Would you accept an IT job as "Jack Of All trades" or run from it?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Networks
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
I don't discount the cert folks as many people have gotten them just to prove to HR wonks that they know what they know.
What irks me is that HR wonks will pass over YEARS of experience in favor of a cert.
by graham.rance
Specialisation is something that can be outsourced. You can always 'buy' the services of an expert. What makes you valuable to a company is an ability to view IT as an interellated resource, and that's why there's a move towards recruiting people with a wide base of skills.
In my experience people who moan about these things are 'old skool' meaning app developers who had no idea about networks, so produced horrible apps which over used the infrastructure, or security 'experts' who ban ICMP on networks because it is bad, without understanding that for apps to work over GRE tunnels you need to use ICMP for MTU discovery.
Jack of all trades shouldn't mean rubbish at a lot of things, it should mean highly skilled at a lot of things.
If you're worried, i suggest you do some work on upskilling rather than moaning
Graham
by d50041
by rwb1959
This thing reads like a PhD dissertation! It's absurd to say the least in terms of what they want and what they will pay!
***************************************
Good Morning
I have a position available for two Network Operations analysts in Manhattan - near Penn Station and the Empire State Building.. I see that you do have past experience working with Servers and desktops in a Windows environment. One position is contract to perm the other start as permanent employee.
Contract range is approx. $40 per hour and will be converted to a perm position - The perm ant position will start in the $90K range. Please read the job description below and let me know what you think. If this position is not right for you and you know someone that is qualified, please pass it along. Thank you.
JOB TITLE: Windows Operations Analyst
LOCATION: New York City
DESCRIPTION AND DUTIES:
Leading media company in midtown - near empire State Building wants to hire 1 or 2 Operations Analysts - positions will be either Contract to Perm or Permanent -
Person will be part of a team of 6 - Day to day responsibilities is 70% server support 30% desktop -
. Provide support for standard server software including, but not limited to, Windows 2000/2003, SQL 2000/2005, IIS, Exchange 2003.
Required Skills, Education & Experience
. 7+ years system administration experience in a large-scale, heterogeneous data center environment (preferably Solaris, Linux, SuSe, NT/Windows2000/2003).
. Advanced skills in the following technologies: Operating systems including Microsoft Windows 2000/2003 Server, IIS. Networking technologies including Conceptual understanding of TCP/IP, Routers, Switches, Hubs, Firewalls, Domains, DNS, DHCP and Subnets.
. Windows 2000/2003 and Windows NT as well as Active Directory.
. Windows Operating System administration.
typical day includes: report generation, access control, provisioning - troubleshooting network, creating files share, user access -r emote desk-top support (citrix) telecom system knowledge is a plus-
Service application monitoring and application / server performance monitoring
MS Sharepoint is a plus
Spyware is a plus -
. ensure that all IT services meet their SLA targets and that the operational infrastructure meets all its operational targets
. operate and implement all operational IT infrastructure and procedures
. ensure that the physical IT environment is maintained and secure according to security and contractual requirements and business needs
. provide day-to-day contact and coordination of third party engineers and support staff
. ensure that the operational requirements of all other IT, Service and Business Management processes are satisfied
. perform the day-to-day management and operation of all IT infrastructure processes
. Maintain all operational documentation.
Responsibilities
. Responsible for ensuring the reliability of the Windows Server and Desktop platform.
. Responsible for completion of PC and Systems support tasks in a timely and accurate manner, including tasks at all levels of complexity.
. Responsible for documentation, tracking and resolution of issues, and monitoring recurring issues and suggesting long term solutions for such issues
. Offer support in finding ways to improve the current environment and service provided.
. Work well with other members of the team, respect ideas and contributions from others, maintain self control in difficult situations, and work well with people at all levels.
. Support tasks include PC, Printers, Phone and Blackberry support.
. Provide support for standard server software including, but not limited to, Windows 2000/2003, SQL 2000/2005, IIS, Exchange 2003.
. Participate in problem solving and troubleshooting for the Windows environment and related applications.
. Participates in and may lead projects to implement or enhance IT services.
. Participate in functional test planning and testing for the Windows environment and related applications.
. Research and implement new technologies to improve the Windows environment.
. Interact with outsourcing vendors to assure timely resolution to any issues.
. Ensure servers and desktop environment meet proper performance and capacity standards.
. Develop and maintain a thorough knowledge of the Windows environment and related applications.
. efficiently and effectively investigate, diagnose, progress and action all operational events, alarms and incidents to the agreed quality and targets, ensuring that issues are escalated where appropriate and all records are updated in a timely fashion; Incident and Problem Management, ensuring that they have the appropriate documentation
. monitor, analyze, review and report on all IT Operations, services, service levels and service quality on a daily basis
. maintain operational logs and journals on all events, warnings, alerts and alarms, recording and classifying all messages; maintain all operational data collection procedures, mechanisms and tools
. maintain all operational documentation, processes, management and diagnostic tools and spares, ensuring that spares are maintained at the agreed levels
. ensure that all routine housekeeping tasks are completed on all operational infrastructure and be aware of, check and test all availability, resilience, emergency and security test procedures and processes
. use management systems tools to determine loads, collect routine performance statistics and create routine reports as required
. ensure that all computer equipment is maintained according to policies and recommendations and perform regular checks on environmental equipment and conditions
. carry out any necessary system tuning to maintain optimum performance levels in conjunction with Capacity Management
Required Skills, Education & Experience
. 7+ years system administration experience in a large-scale, heterogeneous data center environment (preferably Solaris, Linux, SuSe, NT/Windows2000/2003).
. Advanced skills in the following technologies: Operating systems including Microsoft Windows 2000/2003 Server, IIS. Networking technologies including Conceptual understanding of TCP/IP, Routers, Switches, Hubs, Firewalls, Domains, DNS, DHCP and Subnets.
. Windows 2000/2003 and Windows NT as well as Active Directory.
. Windows Operating System administration.
. General experience with server hardware devices, configuring and troubleshooting.
. General network skills required in support of Ethernet, VPN, TCP/IP and FTP.
. Windows server and PC hardware setup and configuration.
. Server based performance and capacity planning
. Problem troubleshooting and root cause analysis skills
. Strong team player and must possess excellent communications skills.
. Must have very strong customer service skills.
. Must be proficient in authoring and contributing to technical design documents.
. Microsoft certified or equivalent work experience working on Windows Server and PC Operating Systems
. Strong communication and analytical skills, with the ability to resolve problems and explain solutions to others.
. Must have strong organizational skills with attention to detail.
. Ability to work both as a member of a group and as an individual contributor.
. Ability to work independently in a fast paced and changing environment is crucial.
. Ability to work flexible hours including other shifts and be able to respond in an on-call basis.
The pay SUCKS and the responsibilites are rediculous for any one person to handle. Come on, even for a seasoned pro like myself with over a decade in IT won't be insane enough to bother with this.
Hey Kids..can you say "This job is an H1-B Magnet"?
Edited
Message was edited by: beth.blakely@...
How's about a posting for technical recruiters as such:
Wanted:
Highly skilled technical recruiter who knows how to use his/her brain, will thoroughly read the resumes presented in front of them, and will not blast emails of irrelevant positions to candidates who are either unqualified or have nothing to do with the technology based on their skills and experiences.
by sereniti
...and will not blast emails of irrelevant positions to candidates who are either unqualified or have nothing to do with the technology based on their skills and experiences....
Every contact I ever got from a headhunter through Dice or Monster in response to my resume that said my skillset was limited to HTML, CSS, and a smattering of .php and javascript said something like, "We have an opening for a C++ and Cold Fusion programmer that we think you would be perfect for..."
I always wanted to blast back, "Did you bother to READ my resume?" LOL
by labrat636
by liame
Been there and its not bad. A Jack in a big company though just sets alarm bells ringing.
The one skill I would seperate off though is developement. That is an art in itself.
As for the "master of none" part well lets look at it. Tech guy A - he's an exchange specialist in a big company... he does exchange all day every day. Tech guy B works for a small IT support company - he does some Exchange amongst all the other stuff, perhaps 1 or 2 installs a month. Lets look where they are after 3 years... Tech guy A has done 1 install if that, and he probably got help in for that. On top of that he has done a shed load of admin that he really will never learn much from. Tech guy B has done 50 different installs by himself - many of which would have been different or odd in some way, and he would have learnt just a little bit more every time. Tech guy B, on the downside, will have had little to no exposure to clustering etc. Master of None? Hardly, master of some is nearer the mark.
I say bravo to the Jacks - it takes a lot to get that broad range of experience and the small to medium sector is your oyster.
by zenwarp
How do you think companies justify the need to go the H1B route?!!?
They put an add in for the 'jack of all trades' that no one can match and then claim they have tried to fill the position, could not find anyone, and then they get an H-1B.
by sereniti
by ralphclark
by hyposave
Why Me Worry,
Your comment there was a bit racist. These people are VERY hard workers and they have great IT skills. Who cares what they eat!
by john.m
by sereniti
Well, I guess there's no way to tell, but I'm not a dude, I'm a lady. You could call me dudette. :)
And I really don't understand the question - insulting me, or commenting on how lucky I am?
by john.m
I feel comfortable saying this because I am in the same boat;
Don't you feel that everything you do is only half-baked because you are not able to afford the proper time on each task to get it done properly-completely and documented for future support and standardization?
by pcbradshaw
by marka
Seriously that describes the job I currently have. I prefer it to a typical IT job as it offer versaility. I can setup projects based on what is upcoming, not based on my specialty. While it can be disheartening at times, especially when finding a weakness in your skillset, it is a lot more rewarding in being versatile.
As for pay, I agree, it does, for some reason, pay less. In the end the job never gets boring, I get to actually "play" at times while still doing my job. Being stuck as a DBA, for instance, isn't worth the extra pay to me personally. I have never been a singular person so it suits my personality to have a varried workload. I tend to get bored very easily.
This also means that I can't do everything (go figure) and sometimes I need to pull in contractors and vendors. We migrated from a team of 5 to 1 over a period of 4 years. The cost savings per year has been close to 300,000$ as an end result. This includes the rare times I pull in a contractor. Its definately worked out best for all parties involved.
by mnemennth
As companies continue to grow an excess of executives, we will continue to see them cut corners wherever they can, even if it is to their own detriment. Remember, a college degree (no matter WHICH prestigious school it came from) is no proof of having a clue whatsoever... and there is a 50/50 chance that the guy making this decision graduated in the bottom half of his class. The one thing to remember is this... EVERY role comes with a few "extra responsibilities" no one ever tells you about until after you're on the payroll. If they tell you UP FRONT they want the kitchen sink and the Dispose-All too, they'll probably have you emptying trash cans between servicing the VP's pencil sharpener and dusting the server racks.
Mnem
"Sarcasm - just another service we offer."
by vaidyashish
by azbill
Did for over 15 years. Loved every moment. No competition and I owned all upgrades. Supported over 125 users in all areas from IT Management to Helpdesk Support to include backup for telecommunication and radio.
This depends on the size of the organization and support being provided. Number of servers, desktops, switches, users, etc. There are advantages and disadvantages. On the positive side you will know who did what when somethings goes wrong or maybe that's a negative. Just the opposite for when things go right. You're in control, takes a lot of responsibility to make decisions, because you can't blame anyone else. So, to do this alone means that you have to be great to survive.
by jellyyacht
There is very little, everyone just expects everything to work "All the time", no downtime, no hardware failures. And God help us if something does go wrong. Good job I do it because I like it eh?
Oh yes, as for proper operating systems VMS is just brill, one of my servers has been up for 460 days and the last time it was rebooted was when we upgraded the OS.
Thats why we use it in a 24/7 manufacturing environment. As you say, what a shame it is being marginalised.
I'll take a guess here , you're mad keen on bright spark cutting edge untried stuff,
because it's really great to start arsing about with stuff you don't understand at two in the am, with a big hairy fitter complaining about his crap bonus this week on the radio.
:d
Sunny Scunny me. Used to be 24/7, left to be a 9 to 5ver, but with a lot of valuable lessons learnt.
by ansocoetzer
by greg o
by azbill
by dr_zinj
Small to medium company with limited IT assets and 1 to 5 IT people, sure.
Companies with greater IT assets and more personnel, you really need to start specializing. KNOWLEDGE of, and previous experience in, related areas may be required; but there is no way anyone in IT can be a fully up-to-date expert in all areas.
If you are talking to an HR person, it may pay to remind them of that fact; and that if anyone tells them differently, that they are probably either, at best, inflating their description, or at worst, outright lying.
The year: 2001.
The requirement: 5+ years .Net experience....
HR think that sounds well clever.
'cept it's too long to fit in the box on the application form unless you write really small.
by aathey
It's been interesting reading about other's experiences in the field and concerns about broad knowledge vs. deep knowledge, so I will throw my own story in...
I work for a company of approximately 50 people, with several distributed locations. The environment is mixed Linux servers with a few Windows 2003 machines and primarily Win XP desktops. We have a thorough range of IT services, including intranet web capabilities and billing software, running on top of a segmented network (my first project).
Therefore, I must by nature be a jack of all trades while working here. Even so, there are still ways to work towards specialization--long-term I am aiming to bill myself as a Linux admin with strong mixed systems skills, so I keep an eye out for useful OSS applications and ways to grow the Linux side of the server farm while satisfying business objectives. I can do this in a way that benefits the company as well as myself, and I do not neglect any area that needs my attention.
I am also focusing my certification training in that direction(yes, I am no fan of paper tigers either, but as people say the little pieces of paper attract HR staff, and I do not believe in yielding hiring advantages to my competition on the job market), so that if/when I evolve to specialize I will be able to sell myself into that role.
Otherwise, as my first network admin job I say I have found the jack approach to be incredibly useful for my development. I have gotten a taste of working with many technologies and have had the opportunity to pick ones that I would most want to specialize in, while gaining good experience. Money-wise, what I have heard and experienced does agree with the consensus on the discussion (specialists out-earn jacks on average, though that may well be because specialists inhabit larger companies in general), but at this early stage of my career I benefit more from knowledge so this is a non-starter for me.
I have not seen the 24/7 time-drain problems that some jacks here have ran into. I mostly stick to the 9-5er routine, and when I need to put in an early morning or weekend bit of work I use flextime to take off some hours during the normal work week. So long as I keep management current on my time situation, there have been no issues. For those of you struggling to keep the job from invading your personal life, I would look into working out a flextime arrangement of some sort if possible, and make sure that your supervisor knows just how many hours you are putting in outside of the typical working day when appropriate. I have found most managers sympathetic once they understand that you have already inconvenienced yourself for the company's sake and would merely like to keep the hours worked in balance.
Lastly, for Why Me Worry's initial point: I completely agree, I find it darkly amusing just how bloated even entry-level job postings can be (junior network admin, with a combined 6 years Windows, Linux, and Solaris experience)! My take on it is that if I want the job, I will tweak my resume and focus my cover letter on the areas that I am strongest at and send it in, counting on the hiring manager being a bit more sane. Should I reach the interview, at the end of the day the decision will rest on me convincing him of my value regardless of the ridiculous job requirements. If not, well, I would rather not work there anyway.
~Alex
by pcthakkar
Alex, a bit of appreciation... You have almost said what i always wanted to say, but was falling short of words at that, good summarization of the kind of jobs we do to reach a position of Jack rather than a master.
I was always feeling that all the jobs that were thrown across to me, had a purpose and each of them brought with them a learning experience. My past experience of almost 12 years, has been a checkerboard pattern of some solution suited to meet a business need or get it some competitive advantage, that over time, i sailed from being a network admin to a system analyst to RF Q builder to decision maker to implementer to help desk manager to now leading my own little enterprise...
a reply to one of early posting-i m no beggar dude!
to be a jack also needs patience with almost everybody, including yourself[at times the most difficult part], something which is a bit hard to come by.
thakkar.
And the jerk-off responded with: "Well, do you know somebody who would be interested in this?"
It's bad enough they blast me with this crap...I now have to "recommend" others to these morons? What's in it for me and why should I help them in their pathetic jobs?
by sereniti
by neon samurai
It sounds much more professional than "Anything I can get my hands on through a keyboard."
So now I have "security auditing" and "cross platform system integration" as more acceptable forms for those who can't read between the lines. ;D
by neon samurai
When I talk to someone I get "What do you specialize in" and 'computers, whatcha got?' doesn't seem to cut it.
When I read job postings it's "Job: asystant systems analyst. Requirnments; 4 years management experience, DQL, DBA.. blah, blah" and 'Administrated a BBS for three years and have Administrated my own cross platform network for over ten years ongoing.' doesn't seem to cut it.
Bah.. The "HR Supervisor" tip seems to be the best one for me here so far. Yup, time to send another letter of introduction to the IT side HR and see if I can't hit a little higher up there food chain.
by neon samurai
ColdFusion is still alive and in use? Wahoo.. one of my programming languages is not completely burried under a gravestone. Ah the good old days of building website front ends for database back ends.
(Sorry, had to say it if only to amuse myself ;D )
by sereniti
...I have no idea what programming languages are "in vogue" now. hehehe I just put in the first language that came to mind - I could have said COBOL and FORTRAN! LOL At least that list would have included something I knew at one time.
Actually, I suppose it's .ASP, .NET, SQL and AJAX now, right?
by neon samurai
during the end of highschool and start of university I developed websites coding mostly in html and ColdFusion with Access or SQL database backends.
ColdFusion and .ASP sort of appeared about the same time with ASP being Visual Basic based and ColdFusion being tag based. I could use five lines of code in .ASP or two tags in CF. For our needs, CF became the language of choice and my home server had a nearly 100% web adminable setup acting as my "let's see what I can do with CF today" platform.
As for my guess on current languages? The Windows side has Studio.NET and anything included in the IDE along with c#, vb, vc++ and whatever other MS favourites are there now. The Unix side seems to have Python, Ruby, Java the age old c/c++ and the favorites like perl. My programming schooling is all on the Windows side so the Unix world of programming is still new too me.
by blueknight
I wouldn't take a position like that now, especially for a company that wanted to pay enough for only one of the positions.
At one place I ended up becoming the jack of all trades because it was a small shop (10 or less in the IT area) and because I wanted to improve things (including my knowledge).
One day I found a new version of the old OS we were running, so I suggested to the boss that we "upgrade." He agreed, so I installed it and we went on.
Some time later, we upgraded the entire system. After we'd been on the new 4331 mainframe a while, I suggested that we run everything under VM so we programmer/analysts wouldn't have to work overtime at night and on weekends to do our testing. The boss agreed, so I went to a training class then installed VM. This led to my creating a test system under VM. That gave me the opportunity to learn CICS and the DL/I database system. At that point, I was System Programmer, DBA and Programmer/Analyst. Over time I added skills in the area of communications, LAN construction on up thru LAN Admin and some other stuff including data center manager.
I really enjoyed the variety of work and was actually pretty good at it all. A position like that would not work in this shop where we have 150 positions in IT to support many departments. Things move fast and when something goes critical, you don't have time for a jack of all trades to finish working on something before he can work on the hot issue.
I'm thankful for that previous position, and I wouldn't mind doing it again in similar circumstances... but applying for a job advertized as "jack of all trades" is just plain nuts. The low salary basically states that the employer a) doesn't know IT and b) doesn't have the funds to hire/retain quality folks in the company, let alone the IT area.
by blueknight
Where have all the VMS folks gone? That's one system I really enjoyed working with. Unfortunately that organization ended up going to UNIX.
Woof!
by amazonv
by azbill
by komplex
1) Would you want to be the expert Jack of all trades?
The drawback to this is users expectation. When systems are built well, it's pretty easy to maintain them. All IT professionals have the basic knowledge to figure out Networking, Database and Desktop problems and the ability to find the answers. The drawback is when something out of the ordinary happens, it will take longer to solve. If a company is willing to have it's SQL server go down for three hours while you are searching technet, then being a jack of all trades isn't too bad. But if they expect a 24x7 environment, if they expect projects to be finished in a quick manner, then this job is a death march.
2) Would you do it for the right amount of money?
I would think maybe, but it would depend more on what the user expects. Can you outsource? Use consultants? Have weekends off?
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending