Thanx for the tips to promote more Outsourcing
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by kurtbooth
Here is a link to a NY Times report of Colin Powell in India on the subject -
http://www.nytimes.com/2004/03/17/international/asia/17POWE.html
I find it interesting that when our building went from 2,000 employees to less than 50 over the past two years, there was no training offered us poor "Customer Interactive Agents"!!
by maecuff
One comment stood out for me..
Most people don't work in IT, and frankly, tech is too difficult to learn for just anyone to do it. It's fun to know but hard to learn.
I was a programmer for 15 years before moving into management and through out those years, I saw so many people it IT with a superior attitude. As in..you wouldn't understand, it's an IT thing... A job is a job, if you are interested, you can learn the job. I'm sure there are many 'just a clerk' type jobs that are difficult. What about people who work in the investment world..just the rules alone would take a year to learn. Or insurance, or well, just about anything that takes some brain power.
This makes me think of Nick Burns..your company IT Guy.
by thechas
You have bought into the "big money" line of reasoning.
The reason that the top 5% pay 64% the tax burden is that they have 64% of the income.
Excuse me if I don't feel sorry for the poor rich SOBs that are working even harder to shift the tax burden away from them so that they can have it all.
Almost ALL of the tax shift plans be they sales, flat, or vice taxes, shift the tax burden from the upper class to the working and middle classes.
The flim-flam men who are pushing these proposals make it look like we will all get a tax cut.
In reality, these plans will result in higher taxes for workers and families while significantly reducing the tax burden for the rich.
Chas
by matt.hodgen
by fluxit
I think understanding the trends and how we are impacted by them affects us on a grand scale. We operate under the precepts of chaos theory. The past is irreversible, the future is upredictable, and the present is emergent.
You spoke of prices dropping and markets expanding. This trend is present in all of the market place. Everything always moves towards the low dollar and high volume.
As far as AI and self configuring systems, these are perfectly ordered systems that operate under the constructs of complex adaptive systems theory. I see enormous opportunity to exploit this technology for profit creating jobs. It is already beginning in the defense industry as we mechanize and digitize the battlespace.
Rounding out professional skills is always a good thing. In fact, because of our changing world I have been through 4 career fields in my 25 years in the workforce. However, I think people should become more like the pioneers. They should strike out and build small businesses to become self sufficent. They should spread thier income resources across several markets to ensure income stability.
I see a future where all these factors can come together to make a grand new way of living! Imagine a food processor that has no buttons - you talk to it in plain language. You buy food modules in your locale grocery to stock it. It is on the internet and reports your taste preferences to the manufacturer of the modules and updated modules are made and sold.
At work you have a virtual personal assistant who participates in phone calls and meetings then takes care of the little details for you. All the interaction is fully human centric.
Granted the extreme is that humans become unneccesary but in all this AI goin' on - only up to knowledge systems can be automated. Humans have the unique quality of wisdom. Our self-awareness or souls are not part of this universe although they act in this universe through our minds. I think we are safe from our technology
but perhaps not ourselves.
by techceo
Well spoken, indeed. And I agree with it--all of it. In fact, my own exit strategy includes escaping into AI. Try as I might, I cannot see further than just a few years in my current industry. My wife and I have diversified our income sources. Personally, I welcome and look-foward to all the benefits of tech. Truly wonderous things are on the horizon.
What concerns me regarding radically advanced technologies are the short-term social impacts. Look at the amount of grief caused by outsourcing alone. I feel for these individuals. Seriously disruptive technologies are already coming down the pike from our own military machine. (ie. The last fighter pilot has already been born.) They will benefit us all in the long run, but there will be significant emotional chaos before the full benefits are realized.
I see millions displaced eventually. It is a necessary component of our collective technological and social advancement, but it will be painful in human terms at first. Ever decreasing numbers of people will be needed to maintain ever increasing productivity rates. I see huge doles, but most govts. should be able to afford them. I don't know the solution.
I think many in IT like to think we work on cutting-edge things, but most don't in reality. My company develops collaboration systems. It's a new mgmt process--not new tech. Marketing calls it innovative; I call it opportunistically adaptive.
If I am smart enough, I/we will steer our firm down the path of true innovation. My goals are to accomplish something genuinely great that benefits many people. Money does not define greatness.
by techceo
I had to reply. I disgree. A heart surgeon once told me, "I don't understand why people make a big deal out of what I do...it's not that hard."
I think what you do is difficult. You obviously have mastered it, so it only seems easier. I have three different degrees from challenging programs. My cumulative GPA was 3.99. The most challenging classes I recall were the CS ones. I finished the program with a 4.0, but man-o-man, I had to hump it. Many of those classes were tougher than accting, and accting is god-awful boring. CS was the only area where I had to read something FIFTY times to "get it."
Personally, I don't think most people can handle the demands of IT. It's something one must really want to learn, and it can be a very dry subject. I love it, but were I a tech, I would probably just be average at best.
by jimgon
by techceo
You make some generalized sweeping statements. Mgmt is just like the general population. Some criminals exist, but that is the exception. Most execs are trying to do the "right" thing and satisfy all constituents. (Which isn't easy by-the-way.)
See the following article from the Wall Street Journal. If you will accept it, it provides some insight into the big picture. http://online.wsj.com/article_email/0,,SB107919804320754591-IBjg4NllaR3n5ytaXmHaqqDm4,00.html
by techceo
by fluxit
The emotional chaos you speak of is what people bring upon themselves by not planning, looking ahead, or training themselves. Perhaps your services, whatever they may be, should be of a turnkey nature for these people to step into. Ray Crock brought more than a fast burger to industry. Could you imagine a business in the future that exploits adaptive systems in a similiar way millions of MacDonalds serves burgers? Do you realize the possibilities?
Anyhow, hayday of the aircraft carrier is drawing to a close. The focus is no longer on building fascinating aircraft that can do things like the Split S and the Herbst manuever. The focus is now on the payloads. The Navy is already phasing out the F-14, F-18, P-3, and the A-6. Soon UAV's with protracted loiter times will fill the airspace and the pilot, if even needed, will be home for dinner at 5.
One point you should take into consideration in your collaborative service is that most likely lower tech attempts were made at something nearly similiar. There were failures and successes you can learn from. The PPO was an attempt to average labor across markets and economies to keep people employed that failed. Your service may have some PPO like precepts. However, your service may vary in slight as logistics and telecommunications may solve the very reasons the PPO failed.
by jerrylee
After reading dozens of posts on this discussion, some of them very well written and heart felt, I came across this one to use as a representative sample (but it is not the only one). No substantive points made to rebut the argument that he/she was responding to, questionable sentence structure, and abhorrent spelling.
As others have noted outsourcing is not new and protectionism is not a workable means to combat it. Continued education and advancement of knowledge is?there is the solution. Gone are the days when you go to school graduate and NEVER have to go back again. We in America have grown fat and lazy because for so many years no one could rival in the technology arena, but time after time someone else eats our lunch. First it was auto manufacturing by Japan, then consumer electronics also by Japan (and other Asian countries), now we see IT jobs moving offshore in the same manner.
Why is this happening? In manufacturing it was because they could produce higher quality goods at a lower price. For IT we have a different culprit, the law of comparative advantage. There is a comparative advantage to be had by performing these services overseas for the US market. This comparative advantage allows companies to provide their products and services to the US market at a lower cost, while still improving profits for shareholders. This benefits all of us because we do get better quality products at lower prices and it helps to improve the quality of life for those people employed in the country where the jobs are outsourced to.
We as Americans have long held a very myopic view of the world, we truly believe that the world revolves around us and everything we do?wake up, it doesn?t and hasn?t for a long time. This attitude is the cause of most if not all of the animosity towards the US in the world today and has been for decades.
Screams and rants will not make outsourcing go away, we live in a global economy now it?s time for the whiners to wake up and smell the coffee. Seek out additional education and advanced skills, turn off the idiot box (TV) at home and read a book. If you cannot find work in the specific niche that you prefer, expand your horizons and try something new you might just like it. Lastly, as a few others have said before me ?Quit your bitching and do something?
by orpheum
Oh my god!! are you serious? Do you mean to say that these countries, whose citizens have been infiltrating our borders by the millions for the past couple of decades, do not welcome skilled foreigners who may advance their technological economies?? (hmm?why does this country allow again??) But wait..can't we find some politically-heavy corporation in said foreign country which would sponsor our citizenship for a work visa so that we can replace some adequately paid, college educated employee at the height of his 'productive' years trying to plant his feet in the ground?? c'mon! it's a common occurrence - NOT OVER THERE IT ISN'T! Those countries are in that predicament for a reason!! They're governments AND citizens are lazier and/or more corrupt than ours. We're more U.N. than the U.N. is on this point! I think it'd about time for INS to be introduced to IRS. Had our left hand known what the right hand were up to, this may have been prevented. Then again, it's not all easily blamed on our tolerant, provisional laws. Most of these foreigners have desperately sought out & found the loopholes they needed. Loopholes developed to protect oppressed people, legislature drafted on the heels of slaughters such as Kosovo or Nazi Germany. Well I haven't seen anybody in any IT department who came from foreign a land in refuge from a genocide. They all came to strike gold and to send it back home - or at least not spend it here.
That my friend is the loophole. A great problem today for a great country like ours, which has found itself bending over backwards through its existence to help out fellow human beings and ensure them that they have a haven, a refuge in which they can trust that a big brother will protect them from a force they cannot reckon with. Generally speaking though, I don't see how our policy makers will terminate immigration without causing a huge stir in the public sectors - and I doubt it will help at this point.
by maecuff
sell myself short. I'm not saying it isn't challanging, I'm just saying it's not heart surgery :)
Yes, I will agree, accounting must have been boring. (Accountants are the one group that programmers get to make fun of.)
And now, I'm going to sound like a geek..but, dry? IT is anything but dry. It can be stressful and frustrating, but it changes all the time. Okay, maybe writing documentation sucks, but even that is better than having a repetetive job.
by altekmg
To take a comment made in an earlier post "I am going to print this and frame it" not to show it to future children when they ask how could we let this happen. But, to show them where the boom started.
If as much energy was put into solving current problems and finding new products to provide to the world as has been put into grousing about the exporting of jobs we could be well on the way to rehiring most quality tech workers that are now looking.
Tom
by dc_guy
Target is not America's largest engine of offshore outsourcing. In a recent interview, Chinese government financial experts said that their nation's three biggest trading partners are:
1. The U.S.
2. The U.K.
3. WalMart
by techceo
I can hear your frustration and anger. Is it justified? Sure. Is it helpful to you? No.
A fast case study for you: My Wife.
My wife works for a $6B a year company, and she is one of the best in the country at what she does. For the past four years, she has been training her own competitors...not on the other side of the world but in her own dept. This practice may sound like foolishness, but there are compelling reasons for it.
My wife is one of the best, but she goes one better than that. She can reproduce herself. This is enormously valuable to her firm, and she is rewarded for her company contribution and team spirit.
If you isolate yourself and practice personal protectionism, your overall value to the org is reduced. It will not get you on mgmt's good side.
This is not patronizing mgmt; you are gaining valuable leverage over them. You want mgmt to be personally indebted to you. If you must leave the job, you want a stable of people to sing your praises and not only release generic position info.
A lot of what I learned came from mentors. I will forever be indebted to these people and will help them anyway I can. Between my wife and I, we have given more than we received. But we now have significant influence with many people.
I think you should adopt a similar outlook and deploy strategic practices over tactical ones. There is a huge "chasm" in hourly costs for offshore. But that is only one component of "cost." I know costs for offshore and domestic workers down to the gnat's whisker. There are trade-offs, and the disparity is not as great as it seems superficially. Research the economic development of Japan and Korea. Production costs can change rapidly.
There are many jobs that will never go offshore. If you can reproduce high-quality people in low-wage regions, your personal value will be through the roof. This will help you secure your personal position regardless of what happens in the industry. This may also help you gain more satisfaction and create a herd of life-long loyalists.
I had a drink for you yesterday. With all sincerity, I wish you good fortune.
by raghu
do you think that a public holding company would crash with
even a 100% boycott of independent share holders and I highly
doubt if FIs will listen to your plea in this forum.
One of the primary responsibilities of a company is to give
maximum profit to its shareholders.
Never the less, this is not the way my friend.
In fact if this happens, then US will not only be out of jobs, it will
be out of business too.
by ahickman
Hi My Indian Friend.....
Here is the real deal...
If we brought a large national/international American company to it's knees finacially through a boycott it would send a message to other American Companies. The message would be "You off shored IT Jobs to save money. Now you get a sneak preview of what will happen to your company when 31+ Million Americans no longer have jobs and can no longer afford to purchase your goods and services."
Currently there are 15 Million Americans out of work or working for substantially less than they used to make.
The are over 400,000 IT Professionals out of work and 450,000 H1B Visa holders working in it.
The White House, which supports offshoring sees another 16 Million jobs going off shore in the next few years.
This current economic recovery is NOT producing jobs for Americans.
So we have 15 million out of work today, add another 16 million to that in the next few years and you have a downwards sprial that will destroy the Targets and Bank One's anyway.
Look at what happened in Detroit and in the Rust Belt of the US when the steel and auto industry took the off shore hits in the last century. Vacant, empty cities.
Where did those cities turn to revitalize their cities....to Hi Tech.
Now we are shipping the Hi Tech jobs overseas where do the cities and the American People turn for revitalizing the American Economy. Become one gigantic Disneyland for Forgien Tourist?
The joke is, if countries like India, China, the Phillipines developed their own economy first (God knows they have enough people) they would be too busy fixing computers, building computers and writing software for internal consumption.
Plus what the lucky recipiants of American jobs do not realize is that if the US Economy fails, it will take the rest of the world with it. If you are doing support for Dell in India, who do you support when no one is buying Dell any more?
Face it, the recipiants of these American jobs better face the fact that if companies that employ you currently fail, guess who is next to be laid off.
We could face a world wide depression with extremly violent consequences. Imagine what you would do my friend if you lost your job in 5 years and there was no one to hire you?
For whom does the bell toll. It toll's for us.
Workers of the World Unite! You have nothing to lose but your chains.
Thanks for letting me share my thoughts.
Art
by orpheum
hey ragu, it sounds like you're very content with your situation in this country. However, let me just remind you that what we are going to ask from our government is that the 4-17 million people like you, who have reached our shores for one purpose only, have their work or education visas revoked and the entire catastrophe of the H1B/L1 and most other types of visa created and issued in the past 10 or say 12 years be ABOLISHED 'my friend'.
So please feel free to have a hearty laugh right now at the Americans who are hurting.
We may not appeal to the corporate profit puzzle, but I believe the US government would see this measure as 'closing the gap' a bit on the new unemployment rate (in case you were wondering how possible this idea really is).
We have begun a fight this year, and I swear that even if I'm back in a plush office chair making 6 figures a year again - I will not make it easy for people such as yourself to ever receive this kind of opportunity again.
BTW an editor friend of mine is cropping pieces of this discussion (the good ones of course) and pitching it to a publisher for a new 'monthly' which he is eager to start pressing.
Regards pal,
-Orpheum
by infoaaa19
by orpheum
feel free to use my suggestions and ideas to good use on your sites. I am not an activist but God knows I now have the free time to become one.
-Orpheum
by infoaaa19
by orpheum
Why does congress care about the dollar amount of an IT technician's salary??? That should be his company's problem. Government should be interested in stabilizing OUR economy, not the ROI or IT budgets of the large corporation. In order to accomplish this, our policymakers should consider adapting a measure to implement certain tariffs on the export of labor in the field of technology. What does the US gov't stand to gain by allowing taxpaying jobs to migrate to countries which don't contribute to our local economy or federal income tax intake? Somebody please clue me in. We aren't talking about the micro-electronics assembly lines now which have been off the table now for too many years. We're talking about well, it's obviously not necessary to elaborate that on this site.
There are tariffs in effect around most of the world in opposition to US goods and services, why don't our policymakers realize this novel, patriotic proposition of fighting for OUR ECONOMY! If corporate America doesn't care about the catalyst of its success, maybe congress can remind it. And if this is taken to THEM and rejected, like so many economical initiatives which are shot down in opposition to 'personal agendas' (alternative energy sources (Cheney)), then we know where the blame truly lies. How can we - working class taxpayers - stand half a chance?
It should be as simple as that!!! But it never is.
Fair trade?!!?!? Don't give me that. Since when did corporate America or government ever play fair with the rest of the world?
Besides, LABOR is not TRADE as in the finished goods market.
Don't dismiss our plight by laying blame on the technician's lazy-ass personal life, bottom line is we just can't live on India's paycheck no matter what. Rent or mortgage, income and sales taxes, food, clothing, transportation, etc?. That's a lot of rupees my friend!!
Nobody has been able to dispute this matter yet. I would like to see someone address that before calling the American IT guy 'lazy and not ambitious'. We get certified. As a matter of fact, certification providers are becoming a commodity by the day due to the fact that we are constantly seeking to advance our professional credentials. Whoever takes that position on the issue, please make sure to add that you yourself may be lazy and therefore assume that is the basis for the IT riddle.
Please don't litter this discussion with racist drivel or ideas you haven't fully thought out as members tend to lose momentum from half-baked replies. We are trying to SOLVE a problem - not start unnecessary new ones.
by infoaaa19
Let us place a referendum on the State ballot so that outsorcing companies will not get a tax break or other measures we can come up with.
I am trying to organize it at www.brattychildren.com If you have an idea or want to do then let us do it. Talk is cheap and time is of the essence.
by infoaaa19
by dneyman
by dneyman
by jimntz
According to this piece on Newsforge, CNET's Builder.com Web site believes outsourcing to India is the way to go when it comes to writing articles at least:
Builder.com outsourcing content production to India
http://trends.newsforge.com/trends/04/03/18/2240229.shtml?tid=137&tid=148&tid=20&tid=85
by infoaaa19
by orpheum
I hate to disagree with a fellow patriot, but I for one do not believe for a second that we're better off in the area of world peace. Since president 'dubbuya' took office, we've not only learned that our white house is nothing but a phony pretense towards the rest of the world and the rest of the world now 'has the floor' to vent back, we've also learned that our white house IS mainly the reason we're attracting all this hatred from other nations. they hate us in different regions simply because we brought back the son of the man who screwed up the world after a wonderful prdecessor left him an empire of monumental, recent global accomplishments.
Please don't misread me as communist or unpatriotic. I am entitled to comment on my personal opinion of the poor job my government has done, due to the fact that i pay taxes and contribute to their inflated salaries. I have been to europe and asia this year and have heard many discussions regarding the global view of the American political blunders of the current presidency and how it has affected the global community and world peace irreversibly, financially and emotionally.
GOD BLESS OUR COUNTRY
-Orpheum
by orpheum
Bottom line is - you were a force to be reckoned with. Mr H1B was not. Management saw their rise to the top (or the illusion thereof) in a fresh off the boat tech who would serve as their bitch and reflect the manager's positive influence in the company to upper mgmt and thereby secure said manager's job. The H1B will never pose a threat to mgmt for at least 5 years or till they themselves are promoted to mgmt - whichever comes first. Humans tend to band together ONLY in times of need and desperation.
On another note, Ken, I am truly sorry about your situation as I ahve been in and out of this boat for a couple of years too. Only I've found a couple of tiny businesses in a vertical market which has allowed me to keep afloat every now and again. I have lost my apartment in a NYC suburb and have been admitted to the ER without health insurance 6 times over the past 3 years.
I sure hope someone worth a crap reads this, Ken.
Stay strong and keep your chin up, man.
GOD BLESS
-Orpheum
by orpheum
the only shouts reaching corporate US is 'we must cut I/T costs even more!'
You can't force a company to use domestic labor for higher wages in the free world, dude. As long as there's a demand for cheaper labor, and foreign policies that allow it, there will always be an India, China, Mexico, etc... to fulfill such needs.
HOW DO WE ELIMINATE THE ENABLING POLICIES?!?
Let's attempt to unravel the plausible elements of our battle to co-exist.
-Orpheum
by orpheum
you can't pull a convince here.
only government, which sets the policies for incorporated business in the homeland, can possibly influece a corp exec to do ANYTHING.
i would say it rests in congress' hands to make ANY change in the outsourcing and H1B hijacking of I/T jobs.
Please continue to spread the word.
-Orpheum
by orpheum
thanx for the valuable input on the global economy. However, when I have no job, I could care less if the rest of the globe is employed.
Secondly, outsourcing overseas DOES NOT MAKE THE GENERAL ECONOMY STRONGER! It only makes the corporation which is doing the outsourcing appear to have maximized their profits and to the contrary only making the economy of the country receiving these outsourced revenues stronger. Leaving Americans unemployed and the IRS losing out tax revenues. India's citizens living in India, aquiring I/T work from the US have never and will never stimulate the US economy.
Although I am an I/T tech with a nice amount of cert's and experience to my resume, I majored in accounting and minored in economics at a prestigous university.
You insult the intelligence of my colleagues and myself by putting forth such ignorance with such conviction.
by shalako
I find I have to agree with Orpheum on this point.
How does losing one's job and possibly making his entire family destitute make our job market or the economy stronger?
The US has lost millions of jobs in the IT , manufacturing, and textile industries for years. The so called service jobs that are supposedly taking the place of these are low paying and many are taking in turn by illegal aliens with the blessing of big corporations and our own government who now wants to legalize those who have broken our nations laws in the first place,
Most of this can be laid to corporate greed. How many 5 or 10 million dollar a year execs are laid off or outsourced?
Every day I see in the paper where white and blue collar workers are laid off to save the company so many millons of dollars a year but I never see where the corporate execs. are downsized are given a reduction in wages.
All of this is encouraged by our tax laws which are written in turn by the corporations and then are signed in to law by our elected officials that have been in turn purchased by the corporations and is passed off by the American people as business as usual.
by orpheum
I think what you just wrote has much truth and optimism to it. I agree that we're all crying because we were hit hard. However, I failed to stress in my opening post that the bigger problem is the lax immigration policy our great country (and the Neil Diamond song) was founded on.
In truth, and I hope you can agree, this is such a painful blow because it is coming from within our borders moreso than from overseas-based operations. I will interupt myself now to point out that I am not racist nor a member of any cult or nationalistic extremist organization. I am just a dude.
This dude, however, believes that this issue will not become any smaller anytime soon. It will also not cause our unemployment, homeless or suicide rates to climb to shocking record levels anytime soon. But, it is, and will continue to cause many Americans unnecessary anguish and hardship for a while.
Had our country been any more or any less socialist. autonomist, capitalist or communalist we would never be here to begin with.
I'll get to my point now - we were not unskilled or incapable of handling our I/T, we have just been outnumbered and outbid on wage!!
Your opinion counts MrCEO, what do you feel about these thoughts?
-Orpheum
by techceo
Orpheum, I agree with you. Our industry and nation have taken some hard shots. (In many ways and even some you omitted.)It breaks my heart to see the anguish that is going on.
As for the offshore guys, I am often pleasantly surprised AND frustrated. Dealing with them is like dancing with a woman that has learned to dance only from footprints on the floor; she knows the steps, but not how to "dance." But they are quick and are learning to Cha-Cha fast though.
I think many companies will develop a "hybrid" approach like we have. I am optimistic because the rest of the world is playing "catch-up" to us. If we work it wisely, they never will.
Competition and cost is based on many aspects and not just hourly rates. I have never been the "low price leader" anywhere I've been, but we were always fierce and capable competitors. The wage/cost differences will level-out in time. Wages here will likely go down some and offshore will go up a lot. A workable balance will be reached.
My firm currently has some products in feasibility study that will loot foreign IP and permanently transplant it here. (The door swings both ways.) Americans have many advantages now, but the key is our leadership. We need hard-liners in govt who will kick-down the door to foreign mkts and effectively deal with issues. (Regardless of political affiliation.) There is some shoving that is needed, and wimps or fools can't get it done.
In closing, I can only say "Take Heart." We have already lost, and shall lose, some painful battles. But these battles are not the war, and I believe with all my heart, that we shall emerge victorious and better as a nation. There is no alternative.
by orpheum
Hey CEO,
I was just wondering - are you a CEO in a company considered a 'key player'?. Also, do you support the call for a heavy tariff on outsourced labor to level the playing field? or do we have to spend another 20 years or so, eating one meal a day and shacking up with our extended family so that we may compete with the global economy therby lowering the American standard of living. Or maybe just bow out of certain positions in industries where we've lost our foothold. There isn't enough room in this country for everyone to become mgmt or exec ya know. Some of the MCSE's who've worked under me are flippin burgers or pouring coffee.
Second, how do you feel about the INS turning a blind eye on the unemployment rate in this country? I know this may not have been 'the' reason the rate has skyrocketed, but it is certainly a contributing factor affecting our local economies. Foreign workers from economically challenged countries tend to spend less in the new land they've landed upon, whether or not their wages and personal budgets permit.
Please don't mistake any of my wording as patronizing or sarcastic.
-Orpheum
by techceo
Well, Orpheum, some people think we are key players. But fortunes shift rapidly these days.
I typically do not support tariffs on anyone from anywhere. I believe in free-market economics; it has an amazing ability to adapt all by itself. (There are limits to that, so it needs qualification. There must be reciprocation by our trade parters.)
I am sympathetic to the plight of many quality American workers. This isn't patronizing; I am the product of an impoverished family from a hell-hole of a small town. I am also an ethnic minority. I have first-hand experience with enormous adversity. I am neither tall, handsome, nor particularly bright. I believe our borders should be sealed tighter than grandma's pickle jars; conversely, were I Mexican, I would be the first jumping the wall.
It is unfortunate, but some jobs will be lost and never return. (The US has not manufactured a TV domestically since 1980.)
The manner in which we compete is key to our collective technological and business survival. I alone made the decision to go offshore; it was no easy choice, and I paid hell for it. Even my wife's friends said, "How could you? You're taking American's jobs!" No one in my firm was displaced by a foreigner, but we did not hire more Americans. (We intend to soon!)
Long-term survival in our business is complicated. I am reviewing work this morning from our offshore depts, and I frequently think, "Aye Caramba! What the !@#$ are you thinking?!" It takes twice as long frequently to get the quality we need. There still is a savings but not as much as many believe. But, offshore will only improve, and there is no good way to contain it. So we must use it to our advantage.
Our IT workforce will become smaller but more elite. (Much like the armed forces.) I knew many MCSEs were doomed even when the cert came out. (I am an MCSE and CNA too.) Low-level positions and the marginal-quality workers are the first to go.
I like and use military analogies because they are relevant in many ways: Business is a competition for scarce resources. Like a military campaign, there will be casualties and losses, but we cannot focus on those aspects alone. We must focus on the strategic objective, and that is US global domination in IT. We can do it, and I will do everything in my power to help the cause.
by orpheum
hey - we can't do without some things buddy. if i were to not own a computer or automobile when my job depends on it - i'd be called an idiot! the country doesn't do boycotts anymore - only the govt does. but I admire your spirit!
please look into the matter on the web and see if your vote can make a difference
http://www.rescueamericanjobs.org/ is a good start.
by orpheum
Here's a thought (again). There is no greater economic force than Wall St in the world, right? Kingdoms and governments may come and go, but we are all slaves to that which is the ultimate driving force in this cut-throat global economy. All those who've been commenting on this discussion, and the comments are EXTREMELY heartfelt, are well aware that we are all just 'bitches' of the stock market, right?. Nothing is 'global' without first passing through the market. Nothing makes it out of our market alive without first turning a profit. Nothing can first turn a profit without an edge or advantage. SO WHY IS THIS COUNTRY SHOOTING ITSELF IN THE FOOT AGAIN??
Just after 9/11, when our esteemed leader of the free world decided to invade Terroristiaville (or at that moment - Afghanistan), he had to land our warplanes and dock our battleships and carriers in close proximity - India's territory (which by the way they should have accommodated us out of gratitude for the INS bills we've been passing in their favor for decades). So India decides that IBM's gift to their construction industry isn't enough -they want even more compensation for this military hospitality. So they brokered an unconditional abolition of TARIFFS ON ALL GOODS AND SERVICES in exchange. They don't want our money - THEY WANT OUR ECONOMY!!!! This handed India a 'wild card' which is now, and will probably always be biting us in the wallet. This has led to the advantage or 'edge' that country needed to put itself over the top and clinch the already unstable markets and industries which we have been losing steadily over the years. This is privileged yet indisputable info I heard from a diamond syndicate site holder who lived in Bombay at the time.
