Discussion Locked

What is the purpose of setting a minimum wage?

0 helpful
323 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

(This is an offshoot of the "How can American IT Professionals Compete with asian workers?" discussion)

And how is it determined?

For what area is it determined? Some places cost more to live than others (sometimes even within the same city), so what do you do? Set it to be minimum for the 'cheapest to live in' place and let those in more expensive places suffer? or set it for the most expensive place, and give those who live in cheaper places a windfall? or do you tell people they can't live in certain places where the cost is too high?

And who do you set it for? Do you set it to suit a single young man? a married couple, no children, both work? a maried couple, two children, one works? a single mother who has to pay a baby sitter? (and does the babysitter get minimum wage too?) or do you have different minimum wages for different people in different circumstances?

And how are businesses supposed to pay for it (especially small businesses)? Does he raise his prices? Lay off some workers? And if he raises prices, doesn't that defeat the purpose? Soon prices on everything will be higher and the new minimum wage will have the same purchasing power as the old one does now, wouldn't it?

And finally is there anyone else who has thought all of these things through?

323 replies

by mjwx

In my definition, to ensure that every person can earn enough money to meet the minimum standards of living. To ensure that each person working can afford, food, housing and utilities (power, water, etc). The second purpose is to stop exploitation of workers by unscrupulous employers.

I then decided to look it up.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minimum_wage

How it is decided, in Australia it is based on the Cost of Living.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_living
I am not too well versed in specifics of the minimum wage is decided for families but I should be as our benevolent leader John Howard is slowly striping away workers rights .

I'm not sure which side of the argument you are on but the minimum wage has supporters and detractors and Max you may call me a socialist if you wish but the minimum wage is good as it prevents some businesses from exploiting under skilled or young workers (16-25). By exploitation I mean paying the workers less and forcing them to work longer hours so they can earn enough to pay all of their bills.

I'm sure we've all heard the stories of the slave labour factories in China I believe the minimum wage and other labour laws such as the work safety and fixing the hours in the work week (40 hours plus overtime) help protect people from working in sweat shop type conditions.

However Tony I am interested in hearing your perspectives on why the minimum wage is good or bad.

by too old for it

The problem is that, as many small businessmen continue to pointout to me, there are some people whose labor is not worth the minimum wage.

by jaqui

usually.

the purpose is to make sure that people working full time make enough to buy the basic requirements for life, food, shelter, clothing.
everything else is a luxury for their calculations.

I actually talked with an MLA for here [ MLA = Member of the Legistative Assembly ] about minimum wages. We have had one in place here for years, wich even full time work at it leaves the employee making 800 / month less than the poverty line. most minimum wage jobs do not offer any benefits either, so medical / dental etc is out of the question for these people.

in my discussion with the MLA, I said clearly that the government has to offer these services to everyone, or force all employers to have benefits, since raising the minimum wage has the obvious issue of reducing employee numbers or bankrupting small businesses.

the best way for any level of Government to boost the wages being paid is to make the tax environment conducive to business, the more businesses that are looking for people the better wages they have to offer to get people.

right now, because of the 2010 winter olympic games coming here, I have heard that even places like McDonalds are offing a $10.00/hr starting wage, the minimum is $8.00/hr, after 500 hours it's $6.00/hr before then if an employer doesn't want to pay the full minimum until the three month trial/grace period is over.

Construction companies around here right now are offering $22.00/hr+ for unskilled labour, they are that desparate for bodies. The people leaving fairly good jobs to get the higher pay are making all industries re-examine their pay scales to a certain extent, there are enough jobs that every company is hiring here.

but like I said, it's only because of the construction boom for the 2010 winter olympics, once the construction is over I expect the economy to nose dive until the games themselves, then the hospitality and Tourism sector will be booming for that period. then most likely, a local depression economically.

by jdclyde

It covers places like your burger joints, where the worker walks in off the street with no skills to offer.

Many of your small businesses do not have to follow this, depending on the size of the company.

Because this is the pay scale for jobs such as this, the cost of raising a family is not a consideration. If you wish to have a family, you need to get some kind of skill or find a shop that pays for manual laborers.

No one is told they can't live somewhere, the fair housing bill ensures that. You have a right to live anywhere that you can afford. You do NOT have a right to live anywhere you can not afford. It is not a matter of "fair", it is a matter of earning what you get. Just like you don't have a "right" to drive a fancy car, you EARN money if you want a car.

When the minimum wage is increased, it is a direct assult on middle class America. People that are in the middle class bracket do NOT work for minimum wage, and it has no basis for their pay so when the rate goes up, middle class does not get that same pay increase. On the other hand, basic goods, such as your burger have gone up increasing your cost of living.

When your costs go up, but your pay doesn't, that is the same affect as a pay cut.

So who is it really that has it in for middle class America, Democrats or Republicans?

Who is it that thinks "living wages" should be mandated for people that don't have the skills to be worth that much, doing a job that again is not worth that much?

Democrats sure are generous and caring, when they are using someone elses money.

by absolutely

Well done, you're right! Well, mostly:

"So who is it really that has it in for middle class America, Democrats or Republicans?"

Both have it in for the middle class, but the socialist wing of the Democrats are such a bunch of pantywaste sissy girls, they're attacking the working poor instead of the middle class. Explanation below.

by tonythetiger

The typical hype is that minimum wage has not risen in xx years... the implication being that all of these poor people have been working at their same jobs for those same xx years without an increase. That implication is false. These minimum wage jobs are typically entry level jobs... and someone who has half an ounce of ambition is not going to be working there very long, unless another in the family is the primary wage earner, and you're just working to have something to do.

That brings up something else... Shouldn't we feel ashamed if our spouse works and doesn't really need to? I mean, as long as there is one unemployed person, shouldn't it be against the law or something?

by jamesrl

If your spouse works, it isn't necessarily true that there are unemployed people waiting around who could step into that position.

Furthermore families with 2 incomes spend more, which in turn creates more jobs. How many more jobs in daycare, fast food etc are created simply because there are more 2 income families? How many more cars, major appliances are built because 2 income families have more disposable income?

My wife can't work due to medical issues. Its tough making a good wage but still struggling - telling the kids we can't afford to do the things their friends do, even when daddy makes a good wage. But I can't be bitter.

If you inherit a fortune, in other words, have more money than you would spend, then perhaps you should feel ashamed for taking a position that someone else could do. But I wouldnt leap from that to a law.

James

by jdclyde

I think that should be criminal, provided the family can get along nicely without that second income.

Even though I didn't make a lot back then (shoprat), I had the ex-wife stay at home with the boys because them getting a good start on life was more important than some extra cash to buy toys with.

On the other hand, after the kids are in school, knock yourself out. Even if it is just as a hobby, provided it is not harming your children, I would never say someone SHOULDN'T work if they don't have to. You can work because you WANT to, but put your kids first.

by absolutely

"Shouldn't we feel ashamed if our spouse works and doesn't really need to? I mean, as long as there is one unemployed person, shouldn't it be against the law or something?"

Who is too pathetic to compete in a free labor market, meaning one in which people are allowed to work if they [i]want[/i] to earn more money than they already have? You are DISGUSTING!

by absolutely

Minimum wages are never enough to support a family, and studies show that they tend to benefit mostly children who still live with their parents, whose income is entirely disposable. The true "working poor" tend to work for jobs that pay slightly more than minimum wage, and which are not entirely unskilled. But as a result of paying high school brats more than they're worth, to flip burgers and do other zero skill jobs, the [b]real workers[/b] suffer in the labor market because the interaction of the market forces called "supply" and "demand" are truly governed by a "law" of human nature. The Soviet Union managed to violate this law for 80 years - not forever! - before going bankrupt. When minimum wage laws violate the law of supply and demand, the price is paid by the rest of the workforce, who must be paid [b]less[/b] than we're worth so the aforementioned high school brats can be paid [b]more[/b] than they're worth.

I'm aware that the preceding hasn't been stated "nicely". But it is correct, and if you would like me to state facts more kindly, you must pay me more.

by absolutely

As I said above, when more money is paid to people than they deserve, the entire labor market suffers. What I intended to emphasize, but forgot, is that those who are [b]most[/b] harmed by minimum wage laws are those whose skills are truly [b]worth[/b] only slightly more than the minimum wage, simply because they can least afford the negative effect on wages that the existence of a minimum wage has on every job that pays more than the value set as minimum.

Consider this:

Joe McTrustfund comes from a rich family, and has never learned how to do anything right. At age 16, after crashing the third of Daddy's Vettes, Daddy decides Joe isn't worth his allowance any longer. So, Joe goes to a local fast food joint and completes an application. He has no initiative and no skills of any kind, and we assume for the sake of this discussion that his ability to obey is worth $3/day on the free market. Because he lives in Oregon, minimum wage laws dictate that we pay him about 32 times that, for an eight hour shift. Those $61 dollars that are paid to him instead of to somebody who would produce more for the same amount of money have [b]been stolen from the community[/b]. Most importantly, they have been stolen from other workers who [b]do[/b] have the skills & initiative to keep the same fast food joint working better, with half as many workers, who are only paid slightly more per person, suppose 75% total labor cost. Minimum wage laws punish all industrious workers in favor of lazy ones, but they punish poor, entry level industrious workers worst of all.

However benevolent you wish to proclaim your motives for supporting minimum wages, their effect is not beneficial. When you study the real effects of minimum wage laws on real people in the real world, you cannot support minimum wages unless you hate the poor who strive to better ourselves.

by jdclyde

The work market does determine the worth of a worker based on both the value of the work provided AND how many people want that job. The more people applying for a job, the less an employer has to pay to fill it.

Last week on the way back from Detroit, the tacobell had stickers taking up most of the window advertising for help wanted, paying $7.50. Where is a good "undocumented worker" when you need one to fill a job americans are too lazy to do?

And yes, the fact that the poor poor DON'T WORK FOR MINIMUM WAGE shows the lack of logic and reasoning by the supporters of higher minimum wages.

Think people. Now is a good time to start.

by shellbot

basic economics 101

min wage shouldn't be "high", but enough to stop exploitation.

i was gonna start something with ya..but i too tired :)

:x

by deadly ernest

It is a figure, set by government, for the whole of its area of jurisdiction, based on the average minimum living costs for the same area above. It incorporates a lot of things, and is meant to relate to a single person, not a married couple or a family. In every case studied, so far, it's more than sufficient to live on, and keep people out of poverty.

The reason for basing it on a single person, is a couple has double the income- as they are both expected to work until they one gets a better job and they can afford to have kids on that one income. Married single income families are usually provided with extra assistance via the tax system. Here in Australia, a person with dependents, usually, gets tax cuts - I say usually because this doesn' apply to a divorced person paying child support where the courts have given custody to the other parent, you can only claim deductions for the period the child is with you, yet you pay for the whole year.

Here in Australia we have had it for many decades and it does work. At the moment there is much arguement about work relations laws and their effect on this and the economy. Much of what is in the media about this issue is lies, generated from improperly used statistics.

A very related issue to the minimum wage is poverty. However, for the last 25 years social engineers have been falsifying the placement of the poverty line, to such an extent that it is now seen as a totally seperate entity that has absolutely nothing to do with poverty by any real, or rational, economists.

By the dictionary, poverty is the state of being poor or deficient - nothing about being unable to survive as poverty is a relative thing.

Economically, poverty is seen as being the state where you are too poor to be able to pay for basic housing, basic clothes, and enough food to live on. Essential, you're starving.

The wikepedia articles, I just read 15.29 AEST 4 Oct 2006, below are fairly good general statements on this issue.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty_level

The modern poverty line used by community social welfare change organisations is usually based on a relationship to the average wage of a society, not the ability to survive in the society. Here in Australia, an organisation, ACOSS, often claims people on the basic unemployment payment are below the poverty line. yet all these poverty stricken people get enogh government benefits to afford alcohol, tobacco, drugs, gambling, and new electrical good on a regular basis. I've spent some years on the same benefits and afforded to replace my computer. while on the benefits. Most people that ACOSS claims are below the poverty line, spend a lot of time eating fast food, and otherwise wasting money in many ways. In the last 40 years, the only people, in Australia, that have been shown to be so poverty stricken as to be starving, have been that way because of their own decisions - they choose to spend the money on other things, like booze, drugs etc, or they choose not to register for government benefits - for personal reasons.

I'm sure that many out there will disagree with the above, but I've lived on welfare, and know thousands who have, or are, and everyone managed well, except where they wasted their money.

by jaqui

right here in Vancouver BC the $8.00/hr minimum wage has people living BELOW the poverty line.

labour laws: full time hours are 7.5 a day

there are on average 22 days worked per month

this gives to a goss monthly income of $1,320.00
minus the 17% taxes and other with holdings -$224.40 giving a net income of $1,095.60

rent, bachelor apartment for this area is $950.00/mo
power is $25.00/mo
food, shopping at cheapest stores around and buying to extend money will run you $200.00 or so.
if you need to take any form of public transporation to get to work, you are looking at a minimum cost of $78.00/mo
laundry, in facility in residential building,
wash $1-2.00/load
dry $1-2.00/load
figure you'll have to do laundry of two loads a week minimum.

telephone, basic $36.00/mo - no long distance calls or it's more, no call features or it's more.

cable, basic, no extra channels $24.95/mo

no internet, since you really can't afford it.

that gives you a total expense of $1,319.95
okay, definately don't have that do we, so take out cable and phone, kill the transit so you are using feet or bycycle, leave expenses at $1,181.00
hmm still more than is made. ok , kill the groceries to be only $85.40 a month, now you broke even, but are starving to death, no entertainment, no means of contact with the world and you have to live like a hermit in your place.

bare cost of living for this area is placed at a take home income of $1800.00/mo
that is the official poverty line.

minimum wages aren't meant to stop you from being poor, or poverty ridden, only to make sure you have a place to live.

by deadly ernest

but I've ssen these same sets of figures for Sydney Australia, where I grew up. The biggest issue with them is looking at the quality of the items concerned, and how you go about living.

Minimum wage, welfare, etc are calculated on the minimum BASIC needs. A bachelor apartment is NOT minimumbasic needs. A dorm bed, or a room, at the YMCA is. Wash and dry at $1.20 a load, why pay?

Over the years I've lived on basic wage, I've lived on welfare (which is lower than MW down under), I've also survived on no income. How much you spend on accommodation and food is very much a choice thing.

At one time in my life, ACOSS (the premier Aust organisation that lobbies for increases in upping MW, welfare and other social welfare agendas) put out figures for what it cost to live at the poverty line in the very suburb I was living at the time. I was working, running a car, living by myself, eating reasonably well, and putting money in the bank. Adding up all my living expenses, I found out that I was living quite well for only 75% of what ACOSS set as the poverty line for my suburb.

I checked where they got their figures, seems they felt the housing costs had to be based on living in a house or two bedroom flat, food was based on eating out twice a week, and using a lot of prepackaged food, etc. Just by living in a bed-sit, hand washing in the bathroom sink, with it drip drying over the bath each day, and cooking meals from scratch, I was undercutting their figures by huge margins. All these matters are personal choice. I chose a bed-sit over a nice apartment or flat or house. I chose to do my own wash, instead of machine it. I chose to cook meals from raw ingredients than buy microwave dinners or frozen foods for reheating - again personal choices.

When official poverty line figures are produced you have to look at the fine details of what they're using to calculate them.

If you're under the poverty line, you should be starving, yet the only people starving in Australia, are those that choose to spend there money on drugs or alcohol, or (more commonly) the kids of parents who choose to buy drugs and alcohol over food for their kids.

Here in Aust, if you handle your money carefully, you can live on minimum wage, and even put some in the bank, I know, I did it when I first moved out from home. I didn't live in a nice apartments, but the YMCA was acceptable and more sociable than any apartment I've lived in since.

Accommodation costs is a very tricky issue. I've seen suburbs where the lowest renatl is higher than the highest in the next suburb. I've lived in places where by paying an extra $0.25 per day on the train, I go one extra station, and save $80 per week on the rental of a two bedroom flat of the same size.

A very close examination and review of the situation in Vancouver may find that the people calculating the PL figure need to review the standards they are using, or the minimum wage figure may need adjusting - I don't live there, so I can't give an exact answer.

by absolutely

Any claim that a topic is too complex to summarize leads me to suspect that you're trying to hide something from me, by using a lot of words while saying nothing, hoping that I'll bore of you and concede the point. While I am quite bored by claims that the [i]effects[/i] of socialism can be justified by benevolent [i]intentions[/i], I will not concede the point. Just as a tree is known by its fruits, socialism is known to be [b][i]evil![/i][/b]

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=201870&messageID=2104332

by deadly ernest

saying it was too complex to give a full detailed account here. In doing so, I left out huge chunks of detail, and related aspects. If you'd bothered to read the post, and my others on this issue, I think you'll find we're in agreement - that this is a social engineering thing that is manipulated to the detriment of society.

We have a problem in modern society, in that it is no longer possible to obtain a block of land, and grow what you need to survive. Taxes, govt charges, fed / state / local, ensure this is not possible. Nor will society allow that these people be left to starve to death. So some thing must be done.

MW is one attempt, Workhouses for the poor was another. Not a simple issue since it involves the whole social spectrum to cover fully.

by jeffykins

My Dear Tony,

In some countries that work on a more "purely" socialized basis, the minimum wage may indeed be intended and work to keep people out of poverty.

Here in the U.S., no such thing.

As mentioned before, the vast majority of people actually making the minimum wage are no-skill kids slacking through their summer jobs.

When I was a teenager, I don't think I ever worked for the minimum wage (though I did, at a camp, work for less).

Even worse, there are some people trying to raise a family with 1 minimum-wage earner. A very bad idea, I'm sure. Like trying to go up a steep hill in a very small car with an automatic.

But, NO-ONE has mentioned the REAL reason why the U.S. minimum wage goes up every once in a while: because of the tens of millions of UNION workers whose contracts are, in fine print, tied to the minimum wage.

Please don't ask me why a teacher or pipefitter or longshoreman earning upwards of $50K should get a raise when the minimum wage goes up, but they do.

The politicians know that they will "give" all these millions of workers a raise when they just raise the minimum wage. That's why, BTW, a raise of the minimum wage has such a huge impact on inflation.

The wage raise is quickly eaten up by inflation, leaving the politicians the only ones who really benefit from it. As usual, small business owners are left carrying their bag (full of poop).

by tony hopkinson

To differentiate between working and welfare.
Leave minimum wage to the market and the tax payer foots the bill in taxes. Set one and the consumer pays the bill.
In a competive market, increased salary does not increase prices, it increases value for money, employee investment and efficeiency, it may cut profits initially, but nobody who wants their people to work in poverty while they own an island doesn't deserve to be in business anyway.

It will be slightly different because of your employment law, but all the UK business types who said minimum wage would cut jobs have been proved very wrong.
Any who say they would have employed more people are lying, the administrative cost of an employee is pretty much fixed.

by shellbot

well, in real life terms, for the average joe, min wage is a good thing.

Not so long ago..8 years ago, i worked 2 part time jobs that payed min wage (in canada), and my ex had a full time job paying slightly above min wage. We had a child to feed, bills to pay, etc etc.

If there had not be min wage and we would have had to work for even less money, i would have had to have 3 jobs to put food on the table.

There is the considerations to small business' however, i rememeber when min wage was increased by a few cents once, and my ex's employer screamed holy murder about laying off people and what not..then proceeded to buy a new SUV.
So really, if you cannot afford to pay your staff a bare minimum, then move on.

Also, when i first moved to Ireland, there was no min wage. They brought one in and all employers cried they would be out of business..i'm sure maybe a few did..but almost all seemed to be OK, they just made a bit less profit in the end.

Ever worked for 1.50 an hour? (in this day and age, i don't mean in 1942)
I have, 4 years ago..10 hour days..but generally only got paid for 8 hours. See, because i couldn't legally work in Ireland, i had to work for cash..that was the going rate.

Not fun. Now i know not all business people are money hungry, in fact i know a lot who are the opposite. But come on, if you expect these people to work for YOU so YOU can make a profit at least pay the min wage so they can feed thier families.

Not everyone is university/college material. Sadly, plenty of people just never get the chance to get educated, and if they are hard working decent people flipping a burger to pay the bills, then fair enough, they deserve to be rewarded for thier work regardless of thier social standing.

by deadly ernest

Sorry if I seem over polite, but I agre so much with your final paragraph, that I feel the need to cheer you on.

I never made university out of school, no free uni in those days, now days it's free - from taxes, and drop out rates are horrendous, costs are outrageous. I finally got a uni degree, some decades later, paying full fees, and studying at night and weekends. But I've spent time on minimum wage, and on unemployment. It's livable, not fun, but livable. Most don't choose to be there, but some are by choice.

by shellbot

:)

I still don't have Uni..I'm working my way up through hard work..but thats my choice..

I don't ever want to be on min wage again.
You are right though, there are plenty of people there by choice. At the end of the day, thats thier problem. I took what little money i had left and saved up for a MS Access course. Took me 4 months to save for the 200 i needed to get started..but look where i am now.

On the other hand, my ex..is currently scheming to get disability pension so he can leave his min wage jobs..he's pushing 40..a min wage lifer and its his own fault

ah..i think if us at TR got toegther, we'd solve all the worlds problems wouldn't we :)

by absolutely

"If there had not be min wage and we would have had to work for even less money, i would have had to have 3 jobs to put food on the table."

Most likely, your ex would have been paid more, except that the existence of an economically false minimum on the pay scale meant that money was diverted from its most productive possible use, to pay that false minimum to workers who would have done the same boring, easy work for less. In fact, you might even have been able to get a better paying job if the lowest end of the pay scale could have been divided into $3, $4, $5, $6, and $7/hr jobs. But the minimum wage forces employers to pay many workers with zero experience, and no proven work ethic, the same as many other workers who have some experience, at least slightly more work ethic, and/or slightly more skills, but no formal education, training, or certificates of any kind.

"Not everyone is university/college material. Sadly, plenty of people just never get the chance to get educated, and if they are hard working decent people flipping a burger to pay the bills, then fair enough, they deserve to be rewarded for thier work regardless of thier social standing."

It may not be easy to explain the dynamics of a complex system like the economy well enough to illustrate why the minimum wage harms the poor more than it hurts anybody else, but I'm willing to keep trying. See, it's only talentless politicians and talentless political commentators who make the argument [i]for[/i] socialist measures, because they don't have any productive ability, but wish to enjoy the luxuries enjoyed by people who have learned to be productive.

by shellbot

but its one thing to understand it, and another to live it..

minimum wage forces employers to pay many workers with zero experience, and no proven work ethic, the same as many other workers who have some experience, at least slightly more work ethic, and/or slightly more skills, but no formal education, training, or certificates of any kind

That was me :)
17 with a 2 year old child..no qualifications, no experience,dropped out of school to look after baby, worked graveyard shift so that i would have my day to look after baby as thats what i was taught good mommies do (and financially if i had to pay for childcare i could't have afforded to be working)..

But ya know what..i worked hard..i knew there was 40 people behind me begging for a job, any job, MY job.. as in Saskatchewan, jobs were not aplenty, and if i didn't work hard i'd lose it. I refused to go on welfare, absolutely refused, the only thing i ever took from welfare was free medicine once for baby, as i could not pay for it. To this day, i would like to give them that 70$ back..this way i owe them nothing!

In 3 months i worked hard enough to be given a slight pay rise, and then another month later i was given assistant supervisor..which gave me a bit more.
and the other job i worked..ahh Tim Hortons..how low can ya go?? What a feeling to get up at 5 am and step into that sh1thole. Again, i worked hard, i smiled the biggest and had the cheeriest Hello..and my bosses noticed, and i climbed ever so slowly up the pay scale..

All the academics and politics in the world don't mean squat when you have to choose between feeding OR buying medicine for your child. I even had a garden..ya at 16 i grew veg and made my own babyfood..

maybe its just my work ethic..i know there are a lot of people who abuse the system and who don't want to work hard, but for those of us who do..we deserve to have a slim chance at bettering ourselves.

by delbertpgh

I worked minimum wage after high school. In rural Colorado, you could get by okay. When I got out of the Air Force, my jobs were close to minimum wage, but I knew I was going to college next, and it seemed okay. When I dropped out of college to support a wife and a baby, I worked for near minimum, lived poor, and knew this was not what I was born to be. So I got out of the trap. Every time a lucky opportunity came by, I was smart enough (and hard enough) to dump everything that was fond and familiar to me (except wife and kids) and make my advantage. Same with the wife. We talk sweet and value kindness, but we've been tough. Tougher than many. If I felt the need to live forever in Craig, Colorado, I'd still be living poor.

I knew a lot of people on the bottom, some of them with very nice hearts, some who had what it takes to climb, and some without it. Some work hard all the time but get lazy or sentimental at the crucial moment, or get drunk and get fired once a year, or just don't have the judgement. A lot of my friends were just dopers who'd never get anywhere except rehab, if they were lucky. The ones who were lazy and no good and had no character were never friends of mine, but they were always around the fringes.

There's a big diverse bunch of people out there. Some of them are just on a short vacation to the low end, and some of them live there forever. I was born richer, and got clear of it. I am not vain enough to say I was born better. The minimum wage made a big difference to me, and it goes on making a difference to good people still. The poor, good and bad, will be with us forever, and they deserve to have a floor under them, beneath which their employers cannot bargain their wages away.

by maxwell edison

Looking at the replies you've received thus far, not one of them provided any facts or reasoning to support their claims or assertions, instead simply repeating the same, tired old nonsense about a person making enough money to live, to support a family, and so on. These sentiments are probably well-intentioned, but they're very misguided.

First of all, let's look at some facts (from the 2004 BLS, Bureau of Labor Statistics):

1. Out of 74 million "hourly workers", only 520,000 are paid the current minimum wage. That's only seven-tenths of one percent.

2. Eighty percent of all minimum wage earners have no dependents.

3. Fifty three percent of all minimum wage earners are between the ages of 16 and 24.

4. Sixty Seven percent of the minimum wage jobs are part-time. (Students, for example, who might live at home with parents or in a dorm paid for by parents.)

5. Other minimum wage workers are retirees, who are also receiving a pension from a previous job and/or Social Security.

6. The average family income of the average minimum wage earner is almost $50,000 per year. (More than the national average.)

7. 1.5 million "hourly workers" are actually paid LESS than the minimum wage (legally), but whose income relies on tips or commissions.

8. Sixty-three percent of workers hired for the minimum wage get raises within the first year.

9. Many minimum wage positions are starter, entry-level, positions, given to people with absolutely no experience, and initially have no value to the employer. Not only is the employer absorbing the cost of training this person, but paying him for an undetermined period of time before this person starts to "earn" anything.

10. We already have a "welfare program" for low-income wage earners, some of whom are families. It's called the Earned Income Tax Credit, through which these people are actually the recipients of taxes rather than the payers of taxes.

I'd challenge anybody to go into any neighborhood McDonalds and inquire about job openings. If a person is breathing, he/she probably qualifies for most positions. And I'd bet a dollar to dirt that the starting wage is higher than the current minimum wage.

So why does the issue of minimum wage often arise? Among other reasons, because anti-free-market activists are hell-bent on controlling more and more of American business; because the usual "do-gooders" falsely believe they are doing some good; because politicians tug on people's emotions in order to gain votes, thereby gaining power; and because union wages are often tied to the minimum wage, thus Labor Unions and Democrats are the usual suspects supporting the measure. A twenty percent increase in the minimum wage, for example, could automatically trigger a twenty percent (or some factor thereof) increase in a person's salary who's making upward of $30 per hour. (And people wonder why Toyota is thriving, while GM, Ford and Chrysler are hemorrhaging money.) But none of the reasons actually produce the results they suggest. It's all a facade. It's all smoke-and-mirrors. It's all irrational and overly-emotional.

The establishment of a minimum wage is not only contrary to the laws of supply and demand in a free-market economy, not to mention a gross infringement on "private business", but is advanced for all the wrong reasons. And those advancing the issue always tug on people's emotional heart-strings, relying on their uninformed and misinformed sense of compassion. And with all such programs, not only do they fail to produce the stated desired end-results, but they are actually doing more harm than good. But as usual, the minimum wage advocates will ignore these facts, and they'll continues to let their emotions trump their reason.

And on it goes.....

by tonythetiger

[i]7. 1.5 million "hourly workers" are actually paid LESS than the minimum wage (legally), but whose income relies on tips or commissions.[/i]

That's often overlooked too. Some of these workers make pretty good tips (My daughter [b]averages[/b] over $200 a night, and some days she makes more than I do!) but not all of them report all of this income (the assumption by the IRS is that tips will roughly equal wages, so that's how much they report). This calls the credibility of the statistics into question.

by rknrlkid

of minimum wage laws. From everything I have ever seen/read/experienced, minimum wage laws are a superficial attempt to redistribute wealth. I think the minimum wage laws are something politicians do to have themselves look effective (without doing anything of substance) and to make them look like they are "for the people." Unfortunately, forced wage levels have historically been bad for both workers and employers. Regretably, the "average" person on the street isn't aware enough of this imposed socialism to make an informed decision.

Here in Oklahoma is case in point. Oklahoma has a depressed economy. This is both good and bad. Its bad because wages are relatively low. But its good, because cost of living is very low. Someone recently sent a letter to the editor asking why Oklahoma sticks with the federal minimum wage when California pays $8.00 an hour for minimum wage. Well, hello.... the cost of living in California is 3 to 4 times more than that of Oklahoma. Other things must be considered besides just dollars in the check. I'll take the lower wage (relatively) in order to be able to afford to buy and pay for my home. I am a native Californian, and I could never afford to own a home there. (My $40,000 home in Oklahoma would easily be a $250,000+ home in California.)

Other people probably brought up similar points. But handicapping free enterprise through socialistic restraints hurts, not helps.

by deadly ernest

this is about the best way to handle this issue.

The very best way of handling tax and minimal living income levels that I've come across, would require a major shake up within all governments and tax systems. I don't see the changes happening as it would greatly reduce the power of the government, especially the public servants, to interfere in your individual life.

First blow away all existing tax systems. Introduce three types of taxes.

a. A flat tax on all goods and services provided, one rate for everything.

b. A flat rate income tax paid on all interest paid out on investments, calculated by, deducted, and paid by the investment organisation.

c. A flat rate of tax on the nett profit, before R&D and expansion, for all limited liability corporate organisations.

Note - no taxes on a private individual at all, if the business is privately own, no taxes either. Take all the risks, you get all the profits.

2. No one can be employed to do anything without a govt registered number tax file number, social security number - whatever, you choose one. But you got to have it before you can start work. All wages and salaries paid to be reported, identification by this number.

3. Use a reasonably accurate method to set a minimum income level (MIL).

4. Anyone not earning the MIL can register for assistance, investigation reviews their whole lifestyle, and where adjudged suitable, they receive support.

NB: Recommended method of support being assisted housing and food voucher processes. The idea is to give them housing and food not money to buy drugs.

This allows the free market to get on with the business of setting wages, while still allowing for the social welfare support process to see minimum levels are provided, and making them adjustable to local areas and individuals.

by tonythetiger

define 'exploitation'. Frankly, if you're using the dictionary definition, I see far more employ[b]ees[/b] doing it than employ[b]ers[/b].

by shellbot

yes, i see that. It does go both ways though.

I guess it even depends where you are and what you are doing. For instance in ireland min wage is 7.65.
5 years ago there was no min wage, and it was not uncommon to work for 2-3 and hour. It was appalling.
I would consider it fair, it is just hardly enought to live on.

I do take the approach that IF you want to have the house, the car and the holidays, then you must work your way up to the larger wages..you should not make 30K a year for flipping burgers.
If you want more money, work for it..I'm not a "bleeding heart", but having worked like a dog for next to no pay, for a small business that made plenty of profit, i think min wage is a good idea.

I think the key word is Minimum. Just enough..the absolute minimum..

by tonythetiger

[i]I think the key word is Minimum. Just enough..the absolute minimum..[/i]

...in the original post, I asked the questions.

by oldjags

that hires minimum-wage employees, I can comment on the direct practical effect that raising the minimum wage has on a small business (retail bakery).

Most small businesses have absolutely no control over what they pay for supplies, inventory, rent, utilities, etc., but they do have some control how much they pay for labor, and they have some control (subject to competition and customer resistance) over what they charge for their products.

In order for us to make a profit, we determined that our labor costs could not go any higher than 32% of our sales.

When the minimum wage last went up, there was a ripple effect on our entire payroll. We had to give raises to every hourly employee from top to bottom, though the raises tended to diminish toward the top of the pay scale. (When you've given someone a raise for good performance and given them supervisory responsibilities, they're understandably upset when suddenly everybody they're supervising is making just as much as they are.)

As a result of the raises, we had to both raise our prices and trim the number of hours worked. All of our minimum-wage employees were high school students working part-time on afternoons and weekends, so they ended up working fewer hours per week on average.

So, in the end, part of the increase in cost was paid by the customer in the form of higher prices, and the rest was paid by the employees in having fewer hours scheduled for them to work.

To me, a minimum wage acts as a barrier to employment, and reduces the number of jobs available at the entry level. Most entry level job functions can be broken down into 10-15 minute tasks, and those tasks will tend to get assigned to existing workers before you'll go to the expense of hiring and training a new employee.

Labor cost as a percentage of sales tends to be much higher in small businesses with lower sales volumes. Raising the minimum wage makes it harder for those businesses to compete with larger ones for which direct labor costs may be a tiny fraction of sales. That's why you can buy an entire box of Nabisco chocolate chip cookies for 2 bucks, but if you come into my bakery, I'll have to charge you $6.00 a dozen.

France is a perfect example of how NOT to do it. Youth unemployment in France runs so incredibly high for two reasons: the high minimum wage and other costs and benefits imposed on businesses by the government, and the practical impossibility of ever being able to fire or lay-off someone once they're hired.

Most small businesses have decided it's better to remain small and hire only family or well-known friends than to try and grow and take the risk of hiring someone worthless who they are then saddled with until retirement.

In their socialistic desire to help the status of the common worker, France has only managed to hurt them and cripple their economy to boot.

by tony hopkinson

of the reasoning taken too far.
Sweatshop economies are the other extreme.

Neither one works for the people at the bottom of the pile.
One pays them to stay there, the other pays the legislature to keep them there.

Course as long as they don't squeak too much when we are standing on them, who gives a bog eh?

by delbertpgh

Setting any kind of minimum wage is guaranteed to kill off some number of jobs. It will make some businesses unprofitable. No way around it.

What the minimum wage is about (besides buying votes) is a measure of how much a society values its low-end workers. Thirty years ago I was making minimum plus fifty cents sweeping and mopping floors. That would be worth about $9 an hour these days. I was supporting a wife and a brand new baby. There were no opportunities in town (Fort Collins), which was filled with hippies, retirees, and college students, all willing to work for dirt. The effect of today's minimum wage would be to cut my money by a third. It was hard then; I don't know how much harder I could have taken. The thing that made it bearable was that I was raised as a middle class kid, and there was a middle class man inside me, and no freaking way was this cruddy situation going to last. I knew it was just a bad holiday.

By the way, France has got a lot more barriers to hiring than its high minimum wage (about $13/hour, plus vacation and benefits.) Once you hire somebody in France, it's just about impossible to fire him, and if you do, it'll cost you most of a year's wage in severance. They also have loads of additional restrictions on business that inhibit entrepreneurial startups. France has a lot more than its lavish minimum wage to blame for its high unemployment.

by jdclyde

Once you allow someone to step in and tell you how to run your business, you have greatly reduced the chances of staying in business.

Years back, "government" decided that all full time employees "deserve" health insurance to be given to them, paid for by the employer. A good friend was working full time at Kmart at the time. No benifits or insurance, but he was paying his bills and was content. When this went through, Kmart cut all of these employees to part-time status. Now, not only did he NOT have insurance, but he now had a huge cut in pay. For a while, he ended up having to work two jobs to make ends meet. The problem with this is now anything over 40 hours a week is not overtime because it isn't with a single employer.

The people that rob from the rich to buy votes from the poor are dragging out country down.

by jamesrl

That was your choice.
And it was my choice - my wife could work when my kids were young, but like you we chose not to.

But I don't agree that even in jest we should force people not to - that would be freedom and wrong.

Lets face it, there are good day cares and bad, as well as good mothers and bad. Who is to say that the extras that the additional income provide don't benefit the kids. Its too simplisitic to say the same rules should work for everyone.

Frankly I know some mothers where it would be better for the kids to be in a good daycare than with the mother all day.

James

by jdclyde

making people get a license to have kids, and have to pass a class on being a good parent and good person.

It is in a childs best interest to be with a good parent over a good daycare everytime.

No, the government can not do this and should not do this.

The hard FACT is that some people should not be allowed to breed.

by jaqui

that make the official poverty line more accurate.
the real estate market is in a huge boom, with prices very similar to those I've heard for Sydney Aus.
[ $600,000.00 to $2,500,000.00 for a house purchase]
this being caused by the previously mentioned winter olympics. [ in my first post in this discussion ]

I based my own food cost estimate on exactly the type of cook from scratch model you used. :) the official food costs are also based on cooking from scratch.

they do base their projection on a full one bedroom apartment, which in Vancouver itself starts at $1,000.00/mo I used a bachelor.
the hostels, such as the ymca, have a rule that you cannot be from the area when you stay there, only from out of town.
the SRO, bet/sit rooms are roughly half the cost of a bachelor apartment, and very hard to find, since they run at 100% occupancy due to the expensive market rent units.

the affordable housing system, with lower rents won't look at anyone not on some form of government assistance, since they already have a 5 year waiting list.

BC has the highest MW in Canada at $8.00/hr.

I have supported three people on a take home pay of $1800.00/month. we always had food.
the only thing that was a struggle was new clothes for growing child. :)
I live as simply as possible myself, I don't need the frills. it was the only was Icould support my wife and daughter before immigration canada kicked them out of the country.
[ and the US immigration service doesn't want to allow canadians to go there. ]

I'm gonna have to find a company outside of canada and the us that would be willing to sponsor me and my family for immigration. just so we can be together.
[ I'm not happy with either canada or us governments for a good reason ]

by johnnysacks

Wow, two working parents to support a lifestyle filled with ridiculous 'toys'. My parents worked so they could afford private school.

Popping them in front of a TV or video games for 6 hours a day is what should be criminal. The myth that daycare has a negative effect on a childs upbringing has been debunked enough, it's a personal choice.

A disease called suburban aristocracy is spreading, symptoms include:
Fenced in back yards filled with scores of multicolored plastic toys.
Driveways filled with crap loaded $40,000 SUV's, mini-vans, luxury cars.
A watercraft or two parked on the side.
Play rooms filled to capacity with toys spilling out into the rest of the house.
Several years history of every new video game gadget target marketed to children.
Gourmet granite\cherry kitchens filled with high end appliances and a freezer and cabinets full of microwave food.

Making something positive from your choice is the challenge. If the income is frittered away on crap or the kids sit in front of the tube for 6 hours a day, it's a lose-lose situation.

by jdclyde

I work so I can support my boys, and be able to DO things with them.

People that dump their kids off at daycare because they have to have the 200k house and the Hummer in the driveway to make up for the hummer that they aren't getting in the bedroom, are really shallow, hollow people with no purpose of value.

If the material goods are the end-all to their existance, they never should have decided to breed a neglected child into the world.

And yes, dumping your kids in front of a TV for six hours a day is another sign of a poor parent. Goes back to needing to pass a class to be allowed to breed. Child neglect is a form of abuse.

by johnnysacks

Something happened in the 80's where a lot of easily borrowed money met up with a perfect marketing opportunity and suddenly, no thought went into the consequences of purchasing bigger-better-more on long term credit.

More and more people who were raised on the bad side of the depression pass away, their lessons totally lost to newer generations. I talk a lot to my son about how my grandparents and parents lived on both sides of our family. Three generations lived in a 1200 square foot house you were incredibly grateful to own. Gardens were a necessity to keep food on the table. A luxury in a car was an AM radio. My grandmother could walk into the woods on a fall day and walk out with a half bushel of fresh wild mushrooms and she knew the orchards where you could buy bruised apples and peaches for pennies on the dollar and can them to eat all winter.

Vacation was a 2 week camping road trip every summer. I have no regrets about any of it, especially not 'having' things, my memories are of 'doing' things.

I could go on and on but history moves in cycles and you don't have to be a fortune teller to know hard times WILL come again.

by too old for it

The move to raise the state minimum wage (which is well below what anyone pays anyway) is just a smoke screen to slip in a provision which would make [b]ALL[/b] employee records available to the public.

Talk about your identity thief's dream!

by delbertpgh

In a modernist, capitalist, democratic society, we're all supposed to be benefiting from our membership in the club. The capitalist types play by the rules and get most of the rewards. The worker types keep their heads down, play by the rules, and get enough to get by. Sometimes the workers have to adapt or there's no place for them to work. Sometimes the capitalists lose everything on a dumb bet. (Often their workers lose everything at the same time, sharing the capitalist's pain. Pain doesn't flow the other way, though.) This is how the most successful economic system in the world works. Capitalists like it 'cause they get rich and have more stuff. Workers grumble, but workers will always grumble. It's part of their class identity. Academics admire it, because it delivers more total stuff to more people than alternative systems, and politicians like it, because rich capitalist nations are more likely to win wars against their less efficient neighbors.

What happens when the capitalists, who also get to write the rules, get greedier and want more than they got formerly? What if they look at an ever-expanding pie, and decide "We get the growing parts, and your piece can stay the same." This is essentially what has happened in the American economy since the Carter administration. What has also happened since the Clinton administration is that more and more people are sweating it out without health insurance, and that the minimum wage has stayed frozen while prices slowly creep up. This frozen wage helps our poor people stay competitive against foreigners, but it does make them a little more disappointed about the social contract.

If people get really bummed about the social contract, what do you have? France 1789? Newark 1967? The poor don't always experience the minimum wage as a first rung on an endless ladder. Their ladder is often about three rungs high, before a business cycle or their bad habits get them bumped back down. The height of the first rung can make a big difference.

A lot of poor people make the trip out of poverty. A lot don't, and they raise children who won't, either. The minimum wage helps to set a bottom for them. Our economy needs them, and needs them at a cheap price, and they aren't going away, and we'd be in trouble if they did. The minimum wage makes more difference to their lives than it does to ours.

by jdclyde

Was reading a study about two weeks ago that found that it isn't "poor schools" that cause drop-out rates and has resulted in less and less people graduating high-school as we go on.

It is uneducated parents that did not get an education that don't see the need of it. This gets passed on to the kids.

A clear case of stupid breeding more stupid.

Society does not own stupid people a way of life.

by delbertpgh

It's kind of nonsense to say that stupid people are owed no kind of life by society. Probably you don't mean that being unable to do simple arithmetic exercises means somebody is eligible to be cheated out of their assets and physically abused by everybody at will. No, you probably think that society owes justice even to stupid people, and legal protection of their rights.

Your mother is owed medicare, because your father earned a wage and paid taxes. (Maybe she did, too.) No IQ test required.

Kensington Nigel Snodgrass IV, twenty-something playboy inheritor, who flunks out of 15 colleges and can't do anything right, is still entitled to society's enforcement of contract law that keeps his daddy's estate pouring money into his checking account. In fact, little KNS4 is entitled to more rights and protections than your mother, and more than the minimum wage cleaning woman, because he is a guardian of capital. Again, no IQ test required.

Society manages to make use of the stupid people who are born of stupid people and spend their spare time raising tomorrow's stupid people. We pay them minimum wage and expect them to rake lawns in the summer and find other work in the winter. If all these stupid guys managed to uplift themselves and started looking for more meaningful work, would it be ready for them? Who would fill all the stupid people jobs? It wouldn't work as well as you'd hope.

by tony hopkinson

If you want people off welfare and which ever political ideology you follow most do.
How ?
Education cost's money, they haven't got it, so it comes out of taxes. Fine now we have an educated poor person. Right, here's a job pays pays less than welfare. Are we seeing a problem here ?

High welfare keeps people on welfare, low wages keep people on welfare.

Who pays for welfare, we do. Who pays for a cut in welfare, politicians. Guess who's going to keep paying. If yiu've got a job, you are probably intelligent enough to work this out.

You can't maximise shareholder value, reduce unemployment and run a democracy at the same time except in extreme circumstances like world wars, preparing for 6m tides, and such like.

by tonythetiger

all the caring words in the politically correct place, and all the demonizing words where they'll have the desired impact; yet it doesn't answer a single one of the questions I asked.

by delbertpgh

If you make sure that the terms of the contract have some appeal to the inferior partner, then he'll reneg. In the case of society and its poor, that means petty theft, armed robbery, riot, and rebellion, in order of escalating response.

Most of the working poor don't believe they are entitled to much. That's fair, too; they tend to have low-value skills, and often behave stupidly. However, it has to be enough to live, offer moments of contentment, and to give the kids a chance. That's fair, too. People who are poor or working class will stand up to whatever life gives them, because they figure they've screwed up enough that they deserve it. But they think the kids deserve to get better, even though they teach them to be just like mom and dad, every day.

Class is not going away. People are proud of who they are. Rich people are proud to be elite, middle class are proud to be mannered, working class are proud to be tough and more real than the rich kids, and the poor are proud to fight everything that gets thrown at them, and survive laughing in spite of losing all the time. Sounds like a loser's game to me, but everybody plays it, and it's not going away. Ever.

Minimum wage sets the bottom. It doesn't need to be great, just enough.

by tonythetiger

and then there's stupid. Some [b]can't[/b] some [b]won't[/b]. The two groups should [b]not[/b] be treated the same by society.

by tonythetiger

[i]If you want people off welfare and which ever political ideology you follow most do.[/i]

An assumption many wouldn't make... there are many whose livlihood depends on maintaining poverty and the problems that often accompany it.

[i]You can't maximise shareholder value, reduce unemployment and run a democracy at the same time except in extreme circumstances like world wars, preparing for 6m tides, and such like.[/i]

Sure you can. You can start by not punishing people for becoming successful! That can be accomplished by taxing unnecessary consumption instead of income. Removing the roadblocks to success will make products more affordable, thus more would be sold, thus more would have to be hired to make, which will create a worker shortage, which will drive up wages.

by tonythetiger

[i]Sure you can. You can start by not punishing people for becoming successful! That can be accomplished by taxing unnecessary consumption instead of income. Removing the roadblocks to success will make products more affordable, thus more would be sold, thus more would have to be hired to make, which will create a worker shortage, which will drive up wages.[/i]

... this is going to be a hard sell to the politicians, since it will rob them of nearly all of their power (and don't think for a minute they don't [b]know[/b] that).

by delbertpgh

Social breakdown is not extortion. It's a consequence.

If you drop a rock and it lands on your foot, is the rock doing it to extort altitude from you?

by tonythetiger

of someone who doesn't think he is responsible for his own actions. The trial for these people usually ends with confinement to a mental health facility.

by maxwell edison

You asked, [i]"For what area is it determined? Some places cost more to live than others (sometimes even within the same city), so what do you do? Set it to be minimum for the 'cheapest to live in' place and let those in more expensive places suffer? Or set it for the most expensive place, and give those who live in cheaper places a windfall?[/i]

The federally mandated minimum wage is established on the national level. Each state may (and many do) establish its own minimum wage, but it may not be less than the national. The same applies to localities (cities), but it may not be lower than the state's established minimum wage.

You asked, "....or do you tell people they can't live in certain places where the cost is too high?"[/i]

I assume this is a rhetorical question. (But don't plant any ideas in their minds!) However, a person's financial capacity and resourcefulness does indeed limit the places he/she will be able to afford.

You asked, [i]"And who do you set it for? Do you set it to suit a single young man? a married couple, no children, both work? a married couple, two children, one works? a single mother who has to pay a baby sitter?"[/i]

Yes.

You asked, [i]"(and does the babysitter get minimum wage too?)"[/i]

No. Such a job is not covered under any minimum wage laws. They only apply to established employers who meet a certain set of criteria.

You asked, [i]"....or do you have different minimum wages for different people in different circumstances?"[/i]

No, one minimum wage applies to all.

You asked, [i]"And how are businesses supposed to pay for it (especially small businesses)? Does he raise his prices? Lay off some workers?"[/i]

Yes and yes.

You asked, [i]" And if he raises prices, doesn't that defeat the purpose?"[/i]

Yes, it does.

You asked, [i]"Soon prices on everything will be higher and the new minimum wage will have the same purchasing power as the old one does now, wouldn't it?"[/i]

Yes, it would.

You asked, [i]"And finally is there anyone else who has thought all of these things through?"[/i]

Yes, I have. Very thoroughly. But not many other people have.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=201870&messageID=2103837

by tonythetiger

I have a pretty good idea of where various people stand, but was wanting to know the "Why's and how's". For example:

[i]You asked, "And who do you set it for? Do you set it to suit a single young man? a married couple, no children, both work? a married couple, two children, one works? a single mother who has to pay a baby sitter?"[/i]

and you answered 'Yes.'

But which one? The financial needs of these groups is certainly different, so am I to conclude that the setting of a minimum wage is completely disconnected from the needs of anyone?

and:

[i]You asked, "(and does the babysitter get minimum wage too?)"

No. Such a job is not covered under any minimum wage laws. They only apply to established employers who meet a certain set of criteria.[/i]

So the minimum wage has nothing whatsoever to do with what employees should earn, but (aside from it's use as a propoganda tool) with what (some) employers should pay?

Interesting....

by delbertpgh

Would you have different laws for people who gave you the impression of being less hard-working? Would you give lower welfare payments to somebody who worked but failed, and even lower still to somebody who failed even further in the past?

There's a difference between knowing who you'd be friends with and being able to execute public policy.

by tonythetiger

[i]Would you have different laws for people who gave you the impression of being less hard-working?[/i]

No, I would have no laws one way or the other.

[i]Would you give lower welfare payments to somebody who worked but failed, and even lower still to somebody who failed even further in the past?[/i]

I would put that decision into the hands of the people in that community... the ones who [b]know[/b] the person; not into the hands of some blind and half-deaf bureaucracy a hundred miles away. It would be a more accurate assessment, as well as a more appropriate and more efficient response.

by jdclyde

You need to get stuff like that written down for future generations.

With everything on a blog or website, nothing in perminate anymore, and this disposable generation will be forgotten because it is not being documented because nothing is getting saved to print.

Some archives will remain, but a lot of pictures are disapearing every day when a hard drive fails or a computer gets a nasty virus and the only copy is on that computer.

by jdclyde

the less you will get.

Ever read a sign that says "Please don't feed the animals"?

Do you know WHY that sign is there? Beleive it or not, it is NOT to be mean or crual to the animals.

Think about it.

"Please don't feed the animals"

by jdclyde

[i]"If you want people off welfare and which ever political ideology you follow most do."[/i]

Over here, the Democrats depend on having a ready made peasent class stuck in a bottomless welfare system. It all part of the different ways you can gain and maintain power, and power is all they care about (top politicians)

One way is to take an army and rule over people.
The way the Democrats rule is called a "gift society", were if I give you things, you will allow me to do as I please. When you pay people to breed, you increase your voter base quickly, and now that people have learned that they can steal from people by voting instead of at gun point, they follow right along.

Democrats "care so much" but think so little. They like to show how much they care, by spending other peoples money.

by jdclyde

gets disability checks.

Won't work gets welfare checks.

See, they ARE treated differently.

by jdclyde

First, you put a limit to how long someone can leach of the teet of society. Say three years. If they can not provide for themselves after three years, to bad.

If they have kids that they can't provide for, find a foster home for them.

Hold people accountable for themselves. It is amazing what people CAN do when they need to.

by tonythetiger

Get them out of there so they don't turn out like their parents!

Every state has laws against neglecting children. Chronically failing to support them is neglect, so criminal charges are in order... in fact, they should be demanded!

But that's not all. The community also has to step up. When these children are removed, don't just sit there applauding. The job's not over, it's just starting. Get involved. Hands on is best. It's the perfect opportunity to change the world, and to practice what we preach, to put our hearts and souls where our mouths are. It's an investment that'll return more than money.

by deadly ernest

they gave free bread issue to ALL citizens, and free entry into regular public entertainment. Kept everyone happy.

by tony hopkinson

We've institutionalised welfare. Minimum wage and the policies that support it is an attempt to fix it. No minimum wage and leave it to market is how we got to this position.

You don't like minimum wage , fine, provide an alternative that encourages people off welfare, that the politicians can swallow, which leaves cutting welfare out.

If a businessman says oh look you are cutting the number of people I can employ, he'll have a smile on his face, he is not complaining! The minimumwage is not a reason for that, it's an excuse.

by jdclyde

Simple, you let them know that they have two years to get on their feet or they are cut off, completely.

You start a "work-fare" program where if people want that government check, they show up from Y to Z at such and such a place and WORK all day to earn the government check. Does it make them more than welfare? No, but they can at least develope a sense of self-worth that they never will from sitting around watching tv all day.

They would also be developing a skill set that can help them move on to non-work-fare jobs.

See how simple it really is when you stop and think about it?

by tonythetiger

If you have them doing things that would ordinarily be done by government employees, their union would bitch about taking away their jobs :)

by wmlundine

...are too young to remember why we established the minimum wage but just keep electing free market privateers and you will find out first hand.

by tonythetiger

No longer are we limited to a single employer in an area, nor is it as difficult to go to another area. As with the unions, the original purpose has faded into oblivion.

by tony hopkinson

The main purpose of a union was to protect employees when there was no legislation to do s. Now there is , but of course that could be changed and who funds the legislature.
You can give away your freedom whenever you want, you always have to take it back though.

by maxwell edison

...that a change in policy will automatically mean a change in the status quo and/or a return to the past. I'm simply amazed that so many people in this discussion apparently believe that's the case. I'm also amazed at how people ignore reality so as to avoid changing their long-held position. (Not one person, for example, has challenged or addressed the "facts" I previously posted, yet they continue with their misinformed arguments.)

Whereas labor unions, the establishment of a minimum wage, child labor laws, et al, once had both a valid and noble purpose, they've outgrown their usefulness -- perhaps even to the point of becoming intrusive and unfair themselves. I apparently give people more credit than you (and others) seem to do, in that I believe society learns from past mistakes and experiences, and is an ever-growing and dynamic force which is built on those past experiences.

We could actually abolish the Thirteenth Amendment to our Constitution, for example, but there's no way slavery would ever be acceptable in America again. We've grown beyond that; and we don't need a law to keep it from happening. I'm not suggesting that we repeal the Thirteenth Amendment to the Constitution, but there are indeed many laws on the books that should be repealed, and the minimum wage law is one such example.

It's almost humorous, if it wasn't so sad, that people debate today's issues on the reality that existed one hundred years ago. After all, we all know that horses deserve the right-of-way on the nation's roads! Right? (And I'd bet that there are, somewhere, still such laws on the books!)

We live (or should live) in a free society in which unnecessary government infringement into the lives of people and private business should be both strongly discouraged and limited in scope. And when laws (which are, by definition, intrusive on individual liberty) outlive their usefulness, they should be repealed.

We simply do not need a minimum wage law in the United States. Not only does the law no longer apply, but the law, itself, has now become the abuser.

by absolutely

"I apparently give people more credit than you (and others) seem to do, in that I believe society learns from past mistakes and experiences, and is an ever-growing and dynamic force which is built on those past experiences."

When people fail to live up to my standards, I withdraw my respect for those people.

by jamesrl

My father took a job that was not intially unionized and didn't pay well. We lived in a house in the country because it was much cheaper than the city. We had an acre of land, and our own apple trees. We also put a third of an acre into a garden. Until we were old enough to earn money, our summer job was planting, weeding and picking. We had a small shed where we raised ducks, chickens and occasionally a pig.

We did go into the woods during puffball season (type of mushroom that grows huge, but only during a short season).

My brothers and I were labour for nearby farms. They paid us when they could, or would just trade favours. Sometimes in the middle of the winter we would find our driveway plowed. Or we would get a call that we could pick the field of beans, corn, whatever, because they had already harvested and we could have the rest.

I remember a car with a hole in the bottom that we could see through.

We all did a lot of favour trading to get by. At one point the farmer next door didn't have enough quota for his milk, so we came by and took the excess - whole unpasteurized milk - totally illegal but it was fine.

Today I live in a small 1200 sq foot house, with a basement apartment that I rent out to a brother in law. I havent' raised the rent for years. I tried a garden but my soil sucks. The only way it would work is if I built boxes out of 2x6s or railroad ties and filled it with good topsoil from somewhere else. I may yet cause I love fresh veg. nothing like a really ripe fresh picked tomatoe or corn right off the stalk.

I do go to farmers markets, including making a long drive to St Jacobs where the mennonites and other farmers have a great market. When you factor the gas costs in I probably save nothing, but I get good quality stuff - Mennonites and Amish are related. I buy maple syrup, mennonite summer sausage, breads and pastries from the mennonites, veggies from whoever has a sale. One of my distant cousins, and some of my childhood neighbours also sell at that market.

I did the camping trips when the kids were young and still would like to, but my wife's condition precludes me from it. I may take them out on their own just so I can show them real wilderness.

I am a different person when I am back home at my parents - more relaxed, happier.

I could probably push to get a bigger house with the equity I've built, but we will make do. I was laid off a few years back and don't want to consider risking more than I have to. I never moved once when I was a kid. Its good to get to know teachers and schools and neighbours.

James

by delbertpgh

Snatch away kids from people who don't have the work ethic and good character, so's you can bring 'em up good? Talk about delusions. If you thought Iraq was a mess of unintended consequences and unforseen difficulties, try implementing a police state that would appropriate all the children in the poor neighborhoods and put them in Tiger School. You'd have to get them young, too, like at age 2 or earlier, before they got imprinted with too many bad habits.

by absolutely

"i know there are a lot of people who abuse the system and who don't want to work hard, but for those of us who do..we deserve to have a slim chance at bettering ourselves."

Nobody gave you that, including any minimum wage law. You earned it, and you have nobody to thank but yourself, and no need of anybody to [b]give[/b] you the chance at bettering yourself which is available to everybody, and which you virtuously chose to use wisely. You succeed by your own effort. Give yourself the credit you deserve. You never needed any law to force any employer to pay you more than you're worth, and you don't owe anybody else any support for laws that allow [b]them[/b] to be paid more than [b]they're[/b] worth.

by tonythetiger

offer or promote an alternative that will fix the root problem. Don't just attack a solution because you're too lazy to participate or you're benefitting from the status quo.

As they say: Lead, follow, or stay out of the way.

[added]

Oh, and to be clear: The 'people' are not inferior, it's the way some of them were brought up that is inferior.

by absolutely

We are not in agreement.

20,000 words (or more) may be required to describe the harm governments do when they take from the rich to give to the poor, but those words would be a waste of time and of the medium storing them.

Very few words are needed to describe the motives for socialism, and the inevitable result of giving any privileged class (rich or poor) something for nothing. Simply put, socialism occurs when incompetent people weasel their way into government power, then promise other incompetent people a free ride. In decadent societies, enough such people vote to ensure the utter failure of that society. Refer to the fall of ancient Rome.

by deadly ernest

Rome was strong and vibrant when a very strong man, Julius Cesear, took control and changed it from a republic to a dictatorship with the outward appearance of a republic in that the Senate existed and got voted in, but had no power and did nothing of value. A few emporers later, it started its slide into decadence, and a few hundred years after that it was badly damaged by internal wars of control damaging its economy and its military. Then external attacks finished it off.

However, I agree that when the government take money from those with it and just hand it out like condetti to those without, it causes damage in many ways. But many elected official like this process as it makes a lot of people dependent upon them and makes vote buying much easier.

by absolutely

Or a deliberate reference to Condoleezza?

"However, I agree that when the government take money from those with it and just hand it out like condetti..."

The ominous parallels to Bush, Jr. in the paragraph above were obvious.

by delbertpgh

Offer real alternatives? Here goes:

Offer a minimum wage that gives a poor person a chance to live in poverty, and not taking the escalator down to even darker depths.

Make decent free public education available. Reward merit.

Guarantee everyone the equal protection of the law.

Guarantee health care, because it's basic, and our society is rich.

There you go. If a poor person who lives on minimum wage and can't get any further has these guarantees, then he is more likely to resign himself to it and not be a problem. It offers the motivated ones the open path and the support to get somewhere else in the economy. It costs, but not that much, and all alternatives have costs.

And, incidentally, it makes you an upright Christian man, decent to the brethern his father provided him, and not a bitter, selfish, and sanctimonious animal in the food chain.

So cheer up... just because you can be a decent human being, doesn't mean you have to stop being a right-wing dupe.

by tonythetiger

[i]Offer a minimum wage that gives a poor person a chance to live in poverty, and not taking the escalator down to even darker depths.[/i]

And this is the reason for the initial questions I asked. An amount that would be "the depths of poverty" for a family of 4 living in the city might be nearly a king's ransom to a teenager with two working parents in a rural area a scant 50 miles from said city.

[i]Make decent free public education available. Reward merit.[/i]

I like this one best... Even college should be free to those so motivated (the payback to society would be greater than the cost to the taxpayers).

[i]Guarantee everyone the equal protection of the law.[/i]

As long as you mean equal opportunity and not necessarily equal outcome, I agree.

[i]Guarantee health care, because it's basic, and our society is rich.[/i]

Yuck. Sorry. Most need for medical services are due to self-inflicted conditions. I don't believe a law mandating this would meet your requirement of 'equal protection' stated above. I would go for immunizations and well-baby care though.

Adults need to take responsibility for taking care of their own health. In the off chance that an illness or injury is due to the actions of another, go after "the other", not all of society.

[i]And, incidentally, it makes you an upright Christian man, decent to the brethern his father provided him, and not a bitter, selfish, and sanctimonious animal in the food chain.[/i]

Your malinformed assumption regarding my beliefs notwithstanding, I wouldn't think wanting people to have the ability to make their own wellbeing is "unchristian-like". I am not at all bitter at anyone. I am angry at those who use their cunning psychological traps to keep other people believing that the only way they can get anything is to leech off of someone else.

by maxwell edison

Does that mean you're in general agreement or general disagreement with the general intent of my message? (Generally speaking, of course.)

P.S. For a person to "set standards" for others to live up to is ...... well, I won't go there, but it's anything but libertarian. A true libertarian will concede that others have the right to set their own standards, as long as the establishment of those standards doesn't infringe in the liberty of another.

Oh well, whatever floats your boat! I find contradictions in your messages all the time. I shouldn't be surprised to see another one.

by absolutely

A small point, but to be as generous as you would be frustrating to me. I doubt you deserve that.

"P.S. For a person to "set standards" for others to live up to is ...... well, I won't go there, but it's anything but libertarian. A true libertarian will concede that others have the right to set their own standards, as long as the establishment of those standards doesn't infringe in the liberty of another."

I agree that others have the right to set their own standards, and I see I was unclear. I don't withdraw the basic respect [b]of[/b] others' rights to set their own standards (provided theirs don't infringe on my equal rights to set mine), but I withdraw the additional level of respect, akin to friendship, when others fail to live up to the basic standards of a rational human, making a reasonable effort. What I was trying to say is that you seem to be trying awfully hard to encourage people who don't wish your encouragement, nor to attempt to live up to the standards that you implicitly assume all two-legged walkers must recognize. Most do not. You have my sympathy, Maxwell, little as you may want it.

by maxwell edison

...was a pretty clear illustration to show how societies grow. Just as I don't believe slavery could ever happen again in the United States (even without that particular amendment), I also don't believe that gross mistreatment of workers could ever happen again either, at least not in today's business and economic climate. Agree or not, it doesn't really matter, though, because the worst that could happen is that I'm wrong about the outcome if all minimum wage laws were repealed -- in which case, they could always be brought back. I think it's more reasonable to assume that I'm right, however, because "society" has grown past that, and it no longer needs that particular law to maintain a reasonable semblance of order in that regard.

And you actually have my sympathy if you disagree. By the way, do you disagree? (A simple yes or no will suffice.)

by deadly ernest

Here in Australia, we have minimum wage laws, we also have fre eductaion that includes university, a free health service, and welfare that can go long term. Yet we still have those same problems that are being discussed in this thread.

The community spends billions each year for the health services to treat self inflict illnesses related to drug addiction, alcohol misuse, and tobacco use related issues - the system has been collapsing since the 'free health for all' was introduced over 20 years ago. Luckily it had a lot of slack and still has some free enterprise aspects, so the government has been able to prop it up and keep it going.

Free education to high school has been in for many decades and is essential in modern society. However, education costs and quality have been dropping since free university education was introduced 20 years ago. Drop out rates have also skyrocketed. Again, slack in the system and previous infrastructure development had hidden the collapse for many years. But today, we have people who are failing their first year uni exams because uni deos NOT have remedial level classes.

These have no effect on minimum wage, nor does it affect them, but they all effect the cost to society through taxation and increased living costs. They have not made our society a utopia, and have created some problems. However, they are no so entrenched in our society that it would be impossible to remove them without major upheaval.

The three biggest mistakes we have made in modern society are:

1. Made it impossible for people to be self sufficient without money - you can't live by just growing your own food anymore.

2. Letting the elected officials convince us that they have a right to take our money in takes and run all community welfare and charity tasks.

3. That people can be helped by just giving them money and free services.

All our ills come about because these three add together to make a significant proportion of the society feel that the government HAS to fix everything and give them everything that they feel they need. And then the government tries to do that by giving them money.

Australia has had an unemployment scheme running for about 80 years. When it started it worked very well, now it doesn't work so well. It's been changed a lot. The original system the government didn't give you money each week. They gave you food vouchers one week, and the second week you got paid full wages for doing so many hours work on government jobs as unskilled labour. People soon worked their way out of unemployment, couldn't afford too much cigarettes, alcohol or drugs on that. Today they give them cash and a lot of it is wasted on alcohol, drugs etc. Since going to the cash handouts, individual self-esteem has plummetted and the feeling of 'why bother' has increased.

by absolutely

Those laws were never necessary. When Pope Leo XIII "benevolently" suggested a "living wage", slavery had already been abolished in the United States, meaning that people were already [b]free[/b] to leave a job that paid too little for them to [b]live[/b]. When somebody can explain to me why workers ever had the right to extort more than their fair market value, I'll discuss in terms of "growing past" that need, but nobody can.