Why did we go to war?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by hal 9000
Your right this was the first time that the US has instigated action against another country rather than reacting to actions from those countries. Like Germany in WW1 and Japan in WW11 in both cases there where attacks on US interests or bases.
While Afghanistan was a valid target Iraq wasn't as has been shown but maybe it was just a case of "Sour Grapes" in an attempt to get even with an administration that had for a very long time been unpalatable to the US. Perhaps if the job had of been finished in Gulf War 1 this would never have come about but then again it just may of happened sooner and been far worse.
Unfortunately it is something that we will never know.
Col
by addison
As we all know, Afghanistan is the worlds leading exporter of Heroin.
Bottom line, Bin Laden fronted Bush a few billion dollars of Heroin, and Bush decided to get amnesia!!!
As we also know, Iraq is the worlds largest producer of oil, and Papa got his but whooped in desert storm!!!
Go figure@@##@??!!
by hal 9000
The previous President was too happy getting "Blow Jobs" in the Oval Office and this one isn't getting the same service so he in a fit of sexual repression had to start a war with a country that just couldn't fight back.
The North Korea's also produce a lot of "White Powder" for sale on the elicited drug market so it could have come from there and not Bin Laden.
OH I should have added at the start "SARCASM ALERT!"
Col
by oz_media
Well there is the uncanny resemblance between missile and phallis. Perhaps along the same line you had mentioned this is a form of subconcious 'compensation'.
Perhaps GWB should be opening more spam mail, being American he is able to partake in many opportunities for personal enhancement that are completely guaranteed to be unique to work better than all other solutions and they REALLY WORK!
If only the White House didn't have spam filters, perhaps none of this would have ever happened.
by thechas
It seems to me that you have a little bit of misinformation. Or at least a misunderstanding.
Afghanistan has been a major source of opium not heroin itself.
Under the Taliban, opium production was brought to the lowest levels it had been in years.
The Bin'Laden family does have ties to the Bush family and other US interests.
However, even the Bin'Laden family has severed it's ties with Osama.
Osama is sort of like the spoiled rich kids who became part of the underground anti-war groups in the US in the late 1960's.
George H.W. Bush did NOT get his arse whooped in Desert Storm.
Quite the contrary, the US troops where over half way across Iraq when it was decided to stop the war and withdraw.
The first gulf war came to an end because President Bush understood the politics of the Middle East, and agreed to stop the war when our Middle East allies said that enough had been done.
Who can predict what history would have been if the coalition in the first Gulf War had agreed to remove Saddam Husein from power?
An interesting point to ponder.
Chas
by nd_it
by dbertsche
by aldanatech
by dbertsche
You speak for all Canadians? I don't think so. This is like a lot of your posts, hate Bush propaganda.
You're obviously brainwashed.
by oz_media
Firstly you say I speak on behalf of Canadians, when did I do that?
"These are just my personal feelings from what I have headr and felt locally, you guys think I am a bush basher or anti-American, I am NOTHING in comparisson to people I talk with who literally despise ANYTHING American."
Secondly, you are American, how can you POSSIBLY have ANY idea whatsoever how Canadians veiw Americans? Don't say by visiting here, because as individuals, Americans are not a problem to Canadians, a little annoying but not a problem. If you speak with authority because you used to live here that also means squat, people USED to like America.
So I am left wondering how you made the two following statements especially after titleing your post 'Meaningless Drivel' when neither apply to my post?
Either that or your title was to reflect the content of your post, which without any substance to suport it is simply 'Meaningless Drivel'.
Brainwashed? By whom? The other side? The black hats? The 'wrong' people? What makes you think you as a Bush supporter have not been brainwashed? Most of the evidence proves he has deceived you all, you say he is stright-up? Please prove that one.
What HATE Bush Propaganda? The only propaganda I've seen is all the pro-Bush, pro-War BS that keeps covering up the real issues that people are pissed off at, like the title of THIS discussion.
"Iraqi's are better off!", "Saddam was an evil dictator that repressed his people!", "Just look at 9/11!"
How about, "Saddam is going to kill us with WMD and because he is stopping inspectors from looking around, he MUST be guilty and really be hiding these weapons that are going to kill us all." THAT'S WHY YOU ALL SUPPORTED THE WAR.
So with kidnappings of Iraqi children escalating to the point that schools are hiring armed guards and some kids are siomply staying home out of fear to go to school, all I see you doing is changing the violence, not stopping it. Kids are being held for ransom, so the US isn't funding Iraqi's anymore, they will find themselves.
Still waiting for the happy ending.
by aldanatech
by nd_it
by oz_media
It's really interesting to see that when many modern day issues are justified by what America's forefathers would have done, or the foundation of America shows us that we must...
NOW, it is convinient to simply forget last years issues and keep looking forwadr without looking back.
Well that IS a positive way to get through lifes little troubles, we are talking about The Leader of The Free World declaring war upon another country. LIES cannot be simply excused. You never excused Clinton for his lies about relations with Minica Lewinski, yet THIS should be forgotten and pushed aside?
That is EXACTLY what the Republican administration has done for over a year now, looked high and low for SOME form of justification to cover the underlying BS that you were mislead into a premature action that has killed US soldiers. Now there are SO many different reasons for Iraq, including even 9/11 but not a SINGLE reason has proven why you refused to follow allied wishes ad postpone the invasion until the inspectors were finished, yes they were working effectively at that time.
So no more smoke and mirrors, get your heads out of.....the sand. Clinton was impeached for getting a freebee from an intern (heaven forbid!), GWB is EXCUSED for sending America to premature WAR??
You can't equate GWB's misleading FALSE premise that caused you to go to war in Iraq to the fact that it was both Bush and Clinton to blame. Clinton isn't leading your country and it's soldiers to thier death, BUSH is.
by aldanatech
by garion11
by oz_media
Well seeing as nobody really likes Bush, outside the USA, I would keep it pretty quiet if I was accountable for Bush being elected again.
In fact, you would probably be safer to say you voted for Kery or even Ronald MacDonald (much better choice by the way).
IF Bush gets reelected, kiss your allies goodbye. Bush maybe able to smarm his way into foreign leaders books again but they are certainly gonna hear it from the people if they try to back him.
It doesn't matter WHO you elect, you can elect the same moron for 20 years if you want, just don't expect him to get your country anywhere on the world stage. main focuse for candidates running outside the USA has been "I will NOT cater to the Bush Administration" This gets votes! people refuse to support leaders who follow or listen to GWB, a politicians worst mistake right now would be to favour GWB.
So as for what people think if you make stupid mistakes, it doesn't matter. Whether your president will have ANY credibility left should be more of a concern. Who cares what intentions GWB has if nobody wants to play his game, it's kinda useless to you isn't it? What's he gonna start to try and run the rest of the world too? Will he be able to provide your country's much needed imported resources? Will America's support system be in tact?
Is America on its own if Bush is reelected? If not, what country's citizens do you think will be backing thier leader's conformity to Bush's ideals?
by thechas
If GWB does win (or steal) another term in office we will be able to take consolation that it will be over in 4 years.
We just need to survive the spiral that the economy will fall into as the Government uses up the available capitol with the borrowing that will be needed to pay for the war and the tax cuts.
Chas
.
I'm amazed that people insist on interjecting such rhetoric, and continue to suggest that GWB stole the election. Facts and truth mean nothing, I suppose, if lies and fabrications suit a person's desired outcome.
GWB did not STEAL the last election. That's been proved time and again. But regardless of how many times that nonsense is dispelled, people continue to say it.
To resort to such tactics is most disingenuous. No wonder there's so much divisiveness in this country.
by hereinoz
Hi Garion,
GWB being re-elected may be the best thing that happened to the US. It has taken four years for a large slice of the US people to realise the type of person they scored as President, and given another four years of him, perhaps the vast majority of the rest will work it out.
