Discussion Locked

Why the Constant Arguing

0 helpful
245 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

245 replies

by absolutely

"I do own a valuable resource, me. I checked the patents copyrights and the deeds. They're all owned by ME.

Everybody else owns their own me as well.

There are some halfwits who think they don't, you are welcome to them."

I couldn't have said it better. I only wish I had said it first.

by absolutely

Lee o: "Really my problem is with the pseudo elitists who feel they are superior designs for the simple fact that they use a Mac."

Why would you care about what somebody else feels? Assuming they're wrong, wouldn't their irrationality make them less formiddable competitors? And if they're right, shouldn't you be switching brands instead of calling them names like "pseudo elitists"?

Lee o: "This is even exacerbated by Mac putting out misinformation in their new Intel ads. "The chip has been trapped in boring little boxes doing boring tasks..." or something to that effect. That is insulting to non Mac creatives the world over."

I'm certain that the insult was directed at the competing manufacturers, not at the potential customers. I'm not affiliated with Apple, but I'm sure they would extend their apologies for the misunderstanding.

On my own behalf, I'll quote Oz_Media: "Oh waaaaa!"

by rkuhn040172

Win XP - SP2 (reboot) - 3 Patches (reboot) - 38 Patches (reboot)

Total time - 1 1/2 hours including formatting

So, going from base install to fully patched took 1 1/2 hours and only 3 reboots.

The rest of the patches at that point were optional.

On a PIV 2.7GHZ with 1GB RAM and 533Mhz motherboard...nice system but not out of the normal.

by jamesrl

If you are required to provide decent support to all users, and those Macs are not going away, you should probably bite the bullet. Macs can join just about any network - way back we even had them able to access Banyan Vines.

If you think that management will force the Macs out of existence, then your time would be better spent on other projects.

James

by codebubba

Rick,

I remember back about 12 or so years ago the same kind of thing went on with the OS/2 folks. I tried to use it for awhile myself so I was in the OS/2 forums. They played the same "We're gonna take over the world" tune that the Linux guys are doing. I finally gave up on OS/2 after a year or so because I found that I just had to keep tweaking it all the time and I had limited choices (very limited) of Natively written stuff to run on it.

I also looked into Linux recently just to see if it might be a viable thing to even think about. I went up to the websites of the major players like CompUSA, Best Buy, Circuit City and the rest. They all carry thousands of Windows compatible items, software etc. Linux stuff? Well, CompUSA had a total of 13 items, 3 of which were the Linux distros themselves. I figured, why should I waste my time even thinking about this?

Everything I own plugs in to my Windows systems and are as idiot-proof as you could get. My cameras, Pocket PC, thumb-drive - you name it, it works. I've also been developing software to the Microsoft platforms ever since 1982 and while not perfect, man has it ever been a good career.

Why the bickering? I really don't know why these guys have to get so "religious" about this. I certainly don't mind someone running Linux if they want to - go right ahead! I don't know anyone who uses Linux other than experimentally myself - but I know there are some who do. The guys on these boards really seem to be in a "we're taking over the world" mode which really doesn't make a lot of sense. All you have to do is open your eyes and walk into any electronics store to see that ain't happening. However ... maybe there's an underground movement that's going to magically reverse the tide all-of-a-sudden and we poor Windows saps just don't know about it!

I used to get involved in some of those arguments myself - but realized that there's just no point anymore. I just let them go use their Linux and I go get my work done. When I need something (like Quicken or Turbo Tax or whatever) I just run down to the Office Depot, buy it and get my work done - that's it. The whole Windows platform has become (IMHO) a very well oiled, well supplied vehicle for getting a LOT of work done with very little hassle.

Later!

-CB ;-)

by tony hopkinson

I don't remember calling you a sap, after reading this garbage though, I can amend the oversight if you wish.

by jmgarvin

What can you do in Windows that I can't do in Linux? What makes you think electronic stores are where people by production machines?

Just so you know, Wal-Mart does sell computers with Linspire (Linux) preloaded on them...

When I need something like Quicken or Turbo Tax, I don't leave my chair. I just download Moneydance (or if you like gnucash) in place of Quicken or I grab Open Tax Solver or even use Turbo Tax online.

For a VERY short (and somewhat data) list of alternatives you can use in Linux:

http://www.uselinuxathome.com/ENapps.htm

by rkuhn040172

No one is saying that we can do something in Windows that you can't do in Linux.

BTW, I'm pretty sure the Linspire PC's at Walmart were a huge disappointment sales wise unless you count people like me that buy them only to put Windows on them.

Just curious because I don't know, but do those Linux programs offer the support and guarantees that programs like H&R Block, Turbo Tax, etc offer?

And I don't mean just tech support, I mean tax support and advice...

by mark miller

So a typical user is used to finding software online. Is that it? If it takes the user being resourceful to find software, that's a loser with them right there. If it isn't on TV, advertised on the web, or in a computer magazine, or on the store shelf, most don't know it exists.

I used to "scrounge for software" many years ago when I used a minority platform. Most computer users I knew at the time didn't care for it, and didn't believe in doing it. I'm fairly sure the same is true today.

by awfeckit2

I see that you and others have mentioned religion in regard to linux proselytizers and it looks as if you're on the right track.

If you compare linuxers to born again christians you see a lot of similarities.

They used to be sinners (Windows users), but, one way or another, they discovered the lord (linux), now it's their mission and duty to save the rest of the world from sin (windows) so we sinners will go to wherever the saved (linuxers) go when they die.
They don't ask us if we want to go there. They just know that what's best for them is best for everyone.

They don't get it that most of us sinners (windows users) couldn't care less about linux and are not interested in going to linux heaven.

That's another similarity with born again christians. You tell them you're not interested and they tell you that's because you don't know any better, but they're bound that they're going to convert you anyway.

Another similarity is they stick they're noses into discussions that have nothing whatever to do with their religion so they can proselytize.

I know all linuxers aren't like this, but too many of them are.

Most windows users, in my experience, don't really care what OS other people use so we aren't forever trying to "help" others see the light.

I doubt that I'll ever see the linux light. I'll stick to windows and won't get to linux heaven when my time is up, thank Bill. I really would rather not spend eternity with some of these people.

amen.

ps. I just chose christians as an example because that's what most of us are familiar with. A comparison with fundamentalists from any other religious group would probably have worked just as well.

by jmgarvin

Wow, I have to give you credit, did it take you 2 or 3 seconds to copy and paste that?

Did you have to search for it long, or did you have it book marked?

by mark miller

I used Unix most of the time I was in college, and used it for 3 years out in the workplace. IMO Unix's main strength is that it's a base-level OS. You can customize it into anything you want (though it doesn't handle realtime applications well unless you have the right kernel for that). The downside was if you pretty much knew what technology domain you were going to stay in, it was difficult to find functionality to support it. You pretty much had to build it yourself. Once I realized I liked working in the business application domain, I found that Windows supports that better, so I've switched and haven't looked back that much. As far as some are concerned, I "joined the Borg" or "the dark side". IMO Windows has the best developer support for the business application domain. Every time I've looked at OSS, I've found it's brought Unix/Linux a long way from where it was 10 years ago, but it still doesn't have the level of support that I expect now for doing the work I do.

But this is just me. Windows isn't right for everything.

What's interesting to me is when I run into Linux/OSS advocates and they make arguments against Windows, I can usually relate to what they're talking about, and their argument does grab my "inner geek" a little because of that. But I also remember what I gave up in order to get what I've gained. I don't work at the operating system level, which is where the OSS advocates typically argue from. They really appreciate the inner workings of technology. I'm more focused on creating applications, not dealing with the OS. So as far as I'm concerned, it's not my problem.

by tony hopkinson

No let's have a first one, because the first wasn't a thought.

You're a professional, take your pick delete and create a user account, restore their data or rebuild the entire server and restore all user data.

by tony hopkinson

Speed and power is the requirement on an easy to use slow system.
Ease of use is important on an opaque system that is at least fast enough.

by npbwbass

I completely agree with this post. I use Linux. MAC, & Windows where I see fit. For me the budget argument supports the Linux side a bit better but I will use what I see fit for the whole equation. The bottom line is user knowledge is the real power behind the operating systems of choice. Professionally I have to account for every item's ROI and that adds a whole new variable to the computing equation and it is much more than just the computer or its operating system. The human variable is a complex player in that game. Learning curves, manpower & time for training, support, and technical skill levels available to maintain the systems needs to be defined before you make any decision. If you are making these choices out of ?emotional content? then you would be incorrectly trying to solve issue.

by tony hopkinson

There are some aspects of both TCO and ROI where the numbers are basically made up, because they aren't quantifiable.
How do you put a monetary value on the existing familiarity with windows, the availability of professional to maintain the systems?

Proponents for BOTH sides can easily come up with a number that looks grounded and supports their case. Opponents can look at that and come up with their solution and say liar, you worked this out wrong.

If you take the intangibles out Linux wins hands down, but that still doesn't prove you should move to linux. After all switching environments will hit you with a big cost in one place or even many. Mustn't forget the risk factor of potential disruption, climbing the learning curve etc.

Very hard to justify that to a bean counter, if he gets a view from both sides, which even a stupid one would do. 9/10 times they are going to plump for staying as is .

There are humans involved so you can't take the emotion out. I'm sure Vulcan's would choose linux everytime, but they are all very intelligent chaps on the path to enlightemnent, new does'nt scare them.
Let's face it, bean counter's have to do a full study and analysis when their bread goes stale.

by rkuhn040172

Since I image all my machines.

10 1/2 minutes later, done.

If something hoses up the profile or machine and the user didn't store data on the server, their bad not mine because even if it was just a profile issue, their My Documents is gone anyways barring some undelete type of program is successful.

by apotheon

That would be you. You're the instigator. If you want to avoid these flame wars, stop trolling for them.

Nobody with two brain cells to rub together could possibly have posted the statements that started this thread without expecting it to be the start of another huge debate on the comparative merits of operating systems. Pretending you didn't expect just that is disingenuous.

Well, good. I'm glad there's a debate. It helps to get the facts out in the open. It also helps to identify the trolls (you, for instance) and to make clear what fallacious, FUDdy arguments are common.

You started four separate and distinct Windows vs. Linux flamewars, took the stance that anyone arguing against Windows was wrong, used fallacies and insults to make your "points", and blamed everyone else for the resultant disagreements. Now, you're doing it all over again, and you expect people to believe you want as all to just "get along". BS. You're full of it.

by tony hopkinson

it's just nice if teh design is robust enough for a work around not to be needed.

Doesn't matter what OS, backups are a given anyway. Don't care how good an OS is, there's no defence against stupidity.

by mark miller

I had heard a little about the WMF exploit, but didn't get into the details. What I'm wondering about is the idea that some claim that one can invade system space from user space in Windows. I've heard this claim more than once. When I've heard detailed explanations of vulnerabilities in the past they're not like this. Anyone remember GPFs (General Protection Faults) in Windows? It's been my understanding that Windows has had memory monitoring technology in it for a long time, and that a GPF was Windows protecting itself from just this sort of thing: a program a user was running straying off into system memory.

For example, there was a SQL Server exploit that used a buffer overflow to launch an attack and spread itself around. It was my understanding that the exploit used a way to get in that was already in the system space. The problem has been that Windows does not separate data space from code space, like Unix does. This has just recently been addressed by hardware DEP. So the reason a buffer overflow worked, is that it could get the computer to copy a string such that a portion of the string overwrote some op-codes in the program that was running. The exploit began in system space and stayed there. The exploit utilized something in SQL Server's communication protocol, something it uses to communicate between servers. This would not be in the user space. Likewise there have been other exploits I've heard about that used the RPC protocol in Windows. Again, another exploit that starts and ends in system space.

I haven't heard of an exploit that crosses the boundary from user space to system space, unless WMF was one of them. The reason why it might seem that such exploits have succeeded is because so many people run Windows as administrators (like root in Unix). They open an attachment in e-mail and it gains permission to the whole system. They can alter or overwrite whatever files they want, etc. Same thing could happen if a user was running e-mail as root in Linux and happened to open a trojan attachment. Most Linux users are smart enough not to do that, but just saying it's a matter of what mode applications are run in.

I asked if anyone had seen such an exploit that crossed from the user/system boundary, and saw that it actually worked that way, because that would prove that it's possible. I know people get the idea that since portions of IE are built into the kernel and all that this MUST be possible. I'm more skeptical than that.

by tony hopkinson

Lets say you have a buffer overun flaw in a routine that renders an image.
In linux that rendering routine only runs in user space. The very low primitives run in kernel (write to device) but they are pretty much solid now and rarely change.

In windows however the render routines are in the kernel. If they overrun and you get a code injection, The code runs with with kernel priviliges, basically local system account.

In linux given that the kernel is solid, the code injection will have the user's access. So unless you've been a complete twonk, it won't do anything outside the user's home directory.

So the vulnerability doesn't really cross from user to kernel space in windows.

For Linux think of one sphere inside of another.

For windows think of it as spiky ball in side of a sphere. ie the kernel projects into user space.

by rkuhn040172

I don't control your keyboard. I just asked a serious question.

But once again, you go on the offensive talking about two brain cells, trolling, and being disingenuous.

Like numerous posters have said before, if you misinterpret my statements or read in between the lines when there is nothing there, that is your fault not mine.

Besides, who made you God? Why do you get to determine what is FUD and what is fact?

I have never said anyone arguing against Windows is wrong. I don't use fallacies (unless you are the only one deciding what is a fallacy and what isn't) and I don't expect everyone to just get along.

I am wanting to hear opinions but don't like the offensive, self centered, egotistical, arrogant comments that I constantly get from certain people.

I can and would like to engage in meaning debates about the merits of certain issues. But certain people have a God like complex and just don't seem to be able to join these debates and remain civil.

by apotheon

Your audacity amazes me.

By the way, the statements I made indicated that you [b]either[/b] don't have two brain cells to rub together [b]or[/b] are a troll and being disingenuous. The rest of my post should point out which case I think to be true.

I don't think you're that stupid. I think you use slipshod reasoning and are looking for a fight, though -- and you're not above pretending to be something you're not to manufacture a false sense of superiority.

by nighthawk808

http://www.opensuse.org
http://www.debian.org
http://www.kubuntu.org or http://www.ubuntu.org
http://fedora.redhat.com/

Pick one. But for a fair comparison, remove the free programs like OpenOffice.org, The GIMP, etc., whose commercial counterparts cost hundreds of dollars extra and don't come on your Windows CD, since Windows only comes with the Windows part. After all, you wouldn't want Linux to install faster than Windows even though you installed a bunch of free extra stuff, would you?

Kubuntu took me 40 minutes to install on a computer that's slower than what you're using. And that included OpenOffice and 1170 other free programs.

by jmgarvin

The others, I honestly don't know. I use a CPA, so I've no idea what support is out there for the tax programs.

As for support with the other programs:
Between the community support and the developer support with most of those, you get EXCELLENT customer support for something that is free beer.

by absolutely

I thought it was hilarious. Although, the Linux geeks I have met have much less of a stench than religious fundies, and tend to have a point: [b]for the accomplishment of productive work[/b], Linux can often be supported [b]rationally[/b] over the competition. My experiences with Win98 will always be a selling point for Apple and whatever Linux distro seems most convenient. I simply no longer trust MS as far as I can throw the city of Redmond.

I also think it's ironic that the OS called "Windows" is so opaque that the term "Power User" is an oxymoron without a silent "L".

by absolutely

H&R Block has an online tax submission form, in addition to whatever software they offer. It probably works with Linux. In general, the worst case scenario for a Linux user is that any software made for Windows that doesn't yet have a superior open-source replacement, can be used in Linux with wine.

by rdavies9

On the other hand, how come Microsoft is always pushing the Windows Server TCO is lower than Linux adverts all the time. Methinks the lady doth protest too loudly.

I run Linux on all my work machines because they are built from scratch and I want legal (and inexpensive) options for web development and browsing and such - no games here. My file server has been running with no down time for the past 3 years. Occassionally we get a power failure and it just boots back up and keeps on jugging away. With other peoples windows machines all I see is security holes, spyware, viruses, BSOD, lost partitions, etc (I fix computers in my spare job).
Anyway - I for one don't miss Windows much, although I keep a spare computer in the back room in case I have to run some Windows only software (e.g QuickTax at tax time).

by nighthawk808

Totally Cool Options or Trustworthy Computer O/S or Total Confidence in Operation, then naturally Windows Server's TCO is going to be lower than Linux. Maybe M$ is onto something.

Here's a brief history of how Microsoft's FUD campaign has evolved throughout the years:
http://lxer.com/module/newswire/view/57261/index.html
Rickk might find this enlightening as well. I posted it especially for his reading pleasure.

Post edited to correct typermagrafical errur.

by rkuhn040172

By posting an article by a clearly biased Linux supporter attacking Microsoft.

That's how to win people over now isn't it?

So, what you are now the authorative source on what's FUD and what isn't by posting an article as such?

The Internet is so vast that I'm pretty sure if you gave me 1 minute I could easily find an article saying the exact opposite by another "expert".

I prefer to make up my own mind using my own experiences and not following someone else's agenda.

That article is kind of like asking Hillary Clinton if Bill Clinton was the best president ever.

by apotheon

Debian Etch/Testing install (lots of updates, because it's an up-to-date release of Debian, rather than Sarge/Stable, which is a "locked" release equivalent to a Windows version):

37 minutes total
83 patches
zero reboots

total interaction:
63 keystrokes (including hostname, username, account passwords, et cetera)

system specs:
350MHz Pentium II
256MB RAM

Mostly, a Debian install for an English-speaker consists of hitting Enter. The core system install itself, including most of the keystrokes involved and the hard drive partitioning, took 13 minutes. Thirteen. Wow. Yeah. Compare how long it takes to get to your first reboot of XP from a retail CD installer.

Wow, is Linux "hard". Maybe I should go back to Windows. That 90 minute install plus reboots sounds much easier. Or not.

by apotheon

"Careful, you kiss apotheon's butt with that mouth!"

I haven't laughed that long, hard, and loud for a long time.

by mark miller

If their software figures your taxes wrong, they'll cover the difference (the deficiency plus interest and penalties).

by jmgarvin

I keep asking, but I've never gotten a straight answer. You sound reasonable, what doesn't work on an *nix platform that ONLY works in Windows...Something that doesn't have a subsitute at all.

by wauchula

Most anything written in M$ Visual basic...
Well, you asked....

I know, I know, use WINE....
Doesn't always work though...

by apotheon

Don't use anything written in VB. Holy cow, is that just a bad idea. Why would I want to use an application so crummy they didn't bother to write it in a better language?

Besides, VB is all moving to VB.NET, which Linux does support using the Mono implementation of .NET, so there's actually quite a lot of stuff written in VB that will run on Linux.

by mark miller

Well this thread has gotten stale, but I'll give a go at reviving it.

It's not a matter of whether there's a substitute. "Substitute" is a broad term. When I talk about "support" I'm talking about "support" for getting my project done more efficiently, and enabling me to get something useful done without understanding the ins-and-outs of how it all works. This is typically where the argument begins, because Linux users believe in digging into the internals of software. They like the idea of working hard to master the infrastructure so they can build what they want. I'm less interested in that.

The ease that VS enables for constructing web applications enabled me to get into the field, do something useful with it for customers and learn as I went along. I now understand more of how it all works, but VS lowered that barrier to entry. I came into this with a background in C/Unix server work (which I got tired of), and C++/MFC/GUI work on Windows.

Plus, if I need to build a web application with a series of screens that gets/updates data from/to a database, I like the fact that VS provides an all-in-one environment for doing that. It allows me to build screens quickly using a page designer. The designer also allows me to see a WYSIWYG rendering of the layout of the page before I run the app. The designer then links events to my back-end server code automatically. I still have to edit the source of a web page often, but not as often as I would if using a text/code editor to manipulate HTML/CSS was my only option. Once I'm ready to test, I can use full-screen debugging, stepping through the .Net code, both for my web pages and web services. If need be I can enable stored procedure debugging by which I can step through T-SQL code. Now with VS 2005 I have full-screen client-side Javascript step-by-step debugging as well.

Speaking of VS 2005, it helps out more than its predecessor. For example, If I want to add sign-on capability to a web site, all I need to do is drag and drop the signon control. It takes care of a lot of the plumbing and control flow for me, so I don't have to write the user sign-on logic. .Net 2.0 also features two-way databinding now, so the data transfer plumbing is less laborious, and I can have it use business objects that I write, if I want.

Further, there's a lot of intangible support. MS offers webcasts on just about anything I'd want to know to finish my application projects, and they have extensive online documentation for every API that's in Windows. My only complaint has been with the Crystal Reports.Net documentation that's been supplied with VS, which has been crap (maybe it's better in VS 2005. I haven't looked at it yet).

I've checked out Eclipse. It has many features in common with VS: like Intellisense (I believe), code refactoring, and it inserts code to help you along when it guesses what you're trying to do. From what I've heard, some of these capabilities are more advanced than what VS offers. I've looked at the specs. and it does not have an integrated page designer.

I've been able to find some freeware and low-cost commercial Javascript debuggers just doing a quick Google search, but they only run on Windows. Even the Javascript debugger extension, Venkman, for Firefox only has a Windows version at this point.

During a further, quick search I've found some commercial PHP IDEs that are cost-competitive with VS. I found one, Komodo, that runs on Linux. The others appear to only run on Windows. That avenue might deserve further inspection. I'm not going to do a survey of them right now. So this is my take on the matter.

by apotheon

When you define quality of a platform as "dominates the market", obviously Windows will "win". I prefer to define things according to metrics that are not derived from a desire to define Windows as the "winner", though.

If you declare that nothing should qualify as quality without being the dominant option on TV, et cetera, then only the current market dominator will ever qualify.

Besides, you don't have to "find software online" when you're running Linux. You just have to open your software manager and pick from the thousands of options available to you. Try using Synaptic or YaST2 some time before you decide that Linux software management requires the user to be "resourceful".

by mark miller

The point was, the guy who started this thread sounded like a fairly ordinary computer user, though he's been using computers for many years. He talked about easy to find hardware and compatible software that was readily available, and fairly easy to use. The next guy responded, "Anything you can do on Windows you can do on Linux" and then proceeded to talk about the online sources where he could find stuff.

I responded by saying "So you expect ordinary users to go search for their software online?? Good luck!" I wasn't talking about quality as a sole criteria.

ABMers often don't understand that in order for their favorite platform to catch on with the public, ordinary computer buyers need to be made aware of what they can do on the platform (the applications), they need to see it demo'd and understand how it's supported, or as has been demonstrated historically, get it installed by default on a popular platform. Suppliers need to make an effort to go to the customer rather than expecting the customer to come to them. If nothing is done along these lines, you can have the best software around but only a small number of people are going to end up using it. And no, talking about it in these online forums doesn't help a great deal in that regard. All you're showing is that OSS is virtually non-existent in the end-user desktop space as far as the U.S. public is concerned, since you're trying to compensate for people's lack of knowledge.

by apotheon

1. I was pointing out that [b]you don't have to "go search for [. . .] software online"[/b]. Somehow, you seem to have missed that.

2. If you really think people "don't understand" that Linux would, for purposes of market penetration, greatly benefit from coming preinstalled on retail desktop systems, you haven't been reading these fora very much. In fact, I seem to recall one or two commenting in [b]this very discussion[/b] about how it would be nice to see retailers offering Linux desktops to the general public.

What planet are you on?

by npbwbass

Nothing in the universe will ever be a constant as defined. Physics is showing us that everyday. Everything will always be a variable given time is applied. A decision is nothing more than a delta change in linear time. Math has shown us that. The decision will always need to assume a ?temporary? constant somewhere.

You say that we can't quantify everything but we have to at a point in time or nothing could be decided. You are correct in stating that people are emotional and I agree but it is possible to make decisions without emotional content. Its called logic.

People make both logical and illogical decisions every day. The professionals are people who have simply learned to make more logical decisions than illogical ones. The pointer here is will the decision help in reaching the goal?

Absolutes have to be assumed right or wrong in the decision making process because a ?rubber band? will always make a bad measuring tool.

Thanks for the intelligent comments. I will always enjoy adding good information to my skills set from someone's well communicated point of view.

I am no Mr. Spock even though I played the part in several local productions. I am a musician and love to bring out the emotional content of people with my music.

by jmgarvin

It is a simple matter of using a graphical tool like YaST or a text based tool like apt-get or yum (which also have GUIs available for them).

I simple choose the package I want, and the system will install the package, along with any dependencies, while I grab a fresh cup of coffee.

The best part is I don't even need to reboot after everything finishes installing.

by nighthawk808

about comparing the installs of different distros. I've installed about a dozen different flavors, and their processes were all pretty much the same. Two stand out, though: Debian, because it lacks all the pretty pictures of the others, and Xandros, because it tries so hard to be Windows XP that it even mimics some of Windows's irritating installation procedures. Maybe sometime over the summer, I'll spend a week or two installing some popular distros and take notes, then compile them into a "How to install 10 different Linux distros" article. In fact, here's the first entry now:

How to install Knoppix:
1. Insert CD.
2. Press power button.
3. Make coffee.

I think most people think Linux is hard to install because it used to be a real pain as recently as, oh, 6-8 years ago when Linux's hardware support was still, shall we say, Mesozoic. This "fact" keeps echoing forth from people who have never used Linux, but they heard it from someone who tried to install Red Hat 5.0 back in 1999 and couldn't get X to work correctly so it must still be true.

In fact, probably the hardest Linux thing I've had to deal with since I made the switch is continually hearing people who have never used Linux, or who tried it once for about an hour a few years ago but gave up when they couldn't find the blue 'e' icon to surf the web, state that Linux is too hard for the average user. Yet when we, who almost without exception have extensive experience with Windows, say something negative about M$, we're called zealots who don't know what we're talking about. It's something I've grown used to, but something I'll probably never grow to accept.

by rkuhn040172

Place the blame wherever you want, but spending several weeks this winter I was never able to get any distro is see my printer and only about half of them to see my video card.

Similar experience with a wireless NIC...thank god I have a wireless and wired connection. I was forced to use my wired connection.

Sure, they all worked with my video card...up to 800X600. But I didn't spend $150 on my video card to see only 800X600.

And my printer, a cheaper model but nonetheless, is a Lexmark and I like it. I don't print much but with Linux, apparently I'm not supposed to print at all, ever.

In other posts, all I ever heard from the Linux supporters was a few things.

1) I shouldn't buy cheap or generic products
2) I could write my own driver
3) Did I search the web for a driver
4) I could switch to a different distro

With Windows, I can buy cheap/generic parts. With Windows, I don't have to write my own drivers (nor do I know how). With Windows, I don't have to search the web for drivers (hard to do if it won't recognize my wireless connection (if that's all I had). With Windows, I don't have to pick a different version/distro to get my equipment working.

With Windows, everything is recognized and the only reason I use my manufacturer CD's is I assume that their drivers is better than the Microsoft one.

by apotheon

You had problems with two things that are still sometimes problematic for Linux, rickk. Wireless access issues can be kind of hit-and-miss in terms of how easy it is to set up. Often, you have to know what you're doing to a nontrivial degree to get wireless adapters working with Linux -- I'll certainly admit that. In fact, just yesterday I started having issues with getting my Broadcom chipset wireless card to interact with my wireless router. For most purposes, Linux is incredibly easy about 98% of the time (and with Windows, I'd say that for most purposes it's acceptably easy about 85% of the time). There are exceptions, however, and wireless networking can be one of them.

Of course, some wireless adapter chipsets are natively supported by Linux, and there are open source drivers that tend to be distributed with the OS for some other chipsets, so that it can be even easier to set up wireless networking with Linux than it is with Windows. That's the exception rather than the rule, unfortunately. I still prefer the greater flexibility and capability of the wireless networking tools for Linux over those of Windows, so that I'm willing to take the reduced ease of use, but that doesn't mean it's easier on average with Linux than Windows.

So, yeah, you have a point -- for wireless networking.

For postscript printers, Linux is generally far easier than Windows will ever be. For cheapie under-$100 consumer printers, the story is a bit different. It's kind of a crap shoot. Windows and Linux average out overall for ease of use with printers, in my estimation. People using quality printers for professional purposes tend to find Linux easier to work with than Windows. People using crap printers for personal purposes tend to find Windows easier to work with than Linux. Such is life.

Your single-example anecdotal experience doesn't make Linux the stone-age OS you seem to think it is. Yes, there are some issues. No, I don't think they're as numerous and difficult as the issues Windows has. You're just more used to the Windows issues, so you don't notice them as much: you work around them without even noticing them. Having been on both sides of the Windows/Linux fence, to rather extensive degrees in both cases, I probably have a bit more ability to make useful comparisons than you, though. For instance, I buy postscript-capable printers, both because good quality printers support postscript, and because I know they work with Linux, with great ease. I check the chipset in a given wireless adapter before buying it because I know that some chipsets aren't as well supported by Linux.

By the same token, I (and probably you) know better than to get an ATI Rage chipset graphics adapter for Windows. The reason they suck is largely related to the crappy ATI drivers for its Rage card series. The drivers just Really Suck. Linux doesn't really have this problem for most purposes, because the open source ATI drivers are pretty good quality (as long as you don't need hardware acceleration). Windows doesn't scale well with hardware, so you always have to check hardware specs against the Windows version to see if the hardware will support the version of Windows you want to run: with Linux that's not really a problem. Windows is notoriously bad with USB Bluetooth dongles: Linux is not.

There are ways to work around the Windows hardware issues. Anyone who buys computers as complete, sealed boxes from Dell, Gateway, and so on, doesn't have to use those workarounds because the hardware vendors have done it for him or her. Those of us who have been working with computers for a long time know the Windows workarounds, and use them pretty much instinctively after long experience: as such, we tend to not notice them.

It's the same with Linux. The only reason these problems seem so huge to you is, simply, that they're new to you. If you either got someone else to do it for you (like the Dell of the Linux world -- try buying your next laptop from EmperorLinux if you want an example) or were as familiar with Linux as I am, you'd tend to not notice problems with Linux either (except that I'm just as familiar with Windows as Linux, and as such tend to notice the problems with both).

by apotheon

Why not use a potentiall biased source? It's a counterargument to a Windows advertising campaign making use of study results produced by Microsoft "partners", after all.

Here's something that's not biased:
Every single TCO study that showed a clear advantage for Windows was sponsored directly by Microsoft or carried out by Microsoft "partners". Every company (I'm aware of) that "switched back" got rock-bottom pricing deals as incentives.

You should absolutely judge by information you've gathered for yourself. Just know better than to gather that information from Microsoft and its lackeys.

by rkuhn040172

But also judge by your own data instead of relying on Linux lackeys as well.

Yes, they exist and we all know it.

Anyone should be suspect of any study depending on its source. The problem with the world today is too many people are willing to make a quick $ by putting out a study like that...on both sides.

by nighthawk808

But Microsoft consistently misspells FUD as f-a-c-t-s, so it makes coming up with good search results difficult.

How about Microsoft's internal memos (the infamous Halloween series)? Here you go:
http://www.catb.org/~esr/halloween/halloween7.html

Sure, these may be hosted by ESR, but they're Microsoft's own words. Even M$ eventually admitted that.

Post edited because I remembered the Halloween treats after originally posting. I'm a little slow sometimes.

by nighthawk808

Here's the hardware that has passed through my desktop in the past two years. The OS at the time was either SuSE 9.3 or 10.0. This machine used to dual-boot Windows XP, but this is no longer the case.