So in conclusion - yes, we were losing our foothold in IT services and importing of polished diamonds & finished jewelry (to name a pair of trillion dollar industries). Are we playing the game on a level field though? Colin Powell gets paid whether you and I eat today or not. And he didn't have to spend one dollar!! - but our own intelligence people have just murdered trillions of future dollars over the next few years. They may as well have given India our currency mint. Their concern was to get our warplanes in position to retaliate against what was correctly coined at that time 'a threat to the free world' and the force responsible for the WTC massacre in my home town of Manhattan. It goes without saying that I am not pointing another finger at someone or something. What the hell would you or I have done. The entire nation was breathing down the guy's neck!! The real culprits here are the ones who decided that this exchange was acceptable!
I am, however, appalled by the reply from a member named " raghu@nextgma.com" who wrote *"What goes around, comes around. Well ! people its about time" as if he was taking some sort of pride in our country's fall from grace. As if his homeland were able to single-handedly conquer the world's most self-sufficient super economy. Hey buddy, we haven't looked your way in 4 generations - you guys caught a break, we were bombed and needed to rent space for a war, that's all. Your people won't know what to do with our money once they've got it! So don't laugh yet. And where do you get the gall?!?
Anyhow, brace yourselves, we're about to find out the price of Bushism and his Powell play.
GOD BLESS THIS COUNTRY!!
-Orpheum
*see string named "India and nanotech"
by orpheum
by infoaaa19
by orpheum
Why do congressmen care about the dollar amount of an IT technician's salary??? That should be his company's problem. Government should be interested in stabilizing OUR economy, not the ROI or IT budgets of the large corporation. Why haven't our policymakers adapted measures to implement certain tariffs on the export of labor in the field of technology. What does the US gov't stand to gain by allowing taxpaying jobs to go to H1B's or migrate to countries which don't contribute to our local economy or federal income tax revenues? Somebody please clue me in. WHY?!? (pssst...I'm not an idiot, I know the answer). We aren't talking about the micro-electronics assembly lines now. We're talking about well, it's obviously not necessary to elaborate any more on this site.
There are tariffs in effect around most of the world in opposition to US goods and services, because they've all lost market share decades ago putting up a clean fight. Why don't our policymakers realize this novel, patriotic proposition of fighting for OUR ECONOMY! If corporate America doesn't care about the catalyst of its success, maybe congress can remind it. And if this is taken to THEM and rejected, like so many economical initiatives which are shot down in opposition to 'personal agendas' (alternative energy sources (Cheney)), then we know that corporate America's 'bitches' were VOTED in! Congress is constantly trying to raise the cap on L1 & H1B visas every year! How do we - working class taxpayers - stand half a chance? Work harder? Donate more blood? Adopt a friendly looking foreign kid? (please don't comment on my sarcasm - it gets me through the day)
Worse yet - outsourcing is not entirely what led to the hijacking of I/T jobs - L1 &H1B visas are more to blame. And again, who sponsors the friggin things?!? Corporate America - that's who! with the help of a couple of tainted representatives, congressmen and senators of course (ahhem.. (kickbacks and personal gains interests)) I'm pretty sure I'm covered under the first amendment on these comments, right?
Fair trade?!!?!? Don't give me that. Since when did corporate America or government ever play fair with the rest of the world?
Don't dismiss our plight by laying blame on the technician's lazy-ass personal life, bottom line is we just can't live on India's paycheck no matter what. Rent or mortgage, income and sales taxes, food, clothing, transportation, etc?. That's a lot of rupees my friend!!
Nobody has been able to dispute this matter yet. I would like to see someone address that before calling the American IT guy 'lazy and not ambitious'. We get certified. As a matter of fact, certification providers are becoming a commodity by the day due to the fact that we are constantly seeking to advance our professional credentials. Whoever takes that position on the issue, please make sure to elaborate that you yourself may be lazy and therefore assume that is the basis for the IT riddle.
The IT tech has not been fired for poor workmanship OR quality of his production - simply b/c we can't make ends meet with the salaries now being offered for our old positions. So now there's a wave of H1B's who meet the criteria of filling jobs which the unemployed IT tech is incapable of filling according to the unemployment office, and the H1B gets hired b/c he can figure out how to undercut the American lifestyle. The IT tech is not overpaid for the responsibility he bears, maybe the dot-com startup execs and mgmt were though.
I admire the folks who refuse to shack up with 4 extended families in a 2 bedroom apartment in Jackson Heights, Queens of all areas, in order to compete with an H1B or L1 visa recipient ( who by the way are paying little or no income tax b/c of their low "official" wage and receiving the bulk of their salary in the form of non-taxable "living expenses" - the official wage is generally in the lowest tax bracket so the employee gets a full refund at the end of the tax year) - http://www.rescueamericanjobs.org/
Please also refer to the bottom of the page for some 'serious impacts' we can expect in the future. http://money.cnn.com/2004/03/11/commentary/dobbs/dobbs/index.htm
Here's a very useful site whish states statistics and facts on immigration visas and the politicians who introduce/support them or veto/deny them - real interesting reading.
http://www.numbersusa.com/interests/hightech.html
And oh yeah - I'll do 'orpheum goes to Washington' if necessary, cause I'm not married, got no kids, plenty of free time and throughout my life, I've always stood up against what I believed was wrong when I can help reverse it - and yeah, I will make a difference when I am teamed up with similarly motivated characters. I plan on attending a conference in my local community (after I thoroughly research the org sponsoring the event), and if need be - I will help form a coalition. God knows many of us now have the free time - I am confident there are independents who will contribute whatever it takes when they're called upon!!
Please don't litter this discussion with racist drivel or ideas you haven't fully thought out as members tend to lose momentum from half-baked replies. We are trying to SOLVE a problem - not start unnecessary new ones. Feel free to insult me personally for my views though, I don't mind it really - constructive criticism is what will take the next discussion directly to the heart of its issue.
GOD BLESS I/T
-Orpheum
by ahickman
Well from what I can tell after almost a week of reading and posting on this disucssion thread is that most of the people in IT are SHEEP who do not belive that one day they will be led to the slaughter house. They believe in this Fairy Tale about an IT Tech who works 70 hours per week, spends $10,000.00 per year going to school for certs and keeps his job while all the rest of the "lazy" sheep are led to slaughter.
Outsourching is killing the Horatio Alger IT Social Myth.
While you and I and others who see what is comming are being treated like the "Little Boy Who Cried Wolf"
The Outsourcing Story has a moral.
But, from what I can tell, most IT people are content to stick their heads in the sand and pretend that everything is ok. Obviously, if it has not happened to me, it won't.
Or, the most Famous of Last Words....."It won't happen here".
Thoes who fail to learn from History are doomed to repeat it.
Obviously what happened to the UAW, the Steel industry, the textile industry, etc., won't happen to the IT industry.
Ah, anyone reading this remember recent history?....The DOT COM Boom and BUST?
Ah..anyone understand what the MATRIX movies were trying to say?
I do recomend that all currently employed IT Professionsals start organizing their finances so that when they are led to the slaughter they have a couple of years worth of money in the bank whille they go to "Burger U" or "Greeter U" for their next career.
Now is a good time to sell your house, pay off and turn in your credit cards and get a used car before your forced to do it. It's not pretty making $9-$12/hour schlepping hardware on a short term assignment.
However, you can get a nice high paying ATM Service Tech job for a cool $13/hour. Lab Techs are making $10/hour these days and the Nursing Profession and Teaching Professions are filling up fast.
And, of course the US Government is giving all the lower paying jobs to illegal immigrants.
OH - this brings up APEASEMENT.....
Anyone remember Hitler and Chamberlain? Oh, that was before the 8088. Not relevant to today.
Guess not, unless you happened to be Jewish in Warsaw or Berlin in the 1930's and 40's.
by infoaaa19
by infoaaa19
For those of you not wanting to be involved, here is the brainchild of the California State Assembly.
I like the one about FENG SUY ACR 144...that will really help you improve the economy....
2003-2004 ASSEMBLY BILLS
SORTED BY AUTHOR
AUTHOR BILL TOPIC
NUMBER
---
AB 2984
AB 2987
Aghazarian
AB 288 Taxation: agriculture: irrigation.
AB 291 Personal income and corporation taxes: tax
credit: agricultural environment remediation
expenditure.
AB 339 Farmworker housing tax credits.
AB 341 Contractors: landscape contractors.
AB 386 Drinking water: local primacy agencies.
AB 387 Hazardous materials: farms: business plans and
inventories.
AB 627 Parkland and coastal protection.
AB 1035 Enterprise zones: Stanislaus County.
AB 1246 Administrative penalties: analysis.
AB 1247 Hazardous waste facility: postclosure.
AB 1248 Waste discharge requirements.
AB 1948 Placement of minors.
AB 2005 Community care facilities: juvenile offender
programs.
AB 2056 Dentistry.
AB 2197 Dam safety inspections and fees: exemption.
AB 2254 Household hazardous waste: used diesel filters.
AB 2341 Public contracts.
AB 2877 Hazardous waste: regulation.
AB 2878 Alcoholic beverage licensees: fixtures and
supplies.
AB 2881 Water rights.
ACR 19 Joash E. Paul Memorial Highway.
ACR 20 California Agriculture Week.
AJR 31 Assyrians in Iraq.
Bates
AB 57 Controlled substances: Ecstasy (MDMA; XTC).
AB 58 State Water Pollution Cleanup and Abatement
Account.
AB 72 Child care providers.
AB 239 Identity theft: minors: sentence enhancements.
AB 270 Jury service: peace officer exemption.
AB 298 Special education.
AB 512 Common interest developments.
AB 615 Advisory Commission on Special Education:
charter school member.
AB 860 Electrical corporations: desalination plants.
AB 951 Municipal storm water.
AB 1319 In-Home Supportive Services program.
AB 1393 Developmental services: regional centers:
vendorization.
AB 1444 Forensic identification.
AB 1446 Crime.
AB 1464 Charter schools: authorization.
AB 1488 Domestic violence protective orders.
AB 1516 Child custody: abduction.
AB 1518 Pupil assessments: redundancy.
AB 1602 Local government finance.
AB 1603 Income taxes: exclusion: stock options.
AB 1604 Personal income and bank and corporation taxes:
credits: military housing.
AB 1605 Employees and service-providers: reporting
requirements.
AB 2320 Unemployment insurance: benefits.
AB 2322 Unemployment and disability compensation.
AB 2325 Income and corporation taxes: credit: disabled
employees.
AB 2371 Attorneys: Legal Consumers' Protection Act.
AB 2374 Consumer credit reporting agencies: creditor
notices.
AB 2376 Common interest developments: architectural
review.
AB 2434 Public Utilities Commission: railroad crossings.
AB 2436 Clinical laboratory testing.
AB 2531 Child abuse reporting.
AB 2534 IHSS providers: fingerprint and criminal
background check.
AB 2650 Private Attorneys General Act of 2004: small
employers.
AB 2652 Electricity: repowering powerplants.
AB 2655 Agreements.
AB 2764 Charter schools: alternative authority.
AB 2765 California longitudinal pupil achievement data
system.
AB 2776 Quality Education Model: school funding.
AB 2941 Special absentee voters: voting by facsimile.
AB 2959 State government reorganization.
ACR 60 Charter School Week.
ACR 133 Oceanside Police Officer Tony Zeppetella
Memorial Highway.
Benoit
AB 1263 Trespass.
AB 1264 Regional notification centers: excavation
equipment: exclusions.
AB 1265 Engineers and land surveyors: limited liability
partnerships.
AB 1289 Toll roads.
AB 1376 Vital records.
AB 1377 School facilities.
AB 1456 Irrigation districts: electrical power.
AB 1490 Taxation: real property interest: withholding
requirements.
AB 1509 Office of Emergency Services: demonstration
project.
AB 1511 Vehicles: unlawful activities.
AB 1565 Forensic identification.
AB 1566 School facilities: construction and
modernization.
AB 1624 Air pollution: smog check.
AB 1625 Vehicles: seatbelts: fines.
AB 1646 Contracting for noninstructional services.
AB 1951 Traffic signs or signals.
AB 2075 State civil service: employee qualifications.
AB 2171 Teacher credentialing: special education.
AB 2229 Birth and death certificates: authorized copies.
AB 2458 Traffic violator schools: lesson plans.
AB 2567 School facilities: supplemental enrollment.
AB 2646 Income and corporation taxes: credit:
information.
AB 2670 Automatic external defibrillator requirements:
public safety personnel.
AB 2781 Charter schools: operation.
AB 2782 Public agencies: joint powers agencies:
meetings.
AB 2823 Highway signs.
AB 2875 Game animals: taking of game.
AB 2904 Auto insurance: express warranties.
AB 2934 Public agencies: joint powers agencies.
AB 2961 Police vehicle pursuit: punishment.
AB 2986 Search warrants: confidentiality.
ABX3 1 Vehicles: social security account number:
driver's license and identification cards.
ACR 29 Daniel J. Muehlhausen Memorial Highway.
ACR 55 Bark beetle infestation and drought emergency.
Berg
AB 1 Area agencies on aging: funding.
AB 946 AIDS: clean needle and syringe exchange.
AB 1164 Telecommunications: mobile telephony services:
fraud.
AB 1166 Residential facilities: terminally ill persons.
AB 1168 Wild and scenic rivers: Albion and Gualala
Rivers.
AB 1172 Joint powers agreement: public agencies.
AB 1199 County of Del Norte.
AB 1201 Medi-Cal: subacute services.
AB 1220 Heart disease and stroke prevention.
AB 1296 Fish: krill.
AB 1354 Commercial Fisheries Capacity Reduction Account.
AB 1363 AIDS: clean needle and syringe exchange program.
AB 1538 Construction contractors.
AB 1881 Integrated health and human services programs.
AB 1936 Local government organization.
AB 1952 Older Adults System of Care Demonstration
Project.
AB 1994 California Commission on Aging.
AB 2517 Crab fisheries: Dungeness crab and rock crab.
AB 2519 Salmon and roe herring.
AB 2704 Employment: domestic workers.
AB 2706 Education technology.
AB 2758 Telecommunications: grants to areas not served
by local exchange carriers.
AB 2760 Fish and game: licensing and entitlements.
AB 2783 Chronic pain treatment.
AB 2786 Hospices: licensing.
AB 2791 Medi-Cal.
AB 2871 Clean needle and syringe exchange: AIDS and
hepatitis.
ACR 93 American Stroke Month.
ACR 94 Older Americans Month.
ACR 136 Assisted Living Week.
Bermudez
AB 62 Outdoor advertising displays.
AB 96 High-priority schools.
AB 236 Physicians and surgeons.
AB 237 Unemployment insurance: unemployment
compensation benefits: temporary employees of a
community college.
AB 278 Gambling Control Act.
AB 281 Local Agency Public Construction Act: bidder
prequalification: notice.
AB 282 Barbering and Cosmetology: threading.
AB 369 Public employees' retirement: employment after
retirement.
AB 375 State employees: memoranda of understanding.
AB 470 Government regulation: religious exercise.
AB 1027 State employees: salary ranges: professional
scientists.
AB 1028 California Apprenticeship Council.
AB 1062 Health care coverage: Integrated Child and
Youth Health Program.
AB 1079 Automotive repair.
AB 1096 Transportation projects.
AB 1108 Child custody: drug testing.
AB 1153 Crime.
AB 1162 Community colleges.
AB 1169 Public utilities: telephone corporations:
disposition of property.
AB 1251 Los Angeles County Hospital Authority.
AB 1253 Public employees' retirement: early retirement
incentive.
AB 1312 Trapping licenses: structural pest control
operators.
AB 1341 Corrections: health care.
AB 1346 Court records: confidentiality.
AB 1392 Medical Board of California: prosecutorial and
investigative resources.
AB 1533 Drug treatment furlough program.
AB 1535 State employees: compensation.
AB 1656 Transit village development planning.
AB 1729 Automobile insurance: persistency.
AB 1795 Home-to-school transportation: East Whittier
City School District.
AB 1797 Medical Board of California: exemption from
hiring freeze.
AB 1803 Pregnant inmates: children.
AB 1812 Drivers' certificates: medical examination.
AB 1816 Medical Board of California.
AB 1831 Homeland security: federal funding.
AB 1926 Trapping licenses: structural pest control
operators.
AB 1975 Prisoners.
AB 2017 Pupil Volunteer Award Program.
AB 2024 Ports: transportation network.
AB 2406 Fire safety.
AB 2407 Kindergarten.
ABX1 13 State employees' retirement: early retirement
incentive.
ABX1 14 State employees' retirement: early retirement
incentive.
ABX1 15 State employees' retirement: early retirement
incentive.
ACR 67 City of Artesia: Little India.
ACR 105 California Travel and Tourism Month.
Bogh
AB 2 Victims: appearances at parole hearings.
AB 80 County employees' retirement: firefighters'
service credit.
AB 87 Workers' compensation: disaster service
workers: funding.
AB 89 Prevailing wages: payroll records: digitized
copies.
AB 133 Public employees' retirement: Riverside County
deputy coroners.
AB 273 Public employees: compensation.
AB 350 Vehicles: driver's licenses: issuance and
renewal: driving and vehicle registration
records: registered sex offenders.
AB 540 Death certificates: peace officers.
AB 543 Jurisdiction.
AB 555 Public employees' retirement: postretirement
employment.
AB 657 Vehicle forfeiture: driving under the influence.
AB 725 Crime.
AB 754 Unfair competition.
AB 796 Occupational safety and health: fines.
AB 797 Controlled substances: manufacture:
conspiracy: enhancements.
AB 861 Criminal street gangs.
AB 963 Criminal street gangs.
AB 1037 Crime.
AB 1305 Identity theft: driver's license and
identification card .
AB 1787 Vehicles: registration: late penalties:
exemptions: deployed military.
AB 1802 Illegal dumping: penalties.
AB 1811 Privacy: social security numbers.
AB 1826 Professional and trade licenses.
AB 1924 Fire prevention: penalties.
AB 1935 Vehicle license fees: local government.
AB 1996 Arson registry: Internet.
AB 2068 Sex offenders.
AB 2562 Private patrol operators.
AB 2563 Crime.
AB 2632 Health facilities: construction plans:
expedited approval.
AB 2694 Litter: cigarettes: increased fines.
AB 2740 Vehicles: engineering and traffic surveys:
Riverside County.
AB 2829 Rape: evidence: sexual conduct.
AB 2865 Safe, Reliable High-Speed Passenger Train Bond
Act for the 21st Century.
AB 2896 Corporation taxes.
AB 2897 Prisoners: medical testing.
AB 2911 Department of Forestry and Fire Protection.
AB 2914 Parole.
ABX1 2 Public employees: compensation.
ACA 21 Motor vehicle fuel sales tax revenue.
ACR 112 California Department of Forestry and Fire
Protection firefighters.
ACR 176 George Washington's birthday.
ACR 180 Blue Star Memorial Highway.
AJR 65 Soboba Band of Luiseno Indians.
Calderon
AB 3 Consumer Credit Reporting.
AB 122 Sales and use taxes: credit: manufacturer's
investment.
AB 153 Student financial aid: eligibility.
AB 174 Community college fees.
AB 258 Retail sales: personal information.
AB 259 Battery: anger management.
AB 523 Collateral recovery.
AB 535 Highways: Route 19 relinquishment.
AB 536 Water replenishment districts.
AB 538 State Environmental Goals and Policy Report.
AB 548 Funeral directors and embalmers: examinations.
AB 840 Public Utilities Commission: evidence: orders
or decisions: review.
AB 1047 Overtime compensation: insurance claims
adjusting.
AB 1048 Insurance: earthquake policies.
AB 1049 Insurance: underwriting: information.
AB 1295 Elder and dependent adult abuse.
AB 1379 Telecommunications: mobile telephony service.
AB 1842 Fred C. Nelles School for Boys.
AB 2170 Collateral recovery.
AB 2544 Commission on California's Future.
AB 2551 California Gambling Control Commission.
AB 2589 Public utilities.
AB 2593 Self-generation incentive program.
AB 2599 Mediation proceedings: videotaping.
AB 2601 Public utilities.
AB 2602 Railroad safety.
AB 2603 Urban water management plans.
AB 2605 Water storage districts: eminent domain.
AB 2799 Telecommunications: billings.
AB 2804 Construction defects.
AB 2876 Continuity of care: terminal illness.
AB 2883 Santa Clara Valley Water District.
AB 2884 California regional water quality control
boards: pollution or nuisance: abatement.
AB 2945 Horse racing: reporting.
AB 3005 Renewable energy resources: California
Renewables Portfolio Standard Program: local
publicly owned electric utilities: renewable
energy credits.
AB 3032 Seismic safety.
AB 3033 Seismic safety.
AB 3034 Environmental quality: biotechnology industry.
Campbell
AB 126 Publicly funded advertisements.
AB 128 Internet Tax Freedom Act: continuation.
AB 130 Department of Motor Vehicles: records.
AB 283 Claims against the state: appropriation.
AB 564 Income taxes: federal taxable income.
AB 612 Personal income taxes: alimony deduction.
AB 613 State-mandated local programs: funding.
AB 687 Alcoholic beverages: brewing industry.
AB 735 Taxpayers' bill of rights: taxpayers' rights
advocate: privacy rights.
AB 876 Sex offenders.
AB 927 Air pollution: hydrogen refueling stations.
AB 1013 Corporations: dissenters' rights.
AB 1176 Proposition 65: enforcement.
AB 1291 Baseline rates: electric pumps.
AB 1292 Public Utilities Commission: telecommunications:
funds.
AB 1966 Energy resources: hydrogen.
AB 1990 Trusts: trustee liability.
AB 2034 Meyers-Milias-Brown Act: agency shop agreements.
AB 2124 Public contracts: foreign-made products:
prohibited labor practices.
AB 2181 Elections.
AB 2195 Workers' compensation: contractors: temporary
workers.
AB 2221 Contracts: translation.
AB 2241 Building standards: California Building
Standards Commission.
AB 2282 Corporations.
AB 2379 Proposition 65: enforcement: judgments.
AB 2419 Public utilities: judicial review.
AB 2421 Franchise Tax Board: disclosures.
AB 2460 State employees: holidays.
AB 2480 Personal income tax and corporation tax:
administration: e-filing.
AB 2482 State reports: electronic format.
AB 2590 Personal income tax: taxable income.
AB 2592 Property taxation: personal property valuation:
actual cost.
AB 2903 State employees' retirement: contributions and
benefits.
ACA 6 Expenditure limit.
ACA 27 State government: reorganization.
ACAX5 2 State expenditures.
ACR 47 Cure Children's Cancer Month.
Canciamilla
AB 93 Safe, Clean, and Reliable Water Supply Bond Act
of 2004.
AB 498 State government: prudent state reserve.
AB 499 State budget: two-year spending plan.
AB 502 Legislature: recording of proceedings.
AB 645 Parks hostel facilities.
AB 741 Water shortage emergencies: notice of hearing
requirements.
AB 742 Streambed alteration.
AB 808 Energy: agency consolidation.
AB 1014 Vessels: abandonment.
AB 1016 Curriculum: John Muir Day.
AB 1120 Pupils: interdistrict transfers.
AB 1121 Public Utilities Commission: report on fees.
AB 1157 Public utilities: water and gas rates.
AB 1170 California Clean Water, Clean Air, Safe
Neighborhood Parks, and Coastal Protection Act
of 2002: cultural and historical preservation.
AB 1225 Land use.
AB 1339 Public employee health benefits: survivors of
firefighters and peace officers.
AB 1349 Wills and trusts: prohibited transferees.
AB 1454 Vector control.
AB 1908 California Water Plan.
AB 1921 Urban water management planning.
AB 2175 Conversion of rental housing.
AB 2445 Advance health care directives: registry.
AB 2450 Sexually violent predators: notice.
AB 2455 Instructional materials: requirements of
publishers and manufacturers: prices.
AB 2634 Local government organization.
AB 2635 Oaks Woodlands Conservation Fund: report.
AB 2642 Energy: natural gas.
AB 2643 Energy: natural gas.
AB 2687 Public administrators.
AB 2808 State Comprehensive Plan.
AB 2809 Air pollution: confined animal facilities.
AB 2810 Forest resources: penalties and fines: report.
AB 2826 Solid waste: landfills.
AB 2831 Public Utilities Commission: complaints.
AB 2834 Water treatment, reuse, and conveyance.
AB 2864 Water rights: fees.
AB 2951 Agricultural water measurement.
AB 2953 Air pollution: Carol Moyer Memorial Air Quality
Standards Attainment Program: eligibility
criteria.
AB 2954 Electrical corporations: rate of return:
alternative energy facilities.
AB 2958 Income and corporation taxes: collections:
private agencies.
ACAX5 1 State finance.
ACR 115 Inspector Raymond J. Giacomelli Memorial
Overcrossing.
HR 17
Chan
AB 4 Personal income tax: rates.
AB 154 Health and managed care plans: culturally and
linguistically appropriate services.
AB 165 School Accountability Report Card: requirements.
AB 179 California Children and Families Commission.
AB 195 Health education.
AB 216 Alcohol: fee: youth alcohol recovery and
prevention.
AB 232 Statewide health planning and development:
hospitals: self-pay policies.
AB 262 Personal information.
AB 302 Polybrominated diphenyl ether.
AB 343 Healthy Families Program.
AB 368 Healthy Families Program: local educational
agency billing option.
AB 374 County employees' retirement systems: capital
expenditures.
AB 377 Vehicles: exhaust systems: whistle-tip.
AB 412 Insurance: consumer protection: senior
citizens.
AB 422 Child development permits.
AB 526 Voter registration.
AB 715 Personal information.
AB 716 Small business financial development
corporations.
AB 908 California State University: disability
retirement: temporary disability allowances for
employees.
AB 918 Classified employees.
AB 1465 School facilities: new construction: small
schools.
AB 1657 Gelatin-based alcoholic beverages.
AB 1815 Personal income tax: rates.
AB 1822 Schools: pupil immunizations.
AB 1841 Public Schools Accountability Act of 1999:
grants.
AB 1876 Public beach sanitation.
AB 1878 Motor scooters.
AB 1940 Hazardous chemicals: testing methods.
AB 1941 Criminal procedure.
AB 2027 State Highway Route 260: relinquishment.
AB 2270 Medi-Cal: administrative claims.
AB 2289 Health care information.
AB 2313 Health Insurance Portability and Accountability
Act.
AB 2316 Insurance: senior protection.
AB 2324 Ethnic minority health: data reporting.
AB 2327 Nutrition and physical activity curriculum.
AB 2366 Registration fees: additional: pollution
control.
AB 2367 Pupil health: asthma.
AB 2483 Adolescent alcohol and substance abuse care.
AB 2485 Schools: environmental and endangerment
assessments.
AB 2587 Hazardous chemicals.
ACR 39 Alexander Zuckermann Bicycle-Pedestrian Path.
ACR 62 School health.
ACR 70 Children's Fitness and Nutrition Week 2003.
ACR 75 Indoor Air Quality Tools for Schools Program.
ACR 90 Asian and Pacific Islander Mental Health
Awareness Month.
ACR 106 Children's vision.
ACR 146 Women's heart health.
ACR 184 Joint Committee on California's Children.
AJR 12 Head Start program.
AJR 20 War against Iraq.
HR 4
Chavez
AB 113 Indian Gaming Special Distribution Fund.
AB 132 Income taxes: designated contributions.
AB 169 Finance lending.
AB 284 Deferred annuities: nonforfeiture.
AB 552 Public employees' retirement: service credit
election.
AB 553 Local sales and use taxes: concrete: point of
sale.
AB 679 Real estate.
AB 788 Air pollution: consumer products.
AB 943 Mortgage guaranty insurance: contingency
reserve.
AB 967 Personal Income and Corporation Taxes: federal
conformity: Victims of Terrorist Tax Relief Act
of 2001: trusts: Subchapter S.
AB 1074 Boxers: MRI examinations.
AB 1204 California State Lottery.
AB 1274 Motor clubs.
AB 1338 Personal income and bank and corporation taxes:
real estate withholding requirements.
AB 1476 State park system: state reserves.
AB 1495 Parole placement.
AB 1564 Special education: community colleges.