At least then, the majority of the US population will hopefully take steps to ensure that it never happens again.
Cheers,
Alan
by aldanatech
by aldanatech
by hal 9000
The worst thing possible would be to pull out now once things have been placed in motion that are impossible to stop.
We made the mess that is there now and we MUST clean it up or we will all be far worse off than we where previously.
If we where to withdraw right now there are insurgents that have no interest in Iraq at all who would become the leaders and their sole aim would be to inflict as much damage as possible on both the USA and the COW at large.
Well here in AU we just do not have any really serious targets that would cause massive damage like the US has but even still there are places where massive pollution could be caused without too much trouble and while it would be inconvenient for us it really would not be the same long term problems that could occur in the USA.
Just after Sept 11 I suggested that while the World Trade Center was a very noticeable target really that is all it was as there where far more serious targets not all that far away and could render massive amounts of the US country uninhabitable. Now some regulars here tore me down on that but as they obviously do not know what they where talking about it was no big deal and now these targets are taken seriously by the administration and protected accordingly.
But even with the best laid plans of mice and men things can still go wrong with terrible consequences that just do not bear thinking about. We have to clean up the mess that we made in Iraq and while the insurgents continue to think that they are succeeding it will only be that much harder.
Col
by aldanatech
by oz_media
by toandyroo
you fool, you cant just go to war because you can. The states think their so great but theyr not they are the biggest terrorist of the lot. the rest of the world sees u as stupid trigger happy idiots.
get off your fat american ass and go have a look and fahrenheit 911. America has invaded something like 91 countries over the last 100 years and none in the mother land. get a life u fool
.
That make me desire an isolationist America.
I'm sick of the rest of the world, the Corrupt United Nations, and the lying foreign media. And it would suit me just fine to tell everyone else to just shove it up their %$%^&.
The next time the French and the Germans let some mad-man overrun Europe, like they've done three times in the last century (including the Soviets in the Cold War), let them deal with it all by themselves. The next time there's mass genocide, and millions are buried in mass graves, let them dig their own holes. If the little mad-man in North Korea wants to attack Japan and overrun the Southern half of the Korean peninsula, go ahead, someone else deal with it.
It would suit me just fine to focus on keeping the radical and fanatical Islamist terrorists out of the USA only, and let the rest of you deal with them - or stick your heads up your butts like you've done for the past forty years. I would be happy to keep all the blood-sucking leaches out of the USA, and force them to remain in their own corrupt and poverty stricken waste-lands.
Perhaps "Up Yours" should be the new American foreign policy.
by dbertsche
First off I didn't say that you reflected what all Canadians think. Check my post ozboy and you'll find I asked a question. Since I don't live in Canada and you do I figured you might know the answer to the question. I do not have any idea if your opinion represents what the majority of Canadians think. Once again that's why I asked the question.
You state somewhere in your rambling response that there is a lot of Pro Bush news etc. Maybe in Canada but not on the major networks here, it's anti-bush. I don't know what you'r watching but I see a lot more liberal bias than conservative bias.
Just as you state over and over, I am entitled to my opinion and I still think you're brainwashed and that the overwhelming majority of what you post is pure "crap". You can choose to disagree as I'm sure you will but tough, that's my opinion.
You know, since the US seems to be a real bother to you perhaps you should move to another country that's not as close, say...France! That's it, you'd probably fit in real well there. Hey, just an opinion!
by sullyman
Max,
I agree with you that some people just don't have a clue, and in this case your emotions got the better of you. But, the US hasn't been the only nation on earth fighting terrorism, in all actuality it's only within the last 5 years or so that the US has been putting up this brave face. Europeans as a whole have been fighting terrorism for centuries, without a single finger being lifted by the US. The 50s-00s terrorism has run rampant throughout European nations.
You say that you are sick of the "lying foreign media" , but who is to say that the US media is not the one spinning information? You believe that the US media for the most part is telling it like it is, while Joe Citizen in whatever country outside the US believes that his media is telling it like it is. Doesn't make him a liar or you for that matter, just different trust zones.
The only reason the US entered the 2nd world war, was because they were attacked at Pearl Harbor.
The rest of the world has not stuck their heads up their butts as you so eloquently put it. But, has been dealing with the same issues as the US for a longer period of time ( terrorism ). They have just chosen to deal with it in different fashions.
.
Yes, of course, I realize that the time of isolationism is in the distant past. It's the "blame America for everything" crap that chaps my ass. These people are, at best, extremely ignorant.
Yes, the US media ALSO spins information. And I'm just as sick of them as well.
World War Two was more than just Pearl Harbor; you and I both know that; and you and I both know that it's irrelevant to the issues of today. (And I'll let that discussion fall into the black-hole of nonsensical arguments waged by others.)
On terrorism over the last 50 years, you and I are again in agreement. I've said dozens of times (in various threads) that the USA also ignored the terrorism issue - every administration of both parties going back to Richard Nixon - until we got a swift kick in the ass in September 2001. However, the United Nations and the European nations have, at best, been tolerating world-wide terrorism, giving it little more than meaningless lip-service. And they want to continue to do the same thing. As far as the USA doing nothing about it, which way does the world want it? Do they want us to mind our own business, or do they want us to intervene? I've heard both, but either way, we get criticized.
I agree with President Bush. We need to identify them and go after them RIGHT NOW, wherever they may be, whatever it might take, and before they strike again. And we should not, as President Bush suggested, wait until the threat is imminent. And yes, Iraq was part of it - just as Iran should be; just as Syria should be; and yes, just as Saudi Arabia should be. (At this point the "ignorant" ones will ask why, then, don't we "invade" Saudi Arabia or North Korea. You just can't reason with such stupidity and ignorance behind such a question.)
And I also agree with President Bush that it will be an effort that will take decades to complete. We've tried the United Nations way for 50 years and the result was 3000 dead Americans in New York, Washington DC, and Pennsylvania. It's time to try a different way. President Bush is the only American president who's done anything significant at all, and look how he's rewarded for his efforts. It's enough to make me want to throw-up - or say "up yours" to the ignorant ones.
.
In my awkwardly worded sentence, I said, "And we should not, as President Bush suggested, wait until the threat is imminent."
Better wording:
President Bush suggested that we should not wait until the threat is imminent, and I agree with him.
(Proof reading is a beautiful thing - if, of course, it's done BEFORE hitting the submit button.)
by sullyman
snip - "Facts and truth mean nothing, I suppose, if lies and fabrications suit a person's desired outcome - " max
Lets use our quote, where are the WMD in Iraq? Why the backpeddling by GWB, that Iran is probably more of threat than IRAQ ever was. I guess facts and truth do mean nothing after all.........
by garion11
by sullyman
.
....you include EVERYONE who was suggesting that IRAQ had stockpiles of WMDs - including the Clinton administration, and including the United Nations. Would you like me to post - AGAIN - all the quotes about Iraq's WMDs prior to the war?
Besides, it's never been proven that WMDs weren't there.
To the contrary:
http://www.news24.com/News24/World/Iraq/0%2C%2C2-10-1460_1340941%2C00.html
http://www.2la.org/syria/iraq-wmd.php
http://www.worldnetdaily.com/news/article.asp?ARTICLE_ID=36463
(Syria, by the way, won't allow inspections.)
http://www.cnn.com/2004/WORLD/meast/04/26/jordan.terror/index.html
(Gee, I wonder where they came from?)
http://www.news24.com/News24/World/Iraq/0%2C%2C2-10-1460_1397233%2C00.html
http://www.foxnews.com/story/0%2C2933%2C120137%2C00.html
http://www.newsmax.com/archives/ic/2004/6/25/114037.shtml
http://www.outsidethebeltway.com/archives/003499.html
Of course, none of this will suit your desired outcome, so you conveniently overlook them.
(Okay, go ahead and "discredit" the sources. That's how the game is played.)
.
http://www.nypost.com/postopinion/editorial/25023.htm
http://www.alertnet.org/thenews/newsdesk/L14508601.htm
http://www.nationalreview.com/may/may200407121105.asp
Or are you going to ignore these things because they don't suit your desired outcome?
by oz_media
Well who am I to miss a nice rhetorical argument?
Great links Max, well posted. Do you have ANY sources that are non-Rpublican suportive or possibly from OUTSIDE the USA?
"Or are you going to ignore these (those) things because they don't suit your desired outcome?"
Here are some of the quotes ffrom your non-biased sources of information.
"The Democratic party is just sober enough to realize it needs a designated driver."
"Democrats use computer hysteria to get out the vote."
But the best quote I think I ever read on TR comes from your own post,
"Besides, it's never been proven that WMDs weren't there."
Ahhh, if ONLY I had known that before. Icertainly would hae supported the war in Iraq and GWB's premature invasion decision would have made SO much more sense. I had NO IDEA that Saddam was guilty until proven innocent, now I can see why other country's don't understand the USA and vice versa, they have it backwards and expect people to be proven guilty, not innocent.
Thanks for the lesson Max.
"Besides, it's never been proven that WMDs weren't there" OMG! :-0
by hal 9000
Places like North Korea who are into wholesale drug smuggling on a "State" level so while you might like to draw down the blinds and hide behind you own borders the reality of the situation is that the USA can no longer exist without involvement by the rest of the world.
Your own companies in a rush to make bigger profits have moved most of their manufacturing plants off shore and into Islamic countries like the Philippines or Malaysia so without these two countries the supply of HDD's and Intel CPU's would immediately stop.
There is a saying that "No Man Is an Island" and it is even truer now for most countries as well all depend on each other to survive {at least the developed and developing ones anyway!}
Col
.
You said, "...the USA can no longer exist without involvement by the rest of the world".
The WHOLE sentence would also include the fact that the rest of the world can't exist (in its present form) without the USA.
(See my "emotional tirade message.)
On your criticism of American companies, I'll simply suggest that you are looking at it with blinders on. You'll see what you want to see, no more, no less. But perhaps the folks in those countries you mentioned - the ones making some $$ off those American companies - would be better off without them. Either way, it will be blame America if we do, and blame America if we don't.
by hal 9000
I was only trying to point out that the US rely just as much on many other countries as they do on the US.
There was never any intention to level any criticism at any one in general and the USA in particular.
It is just a fact of life! We live in a "Global Community" and we just have to accept this of course if you where one of those who where up in arms about outsourcing to Third World Countries this might be some form of criticism but it was never intended that way.
Col
by garion11
illogical and unreasonable arguments from the left that is spewed out.
Blah, blah, there is NO evidence, blah blah, we should have went after IRAN, blah blah..
If we attacked Iran instead of Iraq, NK instead of Iraq, Syria instead of Iraq, you would be saying the same thing that you are saying about Iraq right now. Saddam was required to obey UN and US demands after he signed the treaty because he lost Gulf war I. When he refused by again (look at my facts from my previous posts) we took him out. Now, if he wanted to stay in power, he should have payed attention and not acted so arrogant.
Oh well, I always wondered what would have happened if Neville Chamberlain stood up to Hitler instead of letting him have Poland.
In fact its the British and French that caused WWII by bending over to Germans.
by garion11
by cactus pete
A terrorist attack by whom? Isn't that what matters?
What line are you trying to follow? Who would we attack if... Who would we blame for doing it if... Who would we blame for allowing it to happen if... How would you vote if... Would you vote if...
by tomsal
I with dpetrak, feed us more info on what kind of response you are expecting.
What would happen if a dirty nuke went off in the US?
Millions would die.
Hopefully among those millions would NOT be my family/friends/loved ones.
But considering I live smack dab in middle of two PRIME targets....DC is 3 hours from me, NYC is 2 1/2 hours from me....I think I'm a goner in such a case.
One of the pains of living in the North East USA -- you are in the "bullseye zone" should nuclear weapons be targeted at the US.
CIA Headquarters
FBI Headquarters
The Whitehouse
NYC (our largest city/major financial district)
Norfolk, VA (Navy)
etc. etc.
by oz_media
YOu have enough problems with friendly fire, to the point that armies refuse to fight near Americans. I saw a report ove the weekend whee Kurdish tanks were lined up JUST outside of firig range of KNOWN Iraqi insurgents. The US was firing upon the Iraqi's and asked for suport from the other direction, the Kurds would not enter into the field as they were scared of being mistaken for Iraqi's and fired upon by US troops.
Now what are the chances of someone launching a nuclear attack on the USA? EXTREMELY SLIM, knowing that thier country would be obliterated if they did.
What are the chances of America launching an 'aacidental'nuclear attack upon itself? Too high to be amusing.
by thechas
Garion,
Any major terrorist attack against the US or US interests especially in September or October will result in a landslide for GWB.
It won't be because the people trust GWB though.
It will be because they are scared and won't want to accept the risk of changing Presidents in a time of crisis.
It has been reported that GWB is considered to be Osama Bin'Ladens best ally.
The continued foreign policy mis-steps by the Bush administration are Osama's best propaganda and recruiting tools.
Chas
.
Why is it that GWB has made, as you suggest, foreign policy missteps, but the other party involved has not?
It's interesting that when there are disagreements or negotiation breakdowns, it's never the other guy who's at fault. Why is it that Saddam Hussein isn't just as roundly criticized for his "foreign policy missteps"? I suppose he wasn't at fault. I guess GWB made them, but Saddam Hussein didn't, Kofi Annan didn't, and Jacques Chirac didn't. It's sad that some people apparently see it that way.
by hal 9000
The rest is unfortunately quite correct.
It is the actions of the COW and mainly America in these matters which are playing directly into Bin Ladens and his ilks hands.
Talk about being between a Rock and a Hard Place.
You're Dammed if you do and Dammed if you don't. It's a now in situation whatever happens.
Col
by aldanatech
by oz_media
Interesting that you should pick France as a nation that disgusts you.
So any 'allied' country that doesn't back the US sucks? There is so much crap about France for some reason, did they attack you too or are you simply gonna invade them anyway?
Why don't you protest them again in true American style, have American's all over your country buy French products and throw them away (that'll show them !). Then you can go and buy more French products and throw THEM away, now they'll learn! If they want to mess with America they better start increasing production of exports to the USA, the US citizens are buying them up in protest! Very clever guys, well done!
Now do ME a favour, go and protest European hard rock music and buy up all the CD's, I love the residuals.
But as my unce now lives in the South of France, I was able to visit his coutry home a couple of years back, and yes, I would move there in a heartbeat (long before I ever considered moving to the US that is).
As for moving away from the US to begin with, it can't be done. No matter what country you live in, the US is your your life as a daily event, it cannot be avoided as YOUR peresidet has made your business EVERYONE's business.
As for my media, I watch the EXACT same channels you get in the USA, MOST of our TV here is US networks and local Noth West news. We also get Middle Eastern channels (amusing), Asian channels, Canadian networks, British chanels etc. So who is only seeing PART of the picture?
I would say those that rely on American networks and local news.
Do I speak for all Canadians? No of course not, and I wouldn't begin to. What I have seen from ANYONE I meet in BC is that Bush is an idiot, Bush is a warmonger, Americans are 'waraholics', etc. I have not heard, seen nor met a single Canadian that agrees with Bush. So from what I have seen and geard from Canadians, I can say 'yes that's what they think'.
I aso get the same from British and Australian relatives that I and have talked to recently. Plus from overseas news, polls etc. that all say they are against Bush's actions.
Is it so hard to comprehend that NOBODY likes Bush but yourselves, and even that following is thinning more and more daily as people wake up to reality and realize that you were blatantly mislead due to the presidential Administrations own agenda and not your own personal safety, which is still not proven asd being in jeopardy of an attack from Saddam's non-existant WMD, that he had no possible means of attacking the USA with.
So in my case you can take the easy way out, instead of justifying the unjustified, you can simply say, if you don't like it move. (first of all WHY THE HELL SHOULD I HAVE TO MOE TO AVOID THE USA?) secondly, what do you tell fellow americans with the same conclusions? If you don't like it leave? What about Democracy and personal rights, the Constitution? Isn't this what you are 'apparently' trying to set up in Iraq? You are instantly ready to remove all these rights from someone who disagrees.
by oz_media
by dbertsche
More meaningless drivel! You are so totally predictable, I knew you would respond with a rant which is exactly what you did.
You read way too much into things, France was suggested because it's further away from the US than Canada, it could have been Iraq, Germany, or any other country across the pond. Pick one.
I also never suggested the US invade any other country, don't know where you're getting that from.
We did once think about invading Canada and making it the 51st state, but then.....nah we don't need it! Besides it would unbalance the flag with 51 stars.
Come on back with another rant, you're so good at it!
by oz_media
You say you THOUGHT about invading Canada. IN fact, you HAVE TRIED to invade Canada when under British/French rule, you were defeated miserably and pushed back into the USA. America had fewer citizens at that time however. Out of 286,730 US servicemen between 1812 and 1815 nearly 0.03% of your population was killed or wounded.
Funy enough, this is the same percentage of the US population killed or wouded during Vietnam (0.03%).
Vietnam was America's worst hororshow, while the defeat of 1812 is barely recognized, although the numbers were far fewer the percentage of your total population that were killed are the same.
So yes, in a very broad conclusion, America tried to invade Canada already, they were about as successful as they were in Vietnam.
"The War of 1812 is one of the forgotten wars of the United States...The offensive actions of the United States failed in every attempt to capture Canada."
And this was a cute yet barely related or credible conclusion:
http://www.salon.com/opinion/feature/2003/06/30/canada/index_np.html
.
You've never addressed the fact that there's more proof that there were WMDs than proof that there weren't. The foiled terrorist attack in Jordan, for example, which recovered enough chemical agents to kill 20,000 people (reported in the Jordanian press), or the numerous reports that WMDs were moved to Syria (reported by various foreign outlets) are only two such items you conveniently and continually overlook.
You never mention that numerous people, organizations and nations made identical claims as President Bush - even before HE made them - including Britains and Canadians.
-------------------- Such As --------------------
"Sooner or later, it seems likely that the current Iraqi regime will eventually achieve its objectives. Wait and the threat will grow."
? John Chipman, IISS director
"The argument in favour of taking action now, whether it's to compel Baghdad to accept inspectors or to use military force to change the regime, is that it's better to act when (Iraq's) capabilities are still short of reaching their ultimate objective.
If you wait, you run the risk that the Iraqis will get further along, perhaps even acquire a nuclear weapon, and that will make it much more difficult to pressure Baghdad or to prevent them from taking actions in the region that would jeopardize U.S. interests."
- Gary Samore, a senior fellow for non-proliferation at the IISS
The report also assesses Iraq's biological, chemical and ballistic missile capability. It estimates that Iraq retained "perhaps thousands of liters of anthrax" from before the Gulf War.
Saddam could resume making biological weapons within weeks and could have produced thousands of liters of anthrax, botulinum toxin and other agents since weapons inspections ended in 1998, it says.
On chemical weapons the report says Saddam probably has a few hundred tonnes of mustard gas from before the Gulf War as well as "precursors" for a few hundred tonnes of sarin and perhaps the same amount of VX.
Saddam could resume making chemical weapons in months and could have made hundreds of tonnes of mustard and nerve gases since 1998, the report adds.
David Rudd of the Canadian Institute of Strategic Studies has said that the most plausible threat comes from Saddam's willingness to ally himself with terrorists, and that Saddam could put chemical, biological or nuclear weapons in the hands of terrorists.
-------------------------------------------------
You've never admitted that the United Nations was extremely corrupt in the oil-for-food program, and they personally reaped billions of dollars in bribes and kick-backs. Nor have you admitted that France and Germany undermined the USA's efforts in the UN because they were conspirators in the scheme.
You continually lie about what President Bush did and did not say. However, whether it's intentional deception or unintentional ignorance is something I can't comment on.
You blab on and on about the most nonsensical drivel, and base your arguments on false assertions.
You.......oh, never mind. This is a waste of time.
.
...since Oz, obviously, didn't notice this was a non-American and non-Republican claim.
by oz_media
As for WMD existing at ONE time, yes it is global knowledge. (Is this a LIE?)
Saddam was asked to disarm, and he CLAIMED he did. (Is this a LIE?)
Inspectors were FINALLY allowed to inspect for 'dual purpose goods' or 'WMD' (WMD has far better impact that dual purpose goods.). (Is this a LIE?)
Inspections were coming up empty, with the exception of some unused war heads that were from missiles incapable of an intercontinental attack. (Is this a LIE?)
US informants CLAIMED that Bush had WMD still. (Is this a LIE?)
GWB thought it was a suitable reason to invade Iraq. (Is this a LIE?)
I had no reason whatsoever in any part of this thread or in my responses to mention France or Germany, as neither are the responsible for the USA invading Iraq. (Is this a LIE?)
I had no reason whatsoever in any part of this thread or in my responses to mention how the UN had failed or fuelled the abuse of the OFF program. (Is this a LIE?)
The question is secifically "Why did we go to war?"
It was not because of France, Germany, the UN, Weapons inspectors, past presidents truning thier back etc. YOu went to war for one reason and one reason only, you went to war because you can ONLY go to war for ONE reason and one reason only, because George W. Bush TOLD you to.
Other countries said not to. Other countries said it can't be so. Other countries said the weapons inspections were being effective, which they were beyond ANY shadow of a doubt (have you proved they weren't?).
So I had absolutely no reason whatsoever to raise any of the questions you say I have conveniently not asked, they are irrelevant. Did you go to war because of Germany? Nope. France? Nope. Weapons Inspectors? Nope. Failure of the UN? Nope. WMD and an attack on America? Yep. Were WMD proven to STILL exist in Iraq? Nope. Did you FIND any WMD that started the invasion? Nope.
It's not rhetorical, it's fact! YOU HAD NO VIABLE REASON FOR INVADING IRAQ BASED ON THE WMD PREMISE.
This isn't rhetorical at all, it is the TITLE of the freakin' discussion, Max! It has been sidestepped, avoided, evaded, segued and scoffed at since the beginning, but that's the reality, "WHY DID AMERICA GO TO WAR?"
BECAUSE YOU WERE SCARED THAT SADDAM STILL HAD WMD AND WAS GOING TO USE THEM AGAINST THE USA.
End of story, bottom line, no more to be said.
All of the other little segues such as France, Germany, Britain, the UN, wepaons inspectors, Liberation, rebuilding etc. is all just stuff to fog the horrendous mistake of invading a country without proper justification. It was an act of fear, not an act of courage.
So I guess your inability to retract the following must then in turn show this is your true belief,
"Besides, it's never been proven that WMDs weren't there."
Guilty until proven innocent.
.
Oz = WMD
Windbag of Mass Drivel
by oz_media
Really Max, where do you come up with this quality material?
I think I just ned to learn that instead of actually offering an opinion, it is best to just defame the posters comments then I don't need to actually have a point!
"Worthless drivel", yup, can be applied to ANY comment anytime and simply shows that you have neither the patience or the ability to offer an educated response. Well done Max! Very witty squire, very witty.
I just wish I had comebacks and degrading comments quite as clever, then I would never need to use any thought process, I could just reduce all posts by reducing the poster!
Man you are a clever one, I can see how you got so far in life! If only us disingenious liars could all learn your ways the world would be a better place, downright scary mind you.
How dare someone possibly accet a view or statement other than that of GWB, one day I'll learn, well probably not but there's always Max to remind us of how far below him we all are.
by oz_media
my response asked 8 questions, your reply answered none of them, yet you still found it neccessary to repost and again attempt to degrade my statements and 8 questions without answering a single one or responding to any of the comments, BUT, you managed to get one last chracter stab in for good luck.
Very professional, very mature and vey educated Maxwell, one day when I get old I want to be just like you.
by thechas
Sorry Max,
It is true that GWB did not steal the 2000 election.
However, I remain convinced that Republican sympathizers pulled off enough behind the scenes tricks to provide the winning margin in at least Florida.
A combination of:
Biased election worker training;
The disenfranchisement of a large number of black "inner city" voters;
and the last minute moving of polling stations;
were more than enough to shift the outcome.
So, the 2000 election was stolen in GWBs behalf, not by GWB himself.
Chas
.
.....shaking my head in disbelief.
by oz_media
Americans are generally [b]VERY[/b] politically savvy and hold thier leaders accountable for everything they do. In this case it seems everyone has excused GWB because of the fear of Iraq. No matter if he was wrong or right, he is excused because America is at war.
Now this is the type of thing I would expect Canadians to do, we dont give a crap about our PM or the government and it would be EASY for them to deceive Canadians [i](except the fact that even a threat of Saddam's henchmen comig at Canada on a 747 would go mainly unnoticed as nobody would even pay attention to the news report.)[/i]
So how does this get so easily ignored in a country where the main focus from birth is politics and prsonal political views?
[b]FEAR[/b] This is the easiest way to forget everything, including your own name, [i]scare the crap out of people and they won't backstep to ask questions later.[/i]
Thee's no other logical explanation for it, otherwise people would have burned Bush ( ]:) ) at the stake ages ago.
by garion11
by thechas
Oz as US President would be at least as interesting as "Iron" Mike Ditka as a US Senator!!
I'm not sure if Oz was born in the US or Canada though.
It is possible that the "Arnold" amendment would need to be in place for Oz to have the opportunity to even run for President.
Now, no offense Oz;
Despite the fact that Oz and I may appear to be close to each other on the political spectrum, if there were to be an election contest between Oz and Max my vote would more than likely go to Max.
In this case it is not that I do not trust Oz, it's that I believe that Max would make a better statesmen.
As a side note, I was truly impressed and inspired by Bill Clinton's address at the Democratic Convention Monday.
Whether you like him, despise him, or hate him, you have to admit that WJC is a powerful and gifted speaker.
Chas
.
I agree, I would be a much better president than Oz. (Thanks for the vote, Chas.) But I could never get elected (to anything). I wouldn't promise the moon. Hell, I wouldn't even promise a slice of the moon's green cheese.
I agree, Bill Clinton is a very good speaker.
However, did you notice how he was touting his new-found wealth, and he used it as an example of how "the rich" (whoever they are) didn't need a tax cut? Gee, why doesn't he just write a check and send it to the government? Or why doesn't he just give it all away? I guess he wasn't against it that much. He reinforces the old saying about a liberal who's willing to give the shirt off someone else's back.
by garion11
by nd_it
I think Bill Clinton comes off when he speaks as "one of the guys" and that is what makes people so hypnotic to listen too, because I think he was one of the greatest "speaking"
presidents we have had, even though I don't agree with all the policies, he sure did have a way to get people's attention.
by garion11
Why are we justifying Bush's actions/decisions/leadership to you? LOL.
Awww, he made his business your business eh? How did he do that? Could ya elaborate (sp)?
by oz_media
Basically you have justified America's [i]'foreign policy missteps'[/i]as justification for the USA's actions.
This I am sure you will agree is 100% insanity.
Shall we now fly a few US planes into Middle Eastern buildings so we can make our point that we do not like thier dictatorship and disbelief in God?
Should we start unleashing chemical attacks on one another?
Hey why not, Saddam was forgiven for it all these years, why not Bush? Why would everyone comndemn Bush if he started to slaughter citizens if Saddam got away with it?
I know you consider this post complete onsense, as do I. The scary part is that this is [b]your[/b] justification for the US foreign policy missteps.
by oz_media
WOW guess boobies for boobies may work?
or breast for breast? :P
by garion11
Its amazing how he pushes the focus away from a dictator and pushes it onto Bush. LOL. Its scary that he justifies Saddam's existence by bashing Bush.
I guess you are still waiting for some sort of justification from US or GWB for invading Iraq?? I don't think its a misstep, Bush did the best he could under the intel he received. After your country is attacked, pre emptiveness became our foreign policy. Does that scare you or something?? Is that why you rant and rave everyday??
Actually Saddam wasn't forgiven for it all these years, 10 years of stupidity on his part lead to his ousting.
As far as planes flying into middle eastern countries and your wishful nonsense, I said this before and I am going to say it again, IF Bush really really wanted to destroy the middle east, don't you think he would have?? a few nukes in a few major cities pretty much would have done the trick.
LOL, you really think Bush wanted to deal with this crap? You really think America wants to deal with terrorism? I and many Americans would rather see the billions of dollars invested somewhere else, but this problem hit us (literally) on 9/11. After that, we don't need to justify NOTHING. Absolutely NOTHING. Get it through your stupid thick skull and repeat after me, AMERICA DOESN'T NEED TO JUSTIFY NOTHING WHEN IT COMES TO OUR SAFETY AND SECURITY. If our government feels you are out to blow America up, we will do our BEST to take you out. You don't like it, don't pi/s/s on us then!, like Saddam tried to do. UNDERSTOOD??
by maecuff
by oz_media
Your nonexistant and self ventered thought process (or lack thereof) is a damn scary thing and I am certainly glad as hell that YOU don't run America.
Every country on earth is under SOME threat of attack from another person or country, it always has been this way and always will.
Your analogy states that if you THINK you COULD POSSIBLY be attacked by anyone, you have full rights to go and invade them?! THis is pure idiocy and something that would destroy America as a nation in an instant. Garion would be the end of your great nation, with no doubt whatsoever.
Anyho0w, if you were part of the conversation and had followed it and were the person I replied to, you would understand that the xact same statement was made by your mentor Maxwell. I just pointed out the lunacy behind justifying BUSH's actions by implying 'Saddam did it, why can't we?'.
Now I've said before, you are a complete waste of my time and energy because you have never understood a single post in this forum and take everything on some wierd tangent, no matter WHO made the comments.
So politely step out of my conversation with Maxwell and find someone else's time to waste with your moronic nonsense.
.
I said what I said - no more, no less.
Where you came up with such, as you put it, nonsense, I have no idea.
by oz_media
"Why is it that Saddam Hussein isn't just as roundly criticized for his "foreign policy missteps"?
This implies the expectations of equal treatment between Saddam and GWB. This also implies that everyone is on Bush's case for his forewign policies yet noone is holdng Saddam accountable, which is pure crap.
The entire wold holds Saddam accountable for his horrible repression of the people and actions as a dictator, the whole world would like to see him removed.
THis in no way justifies the US invasion though as you were ASKED to wait for evidence to be confirmed (hindsight, ooops, maybe you should have?). Americans seem to think that nobody wanted to invade Iraq and thought saddam was just fine, wrong.
Americans seem to also think that it is thier DUTY to ignore allies and invade anyway, wrong.
If your country was under an imminent threat, YES, we should ALL go to war. BUT, your country was not under imminent threats from Saddam, yet yu RUSHED to stop the madman.
How can you then try and turn this anything else but a sorry mistake by the US administration?
It isn't only rude, it's wrong. GWB should be charged with a war crime for God's sake, this was not a justified or immediately neccessary invasion.
A&E did a biography on Bin Laden last night, they show just how Clinton and GWB's failure to capture him has made him a hero, Osama is the number one name for baby boys in Afghanistan, you are being laughed at, scofed at and they are planig the next attack. Bin Laden is an IMMINENT threat. Why did you turn tail and run to invade Iraq instead of taking out your IMMINENT threat?
by garion11
by maecuff
by jamesrl
I know Oz was just aching for me to step in.
The War of 1812 is pretty much forgotten in US and British history, but is remembered in Canadian history as a defining moment.
The cause of the war is up to debate. The official US version is that the British were boarding US vessels and impressing sailors into service. The fact that some of them were British Navy deserters isn't brought up that often.
But the real cause, if you read the history books, was the American "manifest destiny" to rule north america - this was sweeping the US, and in particular areas like Kentucky, the "warhawks" were actively pushing for war as a means of expanding territory and preventing British/Indian treaties. Something to note, many New Englanders were violently opposed to the war(sound familiar?) as they were profiting from trade with Canada.
On the Canadian side, it was an alliance of British troops(not too many, as Britain was fighting Napoleon at the time), Canadian Militias, and native warriors, including Tecumseh.
At one time Canada held Detroit, at other times the US held a Canadian Fort on the north side of the Niagara, but it was pretty much back and forth. Time and time again, outnumbered Canadian forces drove back American forces. Battles on the great lakes went back and forth - Oliver Hazard Perry did score the US navy's biggest win, but then again, his ships outnumbered the British, and for the first part of the battle, the superior seamanship of the British nearly won out.
Every american seems to remember that the white house was attacked, but they forget that it was a reaction to the US attacking York(now Toronto) and burning parliament(and generally behaving badly). The White House raid, and the whole New Orleans campaign were not attempted to try and take over any american soil but were meant to draw US troops away from the border battles. So when the Americans crow about kicking butt at the battle of New Orleans(with that silly Johnny Horton song), they don't realise that the point was not to take New Orleans, the attempt was to cause mischief and draw US troops away from Canada.
Nobody really won the war- it was ended by treaty. If it had gone on, the US might have faced more British troops, as by the time of the treaty, the Napoleonic wars had ended.
Canada was also invaded after the US Civil war by fenians - anti-British Irish and their decendants living in america. The US government turned a blind eye, though they certainly were aware - many of them had served in the Irish regiments of the war. They got drunk in Buffalo, crossed the border and had their butts kicked by Canadian Militia. The only real importance to this is that it hurried up those who were negotiating the creation of the Canadian nation(Upper Canada=Ontario, Lower Canada=Quebec, and two of the maritime provinces).
If you visit cities like Kingston, Fort Erie, Toronto, Quebec City or Halifax you can see the evidence of our defensive nature - fortifications built to forestall american invasion. It has shaped out history. America is the only country that could invade Canada - even at the height of the cold war, the Soviets could not put enough soliders on ships to land on Canadian soil(they had no real aircraft carriers). Nonetheless, Canada has fought in WWI, WWII, Korea and the first Gulf war from day one.
James
.
You asked, Why did the USA go to war against Iraq?
Was it because Iraq had weapons of mass destruction? The answer is yes.
Was it to free Iraq from Saddam Hussein? The answer is yes.
Was it because Iraq had links to terrorism? The answer is yes.
Or was it because the Bush administration simply wanted some means to go to war, regardless of its cost both economic and human? The answer is, of course not; that's simply absurd.
The first three questions are legitimate, and the answers can be, to varying degrees, substantiated. That last question, however, is more than absurd. If anyone really believes that, I must question their ability to think rationally.
You said, "So far no WMDs have been found". Well that's simply not true. Some have indeed been found, although not the "stockpiles" that the world thought would be. Read the rest of my messages for some of the details, but the bigger question is this. Did Saddam dupe the whole world into thinking he did have such stockpiles, or are they yet to be found. If it's the former, we should be working on improving the accuracy of western intelligence procedures. If it's the latter, we all have reason to be extremely concerned.
You suggested that finding Saddam Hussein was probably the most expensive manhunt in history. Well, perhaps it was. Therefore what?
Could we have captured Osama bin Laden if we had "done this differently" (translation: not gone into Iraq)? Well, who knows? Maybe yes, maybe no. Neither you or I are privy to the intelligence information concerning Osama's whereabouts, so it's pure speculation. If he's known to be in Pakistan, for example, which he very well may be, that's a political and logistical hot-potato that could ignite a regional disaster. But by asking such a question, if I read you correctly, you're suggesting that we should have focused on only Osama bin Laden until either he was confirmed dead or captured. To that I would suggest that you consider a scenario where you have two (or more) bullies terrorizing your neighborhood - all of whom are very sly and evasive, not to mention, well armed and dangerous. Do you try to deal with only one at a time, or do you try to deal with the multiple bullies on more than one front simultaneously? The USA certainly has the wherewithal to focus on more than one bully at a time. We did, after all, fight World War II in both the Pacific and the European theaters at the same time; and to do otherwise would have been a disaster. The same may be the case in this instance as well.
You suggested that the 9-11 commission reported that there were no connections between Iraq and terrorism. Well that's just a false assertion; no, they didn't report that. They were investigating 9-11 only, and their conclusion was that Iraq was not directly involved in the 9-11 attacks. But President Bush never made such a suggestion either. Iraq was, however, a supporter and sponsor of world-wide terrorism. To believe otherwise is just foolish. And to think the "war on terrorism" is one with blinders, seeking justice for only 9-11, is equally foolish.
You further asked, "does that mean that we should invade every single country in the world with suspected links to terrorism"? To that I would say, absolutely yes, at least eventually - unless, of course, you or anyone else has a better idea of how to stop the madness known as world-wide terrorism. The United Nations (and other individual nations - including the USA) have failed miserably in that regard over the past forty years. How many more innocent people should die before we do something? How many more 9-11s should we endure before we do something? If we don't go to them and stop them - wherever they may be - what's the alternative? I don't think they'll listen if we simply ask them politely to stop, do you?
Could 9-11 have been prevented, you ask? Absolutely - but only with the benefit of hind-sight. Consider this. The current "war on terrorism" (including Iraq), and the creation of the US Department of Homeland Security is intended to help stop the next 9-11. I'm amazed at how the same people criticize those efforts on one hand, but on the other hand, expect the next 9-11 to be prevented. Which way do they want it? What would have happened, for example, if President Bush, in February 2001, stated to the world that terrorists were holed-up in Afghanistan, and they were planning a terrorist attack on the United States and other nations. He further stated that he wanted the United Nations to support a coalition to invade Afghanistan to apprehend them. Sure, everybody would have gone along with that, right? Yea, right. Well that's what we're doing today. We're trying to prevent the next 9-11, and we can't wait until the threat is imminent.
Do I think we would be safer if we spent more on intelligence than on the military, you ask? Well, we need to spend more on both; that should be obvious. However, I think the rest of the world, specifically Canada, France and Germany, are not carrying their share of the burden. And what do I think is the rest of the world?s impression of the US so far, you ask? Well, I suppose I don't really care. The goal here is to stop world-wide terrorism before another 9-11 happens, not to make nicey-nicey with those (countries I mentioned) who don't want to get involved. Just like an individual has to act in a way that he believes is right and just, and just let the chips fall where they may, so must the USA as a nation. It's the function of the US government to protect its citizens from all enemies, foreign and domestic - regardless of what the French may think about it. To do otherwise is not acceptable. And if Canada, France and Germany don't like it, that's just too bad. In my opinion, it's them shirking their responsibilities to the free-world, not us (U.S.). If I were a Canadian, I'd be ashamed of my government for not doing anything.
What do I think is the Muslim world?s impression of the US so far, you ask? Well, most of them are tolerant people who want to live in peace. Others, however, the fanatics, hate us and want to see us all dead. Personally speaking, that would put a real damper on my day. I don't want that to happen, and am willing to do whatever it takes to prevent it from happening.
There ya' go. Each and every question answered - and hopefully, in a well thought-out and rational manner.
But I have a question for you (or anyone else). Can you (or anyone else) discuss this in a reasonable and rational manner, without relying of mistruths and political rhetoric? Or are you content in believing "conspiracy" type fabrications which are unfounded and politically motivated? If it's the former, come back with a reply. It it's the latter, you should really try to get a grip on reality.
by sullyman
Max,
I am responding to the question that you posted. Of course people can discuss these matters in a reasonable and rational matter. But, as you so eloquently put it without relying on mistruths and political rhetoric. That probably won't happen, and if I can I will try and explain why.
There are numerous posters on both sides of this hot-bed issue, both relying on what they view as the truth. Who is to say that your beliefs are not the ones based on mistruths and political rhetoric? We can go back and forth until we are all red in the face, discrediting each others sources. Liberal, Democratic, Republican, Pro-US, and Anti-US media exists everywhere. Just because I do not believe in (not all.. just some) the current US foreign policies and quote sources that do not always take a Pro-US stance, does not mean I do not have a grip on reality. I choose to evaluate the information, view it as I will and draw my conclusions based on my feelings. The same goes for you, if you read an article in the POST that says " WMD have not been found yet in Iraq" your interpretation could be that it is only a matter of time. Where mine is that they might not have any. It's the glass is half full - or half empty decision...it's all in how you look at it!!
.
....and I can't really disagree with any of it.
However my "grip on reality" comments were really directed at sentiments similar to the one the original poster had made when he asked, "......Or was it because the Bush administration simply wanted some means to go to war, regardless of its cost both economic and human?"
Now that is not even close to gripping reality, and all too often, that's what people believe.
by oz_media
Nobody can explain anything in a rational manner unless it mirrors your own thoughts.
You are dead set that you are correct and anything else is siomply a mistruth or an outright lie.
Whereas some others think that they are completely corect and YOUR sources (GWB included) are the ones with the deceptive untruths that people are buying into, and therefore see yourself as not havig a grip on reality.
There's are two sides, not one and each is just as valid as the other. Except that you feel our beliefs and studies have turned up the truth and everyone else is wrong, ca't you see how simple it really is?
People aren't insane for not believing you, they simply choose to see a diferent side, as you know there are ALWAYS two sides to every story.
.
I don't think that you don't simply want to make fun of someone who doesn't think the same way that you don't, don't you think?
.
Would you please articulate exactly what those proposals are? Be exact and be precise.
.
When the Republicans took control of Congress (in 1994), there was a Democrat in the White House. Moreover, when the Democrats controlled Congress for the 40 years before 1994, Republicans were in the White House more than Democrats. (Actually, there was a short period in the 80s when the Republicans held a majority in the Senate, but not the House.) Your logic simply falls apart under the slightest bit of scrutiny.
On your other note, will you please share your "record" comparing the money both Democrats and Republicans have "stolen"? Please itemise each instance of theft, placing the Democrats in one column and the Republicans in the other. That would be interesting to see.
.
Can the USA trust the rest of the world? It looks rather bleak, at this point.
by maecuff
You and me against the World
Sometimes it feels like..You and me against the World
When all the others turn their backs and walk away,
you can count on me to stay.
Remember when the Terrorists came to kill...
and we were damaged by their ill,
wasn't it nice to be around someone that you knew?
Someone who was big and strong and looking out for you and me
Against the World
Sometimes it feels like you and me against the World
and for all the times we cried,
I always felt that God was on our side
And when one of us is gone,
and one of us is left to carry on
Then remembering will have to do
Our resolve alone will get us through
Think about the days of me and you,
You and Me against the World
- Paul Williams (lyrics slightly changed by Maxwell Edison)
by hargerd
I'm getting a bit fed up of everyone showing even the slightest notion of a pro-Palestinian stance being dubbed "anti-Semetic"
I have no issues with Judaism or the Jewish people BUT I do have a problem with the right wing Israeli government stance of land grabbing and almost complete occupation of Palestine, its people and their movements (yes I do call the occupied territories Palestine!!)
AS ARE EVERYONE ELSE (i.e those backward ?commie? countries as some in here would call them)
FLAME IF YOU WISH, I DON?T CARE ! ? THESE ARE MY VIEWS
by hargerd
I'm getting a bit fed up of everyone showing even the slightest notion of a pro-Palestinian stance being dubbed "anti-Semetic"
I have no issues with Judaism or the Jewish people BUT I do have a problem with the right wing Israeli government stance of land grabbing and almost complete occupation of Palestine, its people and their movements (yes I do call the occupied territories Palestine!!)
AS ARE EVERYONE ELSE (i.e those backward ?commie? countries as some in here would call them)
FLAME IF YOU WISH, I DON?T CARE ! ? THESE ARE MY VIEWS
by oz_media
I just don't know whether to puke or cry.
I don't know how all the world can turn thier backs on your poor downtrodden country that sufers so from the evil men of the world.
Other countries have just NO idea what it's like tto be terrorized, they hae never lost men, women and children to attacks on thier own soil. No sons and daughters were sent to war, no families were broken and no love was lost.
They just don't understand how the sorry little USA has been bullied for so long and has finally had enough of it. Awwwwwwwwwwwww. :-(
I am so sorry Maxwell, I didn't realize you were all being picked on and nobody understands.
.
You can read into what I said whatever your warped little mind can conjure up. But I said what I said, and that's all that I said.
Some people read too much into what others say. But in your case, you take it a step further and read into what other people didn't say.
Geesh. No wonder it's not possible to carry on an intelligent conversation with you.
by oz_media
What you hear in your head and what people see on paper needs to be carefully worded, which you often do but in this case you have spurted all kinds of comments out, noting that you have been losing it over the last day or so and simply getting frustrated, perhaps time for a break.
I am not the only one who saw this, I only posted because an email had pointed it out to me, upon reading it I also got the same impression. "Why BUSH if not Saddam?"
Because we expect Saddam to act in a radical and irrational manner, not the 'leader of the free world'.
The other thing I have noticed is you sinmply cannot post a single comment, suggestion or thought without takin gSOME form of a pot shot at whoever is posting, not just myself but almost ALL your replies. Even when you agree with people, you can't do it without saying how you will 'accept thier views even though you disagree' as if people are begging for your acceptance. Buy a dog or something instead, he'll look up to you, praise you, wallow at your feet, follow you faithfully and leave little presents all over our yard to clean up.
Now you may see this as my own little pot shot at yourself, well I suppose it is in a way, what I am sayign is get a life and realize other people also have one too. They don't need for you to validate thier arguments, tell them whata is right or wrong, sane or insane, you have no right to judge anyone or thier comments.
