Why did we go to war?
This is page 5 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 5 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by jamesrl
Yes the data was old.
Yes, it is unlikely that by raising the terror alert for a time and posting armed guards outside the buildings, that the government managed to act at the time which would thwart the act overtly. Unless you plan on keeping those guards there for a long time, and the alert level high for the same period.
Never the less, the publicity involved may have prevented a future attack indirectly. Now that the information is out there, those that work in those buildings will be on heightened alert, for years to come. That alone may discourage the terrorists, and force them to find new easier targets. And yes the planning takes time, so we have more time to find the terrorists.
Its quite possible that the attacks never got beyond the initial planning stages. But in matters of life and death, especially on this scale, its better to be safe than sorry.
Bill Clinton by the wayt, was in Toronto yesterday and 2000 people lined up for 1000 books to be signed. Some people camped over night like it was a rock concert.
James
by tomsal
Don't mean to sound grumpy or anything but we (the American people) don't need the government (or "govment" as some say) to say what is likely and probable to happen.
Anything can happen. Its ALWAYS been that way -- before 9/11 and of course after 9/11.
Sad to say what happened in NYC is hardly the worse scenario or even in the ball park.
I think of our dependency on technology or even worse water supply.
Some well planned strategic strikes at key water treatment facilities through out the country, perhaps some strikes against the major backbone points (NAPs) on the big dog networks like UUNET/MCI or AT&T for example.
With the technology cut you can seriously disrupt a much larger region than just NYC -- how about the whole country?
With the water supply -- you could cause extreme panic and even high death rates if you'd be able to poison it someway.
Granted it this would be a monumental feat and would require lots of man power and incredible teamwork.
911 showed us their dedication already, and it hinted at their excellent teamwork.....hmmmm that only leaves man power.
I'm guessing more than 15-20 terrorists hate the USA enough to cripple or kill it.
Anything can happen.
by oz_media
The world is at war, everyone is bombing and shooting, the over 100 planes (bombers ad Luftwaffe fighters) start bombing London almost 24/7 without ease for several days.
Yup, it COULD get a lot worse. This is just an example of what a madman could do 60 years ago!
But others wouldn't understand what it's like to be in America and under attack I'm sure, no other countries have been attacked this way.
I am not suggesting the Taliban are going to start bombing raids in he USA, but don't ever for a slit second think it's safe or that you're okay.
These are terrorists, they don't give up, they simply regenerate with more hatred each time around until the reason is completely forgotten and two countries are simply at war with nothing to resolve.
by hal 9000
The obvious target that is now beginning to be protected is the "Power Grid & Generating Plants."
Without power we would have no water, technology or emergency services available. It would take about 1 week to cripple the entire country as things all depend on electricity to run. No matter if it is cracking oil to power the generators and emergency vehicles to maintain Civil Control.
The best way to cause mass panic is to remove the ability of the Government to Govern and without electricity this would be the most effective means of doing serious damage to the United States or for that matter anywhere else.
The real fact is that 9-11 was a target that had some meaning to a lot of people in the US but in reality did very little damage it could and should have been far worse as not very far away {in flying terms} where nuke power plants which would never have survived a direct impact from a commercial airliner and gone critical contaminating massive areas of the country for thousands of years to come. Along with the health affects that would occur it would have been devastating.
Just be thankful that the person behind 9-11 had a fixation on The World Trade Center and had no real idea of how to cripple your country.
Col
by hjmoore420
I was just wondering. I know some of it went to a subsidy to the airlines, cooperate welfare as it was...which is ok to Republicans because business is more valuable than people to them, but after the Clinton terms we have a surplus of 500+ billion dollars, and now we are down 400+ billion dollars. Where did this money go?
In the 80's the deficits were blamed on the tax and spend congress, a bunch of liberal spend it alls for the "Good" of the poor. What's the republican response now?
The entire congress is Republican last I looked. What about the senate, not only are the republicans in control but the Dems are down 2 votes since Kerry and Edwards can't show up to vote, so where did this money go??
Or are we too concerned with how Kerry received medals and if Busch showed up to fly planes to ask this question. I would like to think with 1 trillion dollars are country could do some great things, but from where I am sitting we are about the same now as we were after Clinton left, minus some personal freedoms.
So could someone please answer me where this money went?
Thanks
.
I frown on ALL money transfer programs, whether it's going into the hands of an individual who didn't earn it or a business that didn't earn it.
In my opinion, if a business can't survive within the free-market parameters of supply and demand, there's something fundamentally flawed with that particular business, and it should either restructure or close its doors. However, I don't necessarily oppose all government help to restructure an extremely LARGE company, such as an airline, or as was the case with Chrysler in the 80s; nor do I oppose help in the form of loans, such as in the case of "small business" loans. Keeping Chrysler solvent was in everyone's best interest - the company's, the thousands of people who worked for the company, and the nation as a whole so as to remain competitive in the world market-place. But in such a case, I would expect the company to pay back the "loan", again, as was the case with Chrysler. Chrysler needed many billions of dollars to "restructure", and they paid it back - early and with interest, if I remember correctly.
But simply allowing a company to keep more of the money it earns, as in the form of a lower tax rate, is not "corporate welfare". I would define "welfare", whether it's individual or corporate, as the transfer of dollars from the person who earned it to the person (or entity) that didn't earn it. And since corporations "earn" the dollars that a tax cut allows them to keep, a tax rate reduction is not, by my definition, "corporate welfare".
Please define what you mean by "corporate welfare", and please give a specific example of it happening.
By the way, what "personal freedoms" have YOU lost. Please be specific, and please report ONLY first hand information.
.
...I knew you wouldn't (or couldn't) answer them honestly.
.
Great post, James - Thank you.
The problem discussing these types of issues with many people, one of whom is aldanatech, is that they will absolutely never give credit where credit is due, or even give the benefit of the doubt, as Bill Clinton did. (And I'll give your fellow Canadian, Oz, certainly not a big GWB fan, credit as well. He voiced his understanding and support of the alert as well.)
It's painfully obvious, at least to me, that aldanatech has an axe to grind with President Bush; he's a big John Kerry supporter; and he dismisses all reason and common sense - not to mention national security - just to find another opportunity to criticize his political opponent, in this case, President Bush. Sure, there are similar people on the Republican (or Bush) side always trying to defend absolutely everything, or criticize everything on the opponents' side; and it just comes across as more partisan with less of a base in principle. (No, I don't consider myself one of them.)
From those people - on both sides - the gibberish flows like water, and there's no reasoning with them. (I often wonder, why I even try.)
James, even though we've not always agreed, your open-mind has always been appreciated. I further trust that you're more indicative of the Canadian mind-set than what may appear to be the case in these threads.
And I, too, see where Bill Clinton's book signing tour is drawing large crowds. But hey, like him or not, agree with him or not, to have an autographed edition of a past President's book is pretty cool. I missed out on the chance to get one myself when he came to my area, but I would like to have one as well. (Maybe I'll buy one on ebay - at $100 plus. Ouch!)
.
...people give too much credit to the power of one person. To think that nothing can be done in such cases, and to think that an appropriate response can't be implemented without the direct order of one individual, is just plain nonsense. Too much credit is given to the president when things go right, and too much blame is placed on him when things go wrong. He's just one person - one person in a HUGE machine - where so much is cruising on automatic pilot. The military, for example, has pre-approved contingency plans for hundreds of defense scenarios, as does the FAA, as does the FBI, and so on.
On 9-11, I'll guarantee you, no one was sitting on their hands waiting to "receive an order", so to speak, from the president. Sure, on 9-11, one hand (the FAA) couldn't properly coordinate with the other (NORAD), or the other (the FBI), and so on. But whether President Bush (or President anybody) took seven minutes or seven seconds to do whatever he did (and still, none of us really knows for sure), it didn't matter in the least.
by oz_media
But you said it all right here:\
"people give too much credit to the power of one person. "
Damn straight! He's just a politician, a professional liar with a good salary and millions of people and bilions of dollars at his beck and call.
Again, people give too much credit to the power of one person.
by jamesrl
I have a number of signed books.
Having worked in politics, a signature from a politician doesn't mean that much to me personally. Up until the current Prime Minister, I had shaken hands with every Prime Minister since Pierre Eliot Trudeau, who was first elected in 1968. One of them I knew pretty well - worked on several of his campaigns, met his wife, both sisters in law, mother inlaw(who brought a bunch of us camapign workers dinner once). I've had a beer with him, joked with him. They are just people - some good, some bad.
Now a good author - there I like signed books. My wife has a signed copy of a Douglas Adams book - she was reading it in a hotel lobby when someoen asked her if she liked the book - she replied she much preferred his first book(Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy) - turned out to be the author. I have several signed books by political writers, and a couple of fiction writers.
Regarding Bill Clinton's book - not sure they were there for the book - apparently the reviews are pretty bad, even from Clinton friendly reviewers. Many of the young ladies wanted to kiss him - he obliged. He was suprised at the crowd and shook hands with some who were too far back to get a signed book.
I would have liked to chat with him. But I wouldn't have lined up all day to do it. He did make a good speech about Canadian US relations to a reporter and thats the kind of thing I would have talked about.
James
by aldanatech
Look. If you want to right answers you must to ask the right questions. The whole point is not about giving tax cuts to the low class, but the middle class. Or is it that you don't know there is such a thing as a middle class? Do you think the entire country's social status is divided into the low and high class only?
Now IF you finally got it, I'll move on the next point. Both the middle class and the high class work and pay taxes, so if the high class can get tax cuts, so should the middle class. The low class doesn't pay taxes, so forget them. Then again, everybody pays taxes one way or the other.
Other the other hand, we can't just assume tax cuts alone will do the trick. That was one of Bush's biggest mistakes. It is not exactly a magic wand. There's a lot more involved. First of all, tax cuts should be approved responsibly. If certain cuts would underfund vital programs such as education or health care then you must slim it down a bit. Bush did quite the opposite, and now whe red numbers all over the place and a deficit of over 400,000 million dollars. I would love to continue this, but I got to get going.
.
You spew nonsense about the right questions and right answers - how about honest answers to honest questions? My questions were honest questions, and you just don't want to honestly answer them.
I don't necessarily see an America divided by classes. You, on the other hand, do see a nation divided by classes - and you exploit the fears of one class to demonize another. That's not to say that I don't realize many people are better-off or more wealthy than others, but I say more power to them, while you, on the other hand, want to demonize them and take from them the fruits of their success.
I don't begrudge anyone who succeeds and becomes wealthy (no, I'm not even close), nor do I want anything from them. A tax rate cut that's distributed equitably to the people who paid the tax in the first place is fair. If a certain group of people pay 90 percent of the taxes, I have no problem with 90 percent of any tax cut being returned to them.
Consider the following scenario:
If the overall tax rate, for example, is reduced by 10 percent across-the-board (using 10 percent for illustration purposes only), that means that a person who earns one million dollars a year, might see a rate reduction from 38 percent to 28 percent. A person who earns 100 thousand dollars a year, might see a tax rate reduction from 28 percent to 18 percent. The rate of reduction is equal. However, since 10 percent of one million is more than 10 percent of 100 thousand, the dollar amount will be higher. But I don't have a problem with that. Apparently, because of your class-envy tendencies, you do.
In the most recent round of tax cuts, everyone who pays taxes received a tax cut. I received a tax cut, and you received a tax cut - unless, of course, your income is low enough so that you don't pay any taxes at all.
Instead of simply repeating the tired old cliches of the Democrat party talking points, why don't you share with us what you've learned about the past tax rate cuts, and how much was returned to each "class" (as you put it)? Do a little research, and stop repeating the Democrat Party tired old talking-points.
You spew your clich?s about what "is needed", so will you also please share with us your expertise, experience and education in the field of economics. And why should anyone believe you and not these experts?
by oz_media
No I am not from South Africa but Southern England. I am oftenconfised as South African or Australian though because of my broken English/Canadian accent.
Your input is a valued as any, moreso in some cases because it is an outside view. At one time we had several Australian and British peers here but now it seems just few. Several have emailed me and said it is simply a waste of time debating politics with Americans and they have just disappeared due to the futility of it all.
Stick around and have some fun, it gets going pretty good sometimes and people start to trip and stumble on themselves all the time, it is truly a three ring circus here, if you have patience.
:-)
by oz_media
Just a little side note but James's post mentioned how Clinton was received at a book signing and it reminded me of the slip through Port Hardy that Geroge Bush made a few weeks ago (not GWB).
Pretty much everyone in Port Hardy knows when Jim Pattison is setting sail, he is one of the richest and most successful men in Canada, our Donald Trump on a smaller scale.
Well he and George Bush are good friends and he was escorting GB to go fishing on the coast.
Jim's boat was moored on a local wharf and the word quickly got out that George Bush and Jim Pattison were going to land in Port Hardy before setting sail to go on a fishing trip.
So I am drinking coffee (decaf or course) at the wharf and see Jim and Geore get out of a plane, with a few in tow and board his yacht. There were secret service and RCMP all over town, how inconspicuous in their black suits and blacked out vans in a town full of rusty pickups and fishermen, wouldnn't want to draw attention now!
So george Bush is in town, secret service everywhere and barely a soul turned out.
I went to ssay Hi to Jim Pattison as we know each other sorta from being members of the Vancouver Board of Trade, it's not like we are drinking buddies but hw knows me and we usually have a chat when he is passing through. Well the hype over George Bush obviously stooped my talkng to Jim but I think the number ofsecurity in the area were simply stunned as they had never seen such a poor turnout for what is supposed to be a secret transportation transfer.
They were trying to look all busy and serious, meanwhile nobody bats an eye, nor cares.
My point for this is just that it goes to show just how little we give a damn about politicians in Canada, I wouldn't think twice if Cretien handed me change in 7-11.
SUPERSTARS and CELEBRITIES exist in the USA were they were made. A celebrity in Canada is a major league hockey player, and they are just dudes you see in the grocey store or play pool with at the pub while laughing about something unrelated to hockey.
by oz_media
by oz_media
Yes I know that such news while quietly readingto the children would have been a bit of a headwrecker to deal with.
My opnion is that I would have also quietly excused myself while explaining I had to go and run he country for a bit.
Now the first defense of this I saw when people were posting about the movie was that Bush made the right choice and shouldn't have jumped up and alerted the children of the terror.
NO Sh*T Mr.Holmes!
So what would be wrong, as I suggested before with simply excusing yourself? The WORLD knows who Bush is, these children understand he is a very impotent and busy man. I sm sure they wouldn't have been too alarmed if GWB were to be excused from reding a story.
Methinks, he was probably thinking "Oh, SH*T! What do I do now?"
by thechas
Come on, we all know the real reason that President Bush stayed at the school, he had to finish the story to find out how it ended.
Seriously, despite how much I distrust GWB, I do believe that it was at least prudent to wait a little before reacting to the events of 9/11.
We had no concept of the scope of the attacks. What had / was happening was unthinkable prior to 9/11.
Waiting until there was a more detailed understanding of what was happening does make sense.
The only negative I can point out is that while the President remained at the school, the school was a potential target.
I am surprised that the Secret Service did not immediately move the President from his published itinerary.
Chas
by thechas
Of course there are many potentially worse scenarios than what happened on 9/11.
Keep in mind that despite succeeding beyond AlQueda's wildest dreams by collapsing the twin towers, the 9/11 attack can be classified as a major failure for terrorism in general.
1. It galvanized the American people in a way that nothing has since WWII.
2. The leaders of the world suddenly realized just how vulnerable every country was.
3. Likewise, world leaders realized the need to work together to intercept and stop terrorists.
So yes, we can expect that Al Queda or some other group is working on a plot that they hope will demoralize the American people.
Chas
by garion11
You are blaming America for 9/11? You pig! Thats like blaming a woman for getting raped.
No the terrorists hate America because they hate out values. The radical wing of Islam preaches death and hatred. Our support for Israel and our success is why they hate us. Tell me something that we did to "deserve" 9/11.
by hal 9000
By first being responsible for the creation of the State of Israel and supporting it.
What you seem to forget is that there where many Islamic people who fought against Hitler in WW11 and had promises made to them almost all of which where broken. Now you can not honestly expect there not to be some resentment there and it grows over time into what it is today.
Now do you have some small comprehension of the problem you are facing?
Col
by garion11
John Kerry is getting his comeuppance for his snotty comments about President Bush's actions on 9/11.
Here's what the Massachusetts Democrat said July 8 when Larry King asked where he was on 9/11, according to CNN's own transcript:
'Nobody Could Think'
"I was in the Capitol. We'd just had a meeting - we'd just come into a leadership meeting in Tom Daschle's office, looking out at the Capitol. And as I came in, Barbara Boxer and Harry Reid were standing there, and we watched the second plane come in to the building. And we shortly thereafter sat down at the table and then we just realized nobody could think, and then boom, right behind us, we saw the cloud of explosion at the Pentagon. And then word came from the White House, they were evacuating, and we were to evacuate, and so we immediately began the evacuation."
How appropriate that Kerry lumps himself in with fellow leftist do-nothing non-thinkers such as Boxer, Daschle and Reid.
Thanks to the several readers today who sent us this fascinating bit from Blog for Bush: "the second plane hit the World Trade Center at 9:03 a.m., and the plane hit the Pentagon at 9:43 a.m. By Kerry's own words, he and his fellow senators sat there for forty minutes, realizing 'nobody could think.'"
And here's what former New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani told the New York Post about Kerry's latest display of insolence:
"John Kerry must be frustrated in his campaign if he is armchair-quarterbacking based on cues from Michael Moore.
"John Kerry is an indecisive candidate [with] an inconsistent position on the War on Terror, who voted against funding for our troops and who cannot give a clear answer on his position concerning the decision to remove Saddam Hussein."
by garion11
by hal 9000
Now if only everyone did the same thing you would never have been able to invade Afghanistan as there would be no serving military personal or Iraq but what has been shown is just how undermanned the US military forces actually are and how unprepared for battle they are. Without the National Guard the whole thing would have collapsed under its own weight and what is worse the National Guard now considers it unlikely that they will retain existing members let alone attract new members now.
Now if the British had not of apposed Hitler when his troops invaded Poland just who would have stopped him?
Perhaps you have been watching far to much self serving US TV things like Alias where the people magical appear halfway around the world in an allied country and them proceed to shoot the shit out of its citizens. While good for ratings it is hardly believable.
OH incidental when Germany was defeated it was found that the only thing that they needed to produce a Fission Weapon was some heavy water which the British had been responsible for destroying. If it was not the British who stepped in in all likely hood you would be speaking German now and we would lack the technology to communicate like this.
Col
by garion11
"Now if only everyone did the same thing you would never have been able to invade Afghanistan as there would be no serving military personal or Iraq but what has been shown is just how undermanned the US military forces actually are and how unprepared for battle they are. Without the National Guard the whole thing would have collapsed under its own weight and what is worse the National Guard now considers it unlikely that they will retain existing members let alone attract new members now."
"Now if the British had not of apposed Hitler when his troops invaded Poland just who would have stopped him?"
"OH incidental when Germany was defeated it was found that the only thing that they needed to produce a Fission Weapon was some heavy water which the British had been responsible for destroying. If it was not the British who stepped in in all likely hood you would be speaking German now and we would lack the technology to communicate like this."
You have said everything I wanted to say and have said about the American reason for going into Iraq and Afghanistan. Thank you so much for posting this. The word "IF" is like a gateway to hundreds of possibilites. If only Hitler wasn't given a compromise, If only Saddam was still in power, If only 9/11 never happened.
"OH incidental when Germany was defeated it was found that the only thing that they needed to produce a Fission Weapon was some heavy water which the British had been responsible for destroying"
Oh and incidentally when Saddam was defeated it was found that the only thing he needed to produce a Nuclear bomb was enriched Uranium which he was pursing before his removal from power, which the Americans had been responsibily for destroying.
Another thing I will point out to you is that America's military is not so much unprepared or undermanned. Its that they are finding out that this war isn't against terrorists or Saddam's loyalists. Its against Islam, radical Islam. They are finding out this war is going to last a lifetime and test American resolve and determination of its citizens to the extreme. They are finding out how far America has to go to succeed in changing a culture of death and hate that has been brewing for a 1000 years. This country and her citizens are faced with a question of whether we are willing to cross the line and fight a non PC war, where our very survival is at stake.
Its in your interest to support us, and its in your interest to oppose the terrorists. Don't be so blinded by your hatred/jealousy/contempt/envy or whatever negative feelings you have towards US, that you don't see the truth. The radical wing of Islam (and even Islam itself) is a very violent and non tolerant religion that is preaching and raising a culture of death and hatred. Whatever your media showed you about America (and its complaints about American censorship) tell me if they ever showed you this??
(incidentally our media never showed us this either, I picked this up from the Internet).
Watch the muslim woman's magazine and tell me if its normal for a 3 year old girl to be taught that Jews are apes and pigs.
If only people believed the stories coming out of Germany. If only we went in there sooner. If only Neville Chamberlain and France's government didn't compromise with Hitler. If only...
by garion11
by hal 9000
Prior to WW11 there was the "League of Nations" and after WW11 the UN was established but not until the military action was long gone. Just have a look at the War Crime Trials at Nuremberg and see who ran those {sorry no UN staff in sight because they as yet did not exist.} The main people acting there where Allied Military Personal and the team was lead by a US General and made up predominately of US staff.
If you ate trying to make out that the US had no part in the creation of the State of Israel you are sadly mistaken after all being on the winning side and a major contributer to it they had every right to be involved in the rebuilding post WW11 and all hell would have broken loose if they had of been excluded. Seems to me you really do not understand the facts behind being on the winning side. You among others here have expressed the sediment that it was the US who won WW11 so you can not really stand/sit there and then go on to say that the US had nothing to do with dividing up the spoils of war . That is either incredibly childish or stupid nothing else.
Col
by garion11
http://www.adl.org/Israel/Record/creation.asp
Following the defeat of the Ottoman Empire in World War I, the British assumed control of Palestine. In November 1917, the British government issued the Balfour Declaration, announcing its intention to facilitate the "establishment in Palestine of a national home for the Jewish people." In 1922, the League of Nations granted Britain a mandate over Palestine which included, among other things, provisions calling for the establishment of a Jewish homeland, facilitating Jewish immigration and encouraging Jewish settlement on the land.
The Arabs were opposed to Jewish immigration to Palestine and stepped up their attacks against the Jews. Following an increase in Arab attacks, the British appointed a royal commission in 1936 to investigate the Palestine situation. The Peel Commission recommended the partition of the country between Arabs and Jews. The Arabs rejected the idea while the Jews accepted the principle of partition.
At the end of World War II, the British persisted in their immigration restrictions and Jewish survivors of the Holocaust were violently turned away from the shores of Palestine. The Jewish Agency and the Haganah continued to smuggle Jews into Palestine. Underground cells of Jews, most notably the Irgun and Lehi, engaged in open warfare against the British and their installations.
The British concluded that they could no longer manage Palestine and handed the issue over to the United Nations. On November 29, 1947, after much debate and discussion, the UN recommended the partition of Palestine into two states ? one Jewish and one Arab. The Jews accepted the UN resolution while the Arabs rejected it.
Meanwhile, since the time of the British Mandate, the Jewish community in Palestine had been forming political, social and economic institutions that governed daily life in Palestine and served as a pre-state infrastructure. Zionist leader David Ben-Gurion (1886-1973) served as head of the pre-state government.
The British mandate over Palestine officially terminated at midnight, May 14, 1948. Earlier in the day, at 4:00 p.m., David Ben-Gurion proclaimed the creation of the State of Israel and became its first prime minister. Longtime advocate of Zionism in Britain Chaim Weizmann (1874-1952) became Israel's first president. On May 15, the United States recognized the State of Israel and the Soviet Union soon followed suit.
The fledgling State of Israel was faced with many challenges. While fighting a war of survival with the Arab states who immediately invaded the new nation, Israel had to also absorb the shiploads of immigrants coming in daily to the Jewish homeland. Many were penniless refugees from Europe broken in body and in spirit. They needed immediate health and social services in addition to acculturation to their new home.
http://www.trumanlibrary.org/whistlestop/study_collections/israel/large/israelchrono.htm
by hal 9000
But it goes to show that is is sometimes necessary to step in when others wish to hell that you didn't. Just like the British all those years ago it is now another "World Power" who finds it necessary to step in and fight the good fight. But what you fail to understand is that while what is currently going on is more a War against Intolerance it could very easily be seen as a War on Islam which is something that is unwindable this is exactly what the Radical side of Islam is preaching and until this can be stopped it will continue to produce more Ossamas and their ilk.
Incidental just for your reference enriched Uranium is actually U235 and while there has been no proven fact that Iraq was attempting to buy any of this substance they would still require a trigger Element to make it go Fission which they also lacked.
Its in your interest to support us, and its in your interest to oppose the terrorists. Don't be so blinded by your hatred/jealousy/contempt/envy or whatever negative feelings you have towards US, that you don't see the truth.
Actually I'm an Australian and last time I looked {2 nanoseconds} ago we where supporting your country as we are one of the first to put our hand up and be counted in the COW. Personally I'm not blinded by any form of dislike of the USA or anything else but I can see some massive problems arising by unnecessary intrusions into Islamic countries where there is no set outcome for the armed forces. It is something that we learnt many years ago the military is not a police force and they need clear objectives to meet their aims. They can not function with both arms tied behind their backs which is the current situation. What is needed is not military intervention but a solution the the hatred that has been allowed to grow unmolested over the past 60 odd years.
Actually your last sentence is curious as you originally stated that Britain should not of involved itself in a fight with Hitler and then you go on to say:-
If only people believed the stories coming out of Germany. If only we went in there sooner. If only Neville Chamberlain and France's government didn't compromise with Hitler.
I'm sorry but you simply can not have your cake and eat it as well.
Col
by oz_media
"enriched Uranium which he was pursing before his removal from power, which the Americans had been responsibily for destroying"
I have seen both sides of that story and neither is cinclusive.
All I have seen is that Non-weapons grade plutonium was recovered, not that the USA had "destroyed" eriched uranium that he apparently possesed at the same time you say he was seeking it?
If he was 'seeking' it, how can you then destroy it?
NOW if you are referring to the traces of highly enriched Uranium that were found in IRAN, that was a different issue altogether.
As for Saddam, the only conclusions I've seen as that he did not have the facilities or ability at this time to create HIGHLY enriched uranium, although he would like to have.
by oz_media
Are planes allowed to fly over nuclear reacotor sites?
One would think not as any form of accidental crash could cause devastation not known in modern times, but ai really don't know. It would only make sense except the NUMBER of nuclear reactors in use now as well as the number of flights.
I "think" that the hijackers would not have been trained well enough to fly that far off course and actually hit a nuclear planet with enough accuracy but I could be wrong and wouldn't suggest underestimating the terrorists.
Just made me think, does anyone know for sure?
by tomsal
Col, good point -- you are right on the electrical grid thing. However there is a certain amount of "no fly zone" around all nuclear power plants automatically.
And I believe the nuclear power plants -- their "no fly zones" are monitored by the FAA all the time. I could be wrong, I know the first part of what I said is correct so I'm assuming that if they have no fly zones that they must be monitored. (God I hope they are!)
In light of what that could mean if a plane smashed into one of those nuclear power plants, and assuming they are monitored by FAA officials, I would guess if the terrorists selected that target on 9/11 F-18's would of been on their arse MUCH MUCH faster -- as they say "like white on rice".
I'm guessing much less hesitancy would of went into the decision to blow the commercial jets out of sky as well.
by hal 9000
Are about 50 nautical miles in radius but commercial airliners travel at 650 KPH cruising it the person behind the joystick/yoke wasn't concerned they could up the thrust and speed which would give a very short reaction time.
Personally I doubt that with the current range of the "No Fly Zones" there would be enough time to intercept any aircraft as they would at best have to divert Air force/National Guard jets to the site and then try to find out what was going on before attempting to shoot down an aircraft and even with the latest air to air missiles they are heatseaking so they would go straight up the tail pipe of a gas turbine engine which would not necessarily cause the plane to fall out of the sky immediately.
Remember when the Russians shot down the Korean 747 it stayed airborne for 10 minutes before hitting the water. Currently we just lack the ability to stop these things. France did place Surface to Air missiles around their Nuke power plants at the height of the fear but even then they would need to be fired long before the plane become a threat to the installation. Even at cruising speed they cover a lot of distance in a few minutes.
Col
by maecuff
by hal 9000
You have to remember that women in Islamic countries are thought of as "Pigs Constantly in Season" and "Honor Killings" are all to common.
So what you perceive as terrible is normal to those people and while I do not support this kind of crap for a single minute it is a "Fact of Life" in that area of the world.
Women are routinely circumcised as well and public executions are common place not to mention the punishment for some crimes in those countries all of which are held in Public for all to see.
You have to consider these things in the light of the culture of the area I'm sure if you where to look hard enough you could find quite a few Public Beheading's in those countries and while we see them as horrendous crimes against humanity they are normal run of the mill daily events in those countries.
So while the executions of captives in Iraq at the moment are placed on the net they are the normal thing that would happen to any other person in that country, the fact that they are individuals from our countries makes it that much more real to us as we just do not understand the culture or are unwilling to admit that these are normal things in that area of the world.
As far as the racism goes while not acceptable to me or most people it does happen in most countries of the world and while maybe it isn't so well published it is still there and tolerated like for example the KKK in the USA. Their principals are not that much different from those expressed in the item that you posted the only difference is it is aimed at us and not someone else.
Col
by tomsal
Well that's something that is a scary thought for sure.
One would only hope that now, in our post 9/11 world that those chosen to monitor/guard such things from happening are bright enough to question, "Why is Flight 9383929383.2 300 miles from Nuclear Plant 9282 at a cruising speed of xyz, flying straight for the power plant?"
The logic being even though the plane is 300 miles off I would suggest our officials be a little suspicous of all flight trajectory's/co-ordinates that line up with power plants (or other highly critical targets) even from a long range out. They should be watched like a hawk.
Very true, and very scary to think of what you said though...because it would take time for a plane to drop even if clipped its wings.
Plus it would be a weapon itself --- a firey heap --- not a good combo to land even near a nuclear reactor. Especially with secondary explosions going off from the jet fuel.
by protiusx
It never ceases to amaze me how people will second guess others reactions and play Monday night couch coach. We are talking about 5 to 7 minutes during which time he was in front of children in a grade school. Who knows what was going on in his mind? Perhaps we can get a hold of some of the psychic friends network folks to let us know.
You have no idea what you would have done in that situation because you weren't there. Hindsight is always 20/20 and that is it's failing. We can all say that we would have done something different to improve on a situation but the end result is would your response changed one thing about the 9/11 disaster? No. Yours and John Kerry's zealous saving of five minutes wouldn't have saved one life or made one bit of difference. Five to seven minutes, honestly I ask you. Why don't you offer some real issues one can debate other than this tosh.
by oz_media
That these men are supposed to be able to react quick enough and think on thier feet in these horrible situations, moreso than 'normal' people that don't have super powers.
For the leader of the free world to take 5-7 minutes to even BEGIN reacting to a direct attack upon his country is well, sad and pathetic at best, purely incapable at worst.
Good thing we don't allow our medical and emergency response teams the 5-7 minute luxury, the population would thin pretty quickly as all the people died from lack of response.
5-7 minutes, I can have a smoke and half cup of coffee. Paddle my kayak all the way from my place to the Queen Charlott island in 5-7 minutes (if no ferries are crossing), I can say peter piper picked a peck of pickled peppers ????times in 5-7 minutes.
GWB can't excuse himself from reading a book and speak with his intelligence officers though.
I wonder if it takes him longer than 5-7 minutes to realize he need to go to the bathroom, before pissing his pants?
by protiusx
by oz_media
You said "Five to seven minutes, honestly I ask you. Why don't you offer some real issues one can debate other than this tosh. "
My reply explained that 5-7 minutes is not a short period of time at all when it comes to emergency reactions. In fact, it's damn slow!
5-7 minutes for ANYONE to respond in an Emergency situation is completely ludicrous, if you cannot react appropriately in that amount of time, which is a LONG time, for example 5-7 minutes on HOLD is an eternity.
Anything more than a reaction time of about 2 minutes is purely incapable.
So I answered your question exactly, I just didn't answer the question you WANTED people to answer that shows that anyone would have done the same. Any reply to such a question is a pure guess, how does ANYONE kow how someone else would have reacted? It is a ridiculous question for a start and one that seeks to remove blame from the person involved by specualting alternative, unqualified opinions based on a 'guess'.
Those on Kerry's side will say he would have done better, those on Bush's side will say he did worse.
What can such a question possibly hope to answer? It is 100% dependant on who responds to your post, in this case it simply wasn't someone who feels the same as you and I did not answer the question you wanted me to.
I did reply that 5-7 minutes is NOT a short period of time, as you suggsted.
Show me ANY other emergency situation where 5-7 minutes is an acceptable response time from anyone involved.
by protiusx
The question I am posing to you is: What could John Kerry's response or ALGORE's response have done that would have resulted in a difference?
Your analogy is illogical. You aquate the President of the United States to a fire fighter or a first responder. In this instance he was in Florida and no matter what his reaction time he could have done nothing to prevent the events that occurred. Neither could speedy Mr. Kerry.
by gateboy1
by oz_media
Your analogy is great! Your points are fantastic, you actually offered an opinion.
Then you removed ALL credibility from your post, you removed all common sense from your argumet and you removed any hope of sounding aware buy ending your post with a shot at Paul Martin. Now I will never defend a politician, including Paul Martin, but for some reason you thought it was necessary to include that he'd be having fish and chips with some French guy.
Firstly, what would give you this impression, details please.
Secondly, why is the term French dumb ass used?
Are all French people now dunbasses? Explain, in detail.
You have the ability to gain back some of your credibility here, I rally don't think you will though and will simply offer a new rant to mirror your last.
by oz_media
I will just have to rest assured that both our governments would know of these issues and have disaster plans in place.
The other thing I think that's important is that the plans used in 9/11 had ceased tower contact, this should instantly raise a massive RED flag and any pilot who hasn't 'checked' in would need to be shot down or at least planes must be scambled while further communication attempts are made.
But we have deemed these massive WMD to be neccessary all over our countries. We build nuclear reactors everywhere (except in Vancouver which is a nuclear free zone).
If we improved our energy sources, found new ways of generating power and did away with nuclear reactors all together, we'd be one step ahead anyway. Califonia powers several cities on wind alone, other are powered by BC's hydro electric dams. Now if we could increase use of existing power alternatives and spend globally on fiding new power resources, we MAY end up ahead of the game.
by jamesrl
When the planes hit the office towers, the pre-existing emergency readiness plans went into effect.
Nothing the president could do would change that response - nothing whatsoever.
The only thing the President could decide is - whats next? And to be honest - his aide probably said - "here is what happened, we will be finding out more information, and as to your travel plans, we will cancel the rest of the day and arrange to go back to Washington - should have more news for you in a few minutes".
Frankly if he had made a hasty decision to act without more information, I'd be pretty scared.
James
by gateboy1
by oz_media
I don't think I was looking for a hasty decision, just look at what happened in Iraq when Bush made a VERY hasty decision.
The issue is that he never batted an eye. At that point, any leader SHOULD immediately be excused and start to look for more information so he/she is abl to address the issues. He should have at least got up and left pendig updates on the situation.
His response showed a man of fear, just look at his facial and body language, "OH, SH*T what the hell do I do now" would have described it appropriately.
by oz_media
I haven't equated Bush to a fireman or medic at all. You minimized the 5-7 minute lapse by implying that 5-7 minutes is not a bad reaction time and that anyone else may/would have done the same.
Well, I do not support Kerry OR Gore ad nobody can offer even an educated opinion on what thier reactions would have been. That's not the issue though, the issue is WHY did GWb spend 5-7 minutes talkig to the children when it would have been far mroe appropriate for him to immediately excuse himself to begin his briefing on the issues.
When I say it is a poor response time in an emergency, it IS. Plain and simple, waitig 5-7 minutes is NOT responding to an mergency, I don't cae if you are a firefighter or someone who watches someone else get hurt at work. You CANNOT wait 5-7 minutes before responding to an emergency of any kind.
Is there anything h could have done by responding faster that would have stoped the acts? of course not, they had already done it by then. A lack of instant response shows that he was not alarmed by the issues as he should be. The president getting back to his job is imperative first and foremost and no amount of waiting no matter how long or short is acceptable.
by gateboy1
Well, Oz? I grew up with Canadians most my life. I actually have respect for most of them, with the exception of the French Canadians who somehow seem to hate everything American and English. The Fish and Chips comment was just a jab at the somewhat British like lifestyle that Canadians have. A... I mean Canadians are not like the British but everyone thinks they are, and the French Canadians really don?t want to be Canadian but would prefer to be fully French. I put the Prime Minister in the mix to more or less provoke you because I like reading your witty banter.
I think that Bush did a fine job under the circumstances. If the attacks were to happen on Canadian soil I would prefer to see your Prime Minister stay calm and relaxed than run out the door screaming, We?ve Just Been Attacked! To me is shows strength and leadership to remain calm and steady in a time of crisis.
by oz_media
A few minor differences though.
Canadians thinking they are British, I will adamatly object. MOST Canadians I have met bite theri toungue before spewing their anti_british sentiments, not that I would care anyway but it's just a courtesy between friends.
In fact many Canadians I know don't like the British but that's just the snotty one's they see on TV I suppose. Some oppose the Queen ad others oppose the whole commonwealth nation idea, but that's old at now, for the most part, Canadians don't caer if they are left alone to do their thing. Canadians focus on LIFE, theirs, their family and friends etc. not political BS.
Yes the Frech Canadian thing is amusig, expcially becaus ei am out west ad only run into french Canadian techs when they are in town. The ONE occasion I worked an IT job with a French Canadian, I beat him up after an argument at the bar during lunch.
As for Bush jumping up and runnig out in a tizzy, I agree that would not hae been correct.
As the leader of the free world and an icon to the kids he was addressing, he would have had NO problem if he quietly stood up ad explained that he had some very important 'presidential' business to tend to ad the teacher would finish the story.
Do you think the kids would REALLY be alarmed if the most powerful person they could possibly conceive was needed somewhere else?
Perhas they'd be SLIGHTLY disappointed if they didn't get the story finished, prhas they would be disappoitd ATER the story ws read and Bush THEN had to go anyway?
The point here is not the kids or that he was reading a story, it's that it took him 5-7 minures to responde to HIS country being attacked by terrorists. Now some say what could he have done in that time? Well nobody had ANY idea that these were the only attacks, it MAY nt have been too late to stop further terror. He shouldhave been MUCH quicker and more rofessional whan it came to securing the safety of his country. You voted for him because you thought he'd protect you, what if ten other plaes were inbound? What if he COULD have made a difference? He simply didn't know and didn't find out.
We can all say it was too late now, because it was in spetember, but on that day itself I remeber seeing all the ews and NOBODY had any idea that the damage would only be three planes, in fact most reports were America is being bombed! Better finish your story first Bush.
So what if it wasn't only three planes, what if others were inbound for the USA. Did he STILL act accordigly? If so, why even care who you elect? He has all the time in the world to make important decisions and is not expected to think on his feet. As for Iraq, well it was okay for him to act immdediately without proper confirmation of the allegations if he had waited more Americans would have died, or so I am told.
So republicans seem to feel this and never could nr ever has doe any wrong.
He can wait in times of emergency so that he can plan his moves properly and confirm a threat to America (perhaps if he hadn't sat around he would have seen it on TV).
He can act rashly in times of non-emrgency because he doesn't need to prove allegations, and doesn't need to confim a threat before acting on behalf of America.
Bush never lied to America, he was deceived and then passed that deception onto American citizens.
Why should Bush listen to anyone else when it comes to protecting America and not be able to act indendantly and attack to protect the country.
These are all just double edged swords, and yet republicans STILL refuse to see or accept it.
Kerry is not a war hero he has thre purple hearts.
Bush never fought in war and set his entire enlisted time trying to get out of the military.
Clinton lied about having ralationshis with Lewinsky, he was impeached.
Bush lied when he took an oath while knowing he was arrested for drunk driving and being associated with B&E's as a youth, as well as having cocaine issues, he was elected and continus to be supported.
What a mess!
by oz_media
Well I must apologize perfusely or that mess of a post.
I have terrible typing skills (fingers everywhere) and leave a lot of orphaned words. In this case though, I must say that it was the worst post I ever made, based on the number of typos and dropped letters.
I won't waste your time by retyping it all, you should be abble to get my general idea though.
Sorry again,
OM
by garion11
Were those infamous 16 words correct after all?
It has been a year and a half since President Bush's 2003 State of the Union address, in which he suggested in a single sentence that Iraq might have been trying to acquire uranium in Africa for its nuclear weapons program. And it has been a year since the White House and the C.I.A. acknowledged that the evidence behind that assertion was flawed, opening Mr. Bush to a torrent of criticism about the credibility and reliability of the intelligence he used to justify toppling Saddam Hussein.
But now two new reports have reopened the question of whether Mr. Bush was indeed correct when, on Jan. 28, 2003, he told the nation and the world, "The British government has learned that Saddam Hussein recently sought significant quantities of uranium from Africa."
One of the reports was released on Wednesday by a British commission reviewing the intelligence used by Prime Minister Tony Blair in making the case for war. The report stood by the British intelligence assessments that were the foundation for Mr. Bush's statement. Though it did not explain in any detail how or why it judged the intelligence to be sound, the report concluded that the assertions by Mr. Bush and Mr. Blair about Iraq's attempts to acquire uranium were "well founded."
The other report came from the Senate Intelligence Committee. It generally found extensive problems with the prewar intelligence assessments about Iraq's weapons programs and in particular documented a long chain of problems in the way the intelligence agencies dealt with suspicions about Iraq's interest in acquiring uranium.
But it also contained some information that tended to bolster the view that Iraq had tried to acquire uranium from Niger and possibly one or two other African nations. It cited a statement by a French official to the State Department in late 2002 that France, which was resisting Mr. Bush's efforts to make an urgent case for war, "believed the reporting was true that Iraq had made a procurement attempt for uranium from Niger." Neither report, however, found evidence that Iraq had actually purchased any uranium from Niger
Sorry its excerpted, but the link is annoying that you gotta register to view the entire article. But here it is...
http://www.nytimes.com/2004/07/18/international/middleeast/18URAN.html
http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,126124,00.html
WASHINGTON ? It was one of the first signs that the intelligence used to go to war in Iraq was wrong: White House repudiation of 16 words in last year's State of the Union speech that had suggested Saddam Hussein (search) tried to buy uranium (search) in Africa.
Yet even as two recent reports sharply criticized prewar intelligence, they also suggested President Bush's claim may not have been totally off-base.
A British report concluded that Bush's statement and a similar one by Prime Minister Tony Blair (search) were "well-founded." In his speech, Bush had attributed the uranium claim to the British government.
A Senate Intelligence Committee report found inadequate evidence that deposed Iraqi President Saddam had been rebuilding his nuclear weapons program. It cited various reports, however, that Iraq had sought uranium in Africa. Thus, although Bush cited only British evidence that was determined to have been inconclusive, other intelligence files clearly contained other inconclusive evidence of the truth of the claim.
The committee chairman, Sen. Pat Roberts (search), said he believed last year that the White House was correct in repudiating the uranium claim. "Now I don't know whether it's accurate or not. That's the whole question," Roberts, R-Kan., said in an interview.
The White House's repudiation came after The New York Times published an op-ed column by former Ambassador Joseph Wilson (search), who was sent by the CIA to Niger (search) to determine if Iraq had been acquiring uranium. Wilson said it was unlikely any uranium transaction had taken place and the administration appeared to have been manipulating the intelligence.
Republicans said Wilson was trying to boost John Kerry's presidential campaign and looked to discredit him and his mission.
Columnist Robert Novak, citing two unidentified Bush administration officials, wrote that Wilson's wife, CIA officer Valerie Plame, had recommended Wilson for the trip. That has led to a criminal investigation into the leak of Plame's identity.
The Senate report challenges Wilson's denial that his wife had a role in the selection and questions his account of the intelligence available at the time of his trip. It also said that his trip, rather than discrediting the Iraq-Niger link, actually bolstered the views of some analysts who suspected Saddam was seeking uranium.
In an addendum to the report, Roberts and two other Republicans accused Wilson of providing "inaccurate, unsubstantiated and misleading" information. In a letter to committee leaders Thursday, Wilson said a thorough reading of the report supports his public comments.
He said in a televised interview that he wants committee members to reinterview a CIA officer whose testimony, Wilson said, had muddled the record about his mission.
Earlier Sunday, the CIA's acting director, John E. McLaughlin, told "Fox News Sunday," "I think there's some debate about what his report said or didn't say. I just don't want to take a position on it."
Bush, in his State of the Union address on Jan. 28, 2003, used the uranium intelligence to help make the case that Saddam was pursuing nuclear weapons. "The British government has learned that Saddam Hussein recently sought significant quantities of uranium from Africa," he said.
That claim came under scrutiny after the International Atomic Energy Agency determined that documents purportedly showing Iraq buying uranium from Niger were fake. After Wilson's op-ed appeared, the White House said including the 16 words in the State of the Union was a mistake because the assertion was not well enough corroborated to merit mention in a State of the Union speech. The British have maintain consistently that their intelligence was not based on the forged documents.
But the Senate committee disclosed other intelligence suggesting that Iraq was pursuing uranium.
The committee cited separate reports received from foreign intelligence services on Oct. 15, 2001, and Feb. 5, 2002, and March 25, 2002. The State Department doubted the accuracy of the reports, but the CIA and Defense Intelligence Agency had more confidence in them.
Though Wilson reported to U.S. officials there was "nothing to the story" that Niger sold uranium to Iraq, the CIA and DIA were intrigued by one element of his trip. Wilson had said a former prime minister of Niger, Ibrahim Mayaki, mentioned a visit from an Iraqi delegation in 1999 that expressed interest in expanding commercial ties with Niger, the world's third largest producer of mined uranium. Mayaki believed this meant they were interested in buying uranium.
The British inquiry said it was generally accepted that Iraqi officials visited Niger in 1999, and there was intelligence from several sources that the visit was to acquire uranium. "Since uranium constitutes almost three-quarters of Niger's exports, the intelligence was credible," the report said.
The Senate committee also described various reports about Iraqi attempts to buy uranium from French, British and unidentified foreign governments.
But how much credibility these reports had was not clear. The Senate committee criticized the CIA for "inconsistent and at times contradictory" reports to policy-makers on the uranium issue.
An internal CIA memo from June 17, 2003, said, "We no longer believe there is sufficient other reporting to conclude that Iraq pursued uranium from abroad."
But beyond internal correspondence, "to date, the intelligence community has not published an assessment to clarify or correct its position on whether or not Iraq was trying to purchase uranium from Africa," the Senate committee said.
by garion11
by tommydaschle
to see someone so poorly informed. If you were to look at that film without your political glasses on, you'd feel quite foolish.
But only if you are honest with yourself.
by aldanatech
by mcdowell
by hal 9000
Your not steeping on anyones toes and I think you have a right to even if some feel adversely affected.
But there is one thing that you do have to understand and that is any military action can only proceed with the bulk of the public support. Like in Vietnam without the massive public support the troops are nothing more than cannon fodder and treated worse still when they return. While I don't think it right it is just simply a fact of life and we all need to understand these things. What some people do not understand however is that there are many people and the number is growing who originally supported intervention in this conflict but are now beginning to feel betrayed because they where lead to believe that Iraq was a direct threat to themselves and they are now seeing this as a lie fostered upon them by a politician whose appears not tho have their best interests first and foremost in mind.
If we where to blindly follow our leaders we would be no better than places like North Korea, Iraq, Iran and many others. It is the ability to voice dissension that makes us what we are and not lemmings who blindly follow our political masters. I suppose that is the real definition of FREEDOM!
Col
by oz_media
by cloudedyoda
HAL 9000
Freedom sounds good. But many lives have been lost.. Too many. Was it worth it is an answer that Americans know. I am merely one of those spectators in this world and I always find myself torn between both sides. But war is a lose-lose situation, or possibly win-lose for Americans.
No matter how sympathetic you feel towards innocent ppl who died in the war or how little control you have over the war, it is too late! I personally feel that this discussion is over and we have to move on.
by hal 9000
Right?
I'm sure glad that I don't see you read newspapers as you must get really upset when you see contradicting articles written.
You seem to have some mad affinity just like Maxwell to post multiple URLs to prove your point but then forget to understand what you where trying to say originally.
Now from my feeble memory I thought that the US was involved in WW1 again from my feeble memory they brought into that war when a US flagged passenger ship was sunk by a German U Boat.
Now I'll say it again The British along with their Allies screwed Germany into the ground that gave Hitler the opportunity to rise to power with their reprehensible war taxes on Germany. It got so bad that most of the German GDP was being used to bay off the War Damages bill from the First World War. Again it was the British and Allied forces who where responsible for carving up what they thought was good for their own ends. As an Australian we fought as "British Subjects" and where never consulted in these matters and nore where any of the other Colonies of the British Empire. The US not being a Colony of the British Empire was heavily involved in carving up large tracks of land to suit their own ends. The only thing that they did wrong was not to divide Germany as it was then and is now a major power that has to be reckoned with. After WW11 they didn't make the same mistake again.
Col
by protiusx
If I understand you correctly the world community should have let Saddam Houssein keep Kuwait when he invaded in 1990? We should turn a blind eye to the FACT that he had a working nuclear reactor? We should not care that he was selling arms and munitions to known terrorist groups? We should turn a blind eye to the FACT that he was providing money to Palestinian terrorists? We should not care that he was torturing and murdering innocent women and children?
I don't think I care for that "live and let live" mentality.
by hal 9000
Firstly Saddam Hussein did invade and this could not be tolerated by the rest of the world so there was a multinational force dispatched to right that wrong.
But the rest is entirely internal policies and if we where to attempt to over throw everyone that behaved like Saddam we would be in a constant state of war as there are many similar countries who are tolerated for various reasons mostly because it is political expedient at the time and also because their resources are required. While not right it is just a fact of life and I could list many countries that are allowed to continue without any action because they are not worth the effort to stop. Mainly because they do not have any finical benefit to warrant going in there and fixing the situation. Rwanda is a perfect example of a recent type of thing we only acted after the event and currently there is something similar happening in Africa right now in Sudan which of course doesn't get much coverage.
While untenable to me it is a fact that we are not capable of stooping these things from happening and we should not be in a position of enforcing our beliefs onto other sovereign countries. Currently all of the COW lack the manpower to fight battles on all these fronts and even if there was limited resistance we would end up loosing as we just lack the ability to work that way. Then there are places like North Korea where it would be a long bloody battle with no certain outcome so it is easier for our political masters to ovoid these places as they want to be reelected at the next election unless there is a direct threat to ourselves we remain unconcerned. {That is a general term and in no way implies that some people are not concerned just that these causes lack the necessary civilian demand to stop them happening. When China invaded Tibet there was no outcry around the world but if Tibet had massive oil reserves of other necessary mineral deposits it would have been a very different story.}
Col
by jamesrl
Actually Hal, Canada did have a choice.
In WWI Canada did not have a choice, and our armies fought under British control. It kinda chafed, as we felt at times we were cannon fodder. In the end though, as Canadians gained more and more control, we also gained a reputation as shock troops - the elite troops used to break the enemy lines.
After the war, Canada sought to gain control over the last vestiges of colonial influence. In 1931, the Statutes of Westminster gave Canada complete control over all aspects of its foreign policy. In September 1939, Canada declared war independantly. Our armies co-operated fully with Britains, but were independantly lead. There were times when Canadian generals lead British troops and vice versa. Canadian commanders also lead Polish troops in Italy and France.
James
by aldanatech
by maecuff
by garion11
The proof is right there in multiple articles and multiple searches. England had an extensive and intimate hand in bringing the State of Israel into fruitition. Not that its a bad thing, just letting you know America did support it but we weren't the fore runners if you will.
In fact one of the links I posted had a Video of a Muslim Sheik advocating violence against the British for doing this. So whether you believe this or not is up to you...
Now the focus of this post was, Why was America attacked on 9/11? I still have yet to hear a justifiable answer.
by garion11
I never stated we don't have these racist issues. But we talk about them, we bring out the elements of change into the openness and try our best to elimnate those ideas. It won't be done overnight, or next week. The stark difference between us and those videos are, thats on National Television. Thats on for 24 hours a day. Its an unhealthy disturbing obsession with the Jews and Israel. If you are equating our internal issues (and believe me every group of ethnicity in this country is racist in one form or another) with that kind of hatred in the middle east you are blind.
America has racism, Canada has racism, England has racism, India has racism, Israel, Japan, Australia has racism. Its human nature. The difference is there is an element of change in our societies that puts this issue out in the open and attempts to make it better for future generations. And it works both ways, black people are being taught not to blame the white man for their problems and vice versa. My question to you is (after watching those videos) where is that change in the middle east?? All I see is hatred and violence getting deeper and stronger every generation. Thats why I said try to focus and keep it in prespective. Its not healthy to teach 3 year old kids on national television that Jews are apes and pigs. Neither is it healthy to teach them behind closed doors either, but we are changing and in fact we have changed. Where is this in the middle east?
by hal 9000
In that post I was referring to WW1 not WW11 as that was an entirely different "Ball of Wax" I know exactly what you mean most of the Colonial troops where treated the same way and the "Good" British forces where kept in reserve to mop up the "Blood and Guts" from their fallen allies after the event.
Unfortunately here in AU we didn't break the ties quite so fast and while we had the capacity not to attend the British Political agenda our then Political Leaders lacked the Intestinal Fortitude or just went along for the ride. It actually got so bad that Aussie troops where not allowed to be returned to AU to defend AU from the invading Japanese. Seems that Churchill wanted to finish off Europe and then "Mop Up" the remaining enemy and it didn't matter that parts of the British Empire where over run as long as Britain remained free.
Col
by hal 9000
Well that's simple Garrion11 the Radical Islamic side of things uses the USA as a shining example of everything that is wrong in their world and uses some of your trashy TV as examples making their followers think that is how every American behaves.
Also the support for Israel doesn't help at all but it is mainly because their leaders are oppressive and they are attempting to fight their lives that are downtrodden and have no liberties. That along with the idea reinforced that they are doing Allah's work and will end up in Heaven with X number of Virgins also helps quite a lot.
It is when the radicals control religion that things go to hell in a hand basket and since the USA is the biggest power in the world right at the moment you are a perfect target as they can threaten other countries something like this "Well look at what we did in the USA just image what we could do to you!"
Col
by garion11
Thanks for the post. So there was NO justification for their brutal attack. We were completely justified for going into Afghanistan and Iraq. See I knew I always liked Australians, lol.
I heard you guys can have beer in movie theaters, is that true? If it is true, I am moving to Texas. Cause NJ and NY are pissing me off. You can't even smoke in the bars in NYC. How ludicrous is that?
by maecuff
by hal 9000
Firstly it's been a long time since I went to a movie theater and back then you couldn't drink beer in the picture threat re but in the lobby that was OK but of course I live in one of the main cities, in the bush/outback it may be different. I have not been to any of those places in over 12 years so I really out of touch.
The smoking bit is getting harder over here as well provided you sit outside in what they like to call a "Beer Garden" you're OK but I believe that it has been outlawed inside. I last attended a pub about 18 months ago and was allowed to smoke inside then but I think the law has since been changed, that's probably why I have not been asked to go again as I used to help out some friends in a band as I was a general gofer but they have not asked me for some time now so maybe the work has dried up quite a bit.
On Afghanistan defiantly as they openly supported terrorists but I think that the jury is still out on Iraq, There would also be a very good case to be made to invade Bali in light of what is happening in the Courts over there after the bombing but it would not be feasible nor reasonable as most of those concerned came from outside that area but it is a good example of just how these people think the very fact that so many Western Holiday Makers go there and the way they dress was supposed to be enough reason to bomb the place in an attempt to inflict as much pain as possible on the "Infidels!" I don't understand it either but that is what has been reported over here and then there was a major reason to discontinue the trials of those allegedly involved because we supplied investigators to help in the inquiries seems that it is against their constitution to allow this even though the Government requested and accepted as much help as we could supply along with the US experts.
But as far as why the US was attacked goes I think you where just too tempting target as this group is different to all the others in the fact that they are not defending land but an idea.
Iraq is a bit different in that regard as there is land involved. But the majority of the fighters there now are not native Iraq's but come in from outside the country to defend what they see as an attack upon the Islamic Faith. This is why I want to be extremely cautious as I do not want to see this degenerate into what is seen as an attack upon Islam, if that happens then we will be in a no win position and our troops will suffer needlessly.
Col
by hal 9000
It is something that you have to actually see and even then it is hard to believe. The people concerned are worse that children in a sandpit at preschool/kindergarten. Several years ago when I was in Israel I visited the "Wailing Wall" now this is a sacred place to both sides so they set aside days that each side can visit the wall to say prayers or whatever and stuff bits of paper into the wall as offerings. Well on the days when it is the Jews turn the Arabs stand the other side of the wall and throw rocks over the wall into the waiting crowd and the exact same thing happens when it is the others side turn.
They all carry on like spooled children, I saw it and couldn't believe my eyes so I had to return the following day after being told just what happened to see for myself even though I did see exactly what I had been told it is hard to believe that supposedly mature adults can behave in this petty manner. To me it was something that I would expect children to behave like but there where the religious leaders egging on the people to continue this appalling childish action.
Perhaps these young States shouldn't have any modern technology "Mass Media" as it appears to be used to justify these childish actions.
That was just one example that I saw while over there and what shocked me more than anything else is the fact that it is considered as "Normal Behavior" and none of the locals see anything wrong with their actions.
While things as childish as this are recommended by the so called religious leaders I really can not see any improvement and I do question the fitness of these supposedly learned people to teach their followers.
The real problem here is more like a family fight as both the Jews and Palestinians are supposedly descended from the same father and as claimed in the bible where originally started off as half brothers born to Abraham {I think my memory isn't as good as it used to be!} But what I did find interesting is that while the half brothers fought like cat and dog they both laid down their own personal hatred to attend their fathers funeral and I think that was the last time that there are any records of them being in the same place at the same time without fighting.
Col
by hargerd
I'm also getting a bit sick of this "US saved the world", "we won WW2" attitude from the US.
WE ALL WON!! (If we didn?t, don?t think for 1 second the Axis [Inc Japan] wouldn?t be after your ass!!)
Just wanted to pledge support to Oz!
by skipperusn
Not a problem in my book - the next time Europe is at war - the USA will be the Swiss sell to either side - and let the British and Europe win or Lose -
That way 60 years after you don't have Know-nothings like Oz - saying we did nothing and Britian won over Hilter before we even entered the war...
No Problem - I'll save 400,000 american lives - and let Europe live or die by their own hand..
by oz_media
Actually Garion, I have never said the US doesn't invent anything and they don't pay for goods under NAFTA. Yes our economies support ONE ANOTHER.
We don't tell Americans that they couldn't live without us (unless an American says we NEED America to survive, then it is well within my rights to show that we do not just TAKE as so many have suggested, even yourself), Americans buy our exports, well below fair market price but they get them anyway. They then expect more and more production, which is what pisses off the loggers and fishermen and starts the greenies going wild. Yuo cannot deny that America is a consumptive country, your needs are similar to that of the cling-on girlfriend from highschool who always wanted more (material posssions and personal time that is). (almost forgot) lol.
Ys America has contributed a lot to the world ad YES you SHOULD be proud of your country.
It's not pride that bothersmost people though, it's how the pride is thrown in everyone's face 24/7. "Without America...", "If it wasn't for America...", "Americans wil do as they please and not have to apologize to anyone..."
America is a force, not a country full of Americans and THAT"s what people hate.
England was a super power, pride in the heart not the sleeve.
Russia was a super power that wore their pride on their sleeves, much like Americans do.
As I've said before, nobody likes a poor loser, but a poor winner is far worse.
America hasn't saved the world, the world would exist without America. People would have freedoms, people would have rights, people would be happy in other countries even without America.
There would be trrorists, there would be invasions, there would be attacks, there would be victories, without America. You are simply a piece of the puzzle, an important one Ill give you that, but not an indespensable one. The world doesn't NEED America to continue to spin. Life and country's existed for nearly 2000 years before North America was stolen.
by oz_media
Dan Skipper, it was only a SHORT SHORT post and yet you have still proven that your lack of education and sense has blocked your ability to comprehend even the simplest of comments.
Lets see: through an entire paragraph of pot shots, I managed to extract a single partial sentence that shows what you are trying to object to for once.
"like Oz - saying we did nothing and Britian won over Hilter before we even entered the war... "
First, what's with the pronoun, you posted in reply to me? 'HE' should be 'YOU'.
Secondly, please show me where I have said that.
You can also go back and search ANY of my previous posts in ANY discussion. Until you can prove that point that you so adamantly feel I said, I will not respond to your further comments. One at a time please.
again for your reference "like Oz - saying we did nothing and Britian won over Hilter before we even entered the war... "
Prove it.
What I have said, if you look at the full sentence in context, is that ENGLAND beat Hitler in the Battle of Britain. I also went on to say how it was a stalemate and Hitler was unable to invade England. Hitler wanted to invade England, England stopped it from happening not the USA, (again "although logistical support was provided by the US", just to keep you all happy).
The London Blitz was a showdown between the Luftwaffe ad the RAF. Even today, pilots from both sides say te plans were so closely matched the stalemate was inevitable. Luftwaffe had bigger wing gus, RAF had MORE wing guns. Luftwaffe had faster planes, RAF had better visibility and maneuverability, etc. TWO forces RAF vs Luftwaffe. Hitler DID'T WIN the battle of Britain he didn't bomb London into submission durig the blitz. He pissed off Londoners and they revolted against him. Hitler had walked across europe ad then faced his toughest enemy, England, he tried to setup and obtain a position for invasion, it didn't happen, Enlgand won the battle. Get it yet?
THIS IS WHY ENGLISH PEOPLE DON'T SPEAK GERMAN NOT BECAUSE THE USA MADE IT SO.
Now please show me otherwise, only facts not just your usual OZ this and OZ that BS, just prove something for once in your life, put your money where your mouth is, step up to the plate, go to bat?!?
I seriously doubt is is within your abiity to do so though, and I'm sure you will prove it.
by oz_media
"...end up in Heaven with X number of Virgins."
Well sign me up! Find me a plane and let me go kill some people!
Hey, anything in the name of God and Pu*sy
by oz_media
As I just read and was somewhat apauled by this:
"..BC is no longer being represented by Sven Robinson, a queer..."
te same poster also referred to Krauts and Nips a post or two before.
But in between those racist and bigoted posts, he said:
"Why that would bother you I cannot fathom. As far as I am concerned it is really none of my business but then I'm not gay and whether they want and get legal recognition has nothing to do with me nor should it with you."
So while in one corner this person uses gays and germans and asians in a very negative way to make his point, in another he simply plays the PC game to gain credibility and acceptance from another.
So I don't really know if this mirrors racism, bigotry, homophobia, insecurity or just plain ignorance. But we can say one thing for sur, racism IS alive and well, unortunately.
by protiusx
by hal 9000
But the problem is just where do we draw the line? Maybe I'm more than a bit "Jaded" now days but to me it seems that any intervention that occurs always has some side benefits.
Like Oil in Iran "We had a report here a few days ago that we are supposed to be paying in excess of $3.00 AU per Liter for fuel within 3 years" That is a 300% increase in the current high prices that we are paying now.
Maybe we would all be seen in a better light if we only "Helped" those who wanted our help and left the remaining places alone. I noticed that Iran was only too willing to accept Western help when they had a recent earthquake but now are cracking down on any form of activity that isn't considered as strictly Fundamental Muslim.
While I do not pretend to have all the answers or many for that matter it does appear to me that there is always an alternative motive for any military activity. The one good thing that could be said for the Tallaban was they attempted to stamp out Poppie Growing in Afghanistan but we the Westerners made deals with the drug Lords to overthrow them. I don't quite understand that one but it has been said on many occasions "He Who Controls the Poppie Fields of Afghanistan Controls Afghanistan."
Col
by humberb
by hargerd
1.'intirm government' or not - guess where (at least part) the oil revenues went/are going
2.'iraq re-construction' - who had sole bidding on contracts?
by hal 9000
I also think my original post here was to the effect that while a good idea to start something like this it was too late as we already have a done deal.
But also it is something that the US in particular can not afford to lose so it will continue for a long time with no clear end in sight. This should never have happened as Vietnam showed just how bad things can go when there are no clear objectives in a conflict but what was worse is the fact that it was the troops who the public held responsible not the people who sent them there in the first place. To me this was an unforgivable thing to happen.
Col
by padgettrea
Could it possibly be a Boeing 737 (or 4)?
For not having a single WMD, he sure fooled the WORLD into thinking he had lots of 'em.
Solution to everything -- throw more money at it.
Muslim impression of the US - who cares? Muslims are assured of a place in heaven by killing an infidel. According to their beliefs, because I'm not Muslim, I'm an infidel. Frankly, I'm not concerned with the feelings of people who want me dead.
by lujohnson
We DID find WMDs. we found about 500 chemical WMDs
spread throughout Iraq.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending