What is the purpose of setting a minimum wage?
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by tonythetiger
Wealth did decide votes
guess who fixed that? Socialists !
Let me get this straight the 13% of your highest earners pay more tax as a %age of their income than those on less ?
They pay more tax as a percentage of the gross take than those on less?
Your tax system is even more socialist than the UKs?
Or are you a victim of the socialist school system and incapable of basic arithmetic?
Productivity is a measure of efficiency not volume
I didn't mention fairness or in fact equitability, that was ProteusX. We can have fair anytime you want, only problem is I don't think it's fair to take something off everybody who has bugger all and give it those who've got enough already. One of those nasty socialist principals you know.
Not everybody who can't get off welfare is a shiftless scrounger you know. While the economic system you are so fond of, puts them there and keeps them there, you have no right to take the welfare entitlement they paid with their taxes, until one of your fellow travellers off shored them.
So cease with the fair crap, nothings fair and you are not talking about making it fairer, but of weighting the system even more in favour of those of us who for one reason or another aren't on welfare.
Still I suppose it gives you something to do when you aren't taking candy off babies eh?
by rhansen
by nicknielsen
I don't think it's that the American education system is such a letdown. It probably has more to do with the difference in income levels between the top and the bottom.
If anything, CParris understated. According to the U.S. Treasury, for the 2002 tax year, the top 5% of wage earners paid 53.8% of all individual income taxes but reported only 30.6% of the income. The top 50% of wage earners paid over 96% of individual income taxes. http://tinyurl.com/ljn8p - 2 page pdf.
According to the IRS, for the 2003 tax year, the top 1% of taxpayers were earning
$295,495 or more. The bottom 10% of taxpayers were earning $5,432 or less (Caveat-read the note!). The median Adjusted Gross Income was $29,019. 182,932 people declared an AGI of $1,000,000 or more. http://tinyurl.com/rp9kh
Those are the official numbers. Make of them what you wish.
Edit: clarify target...searching...searching...
by tonythetiger
are the reason welfare was created.... they could no longer fool the people of the community that they weren't shiftless scroungers, so they went to the government to fool them!
[i]only problem is I don't think it's fair to take something off everybody who has bugger all and give it those who've got enough already.[/i]
How pretentious of you to mandate what is "enough" for someone else. Especially when that "someone else" is providing a living for others!
by absolutely
Tony Hopkinson claims: "Wealth did decide votes guess who fixed that? Socialists!"
Um, no, American revolutionaries fixed that when they established the first society not [b]based[/b] on inherited class membership, the politics of which you "socialist" Brits still recognize in your houses of lords and commons. We also have two parliamentary bodies, but they exist in order to prevent more populous states from overwhelming the interests of the less populous states. Every state has the same number of Senators, two, but every state has a number of Congressmen which is decided by the population of that state. Whether this is a clever way of preventing a tyranny of the majority, or whether it over-represents rural states, is a separate question. [b]Your[/b] two houses of parliament still acknowledge the concept of inherited political privilege, which is a completely different issue than inherited wealth. You still can't be born a commoner and earn your way into the house of lords, no matter how much money you earn.
Aristocracy: wealth is distributed primarily according to accident of birth.
Socialism: wealth is (supposedly) distributed primarily according to need.
Capitalism: wealth is distributed primarily according to merit.
I know which system I prefer, and why.
Revolutionaries fixed it.
Indeed they did.
Socialist revolutionaries in the UK.
Where do you think one man one vote came from when you created your constituion. european factory owners ? It wasn't constructed from a vacuum, but to address the inadequacies of other systems in existance at the time.
You guys talk like the world and history started on the 4th of July.
"Welfare was invented for scroungers"
That's either the most pathetic quote on this discussion, or we have a major semantic disconnect.
Welfare to me is state assistance , for single mums, broken families, the handicapped...
Guys who make a career out of it are a problem, but you penalise them not Miss Jane Doe who got left holding the baby by John.
Pretentious - I pretend to nothing if you can't afford basic health, education, housing, food and clothes then your state, your community and your government are a cruel joke. Who you pay for this provision does not matter, the fact that you cannot most definitely does.
Try living on welfare for a bit, that way you won't look like you are talking out of your arses.
by bharris09
A nuclear scientist can't/won't dig the ditches to build a nuclear reactor. Someone has to do that. If companies don't pay for a living wage, then our tax dollars will make up the difference in food stamps and medical care while executive salaries are raping EVERYONE.
Easy solution. Pay the executives a lot less and pay everyone else a reasonable wage.
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
Substitute 'deadbeat' for scrounger.
It used to be that the townsfolk helped all who need help, and were in a position to know if, how much, and what kind of help was needed (all problems aren't solved by throwing money at them!). Deadbeats learned to take advantage. The townsfolk caught on to this, and rightfully cut them off. Then the deadbeats went to the government complaining that the townsfolk weren't helping. The government, not knowing (nor caring) that these deadbeats were attempting to scam them the same way they scammed the townsfolk, created Welfare (it was also a benefit to some in government who saw it as a way to control people).
Of course, the townsfolk had to pay for this, which lessenned their ability to help the 'truly needy' in their community. So the 'truly needy' were added to the welfare rolls, requiring even more money.
And if it weren't bad enough, over half of what the government takes for the needy actually goes to greasing the gears of government!
[i]Pretentious - I pretend to nothing if you can't afford basic health, education, housing, food and clothes then your state, your community and your government are a cruel joke.[/i]
Pretentious is that you pretend to know what's "enough" for me better than I do. However, I partly agree with you about government: It is [b]because of[/b] our government that most of these problems exist.
A government cannot create anything, it can only be a drain on its people (and in this case it is a bigger drain than are the people they pretend to help!). How big a drain its people can tolerate is the ultimate question.
by cparris
Let's get things straight. First, I have said it before and I will say iy again, I have no problem helping someone get back on their feet. The structure of our socieity is almost to discourage advancement and betterment of ones self. It's structured that the more you make the more taxes you pay in percentage. For example: Joe makes $15k a year. He pays no taxes. Bob makes $35K a year and pays 27% in taxes. Jill makes $60k a year and pays 29% in taxes. Scott makes $100k+ a year and pays 35% to 45% in taxes.
That is unfair at best. Those that just live off of wellfare and food stamps are the slime of humanity. They are either robbed of purpose, will, or they are just plain lazy.
I have seen several "families" abuse the welfare system. They are perfictly aboe to work but just won't because they will loose their benifits. The welfare system is biased as well. For me, I can't work on the welfare system for two reasons, my skin's the wrong color, and I'm the wrong sex. I would be living out of some cardboard box in an alley somewhere before I got welfare or foodstamps.
So, Is line with the discussion topic, to pay a worker in company note is a bad thing and the worker should be paid in national currancy. As for the minimum wage, I think it's somthing that should be repealed. Welfare, should be limited and the reciepiant should at least be looking for a job and if they haven't found a job in 6 months, then it should be revoked.
by tonythetiger
I wouldn't go so far as to say everyone on Welfare and foodstamps are the slime of humanity. Some genuinely need long-term material help, some just need a little boost to get them started or to to make it across a rough patch, and some are just users and will continue to be as long as they think they can get away with it.
What I would say is that if the people of the community had the money the government is taking from them, they are in a better place to determine if, what kind of, and how much help is needed, and could deliver that help far more efficiently and effectively than some bureaucrat a hundred or a thousand miles away (of course, that might not set well with the bureaucrat... since his livlihood depends on people needing him).
by cparris
I can see how you translated what I said the wrong way. I almost did it myself.
When I said "Those that just live off of wwellfare and foodstamps are the slime of humanity" I was reffering to those that make a career of living on wellfare and foodstamps not the ones that actually need the help. It's easy to overlook the "just" in there.
However, those that aspire to stay on wellfare for their entire lives are the leaches of the socieity. They suck out what they could get on their own. Like tape worms. They will take what is eaten with no regard for the host eventually causing the host's death.
A more localized system would seem to work better. Who would manage it? How would it be controlled? Where would the funds come from? Would the funds come from a voluntary means or would they be required like taxes? What of the poorer areas that don't have as much surplus as the larger ones but more apparent need?
One final thought for the rest of you....
How bout we box up all of the illegal immigrants and send them home. On the ride home, we let them know that if we catch them again, we'll drop them off in anartica next time. When they come back and are caught the second time, we make good on our word and ship them to anartica. And on the trip there, let them know that if they are caught a 3rd time, they will be considered a hostile force or terrorist and shot on sight.
That would be the last time they tried to come here. That would also aleviate the resources required to keep these people alive in our country.
Those of you that think we should give them aministy and make them citizens... Maybe we should treat you that way as well. To be ehre illegaly is a crime. It should be punished as such. As for being born in America to be a citizen... nope, that shouldn't count either unless your parents are citizens of the US as well.
by tonythetiger
[i]A more localized system would seem to work better. Who would manage it? How would it be controlled? Where would the funds come from? Would the funds come from a voluntary means or would they be required like taxes? [/i]
Of course it should be voluntary... it [b]is[/b] charity, after all. And again, it's not always money that is needed. Indeed, that should always be the last resort (Didn't your momma teach you that it's tacky to give money as a gift? :) ). If it [b]needs[/b] managed or controlled (yuck!), I would think the community would be more than capable of coming up with a means... a 'school board' type structure might work but a 'volunteer fire department' structure would probably be better.
[i]What of the poorer areas that don't have as much surplus as the larger ones but more apparent need?[/i]
First things first. I wouldn't be so bold as to march into a community and be a judge of what they need or don't need (poor doesn't necessarily mean distressed or even unhappy). That said, you and your neighbors can certainly offer to help someone in another community. You'd certainly have more resources with which to do it. All you need is the willingness to do something, and not be afraid to get your hands dirty if necessary. Direct involvement. That's what builds and maintains the sense of community... and you sure can't replace that with a check!
[Added]:
[i]When I said "Those that just live off of wwellfare and foodstamps are the slime of humanity" I was reffering to those that make a career of living on wellfare and foodstamps not the ones that actually need the help. It's easy to overlook the "just" in there.
[/i]
and for those, we could always offer one more good-will gesture... give them a ticket to the homeland of our socialist friends who seem to care about them so much ]:)
well that's something we can agree on.
I'm a fully paid up member of the Yorkshire secessionist movement. Though I'll settle for a northern assembly for a start, those wankers down south keep allocating my taxes to their needs.
On average southerners live five years longer than us northern types. So I'm paying for them to live longer by dying sooner.
It's a good start on killing big government anyway.
The other point of agreement is none of us like what institutionalised welfare does to a country. I look at ways to reduce the need, you are looking at ways to reduce the cost of it.
In my opinion, my approach is much more rational, more long term and takes into account the real cost of a purposely impoverished underclass.
That is what socialism is about, a consideration of the real effects of a policy on society. Paying more welfare is not a socialist policy, it's a capitalist one.
Invest in creating jobs and penalise those who destroy them for a short term and personal financial gain. These are the real drain on the state, not the poor twats they put out of work.
by absolutely
by cparris
Think of this for a moment.
say somthing catastrophic happens. A volcano erupts that sends ash in to the atmosphiere that blocks the majority of the suns rays for a year or two. That would make a short growing season. Proabbly so short that not enough food could be grown to support the population. That's when what's stored in those silos would benifit us.
Or better yet, a drought. How many plants do you know that grow with out water that we can actually eat? None or not many? If you do, please let me know. That's when the surplus in those silos would be useful.
The government pays rent to store those reserves in those silos. That's smart. It dosen't benifit us immediately but it sure does cover our arses if somthing happens to stunt our food production capabilities.
Did you think that far ahead? Proably not. That's ok though, most people just aren't equipped to think that far ahead. It's a lesson that we can learn from history and (gasp) even the Bible. It's not trivial to store food for the hard times. It's smart.
So, tell me, would you rather them store the food and have it if and when we need it and accept the cost of storing such provisions, or would you rather not do that and sooner or later look starvation in the face?
Basically, feast or fammon?
by tonythetiger
[i]I look at ways to reduce the need, you are looking at ways to reduce the cost of it.[/i]
... and better determine what's 'need' and what's 'want'. That will reduce the cost even more.
[i] That is what socialism is about, a consideration of the real effects of a policy on society. [/i]
I'd rather make my own policies. It's called freedom.
[i]Invest in creating jobs and penalise those who destroy them for a short term and personal financial gain. These are the real drain on the state, not the poor ***** they put out of work. [/i]
Unless you bury your money in cans in the back yard, anything you do with your 'financial gain' is going to create jobs for somebody somewhere. 'The State' needn't be involved at all, except to print more money :)
by absolutely
"...those wankers down south keep allocating my taxes to their needs."
I think this whole exchange is getting too abstract. What I'd like to hear from a "socialist" or "welfare statist" or "safety net proponent", or whatever name you choose to describe your belief, in partial or absolute collectivism in ownership, is this: how much should be taken, from whom, and given to whom? I'll be asking "why?" later, and repeatedly.
I know you are going to keep asking why until you recognise the fundmanental and inexcusable blindness in your position.
You only consider one side of the equation.
Deride people on welfare for taking 'your' income while simultaneously patting yourself on the back for promoting a system that put them on welfare in the first place.
Wealth will only create jobs if it's put back into the economy, one extra person to help read the zeros on the end of a bank balance doesn't count.
How many jobs come from currency speculation for instance.
You may even be right about global jobs, but all off shoring does is swap one bean counter for many people, and the bean counter doesn't pay that much more tax than one of the people they off-shored.
That should be redressed (not the bean counter's tax). Equally the sort of b'stard who employ's illegal immigrants becuse it's worth the joke of a fine thet get compared to the profit they make.
Are these position too 'socialist' for you or did you have plans to profit from such activities.
I must say I'm enjoying being the moderate in this debate.
LOL
by tonythetiger
[i]Wealth will only create jobs if it's put back into the economy, one extra person to help read the zeros on the end of a bank balance doesn't count.[/i]
Bean counters buy homes and cars, hire babysitters, etc. Like I said, unless it's put into a hole in the ground or a matress, it [b]is[/b] put back into the economy.
On the other hand, bean counting that companies do for government accounting purposes accounts for roughly $500 billion (10^9) a year. That's almost $1700 for every man, woman and child in the country (and that's not inclusive of any other taxes)! That [b]is[/b] throwing money in a hole, because it adds nothing to the value of the company's product or service except make it cost more to the consumer. That's one reason I have been a supporter of the Fairtax proposal here. It eliminates those costs right off the bat, which will lower prices on almost everything.
[i]Equally the sort of b'stard who employ's illegal immigrants becuse it's worth the joke of a fine thet get compared to the profit they make.[/i]
That's one area where I part from many of my friends, conservative, liberal, and in-between. I don't want illegals here either, but my reason is simply because they are illegal. I have no problem with anyone competing for jobs. I am an anti-protectionist capitalist. If someone wants to try to undercut me for my job, more power to them. Truth be told, I'd go pretty low myself, as my needs aren't lavish.
You see, I've been there... I've lived for months at a time with little or no income. I've grown and killed my own food. I've even performed minor surgery on myself. I know what (most) people can do when they have to... because I've had to. That's how I know when someone says they can't live on minimum wage they are full of $hit!
did I.
Aside from in line with inflation type rises I don't see any need for it to go up either.
If they are on minimum they aren't on welfare and they are paying taxes, if that wasn't true it would be an utter waste of time would n't it.
A question for you given.
Politicians use welfare to buy votes and businesses use it to reduce employment costs and sponsor politicians who keep this nasty cycle going so they can make money while we get taxed to support their profits. How effective do you think the lets cut welfare spending campaign is going to be ?
Do you think you are in the majority, in the country or if some sort of devolution occurred , your state ?
After all whther you are 'right' or not doesn't matter for crap, if you are in the minority!
by tonythetiger
I am in the majority... most people instinctively take responsibility for themselves most of the time. It is the politicians who seperate us into various groups to pit against one another for their gain (and I suspect, their amusement). They take the tiniest of problems and make them seem bigger than they are (As Max pointed out... about half a million on minimum wage, and more than half of those in miltiple-earner families. Yet as small as this problem seems to be when you look at the data, nearly every Democratic candidate mentions in their campaign ads that their opponent opposed raising it).
Where I am in the minority, I think, is in my belief that "the government" creates and/or enhances these problems in order to demonstrate the 'need' for more government.
It, however, is a growing minority.
Thank you. I appreciate your perspective and your interest.
I'm way less 'socialist' than I used to be, some real life experience having wiped out the pie in the sky drivel I used to take as self evident. I've never lost the us vs them background that being marked at birth as one of the underclass though.
Half a million, in workforce the size of yours?. Makes you wonder what was worth arguing about. The minimum wage breaking ?5 an hour was predicted to affect about 1.5 million in the UK.
?5 isn't as bad or as good as it sounds, there are a lot of exceptions, which employers take advantage of. Like defining all new young employees as 'apprentices', paying them f'all and then getting rid of them before they are 'qualified'. SSDE as it were.
by absolutely
"Deride people on welfare for taking 'your' income while simultaneously patting yourself on the back for promoting a system that put them on welfare in the first place."
The only system that "put" anybody on welfare is their own digestive system, and their parents' reproductive systems. I promote neither! The system I promote provides only the law enforcement apparatus necessary to leave us all free to earn our own "welfare" or to beg for it, but never to have it given by any entity that has taken it from another person.
by absolutely
I had a very similar conversation this weekend, walking out of grocery store that has fairly recently installed four bar code scanners equipped with payment receptacles, which allow shoppers to check out and bag our own groceries. I find this to save me the trouble of pretending to be as interested in the clerk's day as the clerk is pretending to be about mine, and it also gets me out of the store at least as fast, unless I buy beer or wine. Then I still have to wait for a clerk to check my drivers license.
I was remarking to my friend how inspiring it is that mindless jobs are being eliminated by automation. She replied that such jobs are all that some people have. I believe that's impossible. When such boring, routine work is replaced by automation, money becomes available to invest elsewhere, and of necessity, that investment will require some work which will have to be done by humans. The idea that eliminating mundane jobs reduces the total number of jobs to do is extremely myopic. When mindless tasks are done by mindless automatons, the net result is that the jobs available to humans are more interesting, not that there are fewer. As long as there is greed, intelligent greedy people will find ways to make productive tasks for even unskilled people with barely enough greed to provide for their own basic survival. It's just human nature.
by absolutely
Natural disasters are local, and we'd be better off in the long-term if we send our excess food to countries that would eat it, in exchange for both money and the simple pleasure of putting the food to use, feeding people whose countries aren't productive enough to provide for them all. In the case of a drought or other disaster, the local decrease in agricultural output could easily be covered by imports. The short term financial cost of that solution would be greatly exceeded by the long-term benefits to our relations with the rest of the world.
cparris: "The government pays rent to store those reserves in those silos. That's smart. It dosen't benifit us immediately but it sure does cover our arses if somthing happens to stunt our food production capabilities.
Did you think that far ahead? Probably not. That's ok though, most people just aren't equipped to think that far ahead. It's a lesson that we can learn from history and (gasp) even the Bible. It's not trivial to store food for the hard times. It's smart."
In biblical times, food could not have been imported from the far side of the Earth, in the case of a localized natural disaster. Today it can, and should, instead of ignoring improvements in transportation technology. What we can learn from history, [b]above all else[/b], is that times change, so the choice that was best in one time and place will not necessarily be the best in another time and place. Much of what was smart in the past is foolish now, including hoarding food as though a natural disaster could occur that would uniformly reduce agricultural output everywhere on Earth. Any such cataclysm would kill us all instantly, and we wouldn't have the time to get hungry.
by m4rk.gm4il
Whatever the purpose is...The minimum wage
in the Philippines is way below the
required daily budget. That is why experienced professionals migrate to other countries that offer better living conditions and better opportunities for career growth.
by aspong38
I agree two working parent homes is 90 done out of wanting "TOYS, NEWER, BIGGER, BETTER".I believe some families do need to work two jobs to support thier families. But I believe because our focus has shifted from "Whats best for our Family" to "what bigger, better,newer toy can we get" is why we are having so many issues in the world today such as Guns in our schools or our kids using drugs and we are not winning the war on drugs.
I believe we should be paid higher wages. Everyday prices are going up. Well how can people afford to continue to buy the things they need when thier income stays the same. Lets say The average persons income is $800 a month,and for a year it's tight but they find a way. Come the first of the year they raise the cost of everyone utilities by $10 a month, then they also raise the rent $50 a month. Gas is going up to where it use to cost $20 to fill your tank but now it's costing $27 a tank x 4 "once a week". Right there is $88 dollars a month. That's over a thousand a year. So that's to happen every year. I agree you need to be worth what you make. But company's DO NOT give raises to freely, if at all and if so, a nickle. That's a joke. I think guide lines need to be made on what they have to pay and with in six months of employment making some much extra dollars. Cause in six months you can tell if someones worth the higher wage bracket and if they are not then they shouldn't continue to be on your pay roll.
I worked for the same company for thirteen years before this current job. It was only a waitress job but for a long time that's all I knew. Raising my kids with no help didn't leave alot of time to go to school and learn anything else.
In those thirteen years never was I given a raise. As a waitress you are told if you want a raise it's through your costumers you will get one.
I don't think it's right your costumers have to pay your wages. You don't work for them. If so then should someone working as an sales employee {which is the same as waitressing,the sale of a companies product}be paid by the costumer also. So on the reciept it will give the price,the taxes and the wage for sales person. And when they should be getting a raise we'll just add more to the bill to make up for that raise.
Even after the kids were getting older I choose to continue to waitress cause I felt that was the best for my family. I didn't want to take away more of my time away from them to go to night school, knowing that gives them alot of time on thier hands, and when that happens, thats when these kids start getting into trouble.
So I choose to just slid by every month, knowing we'd make it but not have alot of extras. But was it fair to put that many years into a company and never get a raise? Well most companies are the same way and it's unfair that they can raise the prices or prices for the service they offer, but not spread that extra out to the employees who make that company run.
There's a serious problem in this world and if we don't find a answer soon, I feel sorry for the kids when they get older. I wouldn't want to be around in twenty years if somethings not figured out.
by absolutely
by tonythetiger
[i]Everyday prices are going up.[/i]
Why do you suppose that is? Could "rising wages" have anything to do with it? So aren't you then participating in an endless upward spiral?
[i]I don't think it's right your costumers have to pay your wages.[/i]
Where do you think the money comes from to pay yours? Does your boss have a printing press in the basement? Of course customers pay your wages!
[i]It was only a waitress job but for a long time that's all I knew.[/i]
And did you make any effort to learn a skill that would pay more? Or do you think that money should just fall out of the sky for no reason other than you want it to?
by cparris
at the ammount of people with their hand out but not willing bring somthing more to the table in exchange for the higher wage.
It's sad that people want what everyone else had but dosen't want to earn it. It should just be given to them.
It's sad that the people have the "everyone should have the same" mentality. Demanding that the government rob from those that apply themselves and give it to them.
I'm absolutely sick of the "Poor Me" syndrome. The "I can't do it" people that haven't even tried! I have friends that make $50+ an hour. Hell yes I would like to make that much, but I want to earn it! I don't want it just given to me.
It's time to make a choice people! Either SH** or get off the pot!
by wmlundine
...provide more entertainment and less information than ever in America. For everyone...not just the poor and it is probably just as well. If Americans were informed they might get a little upset with the our lopsided economic model. Pinochet ended minimum wage in Chile' but the people revolted and in 1982 it was re-established.
Moreover...if bad choices create poverty why isn't Bush unemployed? Damn those victims!
by wmlundine
by jdclyde
What are you going off about "One womans injustice"?
And how does it impact on people poor choices on how to spend their money?
Do you KNOW any "poor" people? Of them, how many do not have a TV? How many don't have cable or satalite? How many don't have a cell phone? How many don't have a game console of some kind? How many wear name brand shoes instead of the bargain shoes?
People make their own decisions in life, and a bad decision will negatively impact on your life, with no one to blame but yourself.
by jdclyde
That had nothing to do with rising wages, so not the best thought out example.
Cotton farmers, now that is an example of a shifting economy. Sure they "freed" the slaves, and even started to pay a wage. Of course what they charged to live there was more than the workers made, so they HAD to work more to pay off their debt. I think that is EXACTLY what happens with the minimum wage and the people that are of limited mental capacity that think they "deserve" to make a living at that skill level of a job. Yes, you make more, but the price of everything goes up and so they are not any better off. But the feel gooders like yourself can trot around because you did something to "help" the poor poor without having to reach in your own pocket once, until YOU have to purchase the products at a higher price. You sure are generous with other peoples money.
by tonythetiger
by jdclyde
the boyfriend/girlfriends that live in a state paid apartment without reporting the added household income to make them pay their share of the rent/utilities.
Don't forget about working for cash and not reporting the income.
Now lets talk about vehicles. No one "deserves" or "has a right" to a nice car. You only have a "right" to go out and EARN the money to purchase that car. My EX is dead broke because she has more vehicle than she can afford. Not sure if that is dumb, stupid, or both.......
It does happen way too often.
How about smoking? Anyone that throws away a few thousand dollars a year isn't getting any sympathy from me.
Bottom line, live within your means. You don't like it? Either work harder to increase your "means" or STFU because you have no one to blame but yourself.
by cparris
Move MORE foreigners here??!! Why? They already suck our economy dry by being illegial! They disrespect our country! They fail to abide by our laws! They don't pay taxes! Not to mention that most of the immigrants that come here are criminals anyway! I know what you are going to say... not all immigrants are criminials. Illegial imigrants are criminials! They have violated many laws and the immigration process! I am not opposed to someone wanting to come here from another country legeally and do their best to assimilate into our culture. Our ancestors did when they came over. More power too them and welcome!
It's time for me to stop. I really want to get ugly about this immigrant thing.
by absolutely
"I really want to get ugly about this immigrant thing."
You may check that off your to-do list, you've already done it.
"Move MORE foreigners here??!! Why? They already suck our economy dry by being illegial! They disrespect our country! They fail to abide by our laws!"
Which immigrants? Which laws? Other than wading across the Rio Grande, would you be surprised to learn that crime rates are lower among immigrants, including both legal and illegal, than among citizens born in the United States? That immigrants consume less money in government handouts than citizens born in the United States? That may be partly because they don't own corporate farms or oil companies, but still, they are better citizens, on average, than "you".
Also, they can probably spell "Illegial imigrants" better than you did!
"I am not opposed to someone wanting to come here from another country legeally and do their best to assimilate into our culture."
You are a moron, and intelligent people have better things to do with our effort than "do their best to assimilate into our culture."
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
[i]Don't forget about working for cash and not reporting the income.[/i]
... support the FairTax, doesn't it?
by cparris
1. Since you're in Oregon, I'm fairly sure, it?s an assumption, that you don't have a Hispanic epidemic like we do here in the south.
2. How many stores do you walk into that you have to speak another language to be able to buy or find anything?
3. The spelling thing; most of these illegals can't speak English much less spell or write it. I don?t profess to be and English major or teacher or even have a decent grasp on spelling but I am able to communicate in English.
4. These "angels" as you make them out to be want us to speak their language, and want us to teach in their language, fly their country's flag, etc, etc, etc add nausea. Yes the puke kind.
5. The fact of the matter is the illegal immigrants that are here are criminals. They have and are breaking federal and international laws. You can justify it any way that you want with money, or crop harvesting or what ever. I am not opposed to them being here as long as it?s in some sort of legal sense.
6. For those that have come here legally; these illegal immigrants are an insult, and an embarrassment to who they are. That?s straight from the ?horse?s? mouth. They learned English. They followed the process and actually probably know more about the history of this country than I do currently. As for their original language, I don?t care if they use it at home or between themselves.
7. It is fairly apparent that you have never been in this region of the country. Until you have lived here and understand what exactly is going on; put a sock in it. On the off chance that you are an immigrant, are you legal or illegal? If you're illegal then you are a criminal as well. If you are legal, then congrats, good job, and welcome.
Finally, where do you get your numbers for the support and government funding? What are your other sources of information on this matter?
by wmlundine
by jdclyde
are people we want in this country.
But you already knew that.
by cparris
Then who would pay taxes? How would that be kept up with? The only way that we could be fair on taxes is the national sales tax or the Fair Tax.
There are many many people that we don't want here. We don't want to support them. To open our boarders to anyone and everyone would make us a third world country almost overnight.
by nicknielsen
every Hispanic in the South is illegal? Speaking of smoking illegal substances...
And an alternate point of view from the non-white non-European crowd:
Edit: formatting
by cparris
that every hispanic in the south was an illegal. Just most of them. Don't forget that it's not just the hispanics but there are illegals from almost every country.
Nice pic BTW.
by absolutely
[i]1. Since you're in Oregon, I'm fairly sure that you don't have a hispanic epidemic like we do here in the south.[/i]
In fact, I have worked with legal migrant workers in the landscaping profession, here in Oregon. The Willamette Valley is very fertile, and as in other agricultural regions, a lot of farm work, especially during harvest, is performed by migrants, both legal and "illegial".
You buffoon!
by cparris
You said ?legal?; I said ?illegal?. Their differences are like pistachios and watermelons.
Most illegal immigrants don?t like very cold weather.
by absolutely
[i]2. How many stores do you walk into that you have to speak another language to be able to buy or find anything?[/i]
Zero. I use my eyes to find Asian or Central American foods in those stores, and my US currency is accepted regardless of the proprietors' level of proficiency in English speech. If another language is spoken in a store [i]by the [b]rightful, legal owner[/b] of that store[/i], no person's rights are violated by that. If, however, you walk into a store [b]owned by somebody else[/b] and presume to tell the owner of that store what language to speak, [b]you would be exceeding your station and violating that person's rights[/b].
by cparris
All of the products have the English names displayed? What about a big store like Wal-Mart?
And, no I don?t go to these stores unless it is an ABSOLUTE necessity.
And let?s get something straight. I am NOT proposing to tell someone how to run their store. I am my own keeper not yours or anyone else?s.
by absolutely
[i]3. The spelling thing; most of these illegals can't speak english much less spell or write it.[/i]
If misspelling was a crime you would be serving a life sentence without the possibility of parole. Capitalize "English" you buffoon.
by cparris
Name calling again? Like I said, it shows your true character and maturity level.
If name calling was a crime I?m sure you would be on death row by now and already put under.
by absolutely
[i]4. These "angels" as you make them out to be want us to speak their language, and want us to teach in their language, fly their country's flag, ect, ect, ect add nausea.[/i]
Please cite examples of [b]illegal aliens[/b] asking or demanding any of the above.
The French "et cetera" is correctly abbreviated "etc." with the "t" before the "c". Also, you misspelled the Latin phrase "ad nauseum". People with glass diplomas shouldn't throw stones, you buffoon!
The real problems facing this country are due to ignorance and laziness of citizens born here, not migration of industrious workers from other countries.
by cparris
by cparris
How?s this; friends, family, and myself have all been told by MANY of these illegals to speak their language, to teach in their language, and angrily and forcefully been commanded that we will conform to their society and customs. You?ll never see this on the news.
If you come here there many people that can tell you of their personal experience or someone that has had an experience of such nature.
by absolutely
[i]5. The fact of the matter is the illegal immigrants that are here are criminals. They have and are breaking fedral and international laws.[/i]
You omitted an "e" from the word "federal", you buffoon! I might stop critiquing your misuse of the English language, but only after you stop expecting others to conform to your irrational whims, such as speaking English in stores that [b]they own, and you do not[/b].
It is indeed a fact that immigration without documentation is defined by regulation as "criminal". However, it is also a fact that without the number of "criminals" who immigrate illegally every year, the agriculture industry would be unable to harvest the crops that you and I both enjoy in grocery stores and restaurants as easily affordable meals.
You cannot [b]survive[/b] without Central American agricultural workers, [b]including those who migrate illegally every harvest season[/b]. I recognize the benefits that these "illegal aliens" provide to me and to the entire US society enough to accept that their presence is necessary. To count only the criminals, and inconveniences like hearing a second language in a store or classroom, is plain stupid.
by cparris
That you like to call names. That?s fine, to call someone else a name either to their face or behind their back is dishonorable. I haven?t called you anything.
The federal thing was a typo? so I can?t type, sue me which in PERFECTLY WITHIN YOUR RIGHTS. I never stated or implied that I was an English teacher, professor, or major for that matter.
I didn?t say that the store owners had to speak English or use it as their primary language in their store. However, would it not be in their BEST INTREST to at least have 1 person that spoke English since they are in a primarily English speaking country? You would have to agree that they would make more money that way. Or do you oppose the customer service aspect of business as well?
Necessary that they are here; maybe. Don?t kid yourself by thinking that they go back at the end of the harvest season. I do ask that if they do come here, that they do it legally.
I have always said that if someone wants to come to this country legally then welcome! If they want to speak their language in their family unit; fine. But be prepared to communicate with others that don?t speak that particular language. For example, if I were going to France, I would learn at least a little French. Or if I were going to Italy, I?d learn at least a little Italian.
by absolutely
[i]6. For those that have come here legeally (sic - correct spelling is "legally" without the second "e"); these immigrants are and ("an" not "and", you buffoon) insult, and an (You spelled "an" correctly! Want a cookie?) embarrassment to who they are. They learned english. (If you feel so strongly about [b]other people[/b] using English, why do [b]you[/b] repeatedly fail to capitalize it, hypocrite?[/i]
How presumptuous of you to pretend to speak for [b]all legal immigrants![/b] You really are an [b]arrogant[/b] son of a monkey!
by cparris
sense enough to tease and taunt people. It shows your true character and your maturity level. I sincerely hope that you don?t treat your underlings in such a manner. If so; I would imagine that you either have low department morale, no one wants to work with you, or you have a high turnover rate in employees. I also wouldn?t be surprised if you had a really high IQ either. It?s a proven fact that people with high IQ?s are really book smart but when it comes to common sense, ?they ain?t got a lick.? That?s the norm; however, there are exceptions.
FYI... I don't care if I misspelled any words in this one.
by absolutely
[i]7. It is fairly apparent that you have never been in this region of the country. Until you have lived here and understand what exactly is going on; put a sock in it. On the off chance that you are an immigrant, are you legal or illegal? If you're illegal then you are a criminal as well. If you are legal, then congrats, good job, and welcome.[/i]
Until [b]you[/b] know the facts you incorrectly assumed about Oregon in your part 1, [b]you[/b] put a sock in it, you buffoon.
by cparris
by absolutely
According to the Department of Customs & Border Protection, the cost of enforcing immigration law is only $7.8B:
http://www.cbp.gov/xp/cgov/newsroom/fact_sheets/budget/bush_2007_budget.xml
The agriculture industry, [b]depends[/b] on illegals (52% of farm workers are undocumented, according to http://cds.aas.duke.edu/saf/pdfs/fwfactsheet.pdf), contributes $132B or $149B to GDP, depending whether you calculate 1% of "GDP (purchasing power parity)" or 1% of "GDP (official exchange rate)".
https://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/factbook/geos/us.html
If you don't like the numbers, take your whining to Duke University, the CIA and the Department of Customs & Border Protection, you buffoon!
by cparris
It?s nice to know that you missed the point entirely!
I?m sure that the Department of customs and Border Protection would tell me that they are under funded.
Duke University would say ?so what??
The CIA probably would arrest me for wanting to know about something that is probably secret or higher.
The facts from what I have seen so far is that they aren?t really doing anything to rectify the problem. Weather that actually is that case or not I don?t know. I will find out what they are doing eventually when I have the time or feel like trading the sleep to know.
After all of this; Absolutely will come back and call me a ?buffoon? again. Showing his true character and maturity level.
by tonythetiger
If I don't like the language spoken by a store owner, or the color of his shirt, or anything else, I don't go into the store. Likewise if he doesn't like the language you speak, or the color or your shirt, he doesn't have to serve you.
You'll have that in a free country, donchaknow :)
by wmlundine
by cparris
or harm people. People harm people. To blame money is like blaming guns for killing people. Guns don't kill people by themselves. People kill people.
Think about that and then apply it to other aspects of people wanting control.
by tonythetiger
by wmlundine
by jdclyde
is to ban the money, NOT allow an open house to anyone that wants to come into the country.
We can start by you sending me your next pay check?
by cparris
Tell me...
How exactly does an inanimate object kill someone? Does it get up and paper cut them to death? Oh, I know, a gigantic quanty of it falls on them!?
Face it, your logic makes no sense. It's the person that either has or wants the money that does the killing; not the money it's self.
Money does nothing but sit there unable to think, breathe, move, speak, or anything else for that matter. Same thing with a gun. They both do nothing until a person picks them up and utilizes it.
If you can think of a way that money can, all by it's self, kill; please, let me know.
by absolutely
Would you begin with corporate bailouts, utility subsidies, and other government gifts to millionaires & billionaires, or would you begin with Welfare, food stamps and other government gifts to the poor?
by absolutely
wmlundine: [i]"No, buying food or medicine or housing while poor keeps poor folks poor enough. One [b]woman's[/b] injustice is another [b]man's[/b] "poor choices". Right?"[/i]
Why the different genders in the same question? If you intended to imply something about a disparity in my compassion toward women as compared to men, please make your implication specific. If not, please explain why you [b]did[/b] use different genders in that one sentence.
[i]"People need choices...no?"[/i]
We'll get to that, [b]after[/b] you explain yourself.
by tonythetiger
by jdclyde
they would hang him high as an example for everyone else......
Ever seen "The Stand"?
THAT is enforcement/deterrent!
by aspong38
I understand costumers pay our income. But for a company to get away with paying thier help two dollars an hour and expept the costumers to make up the difference is wrong.
And yes I have gone to school, and have two degrees. But we do what we need to to support our kids and do the job that pays for the needs of our children.
And now that Ive raised my kids I can do alot of other things and I do.
Today I only have to worry about myself so I went away from what I went to school for and away from what I choose to do knowing it would pay the bills to doing a job I have fun at and enjoy and look forward to everyday. It's more physical work than most jobs, but it's my choice.
I wasn't complaining about waitressing, I enjoyed it. I just don't think it's right restaurants don't have to pay thier employee wages and the goverment thinks the costumers should. They are charging for thier product just like any other company and getting what the product is worth.
When I go out to eat I want to tip a waitress because it's my way of saying thank you, not here's part of your income.
But I guess some people look at it differently which is fine, that's your right.
And to think I might not have any other skills, is what most people think of people like myself. Well some of us choose to do a job because it's what's right for our life at the time and is what will be the best in raising our kids. But we still deserve to earn what we are worth and earn what put into out job. And for some companys to be getting off so good as it is and only have to pay thier employees two dollars an hour and not even consider giving raises is wrong. Thay are cheap and selffish people in my view.
by aspong38
I think most everyone thinks about these things. I'm not saying that your thoughts are wrong cause I agree on alot of your thoughts and ideas...
But I also know that at some point somethings got to be done. We have these business were not alot of training or skill is needed, so they pay the lowest wages they can, speaking of fast food, retail, and many more. We can't just close all those places because they don't want to pay a good wage, enough for one to make it, and allow the employees to gain raises. And in the mean time while everyone's worring about other issues, more and more people are loosing things, more and more are becoming homeless.
I don't know the answer to the problem, but somethings got to get done soon or I believe we are in alot more trouble than this war that'g going on
by wmlundine
by jdclyde
then why did the price increase on many products when the COST of gas went up? Because it COST more to do business, cutting into the profit ratio. If that ratio gets below a point, they would make more money with their money invested in bonds than running a business.
So yes, rising costs gets passed on to the consumer in the form of higher prices, as we have repeatedly seen.
by wmlundine
by absolutely
by jdclyde
in the fast food joints, they make their profit on the drink and fries. The sandwich is just to get you in the door.
theaters, your ticket price covers their lease of the movie and overhead. Again the profit is in the concession stand. Mostly the soda and popcorn.
If someone in government were to decide to give away more of the theaters money in the form of a mandatory pay raise (that the employees had done nothing to EARN) then that cuts into the profits. The price of their goods will go up in relation to keep their profit ratio consistent.
Sure is easy to spend someone else's money, and try to justify it away, huh?
Bottom line, the employee gets paid what they are WORTH, and if the employee is worth ANYTHING, they will not be working at minimum wage anyways.
by wmlundine
by jdclyde
will the new increase in the minimum wage make it so people with no work skills will be able to make a living working at McDonalds?
If not, what will be the benefit and to whom?
Will this be what others have argued for, a "living wage"?
by tonythetiger
[i]Well some of us choose to do a job because it's what's right for our life at the time and is what will be the best in raising our kids.[/i]
right for your life, then you wouldn't be complaining about the wage (unless you life [b]is[/b] complaining, in which case I'd recommend a new one).
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
by wmlundine
by tonythetiger
[i]ou could triple wages at a Nike factory and only add about a dollar to the cost.[/i]
Raising the minimum wage won't just increase Nike's labor cost, it will raise the cost of the laces (because the lace contractor also had to rais his wages), the rubber, the little eyelet thingies, etc. All of which ends up coming out of the consumer's pocket.
by wmlundine
by absolutely
Record it on your video phone if it ever actually happened.
[i]How?s this; friends, family, and myself have all been told by MANY of these illegals to speak their language, to teach in their language, and angrily and forcefully been commanded that we will conform to their society and customs. You?ll never see this on the news.
If you come here there many people that can tell you of their personal experience or someone that has had an experience of such nature.[/i]
I suspect it's true that I'll never see any of that on the news. That doesn't help me believe what you say.
by absolutely
I don't know a single, specific meaning of the phrase "common sense" so I'm not certain what it is that you asserting high IQ people haven't licked. Based on what I know of you so far, thank you for the compliment.
[i]It?s a proven fact that people with high IQ?s are really book smart but when it comes to common sense, ?they ain?t got a lick.? That?s the norm; however, there are exceptions.[/i]
Proven how? By whom?
by absolutely
by absolutely
Low wages for wait staff are the result of the fact that tipping is customary, not the cause. If your wages were increased, prices to the customers would also have to increase, and customers would have less money to tip you.
The current system is better for you because it allows wealthier and more generous customers to give you more money, without driving up prices on customers with less cash.
by wmlundine
Sort by Trending