Discussion Locked

The Data are Clear - - We MUST act NOW

0 helpful
390 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

390 replies

by deadly ernest

I am trained in, among other things, Occupational Health and Safety, safe driving and ergonomics. Two years ago when I went to buy a new car I looked at everything available here in Australia - it is represntative of all the world markets thanks to global economy. I found that not one of the sedans below the luxury car level were suitable for use based on safe driving techniques, ergonomics or OH&S. I was left with looking at high end luxury cars, twice what I could afford, light commercial trucks, people movers (Tarago vans etc) or SUVs. I chose a small SUV - Nissan X-trail with a 2.5 litre 4 cyl motor.

The problem with the sedans was that the manufacturers think everyone wants or needs a treet racing car, like in 2Fast - 2 Furious, and they were all low ground clearance. When sitting in the drivers seat and my feet were flat on the ground, like when getting out, my knees were 100 mm (4 inches) or more higher than my thighs. This puts excessive strain on the back when rising or sitting. When I set the seat so as to sit upright my head was jammed against the roof - I am only 5 foot 9 inches tall. The sales people said I was supposed to set the seat in a particular way. They had the seat almost as if they were lying down, pity the poor bugger behind them if their feet reached the floor, and had their arms straight out at full stretch to the steering wheel - no real control of the vehicle in an emergency. No wonder there are so many accidents drivers can not control the cars due to poor seat positions.

The small SUVs were the only vehicles that were comfortable, economic to run (some more so than many sedans), and the seat was at almost the same height as my arse - making it easy to get in and out. I do not need seating for seven or more people or a van.

I agree re your greener comment, and have found that if you are careful and choose to spend a little more to buy things that are more environmentally friendly they save you more in the long run. The most obvious is paying for better insulation and thermal design on housing saves a fortune in heating and cooling costs.

by jdclyde

most of your post has nothing to do with the alledged man-influinced global warming. Toxic chemicals have nothing to do with global warming, and everything to do with poisoning people.

deciding what levels are acceptable and of what is also hard. Remember a bit ago the very decetful and dishonest ads that claimed Republicans were putting arsnic in your water? that is exactly the kind of crap that blows all credibility for when there actually is an issue.

by maxwell edison

...that those of us who are extremely skeptical of the man-caused global warming myth automaticaly assume that we also are in favor of pollution and/or doing nothing about pollution?

One has nothing to do with the other.

by deepsand

I've only now regained use of my machine.

Seriously, though, I've been up to my ass in alligators since last June or July, and only now have had any 'spare' time.

I see that little has changed in the mean.

For example, I've asked one simple question of Maxwell, and am still waiting for an answer.

Thanks for the welcome home.

Enjoy.

by deepsand

Thanks for noticing.

I see that Maxwell is still pushing his "I can do whatever I want, 'cause you can't stop me" platform.

I've not yet had time to read all the posts here, so perhaps you can answer this.

If we were to adopt his idea, i.e. alter the use of contruction matters, etal., just where does he think that the Sun's radiant energy that would otherwise have illuminated those now non-exist materials will end up?

Will it magically do a U-turn and quantum tunnel through the atmosphere so as to re-appear somewhere in the vaccumn of space? Or, will the Laws of Conservation be somehow vanquished?

And, what's up with your new avatar?

by Member 25348569

I'd had the same one for quite a few months and the Demon Butcher of Royston Vasey had served me well but I needed a change so I started a thread a week or two ago asking for suggestions. The For Sale board is a temporary avatar in case someone comes into the thread and offers me money for advertising.

As for Maxwell's thread-starter post, he assures me (in no uncertain terms) that it was sarcasm or satire or some other parody.

by maxwell edison

However, in all fairness, this forum does attract all levels of people, both domestically and internationally. And at the risk of sounding aloof, I think I often write over people's heads, way over, in some cases. I guess I shouldn't blame them or be surprised if they don't understand. And after all, you might be some poor and recent product of America's "finer" public school system, and only have the comprehension and retention ability of a 9 year old.

Many of my messages might be appropriate for the National Review, but you must still be partial to Mad, or just mad, I'm not sure which.

And in some cases, I refuse to lower myself to the comprehension level of my audience. This is one such case. If you don't understand, too bad. I might suggest, however, a course on reading comprehension, combined with the ability to think and apply.

Whoa! I just looked at your profile. "USNA (Annapolis), Class of '68" No friggin' way. I don't believe it. There's no way that fine institution of higher learning would produce the kind of person who lacks the comprehension and reasoning skills like you just proved. No way. I refuse to believe it.

by tonythetiger

Since we know that volcanic ash creates a cooling effect, we could just try to make more volcanic eruptions!

by jdclyde

the people talking about the myth of man-caused global warming start going into aspects of polution that have nothing to do with the global warming as if THEY don't even know the difference (because they don't seem to!)

"mommy, can I have some arsnic in my water?"

The hardest thing is to tell if someone is intentionally lying or if they are just uninformed and are just mindlessly propogating the lies. In most cases I give them the benifit of the doubt and assume that they aren't lying, just wrong.

And remember, according to the "experts", we ran out of oil six years ago......

Wish I could be an expert on things that never have happened, like all the environment scares. I could be raking in the coin big time.

I wonder, the scientist that told us about all this (that was silenced by the government WHILE he was telling us this), what do you bet he got in on Clintons shift and is a registered Dem and is doing this of (gasp) political reasons? :0

by jdclyde

if we look at our history over the last 20 years, which opressors is it that has opened fire on unarmed citizens of the United States of America?

And no, I am not talking about police corruption in LA that started the riots. The federal government is not responsible for that.

While I won't tell you who it WAS, I will tell you it WASN'T Republicans. You can draw your own conclusions from there....... B-)

by x-marcap

So far,It has been the liberals, in fact not even Republican liberals, but the Democratic liberals who use the force of the government to kill people who aren't willing to roll over and cooperate. See Ruby Ridge,Waco, etc... The issue is, if you have a 12 guage and more than 100 shells you are considered a potential terrorist... 100 rounds isn't enough for a skeet shoot if you get beyond the first round...

The poeople who use governmental force to kill are the liberals. I am not a Republican. I am a constitutional Libertarian. If it isn't in the constitution, get rid of it... No more NEA, no more DOEd, HUD,etc.

The point is I don't like the tax and spend policies, of Congress. We constantly put money in lazy peoples hands and shamefully do not provide the Military with the best stuff we can. That is crap forced on us by the socialists. If a person can, but refuses to work, let them go hungry... Laziness shouldn't be subsidized. We should give out lower ranks of the military large raises. Everybody O4 and below should feel like Santa Just visited.

I am a capitalist, and a libertarian. If you need help, ask me. I may give you what you need, or find a way for you to work for what you need. The second is unacceptable to the lazy libs... I work hard and if someone wants something from me, they should ask. I am generous, and may be willing to part from what I have worked for. If I think you should work for something I am not evil, and I am not really a Republican, but I am far more conservative than any Republican.

Means testing for SS is a must, also for Medicare benefits. I hate to add to the buraucracy. I would rather that the people who can afford it buy their own insurance, and not even accept coverage. I hope to do that. I could easily do it if it weren't for this heavy load of taxes I pay... Dang, they get 1.2% on my money. I ususally get 15-20% on good years and haven't yet lost money, but these $^&% taxes eat into my seed money even...

Why don't the Democrats hang on to the 7.5% of my money sent in by my employer and let me work with the other 7.5%? Control. 7.5 % of 50,000 is ~3500.
take 3000 at 10% compounded across the 20 years left in my life, dang I WOULD JUST become a REPUBLICAN WITH THAT MUCH MONEY...

by maxwell edison

The very day after I posted my message showing how it's (global warming) their religion, this story comes out:

http://www.insidebayarea.com/argus/localnews/ci_3683394

The prophet Al Gore is calling for a moral cursade! Thank you, Al Gore, for proving my point, you wack-job.

Neil, (sarcasm) you're in great company, here. (end sarcasm)

And what have I been saying. That's IT'S THE SUN!

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/sci/tech/56456.stm

Neil, these man-caused global warming people are nut-jobs. They are real nut-jobs. Do you REALLY want to be one of them?

by faradhi

and I certainly do not have a stance on global warming.

However, religion is not the source of all morality, and all morality is not necessarily religious.

So just because someone states an moral obligation to something does not mean that position (whatever it may be) is becoming a religion.

by Member 25348569

I'm not going to comment on Gore as I know very little about him other than from the rubbishing of the guy by most on TR. But for the BBC stuff, nice to see you've found something bang up to date!

Friday, February 13, 1998 Published at 19:25 GMT

You're getting a little desperate, a little strident in your opposition. You accuse me of proselytizing but if anyones trying to convert people, it's you!

Nut-job? Me? I'm not the one scratching around in the dusty depths of the BBC's archives to try and prove my point!

by maxwell edison

Just because the article was published 6 years ago, a mere blink of an eye in cosmic terms, it doesn't mean it's invalid. In fact, it supports one of my claims that the media has ALSO run away with propagating the global warming myth. So your observation is actually making MY point, not yours.

How about 2003?

"This trend (from the sun) is important because, if sustained over many decades, it could cause significant climate change," Willson said.

http://www.space.com/scienceastronomy/sun_output_030320.html

Or 2004?

"According to a study by German and Swiss scientists, greenhouse gases can't take all the blame for global warming: The sun is contributing, too. Research results show that the sun, which began brightening 100-150 years ago, may be the strongest it has been in 1,000 years....The sun has been at its strongest over the past 60 years and may now be affecting global temperatures"

http://www.findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m1076/is_8_46/ai_n6260801

Or 2005?

"The sun may have minimally contributed about 10 to 30 percent of the 1980-2002 global surface warming," the researchers said in a statement Friday....Many questions remain, however. For example, scientists do not have a good grasp of how much Earth absorbs or reflects sunlight....We don't know what the sun will do in the future," Scafetta says. "For now, if our analysis is correct, I think it is important to correct the climate models so that they include reliable sensitivity to solar activity. Once that is done, then it will be possible to better understand what has happened during the past hundred years."

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/9544093

What does this mean? It possibly means that the BBC decided to quit running such articles after 1998.

BOTTOM LINE: THEY DO NOT KNOW.

I'm still waiting, by the way, for you to reply back to a message like you said you would. It seems that when I post something that totally discredits you and your position, you either have to think about it or get back to me; yet you always seem to overlook actually doing that.

And for the record, Neil. I didn't go looking for either one of those articles. I regularly visit The Drudge Report, I visited today, and there they were. The links are probably still there, if you care to look.

You are basing your entire LIFE on an unknown conclusion and an unproven theory.

You are discredited, Neil, and are grasping at straws to either find something intelligent to say or looking for a way to get out of saying it. So far, the same nonsense comes from you.

by maxwell edison

Climate changes such as global warming may be due to changes in the sun rather than to the release of greenhouse gases on Earth.

Climatologists and astronomers speaking at the American Association for the Advancement of Science meeting in Philadelphia say the present warming may be unusual - but a mini ice age could soon follow.

The sun provides all the energy that drives our climate, but it is not the constant star it might seem.

Careful studies over the last 20 years show that its overall brightness and energy output increases slightly as sunspot activity rises to the peak of its 11-year cycle.

And individual cycles can be more or less active.

The sun is currently at its most active for 300 years.

That, say scientists in Philadelphia, could be a more significant cause of global warming than the emissions of greenhouse gases that are most often blamed.

The researchers point out that much of the half-a-degree rise in global temperature over the last 120 years occurred before 1940 - earlier than the biggest rise in greenhouse gas emissions.

Using ancient tree rings, they show that 17 out of 19 warm spells in the last 10,000 years coincided with peaks in solar activity.

They have also studied other sun-like stars and found that they spend significant periods without sunspots at all, so perhaps cool spells should be feared more than global warming.

The scientists do not pretend they can explain everything, nor do they say that attempts to reduce greenhouse gas emissions should be abandoned. But they do feel that understanding of our nearest star must be increased if the climate is to be understood.

------------

Okay, the idiot part was my headline.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/sci/tech/56456.stm

by deepsand

These findings, which are far from new, do [b]not[/b]negate those findings which find a positive correlation between ocean temperatures and man made exothermic reactions and the by-products thereof.

Nice try, but it is'nt enough to counter the rapidly growing body of evidence that we may soon be hoist on our own petard.

by jdclyde

[i]"I don't like the tax and spend policies"[/i]

Grow up, pay attention to politics and buy a clue.

It is Spend and THEN tax to cover what you spent.

:D

What could you have been thinking? ;\ :p

by faradhi

I understand you to disagree global warming because who is presenting the data. Because more liberal leaning groups use it as their platform. Many of these people blindly follow these groups, like many blindly follow a religion.

I posted mainly to aggravate. It was not intended to be taken any more seriously than you intended your posts.

Although, it is true that I do not like gore and do not take a stand either way. I think it is possible but there is a lack any sufficient evidence to sway me one way or another.

by tonythetiger

as I do not relish the thought of pedaling 160 pounds of dead batteries for any real distance. The pedals are just so it can be legally classified as a bicycle. I had no intention of actually [b]USING[/b] them :)

by deepsand

By pretending to take various positions, only to later take contrary ones, you've brought this criticism on yourself.

Which Maxwell are we to belief to be the real one?

The one who defends SUVs, or at least pretends to do so, or the one who claims to be so environmentally friendly?

by deepsand

Quite frankly, my dear, I do'nt give a damn what you believe.

And, if you believe that this audience is beneath your station, then you may wish to consider finding another.

Otherwise, given your purported intellect, you should be able to deduce the kind of responses that you can expect.

by maxwell edison

...is your apparent inability to comprehend a simple message. It would, however, take the slightest amount of thought. So perhaps you deserve a free pass.

by dr dij

they like to sit around and debate problems forever without doing anything. And supress reports that indicate problems could be serious.

Basically, either you tune in only those 'facts' to support your views (coming from those who pull facts out of their A** like LImbaugh or unsubstantiated statements made by others)

or you don't know enuf about the issues to realize they ARE real and there is plenty of evidence to act. If you don't know enuf about the issues it is likely because you have a predefined conclusion and don't want to hear anything that could change your mind.

You mention eco-fanatics, your views seem to have the same irrational basis in deciding what you want to believe then ignoring all evidence to the contrary. (and admittedly they also take the opposite extreme, thinking EVERY small issue is a global disaster)

by oz_media

Please notify your president of this incredible fact finding mission you have undertaken.

When your done, post some of the FACTS that prove Jesus Christ existed and that we are derived from the hand of God. Then we can clear that up once and for all too.

Before you get too tired, perhaps jusy one more, a lot of people claim that UFO's and Aliens are real, can oyu post some of thos eacts just wo we can clear up that question too?

Get the point yet?

just because you found one 'scientific theory' that debunks our current global warming theory, it doesn't mean that theory is correct and others are incorrect.

What ISN'T contestible in any way whatsoever, is that those same pollutants people WONDER about effecting the atmosphere are without a doubt killing real people in real life on this real planet.

But if cement is the answer to the supposed global warming, why bother about cleaning up air air or emissions? We don't have to worry about our own health do we? That's why we are allowed to smoke in any building we enter, it doesn't harm people does it?

Oh and whil eyou are going to great lengths to constantly debunk th ecredibility and ability of the UN to do ANYTHING, GWB sucks c**k! Have a good weekend. ;)

by deepsand

Why, the little tart. And, to think that I believed him when he said that mine was the only d**k for him.

by deepsand

Despite your purported superior intellect, you still have some problems in said area.

by absolutely

maxwell edison: "I support most proposals for public transportation, but I wonder about the principle of allowing the transit workers to walk off the job and strike. Not only are they public employees providing a public service paid for by the public, but their actions cause more congestion and more pollution."

Quite right! Once a public transit system is established, it attracts "daily users" who will still commute to work during a strike. So, when transit workers do strike, the amount of passenger vehicle traffic on the road does not rise to levels before public transit, but higher, to the levels caused by the existence of public transit, which invites commuting by people who cannot otherwise afford to commute.

maxwell edison: "They should be prohibited from shutting down the system, and be fired if they do."

Everybody who strikes should be [b]subject[/b] to dismissal. The right to property ownership means the right to hire all workers individually and on "at will" basis, period.

by deadly ernest

In the 1970's and 1980's I lived in a city that had a mix of government owned and privately owned public transport systems. The unions at that time were very militant and hardly a week went by without some union calling a strike.

What was interesting is when the tranport workers union called a strike the entire government owned transport system stopped running, yet the privately owned services continued to operate. It was intriguing in a way as the government owned service staff were employed under the governement staff conditions of service with higher pay and piles of perks that the privately owned staff did not get.

by absolutely

maxwell edison: "And Absolutely, another atheist, who was also emotionally scarred with religion as a child, is also singing in the global warming choir."

I do not assert that my atheism or my childhood experience with the Catholic Church has any effect on global temperature nor on the composition of the atmosphere. Do you?

by maxwell edison

You said, "I do not assert that my atheism or my childhood experience with the Catholic Church has any effect on global temperature nor on the composition of the atmosphere. Do you?"

Of course not. But I never said it did. For you to take that from my message, I must question your comprehension skills. You entirely missed my point.

You know, this kind of thing is that leads me to believe you argue only for argument's sake. What a stupid message you posted. But that's becoming more commonplace. What the hell are you trying to prove, anyway?

by deepsand

Your BTUs are BS, in so far as you neglect to account for the fate of the Sun's radiant energy in the absence of the materials, structures, etal. that you reference.

by maxwell edison

Post a link to MY message that contradicts my stated position. You linked to someone else's, message, not mine. Sure I posted messages to that discussion, but I have no desire to read them all over again. But you made the claim in the first place, dip-stick, go ahead and prove it. But you won't, because you can't,

My position, as a reminder, is as follows:

I do not own an SUV; but for the record, I certainly would own one if I desired one, and I'd own it without one iota of guilt about anything. And I do, after all, own an old pickup truck, which I don't drive very much, but it gets even worse gas mileage than a newer SUV. I don't judge anyone who owns an SUV, nor have I ever judged anyone who owns an SUV. Moreover, the notion that SUVs are a greater contributor to man-caused global warming is bullocks. Especially since the entire man-caused global warming claim is bullocks.

You really are an idiot. And if you think you can find a specific contradiction in any of my messages, you're a fool. You simply won't find one.

by absolutely

Having missed that survey, the original post was the most logical place for me to judge for myself whether maxwell edison's various posts there mean what he says they mean, or what you say they mean. It was interesting.

by absolutely

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=170980&messageID=1743854

See TheChas babble about other people's motivations, and whether thought or emotion is the basis of others' decisions. What a conceited sack of shirts!

maxwell edison, first and foremost, defends personal liberty, especially property ownership. He occasionally mentions his Earth-friendliness, in a sense that seems to me to have more to do with an appreciation of order and cleanliness that is very consistent with all his other professed "core values".

Now, if I can just convince him that all mysticism is in direct conflict with his reality-based core values, he will be correct about everything, just like me!

:D

by deepsand

I concur. Maxwell does seem to have a need to have everything packed up neat and tidy; there seems to be little, if any, room for unsettling things such as uncertainty.

I see this evidenced in his selectively choosing to accept those "facts" which support his position(s), not unlike that seen at EL in the posts of ippirate.

The great irony is that such constitutes a faith based system, rather than a factual one, which stands in direct counter-point to his insistence that his position is grounded in reality!

by absolutely

A person with no vision would conclude that government ownership is the answer, not the problem. In reality, however, the government can only afford such discrepancies while there are more profitable industries to loot. Once the government owns everything, whether that occurs suddenly (USSR, People's Republic of China) or gradually (Europe & North America are creeping that direction), there will be no wealth for the lower class to steal because there will be no upper class, and everybody will be poorer, in terms of real standards of living, than we are now.

by deepsand

I'm in the process of packing for a move, and am already at a loss to find things that I [b]know[/b] are here somewhere.

Considering that it took me 33 years to accumulate everything, I dread the number of years it will take me to un-pack and re-organize it all.

Realizing that such is most likely an excercise in futility, I've resigned myself to discarding decades of trade and technical publications which are now rarely called into service, but some of which will not doubt be quickly and sorely missed after the move.

Best luck in your endeavors to recover from your move.

by absolutely

It might irritate him, but not confuse. I'm sure that as little as he wants to debate the data, those are what scientists use to determine the truth.

I remember ippirate and Mr. Miami both attempting to make the case that rationality is no better than mysticism, and if that's what you mean when you say we've "been through this before with ippirate and Mr. Miami," I can partially agree. Maxwell makes an incorrect assessment when he describes scientific conclusions about the human causes of climate change as "a religion", but given the look and bearing of its most prominent advocates, I can understand his dismissive attitude. A lot of them seem pretty stupid. I can also understand not wanting to believe those conclusions, and maxwell edison is much clearer and more articulate than Mr Miami ever was, and seems more honest than ippirate. So, I'm willing to converse with maxwell edison just a little bit longer. I think he's wrong about the scientific evidence of global warming, but I can understand why he says what he does about it.

by maxwell edison

...that's fine. I can live with the fact that other people might believe I'm wrong. Just like I can live with the fact that just as many people (and possibly more) believe I'm right.

And for the record, I ALSO maintain that the scientific data on which you so proudly base your belief that human activity IS (or probably is) causing global warming is just a theory. It has not been proven conclusively.

So it is YOU who are basing you conclusion on an unproven theory, not me. I'll wait for the 100 percent proof.

This is where the global warming zealots will ask me if I want to see seacoast cities flooded, en masse, as proof. And this is where I'll say they're chicken-little fools.

by deepsand

proof?

What constitutes "100% proof?"

Who gets to decide the measure of such?

And, why is it not logical to act on a lesser probabilty than 100%?

by maxwell edison

I admit that I'm in the minority. I don't care. However, it's not by much.

A recent Gallup poll question:

"[i]And from what you have heard or read, do you believe increases in the Earth's temperature over the last century are due more to -- [ROTATED: the effects of pollution from human activities (or) natural changes in the environment that are not due to human activities]?[/i]"

March, 2006:

58% Human activities
36% Natural causes
6% No opinion

I would be in the 36 percent. Where would YOU (or anyone else) be?

March 2001:

61% Human activities
33% Natural causes
6% No opinion

However, the trend is showing that people are becoming MORE skeptical, not less, as shown by that 3 percent drop. And only 58 percent of the people disagree with me.

Disclaimer: All the regulars know what I think of polls, especially when media outlets are behind them. Most of my negative opinions about polls are the leading questions, and my suspicion that many of them are no more than a desired headline in search of support.

This headline, for example could read (and maybe did read), [b][i]Most Americans Believe Global Warming is Caused By Humans[/i][/b].

However, it could read: [b][i]Fewer Americans Believe Global Warming is Caused By Humans[/i][/b].

Moreover, the way the question is worded could produce different results. For example, [i][b]"From what you have heard or read..."[/i][/b], is much different than, "[i][b]"From what has been proved..."[/i][/b], or, "[i][b]"Do you really believe..."[/i][/b].

Nonetheless, I simply provide this to suggest that I am far from alone in my beliefs. In fact, more and more people are [i]apparently[/i] beginning to believe like me.

Here's the link to the poll:

http://poll.gallup.com/content/default.aspx?ci=22291

That is a pay site, so the link might not work. However, Gallup will give you a free 30 day subscription for the price of a valid email address.

by maxwell edison

[b]Americans Still Not Highly Concerned About Global Warming: Though record number say it's happening now[/b]

[i] PRINCETON, NJ -- Americans are more convinced than ever that the Earth is being affected by global warming...[/i].

http://www.democraticunderground.com/discuss/duboard.php?az=view_all&address=102x2214266

OF COURSE, it's the DEMOCRAT UNDERGROUND with a leading and misleading headline!

http://poll.gallup.com/content/default.aspx?ci=22291&pg=2

(Among others.)

If the first link doesn't work, perhaps this one will:

http://poll.gallup.com/content/default.aspx?ci=22291&pg=2

by deepsand

Throughout his numerous posts, in various discussions, Maxwell's core theme has been "leave me alone." And, throughout such litany, he has either denied or ignored suggestions that the actions of any one person, himself included, can have far reaching and unexpected consequences.

In short, he fails to understand to understand that you cannot do just one thing.

In defending his position(s), he generally holds that [i]his[/i] valuations of truth and falsehood, including those pertaining to physical facts, are superior to those of others.

This is precisely what we witnessed at EL, particularly in the posts of ippirate and Mr. Miami. Hence, the reference to them.

by maxwell edison

First of all, you claim that I made a grammatical error, but you didn't point it out. Go ahead, dip-stick, point it out. If I did make a grammatical error, I'll admit it. But I don't think I did. Even if I did, I don't care. I've already proven myself as one of the best writers in these discussions. And then you made an error, yourself, in that very message. That's the epitome of foolish, you know. But it's already been established that you're a fool, so foolish things from you are a given, I suppose.

As far as your claim that I have left no substantive response, to what are you referring? All of me responses are substantive; well, almost all of them are. There is one exception, I will admit. That's when I go back-and-forth with idiots like you in messages like these.

You prove me right, yet again, when I point out your idiocy.

by oneamazingwriter

I've been following this discussion for days and waiting for someone to answer:

"Okay, why am I posting this message? Well, I have one question. What sounds better, the Desoto Treaty or the Toto Treaty?"

:D Since no one has done so as yet, I thought I would. I like Desoto over Toto...it has more of a melodic ring to it!

That being said, I will be ducking behind my desk, as I am sure at least one of you will be tossing something at the monitor and I don't want your beer splashing on me!

;)

by deadly ernest

Well if we must restrict it to those two

I prefer the Toto Treaty but pronounced as if the word 'to' repeated so it comes out 'TwoTwo' Treaty (22 Treaty as in Catch 22). However Desoto treaty pronounced 'D-sow-two Treaty' is not to bad.

I did really prefer the Tar Treaty as 'tar' is a black sticky material without much real substance - like all these environmental treaties. Also the second version could be called the Tar Tar treaty - down under we have a slang expression for goodbye which sound like tar tar.

Re the beer - I don't drink and when I did I would NEVER waste good alcohol by throwing it at something or someone. However you could be in trouble if I had a urine sample on hand ready to take to the doctor.

by jdclyde

all I think of is "toe toe", as in "I will get you my pretty, and your little dog too! HAAHAAHAAAA!"

Desoto, is just too close to Destro from "G.I. Joe", and I keep waiting for Cobra Commander to show up!

:D

That is as serious as I can get about either of them....... ;\

by oneamazingwriter

Well, that certainly wrecked any sense of poetry that I was feeling! I knew I should have stayed away from these keys and kept reading! :D
Ah! It sounds like you drank in "ernest" as I once did, which is why I no longer drink. (At least then I had an excuse for bumping into walls. Now I just apologize to the wall and step to the left or right through the doorway.)

by absolutely

In addition to the opinion that maxwell edison is consistent to his core principles, while also liking tidiness (just like me), I conclude that it's better to respond in a single post wherever the 3000 character limit allows, to avoid giving the impression that I have no opinion (fat chance!) or have decided to withhold it (ha!).

by absolutely

has to do with when you respond with substance, and when you respond with insult and trivia.

maxwell edison: "You entirely missed my point."

Absolutley: Let's test that claim. I believe the point you were trying to make is that global warming is a mystical belief, not a rational one. Please correct me if I've misunderstood, and I'll be happy to clarify my point if you like.

maxwell edison: "What the hell are you trying to prove, anyway?"

Absolutely: I don't tell a lot of jokes because I believe that things that aren't meant to be taken seriously are not worth my time to say. Whatever I say, that is disbelieved or contested, is what I'm trying to prove, and I'm only trying to prove it to whoever may read or hear, who takes facts and ideas seriously.

by maxwell edison

I believe the notion of human-caused global warming is false. And I know for a fact that the theory of human-caused global warming is just that, a theory, as it has not been proven, 100 percent, beyond any doubt whatsoever.

How much clearer can I be?

Since it's not proven, 100 percent, beyond any reasonable doubt, and since there are so many prominent people who also believe that the notion of human-caused global warming is false -- people who are qualified to make such determinations -- then the unquestioning belief that global warming is happing at the hands of humans who inhabit the earth is tantamount to placing faith in something that is not proven to exist -- just like the belief in God, something else that is unproven.

The belief in God is based on faith. The belief in human-caused global warming is based on faith and/or faith in others. You can justify it all you'd like, but it won't change anything. People come up with perfectly reasonable justification to support their belief if God, but it's still based on faith, to some degree. People come up with perfectly reasonable justification to support their belief in human-caused global warming, but it's still based on faith, to some degree. There are even a good number of scientists who believe in God, so your "scientific" fall-back is silly. And people defend their belief in God and their belief in human-caused global warming with such zeal, and they're so devout in their belief, which is based on faith, that there certainly are parallels and similarities.

Argue all you want, but if you disagree, so be it. That's the way I see it. You can believe in the mystical, pink, flying unicorn, for all I care. Just don't try to get the rest of the world to buy into that silly notion, and trade Unicorn credits, until its existence is proven, 100 percent, beyond any reasonable doubt.

I'm through arguing with you on the issue; Neil has run away from answering any of my questions or replying as he promised; and deepsand holds the current title of the biggest idiot (since ippirate and RiverFreight seem to be history). Therefore, I'll let all you human-caused global warming "true believers" sing in your choir all you want. Keep the faith, man. Keep the faith.

by Member 25348569

and is up to his knees in stripped wallpaper. Oh, and working too, on a new project for our new SAN. (This is lunch, by the way, so I can spare some time).

I will reply all in good time but I hoped you'd realise that it might take a while as I have to find a sufficiently authoritative and significant piece of information to drop at your feet and say "What do you think of [b]that[/b] then, Mr. Smarty?" You have adopted a [b]far[/b] more entrenched position than those of us you accuse of being religious about it. If it is a religion for us then trust me to know an evangelising atheist when I run across one.

I've been reading science papers on lots of subjects since I left school many, many years ago and a lot of these were on meteorological subjects as "the weather" is a favourite topic for the English and I like to be well informed. I've been somewhat convinced that there is something going on with the climate and that we humans have been contributing to it for some time. That's OK for me but I have to find - or maybe I can't - something that even you will have a job gainsaying.

Run away?

Not yet.

by deepsand

Not to mention repeatedly trumpeting your inflated valuation of your literary skills and intellect.

Perhaps you and ippirate should form a mutual admiration society.

by maxwell edison

...than even you. And RiverFreight is a bigger idiot than them all, if you ask me.

Yes, I do like the word idiot -- and fool as well. They are both descriptive of a lot of people who waste my time in these threads. As a disclaimer, however, I've often wondered who the bigger idiot really is, me or the unreasonable idiot I'm trying to reason with? Once I identify someone as an idiot, like I have with you, for example, I should just ignore their messages. But for some reason, I read them -- AND REPLY. What an idiot I AM for doing that. After all, why should I waste my time with idiots?

But I especially like my idiot link. In fact, several people have used it themselves.

You can slightly redeem yourself, however, if you either point out my grammatical error to which you referred, as I asked, and as you conveniently overlooked, or retract the idiotic comment all together. And if you do point it out, and it is indeed an error, I'll even thrash myself for making an idiotic grammatical error!

by maxwell edison

You first criticize me for what you call my inconsistencies.

You discover that you were wrong.

Then you criticize me for being consistent.

That speaks for itself. What an idiot. (There I go again with that "word"!)

by jaqui

oh lords no!! NOT CATCH 22!!!!!!!!!!!!

~twitch..twitch~

damned if you do...

~twitch...twitch~

damned if you don't..

~twitch..twitch~

damned if you do...

~twitch....twitch~

damned if you don't..

~twitch...twitch~

~twitch..twitch~

by maxwell edison

I'm just having a bit of fun at your expense. Feel free, however, to return the same treatment.

I'm getting tired of the human-caused global warming debate. My position is pretty clear. I don't want to argue for argument's sake just to pacify Absolutely's apparent weird need to do just that. The current resident dip-stick, deepsand, is deep into denial (about many things) and isn't worth my time. And you need to get on to your wallpaper job. Besides, I won't change your mind, and you won't change mine, so what's the point?

Disclaimer: I reserve the right to keep pounding away at the devout global-warming faith-based believers so as to keep them from achieving their desired ends, which is to exercise control over other people.

by jdclyde

I see quitters! :D

[i]"why I no longer drink".[/i]

How are you suppose to be able to play golf if you don't drink? :0

There are just some things in this world you are just not suppose to do sober...... :p

by oneamazingwriter

no one ask me to play golf? Aw Shucks! You'll just have to trust me, jd, when I say that a bombed Beth is not a pretty sight! Sober, in my case, does not mean somber. I'm one crazy Injun when I swallow firewater (and there are those who would proclaim me as that even without it!) :D

by jdclyde

attractive women out with the girls, out back half way through the night, taking turns holding each others hair back while they puke. Now that is a friend! :D

No one said you have to get bombed, my dear. Socal is the word of the day! Everything in moderation! ;\

It is funny, for my "Presentations" class a few months back we had to pick ANY topic we wanted, and do a six minute talk with visual aids. In classes like this you get a lot of scared kids in their first college classes, and so they do serious topics about cancer or whatever.

My paper was "Why you should drink". :D Oh, it was priceless the look on everyones face when they realized I wasn't joking and this really was my presentation! :^0 Went through the MANY medical benifits that are all true and real. Then I went on to the social aspects, and ended up with lines about how it has helped white men dance!

Because I presented it well, and had good visuals, I got my "A", to the shock and horror of the other students. They forgot that this was PRESENTATIONS, not a RESEARCH class!

And now, with the assistance of the TR crew, I have even started to add Scotch to my list, and as a drink or three a day is good for you heart, I do that or wine for my health. ;\

No, I do not drink to intoxicate. I do drink to play darts and pool, because I can't do either well sober, but I almost never lose either after a few rounds! B-)

Oh, a passed out Beth does make an interesting visual too.......... :p :x [i] (joke, it was a JOKE!)

by jellimonsta

(good Tool song).

I quit drinking when I was 19. I don't play golf, pool or darts. I don't bowl either.

I am more into snowboarding, mountain biking/ boarding, wake boarding and sky diving. Believe me, you want to be sober for those sports! :D

by jdclyde

GREAT Tool song! "If my hand could move like that, I'd never leave the house! hee hee!"

And those are ACTIVITIES, not SPORTS! :D

Quiter! ;\

by oneamazingwriter

(Shake and tremble) for that I WOULD require at least a case of Tequila and even then someone would have to push me out of the plane. Hat's off to you, Jelimonsta!

by deadly ernest

Like most young people I did not have much money when I started work. Nearly everyone drinks beer as it is cheaper than any other alcohol in Australia. Even small amounts of beer makes me throw up - violently, stomach can not handle the yeast - an allergy problem. That left spirits - could only afford one or two Southern Comforts per drinking session - was not fair to have others buy me drinks that cost 4 times theirs so I did not join in buying rounds.