AB 1791 Internet tax.
AB 2069 Real estate.
AB 2129 Insurance: brokers: contracts.
AB 2264 General plan: housing element.
AB 2265 Off-Highway Vehicle Trust Fund.
AB 2290 Local agency fees: state entities: private
service providers.
AB 2350 Safety in employment: conveyances.
AB 2429 Health Care Providers' Bill of Rights.
AB 2647 High School Remediation Funding Flexibility
Program.
AB 2736 Public employees' retirement: military service.
AB 2892 Peer-to-peer file trading software.
AB 2893 Public safety officers.
AB 2916 Milk products: licensing fees.
AB 2929 State employees: salary and benefits.
AB 2988 Maternal and child health: nutrition.
AB 3017 California Children and Families First Act of
1998.
AB 3042 Sentencing.
AB 3043 Alcoholic beverages: on-sale licenses.
AB 3044 Prenatal ultrasounds.
AB 3067 Fire protection: San Diego County.
AB 3068 Fire protection: aerial equipment.
ACR 142 Los Angeles County Deputy Sheriff David W. March
Memorial Interchange.
Chu
AB 94 Property taxation: pension funding.
AB 309 Contracts: foreign languages.
AB 348 Mental health: involuntary confinement:
psychologists.
AB 373 Healthy Families Program.
AB 376 California Mental Health Planning Council:
composition.
AB 455 Packaging materials: regulated metals.
AB 458 Foster care.
AB 570 Garment manufacturers: fees.
AB 573 Public health: traditional Asian medicine and
herbal health products.
AB 579 Dependent children: notice to siblings.
AB 581 Curriculum: labor relations.
AB 585 Income taxes: Elite Tax Enforcement Unit.
AB 713 State Department of Alcohol and Drug Programs.
AB 814 Rape: withdrawal of consent.
AB 898 DNA evidence: Sexual Assault Victims' DNA Bill
of Rights.
AB 1006 The Healthy Schools Act of 2003.
AB 1242 Street removal from public use.
AB 1244 School facilities funding: modernization.
AB 1479 Vehicles: traffic violator schools.
AB 1669 Peace officers: psychological evaluations.
AB 1671 Peace officers: hate incidence training.
AB 1673 Peace officers: hate crimes and hate incidences
training.
AB 1889 Electrical restructuring: Power Exchange.
AB 1959 Health care.
AB 2012 Department of Motor Vehicles: records.
AB 2015 Special education: individualized education
program team.
AB 2018 Community property.
AB 2021 Hazardous waste: toxics.
AB 2022 Sex offenders.
AB 2025 Adulterated cosmetics.
AB 2189 Immigration consultants: corporate surety bonds.
AB 2191 Hate crimes: person committed to mental
hospital: release: testimony of victim.
AB 2203 Taxation: amnesty.
AB 2204 Property tax: state assessees: property
statements.
AB 2283 State community social services telephone number
system.
AB 2285 Medi-Cal: proof of eligibility.
AB 2428 Hate crimes: release conditions.
AB 2752 Corporations: elections.
ACR 71 El Monte Police Officer Donald Ralph Johnston
Memorial Highway.
ACR 101 Asian and Pacific Islander American Heritage
Month.
ACR 194 Sexual Assault Awareness Month.
AJR 64 Bias-motivated crimes.
Cogdill
AB 5 Local government finance: property tax
apportionment.
AB 63 Taxation: irrigation system improvements.
AB 84 Public utilities: common carrier fees: annual
audit.
AB 124 Joint-use projects.
AB 125 Controlled substances: unlawful manufacture and
possession.
AB 166 State-mandated local programs.
AB 189 Sales and use taxes: exemption: veteran's
organizations: meals.
AB 191 Conservation camps: Madera County.
AB 233 Controlled substances: manufacture.
AB 235 School Transportation
AB 321 Health care service plans: contract termination
dates.
AB 325 Shoplifting: booster bags.
AB 482 State parks: concessions.
AB 484 Corporation taxes: minimum franchise tax:
reduction.
AB 492 Wildlife habitat enhancement and management
areas.
AB 501 Solid waste: grants.
AB 565 Personal income and corporation taxes: credits:
clean-burning fireplaces.
AB 582 Vehicle weight limits: local ordinance:
Tuolumne County.
AB 590 Sport fishing: license revenues: Hatcheries
and Fish Planting Facilities.
AB 1083 Life insurance: notification.
AB 1097 County unified school districts: home-to-school
transportation: apportionment.
AB 1208 Conflicts of interest.
AB 1421 Public works: prevailing wage.
AB 1422 Fairgrounds.
AB 1579 Workers' compensation.
AB 1580 Workers' compensation: local inmates.
AB 1581 Workers' compensation: merit credits.
AB 1666 Cigarettes and tobacco products.
AB 1672 Air Pollution: emission reduction credits.
AB 1786 Public officers.
AB 2030 Cigarette and Tobacco Products Tax Law:
hearings.
AB 2031 Search and rescue.
AB 2077 Air pollution: agricultural burning: biomass.
AB 2078 Controlled substances: iodine.
AB 2194 Prevailing rate of per diem wages:
determinations: task force.
AB 2280 Sport fishing: license revenues: Hatcheries and
Fish Planting Facilities.
AB 2281 Office of Rural Health.
AB 2478 Fairs.
AB 2638 Building standards: public information.
AB 2707 State regulatory fees: counties: notification.
ACA 5 Local government finance: property tax revenue
allocation: local agency relief.
ACR 17 Tuolumne County Vietnam Veterans Memorial
Highway.
ACR 134 California Small and Rural Telecommunications
Week.
Cohn
AB 6 Crime.
AB 123 Professional corporations: dentists.
AB 129 Juvenile court: dual status children.
AB 134 Domestic violence.
AB 141 Domestic violence : evidence.
AB 143 Domestic violence: temporary support.
AB 149 Workers' compensation: asbestosis.
AB 162 Mobilehome and Special Occupancy Parks.
AB 171 Public records and meetings: health-related
entities.
AB 175 Health care provider contracts.
AB 193 State Auditor.
AB 217 School facilities: funding.
AB 245 Crimes: professional sporting events.
AB 279 Special license plates: Purple Heart.
AB 383 Criminal procedure.
AB 525 Hearing aid dispensing.
AB 533 State mandates.
AB 549 Crime.
AB 551 Vehicles: illegal devices.
AB 569 Bureau of State Audits.
AB 669 Public contracts: disabled veteran business
enterprises.
AB 1188 Park and open-space districts.
AB 1195 Midpeninsula Regional Open Space District:
annexation project: eminent domain.
AB 1261 Hospitals: ownership restrictions.
AB 1277 Commissions and committees.
AB 1356 Tourism: Office of Tourism.
AB 1512 Arts education.
AB 1528 California Health Care Quality Improvement and
Cost Containment Commission.
AB 1813 Domestic violence: presence of minors:
enhancements.
AB 1821 Developmental services: parental copayment.
AB 1827 Closed sessions: state audits.
AB 1830 Filmed entertainment industry.
AB 1844 Sex offenders: parole.
AB 1850 Property taxation: business records retention.
AB 1874 Telecommunications: Broadband Deployment Act of
2004.
AB 1913 Foster care providers: criminal records:
exemption.
AB 1927 Vision care benefits.
AB 2224 State mandates: reimbursement.
ACR 3 The National Academy of Recording Arts and
Sciences.
ACR 5 California Holocaust Memorial Week.
ACR 6 Domestic Violence Awareness Month.
ACR 11 Health Cares About Domestic Violence Day.
ACR 92 Physical Therapy Month.
ACR 147 California Holocaust Memorial Week.
ACR 148 Domestic Violence Awareness Month.
ACR 149 Health Cares About Domestic Violence Day.
HR 5
Committee on Aging
and Long Term Care
AB 798 Medi-Cal: all-inclusive care for the elderly.
Committee on Aging
and Long-Term Care
AB 3095 Crime.
Committee on
Agriculture
AB 887 Agriculture: grape rootstock.
AB 1069 Eggs.
AB 1071 Commercial feed: inspection tonnage tax.
AB 1080 California Seed Law: violation of federal plant
law.
AB 1085 Agriculture: pest control: curly top virus.
AB 1304 Cooperative bargaining associations:
conciliation.
AB 1724 Pesticides.
AB 1725 Pest control: pesticide invoices.
AB 1726 Agriculture: certified farmers' markets.
AB 3023 Native plants.
AB 3024 Seed law.
AB 3025 Agriculture: "Buy California Program."
AB 3026 Agriculture: marketing of commodities.
AB 3027 Canneries: inspection fund.
AB 3028 Pesticide mill assessment.
AB 3029 Cattle: disease control: tuberculosis.
AB 3030 State Veterinarian employees: continuing
education.
AB 3031 Milk.
AB 3045 Milk: inspection fees.
AB 3046 Milk inspection.
Committee on
Banking and Finance
AB 1772 Identity theft.
AB 1773 Search warrants: identity theft.
AB 1774 Financial institutions.
AB 1775 Money transmitters.
AB 1776 Foreign corporations: production of records.
AB 2014 Credit unions.
AB 3070 Securities.
Committee on Budget
AB 351 State lands: acquisition.
AB 1419 School finance.
AB 1746 Budget Act of 2002.
AB 1747 Public resources.
AB 1748 Public resources: California Clean Water, Clean
Air, Safe Neighborhood Parks, and Coastal
Protection Act of 2002: Water Security, Clean
Drinking Water, Coastal and Beach Protection Act
of 2002.
AB 1749 Booking fees.
AB 1750 Sales taxes on motor vehicle fuels: partial
suspension of transfer.
AB 1751 Transportation finance.
AB 1752 Human services.
AB 1753 Habilitation services.
AB 1754 Education finance.
AB 1755 Redevelopment.
AB 1756 State government.
AB 1757 State agencies.
AB 1758 Corrections.
AB 1759 Court fees.
AB 1760 Victims of crimes.
AB 1761 Budget Act of 2002: contingencies and
emergencies.
AB 1762 Health.
AB 1763 Healthy Families Program: rural demonstration
project funding.
AB 1764 Resources.
AB 1765 2003-04 Budget Act.
AB 1766 Local government finance.
AB 1767 Vehicles: fees: funding.
AB 1768 Local government: vehicle license fees.
AB 2098 Claims against the state: appropriation.
AB 2099 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2100 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2101 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2102 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2103 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2104 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2105 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2106 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2107 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2108 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2109 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2110 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2111 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2112 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2113 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2114 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2115 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2116 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2117 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2118 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2119 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2120 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2121 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2122 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2123 Budget Act of 2004.
AB 2356 Claims against the state: appropriation.
Committee on
Business and
Professions
AB 827 Board membership qualifications: public members.
AB 1570 Public agencies.
AB 1777 Health care practitioners.
AB 2004 Psychiatric technician schools.
AB 2007 Gift certificates.
AB 2008 Vocational nursing schools.
Committee on
Education
AB 300 Education.
AB 2525 Education: planning.
Committee on
Elections,
Redistricting and
Constitutional
Amendments
AB 1677 Absent voter ballots.
AB 1679 Elections: procedures and the Democratic
Presidential Primary.
AB 1681 Elections: absentee voting.
AB 3098 Voting.
AB 3099 Recall elections: vote count.
AB 3100 State elections: measures to be submitted to
the voters.
AB 3101 Political Reform Act of 1974: voluntary
expenditure limits.
AB 3102 Elections: voting systems.
Committee on
Environmental
Safety and Toxic
Materials
AB 1702 Hazardous substances: underground storage
tanks: redevelopment.
AB 1703 Department of Water Resources: water trades:
reporting.
AB 2465 Hazardous Materials: release of hazardous
materials.
AB 2466 California Environmental Protection Agency.
AB 3039 California Coastal Act.
AB 3040 Military base remediation: oversight.
AB 3041 Environmental laboratories.
Committee on
Governmental
Organization
AB 1779 California State Lottery.
AB 1780 Gambling establishments.
AB 1781 Secondhand dealers.
AB 1782 Emergency preparedness: report.
AB 3083 Horse racing.
AB 3084 Indian Gaming Special Distribution Fund.
AB 3085 Alcoholic beverages.
AB 3086 Alcoholic beverages.
AB 3087 State emergency plan.
AB 3088 Emergency response: emergency response team.
AB 3089 Indian Gaming Special Distribution Fund.
AB 3090 First responders.
AB 3091 Horse racing: the Travers Stakes.
AB 3092 Cigarettes.
AB 3093 Tobacco products: licensing.
AB 3096 California State Lottery.
Committee on Health
AB 1738 Retail food facilities: mobile units.
Committee on Higher
Education
AB 843 Public postsecondary education: mandatory
systemwide resident student fee policy.
AB 1778 California State University.
AB 1783 Public postsecondary education:
cross-enrollment.
AB 1997 Postsecondary education: student financial aid:
National Guard.
AB 1999 California State University.
AB 2469 Public postsecondary education.
AB 2615 Public postsecondary cross-enrollment reporting
requirement.
AB 3063 Community college interstate attendance
agreements.
AB 3064 Public postsecondary education: group purchasing
programs.
Committee on
Housing and
Community
Development
AB 1731 Buildings and housing.
AB 1732 Rental housing.
AB 3022 Housing: Mobilehome Park Purchase Fund.
Committee on Human
Services
AB 1716 Local Revenue Fund: allocations.
Committee on
Insurance
AB 1727 Insurance: cancellation: notice.
AB 1728 Insurance actuaries.
Committee on Jobs,
Economic Development
and the Economy
AB 1613 International trade and investment offices:
private donations.
AB 1614 Technology, Trade, and Commerce Agency:
responsibilities.
AB 1615 Harbors: ports: security.
HR 37
Committee on Jobs,
Economic Development
, and the Economy
AB 3057 Economic strategy panel: meetings.
AB 3058 Citizen Complaint Act of 1997: Internet Web
sites.
AB 3059 Commission for Economic Development: advisory
committees.
AB 3060 Economic strategy panel: meetings.
AB 3061 Enterprise Zone Act: reports to the Legislature.
AB 3062 Enterprise zones: job opportunities.
Committee on
Judiciary
AB 1704 Family law: recorded documents.
AB 1705 Trustees: distributions: liability.
AB 1706 Unlawful detainer.
