The Data are Clear - - We MUST act NOW
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by absolutely
by deepsand
Firstly, it is not the case that there exists but a single error in your posts; there are, in fact, several.
Secondly, as I possess neither the time nor the inclination to enumerate them, and as such is in fact unnecessary, and therefore irrelevant, I shall not do so.
What is important is that such errors would generally be unnoteworthy. After all, most, if not all, of us here gathered have made similar mistakes, not because we are incapable of doing otherwise, but because we chose not to take the time to minutely examine every keystroke before we commit them to public view.
What makes your errors worthy of mention is that you have repeatedly and pointedly stated that you consider yourself to possess both an intellect and a literary skill that is superior to those of others present here. I would venture to say that there are many here, both friend and foe, who are at least the equal of either you or me.
Do try to bear in mind that most are here not for to engage in formal scholarly discourse, but rather to engage in a lively and spirited debate, warts and all. But also remember that many of us will insist that the accepted rules of logic, and their application to facts, will be expected in all discussions that purport to deal with facts.
In conclusion, your writings have been criticized [b]not[/b] because you have made errors, but because you have held yourself out as being [b]superior[/b] to others, and you must therefore be taken to task for failing to live up to your own standards.
by puppybreath
by absolutely
I wonder if Bill Clinton had this much fun butting into other people's disagreements at Camp David. I can just imagine his strange drawl, chuckling "this one wants to blow up stuff because he prays to Allah, that one wants to blow up other stuff because he wants to pray to Jehovah in the same place. You guys are hilarious!"
I see that you capitalize your name, except in your profile, so I'll start capitalizing it when I refer to you, Maxwell Edison. Are you sure deepsand confused us? He might have just been insulting me, for variety or something.
:D
by absolutely
by deepsand
There, at least, the blatherings of the jealots offered some occasional amusements, not to mention Gret's informative input re. ancient Scriptures.
Here, naught but drivel.
by absolutely
by tonythetiger
defies logic
They (*) seem to be assuming that Global warming comes from increased CO2 levels, when it's entirely possible that the reverse is true... that Global Warming [b]causes[/b] increased CO2 levels.
Likewise, they have not satisfactorily explained why there have been global warming episodes [b]worse[/b] than the current one, even though the CO2 level wasn't as high.
Nor have they satisfactorily explained what caused the global warming episodes that were as bad or [b]worse[/b] than the current one, before humans existed.
(Not that I expect an explanation, nor even an acknowledgement of the points, but please feel free to comment on my syntax, grammar, or spelling, or write anything else that will allow avoidance of the subject.)
(*) "They" = those scientists who are getting hundreds of millions of dollars to figure out these things
by absolutely
...were caused by the well-known fact of greater vulcanism during those periods. Geologists call them "eras".
adunlap: "Nor have they satisfactorily explained what caused the global warming episodes that were as bad or worse than the current one, before humans existed."
Avoidance? Me? You are absurd.
by ar-15
By generally accepted, I am not referring you or your ilk, but scientists who propose theories and test them in our quest to understand the world we live in.
Have you heard of Occam's Razor? If you haven't, Google it.
Your argmuents are quite vague. At one point in time the Earth's atmosphere was mainly CO2 and Oxygen was a poison for most life on the planet at that time. But interesting as this fact is, it has no bearing on today's problem with exponential growth in CO2 (a known greenhouse gas) emissions.
Please see: www.npg.org/specialreports/bartlett_index.htm
for a lesson on exponential growth.
I am surprised at the level of denial among the Cornucopians... but perhaps I shouldn't be. They have a vested interest in the status quo.
Today's casual disregard for science borders on pathology. Hopefully history won't repeat itself and we find our best minds labelled heretics and martyred in order to protect the status quo.
by deepsand
by absolutely
"Maxwell is wrong but I can, at least, see why he thinks he might be right. I would still definitely take his truck away, though."
Goddam you, if you don't like his pollution, bio-engineer a yeast that excretes ethanol or some other cleaner-burning fuel, you !#@%$#!@!!! commie !#$$%!!!!
by puppybreath
Instead of arguing back and forth non-stop with neither side having enough "acceptable" proof to convince the other side, how about a reality TV show to settle it once and for all?
We'll get experts from both sides of the debate and let them fight it out in the ring. The winner gets to decide what the "truth" really is and then everyone is forced by law to agree with the decision of the show.
We could call the show "My Scientist Can Beat Up Your Scientist".
We could even let Air America sponsor it since they seem to be having trouble keeping viewers and getting funding.
Everyone OK with this?
by jellimonsta
by puppybreath
by deepsand
Since you are the one who has made the claim that you are the superior writer here, the burden of proof rests with you.
Kindly do your own proof-reading, rather than asking others to shoulder your burden.
by deepsand
And, do you mean to say that an unknown probability must be treated as being 0%?
If so, why not treat it as any other arbitrary value, including 100%?
by deepsand
by deepsand
by deepsand
by absolutely
It took 65 million dead peasants, but Mao got his 100% proof, for sure, although the way it was told to me, his Party only told him about the ones deliberately murdered for non-communist words and actions, while most of the 65 million died of simple starvation by communist ineptitude. I don't suppose it made much difference to them [b]why[/b] they died. I'm sure their main concern, leading up to their death, was just wanting to not die.
I wonder what it will take to convince the global warming "skeptics". To me, it's as simple as
(1) combustion produces carbon dioxide
(2) carbon dioxide in the atmosphere reduces the radiation of infrared photons into space, leading to increased ocean temperatures (*)
(3) Antarctic ice shows that during the Industrial Period, there is a lot more carbon dioxide in the air than in other periods.
* The ocean, and every other object, radiates its thermal energy at a rate proportional to the inverse of its "specific heat", usually represented by a "C" in scientists' equations and reference books. Because there is too much carbon dioxide in the air, too much of that radiation is scattered, and prevented from leaving the atmosphere. Because the ocean is made of mostly water, which has a higher specific heat than most substances on Earth, and because there is so much water in the oceans, the effect of having too much carbon dioxide is expected to be most noticeable in the oceans. The NOAA (national oceanic and atmospheric administration) has recently deployed more buoys in the ocean for this reason, and the last time I checked (not recently, not for this thread, certainly!) the data looked pretty annoying to me. I think it's getting warmer.
PS maxwell edison, the point is not to equate you with Mao, only to emphasize that 100% proof is either in the scientific data or not, and that ignoring that proof (if it exists) for political reasons, would be wrong. I admit, I still haven't posted that proof. The most convincing data I ever saw were the ocean temperature data, and I hope you'll answer the theoretical mechanism I've presented here while you wait for those data. I promise, I'm looking. Occasionally. I do, in fact, have commitments that occasionally get in the way of side projects like these.
:(
by deepsand
The average albedo of Earth is approx. 0.30-0.38; that of ice and snow, up to 0.80 in the absence of sediments.
Given the high albedo of the Arctic sea ice, it is difficult to seriously posit that solar radiation alone was responsible for its rapid melting.
by deepsand
You've piqued my curiousity.
Kindly elaborate.
by jdclyde
whatever works for you is just fine! :D
Coke? With SC? ewwwww. too much sweet and syrup of a combination for me, which is why I personally did the sprite.
I have always been a rum drinker. Bacardi, dark. It really does make a difference what KIND you get as to the flavor. Throw in a lemon AND a lime with your coke, and it takes all the bite away. Good stuff.
To put in perspective though, I don't drink to intoxicate, just medicate! ;\
At the same time, I know enough that drinking or not drinking is not what determines what is a "real man".
Like I said, go with what works! (coke.....ewwwww!)
That is part of what I like about getting into the scotch, no coke mixer.
like me. You know sweets for the sweet - lol.
Anyway to each his own poison. I never drank enough to qualify as a social drinker anyway. Was great fun though, I was always the deignated driver and we had an arrangement if one of my mates passed out their girlfriend was free to seek consolation from me. Give up the booae and get more cuddles - hey man you can't disagree with that arrangement.
deepsand made a comment to me that I should use a [i]"grammer"[/i] checker. He was the first one to mention anyone's grammAr. I did two things. I asked him to point out my grammatical error, which he never did; and I pointed out how foolish he looked by correcting someone else's grammar in a message that contained such a blatant spelling error.
Ever since then, he has posted several references suggesting that since I brought up grammar (or grammer for deepsand), that I should check my own. What an idiot! He brought it up, not me.
Anyway, the whole grammar thing (or grammer for deepsand) was started by him in dialogue with me, not you. So it appears that his message was directed at me. If not, I will certainly stand corrected. However, if I am mistaken, it only means that he is now attacking YOU for YOUR grammar (or grammer for deepsand).
So it's not a question of IF he is an idiot, in this case, but rather WHY he continues to be an idiot. Either he mistakenly posted a message thinking he was replying to me, or he is now attacking your grammar (or grammer for deepsand) as well.
It's kinda' like that old joke about a guy propositioning a woman with an offer of $1,000,000, which she accepted. She refused a second $10 offer by asking, "what do you think I am?" The punch line, of course, pointed out that it had already been established WHAT she was, but he was just negotiating the price.
So either way, deepsand, yet again, proved the he is indeed an idiot.
by deepsand
You're getting quite good at the art of obfuscation, while ignoring the issues.
In particular, the issue of your having held yourself out to be intellectually superior, and the more skilled writer, which, of course, subjects your missives to closer scrutiny than might otherwise be the case, has yet to be addressed by you.
You've painted a rather large bull's eye on yourself.
Deal with it.
by deepsand
The post in question was intended for Max, but was inadvertently posted in the wrong place in the thread.
However, I think that by now Max realizes that it was intended for him, but simply chooses to ignore such.
I always admit my mistakes, when I make them, and I certainly have before.
You started the grammar thing, [i]dipstick[/i], not me. But you just didn't point out anything specific. Point it out, and if it's a mistake, I'll admit it. But like I said, you started the whole thing, not me. Personally speaking, I don't really care about such things.
What an absolute idiot you are.
by jellimonsta
Arnie can't run for President!
How many Dems are gonna mess with that??? :D
Dunce and loser might apply here. Moron is a good one, which would also apply. And so would loony, clown, and ninny.
But I prefer idiot. That way I can use my idiot link on unsuspecting dolts. (Hey, there's another one when it's used in the plural form!)
by deepsand
by deepsand
by absolutely
by deepsand
by jellimonsta
by deepsand
I believe that he has her personal e-mail address.
I do hope that she's ok.
Perhaps we can coax her back.
by absolutely
Excessive use of irony!
"God, I miss EL."
Hardy-har, deepsand. Hardy-har.
by deepsand
by absolutely
I don't care. Take a sick day, go on a walkabout, wtf-ever. I don't sign your paychecks.
I don't work for anybody, except The Man signing my paychecks. You?
by tryten
by tonythetiger
Key dates in the story of climate change:
-- 1750: Before Industrial Revolution, atmosphere holds 280 parts per million of heat-trapping carbon dioxide, later research determines.
-- 1898: Swedish scientist Svante Ahrrenius warns carbon dioxide from coal and oil burning could warm the planet.
-- 1955: U.S. scientist Charles Keeling finds atmospheric carbon dioxide has risen to 315 parts per million.
-- 1988: NASA scientist James Hansen tells U.S. Congress global warming ``is already happening now.''
-- 1992: Climate treaty sets voluntary goals to lower carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gas emissions.
-- 1995: U.N.-organized scientific panel says evidence suggests man-made emissions are affecting climate.
-- 1997: Treaty parties approve Kyoto Protocol mandating emission cuts by industrial nations, an approach rejected in advance by U.S. Senate.
-- 1998: Warmest year globally since record-keeping began in mid-19th century.
-- 2001: U.N. scientific panel concludes most warming likely due to man-made emissions; President Bush renounces Kyoto Protocol.
-- 2004: Carbon dioxide reaches record 379 parts per million; Russia gives crucial ratification to Kyoto Protocol.
-- 2005: Kyoto Protocol takes effect on Feb. 16.
Source:
http://www.geo.umn.edu/courses/1006/spring2005/handouts/Kyoto_News_stories.htm
----------
Interesting wording, to say the least.
[i]U.N.-organized scientific panel says evidence [b]suggests[/b] man-made emissions are affecting climate.[/i]
[i]Suggests[/i] is a far cry from proves.
[i]U.N. scientific panel concludes [b]most[/b] warming [b]likely[/b] due to man-made emissions.[/i]
Define "most". Moreover, both "most" and "likely" only water-down each other. And again, "likely" is a far cry from proves.
And consider this. On one hand, the carbon dioxide measured in the atmosphere has increased by about 25 percent since 1750. Wow, a person might say; that's a huge increase.
(Aside from the fact that verifying, with absolute certainty, exactly what the carbon dioxide levels of 1750 really were, is questionable, at best.)
On the other hand, however, considering that the 99 parts of increase are PARTS PER MILLION, then it's easy to calculate that the atmosphere has only absorbed an additional .000099 percent of the stuff. If you ask me, that's tantamount to pissing in the ocean and calling it a toxic body of water.
And you people wonder why I remain skeptical? Actually, I'm more than just skeptical, but I simply don't believe it.
by tonythetiger
CO2 makes up about 20% of the "Greenhouse gasses" in the atmoshpere.
and
Man is only responsible for 20-30% of the CO2.
hence
Man is responsible for 4-6% of greenhouse gasses.
That's assuming (and it's only assumed because there is [b]zero[/b] evidence) that greenhouse gasses cause global warming, rather than the reverse: that global warming causes increased levels of greenhouse gasses (which again is only logical, since warmer air will evaporate and hold more water vapor (which makes up 80% of greenhouse gasses)).
Of course, we can't look at that too closely... peoples livlihoods are on the line, dontcha know!
....sounding rational and logical.
How can they dupe, I mean convince everyone that the earth is doomed with talk like that?
Nothing like using their own numbers to discredit their argument, don't you think? (An increase of .000099 percent as it relates to parts per million!)
by absolutely
Carbon dioxide is measured in "parts per million" instead of percentages of atmosphere because it is such a small fraction of the gas mixture called "air", which is ~80% Nitrogen and ~18% oxygen. The remaining ~2% is mostly inert, noble gases as I remember my old chemistry lessons. Increases in the single component, carbon dioxide, should be in comparison to previous levels of carbon dioxide: (379-280)/280=35%.
Or, if you don't believe Arrhenius (!), but you do accept the measurements of 1955, (379-315)/315=20%.
Increases in carbon dioxide should me measured in comparison to previous, "baseline" levels of carbon dioxide, not diluted by comparison with other elements in the atmosphere, at least unless you can prove that the effect of carbon dioxide on temperature is negligible up to a much higher concentration. Can you do that?
First of all, I don't claim to be a chemist, a scientist, a physicist, a meteorologist, or any other kind of "ist" who is schooled and trained in this, or some other related, area. And unlike you, Absolutely, I don't try to come across as the "absolute" expert in EVERY FRIGGIN' FIELD. What you (and I) really know about this, you could shove into a thimble, and it would rattle like a bee bee in a boxcar. That's probably the biggest reason I find you so distasteful. You're such a friggin' know-it-all. You're a legend in your own mind. Yet you post messages in this stupid discussion forum. Yea, right.
Let's see. On one hand I could "believe" the know-it-all Absolutely. On the other hand, I could believe Richard Lindzen, atmospheric physicist and a professor of meteorology at MIT.
http://www.opinionjournal.com/extra/?id=110008220
You lose.
----------
Edited to correct a mistake. Thanks to the Phred Phlinstone for pointing that out.
by ar-15
I think you are misrepresenting the facts.
I believe you are referring to Peak Oil, which is not running out of all oil (that would be close to impossible-not all oil is economically or ecologically recoverable), but reaching the half-way point of all recoverable oil. After this peak oil prices begin to rise irreversibly until reserves are rapidly exhausted. Hubbert predicted the U.S. would reach peak oil in ~1975, and he was right.
Others have taken his methodology and applied it to global peak oil which will only be known in hindsight, but many believe it occured last year (2005).
There's plenty of information about those 1970s predictions if a person cares to do a little research. And I even remember them; I was there. Just like I remember the "global cooling" warnings.
The reason the predictions didn't materialize was that they were based on the known oil reserves at the time using the current-day methods and costs of extraction. The predictions didn't factor in any newly discovered oil reserves and newly developed technologies (see note below). Moreover, what might have been cost prohibitive to extract in 1970, is more economically feasible today.
I'm a firm believer that tomorrow's problems will be solved with tomorrow's technology. In 1900, for example, one of the big debates was what to do about all the horse crap in the streets. What will happen in 30 years, they asked, when there are even more people and more horses? Well, the problem took care of itself, didn't it?
You doom-and-gloom people just amaze me.
Note: Mexico discovered another huge reserve just this year. And extraction techniques are getting better and more cost effective all the time.
by ar-15
I don't quite understand your angst at those working to make civilization sustainable on this planet.
Ultimately, it is getting people like you to look into the nature of the problems facing mankind that is most important right now. Denial is not serving civilization well.
Fortunately it appears that activism and awareness on this front is gaining traction and will hopefully achieve critical mass, but this planet needs people like you to take an intellectually honest look at yourself and the choices you make in light of the current prognosis that there IS a problem (scope and scale can be argued), but there is a problem.
The truly conservative approach would be to embrace the Precautionary Principle with regard to any potential problem. But not in the U.S.A... we remain commited to our blind adherence to business as usual.
No, I don't own an SUV. I do, however, have an old pickup that I drive on occasion. Yes, I do have kids. Well, one from a previous life who's on his own, and a teenager at home.
You said, [i]"...make civilization sustainable on this planet."[/i]
Well, personally, I don't think civilization is doomed. In fact, I don't think that the .000099 percent increase in greenhouse gasses (as related to parts per million) is capable of changing a thing. And it's that kind of dire, doom and gloom prediction that's misleading people.
You said, [i]"Ultimately, it is getting people like you to look into the nature of the problems facing mankind that is most important right now. Denial is not serving civilization well."[/i]
I think the nature of the problem facing mankind is misinformation and false information. You are the one in denial, not me.
You said, [i]"Fortunately it appears that activism and awareness on this front is gaining traction and will hopefully achieve critical mass..."[/i].
Actually, it's the other way around. Fewer people today believe that human activity is causing global warming than did just a few years ago. (Maybe people really ARE listening to me!)
You said, [i]"....but this planet needs people like you to take an intellectually honest look at yourself and the choices you make...."[/i].
That's exactly what I'm doing. If you think otherwise, you don't know me. In fact, I don't recall a single dialogue between us. How can you possibly know what I've done, what kind of research I've done, and what kind of "intellectual thought" I've given this issue? You don't. Personally, I've probably given it more thought than most people who just blindly follow the pack. I think it's time for people like you to question what you're being spoon-fed.
You said, [i]"....in light of the current prognosis that there IS a problem (scope and scale can be argued), but there is a problem."[/i]
I don't think that the .000099 percent increase in greenhouse gasses (as related to parts per million) is a problem. I think you are being duped.
You said, [i]"The truly conservative approach would be to embrace the Precautionary Principle with regard to any potential problem."[/i]
I am applying the Precautionary Principle. If we were to go along with the U.N. zealots, and follow the desires of extreme environmental activists, and sign on to the Kyoto Treaty, the consequences are unacceptable to me. I am EXTREMELY precautionary when it comes to blindly following these global-warming wackos who try to spoon-feed fear into everyone. Get a grip, man.
You said, [i]"But not in the U.S.A... we remain committed to our blind adherence to business as usual."[/i]
Yep, just as I thought. You're another "blame America first" kinda' guy. Well, I'm not.
I think you're the problem.
by ar-15
What are you saying?
Liberal courts!?! The current President was not originally elected into office, but was installed by a 5-4 decision in the U.S. Supreme Court.
Rules and Regulations are based on the rule of law. It sounds like you swallowed the "Activist Judges" talking point-- hook line and sinker.
Regarding markets... I assume you are referring to "Free Markets". Unfortunately they only exist in economic textbooks. For a market to be truly free all costs of goods and services have to be accounted for... the environmental costs (trillions) of our so called "Free" market remain off the books and therefore we cannot rely on them to solve our most important problems.
Is it the liberals taking away freedoms or the conservatives--hard to tell really.
I hear you about arming yourself to the teeth. If I'm around when the shit hits the fan, I will be looking out for all the Cornucopians who thought the world could go on with business as usual forever and who are armed and looking to take from others what they can't supply for themselves, now that their basement/bunker is depleted of stores.
Liberals need to co-opt the tactics of the opposition and begin to use force. It is a catch-22, but intolerance needs to be met with intolerance.
You said, [i]"Liberal Courts!?! The current President was not originally elected into office, but was installed by a 5-4 decision in the U.S. Supreme Court.[/i]"
What kind of misstatement is that? (Do we really have to debate this yet AGAIN?) The U.S. Supreme Court only overturned a lower Florida court's ruling. And the U.S. Supreme Court voted 7-2 that the Florida Court overstepped their boundaries by ordering a recount. The 5-4 vote was a second decision that asked for a recount.
You said, [i]"Rules and Regulations are based on the rule of law. It sounds like you swallowed the "Activist Judges" talking point-- hook line and sinker."[/i]
I suppose, in this case, those [i]activist judges[/i] would be the seven in Florida who ignored Florida's established [i]rule of law[/i] by ordering a recount even though the law of the land was quite clearly against it.
You said, [i]"Regarding markets... I assume you are referring to "Free Markets". Unfortunately they only exist in economic textbooks. For a market to be truly free all costs of goods and services have to be accounted for... the environmental costs (trillions) of our so called "Free" market remain off the books and therefore we cannot rely on them to solve our most important problems."[/i]
B.S.
You asked, [i]Is it the liberals taking away freedoms or the conservatives--hard to tell really."[/i]
I kind of agree with you on that one. You have to hold on to your wallet in both cases, or else they'll take the liberty to take your liberty by taking liberties with your property (money).
Having to wear a snorkel parka in mid june.
Sand bags in front of his bedroom window.
Islam becoming the dominant religion in the mid west through the bedouin tradition of hospitality.
by ar-15
I am not aware of any SCIENTIFIC claims as you have suggested... I am aware of the research of Dr. M. King Hubbert, Geophysicist. I have already summarized his work which you have not refuted. Google him to do some more research on this subject.
See also the research of Dr. Al Bartlett, Physicist, on exponential growth.
www.npg.org/specialreports/bartlett_index.htm
Listen, this is not rocket science, you seem like a relatively bright person, look into it.
So let's say you're right and we do not need to worry about the quantity of oil available to us for use as fuel and raw materials. If we were to continue mankind's rate of consumption growth of these fuels, we are looking at exponential growth in the amount of CO2 emission and thusly global warming.
You keep mentioning 1 deg. temperature increase as if that's the point. It's not. This is a straw man argument, because it is the rate of growth in CO2 emissions and therefore the coupled rate of growth in global mean temperature that are the issue here. Get it?
Mentioning a 1900's issue with horse crap is also a straw man argument and a bit of a red herring.
The straw man argument is quite in vogue these days with the conservative movement, unfortunately it only destroys any intellectual credibility right-wingers may have had.
I really do not have the time to fully educate you on this subject as I am working on solutions. If you have an open mind you can figure this out for yourself.
Baiting people into your cynical idea of a debate solves nothing.
"....But there is a more sinister side to this feeding frenzy. Scientists who dissent from the (global arming) alarmism have seen their grant funds disappear, their work derided, and themselves libeled as industry stooges, scientific hacks or worse. Consequently, lies about climate change gain credence even when they fly in the face of the science that supposedly is their basis.....So how is it that we don't have more scientists speaking up about this junk science? It's my belief that many scientists have been cowed not merely by money but by fear. An example:....Sadly, this is only the tip of a non-melting iceberg. In Europe, Henk Tennekes was dismissed as research director of the Royal Dutch Meteorological Society after questioning the scientific underpinnings of global warming. Aksel Winn-Nielsen, former director of the U.N.'s World Meteorological Organization, was tarred by Bert Bolin, first head of the IPCC, as a tool of the coal industry for questioning climate alarmism. Respected Italian professors Alfonso Sutera and Antonio Speranza disappeared from the debate in 1991, apparently losing climate-research funding for raising questions...."
http://www.opinionjournal.com/extra/?id=110008220
I am on a NEW mission. To CONVERT as many global-warming believers as possible. You have been consumed by the dark side. Man-Caused Global Warming is a farce! A .000099 increase in CO2 levels as measured in parts per million IS NOTHING!
Neil, YOU HAVE BEEN DUPED!
by deepsand
by ar-15
What else could it be?
Maxwell sees it as a fight for control of the planet. The environmental religious zealots are trying to take control away from reasonable people like Maxwell.
It has nothing to do with facts because facts are relative and we truly can't know anything.
I'm out. Good luck discerning the nature of reality with Maxwell!
by ar-15
Maxwell,
What are you afraid of? You could change a few words in your last post and aptly describe your own cause.
What are you some kind of twisted nihilist?
by deepsand
by deepsand
to global warming currently being experienced?
If you allow that his actions [b]can[/b] contibute, then you have also allowed that the probability of his being presently culpable is [b]greater then 0%[/b].
This brings us back to the question as to what threshold of probability is required before one seeks to, in this case, reduce his influence on the climate.
by ar-15
Maxwell,
You made up your mind on this topic a long time ago and seek only to shore up your position which appears to be based in your conservative ideology. Ironically, this is what you are assuming that the other side is doing with their ideologies.
This would be funny if it wasn't so sad.
There appears to be no point in arguing with you or the others here who share your mind set and apriori approach to pseudo-science.
by tonythetiger
by jdclyde
you came here to "argue" instead of discuss.
You have made your statements, just like Max did. The fact that neither of you repented to the other just means that either both "sides" are correct, one side is not being accurately portraid, neither of you was even listening to what the other said, or a combination of all of the above.
You have clearly with your wording of "apriori approach to pseudo-science" have shown that you have ALSO made up your mind long ago.
Your right about something, that this is sad. Sad to stand there and do the exact thing your trying to berate Max for doing.
by tonythetiger
by deepsand
by tonythetiger
Some people are pre-disposed, others are resistant. Some people seem to never get sick no matter what they are exposed to. Medical science still has a long way to go. Most of the time they only treat symptoms.
Wouldn't it be great for them to discover why it is that those people who never seem to get sick are the way they are, so they could reproduce that trait in everyone? Do you think they would? (I mean, it might cost them or their profession some future business.)
by deepsand
I.e., what cause & effect mechanism(s) has(have) been identified?
And, for said mechanism(s):
1) Is smoking [i]necessary[/i] in order to contract that particular type of cancer?
2) Is smoking [i]sufficient[/i] to cause that particular type of cancer?
3) What is(are) the [i]likelihood(s)[/i] that a smoker will develop cancer from said mechanism(s)?
The point here is that while it is now generally accepted that smoking cause cancer, there is still no "proof positive," of the sort that would here seem to be satisfatory to either you or Max with regards to the cause(s) of global warming.
Still, you have accepted that smoking [b]does[/b] cause cancer!
by ar-15
Deep you got the point.
It's amazing how so many people can miss the point.
The Cornucopians assume that there is no rate of change in either environmental forcings or resource depletion that can outpace technology's ability to maintain the status quo.
Hmmmm... WHAT IF THEY ARE WRONG? What then?
Believe me, I am not a luddite. I have great faith in our ability to apply scientific understanding to social problems (aka technology).
Here's the nut of the problem in my view. If those calling for the reforming of man's impact on the planet are wrong, what have we lost as a society? Not much because sustainability is a principle that makes sense--basically live within your means--it's that simple.
If those calling for business as usual are wrong, what have we lost as a civilization? Many human lives and other life sustaining species--and perhaps the end of civilization as we know it.
So which general path should we take:
The blind adherence to the status quo or the path of precaution due to what is potentially at stake?
...is your lies and misrepresentations.
You said, [i]"....it has no bearing on today's problem with exponential growth in CO2 (a known greenhouse gas) emissions."[/i]
1750: Before Industrial Revolution, atmosphere holds 280 parts per million of heat-trapping carbon dioxide, later research determines.
(Disclaimer: IF they can even measure it accurately.)
-- 2004: Carbon dioxide reaches record 379 parts per million;
From 280 ppm to 379 ppm.
How do you get [i]"exponential"[/i] from that?
That's an increase of what, around 30 percent, or 1.35 times? That's hardly [i]"exponential"[/i].
Actually, as relative to parts per million, it's only an increase of a very insignificant .000099 percent.
And you wonder why I think people like you are delusional.
....borders on criminal.
"Exponential"? Do you retract that lie?
by deepsand
Max and I have crossed paths before, most notably at the discussion re. SUVs that I referenced in an earlier post here.
He is, in kind, no different than the religious zealots who gave us so much cause for amusement at "The Evolution Lie," affectionately known as "EL."
If you've plenty of bandwidth & RAM, a fast CPU, and time to kill, you may wish to grab some chuckles there. It can be found at
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=165453&start=0
Enjoy.
by tonythetiger
has been pretty constant (plus or minus a few percent) for the past several million years at least. What caused the several warming periods during the past, say, half million years or so (Please reference http://www.daviesand.com/Choices/Precautionary_Planning/New_Data/ )
I'm not denying, I just think the evidence is a lot thinner than mainstream science is letting on.
by deepsand
You're [i]assuming[/i] the reason that he's given up debating with you.
I could make the same assumption re. your dropping our earlier threads!
You don't get to change the rules of engagement so as to suit your momentary purposes.
by tonythetiger
don't think ANY data is irrelevant! I just don't agree that it means what some others think it means.
Global temperatures, as recently as 125,000 years ago, were higher than they are today. CO2 levels were nearly as high. All without SUVs and concrete plants. How is a person to believe that humans were not the cause back then, but they are now?
by deepsand
by absolutely
C*e^t
Exponential growth refers to the rate of growth of a population [b]relative to its previous population[/b] not relative to another population. The rate of increase of CO2 [b]relative to previous QUANTITIES, not proportions, of CO2[/b] in the atmosphere, has been approximately exponential. Our new contributor was [b]absolutely[/b] correct to use the word "exponential" to describe the mathematical equation that best fits the pattern of CO2's increase [b]during the Industrial period of human history[/b]. I capitalize "Industrial" because it's better than what preceded it. But it is also imperfect.
by absolutely
adunlap: "Since previous global warmings occurred without man being present, we cannot determine the probability that this episode of global warming is different than all of the previous episodes."
Previous global warmings occurred as results of known causes, including massive volcanic activity, as described by another contributor to this thread. We [b]know[/b] that no volcanic activity in our era is comparable to that, and that none of the other causes of other warming periods applies to the present case of global warming. In the absence of any of the factors known to have caused global warming in the past, [b]the[/b] logical conclusion is that the present warming trend is explained by the single variable that was absent in all previous warming periods: human industry.
by tonythetiger
No, I am not claiming that man has no influence, only that the existing evidence is not enough to convince me that man is the major cause. He wasn't the major cause 500,000 years ago, or 375,000 years ago, or 250,000 years ago, or 125,000 years ago, all times in the past when both the average global temperature and the CO2 concentration spiked. I'm just suggesting that maybe the cause of the current spikes is the same as the cause of the previous ones. I don't think it's unreasonable.
Oh, and I've sought to reduce my impact on the environment since before most people have even heard of global warming.
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
by absolutely
What accounts for the discrepancy?
The discrepancy I mean is: if, 125,000 years ago, there was ALMOST as much atmospheric CO2, but not quite as much, why was temperature HIGHER? Possibly, the present CO2 levels haven't finished doing their work, and unless they are reduced to LESS than the levels of 125,000 years ago, tomorrow's temperatures will also be higher than the temperatures 125,000 years ago. In short, I challenge you, adunlap, to explain why, 125,000 years ago, CO2 levels were lower than today, but temperatures were higher. The information I quoted in this title suggests to me that we can expect further temperature increases.
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
in [b]some[/b] (maybe even [b]most[/b]) people who smoke.
The evidence of smoking causing cancer is a lot more substantial than the evidence that man causes global warming. I don't need "positive proof". I would settle for a 51% likelihood.
From American Heritage Dictionary
[b]Exponential:[/b] [i]1. Of or relating to an exponent. 2. Expressed in terms of a designated power of e, the base of natural logarithms.[/i]
[b]Exponent:[/b] [i]A number or symbol, as 3 in (x + y)3, placed to the right of and above another number, symbol, or expression, denoting the power to which that number, symbol, or expression is to be raised. Also called power.[/i]
[b]Example:[/b] Absolutely is ridiculous to the 10th power. Absolutely, it seems, gets exponentially more ridiculous every day.
You have a serious problem, Mr. know-it-all.
Sort by Trending