After a few years I got fed up of arguing with people about drinking beer. I just drank soft drink and said I was tea total - got way less arguements that way. Seems Aussies accepted tea totallers more readily than non-beer drinkers in the 1970's and 1980's. never bothered with alcohol again since - except for sterilising cuts etc.

Editted to fix typos and add this bit below.

I did try some wines and liked sauturnes - but then drinking wine in a pub with your mates was even less acceptable than being tea total.

by jdclyde

I used to work second shift, and by the time I would get to the bar my buds would already be half toasted. So to catch up, I would walk in and order my kickstart. People would wonder what I was talking about, until they would see the bartender appear with four shots of southern and a glass of sprite. Slam the four shots, drink the sprite, and I was caught up to everyone! :D (this was "back in the day")

I still have people say something if I don't keep up with them drinking, and I just tell them that I am not drinking to impress them. I am also almost ALWAYS the driver, so I switch to coke about two hours before we have to get going, and again get questioned about this. I inform them that they are worth more to me than the extra few drinks.

Drugs. I never got into them because I never wanted to do anything I might like too much.

I am on the wagon right now, because I haven't had a drink since yesterday. ;\ (the TR boys got me into Scotch....)

Oh, if you drink vodka or rum, it is MUCH more affordable than beer! I learned that a long time ago in the highschool party daze.

by absolutely

I argued long and pointlessly that the inability of science to be omniscient does not constitute any part of proof of an unknowable, omniscient entity. I see maxwell's position here more like nielb's at EL: "prove it". He doesn't say there is No Global Warming, just that there might not, and that despite some evidence for Global Warming, there is enough that he remains in doubt. His insulting claim that global warming is a religion is irritating, but since maxwell edison is defending a right to choose, I take less offense than when ProteinDrinx & friends tried to argue that their religion should be mixed with government-paid education.

by maxwell edison

By reading the following article, it becomes obvious that global warming, much less human-caused global warming, is anything but a forgone conclusion, and it's anything but leading to certain catastrophic consequences. Let's take a closer look at what this article says, but more importantly, what it doesn't say.

http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2005/07/0727_050727_globalwarming.html

[i]"A broad scientific census says that Earth is already experiencing significant global warming...."[/i].

Define "broad". That also means, since it doesn't say total agreement, that there are also some number scientific dissenters. A "broad scientific consensus" might also mean that there's a significant number of dissenters.

Define "significant global warming". One degree hardly seems significant. Moreover, as I poked fun at in my previous messages, what is the margin of error? One degree perhaps?

(I'd bet that the [i]significant[/i] number of dissenters would be more than one!)

[i]"Some climate scientists warn that the pace of global warming could be much more rapid than that predicted even a few years ago."[/i]

Some, but not all. Define "some". Besides, why should we believe people who are always making wrong predictions?

[i]"Any time you get into projections, you get into a lot of uncertainties. But the [climate] models are getting a lot stronger..."[/i]

Uncertainties? No sh1t, Sherlock! The models are getting stronger, you say? That's meaningless. On a scale of 1-10, for example, a 2 is stronger than a 1, but it's a far cry from a 10.

[i]"Gulledge says some current projections point to a rise in average global temperature of 0.5?C (slightly less than 1?F) by the year 2030."[/i]

Not counting the 1 degree margin of error, of course.

[i]"Gulledge cautions, however, that warming rates depend on many factors, some of which have yet to be discovered.[/i]

Well, let's "discover" those factors first, and then you can get on with your models for prediction which have, up to now, by their own admission, proven wrong at worst, and very unreliable at best.

[i]"One of the big unknowns is how society will react...." [/i].

Well, assume the worst case scenario, you idiot! Assume nothing will change and society will ignore your proven unreliable models and wrong predictions, and PROVE something for once instead of guessing at everything.

Moreover, what are some of the other "big unknowns"?

[i]"John Harte, an ecosystem sciences professor at the University of California, Berkeley, is already seeing possible future outcomes of global warming. For 15 years, he has artificially heated sections of a Rocky Mountain meadow by about 3.6?F (2?C) to study the projected effects of global warming. Harte has documented dramatic changes in the meadow's plant community. Sagebrush, though at the local altitude limit of its natural range, is replacing alpine flowers. More tellingly, soils in test plots have lost about 20 percent of their natural carbon. "[/i]

First of all, if you guys are predicting a ONE degree increase in the Earth's average global temperature, why is this idiot conducting his experiment with temperatures that are almost FOUR TIMES greater than that? Second of all, what other factors have effected this experiment? Third of all, who's been paying for this idiot to travel from Berkeley, California to Colorado for the past ten years for his vacations, I mean to conduct his experiments?

http://www.berkeley.edu/news/berkeleyan/2000/09/27/roast.html

http://socrates.berkeley.edu/~hartelab/

And you guys base your future global predictions on this? This is meaningless crap.

[i]"Now, [the test plot] is just one ecosystem, and you can't make global claims from one alpine meadow," Harte cautioned. "But bogs, prairie, and tundra ecosystem studies are beginning to show similar results."[/i]

And were those tests also conducted with a [i]similar[/i] FOUR HUNDRED PERCENT increase in the predicted ONE degree temperature rise? (Not counting the one degree margin of error.)

[i]"Vanishing Ice: Elsewhere real-life signs of global climate change blanket the globe ..... Arctic regions are feeling even more heat and will be among the most altered over the next few decades. Temperatures there have already increased as much as 4? to 7?F (3? to 4?C) in the past 50 years?nearly twice the global average."[/i]

Wait a minute, it just said ONE degree. Now it's saying FOUR to SEVEN degrees, which is TWICE the global average. That simply does not compute. Besides, where is the factor for the proven and conclusive INCREASED SUN ACTIVITY over the past ~11 years?

[i]"We know that most of the world's small glaciers are shrinking," said Mark Serreze of the National Snow and Ice Data Center at the University of Colorado at Boulder. "A few are still advancing."[/i]

Again, wait a minute. WHY are those glaciers advancing? How can that be?

[i]"In testimony last week to the United States Senate's Energy and Natural Resources Committee, Houghton referenced the unusually extreme heat wave that killed some 20,000 central Europeans during the summer of 2003."[/i]

Another reference to that "disaster":

http://quote.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=10000100&sid=ayajcPMaPYf4&refer=germany

[i]"Careful analysis shows that it is very likely that a large part of the cause of this event is due to increases in greenhouse gases and projects that such summers are likely to be the norm by the middle of the 21st century.[/i]

Very likely is a far cry from a certainty.

[i]"The heat wave began to envelope the continent just as Luterbacher and his team were preparing to announce that their work had determined the hottest European summer of the past 500 years was that of 1757. As temperatures rose, they decided to wait and extend their research into 2003."[/i]

In other words, they decided to wait so they could find more justification for their desired conclusion. This is especially evident by realizing that the "almost" hottest summer of 1757 had nothing to do with "greenhouse gasses" that were caused by those evil SUVs. Did they have SUVs in Europe back in 1757? And what caused that record heat-wave?

[i]"...when the temperature reached 40 degrees Celsius (104 Fahrenheit)."[/i]

Wow, 104 degrees. I guess everybody in southern Arizona is dead by now, since their summers have always reached temperatures of 110 to 114 degrees. I remember the two summers back in the early 70s when I actually lived in Arizona with such temperatures. Why didn't I die? I guess it was the global cooling predictions of that day that saved me from perishing. Thank God for global cooling! (Make that "thank goodness" for all you atheists out there.)

[i]"Busalacchi, the University of Maryland meteorologist, cautions that it is difficult to attribute any single extreme weather event to global warming."[/i]

Then why did you just do it?

And why do you continue to do it?

These people are amazing.

These people have always been wrong.

Why should they be believed now?

by puppybreath

Now we have giant hail:

http://www.ktvu.com/news/8575846/detail.html

when are you going to admit that the world is really coming to an end? What does it take to convince you? More and more of these weird weather occurances are happening daily. It HAS to be global warming!

Imagine one of these puppies hitting you on the head or on your precious SUV (of course a Hummer would be safe but that's beside the point)!

I don't know about you, but I'm hiding in my bomb shelter until the danger passes. Then I'll be able to tell my children what caused the world as we know it to disappear.

by maxwell edison

But first, the setup:

1. Human-caused global warming is not proven.
2. The existence of God is not proven.
3. The ice ball did not fall from an airplane.
4. The ice ball did not originate from a weather pattern.

Okay, here's how and why it happened.

God got pissed off at that professor at Berkeley, and He wanted to knock some sense into him. "So you think global warming is caused by you morons", God said. "So you think you can change what I created", God said. "Well I'll show you", He went on to say.

At that, He threw a huge ice ball at that Berkeley professor, hoping to hit him up-side the head to knock some sense into him. His aim was a little off, and instead the ice ball landed in Oakland.

by Member 25348569

Actually, I wonder if I am going to post much here as you've certaily taken in all of the good stuff put out by oil company fuelled think tanks and their publicity machines.

One of the difficulties that you present me with is the sourcing of information that you won't - cannot - disregard and label as "politically motivated". I'm being polite, by the way, and not labelling it "anti-US conspiracy" which is how you come over. I would normally invite you to read some of the material published by the IPCC but I feel that you would probably consider them as a politically motivated, anti-us body coming, as they do, from the UN. If they are political, though, it's the US that made them that way by the ousting of Chairman, Robert Watson. The usual way to counter a scientific argument is with better science. The US under Bush disapproves of the message coming out from the IPCC so - in typical fashion - you shoot the messenger.

Anyway, the IPCC reports - believe them or not - are a compendium of peer reviewed and published science. Each subsequent IPCC report notes areas where the science has improved since the previous report and also notes areas where further research is required. A peer reviewed publication is the only source that I will accept as authoritative for any scientific data - it's why I get so fired up against ID - because it's the best method to ensure scientific objectivity. Obviously, peer review is not immune to the workings of a global conspiracy. But then, what is?

So, what is the conspiracy?

A global secret cabal targeting the United State's economy? Taking into account, by the way, that Canada, the UK and other members of this cabal have economies that would be destroyed by any serious US downturn. I know! It's FRANCE! The BASTARDS! I know. It's the Arabs! They want to destroy you so you won't buy their oil! Unh?

Big oil and big auto just trying to keep their noses eyebrow deep in the trough for as long as possible. Well, in mitigation, I say that...er...erm...well....I know. It's the Arabs! They want to destroy the GW argument so you will buy their oil! Hmm?

It's Elvis! I've seen him! HE killed Diana.

by Member 25348569

I have a more regard for Maxwell's position in this debate than I had for any of the ID nutters over at EL. The global warming debate is over the differing ineterpretations of publicly available scientific data but, unlike the Evolution debate, those interpretations are being made by scientists. It has become, unfortunately, politicised to the point of a conspiracy theorists wet dream but at least there is some sense and professionalism on both sides if you can find it.

Maxwell [b]is[/b] wrong but I can, at least, see why he thinks he might be right. I would still definitely take his truck away, though.

:D

by oneamazingwriter

passed out, I might have been able to keep drinking! ROFL I'm one of "those", jd. My body chemisty and alcohol just do not mix. I'm the same with even the mildest drug...ultra-sensitive, destined to be the exception to the rule often. Moderation in all things is something I think it wonderful, but for people like me some things need to be totally avoided. (If there truly are many other people like me! Sometimes I wonder!)
I love darts and pool...anything with a target! The first time I went skeet shooting, I got 3 out of five. A friend took me to a batting cage once, since he was a Little League coach. I missed the first pitch and hit all of the rest. When he asked how I did that, I told him that it was like skeet only they were shooting at me! Apparently it's all about timing.

by jdclyde

there is an old saying about anyone that would intentionally jump out of a perfectly good plane..... :0

by x-marcap

The attitude is that of the Regular Navy officers I have met. They were political to the extreme. That screams Annapolis almost as much as the rings they knock on wood with hence "Ring Knockers"...

The USNA became political in the 60s...