will take to recover is a subjective variable. Monetary things can be regained. A marriage, well, it may test a marriage. In my opinion, should a marriage fail because of economic misfortune, it was flawed as a marriage.

by tait

TechRepublic is the best site for IT pros, but I think they are really shooting themselves in the foot by helping companies outsource. IT guys like me and most of you are what keeps TechRepublic in business and they need to remember that. When we all switch fields because the IT jobs are gone TechRepulic will go down right after us. Not sure about the rest of you guys, but I've about had it with TechRepublic supporting the loss of my job. They must be in bed George Dumbass Bush too.

by american_it_guy

and am inches from that myself.
This is exactly why TechCEO is wrong and what they are doing to the backbone of our country is criminal.

by american_it_guy

Just a few idiots in positions of power are behind this specific mess rich is not free or fair; and are giving away the farm to make themselves rich. It is beyond me how it got out of control.
Yes, we Americans love the idea of free & fair trade.
I have yet to see that in the last decade or two.
Do you know what a trade deficit is?
That is only for material goods.
You better hope we don't go under because it seems like we have the only work on this planet and are the biggest customer.

by yelt62

I have had to do it many times in my career in IT. Started in PC Maintenance (outsourced, Networking (outsourced), Project Management (outsourced), Reliability / Enterprise System Management currently inhouse but I will likely outsource it in the next 3 years.
Rb

by gscutt

Many Americans assume that high employment is our birthright. That was true only following WWII, due to the devastation of Europe. Limited natural resources, average intelligence, and indifferent education have led to a lower standard of living. We could (1) upgrade education, (2) increase resources, and/or (3) ruin others' economies. Or, continue the slide downhill.

by anom_amos1

What happens when all these highly trained Indians,
Singaporeans and Pakistani?s finally price them selves out of a job as it has happened to us ?
While the vast majority of these people are just like you and me; trying to support a family and get ahead in this world. Many of them are of a religion or disenfranchised group that would be easy prey for the recruiters of fanatical cults.
The moment the paychecks stop coming they like the rest of us will be looking for a new sources of income. Who will offer this when the big Multi Nationals pullout ?
Terrorists and criminals that?s who !

And what about the rest of us ?
I have seen my pay check almost halved by the outsourcing trend. The offer of a few extra bucks to write a virus or sabotage and employer who is about to sack you would seem very attractive to someone who can no longer feed their family.

by gscutt

Unfortunately, desireable employment in India requires fluency in English and/or Hindi....

by majer3rd

How many millions of people are terrified that they won't have a job tomorrow to support their families? How many thousands are already at poverty level collecting unemployment and unable to attain a position because of outsourcing? How many thousands are already going hungry because their unemployment ran out? The answer... TO DAMN MANY!!!

We know that Corporate America is more interested in the immediate bottom line number than to look to the future to see that this will only lead to a downward spiral of economic devastation. Corporate America doesn?t care that they have displaced thousands of United States citizens to put a few more bucks in the pockets of executives and board members.

How is Corporate America?s inconsiderate nature so different than that of the Saddam Hussein or Usama Bin Laden? Granted there is a degree of brutality to contend with on the part of the Saddam and Bin Laden; but like them, Corporate America is suppressing citizens because of their greed.

How can our government be so BLIND as not to see how this is effecting or citizens and our economy as a hole? This needs to be stopped by our government, but how do we get them to hear us? Who will listen to our complaints? Tell everyone and someone will listen.

Here are some links to provide you information on who to email. I suggest that you notify you State Senator and State Officials, and CC: (carbon copy) the President and Vice President of the US.

Please use the subject link of "UNSEEN TERRORISTS IN UNITED STATES"

president@whitehouse.gov
vice.president@whitehouse.gov

Links to find your state officials.
Your State Senator: http://www.senate.gov/general/contact_information/senators_cfm.cfm
Your state officials: http://congress.org/congressorg/dbq/officials/?lvl=L

by yelt62

I don't think terrorism can be related to outsourcing, but eh it made me read your post.
I think that you did have a good point buried in your rant. Eventually people are going to become despondent because of their plight and may rebel as a consequence. What form that rebellion may take is unknown. It will certainly be a drain on the social fabric of the U.S. if alternate employment opportunities or retooling of skills is not provided.
Rb

by yelt62

I agree with most of what you said. It appears this thread has smatterings of Pat Robertson and most recently Lou Dobbs regarding protectionism. I am from Canada and we like the States have outsourced a number of IT jobs over the recent years. Most of them for my company are to larger urban centers where the wages and living expenses are more economical. Fundamentally there is an evolution of the IT industry that has shifted from the techie to the enabler. Regardless of where the work is performed, IT folks in North America need to focus in on the business need not the bits and bytes required to deliver the end product. That is our strength, business intelligence not coding or turning a screw driver.
Rb

by mrbill-

So instead of being high tech programers and network engineers we all should be MBAs? I would rather be turning a screwdriver so I do not deserve to work? I do see what you are saying, the US needs to be a leader in the biz world, but only so many people can stomach that kind of job. I guess I should be happy flipping burgers at Macs. Don't come crying to me when the infrastructure falls out from under you. Maybe I can get you a job making fries.

by techceo

Sorry, ol' bean, but you're way off on this. Foreign workers are a pain-in-the-butt actually. "Greed" has nothing to do with it. "Survival" is the operative term. If I could use all American, I certainly would. It would make my job easier. And I am hardly a lemming, nor have I "screwed anyone over."
I hope your MBA helps your insight. Foreign workers are not "better" than Americans. They are less experienced and communication is even more of a challenge. They are, however, highly-motivated. This is something your could learn from. Your attitude is counterproductive. My primary market is the 5.7 billion people who do not live in the US. Instead of fighting the notion of training foreign workers, you should be grooming them to be your loyal subordinates. The wage disparity that exists is a temporary condition. Study your business history and you will see that all of this has occurred before. Your management skills, especially those utilizing remote teams, will be in strong demand. (You must first acquire some experience by working with some remote teams.) Your MBA will not help you unless you release your anger over the "way things SHOULD be" and learn to excel with "the way things are." Otherwise, you could find yourself in a position where the foreign worker you refused to train today winds up being your boss tomorrow.

by rcsteinbach

One angle that many people miss is that historically it has been labor shortages that have spurred on much of the business technology development. Since many executives believe that a man-hour is a good measure of productivity for programmers (which is assuredly not true) and labor is "cheaper" in other countries, that creates an apparent labor glut in this field, not the labor shortage that had spurred on the rapid development of software technology until about the late 1990's. As long as this situation continues there will be very little incentive to push the development of practical Computer Aided Software Engineering (CASE) tools. Much of CASE theory developed when I was in college in the early 90's is still not anywhere nearly fully implemented in any of the tools I've seen because there is little market for it.

Something must be done to change this situation or we Americans will soon find ourselves in deep trouble in the field of Software Engineering because within 10 years.

Also, another possibility is that within a few years, if outsourcing continue at the present increasing rate, a possible Mid Asian Nuclear War could wipe out the American economy and possibly the World economy.

Note that that such a horrible world-wide economic depression could be enough to send the world back in technology by about 100 to 200 years. Think of it, what will happen when 50% of the American businesses lose on the average 50% of their data due to such a war?

Why do we (collectively) want to pay someone else to put our financial interests above their own pressing military interests?

by twohlrabe

among the first -and worst -was Lucent. in the chicago area they and Motorola have shipped IT and engineering jobs en masse overseas. others follow. Latte Frothing will become a valid degree major at most universities if we continue to allow import and purchase products that we used to design and build from countries where an EE makes $5/hr.

by dilbert_envy

Most people who preach stockholder profit forget that the goal is to return earnings over the long hall. The idea that an investor is entitled to a profit is misdirection -- an investor is entitled to receive the net worth (or market value) of the investment upon its sale. The profit - if any - comes from the public perception of its value.

If I am whining and crying it's not because I am concerned about my job. I'm concerned about the long-term value of my investments. I see that value being trashed along with the intellectual resources and the ability to recover ? and not just in IT.

I too have extensive experience in dealing with development issues, and also with quality issues and good management practices. Over 40 years of management (including that of a publicly traded firm) and consulting, have convinced me that what we are seeing today has little to do with corporate concerns and almost everything to do with the CYA management currently in control. Yes, many Indian and Chinese programmers do produce more than their US or UK counterparts. At the surface level, the quality often appears to be the same. In my experience when you try to introduce changes after the development cycle (17 projects of over 20,000 hours each reviewed) the final ?customer acceptance level? shows the impact of this ?additional production? to be largely without substance. Customer satisfaction and repeat business keep the doors open. The lessons learned from these exercises are simple: There is a substantial hidden cost with outsourcing; it increases with off shoring; and its failure, like any other, leaves a legacy that hangs in the air like the smell of death.

Could we do better ? of course we could. I have also seen managers, leads, and even directors of IT with no clue as to the importance of timely production, the necessity for quality, or the ability to give clear direction to those who are actually creating the deliverables. In quality audits I track these down to the individual level. These are also the same individuals who are the first to complain about non-production, poor employee attitudes, and seek quick fixes for their own lack of management ability. If I could fire them on the spot, I would. Unfortunately, it usually takes about 6 to 9 months to get rid of the really bad trash and I can only start that process if they report directly in my chain. In the meantime, most of my daily effort goes toward deciding which projects get funded and which ones don?t.

by nz_kiwi

You've inadvertently hit one of the problems.

A big issue is the Western World's race to improve our lot (good or bad, not for me to say). In doing so we've inflated ourselves out of the market.

If we went out and bought all the cheap goods then we would not need as high an income. You can see where I'm leading - reverse inflation.

The question is what od we want, a high standard of living (mostly on credit) or a job??

by kevin5203

The president has promised us that he will start a job training program, just in the nick of time, for all of us highly trained, unemployed, or about to become unemployed tech workers. And all the unemployed manufacturing folks can join in, too. The primary course studies will be hamburger flipping and dishwashing, with CERTS offered in both fields. Sign up early, these fields are expected to be saturated soon!

by ahickman

It's too late to get a cert in burger-flipping or foam making.....Bush is going to let 8 Million to 15 Million ilegal aliens stay in the US to make sure us out-of-work techs can't get into these new lucrative jobs.....

by ahickman

You amaze me. Thank God there are people like you to point out the errors of our ways to the unwashed masses.

The point TechCEO was not to absolve the out-of-work tech worker of all the blame in their being out of work, but to point out that there are not a lot of options out there for people who are out of work for the first time in 10, 20, 30 or 40 years.

In fact the latest count is 15 to 20 million people out of work, or under-employed. Not the measely 5.x% the Govt is reporting.

Like your wife, I could go into Real Estate, but that market is going to probably tank in the Chicagoland area when interest rates go up. Since housing prices have gone up about 20% in the last 4 years (based on what my house has done.) If interest rates rise 1 or 2 full per centage points, it will lock a lot of people out of the market and that will start to force property values down as sellers become more desperate. I saw that in CA where my parents house went from being worth $600,000 to $250,000.

In fact, if you want an example of the effect that a downward swing in the job market, including outsourcing, has on an economy. Check out the Indy real estate market. I have an out of work Tech Friend who lives in a middle class housing tract, that has, on his street alone, 3 houses that have been vacant for 2 years now, lost in bankruptcies when the owners lost their jobs and could not find a new career fast enough.

Plus home values have gone through the basement. Homes in downtown Indy are selling for as little as $10,000.00 in the lower middle class and border line poverty areas, and from what I can tell real estate value is down at least 25% or more on most properties.

Also, as another side-bar. I hired over 100 techs to work on a deployment project. Out of the 100 techs I hired, over 50% of them had not seen a paycheck in over 1 year, and in some cases in two years. And these techs were by-in-large well educated, certified up the wazoo and with good, solid experience. In fact most of them were better educated than I, and had more certs than I can ever hope to have. And all their college and certs and $3.00 will buy them a cup of coffee at Starbucks, but won't land them a $12/hour Level 1 Help Desk job. Because a lot of thoes jobs have gone to $3/hour workers.

And once the project was over, all 100 of them and myself were back on the street again wondering where our next paycheck was coming from.

Not too many of the people who are currently out on the street are so stupid that they do not know they probably will have to get out of IT and into another profession.

And the question still remains.....where do they go? Now there is the food service industry....average wage maybe $10/hour. Banking? Avearge starting salary seems to be about $12/hour. Grocery store clerk. Hum...have you seen the self-check out lanes...they can make as much as $15/hour. The trades? Thousands of Electricans are on the bench, along with plumbers and other trades, plus you still need to have someone train you if you can get a job. My son-in-law is an apprentice electrican in CA for $12/hour. Won't see even $40k a year for maybe 4 more years. But he is young and part of GenX who does not expect much in life.

Check out the ads for lab techs....$10 to $15/hour.

And it goes on and on and on.

Anyway....maybe I should go back to Northern California, buy some land like I did in the 60's and live without computers, electricity and running water, when I was young, nieve and did not worry about the future.

The new IT Retro Movement...back to the "Little House on the Prarie" and watch the American Economy and your job tank when we all learn to live without, becoming rugged individualist again. Maybe the government will give us 40 acres and a mule. Or at least a chicken in every pot!

Perhaps one of us will become the new Woody Gutherie or Studs Turkel riding the rails looking for work or a handout...

Buddy TechCEO can you spare me a dime?

by techceo

I read your post, and all I can conclude is that you seem deeply depressed. Life changes beyond one's control, and you are not the first to be in the position and neither are you unique. There are a million things to get into. It takes some time to establish yourself, but that is unfair? I am in California. I took major hits in real estate. My wife was three years in the business before she made a dime. From your postings, all you have told me is what you cannot do, and you have said nothing about what you can. Your perspective is the problem. I hope you gain a handle on it. It is not as bad as it seems. I've been there and done that too.

by ahickman

Hi TechCEO,

You have a great mind. And I am not being sarcastic.

Your right to an extent. I think I have been trying to lay out some of the issues that face a lot of my out-of-work friends.

Having lived to 54 and gone through a number of recessions, I know that eventually I will land on my feet and move on. It is inevitable. Publish or Perish.

Have a good one!

by rahcn

www.RescueAmericanJobs.org
Grassroots, nonpartisan group of American White and Blue collar workers working together to Keep Jobs in America for Americans. Working with other Pro-labor groups, our voices are being heard.
Watch for the AFL-CIO sponsored Show US the Jobs National bus tour.

by rahcn

Several States are offering legislation to keep their State Government subcontracted jobs in house. MI Bill Number 4950, 5080 and 5081, MD HB183, IL SB2375 HR4550, CA AB1845 SB1451, 1452,1453, CO SB169, MN SF1792, NY S6040, WA HB3187, WI, MO, KS,CT SB501, SB403 and SB395. Contact your local state representative and State Senator and encourage them to support these bills. The job they save could be their own. www.RescueAmericanJobs.org

by blarman

I am a result of outsourcing. I am a contractor to a very large company who has chosen the route of outsourcing as a modus operandi. I would not have a job without outsourcing. However, I feel that as a contractor, there are some very dangerous assumptions which get made by Corporate America when choosing to outsource.

1. Outsourcing will save money. This is the most standard line corporations use. Yet their financial analysis rarely includes intangibles such as language difficulties, time zone difficulties, productivity decreases, loyalty, and intellectual property.

2. Competition creation. When a company outsources, it spends its money teaching someone else how to compete and defeat them. It is also the biggest recipe for disaster to outsource any kind of engineering or development. Companies which engage in this are effectively ceding the market to their outsourcees.

Outsourcing can save money. It is a double-edged sword. In certain circumstances, it does make sense. In others it can save money. But is the cost worth it? Far too many companies look at the financial side, and no further. But it's good for the outsourcee.

by american_it_guy

say anything to the preverbial employee?
No ultimatums, no warnings, no guidance.
From what I understand no input to the secret plans to outsource for the vast majority.
Why? because it was a devious "cut throat" endevour.
There is your shame and guilt my friend.

Things other than long hours in vain made us great. Apple pie? Baseball? how about a well rounded life?

I work harder each year; years ago my type was thought of as a workaholic, now it is the norm in our scardy-cat society as owners want it.
Indentured Servants ring any bells?
The people building the house next door can't speak a lick of english. Not only do they not have any rights and are getting screwed, I can't lawfully help them.
We are in this mess because of law & greed.
Americans are taught that "its not your concern"

True, I see a lot of lazyness, but all my employer need do is say handle it, and it stops there, I would nerver tolerate it if it was up to me, usually it is not. Otherwise its harassment or some other bull.

No hands are clean in this mess.

by laurengr

Don't think for a minute that Americans can just emigrate anywhere they want!! You'll not be able to move where the jobs are. India, China, Russia, they don't want us, don't allow us to move there to take a job away from THEIR citizens. What's wrong with that picture?

by rossno

In his infinate wisdom, Larry Ellison laid off eight thousand (8,000) American workers and replaced them with ... guess what! Indians!!

by tech-trend

From what I have read thus far, you folks are on the right track. Businesses will do what they need to do in order to survive. Our government deserves the blame for creating an environment that is hostile to the American middle class and encourages business to set up shop offshore. The "Free Trade Area of the Americas" (FTAA) is NAFTA on steroids and will kill even greater numbers of US jobs. These "free" trade agreements are not fair trade agreements for anybody, especially us Americans. While you are writing those spineless politicians, be sure to insist they click the big CANCEL button on the FTAA scheduled for passage in January 2005. Check www.stoptheftaa.org for the dirt on it.

by derhexer

I dispute the idea that managers have a responsibility to control costs and increase profits period. Managers, and their companies, are part of society. They also have a responsibility to do as little harm as possible, and maybe even do some good. If their sole responsibility is to increase profits, then society should allow them to pollute streams, sell tainted food, or generate acid rain.

Several years ago I read about a textile mill in Massachusetts that caught fire during the winter. The mill was heavily damaged. A day later, the mill owner announced that all of his employees would be paid until the mill was rebuilt. If his sole responsibility was to increase profits, he should have used this opportunity to reopen his mill in Mexico or India. Made me proud to be an American.

by crake

The fact is (and this may have been stated in another response) - outsourcing has been going on for years... at least since the '70s with the outflux of American automobile assembly line work. Remember those days? If not, I can vouch for the fact that they were as heavy a blow to American families as I.T. outsourcing is today. The paradigm has shifted from the manufacturing sector to the non-manufacturing sector, thus from blue-collar workers to white-collar workers.
It's not going away, no matter how much you complain. If we impose regulations on American companies to prevent outsourcing, they will not survive because they will not be able to remain competitive in the global marketplace. It's just that simple.
How about a different perspective? What about the resources these outsource vendors use? Microsoft software, Compaq computers, office buildings and infrastructure all American-made... yes, in India. On top of that, who do you think holds the majority of shares in these outsource vending companies?
It's not the Indians.
The U.S. is no stranger to diversity and innovation. We've been through it time after time.
It's time to view outsourcing from a more mature, broader perspective and seize these opportunities as they present themselves.
This is the nature of American business.

by ahickman

Dan,

I think everyone agrees with you. Trying to stop change is like trying to make the Sun rise in the West.

Name some fast track alternatives for thoes of us who have droped our income by 40% to 100%.

I am sure new opportunities will open up...the question is..Will we still have our houses and our cars, etc., when this time comes?

by crake

Dear AHickman:
I cannot offer any stock answers to your questions, much less guarantee anyone's secure future.
I can offer the following:
I have been laid off three times. The first time was the hardest. I had to sell everything, including my house, truck, boat, and a number of other recreational "toys" in order to avoid filing for bankruptcy. We moved into an apartment and I went to work hanging drywall and other odd jobs during the day, then working at a video store at night. Obviously, nobody was hiring Netowrk Engineers at that time, so I opened my own business as a sole proprietorship. There was zero profit in it, but there was also zero risk and zero liabilities. There was, however, the intangible benefit of keeping my technical skills sharp and my name in certain circles.
These aspects were influential in my getting hired by my next employer (a PR agency).
This job lasted two years, then I was laid off again... only this time I was more prepared.
I already had a substantial client base in a broad range of industries. This did not mitigate all of our financial burdens, but I was spared from working those physically gruelling 16 to 20 hour days.
I partnered my skills with, of all people, an acquaintance in the music industry and we began working on projects for local producers of all media types, including short films and streaming web.
Then I was hired by my current firm. One of the owners here attended a board meeting where a short film, one we had digitized, was used. He was impressed enough to ask for my resume.
Incidentally, my current salary is 40% of what it was when I had the house, boat, etc.
I still assist with the multimedia projects to pick up the slack, and am setting my sights on other long-term goals.
To date, the key for me has been to actively seek, or even generate several opportunities - especially since my resume was yielding no results.
I apologize for this lengthy reply - I offer it out of respect for your questions.
Dan

by raghu

Well ! its not that easy an question and definetely not a easy
schenario. In India, we have a huge competetions in almost all
the fields. We have economy based on numbers. Companies
have altogether different strategies to even get to break even in
their business. You can take any industry i.e. iron, shipping,
telecom, IT etc. Indian are used to this market toughness are
this is the reason they can perform any where.

Any American, european or even NRI tring to come to India is a
very very tough.

by cozabrad

The whole point of outsourcing is to make a company more efficient and competitive. If you try to impose how companies do business and save costs they need to find other ways of saving money, maybe by moving out of the country all together. America is the Global economic super-power because of it's ability to run their companies efficiently and freely.

If you hold on too tight you'll protect yourself out of existence. The world is becoming more international. Country borders are ceasing to have real meaning. Jobs, money, food and poverty are becoming more distributed. Maybe this is the legacy of previous generations only looking out for themselves, at the expense of other countries.

by aaron

Thats just it with you Domestic Terrorists... someone goes to the aid of their nation, and you attack them, for attacking someone else's free speech. You are just as dangerous to our well being as Fascism is.

Who made me and every other American Emperor? The same Constitution that you would burn for a peanut butter and jelly sandwich and a cheap calculator.

Go intercourse yourself and your free speech theory. Nobody told that jerk he couldn't say what he wants... just do it from another country.

LOLOL

Land of the Free, Home of the Brave, and Mr. Bill, the Inside Trader.

by mrbill-

First off I must apologize to Aaron for the John Ashcroft remark in my other post. This is a discussion board where we are all allowed to express our views, as long as it is done in a respectful way. That being said?

How dare you call me a ?Domestic Terrorists?!!! What have you done to defend our Nation? Besides spouting right-wing drivel. I have re-read your posts in this thread and have to admit I agree with most of them, but not all. When you said, ?You are apparently either a spy for India or China, or a damned communist. Leave my country, you are polluting it.? to DC_Guy you went too far. Then when I mistakenly tried to defend another American?s right to express his opinion you slam me with allegations of being everything from a terrorist to a fascist to an inside trader. You also suggest I would burn the Constitution for a sandwich and a cheap calculator. I have no idea where you got such ideas from, were you high at the time? As to your remark ?Go intercourse yourself and your free speech theory. Nobody told that jerk he couldn't say what he wants... just do it from another country.? Are you advocating forced deportation of anyone who does not agree with your point of view? Do you have a ?free speech theory? that is better than the 1st amendment? If you do I would like to here it.

I hope I did not offend anyone?s fragile ego. And I hope you all forgive my lack of writing style, I am not as eloquent of speech as the rest of you are, or as smart as some of you ?think? you are.

As always, awaiting the flames.

mrbill

by aaron

If I had a glass full of beer or something, I'd toast your post, bud. Nice response, and that is a good idea. That is probably the best idea on this topic I've seen!

Aaron

by wroach4

After Americans spend tens of thousands of dollars to get the education and training to practice their trade, they are told that they cost too much to hire. Yet Corprate salaries are bloated beyond shameful. The counties where these jobs are sent have their domestic economies destroyed because of the difference in foreign salaries versus domestic and the cost of living increases to the point that the poor in these counties are further victimized. There is a great evil behind outsourcing that is not seen or heard of by the public due to the impact on foreign domestic economies . A few prosper while the many suffer for teh sake of greed.

by netguynw

Your blanket statements about greed could apply to all countries and cultures - that is if they had any actual basis in fact.

Corporate salaries - which have nothing to do with the outsourcing argument - have been bloated long before I.T. outsourcing.

In America, this "great evil" you mention is called capitalism.

You make it sound like all those who outsource are members of a cartel who snort coke and blow poor people away just to watch them bleed all over their dinars.

Get real.

by dc_guy

This thread is growing so quickly that it's hard to post a new message in the right place and have it seen. Anyway:

Amos's original use of the word "terrorism" was correct. He's talking about desperate people resorting to violence. But the subsequent references are incorrect.

Terrorism is "a type of extortion used by individuals and groups with little or no political, military, or economic power: the deployment of (usually random) violence against non-military and non-combatant personnel and other targets, in an attempt to achieve, by inculcation of fear, an objective so unpopular that it cannot be achieved by any other means."

Sending our jobs offshore is neither random nor violent; it is planned, predictable, and peaceful. The people who are doing the offshoring do not lack power; in fact it is their economic power, and to a lesser extent their political power, that makes it so easy for them to do. Their objective is not unpopular universally, but merely among the people whose jobs are lost; it is quite popular among the people who gain the jobs.

The domino effect of offshoring has already begun. Japan has been shipping jobs to Korea since before the first Hyundai rolled off the line. The Indian IT professionals who have our jobs go shopping in their bazaars on Sunday and find all the wares marked "Made in China." It will finally stop only when there are nanobot factories in New Guinea and telephone service centers in Botswana.

Some of you have understandably misintepreted my previous postings. I am no minion of the Nanny State. I work in the private sector like the rest of you and am just as worried about losing my job.

Nonetheless as a concerned member of the human race I can't help taking my role as an "elder" to heart. There are billions of people out there whose lives are so squalid and hopeless, through absolutely no fault of their own, that I can't believe the rest of you aren't at least slightly touched by their plight. Some process with the word "globalization" in its title has to take place before civilization collapses -- either under the weight of their burden, or from the violence of their most despondent extremists.

Nonetheless, the wholesale shipping of jobs overseas is a stupid and short-sighted solution. The designer sneakers and flat-screen TVs built by these low-paid workers may seem cheap by our standards, but when we're all unemployed and can no longer afford to buy them, those workers will still not be earning enough money to buy them either.

Someone else mentioned that it's economically unfeasible to raise corn in Mexico. That's not true. The U.S. levies a huge tariff on Mexican corn. So the Mexican farmers have to abandon their farms and come here to work as busboys. The U.S. government only believes in globalization when it can twist it to its own advantage.

by altekmg

Actually I was waiting for someone else out of work to post. Thank you for your input. I was out of work (In my profession) for over 2 years. Try to get a job in the IT industry if you are over 50. It is very difficult, even if you have been working or studying in the industry since the mid 60's.

The only reason I have a job is I started my own business. I succeed only because I stay under the radar of the large companies and deal with small businesses that need support but cannot afford the retainers large support companies require.

Tom

by altekmg

The reason Governments cannot fix the problem is that Government has no understanding of Business. They think they do but being insulated in the various bureaucracies they are not able to implement a good fix.

Just look at the steel, auto, aircraft industries. Governments (not just the US) have tried to save those industries and have failed miserably. If government A tries to "balance" the playing field then countries B through ? try to retaliate. All we consumers get is higher prices and les choices.

I am not saying Business is any more able to correct the problem. I am saying Governments cannot fix it. Governments are only in place to propogate their own interests.

Tom

by american_it_guy

good logic.
I hope it works out.
I consider myself powerless and efforts like that of Lou Dobbs tonight (CNN) most powerful. And can not vote for business leaders but instead government officials.
Who do we go to with the charge to establish these changes and standards? In the past it was unions.
I like the idea (for example) of a mandate for business to notify local government and effected employees with a reasonable amount of lead time.
Reasonable = not a proporietary disclosure and giving enough time for the local government to assist, employees to look after their interests in employment.
Since that is not being done "inuitively" as a moral business process would do, then I am left thinking that government is the only body that can mandate that.

I guess my view is government executing these solutions as layed out by business. If solutions are pro America and pro business, they are automatically okay with me.
For the good of the nation, not just me or citibank.
I have thought that this was what happened all along; i.e., lobbying & the debate process.
And is not working for too many of us. Too many consideratins for non citizens and non-US interests are in the mix now.
I do not agree that it is the employee's fault in most cases. If he is doing his job and his boss fails to get work, employees must be let go. Their is limit to what any 1 group can accomplish in broadening their employability and still be performing on task at peak. That is life. A lot of times the small companies are blind sided. However, that does not relieve the decision maker of the reponsibility. Many times these days the real intent seems to be founded in misleading employees to their prospects of a future, however implicit it may be.
This describes (to me) the megashift of "outsource or die"
Which is not necessarily better, few have thought it through. American workers in general can not ever agree to outsourcing their livelyhood offshore so this is a really tough set of choices.
Government must be involved, cooperative and part of the solution.

by altekmg

Spot on.

As long as People are put into positions they are not qualified for and as long as there is greed in the world we will suffer with these problems. Power corrupts, absolute power corrupts absolutly.

Tom

by altekmg

If fair minded and accepting is name calling I opt out. You contridict yourself in your first sentence.

Tom

by jvoicheck

Basic Economy 101 states that for every dollar spent, at least 80 to 90% goes back into the local businesses in forms of services and products. If no dollar goes in, those businesses fold. If those businesses fold, they have no need for IT, no matter where it is based. So lets think through some basic economics before we promote outsourcing outside our country's borders. If we outsource, whose going to buy all those expensive homes and expensive imported cars that we see advertised as part of the American good life? Not to mention putting food on the table....

by altekmg

I agree with you.

Additionally, employees at all levels need to sell their value to the company. When an employee prepares for salary review they can no longer just go in and listen to the "boss" tell them how they have done this past year. They need to go in with charts and graphs (so to speak) and present their worth to the bottom line.

Managers need to do the same on their level. More importantly the manager needs to sell their work groups worth to the company bottom line.

With world communication where it is today there is no reason for any employment to be located in any particular region of the globe.

CEO and CFO need to be sold on the value of any given organization that is in the company. This is not our parents work environment. It is a new day and those that survive will be the ones that adapt and grow with it.

Tom

by altekmg

Have you possibly looked around to see if you expertise could be used to start a small consulting firm to support those businesses that are too small to hire you full time. It is scary as all get out but beats being out of work.

Tom

by ahickman

I have tried. With 10,000 hi tech workers out of work the market is flooded in my area and people are now doing support for companies for $15/hour...

by fluxit

It amazes me time and time again how many people are simply brain dead!

During the 60's and 70's the steel industry collapsed and went overseas as the Russian's and Japanese flooded the market with steel products driving the price down. US steel workers were making ridiculus UNION salaries manufacturing lug nuts and steel slugs. They screamed protectionism and voted for liberals who were then elected. There was no change or improvement. Its 30 plus years later and in the rust belt (places like YoungsTown, OH) sit empty shells of once firery steel mills. There are people still bitter by the overseas exodus of their jobs. In fact, some for many years got Government entitlements. The steel jobs are gone for thier life time. They need to move on find new careers. Many did after some time.

Fast forward to today. The IT industry's bubble burst in 2000. The US economy plunged into a recession and IT jobs surged overseas. Many information technologist were garage mechnanics who backed filled the shortage of talented and skilled IT professionals. Then other dynamics came into play such as a cycling economy where the US societal fabric is shifting towards a new way of living. US citizens need to find a new way to earn a living.

Our President is trying to increase the availability of cash in the economy and stir up technological innovation. In this way there will be new products and jobs to support these products. We see this when he keeps the federal interest rate low and provides tax cuts / rebates to the citizens and business. We also see the incentive to pursue space exploration.

There was an earlier TechRepublic discussion on the American Character. The character I know is adaptive, curious, and innovative. I see a bright future for the United States and technology wizards.

by hammertimecat

Great post!

Everyone - don't stick your head in the sand on the outsourcing issue. Make sure your skills are the best in the world and you will ALWAYS have employment. If you look inside yourself for a solution, you control the answer. If you look to government, you look to abdicate responsibility.

by techceo

You very eloquently summarized the relevant aspects of business history. What is being experienced in the tech industry is hardly new. Many aspects of all industries are cyclic, and the tech sector will/should rebound substantially. The US needs to assume a leadership position in digitizing the world. We cannot surpass the emerging economies (India/China) on an hourly basis. Their economy is more comparable to that of the US in the 1950s. Therefore, we must utilize them while their costs remain low (a temp condition, see Japan and Korea as examples) to help establish the US as the affordable source of IT for the rest of the world. To put it bluntly, they can do the grunt work. We can repackage and brand it, then resell it. Production costs in China and India shall rise; eventually a new type of competition shall emerge, but they will be decades behind. To those who are in a pinch as a consequence of the tech "depression," take heart. Leave the industry if you must, but better times are ahead. My firm will be looking for strong PMs soon, especially those with international and remote team mgmt experience. I know many others that will be doing likewise. We will be offering all the perks again as well, but you must be outstanding with numerous diverse abilities including "soft" skills. It's still early in the tech game, folks. Thousands of potential employers for you will soon join it.

by worker bee

I will be sure to print out your post and frame it so one day when we are all living in the middle of some hellish Road Warrior movie I can show it to the children who ask me "How could your generation have let this happen?".

by pegasusgroup

All actions must be geared toward preserving our selves, families and way of life. More people should actually go to college and take courses on philosophy, theology, biology, sociology. To look at this outsourcing issue with blinders on is the most superficial of actions, and quite stupid. Capitalism is not always a good thing, and must be aligned with the human condition.

If you're over 35, you should be wiser.
Get some wisdom my man!
Mark

by ahickman

Well...them is fighting words. No matter how civilized we think we are, we are still loyal primairly to our family then our tribe then our nation.

And maybe if you have no family, no mortgage, no other responsibilites you can afford to have a social egaltarian point of view of rapid changes in the work force.

My main question to you is are you out of work with a family, mortgage, car loan, utilities, etc?

The are no atheist in fox holes

by mrbill-

Good words, too bad the CEOs are too busy buying their next lexius and BMW to read this thread. Maybe anyone in a large IT company could send the CEO, annon if possible, this thread and let them see what they have caused.

by mrbill-

When they took the jobs from the auto industry I said they needed to learn a lesson from the Asian auto industry?

When they took the jobs from the manufacturing industry I said they needed to learn a lesson from the foreign manufacturing industry?

When they took the jobs from the steel industry I said they needed to learn a lesson from the foreign steel industry?

When they took the jobs from the Oil industry I said they needed to learn a lesson from OPEC?

When they took the jobs of the farm worker I said they needed to learn a lesson from the migrant Mexican worker?

When they took the jobs from the IT industry I said they needed to learn a lesson from the foreign IT industry?

When they took my job it was too late to learn my lesson?

by matt.hodgen

Quoting Wall Street journal from 3/14
Greenspan "Warned Congress not to take protectionist steps to curb movement of white-collar jobs abroad." His point is that the economy as a whole will benefit even though a sector of the economy will get blasted. This is exactly what happened to manufacturing in the 80's and 90's. It seems that it is our turn. I've only been in IT 5 years and have had to remake myself twice and lost one job to outsourcing. Guess I'll start reading "Mandarin Chinese in 127 easy steps" tonight.

by celloman

Outsourcing has hurt me since 9-11. Been waiting for the IT market to open again all the while searching for work. Co's letting people go slowly are now thinking about outsourcing. Co's that handle outsourcing are working for 25-35+ different other companies, receiving 75-85+ calls a day per person working, which may lead to overwork and errors by such personnel - here in the US.
Hardest thing to deal with now, is most companies want recently working people - a catch-22 if your an invisible sufferer.
A family member called a 'helpdesk' and couldn't make them understand the troubling issue - software compability/internet access. We could barely understand the person with the india like accent and they couldn't/wouldn't give us over to a supervisor - we hung up. Outsourcing in India might be business cheap, but they aren't helping us end users.

by protiusx

I agree with Orpheum albeit not quit so loudly. I understand that our industry has shifted its IT resources overseas but what shall we do about it? What are our options? Should we get mad at the companies who are making the ?business? decisions that will reflect beneficially on their earnings statements? Or should we blame the government for not regulating the companies more? Or for not providing enough education subsidies for our children so we can afford to put them through school or a technical/vocational-learning center? Should we blame our parents for not pushing us harder to achieve? Or should we simply take responsibility for our country and ourselves and stop whining about what others are doing? Would it not be better for us to collectively say, ? you know what, I am an AMERICAN and that means that I can be what I want to be? It means that I can work hard and dedicate myself to learning a new skill set that will make myself better at what I do than my peers regardless of what country they are in??
I guess my point is that if we don?t like the way things are then change them. Take responsibility for our own lives and stop ?blaming? big government or big business, or foreigners or anyone else. I AM NOT A VICTIM! Are you?

by northgatenet

OUTSOURCING!

Although it was necessary to enable American firms to hire the best and brightest foreign workers, I also believe that these companies should first make every effort to ensure that these valuable jobs are made available to qualified Americans. It's quite the contrary.

THE PROBLEM:

Major Corporations are laying-off hard-working IT professionals, while using the excuse "to gain a competitive edge with global (overseas) business during a less than highly profitable economy". Eliminating paying technical jobs of hard-working American, who probably haven?t seen a pay raise within the last three (3) years. Will this stimulate the economy? I think NOT. In fact, the Operations Engineers are not low paid technical workers. Not by a long shot, these are professionals who have several high-level certifications that take years of study, working from home, as well as on-the-job to achieve.

I work for a company that does lay-offs, at the end-of-the-year, in an effort to show profit. This has been accepted for many years and no one has addressed this issue.

These Chief Executives need to get their facts straight or report the TRUTH. Truth of the matter is, large corporations are planning on removing Operations Support Engineers as well as Testing Engineers abroad. These are professionals responsible for moving major Voice Over IP Solutions from Research and Development to Production. Not to mention, support them from an Operations aspect. So, where's the next level of high-level jobs they say? There are none, unless your trying to consult when there's major issues with the networks. These certifications are far and very few (just over 10,000) to be exact. The Project Managers up to the CEO's are making the profit off the sweat of whose back?

We have stood by these companies taking pay cuts and not even seeing a raise for two (2) or three (3) years. I've been with my company for five (5) years and have seen two (2), wage increases which amount to peanuts (considering my high-level qualifications). And, now they ask us to "Think Global". I believe the operative word here, is "GREED".

If you think it's bad, now, just wait until every-other company starts outsourcing. It seems as if the more certifications you get within this industry, the higher the bar is raised. These companies know that they get their contracts through ?highly-qualified, certified engineers?. This can't be what the American dream is all about? I know that there's a need for Managers, just as there's a need for Law Enforcement. But, this is RIDICULOUS!

It?s gotten way out of hand and should be dealt with accordingly. We should be Standard Setters, and are the main offenders of human rights. We go into third world countries and set up "sweat shops", for lack of better words, eliminating thousands of High Tech, jobs here in the US.

Bottom line, these CEO?s and other key Decision-Makers, should be held accountable for the demise of our economy.

Bottom line, organizations get contracts off the back of certified, skilled workers. We helped build these organizations to what they are today. While there are some benefits to outsourcing when you you keep highly skilled workers and are in need of assistance with the workloads, there is no reason to turn your backs on workers because some project managers did not clearly get the requirements from the customer. The majority of failed projects fail due to a variety of factors and for the most part are not because the highly skilled workers did not meet the deliverables. In some cases it's buggy software/hardware from vendors. Poor project management (some of which don't have a clue of what it takes to move the project through it's production life cycle). Promises to the customer that they can deliver the whole enchilada and not clearly defining the services to be delivered. Just ask some of the people who've worked on major projects, and you'll be very suprised. Generally, there's no communication from the top down to the boiler room. We were overworked and under paid... Sometimes 60-70 hours a week and sometimes didn't get a raise between two to three years apart... Now, after the projects fail, they want to bail out! Maybe I should go to a third world country and open up a sweat shop, I mean "Outsource"... There they go changing the rules as they go along... Purely Insane.

Thank you for taking the time to read my concerns on this issue.

Sincerely,

D W
MCSE, CNE, CCNP, CCDA
Michigan, USA
United States Marine Corps (Veteran)
Soon to be searching for employment

by derhexer

Outsourcing is such a typically short-sghted action by management. They have their eyes fixed only on this month's or this quarter's bottom-line, that they can't see the long-term damage they are doing.

Once a large number of jobs are out-sourced to India, China or Russia, who will the companies that outsource sell their productsto?

by fluxit

The US is tranisitioning into a new way of living. It happens every 80 years. We are due in 2009 but it may have happened a little early. Other times the economy transitioned include:

1929 - The roaring twenties came to a halt when the stock market crashed. Coincidentally, the first tv broadcast was that day. The 1930's struggled with the down turn with protectionism and social programs. Following this down turn we saw expansion the logistics network leading to the nations highways and air industry. Other growth areas included personal electronics and peoples homes increased in size. The characteristic buzz word of the day was 'Luxury'

1849 - The westward expansion came to a halt following the over production of cotton that drove down prices. The 1850's struggled with an unmanaged down turn. The growth areas we saw following this were characterized by the industrial revolution with sprawling manufacturing plants and a shift from a farming society toward more urbanization as workers moved close to manufacturing centers.

1769 - The US colonization came to a halt as angry colonists became increasingly frustrated with the taxes and controls placed on them by England. The Boston Tea Party focused this anger. The US economy was being born and the Forefather's new its potential as many were Aristocracy and their businesses were being drained of cash by the King. They drew on Queen Elizabeth I fiscal practices and commented about managing the US economy. For example, the only time we should run a deficit is during austere economic hardship and war. Following this brief period we saw growth in technologies such as the cotton gin and steam locomotive. Americans became explorers and statesmen. The modern education system formed.

It is short sighted to proclaim that our only jobs are leaving and that Americans will be left bankrupt. There are people out there who are 'Technocrats' forming new industries through innovation. Technocrats are a small group of highly educated and relatively underpaid people who really form our world. They are people like Thomas Edison, Alexander Graham Bell, The Wright Brothers, or the 14 year olds who envisioned Yahoo... Who are you?

by ahickman

You forget, that these incidents you cited were internal economic adjustments. With a much smaller US and World Population.

Today, the economic changes are happening in a global world economy with probably 4 to 5 times as many people out there looking for economic redistribution.

And, back in 1929, 1849 and 1769 American was still primairly an Agrarian Society. So you always had farming to fall back on.

Plus it took us a major world war with hundreds of millions of deaths on all sides to bring the US out of the post 1929 economic slump.

You have to see history within a larger context. What happened 80 years ago may parallel what is happening today, but it is not the same.

And why worry, the US lived through the "Great Depression" nicely with 20-25% of the population out of work and starving. And the shifting of a part of our population due to the Dust Bowl during the same period of time.

And of course, Europe survived the Black Plauge. Largest transfer of wealth in the history of the world with up to or over a 50% mortality rate from the plauge years.

by kairos1

If the tax breaks for outsourcing were used for apprenticeship programs, we would be able to create more skilled labor for those people who have studied and have even had a hard time getting an entry level position. The company could use the tax breaks for training capable people for the future and wouldn't have to look somewhere else.

by ahickman

Wow....maybe you can also retrain us over 40 highly skilled tech workers and put us in an apprentice program.

by derhexer

The outsourced jobs are going to countries like India, Pakistan, Russia and China. India and Pakistan are somewhat unstable countries that have militant Muslim minorities.

The jobs that are being outsourced are high-tech jobs involving programming and infrastructure support for major American corporations.

How can a company know that an Indian or Pakistani programmer hasn't built in back-doors that may allow hackers to bring a compnay to its knees?

Or, consider this, a change in government in any of these countries may result in a company having its tech support being done in a company hostile to America.

by fluxit

This sound more like a homeland defense issue than a IT. When developing any complex technical project a major design consideration is maintaining integrity. Integrity is designed into a project by componentizing and modularization. Should a module fail then it is limited to its break points. Critical modules are closely managed by a small trusted group and overall design is only known by a few as well. Many defense projects are managed this way.

However, techniques like chipping have compromised many American commercial products ready. Cell phones can be remotely activated without anyone knowing and conversations can be listened to. Easter eggs in software have been embedded in manufactured software for years and even MicroSoft has outwitted the law on this aspect. One urban legends suggest a programmer during the 70's used an Easter egg in a banks computer to collect and deposit fractional cents in an off shore account. It took years for the bank to figure it out. Meanwhile, the programmer made billions supposedly and they cannot find him.

As far as geopolitical events disrupting the economy there is another thought on this. Economic warfare is a Information Operational tool at the United States disposal. There is a warfighting doctrine that a war is winnable without bloodshed. By influencing societies economically, a focus shifts from ideological viewpoints (Radical Islam) to economic necessity. Societies derive diginity and self worth through the incomes these jobs offer thus shifting radical religious views of a society towards economics views.

The goal of the New World Order is to destroy national sovereignty and replace it with regional areas of economic influence such as NAFTA, European Union, Caribbean Basin Initiatve, etc... There is a thought in the Judeo/Christian Bible that the anti-Christ reigns over these and there are specific references indicating that New Babylon caused this. Some people suggest that New Babylon is the United States. Revelations 13 and 18.

Your time may be better spent coming to know God than worrying about if your software is rigged.

by Member 19345100

We could be like the teamsters - how hard can it be to drive a truck?

There is a labor union in Seattle that is trying to organize the Microsofties. http://www.washtech.org
You could join them. It won't help now. It will help in the future. We have look long term here.

by ahickman

I can see in this discussion there are the "i have a job" and the "i don't have a job/or am worried I soon won't have one"

It will be interesting to see everyones comments in a year if the IT Sector continues to tank.

by ahickman

Rory Terry on Outsourcing

The costs of the decision to outsource are not borne by the decision maker. As a society and as a country, we experience many costs from outsourcing, including the loss of jobs, social costs, higher costs of raw materials and loss of national sovereignty. Loss of jobs reduces the tax base, creates high unemployment benefit costs, and raises the cost of government retraining programs. Displaced, unemployed workers have higher rates of child and spousal abuse, alcoholism, bankruptcy, divorce, etc. As China and India and other large populations grow, they demand huge quantities of oil, gas, steel and other basic raw materials. These costs are born by all of us -- every time we fill our gas tanks, for example. And as a nation, we lose our ability to make independent decisions that are in our best interest when we are dependent on foreign debt and foreign manufacturing. This is a classic externality.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Rory L. Terry is an associate professor of Finance at Fort Hays State University

by ahickman

These two companies would be ideal to boycot. Both depend to a great extent on consumers.

If we drove their stock prices down through a boycott, it would sure make the point.

I guess I am still a 60's radical at heart.

by sql_joe

Okay TechCEO, then explain why many of the companies outsourcing to other countries, or even worse, bringing IN H1B's to replace Citizens are saying it's because there is a SHORTAGE of American Tech workers?

Also, while we're on the discussion of Protectionism and Free Trade: Since when is it Free Trade when only one of the countries participates? Most countries protect their workforce, yet cry foul when the United States makes a move to protect theirs. Life is good when you're on the receiving end of the one-way street.

It is the responsability of a government, any government, to protect its citizens PERIOD, and I mean ALL OF THEM, not just lawyers and business executives.

by billh

Ok, so now our government is supposed to add IT to the list of subsidies? The bottom line here is, if someone else can do your job as well as you for less money, you can't blame the customer for going there.

The problem in the computer industry actually goes a little deeper than that. If an industry as a whole, grossly mismanages its customer base and doesn't build value into what it does and its customers are unwilling to pay, then whos fault is it?

The reason Dell and IBM and ___ (you fill in the blank) outsource their help desk to India is...
1. they can (do to the same marvels of technology that gave alot of us our original opportunity (at some "big iron vendors" expense). Now that the same thing is happening to you - you cry foul and want the rules changed?
2. Customers want good support but are unwilling to pay for it. (actually - they are, you just had better differentiate yourself from these vendors that at first glance appear to be "low cost". Free tech support isn't FREE when I'm burning time on a phone call with a tech I can't understand or - who (do to cultural/language differances) doesn't understand me.

America is still the land of opportunity. Rather than standing around crying about these problems, view it as an opportunity to do something better or different. That's the American Way!

by marshb

We didn't act when it was low tech jobs. Now we are feeling the pain of shipping jobs overseas (Cheap Labor). One of the most telling comments came from India. America will have more jobs than ever as the Indian standard of living increases. We will have more money for travel and leisure. This will generate an increased need for help. Translated as porters, waiters, baggage handlers and maids. As a once famous cartoon character said. "We have met the enemy and he is us!"

by robert.ballheim

I hear a lot of people talking about the economic impact of "Off-Shoring" IT jobs, but I don?t hear enough about the impacts of off shoring on our nation?s security - economic and physical.

In the US we have many forms of security - physical and economic being the most prevalent in our national conscious. Our national security was won with a combination of force (muscle) and intelligence as was our physical security.

One of the reasons we have continued to lead the world in economic and military force is our creativity as a nation. We have continued to innovate and apply innovation in our economy ? leading to gains in nearly every area of life.

If we continue to provide disincentive for people to go into the sciences (computer sciences included) because American corporations can get what they perceive as ?the same quality at a much lower rate? is back or front office processing (which isn?t true) we will be shipping our national strengths overseas WHOLESALE.

Here?s a thought. Hitler kicked all the brains out of Germany prior to WWII, and western nations took them in ? in droves - to our Universities, Businesses, Industries, and Military Institutions. We won WWII and created a place where everyone wanted to come. NOW we are shipping all our "Intellectual" jobs ? OVERSEAS ? were minds can chew on some of the largest challenges of our day.

Are we foolish enough to think that another upstart nation won?t become more powerful, smarter, and stronger than the US if we move all the ?IP? jobs overseas?

This trend WILL kill three things ? National Security, Economic Security, and the Middle Class. We are providing "them" the incentive, the capital and the resources to make their angry thoughts and desires reality.

If you think that the countries and the citizens of those countries we are outsourcing our jobs to don?t mean us ill will or, "they" aren?t taking the money and resources we give them and plying towards our demise already ? think again.

Here is a test?

Microsoft is one of the biggest users of off shore ?talent??right? Right! Now open up nearly any version of MS Word. Type NYC in big letters in any font you chose. No go back, highlight NYC and change the font to ?Wingdings? and you will see a clear symbolic message that "Killing Jews is GOOD". I can?t share the symbols here due to the limitations of the HTML and this media but do it! It doesn?t take a Cryptanalyst or ?Glyphologist? to figure out what the message is and where it came from. Any police officer familiar with gang symbols and gang communication can tell you that the intentions of many gangs and the demise of rival gang members is ?foretold? in gang graffiti far more symbolic and cryptic than what carries the above message?

THINK!!!

If our money is going to support people that are programming this into Microsoft Products - who knows what other "back doors" are being programmed into our products or solutions without our knowledge and what it could lead too.

THINK!

NOW, do you think that the nations and the citizens of the nations that we are supplying capital, intellectual challenges, and our jobs to are our allies? Do you see India, Pakistan, or China supplying aid to us in our fight on terror?

There are no mistakes in IT and the above example can not be written off as mere coincidence or the ravings of ?lunatics.?

THINK ? and demand that off shoring be stopped in the name of our National Physical and Economic security.

by fluxit

The NYC oddity gained significance after the twin towers were attacked. However, the symbols were in wingdings for years prior. I do question where the character set standards are established? As in IT there are standard boards for everything.

by fluxit

Nothing was forgot. I abbreviated the posting. With every tranisitioning economy there is also a war or major armed conflict associated.

Additionally, there was global effects in those others. There were huge influx of immigrants and migrant workers seeking jobs here in 1850's. They, chinese and irish, built the rail system. In the 1920's, when my grandparents came over from Europe, huge ships poored into the US with immigrants seeking a better life through jobs.

The US was no longer principally an Agrarian society by 1900. In fact, in the 1930's over production of farming products because of mechanization contributed to the poor economy. Even mechanization in the 1850's lead to overproduction but after the 1850's is when we transitioned towards more urbanization.

Today, the reverse is happening. People are leaving the urban areas and moving into more rural areas. Their incomes and jobs are being facilitated by logistics and information networks formed since the last transition. And unlike the earlier tranistions having migrant come here the jobs are going to them for the reasons.

by techceo

Guys, your history discussion is good. General historic trends can be used as an analytic tool, and you are both correct: the current environment is unique in many respects. I don't usually participate in discussion groups, but this one got my attention. The long-term (25 years) technological effect on mankind will be profound. Outsourcing, dead products, etc. really don't concern me. They are small-scale events in the great scheme of things. Self-configuring systems and AI scares me. I predict there will be huge displacements of IT people world-wide in the next 20 years. I wasn't surprised by the dot bomb; however, I was very surprised by the speed at which it happened. (The rise AND fall.) Moore's law will march ahead, and even silicon-based chips will reach near human-level processing capability sooner than anyone thinks. Ultimately, there will be huge displacements of people in many industries and not just IT. The kicker is that there will not be a corresponding loss in productivity.

Continuing on the immediate aspects of the discussion, many IT jobs would not be here if there were not a dramatic drop in the costs of hardware. That is the key point: As prices drop, the market expands. The same economic principle can be applied to tech labor. Soon, even small companies can have powerful IT depts. The current group of skilled IT people in the US will find new opportunities with firms that are smaller or different than those they are accustomed to. When the current crop of American IT people become the CTO for a smaller firm that is counting on them, they will use resources from anywhere that will help their cause.

The best thing for American IT people to do is improve their mgmt and people skills. They should maintain tech skills and make themselves more well-rounded. Most people don't work in IT, and frankly, tech is too difficult to learn for just anyone to do it. It's fun to know but hard to learn. Many smaller co's will launch sophisticated IT initiatives; they know they need it but have no clue how to actually implement it.

India and China will get theirs in the end. They will have a boom and bust much worse than anything here. We will have already experienced, and recovered from, the down side of tech.

Thanks for reading this rant. I am doing research and have implemented changes in a flagship product as a result of info learned here.

Thx.

by maecuff

POWELL ADMITS BUSH SUPPORTS OUTSOURCING
>
> Last month President Bush strongly endorsed the loss of U.S. jobs to foreign labor markets, personally signing a report that touted overseas
outsourcing despite more than 8 million Americans being out of work.
After the public reacted with outrage, the White House tried to back off its endorsement of outsourcing, with the president reassuring America that he is concerned about "people looking for work because jobs have gone
overseas" and saying that "we need to act to make sure there are more jobs at home." However, as the controversy subsides, the president is
apparently endorsing outsourcing once again.
>
> Specifically, the president has deployed Secretary of State Colin Powell to India "to assure Indians that the Bush administration would not try to halt the outsourcing of high-technology jobs to their country." The
admission came despite a new study showing that up to 14 million American jobs could be lost to outsourcing in the coming years. Instead of endorsing congressional action to prevent such a tide of lost jobs,"the White House endorsed Mr. Powell's comments" that outsourcing is just "a
natural effect" that cannot be stemmed.

by mrbill-

Let?s see, if I?m paying an Indian worker 3/hr plus lets say 10/hr overhead for utilities and such, that comes to 26K/yr add 10K for taxes that is 36K. If I have to pay a US employee 40/hr plus 40/hr benefits, then add overhead for utilities and such it comes close to 90k+/yr. Who are they going to hire?

Nice start though.

by flyers70

TechCEO,

Thanks for the advice, but what you blithely call a "wage disparity" is a "wage chasm" when you look at how overseas consultants have depressed the wage market. That's great for you; your overhead is down. It sucks for everyone else whose bargaining leverage has gone to nothing.

And while I may work with remote teams in a managerial vein, I would never pass on my own technical expertise to an overseas consultant as I respect how real technical expertise is attained (I am an EE by trade). If they are as good as you say they are, they should be as skilled as any other consultant that walks through the door. Otherwise, your picking them on price and you will lose in the end.

Again, thanks for the advice and take care!

(I'll have a beer for you at Happy Hour today)

by thechas

The owner of Malden Mills was in a unique position. They had a product (Polar Fleece) that they had little or no competition for.

Unfortunately, Malden Mills has fallen on hard times and is reducing staff and potentially going to close down.

Social responsibility usually ends when a company transitions from a family owned business to a corporation.

Corporations tend to do only what is good for the bottom line.

Anti-pollution laws and consumer watchdog groups have made it more economical to control pollution than to simply dump the waste in the local stream.

On the flip side, there are now "fly-by-night" waste haulers.
These companies haul waste to a storage location then when they have stored all that they can, they disappear.
Or, they open valves on the trucks and spread the waste along a road.

In the US, the present administration has hung out the open for business sign.
Any company that makes a significant campaign contribution can get environmental rules that restrict them given a second look.

The H1B visa program originated not because the US had too few information workers, but because the companies did not want to pay the escalating salaries.

Outsourcing simply skips the need to bring a worker to the US and pay US wages.

Like it or not, the goal of the rich is to eliminate the middle class and reduce the lot of the rest to that of 3rd world slums.

The only option, is to support the small local business man.
Avoid spending any money with large corporations.

Most of all, DON'T shop at WalMart.

Chas