The Data are Clear - - We MUST act NOW
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by jdclyde
I didn't and don't have a problem with your posts adunlap. :)
I just couldn't help but laugh at him playing the preacher complaining about sins, after spending a night with a "lady of the night".
And yes, he came to argue with people that "don't get it" instead of have an open discussion where people present their sides and then everyone takes something new away from the table. He has no interest in that. All too common these daze.....
by tonythetiger
by jellimonsta
by ar-15
OK... you are supporting my statement I put forth in the post you replied to... perhaps I am an ideological zealot. I might also suggest that we are all guilty of ideological zealotry at one point or other. And YES I did come here to argue (in the Socratic sense of the word)... that IS the point. The conclusion that I am an ideological zealot does not necessarily mean that I cannot make valid logical arguments. And yes, this goes for all ideological zealots.
To get past ideological zealotry one has to be committed at some level to finding (approximating an understanding of) the truth. The required committment includes an effort to be as objective as possible and remain intellectually honest. The committment also takes time.
Forums like these do not seem to be well suited to this endeavor (truth seeking)... participants appear to lack the discipline to stay committed (myself included of course) and those involved often don't have the time to pursue arguments exhaustively to ther logical conclusions and therefore new understandings.
A structured approach would be to agree to terms of engagement that define the methods to be used to come to an understanding, e.g., logical argumentation where assertions are made, tested, and conclusions drawn. In this regard, the avoidance of logical fallacies is important, e.g., equivocation, ad hominem, straw man, etc...
We all need to know the rules, accept them, and when we break them, accept and acknowledge this and move on in the process. This takes committment.
Since it is not possible to restrict participation in these forums to only those that have agreed to some rules of engagement for argument, these forums are not the place to attempt such an effort. However, I will indulge.
I do have some logical progressions of assertions that I am working on.
If you all would like to test them... have at it.
1) Exponential growth within any physical (finite) system is not sustainable. (see Al Bartlett's work)
2) Human population has grown exponentially up to the present day.
3) It is possible for living organisms to exceed the carrying capacity of their life support systems either through the quality of their lifestyles or the quantity of their populations or both.
4) The boom and bust cycles of various species on this planet exhibit patterns, e.g., exhausting food supplies and related resources preceding massive die offs.
5) It is possible to determine the ideal population size of a species that is sustainable within a system. This assessment must be ongoing and reflect new information as it becomes available.
6) By maintaining sustainable population size, species can avoid boom and bust cycles.
7) Human population size has reached levels that are not sustainable within our physical system (Earth). (see diminishing fresh water supplies, oil reserves, clean air, massive species extinctions).
8) Humans have the capacity to modify their own behavior.
9) Using scientific methods, humans can use the best available information, at any given time, to discover/develop best practices for sustainable living.
10) Humans can re-organize their societies around sustainable practices.
11) Considering that civilization as we know it MAY be at risk of major collapse, based on evidence that is widely accepted and available, we should adopt sustainable practices as soon as possible to preserve the life sustaining systems on this planet.
by ar-15
by ar-15
If you are referring to me, you have not proven the main thrusts of my assertions incorrect. If you are interested in doing so, in an open manner, please see my post of 4/13 under "Ideological Zealotry... "
(https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=192789&messageID=1994631)
I have made some points/assertions there that I believe support logical conclusion (the last point).
I also make some points there about the nature of online forums and how they are not conducive to socratic argumentation. So I do not expect that I will be able to argue with you on any agreed rules of engagement and I don't have the time to do the argument justice. However, an intellectually honest person's straw men are not so easily beaten... they have many lives. In other words, you should be able to argue my position for me as well as I can or would try to (assuming you might not think much of my cognitive capacity).
I have tried to do as much over the years and I ended up changing my position based upon this effort (having once supported Reagan and Bush I). I am not trying to prove anything here other than the fact that I do have an open mind concerning logical argumentation leading to rational conclusions.
I am not running away from you or this argument. I simply do not have the time to partake in a meaningful way within this framework.
Cheers
by sleepin'dawg
in my books that is running away. If you can't bring forth any cogent points supported by data from proper sources and are prepared to argue your points, you have abandoned the field and regardless of how you define it, you have run away.
BTW aside from your argument being wrong it was incomplete but then Maxwell's wasn't much better. I think Max was/is a bit fed up; he usually does much better even when he is wrong. Lately,I've denoted a note of shrillness to his arguments and that isn't like Max at all.
[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)
In a nutshell, as it concerns human-caused global warming, I'm in the same boat as 99.999% of the world population. What amazes me, however, when we discuss the issue around here, is just how many "experts" come crawling out of the woodwork. Absolutely is one such person, Neilb is another (although Neil is much less grating), and you appear to be trying to pass yourself off as one as well. Quite frankly, I don't buy it. I highly doubt if there are ANY such experts who waste their time posting messages in a TechRepublic discussion forum. And I just shake my head in disbelief at some of you guys who throw around facts and figures, about which, if you were to really admit it, YOU KNOW NOTHING!
At best, all we can do is research the issue (and by that I don't mean to become a scientist or climatologist), try to become informed and make some semblance of sense out of the whole thing, try to decide what sounds reasonable, and yes, consider the source of information we are fed. I've done those things, and I've formed my conclusion accordingly. My conclusion will follow my reasoning.
One point, for example, that I've mentioned numerous times, but NOBODY has disputed, is a little thing called "margin of error". Measuring something such as the average global temperature fluctuations over hundreds of thousands of years is anything BUT an exact and precise science. A margin of error MUST become a consideration. What IS the margin of error when it's suggested that the average global temperature has risen one degree? One is about the lowest number I can think of, and I've read that the margin of error IS one degree; so the claim is certainly within the margin of error, which means it might not be happening at all.
Add that to the fact that there are just as many REAL experts, such as MIT Professor of Atmospheric Science, Alfred P. Sloan (as well as many, many others), who dispel either the entire notion of global warming in general, or human-caused global warming in particular, and we can surmise that it is not a forgone conclusion, and either more study is required OR it's reason to consider the motives of those "experts" who disagree. (Professor Sloan calls it all "junk science".) Follow the grant money, by the way, is certainly a strong motivation.
I use an analogy of meteorologists who, in concert, might predict an approaching hurricane and its general direction and intensity. When these "experts" are all in agreement, then I'll be convinced. The way it is now, building on my analogy, a third of the meteorologists are predicting a category 5 hurricane (the ones getting paid to "study" it some more, by the way), a third are predicting clear and sunny skies, and another third are unsure. That is anything BUT conclusive. And sorry, that's not sufficient for me to board up my windows and flee inland.
Now let's build on that hurricane analogy some more. The people screaming the loudest about "human-caused global warming" are not the scientists, per se, but politicians and media pundits. These aren't the people making the predictions, but rather the ones who are trying to sell us the plywood to board up the windows and the transportation to get outta' Dodge. If there are any two groups of people I trust the least, it would be media people and leftist politicians -- the two groups screaming the loudest. (Make that three groups, and let's throw in the United Nations.) Moreover, when the predictions are of certain doom-and-gloom, my red flags of skepticism start popping up all over the place.
Than there are the numbers themselves. You claim that an "exponential" increase in the levels of CO2 are causing catastrophic conditions. Wait a minute and hold the phone. I used the numbers provided by global warming zealots, and showed that the increase was nothing NEAR "exponential", but rather ONLY 30 percent, at best, something you have yet to address. Moreover, when I pointed out that the numbers were measured as parts per million, and the increase was only .000099 percent as relative to the whole, you still said nothing; and the best Mr. Know-it-all, Absolutely, could come up with was some "baseline" nonsense. Like I said, it's like pissing in the ocean, and calling it a toxic body of water. Sorry, that bird just won't fly.
And then, the icing on the cake. "Mother Nature" and the forces of Earth are much more powerful and controlling than man could ever be. Nature controls us, not the other way around. To suggest that little ol' man can destroy our planet is, to me, a ludicrous notion. And adunlap has been hammering home another interesting point. IF, and that's a big if, global warming really IS happening; and IF, and that's another big IF, CO2 levels ARE increasing (1.3 times, not exponentially), who's to say that the SUN CAUSED global warming is not causing the 30 percent increase in those greenhouse gas levels? And you guys conveniently overlook considering the fact that the scientific community IS INDEED in total agreement that the SUN has been experiencing a very active stage over the past couple of decades.