These have stayed the same:
Asus A7N8X-E Deluxe mobo
AMD Athlon XP 3000+ (overclocked to 2.35GHz)
1GB Geil Golden Dragon PC3500 dual-channel DDR

These have changed:
Sound:
--Turtle Beach Santa Cruz
--SoundBlaster Audigy 2 Platinum Pro
--Onboard AC '97 chip (what I use now)

Video:
--nVidia GeForce4 MX-440
--ATI Radeon 9800Pro
--nVidia GeForce6200 (what I use now)

HDD:
--Western Digital WDC2500/WDC300
--Dual 80GB Hitachi SATA/150 (what I use now)

CD/DVD:
--Samsung CD-RW/DVD combo
--Sony DRU820 (What I use now)

Printer:
a networked HP DeskJet 930C and a Lexmark X3350

None of these has ever had a problem in Linux (except a less-than-smooth change from the Radeon 9800 to the GeForce6200). Here's the problems I had with them in Windows:

--Couldn't overclock processor when using Windows. Got random BSOD's. Worked fine as long I was in Linux.
--Audigy2 didn't handle 5.1 sound correctly.
--Radeon 9800 would reset itself rather frequently. Tried four or five driver releases; no change.
--Could not install Windows AT ALL when I got the SATA HDD's. It had no built-in SATA drivers (I can't blame Microsoft for this--the technology didn't exist when XP first came out), and pressing F6 to specify the included drivers didn't work. Windows refused to even acknowledge that they were drivers. This is why I took a different computer and made it my gaming box instead of dual-booting like I used to. SuSE didn't blink an eye when it saw my new SATA drives.
--The print quality of the DeskJet 930 was _much_ higher when printing pictures from Linux vs. Windows.
--The Samsung drive twice "forgot" that it had CD-RW capabilities. Windows would only consider it a CD-ROM when this happened. Uninstalling it completely and reinstalling it didn't fix the problem. Hours of searching and reading online only showed me that this is not an uncommon problem in Windows, and there is no good solution. Only a complete reinstallation of XP fixed it. By the time this happened a second time, I didn't care anymore whether it worked in Windows because SuSE's k3b had no problem burning anything I wanted.

I'm rather suspicious when you claim that your generic hardware doesn't work in Linux. Generic hardware is _more_ likely to work, assuming they are generic because they are one of those companies who licenses a chipset to make cheap hardware out of. Hardware support, especially for standard chipsets, is already very good and rapidly approaching outstanding in Linux. Usually it's those with bleeding-edge hardware who have problems, and those people are usually the technically-savvy ones who either like tinkering and getting it working themselves or they know to submit a report to their favorite distro so the Open Source delevopment method can do what it does best.

Post edited to correct some typos. I wish TR had a "Preview post" feature like the rest of the world.

by rkuhn040172

I say I had problems and you are suspicious.

Yet, you have problems and simply give greater detail and we're suppposed to all believe you but not me.

Typical Linux speak.

Why are you suspicious of me but I'm not supposed to be suspicious of you?

I know because you support Linux and my problems don't fit your nice little view of the world.

by rkuhn040172

While I disagree with some of what you are saying Apotheon, I do appreciate your honesty. That post did add something to this discussion.

Nighthawk, on the other hand, rants on and on at times about nothing and typically adds nothing to these discussions.

by jmgarvin

Ok, the skinny is this:

You make up problems about Linux.

Apo and Night state common issues and work arounds that are available along with basic troubleshooting steps.

Linux is NOT hard to install, just check the blogs section. The Hot Button had a Linux vs Windows shoot out with installs. Typically a Linux install is click and forget...while with Windows (and two reboots later), you have nanny it and then you have the installation.

Wireless DOES work in Linux, it just takes a little doing because VENDORS don't make drivers for most wifi cards.

SATA does work, NVidia does work, ATI does work, 3d acceleration does work, most NICs work, USB PnP does work, etc...So what doesn't work Rikk...Without the FUD...Tell me please.

by noyoki

Actually, Firefox has a plugin that can save sessions. This way, you are happy, as well as the other guy saying it was an insecurity. (The latter isn't forced to use it.)

by rkuhn040172

I will go home, list my components, tell you again what I experienced, and you jmgarvin will once again not believe me.

What's the point?

That was the whole point of this discussion. You just can't let it go. You are a Linux zealot.

I have my OS of choice and you have yours. I'm not trying to convert or prove anything...you are.

But more to your points: (these are my opinion)

"Linux is NOT hard to install" - I have installed probably 5-6 different distros now and while 99% of the time everything goes OK, it's that 1% that kills me.

"Wireless DOES work in Linux, it just takes a little doing because VENDORS don't make drivers for most wifi cards." - Like I care. My OS of choice does support virtually any and all wireless cards. I don't care what mnaufacturers are doing or are not doing...I just want the thing to work.

"SATA does work, NVidia does work, ATI does work, 3d acceleration does work, most NICs work, USB PnP does work, etc...So what doesn't work Rikk" - All of the above work in Windows as well. I have a NVidia card at home with no problems. I have a ATI card at home with no problems. I told you what wasn't working for me in Linux but you have selective memory.

It was the printer, a Lexmark something, and my wireless NIC, a D-Link something.

I will go home tonight and get the specific model numbers for you, however, I know that won't do me any good because you are God and have an excuse for everything.

It'll either be the cheap equipment, the lack of a manufacturer driver, not the most recent distro, my lack of something (even though I've been in IT for 6+ years now)...you always have an excuse.

Those two things, the wireless NIC and the printer work fine for me in Windows yet aren't even seen at all in Linux.

It's actually unbelievable that Linux continues to improve everyday (which it does) with people like you who don't recognize issues and try to resolve them. You ignore facts that you don't agree with.

"It depends what is is" should be your motto.

"You make up problems about Linux" - So, apotheon and nighthawk's problems are real and I'm are imaginary.

Dude, your head is so far up your backend, I'm surprised you can even drink the free beer as in Linux.

by rkuhn040172

1. HAL 9000
2. NZ_Justice
3. nighthawk808
4. jmgarvin
5. apotheon

And they are all Linux lovers.

I'd bet if anyone, anywhere on TR posted anything about Windows that was positive, these same people would come out of the woodwork.

That was kind of my point with this discussion.

What these guys don't understand is that the 85% market share plus home users of Windows just don't engage in debates with them because it is meaningless and a waste of their time.

These five think they are the majority.

by jdclyde

An incorrect generalization, as I have seen HAL 9000 be very fair to all points of view, and is regularly in the TQ&A helping people with Windows problems.

Garvin, while pro-linux, has always been very open in his discussions and does not beat you with linux but does counter the FUD when people make intentionally incorrect statements about what Linux can or can't do.

Apotheon, while always right, tends to lose patience with people that again are making statements about linux based on FUD that they have been told, and are propogating the lie. The mighty club "cluefinder" is brought out a little quicker! ;\

Justice, I haven't been keeping up on his rants and raves so I can't make a judgement on that.

Nighthawk, tends to be a little more abusive, but hey, nobodies perfect, right?

But they are doing what people do in a DISCUSSION. Bring their ideas to the table, support their ideas, and listen to other peoples support of alternative views. That is how you LEARN something, by challenging your own beliefs and views.

People with the same views as you have, leave you nothing to debate other than who likes X feature better.

Home users don't engage them because home users are not interested in anything better, if it requires any effort at all on their parts. If they push a button, click on a few pictures on the screen and something happens, they are happy.

Anyone that discounts or disregards any technology out there is a fool. There is generally not a single one perfect tool for everyone, and again it is foolish to claim otherwise. Use the right tool for the right job. You not knowing how to use one of the tools does not make the tool any less valid.

by jchapple

I prefer Linux for my software projects, as it is easier to deal with when running Java application servers. But...

If Linux is the best tool out there right now, how come it is so hard to use? I have been trying to train a bunch of people who can do anything on Windows and zOS, but Linux just baffles them.

I agree that Linux is better for many things, but if people cannot use it, then it is worthless. For example, a high powered sports car does me no good in the dead of a Minnesota winter. It does not matter how many Car and Driver articles are written about how good it is. The same for Linux on the desktop. Every December I read predictions that Linux will be on the desktop in the coming year, and every year guess what? It did not happen, but just wait until next year when Linux will replace Windows on the desktop.

If Linux is the better tool out there, then prove it. It has to be easy enough for a moron in a hurry to use it (to borrow a phrase from the legal profession). Since it is not, it will never make progress.

by shelli_2005

we use Windows on the desktops here, I cant imagine "Susie Q" in Acct or "Joe-Bob" out in the field trying to use a Linux workstation...I can hear them now if we tried that.. "Well this thing doesnt even have the internet installed!"(Translation: no big blue E)
and "My email doesnt work" (Translation: no Outlook icon).It's a fact, "Joe and Susie Average" are used to Windows and dont want to learn Linux (or anything else)

by jdclyde

will you really make major decisions one what an employee "wants"?

You pay "joe and suzie" to do a job. If part of that job is to learn a new version of MS Word, or switching to FireFox, or even running a linux work station, what they WANT means NOTHING to the bottom line of the company. This is NOT a reason to make a decision.

Migration to any new package takes training and buy-in from the highest levels. The people that addapt to the changes will prosper, the ones that are too stupid or lazy will be replaced.

The trained monkeys you work with can be trained if they had to. After all, these same people did not just sit down and start using MS products. They were TRAINED to use them.

You are confusing a lazy person with someone that CAN'T learn something NEW AGAIN.

A few years back, Dow Chemical went through and pulled out all the MAC's and put in PC's. These people had to learn to use the PC or get a new job. Jobs change, and the less you expect out of people, the less you will get.

by jmgarvin

I've said before (and I'll say it again), I like .Net. Some of the features are quite nice. I wish there was as clear and "integrated" IDE for Linux. "You act as if liking Linux and finding the ideals of FLOSS better than that of proprietary software is something dirty and at best suburban. Without FLOSS we'd be stuck in the days of IBM and Sun when all software was proprietary and only the vendor (for a cost) could "save" you."

What "these five" do is squash the FUD. There is too much bogus being thrown around about MS and I've grown tired of it. While I do give MS some props (eg for cleaning up AD in Win2k3), I must say that to slobber all over them is not only silly, but stupid.

They have an insecure OS, with insecure apps, that are built off the same turd that they started with in the NT days.

My suggestions have ALWAYS been:
A) Deintegrate IE (Vista STILL doesn't do it)
B) Kill the whole idea of the registry
C) Make a true multi-user OS
D) Clean up the architecture so that it IS secure
E) Stop lying to the developers about what a certain API is or does
F) FUNCTIONALITY over FORM...for the love of god, no body cares about the new OS X alike interface, where is WinFS? Where is the new functionality that was promised?

In other forums I've also posted that MS is going down the same road IBM traveled in the 80's. They need to clean up their game, get lean and mean, and start over....

* Edited to add the portion in quotes.

by nz_justice

Before you call me a Linux Lover.

Sure I sometimes don't dislike Linux, and I like free over pay. And sure I have an affront to big corporations who just take all of my hard earned money. And sure I hate the OIL companies fixing prices which is illegal. But I have gone from liking Linux to supporting windows. I am not totally X Linux, but I can't see myself playing World of Warcraft on a Linux box, but I can see myself playing it on a MAC.

And a person who starts the Thread "The Best OS ever without a doubt" in the windows forum area and is number 2 in the most active users in the "windows" forum area can hardly be said to be against Windows or for Linux.

And I agreee I don't "engage in debates with them because it is meaningless and a waste of my time" but When you call me a Linux lover like I am their poster boy I have to type something.

Windows forever.

;)

PS jdclyde's comment was pretty fair.

by rkuhn040172

I probably shouldn't of included you in the top 5.

And jdclyde's comments were pretty fair indeed. While he strongly leans towards Linux, he does give usually fair comments.

But it is almost comical that certain people on TR just can't seem to not comment.

They must have more time on their hands than I do. I struggle to comment as much as I do and typically because of family, work, etc I go in streaks.

I'm due to go cold for a while. Projects coming up...

by jdclyde

Decided to stay around I see.

Sure have come a long way since the "egg" discussion, huh? :D

by tony hopkinson

You forgot me !

I put a lot of effort into communicating with you sensibly without any FUD.

You p!ssed on it to engage in flame wars.

Why was that exactly ?

Why the constant arguing? you like it !

Nothing wrong with that of course, I do as well.

by nz_justice

Look who is number 2

Top 5 in this topic
1. apotheon
2. rickk@...
3. Jaqui
4. Palmetto
5. jmgarvin

by nighthawk808

ripping your argument to shreds and stomping on the pieces, I guess I'm guilty as charged.

I've always found it quite pleasing when a discussion reaches a point where the other side simply calls me a zealot and/or attacks my posting style and doesn't present anything substantive. It basically means they've run out of things for me to beat down.

What makes this time somewhat ironic is that I predicted you would say something like that in the post you have to reply to because of TR's "max level" limitation. "Fanatic" and "zealot" are pretty synonymous.

Well, it was fun while it lasted. It's init 0 time for me.

by jc williams

There will *never* be peace in this arena. That is why I have chosen to work on web-based applications and solutions. I can use whatever script or "language" that I want in a mix-and-match fashion ... using the one that best suits my needs.

But, then again, this.Will.Stir.Up.Comments();

:)

by nz_justice

Your web based applications have to run on something. They have to hosted on some hardware, running some operating system. And you have to have a browser developed by soemone. No way around it. Really to be OS independant you have too write your own.

by jc williams

You are correct, if I want to worry about those things ... however, it does not matter to me if the system that hosts my pages is running Apache or IIS. Both do a good job of spitting out the html. The client side of the world can consume my codes without me worrying about many things. That is the beauty of platformless coding ... not having to worry if the person consuming your code is running Win95, Win98, XP, Win2K, Linux, BSD, Mac OSX, homegrown, experimental, or anything else. The only thing I ever worry about is if the person attempting to consume my code is running in a text-only browser or not. If they are, then I gently inform them that the application must be running under one of many GUI based browsers.

So, how is it that I really need to worry what it is that is either hosting my code or consuming it?

Volley to your court ...

by rdcpro

Well, as far as Office 12 goes, I think you'll find that it's a lot more inclusive than before. They've finally abandoned the old proprietary binary doc format, in favor of a new format called Docx. It's a zipped archive of the resources that go into a file. The content, styling, metadata, etc. are in separate XML files in the archive.

This will make it very easy to integrate with.

Perhaps it's mostly this particular site and forum, but it seems to me like most of the hate posts are from the linux crowd. Go ahead and flame away, everyone, but you're only fooling yourselves.

Ernie, whoever he is, certainly doesn't speak for microsoft, or even any ISV that might be partnered with them. You may actually be closer to the truth with your joke about him being a linux loonie...

I'd have hoped that most people would read his rants, and ignore them as noise from someone who clearly doesn't speak for anyone. But then, troll baiting has always been a favorite pastime.

by tony hopkinson

the linux crowd don't hate MS (well barring one or two exceptions), we hate FUD. We hate FUD because it's an insult to our intelligence, no one likes to be treated like an idiot.

I'm not surprised you want to disassociate your self from ErnieM. Be assured though there are more Ernie's in the world than linux loons.

by nz_justice

If it has to run on something i.e. "a platform", is it platform independent?

I concede you don't have to worry about OS.

If you could get your web application to run straight of the any hardware, then I guess it would be truly be platform independent. I could run the platform independent applications on my PS2 or my nokia mobile or my Casio watch.

But then again you need the OS as a platform to have an environment to build a platformless application.

by jc williams

Ah, yes ? one of the great conundrums of modern programming (versus medieval programming?): is anything truly independent? I do concede that both the server and the client must run on something. It would be nice if the code could exist as a purely mental image that the user could directly interact with, however, there too we are not really independent of a "platform", are we? (this dang thing won't work on a Fred v7.05 or Robert 6.23) :) I am sure that at some point your Casio or Swatch watch will be able to consume some of my code. Your refrigerator, toaster, and dishwasher already can. :)

Until later becomes now ? Caio

by apotheon

1. I disagree with your assessment of what nighthawk808 said, and how he typically behaves. He was a bit harsher than me this time, and he didn't "balance" his post by discussing why you might have had problems with Linux hardware support the way I did. He brought up a laundry list of Windows issues. He stated that he was suspicious of you, for which I can hardly fault him considering that you have a tendency to sow FUD and troll for flames. You even jumped into the midst of an amicable mutual ribbing that some Linux users were giving each other just to stir up strife. I decided to be nice: nighthawk808 didn't. That doesn't make him wrong.

2. It's difficult for people like jmgarvin (and me) to take what you say at face value. You have repeatedly contradicted yourself in the midst of trying to contradict anyone that says anything that favorably compares Linux to Windows, and you stir up flamewar threads like this one while claiming to just want everyone to get along. While I am trying to respond to your specific complaints about hardware support as though your entire history of disinformation doesn't exist, jmgarvin is responding to what he knows of your history here. His approach may not have been as nice as mine, but it was no less valid.

3. The word "zealot" as applied to a Linux vs. Windows debate should have the same status as the words "Hitler" and "Nazi" in other debates. If you want to be seen as anything other than a "zealot" yourself, you should probably stop using that term. Of course, I don't think you really care: you're more interested in trolling for flames than in having a reasoned discussion. I think you're deliberately provoking people with the word "zealot". I've been wrong once or twice before, though it's rare -- so I suppose I might be wrong again. I don't think so, though. You seem to enjoy this strife too much.

4. With extensive experience of both Linux and Windows, I have seen Linux installs go from more difficult than Windows about three or four years ago to notably easier than Windows now. There might be a 1% problem rate, but if so, the 6% problem rate of Windows installs makes that look good.

5. Actually, Windows [b]doesn't[/b] support all those wireless cards. The wireless cards support Windows. How many of those can you install and use without the vendor's drivers? 40%? 50%? Something like that is my experience. Probably only about 15% of wireless cards are supported by Linux without vendor drivers, but 90% of wireless cards [b]are[/b] supported by Linux when you use the vendor's drivers and ndiswrapper, as compared with about 98% of cards being supported by Windows when you use the vendor's drivers. Yes, Windows is slightly ahead, but not to the degree you seem to be suggesting. It's also worth noting that those 15% of wireless cards that are supported in Linux without vendor drivers tend to be better supported than [b]any[/b] card, under any circumstances, in Windows. This is because that native support in Linux is provided by open source drivers that incorporate far more functionality than you can get with the vendor drivers for Windows. While all this extra functionality is lost on most users, it's certainly a boon to those of us who use wireless adapters to survey wireless security at clients' network sites. (note: those percentages are estimates based on my own experience and analyses of wireless support statistics gleaned from a number of online resources)

6. Windows doesn't support ATI or nVidia nearly as well as Linux. Add vendor drivers, and suddenly the Windows and Linux support for them becomes about even, but natively, out of the box, Windows support for those cards is sketchy at best, while Linux support under those same conditions is rock-solid even if it's not quite up to the standards of the vendor drivers. As for SATA, it's true that Windows supports SATA drives pretty well [b]now[/b], but there was a time (shortly after the release of SP2 for Windows XP) that the SATA drivers would often be classified as "uncertified" and thus rejected outright by the OS, effectively turning the drive into a paperweight as far as the computer was concerned. It took months for Windows to get caught up on SATA support again. The cost and aggravation incurred was impressive. As for NICs, aside from wireless, there is no OS family of which I'm aware that has better general network adapter support than Linux, Windows included. In fact, Linux has far better native NIC support than Windows. Ethernet NIC support is one of the pretty much indisputable wins of Linux. Windows, on the other hand -- well, it's a crap shoot. NICs are supported more than half the time without vendor drivers, and they work almost all the time with vendor drivers, but pulling a random NIC out of a box in the closet, with no vendor drivers, and slotting it into your Windows machine runs a substantial risk of being pretty soundly b0rked.

Do yourself a favor: when you get home and find that D-Link NIC, check on the ndiswrapper wiki for the list of supported cards, and see if your card's chipset is supported. If it is, you can bow out gracefully, and just say "Well, it would be nice if it was easier to get it working than by using ndiswrapper." Try to avoid claiming it doesn't work at all without being absolutely certain.

by apotheon

1. That had nothing to do with what jdclyde was saying.

2. There wasn't any (good) reason to imply jdclyde is a "tool" in your commentary.

3. Linux is plenty easy. It just [b]isn't Windows[/b], and if you're used to Windows you have to adjust.

4. Some things on Linux are not easy, despite the fact most things are. I'll take that over the Windows approach any day of the week: many things are easy, a few things are difficult, and many things are impossible.

5. If you think a moron in a hurry can't use some version of Linux, you haven't encountered Xandros, MEPIS, Linspire, or any of a number of other Windows-alikes. That, or the moron that can't use these things won't be able to use Windows either.

6. Linux isn't the be-all and end-all. It's just usually a better option than Windows, in my experience, to judge on purely technical terms. The only really compelling reason to use Windows in most cases is the simple fact that there are a lot of other people using it, and the tools that run on it, too. Even that reason is beginning to go the way of the dodo, with the increasing ability of Linux-compatible tools to interoperate with Windows-compatible tools.

by apotheon

Isn't jdclyde mostly a Windows user?

Aren't you the one [b]starting[/b] these discussions that just [b]beg[/b] for someone that knows something about Linux to set your ass straight?

by jdclyde

I have linux servers, almost exclusively. The only server that isn't linux is a win2k to run Symantec AV, which I am NOT going to renew when it expires in June.

Sure, it is fun to jump on whatever bandwagon and bash this or that, but most of my comments have been for the windows users to stop making excuses for what is wrong and demand that MS fixes it. I realize they are not looking for an alternative, but so does MS, and as long as THEY KNOW that their customers will stay around no matter what, they will continue to put more effort into securing licensing for XP than for securing the actual OS from hackers.

I AM getting around to trying my first linux desktop though! Linux is becoming mature as a desktop, and I don't see ever moving to Vista. When we move off of XP I see it being on to SuSE, based on talks with my boss. (HE is the anti-windows guy!)

by apotheon

Let us know how the migration works out. Feel free to hit me up for advice now and then.

Actually . . . are you looking for someone to consult?

by rkuhn040172

That is exactly what I'm talking about.

While I disagree with many of your points, especially 1-4 :) 5 and 6 were more debate like.

Some on here just can't seem to make points without attacking someone.

You and I have had numerous run ins but that post was what my title "Why the Constant Arguing" was all about.

We can all debate, agree, or disagree, but why the constant arguing?

You may have actually sent me down the road of fixing my wireless card issue. Thanks! We need more of that on TR.

But you have to admit, whether you agree with me or other TR members or not, the constant bickering on TR is starting to get annoying.

I've been on TR now for a little over 4 years and maybe it's my imagination but I don't think it's been this bad before.

by jdclyde

is that linux already is better for many of the SERVER applications, providing the tool that I was refering to. I know you in your little desktop world the same as many other windows guys, you forget that without the SERVER, there isn't information to share, and your network of workstations lost a lot of their value. Get into web servers, and the larger ones are not running on a windows platform.

If you agree that linux is better for many things, you use it for the "many things".

If you also believe this, why the hostile reply to me? Why turn around and demand that I prove to you that anything is anything?

Or were you really replying to someone else, as I AM the one that said use what works?

Is the determination of is something is "better" only if a moron can use it? YOU are using windows, right......... :0 :D :p (that is just too funny!)

by jdclyde

MAYBE they have more time on their hands BECAUSE they run linux and it doesn't take as much daily support once it is in position? :D

My linux servers take up almost no time in an average week, the cisco routers very little as well. After switching all of my users off of IE and on to FF, my service calls when dropped by 70%. Most of what I was doing was adware/malware/spyware removal and cleanup. Now, I come here and other tech sites looking for the new tech advances coming out to bring improvements to the workplace instead of spending all my time spinning my wheels. I have been able to put NEW things in place that have really improved our ability to communicate, BECAUSE I can spend my time looking for new things instead of fixing the same thing over and over.

Something to think about. I think my next project will be to start switching people over to "OpenOffice". The first step to migration is to get the user used to the APPLICATIONS they will be using. Once they have the applications down, they really don't care what the OS is, as they made the switch from win95 to 98 to 2k to xp just fine. Why? Because standare applications. THAT is the key.

Good luck with the projects. ;\

by swine

In my toolbox are many screwdrivers. I chose the
one that best fits the job at hand. Same with
operating systems.I run my webserver on linux.
Process most of my photos on windows. argueing
about one or the other is like saying one
screwdriver is what everyone should use...It just
doesn't work that way.

by awfeckit2

Although I agree with your point of view, I don't think that is any longer the purpose of this discussion. The discussion has gone on from an argument about one OS being perceived by some to be the better one.

Now the purpose of the discussion is to argue and flame. As some have admitted. And it's fairly obvious when you read about Windows users being referred to as "monkeys" by some of the kids playing here.

Most everyday computer users don't care enough to follow these discussions about OS vs OS except for the curious (like me). Computers, for most, are just tools to be used. How they work isn't important.

Linux vs Windows. Ford vs Chev. Ho hum.

I still drop in on the discussions occasionally for a laugh and once in a while make a comment.

If I'm putting new screws in I prefer the Robertson because it doesn't slip out of the hole as easily when you have to put the pressure on. But if you prefer Philips I won't call you nasty names.

by jc williams

My personal fav is Torx, with all of the different sizes, just so that you will *never* have the right size when you need it :)

I am a Dodge owner and prefer alcohol over gas or diesel just to P.O. both sides of those arguments :)

Strange that it seems to always come down to a contest of one or the other, when other solutions also exist, but are dismissed out-of-hand, just because it isn't one of the two that the zealots have had their personal epiphany over.

by nz_justice

I am biding my time and trying to come up with an ultra offensive way to piss off people in the TR (going back to grass routes). Currently in the Brain storm phase. So far no-luck. I can think of heaps of offensive stuff to do and say but my stupid "egg" e-personality has a conscience and really doesn't feel like it. :D

by aaron a baker

I fail to understand your need as self described to get everybody annoyed and fighting. This is supposed to bring people down to grass roots? I'm sorry but I have no idea how. All I can see is that there would be a lot of horrid things said to one another in an inane attempt at looking superior.
In case you haven't noticed, this isn't the TR way. Here we share. What's so bad about that? When I ask a question,even if it seems really dumb at the time, I wouldn't appreciate it if someone were to trod all over me because my question was "Inferior" or something and banal as that.
As for the TR members being so high and mighty " they must be or you wouldn't need to bring us down" I have no idea where you get this.
TR People have been the most kind considerate and helpful people in the industry. This isn't a wish, it's a fact, read the blogs and above all, read the answers and "How" those answers are put forth."So as not to offend"
I'm sorry but try as I may, I just don't get your problem with TR. If they ever did go to the level you call "Grass Roots" I strongly suspect that most of us would move on to a more intelligent form of communication.
So bide your time and while you're doing so, take the time to read the answers put forth by some of the very best people in the field today. The answers are couched in consideration and kindness. I don't ever recall a TR member degrading a person for a question asked.
I'm truly sorry that you feel this way because it shows just how little you understand what you read here or the good people who go to the trouble of researching and writing the information down so as to help out someone who is stuck.
They do so without Rancor, Anger, Frustration, Prejudice and a host of other terms that would be easily applicable.
So you see, I really do not understand this fixation you seem to have on the need to fight.
If you need to fight that badly, go to Yahoo, Pal Talk or any other of the so-called forums who specialize in the art of trying to destroy one another.
But at TR, we know how to live and have no problem conducting ourselves accordingly.
Perhaps someday, The sun will rise and you will come to understand what you see here. Who knows, you may even want to join.
Good Luck
Aaron

by jdclyde

At least I think so.

When he first came on TR, it was as a loud kid looking for attention. After seeing what we are about AND watching a stupid punk get evicted from TR, I think he decided he liked what TR really has to offer.

So that would be the "roots" of which he was speaking of, but I think those roots have shrivelled up.

As I said earlier though, I haven't been in many converstations with him since, so just giving him the benifit of the doubt.

by nz_justice

It was sort of a joke.

But your interpretation is amazing. Jdclydes interpretation is a little bit more accurate but he's old what can you do about that. :p

self described? what the hell is that? (please don't answer this, although I have no idea what your talking about I still won't understand your answer).

The roots thing was just a ref too how I started out in the TR Discusion area, not about what ever your typing about.

Where did you get bringing down come from? If any thing my goal (if I had one in terms of the TR) would be to improve the TR rather than bring it down.

Fighting you said anything about fighting. I have no idea what the rest of your post is about.

I have no ill feeling towards anyone in the TR. And I fully understand concepts of discussion etiquette and crap like that.

I don't want to destroy anybody.

I'm also pretty sure that I can piss people of without intensionaly attacking them.

People just take stuff personally weather you intend it that way or not.

Each to his\her own. ;)

Happy Easter, get off the computer, away from the TV and go do something outside. I recommend trekking or bike riding or sky diving or if you stay at home do something two people (conseting adults) can enjoy togther, have sex\make love\****. :D

by wauchula

I agree about VB, VB.net isn't that great either, now there's another thats free for a year, but programs that are compiled with all vb versions is so much slower than machine code.

by tony hopkinson

biggest costs in switching OS.

Noticed this going from NT4 to 2k and and 98 to XP.

Now this would be really funny but for the fact that MS have caused me any number fo hard to discover and expensive to solve issues during OS upgrades.

Porting to Linux and running in a completely different language/environment in some ways is a boon, because at least you don't assume it will work.

by jc williams

Who would have ever guessed that it would take 3.9gb of *compressed* code to make anything work? OOPS ... appear to work :) I can't find the Bunn-O-Matic VPR series Coffee Maker drivers on my Windoze 2010 distro ... help! :)

I agree that you don't need to incorporate every little thing into your product. My install at home for my flavor of Linux is about 26mb. The install (also at home) for my w2kPro is about 120mb. Both machines are identical, hardware wise. So, I must need all of that extra code just in case I install the Binsford 2000 Leafblower?

BTW ... I must belong to both camps until someone comes up with a way of developing non-platform dependent application on a non-platform. :)

Until later becomes now ... Ciao

by jc williams

I wish life was so simple as you try to paint it Rickk. I have a couple of tape transports that are now relegated to the surplus bins at the swapmeets. When I upgraded to Win2KPRO, lo and behold, I could not find a driver that would work. It would not use the drivers on the CD that came with the drive. All that wonderful 16 bit stuff just did not install. I did not have the same experience with the RH9 install ? in fact, it recognized the drive and I was able to use the drive after I finished installing from the CD and BRU works great on it. As I have SIMBA running on that machine (my main server at home), I am able to backup and restore all of my server-side stuff, which I can't say is true on the Win2KPRO. I use Ghost to make image backups to my server so that BRU can save my bacon for when my machine gets attacked/hacked and Win2KPRO won't come up.

Until later become now ? Ciao

by aaron a baker

Thanks for letting me now. I really tire of this childish attitude where everything is a "fight".
I really do enjoy our TR conversations and derive great pleasure from the observations put forth,"by the intelligent members.
So I would hate to se it slope down to this level.
I guess we're still dealing with an unabated,spoiled rotten, little kid with nothing to ask or add. I think I ill just scratch him off.
Regards JD

Thanks
Aaron

by sleepin'dawg

[b]https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=189869&messageID=1994685[/b]

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by sleepin'dawg

really have to get out more. In the mean time you could refer him to this. Always glad to help out.

[b]https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-11183-0.html?forumID=89&threadID=192607&messageID=1994687[/b]

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)