Discussion Locked

What is the purpose of setting a minimum wage?

0 helpful
323 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post

323 replies

by jdclyde

if the cost of the meal keeps shooting up, people will not go to that establishment. A good reason to keep the expenses low, huh? You wouldn't want to be directly responsible for these people losing their jobs now would you?

by absolutely

[i]if the employee is worth ANYTHING, they will not be working at minimum wage[/i]

Although unskilled labor is less valuable than skilled labor, it is not worthless.

by tonythetiger

and I disagree with the president's statement.

Anytime you base a person's wages on anything besides the market value of their labor, you are damaging the system.

by jdclyde

I didn't say unskilled labor was worthless, but many that work in the unskilled labor shops make well over minimum. working hard makes up for the skilled aspect, giving a higher value to their work.

For someone to make minimum wage, they are doing a job that is not worth much, and so it will be at the lowest minimum allowed by law.

Of course the minimum wage does not affect small businesses either. You go into a mom and pop ice cream shop and the kids working there generally will not be making even the minimum.

so while not worthless, it is worth less.

by absolutely

[i]"And let?s get something straight. I am NOT proposing to tell someone how to run their store."[/i]

Not directly or literally, I agree. Instead, you have taken the less honorable approach: you have included the complaint about foreign-born shopkeepers speaking their own languages in [b]their own[/b] stores in this discussion of illegal aliens (who will never own stores, unless US-born citizens transact illegally with them), but then disclaimed the assertion, disowning your previous complaint like a coward and ignoring the context of your remark.

[i]I am my own keeper not yours or anyone else?s.[/i]

Let's get that straight, and apply it continuously.

by absolutely

What do you mean? I know my avatar used to take a ridiculous time to load, but I thought that replacing the .bmp with a .jpg fixed that long ago.

Anyway, what would the mouse have to do with a picture file problem? You techies...

by absolutely

And if they don't start doing it [b]for themselves[/b] as soon or sooner, the collective dead weight will become impossible for the few whose production exceeds our consumption, regardless of our willingness to continue carrying unproductive sacks of water & carbon-based tissue.

by absolutely

Your error reveals carelessness, either now or in the past when you should have been learning when "who's" is appropriate vs. "whose". Which of those is the case is irrelevant. Your carelessness reveals that you do not care enough to be correct in your attempt to blur the distinction between the concepts "justice" and "compassion", meaning that you are not sincere enough in the assertion you imply to present it in a manner that portrays you as literate and your assertion as that of a literate individual.

by absolutely

Assuming you are correct, what is the point? or your point, whatever.

[i]It?s nice to know that you missed the point entirely![/i]

Maybe. Until you state the point, we won't know whether I missed it.

[i]I?m sure that the Department of customs and Border Protection would tell me that they are under funded.[/i]

Do you mean the director, or every single individual working there? I'm sure you could find more than one employee who, in private at least, would confess that strategy, not funding, is the problem, but that admitting as much would result in a fired & scandalized director, possibly preceded by a dangerous spending cut. "Spend it all or get less next year" applies in entities funded by taxation to a degree impossible to entities funded by production.

[i]Duke University would say ?so what??[/i]

If Duke University doesn't care, why did it fund the production of that web page?

[i]The CIA probably would arrest me for wanting to know about something that is probably secret or higher. [/i]

I used my Comcast connection and an old Linksys router to connect to their web page and I haven't been arrested yet. I think it's pretty safe to use information posted on unencrypted websites ending in .gov, and beginning in http://www. If it began with https and ended with .gov that might be a reason to worry, but I guarantee you, I did not obtain any secret or classified information from the government for this nor any other discussion.

[i]The facts from what I have seen so far is that they aren?t really doing anything to rectify the problem. Weather that actually is that case or not I don?t know. I will find out what they are doing eventually when I have the time or feel like trading the sleep to know.[/i]

What problem? How many illegal immigrants are jobless? Homeless? A real problem is certain non-immigrants who won't lift a finger to better themselves and presume to blame their troubles on people willing to travel hundreds or thousands of miles for the privilege of working 18 hours, 7 days a week. If you grew up in this land of plenty and cannot compete against immigrants who did not, what is your excuse?

Also, iff you insist on misspelling "whether" please remember to also misspell "naught".

[i]After all of this; Absolutely will come back and call me a ?buffoon? again. Showing his true character and maturity level.[/i]

No, I have cleared that string from my clipboard, and achieved the desired effect.

Please tell me, do you consider yourself a patriot? Are language, ethnicity and religion more or less important in your concept of the United States than the premise that individual rights are inalienable? My belief is that some governments recognize these rights, but that they are the rights of every person. You?

by absolutely

[i]However, before that takes place, I will be exercising my right to leave if they actually decide to do that.[/i]

Want help packing?

by absolutely

"if the employee is worth ANYTHING, they will not be working at minimum wage"

Your words, your CAPS.

by cparris

Here is what I mean by all of that. I was providing a service for a Hispanic bar owner. I had built this guy up to 4K to 6K in gross sales on the nights I was there. I was the one that carried the bar and kept it open. Well I guess I wasn?t Hispanic enough for this fellow and he canceled my show only to bring me back 3 months later trying to jumpstart the crowd again. After My show was canceled he brought this Hispanic DJ in that was cheaper than my service. I watched his place go bankrupt over the course of les than six months. His Hispanic compadres had ultimately let him down. I didn?t tell him because I didn?t want to offend him. I hate to have seen that happen to a good guy. He called me up later wanting to sell it for $475K.

That?s what I mean by ?in their best interest?. If they are able to make it speaking whatever language they want, fine, it just seems to me that they would make more money by having the English as a secondary language. It just seems to me that they would have more customers spending money. If they want to fight the economy, fine. If they can keep their finances straight and in the ?black?, fine.

Keep this in mind; I have a hard time communicating my thoughts at times. However, I was not being cowardly or sheepish or anything else of that.

Make no mistake, though, this is an invasion.

by cparris

The director or whomever is in charge of the finances would state that they are under funded.

Good! I?m glad that you are legal.

I hold my own. I don?t rely on anyone to ?give? me anything I cannot get on my own.

Let me ask you a question; IF our country is so great that all of these people come here to become part of it and start anew, why do the majority of them insist on turning it into what they left behind? I thought they came here to have a new life, not recreate the old one. Did you think about it that way? Maybe you did and maybe you didn?t.

If you persist in this ?everything must be explained? direction; I?ll start explaining things like programming.

by absolutely

"Let me ask you a question; IF our country is so great that [b]all of these people come here to become part of it and start anew,[/b] why do the majority of them insist on turning it into what they left behind? I thought they came here to have a new life, not recreate the old one. Did you think about it that way? Maybe you did and maybe you didn?t."

I haven't met "all of these people", and I don't agree that you have any right to expect that they come to "start anew" & "have a new life, not recreate the old one". Each immigrant has their own reasons, and once they earn the money to buy a store, they have the same right as any shopkeeper, to reserve the right to refuse service to anyone. Most stores don't exercise this right often because they exist primarily to earn money, and refusing service isn't profitable. But, ownership means the right to control one's property, and [b]that[/b] is part of what I think is best about this country, and hopefully part of why many immigrants come here. With luck and enough immigration, the likes of you will be taught the meaning of the word "inalienable", and that your rights are dependent on your respect for the rights of others.

by absolutely

I responded to what you posted:
[i]So I take it that?
All of the products have the English names displayed? What about a big store like Wal-Mart?
And, no I don?t go to these stores unless it is an ABSOLUTE necessity.
And let?s get something straight. I am NOT proposing to tell someone how to run their store. I am my own keeper not yours or anyone else?s.
[/i]

You were talking about a store, and only changed the subject to your DJ job after I destroyed your argument as you originally presented. It isn't my job to figure out what you mean but don't say, nor to accomodate your deficincies in written communication.

[i]You have it wrong again... Clairify before assumption, please
Here is what I mean by all of that. I was providing a service for a Hispanic bar owner. I had built this guy up to 4K to 6K in gross sales on the nights I was there. I was the one that carried the bar and kept it open. Well I guess I wasn?t Hispanic enough for this fellow and he canceled my show only to bring me back 3 months later trying to jumpstart the crowd again. After My show was canceled he brought this Hispanic DJ in that was cheaper than my service. I watched his place go bankrupt over the course of les than six months. His Hispanic compadres had ultimately let him down. I didn?t tell him because I didn?t want to offend him. I hate to have seen that happen to a good guy. He called me up later wanting to sell it for $475K.

That?s what I mean by ?in their best interest?. If they are able to make it speaking whatever language they want, fine, it just seems to me that they would make more money by having the English as a secondary language. It just seems to me that they would have more customers spending money. If they want to fight the economy, fine. If they can keep their finances straight and in the ?black?, fine.

Keep this in mind; I have a hard time communicating my thoughts at times. However, I was not being cowardly or sheepish or anything else of that.

Make no mistake, though, this is an invasion.[/i]

I've heard that story before, but usually not in the context of race or immigration. A lot of owners of bars have been known to treat "the entertainment" as a commodity and sacrifice quality to save a buck. Every time, the more talented DJ is inconvenienced, but finds work, while the bar goes kaput. Usually, this story is delivered by a gloating DJ who has fared better than the guy who acted like he was "in charge" because he owned a building. It's usually a very funny story to hear told.

It still looks to me like you're trying to define somebody else's best interest for him, but I appreciate putting your comments in context.

[i]That?s what I mean by ?in their best interest?. If they are able to make it speaking whatever language they want, fine, it just seems to me that they would make more money by having the English as a secondary language. It just seems to me that they would have more customers spending money. If they want to fight the economy, fine. If they can keep their finances straight and in the ?black?, fine.[/i]

A legal immigrant, who owns property legally, has inalienable rights, so, no matter what, as long as he doesn't commit a crime, "fine", with no qualifications whatsoever as to how he manages his property.

by roaming

I've lived on welfare too and it's fine as long as nothing major goes wrong. Fortunately, in my case nothing did go wrong.

by roaming

It may take a little longer than that. It will be their children that learn that lesson.

This discussion is closed to new replies.