Offer your own views but learn to accept that some people will never accept yours, no matter what you call them, some people will ALWAYS see your views, no matter what others call them.
You are NOT right, you are NOT wrong, you simply have your own beliefs and opinions just as others do, stop tryig to moderate ad correct everyone, it's SOOOOOO tiring and expected.
by oz_media
You MUST be kidding, right?
America's actions will hae no efect whatsoever on any other part of the world, this is just a small isolated incident that America is takig care of by themselves and it shouldn't raise any eyebrows.
Based on your analogy, you could also say, what has Saddam done to you? He is just doing his own thing on the other half of the planet and it has no bearig on you.
Before you reply, Saddam is NOT responsible for the 9/11 attacks. Saddam was NOT in a position to launch an attck on the USA.
So given the theory that your preemtive strike is justified, then so is my dislike toward america's president welcoming and bringing on even more hatred towards North America, not just the USA as you seem to feel. What you do has immediate effects on allied countries. BinLaden was against America and anyoe who sides with America, not just the USA.
When you start bashing a stick into a beehive, all is fine and well (have at er) if nobody else is beside you. If you do it in a public park, you must expect people to start coming after you for it if they are running the risk of gettig stung too.
Be an idiot in your own damn backyard, not the global stage, THEN it becomes EVERYONE'S business.
So, what has GWB done to ME? Well, he has brought more hatred and need for terrorist revenge upon north America, where I live too. Just as anyone POSSIBLY harming your country must be stopped, why is it that anyone outside America is not allowed to voice thier dislike for bringing them into it because of your irrational actions?
by cactus pete
You're saying that there's no way a rich person can be a democrat, unless they're just about to give it all away? And if a democrat becomes wealthy, they have to immediately become poor again?
Where's your cutoff, anyway?
Personally [admittedly, I'm not a dem, but most people push me into that category when speaking on social issues and only allowing for red or blue] I feel that I won't pay the government anything I don't have to. However, I vote for higher taxes when I think the money will be put towards a good cause. That's part of living in a society. I am proud to be an American who pays his fair share. But I prefer it to be a fair share, not an unfair share.
Come on, Max. Do you really think that Clinton has to give the money back or swallow his words?
.
My comments about Bill Clinton giving away all his money was to make a point, although I do believe that a true liberal today is indeed willing to give the shirt off someone else's back - including Bill Clinton and company. How about the loud-mouth Hollywood Limousine Liberals, the ones making tens of millions of dollars every year, while the "little guys" who build the sets and so on (probably 90% of "Hollywood") are working for low wages? Let those hypocrites share some of their wealth instead of hoarding it all themselves, while at the same time lobbying government to force you and me to share ours - which is significantly lower, by the way.
You and I have had quite a few discussions on the transfer of wealth programs forced upon the American people. Usually, however, your arguments seem to be based on the premise that there aren't any, or at least not enough, and that there are still needy people out there. With all due respect, that's total B.S. We transfer 1 trillion dollars - in fact, more than 1 trillion dollars - each and every year in the name of funding various social programs, and in the name of compassion. If we transferred zero dollars, you and people like Bill Clinton might have a legitimate point. In fact, being the compassionate person that I am, I might even agree. But I must ask you. When is enough, enough?
I don't think you understand how much money is forcefully transferred each and every year. Have some fun and do some calculations with one trillion dollars divided by the 300 million total population, or the 100 million total households - or better yet, divided by the "needy" population (whoever they really are). How much more do these people want? To them, enough is never enough. In my opinion, however, these "tax and give-away" liberals don't do it to be compassionate. They do it to gain power over those they want to convince are "needy". They want dependency on government so they can maintain their power over those they govern. And consider this, the US government, as it is now, is obligated to give away 46 TRILLION DOLLARS based on the programs currently in place. And of course, you and I both know that the government usually underestimates such things.
If you tax something (productivity), you get less of it. If you subsidize something (give-away programs), you get more of it. How long will it be before we have less of the former and more of the latter? I think we need to convince people that they need to live their lives relying on themselves instead of relying on the government. The level of wealth transfer simply cannot be sustained. Since the end of World War II, federal spending has remained at about 20 percent (give or take a few) of the GDP. However, the growth in the cost of all the various transfer of wealth programs has outpaced the growth in the GDP, and where it once accounted for only about 4 percent of the federal budget, it now consumes well over 50 percent of all federal dollars spent. If left unchecked, it will soon collapse under its own weight. The growth is simply not sustainable.
And look at it in a couple of other ways.
First of all, a "socialized" government is not what the founders envisioned. To the contrary, the common thought was that a government that governed least, governed best. The big argument of that day was a stronger federal government versus stronger states' governments. But the every-day care of the individual was not even part of the equation. Working from that beginning, the USA became the economic power of the world in a little more than 100 years - leap froging over the long established nations of the world such as Great Britain, Italy, Spain and France. It wasn't done with a socialistic system, but rather one of individual responsibility. It was the socialistic countries that grew weaker, while we grew stronger. When people can vote themselves other people's money, and politicians give it to them so they can get votes, this will lead to the degeneration of the general welfare of our nation. The doom of democracy, as we know it, is inevitable if we remain on the same path.
In addition, I think the politics of class-envy is harmful to the hopes and dreams of the common guy. And the Democrats play the "class-envy" game to the hilt. Why not reverse the trend of being a nation of enablers, to becoming a nation of encouragers? Why not reverse the trend of creating dependency on government, to becoming independent from from government? And yes, I think a person is entitled to enjoy the rewards of his efforts without being demonized in the process.
I think the dialogue has to change. I think that the time has come to say enough is enough. Or do you think ONE TRILLION DOLLARS each and every year is not enough? And how long can we guarantee individual liberty if we continue to pander to those who vote only to raid the public treasury - or especially to the politicians who promise it?
Give them your money, but leave mine alone. I have a family to look out for.
by garion11
Your ridiculousnes and truth spinning posts show noone is disallowing your rants against Bush. LOL. Where did you come up with this one??
The fact that certain people here don't care about what your opinion is (since its the same anyway), thats the issue.
These terrorists wanted to attack and have attacked America since the 1970s lol. America is just starting to fight back. If you feel unsafe, oh well too bad. Now you know how Americans feel since 9/11.
I love the fact you rant that Bush is causing terrorism LOL. When are you going to give the terrorists any credit?? I mean they will be disappointed.
by oz_media
You ask a question and when I offer an honest answer you come back with nobody cares. Well if you don't care, shut up and stop asking stupid questions.
You have started to take on a holier than thou attitude, which mat be excusable for some of the peers here but most definitely not someone such as yourself. You dictate and condescend, you lauch at others comments, you have adopted the character bashig resolution to anything you don't like, instead of simply providing your opinion. You have proven before, not too long ago, that you are simply here to raise sh*t. You have NO interest in helping anyone in the IT community (which is what TR is all about) you have NO interest in hearing ANY alternatve view to your own. It is really tirig for eeryone, it is really immature ad it is not what I not anyone else comes here to read. You waste my time as well as everyone elses.
Like I said before, when you are able to show that you hae particiated in theis community OUTSIDE the ability to simply rant about Bush and say how stupid the rest of the world is, you MAY start to gain some credibility and hold a worthwhile conversation. As you hae proved in this discussion several times, this is far beyond your capabilities at this time.
So now you can post your little LOL post and start off on your guffaws abot how stupid I am and what nonsense I speak (you really hae to start coming up with your own material instead of just following your mentors)and I will not reply. This way you will hae the last word and can feel like your comments made you look like the better man.
You are the epitomy of what people dislike about America and Americans, full of sh*t but you think you're clever, when will people like youself ever wake up? You just haven't seen or heard enough to know better I suppose.
by claudiamesna
Sort by Trending