My conclusion: Human-caused global warming in a farce, and people are being duped into capitulation. You, my man, are the one blindly following an ideology, not me. Nothing about the claim sounds reasonable to me at all.
By the way, your 11 points are all nonsense. I might dissect them, one by one, and discredit each and every one of them. But it would probably be a waste of my time -- just like this is. (You sure like to misuse the word "exponential", don't you?)
is that the CO2 rise exists and is human-made:
Ice cores show that during the past 1000 years until about the year 1800, atmospheric CO2 was fairly stable at levels between 270 and 290 ppm. The current level of 381 ppm is higher than any CO2 level observed over the past 620,000 years.
The rise of atmospheric CO2 closely parallels the emissions history from fossil fuels and land use changes.
The rise of airborne CO2 falls short of the human-made CO2 emissions. This means that, taken together, the ocean and the terrestrial vegetation and soils must currently be a net sink of CO2 rather than a source.
Most "new" CO2 comes from the Northern Hemisphere. Measurements in Antarctica show that Southern Hemisphere CO2 level lags behind by 1 to 2 years, which reflects the interhemispheric mixing time. The ppm-amount of the lag at a given time has increased according to increasing anthropogenic CO2 emissions.
Fossil fuels contain practically no carbon 14 (14C) - which decays - and less carbon 13 (13C) - which the plants that make fossil fuels don?t like - than air. CO2 coming from fossil fuels should show up in the trends of 13C and 14C. The observed isotopic trends fit CO2 emissions from fossil fuels. The trends are not compatible with a dominant CO2 source in the terrestrial biosphere or in the ocean.
I'm not saying it's a "cause" of any temperature rise but I am saying that it's definitely not an "effect" of anything but our burning of fossil fuels.
More later
Neil.
[Plot Spoiler] Plot? Who am I kidding?
ps Just finished "State of Fear". He had some good stuff to say and I'll investigate further but he certainly ruined any message by painting all of the environmentalists as the worst sort of terrorists - allied with South Sea Cannibals and driving hurricanes towards Miami for Chrissakes! I still can't work out why they killed the physicist on page ten.
The hero lawyer was the only "good" environmentalist and they turned him to the Dark Side - [b]and[/b] saved California [b]and[/b] he got the Girl.
As a thriller, though, fun to read. :D
by tonythetiger
"I'm not saying it's a "cause" of any temperature rise but I am saying that it's definitely not an "effect" of anything but our burning of fossil fuels."
Exactly. Each side sees things that seem to contradict what the other side is saying, and they want it explained. More than anything else, I think it shows how little we know. Either extreme is bad (would you rather be fried alive or be run over by a glacier?).
"[Plot Spoiler] Plot? Who am I kidding?"
Gee Thanks :)
by tonythetiger
Humans love to hear/see bad news (how many of you read about the plane crash versus who is on the honor roll in your town?). They like to see other people hurt or in danger of being hurt. While anecdotal, I'll bet everyone has seen the evidence. How many times have you been stuck in traffic, creeping ahead slowly, only to discover that an accident alongside the road has everybody slowing down to look? How many people deliberately turn to the weather channel during hurricane season, even when you live nowhere near the area it may affect?
Oh, and our memories play tricks on us too. We tend to exaggerate the extremes, and play down the norms. How many of you remember the really hot summer, where it was over 90 for it seemed like a solid month? How may of you remember getting out the sled nearly every winter when you were a kid? Well, I'll bet dollars to doughnuts that if you go to your local airport and check the reports, you'll find that it wasn't over 90 for a solid month, and you couldn't possibly have sledded half as much as you think you did.
The power of suggestion plays a role too. Tell something often enough, and almost anybody will start to believe it. There was a 20/20 episode where they chronicled an experiment in "false memory". They told some people about an insignificant event that didn't really happen to them, repeated it a few times, then sent them home. Several months later, almost all of the subjects remembered the event as having really happenned, and actually argued with the researchers when told that it hadn't, adding that they remembered because... (and went on to embellish the original event). It was pretty interesting.
Something for which the exvidence is pretty conclusive.
The next step is to find if the CO2 has an effect.
I'm not on anyones side except my own. I suspect that I'm not on yours in this. I was answering, for Maxwell, the question in his post, "who's to say that the SUN CAUSED global warming is not causing the 30 percent increase in those greenhouse gas levels?"
Well. I'm saying it didn't.
And I was thanking him for suggesting "State of Fear" which was a really funny mixture of anti-GW rhetoric, fairly bad action sequences and really piss-poor characterisation.
Happy ending, though. Except for the poor bugger who got eaten.
by ontheropes
by deepsand
by ontheropes
and Mr. Maxwell Edison is boss hoss!
Assimilation is much easier if you go to sleep.
Sleep deepsand, sleep. You may feel a tiny pinch but it too shall pass. Sleep deepsand. That's right. Sleeeeepppp.
Ahhh. Assimilation has begun.
Sleeeeppppp.
:D Let's debate that! I chose Desoto.
1. Desoto is melodius
2. It's the name of a most solidly built car (They don't make them like they used to!)
3. Toto was a cute but silly little dog
4. Toto is THE BRAND NAME on my toilet!
by ontheropes
by deepsand
Cool!
Is that made by the manufacturers of the Roto Rooter?
by deepsand
It is my fear that by the time mankind collectively realizes that our resources are finite and/or we have so thoroughly soiled our cradle that it is no longer habitable we will no longer have the requisite resources to escape the gravity well within which we live in numbers sufficient to ensure the survival of the species.
In short, I see mankind becoming extinct unless we become very wise very quickly.
by deepsand
Please see
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=192789&messageID=1992711
by deepsand
by deepsand
One [/i]can understand[/i] the effects of a given action [i]without[/i] first needing to know all other possible relevant actions and their respective affects.
So, what is, in this instance, to be gained by waiting?
by deepsand
by deepsand
Time is my most precious possession, and the demand for such always seems to exceed the supply.
Perhaps I should take the approach suggested by Max and company, and assume that I'll live as long as I wish.
by deepsand
by absolutely
by deepsand
by absolutely
by deepsand
That one has withdrawn from the field of battle means only that he has ceded such field.
It does not mean that he has conceded the issue.
If one adopts Max's spurious definition, then he too has admitted defeat and accepted the correctness of his opponents' position(s).
by deepsand
Are you taking issue with the use of the word "exponential," or are you simply using it as a vehicle for more ad hominem attacks?
If the former, kindly say so and state your reason for so saying.
If the latter, ask us if we give a damn.
by deepsand
If you can accept that tobacco smoke [i]contributes[/i] to the incidence rate of certain type of cancer, but that it is neither [i]necessary[/i] nor [i]sufficient[/i] to cause such, yet still hold that it is a "cause" of cancer, why not use the same standard of "proof" here.
Do you maintain that mans' activities [i]cannot, beyond all reason[/i], contribute to climate changes?
by absolutely
by absolutely
I apologize for the excessive use of [b]bold[/b]. I had too much to drink.
However, I got the facts right, and I chose the right facts to note. Maxwell, you argued that the word "exponential" was incorrect because the quantities of CO2 in 1750, 1955, and 2004 were such small percentages of the atmosphere that instead of percentages, or parts per hundred, the most convenient scale to use is parts per million.
But "exponential [b]growth[/b]" describes only the geometry of a graphical representation of the increase of CO2 in absolute, not relative terms. If the total mass of CO2 in the atmosphere increases slightly in interval 1 over its initial value, more in interval 2 than in interval 1, more in interval 3 than interval 2, etc, that growth pattern can be described with exponential notation, but not with a straight line.
It just occurred to me that I've been arguing only based on scientific data, for the conclusion I reached while attending a public university. But public education is a by-product of the collectivist entitlement mentality I hate. I have the integrity to question the honesty of that institution, and will take a closer look at what you've said about the parties making global warming claims, their funding, and promise to look for sloppy analysis whenever I can find the original data published.
by deepsand
by absolutely
Have fun exchanging insults. That isn't how I want to use this communication medium.
Maxwell does not ignore all facts, and it would be inaccurate to say that he is consistently illogical. He consistently opposes collectivism, which is nearly always bad for the majority of individuals, and thus, ironically, most of the collective. It may be just the recent turn of this thread to a "pig-pile on Max", or maybe improved emotional balance has helped me develop a more open mind.
Whatever the cause, I notice that Maxwell has said that global warming is unproven, and believed fervently like faith. He has not said that global warming has been proven false. Ironically, I'm watching public television as I type on my notebook, and on Nova on Tuesday at 8pm is an alarming program that explains why global warming is much worse than anybody had expected. If the content of this Nova special is accurate, I wonder why I would be watching an informative entertainment program, and not reading a House resolution. Maybe I have a problem with facts and logic, but public funding makes me skeptical, and I won't dismiss Maxwell just for [b]questioning[/b] the objectivity of the government.
by absolutely
I'll continue to not pay you, and you can do no work for me for as long as you like!
How's that?
by deepsand
You state that "Maxwell does not ignore [b]all[/b] facts, and it would be inaccurate to say that he is [b]consistently[/b] illogical."
I did not state that he consistently ignores either the facts of the rules of logic. In fact, as I have stated elsewhere, he selectively chooses those facts, or lack of such, which support his position, while ignoring or otherwise failing to allow those which either contradict his position or support alternative positions.
I.e., he neither consistently [b]accepts[/b] all facts nor consistently [b]follows[/b] the rules of logic.
This is not an insult; it is an empirical observation.
by deepsand
Permission accepted.
Enjoy.
by deepsand
And, we're in your midst.
Watch your back.
by absolutely
"Watch your back."
Ha!
by deepsand
we are the mirrors?
Can you be certain that we are not?
All may not be as it appears.
are you any relation to Smorgas Borg and Inger Borg?
You are from Norway, right? :p
by deepsand
by sleepin'dawg
Hey man, it has definitely been awhile. Glad to see you are still on the green side,(as in green up, brown down) even if I am going to disagree with you somewhat on the causes of global warming. I'm not saying you are wrong but neither are you completely right. I still think there is much not being understood and too much profligacy in consumption but no one has yet determined to what extent we are reaching the full capacity of the environment. I frankly believe we are far from that point yet and still have time for lots more study, in the mean time it wouldn't do any harm to practise consevation of fossil fuels because there are finite limits on their availability. With the recent announcement of Canada's proven reserves, I guess Canada is about to become the new supplier of choice. I hope this means Canadian taxes are going to be reduced.
I'd like to debate this with you but I've had a rather full day and am not up to it right now. Perhaps later; in the meantime glad to see you're back.
[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)
by deepsand
I think that you may have mis-understood my position re. man's role in global warming.
I do not maintain that mankind is the primary cause, let alone the sole cause, of global climate changes, but only that he is a contributing factor.
And, although our actions may be neither necessary nor sufficient to cause the observed changes in climate, the simple fact is that we do have the ability to withdraw our contribution to such changes.
Not only is such prudent, given that our present contributions may yet be incontrovertibly proven to be deleterious, but it may, by virtue of reducing the number of inputs into a complex system, improve our understanding of the relevant natural processes and their effects, which may eventually be tamed to our benefit.
To wait for the "final" proof that a six-shooter with five empty chambers is deadly is shear folly.
by absolutely
3296 : 1
In the same period of time, cars excreted more than 3000 times as much CO2 as Mount Saint Helens in seven months of 1980, which was the largest volcanic eruption in North America in my lifetime, I'm sure. (Perhaps in the world? In the 20th century?)
Anyway, it was darn big, and I'm very certain that any eruption 3000 times as big as Mount Saint Helens would kill so many of us immediately that civilization would come to an end, and the unfortunate "survivors" would only die slowly. So, let's drop the volcanic activity argument against global warming caused by fossil fuel CO2, please.
by deepsand
I'm talking 40 years ago.
And, the "processor" that reeled from trying to cope with infinite recursiveness was the bio-chemical one between one's ears.
by absolutely
by absolutely
by absolutely
by deepsand
Are the brain's functions inherently recursive?
Given that they perform integration & differentiation, functions that are necessary for process control, in a manner analogous to an op amp, my initial response would be "yes."
by deepsand
by ttspff
by jdclyde
when they drop their pants though....... :0
This is NOT what is meant when you are told to LOVE trees!!!!! :^0
B-)
by jerome.koch
I hope your post was tongue and cheek. Concrete, certain building materials etc...absorb incoming solar radiation. After the sun goes down, this absorbed heat is then radiated back into the atmosphere. Temperature invesrions which form at night are caused by the radiation of stored near surface thermal energy. The strongest inversions are found in deserts. The Urban Heat Islands which form are cities give false indicators of actual ambient temperatures due to absortion qualities of certain building materials - namely concrete. This was noted in a number of famous studies during the 1970s. The albedo of concrete is different than that of grass and trees.
Once the nocturnal inversion breaks -usually at mid morning- the cycle of absorbtion and radiation begins again. In reality, the presence of Urban Heat Islands have little bearing on climate, but do have a minimal effect on local temperatures.
The increase of 1 Deg C in our global temperatures over the last 120 years hasn't been a perfect curve; there have been 3 significant periods of "cooling" -the late 30s-mid-40s,the early 60s, and the 1970s. The largest jump in global temps occured in 1998-2000 during an intense episode of ENSO (El Nino Southern Oscillation). Since 2000, despite all of the reports to the contrary, global temps have actually decreased about .3 deg C. Four of the last 6 Winters in Europe and Central Asia have actually been well below normal for both precip and Temps, and North Africa has seen above average spring and winter precip. Some parts of the world have had intense droughts, while others above average precip; some places like the artic have seen winter temps go below normal, while thier summers become very warm.
To make matter more confusing, we are entering a new El Nino episode. The West Coast has already been hammered with unusually strong storms, while a drought has plagued the Southwest and Southern Rockies- all indications of an El Nino Year.
by jerome.koch
by jerome.koch
by jerome.koch
You don't even need ship logs. Just investigate the diaries of farmers from Europe, New England, Austrailia, and New Zealand.
It snowed on the 4th of July in Maine (1816).
In 1815, blizzards hit much of Europe in October.
It snow in the middle of New Zealand's summer in 1816.
Farmers in New York had snow in May and June
by kpotter
"Man does have an effect, as do all animals - just think about all that methane from farts - but it is wrong to attribute all the faults on man's activities as some do."
Yes, the temperature varies but the amount and timescale are what's important. The timescale is typically on the order of 10,000 years (probably due to orbital mechanics) with at least one instance where we saw a significant temperature spike occur over 1000 years (which preceded/occurred during a massive extinction event).
Volcanic ash from an erruption can significantly reduce temperature (as can any increase in particulate matter), however the time scale until it is removed from the atmosphere is on the order of decades if not years. CO2 is closer to 1000's of years to remove naturally.
Taken from a post on realclimate.org "I've seen a slightly different "98%" argument made by climate skeptics (e.g., U. Berner in various popular brochures and articles): "98% of the greenhouse effect is natural and only 2% anthropogenic".
This is because the anthropogenic greenhouse gas forcing (~2.4 W/m2 until now, here IPCC is cited) is only ~2% of the total ("natural") greenhouse forcing.
What these people usually leave out, of course, is that the natural greenhouse effect warms the surface temperature by ~33 ?C (all else being equal, notably albedo).
A rough and linear back-of-envelope estimate of how large the 2% anthropogenic change in greenhouse effect might be: 2% of 33 ?C is ~0.7 ?C, very similar to what the more detailed and correct calculation gives.
So, there is nothing wrong with this version of the 2% argument - except that it is often used in a context and in a way designed to mislead the public, i.e., it is used to suggest to a lay audience that "global warming is 98% natural", so we are not responsible and can't do anything about it."
by rush2112
Build HeatExchangers into the innerworkings of large structures (skyscrapers, super structures etc) (not the quicky mart, although with enough of them in a row, this could also contribute)
that remove the heat 24 hours a day from the strurcture store it for later use
to turn a turbine or some similar device to create electricity?
by mr stumper
by d.k.rich
by kpotter
I just had to respond to that comment. Water vapor is a feedback effect (the level of water vapor in a given area is proportional to the temperature and available liquid water). Water vapor equilizes on the order of days while CO2 is on the order of millenia. So, while water vapor does cause a greenhouse effect, it's more of an amplification of other effects than a significant force on its own (i.e. without water vapor's effect, the CO2 emmissions of humans would only be responsible for a .7 deg increase rather than a 1.8 deg shift)
by d.k.rich
by lvyoung
I admit, the 100x was a little hyperbole. It is, in fact, closer to 30x but what the hell - I couldn't be bothered to do the maths for this thread. Who would care?
As a long-term average, volcanism produces about 5X10^14g of CO2 per year; that production, along with oceanic and terrestrial biomass cycling maintained a carbon dioxide reservoir in the atmosphere of about 2.2X10^18g. Current fossil fuel and land use practices now introduce about a (net) 17.6X10^15g of CO2 into the atmosphere and has resulted in a progressively increasing atmospheric reservoir of 2.69X10^18g of CO2.
Hence, volcanism produces about 3% of the total CO2 with the other 97% coming from man-made sources.
Morse and Mackenzie, 1990, Geochemistry of Sedimentary Carbonates.
Now go and do some work for yourself.
by dr_zinj
You stated, "commonly accepted data that has clearly shown the thermal conductive properties of concrete generate 12 BTUs of heat, per hour, per square foot/inch thick slab of concrete;"
Concrete doesn't generate any heat at all. Nor does steel or aluminum for that matter. Kinetic energy in the form of heat is liberated in vast quantities in the production of these materials; and concrete releases heat during the curing process; but once hardened, stops. And these materials can store large amounts of energy as heat, but the heat comes from elsewhere.
Most of the energy used to produce concrete, steel, aluminum, etc. come from solar energy stored in chemical bonds of carbon molecules formed from plants utilizing photosynthesis for the conversion process that had occurred millions of years ago. Yes, some metal and concrete may be produced using burning wood and peat from current or historically living plants; and some energy is produced hydroelectrically from kinetic energy tied up in the water cycle, but that's not important at the moment.
Still can't decide if this really belongs under miscellaneous, or if it should be filed under humor or fantasy.
by r. neil
The whole discussion was a farce aimed at the Kyoto Accord.
In the 1950's, we were being warned of the "impending Ice Age", now we are being warned of the "impending Melt-down." The only difference is that in the 1950's, no one tried to blame the development of civilization for the earth's cooling down.
No one in the discussion seems to be aware of the major climatical cycles of the earth's climates, which are affected by volcanic activity in the short (less than a decade) term.
Other than some minor flare-ups by some authors, the thread is mildly amusing, if not really informative.
by dr dij
he did a thread on the torture at Gitmo and riots in pakistan killing people. blamed the newsmedia for the riots and killing. When the torture was found to be true, (despite politically force retractions by newsweek) the logical conclusion according to Max logic is that the blame should then be switched to those who actually did the torture, the Pentagon.
But no word from max, perhaps due to misguided patriotism. Instead he declared that he was 'joking' during the whole discussion.
Sure.. I killed 4 people, sorry about that, just kidding, hope you don't mind being dead...
Max, in a rut similar to people on both sides of the issue (and other issued) doesn't want to hear or believe any data that might contradict his predefined view.
Open your mind, Max. The sky isn't falling, but the poles ARE melting (sea ice and greenland melting quickly). Chunks the size of Rhode Island are breaking off the floor (south pole).
Will it destroy the human race? probably not.
Will it kill alot of people, coral reefs, species, destroy alot of property and cause alot of people to starve due to shifting climate patterns hampering crop growth? probably.
we're somewhat shielded in the developed countries. if you lived in bangladesh where the bulk of the country is less than 30' above sea level you might feel different.
I would suggest that instead of farcical discussions you suggest answers you'd like but that would be a waste as you appear to deny the existance of ANY major enviromental problems.
Good luck! you'll need it when the rising sea levels reach the sandy spot where your head is buried.
by nicknielsen
by oz_media
Just as you say that on a scale of 1-10 if something is increased and it's now a 2, there' s little to worry about.
If the PPM for a vehicle's CO emissions is .02 then ANY increase would take it to a more dangerous level.
You just made a similar example to reduce the change of 1 point, it works both ways.
by oz_media
the Sun warms th eEarth? Haven't heard THAT theory before, who'd a thunk it?
So because the sun warms the Earth, then you have brilliantly deduced that we are not expediating that proces ourselves.
All fish live in water, therefore all that lives in water is a fish! Well done, Maxwell!
by oz_media
by oz_media
by nicknielsen
"Max, in a rut similar to people on both sides of the issue (and other issued) doesn't want to hear or believe any data that might contradict his predefined view."
I know what's true, don't confuse me with facts!
The problem is, while I agree with you that the planet is indeed getting warmer, I am not sure I agree with you as to the proximate cause or causes.
It has been bugging me since the start of this thread.
The title should be "The Data ARE clear..."
OneAmazingPedanticGit
by founder
I live in Alaska where Glaciers are everywhere. They are indeed receeding but they have been receeding for several thousand years.
Early Explorers (1700's and earlier) have mapped these Glaciers and their melting has been recorded ever since.
So the fact is that global warming is a natural occurance. Industrialization has probably sped the process but it did not cause the problem.
Oh yea, the average temperature over the last hundred years here has gone down 2 degrees F.
by r. neil
by inertman9
by tryten
by jerome.koch
The years 1998-2000 were, overall, the warmest years of the last 100 or so. What many scientists fail to tell people was that these years were influenced by the Southern Oscillation (El Nino). The sea surface temps over the Cen Pac were the warmest on record.
2006 is the beginning of another ENSO event. Aleady the West Coast is seeing El Nino events. The Southwest US is expirencing a drought brought on by El Nino.
by tweakerxp
Science does not work that way (which is why creationists can still get away with the ludicrous "evolution is just a theory" nonsense).
So, what level of proof is required in order to take action? If the risks of inaction are very high, then action must be taken with a balance of probabilities that is somewhat lower than would be true in other situations.
To do otherwise, is the "head in the sand" approach, like this sort of extremely silly argument: "Estimates of when the oil will run out have been very wrong in the past so we can ignore scares about oil running out". The "head in the sand" is the approved posture of big oil in just the same way that excessive panic "the sky is falling in" is the approved posture of one-note environmentalists.
The other problem with the discussion is conspiracy theories promulgated by both sides - you know, distractors like - the Kyoto Protocol is designed to give economic advantage to the Chinese - big oil crushes all research into eco-friendly cars.
Hint: avoid the politics, avoid the posturing, stick to the science and accept that science is always, and must be, a balance of probabilities that is constantly revisiteed and retested but, by sane political decision, acted upon as a matter of urgency.
by switchfoot
Big Oil and the OPEC nations are using this propaganda to justify their prices and environmentalists are using it as a doomsday scenario. It really depends on which side of the fence you're on as to who you think is behind the BIG conspiracy.
Instead of focusing so much energy on why we should take better care of the environment, and who can make the more extreme case to get their point across, we should be focusing more on why each of us has a personal stake in living a cleaner lifestyle.
It doesn't matter if man is responsible for driving up global temperatures, this planet will be here long after we are gone and a new species has risen to the top of the food chain. What matters is that those of us with pride and conscience leave it the same way that we found it. Backpacking has a rule called "Leave no Trace" I try to live my daily life as much to that credo as economics and reason allow. If we all did that instead of trying to focus on whose agenda is most important, then maybe this argument would be moot.
After all, you wouldn't buy a house and then start tearing it apart a piece at a time to sustain your daily habits. You're going to put time and energy into having a nice place to come home to and eat your dinner in at the end of the day. Sustainability is really nothing more than the concept that the next person who comes along will have just as equal a shot at enjoying the house.
Let's take care of our houses ladies and gentlemen!
by maecuff
by inertman9
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending