Discussion Locked

What is the purpose of setting a minimum wage?

0 helpful
323 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

323 replies

by dogknees

So, if you lose your job, and your spouse still has one, you would be banned from getting another until the unemployment is 0%. Or to be more precise, while a single person is unemployed.

But hang on, you're unemployed, since you lost your job, so the rate can never be zero, and so you should never work again.

by tony hopkinson

off to those who coudl earn and the economy was going well enough to give them something to go for I'd vote for you. None of those in welfare mode would though.

How about you only get a vote if you could pay taxes and you do. That would cut out MDs and scroungers.
Course that would violate both our constitutions.

Seriously whatever incentives we create, without something to put opportunities within reach, we are just swapping problems.

We are probably the worst people to come up with a solution, we've built our lives on wanting to pay our way and wanting to better ourselves and through ability, drive and a smidgeon of luck succeeded.
I know a few lifelong welfare recipients, they are alien to me. I don't get the way they think at all.

by tony hopkinson

Slavery still exists.
So does indenture.
Repeal the laws and someone will use them to make a profit. It's not against the law, so why should they not? There's only one reason to support repealing the codifications of basic human rights, so you can violate them again 'legally'.

You want to have a real effect on society by repealing a law, drugs is where you should look. That's profitable because it is illegal.

by maxwell edison

Slavery does not exist in the United States, which is what I said. Nonetheless, it's a moot point, since our 13th amendment should not, and will not, be repealed.

I'm also in favor of repealing most drug laws as well.

by tony hopkinson

It doesn't exist as an instituion. I bet there are slaves in the US. Prostitution slavery is big business in europe.

Nice to know we do agree on something else though. I'd love to see the drug cartels faces if it was legalised.

by ericl_w199

i dont believe the minimum wage is enough to live anywhere really.BUT most people do not call the basics "food,shelter" its food,shelter,cell phone,cable,nice car.I know a few people at work who complain all the time about not being able to pay bills and such but they all have cell phones,all the cable channels you can get.so i dont understand that part.we have a local news guy that did a story about time warner charging a dollar to pay their bill in person.and the person who is complaining about this is some poor person and im supposed to feel bad he is being charged a dollor to pay his bill?.....yea whatever.

by jdclyde

If "you" run up "your" expenses because "you" feel you DESERVE something, then the average person would not and should not shed a tear of sympathy over "your" stupidity.

[i]disclaimer: "you" is meant in the generic form, not pointed at Ericl or anyone specific. If you see that it applys to YOU, then YOU are the YOU I was refering to.[/i]

Secret to happiness, want less, and appreciate what you DO have more.

by cparris

are two diffrent things. Dumb is you don't know better so you don't or can't do better.
Stupid is you know better but you still don't do any better.
With that said, if anyone is actually stupid enough to run up their debts to where they can't afford it; I have absolutely no sympanthy (sp?) for them. They knew that they shouldn't do it but did anyway.
The question here actually is "why should I be penalized for your lack of ability to have dicipline and manage your finances correctly?"
Speaking of which....
Why should I penalized for those that won't make an effort to get off their tails and get a job? Why do they have the fedral govenment rob from me to support their stupid lives and choices?

by jamesrl

Yes it has been years since my university days, but when I look back, here is what I had and didn't have.

I didn't have a car. I took the train or bus from school to home(not often), a trip of about 400 miles. I had a bus pass for the winter and a bicycle in the summer.

I didn't have a TV. My roomate did and that was fine. I was studying with a radio, mono with cassette. I didn't have a stereo. We just had rabbit ears and got 4 channels.

Didn't have a cell phone, or even an answering machine. Roomate would take messages for me and vice versa.

I couldn't afford to eat out much. I did get one meal a day at the university - the salad bar was cheap. That was my luxury. A couple of times a week I might have a beer.

But when I look back at it, it was some of the happiest times in my life. I had great friends. We had good times on the cheap.

James

by cparris

of raise and then everything else goes up. The vast majority of people don't know that the money that it gets raised by comes from somewhere. It's a vicious cycle that will never stop. The minimum wage gets raised. Well this raise costs the employer about twice what the actual raise is. Where does this money come from? The employer is going to raise the price on their goods to make up for this difference. So the people that are making only minimum wage are back where they started and everyone else is in worse shape simply because now we have to pay more for things we want with the same ammount of money. Since the minimum wage worker is back where they started they cry for another raise in the minimum wage. It gets granted and the cycle starts over again.

Now don't get me wrong; I'm for people getting paid what they are worth. However, I do have to agree that there are alot of people out there that aren't worth half of what they are paid weather they are minimum wage or not. Suprising thing is, these people always seem to be the ones that are kept while the good ones are sent packing to look for another job.

If you don't believe me then take this into consideration; every time that the minimum wage was raised, inflation went up proportionally as well. True; there are several factors that drive inflation like the deficit and the national debt. However, those are usually very steady, unless we are at war, and increase at a fairly constant rate.

If you are in the United States, research the Fair Tax. This would help better than ever raising the minimum wage.

by tonythetiger

If you accept the premise that liberty is the desired state, you should also accept that government (whose every action [/b]restricts[/b] the liberties of someone or other) must be strictly controlled. The FairTax will be a good start toward regaining that control in the U.S.

by cparris

For someone to work weather they need to or not should never be aginst the law. That's like telling them that they can swim. We aren't going to help you out of the middle of the lake even though you might drown getting to shore.

by nicknielsen

In almost every situation where higher education has been made essentially free, both initial enrollments and student drop-out rates have soared. People sign up because "I couldn't afford it before, but now I can get a good education." After the first weeks, they realize they are woefully unprepared for the rigors of college courses or this isn't what they wanted or this is too much like work and drop out.

If you wish to provide free education, charge a substantial up-front fee, then reimburse that fee on the [u]successful[/u] completion of all enrolled courses. The reimbursed fee could then be applied to the next term's classes. This will weed out those who are not absolutely serious about taking advantage of such a opportunity.

by nicknielsen

[i]...slavery had already been abolished in the United States, meaning that people were already free to leave a job that paid too little for them to live.[/i]

Did I miss something in my labor history classes? Could you please explain to me how a coal miner living in a company town, being paid in company script, was "free" to leave on the company train and not essentially a slave? Many other workers in single-industry towns were in the same situation. They were not free to leave because they were paid in script, not cash, and therefore had no actual money. "Fair market value" was decided by the same people who hired the thugs to keep workers in and unions out.

Granted, by the time the first national minimum wage was passed in 1938, companies were required to pay workers in currency and allow other businesses to compete for the worker's custom, but it had only been since 1933.

by tonythetiger

working for minimum wage. They consider it working for the difference between minimum wage and what they are getting by not working (or not working legitimately).

by tekboyny

Everyone's is worth at least 6.50 -7.00 and you can't even live on that. You not only pay for the work done bu tthe person's time and commitment as well. Besides, for the "small business man" who can't stay in business without illegal workers at lower wages than minimum, drive a mid sized sedan instead of a mercedes. Live in a slightly less expensive home. Stop living in excess. Why should I have to pay for the cost of your "cheap lab or" with my taxes? A bit off topic but I think it kind of is related.

by tonythetiger

then ALL employers would be required to pay it. Compassion is a human emotional trait. It's not, nor should it be, a government policy.

by mylord

The minimum wage doesn't violate the law of supply and demand. It merely sets a new equilibrium level for them. No one paid the minimum wage is overpaid. Their work becomes worth that once the new equilibrium is reached. At the most, very most, some jobs that shouldn't even be done in this country, jobs that often rely on shifting their costs on to the backs of taxpayers to subsidize, are no longer done. That is little loss at all. In fact it is a benefit to be rid of such poor jobs.

by frgough

Nobody is "worth" just 6.50 to 7.00 an hour. A person's worth is
incalculable. However, I believe you are actually referring to the
worth of a person's labor, and that is determined by how many
others can do the same job.

More people can dig a ditch than can build a nuclear reactor.
The ditch digger's labor is worth less.

This is a fundamental law of human interaction. A government
telling you a ditch digger labor is worth $6.50 does not change
the actual worth of his labor, it simply assigns an arbitrary value
to it. The Nuclear scientist is still worht 50 times more and his
salary will increase correspondingly, thus re-asserting the true
value of the ditch-digger's salary.

Minimum wage legislation does nothing except slow economic
growth, increase unemployment and create inflation. Oh, yes,
and buy votes.

by wmlundine

Joe Mctrustfund is the President (aka GWB). We should pay him to just stay home (he does less harm that way and his daddy can afford it).

by tonythetiger

but there are several hundred thousand people who [b]are[/b] living on that, and more than likely at least as many living on [b]less[/b] than that. (for comparison, I think Welfare and foodstamps in ohio were, when a single person could get them, $216 and $128 respectively... that's $344 a month, so that would be equivalent to what, about $1.90 an hour using 40 hour weeks?)

Perhaps you've never been in the position to know just how little you really can get by on. IT might not be a bad skill to learn... you know, just in case....

by jkowolf

Everything you mentioned should be considered but you never mentioned the history behind the whole thing. Why did it start in the first place? Weren't the open markets able to support an adequate wage for all employees? Maybe not. A sliding scale seems to be valid. You never mentioned taking a cut in profits to pay your employees more. If you're running a small business and you have to pay too high of wages to make a go of it; find another business or go get a job. Cotton farmers in the South took a huge cut in profits when slavery was abolished. Stop making buggy whips and create a business model that pays a high enough wage to the people who are making your business function. Unless you want to do everything yourself.

by deadly ernest

but in Australia it was brought in by the political arm of the Trade Union Movement, way back when.

You guys think you have it bad, here in Australia, one of our major political parties is the mouth piece for the Trade Union Movement, and their constituion is such that if the party membership says "a" and the union leadership says "b", then the political party MUST do "b" and any attempt to do otherwise sees them dumped from their position in the party.

There have been cases of the party pushing a policy during an election campaign, and upon election the trade union mangement say "don't do it" and the elected government doesn't do it as its that party - seems not even the voters have a right to expect those party people to do anything but obey the union movement.

by cparris

to business and the work place anywhere. They want a raise... they go strike and just about shut the business down. I see it like this...
If a union strikes... fire every one of them that's out there picketing or on strike, hire new people, move on with life.
Unions impede progress. Unions say that you can't fire someone just because they are part of a union. Unions expect dues paid to them and what I've here they aren't cheap. Unions say that every year that the company is REQUIRED to give a specific raise weather the employee is deserving or not. And if a company dosen't... look out they start threatening to strike or actually do strike until their demands are realized.

For those of you that are part of a union, please don't be offended. This is only what I have seen as an outsider looking in.

However, if the shoe fits; wear it.

by absolutely

The minimum wage sets a [b]false[/b] equilibrium level, [b]different[/b] than the one set by the laws of supply & demand, [b]unless[/b] everybody is [b]already[/b] paid more than the wage set as "minimum" by the laws. In such a case, bleeding hearts would have more trouble stirring up the unwashed masses to support such regulations.

by absolutely

I have never heard of laborers accepting jobs that pay anything but government-backed legal tender. Assuming that your story is something more than the product of your own imagination, the workers in question did, at they time they accepted employment, have the option to decline such employment. Based on the fact that they accepted the terms of employment in the first place, [b]the[/b] rational conclusion is that such was their [b]best[/b] option, at that time. Do [b]you[/b] assert that all laborers are morons incapable of identifying, and choosing [b]how[/b] to pursue, our own self-interest?

[edit: specified replying to NickNeilsen]

by absolutely

[b]If[/b] that is true, "my friend", there is no need for a minimum wage because corpses are notoriously lazy & non-productive.

by protiusx

Rubbish. Absolute rubbish! I suggest you read Maxwell's post which clearly and very concisely deals with the subject of a minimum wage.

As to your notion of a social contract - One of the things that has always made this country great and has attracted hundreds of millions of people from around the world to flock here is that in the United States of America it is possible to create vast amounts of wealth and prosperity from relatively nothing. As examples of this I give you Bill Gates (now the richest man in the world) and Oprah Winfrey. Both individuals were born into the middle class and both took the opportunities given them and forged great wealth and prosperity from it.

Social contract indeed, Hogwash!

by tonythetiger

they [b]created[/b] opportunities that others have taken advantage of. I wonder how many [b]more[/b] opportunities they could create if their corporate taxes were eliminated.

by tony hopkinson

after your allowance, 22% 'til ?37k then 40%.
Then there's 17.5 VAT on a lot of stuff. Duties on fuel, tobacco and alchohol. Then there's local taxes, called the council tax.....

We pay but the safety net is very good, depends on where your priorities are. It could be argued in my case I'd be OK if the burden for thing like health care and education were shifted from the state to the individual, but that has not always been true.

I'left school in 79, in time for hideous levels of unemployment that were a direct result of government policy. The sort of policies, you and others are advocating. So getting buy in off me is going to be impossible, no matter how much personally I might be better off now.

Institutionalising welfare to keep a low wage economy, is a disastrously stupid policy.

by absolutely

Anybody who needs any encouragement beyond the profit available in a [b]free[/b] market deserves [b]less[/b] encouragement, not more.

by absolutely

The minimum cheer was raised, and almost immediately we observe inflation in the cheering market.

by absolutely

I don't assume you're playing. I say what I mean and I treat others as I expect to be treated.

by lexva

Or, more commonly, it's called being a troll, stirring up needless controversy for the joy of annoying other people.

by deadly ernest

the bit about expecting me to know who Condoleezza was, I had to google the name to understand who you were refering to. But in a way it's a nice double pun. I meant to say confetti, and rice is a commonly used in place of confetti - hmm, wasn't intended at the time, but not bad in hindsight

by wmlundine

...Corporate profits, meanwhile, are at their highest share of gross domestic product since the 1960?s...(meanwhile)...We are getting closer and closer to a work force with no benefits and no substantive protections.

Now me...Our elected officials (federal) take an oathe to uphold the Constitution. Historically; the government has enacted worker protections (like minimum wage) under the welfare clause. That is ..."promote the general Welfare..." of the people to whom the Constitution is dedicated (as in "We the People..". Nowhere does it say "..to protect our corporate interests here and abroad". But like I said...keep it up and you we learn the hard way..."those who forget history are doomed..."

by tonythetiger

[i]...Corporate profits, meanwhile, are at their highest share of gross domestic product since the 1960?s]

I'll bet that the New York times thought you understood the significance of that statement, they wouldn't have printed it.

(clue: What happenned (or perhaps more accurately, "Who") in the 1960s to cause the profit margin to drop?)

by deadly ernest

Being up asa percentage of domestic product, just shows that the DP is down for some reason, and they're getting more profit from overseas. Another side aspect is that they are looking at the total dollars - a much more accurate way of looking at corporate profit is to look at it as a percentage of total revenue, this gives a much clearer picture of their profit margins. If small business worked on the same profit margins as major corporations, they wouldn't exist - many overheads reduce, per capita, with size.

However, a few really big companies are a problem, either individually, or as a group, because of their predatory business practices (notably MS and RIAA) it's these types that go about buying protective actions and legislation by buying elected officials.

Anyway, back to the subject - corporate profits are not directly affected by the minimum wage issue, while small business operations are.

by delbertpgh

Yeah, and abolish the minimum wage, so they can get on their feet for $2 an hour. Probably the minimum wage is destroying all kinds of sub-five-dollar jobs. Ain't that the story you're peddling?

Despise the poor. If they were worth your respect, they'd be doing okay already. And cut their minimum income, just to make sure they have an extra incentive.

by wmlundine

Forget the poor...any breaks they get will be squandered on stupid stuff like food and housing. Tax breaks for the rich (on the other hand) stimulate the economy 'cause they what to do with money...buy an expensive gas guzzler...of course!

by nicknielsen

Stupid is forever.

The ones that bother me are the ones that rack up the bills, then declare bankrupcty, rack up the bills, then declare bankruptcy...

My question is who do these people know that they can continually get credit after consecutive bankruptcies?

by cparris

People who declare bankruptcey cannot declair it for a few years after that. During that time they have to pay every bill they've created or settle the agreement in satisfactory terms. After the time limit is up they can declare bankruptcey again. That's how they get credit afterwords.

Now, if you have to point the blame finger, it would have to be at the financial institutions that do this even though they have a guarranteed payback for a few years. They should deny anyone that has declaired bankruptcey more than once within 15 years.

by nicknielsen

The people I am talking about are the serial bankrupts: rack up the bills, bankrupt, discharge, rack up the bills, bankrupt, discharge, ad infinitum. I know of a couple in their 60s who have declared bankruptcy 5 times! Five! Every 8 years, like clockwork. Each time they owed over $100k (not including the new house). Each time they kept a bigger house and better cars.

How do these people get credit? I should think the credit agencies would flag their records or something.

by deadly ernest

of the debt after 'x' years, and it's not allowed for people to hold that against them. Maybe we should see about changing the laws and reinstating a debtors' prison, where they can do semi-skilled work to pay off the debt.

by tonythetiger

[i]Now, if you have to point the blame finger, it would have to be at the financial institutions that do this even though they have a guarranteed payback for a few years.[/i]

Just like a store owner includes the loss due to the occasional theft in his prices, banks include the loss due to the occasional default in theirs.

It's just business!

by absolutely

"get on their feet"

I didn't knock anybody off their feet, and I don't owe everybody help getting on their feet.

"Yeah, and abolish the minimum wage, so they can get on their feet for $2 an hour. Probably the minimum wage is destroying all kinds of sub-five-dollar jobs. Ain't that the story you're peddling?"

I'm not peddling anything, fool. The fact is that if living people take a job, and don't die, they are able to [b]live[/b] with that wage. They may need another job to buy all the necessities of life, but convenience and ease are not guaranteed by the Constitution, and for good reason. Hard work builds character.

by wmlundine

...decided it is a good idea to lower taxes on the wealthy during times of war...and who says it is ok to spend Trillions on a war based on lies while cutting social programs..and who would advance those corporate interests abroad while demanding draconian cuts in funding in oppressed countries? If people are that stupid they deserve what they get.

by tonythetiger

[i] And Who...

...decided it is a good idea to lower taxes on the wealthy during times of war.[/i]

...However you figure it, actual dollars, adjusted dollars, or percentage of GNP, spending on social programs has increased every single year since LBJ took office.

And I hate to tell you this again, but businesses (most wealth is created by business) do not pay taxes... any tax levied upon them is passed along to the consumer, built in to the cost of the product or service... so when you cut taxes on business, you are actually helping the consumer.

[i]and who would advance those corporate interests abroad while demanding draconian cuts in funding in oppressed countries?[/i]

You really should see an eye doctor, because you're as blind as a bat! Do you really think the government makes anything? Did they build a single city? Have they made a microwave, a car, or even a bicycle?

No, they didn't. They [b]can't![/b] "Corporate interests" makes these things. Always have, always will. It is they who put off their 'instant gratification' by investing, and they who risk losing their capital in the process. Profit (when it happens) is the reward for their patience and willingness to risk.

Leeching off of that profit is what big government, and those who support it, do. You can only load the mule down so much before you break its back. That's what you and yours are trying to do, and if you are successful, more businesses will pull out of this country. Then what are you going to do? Who is going to pay for the social services then? Oh, I know, you'd do what the Russians did... have the government take over all capital... well, we know how that one turned out. Without profit, there was no new capital created, so they just rode that horse until it broke down.

Your way is already a proven failure. Government, any form... any party..., is the enemy of human advancement. They leech off the fruits of your labors, and restrict your freedoms. The need to be minimized and put back in their place as [b]servants[/b] of society and the first step is to get them completely out of the charity business (they're obviously not very good at it!).

by delbertpgh

While I'm not anti-capitalist, I don't lean on fantasies to make them seem more saintly, nor government more evil.

Spending on social programs, even as a % of GDP, probably has gone up every year since LBJ, but that includes a little program called Social Security. Possibly you were thinking of everything else (job training subsidies, welfare, etc.)

The idea that the consumer, in the end, pays all business taxes in the form of higher prices is true, but if businesses were not taxed at all, then business owners would find ways of including personal activities as business operations, to exclude them from tax. For example, in the 70s, somebody I knew very well created a leasing corporation to own his family cars. It only cost $20 to file a corporation in Colorado in those days. Everything he invested in the business was lost, because it made no profit and was left with nearly worthless cars at the end of his lease; hence his car payments became business losses, deductible against his other investment income (which was taxed at the rate of 40% to 80% in those days.) Clever, and completely legal, at the time.

Corporate owners do not actually "make" anything... they assume risk, and they manage, but the president of a pencil company does not spend many hours in the year bent over a lathe or a glue machine. His workers make the product, and the gross margin (retail value vs factory cost) is what makes all other business activities, including profit, possible.

It is possible to break the financial back of the business owner, by assigning more and more costs to him, but it is sure possible to break the spiritual back of the worker, who is the fuel for the whole capitalist engine.

That's one of the reasons why we need a minimum wage.

by wmlundine

...that's the same crap Regan spread in the eighties..."..get off the back of business and they will energize America" (to paraphrase)... and America is still waiting. Business took the windfall profits and headed offshore before people woke up. What is a corporation without people? When is the last time you saw a corporate executive create anything (or their rented politicians for that matter)? And please do not tell me we are better off! I have lived long enough to know better!

by cparris

Praise Jesus!
Sombody spoke the truth!
Big government is the downfall of any nation. Big government "robs" from the working man or woman no matter how much they make and gives it to the "poor me" people that are too lazy to get off their duffs and make a living like everyone else. The "I should have what they have" dilusion that most people are under these days is redicilious! It's just plain out crazy and will lead to the fall of us all!

How bout this...
Why don't we try taking the money that the government is giving away to these lazy "couch testers" and breeders and pay off the national debt. Remember when gas was $0.50 a gallon? Milk was less than a dollar a gallon? A loaf of bread was $0.75? what was the minimum wage then? I believe it was somthing like $4.25 and hour. Now it's $5.75 and hour and Milk a gallon is almost 4 buck, bread is 2 buck and gas in back down to 2 bucks a gallon.

I hope that you see a point in this comparision. If you don't, then you are truly blind.

by wmlundine

...then we are the problem...all of us...as in "We the People...". (You should try to think these things through).

by tonythetiger

If there's no tax, there's no reason for a loss deduction! The only thing that should be taxed is excessive consumption ('excessive', for this purpose, is defined by the poverty level), as everything people tend to do with capital (besides consuming, of course) tends to create more capital.

[i]It is possible to break the financial back of the business owner, by assigning more and more costs to him, but it is sure possible to break the spiritual back of the worker, who is the fuel for the whole capitalist engine.

That's one of the reasons why we need a minimum wage.[/i]

First, as has been pointed out incessantly by those who are accusing the government of violating the first amendment, [b]It's not the job of government to care for anyone's 'spirit'![/b] Second, if anything, setting a minimum wage breaks the workers' spirit, thus also violating the first amendment. It also violates the 14th (equal protection). How dare the government prevent the lesser-skilled citizen with no prospects of formal education the same option that others are allowed to freely choose. A business owner is permitted to operate at a loss (investing in the future... when it is hoped that business will pick up). A college student is allowed to work a few hours a week when not studying (basically doing the same thing... studying is an investment in [/b]his[/b] future when it is hoped that [b]his[/b] 'business' will pick up). Why is the low-skilled worker not allowed to do the same thing? operate at a lower wage to start... to get an opportunity to learn... in the workplace itself, in the hope that [b]his[/b] 'investment' will lead to bigger and better things?

It seems to me... yet again... that the government is actually [b]causing[/b] the problem it claims it is trying to solve!

by tonythetiger

actually 'gotten off of', it would have slowed, but not stopped the problem. Even Reagan couldn't undo the damage that has been done. Government cannot solve this problem... they [b]are[/b] the problem!

by protiusx

I think we can agree then that less government is better. I am for the individual keeping his or her money and doing with it what they will rather than giving the money to a central government so that government can institute regulations and controls on what the individual can and cannot do.

by tony hopkinson

I'm all for minimising government, compressing them all in a garbage masher seems like a good start.

A pure free market economy, now globalistaion is a fact, will be just as damaging to a country as a socialist model like France's.

One gives you a nation of professional welfare scroungers the other increases the gap between rich and poor, that will divide society and bring it down in flames.

Neither is good for business.

I've seen "I'm alright Jack, FU" in action. been there done that, sold the teeshirt for a crust of mouldy bread when it went nipples up.

A goverments role is to create the conditions where businesses will invest to reduce the weklfare burden , not pay them off for keeping it, so it can milk votes.

Whether you pay Acme corp or the government for such basic services makes no odds, it's still money you have to spend! It's outgoings, who gets it, is immaterial.

Who should profit from providing health and edcuation, the state, or some fat b'stard in a tax haven?

by protiusx

I don't understand why you associate wealth with greed or avarice. I also don't understand why you assert that we will either have to pay "the man" for government programs or "fat b'stard" in order to work. As I am a normal worker I get paid for working and not the other way around.
If your greif is with an "unfair" tax system I agree with you. I say equal rights for everyone and special rights to none. Flat tax across everyone, remove Indian reservations and take away all entitlements. Sink or swim but everyone gets the same treatment.

by cparris

Let's see here...
We the people...
Elect government officials...
The people never have direct control if any control over the House, Senate, or the legislative branches...
Then the elected officials do what they want to...
Elected officials hiding what they actually do by distracting the people with other things...
Elected Officials do one or two things at the end of their term for the people to get re-elected for their office...
Somewhere in all of this they vote to give themselves pay raises...

Now... think about that for quite a while before responding...

Our government is never actually and has never actually been controlled by the people, EVER! In the end, it all comes down to what do I have to do to buy votes.

It's not about lierity. It's not about happines. It's not about freedom.

IT IS ABOUT MONEY! ALL ABOUT MONEY!

Stop being blind and realize this.

by tonythetiger

while your representative votes himself another raise, without producing a raise in the level of 'service'.

[sarcasm]
Gee, maybe everyone should work for the government, then everyone would get a raise.
[/sarcasm]

by cparris

We should run for pres and vice pres!
Then we could vote ourselves a pay raise and maybe make some good change!

by tony hopkinson

the only reason you don't need a union now is because they were needed once, and they answered that need.

Every piece of legislation that safeguards us from abuse by an employer is a result of union activity.

I'm a brit without the labour movement which was paid for by my forefathers contributions to a union out of a salary that an illegal immigrant wouldn't touch, I wouldn't even have a vote !

A lot of your constitution is a reaction against the injustices unions were fighting.

There are unions who've forgotten, there are workers who have, but remember the union wasn't some external political body, it was us and if required it will be again.

by cparris

The unions that have forgotten will eventualy take the companies that they work for and make them go under. It is good that they caused good changes, but when they get upset over somthing like a pay raise and strike, that's bad for business everywhere espically if it's a company like FedEx or UPS.
The last UPS strike is what I remember. UPS lost millions of dollars in accounts simply because the union striked. The vast majority of that business went to FedEx and Airborne. Then after that, UPS laid off lots of people. This all happened over the thanksgiving and Christmas holidays. That was a nice present from the union to those that wern't protected by it.

That's my point. People are too selfish to consider the big picture. It's almost always "what can I get me with the lease ammount of effort?" not "What kind of ripple will this cause and could it possiably put me or anyone else out of a job?"

Does that make any sense?

by tony hopkinson

Unions with this sort of practice no longer exist in the UK.
I was a fully paid up member of a union from 81 - 99. I've never been on strike.
I have been injured though, I've seen colleagues suffere even worse. I've seen management encourage people to fracture safety procedures so they can make and extra buck. I've seen them try to hide the evidence of their culpability. I've seen them try to rip me off, to renege on verbal and written agreements.
All of which I would have been next to powerless to fight on my own.

Don't throw unions out, throw the chiselers out. Like any other politician the only power they have is that which you lend them. If they aren't using it in your interests, take it back.

by ontheropes

Not the home of the whopper. BK is how it shows up for 10 years on your credit report.

It's not that difficult to get credit after a BK. You may end up paying a higher interest rate but you can get credit. I get at least one credit card offer every day of the week. Sometimes two or three. Add a little melted parrafin wax and they make great fire starters. B-) I have a debit card. It works for me.

I worked on the same hierarchy level with a Corporate Manufacturing Engineering Manager at a Fortune 500 company who had owned and bankrupted 3 [b]businesses[/b]. He worked there to pay off a personal loan from the very wealthy Chairman of the Board thru payroll deduction.

Think of the lives disrupted.

Amazingly, to me, some of his former employees were still loyal to him. That's probably because he found them to be "qualified" for jobs at the same place we both worked. They seemed to avoid me for some reason.

He was a trip.

During an overseas assignment to India he had to fly Tourist class while the rest of us flew Business class at $5,000.00 a pop. Bummer. His sense of humor about that was what you'd expect when I asked how he managed to squeeze his fat ass into one of those seats. He almost spewed his after dinner cocktail thru his nose.

There must be some way to finagle debt that I don't know about. The dood mentioned above never lost his home, his cars, or anything substantial. He'd laugh about the entire BK thing. He wouldn't explain anything, he'd just laugh.

I'll guesstimate the market value on his home during his last BK at $750K. It's a little bit nicer than the one I have.

Seems fair to me.

by absolutely

Move the Asians here. In other words, increase immigration quotas. That way, the competition will at least have to pay American prices, and will be less able to work for drastically less than American wages. Anyway, we're competing against person X in country Y already. The more "foreigners" we see in person, the better we'll understand the competition.

by tonythetiger

but there are several hundred thousand people who [b]are[/b] living on that, and more than likely at least as many living on [b]less[/b] than that. (for comparison, I think Welfare and foodstamps in ohio were, when a single person could get them, $216 and $128 respectively... that's $344 a month, so that would be equivalent to what, about $1.90 an hour using 40 hour weeks?)

Perhaps you've never been in the position to know just how little you really can get by on. IT might not be a bad skill to learn... you know, just in case....

by tekboyny

That is true . Perhaps part of the point I was trying to make was unclear. Living and surviving are two different things. Now , I am of the school that everyone should have the right to make whatever their abilities will take them . Realistically, while it isn't my problem the guy who can't make more that xyz lives above their means, I think to expect someone to "Live" on so little. And although its not going to happen what if the people at the top lived a bit less over the top and minimum wage was a bit higher. As far as the little guy who claims he can't survive on paying out higher wages, I see plenty of them at least in my parts living it up. As far as the argument I can't be in business if I don't pay illegal workers illegal wages, the price of a meal may be a dollar cheaper but for sure your paying the difference in taxes. Oh and try living in NY on Minimum wage its all but impossible without public assistance which comes from taxes which I pay.

by tonythetiger

The difference is subjective. Nevertheless, I'll go with it for the purpose of the following.

Does either of the two obligate "someone else"?

by cparris

Who are you to tell me or anyone else what is over the top and what isn't? How bout this TekBoyNY; why don't we take all you make and give to the poor people everywhere?! Why is it you want to punish those who actually want to make somthing of them selves and have proven it through hard work, diligance, and dicipline? Why is it that you want to reward those who want to do nothing with their lives and have no desire to do better or make things better by working for it? Why do you want restrict how people live their lives and have the government steal what they have earned and give it to someone who is not deserving?

Now I understand that there are special cases. They should be delt with on a case by case basis. I have no problem helping someone who is down on their luck and needs help standing back up. For those who have a minimum wage job and that's all they have had for more than 3 years; I don't really feel sorry for them. I started work when I was 13 for my dad just to earn a little money (and so they didn't have to spend money on a babysitter). It tought me what work was. It also tought me how to budget and how to work smarter and not harder.

Just who are you to tell me not to live so over the top? What gives you the right to tell me that I spend too much or make too much and let's give it to the poor? Are you God? I didn't think so.

Like I said, deserving people I have no problem with, it's the ones that don't make an effort or even try that just grate the crap out of my nerves. When they show effort, progress, and a desire to make somthing of themselves instead of being the bottom feeders of socieity, then and only then should we help them. The other kind that I hate more than those that just wont are the enablers of these bottom feeders.

by jdclyde

I was making $6 an hour when my twin boys were born, and the wife stayed home with the boys for the first two years.

I did not receive government assistance.

You keep your expenses low and work hard.

The problem comes in is when losers think they DESERVE ANYTHING but an opportunity to EARN a living based on the skills they have acumulated.

You are free for the [b]Pursuit[/b] of happiness. You are not guaranteed anything.

If you have cable tv, multiple tv's, multiple cars, cell phones [b]cigarettes[/b] and on and on, [b]the only thing you "DESERVE" is to get the bill at the end of each month.[/b]

Can't afford them and still have the big fancy house? Nothing but stupidity is holding you back, by refusing to keep your spending in line with the income you have provided yourself.

And I don't see small business men driving mercedes. Your completely detatched from reality if you think the SMALL business man is RICH, on an average.

by tekboyny

Perhaps what I consider small business and you do is subjective. Come to my area in 2007 and see all the small factory owners with a bunch of illegals as employees, while they drive mercedes(general example for the literal amongst us), etc. Even the small pizza place/deli owners living in access. I do realize that life exists outside of my area, but, am I any more guilty of using my own experiences as a basis for argument than you are? You CANNOT in NYC in 2007 survive on minimum wage without assistance(whether it be family, friends, government, charity, etc). With that being said, that doesn't obligate anyone else to assist anyone else. I thought I agrued that point myself eailer with the whole "We pay for it one way or another argument." At the same token, the people whom I speak of shouldn't be complaining then can't afford to pay people more when they themselves overspend for what is really necessary for "survival." As for the being out of touch with reality comment, let's keep the discussion intelligent like adults and revert to personal attacks. Someone who is out of touch with reality can not even grasp how and why their point of view may differ from that of another but rest assured I do not suffer from that problem.
Here is a hypothetical example of what I mean. Company A has 50 employees. 35 of which are factory workers. The factory workers even if legal and on the books make minimum wage. They cannot afford to pay the outrageous fees of living in NYC in 2007. So they seek out public assistance. I pay taxes , thus I , stuck in the middle, offset some of their costs through the taxes I pay at my own expense. Company owner A cries poverty but shows up to work with a very expensive car, lives in an expensive home, does what he wants.Company A makes 1 Million Dollars in Profit each year . They do not reinvest most of it into the money into the company but instead the Owner makes himself richer. That is fine and he is entitled to that the way things work. Simply put if that Boss raised his 35 employees' sallary 2 dollars per hour it would cost him more or less $150,000.00 per year to do so. It would cover the cost of the wellfare example given above, leave more than 3 qtr of a million in company resources for himself or whatever, and perhaps in some fantasy world make better use of my tax money. Now is every company that well off, no, but the point here is that from where I see things, everything is abused on all ends like crazy. Since a boss isn't likely to pay his employees more if he doesn't have to, I know I wouldn't, raising the minimum wage would help that somewhat.

by tonythetiger

if someone is holding a gun to your head, forcing you to stay in that 'neck of the woods'. Almost anybody can walk 20 miles in a day.

by tekboyny

I am not saying I have it so bad. My situation is decent. On a perosnal note I also am leaving this area at some point anyway. I am making a point of the reality of the situation in my neck of the woods. It is unrealistic to expect everyone who doesn't like it to shutup or leave becuase if everyone shuts up the current system which doesn't work continues, if everyone leaves , then the economy of NY has issues (which is negtive to the overall country ) or people replace them and someone else is in that spot. On a side note. It is unreasonable if not unrealistic to travel to most places on foot in my neck of the woods. What I suggest may not work for you in your area. I haven't been there I know little about it. I do believe that you are in no postion to tell me what works for me. So let's agree to disagree. In all likely hood there is not a one size fits all answer anyhow . I have work to do good day :).

by tonythetiger

how many of those (things that determine profit) are imposed on them by the government... how much "overhead" is used, just to comply with government regulations (and add no value to the product or service). In the U.S. it's some half a trillion (that's the US trillion, 10^12) dollars a year! money that consumers are spending, but does nothing useful for the economy.

by tekboyny

First off my friend, I never said you can only make so much money or give money to the poor. Im not sure where you got that from. Im saying that the minimum living wage should be increased at least in my Area based on what I have seen. (people taking money from my pocket in taxes, because certain employers complain they have no money when clearly they do). Secondly, I expressed an opinion which I also have a right to do. You have the right to disagree with it even to the point of an agry response. Just don't act like I dont have the right to say what I think.

Ultimately we are all responsible for ourselves and thats fine.(If I am guilty of anything , it's making my point to benefit myself just like most people do.IE YOU )I'm all for hard work. I have always busted my hump for anything always and continue to do so. I will have financial success in life because I want it. I never claimed to be God so that was a bit over the top on your end .You know who enables "bottom feeders," welfare and the institutions that cause it. Not Middle class folk like myself not wanting to pay for them through my taxes. Anyway I wish you a good day .

by tonythetiger

[i]Ultimately we are all responsible for ourselves and thats fine.[/i]

Then "we" should have no trouble making what we are worth without resorting to extorting it from someone else.

by wmlundine

...half of you friggin' techno-geeks would starve. What are you gonna eat?...code...printed circuits?...no...you need food, which means you need farmers...which means we need everyone, so forget the life-boat politics and the "bottom feeder" hate-speech. This is the USA damnit and there better be a social contract. That's why there is a minimum wage!

by jdclyde

the less you will get.

I can't speak for you or the techs you know that you seem to think are all way over paid, but I AM worth what I am paid.

Earn your own keep.

Expanding the welfare state is not a solution, and raising minimum wage does not help low income as the majority are not working at McDonalds flipping burgers, and generally make over minimum.

Do you really think farmers are poor? Do you think farmers pay more than minumum wage to field workers? Who do you think one of the biggest employers of illegal imigrants is? Bingo, the farmers.

This has been your wakeup call.

by tony hopkinson

Everybody gets the same treatment!

I know I'm a tree hugging socialist and I foolishly don't believe in god or GWB, but I aren't the one who continually underestimates his opponent either.

Get real !.

Taxes will always be unfair, the main purpose of getting ahead in the system is to shift the burden of paying them to someone else!

Who pays more tax in %age terms you or Bill Gates?
Why ? Because he has the power to manipulate the system and transfer that burden on to you. You aren't advocating equality, you just want to pass the kick in the nuts down to those worse off than you.

If that's the system, thats the system, but do not come out with crap about it being fair!

by cparris

The 13% that make more than 250K/yr pays most of the taxes. Why? Because they are the minority of the vote. It's all because of the "everyone should have what they have" mindset. The only way to shift the burden of taxes to someone else is to show a loss or to just not make money and sit on your a** at home while drawing welfare or some other government subdisied program.

by tonythetiger

Who claimed that a percentage was fair? People get ahead by being productive. Penalizing them for that is unfair (not to mention that it will encourage them to be less productive, which is why socialism ultimately fails every time... you can't legislate human nature).

One man, one vote, one breath every three seconds, one dollar in taxes. Now that's fair.

by cparris

leave a field fallow for a season by the government.
(For those who don't know what fallow is, it's where you don't grow anything there for a while. To let the soil rest.)

From what I understand, the government pays them more to let it lay fallow than they would actually make growing somthing on it. I could be wrong on this fact considering that I heard it third hand.

Yes most to all farmers are one of the highest contributors to illegal immigrant employment. The second is the small construction companies. If you think your house was built by a white guy? Think again, the white guy was calling the shots and the illegal mexicans built it. That's one reason that build quality is so poor.

If you doubt me; go by a subdivision they are building in your area while the construction crews are there. Count how many hispanic workers to others. Now take 95% at least and those are illegal. Let Immigration come by, only the black and white guys will be left and all the hispanics will have fled. I've seen it first hand.

by too old for it

The Only thing that makes more sense than the Fair Tax is an Objectivist ethic, and government, to go along with it.

by too old for it

Now maybe the wife and I can move away from the utter lack of economy that is Central Ohio. The kid will do ok in college. I have taught her most of what I know about IT, after extracting her promise to never take it up as a career. She should do something she likes, has value, and in a place where people actually will compete for your skills. (She has been talking either history or music major, so she is on the right track.)

And I get to look for a place where I can be employed, and not have to work two jobs while constantly lining up the next gig.

I don't have to be bitter: I affirmatively choose to be as an alternative to chronic depression, which is more expensive to treat. The bitterness goes away fairly quickly when a recruiter is apologizing that he can only offer me 2.5 times my current salary to move away from this economic wasteland.

I can see why businesses stay here: labor is cheap when your state is 47th in new job creation. What I don't understand is why businessmen whine the blues because "all the good talent" is packing up and moving out of the area. I am neither an econ nor a business major, but I can at least figure [b]that[/b] much out.