Discussion Locked

Why the Constant Arguing

0 helpful
245 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

245 replies

by apotheon

"[i]working hard to master the infrastructure[/i]"

You're joking. Right? I'm lazy. I prefer to avoid working hard. That's one of the reasons I use (Debian GNU/)Linux instead of Windows for my primary OS. I spend far less time maintaining my system as a result. There's a little more up-front configuration involved [b]because I don't just settle for the defaults, and Linux-based OSes provide me more options[/b], but I could just use a default install without customizing if I wanted to -- but then, once it's all running, there's far less work involved. One of the reasons I use Linux is that I'm [b]lazy[/b]. Work hard? Hah. That's a good one.

In fact, even the customization I do is based on the idea that a little extra effort initially saves me a lot of effort later. The customized environment makes me more productive by facilitating my work instead of getting in the way. It serves my laziness by helping me achieve my aims rather than making me fight it every step of the way. If you'd rather be lazy up front, though, that's an option too -- rather than a mandate as with Windows, and without as much of a time/effort cost down the line.

Why are you talking about IDEs as though they're the sole domain of Microsoft? There are other IDEs in the world than Visual Studio. Perhaps you should educate yourself in that regard. Worse yet, you seem to think that an IDE is the only way to do web design work without getting down to "bare metal", as 'twere. Have you never heard of such WYSIWYG tools as Dreamweaver (for Windows) and NVU (for unix)?

Do you enjoy being limited to doing web development with .NET rather than being able to develop using other (competing) technologies? Do you enjoy being limited to a minority web server platform?

Only one PHP IDE that runs on Linux . . . ? You didn't search very hard.

CoffeeCup's PHP Editor
Amaya HTML/PHP Editor
HTMLKit
Quanta
Bluefish
NuSphere PhpEd
Maguma Workbench
Anjuta
Zend Studio
PHP Eclipse
Xored::WebStudio
PHP Side
Roadsend Studio
TruStudio
PHP Backend Generator
Pidela

. . . and, though there are a couple of commercial items in that list, most are freely available.

The main problem with the general public getting accurate information about options other than the mainstream market dominators is people like you, who see one or two comments about a subject, assume that constitutes useful knowledge, and start making up "facts" about the state of the industry. Before trying to educate others, educate yourself.

EDIT: I stumbled across a couple more PHP IDEs in the last five minutes or so.

K PHP Builder
Goblin

by berak

I agree with you wholeheartedly! Unfortunately, the "my dog is better than your dog" attitude is common and, again unfortunately, is not limited to the computer field(s). Folks seem to have a need to espouse that whatever they are doing, thinking, eating, driving, etc ad nauseum is better than the other guys. If you do not agree with them you are an idiot and must be shown the error of your poor beknighted ways.

Why? I haven't a clue.

A need to feel superior? Perhaps. Unfortunately, those who feel this particular need are frequently overcompensating for their own shortcomings. Trying to have a intelligent discussion on the merits and failings of your divergent points of view is frequently like trying fill the Grand Canyon with bricks.

You are quite correct, rickk. What works for one person may not work for someone else. This is the point that the closed-minded zealots of the world, regardless of their flavour of zealotry, refuse to accept. I guess if they did they would be drummed out of the Zealots Union or something.

It is refreshing to see that someone else out there is more than little tired of this particular brand tomfoolery.

by apotheon

He's one of the worst zealots of the bunch. In fact, he just posted that to stir up a debate so he could go around dithering on about how his flavor of the week is better than others'.

by jmgarvin

Not only do you keep the FUD alive, but you've offered nothing in the way of truth.

A) You don't have to search online. There are EXCELLENT package managers (that work similarly to add/remove programs in Windows) that will GO OUT AND GRAB THE PACKAGE WITH ALL THE DEPENDENCIES FOR YOU! I suggest you educate yourself about these things before you spout off.

B) FLOSS is making HUGE inroads into the desktop realm for two reasons:
1) Drivers are available from vendors. Vendors do take the whole idea of Linux seriously now. Sure not all vendors do, but many have started to offer drivers
2) SDL has made porting games far simplier. It looks like XGL will also improve the ability to port games. (If you don't know why games are important, you aren't paying attention). Yes there are SDL ports. Neverwinter Nights is probably the most popular. There are also tools to play Windows games in Linux (WineX and Cedega)

The customer MUST go to them because Linux isn't offered as an alternative at many major vendors. So, if I buy a box I either get a naked box or one with Windows (which I don't want and can't return).

As far as the US public goes, the NSA is taking a good look at Linux (esp SELinus) and corporate desktops seem to be moving in that direction.

What's the point? You spew FUD and nothing more.

by jmgarvin

Let me start with:
I've stated plenty of times that I like .Net...However, I'd like to squash some of the FUD or whatever it is you are saying.

1) Support: There are plenty of IDEs and GUI options available. Hell, there are tons of options that make life easier both long term and short term. What is so hard about Linux "infrastructure?"

2) Programming environment: You are saying various calls are cleaner in Windows? Come on! Try to do a system call and tell me it's easier...not to mention the wonkiness of some APIs. I also have to say that some of the documentation is a little too limited and can be misleading.

3) Web design: The same thing(s) is/are available for Linux, so what's your point? Various IDEs and builder apps are available.

4) Support Part II: FUD. What can you NOT find in various Linux documentation? The Linux Documentation Project is HUGE!

5) Eclipse: IIRC (although don't quote me on this) there is a LAMP plug-in available. Also, there are some other apps that have PHP, HTML, CSS, etc functionality, but not the total IDE (which I've never really used in web design anyway)

I'm not trying to rip on you, but I'm trying to clear away the FUD...

by lsatenstein9

The big box stores make money and sell only fully equipped pc's, in which up to 50% of the price is for the operating system and the software that is offered as an incentive.

The software is around $250 to $300 US dollars of the total cost.

I tried to buy a PC from them with linux installed. I could not. They would/could not even sell me a PC without any software installed.

Dell will sell their pc with a linux system installed. I do not know if it is offered below the cost of their standard offering.

OEM agreements that exclude competition are the reason I dislike one of the most virus prone software products on the market.

by dr dij

they regularly have several pre-loaded linux boxes among the dozens of brand name and clone windoze and mac PCs and dozens more portables.

the linux boxes are always cheaper due to the lower cost of OS and apps they preload.

I'm sure some people buy them then put their own OS such as w2k on to avoid paying for winxp again.

by mark miller

Re: 1. I was pointing out that you don't have to "go search for [. . .] software online". Somehow, you seem to have missed that.

jmgarvin apparently knew this too. He just didn't make it that obvious on his initial post on this thread. I reacted to the fact he referenced a web link where the original post-er could find OSS substitutes. I see this all too often in online forums, but it's not going to create the groundswell that will make desktop Linux a huge success.

Re: "2. If you really think people "don't understand" that Linux would, for purposes of market penetration, greatly benefit from coming preinstalled on retail desktop systems, you haven't been reading these fora very much. In fact, I seem to recall one or two commenting in this very discussion about how it would be nice to see retailers offering Linux desktops to the general public.

What planet are you on?"

Yeah, you all are REAL AWARE. The very fact that you're pointing out "People have said it would be nice if Linux was preinstalled on PCs" makes my point. THEY AREN'T AWARE IT EXISTS! What? Do I have to club you over the head with a 2x4?

WalMart still sells Linux PCs (Xandros), and they sell a PC with no OS so you can put whatever OS you want on it. They sell Red Hat separately. See? A retailer sells them. And there's a WalMart near you (if you live in the U.S.), I guarantee it. The very fact that I have to point this out shows that Linux advertising for the desktop is not where it should be, that is if anyone's interested in penetrating that market.

by mark miller

Re: "A) You don't have to search online. There are EXCELLENT package managers (that work similarly to add/remove programs in Windows) that will GO OUT AND GRAB THE PACKAGE WITH ALL THE DEPENDENCIES FOR YOU! I suggest you educate yourself about these things before you spout off."

Okay. Apeothis was saying this too. I was just saying it because all too often I see people in the online forums saying "See? See?? You can get what you want here!" and they give a bunch of web addresses. I just shake my head. These people keep hoping that with their own self-styled advertising campaign they'll convert the world. It doesn't work like that.

Re: "1) Drivers are available from vendors. Vendors do take the whole idea of Linux seriously now. Sure not all vendors do, but many have started to offer drivers"

George Ou recently posted an article on ZDNet about this, basically saying that some in the OSS community are having a cow that some vendors want to offer proprietary drivers on Linux, and are proposing that the next Linux kernel BAN them. I doubt this is going to happen since Linus has come down on the side of allowing it. Not to say that he's the "master controller" of Linux, but from what I understand he carries great sway over it.

Re: "The customer MUST go to them because Linux isn't offered as an alternative at many major vendors. So, if I buy a box I either get a naked box or one with Windows (which I don't want and can't return)."

You can get a Xandros box at WalMart, with it preinstalled. At least if you live in the U.S. there's guaranteed to be a WalMart near where you live. What I keep pointing out is the very fact that many people I run into online don't know this proves my point. The marketing for Linux on the desktop just isn't there. Like yourself, even some Linux advocates I run into don't know this. They among anybody should know this, and it's striking to me that they don't.

Re: What's the point? You spew FUD and nothing more.

FUD's for corporations. I may spread around my own ignorance, but it's certainly not FUD. But on the whole, while I didn't know about the autodownloading of sought after apps. (easy to use installation), I knew about Linux PCs at WalMart. Can we call it even?

by apotheon

I'm fully aware that it is possible to get a preinstalled Linux system from Wal-Mart, Dell, and a slew of bit players. On the other hand, without having read about it in some tech rag, [b]we wouldn't know[/b]. You go to the Dell website, the Gateway store, a Wal-Mart, or your local mom-and-pop computer store some time, and try shopping for a computer like you normally would: start by picking out something that has the specs you want, then look at the operating systems available. It'll be a rare treat to even find the computer hardware package you want anywhere but the mome-and-pop store [b]without being forced to buy it with at least WinXP Home[/b] installed, let alone with a different OS.

Do preinstalled Linux systems exist? Yeah.

Are home end-users likely to ever know about it, as things currently stand? No.

by apotheon

"[i]some in the OSS community are having a cow that some vendors want to offer proprietary drivers on Linux, and are proposing that the next Linux kernel BAN them[/i]"
Either Bill G. or Steve B. (I don't remember which, they're both nuts) compared open source software development to Communism a few months ago, but I'm not holding that against all Windows users everywhere. Maybe you should take a cue from me, and not hold the rantings of Richard Stallman against those of us using Linux.

"[i]You can get a Xandros box at WalMart, with it preinstalled. At least if you live in the U.S. there's guaranteed to be a WalMart near where you live.[/i]"
That's mildly disingenuous -- or you don't realize your error. Last I checked, you can't get a Linux system by going to Wal-Mart. You have to go to the website and search for it. jmgarvin is right: it's not an alternative, it's a scavenger hunt.

"[i]Like yourself, even some Linux advocates I run into don't know this.[/i]"
Like me, jmgarvin actually does know that Wal-Mart has Linux machines for sale. He just knows, as I do, and as you apparently do not, that it's pretty much a given that no retail end-user will ever be able to find them.

"[i]I may spread around my own ignorance, but it's certainly not FUD.[/i]"
It's FUD whether you know it or not. The problem is that you're [b]willfully[/b] ignorant: you take someone's word for something without examining the source, the "information" that was given to you, and the likely falsehoods buried under reasonable-sounding phrasing. Most of us who regularly work with technologies on both sides of the divide have learned to be a bit more discerning in what we accept as fact.

by jmgarvin

"Okay. Apeothis was saying this too. I was just saying it because all too often I see people in the online forums saying "See? See?? You can get what you want here!" and they give a bunch of web addresses. I just shake my head. These people keep hoping that with their own self-styled advertising campaign they'll convert the world. It doesn't work like that."

Typically we say this because:
1) We don't know what distro they are using
2) We don't know if they have access to yum, apt, etc
3) You can get info at the web address beyond what you can get with me just saying:
yum install packageA

"George Ou recently posted an article on ZDNet about this, basically saying that some in the OSS community are having a cow that some vendors want to offer proprietary drivers on Linux, and are proposing that the next Linux kernel BAN them. I doubt this is going to happen since Linus has come down on the side of allowing it. Not to say that he's the "master controller" of Linux, but from what I understand he carries great sway over it."

NONONONONONONO...The FSF (the Free Software Foundation, a different thing all together) and their leader Richard Stallman said this. I think most of the FLOSS community are shaking their heads in shame. Typically we side with Linus because he isn't a utopian.

Think of Stallman as the great philosopher and Linus as the engineer. Without Stallman we wouldn't have GPL, Gnu, or the whole idea of free software. However, Stallman isn't an implementer, but an idealist...philospher.

Linus on the other hand realize the realities of the situation and typically states that while Stallman has every right to say what he wishes, Linux will not go down that road. Linus understands that the FSF crowd tend towards the extreme and will eventually help drive Linux in a certain direction, however typically their voices are so shrill and annoying, it's just easier to let them vent and then do your own thing anyway.

"You can get a Xandros box at WalMart, with it preinstalled. At least if you live in the U.S."

You can only order it only and after great searching. You cannot buy it in the meat world, it is an "online exclusive!" I've stated before that you CAN get Linux pre-installed, but try to find it on a vendors web page. Dell doesn't, as far as I know, sell a Linux installed computer to the home user.

"The marketing for Linux on the desktop just isn't there. Like yourself, even some Linux advocates I run into don't know this. They among anybody should know this, and it's striking to me that they don't."

A major part of the problem is that there is no support for marketing. While Linux is huge in the server market, the reason it can't get into the desktop market, easily, is not only because of the vendors, but also due to dirty business practices that MS uses.

"FUD's for corporations. I may spread around my own ignorance, but it's certainly not FUD. But on the whole, while I didn't know about the autodownloading of sought after apps. (easy to use installation), I knew about Linux PCs at WalMart. Can we call it even?"

Evenish ;-)

I'm glad you actually are civil and understand that it isn't an attack, but I think most of us are frustrated by the amount of FUD (and sometimes ignorance) that is propogated about Linux. Sometimes it is intially hard to tell a Rikk from a decent guy like you...

by mark miller

The information about WalMart was enlightening. I honestly thought they were selling Linux boxes in the retail outlets. I'm sure they were a couple years ago, because I read about it. I just assumed they still were. I read recently that WalMarts now have a "Microsoft Center" in their stores, but I thought they also were still selling "blanks", where consumers could get a PC and then choose the OS to go with it. It may vary from site to site.

I just recently ordered a couple items from the WalMart website that when I checked at the local outlet, they didn't have. So I see your point on this.

I did not know Stallman was the leader of FSF. I think I got them mixed up with OSF (Open Software Foundation). I used to use the Motif window manager on the X-stations I used back in college. That's what I associated it with. I just looked up their Wikipedia page, and the group is no longer OSF, but The Open Group. And it had this interesting closing note:

"Despite the similarity in name and the fact that both groups were based in Cambridge, Massachusetts, there was never any connection between OSF and the Free Software Foundation."

I guess it's happened to lots of people. :)

jmgarvin said: "Dell doesn't, as far as I know, sell a Linux installed computer to the home user."

True. I checked that. Dell is selling Linux desktops for businesses. If you look under their Small Business selection, the Linux machines are easy to find. if you select "desktops & workstations", they have a selection called "Open Source Desktops". That's where they have them. Then they have a bunch of verbage explaining to people "these are not Windows desktops", just to avoid confusion--they know people tend to associate "PC" with "Windows".

You can also find them on Dell's site by using their search facility, with "Linux desktop".

IMO Dell sometimes misclassifies things. I recently bought a Pocket PC from them, and it turns out they classify them under "Electronics". I kept looking under "Computers" and not finding them. I thought for a moment they weren't making them anymore, but I did a search on their site and finally found the one I wanted.

My main point during this discussion was marketing, marketing, marketing. If you don't have that, the rest doesn't mean that much in the larger scheme of things.

My understanding of Linux's history is that it started getting some buzz in the late 90s, but didn't really get "put on the map", where certain corporate customers started to sit up and take notice until companies like IBM and HP got behind it. Up to the present day these companies have marketed Linux as a server OS. I imagine that most corporate customers think of them in just that way. IBM has made noises of late that there could come a point where it's a viable desktop OS, but they haven't committed to that notion yet. I think it's going to take a major corporate sponsor that believes in Linux as a viable desktop alternative to get it to the point where major vendors and retailers start selling it more broadly to ordinary consumers.

by mark miller

Re: "That's one of the reasons I use (Debian GNU/)Linux instead of Windows for my primary OS. I spend far less time maintaining my system as a result."

I wasn't talking about "working hard" to maintain the OS. Did you notice I was talking about application development?

Re: "Why are you talking about IDEs as though they're the sole domain of Microsoft?"

I did not say that. I mentioned Eclipse. It has an Integrated Development Environment (IDE). I said that it didn't suit me. I know there are other IDEs out there. I mentioned some PHP IDE products as well.

Re: "Perhaps you should educate yourself in that regard."

Yeah I bet you tell a lot of people this. Are you getting this off a script?

I look at other features besides whether a development tool allows me to do WYSIWYG editing of the HTML/CSS. I also look at whether it has good debugging capabilities, and whether it helps take care of the plumbing for me (like connecting to the database, getting data out, putting data in, interfacing to a web service, etc.) with minimal assistance from me. I'm interested in the business problem. I don't want to have to deal with the plumbing if I don't have to. What I particularly like about the most recent version of VS is it provides controls plus supporting infrastructure for them that allows me to put them on a page, and they take care of setting up a lot of the functionality for accomplishing the task they were designed for, like the login control I mentioned, so I don't have to code it all. Maybe you can't relate to what a time-saver these things are, but they count for a lot with me.

Re: "Worse yet, you seem to think that an IDE is the only way to do web design work without getting down to "bare metal", as 'twere. Have you never heard of such WYSIWYG tools as Dreamweaver (for Windows) and NVU (for unix)?"

I heard of Dreamweaver a long time ago. It's a high-end HTML/CSS editor. I prefer an editor that's part of an IDE, because it integrates well with the (C#, PHP, Java, insert your favorite language here) code editor. Like I said, it sets up events within the code that link to the controls on the page designer. I don't have to worry about creating functional links between the web page to my back-end code. It does it for me. One less thing for me to worry about, thank you very much.

NVU? Never heard of it.

Re: "Do you enjoy being limited to doing web development with .NET rather than being able to develop using other (competing) technologies?"

For a while I have been, actually. Like I said, it lowered the barrier for entry for me into the web application field, from the standpoint of a learning curve, which was quite an adjustment from the skillset I came from. I've considered expanding my skillset to other platforms now that I'm more familiar with how the web application paradigm works.

Re: "Do you enjoy being limited to a minority web server platform?"

It's not that much of a minority. I've looked at some job statistics and .Net job openings are numerous nationwide in the U.S. I did a comparison a month ago on Dice. As far as languages that are used on the web and are cross-platform: Java, Perl, Ruby, Python, and PHP combined had about 4,700 openings (the bulk of this was Java and Perl, most of it Java). .Net had about 3,700 openings.

Re: "Only one PHP IDE that runs on Linux . . . ? You didn't search very hard."

You're stating the obvious: I said this in my post.

Re: "The main problem with the general public getting accurate information about options other than the mainstream market dominators is people like you, who see one or two comments about a subject, assume that constitutes useful knowledge, and start making up "facts" about the state of the industry. Before trying to educate others, educate yourself."

You act like this is some job description of mine. I don't have to educate myself about anything before I post, just as nobody else on here does. The very fact that I get things wrong is sometimes because nobody else has bothered (I'm talking about vendors) to bring some piece of knowledge to my attention. There are a lot of times when I go out and search for knowledge if I'm curious about something, but I don't make it my business to know about every little development tool out there. I used go searching for freeware development tools some several years ago, but only because I had to, and I didn't particularly like it. What I often found is one development tool would have some features I liked, but didn't have others I needed; or it would have some I liked and some I didn't, so it was kind of a wash. I understand what you're saying, that a few of the ones you mentioned are commercial.

Like I said earlier, I don't like having to work harder than I have to to create an application. That was my point. No need to make it into more than it is.

by apotheon

"[i]I think it's going to take a major corporate sponsor that believes in Linux as a viable desktop alternative to get it to the point where major vendors and retailers start selling it more broadly to ordinary consumers.[/i]"
See "Oracle Linux". It looks like it's happening.

by apotheon

You're absolutely right: you don't "have to" educate yourself before spewing half-baked crap all over the Internet. You absolutely have the ability to speak with the tone of authority when, in fact, you know almost nothing about the subject you're addressing.

That doesn't make you any less wrong.

I never tried to imply that you are somehow functionally incapable of being an ignoramus. I just suggested that it's not a very good idea to consciously choose that path. For one thing, it makes you look bad. For another, it wastes my time correcting you. Finally, it misleads others -- the worst crime of the bunch.

edit: I don't know how that typo got away from me for so long.

by mark miller

There are some people who think you have to know everything before you come to discuss a subject online. I don't. Further I don't see the point of it. If you already know all there is to know on a subject, why discuss it? You're not going to learn anything, right? I don't believe discussion forums are just places to state what you know, but to also learn something new. Programmers like myself often have a habit of stating things as fact when in fact we're just floating a "trial balloon". If you're not used to it, you haven't hung around developers that much, or just haven't chosen to adjust to it.

One of the ways I learn is by exposing my ignorance, unintentionally, and letting others correct me. I saw you do a little of that (correcting me), but not much. For the most part you disregarded my concerns as a developer and told me I was an idiot. I don't see how that's correcting me. It seems more like you get off on your own sense of self-importance. Don't worry. I've dealt with your kind at one time or another for 17 years. Another know-it-all is born every day.

As for your claim that you're wasting your time correcting me, well, you don't seem to have a problem with that. You've responded to just about every post I've made. Sounds to me like you don't think it's a waste of time at all, or else you'd stop doing it.

by apotheon

"[i]There are some people who think you have to know everything before you come to discuss a subject online. I don't.[/i]"
You probably should refrain from insinuating I'm one of those people when I've said nothing of the sort. I just pointed out that when you don't know something [b]you shouldn't pretend you do[/b].

"[i]stating things as fact when in fact we're just floating a 'trial balloon'.[/i]"
If it didn't involve telling other people they're wrong when, in fact, [b]you have no idea what you're talking about[/b], then I'd see your point. By specifically disagreeing with people about things you don't understand, on the other hand, you're doing more than floating a trial balloon. You're BSing. There's a big difference.

"[i]You've responded to just about every post I've made.[/i]"
What I said is that you're wasting my time, not that it's a waste of my time to correct your crap. The problem is that you're going around spreading FUD and otherwise misleading nonsense, and it's because of people doing that crap that a great many people get the wrong ideas about things and go on to pull the same nonsense you have. It's a self-perpetuating problem and has little or nothing to do with the proclivities of programmers. It has more to do with the tendencies of the willfully ignorant.

Frankly, you just come off like some idiot trying to sound like he knows more than he does. If that's not what you're actually doing, you need some serious lessons in social interaction, because that's how you're succeeding at presenting yourself.

by mackenga

...but MS can spend billions trying with glossy adverts, billboards, TV and radio advertising, cushy deals with hardware manufacturers and retailers, etc. Linux has nothing - no marketing machine behind it. And yet it is vastly superior to Windows. That's why the Linux community try to push it - for your benefit, not for their own.

Granted, some of us seem a little too keen to bash Windows but we're faced daily with the apparent unassailability of this god-awful platform. Microsoft's propaganda prevents people like you from making an informed decision based on your wants and needs. We're here to try to avoid that. Unfortunately some of us are a little too zealous and focus too much on the disadvantages of the opposition rather than the advantages of our platform, but if we're biased, at least it's not because we want your money.

by jerome.koch

WinXP at work, and XP and SuSe at home. Where I think the Linux people go wrong is to assume that the average consumer gives a crap about computers. They want to game, check email, download music and other content. They want thier PCs to be easy to use and to be transparent to thier operations. Linux OS cannot offer this to most people out of the box.period.

Linux has a future in the embedded market (Cellphones, PDAs,gameing platforms etc...)But for an OS for the "average consumer", Linux is dead. But so is XP. The market is beginning to shed its need for PCs. In a few years (probably less then 10), the home PC will join the betamax and 8-track player. In the near future people will have internet enabled appliances such as the Razor phone, Blackberry's, and home entertainment centers. This is where Linux will shine. However, it won't be a closed system, but an open one coded for specific electronic platforms.

MS knows this, that is why they are attempting to leach as much cash out of thier OS as they can. Vista will be thier last OS. If they are smart, they will launch thier own version of Linux. Many moons ago they had Xenix - a MS variant of Unix- why not do they same with Linux? In a decade it will all be embedded anyway.

by apotheon

"[i]Where I think the Linux people go wrong is to assume that the average consumer gives a crap about computers.[/i]"
I believe you are correct in that assumption, in sort of an overgeneralized sense. There are a lot of Linux people that don't "go wrong" that way, but many don't pause to think about that fact and operate on the assumption that other people care, too. I've made that mistake from time to time, both as a Windows user and as a Linux user.

"[i]Linux OS cannot offer this to most people out of the box.period.[/i]"
I believe that on this detail you are full of it, and don't even know it. Period.

"[i]But for an OS for the 'average consumer', Linux is dead.[/i]"
Nonsense. It's just getting started. There are Linux distributions that, if they were widely available, preinstalled on the hardware and properly preconfigured for the retail end user, would kick any Windows version's ass all over the place as an OS for the "average consumer".

"[i]The market is beginning to shed its need for PCs.[/i]"
I think that, as a technologist, you've lost touch with the end user market. There are tens of millions of Americans that will be getting their first PCs for the first time in the next ten years. Get past the hype and realize that not everyone in the world is IT buzzword-compliant yet. That doesn't even take into account developing third-world nations whose communications infrastructure will finally be catching up with the late twentieth century during that time, thus recreating the 1990s US PC industry.

"[i]In a decade it will all be embedded anyway.[/i]"
I think "in a decade" is pretty spectacularly optimistic on that. I also think that depends on your definition of "embedded", even if you extend the timeline to twenty years. We'll still have multipurpose personal computers in twenty, or even fifty, years -- they'll just become wearable and/or directly interfaced with the users either transcutaneously or via subcutaneous wireless peripherals (and, eventually, the entire computer might be subcutaneous with wireless networking capability).

by jmgarvin

I've been hearing about the death of the PC for about 2 decades now.

My take:

A) We need PCs to word process, play games, email, etc. You need a robust multi-function platform with a LARGE screen. Cell phones, PDAs, et al don't fit that...

B) We can only hope that Vista will be the last. I have a feeling we'll be seeing server 2008 soon enough....

As for Linux not working "out of the box." BOGUS.

A) I get OO installed OUT OF THE BOX, unlike MS Office which I have to purchase
B) Cedega allows me to play games via my Linux box, a simple download and double click and I'm playing Windows games
C) There are tons of media players, codecs, tools, apps, etc that come pre-packaged with Linux distros, what DOESN'T a user get?

by apotheon

He doesn't try to "convert" anyone because he's too busy trying to piss everyone off. He's a troll.

by meesha

I too over the yars have come through various paths of technologies with the same view as yours - whatever works best for the situation at hand.

I started out in VMS some years ago and with market forces being what they are, moved into Windows along the way. Regardless of the general view that Windows is good for everything, this is exactly why I've moved on to the *NIX. Windows although very good for almost all home use left me wanting in business functionality.

What business in their right mind would not consider the best fit for their org in terms of overall TCO/ROI? If Windows does that for them, so be it. In my own business Linux et al has proven to be the overall winner.

Does this mean that Windows doesn't have a fit? Or that Linux is still unable to meet business needs? Not by a long shot. The market can and will bear all flavors of technology for many years to come.

As technologists, we'll still have a job for quite some time regardless of "which camp" you're in.

by dksells

Linux for servers, Windows for PC's. This is what works for me. But,... Windows still pisses me off!

by jerome.koch

I use Windoze and SuSe. About 4 years ago I began to lear Linux on my own and at work. Back then I began with RedHat. I was having some problems right off the bat recompiling the kernal for a device driver. I found a message board (IRC) went in and posted a question. I cannot repeat what was thrown at me. The arrogance was one thing, but these people are not only nasty, but also sociopathic.

I'm not saying Windoze people cannot be arrogant-I work with a few. Both there are lot of Linux people out there that are very angry. I know several UNIX admins and they don't even come close.

by apotheon

You're trying to blame the failings of IRC trolls on Linux?

If you want good attitudes and people who aren't obnoxious, IRC typically isn't the place to find them.

by wbgrant

That Docx file format sounds very similar conceptually to the old (pre Open Document) Open Office format.

The continual standoff between Windows and "alternative" computing generates a lot of noise, but it also creates a great deal of developmental dynamics.

Both Windows and Linux are much better now than they were a decade ago because of this.

by zal9

that there is a debate at all. Wouldn't have been much discussion
15 years ago. MS's stranglehold is obviously loosening, and the
monopoly is coming to an end, so we should all be happy about
that. The free market is working, just slower than predicted.

by apotheon

The reason the market is so slow to correct itself in this matter is that it's not really a [b]free[/b] market. It's a managed market in a mixed economy.

by jmgarvin

The barried to entry are too high and the need for complements too great to enter freely (exiting is easy)....

The monopoly that MS has has killed the OS market for YEARS...now, FINALLY, something is happening and reality is setting in...

by apotheon

Start small. From "ignore them", you should first try getting comfortable with something that's only one step removed from that. Try giving a knowing, indulgent look and saying "Here's a nickel, kid. Buy yourself a real computer." Once you've mastered that, get back to me.

by robax

Yep, that's the conclusion I've come to after the last few months of skimming through the rather large volume of TR newsletters that I seem to have subscribed to somehow.

It's pretty obvious that the editorial staff purposefully seed controversial discussions and pull them to the fore. The reason is to generate traffic,and hat is after all in their interest... it's how they make their income and I've got no problem with that... but it is tabloid journalism, and I won't take the bait and partake in the threads (other than this post here).

It's like when Springer gets a bunch of black power people on stage and then marches out the kkk... just sit back and watch the mayhem... but never ever get involved.

.. it's all about profiteering off the battles, not solving them.

by nicholson.eric

As a user of Linux, what I don't understand is why you would SPEND several hundred dollars for MS. You say it does what you need . . . show me what MS does that Linux can't do. If there is a program not available, it is probably in progress.
Now, if you still like Windows and don't mind paying the money . . . more power to ya. You're providing job security for someone.

by jerome.koch

For most users, XP rarely locks up. When run with Virus Protection it is secure, and it is easy to use.

by apotheon

In my world, "rarely locks up" means it's locking up far too commonly.

Unlike Linux, Windows is highly vulnerable to viruses and other malware.

Unlike Linux, Windows is very susceptible to damage by viruses and other malware once it's infected.

Unlike Linux, Windows configuration changes often require downtime.

Unlike Linux, Windows doesn't have a stateful packet filtering firewall built in.

. . . and that's just the beginning.

by oneamazingwriter

:D The last person that I knew who preffered alcohol over gas was stuck out of gas dead drunk. When arrested for drunk driving he argued, "But Ossifer, I wazn't going anywhere!"

Not Edited: I was going to take the extra f out of prefered, but I though tit looked cute! :p

Still not edited: ROFL!!! Look what happens when you type thought it, but get the spacing wrong!!

by jerome.koch

Dell, IBM, HP all offer Linux out of the box to the general public. These are custom built loads for thier platforms. Where are the takers? You even get Free Office and other add ons. This is all free!

Linux hasn't even come close to getting the general public interested in let alone enthused about thier product. Why? Because the public doesn't care for Linux. Linux is free, but there is still much more enthusiasm for Apple OS X then Linux. And OS X is much more expensive. You would think that a free product would generate tens of millions of new users every year.

I use SuSe at home, but my wife and kids tried it, and wouldn't switch. Linux isn't easier to use- device drivers are at times buggy, both SuSe and Red Hat require frequent patching.

As said before, the desktop will become extinct as far as home appliances are concerned. The future of Linux is in the home entertainment market. My nephew's Razor has replaced his PC. He still has it, but it collects dust in his room. He downloads songs, takes photos, text messages, emails and phones from there. He has a nice iMac. Except for school, he rarely touches it. When he graduate next month, he's giving it to my son.

Redhat would make a killing if they would partner with Verizon. Apple makes all of its profits on the iPod and iTunes.

by apotheon

Your first sentence is complete crap. The rest follows suit. Example:

Dell only offers preinstalled Linux for corporate packages.

IBM isn't even an OEM, let alone one that sells preinstalled Linux systems. Didn't you notice that they sold their PC business to Chinese PC manufacturer Lenovo?

by meesha

just to give Jerome his due, those who've only ever experienced Windows O/S have noticed that the newer versions have be less prone to the blue screen of death. Instead, it just crashes more "elegantly" with no know cause, oops, except for the constant patching installs required.

Win2003 server is far better than previous versions but not when constant testing of new "fixes" and security patches are required.

So Jerome, we're glad YOU think MS anything is stable.

by rkuhn040172

Focusing on home users:

"In my world, "rarely locks up" means it's locking up far too commonly."

My PC hasn't locked up in at least a year because it is properly maintained. Patched, disk clean, defrag, etc.

"Unlike Linux, Windows is highly vulnerable to viruses and other malware."

AVG is free. Spybot/Adaware/Spyware Blaster are all free.

"Unlike Linux, Windows is very susceptible to damage by viruses and other malware once it's infected."

See above...rarely gets infected.

"Unlike Linux, Windows configuration changes often require downtime."

Home users don't care about having to reboot once in a while.

"Unlike Linux, Windows doesn't have a stateful packet filtering firewall built in."

ZoneAlarm is free.

All my points are convenient, easy to use, cheap or free, widely available and allow one to eliminate all your points and still use the OS of their choice.

Add to that a free router/firewall from your ISP like SBC/Yahoo and one can have both hardware and software firewall for free minus $12.99 a month for 1.5Mb service.

Not bad at all for a home user.

by apotheon

"[i]My PC hasn't locked up in at least a year because it is properly maintained. Patched, disk clean, defrag, etc.[/i]"
Good for you. Mine either. I don't have to reboot for patches, run disk cleaning utilities, and defrag my filesystem, but if you like doing that sort of thing, more power to ya.

"[i]AVG is free. Spybot/Adaware/Spyware Blaster are all free.[/i]"
So is ClamAV, and its Windows desktop version, ClamWin -- and it tends to be faster for definitions updates than the major proprietary offerings for Windows (including even AVG, which is one of the best). I'm just glad that if ClamAV should happen to miss a virus on my Linux systems, the worst that will happen is [b]someone else's[/b] computer will be infected. I'm pretty much covered by the fact that Linux patches virus vulnerabilities, rather than leaving the vulnerabilities in place so that AV software has to try to filter it out with virus definitions.

"[i]See above...rarely gets infected.[/i]"
I definitely prefer "never infected" over "rarely infected".

"[i]Home users don't care about having to reboot once in a while.[/i]"
That's a very good point, mostly. Some home users care. Most don't, because they think appliances are always supposed to be turned off when not directly being used, and that computers are appliances.

"[i]ZoneAlarm is free.[/i]"
ZoneAlarm isn't a stateful packet filtering firewall. It's a stateful application firewall. It needs to be combined at least with a separate socket-layer firewall to reach a level of security I'd ever consider acceptable, and it's still not up to the standards of a stateful packet filter like iptables.

A separate firewall/router appliance does provide packet filtering, however, so with the addition of external hardware you can indeed get reasonable protection from everything except viruses and the like.

by rkuhn040172

But are any of your counter points strong enough to sway someone who has been using Windows for years and years to switch to Linux...that is my point.

A Windows user can achieve a relatively high enough level of safety and security using easy, free or cheap and widely available tools.

I'll grant you many of your points, but they are not strong enough to convert a home user from Windows to Linux. Not going to happen. At least not in large numbers any time soon.

by apotheon

You're right -- home users tend to not even be aware of such issues, and that's a significant hurdle in the way of widespread end-user adoption of Linux. Kind of a shame, really. It's a lot less annoying to support unices than Windows, but most of the desktop market is still in Microsoft's hands.

This discussion is closed to new replies.