AB 1707 Civil rights: disabled persons: full and equal
access.
AB 1708 State Bar of California.
AB 1709 Trial Court Budget Commission.
AB 1710 Courts.
AB 1711 Attorneys: State Bar Act.
AB 1712 Courts.
AB 1713 Consumer arbitration agreements.
AB 1714 Arbitration: consumer arbitration agreements.
AB 1715 Employment arbitration agreements.
AB 3078 Procedure: civil actions.
AB 3079 Subordinate judicial officers: postretirement
employment.
AB 3080 California State Bar.
AB 3081 Civil discovery.
AB 3082 Maintenance of the codes.
Committee on Labor
and Employment
AB 1719 Employment.
AB 1722 Agricultural Labor Relations Board.
AB 1723 Meals and rest periods, mass layoffs,
relocations, and terminations.
AB 3018 Unemployment insurance: employment programs.
AB 3019 Employment: working days.
AB 3020 Employment.
AB 3021 Payroll reports.
Committee on Local
Government
AB 3077 Local government reorganization.
Committee on
Natural Resources
AB 2514 Natural resources: California Coastal Act of
1976.
Committee on Public
Employees,
Retirement and
Social Security
AB 419 Teachers' Retirement Board: elections.
AB 1584 Public Employees' Retirement System.
AB 1585 County employees' retirement systems.
AB 1586 State teachers' retirement benefits.
AB 1587 Local public employees' retirement: benefits.
AB 2231 Public employees' retirement.
AB 2232 State teachers' retirement: service credit.
AB 2233 State teachers' retirement.
AB 2234 County employees' retirement.
AB 2235 Ralph C. Dills Act: employer-employee relations.
AB 2236 Public Employees' Medical and Hospital Care Act.
AB 3076 State Teachers' Retirement Law.
AB 3094 Retirement systems.
Committee on
Revenue and Taxation
AB 1740 Income taxes: nonresidents.
AB 1741 Taxation: deficiencies, refunds, and interest.
AB 1742 Income and corporation taxes: interest:
abatement: administration: minimum franchise
tax.
AB 1743 Personal income and bank and corporation taxes:
technical code maintenance.
AB 1744 Taxation: administration.
AB 2508 Fred C. Nelles School for Boys.
AB 3069 Public contracts.
AB 3071 Income tax: innocent spouse.
AB 3072 Income taxes: claim of right.
AB 3073 Corporation tax: "S" corporation.
AB 3074 Property taxation: welfare exemption:
facilities in the course of construction.
AB 3075 Property taxation: qualified contaminated
property: limited liability companies.
Committee on
Transportation
AB 1717 Transportation.
AB 1718 Vehicles.
AB 1745 Public contracts: bonds.
AB 3047 Transportation.
AB 3048 Vehicles: removal: value.
AB 3049 Motor vehicles: commercial.
AB 3050 Toll Bridge Seismic Retrofit Account:
investments.
Committee on
Utilities and
Commerce
AB 1457 Telecommunications: High-Cost Fund-A.
AB 1730 Telecommunications: high-cost funds.
AB 1733 Electricity: procurement plans.
AB 1734 Public utilities: energy efficiency budgets.
AB 1735 Public Utilities Commission: ratesetting and
quasi-legislative cases.
Committee on
Veterans Affairs
AB 1591 County veteran service officers: disbursements
to counties.
AB 1592 California Disabled Veteran Business Enterprise
Program.
AB 1593 Veterans: Cal-Vet loans.
AB 1594 Discrimination: veterans.
AB 1698 disabled veterans.
AB 1736 Veterans.
AB 2266 Military and veterans: Cal-Vet Farm and Home
Loan program.
AB 2267 Veteran benefits: preference groups.
AB 2268 Veterans' homes: residents' rights.
AB 2269 Health professions planning and development.
Committee on Water,
Parks and Wildlife
AB 1770 Fish and Game Commission: marine resources.
AB 1771 State government.
Corbett
AB 7 Privacy.
AB 76 Employment discrimination.
AB 83 Bottled water.
AB 88 Contracts: telemarketing.
AB 95 Private actions.
AB 106 Teachers' Retirement System: surviving spouse.
AB 107 Water Security, Clean Drinking Water, Coastal
and Beach Protection Act of 2002.
AB 111 Child abuse: mental suffering.
AB 139 Transportation: needs assessment.
AB 202 Birds: sale.
AB 222 California Reading and Literacy Improvement and
Public Library Construction and Renovation Bond
Act of 2004.
AB 234 Income and corporation taxes: net operating
losses.
AB 651 Career Technical Education Campaign: income and
corporation taxes: manufacturer's investment.
AB 656 Child support collection.
AB 660 Master Plan for Pupil Support Services.
AB 671 Licensing.
AB 682 Mobilehomes: termination.
AB 693 Mobilehome parks: actions.
AB 705 Career technical education.
AB 853 State funds: deposit of interest earned.
AB 913 Manufacturing incentives.
AB 1095 County law libraries.
AB 1207 State teachers' retirement: retirement
incentive.
AB 1573 School construction: design-build.
AB 1598 Seismic safety: insurance: retrofitting.
AB 1789 Taxes: personal property: exemption.
AB 1790 School facilities: seismic safety upgrades.
AB 1885 Employment: biotechnology employment and
development.
AB 1937 Sex offenders.
AB 2230 Life science companies: credits: NOLs.
AB 2326 Prescription drugs: consumer assistance.
AB 2329 Prisoners: local costs.
AB 2332 Sales and use taxes: exemptions: food products.
AB 2337 Fire suppression assessments.
AB 2344 Corporate taxation: credits: career technical
education programs.
AB 2346 Taxpayer contributions: Police Activities
League Fund.
AB 2349 Local government finance.
AB 2351 Mobilehome parks: sales of parks.
AB 2753 State teachers' retirement: early retirement
incentive.
AB 2840 Vehicle rental agreements: electronic
surveillance technology.
AB 2886 Taxpayer contributions: D.A.R.E. Fund.
ACR 57 Irish-American Heritage Month.
ACR 91 California Earthquake Preparedness Month.
ACR 128 Juvenile courts.
Correa
AB 55 County employees' retirement: additional
retirement credit.
AB 69 Public works.
AB 137 Income taxes: designated co
by markaphelps
by fluxit
by freddy2k1
by riccijo
by jmottl
Dear TechRepublic Members,
I caught Lou Dobbs, of CNN, interviewing Marc Andreesen about outsourcing -- Andreesen is all for it and it shocked me nearly out of my seat. I'll try to post the text transcript here, but if it doesn't fit or paste well into the forum, feel free to email me at judy.mottl@cnet.com and I'll send you it.
Judy Mottl
Senior Editor
DOBBS: In a moment, I'll be talking with a California lawmaker who says outsourcing has devastated her constituents in Silicon Valley. But, first, Marc Andreessen is an Internet pioneer. He co- founded a Silicon Valley firm that helps companies outsource work overseas. He's the chairman of the company Opsware. He also, of course, co-founded Netscape.
Marc Andreessen joins us tonight from Mountain View, California.
Marc, good to have you here.
MARC ANDREESSEN, CHAIRMAN & CO-FOUNDER, OPSWARE INC.: Great. Thanks, Lou.
DOBBS: There are very few issues right now that are more difficult for corporate America to deal with than the issue of outsourcing. You support it. You support it vigorously. Why?
ANDREESSEN: Yes.
I think it's purely good for the American company and it's good for American workers. It's part of the natural process of creating new jobs. I think job destruction and job creation go hand in hand. In the last 10 years, this economy has destroyed 325 million jobs and created 342 million new jobs. And, in general, those news jobs are better jobs than the ones that were destroyed.
And I think, in the next 10 years, we're going to destroy another 400 million, create another 430, 450 million new jobs, and those jobs will be better. I think it's blue skies.
DOBBS: Mark, I quite appreciate job destruction, job creation and the net effect. And that argument is advanced considerably. But that argument doesn't really work if the net result is not a higher value job and that has not occurred in this country now for three years, and perhaps more, actually.
That being the case, why should we accept it as a matter of faith that we can destroy lives -- and it is looking as though -- some estimates range as high as three million jobs have been outsourced now to cheap overseas labor markets.
ANDREESSEN: Right.
DOBBS: Why should we take it as an article of faith that that kind of pain results in better jobs, when we're not seeing it demonstrated in any of the data anywhere?
ANDREESSEN: Right. So, first of all, nobody cares more about the pain caused by job destruction than I do.
I grew up in Wisconsin. And, as you know, in Wisconsin, there have just been a huge number of jobs lost over the last 80, 90 years from agriculture. And when I was growing up, that process was continuing. The flip side of that is, new jobs were created and in general people in Wisconsin have a higher standard of living and higher per capita income now.
(CROSSTALK)
DOBBS: I understand that, Marc.
(CROSSTALK)
ANDREESSEN: That exact same thing...
DOBBS: But what I'm asking you for, why should we take it as an article of faith when we have not seen this happen for four -- nearly four years?
ANDREESSEN: Right, because, for four years, we've been in a recession. If you look at the impact of the recession, it's almost entirely responsible for what is going on.
So let me give you a couple other numbers. In the last 15 years, the number of Americans employed by foreign companies has gone up from 2.5 million to 6.5 million. Offset against that is, yes, American companies now employ 10 million people overseas. But do you think we pay overseas people more or less than foreign companies are paying the American workers?
(CROSSTALK)
DOBBS: That's a different issue, Marc.
(CROSSTALK)
DOBBS: I have got to interrupt you, Marc.
ANDREESSEN: OK.
DOBBS: That is not outsourcing. That is not exporting jobs overseas.
ANDREESSEN: Sure, it is.
DOBBS: If I may finish, then I'll
(CROSSTALK)
ANDREESSEN: Cars are now being manufactured in the United States by Japanese car companies like Toyota. They're outsourcing to us all over the place. There's all kinds of jobs. Siemens is manufacturing new jobs to the United States.
(CROSSTALK)
DOBBS: Are they doing that, Marc, to produce products for this market?
ANDREESSEN: Sure, absolutely, they are doing that.
(CROSSTALK)
DOBBS: That's right. And that's the distinction. And that's the distinction here.
The service jobs, the high-value jobs that are being exported to various countries around the world are not being exported so -- for entry to those markets of those countries, but rather for the return of those services and products to this market. That is the distinction in outsourcing, Marc.
(CROSSTALK)
ANDREESSEN: Actually, that's not entirely true.
(CROSSTALK)
DOBBS: Well, no, it's actually -- it's entirely true.
ANDREESSEN: Well, the data doesn't actually show that. So, for example, let's look at it a different way.
DOBBS: What data? I would like to know.
ANDREESSEN: It doesn't make any economic sense.
So, for example, I guess the implication is, we're shipping dollars overseas and those dollars are staying overseas and they're never coming back. We're creating economic growth in the U.S. We're creating economic growth overseas. When we put jobs in India, we're paying Indians in U.S. dollars. Those dollars are being turned around and spent on American goods and services. The new middle class in India that's emerging as a result of the I.P. offshoring...
(CROSSTALK)
DOBBS: Oh, I assure you..
ANDREESSEN: They're buying Levi's jeans. They're buying Nike shoes. They're buying Apple iPods. They're buying Merrill Lynch financial services. We are creating new markets all over the world as a process in doing this.
DOBBS: It's -- that is absolutely true. Markets are being created. Middle-class jobs are being created in India, as you suggest.
ANDREESSEN: Yes.
DOBBS: There is just one problem with that.
ANDREESSEN: And those -- and those people are consuming American products and services.
DOBBS: They are assuming about half what we're buying from them right now.
ANDEREESSEN: Actually that's not true.
DOBBS: Actually it is exactly true. The deficit with India is -- for this instance is precisely twice.
ANDEREESSEN: For manufactured products that's true. Look at services.
Do you think we run a services deficit or surplus?
DOBBS: Marc, you were saying what?
ANDEREESSEN: We run...
DOBBS: Were you not talking about buying products?
ANDEREESSEN: Products and services. We run a deficit on products. The difference in the dollar comes back in investing America. We run a surplus in services. Lou, we run a $75 billion a year services surplus. $75 billion...
DOBBS: Are you talking about globally, Marc.
ANDEREESSEN: Yes, globally.
DOBBS: Oh, absolutely not, Marc. We have $550 billion current account deficit in this country.
ANDEREESSEN: Right, I'm telling you...
DOBBS: That is services that is products in -- I mean, Marc, let's -- let's go back to the issue of outsourcing. If you prefer.
ANDEREESSEN: Well, hold on a second. The president's economic report that just came out in 2002 we ran a $75 billion surplus in services.
DOBBS: In 2002?
ANDEREESSEN: We benefited services trade.
DOBBS: In 2002?
ANDEREESSEN: In 2002.
DOBBS: Do you release...
(CROSSTALK)
DOBBS: Marc, we can sit here and not really edify anyone including ourselves by trading statistics. The fact is it is 2004, the fact is in the most event report on trade we show for the first time negative numbers in the area in which you live, that is technology which is supposed to be bringing us all of these wonderful jobs that so far are not materializing.
ANDEREESSEN: Look, technology took a big hit in the last four years due to recession. When I was involved in creating the first Internet browser in 1993, I can tell how many Internet jobs there were, there were 200. I can tell you how many there are now, there's two million now. We created new jobs in the next 10 years. I'll tell you what, we're going to create a huge number of new jobs in the next 10 years.
DOBBS: I expect you to do so. What I don't expect you to understand is that there is no one listening to us that should take -- has any reason to take as you an article of faith that by moving jobs overseas simply to acquire cheap labor that in any way adds to innovation to this country.
ANDEREESSEN: Absolutely it does. It compounds innovation, allows American companies to invest both overseas and the U.S. It allows American companies to hire more people in the U.S. It allows American companies to sell their products and services into a larger global market. I tell you another thing, it encourages peace and stability worldwide. The best thing that can happen to us from a national security standpoint we determine to develop the middle classes in India and China. And in fact the really best thing we could do is to start offshoring to the Middle East.
If you want to systematicly go after global security and peace, figure out how to bring everybody into this world of increasing returns from economic, increasing returns from trade...
DOBBS: Marc, you surely not suggesting that we create a middle class anywhere in the world at the expense of our own?
ANDEREESSEN: Of course not. It's not at the expense of our own.
DOBBS: That's precisely the effect of what is happening.
ANDEREESSEN: No it's not.
DOBBS: No, sir, it is.
ANDEREESSEN: Trade has been win-win for 200 years.
DOBBS: Win-win. Marc, you are too smart for this. You are absolutely too smart for this. When you hear win-win, what do you think of, a software salesman, right?
ANDEREESSEN: Not at all.
DOBBS: Come on. If it's -- thank you. I also have a sense of humor like you do, Marc. You know what, I don't think we should have too much a sense of humor about what we're doing to hardworking men and women in this country. Please, would you take as an article of faith if you were sitting there driving code that you are going to get to a result or would you want to empiricly be able to demonstrate it?
ANDEREESSEN: Absolutely.
DOBBS: Here are the empirical demonstrations of what we're dealing with right now.
We have a half trillion dollar trade deficit. I'm sorry, go ahead. ANDEREESSEN: Empirical demonstration is over 200 years of standard of living has risen massively. We created 140 million net jobs. They say we created 342 million jobs in the last 10 years alone.
DOBBS: You do understand we have to talk in net terms.
ANDEREESSEN: Per capita income. We're up 17 million net new jobs in the 10 years, including the impact of the recession.
DOBBS: The last 10 years.
ANDEREESSEN: The last 20 years we're up 38 million net jobs. And those jobs per capita income, in that period of time, since World War II to today, per capita income is up. Everybody is better off.
DOBBS: By the way, if you are trying to convince me, our viewers, that it's good to live in America, that really isn't the issue. The fact is how do we preserve and improve on the quality of life for our middle class, for all Americans.
ANDEREESSEN: Economic growth is the key.
Would we agree economic growth is the key?
DOBBS: We -- I would agree absolutely that economic growth is the key.
ANDEREESSEN: We agree job creation is the key?
DOBBS: Absolutely.
ANDEREESSEN: Right, and this is what happens. We create jobs, grow, innovate, exploit new markets, we develop new markets.
DOBBS: But you haven't accounted for the experience of the past four years nor the failure of this economy through two and a half years since the recession ended to generate jobs and that is the critical issue, Marc.
ANDEREESSEN: Let's separate out. No. 1 in IT we had a big recession, right. We had a big bubble. We had a dotcom bubble.
DOBBS: Marc, I got to be honest with you. We have taken far more time than we should have. Come back, we're going to argue some more, do me a favor -- watch that, you know, faith based economics, will you?
hit's dangerous stuff, macro economics as well as it is in technology. You can reciprocate with counsel to me as well, Marc. You get the last word.
ANDEREESSEN: I reciprocate to you with exactly the same counsel, for 200 years the standard of living in this country has risen. and it's going to continue rising for the next hundred, I don't think there's any question about that. DOBBS: I admire your faith and we appreciate your time.
ANDEREESSEN: Thank you.
by erekose mcne
by freddy2k1
by infoaaa19
Look if you are running a company, your job IS to save as much money as possible. It is called capitalism, as Mother Theresa is dead and nobody will give you anything unless you give them a reason to give you something. It is your simpleton and moneyhungry elected officials in Washington and California who gave away the store.Look what happened to the steel industry. Now we are importing oranges thought...US carmakers went to Japan and are unsuccessful not because of the product, but Japanese hava a national identity and pride and they will not buy other then Japanese in most cases. WE MUST DO THE SAME...If you put propositions taking away advantages on the November ballots, boycott companies doing code and products outside, I am talking secondary companies at first, such as BofA, Sprint, Etc...then business would come back,
What these people counting on is that you can not organize this becoause you do not have the will, the money, and like usual you forget by election time. And you know what? If you do, you deserve what you get, I just feel sorry for your family, because the head of the household is too meek to stand up for them
by orpheum
I wasn't trying to make you feel stupid when I commented on that. If you want to call out companies who owe the public zero, make them feel guilty or embarass them, think again.
they owe the ad/marketing gurus their existence. ad mktg gurus are the biggest whores.
So no - I am sorry to burst your ego bubble, but I do not feel stupid, pal. Thanx 4 asking, hope you find someone else to harass tho.
-Orpheum
by freddy2k1
by jrcrutcher
by jrcrutcher
by jrcrutcher
by jrcrutcher
by jrcrutcher
by infoaaa19
by jrcrutcher
by jeff
There is a bright spot to some of this outsourcing. We're gathering great techs on our web site and sending them service calls every day. Some have been laid off but are now building there own businesses. Re-invent yourself and stop complaining. Can not outsource on-site support to India.
BTW, look around your home and if you see anything that says "made in China" you have only yourself to blame for all this.
by k_os98
Your clothes and apparels (Nike, etc) are made by chinese slaves in sweatshops, would you allmighty americans be so kind to work like them?
or you only want the IT well paid jobs?
by jmclain12
I'm coming around to the old union stickers that say "Buy American". I won't be buying ALL American (I'm not sure that's even possible) but I'm making the effort. I've quit going to Wal-Mart, they are SO intent on driving down costs that they drive companies out of business. And I'm trying to buy more from locally owned businesses.
We Americans need to bring more discipline to our purchasing decisions. Let's do with a little less. As a tangent, that includes spending so much on tickets to sporting events that pay such outrageous salaries to athletes. Let's spend more money on local plays for another example.
I am sorry about the ravages that the free market system systems has on specific individuals. However, if we are to start protecting industries or job types, we would need to revert back and protect buggy whip makers and steam engine coal shoveling jobs also.
If a guy in India can do the same work as a guy in America at half the cost, watch out America. The free market system says, stay competitive and cutting edge or get out of the way. Competition is a way of life and every day is a new game. You get no new points for yesterdays efforts. Look ahead and don?t let the door close before you pass through. We do not live in yesterday, last week, or last year. If you want to be a player, then you have to be looking at the future and making sure that your skills are ahead of the curve.
by generalist
Being competitive might result in lots of job losses in the outsourcing industry.
I wouldn't be surprized if there are several groups of out of work IT people who are working on the next killer app when they aren't making ends meet in lesser jobs.
One of these killer apps could be AI based support software that would greatly reduce the need for call centers. If a group of fifty people, working with a high tech product, can do the job of several thousand outsourced people, the economics tilts the other way.
by hal 9000
out this little "GEM"
http://news.com.com/2100-1022_3-5181612.html
Claiming that Offshore outsourcing is actually a very good thing to do as it increases the US's GDP.
Now what was that saying "There are Lies, Bloody Lies and then Statics?"
Col
by generalist
Note that the group that sponsored the research is the same one that promoted the increased H1B quotas not long ago.
I sometimes wonder where the group gets it numbers and how it creates its models. I would love to see their raw data so I could analyze it and determine if their projections are reasonable or if they were designed to promote an agenda aimed at lowering IT costs by increasing competition.
While competition is good, I do worry that the United States may be outsourcing itself into future Third World status. If the IT field doesn't support high wages because of outsourcing, then why should people go into that field, especially if they end up assuming thousands of dollars of debt paying for training or retraining?
by hal 9000
I really can not understand exactly how sending jobs off shore creates jobs.
Maybe it's just my stupidity but to me every job that you send of shore is one less job for a citizen of your country to take. To me the whole article made no sense but as I've already said I'm not that bright when it comes to high finance.
Col
by wordworker
In spite of CNET's outsourcing content creation (gasp quelles horreurs!), it's a great time to be a tech writer and trainer. That's the one thing most companies simply cannot outsource. I'm going to teach interm. and advanced Access to local metro employees next month, and there's NO WAY they could outsource or offshore those services.
I remember when you were an I/T guru who could double your annual salary if you knew how to write HTML, for crying out loud, and those jobs got eliminated by drag-and-drop, WYSIWYG web page builders. Did everybody get freaked out and want to boycott the software companies that made those apps? No. Part of the natural evolution of things, and we accept it. We're going to have to accept that there's no IT magic carpet career ride any more -- unlimited jobs and too few qualified people to fill them. But it's still a pretty decent industry in which to make a living.
The cream will rise to the top and stay employed. The paper-MCSEs, less trained IT wannabes are going to have spend longer incubation periods "paying dues," but ALL of the jobs CANNOT go overseas. It's just impractical.
by infoaaa19
by maecuff
by generalist
There is an economic model that looks at jobs in terms of whether they are primary industry jobs or secondary industry jobs.
Primary industries are those that create something for sale outside the area or that bring money from outside. Farming, mining, manufacturing and things like national call centers fall into this category.
Secondary industries are those needed to support people. Store clerks, fast food workers, local lawyers, car mechanics and even home construction workers fill the jobs created by these industries.
If you want an economically healthy region, you want a variety of primary industies to bring in the cash. With a variety you can weather most recessions.
If the primary industries leave the area, the secondary industries suffer because there isn't enough income from the primary industries to support them.
It would be interesting to create a simulation that models when secondary industries start feeling the impact of primary industry loss. If that starts happening, then the market for the products that save money due to outsourcing will drop and profit margins will decrease.
Outsourcing white-collar jobs to low-wage
countries such as India and China has thrown
some Americans out of work, but a new report
predicts that the trend will ultimately lower
inflation, create jobs and boost productivity in
the United States.
The Information Technology Association of
America, in a survey set for release Tuesday,
acknowledges that the migration of tech jobs to
low-paid foreigners has eliminated 104,000
American jobs so far, nearly 3 percent of the
positions in the U.S. tech industry.
Software engineers have been particularly hard
hit. Researchers at Global Insight Inc., which
prepared the report for the ITAA, predicted that
demand for U.S. software engineers would shrink
through 2008.
But ITAA leaders emphasized that outsourcing has
damaged the job market far less than the dot-com
meltdown of early 2000, when Internet startups,
telecom companies and other companies eliminated
as many as 268,000 positions.
"The myth is that we've started this long
decline into the midnight of the technology work
force," ITAA president Harris Miller said. "This
report shows that, assuming the recovery
continues, the number of IT jobs will actually
increase."
Indian programmers earn roughly one-sixth the
$60,000 U.S. average, and Chinese engineers earn
even less.
Outsourcing dramatically reduces labor costs,
allowing companies to sell goods ranging from
software to tax-preparation services at lower
costs or higher profit margins. Greater profits
theoretically allow companies to buy new
equipment, build laboratories and conduct
scientific experiments
even in expensive Silicon Valley and other U.S.
tech hubs.
Savings from outsourcing allowed companies to
create 90,000 new jobs in 2003, with more than
one in 10 of them in Silicon Valley or elsewhere
in California, researchers said. The report
predicts that in 2008, outsourcing will create
317,000 jobs
34,000 in California.
Companies spent $10 billion last year to
outsource jobs ranging from medical
transcription to nanotechnology research. The
ITAA predicted the companies would spend $31
billion in 2008.
Democratic presidential candidate John Kerry
introduced economic proposals Friday that he
said would reduce the sting for outsourced
workers. More than two dozen states are
considering bans on outsourcing government
contracts.
Such legislation would be "protectionist" and
"unwise," according to the ITAA, whose 500
members include Microsoft Corp., Hewlett-Packard
Corp. and Amazon.com.
But Cynthia Kroll, senior regional economist at
the University of California, Berkeley, said
policy makers can't afford to ignore
outsourcing.
"If R&D is coming out of India, will the next
wave of growth bypass us entirely?" Kroll asked.
"We need to pay attention to what India and
China and these other countries are doing to get
these new rounds of investment."
by hal 9000
More profits for big business and fewer well paid jobs for the citizens right?
Microsoft already are insisting that they offer low cost Software and it is as cheap as it is possible to make, but I've never heard of any of the senior management of Microsoft filling for bankruptcy either have you?
They also incidental insist that they have a lower Total Cost of Ownership than the Linux alternative although these studies are subjective.
Lets face it we are currently exporting technology at an alarming rate to third world countries and we at the same time expect them not to benefit from this but only the Big Business to benefit. If this trend continues we will all see ourselves in a position of needing these off shore countries to supply our High tech needs and what would happen if they banded together and refused to supply whatever?
Right now nothing from the High Tech area is made in the US and while some of it may be developed there all the manufacturing is carried on off shore. We are currently selling our souls for the all mighty Dollar and to hell with the consequences as so far no one is even looking there.
Even now the COW is at war against terrorism that predominately originates from Muslim areas of the world what. Would happen if all the Muslin countries united and refused to allow any supplies to leave their countries for our shores? granted I'm not a US citizen but I can see potential problems that will cripple all of the Western World if this trend isn't reversed.
Col
by dwdino
That is all that outsourcing is.
When Fortune level companies are paying C level personnel X Million dollar salaries, and attempt to save 500 thousand dollars in IT salaries...
Lets really do some math:
1 CEO = 7 Mill
1 CFO = 5 Mill
1 CIO = 500 K
-----------------
C = 12.5 Mill
Scenario 1
--------------------------------------
35 Programmers = 2.275 Mill (65K)
-20 Programmers = 1.3 Mill (Released)
--------------------------------------
Initial total = 975 K
20 Cost of severance = 100 K
--------------------------------------
Second Total = 1.075 M
20 Outsourced Programmers = 100 K
Outsource Mgmt Overhead = 100 K
--------------------------------------
Third Total = 1.275 M
--------------------------------------
Final Savings = 1 Million Dollars
20 American families without income and desperate.
Scenario 2
--------------------------------------
C level employees = 12.5 M
----------------
Adjusted Salary
---CEO = 500 K
---CFO = 350 K
---CIO = 275 K
----------------
Total Adjusted Salary = 1.125 M
--------------------------------------
Total Savings = 11.375 M
20 American families with sustain income and peace of mind.
You choose.
by generalist
Note that those twenty families, when cut off from high end wages, will be spending less and may require additional social services.
The reduction in spending will result in fewer houses sold, which in turn results in unemployment in the home construction area. Stores that sell non-essentials like new furniture and electronics will have fewer customers. New car dealers will have fewer people buying cars because the families need to keep the existing vehicles going longer.
Competition for low end jobs increase when unemployment benefits run out and the highly paid workers have to accept whatever job is available.
And if you are dealing with programmers who tend to have more computers than most, software sales will drop, decreasing the profits made by software companies.
This is the negative side of the trickle down theory of economics. But unlike the better known side, this one can easily tracked.
by dc_guy
The ITAA article posted above is worth reading. Of course there's some bias in it but we're all skilled at reading between the lines. Nothing you read is totally impartial.
The offshore outsourcing phenomenon has indeed been exaggerated. The IT industry is being hit particularly hard at the moment -- "your turn," the steelworkers might say -- but the total rate of American jobs being lost to offshore displacement is not accelerating dangerously.
Let's face it, America's forte is creativity. Once an industry gets to the point where it's just a matter of predictable, incremental improvements and jobs that a bright high school graduate could do well, it doesn't fit in our economy any more.
Fifty years ago, America spent a fortune giving virtually every child a high school diploma. A lot of them ended up pushing buttons on an assembly line. That was not a sensible deployment of those resources and the increasingly automated manufacturing jobs migrated to Japan, where education cost less. As Japan's economy improved and the cost of educating its workforce rose, they moved to Korea, Taiwan, Indonesia, and eventually to China.
These days, practically every American intends for their children to get university degrees. We're diverting a huge chunk of our GDP into getting them those degrees. The economy will implode if they don't end up with jobs that generate a good return on that investment. Staffing call centers and building software with coding languages that kids learn in the ninth grade are not that type of job.
Labor unions kept wages artificially high in the manufacturing sector for many years, but as the actual value of that work steadily diminished, all they accomplished in the long run was to fuel the inflationary spiral that only recently stalled. This encouraged other countries to build their own auto factories and steel plants to compete with us in the world market.
Huge nations like China and India have begun building their own high-quality university networks. As the cost of producing an educated worker rises in those nations they will have the same experience we did, losing their manufacturing sector to... who knows, perhaps Tajikistan, Zaire, and Paraguay. But they will become even more competitive with us than they are now for "knowledge worker" jobs.
Software may become the automobiles of the 2010s -- the value of the product could fall too low for all these Americans with their $120,000 university educations to produce economically. (That's total cost, not just what their parents pay.)
What our economy needs right now is huge investments in research, so the next big, new industry requiring lots of creative talent for its launch will start hiring. Instead, (with a few notable exceptions like the empires of Warren Buffett and George Soros) our leading corporations have become scavenging engines, subsisting by killing each other off and consuming the carcasses. As someone recently said, the only place that most American corporations show any creativity anymore is in their accounting.
If you want to be frightened out of your mind by a trend that's threatening to destroy our economy and turn us into a third world country, it's not offshore outsourcing. It's the death of creativity in the American corporation.
by dwdino
Now, I don't all the x's and y's of the steel industry, but if my memory serves, there was one monumental difference here:
When the "3rd world" countries began there steel industries, they used cheap labor as a primary means of undercutting a bloated American industry. This was pure competition. As the prices were lower than Americans were willing to go, the bids for new purchases went to over seas.
Now in the IT sector, the difference is not so much being out-bid, as being replaced. Joe is fired on Monday, outsource personnel is hired on Friday. We are being gutted from the inside out.
I have no problems with healthy competition. I do have problems when selfish desire slitting one throat to rob another.
I think one way to handle this, is to produce a bill that states that if job Y is cut and is replaced by job X overseas. Job X must be paid and maintained at the same expense as job Y. Therefore, if overseas is more effecient, you can get your reward; if not, no advantage.
by infoaaa19
If I were studying this situation through a magnifying glass in a lab I would definitely agree with you. Problem 1.) Education thanks to several factors are the pitts unless you make sure your kids are in the RIGHT school. I know one 15 year old in High School who can not read, nothing wrong with the mind, I know one 11 year old who can not do basic multiplications, has not learned geography, history, or any of that, Thank you California Teacher's Union, and this group is competed against by illegal immigration. IE secondary service jobs
2) Jobs going offshore are jobs that these people can do. I am not just talking programmers. I am talking tech support, basic banking, collections,etc and the tax code looks at these jobs as if ihey were local. The welfare and unemployment money is coming from the local taxes without any regard to expenditures we are facing. Both the Feds and our illustrious California Assembly and Senate sold out to special interests, and should be dissmissed in November.We have the only Coin Operated Goverment in the US. That is why we in California are the proud owners of a 14 billion dollar bond, to pay off the idiocies of our wise elected officials, who no doubt came out of the same school systems they are ignoring now.
by dc_guy
Yes. Despite my temporary screen ID I am a Californian. Our proud tradition of being the test bed for every zany idea from the left (smog devices) the right (Prop. 13) and the asylum (wood shake roofs in high-risk fire areas) is about to do what no earthquake has ever done: destroy the state.
Our workers' compensation laws are the most draconian in the country; they are reported to be the reason that businesses don't want to locate in the state in more than 50% of the cases. And how many of us don't know at least one person who has abused them?
Our schools are a mess but the rest of the nation is not so far behind in that arena. Across the U.S., the average university graduate reads at what used to be called the sixth-grade level -- and only if it's something they really want to read. Otherwise it's fifth-grade. Every wonder why people who complain about TV news continue to watch it? It's too hard for them to read a newspaper.
This is the same population who gripes that they deserve a salary fifty times that of their counterparts in China. Ninety percent of whom can read at the eighth-grade level -- in CHINESE!
by infoaaa19
by jmottl
Hi TR members,
I caught this in my news cycles and thought you'd be interested in how Lou Dobbs is trying to stop the outsourcing trend...
Judy Mottl, Senior Editor
The Associated Press
Updated: 12:57 p.m. ET April 09, 2004LOS ANGELES - Lou Dobbs is a newsman on a mission. Or, as detractors would have it, he?s a ?raving? trade protectionist, a ratings hound, or possibly suffering ?some sort of intellectual midlife crisis.?
advertisement
Every weeknight for more than a year ?Lou Dobbs Tonight? on CNN has insistently covered ? and condemned ? sending American jobs to other countries, aka outsourcing or offshoring.
At 24-hour cable news networks, both time and opinion are in abundant supply. But exhaustive reporting on a single issue is unusual, as is Dobbs? strong blend of journalism and advocacy.
Unapologetic, Dobbs says he?s driving a story of critical importance with ?Exporting America,? the program?s catchy tag for its series of reports.
?I think if this trend continues, is allowed to continue, that the United States, without being unduly alarmist, is headed toward if not a third-world category than a second-world category as a nation,? Dobbs said in a recent interview.
Without tarring all corporate executives, Dobbs said, ?There are some who simply look at this (U.S. economy) as a convenient piggy bank to loot, and the worker be damned.?
His show?s approach includes detailed coverage of stories such as IBM?s December announcement that it was shifting thousands of skilled software jobs overseas.
Calling out offending companies
There are interviews with an array of lawmakers, labor leaders and others, including Democratic presidential contender John Kerry; Richard Trumka, secretary-treasurer of the AFL-CIO; and David McCurdy, president of the Electronic Industries Alliance.
And, every night, there?s an updated list of companies that have shipped jobs abroad ? a kind of rogue?s gallery that viewers are invited to help keep current.
(CNN?s parent company, Time Warner Inc., was among the first to be included on the list, Dobbs says.)
Taken together, the segments add up to least several minutes and as much as 10 minutes nightly, a lifetime in television. By comparison, network evening newscast stories average slightly more than two minutes, said Andrew Tyndall, whose Tyndall Report monitors news content.
The tone of Dobbs? reports and questioning is pointed. As his show?s introduction puts it, ?Lou Dobbs Tonight? is an hour of ?news, debate and opinion.?
?Senator, do you find yourself being called, because of your views on this (issue), ?xenophobic,? ?protectionist,? because you have the audacity to suggest that the United States, the most powerful economy and nation on earth, should have a manufacturing base?? Dobbs queried Sen. Byron Dorgan, D-N.Dakota, last month.
Dorgan later termed the loss of American jobs ?very alarming,? drawing this response from Dobbs:
?And also, to me, as alarming is the fact, the United States Congress, this administration, has taken no step to reverse the course that we are embarked upon.?
Giving voice to an issue
As debate about the issue of offshoring has grown and become an increasing part of the presidential election year dialogue, so has attention to Dobbs? crusade.
?I?m thrilled he?s giving this sort of attention to it,? said Robert Bruno, an associate professor of labor and industrial relations at the University of Illinois and a critic of outsourcing.
The role of politics could be more thoroughly covered, Bruno suggested, but he called Dobbs? work overall ?extremely important and helpful.?
?There is a person that is asking the right questions to the right people. ... This man is Lou Dobbs. He is the greatest voice for the American worker,? trumpets the Web site of the American Workers Coalition, identified as a small grass-roots group.
Other observers shake their heads over what they see as a baffling transformation.
One newspaper opinion piece made him the poster child for ?biz pundits who hate business,? lamenting what it deemed as his shift from free-market advocate to ?raving? protectionist and mulling the possibility of a midlife crisis.
James K. Glassman, a resident fellow at the conservative American Enterprise Institute, has dueled on air with Dobbs over offshoring. Glassman said he found the TV host combative in his questioning ? and wrong in his analysis.
?What Lou Dobbs has been doing night after night is bad economics,? Glassman said. ?His very selective list of evildoers are among America?s most innovative and dynamic companies that have contributed millions and millions of jobs to the U.S. economy.
Just part of the ?ratings game??
?It?s foolish and typical of what he?s doing, taking a narrow and myopic view of this issue,? he said, adding that Dobbs has moved from a pro-business stance to ?table-thumping? protectionism.
Glassman devotes part of his Web site to countering Dobbs on the issue.
The TV journalist shrugs off the brickbats, including implications he may be more interested in audience share than fiscal policy.
?A drive to raise ratings that ignores Scott Peterson, Kobe Bryant and Michael Jackson and focuses on trade and outsourcing would probably leave most programmers laughing hysterically,? Dobbs said.
CNN?s competition with Fox News Channel isn?t a factor, he said. Fox has surged ahead with its contingent of sharp-tongued hosts but Dobbs firmly denies any marching orders to ramp up the conflict.
Dobbs? numbers are increasing, however. The program is averaging 523,000 viewers, up 7 percent compared to last year.
Characterizations of his economic stance are way off base, asserts Dobbs, who describes himself as a lifelong Republican who remains moderate in his views.
?I think every American should be offended by anyone ... who would suggest there are only two choices in trade policy, protectionism or free trade,? Dobbs said. ?There are a host of choices between those polar extremes. The policy I favor is balanced trade, which is the policy pursued by all of our principal trading partners.?
His passion over the issue was stoked by the refusal of several chief executive officers to acknowledge ?there was any negative impact? from offshoring jobs, he said.
Whether his message is getting through to business owners or under their skin, Dobbs maintains that viewers are hearing it ? and appreciate it.
?People are literally saying, ?Thank you for talking about an issue that we feel is important,?? Dobbs said. ?Our viewers fully understand this transcends party lines and partisan politics. There is an absolute national value in truth on these issues, and we can?t ignore them.?
? 2004 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
by scott.917
by scott.917
Working from home comes with a whole bunch of its own issues.
Even though it is something that would save a company a ton of money, it is not the right kind of money. Employees are a direct expense, contractors, land, supplies, etc, are capital expenses, which can be depreciated and written off in a whole different way.
Until the repulsive term "human capital" applies to direct employees as capital, rather than expense, we'll continue to see businesses cut direct employees FIRST, and then look to other cost-cutting measures.
I am also concerned about Americans loosing their jobs, but since I have worked with Indian Software companies, I can't help seeing how many American products they buy.
America has through WTO forced India to reduce their trade barriers from 300% down to almost nothing in the last 15 years, America has forced India to accept Western patent and copyright laws (and they are now mostly followed, in fact better than in some South European Countries). American PC's, Software or Laptops are now imported without any duties and the average duties is down to about the same level as in Europe or America.
On the other hand it is worth remembering that European and American countries are using huge subsidiaries to protect themselves from competition from third world countries. When it comes to food, Western products are becoming cheaper than India products, though the labor costs are a fraction and it is only due to Western subsidiaries that they can become cheaper. I think it is very realistic to assume that the number of farm workers and food industry workers in India loosing their jobs due to such subsidiaries are many, many times higher than the number of people in America who are affected by the current outsourcing trend.
The salary increases for IT people in India is in the range of 30% per year, the dollar is falling against the rupee and I don't think the number of years it will take for India to be as expensive as Western Countries is far away.
I think a healthier perspective is to look at it from what we can do to create more jobs in America while giving credit to India for its success. Good for India that it can move away from being a very poor country to a probably better place to live,
The same thing which is happening with software services have happened to a lot of other industries before, Japan, South Korea, Singapore Hong Kong, China, has taken a lot of jobs from the West, but we have managed to create new jobs.
America has always been a leading country when it comes to Inventions and to find out new ways to do things. The answer to the current scenario is not protectionism but inventions. Indians are copying things which we have done for long; they are not inventing anything new. Indian companies are with very few exceptions not creating software products, but only selling services. And in many cases we are talking about services which many of us don't really like to do (Call center attrition rates are very high).
I believe in free trade, sure when India or other countries have an advantage it will hurt us. But instead of responding negatively to this, it is time to put our act in order and create new jobs in America where we can win because of being better and more innovative and not cheaper. We can create more wealth for everyone in America and India that way!
by webmaster
Well... As an IT worker, I definately have a problem with the outsourcing issue. What I think... Is that if the IT workers have a problem with outsourcing, the IT world is more than capable of uniting and speaking as a WHOLE. No-one is going to listen to 1 individual whine and complain about losing their job. They are not going to listen to 50 people complain. But if they unite and start speaking with some force, then you will be listened to.
I'm a web designer/programmer, if other IT workers would like to unite to create 1 unified website that can help the IT force come together and start some actions, then great, I will even donate some time. If your not willing to do anything about a problem, why complain. Its just like complaining about who got into office if you didn't vote.
There are many smart IT programmers in this country. Stop complaining; do something.
by kevinaaa21
by mparker_uk
Yes outsourcing will mean some people losing jobs.
But it means there is more time for value-add roles designing solutions instead of supporting them.
We need to embrace outsourcing - run of the mill (body shop) type roles will dissapear in the West to be replaced with business-aligned IT roles.
Despite initial fears, my experience has been positive. We have now offshored boring repetative work and now concentrate on engineering high quality solutions. I have gained management and business skills I would have struggled to gain pre-outsourcing.
Its happening so my advice is position yourself to gain most benefit.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending