461 replies
by mslamen
by deepsand
the [i]subjective[/i].
Your statement that which you "[i]deem to be "cultural rudeness" on the part of the Indians[/i]" is, by the use of the word "deem," clearly subjective. Apparently you seem to hold that others should conform to your cultural standards. If that is the case, then yes, by definition, you are bigoted.
From Merriam-Webster:
Main Entry: bigot
: a person [b]obstinately or intolerantly devoted to his or her own opinions and prejudices[/b]; [u]especially[/u] : [b]one who regards or treats the members of a group (as a racial or ethnic group) with hatred and intolerance[/b]
by deepsand
by mslamen
No, I have no evidence nor am I suggesting that TR is concerned about being PC. I simply stated that "I would hope they would not resort to that".
I have noticed that these forums contain alot of different subjects, some of which have nothing to do with the field we all work in. I am not OK with racial slurs nor do I beleive that TR has the obligation to post any dribble we wright.
Liberals? Just what the hell is that to mean?
Surely you can connect that.
by jamesrl
And no, I'm not in any way shape or form affiliated with them...
The business has the right to edit anything they like.
They are not denying you free speech, you have the right to say whatever you want. They/the moderators, on the other hand, have the right to choose the kind of content they want on their website.
You don't have the right to post anything here, and neither do I. Sorry, doesn't exist.
TV stations and newspapers have the right to and often do refuse content and/or advertising on whatever grounds they see fit. Bars kick out obnoxious drunks. This website is the same.
You don't deny TR the right to trim SPAM do you? Well they obviously judge some of your posts to be equally as undesireable.
If I thought they were censuring you because you were slagging Microsoft or something similar, I'd be on your side. But I don't see that free speech extends to forcing private organizations to carry your opinions if they chose not to.
James
by tg2
by absolutely
The terms "freedom of speech" and "censorship" are frequently misused in this country. You have the right to say, print, or otherwise distribute whatever you want, as long as it isn't slander or libel. However, neither TR nor anyone else is obligated to provide you a forum. This is their site, subject to their whims.
It's going to be difficult to determine why they edited you without copies of what you posted. Obviously its going to be equally difficult to include those examples here without them getting re-edited. If you'd like to send me a PM with some edited content, I'll be happy to take a guess at why they pulled it. Since I'm not on the staff, a guess is all it will be.
by mjd420nova
I don't think that "freedom of speech" is being curtailed at all. I've made a couple of thousand posts about absolutely anything that I wanted over the last couple of years. I've got about as close to burning the US flag on some occasions as I can do without matches and not a single post has been pulled or edited. I've insulted anyone I wish exactly how I wish.
Most of the other peers - at least those who do get properly involved - can say the same.
So, I suggest you need to have a quick look in the mirror. You could even get yourself your own username rather than poncing off others. You're a bit stupid, aren't you? You can't get by in any discussion without loudmouthing it and chucking insults around and what that makes you is really BORING. You've even come out with the classic "that someone has a choice of not reading my posts". Tell you! We don't WANT to read your posts and we're all happy with Beth's clean-up of your crap.
If I'm wrong, I invite all of your supporter (sic) to flame.
Neil
THIS post won't be edited out. Betcha!
You just don't get it, do you?
If you want to actually post something other than simple insults - something with a bit of substance - it would probably be a first; I might even reply. Might...
Until that happens, every post you make just nails what a shallow individual you are. This is not a dispute. This is fact.
"Wanker"? Get a life you sad, sad child.
by absolutely
"This is one dispute I won't back down from."
There are plenty of sites that let you post any BS you like. What is so important about having your words appear [b]on TechRepublic[/b] that you "won't back down from" [u]this[/u] dispute? If TR is so important that you won't back down, isn't it also so important that's it's worth abiding by the standards? I think so.
"If my posts are offending someone, then that someone has a choice of not reading my posts."
If neilb's posts offend you, you have the choice to not read them. You expect him not to offend you, but you don't care if you offend others. You can't have it both ways without looking like a hypocrite.
by thechas
The root cause of your post being edited may not be directly tied to the staff of TR.
Unless the staff is a lot more people than I anticipate, and they have nothing to do but watch the forums, they just don't have the time to read all the posts.
What is more apt to be happening is that some peer is offended by your posts and reports them to the TR staff. The TR staff then reviews the post and acts in what is the best interest of TR.
The most memorable instance of this was the thread the Guru Of DOS started a few years back on the prospects of what would happen if all of the spam offers of treatments for male enhancement he received over the course of a month could be added together. I missed out on most of the posts, but hear that things got well out of hand.
Even if you are using a pseudonym, it is wise on ANY public forum to control your language. You never know who might be able to trace it back to you.
Chas
'Nuff said.
I won't be shocked if this post doesn't survive.
by absolutely
Or, do I mean 'wood'?
I'd be slightly surprised if anybody objects to that post. I've seen much worse.
by nicknielsen
I don't see where you have been kicked off, and even if you have, TR has every right to do so. I do see where some of the more obnoxious name-calling has been edited out. And no, you haven't been singled out.
Edit: Just based on this masterpiece of maturity (https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=222058&messageID=2249428), if I were the moderator, I'd block your ISP.
because there is nothing in there that is so outrageous or offensive to warrant being edited
I think my posts are funny and sarcastic, but if some find them offensive, it's their friggin problem!
by nicknielsen
Sarcastic is easy for most people. Funny takes some work. Getting them both right at the same time is extremely difficult. Apparently, somebody thinks you aren't quite getting it right.
I understand how you feel about being edited as I've always hated it myself. But if it's happening to the majority of your posts, you might consider cutting back somewhat on the rhetoric.
"I think my posts are funny and sarcastic, but if some find them offensive, it's their friggin problem!"
No, it's TR's problem, possibly every members' problem, and to some extent your problem too. The TR business model, like so many web businesses, is to make money by providing advertising-supported content to a target market audience. If too many in that audience is offended by your posts, they'll leave and not come back. Fewer eyeballs watching the ads, less money from the advertisers. Also, some advertisers do not want to be associated with some types of content. If enough advertisers pull their accounts, either because of low ad viewership or because they find the site offensive, no TR.
As to it being your problem, it's a question of what you want from your membership. If all you're looking for is a place to spout off, then you're right: what others think is not your problem at all. On the other hand, if you're at all concerned with having others here respect your opinion, or want to include your TR membership on a resume, you may want to express yourself differently. You can't expect people to respect your opinion without you respecting theirs.
Consider trying to post without trying to be sarcastic. Sarcasm rarely elicits a positive response from others; it's difficult to write sarcasm in writing without looking mean-spirited or contemptuous instead. It's especially difficult to pull off if the only content in your post is a sarcastic remark devoid of supporting facts or opinions, just sarcasm for sarcasm's sake. Look at some posts from TR members whose opinions you may value and see how often they're sarcastic without providing additional information. Plus, it's far more effective if you use it less and save it for occasions that truly deserve a cutting remark. Try presenting a reasoned position and slip the sarcasm in at the very end, you stupid dingleberry.
Oh well, the Imus crackdown is in full force here on TR from what I'm seeing...LOL.
Message was edited by: beth.blakely@...
by absolutely
NOBODY is complaining about your posts because of stomach injuries suffered due to excessive laughter.
That was sarcastic AND funny. It IS a delicate balance, like Nick said. You could learn a lot from neilb on that score. Also HAL9000, sleepin'dawg, apotheon & sometimes OzMedia are masters.
by deepsand
by nicknielsen
Yes, that's possible. But if there is a "crackdown." I suspect it's less about political correctness and more about trying to decrease the rudeness coefficient on TR.
Edit: just finished browsing the remainder of this thread. Not a lot of maturity from either side of this one...
plussungood oldspeak was noticed and upgraded. All references to unpersons now good.
doubleplussungood citizen WMW has been given plussgood retraining.
by jamesrl
Let me ask you something.
If Imus had called your wife or your daughter a "Ho" on national radio, would you be upset?
If you owned Imus' radio station/network, and you were worried about losing network sponsors - $$$, would you not want the right to decide what to broadcast on your own network?
If Imus, or you, want to create your own website and say whatever you want, go fill your boots, none of us can or would stop you.
If you want to play on someone else's site, play by their rules, or go somewhere else.
I've never found you funny. I have found you bigoted and nasty. Now Dawg, he is funny (and scary sometimes).
James
by absolutely
by sleepin'dawg
and with a modicum of intelligence you might not be called to task and be edited. From what I've read of your drivel regarding the H-1B matter, you came off as a small minded, despicable, racist bigot and I'd bet my last dollar, that in your real life you don't dare speak like that. If you talk the talk, you've got to be prepared to walk the walk but your kind doesn't walk, it slithers.
For what it's worth you've come off sounding like a gutless whiner who figures the anonymity of these forums gives you carte blanche to spew your childish hatred without fear of being called on it. You may think you have a razor sharp wit but from here I see you as a nitwit whose tongue and/or mind would probably be best used as toilet paper.
There were/are many points to consider on the H-1B topic; yours just aren't amongst the ones worthy of consideration. Beth edited you??? Well TS. You got precisely what you deserved. Don't like it??? Find somewhere else to pollute with your despicable, infantile garbage. If you fail to comprehend the intended insults here let me quote you:
[i][b] It's like the loudmouths who complain about "offensive" TV or radio broadcasts. Hey morons, there's something called a remote control and tuner knob to change the station or channel if you don't like it.[/i][/b]
You tripped over your own dick and whining like a snot nosed, little titty baby, isn't going to garner you any sympathy. TR has seen many of your kind before, a lot of punks just like you, over the years. It will continue to survive, with or without you and without you would be no great loss.
For what it's worth, I have been deliberately and gratuitously insulting in regards to you, and I admit I'm pushing the envelope here. If Beth chooses to edit me, so be it but this is what the majority thinks of your little tantrum.
[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)
by sleepin'dawg
by absolutely
:^0
You are too much!
[i]You tripped over your on dick and whining like a snot nosed, little titty baby, isn't going to garner you any sympathy. TR has seen many of your kind before, a lot of punks just like you, over the years. It will continue to survive, with or without you and without you would be no great loss.[/i]
What diplomat is that, the ambassador to Iraq the week before the invasion began?
Well said, by the way.
by sleepin'dawg
by sleepin'dawg
agree whole heartedly. For the nonce making ourselves bigger than you will be a chore few here, will be willing to undertake. You may rest assured you remain the biggest ass extent.
Gee you wouldn't be MrMiami in disguise now, would you??? I thought he was the biggest but you've definitely given him a run for his money in the [b][i][u]ASSHOL SWEEPSTAKES[/u][/i][/b]
[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)
by shellbot
i've had stuff pulled and edited..so what..big deal.
i've had people say they don't like what i say..big deal.
I'm all growed up and can take it..
its a website dude..if its hurting you that much..move along and don't let the door hit yer @ss on the way out
by deepsand
people that your posts are regularly being flagged by viewers as Spam? Seems to me that the message is quite clear; you've made a very bad first impression.
TR is like the local watering hole, where nobody has to like the newcomer; it's up to him to fit in. If he can & does, fine; if not, that's fine to, and no tears shed when he leaves.
The ball's in your court; the game is your's to lose.
by absolutely
by deepsand
You got your ass booted out & thought that with new clothes alone you could return to a warm welcome.
Did it not occur to you that your voice, left unaltered, would be your undoing?
Seeing as you were censored before I had the opportunity to be offended and to be fair offensive back, there's no way I can comment on whether I would have found it offensive.
If you do offend me I will tell you, then it's down to you whether you continue to do so or amend your behaviour.
This however is TR's site, if they don't like what you say they do have the right to stop it being said, whether it's you, me, George Ou, Maxwell or any f'cker else.
Their 'house', their rules.
If they censor you don't rail about your freedom of speech, reply and reword.
If someone was to say most US criminals aren't white. If they said that as a piece of supporting evidence in a diatribe on caucasian racial superiority, many would find that sort of racist drivel deeply offensive.
If they said it as supporting evidence for continuing discrimination, some would find the pinko, liberal hand wringing eqyually offensive as well.
Perhaps you could put "warning offensive material in post" in the subject line, that way we could choose not to read.
by deepsand
Go see the Chaplain about getting your TS card punched.
It's good advice; and, for you, absolutely free.
by deepsand
To bad that it's reserved for those in uniform.
;-)
by beth blakely
by sleepin'dawg
;) :^0
Just pushing the envelope a bit.
[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)
by sleepin'dawg
who takes the bedsheets with them when they get up to go burn a cross on someone's lawn. That little comment was how I used to refer to the KKK idiots and when I read comments like yours I can see the levels of hatred and bile are still high, just refocussed slightly to be more inclusive of other races.
The fact that you can't see or understand this pretty much says it all. Norrow minded mental midgets such as yourself need to be isolated so that your hatred doesn't fester and breed. You finding Indians rude and obnoxious, I find very difficult to believe, unless, of course, you were the one being rude and obnoxious to start with. I guess you just don't like anyone who is slightly different from you in colour and/or culture.
Your levels of bile and hatred usually indicates an individual with esteem and identity problems coupled with paranoid delusions of grandeur. There's nothing grand about you and I can only hope you crawl back under the rock you came out from under.
As was pointed out by the majority, TR is a business and the people running it police it accordinly. Beth is/was only doing her job and from this seat she's doing a damn fine job of it.
Now, not to be impolite, bugger off and stop bothering the adults.
[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)
by deepsand
by jamesrl
And I will readily admit I did hit the spam button on at least one of his posts. Of course I can't quote them now...
When he came on with the Indian sounding name that was the last straw...that was clearly racist.
Beth, you are doing a fine job.
James
by beth blakely
And, I'll repeat: Calling people RACIST SLURS has nothing to do with your political beliefs.
That's all I'm saying on this subject. Actions speak louder than words.
by deepsand
While there is much about the site design & its functionality, or lack thereof, that drives us nuts, the addition of the "Button" stands in sharp contrast.
And, it's good to know that community input in this regard is sufficiently valued so as to warrant action.
Thanks.
WMW's posts weren't nearly as nasty as some of the replies to him have been.
I can certainly understand his consternation.
If you want this matter to drop, let him vent and be done with it.
by jamesrl
The worst ones of course were edited by the moderator.
I would say racist and hateful would apply.
James
Assuming the worst about him, all this dogpile is doing is convincing him he's right.
That, and turning this place into a slugfest rather than an IT forum.
He's gotten a slapdown from TR and lost his old account.
He's peeved now.
Remember the good old days of USENET when we used to cal a P.I.S.S. on someone?
What's he going to do? Argue with himself?
by jamesrl
If Why worry was simply annoying, I wouldn't bother.
And I don't dogpile on many political discussions especially if its the same old democrats suck/republicans suck song that just seems to endlessly repeat.
I come from usenet, and before that BBSs. My inroduction was alt.folklore.urban, when dogpiling is a way of life.
I will tell you why this one bothers me. Racism. Now I am a white anglo saxon protestant male, so I have little stake in the game. But a wise person taught me not to ignore racism, because turning a blind eye to it helps it grow.
I don't think any of us have an impact on how he conducts himself, or he would have left long ago and not come back. Maybe if enough people call him out, he might just finally take the hint.
James
are three different things.
Too often the first two are labeled the third.
In fact, I have reletives who could never tell you about the third, if you get my drift.
Still,
at this point, what is being served?
What can possibly be said to him that hasn't been said already?
He's not continuing, so he's obviously ended the behavior.
Should we take him into the public square for a flogging?
by big ole jack
by sleepin'dawg
by deepsand
To the contrary, he's continued the same behavior here, by repeatedly mention of such, with the clear intent to defend it as being both justified and "protected speech."
By demanding that we allow him to here speak as he wishes, he's evidenced that he's neither changed nor intends to attempt to change.
[b]After reading all of the posts in this incredibly long diatribe, I couldn't help but feel I had heard it all before...[/b]
After years in many other forums, The appeal that TR had and has is that its members are primarily made up of like-minded professionals that have some direct or indirect relationship to computer tech.
The opportunity to help people with technical issues, learn new things and communicate directly with others in my field was what brought me here.
There are hundreds of the stereo-typical forums that are filled with many members that have their own agenda to pound home. I remember being somewhat guilty of that myself at one time or another. But I grew out of that long ago.
The fact that you are crying freedom of speech is something I have heard all too many times before. Nothing new. In fact... it reminds me of an article written in 2001 by Timothy Campbell titled "What is a Troll?"
If you have never read it, you owe it to yourself to check it out. Perhaps it will hit home or, like it did for me, provide a distinct echo.
Specifically the section titled; 'What about Free Speech?'
[b]http://tinyurl.com/23t6rf[/b]
now... let's move on.
I'm trying to figure out what terms he used. I know some slurs for Middle Easterners in general, but none specific to Indians. I feel like my education is being neglected.
Oh, wait; I'm over it. Thanks, and carry on.
"Sure it was". 'Nuff said both for your friend and for Why??. Especially given that your "excuse" for your friend of constant victimisation doesn't apply to him and, I suspect, to Why?? either.
I'm white but I'm neither Anglo-Saxon nor Protestant in a WASP culture so although racism doesn't directly affect me yet, it may at some stage. I'd rather we not get into a social mind-set where any sort of racism doesn't immediately attract censure or is even deemed acceptable.
Neil :)
by deepsand
by mslamen
Deepsand-
Do you disagree with that? I dont think that placing the word Liberals in my initial post which conatined references to (editing, Political correctness and cencorship)was that big of a stretch.
In the future, I may reframe from conveying my political views in my psot.
by deepsand
by deepsand
That's for him to decide.
What [b]is[/b] for [b]us[/b] to decide is whether or not he's welcome to spew his venom here.
Dogpile on the rabbit, Dogpile on the rabbit!!!
Dogpile on the rabbit, Dogpile on the rabbit!!!
Dogpile on the rabbit, Dogpile on the rabbit!!!
Dogpile on the rabbit, Dogpile on the rabbit!!!
Dogpile on the rabbit, Dogpile on the rabbit!!!
DD: Let's try that again, shall we?
BB: Okay. Do you want to shoot him now or take him home?
DD: Ah ha! Pronoun trouble. It's not, "Do you want to shoot HIM now?", it's "Do you want to shoot ME now?". Well, I say, "SHOOT ME NOW!"
Kill the wabbit
Kill the wabbit
Kill the wabbit
Kill the wabbit
Yo ho to-ho
Yo ho to-ho
Yo ho to-ho
Yo ho to-ho
by deepsand
We are neither his support group nor his psychoanalyst.
And, we are certainly not his close friends.
by absolutely
by mjwx
by ontheropes
Seriously, I don't know what you're talking about.
Of course TR can edit out anything they'd like as Max said so succinctly but where have you been "censored"?
I create a post in OO.o then paste it into a reply so I have record of the crap I post sometimes. If you've done that please feel free to send me peermail and I'll see if I can guess why TR edited and get back to you. I'm hard to shock so any content you'd send would be okay and I never post email content, anywhere.
I thought that I might be booted for some of my own drivel but that hasn't happened and I don't think that it will happen. Some folks seem to have difficulty viewing my latest discussion but I can hardly lay blame for that on TR's doorstep. I find that a page "reload" often works just fine if I get an error. There are so many browsers and add-ons/security settings that it's hard to say why any particular pc can't "do" any given task online
I try not to post slanderous and inflammatory appearing comments unsupported by facts or evidence. I got a well deserved TR smackdown for not posting reference links a couple of years ago and the lesson still sticks with me. In other words if I call a spade a spade I show that I have reason to believe it's a spade and not something else.
I'm about as politically incorrect a person as you'll find at TR and to my knowledge I've never been edited out by anyone at TR. I've edited myself "out" but if you take a look at my contacts you'll see that there are some heavy hitters there, some of whom would no doubt report my drivel as offensive if they thought they were offended.
Awaiting peermail...
Edited because heference isn't really a word.
by shellbot
by gadgetgirl
is what you keep your heffalumps held behind.......
GG
]:)
:p
by gadgetgirl
You looked!
:D
GG
]:)
to your hefalumps, I think they are bovine. ...and I mean that as a cowpliment.
But, you've probably herd that all before.
by gadgetgirl
You're all just milking this one!
beef-ore this gets udderly outta hand, I'll pat it back to the Cap'n.... :D :p
Stef - ok, where da webcam? How you know I have Thursdayitis?!
Cap'n - if the sun's over the yardarm, have your daily ration on me - I enjoyed that one!
GG
by shellbot
where ya go to get a nice meal??
]:)
by steffi28
by steffi28
Why all I can think of is Elmer Fudd singin
"Kill the wabbit, kill the wabbit" ??
by gadgetgirl
Crying with laughter, splurted all over the keyboard and monitor!
Ok, who's got the monitor wipes this time? Pass em over here, please....
(My "new girl" now thinks that not only have I lost the plot, I was never really in possession of it in the first place......)
:p
GG
by steffi28
by steffi28
She would be right wouldn't she?? hee hee ]:)
Just invite her over let her see what all the fun is about :D
Trending Peripheral posts
Sort by Trending