Why did we go to war?
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by claudiamesna
by claudiamesna
by claudiamesna
Thank you, that seems like a very fair assessment. Every "dog" has his day..........
Thank you, your comments are always interesting, not to mention easily read in plain english which is wonderful. back to IT, oh dear....
by claudiamesna
by cactus pete
I don't see your definition of fair, unless it's "You can't have ANY of my money" and I don't see your cutoff listed anywhere. So you can continue to spew forth your rhetoric as much as you want. But I'll remind you that you didn't address the point of my post.
You've made a few assumptions, none of which are proven.
"If you tax something (productivity), you get less of it. If you subsidize something (give-away programs), you get more of it." This is not necessarily true, and certainly not true at all in your over generaglization.
"How about the loud-mouth Hollywood Limousine Liberals, the ones making tens of millions of dollars every year, while the "little guys" who build the sets and so on (probably 90% of "Hollywood") are working for low wages?"
First of all, your name calling, labeling - whatever you want to call it - is beneath you, and I've been seeing more of it from you lately. That's just a shame. But you really think that the people building those sets make low wages? Were you pulling that out of some dark cavity, or were you, um, embellishing a little?
You've thrown around the trillion dollars a lot lately, and I've pretty much just believed you on it. But now I recall that there are figures, and you can bend them to appear how you want. So I'll ask you [since you've already done the legwork, obviously] instead of looking it up myself: Is that trillion what was taxed, appropriated, or actually delivered? I'll remind everyone that with half a trillion deficit for one year, some wealth transfers are in fact not taking place.
Now I agree, there must be some great reform of te social services. I voted for a governor of Michigan some years ago who ran largely on htat platform. And he did it. I was pleased with that outcome. When he moved his focus away from that, he lost my support.
Now, please see if you can't answer the question.
by garion11
Yeah, um..right whatever little man. One of these days I am sure you will get your point across (whatever that maybe).
One of these days I am hoping you might make sense instead of ranting against Bush's "terrorism" and actually giving America some credit. Its because of people like YOU, Americans feel the world is being ungrateful and selfish.
.
.....So why don't you decide your life for yourself, and respect another's right to decide his live for himself?
Fair is relative. What's fair to me may seem unfair to you, and vice-versa. Therefore, it's a flawed concept for some other third party (individual or politician) to decide what's fair or not fair. Moreover, our Constitution guarantees freedom and individual liberty, and forcing a person to give money to another person is a gross infringement on those rights. (Okay, the "general welfare" argument is what's usually cited as a rebuttal to this. See the words of Jefferson and Madison below.)
Name calling????? Please, spare me. "Loud-Mouth Hollywood Limousine Liberal" is not exactly name-calling. Even if it is, it pales in comparison to the stuff they spew.
And what questions did I not answer? (They actually seemed like rhetorical questions, anyway, and I thought I generally answered them. But if you insist, here ya' go. (I looked for all your question marks. I hope I didn't miss any.)
You asked, "You're saying that there's no way a rich person can be a Democrat, unless they're just about to give it all away?"
Answer: No, I'm not saying that at all. What I am saying, however, is that if they determine a need, they should give away their money to satisfy that need before they attempt to have government take money from another.
You asked, "And if a Democrat becomes wealthy, they have to immediately become poor again?"
Answer: No, I'm not saying that. See my previous answer.
You asked, "Where's your cutoff, anyway?"
Answer: My cutoff is less than the levels - much less than the levels - that are forced upon us today. But if you want to hold me to an exact number, I can't provide one. I will say this, however; it's a lot closer to zero than it is to one trillion.
You asked, "Do you really think that Clinton has to give the money back or swallow his words?"
Answer: This is, I assume, a redundant question. I believe I answered it above. I will say this, however. What Bill Clinton swallows is his business. What he makes others swallow is - and has been - harmful to the country. (Not to mention a young and impressionable White House intern.)
You asked, "But you really think that the people building those sets make low wages? Were you pulling that out of some dark cavity, or were you, um, embellishing a little?"
Answer: Yes, I was embellishing a little. It was to make a point. Actually, I have no idea what those folks make.
--------------------
You accurately quoted me as saying, "If you tax something (productivity), you get less of it. If you subsidize something (give-away programs), you get more of it."
You went on to suggest that, "This is not necessarily true, and certainly not true at all in your over generalization".
Well, you and I will apparently have to agree to disagree. However, this isn't something I just made-up because it sounds good. It has a basis in sound economic principle.
"When you tax something, you get less of it."
Isn't that the very argument the government uses to discourage the use, and reduce the consumption of tobacco and alcohol?
But don't take my word for it - or the government's. How about an economist?
"When you tax something you get less of it, when you subsidize something you get more of it. If you tax income, producers, consumers, workers work less, produce less taxable income and the tax base has a tendency to decline. That's true of any form of taxation, if you get less consumption and more savings, more investment more growth."
- Dr. J.R. Clark, Probasco Chair of Free Enterprise and Professor of Economics at UT-Chattanooga
"The idea is simple: when you tax something, you increase its cost and you get less of it. But what do we mostly tax? We tax "goods" -- things like income, investment, labour and property improvements. As a result, we get fewer jobs, less innovation and less investment in property."
- Donna Morton,executive director of the Canadian Centre for Integral Economics
---------- ONE TRILLION DOLLARS ----------
You don't think we spend ONE TRILLION DOLLARS on money-transfer social programs?
(Note: The following sources are from two different fiscal years, thus the difference in the TWO TRILLION plus numbers)
Our current fiscal year spending is $2,156,536,000,000. That's two trillion, one hundred fifty six billion, five hundred thirty six million dollars.
http://www.heritage.org/Research/Budget/BG1710.cfm
Last year the federal government spent $2.3 Trillion, or about $7,835 for each man, woman and child in America.. The chart displays this $2.3 Trillion as a pie chart, with each major spending component (slice of the pie) shown as a percent of the total.
1. The BIGGIE is that HUGE RED CLOUD in the chart called SOCIAL PROGRAM Spending, which consumes 59% of the budget. (To place this in perspective, in 1948 social spending was but 10% of the federal budget - - prior to the New Deal it was near zero).
2. Foreign aid is less than 1% of the budget, and therefore will not be discussed. (this consumed 10% of 1948 spending).
SOCIAL PROGRAM Spending, which consumes 59% of the budget
SOCIAL PROGRAM Spending, which consumes 59% of the budget
SOCIAL PROGRAM Spending, which consumes 59% of the budget
SOCIAL PROGRAM Spending, which consumes 59% of the budget
http://mwhodges.home.att.net/fed_budget-a.htm
(That makes it more than one trillion, doesn't it?)
Where it all goes - a breakdown (happy reading)
http://www.cato.org/pubs/handbook/hb108/hb108-23.pdf
---------- More from some very wise people ----------
"When the people find that they can vote themselves money, that will herald the end of the republic."
-- Benjamin Franklin
"A wise and frugal government ... shall restrain men from injuring one another, shall leave them otherwise free to regulate their own pursuits of industry and improvement, and shall not take from the mouth of labor the bread it has earned. This is the sum of good government."
-- Thomas Jefferson, First Inaugural Address, March 4, 1801
"Congress has not unlimited powers to provide for the general welfare but only those specifically enumerated."
-- Thomas Jefferson
"With respect to the two words "general welfare," I have always regarded them as qualified by the detail of powers connected with them. To take them in a literal and unlimited sense would be a metamorphosis of the Constitution into a character which there is a host of proofs was not contemplated by its creators. If the words obtained so readily a place in the "Articles of Confederation," and received so little notice in their admission into the present Constitution, and retained for so long a time a silent place in both, the fairest explanation is, that the words, in the alternative of meaning nothing or meaning everything, had the former meaning taken for granted."
-- James Madison, the Father of the Constitution, elaborated upon this limitation in a letter to James Robertson
"If Congress can do whatever in their discretion can be done by money, and will promote the general welfare, the government is no longer a limited one possessing enumerated powers, but an indefinite one subject to particular exceptions."
-- James Madison, Letter to Edmund Pendleton January 21, 1792
"The government of the United States is a definite government, confined to specified objects. Charity is no part of the legislative duty of the government."
-- James Madison, speech in the House of Representatives, January 10, 1794
"If Congress can determine what constitutes the general welfare and can appropriate money for its advancement, where is the limitation to carrying into execution whatever can be effected by money?"
-- South Carolina Senator William Draden 1828
"They that can give up essential liberty to purchase a little temporary safety, deserve neither liberty nor safety."
--Benjamin Franklin,
"Remember democracy never lasts long. It soon wastes, exhausts, and murders itself. There never was a democracy yet that did not commit suicide."
-- John Adams
" I am for doing good to the poor, but I differ in opinion of the means. I think the best way of doing good to the poor, is not making them easy in poverty, but leading or driving them out of it."
-- Benjamin Franklin
"A democracy cannot exist as a permanent form of government. It can only exist until the voters discover that they can vote themselves largesse from the public treasury. From that moment on, the majority always votes for the candidates promising the most benefits from the public treasury, with the result that a democracy always collapses over loose fiscal policy, always followed by a dictatorship."
-- Professor Alexander Tytler
"The State is great fiction by which everyone seeks to live at the expense of everyone else."
-- Frederic Bastiat
"If a nation values anything more than freedom, it will lose its freedom; and the irony of it is that, if it is comfort or money it values more, it will lose that too."
-- William Somerset Maughan, 1941
"Democracy extends the sphere of individual freedom, socialism restricts it. Democracy attaches all possible value to each man; socialism makes each man a mere agent, a mere number. Democracy and socialism have nothing in common but one word: equality. But notice the difference: while democracy seeks equality in liberty, socialism seeks equality in restraint and servitude."
-- Alexis de Tocqueville
"Socialism in general has a record of failure so blatant that only an intellectual could ignore or evade it."
-- Thomas Sowell
"The inherent vice of capitalism is the unequal sharing of the blessings. The inherent blessing of socialism is the equal sharing of misery. "
-- Winston Churchill
"When men get in the habit of helping themselves to the property of others, they cannot easily be cured of it."
-- The New York Times, in a 1909 editorial opposing the very first income tax
"Of all tyrannies a tyranny exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive. It may be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies. The robber baron's cruelty may sometimes sleep, his cupidity may at some point be satiated; but those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience. They may be more likely to go to Heaven yet at the same time likelier to make a Hell of earth. This very kindness stings with intolerable insult. To be 'cured' against one's will and cured of states which we may not regard as disease is to be put on a level of those who have not yet reached the age of reason or those who never will; to be classed with infants, imbeciles, and domestic animals. But to be punished, however severely, because we have deserved it, because we 'ought to have known better,' is to be treated as a human person made in God's image."
-- C.S. Lewis
"Charity is a noble instinct; theft legal or illegal is despicable. Or, put another way: reaching into one's own pocket to assist his fellow man is noble and worthy of praise. Reaching into another person's pocket to assist one's fellow man is despicable and worthy of condemnation."
-- Walter E. Williams, Professor of Economics at George Mason University
"Republicans and right-wingers support taking the earnings of one American and giving them to farmers, banks, airlines and other failing businesses. Democrats and left-wingers support taking the earnings of one American and giving them to poor people, cities, and artists. Both agree on taking one American's earnings to give to another; they simply differ on the recipients. This kind of congressional activity constitutes at least two-thirds of the federal budget."
-- Walter E. Williams, Professor of Economics at George Mason University
"No man's life, liberty, or property are safe while the legislature is in session. "
-- Mark Twain
--------------------
.
.
.
You may not agree with me, but I am certainly in good company with my principles.
.
.
.
--------------------
For some comparison:
"We're going to take things away from you on behalf of the common good"
- Hillary Clinton
Kinda' puts things in perspective.
.
.
.
By the way, did I miss any of your questions?
by protiusx
It never ceases to amaze me how we Americans can be so short sited and ignorant of the world at large. We think in terms of dollars and "how does this affect me?".
The fact of the matter is this: Saddam Hussein had chemical and biological weapons (it's a fact and no amount of whining by conspiracy whacko's will change that) and at one time had a functional nuclear power plant that he used to enrich weapons grade uranium for a nuclear device. Perhaps if you look at recent history you will find that it was actually the Israeli's who flew F-16 fighter/bombers more than 1600 miles during the Iran-Iraq war to annihilate the reactor. Look it up.
So why do my fellow Americans insist on the innocence of this poor defenseless Iraqi leader? Are you so immersed in the Jerry Springer culture that you think the President of the United States will use the most powerful military in the world and spend billions of dollars because he had an "axe to grind"? Why do my fellow Americans insist on defending a mass murderer who thought Stalin and Hitler were pretty swell guys? You all disgust me! He murdered women and children en mass. He was solely responsible for the murders of hundreds if not thousands of people and you sit there and so nonchalantly become angry when we as a nation finally stand up for what is right and decent. I am glad you weren't around during WWII or the world would be a much different place.
.
The answer is because they put politics above principle; and they will do anything, and they say anything just to get their "Democrat of the Day" elected.
I can think of only ONE elected Democrat who's putting principle above politics. His name is Zell Miller.
by admin
I am curious to have heard that he may have done this again by suggesting people vote third party at the Democratic convention.
I can't help but admire a principled person who maintains their values even in a challenging or hostile situation, including politically. I always thought as a Republican, Abe Lincoln acted on principle to a large degree as well. Following ones principles too much can make for difficulties in a presidency, however, I do still admire this and you have at least shown me that Bush Jr. may in fact as a person be acting on principles he truly believes in. I may disagree with one of the directions he has led us into, but I can respect him for holding his principles.
To some extent at least on some issues I believe most or all of our presidents have displayed this value. To me, even Nixon's presidency had some good points especially globally, and although there were things I greatly disliked about the Reagan presidency, he will always be admired by me for succesfully concluding the Cold War. He had an amazing understanding of that situation and an amazing ability to time great decisions flawlessly. The tearing down of the Berlin Wall will always have special meaning to me.
Personally, I do not like the current Demorcratic presidential choices, but I hardly believe all Democrats "will do anything, and they say anything just to get their "Democrat of the Day" elected". There are some great principled Democrats and some great principled Republicans. I will of course be voting for Michael Badnerick, the Libertarian, but that is because I most agree with that party in principle, not because of lack (or wealth) of principle in the other candidates.
In my opinion, humans should be sized up according to their principles, Politicians should be judged according to how well they will perform their political responsibilities. On the whole, these should blend together, but you can have an immensily principled person really screw stuff up out of, for one, naivete. We experienced this on a state level here IMO a few years ago. Great guy- but an incompetant politician. I also don't particularly admire and even dislike many things about Thomas Jeffersons personal life, and yet greatly admire what he did for the US politically.
In an ideal world, there would always be the Philosopher-King in the Platonic state that merged a highly principled personal life with a highly successful political career, but I believe it is never black and white in real life, but blended in each individual according to their gifts, talents, integrity, opportunities and work ethic. Oh, and some luck in what happens during their 4 (or 8) years! :)
by oz_media
I really haven't seen nor heard of anyone who has supported Sadam, or felt as if he was a poor defenseless Iraqi.
People aren't pissed off that the USA has removed saddam from power, people aren't pissed off that you have paid Haliburton $1.50 gallon to ship gas to Iraq to be sold for 5 cents gallon and your own prices are ot of control. Peple aren't sayig Saddam NEVER had WMD and yes the operative wod is as you say "DID" have WMD.
He was told to stop, he SAID he did, nobody believed him and after many unsuccessful attempts, the UN was finally allowed to conduct full inspections and they found nothing of any valus, other than old unused warheads.
There was little or no prior knowledge of the mass graves, although with the Kudish war, there MUST have been some form of mass burial, just like there would be now if that number of Iraqi's were killed by the USA. We can't just leave bodies laying in the street, when they have no way of returning the dead and injusred to families for proper 'Christian burials' there is no other choice.
So while all of your points are somewhat valid, they were also unknown by the general public who supported the premature invasion to begin with.
You cannot for one second deny that you went to war based on false premises.
So the question "Why did we go to war" cannot be answered with, mass graves, existing WMD, terror inside Iraq etc.
You went to war, and we STILL see people saying it today, to save your babies as any threatened and attacked nation would and should. Except you were neither threatened nor attacked.
by protiusx
Unfortunately either you have swallowed the party line or you haven't researched your facts. Human rights violations and out right slaughter was known about prior to the second Iraqi war.
Look at: http://www.christian-aid.org.uk/indepth/0000iraq/iraq.htm#protecting
This is but one example. We can not as a nation say that we "didn't know about it" because we did. I think what was deplorable is the fact that we waited so long before doing something about it. This is where I differ from some of my "republican" brethren in that I believe that as humans it is our duty to protect those who can not help themselves, feed those who are starving and help those who are in need.
For the United States to turn it's back on a downtrodden people or those who ask for our help is tantamount to approval. I have heard it said that we can not help the whole world but if we can't who can?
by cactus pete
In order, as much as possible...
".....So why don't you decide your life for yourself, and respect another's right to decide his live for himself?" Don't quite get what you're implying, given the context. But here's a stab at it: We live in a country made up of many people - at some point, decisions must be made for the group as a whole. There will be differences of opinion, but what's best for society will, hopefully, be the end result. This means that someone at some time must drop the "me first" attitude that appears to be so prevalent these days. That cuts both ways - you have to pay some taxes you don't like, and you have to do some of the work your damn self, rather than relying on the collected taxes of others.
"Fair is relative. What's fair to me may seem unfair to you, and vice-versa. Therefore, it's a flawed concept for some other third party (individual or politician) to decide what's fair or not fair." Same as above - the good of the country come sbefore the good of a particular person - in some cases. This is the built-in problem with our country, actually. People have every right they can muster - so long as it does not harm anyone else. But many people will fight wars to be sure that the right exists in the first place. The argument can sometimes be where that line rests, the one you cross to harm others. You know, the shouting FIRE in a crowded theater...
"Name calling????? Please, spare me." As I said, that, labeling, whatever you want to call it. It isn't an educated means to support your side of the debate. It's hostile, demeaning, and not the only time you've done it. That just happens to be the time I brought it up. I believe I've tried to show even the more fundamentalist people on your side of things some respect, particularly when it's a matter of opinions.
"Answer: No, I'm not saying that at all. What I am saying, however, is that if they determine a need, they should give away their money to satisfy that need before they attempt to have government take money from another." Again, it's a social benefit for the good of the whole country, but you expect just the few who have the means and aptitude to shoulder the responsibility. That's the "me first" mentality to which I was referring. It's like saying, "I don't like them, I didn't personally cause them to suffer, someone else has more money and is the one complaining, let them pay for it all." If a wealthy man says, "I'll pay my portion if you pay yours" everyone benefits.
Without quoting your cutsie little play on words about Clinton's "disgrace in office", let me just say that it was another unwarranted, unnecessary slam to people who don't think just like you. Yes, yes, it was cute, I hope you get the expected giggles... But it distracts from the topic, don't you think?
"Isn't that the very argument the government uses to discourage the use, and reduce the consumption of tobacco and alcohol?" Why yes it is. But the premise doesn't always mesh with reality, does it? if you tax the hell out of an addictive substance, which is perfectly legal, and it is a social fashion [a fad, whatever], then you'll just rake in lots of money. That particular good is not necessarily lessened. You see, it has to do with the supply/demand chart. If demand is represented by a verticle line [referring to the common econ 101 chart] it won't matter. In fact, it's usually a curve, not a line, and the curve can even bend back on itself, allowing for more than one price at the same quantity. In economics, we [I have a degree in it] use differential equations [calculus] because those little lines get so complex. And still, we're working from assumption, because it's not a "hard" science.
So, all of those quotes you have, while generally and in a simple context, are correct, they are hardly correct in all situations, which is what I said. In fact, my quote, with emphasis added, was "This is not necessarily true..."
And all of the people you quoted, and even you, would agree that some level of taxation is necessary, and can provide for good for the society at large. So, instead of arguing a black and white world, let's all admit it's rather gray, and go about finding a better place for where the line should fall. Instead of arguing with malice, how about reasoning with civility?
by admin
I heard about the Democratic convention.
I didn't watch it, but some friends did and we had a heated debate on a front porch recently where I was informed that Jimmy Carter in his address sugggested people vote third party this year. Is this true?
by protiusx
Here we are again and again I must disagree. Truth is truth. It does not change from one persons experience to another. It is true to say that water is wet. It is wet to me and it is wet to you. It is true to say that fire burns. It will burn each of us equally.
It is not logical to say that there are two sides to every story or that truth is in the mind. There is right and wrong. Right can not be by definition both right and wrong. Light can not be by it very definition both light and darkness. Here we are speaking about absolutes and not gradations.
Gradations are applied to truisms so it is correct to say that brightness is a gradation of light and darkness. One could also say that fire burns but it is not as hot as say the sun. However, these gradations do not fundamentally change the very nature of the truths that they apply to.
So although we may disgree the end result is that logically we both can not be right.
Welfare, tax reform, re-distribution of wealth, social issues such as gay rights and abortion are examples of issues that I am sure we disagree on. Who is right or wrong will be determined ultimately by time and the affects that the decisions we make today have on our progeny.
by admin
"For the United States to turn it's back on a downtrodden people or those who ask for our help is tantamount to approval. I have heard it said that we can not help the whole world but if we can't who can? "
Why do you think we are not in Sudan right now then? Shouldn't we be?
by garion11
by admin
ProtiusX posited the premise: "For the United States to turn it's back on a downtrodden people or those who ask for our help is tantamount to approval. I have heard it said that we can not help the whole world but if we can't who can? "
to which the logical outcome when accepting this premise having awareness of the situation in Sudan would be to help them as this is not a situation we could conscionably approve of.
.
That's a faulty conclusion, or so it is as far as I see it.
We have to choose our battles carefully, each on its own merit, and each according to the political and practical realities at the time.
But perhaps in due time.
But that leads to an interesting question.
If the U.S were to go into Sudan for the purpose of either tracking down terrorists holed-up there, or to stop the mass slaughter, or both, how long should the U.S wait for the United NAtions to sit by watching, doing nothing, letting people get killed, and so on? We know that the United Nations is impotent, and that they can do nothing about it. So IF the U.S. does, should we wait one year, three years, five, ten, twelve (we waited for twelve in the case of Iraq), or more - or never? How long and/or how many dead people before the U.S. does something?
This is a serious question, by the way, even though it's also a rhetorical one to make a point.
by admin
"We have to choose our battles carefully, each on its own merit, and each according to the political and practical realities at the time."
as added may draw a different conclusion.
I was throwing that out as pure logic to consider on the original statement. Without additional premises or standards to follow we would soon find ourselves fighting everywhere.
If you are asking for my personal position as a serious question, adding your premise would be my idea of why we should not get involved in North Korea.
As far as Sudan, It has been in a civil war since it's independence from the British (wasn't it in the 50's?) with the exception of a few years. People didn't start dying en masse there just recently, the media just started paying attention again. It's been an ongoing thing. While my heart goes out to those people, I cannot see where intervention in the form of a short war will help. Just as the Kurds will never have real lasting power in Iraq, the southern Sudanese will always be under-represented if at all in their government.
The fact is, we in the US do stand by while atrocities happen in many regions and for good reason.
Personally, while I have tons of respect for Israel, and especially their covert ops, I think the US should threaten to and then if they don't stop, kick their ass for overrunning their borders. That land was a gift from the world, and now they cause problems for everyone by disrespecting their boundries? When they are bulldozing humans where are all the people yelling that terrorism everywhere must be stopped? Action against Israel on the Palestine border issue would be a conflict worth having for many reasons in the world today. The Jewish people are wonderful but the Israeli government is out of control in this area and we turn a blind eye.
I know this is oversimplification, but good fences make good neighbors. There are no good fences in many of these countries that have lasting unrest. Until these warring factions have their own areas and are forced to keep their borders there will be unrest and human rights violations. Do we really want to try and manitain all these borders indefinitely with our military? If we do will we, like Rome, get so spread out that we can't sustain oursleves and die like the ringworm on the back of a dog? I would not want to take that chance. We should use our power and wealth wisely for the benefit of mankind and that's why I like this additional premise.
"according to the political and practical realities at the time" Yep, that's good advice in my book.
No sense trying to squeeze blood out of a turnip neither.
by protiusx
.
Of course we live in a land of many people, and there is indeed a point where we must consider the group as a whole. But it's your "what's best for society as a whole" sentiment that's open to interpretation - and the divide is as wide and as deep as the Grand Canyon. Now, I might come across as having a "me first" attitude (when in actuality I am quite generous with both my time and my money), but mine is a "me first" sentiment with MY PROPERTY. It's the "me first" sentiment that takes other peoples' property that's driving us down the road to ruin, and it's dead-wrong in both principle and implementation. (Yes, I know, the "dead-wrong" is my opinion.) I suppose this might also answer your previous question about where my "cutoff" level would be, but my cut-off would be just above the level of life-and death, unacceptable suffering, and literally nowhere else to turn. As just one example, no, I don't think you and I should pay for, with our tax dollars, the millions of knee-replacements performed on eighty year olds. But if an old lady is left destitute with no place to go, then absolutely we should care for her in a dignified manner.
And actually, my "me first" sentiment isn't really accurate at all. I'm not taking this position to be selfish. I'm taking it because I want to ensure the continued success of America - as it was intended to be. I think we're on a slippery slope to absolute ruin, and it's our grandkids who will be the most harmed because of it. I believe it's the "me first" people, the ones who are "me first" with other people's money, who are looking for the instant gratification, not considering the long-term consequences of their actions.
In your second paragraph, I'm not sure what you're suggesting, because I agree that a person's individual freedom and liberty stop at the threshold of infringing on the freedom and liberty of another. In that regard, we're in total agreement. But I'm not crossing any line at all - but others are, by demanding that the property of others be transferred to them. And whether you admit it or not, we do indeed have equality of opportunity in this country; and contrary to what the "power mongers" want you to believe, people do indeed rise from the depths of despair to take advantage of those opportunities. Sure, some people have more advantages than others to get started, but the opportunity is there nonetheless. Again, we have a big divide in defining where a person's equality of opportunity turns into a desire to create an equality of outcome. It's not the role of government to create a level playing field, so to speak, just so everyone starts from and ends at the same place.
And besides, before all these social programs were implemented, people were getting along just fine. We Americans are a kind and charitable bunch, and I'm sure those who needed care would get it. You're coming across as though people would be dying in the streets without some government program. Moreover, I apparently have more faith in the human resolve than you do. Left to their own devices, most people could get along just fine - and it's a disgrace that there are those in government who want to convince them otherwise.
On the quotes, especially from Jefferson and Madison, I must suggest that you are not very well versed in their philosophy. To see where we've gone, both must be turning in their graves. Mr. Jefferson, did you know that 200 years after your efforts.........
"You mean a person MUST report his income to the government", Jefferson would probably proclaim?
"You mean the government forces you to be charitable?, Jefferson asks?
"No, no, no. This is not at all what I had in mind", I suspect Jefferson would say.
No, I think Thomas Jefferson, if alive today, would be the first in line to fight the next revolution against a most oppressive government. He would recall his other sentiments:
"The majority, oppressing an individual, is guilty of a crime, abuses its strength, and by acting on the law of the strongest breaks up the foundations of society."
-- Thomas Jefferson
"The tree of Liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots and tyrants."
-- Thomas Jefferson
"The greatest [calamity] which could befall [us would be] submission to a government of unlimited powers."
-- Thomas Jefferson,
But my bottom line is that these money-transfer programs are contrary to the intended role of the United States government. It's not what our government is supposed to do; and I'm sure Thomas Jefferson would be closer to agreeing with me than agreeing with those who believe otherwise.
On your last comment, I'm certainly not arguing with malice - with passion, perhaps, but not with malice. But I must say, considering all the conversations you and I have had, both public and private, it appears to me that you are the one who is forgetting your civility, not me.
But let's just let it go, and simply agree to disagree. (I know, I didn't address all of your items, but what's the point?)
By the way, why aren't you as vocal against the slams on President Bush as you appear to be on my " cutsie little play on words " concerning Bill Clinton? Just an interesting observation.
.
The following is a transcript of a speech by the Honorable Jimmy Carter at the Democratic National Convention on Monday, July 26, 2004
My name is Jimmy Carter, and I'm not running for president. But here's what I will be doing: everything I can to put John Kerry in the White House with John Edwards right there beside him......
.
In some people's estimation, this would simply be "a difference of opinion".
How thoughtless of me to say that it wasn't true.
(I always confuse "truth" and "opinion".)
by admin
Actually, when I was told this erroneous fact, I was somewhat surprised, yet in a hopeful way. I still like Jimmy Carter, but will be passing on his advice to vote Kerry\Edwards in this case.
hehe- I i would of said it's not true.
I'll say it now- it's not true :)
.
Truth and opinion are easily confused around here. Especially when someone is faced with undeniable facts, it suddenly becomes a "difference of opinion".
Will you never learn??????
by oz_media
We don't actually attack each other except when in political debates.
Many of us here have a rather sordid past on TR for 'flaming each other' in political forums, I've seen it from you as a newbie to (sorry buy you said you were a new here).
Do not let this be a place to learn about anyone though, the opinions shared here are definitely not a reflection of most of the people here, it's just a way to blast off some steam. I am sure many of the folk who I would hut down and kill for thier political stand would be just fine to have a beer or ten with one day and we'd probably find we have more in common than we first thought.
It is simply impossible to get a god read on somebody over the interet, that's why there are so many abductions and kidnappings from people met in chat rooms. Words can be VERY deceiving and especially the tone of voice used by the person who says the words, which cannot be heard online of course.
I am still somwhat confused to your own political stand though, in one post you are agreeing with Maxwell's points, in another you are sayig you believe GWB didn't actually get elected, which leaves me confused as to who you support but from the general feeling of your posts I'd say you were somewhere in the middle.
As a Canadian, it makes no difference to me, your left wing is our right wing, so for one, we can't compare political views across our borders. Secondly, Canadians don't really gie a cra about politics or politicians as long as they leave us out of the picture and let us get on with our lives.
My personal distaste toward Bush is his mannerisms indicate he lies, his body languiage SCREAMS liar, even based on the FBI's own profiling techniques. Even then, he's not a liar in MY country nor do his political mistakes effect me. BUT when he lied to America to prematurely ivade Iraq, it became my business and remains so. The part I simply don't understand, nor have from the beginning is that Americans are VERY politically savvy (toward US politics) they hold the highest level of trust in thier president (Canadians wouldn't trust a politician as far as we could launch him with a truck, they ae jusr liars with jobs and have no immediate efect on ou lives)but even when blatantly mislead, not just an evasive mistake but blatant deception, it is all ignored because America is at war. Clinton was IMPEACHED for getting a bit on the side, BUSH is responsible for the deaths of many US citizens and yet he is completely defended by SOME anyway.
This just boggles the mind how no matter what is said or done, if they truly believe it is for thier own safety, people comlpetely ignore decption from the ONE person they place all faith in.
Some are waking up and starting to realize he must be held accountable, others are just blindly defending him to the death. The I hear, "You just don't understand" I suppose in that case, they are right, I certainly don't understand this irregardless allegiance.
by hereinoz
Oz, they simply tried to do it, but he avoided it rather deftly. They didn't call him the Teflon Kid for nothing!!
I do agree with you about the almost myopic way that some (not all) US citizens trust their Prez. As a politically cynical Australian, I find it a bit wierd.
by aldanatech
.
Being impeached is often misunderstood. Being impeached does not equal being removed from office.
The U.S. House of Representatives votes on the articles of impeachment, and if it passes with a simple majority, there is indeed an impeachment. An impeachment is, perhaps, similar to a Grand Jury decision, who decides whether or not the evidence is sufficient to warrant a trial. If there is, the matter is then sent on to the Senate, where they will decide the merits of the case, and decide whether or not the person will indeed be removed from office. So in the case of Bill Clinton, he was indeed impeached by the House of Representatives (by a narrow margin), but the Senate decided not to remove him from office.
The House of Representatives impeached Bill Clinton on two charges, perjury and obstruction of justice. The Senate held a trial, with the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court overseeing, and found Bill Clinton not guilty of perjury by a vote of 55-45, and they were split on the obstruction charge 50-50.
What's interesting about this, however, is that the American Bar Association revoked his license to practice law in both Washington D.C. and in Arkansas because a judge in Arkansas found him guilty of perjury. Go figure.
Bill Clinton was the second U.S. president to be impeached by the House of Representatives. Andrew Johnson, the 17th president, was charged with serious misconduct (or something like that), but he held onto the presidency by virtue of a single vote in the Senate. John Tyler, our 10th president, faced an impeachment hearing on charges of corruption, but the measure failed to pass in the House and was never sent to the Senate for trial.
Richard Nixon surely would have been impeached by the House, probably on the single charge of obstruction of justice, but he resigned before the House vote. And to put the matter to rest, suggesting that Nixon's resignation was punishment enough, President Ford granted a full pardon to Nixon. (The right thing to do, in my opinion, but it probably cost Gerald Ford the election in 1976.)
.
You missed this discussion, as it was active before your return.
I nominated President Bush for an entry into John Kennedy's "Profiles In Courage", for that very reason - putting his political life on the line to do what he believed to be the right thing, even in the face of fierce political opposition
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=151268&start=0&tag=search
(Some people just didn't get it. Go figure.)
.
Truth and opinion are easily confused around here. Especially when someone is faced with undeniable facts - or "truth" that is contrary to their desired outcome - it suddenly becomes a "difference of opinion".
(Don't try to fight it. Resistance is futile.)
by admin
by aldanatech
Somebody asked to itemize the expenses from the Democrats and Republicans. Oh, common! I got far better things to do. That is like watching grass grow. However, I will summarize in a few specific points of what I think when I hear the word ?republican? in terms of economics:
1. ENRON
2. Tax cuts, good for the top 1%
3. Going from a big time surplus to an almost 600,000 million dollar deficit
4. Loosing millions of jobs
5. Making up some of those jobs by outsourcing from abroad
By the way, I was one of the millions that lost his job. It was a nice IT job. Now I'm lucky enough to get an entry-level position.
by aldanatech
Rather than your own personal opinions, it seems to be based more on what the Bush administration wants us all to think. I?m not the kind of people that just assumes things are going the way they are reported by politicians. I like to analyze their actions, try to determine the legibility of their actions, and get as many points of view as possible. When 9/11 happened I didn?t how the administration would react. First I thought he would get together with the international community to hunt down Al Qaeda and Osama Bin Laden. After all, the world was sympathetic with us at that time.
So Bush?s first move was to attack Afghanistan; not exactly the best move, but acceptable. It didn?t get Bin Laden or Al Qaeda, but it stopped the Taliban. Then his next move is to attack Iraq. What! What does Iraq have to do with anything? I asked myself. Eventually, the reason was because Iraq had weapons of mass destruction. Well why didn?t they let the UN inspector finish their job first? Another was that Saddam Hussein had links with Al Qaeda. Where is the proof of that? That Hussein is a brutal dictator. Well we got lots to choose from. How about if we start we Fidel Castro? He is just across the gulf, so it would be a lot more inexpensive.
To be quite honest, I find this war to be useless and extremely expensive. If Bush?s purpose is to truly fight terrorism then by all means he made the wrong move. What is the point of launching a war on a country such as Iraq? I mean think about. What is the worst thing that can happen to you in a war? Loose your life. Well these guys aren?t afraid of death. And what would of happen if we attack Iraq before 9/11? It would have been just one more of a reason to attack us. Look, the only way you can stop them is by convincing them their efforts simply don?t work. Well our actions so far show them that their efforts do work.
So if we really want to stop them then we must implement major intelligence reforms ASAP. Next we to gain back the trust from the world and get them to join us. Lets face it. These guys are all over the place and it is unrealistic to think we can handle it stubbornly by ourselves. Remember that terrorism is not Desert Storm. It is organized crime to the next level, and the only way to fight that is with big time intelligence from the US and around the globe. Eventually, if we follow the right path, not only will we show them we don?t fear them, but they won?t dare to attempt to do anything because they will know we will hunt them and get them before they even realize it.
.
....I think you are extremely uninformed and naive.
Your, "attacked Afghanistan...and stopped the Taliban" statement says it all to show your lack of understanding.
by garion11
http://www.keepmedia.com/pubs/Esquire/2004/08/01/505604?page=1
The Case for George W. Bush
by Tom Junod | Aug 01 '04
Page 1 of 3
It happened again this morning. I saw a picture of our president?my president?and my feelings about him were instantly rekindled. The picture was taken after his speech to the graduating seniors at the Air Force Academy. He was wearing a dark suit, a light-blue tie, and a white shirt. His unsmiling visage was grim and purposeful, in pointed contrast to the face of the elaborately uniformed cadet standing next to him, which was lit up with a cocky grin. Indeed, as something more than a frozen moment?as a political statement?the picture might have served, and been intended to serve, as a tableau of the resolve necessary to lift this nation out of this steep and terrible time. The cadet represented the best of what America has to offer, all devil-may-care enthusiasm and willingness to serve. The president, his hair starting to whiten, might have represented something even more essential: the kind of brave and, in his case, literally unblinking leadership that generates enough moral capital to summon the young to war. Although one man was essentially being asked to stake his life on the wisdom of the other, both were melded in an attitude of common purpose, and so both struck a common pose. With the cadet bent slightly forward and the commander in chief leaning slightly back, each man cocked his right arm and made a muscle. They flexed! I didn't know anything about the cadet. About President George W. Bush, though, I felt the satisfaction of absolute certainty, and so uttered the words as essential to my morning as my cup of Kenyan and my dose of high-minded outrage on the editorial page of the Times : "What an asshole."
Ah. That feels better. George W. Bush is an asshole, isn't he? Moreover, he's the first president who seems merely that, at least in my lifetime. From Kennedy to Clinton, there is not a single president who would have been capable of striking such a pose after concluding a speech about a war in which hundreds of Americans and thousands of Iraqis are being killed. There is not a single president for whom such a pose would seem entirely characteristic?not a single president who might be tempted to confuse a beefcakey photo opportunity with an expression of national purpose. He has always struck me as a small man, or at least as a man too small for the task at hand, and therefore a man doomed to address the discrepancy between his soul and his situation with displays of political muscle that succeed only in drawing attention to his diminution. He not only has led us into war, he seems to get off on war, and it's the greedy pleasure he so clearly gets from flexing his biceps or from squaring his shoulders and setting his jaw or from landing a plane on an aircraft carrier?the greedy pleasure the war president finds in playacting his own attitudes of belligerence?that permitted me the greedy pleasure of hating him.
Then I read the text of the speech he gave and was thrown from one kind of certainty?the comfortable kind?into another. He was speaking, as he always does, of the moral underpinnings of our mission in Iraq. He was comparing, as he always does, the challenge that we face, in the evil of global terrorism, to the challenge our fathers and grandfathers faced, in the evil of fascism. He was insisting, as he always does, that the evil of global terrorism is exactly that, an evil?one of almost transcendent dimension that quite simply must be met, lest we be remembered for not meeting it . . . lest we allow it to be our judge. I agreed with most of what he said, as I often do when he's defining matters of principle. No, more than that, I thought that he was defining principles that desperately needed defining, with a clarity that those of my own political stripe demonstrate only when they're decrying either his policies or his character. He was making a moral proposition upon which he was basing his entire presidency?or said he was basing his entire presidency?and I found myself in the strange position of buying into the proposition without buying into the presidency, of buying into the words while rejecting, utterly, the man who spoke them. There is, of course, an easy answer for this seeming moral schizophrenia: the distance between the principles and the policy, between the mission and "Mission Accomplished," between the war on terror and the war in Iraq. Still, I have to admit to feeling a little uncertain of my disdain for this president when forced to contemplate the principle that might animate his determination to stay the course in a war that very well may be the end of him politically. I have to admit that when I listen to him speak, with his unbending certainty, I sometimes hear an echo of the same nagging question I ask myself after I hear a preacher declaim the agonies of hellfire or an insurance agent enumerate the cold odds of the actuarial tables. Namely: What if he's right?
As easy as it is to say that we can't abide the president because of the gulf between what he espouses and what he actually does , what haunts me is the possibility that we can't abide him because of us?because of the gulf between his will and our willingness. What haunts me is the possibility that we have become so accustomed to ambiguity and inaction in the face of evil that we find his call for decisive action an insult to our sense of nuance and proportion.
The people who dislike George W. Bush have convinced themselves that opposition to his presidency is the most compelling moral issue of the day. Well, it's not. The most compelling moral issue of the day is exactly what he says it is, when he's not saying it's gay marriage. The reason he will be difficult to unseat in November?no matter what his approval ratings are in the summer?is that his opponents operate out of the moral certainty that he is the bad guy and needs to be replaced, while he operates out of the moral certainty that terrorists are the bad guys and need to be defeated. The first will always sound merely convenient when compared with the second. Worse, the gulf between the two kinds of certainty lends credence to the conservative notion that liberals have settled for the conviction that Bush is distasteful as a substitute for conviction?because it's easier than conviction.
IN 1861, AFTER CONFEDERATE FORCES shelled Fort Sumter, President Abraham Lincoln suspended the writ of habeas corpus from Philadelphia to Washington and thereby made the arrest of American citizens a matter of military or executive say-so. When the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court objected to the arrest of a Maryland man who trained troops for Confederate muster, Lincoln essentially ignored his ruling. He argued that there was no point fixating on one clause in the Constitution when Southern secession had shredded the whole document, and asked, "Are all the laws but one to go unexecuted, and the government itself go to pieces, lest that one be violated?" During the four-year course of the Civil War, he also selectively abridged the rights of free speech, jury trial, and private property.
...continued from page 1
Page 2 of 3
Not that the war went well: His army was in the habit of losing long before it learned to win, and Lincoln did not find a general to his liking until he found Ulysses S. Grant, whose idea of war was total. He financed the bloodbath by exposing the nation to ruinous debt and taxation, and by 1864 he had to contend with an antiwar challenge from Democrats and a political challenge from a member of his own Cabinet. On August 23, 1864, he was motivated to write in a memorandum that "it seems exceedingly probable that this administration will not be reelected," and yet his position on peace never wavered: He rejected any terms but the restoration of the union and the abolition of slavery. The war was, from first to last, portrayed as his war, and after he won landslide reelection, he made a vow not only to stay the course but to prosecute it to the brink of catastrophe and beyond: "Fondly do we hope?fervently do we pray?that this mighty scourge of war may speedily pass away. Yet, if God wills that it continue, until all the wealth piled by the bond-man's two hundred and fifty years of unrequited toil shall be sunk, and until every drop of blood drawn with the lash, shall be paid by another drawn with the sword, as was said three thousand years ago, so still it must be said 'the judgments of the Lord, are true and righteous altogether.' "
Today, of course, those words, along with Lincoln's appeal to the better angels of our nature, are chiseled into the wall of his memorial, on the Mall in Washington. And yet if George Bush were to speak anything like them today, we would accuse him of pandering to his evangelical base. We would accuse him of invoking divine authority for a war of his choosing, and Maureen Dowd would find a way to read his text in light of the cancellation of some Buffy spin-off. Believe me: I am not comparing George W. Bush to Abraham Lincoln. The latter was his own lawyer as well as his own writer, and he was alive to the possibilities of tragedy and comedy?he was human ?in a way that our president doesn't seem to be. Neither am I looking to justify Bush's forays into shady constitutional ground by invoking Lincoln's precedents with the same; I'm not a lawyer. I am, however, asking if the crisis currently facing the country?the crisis, that is, that announced itself on the morning of September 11, 2001, in New York and Pennsylvania and the District of Columbia?is as compelling a justification for the havoc and sacrifice of war as the crisis that became irrevocable on April 12, 1861, in South Carolina, or, for that matter, the crisis that emerged from the blue Hawaiian sky on December 7, 1941. I, for one, believe it is and feel somewhat ashamed having to say so: having to aver that 9/11/01 was a horror sufficient to supply Bush with a genuine moral cause rather than, as some would have it, a mere excuse for his adventurism.
We were attacked three years ago, without warning or predicate event. The attack was not a gesture of heroic resistance nor the offshoot of some bright utopian resolve, but the very flower of a movement that delights in the potential for martyrdom expressed in the squalls of the newly born. It is a movement that is about death?that honors death, that loves death, that fetishizes death, that worships death, that seeks to accomplish death wherever it can, on a scale both intimate and global?and if it does not warrant the expenditure of what the self-important have taken to calling "blood and treasure," then what does? Slavery? Fascism? Genocide? Let's not flatter ourselves: If we do not find it within ourselves to identify the terrorism inspired by radical Islam as an unequivocal evil?and to pronounce ourselves morally superior to it?then we have lost the ability to identify any evil at all, and our democracy is not only diminished, it dissolves into the meaninglessness of privilege.
YEAH, YEAH, I KNOW: Nobody who opposes Bush thinks that terrorism is a good thing. The issue is not whether the United States should be involved in a war on terrorism but rather whether the war on terrorism is best served by war in Iraq. And now that the war has defied the optimism of its advocates, the issue is no longer Bush's moral intention but rather his simple competence. He got us in when he had no idea how to get us out. He allowed himself to be blinded by ideology and blindsided by ideologues. His arrogance led him to offend the very allies whose participation would have enabled us to win not just the war but the peace. His obsession with Saddam Hussein led him to rush into a war that was unnecessary. Sure, Saddam was a bad guy. Sure, the world is a better place without him. But . . .
And there it is: the inevitable but . Trailed by its uncomfortable ellipsis, it sits squirming at the end of the argument against George Bush for very good reason: It can't possibly sit at the beginning. Bush haters have to back into it because there's nothing beyond it. The world is a better place without Saddam Hussein, but . . . but what ? But he wasn't so bad that we had to do anything about him? But he wasn't so bad that he was worth the shedding of American blood? But there are other dictators just as bad whom we leave in place? But he provided Bush the opportunity to establish the doctrine of preemptive war, in which case the cure is worse than the disease? But we should have secured Afghanistan before invading Iraq? But we should have secured the cooperation of allies who were no more inclined to depose Saddam than they?or we, as head of an international coalition of the unwilling?were to stop the genocide in Rwanda ten years before? Sure, genocide is bad, but . . .
We might as well credit the president for his one great accomplishment: replacing but with and as a basis for foreign policy. The world is a better place without Saddam Hussein, and we got rid of him. And unless we have become so wedded to the politics of regret that we are obligated to indulge in a perverse kind of nostalgia for the days of Uday and Qusay, we have to admit that it's hard to imagine a world with Saddam still in it. And even before the first stem-winder of the Democratic convention, the possibility of even limited success in Iraq has reduced the loyal opposition to two strategies: either signing up for the oversight role they had envisioned for the UN, or else declaring the whole thing a lost cause, in their own war of preemption.
Of course, Iraq might be a lost cause. It might be a disaster unmitigated and unprecedented. But if we permit ourselves to look at it the way the Republicans look at it?as a historical cause rather than just a cause assumed to be lost?we might be persuaded to see that it's history's judgment that matters, not ours. The United States, at this writing, has been in Iraq fifteen months. At the same point in the Civil War, Lincoln faced, well, a disaster unmitigated and unprecedented. He was losing . He didn't lose, at least in part because he was able to both inspire and draw on the kind of moral absolutism necessary to win wars. Bush has been unable to do the same, at least in part because he is undercut by evidence of his own dishonesty, but also because moral absolutism is nearly impossible to sustain in the glare of a twenty-four-hour news cycle. In a nation incapable of feeling any but the freshest wounds, Bush cannot seek to inspire moral absolutism without his moral absolutism becoming itself an issue?indeed, the issue. He cannot seek to engender certainty without being accused of sowing disarray. And he cannot speak the barest terms necessary for victory in any war?that we will stay the course, through good or through ill, because our cause is right and just, and God is on our side?without inspiring a goodly number of his constituents to aspire to the moral prestige of surrender.
...continued from page 2
Page 3 of 3
THERE IS SUPPOSED TO BE a straight line between Bush's moral absolutism?between his penchant for calling our enemies "evildoers" or even, well, "enemies"?and Guant?namo, and then between Guant?namo and the case of Jose Padilla, and then between Padilla and the depravities of Abu Ghraib. More than a mere demonstration of cause and effect, the line is supposed by those opposed to a second Bush presidency to function as a geometric proof of the proposition that the American position in Iraq is not only untenable but ignoble. It's supposed to prove that victory in any such enterprise is not worth the taint and that withdrawal is tantamount to victory, because it will save the national soul. In fact, it proves something quite different: It proves that just as the existence of the animal-rights movement is said to depend on the increasing American distance from the realities of the farm, the liberal consensus on the war in Iraq depends on the increasing American distance from the realities of soldiering. All Abu Ghraib proves is what Lincoln made clear in his writings, and what any soldier has to know from the moment he sizes up another soldier in the sight of his rifle: that war is undertaken at the risk of the national soul. The moral certainty that makes war possible is certain only to unleash moral havoc, and moral havoc becomes something the nation has to rise above. We can neither win a war nor save the national soul if all we seek is to remain unsullied?pristine. Anyway, we are well beyond that now. The question is not, and has never been, whether we can fight a war without perpetrating outrages of our own. The question is whether the rightness of the American cause is sufficient not only to justify war but to withstand war's inevitable outrages. The question is whether?if the cause is right?we are strong enough to make it remain right in the foggy moral battleground of war.
In 1861, Abraham Lincoln suspended the writ of habeas corpus, and historians today applaud the restraint he displayed in throwing thousands of American citizens in jail. By the middle of 2002, George W. Bush had declared two American citizens enemy combatants, and both men are still in jail at this writing, uncharged. Both presidents used war as a rationale for their actions, citing as their primary constitutional responsibility the protection of the American people. It was not until two years later that Congress took up Lincoln's action and pronounced it constitutionally justified. Our willingness to extend Bush the same latitude will depend on our perception of what exactly we're up against, post-9/11. Lincoln was fighting for the very soul of this country; he was fighting to preserve this country, as a country, and so he had to challenge the Constitution in order to save it. Bush seems to think that he's fighting for the very soul of this country, but that's exactly what many people regard as a dangerous presumption. He seems to think that he is fighting for our very survival, when all we're asking him to fight for is our security, which is a very different thing. A fight for our security? We can handle that; it means we have to get to the airport early. A fight for our survival? That means we have to live in a different country altogether. That means the United States is changing and will continue to change, the way it did during and after the Civil War, with a fundamental redefinition of executive authority. That means we have to endure the constitutional indignity of the president's declaring Jose Padilla an enemy combatant for contemplating the still-uncommitted crime of blowing up a radioactive device in an American city, which seems a constitutional indignity too great to endure, unless we think of the constitutional indignities we'd have to endure if Padilla had actually committed the crime he's accused of planning. Unless we think of how this country might change if we get hit again, and hit big. In defending his suspension of habeas corpus, Lincoln sought to draw the distinction between liberties that are absolute and those that are sustainable in time of war. Bush seems to be relying on the same question, and the same distinction, as an answer to all the lawyers and editorial writers who suggest that if Jose Padilla stays in jail, we are losing the war on terror by abrogating our own ideals.
Losing the war on terror? The terrible truth is that we haven't begun to find out what that really means.
I WILL NEVER FORGET the sickly smile that crossed the president's face when he asked us all to go shopping in the wake of 9/11. It was desperate and a little craven, and I never forgave him for it. As it turned out, though, his appeal succeeded all too well. We've found the courage to go shopping. We've welcomed the restoration of the rule of celebrity. For all our avowals that nothing would ever be the same, the only thing that really changed is our taste in entertainment, which has forsaken the frivolity of the sitcom for the grit on display in The Apprentice . The immediacy of the threat was replaced by the inexplicability of the threat level. A universal war?the war on terror?was succeeded by a narrow one, an elective one, a personal one, in Iraq. Eventually, the president made it easy to believe that the threat from within was as great as the threat from without. That those at home who declared American moral primacy were as dangerous as those abroad who declared our moral degeneracy. That our national security was not worth the risk to our soul. That Abu Ghraib disproved the rightness of our cause and so represented the symbolic end of the war that began on 9/11. And that the very worst thing that could happen to this country would be four more years of George W. Bush. In a nation that loves fairy tales, the president seemed so damned eager to cry wolf that we decided he was just trying to keep us scared and that maybe he was just as big a villain as the wolf he insisted on telling us about. That's the whole point of the story, isn't it? The boy cries wolf for his own ends, and after a while people stop believing in the reality of the threat.
I know how this story ends, because I've told it many times myself. I've told it so many times, in fact, that I'm always surprised when the wolf turns out to be real, and shows up hungry at the door, long after the boy is gone.
by oz_media
I think this is ONE mans realization that pulling out of Iraq now would be a horrible mistake, which everyone prety much agrees with.
That even though he originally saw Bush as a villain he now sees the inevitability of the ivasion in Iraq. That he now understands that a war on terorism must be just that, regardless of a single focus.
A few points I do not really agree with, 9/11 without any warning, well that's a thin line but yes I will agree it wasn't a waged war and simply what the 'Christian' world considers as an act of terrorism, while another race sees as an act of bravery and support of what they FEEL is thier religion.
This in no way covers the issues that bother me though, a premature invasion is not justified anywhere in this document. It merely see a justification for the invasion in general, which even I can agree on.
You were asked to wait a few weeks fro insectors to finish, Bush said no way and then proceeded to warn America of saddam's ability and intent to attack the USA. Of course he is a teeor, of course Iraq needs to be liberated, but why did you reuse to wait for support of the allies? Why did you refuse to let the UN finish thier job, especially when they were successfully completig it? Why did American's feel they were savig thier lives and it needed to be done immediately, when allies had suggested waiting for the UN's finished inspection report?
Was GWB scared that nothing would show up and then he would have a harder time justifying the invasion?
Was GWB scared that perhaps his allies wouldn't support him unless an imminent threat was identified?
Either way he lost that one I suppose, they didn't back his premature invasion either.
So what exactly was the urgency, not the reason, not the end result, the URGENCY behind the invasion? The immediate need to coerce America into action by reporting premature and unconfirmed reports of saddam's WMD? Why not wait and find out for sure, then get the allied nations to go after Saddam's regime in th eface of stoppi gglobal terrorism, instead of suspected WMD? the terrorism approach would have been received with open arms by the allies. When you tout an unconfirmed premise, people are goig to be somewhat leery of your true intent, thus no support from the allies.
IF GWB had waited, whether or not WMD were discovered by the inspectors, I am sure you would have received gobal allied support, lost fewer lives, had better support financially and in military numbers etc.
yes I know I am backtrackig and repeating the rhetorical reasons I have all along, but to me THAT'S the bottom line. Not so much WHO you are stopping, WHO you are helping or WHO's country you are invading. But WHY were your allies ignored, nobody said to wait another ten years, or even ten weeks, just until inspectors had completed thier job and returned a full report.
Bush was blatantly RUDE to not abide by the wishes of others that you all rely on heavily economically and in battle. He SPAT in the face of alliance, he pissed the bed of allegiance, he stabed his allies in the back.
And yet you get upset when people don't back him.
Tell you what, I'll come down to your home to help you dig a new pool in the backyard. When you want me to wait until the cement is dry, I'll just start filling her up anyway. IF you get pissed off, I will just keep filling the pool and say FU, I need to go swimming because it's best for MY back.
Will we be digging a pool togethe NEXT summer, I thik not. Are you a jerk for not wanting to dig a pool with me after I filled it prematurely? Of course not, my back needed it.
What's wrong with that picture?
I am a knob who intended to help and simply filled your still wet cement pool with water because I needed to save my sore back.
I am justified in saying my back was sore and I needed to swim though, so whether or not I made a mess of your pool, or went against your ideas that would have not made a mess of your pool, I am still right because I needed to swim.
MY back was sore NOT yours, I was looking out for myself, NOT you, even if the pool is a big mud puddle now.
by protiusx
Just as no man is an island unto himself I understand that the United States of America is not an isolated country but one country (albeit a very powerful country) in many. We do however, maintain our sovereignty which is to say that we will do what we will in the world if it furthers the best interests of our country. We are not a vassal state of France or Germany or any other country. We do not need permission from the UN or any other organization to do what we must to protect our people and our interests.
If the UN doesn't like it - tough. If France doesn't like it - tough. I think you get my meaning. Has any other country in the last three hundred years done so much for the world at large than the US? Did France come to our aid in WWII? Did Germany send aid to the furthest reaches of the globe during WWI? Did China send food to the USSR during the 50's when the Russians were starving?
by garion11
The world is a better place without Saddam Hussein, but . . . but what ? But he wasn't so bad that we had to do anything about him? But he wasn't so bad that he was worth the shedding of American blood? But there are other dictators just as bad whom we leave in place? But he provided Bush the opportunity to establish the doctrine of preemptive war, in which case the cure is worse than the disease? But we should have secured Afghanistan before invading Iraq? But we should have secured the cooperation of allies who were no more inclined to depose Saddam than they?or we, as head of an international coalition of the unwilling?were to stop the genocide in Rwanda ten years before? Sure, genocide is bad, but . . .
But here are some more points...
The Coalition of the Willing
Afghanistan: Afghanistan has pledged its support for the U.S. backed effort to disarm Iraq.
Albania: Offered to send troops. Approved U.S. use of airspace and bases.
Angola:
Australia: Sent 2,000-strong force of elite SAS troops, fighter jets and warships to the Gulf.
Azerbaijan:
Bahrain: Headquarters of the U.S. Fifth Fleet.
Bulgaria: Offered use of airspace, base and refueling for U.S. warplanes; sent 150 non-combat troops specializing in chemical and biological warfare decontamination.
Canada: Sent military planners to join U.S. counterparts at their command post in Qatar. A destroyer and two frigates sent to the region could protect U.S. ships.
Colombia:
Croatia: Airspace and airports open to civilian transport planes from the coalition.
Czech Republic: Sent non-combat troops specializing in chemical warfare decontamination in response to U.S. request.
Denmark: The government decided to take part in the military action with submarine, surface ships, and a medical team comprised of 70 elite Jaegerkorps soldiers.
Dominican Republic:
El Salvador
Eritrea
Estonia
Ethiopia: Ethiopia has publicly pledged its support for the U.S. backed effort to disarm Iraq.
Georgia: Georgia has expressed strong support for the U.S. attack on Iraq, and has offered both its airspace and military bases to support the campaign.
Greece: U.S. naval base in Crete serves U.S. sixth fleet and supports Navy and Air Force intelligence-gathering planes.
Honduras:
Hungary: Hosts a U.S. base where Iraqi exiles are trained for possible post-war administrative roles. NATO can use the country?s roads, railways and airspace to carry military support for Turkey?s defense. May open airspace for U.S. military flights.
Iceland:
Italy: Offered logistical help and use of military bases and ports under longstanding NATO commitments.
Japan: Japan expressed unequivocal support for U.S. plans to forcibly disarm Iraq. Will provide post-conflict assistance.
Jordan: Opened its airspace to coalition planes; hosts U.S. troops carrying out search and rescue operations in western Iraq and manning a Patriot anti-missile defense system.
Kuwait: Hosts coalition forces massed for an invasion.
Latvia: Government has authorized the deployment of a small number of troops.
Lithuania: Authorized use of airspace for U.S. backed mission to disarm Iraq.
Macedonia:
Marshall Islands:
Micronesia:
Mongolia:
Netherlands: Several hundred Dutch troops are stationed in Turkey to operate three Patriot missile defense systems, allowing movement of U.S. troops and supplies from Germany through the Netherlands en route to the Persian Gulf.
Nicaragua
Norway: Offered to send 10,000 chemical warfare suits to Turkey.
Philippines: The Philippine National Security Council offered political support for a U.S. led war to disarm Iraq.
Poland: To deploy up to 200 troops in the Gulf region, which will perform an unspecified non-combat role, supporting the U.S.-led offensive. More than 100 Grom elite commando troops and transport ship already stationed in the Gulf area, as part of the Afghanistan campaign, has been offered to be enlisted.
Portugal: Made available NATO air bases and an air base in the Azores.
Qatar: Hosts a mobile HQ for U.S. Central Command; allowed Washington to expand an airfield to handle more combat jets.
Romania: Airspace and a base open to U.S. warplanes; sent non-combat specialists in chemical decontamination, medics, engineers and military police in response to a U.S. request. Will make available Black Sea air and naval bases.
Rwanda:
Saudi Arabia: U.S. and British planes use its Prince Sultan Air Base to enforce a "no-fly zone" over southern Iraq.
Singapore:
Slovakia: Sent non-combat troops specializing in chemical warfare decontamination in response to a U.S. request. Has approved U.S. flyovers and use of its bases.
Slovenia: Signed the Vilnius 10 declaration supporting the United States
Solomon Islands:
South Korea: Seoul will dispatch some 500 army engineers to support a U.S. led war on Iraq, in addition to post-war assistance.
Spain: Strongest ally of the United States and Britain. Promised use of its NATO bases for a strike on Iraq. Spain will send a medical support vessel equipped with nuclear, biological and chemical treatment facilities. A frigate and 900 troops will accompany the support vessel in the event of a conflict.
Taiwan: Taipei opened its airspace to U.S. military aircraft.
Turkey: Hosts U.S. planes enforcing "no-fly" zone in northern Iraq. Parliament has rejected a resolution to allow use of airspace and deployment of American troops for an attack on Iraq but the cabinet was to debate the resolution again on Tuesday with a possible parliamentary vote on Wednesday. (Update: 3/19 Turkey has granted the United States the use of its airspace.)
Uganda:
Ukraine: Agreed to U.S. request that it send chemical warfare and nuclear decontamination experts
United Arab Emirates: Base for U.S. reconnaissance aircraft and refueling; host to an estimated 3,000 western troops. Has pledged 4,000 troops supported by Apache attack helicopters, Leclerc tanks, BMP3 amphibious armored vehicles, a missile boat and a frigate to defend Kuwait in case of war in Iraq.
United Kingdom: Washington's chief ally on Iraq has sent or committed 45,000 military personnel, planes and warships.
Uzbekistan
France, Germany, and Russia opposed us. Thats not the whole world, nor is it every ally.
"the crisis, that is, that announced itself on the morning of September 11, 2001, in New York and Pennsylvania and the District of Columbia?is as compelling a justification for the havoc and sacrifice of war as the crisis that became irrevocable on April 12, 1861, in South Carolina, or, for that matter, the crisis that emerged from the blue Hawaiian sky on December 7, 1941. I, for one, believe it is and feel somewhat ashamed having to say so: having to aver that 9/11/01 was a horror sufficient to supply Bush with a genuine moral cause rather than, as some would have it, a mere excuse for his adventurism."
"The issue is not whether the United States should be involved in a war on terrorism but rather whether the war on terrorism is best served by war in Iraq. And now that the war has defied the optimism of its advocates, the issue is no longer Bush's moral intention but rather his simple competence. He got us in when he had no idea how to get us out. He allowed himself to be blinded by ideology and blindsided by ideologues. His arrogance led him to offend the very allies whose participation would have enabled us to win not just the war but the peace. His obsession with Saddam Hussein led him to rush into a war that was unnecessary. Sure, Saddam was a bad guy. Sure, the world is a better place without him. But . "
BUT!!!!!!!!!
Another point
"well that's a thin line but yes I will agree it wasn't a waged war and simply what the 'Christian' world considers as an act of terrorism, while another race sees as an act of bravery and support of what they FEEL is thier religion."
I am not sure what "the Christian world" is, because I am neither Christian nor Jewish. What did happen on 9/11 was war, an unprovoked act of war AGAINST civlians. It was not against the military, nor governments. It was against civlians.
"while another race sees as an act of bravery and support of what they FEEL is thier religion."
If another "race" considers this an act of bravery and support (an attack on civilians intentially), doesn't that tell you who is right and who is wrong? Doesn't that show you who is right and who is wrong? Doesn't it have show our so called "Allies" exactly who is right and who is wrong? If your ideology and moral values are the same as freedom loving people around the world, on that morning and since then, shouldn't it have shown you who is right and who is wrong?
"The attack was not a gesture of heroic resistance nor the offshoot of some bright utopian resolve, but the very flower of a movement that delights in the potential for martyrdom expressed in the squalls of the newly born. It is a movement that is about death?that honors death, that loves death, that fetishizes death, that worships death, that seeks to accomplish death wherever it can, on a scale both intimate and global?and if it does not warrant the expenditure of what the self-important have taken to calling "blood and treasure," then what does? Slavery? Fascism? Genocide? Let's not flatter ourselves: If we do not find it within ourselves to identify the terrorism inspired by radical Islam as an unequivocal evil?and to pronounce ourselves morally superior to it?then we have lost the ability to identify any evil at all, and our democracy is not only diminished, it dissolves into the meaninglessness of privilege."
Nuff said.
by k_needles
Boy, is that a stretch. You accuse Kerry of stealing our money if he gets into office. What do you think Bush has been doing over the last four years! He has outdone Reagan with a deficit. He has stolen money that Congress voted for Afghanistan and put it into Iraq even before his war was declared. I kind of think that that was anti-democratic, HUH! I haven't reaped any benefits of his tax cuts. And I am still looking for a job to replace the one I lost in 2002 with budget cuts!
Billions have been blown overseas, America is being financed and is liened to foreign countries, mainly China and Japan, our infrastructure is a disaster, our schools are crumbling, and our firefighters, police officers, and first responders are being hauled off to Iraq to fight without the proper weapons and armored vehicles needed.
I financially can't afford another four years of George Bush, so who do you recommend as an alternative? Nader?
.
...that I was asking you to itemize.
A targeted tax cut (or anything else you mentioned) does not equal stealing.
Language is a beautiful thing if the correct words are used. But language can also be a misleading thing when those words are used incorrectly.
Personally, I think better dialogue results when we avoid misusing the language. And the use of "stealing", in this case, is a misuse of the language - not to mention how it reduces the credibility of your overall comments.
.
I encourage you to follow your principle and vote for Ralph NAder. My hat's off to you.
by oz_media
It's not black ad white and only some see the white.
You make statements and quote what YOU feel are facts from YOUR trusted sources.
I may also make statements ad quote what I feel are facts from sources I trust.
The fact that you DON'T believe in my sources and DO believe in your own, does not make you OR your sources correct and vica versa.
As for us BOTH not being right, well this is SOMWHAT true, we can be right in how ad why we formed our opinion but as always the truth eventually comes out and oe side ro the other is proven wrong, AGAIN THOUGH, based on the theories and conclusions of sources YOU may believe.
It's like the whole war garbage, SOME say Bush lied, Others say he was deceptive and stil others say who cares, we hae done some good.
Nobody is really wrong, we really do not know yet. All you have is your own beliefs and opinions that are reflected by the sources YOU choose to believe in.
Even 50 years after the war we probably still won't know the real reasons Bush decided to jump the gun, he just did ad we are all left arguing about it. It is for this specific reason, nobody knows, that I do not like Bush. This is pure deception, on both sides, and nobody may ever really know the truth. We will reach conclusions, we will be told a few different things but we will never know, just speculate based on the sources WE believe in as individuals. In the end, neither may be right and we will never know it.
by oz_media
Well of course you KNEW about it, you also aided and stood by Saddam's side with your heads turned as he used WMD.
Yes everyone knows Saddam was a repressive dictator, the world is full of them that have been left to terrorize thier citizens for years.
My point was that NON of this was given to the citizens of the world to justify the need for an ivasion before weapos ispectors had finished thier job, which they were finally doing successfully.
You can stop he Mister rogers approach, everyone knows you didn't go to Iraq JUST to help Iraqi's. When the war first started this forum was FULL of Americans sayig how it was justified because they were savig America from attack and Saddam WAS in possession of WMD that would be used on America.
Not one single solitary soul even mentioned the foggiest theory of Liberating Iraq OR saving Iraqi's.
After so many people raised concers regarding false informatio0n given to Bush and Blair, the Bush administration started in on the whole Liberation, Operation Iraqi Freedom BS.
Tony Blair realized his misinformation, explained as much and then added that he had received a letter from 3500 Iraqi exiles living in England begging fro him to continue and liberate the Iraqi people.
As this was accepted it was pushed around the globe as the REAL reason for war, and everyone got in line to buy it.
And yes your ideals of helping the world become a better place, taking care of the sick and starving are all fantastic ad very human ideals, but you are seriously fooling yourself if you actually believe THAT is why Bush invaded Iraq. Like you said, it goes against your republican breathren's ideals.
Now lets just assume that there was NO WMD mentioned and you ONLY did it for the better of the Iraqi people, which would be quite commendable, what about the poor, downtrodden, and starving in your own country?
Is this not just another example of failure to see your own problems?
by protiusx
The United States of America has the highest standard of living in the world. I here this argument of "America's starving people" and yet this nation has an epidemic of obesity. How is it that a countries population can be both starving and obese at the same time?
Living where I do I see homeless people on a daily basis. They are not starving. The people I see pan-handling for change look well fed if not overweight.
I am not saying that we do not have our problems but I don't think starvation is one of them. I am not saying that there are not children who go hungry in our country but it is not for lack of a solution or a national desire to help. Americans have a long history of feeding the hungry people of the world.
As far as poor and downtrodden. Hmm. I think we can agree to disagree on the point where I believe people are responsible for their own actions and make of their lives what the will. I do not believe people are slaves to their environments or their circumstances. So, if people are "poor" it is a result of the choices they have made in their lives.
Now downtrodden, you'll have to elaborate on this one for me. Is that a reference to "the man" keeping the people down?
by oz_media
I ws sayign downtrodden in the sense of the have's and the have nots. Yes, ALMOST anyone can become what they want to. Society represses it's own though, I know a close friend who grew up in a not so happy Alabama neighbourhood, half of his friends and family have been shot or stabbed in gang related garbage, he finally had enough and moved to canada whee he met his wife and stated a new life for his children.
he said he sees young kids all the time with such potential being dragged into the same crap he was as a kid. Now these people DO have choices, they CAN make a better life for themselves, it is not even remotely as easy in that sort of situation as it is for you or I though. These people are born doomed and work three times as had as we do to create something better forthemselves.
certainly ANYONE has opportunity, btu we also need to consider HOW much opportunity we give people. Some have it easy when it comes to building a life and career, for some it is virtually impossible without quite the fight, this is because they are born into recession and crime and have to fight from the get go, the future is often lost in the fight.
Starvation, FAT people are not neccessarily well fed. there is a great deal of poverty in Vancouver, the drug slums and skid row are also full of people who are given money for food and forgotten. In these same neighbourhoods, there are not very many 'rooms' with refrigerators, most don't even allow a hot plate. These poeople eat and get fat but is it because they are eatig so much healthy food that they need to loosen the belt a notch or is it because they canot aford decent fod ad live on garbage with no nutritional value instead? no you won't die eatig Kraft dinner and Mr. Noodle but it certainly isn't a healthy diet.
Yes they are fat, they are also hungry, poor, repressed by society and in need of pshychological help in many cases. Why are there more suicides in the 'downtrodden' neighbourhoods than in other neighourhoods? Why do people turn to dugs? (okay many reasons, but being repressed is a big one).
by cactus pete
Fine, we'll drop it, then. Although I must say two things - I don't see where I was being less than civil, and to answer your last question... Because I read your posts. [I have stopped reading many of the others', from both sides, unless the topic and title appear to be less argumentative.]
I've stopped reading many of yours, too, as they are largely responses to others I don't read. But I usually scan for your alias.
.
I read the following message as though you lost your civility towards me, and I considered it a rather surprising and unwarranted blind-side.
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=155787&messageID=1630695
(Spewing my rhetoric????)
Sure, you replied to a message where I insulted the Hollywood types and Bill Clinton, but you replied with insults aimed at me.
But as far as addressing you, I did so in a very respectful manner, and with a lengthy and well-thought out reply.
I must admit, I just don't get where you're coming from.
by protiusx
You speak about these people as if they are being repressed by SOMEONE or a group of people. This is not so. People are repressed by their own actions and choices. People make choices in life and these choices affect not only themselves but the people in their families and in their communities.
I have a choice to pick up a gun, or a crack pipe or a book. I have a choice to respect and love my neighbor or hit him in the head with a brick to take the five dollars in his wallet. Our choices have a ripple effect like a pebble being thrown into a stream. They not only affect us but everyone around us. Sin begets sin.
I choose to pick up a book and a pen and to love my neighbor. I do this because this is what I want in return. Sounds like scripture doesn't it?
by itgirli
by oz_media
If it reflected my own post in anyway I'd probably agree with you.
You completely missed the point though, YES we can make a choice to leave our current BS job and go and fin better.
Yes we choose to learn things and improve ourselves as individuals.
What if you are the son of a crack head, your opportunities are reduced considerably by being born into poverty, neighbouhoods where education levels ae below standard etc. Perr grous will often dictate your future and it takes and EXTREMELY strog will, above average, to get out of it and make something of yourself.
You cannot equate poverty to the choice between hitting your neighbour on the head with a brick as they are both choices.
What an insane analogy!
Have you been poor?
Why have you not chosen to bcome a billionaire? It's YOUR choice and you can do anything you want, and there is no part of society or government that inhibits your ability to succeed and become a billionaire. If it is truly YOUR choice, why don't you become an astronaut or rpesident of the USA? Or are those options NOT available to you?
I am the first person to tell someone it is up to THM to become what they want. People don't like IT and get frustrated, my response is just to do dsomething else instead, we live in a land whee MOST of us can do whatever we want and will be successful at it. Then there's the "other' people, the ones we choose to forget about as it is either ugly or unpleasant to be reminded of the poverty in our own countries.
YES, Many of these people ae there from making the wrong choices, others just never had a fair opportunity.
But lets forget about all of them, they will always be the poor, they will always be the hard-up, why bother after ALL these years of failing to end poverty? We can just Liberate another country instead, at least we have that solution, the US military might will fix things.
by mashane70
My first morning reading the world according garp/s - gee I've missed zip in three years it appears. The discussion, as a mere mortal from the real OZ, as in Ossie, and not as in Osborne, started with a back handed at the Bush administration and the need for supreme power. Read a little deeper and whilst it does have those under/over tones - a reasonable Q. A Southern response, perspective, is also - well why. WAS/IS Saddam a bad dude, open to suggestion however the over whelming Australian population believe that anyone who participates in genocide is not one you want as a neighbour, no matter how far away they live. Without attempting to envoke the wrath of some in this 'discussion' [which appears to have become an emotive slanging match - I'm not going to read the 350 + responses, the first half a dozen were enough] it my considered opinion, and as I said of the majority of OZZIES, that whilst he had to go, the method employed left a lot to be desired. Sure diplomacy was less than effective however consider the bigger picture, and the current situation. Maybe some relevant stats [be what they may] could assist - more US service personnel [and of the coallition] have been killed since the victorious end of the war. More citizens of Iraq have been killed in the last 12 months than in the last 5 years under Saddam. More relief workers in 'modern' peace time [whatever that means]have been killed since the liberation/occupation of Iraq, and more relief agencies on record have deserted a 'secure' country than in history, even those kind and caring but slightly crazy 'doctors without frontiers' , my french sucks, have pulled the pin - unheard of.
The point of this diatribe is - was the right decision made, maybe not! Is the outcome, as they so quaintly put it, 'worth the collateral damage', many would argue NO. So why do it - lots of theories abound, from GE'S profits being down, 'gotta sell a few bombs to get the balance sheet back in order', to 'we need the oil to keep the economy going' [we got plenty - come on up], to 'the USA is the great patriach of the world' and of course arguements 'he has to go at all costs', 'our country is under attack - we must retaliate', 'why are we focusing on a spent force', 'can't peace prevail' etc.
It is sometimes hard to dissemenate the difference between the arguements of the 'fors' and 'against', but not if you think about it.
Possibly threads of truth in most arguements.
So I will leave you with impressions of America, Vs Americans - cos I'm sure based on people I have met who are, or know Americans, don't appear to represent 'America' as the world sees it.
Very insular country which can do no wrong, only comment re 9/11, which I had the mis/fortune to watch live and must say has had a lasting impact both personally and on many people across the world - how can anyone be driven to such bigotted hatred. Did the citizens of the US deserve it, no, did any good come out of it, remains to be seen however if it makes the power brokers reassess the standing of 'AMERICA' in the world forum, maybe.
This is not a yank bashing comment, purely some insights from an outsider, be what they may. The general concensus is americans should truely become a part of the ever growing global community, and look outside America, lots of interesting things and lots of work to be down across the globe, 'have a look outside your own backyard' or more aptly - 'see how the other half live!'
Before I get slagged off, any constructive criticism is fine, read it twice, right down the parts that fired you up, and read it again, totally ignoring the parts that have fired you up, then if you need to, and only then - you may proceed to slag me off or support me, as a wise person once said, 'just as there are two sides to a coin - there are always at least two sides to a story' - if ya got this far well done, regards to one and all, Shane
by oz_media
I think you made a LOT of valid poits, one that gets me is that when I say MOST othes OUTSIDE America see Americans as being arrogant or bullish (holier than thou) I get slagged for not understanding them. Isn't it the other way around though? I understand where they are coming from I would be livid if my coutry was attacked, as it was during the London Blitz. I just see nothing but Americans seeing what is done to themselves and having no concern or knowledge of how they look from the outside inward.
It is always "poor us" you guys don't understand what it's like to be attacked (note: I am originally from England, my country's never been attacked :-) )
or
"What business is it of your's" Nice GLOBAL approach to foreign affairs.
or
"It is my right to protect my family. Why should I wait for others to help when I am threatened" or whatever, you've seen it all.
Anyway, from another OZ, (not from Australia or from Ozzie Osbourne), thanks for the thoughts and Kudos for stepping up to the plate most avoid out of fear of republicans.
by oz_media
You started to make some sense at least as to where you stood, but then you went off on some bizzare and delerious tangent about how nobody helped you in WWI or WWII.
In fact, you were the last of the allied countries to show up for WWI AND WWII, yet ,any Americans CLAIM you won BOTH wars for some odd reason.
Did France come to you Aid in WWII? What the hell is THAT supposed to mean? France was invaded! Canada and the UK thwarted Hitler through several years of continal attempts to take over western Europe, THEN the USA came into the picture. So how exactly was France supposed to be 'aiding' you?
You said "We do not need permission from the UN or any other organization to do what we must to protect our people and our interests."
And I agree, well all but the 'our interests' part. You do not have the right to do whateer suits your interests, if that was so, we'd all be at war still trying to aquire what best suits our agendas. Saddam did whatever he chose to as it was in his best interests, do we then permit it? Don't be ridiculous.
You DO have the right, of course, to "protect our (your)people" ?
How could ANYONE argue about a country saving it's people? I would help you fight the fight for your people.
Fortunately in THIS case, you were not needing to SAVE your people from anyone, thank God!
Or
Are you suggesting that because Saddam at ONE time was KNOWN to possess WMD and you had ignored it the first time, that you had legitimate reasons to feel you are protecting Americans and at NOW it was IMPERATIVE that you act immediately because you knew of some threat that nobody else did?
If so, I apologize pefusely, maybe next time you could inform the world of these threats so we can all be on the same page.
But I will leave it thee, you're obviously confused enough, I know I would be if I was trying to make heads or tails of the current presidents actions.
Bottom line, MOST people DO have a chance to make a better life for themselves, others do not have the same opportunity.
France was invaded several years before the US came to help Great Britain, Canada and Australia fight WWII it is a little had for them to come to your aid at that point. I think you are startig to get quite arogant in your posts, your last post indicates that perhaps you FEEL that YOU saved France and ae now saying why didn't they come to YOUR aid?
Whatever, get with the program first.
by gateboy1
by oz_media
Your post is SO antiquated and typical of an uninformed American. Even your American peers wil say "NOBODY SAYS THAT" if I say Americans think that way.
Britain was NOT ALMOST defeated when you moved in, you did NOT WIN WWII.
The Luftwaffe had TRIED for some time to bomb England into submission (the London Blitz, that would have crippled America beyond comprehension, damn a few planes shut your country down).
the luftwaffe failed to beat the RAF and Hitler was defeated in invading Southern England as he realized he met his match and they weren't submissive like the French(this is why he chose to take France first and try to build bases there, unsuccessfully due to Canadian and British soldiers).
You also seem to forget that at that tme, Canada had a rather formidable military and sent hundreds of thousands of troops to England. You are also forgetting how the US military TODAY relies HEAVILY on Canada's Coyote recon vehicle to conduct battlefield recon at high seed with advanced technology. One such mission ATTEMPTED by a US tank in Iraq ended up in the crew being killed as the tank was not fast enough and not equipped for recon, a few weeks later (after inspectors were finished), Canada may have joined in and these men and women may not be dead, great choice by Bush don't forget to thank him for the families of the dead soldiers.
Your post shows you have been force fed American history propaganda and very little else. Your knowledge of Canada and it's role in previous wars is sad and pathetic at best.
A former associate of mine was a history teacher at UCLA and he quit ater 12 years due to the one sided history he was FORCED to teach and how much of the world's history he was NOT allowed to teach, UNIVERSITY students.
I supose the USA did all the damage on D-Day as well? Whereas Canada was the first to land in France the morning of D-Day with glider patrols that seized key bridges for transporting reinforcemnts to the beaches.
Here's some actual history to help you understand what really happened on D-Day.
http://www.tinyurl.com/yrv3t
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
How America saved the world:
Numbers on D-Day : (Note British sector obviously includes Canadians)
Gold Beach - British sector 24,970 troops.
Juno Beach - British sector 21,400 troops
Sword Beach- British sector 28,845 troops.
TOTAL: 75,214 troops
Utah Beach - American sector 23,250 troops
Omaha beach - American sector 34,250
TOTAL: 57,500 troops.
including Canadian, American and British pilots
the total number is approxinmately 156,000 that landed on D-Day, of which nearly 90,000 were NOT Americans. Now I am not saying you rweren't needed or welcomed and the men who fought were extremely bave men whom I owe my freedom to, but it wasn't just America that ended the war and NO Europans would be speaking German if it wasn't for America, Hitler had been bitch slapped by the RAF and still had sting on his cheek.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
As for your next statement, this is just pure insanity and I don't think you could muster a handful of people to agree with you, well I know a couple but they hardly count.
"As Americans we have the right to say that we saved the world? We took down Hitler and Tojo and afterwards assisted with rebuilding every ones economy, namely the Germans. We have a right to be arrogant and boastful. America has always come to the rescue of other nations and we always will."
You do nto have the right to say you saved the world, no more than I do to say I am president of the USA anway. Now even if by some turn of events, you actually DID save the world (ignoring the others until after being attacked yourselves)you STILL don't hae a right to be arrogant or boastful. What kind of grade school mentality is THAT? God, this forum ticks along well and then some idiot comes and drags america back into the dark ages. It seems that I am always thinking, Americans aren't bad, it's just the one or two who feel the way you do that gives them a bad name. THen ANOTHER comes along, then ANOTHER and ANOTHER!. Yet when I tell your more intelligent peers that's how people see Americans and that Americans all feel they won WWII for some bizzarre reason andsaved the world, they tell me it's pure hogwash, nobody thinks that. Yet along another one comes, ad so on and so on. I am begining to have a solid case again that MOST or MANY Americans are either undereducated or arrogant and that they think they saved the world.
Give your head a shake and go back to school, a REAL school this time.
At least get your facts straight about a war that happened over 60 years ago and has been well documented since.
America WonWWII, what a maroon! :D
by protiusx
Forgive me for being less than clear. I will attempt to clarify here but first I need to discuss some of the points you made about WWII and I shall try to be brief.
France was invaded by Germany as was most of western Europe. During 1939 and 1940 Britain was struggling for it's national existence while Germany was planning an amphibious invasion of the British Isles. During this time Britain was being supplied with food, arms and raw materials streaming in from the United States. Canada having national ties to Britain sent over troops that fought next to all the other countries troops that had been disposesed (i.e. Poland, France, etc). If the United States had not entered the European war as an ally of Great Britain they would have been invaded and things would be very different now.
WWI was the same. France had been defeated and would have ceased to exist if the 'dough boys' hadn't come from 'over there'. Think about it.
My point to all this is that over the last 300 years the United States has stood out as a beckon to the rest of the world. We have been the bread basket to the world and have spent untold monies helping people all over the world make their lives and the lives of their children better. This is because of our national character that is second to none.
Face the facts: France and Germany (The leaders of the UN) didn't want us to invade Iraq because they had substantial financial dealings with Saddam Housien. If he was overthrown they stood to loose a great deal of money. The Russians had supplied Saddam with military technology that he used against us.
Saddam's regime made cash payments to the families of Palestinian suicide bombers to encourage their terrorist activities there. He directly funded terrorists that targeted the US and our citizens overseas. Saddam had manufactured Biological, chemical and nuclear material for use in weaponry to be sold to the highest bidder. Who do you think was bidding on this stuff? Marry Poppins?
by oz_media
Pure crap!
England beat Hitler during the Battle of Britain, the Luftwaffe and RAF were at a stale mate when Hitler realized he had neither the resources or the logistical ability to invade the british Isles, and YES he ahd tried unsuccessfully. YOU DIDN"T SAVE ENGLAND.
in the sense tha AMERICA helps the world surive, if Canada cut off exports to the USA you sure would have some major problems. We power a great deal of California from OUR dams, American companies rely on Vancouver Island for lumber and OWN the North half (that's unprotected), they fish our oceans, they buy our natural gas.
THAT's JUST B.C.! You get something from EVERY Province in Canada, thanks to the one sided NAFTA agreement.
Don't worry, you take as much as you give.
You rely on others just as much as others rely on you.
Yet you feel you are all out to savet the world, my god would you guys get a life already ad get with the program? You're just ANOTHER country, and a VERY young and inexperienced one at that.
by garion11
One way or the other, we are determined to deny Iraq the capacity to develop weapons of mass destruction and the missiles to deliver them. That is our bottom line." - President Clinton, Feb. 4, 1998
"If Saddam rejects peace and we have to use force, our purpose is clear. We want to seriously diminish the threat posed by Iraq's weapons of mass destruction program." - President Clinton, Feb. 17, 1998
"Iraq is a long way from [here], but what happens there matters a great deal here. For the risks that the leaders of a rogue state will use nuclear, chemical or biological weapons against us or our allies is the greatest security threat we face." - Madeline Albright, Feb 18, 1998
"He will use those weapons of mass destruction again, as he has ten times since 1983." - Sandy Berger, Clinton National Security Adviser, Feb, 18, 1998
"We urge you, after consulting with Congress, and consistent with the U.S. Constitution and laws, to take necessary actions (including, if appropriate, air and missile strikes on suspect Iraqi sites) to respond effectively to the threat posed by Iraq's refusal to end its weapons of
mass destruction programs." - Letter to President Clinton, signed by Sens. Carl Levin (D-MI), Tom Daschle (D-SD), John Kerry ( D - MA), and others Oct. 9, 1998
"Saddam Hussein has been engaged in the development of weapons of mass destruction technology which is a threat to countries in the region and he has made a mockery of the weapons inspection process." - Rep. Nancy Pelosi (D, CA), Dec. 16, 1998
"Hussein has ... chosen to spend his money on building weapons of mass destruction and palaces for his cronies." - Madeline Albright, Clinton Secretary of State, Nov. 10, 1999
"There is no doubt that ... Saddam Hussein has invigorated his weapons programs. Reports indicate that biological, chemical and nuclear programs continue apace and may be back to pre-Gulf War status. In addition, Saddam continues to redefine delivery systems and is doubtless using the cover of a licit missile program to develop longer-range missiles that will threaten the United States and our
allies." - Letter to President Bush, Signed by Sen. Bob Graham (D, FL,) and others, December 5, 2001
"We begin with the common belief that Saddam Hussein is a tyrant and threat to the peace and stability of the region. He has ignored the mandate of the United Nations and is building weapons of mass destruction and the means of delivering them." - Sen. Carl Levin (D, MI), Sept. 19, 2002
"We know that he has stored secret supplies of biological and chemical weapons throughout his country." - Al Gore, Sept. 23, 2002
"Iraq's search for weapons of mass destruction has proven impossible to deter and we should assume that it will continue for as long as Saddam is in power." - Al Gore, Sept. 23, 2002
"We have known for many years that Saddam Hussein is seeking and developing weapons of mass destruction." - Sen. Ted Kennedy (D, MA), Sept. 27, 2002
"The last UN weapons inspectors left Iraq in October of 1998. We are confident that Saddam Hussein retains some stockpiles of chemical and biological weapons, and that he has since embarked on a crash course to build up his chemical and biological warfare capabilities. Intelligence
reports indicate that he is seeking nuclear weapons...." - Sen. Robert Byrd (D, WV), Oct. 3, 2002
"I will be voting to give the President of the United States the authority to use force-- if necessary-- to disarm Saddam Hussein because I believe that a deadly arsenal of weapons of mass destruction in his hands is a real and grave threat to our security." - Sen. John F. Kerry (D, MA), Oct. 9, 2002
"There is unmistakable evidence that Saddam Hussein is working aggressively to develop nuclear weapons and will likely have nuclear weapons within the next five years . We also should remember we have always underestimated the progress Saddam has made in development of
weapons of mass destruction." - Sen. Jay Rockefeller (D, WV), Oct 10, 2002
"He has systematically violated, over the course of the past 11 years, every significant UN resolution that has demanded that he disarm and destroy his chemical and biological weapons, and any nuclear capacity. This he has refused to do." - Rep. Henry Waxman (D, CA), Oct. 10, 2002
"In the four years since the inspectors left, intelligence reports show that Saddam Hussein has worked to rebuild his chemical and biological weapon stock, his missile delivery capability, and his nuclear program. He has also given aid, comfort, and sanctuary to terrorists, including al Qaeda members. It is clear, however, that if left unchecked Saddam Hussein will continue to increase his capacity to wage biological and chemical warfare, and will keep trying to develop nuclear weapons." - Sen. Hillary Clinton (D, NY), Oct 10, 2002
"We are in possession of what I think to be compelling evidence that Saddam Hussein has, and has had for a number of years, a developing capacity for the production and storage of weapons of mass destruction." - Sen. Bob Graham (D, FL), Dec. 8, 2002
"Without question, we need to disarm Saddam Hussein. He is a brutal, murderous dictator, leading an oppressive regime ... He presents a particularly grievous threat because he is so consistently prone to miscalculation .. And now he is miscalculating America's response to his continued deceit and his consistent grasp for weapons of mass destruction... So the threat of Saddam Hussein with weapons of mass
destruction is real." - Sen. John F. Kerry (D, MA), Jan. 23. 2003
SO NOW THESE SAME DEMOCRATS SAY PRESIDENT BUSH LIED, THAT THERE NEVER WERE ANY WEAPONS OF MASS DESTRUCTION, AND THAT HE TOOK US TO WAR UNECESSARILY !
Politics of power indeed.
by oz_media
EVERYONE in the entire planet KNOWS Saddam HAD WMD at some point. The US knew it and ignored it before when Saddam was using them against US enemies.
Clinton MADE AN EFFORT by bombing the hell out of the known training camps. unfortunately, Bin Laden was gone already and was held as a hero for thwarting Clinton's attempts to kill him, THIS was when Osama became the most popular ame for newborn boys in Afghanistan.
So there's ONE democrat who did NOT ignore the issue.
Saddam was told to disarm because we KNEW he had WMD, he SAID he did.
Nobody believed him, so weapons inspectors ad all the BS started over failed inspections, allowing them back in, Oil for Food, US ad Iraqi sanction breacjes and the story goes on and on.
After all this, Saddam had started letting inspectors actually finish inspecting, at this point I think he knew the USA was playing hardball. They found nothing. Saddam said he had disarmed, the USA didn't believe him, still inspectors found nothing. Saddam again said he had disarmed, yet "inside" sources (that those who had used this informant before SAID they weren't sure of) said he stil had WMD. This caused Bush to pull out the inspectors, WHILE they were successfully doing thier jobs, and order a premature invasion of Iraq based on the premise that Saddam was harbouring WMD and would eventually use them against the USA. Whereas it was more likely he'd use them on GB or other european coutries first, this would give the USA the opportunity to JUSTLY go to war again on another continent and they could say how they saved the world fom WWIII (oh what fun you all would have had!).
But no. Saddam said he had disarmed WMD. you invaded because you didn't believe him OR the weapons inspectors because a sketchy informant said otherwise. Way to use your resources!
You invaded anyway, because the Iraqi informant was deemed more credible than the weapons inspectors or allied countries.
Now America is pissed at the wold for NOT supporting the act of ignorig allies and doing as you please with no justifiable reasons given.
like many rom OUTSIDE America have said, you just need to see yoruselvs from the outside in, the same way you judge every other country from the outside in.
by aldanatech
by protiusx
I think I would ask you for some proof of your claims. If what you say is true why is not congress or anyone else pushing for criminal charges? I think you are allowing your emotion to get the best of your reason.
I hear a lot of this nonsense from leftists. It is usually do to a lack of a clear and concise argument. What is your point here? Do you honestly believe that the President of the United States STOLE government funds? I think you need a lesson in political science, government and the powers of the Presidential office.
If you have not benefited from keeping more of your own money then perhaps you don't need a job. I for one among millions have realized a benefit from the tax cuts. I keep more of my money which is a good thing.
As for military spending: Perhaps you should talk to someone who has been or is in the military before you pass judgment. Bill Clinton and the democratic left spent eight years during the last decade dessimating our military just as it was dessimated in the 70's by Jimmy Carter.
As for China - Perhaps we should ask Mr. Clinton about his dealings with the Chinese and what technologies were transfered to that COMMUNIST government during his tenure in office?
As for our Infrastructure? Please give a good example and explain how George W. Bush has adversely affected this system during his presidency.
Please explain how George W. Bush caused you personally to loose your job. Can't? Then please explain how any United States President can cause a non-government worker to loose their job (unless your talking about how Reagan fired the union air traffic controllers back in the 80's).
by gateboy1
by aldanatech
.
In reply to:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=155787&messageID=1631668
(posted here because maximum thread had been reached)
First of all, I must say (with no reflection on yourself) that I'm really getting tired of these types of discussions. The same things are argued over and over again, sometimes with the same people, sometimes with different people. You (and others) clearly have an ax to grind with President Bush, and you'll not concede a single point or give him credit for anything. Conversely, I (and others), who support President Bush, and believe that he's acting in the best interest of the USA, will defend his actions at all costs. So round-and-round we go, where it stops depends on who gets tired first.
I'm beginning to feel like the dope in this rope-a-dope, because I realize that I'll change no one's mind, I'll not influence a single thing, and I certainly know that I have better things to do with my time than to argue with an America-hating Canadian (or America-hating American) or some other equally closed-minded person. (I know, I'm the one who's closed-minded, or so they say. And that's my point.) Hell, I've even pissed-off some people that I would have preferred not to piss-off, nor did I intend to piss-off. In short, this is a colossal waste of time, and it will achieve absolutely nothing.
However, I'm willing to go one more round (but don't ask me why). You and I, or Oz and I, or Julian and I, or any number of people and I will never agree on anything concerning President Bush and the war on terrorism. You guys have your bias, and I have mine. You guys look at it one way, while I look at it another way. But I'll try once more to articulate my position, my thoughts, my observations, and so on - and hopefully without offending anyone.
I believe, for example, that the actions in Iraq are part of the bigger and overall war on terrorism. Apparently, you don't. I believe that Saddam Hussein had both the willingness and the capacity to contribute, in some way, to future terrorist attacks. Apparently, you don't. I believe that, after putting up with forty years of world-wide terrorism, and seeing how ineffective the United Nations - and the past four American administrations - have been to put a stop to it, that the USA (and President Bush) has a right to preemptively strike a target - wherever it may be - to prevent a future attack such as the one we experienced on 9-11. Apparently you don't. I believe that any nation-state that sponsors or supports world-wide terrorism in any way whatsoever - regardless of how involved that nation-state may or may not be in the actual perpetration of terrorism, is not only a threat to the USA, but to the world as a whole. Apparently you don't. I think it's time to finally put our foot down, saying enough is enough, and we're going to dedicate every resource necessary to stop world-wide terrorism. Apparently you don't.
I don't think the "terrorists" will stop with negotiations and talks. Apparently you do. You think that the only way to stop them is to, as you said, "convince them that their efforts don't work". I, on the other hand, believe that the only way to stop them is to kill them (in self-defense), and to establish a basis to prevent future generations (of terrorists) from being taught their hatred of the western world. You think that people like me have been "brain-washed" by the Bush administration; however, I give myself more credit than that, and realize that I'm extremely informed - perhaps the most well-read person who participates in these discussions (speculation, I know). I think, however, that it's the terrorists who have been "brain-washed".
I'll concede the point that the suspected stockpiles of WMDs have not been found. However, while you (and others) want to hold President Bush solely responsible for this miscalculation (if it was indeed a miscalculation), I believe that the whole world should shoulder the burden of responsibility. Absolutely everyone - the UN, the UK, the Democrats, the Republicans, Al Gore, Bill Clinton, George Bush, Colin Powell - absolutely the whole world - believed this to be the case. I believe it's most disingenuous to blame only President Bush for this miscalculation (if it was indeed a miscalculation). Moreover, I believe that the more important question is either, how was the whole world duped in such a way, or where in the hell did they go? Apparently you're content with simply grinding your ax to discredit President Bush. I'm willing to give him the benefit of the doubt, believing he acted in the best interest of the USA.
You believe that no significant WMDs have been found. I, on the other hand, believe the reports that suggest they were sent to Syria in the days and weeks before the war; and I also believe that the chemical weapons that were confiscated in a thwarted terrorist attack in Jordan - chemical weapons that could have killed 20,000 to 80,000 people - probably had their origins in Iraq. (I've mentioned these things probably a dozen times, by the way, but no one has ever challenged or questioned the accuracy of the reports.)
I believe that France and Germany are (were) selfishly looking to protect their own self-interest, that they were conspirators in oil-for-food scams, that they accepted bribes and kick-backs, that they had a huge financial interest in keeping Saddam Hussein in power, that they want to establish themselves as some sort of "super-power" in the new European Union, and that they were acting in a way that was contrary to the best-interest of the world in standing up against world-wide terrorism. (The fact that the Muslim population in France is quite significant may have something to do with it - at least in my opinion).
Without even realizing it, at least as I read it, you even contradicted yourself in your very own message. Early in your message, you suggested that the action in Afghanistan was only successful in unseating the Taliban. But later in your message, you suggested that al-Queda is "everywhere". Well, which is it? I believe it's common knowledge that the ruling Taliban in Afghanistan, while not directly involved in the 9-11 attacks, were harboring terrorists. You believe that the actions in Afghanistan didn't result in weakening al-Queda. I believe the reports that indicate al-Queda was significantly weakened (killed or captured), that many of their "leaders" were killed or captured, and that we have them on the run. I believe that we can - and should - fight the "terrorists" on more than one front at a time. You, apparently, disagree.
I believe that most of the "insurgents" in Iraq are "terrorists" themselves, or sympathizers of al-Queda, who came into that country in an attempt to foil the American's efforts to establish some semblance of a democracy in the region - something that's vital in the longer-term goal of establishing a basis to prevent future generations (of terrorists) from being taught their hatred of the western world. (Democracy, freedom, and liberty have a way of being contagious.) You, apparently, don't think so. I remember the January 2003 tape of Osama bin Laden calling for al-Queda to go to Iraq to fight the Americans. Apparently, you don't remember. I do, however, feel sorry for the good people of Iraq who have to deal with the fact that their country is being used as a battle-ground. But if not there and now, I must wonder where and when? In my opinion, it's better to fight them on our terms and with our Army, than in the streets of Boston or some other world city.
I believe that the transformation of Iraq is vital in the longer-term goal of changing the pattern of teaching hate. I hear this nonsense about "waiting a few more weeks for the weapons inspectors to finish their work" as justification to oppose the action in Iraq, but I have to wonder what's been going on for the twelve year prior. If it couldn't be done in twelve years, what makes a person think that a few weeks would make a difference? I remember that Saddam Hussein was urged - by both the USA and neighboring Arab nations - to leave Iraq and live in exile in any one of a number of countries that would host him. Apparently, you don't remember those pleas.
I believe that Libya, a known sponsor of terrorism, surrendered without a single shot being fired (directly against them), and it was probably out of fear that they may indeed be next. I believe that Jordan, who sided with Iraq in the first Gulf War, is beginning to capitulate to the reality that the world, in general, and the USA, in particular, will not tolerate the proliferation of world-wide terrorism any longer.
In short, I believe that we are on the right path to correcting the miscalculations of the past forty years, while you (and others) apparently don't.
I also believe that today, while America is being criticized for "acting alone". even though other nations are indeed contributing to the effort, if we succeed we will not get any of the credit, but if we fail, we will have to shoulder all the blame. I believe that many of the civilized and industrialized nations off the world - Canada, France, Germany, and Russia, in particular - are turning their backs on a much needed campaign to eradicate the world of such terror, and are missing out on the opportunity to bring freedom and liberty to a piece of the world that has known only oppression.
Every day, I pray for the well-being of those on the front lines of this most selfless and noble effort. Every day I pray that God give President Bush the strength and resolve to continue on the right path. And every day, I wonder why I see things so differently than so many. Perhaps, some day, we'll know the answers. But I fear that we may be dead and gone before we really do.
by oz_media
I know your stand you've always been pretty clear in your convictions, with only a few exceptions where you've contradicted yourself probably from frustration.
I cannot agree with how you think the war is seen by others, well I'm sure some see it that way but for the most part I don't. For example, I don't disbelieve that Saddam was an evil dictator who needed to be removed, I disagree with the timimng, not the action as you should know.
Yes I agree there were WMD, perhaps they WERE moved, if so go after THEM not Iraq, unless of course you want to Liberate Iraq, then so be it.
Just don't confuse the issue to gain support.
AlQAEDA, well yes it was a valiant atempt and one I could see a good end to, but then it was over, troops were pullled ad Iraq was on the list?! WHat about Afghanistan, there's not enough troops or support there. I too have heard several times from different sources that they KNOW AlWaeda is rebuilding and is finding new alliances to form against the common goal of terrorising America, being so news savvy you can't imply this is new to you, can you?
Yes you probably are on the right path to clean up all the past mistakes, yes Iraqi's will be better off one day, but what has this done to America and allies who have REALLY turned on you? Not just Germany and rance but almost all the world's countries are against this invasion. People in England are just as pissed at Blair as people in America and Canada are at Bush.
It will be a LONG time before people trust these nations governments again.
To conclude, I agree wholeheartedly that these discussions willNEVER solve anything for the exact same resons you have cited, we believe different sources and have different core values, neither is worng or right (yet) and we may never know who is/was in the future.
And every time we get to this point, someone signs up on TR and reads an old post from 2003 and makes some ridiculous post about how America shoudl KICK ASS and everyone should shut up and mind thier own business or end up like the Germans did in WWII.
and so the world turns...round and round and round and round and round and....sigh. :l
by admin
"He who controls the past commands the future. He who commands the future conquers the past."
As Orwell eloquently points out, for me, it is worth debating.
I for one, have a better future in my belief that George Bush may be a very principled good person. This has largely come about slowly through watching you construct your sides of debates here at TR. It does make a difference.
At any rate, I believe we are all in the ongoing process of creating what we know and there is no better way to know solidly than the rigors of discussion and debate. Win or lose, one side, the other or even many others, we all benefit by improving our own opinions when we put it out there for the world to see and then reflect.
IMO -Every time an individual voice dies we are left with an incomplete history and answers that are, well, less than complete.
I want to step towards the complete answer. The one that may be more difficult to reach, yet the one in which we can move forward as humans taking a hold of the future with a complete grasp and commanding more positive outcomes for all. The complete answer requires complete participation.
We won't passively know the answers. We will have decided whether or not to participate in their creation. At the end of the day, or even our lives, we may not know how many people have have read the threads here, nor their level of impact, but the possibility that they have been of some positive outcome to our future is much higher than if we were to say nothing- to remain silent believing we are inneffectual because only the people in the thread who write back are impacted by this. You have no idea who will read this over time or how they will be impacted and touched.
Proclaim liberty, truth and knowledge loud and often. If not you, you the reader of this- if not you, who will command the future?
:)
by garion11
One thing we can all agree on is...
We are all a bunch of political hacks and junkies working almost entirely with speculation, with a sprinkling of ignorance and a pinch of bitterness.
Only time will tell where this world is going to be in the next 50 years.
by oz_media
Based on our sources and our standing on political ladder, we know SQUAT. Diddly, just what we've been told or choose to believe.
As far as bitterness, I would say it is Screaming for Vengeance (gotta love the boys of JP).
Hey listen don't you let them get your mind
Fill your brain with orders and that's not right.
They're playing at a game that draws you closer
Till you're living in a world that's ruled by fear.
Always takin' baby out that's o.k.
What they're givin' maybe it's out of phase with me.
Told you once you're never gonna win the race
Same old no tomorrow kicked in the face.
We are screaming, screaming for vengeance
The world is a manacled place.
Screaming, screaming for vengeance
The world is defiled in disgrace.
Tie a blindfold all around your head
Spin you 'round in the torture before the dread.
And then you're pushed and shoved into every corner
Then they lead you out into the final slaughter.
As the sweat is runnin' down your neck
All your praying for's to stop your body breakin' up.
Oh your heart is pumpin' gonna soon explode
Got to fight the horror of this mental load.
So you wait it out and bide your time
Rip off that straight jacket gotta break that line.
Everyone who wins in the great escape
Leaves a thousand more who suffer in their wake.
I don't talk about it but that's alright
Table's turned now there's a revenge in sight.
If it takes forever babe I tell ya I can wait
Send them screaming back through their hell's own gate.
]:)
by garion11
Yeah, yeah we know, Canada contributed. Noone ever said they didn't. Did you know what I found out recently about Canadians?
The Canadian people are the former American colonists (about 50,000) who opposed the American Revolution and supported the British, before, during, and after the war. After America gained its independence, these people left to go and live in Canada, LOL. Now that makes a LOT of sense as to the Canadian attitude about America, sheesh. LOL
The point of WWII was, if Neville Chamberlain (sp) and the French had only, HAD ONLY stood up to Hitler (instead of bending over like they did), like Bush I, Clinton, and Bush II stood up to Saddam, WWII might have never happened.
Good job, you dragged the whole world into war by your stupid, arrogant, thickheaded cowardness, sigh. (which obviously continues today). Now you are blaming Bush of the exact same thing?? LOL...Oz you are a funny old duck.
by garion11
OZ, for some odd reason, US has the largest economy in the world by far, I am sure we are doing something right, instead of consuming Canada's??? natural resources, LOL.
Yes, noone ever disputed in today's world of global trade, we all need one another. The point is, US does pay for your imports, Canada is not giving this stuff away for free, lol.
What he means by helping other countries is the Foreign Aid and innovation. Did any Canadian invent the Internet?? or a British for that matter? It began as a US DOD project...funded by the US government and my tax money. So...um...wait...holy cow...I invented the Internet.
Anyway, all joking aside, here is a link to America inventors and innovation.
http://inventors.about.com/library/bl_by_state_inventors.htm
Don't be so blinded by your partisanship that you don't acknowledge anything positive about US. Our contribution to the world has been tremendous, dwarfing almost every other countries. So we do have a reason to feel proud. And we will do it again, without any problems. The issue (I know I am repeating myself but thus thats where the discussion is heading) is, if you consider us your ally, then support us during our need, like we supported you. Don't backstab us like the French did. Don't backstab us like the Germans did (Shroeder ran on the campaign of opposing the Iraq war to win). I mean what does that tell you about the gratefulness of our "allies"??
According to the American Battle Monuments Commission
There are 26,255 Yankee dead from World War I buried in 4 cemeteries in France.
There are 30,426 American dead from World War II buried in 6 cemeteries in France.
These 56,681 brave American heroes died in their youth to liberate a country and continent.
UK and Australia (among others) supported us, even though they told us to wait. Even after GWB didn't as you so suggest, they still supported us. French and Germany didn't. Don't confuse the term "allies" with France and Germany. 2 countries intense opposition does not fall under the guideline of "allies opposition".
by oz_media
Well you read the post before mine, or maybe you didn't, but any sane human being would know that this person is really mislead and full of that a-typical we are the champions attitude.
NOW, why have you even brought Saddam into it? I am responding to a typical pig headed post about how America won WWII, not how it started, who started it, why or what modern day warfare has any relevance to, okay?
Don't even go there, wasting our time.
I saw this EXACT same crap from you oi your first week on TR, WE WON the WAR, YOU'D all be speaking German, it's pure bulls**t and you know it.
It took several MANY men and MANY countries 5 years to defeat hitler. You cannot claim victory or expect undue gratitude for anything done 60 years ago.
You know very well that I agree the US was the force that gave the tired Allied forces the fresh new resources and numbers that ended the war. This does not mean you won anything though, if you were on te pther side of the pond you would have suffered just as bad without allies, just look at the devastation of 9/11 and there is NO way of comparing that (as hoorrible as it was) with the bombing raids in England. You took quite the beating in WWII and didn't come out all sh*ts and giggles anyway.
So lets agree the allied nations won WWI as a joint force and leave it there alright?
My issue was with th epigheadedness of the post I was responding to, which I am sure even you agree was off line and wrong all over.
by oz_media
Hey Garion, I could spend hours wading through Pro war and Anti War propaganda all by myself. The reason I don't is because it neither solves nor explains anything, it's the same thing over and over again. It just wastes time and effort.
You are not posting anything of enlightenment, nothing any of us haven't heard spewn all over the internet. Nothing any of us haven't heard over and over again.
If this site needed an Acrobat Distiller to capture and print web text all day, I'm sure they do it.
Most of these are worth about three lines.
by garion11
Esquire magazine. I found it posted on another MB, where the discussions are just as passionate, but not so eloquent (sp). Name calling is expected there, LOL.
But anyways, I posted that article to illustrate the way the author soul searches and finally concludes, What if Bush is right?
What if? I wonder how many people asked that throughout history.
by oz_media
Just that both sides have similar stories all the time and it;s is othing new. Yet to be fair, I found myself wading through pages of nothing, with no poinr, no opinion, nothing. Just some dude that saw the light.
People find religion all the time, people leave religion all the time. I don't get the Watchtower because I am not interested in seeing how Billy and Bonny saw the light. I come to TR to share thoughts with PEERS and find myself stuck into a lengthy article of nothing. I don't care what magazine article says, I am interested in sharing ideas with IT peers.
by hal 9000
And the Norwegian Solders under British orders who devastated the plant and put back Hitlers Nuke program for months or the very same people who stayed in enemy country and reported back on rebuilding progress and eventually sank the 700 Lt of H3O in the deepest part of the nearby lake. All the time being resupplied by the RAF and the pathetic attempt by the by now left out Americans who insisted on bombing the plant only to do little damage and not touch the already prepared "Heavy Water."
Now if it had not been for those brave souls who by every account should have died waiting for the first attack Garrion and his ilk most likely would never have been born. If the German Scientists in Germany had developed the A Bomb first America would sure as hell not be the place it is today and most likely under German Occupation.
Col
by hal 9000
Australia has more inventors per head of population than any other country in the known world.
And Garrion we make thing work after your people insist "It Can Not Be Done" for example the Jindalee Over The Horizon Radar which incidentally renders your US "Stealth" aircraft useless as they are highly visible on that radar platform. But the people in AU thought it could be done and then set about developing a prototype for under $500,000.00 when your Government had spent Billions on an attempt to make something similar work. Just be thankful we are friends because your country companies ends up producing most of the inventions from this country.
Then there are the things like those freely given to mankind like the Parabolic Antenna again an Australian designed unit that is used world wide with no residual payments to its inventor.
Just out of curiosity would the people in your country be so generous?
Col
by guruofdos
Because the US military did a stock-check of all their ordnance, and found several hundred cartons, cases and containers with 'Use By: 2003' stamped on them. Now, not to upset the American and British taxpayers, the DOD and MOD decided that instead of throwing all this ammo away or burying it in a land-fill, they'd have to find something else to do with it.
After all, elections are coming up and nobody will vote for a government who takes all our hard earned cash, taxes us to death on it under the pretext of defence spending and then says 'Ooops....sorry! all those billions we took from you have been spent on bombs and rockets which we never used and are about to expire'.
Nope. The reason for the war is so that us taxpayers get our money's worth. If the stuff just got buried, we'd see the defence budget as a waste of money and start complaining. Bush and Blair got together to discuss the issue and decided to give the taxpayer 'value for money'. The only way they could do this was by 'letting off' a few billion dollars worth of fireworks and Iraq just happened to be 'in the way'.
After all, this war didn't COST anything did it? Nobody suffered financially because of it did they? It was already paid for 'up front' out of the percentage of national taxation that has been taken out of our pockets in the past in the name of defence spending. It hasn't and won't cost us any extra will it?
Whether we have conflicts or wars or not, every year the defence budget is taken out of our taxes. No British government has ever said to the public "We didn't do any fighting this year, so the defence budget is only going to be the soldiers, sailors and airmens wages". The US government never turn round to the electorate and say "$20 rebate this year on your taxes....we didn't fire any Tomahawks last year so we still have a thousand in stock and don't need to buy any extras".
Nope. Governments have to justify their spending to the electorate, and since the end of the Cold War, the US and UK have still been spending billions a year on armaments, even with no percieved enemy hovering just over the horizon. Nobody wanted to 'play ball' and give us the opportunity to rotate our munitions stocks so George and Tony dreamed up a scheme to lie about Iraq and then convince the public there was a need to use all this hardware.
Well, I for one can rest much easier in bed at night now, knowing that my taxes are being put to good use and not just being buried in a hole in the ground.
by oz_media
That was great man! Awesome post and one that should be adde dto the TR hall of fame.
Priceless! :D
by hal 9000
Last year we had a British War Ship strike a rock off Norfolk Island and get all its weapons submerged. All that ordnance had to be destroyed and was covered by the mass media and at the same time they where complaining about the massive waste of money involved.
Your dissection of the whole subject is Perfect Guru and it now all makes perfect sense.
Thanks for the enlightened explanation.
Col
by aldanatech
by oz_media
I know it's cold but we are just joking here.
Interest payments?
Loss leaders? (or 'lost leaders' if you wish)
by guruofdos
Doesn't it make you laugh, that these people join the military, and then start complaining when the bullets start flying. I actually spoke to a bunch of guys fresh back from Iraq only last week. Three of them actually had the audacity to say they'd have never joined the US Army if they thought for one moment they'd actually experience conflict.
So this begs the question...why?!!!
by oz_media
by admin
Although it preceded this conflict and isn't trying to address it, if you want to know, right or wrong, the positive strategic implications for the US this book is a must read.
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/0465027261/102-6182829-5741730?v=glance
by aldanatech
Okay. It seems to be that this discussion is taking us virtually nowhere because it is just about as divided as the country itself, so lets get to another point. Do you think we are truly following the right way to fight terrorism? So far I see two ways we can do this. One is by preventive wars, such as the war on Iraq. If we follow this path, we would probably have to do the same on every country with suspected possession of WMDs or links to terrorism. That means that at any point we might have to deploy troops to countries such as Iran, Pakistan, North Korea, and so on. Is this a viable option? Would this show that terrorism accomplished its ultimate goal, which is to show that we live in fear?
Option two would be to establish major intelligence reforms and international support. Rather than going through the stubborn attitude of ?either they are for us or against us?, let us form allies from all over the world in a global intelligence effort to track down and stop terrorism attacks before they happen. Terrorist groups seem to be extremely well organized and collaborative. Do you think governments and intelligence services from the US and other countries should do the same in search of a win-win deal? Would you consider this to be a more realistic or effective alternative? If something like this is implemented, can it also be used to fight other issues such drug cartels?
by garion11
Thats exactly the question we should be asking. First we need to define terrorism. Lets face it, one man's terrorist is another man's freedom fighter. So having said that, we must pronounce ourselves (ourselves = Democratic nations) morally superior than the ideals of terrorists (which is an undeniable truth). Right now its radical Islam, Pre-WWII/Post WWII it was the Third Reich, during the Cold War it was Communism, they can all fall under the umbrella of terrorism. Frankly any non Democratic government can fall under the umbrella of terrorism. So thus we should use intelligence and international support and work together with OTHER DEMOCRATIC ONLY nations to remove threats to our freedom.
Preemptive war is an excellent way of removing the threat before it happens. Whether the dictator/country/government showed agressivness or not, based on our moral premises, any Democratic nation is justified in removing a threat (or a potential threat) and more importantly replacing that threat with another Democracy.
But here is where it gets sticky, especially with radical Islam. Hitler had Germany, Communism had Russia. There was a country to be defeated in order to defeat the ideology of the past 2 enemies. Radical Islam doesn't have a country. Its origins are many countries, across many peoples and races. Its a faceless enemy. So the question is how do we defeat something like that? I am not sure I know the answer. The best intelligence in the world and all the international support cannot prevent an attack from a faceless enemy. It might catch 99% or even 100%, but one day someone or something is bound to slip and then we are attacked again.
So again how do we prevent terrorism?
My best idea is to remove the opressive governments of radical Islam, teach and educate the people living under those governments, moderate the influence of Islam with outside influences (such as western and eastern freedom ideologies). This is not a quick fix. This "war" has to be fought for generations if not more (20-50 years).
So then we come to the next question which is, will Freedom take hold and sustain in these countries? I certainly hope so, but only time will tell
by admin
"If something like this is implemented, can it also be used to fight other issues such drug cartels?"
Seems to me that we have been fighting the war on drugs for a much longer time and now should be able to apply what we have learned to terrorism.
It would almost seem as stated to be close to an implication that the war on drugs hasn't been successful and we haven't learned enough from it to help with other less than specific wars.
by thechas
The reason we have not made an major impact with the war on drugs is that politicians in their efforts to be seen as tough on crime continue to focus the drug war on the wrong target.
The target needs to be dealer profits.
The drug trade is an excellent example of capitalism run amok.
Inner city youth get into gangs and the drug trade as the quick and easy route to money.
Most of the efforts in the WoD are focused on reducing the supply. This has the effect of raising prices and profits.
The WoD needs to change focus, and concentrate on the elimination of demand.
If we want to win the WoD, we need to invest heavily in substance abuse treatment programs.
All users need to sent to drug treatment programs that include both personal and job skill training. We need to give the users HOPE for a better life where they do not want or need mind altering substances.
Chas
by hal 9000
The best way to fight terrorism is to cut off their funds. That is only possible if most of the countries involved get together with well funded intelligence operations and sufficient man power not just technology to investigate all suspected links.
Currently we rely far too much on technology to perform this and lack the necessary manpower to fully follow up on the intelligence gathered. A lot of the countries involved are willing to help in this but lack the necessary resources or ability to function in certain areas within their own borders like Pakistan for example. It is only by helping the current administrations in these countries that terrorism will ever be defeated.
Now the BUT while we must be willing to support these administrations we CAN NOT allow ourselves to keep them in power when the majority of the country wants them gone. Currently we are reaping the rewards for this type of action in the Middle East from decades ago and as it has taken this long to reach fruition it will obviously take as long to put right as well.
Col
by thechas
The "best" way to fight terrorism is to work toward solutions to the injustices in the world and for the US especially to stop adding to the injustice.
Osama and the other terrorist leaders are able to attract followers because the US and other "civilized" nations continue to say one thing, yet act in the opposite.
We can start by treating the detainees at Guantanamo the same way we would want our own people to be treated if they were captured.
Disposition all of the detainees as either criminals, prisoners of war, or release them.
Next, do the same thing with prisoners in Iraq.
Them, work on revamping our allegiances to match our countries pledge of supporting democracy throughout the world.
Why are we still supporting dictators and feudal monarchies?
(Oh, sorry, it's oil and money)
The tough part will be making corporations into good world citizens.
The face of the west that most people in middle east and third world countries see is that of corporations looking to extract resources at the lowest possible cost.
Companies and their subcontractors need to wake up to the role that they play in global insurrection.
Then, they need to work to show the positive side of capitalism:
Pay workers a living wage for the country they live in.
Take reasonable safety precautions.
Treat the land and the environment with respect.
For that matter, treat the workers and the people around the plants with respect.
Only once we treat all of our world citizens with respect can we expect a reduction in terrorist ranks.
Chas
.
Gee, silly me. And I want to blame the terrorists themselves....
you said, ".....work toward solutions to the injustices in the world..."
I thought the United Nations was in-charge of that?
you said, ".....and for the US especially to stop adding to the injustice."
Will you be specific, and list some of these "injustices".
You said we should be, "treating the detainees at Guantanamo the same way we would want our own people....if they were captured."
Okay, let's pay for their defense attorneys, keep them in air-conditioned cells watching color television , and let the ACLU file suits on their behalf so they can all get released.
You said we should be, ..."revamping our allegiances to match our country's pledge of supporting democracy throughout the world.....Why are we still supporting dictators and feudal monarchies?"
That may sound nice in theory, and yes, it is (partially) about oil? So I suppose you would suggest that we simply sever all ties, and never buy another quart of oil from the Saudis until they change their form of government?
You said we should be, "...making corporations into good world citizens."
I guess this is the "big-bad business" argument again.
You said they should, "Pay workers a living wage for the country they live in."
Just like they do in the USA - like they deal with the labor unions, and the high cost of medical coverage, and the lawsuits, and the regulations, and all the other things that drove them to those countries to begin with. And then the corporations can raise the prices of those goods as well, to cover their costs, and pass them on to the consumer in the form of higher prices. It sounds like it would defeat the purpose of manufacturing there in the first place. But then those corporations might as well just move their manufacturing back to the USA, and then those "poor workers" wouldn't be making anything at all. But I guess you think they were better off before they had a job.
You said that we should treat the environment and the people "with respect".
The environment: Why do you think the US Senate voted 99-0 opposing the Kyoto Protocol treaty?
Did you know that Thailand has some of the most stringent regulations on pollution. But Bangkok is one of the most polluted places on Earth? did you know that Mexico city is the most dangerous city in the world in terms of air quality? Did you know that the USA has nothing to do with it? Did you know that the Germans have been selling those "old style" VW Beetles in Mexico because they didn't have to meet air quality standards? did you know that the greatest environmental disasters in recent years have taken place in Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union? I could go on and on and on, but it's not (just) the USA.
By the way, did you know that the U.S. Senate voted 99-0 against ratifying the UN's Kyoto global warming treaty? I wonder why? (A rhetorical question)
On respect - personally, I think the terrorists should be taught a little respect. It is them, after all, who steal airplanes and crash them into buildings.
by oz_media
Despite what many think, BC is not a free for all dope is okay province. People seem to feel that changing drug laws have legalized weed, whereas they merely decriminalized posession of more than a half ounce.
They Cannabis Club now privides marijuana to terminally ill with HIV, cancer etc., after a doctors prescription is filled.
THIS STILL hasn't slowed the drug trade. The gocernment is not funding these 'legal grow ops' properly, the amounts available are minimal and the price is too high to make it a feasible solution, YET.
They are mainly just playing lipservice to the people but not actually providing the support needed to make these changes effective in the way they are intended.
The poor quality of government grown weedkeeps the trade on the streets,the high cost of privately grown, but government approved but supported, grow operations causes the trade to remain on the street. So despite what many think, they've done nothing but save money on small court cases that cost the province money.
This is a typical half-assed political solution. People went to the government on the basis of approving it for medical patients and imrpoving thier qulity of life. They also noted that small personal amounts are not the problem, the underground production is, and it is costing the province too much in court costs to prosecute minor offences of possession.
The government responded well on the oney saving part but dropped the all elsewhere. I think the negative outcry from the US played a major role in halting the process in mid-flight.
Our provincial PM doesn't 'bend for Bush' but the Paul Martin certainly used to, perhaps we can move ahead and find better resolutions with the Conservative party being so prominent in our government now.
by oz_media
Despite what many think, BC is not a free for all dope is okay province. People seem to feel that changing drug laws have legalized weed, whereas they merely decriminalized posession of more than a half ounce.
They Cannabis Club now privides marijuana to terminally ill with HIV, cancer etc., after a doctors prescription is filled.
THIS STILL hasn't slowed the drug trade. The gocernment is not funding these 'legal grow ops' properly, the amounts available are minimal and the price is too high to make it a feasible solution, YET.
They are mainly just playing lipservice to the people but not actually providing the support needed to make these changes effective in the way they are intended.
The poor quality of government grown weedkeeps the trade on the streets,the high cost of privately grown, but government approved but supported, grow operations causes the trade to remain on the street. So despite what many think, they've done nothing but save money on small court cases that cost the province money.
This is a typical half-assed political solution. People went to the government on the basis of approving it for medical patients and imrpoving thier qulity of life. They also noted that small personal amounts are not the problem, the underground production is, and it is costing the province too much in court costs to prosecute minor offences of possession.
The government responded well on the oney saving part but dropped the all elsewhere. I think the negative outcry from the US played a major role in halting the process in mid-flight.
Our provincial PM doesn't 'bend for Bush' but the Paul Martin certainly used to, perhaps we can move ahead and find better resolutions with the Conservative party being so prominent in our government now.
by hal 9000
It is exactly for those reasons that you've listed that make people like Ossama a large following. When all hope is lost the only alternative is radical action and since they already have nothing to lose so what if I kill a few of the "Infidel" who caused me to be in this situation in the first place.
America is the current whipping boy for half the world and the best friend of the other half sometimes being supported by Governments and not the people of the same country.
Iraq was a perfect example keep the Shaw in power against the peoples wishes well we all know how that one ended but unfortunately it didn't end within the borders of Iraq we are still feeling the consequences of that action now and the funny thing is that it is people from other Arab countries who have built the terror networks and have them well funded to carryout their objectives.
Personally I think Chas has the right idea in preventing these fools getting the following in the first place but that being said his argument offers no alternative for what we presently have only a fix for some time down the road. On the other hand the current actions are not helping either so something new has to be tried.
Now for that option I'm open to suggestions!
Col
.
Legalize the sale and use of recreational drugs. Smoking a little dope is no different than drinking a few beers. Prohibition doesn't work, as was proven during the fourteen years it was in place in the 20s-30s. (More of the same "gang" activity, but a little more sophisticated with people like Al Capone and Joseph Kennedy, Senator Ted Kennedy's father.)
As far as treatment for the hard drugs, such as heroin and such, taxes on the sale of the social drugs could pay for the treatment programs. But actually, it may not be "as necessary", if recreational drugs were readily available, and the so-called war on drugs could focus on the more dangerous ones.
As far as treatment for the social drug addicts, AA takes all comers, and is considered one the most successful treatment programs ever devised - and it's FREE. Why? Because it espouses self-responsibility. (Why are so many people opposed to advancing an agenda of self-responsibility? I just don't get it.)
by oz_media
You guys should erect a giant statue of Bush in downtown DC, lie Saddam had in Iraq.
THat way, if he loses the election, we could televise the removal of bush and have a tank pull it over!
Sorry, just popped into my head while reading another post.
by guruofdos
Hands up anyone who thinks they could survive without an arsehole???
Lets face it, your intestines would back up pretty quick without one. Farting just wouldn't be the same. Which other muscle in your body has the capacity to oscillate as rapidly in times of danger?
Whether or not Oz is an arsehole is a side issue. He oftentimes 'proclaims' to be an arsehole, many people accuse him of being an arsehole. I myself take it as a compliment in certain contexts when I am accused of being an arsehole. If God wanted to give the world an enema, he'd stick the tube in Benidorm...
The arsehole is a much used, highly necessary and vastly under-rated organ. Do not dismiss arseholes so lightly. Look after your arsehole and it will reward you with many years of reliable service. Politicians only have two major organs...their mouth and their arsehole, and these are often regarded as interchangeable. In fact, on the newest generation of politico, they are even seen as 'hot-swappable'.
Arseholes of the world unite! The world can't live without them and anyone who thinks they can is talking out of their rectum!!
Sort by Trending