Why did we go to war?
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by lelias
by jamesrl
does no one any good - it erodes credibility.
Saddam did use poison gas to kill 5-7000 people in one Kurdish villagein 1988. Thats well documented and accepted. Its also well documented that the US knew that Saddam had that capability, but turned a blind eye because Saddam was an american ally because he was fighting Iran. So you number are exagerated by a huge factor.
No one seemed to care that Saddam used those same weapons on the battlefield to kill Iranians(and in some cases his own troops accidentally, which is why mustard gas was never used in WWII). I will grant that those numbers may be hundreds of thousands and those dead are what you find in those mass graves in the south of Iraq.
Its those shells that were found - the ones Iraq used to deliver mustard gas on attacking Iranians.
Clinton's policy for regime change did not include the words " by use of force". Clinton and the rest of the world was hoping to force regime change from within through the economic sanctions.
I've said it before and I will say it again - Saddam and bin Laden were natural enemies. bin Laden called many times for Saddam's overthrow because Saddam promoted a secular government. The only Al Qaeda camp in Iraq was in an area that Saddam did not control(in the kurdish area). It is probable that these people infiltrated from Iran.
I would also suggest that the work in Afghanistan is far from over. Some of your "friends" who did not join the Iraq invasion are just fine with continuing the work in Afghanistan - Canada was supposed to pull out its troops when the tour was over, but has agreed to send a smaller force. But the war in Iraq does take focus away from Afghanistan, where US troops were welcomed by many.
James
by hal 9000
The last word was it meant to be Rectum or Wrecked-him?
Col
by jamesrl
Cromwell and his excesses were replaced - by the same system he overthrew. It was called the restoration. And after that, democracy grew, but at a slow and steady place. There is a reason why people call them revolutions - things go around.
And its fair to say that many American revolutionaries were inspired by Cromwell. The Pilgrims were of the same strict faith as Cromwell. There was the same intolernace of other faiths; British leniancy in their treatment of the french in Quebec was major sore point with the Americans who had fought the french alongside the British, and the sore point was based on religious tolerance(but that doesn't make the high school history books).
And if you want to talk terrorism, have you not heard of tarring and feathering? This was done by american revolutionaries to drive out loyalists. Indian settlements on the frontier at the time, were often raided, longhouses burned, so that there would be more land for settlers(hence most of the Mohawks fought for Britain).
I don't know of any country that has no dark pages in their past. The Hagganah in British controlled Palestine set off bombs in British hotels in their effort to establish the state of Isreal.
Britain abolished slavery a generation before America, and went further - attacking slaver's ships and blockading Africa with the Royal Navy. That too never makes American history text books.
So I am not sure what your point is about Blair's support for the war - doesn't seem ambivalent at all to me. Britain had been fighting IRA terrorism for more than a century. But many Americans supported that.
James
by jamesrl
Cromwell and his excesses were replaced - by the same system he overthrew. It was called the restoration. And after that, democracy grew, but at a slow and steady place. There is a reason why people call them revolutions - things go around.
And its fair to say that many American revolutionaries were inspired by Cromwell. The Pilgrims were of the same strict faith as Cromwell. There was the same intolernace of other faiths; British leniancy in their treatment of the french in Quebec was major sore point with the Americans who had fought the french alongside the British, and the sore point was based on religious tolerance(but that doesn't make the high school history books).
And if you want to talk terrorism, have you not heard of tarring and feathering? This was done by american revolutionaries to drive out loyalists. Indian settlements on the frontier at the time, were often raided, longhouses burned, so that there would be more land for settlers(hence most of the Mohawks fought for Britain).
I don't know of any country that has no dark pages in their past. The Hagganah in British controlled Palestine set off bombs in British hotels in their effort to establish the state of Isreal.
Britain abolished slavery a generation before America, and went further - attacking slaver's ships and blockading Africa with the Royal Navy. That too never makes American history text books.
So I am not sure what your point is about Blair's support for the war - doesn't seem ambivalent at all to me. Britain had been fighting IRA terrorism for more than a century. But many Americans supported that.
James
by jamesrl
In the case of marijauna and derivatives, I don't believe we should make them legal - just make possession of small amounts for personal consumption a non-criminal offense. Make it like a traffic ticket. Pay a fine. The exception I would make is consumption while driving - you have to make it like drunk driving - a strongly prohibited activity. There are cases right now in Canadian courts about this - will be interesting to see the results.
AA and other programs work, but only once one has gotten through the physical part of the addiction. Problem with the 30 day rehabs, is that you are clean physically, but if all the old issues are there, then relapse is likely.
I am all about self responsibility. There are no rights without responsibilities as well.
James
by oz_media
BC already got that far and it is not a viable resolution. It is just playing lipservice and reducing the city's court costs.
Noody benefits, the drig problem is exactly the same as before. Cops here never even blinked twice about possession and smoking unless you were in a VERY public place and not being somewhat discreet.
Nothing has changed, the government grow ops are a waste of time, the government is NOT supporting Cannabis Societies even though they have allowed them to operate and provide soft drugs to those with doctors prescriptions.
>> A B.C. judge has ruled the law prohibiting the possession of marijuana does not exist.
Provincial court Judge Patrick Chen found the pot possession law went up in smoke three years ago when Ontario's top appeal court found the law invalid.
Once declared invalid, the law prohibiting pot possession ceased to exist, the judge concluded.
"Once invalid, it became a nullity and could not be resuscitated, it could only be re-enacted," Chen said in a 29-page written judgment earlier this month.
"As a result, there was no longer any prohibition or penalty... for simple possession of marijuana. It follows, therefore, there is no offence known to law at this time for simple possession of marijuana."<<
They proposed a $400.00 non-criminal fine for possession under 15 grams, but this is worse than when they just ignored it. It cost too much money to push possession cases throughcourts only to have everyone let go MOST without even a fine.
SO now they push a $400.00 possession fine on it and say they have decriminalized it. Whereas you were better off being charged under criminal law before, it would almost always be thrown out and never hit a permanent record anyway.
Now they are not finding a solution to providing medical grade marijuana, they are not allowing LEGALIZED government approved grow ops (Cannabis club that provides medical marijuana) to purchase seeds or cultivate in a commercial space, rendering grow ops pretty much useless.
Thyey did a half as*ed job of resolving an issue and have ONLY seen it fit to save the court money and have even tried to impose hefty fines for posession, which many can't afford and will be negligent in paying, therefore end up in jail due to mandatory bench wwarrants.
But as for the current time, you'd be hard pressed to find a judge in BC that would convict you on possession. It usually doesn't even hit a courtroom before it is thrown out.
by oz_media
Well I have always been stright up with people since I was a wee lad.
"I am a nice guy...for an arsehole."
Some people say I'm too nice, or that I am always the nice guy (yes other people actually know me)I am quick to correct them though. As far as arseholes go, I am a nice one, that's enough credit for me. That also alows me to accept 'nice arse' comments well too, "Why yes, I am a nice arse!".
by oz_media
WIthout degrading soldiers, many see the US military as the USA's answer to welfare. I am sure that MANY US soldiers do also. When they are unable to find work, get o with thier lives, escape thier neighbourhood etc. they will join the army for a paycheck and trainaing.
Perhaps they should show American soldiers being hit point blank with RPG fire (shown recently on a Canadian war documentary about front line reporters in Iraq)in all those Join the Army propaganda films. 'Train in avionics, learn mechanics, get college degrees, and maybe do a little of this (boom). THen people would actually take the military seriously and perhaps think twice when it comes to war.
We need highly trained brave men and women to protect our countries, not just those who are too lazy to get a job.
I see many reasons for joining the army, I think the biggest one is family pride, the great grandfather, grandfather, father, uncle, brothers etc have all fought, Imust too to show my loyalty and faith in my country and family. This can be a form of peer pressure that gets people to enlist when they really don't want to.
The main problem I see, undertrained troops, troops with the wrong mental capacity for war etc. The number of friendly fire casualties are actually stats added to the lists of deaths and injuries now.
Even the Kurdish troops were too scared to attack an Iraqi tank squad until US troops were moved out of the area as they feared getting hit by friendly fire or mistaken as Iraqi's.
Seem quality suffers to quantity.
by aldanatech
.
You said, "Cities, towns, and neighborhoods with high unemployment rate tend to show much higher enrollment than other places." (I assume you meant "enlistment".)
Will you please provide your source for that assertion?
You said, "Very few do it to actually serve our country."
I say, again, prove that assertion.
Oh, I see, you've drawn those conclusions because you claim to live in an area with a high unemployment rate, and it happens to have an Army base close by.
First of all, what is the unemployment rate in your area? How does it compare to the nation as a whole? Be specific, please.
Second of all, how many of those people serving on that particular Army base are from your area (People don't join the service and go to the base down the road. They are stationed all over the place.), and how did you gather that information? And what's the ratio of "locals" serving at that base, compared to the ratio of people in the military in general?
I've been in the military (I was never stationed in my hometown, by the way), I personally know (or have known) hundreds of people in the military, and I've NEVER known one person to join because they couldn't find a job. How many people did you know - when YOU were in the service - that told you personally that they joined because they couldn't find a job? (I didn't think so.)
This is just another flawed and ridiculous assertion from you that resulted in a flawed and ridiculous conclusion. Don't throw out claims unless you can prove them. And a claim like that is an insult to the many - make that the majority - of those who serve their country for honorable reasons.
In actuality, military towns do indeed have more volatile employment/unemployment cycles, but it's largely tied to the deployment status of the units stationed at the base. For example, when that base's unit is not deployed, the town population is higher, more goods and services are needed, and the unemployment rate goes way down; and actually, those towns' economies do quite well. When the unit is deployed, however, perhaps sending tens-of-thousands of people "out of town", fewer goods and services are needed, and the unemployment rate may increase. (Emphasis on "may" because it may not.)
By the way, I'm still waiting for you to outline those "better" Kerry proposals.
by nd_it
by admin
by jamesrl
Sometimes Max, the US can act like a petulent school boy - if you aren't for us, you are against us.
Thats not the way to treat your friends.
And Canada has always been the friend of the US, at least since you stopped attacking us.
Canada has participated from the beginning and is still participating in Afghanistan. Despite the fact that US National Guard Pilots disobeyed direct orders from their air controllers and bombed our troops, killing 4.
Canada lead for 18 months the naval interception duties in the Arabian Gulf, leading coalition warships in the attempt to intercept arms and terrorist smuggling. We no longer lead the mission, but we still have ships there.
Canada has co-operated fully with the department of Homeland security. Canada shares intelligence with the US on an ongoing basis.
We disagreed with the US on Iraq. But we had tried to form a compromise which would have seen a 6 month time table for compliance. If Saddam had not met the timetable, Canada would have joined the effort. But the US and Germany and France were not willing to compromise. If that compromise had been reached, the attack would have taken place 4 months later, with Canadian involvement.
Max, you have to accept that someone can disagree with you on one issue, and not be "against" you. This happens in families all the time, countries aren't that much different.
James
.
Your opinion - Canada did the right thing.
My opinion - Canada ...... well, read again exactly what I said.
I said, "Canada, France, Germany, and Russia....are turning their backs on a much needed campaign to eradicate the world of such terror, and are missing out on the opportunity to bring freedom and liberty to a piece of the world that has known only oppression."
I never said you were "against" us.
I certainly respect your decision to disagree with me, but by default and definition, that means that I can also disagree with you. It works both ways, you know.
You said, "......at least since you stopped attacking us"
You said, ...." the US can act like a petulant school boy"
Those are mean-spirited thing to say. Doesn't Oz say enough of those things without you adding to it? I've never said anything bad about Canada - never. Can you (or Oz) say the same thing, my "friend"?
As far as the correct ways to treat a friend, I suppose you think that criticism on the international stage is a way to achieve that? Please, spare me.
All I said is that I think you should have..........., while you, on the other hand, think you should not have. Okay, great. We disagree. What's wrong with that.
You keep telling me what the USA should do and should have done. Can't you take even one instance when I say what I think Canada should have done?
You said, "Max, you have to accept that someone can disagree with you on one issue, and not be against you. This happens in families all the time, countries aren't that much different."
Of course, you're right - I agree. But you, too, have to accept that fact. Or are you applying a double-standard, here?
Okay, what's the problem?
by mallardtooxx
I seem to spend a lot of time with my head up my ******** just ask my wife.
-duck
by aldanatech
You do make some important points, and I do find many of them to be valid, but not sufficient. Now don't get me wrong. It is not that I actually want Bush to fail. After all, he is a president and if he succeeds, everyone succeeds; but I do disagree with the way he handles it and so far he hasn't done anything to make me think otherwise. And this is not just from 9/11, but all the way from the election and even when he was governor of Texas, as he was just one step of committing an atrocity. He attempted to place a nuclear waste land in a location below the authorized proximity with border of Mexico. This was in clear violation of an international treaty. The only reason why he didn?t made it was because people from both sides protested heavily and government officials fought against it. He never admitted he committed any wrongdoing, much less apologize. Apparently, this little incident was never made public beyond the borders of the region. Now if your governor did something like this, would you trust him to be a suitable president? I continued to ask myself: "How can somebody who doesn?t even have the ethics to comply with a simply treaty can have what it takes to properly run a country?!"
In my opinion, his administration will probably be remembered more for the war on Iraq. History will most likely criticize him for ignoring the UN because eventually it turned out that there were no WMDs, so Iraq was really not a treat to the US. Those countries that opposed the war in Iraq did so because there was simply not enough evidence to back it up. Also, remember the UN weapons inspectors were pulled out a lot earlier before they could finish the job to bring in military action. It is already considered that going to war a hasty decision. Now the country is seen as some sort of a liar and a bully.
Even Colin Powel once said in an interview that the president rushed him kind of hard to find some means to get Saddam Hussein out of power. Some of the countries of the coalition already pulled their troops out of Iraq, primarily because they consider that this is going nowhere. Spain?s main reason to pull out is because ?this war was a disaster, and it is still a disaster?. As for Bin Laden, it seems that he is still alive and well, due to recent recordings where he commands Muslim extremists to go after the US for attacking Iraq and killing innocent people. Now I'm sure US soldiers didn't mean to, but it is hard to avoid casualties in war. As a matter of fact, there was a recent recording of Bin Laden saying that he was planning a big time attack on the US on Election Day.
There are a couple of reasons why Islamic extremist kill themselves for terrorism purposes. They don?t fear dead. From a very young age they are taught that god is waiting for them to reward them for their sacrifice in the name of their religion, and they generally believe that attacks from the US on Islamic regions are attacks on their religion. Of course this is what you mean when you say they are brainwashed. What I mean by the US being brainwashed is that the government only tells the people what they want to hear and I perceive that media to be rather biased.
by aldanatech
by oz_media
We could burn Bush dimmies (very fitting) on a fire each fall and call it George Bush day the same as GuyFawkes day (sorta like England's halloween).
On Guy Fawkes day (November 5th), kids go door to door collecting a penny for the guy, you could make kids go door to door and conduct random home searches (they are gonna have to do it one day, may as well start young).
Then thay have family/community bonfires where they burn a scarecrow like dummy to represent Guy Fawkes, the conspirator behind the Gunpoweder plot to destrot parliment as they were imposing laws against English Catholics. It is symbolic of upsrising to protect freedoms against Parliment.
Or we could place GWB dummies in mass graves and gas them each year.
There's got to be a better way of remembering the knob other than reelecting him.
by hal 9000
Heard it so I resisted from that joke but it was effective in getting a point across.
To be the Boss you don't need brains you just need to be a Rectum.
Col
by zuhairl
We keep hearing over and over the word "Terrorist"
Did anybody hear a definition of a terrorist? What about freedom fighters? This word was all over the media during Regan's era
I think there are a lot of injustice in the world, and commom people have nothing to do with it. Does anybody know that even the CNN we get here in the Middle east is different than the one you are viewing in the states? We ought to use our heads to evaluate what we hear.
by hal 9000
Most of the people who post here are so caught up in what their country is doing that they are either unable or unwilling to actually accept that there may be another side of the story.
However I hope that it doesn't put you off continuing to post here as we all need a different prospective on events so we can get a balanced view.
Keep up the great work
Col
by admin
Yes, Internet re-broadcasts of TV offer one way accessible to most of us to view many different takes on these situations.
Of course if the past is any indicator, the line between Freedom Fighter and Terrorist is not so clear as time progresses. Our support for Osama Bin Laden and Saddam Hussein are clear examples of Ops in our interest that turn sour in time, but there are many examples under both Democratic and Republican Presidents.
It is interesting to me that there are not a lot of arguments about the outright sinking of The Maine anymore. The Lusitania is also generally accepted to have been sunk with partial responsibility because the Germans even tried to keep Americans off the ship by directly warning us and it was not heeded for probably political
reasons, then munitions were loaded on board even according to Lord Mersey's official description of the facts (the New York to Liverpool Manifest has still not been made public) and still, we widely hold that The Maine was sunk by the Spanish and the Germans killed innocent people for no reason and without warning. The only factual part of that is that the people were, indeed innocent.
No one bothers with facts really, unless they help the Republican Conservative side or the Democratic Liberal side. I agree strongly that: "We ought to use our heads to evaluate what we hear" and yet it seems to take a century before it is far enough that people can admit that their government acts in their best interest at times by deliberately manipulating a situation. Maybe in 50 or 60 years the general public will face facts and realize that the Freedom Fighters were largely the equivalent of terrorists fighting for our concerns. Fire is often best fought with fire at some point and we need to just accept this.
I do agree though:"commom people have nothing to do with it" in almost all of these cases. We need to keep these actions as far away as possible from the innocents as we can and not use them for cover like the Lusitania. If there is one thing we can learn through history it is that with our post WW2 military in the US being so strong, it is still not truly strong and will not be until we can take out specific targets and leave the innocents to live, laugh and love in peace.
This is the sign of true strength- that you effect the desired outcome with the least force, the least cost, the least damage and the most protection of the area and life in proximity. This is truly acting out of strength.
Why is is that every time some pecker-necked right wing nut-job gets his panties in a twist, the first piece of verbal diarrhea that dribbles over his chin is "We'll NUKE 'EM!! We'll do it 'cause we can. Nuke 'em!!" etc, etc. I'll do you a deal, whack-job; You can drop three (3) nukes anywhere you like. I personally will be laughing my ass off watching most of the rest of the world lining up in a mass wave, wading through the ruins of a once great land, screaming for the blood of the last living American. Don't think it could happen?? Exactly how many of the 220 million "Known" residents of America were actually born there...
AND THE NUMBER GETS LESS EVERY SINGLE F*$KING DAY!!
by jamesrl
Not sure why Max you take every criticism of America as a personal affront.
When I said America was acting like a petulent school boy, I was referring to some of the things GWB has said regarding Canada specifically; "If you aren't with us(coalition of the willing) you are against us". There has also been a great deal of speculation about Canada being a haven for terrorists, when in fact none of the 9/11 terrorists came through here, and we probably have fewer terrorists here than in the US.
I never said you said those things, but if you support everything your president says and does....
At least since you stopped attacking us refers to history. Yes the last official war was 1812, but after the Civil war you let fenian "terrorists" cross the border to attack. I don't blame you personally Max...you were probably only a baby back then.
Mean spirited? Blaming my country for 9/11 was mean spirited. And it happened - and not just by ordinary citizens but by government officials who knew better.
Canada has not been vocally critical on the international stage. Canada has always seen its role as a broker, and we tried to broker a compromise.
I have never said that you don't have the right to criticise Canada. And I for one do not think that Canada, or any country, is perfect.
Max, there is no double standard here. I am not against you, or the US. I don't always agree with your stands on issues, nor you with mine. Frankly I think public debate is healthy. Apparently you don't feel the same.
James
.
I've avoided these types of comments in the past, however, I'll make this exception.
This nonsense that the United States has ever invaded Canada is just that - pure nonsense.
First of all, the U.S. War of 1812 is often mentioned as one instance, but "Canada" didn't even exist in 1812-1814. So any territory north of the U.S. border was no more than British (or French) North America. And we all know that the U.S. war with Britain in 1812-1814 was, in many ways, an extension of the American revolution that ended only about 25 years prior.
As far as skirmishes related to the U.S. Civil War that may have found their way north of our border, there was never anything sanctioned by the U.S. government.
But all you have to know is when Canada became a State unto itself, and no longer a mere British Colony. When was that, 1867 or something like that? It's kinda' like when people say that slavery existed in the United States for 300 years, when, in actuality, it took the "United States" only about 80 years to totally outlaw it - and in half the "United States", it was NEVER allowed.
But my point is that it's ridiculous to even bring up. Those events have absolutely no bearing on anything of relevance today.
by oz_media
Was watching some documentary the other day and at the end they were talking about slavery.
Now American's will ALWAYS pass the blame of slavery on the British Empire, which may be true, but apparently it is little known that the British stopped slavery and made an attemptto stop slavery around the world more than a decade before the US did, I am not sure which wars but apparently many of the British/US naval battles were when the British setup and anti-slavery blockade off the coast of Africa to stop slave ships from the US.
by jamesrl
You say that Canada didn't exist before 1867. Do you think India existed before 1949?
The US invaded the colonies of Upper Canada and Lower Canada during the War of 1812. These colonies did have their own form of government, though it wasn't a democracy until the 1840s.
From many american's perspective the war of 1812 was an extension of the revolution, but "Manifest destiny" was a post revolutionary concept, and it was manifest destiny which inspired the warhawks in congress to push for war. In other words, some people in the US were out for land, some were out to settle old scores.
As far as the Fenian raids, I made no suggestion that the US Government "authorised" it. But the people involved were ex soldiers, and some were active duty. They wore US uniforms and carried US arms. They carried regimental flags of Irish regiments in the Union army. The US government was aware of what was going to happen. They chose to do nothing.
In the same way that you don't measure US history as starting once the British surrendered at Yorktown, or singed the treaty, we don't measure it from the time that Britain signed the formal act to make us independant.
And as to your other point, I do interact with Americans on a daily basis. They don't all share your views though.
The US has the right to make its own decisions, and live with the consequences. Some of those consequences may be criticism from others. The US also doesn't refrain from criticising others. Its not unhealthy for any of those things to do be discussed. The same goes for us. The only time I am distressed is when we get into name calling and ad hominem attacks - and Max, you are in general not guilty of these. Oz may differ in his opinion.
James
.
You said that you're, "not sure why I take every criticism of America as a personal affront."
Well, there are many who do indeed understand why.
Perhaps you should do a better job of trying to understand your neighbors to the south, and be more tolerant of others who place importance in things that you don't.
by steve biko
Hate to break it to you Mr Edison, but America's foreign policy is already up yours. Take a look at how many times talks have been de-railed by the US, such as world environmental policies and world trade agreements.
America's response is Up Yours, we'll continue to look after our own, stuff the environment up and stuff the rest of the world.
One of the comments in the first message in this thread was "what does the rest of the world think of America?". In South Africa it is: we are not surprised that 9/11 happened. We don't think anyone deserves what happened, but are you that ignorant that you did not think someone would try to hurt America as much as possible.
I wonder if you know where South Africa even is or who Steve Biko is?
.
You asked, "I wonder if you know where South Africa even is or who Steve Biko is?"
The answer is yes and yes.
by steve biko
by steve biko
Sorry, other thread maxed out.
I would agree with you to some extent, it's not up to the USA to get involved in the world's problems, United nations should be more involved.
Regarding others in Africa: Our people have been pushing Mbeki to get more involved in Zimbabwe. His response has been interesting: he has talks with Mugabe, but he is also working a hell of a lot to promote peace and stability in most of Africa. Due to this, South Africa has become a huge investor in Africa (I'm involved in a project in Zambia at the moment). This is a different approach to what seems to be the USA's policy of go in, bomb them and then re-build (also giving additional work for Americans). That is the perceived way the USA handles things and what makes it worse is that people running for the presidency at the moment keep talking about their military careers, making you seem like a very militant nation.
I am convinced that if you and I sat at a table together, we would not be vastly different from one another. The country you and I live in however, makes us different. If you made the decisions you may have chosen differently. Your leaders however make the USA look like the militant bullies on the block.
By the way, how on earth do you post all the messages you do?
by hal 9000
We don't even have that day of fun anymore as it has been outlawed. First they {The Government moved it to June and then did away with it all together.} Now if you are caught with any fire crackers it is a criminal offense.
Maybe I'm just getting old but I really enjoyed those days as a kid and while the odd letter box got blown up there was very rarely any problems but some well meaning person "Bloody Idiot" thought it was too dangerous for kids to play with fireworks so it was eventually ended here.
Almost makes me want to pack up and leave the place particularly when a couple of years ago I heard someone letting off fire crackers and it ended up in a major police investigation with some idiot reporting gun fire to the police so they naturally roped off the area and insisted we all stay indoors while they found the guilty party with the gun. They got even more worked up when I told them it was fire crackers not gun shots and insisted on how did I know the difference. Of course they where all to young to ever have a Guy Fawkes day or for that matter know what it was.
Col
by tomsal
Any WWF (oh yeah its WWE now) fans out there? I'm not either, but a few of my nephews are so I pick up on the wrestler's lingo from time to time.
I think if I were the president back on 9/11/01 I would have wanted blood myself. One thing people forget, as "ordinary citizens" we have the luxury to be a Monday morning quarterback. Millions of people aren't dependent on the decisions or actions we make or do.
So I kind of hate a little (if I don't like the president or not is irrelevant in how I feel in this) how people make it sound like "DUH Mr. President you are a moron to do that..."
We need to pull our guys out of the middle east, enough have died for little to no real purpose. This is abundantly clear now. It wasn't so clear in 2001 however. Hind sight is always 20/20, the problem is we as "citizens" can speak our mind, act like we are the brilliant ones with all the answers on what the president should do or should not do...but would be so bold, so daring if one of us were actually the president? I think there's alot we don't realize, that the public doesn't know or ever will --- and yet we all act like the tough guys with all the answers.
The world is an evil and cold place. I don't want the responsibility of nearly 300 million lives in my hands thats for sure.
"That's the bottom line, because Stone Cold says so!" ;)
by oz_media
Well yes making such decisions is an intense responsibility that none of us can possibly relate to.
That's just another reason that these decisions must be made based on factual evidence.
In this case, the invasion of Iraq was not a knee jerk reaction to 9/11 as much as a reaction to suspected threat.
When 9/11 occurred I was actually quite surprised at how well it was handled and the reactions of those in New York to all step up to the plate when in need. It was certainly an impressive show of brotherhood.
The attack on Iraq had nothing to do with any of this, or making a quick decision to retaliate, it has been brewing for over a decade and the choice to invade wasn't such a bad idea at all. The irrational reasoning behind it was.
We cannot alow people with an irrational thought process to be in charge of the largest military on the planet, it's irresponsibility on the citizens part that such a man can be in office to begin with.
Yes I agree that these things are much asier when we sit back and reflect on the results of actions, but we must also consider the ability of the person in office to make the best decisions in such time.
I know some people think it was a just and right decision and as GWB said himself, you are either with us or against us (which I hear people chanting in defense all the time...pathetic really).
You must have enough sane citizens to see that the next president is at least capable of making a retional decision after 10 years of prior knowledge AND a meeting with the allied nations.
It's not like he was asked to thnk in a minute and act on his feet.
by tomsal
Well said, I see your point. As I've said before -- I'm not overly thrilled with any of my choices this year as registered American voter.
You know its a shame that Guiliani (sp?) isn't running for President, he impressed me greatly how he handled 9/11 in NYC.
I really thought he showed what a leader should be.
by onbliss
hey, hope you don't consider it kinda sarcastic/rhetoric question on my part. But I am curious to know what qualities of him that appealed to you.
Thanks!!!
by tomsal
#2 He was calm in the midst of the worst act of terrorism the USA has ever experienced.
#3 He had no problems answering all questions, he didn't shy away from the people -- it embraced them. In short, he had display a quality that is extremely rare for a politican -- genuine caring and concern.
#4 He created organization of rescue personnel in America's largest city when 90% of the city was in nothing but complete panic. He did this and he acted quickly, he was decisive.
#5 He was a leader.
.
(CNN) -- President Bush addressed a prayer service on Friday at the Washington National Cathedral. Here is a transcript of his comments:
"We are here in the middle hour of our grief. So many have suffered so great a loss, and today we express our nation's sorrow. We come before God to pray for the missing and the dead, and for those who loved them.
On Tuesday, our country was attacked with deliberate and massive cruelty. We have seen the images of fire and ashes and bent steel.
Now come the names, the list of casualties we are only beginning. They are the names of men and women who began their day at a desk or in an airport, busy with life. They are the names of people who faced death and in their last moments called home to say, be brave and I love you.
They are the names of passengers who defied their murderers and prevented the murder of others on the ground. They are the names of men and women who wore the uniform of the United States and died at their posts.
They are the names of rescuers -- the ones whom death found running up the stairs and into the fires to help others. We will read all these names. We will linger over them and learn their stories, and many Americans will weep.
To the children and parents and spouses and families and friends of the lost, we offer the deepest sympathy of the nation. And I assure you, you are not alone.
Just three days removed from these events, Americans do not yet have the distance of history, but our responsibility to history is already clear: to answer these attacks and rid the world of evil.
War has been waged against us by stealth and deceit and murder.
This nation is peaceful, but fierce when stirred to anger. This conflict was begun on the timing and terms of others; it will end in a way and at an hour of our choosing.
Our purpose as a nation is firm, yet our wounds as a people are recent and unhealed and lead us to pray. In many of our prayers this week, there's a searching and an honesty. At St. Patrick's Cathedral in New York, on Tuesday, a woman said, "I pray to God to give us a sign that he's still here."
Others have prayed for the same, searching hospital to hospital, carrying pictures of those still missing.
God's signs are not always the ones we look for. We learn in tragedy that his purposes are not always our own, yet the prayers of private suffering, whether in our homes or in this great cathedral are known and heard and understood.
There are prayers that help us last through the day or endure the night. There are prayers of friends and strangers that give us strength for the journey, and there are prayers that yield our will to a will greater than our own.
This world He created is of moral design. Grief and tragedy and hatred are only for a time. Goodness, remembrance and love have no end, and the Lord of life holds all who die and all who mourn.
It is said that adversity introduces us to ourselves.
This is true of a nation as well. In this trial, we have been reminded and the world has seen that our fellow Americans are generous and kind, resourceful and brave.
We see our national character in rescuers working past exhaustion, in long lines of blood donors, in thousands of citizens who have asked to work and serve in any way possible. And we have seen our national character in eloquent acts of sacrifice. Inside the World Trade Center, one man who could have saved himself stayed until the end and at the side of his quadriplegic friend. A beloved priest died giving the last rites to a firefighter. Two office workers, finding a disabled stranger, carried her down 68 floors to safety.
A group of men drove through the night from Dallas to Washington to bring skin grafts for burned victims. In these acts and many others, Americans showed a deep commitment to one another and in an abiding love for our country.
Today, we feel what Franklin Roosevelt called, "the warm courage of national unity." This is a unity of every faith and every background. This has joined together political parties and both houses of Congress. It is evident in services of prayer and candlelight vigils and American flags, which are displayed in pride and waved in defiance. Our unity is a kinship of grief and a steadfast resolve to prevail against our enemies. And this unity against terror is now extending across the world.
America is a nation full of good fortune, with so much to be grateful for, but we are not spared from suffering. In every generation, the world has produced enemies of human freedom. They have attacked America because we are freedom's home and defender, and the commitment of our fathers is now the calling of our time.
On this national day of prayer and remembrance, we ask almighty God to watch over our nation and grant us patience and resolve in all that is to come. We pray that He will comfort and console those who now walk in sorrow. We thank Him for each life we now must mourn, and the promise of a life to come.
As we've been assured, neither death nor life nor angels nor principalities, nor powers nor things present nor things to come nor height nor depth can separate us from God's love.
May He bless the souls of the departed. May He comfort our own. And may He always guide our country.
"God bless America."
.
"Leadership on that day (9-11) is central to his (President Bush) record, and his continued leadership is critical to our ultimate success against world terrorism."
-- Rudy Giuliani
"Mr. President, the uniformed officers -- the police, the fire, the emergency service officers, their families -- will really appreciate this. We're going to sustain a tremendous loss of our bravest and our best people. And the relief that you're now making available to the families is going to mean a lot to them. They're going to be able to think about the fact that their children are going to be taken care of, that they're going to be able to go to college, that they're going to be able to carry on. So I can't express to you how appreciative we are of your acting so swiftly. And also, on that terrible day when our city was being attacked, you were in immediate communication with us, Mr. President, and helped to secure the city. And the work that you've done for us, we all eternally appreciate. You've been a terrific leader, and we're taking direction from you and we're following your example. You've done a terrific job, Mr. President.
-- Rudy Giuliani
"You've been a terrific leader, and we're taking direction from you and we're following your example. You've done a terrific job, Mr. President."
-- Rudy Giuliani
"You've been a terrific leader, and we're taking direction from you and we're following your example. You've done a terrific job, Mr. President."
-- Rudy Giuliani
"You've been a terrific leader, and we're taking direction from you and we're following your example. You've done a terrific job, Mr. President."
-- Rudy Giuliani
(Okay, I got a bit carried away.)
Same question, if Yes on Rudy, why not yes on President Bush?
by admin
I assume no one has read this book?
You really should if have an interest here. Especially if you like to play Risk.
.
If you could support Rudy Giuliani, why in the heck couldn't you support President Bush?
I agree with you; Rudy Giuliani has impressed me as well. I've personally attended speeches he's given (twice), and I've read his book "Leadership". (A great book - I recommend you, or anyone, read it.)
You said that he, "showed what a leader should be." Again, I agree 100 percent.
Therefore, if he knows what it takes to be a great leader, and you and I both agree that he does, doesn't it also mean that he can identify similar traits in others? I can certainly make that conclusion, why can you? Rudy Giuliani considers President Bush, not only an extremely honorable man, but a great leader in his own right. If you support Rudy Giuliani, and Rudy Giuliani supports President Bush, then why can't you also, in the very least, give President Bush the benefit of the doubt, and consider that the slams against him are more politically motivated and have a much less basis in truth.
Rudy Giuliani on "the issues":
You are either with civilization or with terrorism. (Oct 2001)
No need to understand reasons for terrorism-just stop them. (Oct 2001)
(Feb 2000) Iraq: More inspections; counter OPEC?s oil production cuts.
(Oct 2002) "The reality is that Saddam Hussein remains a significant danger to this country because he supports, condones and makes terrorism possible......The United States must be prepared to act on its own to depose Saddam Hussein in Iraq, to help rid the world of terrorism......It's the necessary thing to do in order to defend ourselves properly."
"On September 11, maybe an hour into it, there was a moment in which I just had this realization and said it to the police commissioner, I said, 'Thank God George Bush was elected.' Because at that time we were less than a year away from that very, very close election, and then all that happened in the courts.....So we want to make sure that we reelect President Bush (in 2004), and then the future will take care of itself.
-- Rudy Giuliani (2004)
Question: "Do you applaud the current Bush initiative to cut taxes?"
Giuliani : "Vital. It's absolutely vital to the stimulating of our economy. The federal tax reduction will stimulate jobs....in a very, very big way."
More Rudy Giuliani on "the issues":
Govt. stabilizes business; businesses provide jobs. (Sep 1997)
Change welfare offices into job centers. (Dec 1999)
Tax reductions of $10.4B through 2003. (Dec 1999)
Supports Task Force to continue reduce taxes. (Dec 1999)
Eliminated sales tax on clothes; reduced real estate tax. (Dec 1999)
Open Strategic Petroleum Reserve to battle high oil prices. (Feb 2000)
Oil crisis is ?compelling justification? to use Reserves. (Feb 2000)
Improve schools by taking on the unions & special interests. (Jan 2000)
Reading projects offer tutoring & improve test score. (Dec 1999)
$50M for more art teachers & art programs. (Dec 1999)
Replace Board of Ed with appointed commissioner. (Apr 1999)
Drug policy should be an integral part of foreign policy. (Sep 1997)
Anti-Catholic art is disgusting; appoints decency council. (Feb 2001)
Brooklyn Museum closed due to lease rules, not censorship. (Oct 1999)
Free speech for private expression, not publicly-funded art. (Oct 1999)
No taxpayer dollars for offensive art. (Oct 1999)
No, Rudy doesn't agree with President Bush on all issues (they differ on abortion, for example), but on the economy, foreign policy, and the war on terrorism, they could be political twins.
by tomsal
Good question. Though I think its great that you take the time to find sources and quotes and news articles, etc. for backing up your posts -- I think its highly relevant in technical/scientific discussions, when you are speaking about something to do with personal opinion -- quotes, articles, etc. are of much less importance or relevance.
What is one person's opinion or personal view on such matters -- is their right and it doesn't matter what the "sources" say.
All that you post may well be true, in fact a few of the quotes I remember hearing or seeing for myself....
Point is -- in my gut I just like Rudy better from a personal prespective, call it a gut feeling -- I think he is a better quality leader.
Also keep in mind in the world of politics don't believe everything you read or hear politicians say about other politicians....agreeing with another is merely showing respect sometimes, when the camera/mic is in their face for the world to see and hear.
It would of been very bad taste, for example, for Rudy to NOT stand by the president during the height of the 9/11 incident.
by oz_media
I honestly think GWB didn't to too bad after 911, he was clear and concise, made his objectives clear, made his plans clear, made his disgrace of terrorists clea and sent a message he would not allow it again.
Bin Laden wasn't captured (yet), they say AlQaeda is rebuilding a bigger force than before and terror has NOT stopped at all, in fact just look at New York today as people wait for the next shoe to drop. THey are still going about their lives which they must but also look over their shoulders all day, which they also must.
BUT Bush still acted what I consider appropriately on 9/11, as soon as the Taliban accepted blame for the act, he went straight in and attacked Afghanistan with the world's support at his side.
As for Iraq, well that's a WHOLE new story and one in which Bush did not act with any relevant thought process and simply used the 'war momentum' to sate his appetite for removing Saddam and establishing a democratic oil partner for those he had let down in the past and to further instill big dollar Republican support of his presidency and future Republican parties.
Once Iraq is a democracy on the US side,it will further increase intelligence throughout the Middle East and Bin Laden WILL eventually be found, alive or dead.
.
Oz doesn't think President Bush acted properly with the Iraq issue. What a surprise!
Don't you think I know that by now? Don't you think we all know that by now? You think he acted wrong, I think he acted right. I think Iraq is part of the bigger war on terrorism, while you don't. I think we both know where the other stands.
Why do you feel compelled to ALWAYS add your two-cents worth? And it's always the same, tired-old two-cents. The answer is that you have an axe to grind, you're obviously obsessed with it, and you are doing your part to damage his credibility, probably wanting to influence a person's vote.
.
The British did indeed abolish slavery before the USA - except the northern USA states, where it was never acceptable. That's why those "300 years of slavery in the USA" claims are nonsense.
.
You asked, What is it with America and nukes"?
Actually, "America" doesn't do what you suggest. Its leaders don't and its policy doesn't. Don't confuse what "America" may or may not think or do with what a few isolated individuals might say.
I, too, wish such rhetoric could be seen for what it is by the person saying as much. It's detrimental to the "cause" a person is trying to advance.
by oz_media
You ARE a person who takes any comment about America as a personal attack, as if you actually have anything to do with the American Government other than being a taxpayer, or as if they actually see you as more than a mere taxpayer, you are income, bottom line, fodder. Don't be too upset though, we all are no matter what country we live in. Now if America was YOUR responsibility and you had been responsible for 'her' actions, I could understand, instead you are a mere statistic that helps fund a military budget, not a person a taxpayer. Get used to it and stop flattering yourself that your opinion/defense of the US administration matters.
I simply offered a very open reply that clearly staates that I do not see 9/11 and Saddam as related and therefore I say so when people constantly equate them, which has also been said a thousand times, Maxwell.
NOW you [i]claim[/i] you KNOW what I think and it's the same old two cents [i](as if you have offered anything but the same staunch pro-Bush opinion since day 1)[/i] but then you completely counter your statement by providing an outright lie.
Yuo said; [i]"I think Iraq is part of the bigger war on terrorism, while you don't. I think we both know where the other stands." [/i]
Well if it's tha same old two cents and my argument is so old and rhetorical, how can you not understand my actual view regarding Iraq and global terrorism? I have NEVER at any point in time said that I didn't think Iraq was part of the bigger war on terrorism, please show me where I have said this or I will simply dismiss it as an outright lie on your behalf, which we BOTH now it is.
The only other explanation is that you ismply don't read, comprehend or undertsand posts other than your own, which you often say people misconstrue or take out of context.
It's like I've said before, you just want to bitch and complain whether someone agrees with you or not, you just HAVE to argue with people and I don't think you even realize what points you are arguing half the time.
Mu previous post, actually supported BUSH and his reaction to 9/11. YOU were the one who asked
[i]"if Yes on Rudy, why not yes on President Bush?" [/i]
Well I explained very clearly that Guliani reacted well on 9/11, SO DID BUSH, I was behind you guys all the way.
But as for why people would stand behind Guliani NOW and not GWB, well that is easy, Guliani made a great decision and acted accordingly, he didn't then run off and invade Iraq, as mayor of New York city andsomeone who has relied on the had of the US Admionistration in New York, how could he possibly NOT take favour with GWB?
YOu seemed to expect Bush to be treated like Guliani, actually that's EXACTLY what you wanted, the bottom line is that the rections were both valiant after 9/11, Iraq is what has lost Bush his support.
THAT's WHY I MUST KEEP REITERATING MYSELF, SOME PEOPLE, yourself included, JUST DON'T GET IT.
That's okay though, I'll try to be patient while you try and absorb it all.
by garion11
"I have NEVER at any point in time said that I didn't think Iraq was part of the bigger war on terrorism..."
So if you NEVER said at any point in time that Iraq wasn't part of the bigger war on terrorism, why do you oppose our invasion of Iraq? Why do you oppose GWB actions??
by oz_media
I know even the most autistic savant would have caught on to my reason for disliking Bush and NO I never opposed invading Iraq either.
YOu constantly moan that I keep repeating myself but as I suggested to Max earlier, I don't think you are capable of understanding my views and that's WHY I am constantly forced to reiterate my position. It seems that no matter HOW much someone explains themself, you will believe exactly what you want to believe in order to lump them into a group of Anti-Bush supporters or Anti-American's.
'Either for us or against us', damn I wish Bush had never filled you all with that crap, what was he (his writers) thinking??.
so anyway, I don't oppose invading Iraq in fact I supported the Gulf War as it was due to an attack on US soil that was proudly claimed by the Taliban, Clinton had already tried to bomb him out but he came back and attacked.
I think Saddam is an evil dictator that should have been removed.
I think that Iraqi's would be better off with a diplomatic government than they were under Saddam's rule.
OKAY, so we got that straight, right?
NOW, I DON'T support the TIMING or the REASONS given for going to war. To be extremely nice, one could say it's deception of the US government to scare the people into supporting an invasion.
INVASION GOOD > TIMING BAD
PROPOSED RESULTS GOOD > REASONS FOR INVASION BAD
SUPPORTING PRESIDENT GOOD > MISLEADING YOUR SUPPORTERS BAD
OKAY? ?:l
by zuhairl
Thanks for the warning HAL. I went to school in the Midwest, and traveled all over the US. Loved it there, I know how some uneducated Americans on the world affairs think. But the majority are very open minded and willing to discuss and accept the facts. Some, sorry to say, think that the world revolves around their Neighborhood. This is an opportunity to get educated on the world affairs and educate in the process.
I wonder how would anybody feels if some bully comes from nowhere and start kicking you out of your own house. Naturally, you fight back. in the process, god forbid, your brother, sister, and god knows who else from your family get hurt. You are labeled a terrorist. Injustice?
by jimhm
You got to be a big of Arse as Oz - Did you read the above posts? Me Thinks Not ... You sense of humor is in your arse (we call it an Ass - but its better to just say F'Off) ..
You all - no matter what unless it is pure - weak kneed - arse licking - sucking up to some mad-man you all don't like it... The next time someone kicks the crap out of europe let them deal with it... And they will bread another one - gee they had 5 or 6 so far - Americans are tired of paying for your support against these people then getting slapped for doing it... You are big boys and girls now - take care of yourself - we will keep our money (Oh yea - how about paying the US back for all the lend lease stuff during WWII - pay your bill plus interest)-
That isn't a joke - Next time we will be netural - and sell goods to both side like the Swiss did - then keep the billions in Gold in our banks like the Swiss did. Or England that didn't give back gold - and pressured the Swiss so that Britian had money and Swiss credits to rebuild their country... Yepper - Britian was really kind to the Jews and other countries that had their treasuries looted by the Germans... Go Britian..
Take the log out of your eye before you want to take the toothpick out of ours... Oh not even to mention the terrorism and murder of civilians in the US by Britian during the American Revolution - Even thou it took France a few years - that is one thing we can thank them For...
So KISS MY SWEATY ARSE -
.
You agree the cause was just and the reasons justified.
But it's the how and when that you don't like.
Well, too bad. Get over it. No one appointed you the Grand Pubah of anything - much less our business.
But you should really get over this obsession you have.
Just because a person can't or won't agree with you, or understand why you might say something, it doesn't mean you have to force them to. That's just plain weird. You keep going on and on and on, even though the person doesn't want to hear, and even though the person will never agree with whatever point you're trying to make, you go on and on and on in your attempt to make them do something. Get over it, already.
Geesh, get a life.
But I am certainly glad you are admitting that President Bush did the right thing.
.
Just because a nation takes action against one adversary and/or injustice, doesn't mean that it will, should, or can take action against any and all. Each must be considered on its own merit; each must be dealt with individually; and each may require different methods, depending on the political and logistical realities at the time.
But the bigger question is, why isn't the United Nations involved; why can't the United Nations correct this wrong; or why aren't the other nations of Africa dealing with it?
Instead of blaming the USA for every problem, and the USA is always blamed for something by someone whether it acts or not, why not blame the United Nations? After all, it's the UN who is "supposed to" deal with these kinds of things, isn't it?
by ljmathi
by oz_media
We KNOW what Bush THOUGHT you should go to war. Yes Saddam DID have WMD that you had ignored for so many years as he was using them to attack your enemies at that time. He can have what he wants if he's with us.
The focus then changed to everyone (including America) breaching sanctions. Insopectors were kicked out of Iraq as Saddam was protesting the US holdig O.F.F. imports indefinitely for inspection. You were stopping food and medical supplies from entering Iraq under the theory of inspecting for dual purpose goods.
So you played a little back and forth and FINALLY Saddam realized Bush was serious ad allowed inspectors into Iraq. They were inspecting successfully, had turned up unused warheads left over from the Kurdish conflict but little else that yuo CLAIMED he ahd. Well he probably did at one time, not with the ability for intercontiental attack but he did hae mustard gas. Now oe thing about mustard gas, if you intend to stop dual-purpose imports, in the case of a efrigerator, this would be disallowed as it is a dual purpose import. Freon used in refrigeration becomes nerve gas when it is burned. Therefore importing refrigerators can be reported as receiving dual purpose goods.
So YES Saddam HAD something, he said he got rid of it, the weapons ispectors found nothing while inspecting KOWN sites. So who lied? Saddam asaid the WMD wer not there, inspectors didn't find them there. Bush said saddam had WMD and was going to use them to attack the USA, then he said Iraq needed liberation and democracy, again, WHO LIED?
It is highly probably that Saddam still had WMD and possibly moved them. Was he planig on using them against the USA, well I'm sure he wished he had the technology and delivery systems fro that anyway. Fact of the matter is, England was under a MUCH greater threat of attack than the US ever was, but your soldiers wouldn't have been supported for a milti-billion dollar effort to save England. Most American's already THINK you did that once and have ben helping the world ever since.
So t epoint is NOT that saddam had WMD, it is NOT that Saddam was a terorist. You went to war becaus eyou were told you needed to protect yourseles. not save Iraq, not remove a dictator but to SAVE yourselves from attack.
thee is ONE person who put your troops in Iraq. There IS only ONE person that CAN put your troops in Iraq. YOUR PRESIDENT.
WHY? Fear of attack.
FROM WHAT? WMD that you knew Saddam once used, although you didn't care then?
Well that hasn't been determined yet, but they are still spending billions and soldiers die daily to find a reason.
by tomsal
I've grown pretty burnt-out over this issue to be honest, I think (as the high post count will show) we are now crossing into the realm of "beating a dead horse"....
However, as I've recently picked up my "Knowledge of the World" book (I'm serious its really called that) last night, I was reading a section on the history and tactics of warfare which dates back to the Roman Empire and even further.
Going on what Oz said, about how we (as in USA) did nothing about Saddam's WMD while he used them against our enemies --- this is nothing new in the history of war.
In the Ancient world this was a tactic that was exploited time and again --- get your enemies to kill your enemies, THEN strike when their numbers have decreased or their supplies or spirit has been depleted.
The Romans did this, so did the Greeks...I'm sure others did too -- I'm not done the chapter, I feel asleep in the middle of reading it.
Just a tidbit I thought I'd add.
by aldanatech
by aldanatech
by oz_media
While reading through I noticed something that raised a simple question and I know you can offer an explanation.
I noticed that your reply was 'why doesn't the UN do anything about it?, Why is it up to the USA?' (or something to that efect).
Now from what I read here daily, you all see the UN as a waste of time and they are pretty useless. You stepped aroud the UN to go into Iraq and ivade as they were not doing anything to stop this threat you all feared so much. The justification is that it is YOUR responsibility to take pre-mptive actions against your enemies ad pretty much say FU to anyone who stands in your way.
Now with other countries also out to 'get' the USA, you are saying it's up to the UN to do something about it and why must you?
Sounds like you're expecting the best of both worlds, or whatever suits the moment.
Just a observation, but I'm sure you can twist it into a logical conclusion to support the US actions, or lack thereof.
by oz_media
Very evasive fact logging jimbo, keep your arms inside the windows while the bus is rolling.
Well Jim, actually I have NOTHING in common with the poster you are comparing me to. In fact, I don't se the same views at all, well not exactly anyway.
This is just yet ONE MORE USELESS POST FROM JIM, who has NEER had a relevant comment, NEVER had anything to add, NEVER had a statement that he made clear. JIMHM's ONLY use for TR discussions is to call people names and discount posts. Call people an arse or start flaming thier countries (WHICH NOBODY BUT AMRICAN CITIZENS GIVE A TOSS ABOUT). so I don't know WHO you ae trying to show off to, but it isn't anyone outside of America, I think your just looking for a hummer from your countrymen.
ONE DAY, actually probably not, you will have somethig relevant to say or add to a discussion that provides more than just a slam against someone. YOu may even be clear on you point or even have a point to begin with, but until that time, as it as been for over a year now, you just spout pure nonsense and never have anything worthwhile to add.
Keep it up Jim, you ae a perfect example of the high level of education and individual logic taught in you country.
by oz_media
Maxwell, you have always come across as someone who understands what is going on. Yet you say I keep repeating myself and then say you nkow what I think followed by some crap that has nothing to do with what I think. YOU ARE DARRING IT OUT, NOT ME.
If I ket saying "Well I know you supopted the war because of fear from WMD, Bush said so. Would you not constantly be correcting me and reiterating your point? Of course you would and I wouldn't expect you not to correct me ad reitersate yourself.
When someone else does it, it is wasting your time. Again, blind to your own actions.
I have never at ANYTIME said I didn't think Iraq was worthwhile, if so, please show me where.
I have also never said ANYTHING negative about the Iran conflict, if so, please show me where.
I don't see what the big surprise is? Or are you telling me that after more than a year of constantly correcting people's analogy's of what I feel, it is FINALLY starting to sink in? If so, well done but I wouldn't be too proud, I think many of your peers already understand my views quite well and have been clear for some time.
At first Bush was actig appropriately and counterig terrorism, well done.
Then he went to his alies with suspected information that would justify another war against Iraq for it's terrorism, again this is fine. When they wanted to wait until inspectios were finished, cowboy Bush from the Lone Star state decided he would wrangle him up some Iraqi's. Off goes the Lone Ranger to save his country from nothing. What a putz!
The at that gets me though, is that your president mislead an entire country and used that information to justify his country going to war. Now i your people thought it would be in anyway a long or brutal war, I'm sure support would have dwindled. With his strong willed speaches of stopping a threat on America, who couldn't support him?
Then the real story comes out. POSSIBLITY of WMD because nothing has been found yet you KNEW he had them at some time, er, good conclusion.
Oh well, they needed to be lberated anyway, and that Saddam's a bad guy anyway so it isn't all bad. Well of course not, but the people of america didn't seem to care, well SOME people didn't. You can tell them one thing, then change your mind and tell them something else and they will STILL defend your choices. Yeah, you guys have a real grip on your presidency? he is working FOR the people, not manipulating you all as many others claim. You knew all along he was full of Sh*t and simply figured even if WMD were NOT there, it was still worth sending troops and spending billions just to save the poor Iraqi's, my arse! I would be amazed if ONE SOLITARY AMERICAN CITIZEN (especially yourself)would have supported a war of high cost and no forseeable end for the sake of helping others! That's just not Maxwell, why should HE pay to save OTHERS!! That would be like HIS government taking HIS money and giving it to somebody in a third world country, damn that's worse than helping your own citizens!! Max didn't vote for a pussy, he voted for Republican! Repulicans support the have's not the have not's. How could this possibly happen?
nobody buys the SAE Iraqi's BS for a minute, itwasn't plastered all ober TV while yourresident looked so worried and concerned for america's safety ad the well beig of 'her ' people.
Absolute hogwash, pure BS and not a single ounce of truth to it at all.
YOu thought it would be an easy invasion to save your lives, wrong.
Bush thought it would be an easy invasion and the oil would flow with a pleased democratic ally.
Nobody else did, nobody else supported you. our president assued you he was right in SAVING America fom the madman. You then defended him against your new found enemies. They were right, Bush was wrong, you STILL defend him like complete and utter bufoons. Yet if he said he was unfaithful to his wife, and therefore bastardizing the religious face that America shines, he would be impeached.
What a F****D up society ?!?
by ljmathi
by oz_media
not that I disagree with you quote;
Anyone who uses George Bush as an authority fits solidly in the category of "idiots and fools".
If we say that MM's 9/11 is MOSTLY fabricated, what 5 or 10 percent of it being truth do you wish to accept? I know NOTHING as it is Anti-Republican and strictly unAmerican. If you don't supoprt reublicans yuo must be against America and all that BS. No wonder your country is divided within itself.
.
In fact, no one can be as smart as Oz, because Oz thinks he knows all. Oz is simply the smartest person ever to be born - or so he would like to believe. Yep, he's right, everyone else is wrong. Yep, he understands everyone and everything, others don't understand.
You're a real bore.
Like I said, get a life.
by oz_media
You certainly set me straight. Man I bet all the other TR pers really se you as beig right now, what a way to mak your point!!
Unfortunately, you addressed NOTHIG I mentioned, probably just don't get it still. Or else you simply realized you have been wrong in your assumptions again, thus making your last post invalid.
Well done, way to counter and offer a logical retort, we could only hope that our citizens dcould be as smart as yourself one day.
Now, you suggested that I am the smartest person on earth, well I'm flattered but have to disagree. A four year old child could see this deceptive BS from Bush though, I KNOW as a fact that you can, you simply don't wish to address it though. You know he mislead you but don't care because you still fel he is just in his actions. Well the action was okay, the REACTION was not. This was a REACTION to a suspected threat. Not a confirmed action against a proven threat, you know it, I know it, the world knows it, you just refuse to believe it was deceptive.
Well it Maxwell and his inions against the world, Max is right, the world is wrong.
So I supposed that make YOU the all knowing and never wrong Maxwell, I'll take credit for being observant and recognizing deceit, but nobody could ever be possibly as correct and all knowing as Maxwell, America's best ally, the world's worst enemy.
.
I said what I said, no more, no less.
As far as "twisting" to reach a desired conclusion, I'll leave that up to you.
by sullyman
by admin
It makes some people a little more uncomfortable to read about current issues, so studying Rome, or I pointed out above, The Maine all lead to some people having an easier time being objective.
If you can be objective about the present time and can seperate good strategy to understand and appreciate it, you should read The Grand Chessboard. It's eerie how well thought out it is.
by oz_media
I suppose as you said what you said, then you are agreeing that the UN is of no use to the USA, or anyone else for that matter, and you are warranted in taking care of things yourself. F**k the UN, which you have said many times, though perhaps in different/prettier words though.
At the same time, you are suggesting that it is up to the UN to resolve OTHER matters that don't benefit yourselves directly and it shouldn't be YOUR duty to protect yourselves against terrorists in countries or help repressed citizens where you have no interest in gains from thier resources?
You will do what is best for America, forget the terror and liberation smoke screen, if it's not for the benefit of America, it's just not worthwile.
So there's your TWIST, as I'm sure you will call it. Unfortunately, that's the conclusion your prior statement CLEARLY points toward, not much TWISTING needed at all, you were quite clear where you stand, unfortunately.
Do ALL American citizens know this or do some actually believe you are attempting to conduct a humanitarian effort by shelling Iraq?
What I do find interesting is that The UN is useless to Americans but the rest of the world is supposed to listen to them.
It's as if you have washed you hands of the US/UN association and simply feel it is okay for those who don't want to follow UN rules to break out and be cowboys (well those that are on your side anyway, Saddam he must obey the UN though), I mean why should you (who are always saving the thankless world from certain doom) listen to the UN for God's sake?
Well this is exactly what happened when you ignored the sanctions the first time, you were accused of breaching sanctions just as you had accused Saddam and it has finally lead to Americans doubting the UN and other allied countries who they were told didn't follow America's rules.
How many understand that America didn't hold up THEIR end of the bargain either?
America went against UN sanctions and virtually starved Iraq of needed resources, so when you point the finger at Germany, Russia and the other 'unpleasant' countries, do you actually believe that America played by the rules too?
You either stand by the UN or you don't, or if you prefer, you are either WITH them or AGAINST them. If you are AGAINST them, why would you invade a country based on the fact that they never followed UN regulations? You don't think YOU have to.
So do we obey the UN, do we obey them only when it is in our best interests or do we obey America and do what is in your OWN best interests? You tell me.
Noting that ANY resolution that declares each country for itself is completely absurd when fighting a global terrorist threat.
There MUST be SOME form of organization on a global level, I suppose you will say it should be the USA that dictates how the world will handle terrorism, I say it should be Bella Coola that's in charge.
You cannot continually isolate yourself from every other country, and then complain that nobody supports you.
You say how people don't react to threats and how detrimental it has been in the past, leading to modern day terrorism.
Then in the same breath, the US will do as it wants when it wants and it's nobody else's business?
Unfortunately, Saddam had that same mindset, he did what he wanted and it is nobody's business, including yours.
Of course you wouldn't stand for this and BS'd America into supporting the war. So where do the lies and deception stop? They don't and they won't as long as you all suport such things as they get spewed from your government.
Save America, screw everyone else. If others don't play by our rules we will invade them, yet don't expect US to play by YOUR rules.
What a two-faced and hypocritical crock of crap.
Yup, two sides to your mouth and yet you have the uncanny ability to speak from both simultaneously.
This is just more know it all BS from Oz though so there's no need for you to go out of your way and tell everyone I am a liar. Especially when I have just provided observations based on your comments.
Everyone can see how the discussion flowed and your pals will always see you as right and me as wrong, some minds are so fixated on an specific conclusion no plot changes could possibly take them off track. the easiest way to discout any opinion without having a justified response is to somply discount the opinion as a whole, or the poster as you usually do.
The more I speak to you, the more I realize how single minded you are and how you simply MUST put everything into it's rightful place so that you can apear to be somewhat open minded.
Then again, some people will believe anything, even Bush.
by garion11
"You know he mislead you but don't care because you still fel he is just in his actions. Well the action was okay, the REACTION was not. This was a REACTION to a suspected threat. Not a confirmed action against a proven threat, you know it, I know it, the world knows it, you just refuse to believe it was deceptive"
Obviously you still don't fu**king get it. So again here it is,
"You know he mislead you but don't care because you still fel he is just in his actions."
No he didn't mislead us, its his policy we chose to support. YOU may THINK he mislead us, we don't think he MISLEAD us. Its a matter of opinion, stop trying to tell us what you think we should know, kk thx.
"Well the action was okay, the REACTION was not. This was a REACTION to a suspected threat.
Yes this was a REACTION to a suspected threat. Guess what??, thats the US policy now. Pre emptive action!!!, if you don't agree with it, thats fine, please continue to spew your stupidity on this board (which I am sure you will).
"Not a confirmed action against a proven threat, you know it, I know it, the world knows it, you just refuse to believe it was deceptive"
Yes, it was a reaction to a suspected and proven (proven = ?? whatever that means, I guess we had to wait till we were attacked?? for it to be a proven. Saddam attacked US and British warplanes and defied 17 UN resolutions for 12 years, but forget that a moment) threat. I am not sure what "proven" is but the pre emptive and PROACTIVE (as opposed to REACTIVE) action against a perceived threat is now the foreign policy of the United States AGAINST rogue and terrorist states.
You don't have to agree with it, nor do you have to understand it. Frankly I don't care. But from your stupid, reckless, and repititive posts, you obviously aren't understanding the US foreign policy and WHY we did what we did. If we win, its great. If we lose, we will feel the pain. Whats it to you what happens??
Now WTF don't you understand??
by oz_media
You picked up on oe point that is just a result of poor grammar on my part.
I said "This was a REACTION to a suspected threat. Not a confirmed action against a proven threat, you know it, I know it, the world knows it, you just refuse to believe it was deceptive."
I should have used a comma between threat "and. Not".
I mean that the threat of WMD and an attack on America requiring immediate action was not confirmed and what should have been a decisive action was more of a knee-jerk reaction to a suspected threat that deserved investigation. I would be all for it if Bush hadn't used deception and then simply changed focus with little explanation. Even that isn't so bad but I couldn't believe it when Americans didn't seem to care.
It isn't MY opinion compared to yours when it comes to the deception though. Many say GWB outright lied, which I also said at first. There IS no proof that Saddam STILL has WMD and is planning or capable of using them against America, thus making the threat less of an urgency when compared to an outright declaration of war or something. It is PROVEN that the information was unreliable and doubted BEFORE being submitted.
The war was SOLD to America as a war that couldn't wait for the allied nations committal, it couldn't wait for the inspectors to finish what they were successfully doing, America was at risk of attack from Iraq and Saddam's known stashes of WMD. He was not cooperating with weapons inspectors and they were finding nothing (which is entirely untrue).
Now I know Bush had his writers put this much more eloquently and with many more words but the bottom line is that you were told, I was told, Toni Blair was told and England along with the rest of the world was told, that Saddam was going to attack the USA with weapons of mass destruction and his terrorist MUST be stopped immediately.
Having recently watched the atrocities of 9/11, who in their right mind would possibly argue with this reasoning ?
So far Bush is doing okay,
So then they yank the inspectos out and line up to start blowing te crap out of Baghdad, er....well okay, I suppose, if you are SURE you are going to be attacked.
Ten it starts to surface that the reports are not decisive. Hmmmm. Okay, why not?
Well the sources aren't reliable, the document was not really supposed to be so definitive, well it was a long shot but we KNOW he killed a bunch of Kudish with Mustard Gas and he breached UN sanctions (not that you didn't but in more of a 'little white lie' way).
okay, so perhaps it wasn't so urgent and you weren't at threat of attack from Saddam and WMD. NOW what? Well the British found mass graves, so they sold the horrible man's masskilling of his people theory so that we would all think he'd been gassing Iraqi's for all these years and still support the war.
All along, nobody has even batted an eye that you are invading a freakin' country under false premise! American's who are SO patriotic and SO proud of the flag and JUSTICE and FREEDOM and FAITH IN THE GOVERNMENT stuff, aren't lynching this guy right after freaking out because Clinton got gobbled in his office, like any other lucky worker who gets a piece at work (yes married men too).
Hang on, something's wrong here, it's PROVEN the information was faslified at best, why hasn't this been addressed?
Blair did, and then he added that he had been begged by several thousand Iraqi's to help Liberate the country. Poeple were pretty miffed but for the most part it was acceptable.
Bush just proudly visited an Aircraft carrier and carved a plastic turkey for a phto op and kept on going. Meanwhile half of America is arguing about whether WMD exist or not, they wer told they did, where are they?
Nothing on the news, nothing in the paper, just debates, not decisive statements.
Found anything yet? You KNEW he had em, you even KNEW where they were at one time.
The people that provided the information say it was false or misleading. The person who used that information to coerce America into a state of war did NOT accept that it was false or misleading.
You were decieved by your president without apology or explanation.
Yet you don't care.
You are at war in another country.
Yet you don't care.
That's the whole problem all along I think, he got away with it because when people are scared they just don't care about reason or justifications, they act in a rash manner. This is why we are supposed to elect rational leaders who can act appropriately in such situations.
by aldanatech
by aldanatech
by steve biko
I have heard comments made by some: If everybody just agreed with Bush (and the USA), then we would have no conflict (you're either with us or against us? Remember that?). It's like being in an abusive marriage: "if she would just listen, I would stop hitting her"!!
USA, land of the free and the brave (once they've hammered their opposition into submission); and the maker and enforcer of rules.
by sullyman
by thieleh
by steve biko
by oz_media
I just posted a reply in the wrong place!
I meant to reply to your last comment but somehow ended up posting above. Ahhh, you'll get used to it.
.
"Today I am signing into law ************. This Act makes clear that it is the sense of the Congress that the United States should support those elements of the Iraqi opposition that advocate a very different future for Iraq than the bitter reality of internal repression and external aggression that the current regime in Baghdad now offers.
Let me be clear on what the U.S. objectives are: The United States wants Iraq to rejoin the family of nations as a freedom-loving and law-abiding member. This is in our interest and that of our allies within the region.
The United States favors an Iraq that offers its people freedom at home. I categorically reject arguments that this is unattainable due to Iraq's history or its ethnic or sectarian make-up. Iraqis deserve and desire freedom like everyone else. The United States looks forward to a democratically supported regime that would permit us to enter into a dialogue leading to the reintegration of Iraq into normal international life.
My Administration has pursued, and will continue to pursue, these objectives through active application of all relevant United Nations Security Council resolutions. The evidence is overwhelming that such changes will not happen under the current Iraq leadership.
In the meantime, while the United States continues to look to the Security Council's efforts to keep the current regime's behavior in check, we look forward to new leadership in Iraq that has the support of the Iraqi people. The United States is providing support to opposition groups from all sectors of the Iraqi community that could lead to a popularly supported government.
One way or the other, we are determined to deny Iraq the capacity to develop weapons of mass destruction and the missiles to deliver them. That is our bottom line.
If Saddam rejects peace and we have to use force, our purpose is clear. We want to seriously diminish the threat posed by Iraq's weapons of mass destruction program."
by oz_media
Jim's not a bad guy, he tries hard and means well, unfortunately it just doesn't seem to come together too often.
We used to have a real nutter here called RiverFreight, who's most common answers in tech Q&A usually involved replacing and soldering semi conductors on the motherboard, he disappeared from here but pokes his nose into Tech Q&A still.
Anyway, Jim's got NOTHING on that guy.
I will say he (Jim) usually leaves me stunned and rereading his posts over and over again as I can't actually believe a modern day living human would see the world that way. For he most part it's simply cheap entertaiment and a good way to kill time. On the other hand it get's frustrating if you are here on one of your 'bad' days, and then it seems to just get plain annoying. Then the loop begins again.
Many people disappear for a month or so but they almost always come back. Sometimes it's like vistiing the zoo and watching the monkeys toss feces back and forth all day. :-)
The hardest part has got to be sitting back and watching the show, you almost ALWAYS get dragged in by someone.
.
Why do you demonize those who make more money than you?
Why do you want them to give their money to you?
How can you give a "tax cut" to someone (low income earners) who pays no taxes in the first place?
Has a "poor guy" ever given you - or anyone - a job?
Why do you think it's right for a government bureaucrat to take a dollar from the person who earned it, just to give it to a person who didn't earn it?
Don't you think taking ONE TRILLION dollars a year from the people who earned it, just to give it to people who didn't earn it, is enough?
Do you think a person is born with the inherent responsibility to take care of him/her self, and not become a burden to society?
Seven questions. That's enough for now, but can you answer them without falling into the normal "class envy" rhetoric?
I have my own persoal, private oppinions about President Bush, and these oppinions shall stay as such. By the way, I'm a Canadian, and wonder how the Americans feel with all that blood from all those innocent people on their hands.
The terrorists do what they do because they hate that US commercialism is in their faces. If thats not all of it, at least it's a big part of it, and if America really wants to stop terrorism, Americans should quit sticking their noses in countries that really hate the intrusion of their businesses.If thats not it, then the arrogant, pigheaded leaders might want to ask themselves what it is that the Americans are doing that so piss off people that they would want to kill themselves in a suicide attack. Stop what you're doing that pisses off peoples of the world and you'll stop terrorism.
.
First you say that you will keep your opinions to yourself.
Then you immediately ask how Americans feel with "blood on their hands", and go on an on with your other "sticking their noses in other countries business", "arrogant" and "pigheaded" comments.
Are you for real? Or were you simply blowing smoke when you said that you want to keep your opinion to yourself?
Blow some more, and show your true ignorance.
.
I can't believe how ignorant and naive so many people are.
Grow up and see thing for what they really are instead of spouting all your platitudes and pie-in-the-sky, Polly-Anna crap.
by aldanatech
.
Because to not do it would have been irresponsible.
Even Bill Clinton agrees that President Bush did the right thing.
Did you know that 9-11 was six years in the planning? Did you know that some of that intelligence information could have also been years old?
Your ignorance amazes me.
by aldanatech
Here are my answers:
Why do you demonize those who make more money than you?
Answer: I don't, but the government should treat everyone fairly. If the middle class (which is a working class, people that do pay taxes) can pay taxes, so should the high class.
Why do you want them to give their money to you?
Answer: Its not that I actually want them to give me their money, but the middle class deserves those tax cuts more than they do.
How can you give a "tax cut" to someone (low income earners) who pays no taxes in the first place?
Answer: Again, I'm not talking about the low class, I'm talking about the middle class; people that work hard and do pay taxes.
Has a "poor guy" ever given you - or anyone - a job?
Answer: You mean the middle class, right? Yes, I have worked for small businesses and government programs.
Why do you think it's right for a government bureaucrat to take a dollar from the person who earned it, just to give it to a person who didn't earn it?
Answer: Both the high class and middle class earned it, so if the high class can get money back, why can't the middle class.
Don't you think taking ONE TRILLION dollars a year from the people who earned it, just to give it to people who didn't earn it, is enough?
Answer: Well Bush thought HIS Tax cuts were enough. It turned out to be a total bust, and again you are still refering to the low class, not the middle class.
Do you think a person is born with the inherent responsibility to take care of him/her self, and not become a burden to society?
Answer: Ask the low class.
by aldanatech
On September 11, 2001, Bush was reading to an Elementary School class in Florida. When the White House Chief of Staff told him that a second hijacked jetliner had hit the World Trade Center, it took him between five and seven minutes to get a grip of himself and excused himself from the class. In response to a journalist's question about how Kerry would have handled the situation, this is what he had to say:
"Had I been reading to children and had my top aide whispered in my ear, 'America is under attack,' I would have told those kids very politely and nicely that the president of the United States had something that he needed to attend to -- and I would have attended to it."
So do think Bush's reaction to 9/11 was appropriate?
.
...instead of letting Michael Moore think for you.
You have no friggin idea what President Bush was thinking, why he was thinking it, and what his intentions may have been. You just don't know - and neither does Michael Moore.
Why can't you think for yourself?
by aldanatech
by jamesrl
I have to say I had questions about it, long before Micheal Moore. I would have expected a quicker reaction.
But in the end - I don't think a nine minute delay had any impact on anything. It would have taken at least that long for the handlers to rearrange travel plans, and start organizing.
James
by aldanatech
Recently, the 9/11 panel reported that an attack of even greater magnitude than 9/11 is now possible and even probable. Kean, a former Republican governor of New Jersey said "Every expert with whom we spoke told us an attack of even greater magnitude is now possible and even probable. We do not have the luxury of time."
The panel also said that "the Al Qaeda network and its affiliates are sophisticated, patient, disciplined and lethal." Do you consider then, that Bush?s plan to fight terrorism has been rather ineffective?
by aldanatech
by steve biko
Hey Oz, you sound like a really good guy. You didn't immigrate to Canada from South Africa did you?(don't take that as an insult). Many South Africans immigrated to Canada, not too many to the US though, despite the cold in Canada.
My ramblings probably give you a bit of entertainment as well, comments from a country struggling to get of the third world and into the first world. We speak about different things to what I have seen on these discussions, it's interesting to see how different priorities are.
We've had enough of war, it cost our country R 8 million per day when the exchange rate was nearly R1 = 1USD in the 80's. Lost a lot of good young men for nothing and probably killed a lot more. But hey, they were fair game, on the other side and some were even armed!
In general South Africans are interested in politics just because we all have a say for a change. Does'nt make much difference sometimes, we really only have 4 serious parties: ANC, Democratic Alliance, Inkatha Freedom party and the New National Party (these buggers should just pack it in after what they did to the country in the past, I'd be too embarassed to keep going!).
ANC still have more than a 2/3 majority though, mostly because they represented the masses when they weren't allowed to vote.
Sort by Trending