Discussion Locked

Why are vendors demanding WinXP?

0 helpful
115 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

115 replies

by skooboy

Yes, they will lose $ on this, as well they should. And to the comment above this one, yes, if iriver wasn't extremely clear with the XP requirement on their exterior packaging, you have a legit beef. Return the items!
As regards *nix, I was referring to the desktop. How many enterprises utilize this on the desktop? None I've heard of.

by jdclyde

Entire CITIES are moving EVERYTHING over to linux around the world.

It is bigger than you will hear in normal Windows circles. Not sure how much you step outside that realm. Can look for links if you are interested.

And when you refer desktop, PLEASE state so. Many of us here are admins that deal with servers as much as we do desktops, so we think of COMPUTERS, not so much desktop OR server when we have the discussions.

by jmgarvin

The entire city of Munich has moved to a *nix desktop.

As for the "I was talking about the deskop" argument, it is bunk anyway.

There are estimated to be 50 to 100 million linux users out there...

Also about 50% of the server market it *nix...

by Former member

Sorry I can't help you. A friend had to upgrade his computer to winxp for his sons ipod. I know that amarok(?) in linux does connect to some media devices but am not sure about the iriver. I guess it has something to do with digital security?

by jdclyde

part of a way to lock down illegal file sharing.

It could also be they are on the payroll of MS to only support xp as a way for Gates to take over control of the mp3 market.

There was a big write-up the other day of Gates declaring war on Apple and the iPod, and this might be how he is looking to do it.

I stumpled on the tip of the iceburg it seems.

Thankfully I did find some that aren't locked in yet.

by noyoki

"Thankfully I did find some that aren't locked in yet."

The keyword here I think, sadly, is "Yet".

by coyotenm

Leasing is a good way to go, although it has its own headaches. The civil engineering offices where I used to work often leased, since they also had to keep up with the CAD and modeling programs. The university where I work now has good purchase contracts set up with the major vendors. We end up buying new because of that, then passing the replaced ones on in the university system. Also, it's a small group. We're only talking about 30 computers. We keep computers for 2 or 3 years, then get new ones, upgrading 1/2 of them at a time. It works well for us. But if your company can work well with the older stuff, then of course, why upgrade...

by jdclyde

Well, a few weeks out, but I finally got a reply to the email I sent them.
I wrote back that I am NOT interested in on-line downloads, but will only be listening to music I have ALREADY purchased and have on CD.

Here is the email, unedited.
---------------------------------------------

iriver America Response: (01/18/2006 10:15)
The T series devices requires MTP support to work properly. The drivers and support for this are built into Windows XP (Service Pack 1 or 2) and Windows Media Player 10.

Other operating systems do not support this new technology and therefore the T10/T30 will not be compatible with other Operating Systems. This support is needed in order to allow the T Series players to be compatible with Subscription services such as Napster to Go and Yahoo Unlimited. The T Series players are the first flash based players that are compatible with these new services.

Thanks,

Marcus

by nazil dsouza

hey jdclyde
yeah gizmos on the shelf need to have a stabilised os for connectivity. I think u cant help it cos my friend had a sony phone she could not have a connectivity with her win 98 as her system was old so she was whats wrong with the world ..... gave her a big hug and told her "girl the world is changing " and she had to accept it ......

by deadly ernest

the device could just have easily been designed with the intent of using industry standard protocols, after all the connectivity is supposedly an industry standard USB connection - they are NOT operating system dependent. I have friends who have portable MP3 players, all of wehich use USB and they show up as standard USB hard drives on whatever system they connect them. Another friend has one that connects via wireless and uses TCP/IP for data transfer with a set IP address for the unit of 192.168.0.101 - again not operating system dependent.

by jdclyde

because there are so many people out there that are so uninformed about IT that they actually thing that MS IS the one to determine industry standards.

It is bad when it is just an end user, it is scary when that person actually works in the field!

by deadly ernest

of the minimum you can legally get away with and how to do things badly. Sad that they used to be the leaders - Oh well the days of DOS 6.2 and Win 3.1 are well and truely over.

It is extremely frightening when an IT person thinks MS is the correct standard. Imagine what it would be like if we all adopted the MS security standard of leaving everything open to attack.

by jdclyde

if you have everything turned on and allow connectivity "out of the box". It is just suppose to work after plugging your system in and awaaaaaay you go!

Security? We don't need no stinken' security! :D

That is for SISSIES! :O

by deadly ernest

I object to having to rebuild a machine because a known security hole got used to screw it up again - best user effort 15 rebuilds in 42 days, each due to them picking up another virus. The other machine in that same house and using the same connection is an old Redhat 6 box, never touched since it was built way back when - so way back I cant remember. he likes Windows she like KDE - guess which has the cheaper TCO.

This discussion is closed to new replies.